50 ms·
Google mandates workers back to Silicon Valley, other offices from April 4
- Gene_Parmesan 5y agoHere's my anecdote. When the team was still intact -- the people who were WFH were the same people who had been in the office together -- things were mostly fine. Now there's been significant turnover and it feels like we're imploding. Management has no idea how to onboard people remotely; the team culture is completely gone. Communication is horrible. People who used to be dependable are now half-assing things. A 40 hr/wk job has become one where people are working 55, even 60, because the new people can't see us all physically leave the office after 8 hours to be able to trust that yes, really, it's just 40 hours. All of this is a huge personal tragedy for me; you can even see my profile where I've had a number of comments talking about how positive the working environment has been historically. It's all changing though. It just feels like a disaster. Everything hummed along fine for the first several months, but as churn has happened something has been lost. We never spent time and effort looking at how to become a remote organization. We simply told everyone to WFH. I've been reading about some of the downsides of fully remote work for over a decade, and I'm just seeing them in spades now. Even teams who were built to be remote from the ground up have (pre-pandemic) write-ups talking about the challenges of communication, team bonding, trust building, and so on. What I see in my circles is a bunch of people who say how much they love not having to leave the home. What I don't see is a ton of people arguing that it makes their team better. Let me be clear I'm not discounting the value of being able to be at home; I know it's a huge benefit to many parents, for instance, and I know there are some who used to have a 2 hours commute. I'm just saying I haven't actually heard any arguments supporting the idea that it is a net improvement for the team -- and when the team becomes dysfunctional, people's mental well-being and happiness begin to suffer for other reasons. These are all obviously just personal anecdotes. I would not be surprised, however, to see companies start walking this back slowly over the next few years, especially the non-tech companies. I think we will see increased inefficiencies show up as churn continues, as well as people with even moderate extroversion getting fed up of the isolation. Further, there is a strong tendency for people to want to work with other people "like them," and so I don't see local/regional companies being open to hiring nationwide for very long. Google hiring nationwide is one thing; Regional Health Insurance Corp, with business 100% focused within a half-state-sized region, is something completely different. I could be completely wrong. I hope we can sort of collectively settle on some sort of moderate state, one where WFH days are liberal, but you don't have organizations of 1000+ people who never physically see each other. For instance, I feel somewhat stuck at my current position because the thought of trying to grow trust with an entire new team of people over calls and internet chat is horrifying to me.
- whiplash451 5y agoDuolingo is also back to 3 days a week in the office, and their CEO seems happy about it.
- lmeyerov 5y agoManagers like it bc they don't do deep work, and do benefit from happenstance + zoom relief. A CEO manages managers, so even more extreme. (And I assume even more so in sales/marketing heavy orgs where folks aren't digital natives.) We are tiny, and while actively hiring, no intention of getting an office again. Too much to do to waste on management, commute, etc.
- whiplash451 5y agoI think we agree. There are so many company topologies/contexts/situations that a one-size-fits-all answer does not exist. That was really the point of my post. Some companies are happy to switch to 3-days in the office, and we should respect them as much as the ones that go full remote.
- lmeyerov 5y agoI like how an MIT CS professor put it to me once: He stays home to work, and goes to work to socialize. Most people are not digitally native, and as in my original comment, management layers are especially social. So I'd expect deep work orgs to be more remote-friendly: small technical startups like ours are happy fully remote, and it's an advantage. In contrast, most sales/marketing/large orgs are less remote-friendly: 1+ days in office, bad promotion paths for fully remote, ... . Not inherent and always exceptions, but just about what's typical, natural, & easy.
- taylodl 5y agoGoogle employees generally don't have much difficulty in finding other jobs.
- hindsightbias 5y agoI’m sure there will be plenty of takers for the keep-seat-warm-for-$250k-a-year jobs. Not like Google is doing anything innovative and needs rocket scientists.
- meddlin 5y agoIn my experience, offices have simply been judgemental, time wasting, lacking in proper equipment/tooling, and quite frankly just uncomfortable. Granted, it's been a lot of mid-size enterprise/corporate places, but it's been backed up by a lot of middle/upper management that don't bother to think through why such criticism would come their way. I'm all in favor of a GOOD office to come to, but until then I'm spending no more time on the property than required. Our white-collar culture and urban areas are too dysfunctional for hybrid and remote options to not be normalized. (In the US) If we're going to be "right-to-work", then give us the right to be remote.
- hooby 5y agoRemote work has many upsides as well as downsides when compared to working in office. What's interesting to me is, that many of the upsides of home office (which are also the downsides of going onsite) seem to be pretty much inherent and unavoidable. Companies doing home office can hire from a larger pool, have less expenses for offices and onsite services, no commuting allowances, etc. Employees working in home office have no commute, less car costs, more food options, are freed of open-plan office distractions, etc. At the same time, most of the downsides of home office (and thus the upsides of onsite work) do mostly concern communication and organization and should be solvable. Online Meetings suck, because all video/voice chats are crap. You can't get in touch as quickly as tapping someone on the shoulder - because messengers are crap. And so on, and so forth. So basically, all our tools for online-collaboration are not able to adequately replace in-person communication. Something is obviously getting lost. It's kinda interesting, that Google does not seem interested in figuring out what the problem is, and improving upon their tools. It would seem to me that making Google's online collaboration tools better to overcome those problems and provide a remote work experience that doesn't suffer from all those drawbacks, would be a great business opportunity. Instead they are basically throwing in the towel and admitting that they are unable to make it work well, right?
- MrDresden 5y agoBefore the pandemic I would have firmly placed my self on the 'introvert' side of the spectrum, and if asked about the ability to work remote or from home would have said that would be my dream. Through the last two years I have realized that I am closer to the middle of the spectrum, and enjoy (and in a way need) the thoughtful company of my peers much more than I realized. However I also enjoy immensely the ability to work from home when I need to focus without meeting and distraction. And here is my realization (which really isn't very profound); most offices, even those who are "designed" to be nice for the workers, are awful places for focus work. They are however fantastic for the exploratory phase of work, where bouncing ideas happens and the boundaries and limitation of the work haven't been discovered yet. My dream now is the ability to work 2-3 days remote and the rest in the office. Thankfully the old money financial institution I work for allows this.
- raman162 5y agoRemote works has it's pros and cons. I love being able to be with family, no commute, a fully stocked kitchen with things I prefer to eat and the ability to take a nap when needed. The con for me is that I feel lonely throughout the day sometimes. The loneliness is great when I need to hit a flow state but other times it can be a bit sad.
- avnigo 5y agoWhat I don't understand is that, at least on the surface, companies save money (utilities, rent, etc.) by having employees work from home. So it seems to me that the only reason companies like Google would mandate the return to offices is because they see a greater cost in having employees work from home. Are they afraid of the cost of lost happenstance collaboration being so high and not trusting in technology (some of which Google built) to bridge that gap, or are they worried that their employees are slacking off? Personally, slacking off when working from home would not be unimaginable, but more often than not, I may work longer hours from home as I won't have the commute burden or feeling that it's time to finally leave the office, so it's actually easier to get carried away. Admittedly that has other mental health implications, but not ones I would imagine most companies considering the cost of.
- t43562 5y agoThe same knobs who outsource jobs to countries in far away timezones tend to argue that being in an office is important.
- motbus3 5y agogoogle is the new early's 2k Microsoft what happened to Google. now they are hiring almost anyone who applies and have stricter processes and serious meetings. that ceo is destroying Google for good. he wants to blame other people for putting money in the wrong things.
- motbus3 5y agonot only about commute time but it's cheaper to work from home as petrol and food prices are skyrocketing
- cryptica 5y agoThese days, every time the elites do something in unison, I assume there is an evil agenda behind it. I'm usually proven right.
- simonswords82 5y agoVote with your feet Googlers. If you enjoy being in an office - by all means get stuck in. If it's not your cup of tea and you'd rather work remote, you should be able to find work elsewhere and I recommend you do.
- democracy 5y agonot going back to the office, f@k off )))
- therealbilly 5y agoI bet the middle managers cheered when they heard this news. It's been hard for them to show value when everybody is at home. Hope fully most of the folks over there can choose what works for them. Assuming the work gets done regardless.
- Jenk 5y agoIn other news: Owner of expensive commericial property demands occupants return to expensive commerical property to prevent price of expensive commericial property from falling.
- totorovirus 5y agoIt only works in big tech companies where you don't need to take care of everything. Still, there are some management issues like sharing same philosophy, mentoring, etc that you wouldn't get in remote work. I think apple sensed this first and now it's google's turn
- unnamed76ri 5y agoWorkers were probably developing too much independent thought away from the collective.
- cyberlurker 5y agoI wish I could afford a nice house close to the office. I do like to socialize. Until then, remote work is all I will do.
- vondro 5y agoMany people in comments write about difficulties with onboarding to remote-only companies, with establishing relationships with colleagues at work. My close friend works remotely at a Finnish company (he is Fin himself), and every Friday at 14:00 they finish working, and have beer drinking session and casual chit-chat over teleconference. Every week. He likes the experience overall. Of course, not everybody wants nor can drink, but it is some idea to get each other better.
- bdcravens 5y agoI'm pro-remote, but I worked from home years prior to COVID. I also never have even considered working for a Google or the like, forgoing whatever benefits that incurs. When they were hired, they knew what the expectations were. If after experiencing an alternative they decide that's the lifestyle they want, there are plenty of options.
- raygelogic 5y agoI think remote work makes more sense the more stable the development pathway is. the more cross function work, the more uncertainty, and maybe the higher the required velocity, the more important it seems to be able to have impromptu discussions. I find I spend a few hours a week just catching up on things I'm missing in the office while working remotely. and when I do go in, I'll learn something that causes a total pivot in my understanding of a business need. that said, I never have had as much deep focus as when I'm working from home, in particular in the evenings. really important discoveries are made there too. so I think having both is optimal. and above all, having a flexible job is something I've come to expect for work-life harmony.
- ThalesX 5y agoI kinda like it how we do where I am working now, and we're doing highly exploratory work. We have an ongoing call throughout the day where people kinda join up, and a lot of impromptuu discussion is done in this way. It's not mandatory, but most of us just chill there, mute and webcam on or off, depending on the mood, and kinda work. It's super natural to just ping someone in chat and if it's the case, you can share the screen and if anyone else is interested they're already there and can just throw an eye. If the discussion is annoying you, you can just mute and focus, but most of the times if it's a longer discussion, we make a split conversation and rejoin main after we do the back and forth. Really natural way of doing things and I can work from anywhere with people from anywhere, as long as we can get some overlap with the daily calendar group chat, which is very easy to do given its immovable nature.
- jballaballa 5y agoI'm not really sure what other people think the long term effect of shifts to remote work will do, but to me it seems like, long term, tech salaries will be lower. It doesn't really make sense to me to pay the same Silicon Valley wages when people can be working from anywhere. Why would I pay an extremely high wage to someone living in the Bay Area when I could instead pay a lower salary to someone in India who speaks perfect English and is willing to work CA timezone hours? In the short term, companies might keep salaries where they are to avoid disruption, but long term I'm not so sure. Obviously, companies have to compete with other companies from all over the world for tech talent, but the ratio of tech money to tech talent is much higher in certain parts of the U.S. than pretty much anywhere else in the world. As a result, if that money gets to shop for talent around the entire world then the 'price' for that talent seems like it will go down. But maybe there is something I am missing. And maybe all the people who want to go full time remote are ok with that, but depending on how big the pay cut is, maybe not. Presumably, if companies now see less benefit in having in-office engineers, then everyone including in-office workers will get pay cuts due to the globalized market for talent. So perhaps, selfishly, we should want companies to put a high value on being in person, but I guess we will have to wait and see.
- mekal 5y agoI'd like to see mankind drop everything it's doing and focus on making portal guns a reality. Once we have the ability to step from our home office into our work office (and back again as many times as we want throughout the day) then we can all happily continue working together on other stuff.
- ctvo 5y agoThere's two extremes of employee behavior I've seen, with most folks somewhere in the middle: - My co-workers are friends. We hang out, we go out drinking after work. We do activities on the weekend together outside of work. Early stage start-ups often are like this, most of the time not by intentional design, but due to the hours and intimacy of working closely with peers. - My co-workers are colleagues. We're professionals, but our interaction stops there. I don't particularly care to get to know my colleagues on a deeply personal level. Your preference for working remotely seems very closely tied to which camp you more strongly identify with.
- simpthrown8id 5y agoHere's my reaction: If google wants me in the office, then fine, I'll just arrive an hour later and leave an hour earlier ~ the length of the average commute. It's obvious that the company values seat time in the office more than 25% extra productivity. Google chose to put their offices in the least accessible areas of the country and there is a price to pay for that. Either you pay higher salaries or put up with less producitivity. It just reminds of those articles from the 99s when companies hired people to be in the office right before the dot com bust.
- animanoir 5y agoI will never return to an office. No matter what. Simple as.
- xtat 5y agoRIP google
- picsao 5y ago
- _3u10 5y agohttps://archive.fo/AfRlK https://archive.fo/AfRlK
- c7DJTLrn 5y agoDo Googlers mind working in the office much? They get plenty of free meals/snacks/beverages, great equipment, and great salary allowing them to live close to the office and pay for childcare if needed. I can't see the rest of the industry moving in the direction of returning to the office, because they don't have these things.
- pinephoneguy 5y agoHousing in SF is crazy expensive, commuting takes ages (and we've shown it's a complete waste) and a lot of people probably don't even want to live in California. Forget snacks, the amount of money you save by not living there and not commuting could pay for an in house chef.
- qbasic_forever 5y agoIf the last 3 years are any indicator, living in SF and the west coast in general means putting up with 2-3 months of choking, dangerous wild fire smoke every year too. It was a novelty for one summer but is slowly going to poison and cause serious long term harm the more it continues. I don't think people realize how unlivable the west coast is quickly becoming.
- Psyonic 5y agoThis year, the smoke from the California fires was actually much worse in Colorado & Utah than the bay area proper. You can't necessarily escape this by moving.
- jeffbee 5y agoTrue, but it's going to be bad some years. This year I expect an outright disaster, considering we've had the driest winter in 150+ years of recorded history. Probably it's going to be unbreathable at certain points.
- pinephoneguy 5y agoOn rethinking my statement I've realized I should encourage the Californians to stay in California and not spread communism to the rest of the country. So yeah, you can't escape the bad things by moving, stay there.
- infamouscow 5y agoAfter two years of not being in the office, I don't see how anyone can justify going into the office without putting themselves into a quagmire of hypocrisy and contradiction.
- foogazi 5y agoWhat do you mean ?
- formerly_proven 5y ago"Despite shipping more than ever and having higher velocity than ever before remote work clearly does not work hence you must return to the office"
- colinmhayes 5y agoI do think there's something to be said for the long term culture effects remote work has. Maybe the current employees who used to work in the office are more efficient remote, but is the same true for new remote workers? What about in a few years when a large percentage of the employees may have never worked in the office at Google?
- ipaddr 5y agoIf any company Google should be able to create a compelling online employee culture and it does and did before covid.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> "Despite shipping more than ever and having higher velocity than ever before I've been a member of several manager-centric forums since before COVID. This was definitely not the case for most teams. The sudden switch to remote was not a productivity or even a morale boost for most.
- 5y ago
- jefb 5y agoMandates? "Since last June, Google has approved nearly 14,000 employees globally to transfer to a new location or go fully remote, Casey said. About 15% of applications have been denied, he added." "Employees not prepared to return April 4 also can seek a remote-work extension, Google said."
- qntty 5y agoI guess like most companies, return to office means show your hand see if you have enough power to convince them otherwise.
- ramesh31 5y agoMade my move to permanent remote last Fall, when it was becoming pretty clear that return to office was on the horizon. Sure enough, we're going back company wide starting this week. Really glad I did it while I could. I will never go back to a 9-5 daily commute ever again.
- d0gsg0w00f 5y agoI would hesitate to make such sweeping statements. As work returns to the office my prediction is that you'll end up with pockets of high functioning teams that are physically colocated and distributed teams will inevitably be at a disadvantage which will lead to them being relegated to "tolerate" despite the talent on those teams. It's not to say that distributed teams can't be high funtioning it just takes 3x the effort from a management perspective. Good management is in even higher demand than SWE skills. A good manager will gravitate towards teams that are colocated because they know they can be more effective for less effort. To level the playing field it has to be all colocated or all remote. Talent currently holds the cards because of demand but talent+colocation will always win in a contest.
- Wiseacre 5y agoI imagine over time the permanent employees will be "managed out".
- bubblicious 5y agothis is only for those who have opted to not be fully remote. those folks have a reserved physical desk / office space at which they will be required to go 3 days per week starting apr 4th. They may switch to fully remote but cannot keep a dedicated physical spot if they do so. source: googler
- bpodgursky 5y agoHonestly that seems like a totally reasonable ask, assuming there are a reasonable number of flex desks for people who are nominally remote.
- itsangaris 5y agodoes going remote impact one's salary?
- ASinclair 5y agoYes, it's based on where you work. Though you can work remote from the same city as your current office and have no pay difference.
- Johnny555 5y agoCan you go remote within commute distance of the office and keep your salary? What's the limit? Living in Pleasanton is cheaper than living in Mountain View, but still commutable. Living in Tracy is cheaper still and people still commute to the Bay Area from there. Living in Fresno or Sacramento is even cheaper and farther but still some people will do that commute daily.
- brandonhorst 5y agoIt's all based off the CoL in county of your primary residence. Has nothing to do with the proximity to an office.
- 5y ago
- jdlyga 5y agoI work for a large company, and my team has changed so much since before covid. Before Covid: 5 people in the same New York office, 1 remote in Europe Today: 2 in New York, 2 in California, 1 in Ohio, 1 in Europe There is no single office to return to. Though we could meet up with other coworkers on different teams and projects. But in essence we've become a remote team. Has anyone else's teams become geographically distributed since covid?
- TranquilMarmot 5y agoThis happened at my last job before I left. We had ~50 employees working at an office in Seattle. The pandemic hit, we went remote, and there was basically a mass exodus out of Seattle. I think only about 20 people were still in Seattle by the time I left (for another job that's 100% remote with people scattered throughout the globe). It took the company almost two years to start adjusting salaries...
- awslattery 5y agoCOVID definitely helped push my recommendation that our small team move to full-remote, and start to transition to more asynchronous work. It's great being able to hire outside of our local market (especially for SWE talent), and we won't be renewing the lease on our albeit small office this year (moving to grant coworking or at-home furniture/equipment reimbursement).
- standardUser 5y agoAbsolutely. I'm at a mid-size startup based in SF and we went from a few remote engineers outside of the country to over half our team remote internationally and many of our longest-tenured US-based engineers moving to places like Oregon, Texas and Colorado. I moved to NYC. There will be no significant engineering presence in SF when our office finally reopens.
- JacobThreeThree 5y agoYes, something similar happened with my team, although there was a consideration to allow some work to be remote before Covid, once it started that sealed the deal. It is strange to walk around an office and see a bunch of workstations, desks and PC's that are all setup to do work in person, but only the PC is being used remotely and the only other people in the building are a security guard or janitor.
- shmerl 5y agoBad shift. What's their problem?
- paxys 5y agoI see two reasons to go back to the office: 1. You need a physical space to work from. 2. Your entire team is at the office as well and you can collaborate with them face to face. I imagine 1 is not a concern for most people who have adapted to the situation over the last two years. And 2 requires that most of your team is local and agrees to come in as well, which I can't see being too likely. For me personally going back to the office and still sitting in video calls all day with a geographically distributed team makes zero sense. It is a lot more comfortable to do it from home.
- citizenkeen 5y agoLot of people saying they don't see the status quo returning in a thread about the status quo returning.
- spookthesunset 5y agoGive it about a year or two and everything will be as it was in 2019…
- Johnny555 5y agoFor me personally going back to the office and still sitting in video calls all day with a geographically distributed team makes zero sense. It is a lot more comfortable to do it from home. It's worse since we have an open office, so to do a video call you need to book one of the conference rooms that are in high demand, even the smallest rooms were perpetually booked even prior to the pandemic. At least when working from home, I can do a video call any time without having to find a room. And I think people have forgotten about commutes and lunch. Now meetings are booked anytime from 8am-6pm and assume people will be available anytime from home. But since some people commute earlier and some people commute later to miss traffic, if everyone's back in the office, the only safe window to book a meeting is 10am-12pm and 1pm-4pm
- WheatM 5y agoIf anyone books a 5pm meeting with me, home or not, it's getting declined.
- vinnymac 5y agoFrom my visits to Google's offices in Manhattan, I don't expect many who reside within the city, to resist this change. People will accept leaving their small city apartments and visiting the vast offices, with a plethora of services available as a welcome alternative after two years. It's those who've moved on from that lifestyle, and may have physically relocated, who will resist this change. They will be inclined to make an argument for working remotely, or work elsewhere, whatever works.
- dsl 5y agoIt is vastly different in the bay area where public transit is a horrible mess and the freeways are all at 300% capacity. A friend who is a Googler is looking at a 30 minute commute to a GBus stop for a 90 minute ride each way. Going to the office is cutting productivity basically in half.
- xanaxagoras 5y agoThat 4 hours to and from work doesn't come out of "his time"? e.g. leave at 7 to get there by 9, leave at 6 to get home at 8.
- teaearlgraycold 5y agoSome Googlers might choose to live like that - but I don’t think they can make Googlers give up their entire lives to work.
- yupper32 5y agoHonestly that's their issue that can be fixed. There's no reason someone with a Google salary needs to be 2 hours commute from the office.
- Thrymr 5y agoUnless of course they have family/spouse/SO who also need to be somewhere else.
- 5y ago
- onychomys 5y agoI work for an extremely famous hospital in a small city in Minnesota, and we've gone 100% remote forever in large part because then the hospital doesn't have to pay for heating/lighting/internet/etc for all of the buildings that used to be full of us. Eventually they'll probably sell the offices entirely. I'm not sure why Google thinks it's economically worth it to have people come back in, I'd imagine the savings must be even more immense for them than it is for us.
- jonas21 5y agoI hope you don't mean the entire hospital has gone remote. I'd not be happy if my surgeon was working from home.
- randomsearch 5y agoYou could save even more money by firing your staff and winding up the company.
- dmitrygr 5y agoA gift to Meta recruiters, brought to you by Sundar.
- whiplash451 5y agoMeh. It is unclear to me that so many people will want to work fully remote when their company offers a (real) office to work in 3 days a week. The mental benefits of in-person working can be significant.
- ryanSrich 5y ago> The mental benefits of in-person working can be significant Just remember there are just as many, if not more, mental detriments to working in-person.
- hungryforcodes 5y agoOnly for people that dislike it.
- ryanSrich 5y agoCorrect. And to the parent comment only for people that like it.
- primax 5y agoThe negative externalities of working in an office are pretty major too. Time and cost of commuting unpaid Cost of work wardrobe Requirement to wake earlier to make it in on time for people who aren't morning types
- amyjess 5y ago"3 days a week" is untenable because it requires that you live within an 8-hour drive of your office. If they want to make a mandatory mix of remote and non-remote work, it should be like oil rigs, where you go to the office to work and live on campus for two consecutive months out of the year, and then you go home for the rest of the year. Requiring that you be chained to a single metro area for the entire duration of your employment is objectively inferior to a situation where you can live wherever in the world you want (except I guess for countries that have sanctions) and you can even just get rid of your home and spend each week working out of a different city and just have to give 2 months of your life to the company.
- floren 5y agoA few months back I was talking to a manager at [huge established software company]. He was making the case that obviously anyone who has moved away from the Bay Area should have their pay cut. He personally has not been in the office for a single day since spring 2020, but since he telecommutes from Berkeley rather than Omaha, he sees no reason to cut his own pay. Later that same day I spoke to someone who's managing at [online payment processing company]. Shortly after bragging that he frequently spends only 2 hours a day actually working, he expressed that full-time remote work will never work out because you can't tell if someone is actually contributing. I refrained from pointing out that ICs actually have targets to meet and code to produce, and that you can put them on a PIP if they fail to meet expectations, while he's busy proving that management can apparently get by just phoning in to the occasional meeting. edit: company names changed because it feels a little weird to call them out like that, I dunno
- colordrops 5y agoDespite not making any sense, cost of living adjustments based on your location seem to be the trend that we are heading toward. If you contribute the same work, it seems that it shouldn't matter where you are located, but companies are sociopathic by nature and will reduce costs anywhere they can get away with it. This opens the door to the next step of having salaries match the lowest common denominator - if you can get good enough devs at a quarter of the cost, the salary will be that rate no matter where you live. Regarding not being able to tell whether someone is contributing if they aren't in person - this manager is just plain dumb, as they aren't measuring the right criteria.
- birdyrooster 5y agoI find it interesting how well this tracks: From each according to [their] ability, to each according to [their] needs.
- eloff 5y agoI don't think that's guaranteed. I work remotely and I just exclude companies that do cost-of-living adjustments. Those companies might end up paying less, but they also have fewer applicants to choose from. You tend to get what you pay for in life. Hiring is really difficult right now, it's not wise to make it more difficult by driving away applicants.
- gitowiec 5y agoThat's good to be back in the office. For me it's only a week to start feeling bad. Loneliness, the same walls I live with family, no colleagues around to talk to. That's not for me. Sometimes I prefer to work from home, because I need to run some errands, from home I have better control. Everybody should have an option, or possibility to work from home some days in a week. But nothing replace morning coffee in the kitchen with colleagues!
- ipaddr 5y agoI look forward to your post April 4 rant on traffic.
- ryanSrich 5y ago> Everybody should have an option This is actually a major red flag if I'm an employee. There's no half way with remote work. Either everyone, including execs, works remote, or no one does. I've been in hybrid situations and it's complete hell. My suggestion is pick what works best for you, and then find a company that's committed all the way to either one. For me, there's no amount of money that doesn't start with billion that could convince me to work in an office. I understand some other people are different, and they should find companies that support forced-commute co-located working.
- RC_ITR 5y ago> There's no half way with remote work. I’m sorry you’ve only been in toxic environments, but you really think “we are in office t-th” is impossible?
- ryanSrich 5y agoNot impossible, but very unlikely → https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30534756 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30534756
- RC_ITR 5y agoI just really fail to comprehend why “5” is a perfectly feasible number of days in the office on a set schedule and “3” is a pipe dream. No one thought it was weird to close offices sat/sun, why would that change (now that we all have remote set ups by force)?
- librish 5y agoI think anyone who's claiming that remote work has been "proven" to be better or worse is wrong. There are some studies but they use estimations and proxies, carrying the same flaws as doing performance reviews based on lines of code. We've proven that the big tech companies can go fully remote and not completely crash and burn, that's about it. Some people love the lack of commute and less semi-forced hanging out, some people hate onboarding on a new company as a remote person and so on and so on. I personally prefer a company where everyone's on site. I want to be able to quickly resolve any issues in person, not over voice call or slack, and I think that an environment where someone can tap me on the shoulder when they need help leads to overall higher productivity, even if individual productivity suffers temporarily.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- enos_feedler 5y agoNot crashing and burning has a lot to do with development momentum from before the pandemic. It will take all of 22 and ‘23 to be able to compare the output of pre pandemic versions of big tech. This is especially true for hardware companies and products that have annual release cadence.
- Zanneth 5y agoMost of the studies I've seen that evaluate productivity are based on surveys given directly to the employees. I imagine workers have a lot of bias when asked to evaluate their own productivity, especially when there are significant personal benefits from working at home.
- lnxg33k1 5y ago>>> I personally prefer a company where everyone's on site. I want to be able to quickly resolve any issues in person, not over voice call or slack, and I think that an environment where someone can tap me on the shoulder when they need help leads to overall higher productivity, even if individual productivity suffers temporarily. And that's what is wrong about being in office, especially as a software developer I hate having my focus interrupted because someone can't send an email
- jolen33 5y agoFor whatever it's worth, even with the salary cut remote employees are facing, the paybands for FAANG employees in (relatively) affordable cities are still top-of-market. For example, remote GOOG employees in Atlanta take a 10-20% salary cut compared to the Bay Area salaries. But the net takehome is still higher (on average) than the takehome for the in-office Bay Area engineers. And the overall compensation is better than >80% of existing Atlanta metro SWE compensation. That's part of the reason why there has been such a huge influx of people to metros like Atlanta, Charlotte, Detroit, etc.
- ryanSrich 5y agoI've been working remotely since I graduated college in 2013. It's a competitive advantage that Silicon Valley likes to ignore. If I'm another FAANG I'm frothing at the mouth now. I can poach all of these Google workers who have no interest in archaic working conditions.
- kbos87 5y agoI work for a large tech company based on the east coast. My partner works for another large tech company. We are both mid-level managers at companies that seem to be taking a pretty dramatically different approach. My company: - Started with a strong in-office culture - Communicated to managers that all employees now have a choice between being fully remote, hybrid, or in-office; there’s never a mandate to be in person - All new roles can be based anywhere in the country of the roles’ origin - All salaries are being standardized to one city per country (NYC for the US.) By contrast, my partner’s company: - Mandated return to work date 3 days/week minimum unless you’ve transitioned to remote (and they don’t seem to be making that easy for existing employees) - Significant, growing attrition problem causing serious concern among leadership - Growing pushback from employees asking great questions… for example, why they should be required to sit on zoom at an office, conferencing with their remote colleagues If I had to put money on which company will thrive and which one will seriously regret it’s decision a year from now… the answer seems very clear.
- natdempk 5y agoThe first one is HubSpot for anyone wondering (and yes we are hiring). I do think that companies that allow remote are going to see an influx of workers as people leave other companies with in-office mandates. So many people have adjusted to remote working that it seems somewhat crazy to me to try and walk that back. There’s a clear preference based on what we’ve seen for some level of remote work among existing in-office workers who probably aren’t going to put up with a shift back, especially when tech jobs are in such high demand.
- icedistilled 5y ago>Mandated return to work date 3 days/week minimum unless you’ve transitioned to remote This is what bugs me about the hybrid set up. If the company onboarded a lot of permanent remotes and also doesn't have people sync up the in office days, then there is no point of going into the office. It's the worst of both worlds.
- randomsearch 5y agoWhich is why hybrid doesn’t work, and back to the office will win for most companies.
- ejb999 5y agoI have been fully remote my entire career (several decades), in fact in 30+ years have never been on site anywhere for more than 2 weeks total. Wouldn't have it any other way. But as a counter-point, seeing a whole bunch of people who were never remote before, how little work they are actually doing, it is no surprise to me that a lot of employers are going to start forcing - to the extent possible - employees back into the office. I think a small percentage of people are self-motivated, and more productively at home, but watching this all play out for the last 2 years makes me realize that an awful lot of people are going to try to get away with absolutely anything they can - including working as little as possible - when allowed to be on their own. I have had coworkers literally disappear for days at a time, miss meetings for weeks at a time, constantly miss deadlines etc - and as a manager, that is very hard to manage underperformers with a remote work force. Remote work isn't for everyone, and unfortunately there is a non-trivial percentage of the workforce that actual does need someone watching over them to make sure they do what they are supposed to be doing each day. Let's hope they don't ruin it for the rest of us.
- runarberg 5y ago> I think a small percentage of people are self-motivated Why does that matter? We should probably start asking how much does it actually correlate with productivity, before assigning it importance. I have a hunch that even if there even is such a thing as self-motivation, and even if there is a correlation with production, the effect size is probably not high and is conflated with other factors which explain a much higher proportion of the variability. An employer which cares about their workers will (a) grant them the freedom to work from home, and (b) provide them with the structure to do so effectively. In the absence of such structure I can see how motivation could replace it and make up the productivity, however that should not be the worker’s responsibility. The loss in productivity is 100% on management for failing to provide to structure to keep the workers productivity while remote. self motivation seems to me to be a poor excuse to shift the responsibility of management to the worker.
- sixstringtheory 5y ago> disappear for days at a time, miss meetings for weeks at a time How is this not an immediately fireable offense? At least at the point of reestablishing contact where a doctor’s note or equivalent excuse can’t be furnished…
- anothernewdude 5y agoUse your time with temporary remote work to find permanent remote work. Avoid places that pay based on where you live. And frankly, given what people I know say about working at google, I don't think they could pay enough to put up with their organisational issues.
- VBprogrammer 5y agoWe've just done a survey at work to talk about about attitudes to returning to work. The results were basically that 95% of people are happy with work from home but want more social gatherings. Most people would be happy with visiting the office once every two weeks. I expected a small fraction to be extremely pro return to office but actually these didn't appear at all in our survey. What we did have is a couple of people who said they'd resign before returning to the office on a regular basis. I wonder how different attitudes are at Google or if this is more of a top down push?
- ghaff 5y agoThat seems like a high number. Different external surveys I've seen tend to show about 20% wanting to come in five days with a permanent desk, about the same (or a bit more) fully remote, and the rest 2 or 3 days. That's not just developers though.
- erosenbe0 5y agoThat 20% slips to 5% in major urban downtowns where average commute is 1 hour and you have to wait for trains in uncomfortable weather. Cost of extra hour or 90 minutes of child care is also stratospheric.
- ceras 5y agoDo you have data backing that? I definitely agree about super-commuters, but OTOH in NYC: with small apartments and convenient transit commutes, there are some extra reasons to want to go back to the office. I'm willing to bet the super commuter effect is stronger, but I'd be surprised if it were strong enough to change it to 5%. E.g. almost all my coworkers live close to the office here in NYC.
- erosenbe0 5y agoI don't have data and it probably depends on various factors. Google in Chicago made a definite choice to locate itself 1.4 miles from the commuter train and a 1.2 miles from the main city train lines. But they have a gorgeous office with great cafeteria food and they pay more than anyone else with similar job security and work hours. They also have a shuttle bus, I think. If they paid average Chicago tech wages and didn't have free healthy meals then they would have had a hard time recruiting to that office location choice even before COVID.
- DebtDeflation 5y agoWhy do so many assume that there are only 3 options: - 100% remote. - 100% office. - Some rigid hybrid scheme of n days per week in the office every week where n = 3 +/-1. Why not "mainly remote but be in the office when it makes sense to be in the office"? This is how my team has been operating since last July - remote first but every 1-2 months we'll do a week onsite somewhere. Now we're getting pressure to start being in the office a few days per week every week starting later this month (and since we're dispersed that means going to the office to be on video calls all day).
- 727374 5y agoYeah a lot of places are doing this. My old company calls it "ad hoc" office attendance.
- ryanSrich 5y agoThere may be some highly specific scheme that could make hybrid work, but in every situation where I've encountered hybrid it's been riddled with problems: - Decisions made in the office, remote employees input ignored - Manager sees others in the office, remote employees ignored for promotions - Remote employees given the green light to work remote, others who don't work remote resent the remote employee for having that privilege - In-person workers dictate working schedules, remote person's preference for async is ignored, remote person has to work a set schedule based on arbitrary availability of in person workers
- sumedh 5y ago> remote person has to work a set schedule based on arbitrary availability of in person workers Not sure which schedule you are talking about you shouldn't all the employees be generally available between 9 am to 5 pm?
- ryanSrich 5y ago> shouldn't all the employees be generally available between 9 am to 5 pm? For me that's a resounding "fuck no". For what purpose? If you're a software engineer why would you have to be working when someone else is? Collaboration can and should happen async. Unless you're working on some highly life-critical real-time piece of software that's invariably complex, I see no reason why software engineers need to be on the same schedules. In fact, much of why remote and even in-person work is a vast hellscape is because of these old traditions that we think we have to continue living by. The 40 hour work week, full-time all the time, real-time collaboration, set schedules, etc. It's all bullshit. You can build a highly scalable and successful business without following any of these "rules".
- voisin 5y agoMy problem with remote work is that it exacerbates a divide between blue and white collar workers that breeds further resentment, which has already led to all sorts of social ills. I’m not sure the individual benefits outweigh the collective rage.
- munificent 5y agoI agree 100% that the growing divide between winners in the information economy and losers is a major source of societal ills. We should address it by making the lives of blue collar workers better (higher minimum wage, universal healthcare, high density housing), not by making the lives of white collar workers worse.
- chii 5y agoit's easy and cost free to make white-collar workers' life worse, where as it costs a lot of capital and money to increase the minimum wage, etc, for the blue-collar workers. The people who would have to make the sacrifice are the capital holders and high tax payers - they certainly don't want to do this (in aggregate of course - even if some individuals would choose such a sacrifice).
- sumedh 5y ago> which has already led to all sorts of social ills. Isnt that the govt's problem to tackle not a private corp?
- blinded 5y agoyes pull the performers down a level that will help, not.
- voisin 5y agoIf anything, the pandemic has highlighted our dependence on blue collar workers, even if you snidely leave them out of the definition of “performers”.
- tapatio 5y agoThat’s wack.
- supernovae 5y agoPeople who don’t work remotely don’t work at the office either. They’re just gonna find other things to waste time on. life since 2016 has been one shit show after another in America and going back to work as if nothing happened just seems stupid.
- InTheArena 5y agoI think people need to look at the multiplier FAANG companies provide salary / bonus / RSU wise. My experience is that these companies pay a significant market premium, but expect total control over your life for that margin. Everyone else I suspect is going to adapt to this work. There are people who want to work in a office. People who don't. We will need to find ways to make both successful.
- munificent 5y ago> but expect total control over your life for that margin. Data point: I work at Google and the amount of control they have exerted over my life is significantly less than any previous job I've had, including random minimum wage jobs in high school. FAANG companies want high productivity at fairly intellectually challenging work. You get that by treating people like humans, not machines.
- tsycho 5y agoUnfortunately, almost every company expect "total control" [1] over your life during work hours. FAANG companies just pay more. Also, tech workers probably have way more autonomy on their schedule than most other industries. Btw, I am just responding to your comment that "FAANG companies own you life"; not making an argument for remote vs in-person. I personally think that a hybrid model is great, and strongly agree with the currently-top comment by librish[2]. [1] significant control, if not total control [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30534539 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30534539
- UncleMeat 5y ago> but expect total control over your life for that margin Today I started work at 11 and ended work at 4 because I slept poorly last night. I'm a staff engineer at Google. This "total control" thing hasn't been my experience at all.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- skybrian 5y agoI've worked at a startup where everyone being there was essential in how we worked. (We were all pair programming.) It was great. It beats code reviews any day. I learned a lot. But when I was at Google, we would schedule VC meetings with people in a different part of campus just to avoid the walk. Also, I worked on teams that had people worked out in many offices, mostly not Mountain View. I was surrounded by Googlers in an open-plan office, but it was often lonely. I ate alone sometimes. It was often not worth the commute. I think Google having a company-wide policy on this is nuts. Teams vary a lot. They should probably be left to make their own decisions.
- devoutsalsa 5y agoI tried pairing in an open office environment, and I'd go work at McDonald's for minimum wage before returning to that environment again. It was pure hell for me.
- notreallyserio 5y agoI've never tried it but I feel the same way. If people saw the sort of work I did to test/PoC ideas I think they'd either a) flip their shit or b) stop me in my tracks so they could do it their way. It sounds like an absolutely terrible way to learn and grow as a developer.
- tfsh 5y agoI believe there are teams which will be primarily remote
- UncleMeat 5y agoIndividuals as well. My team is going to mixed-remote. Every single application for full time remote work in my org of hundreds was approved.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y ago> I think Google having a company-wide policy on this is nuts. Teams vary a lot. They should probably be left to make their own decisions. This seems rational until you are actually responsible for managing a large organization. First off, the article itself states that Google is giving a lot of flexibility ("Employees not prepared to return April 4 also can seek a remote-work extension, Google said. Since last June, Google has approved nearly 14,000 employees globally to transfer to a new location or go fully remote, Casey said. About 15% of applications have been denied, he added.") But it get's very difficult to manage a large company without at least some sort of consistent policy.
- enw 5y agoI hate on-site because I'm unable to pee next to others. It's embarrassing, so I avoid office bathrooms. Surely I'm not the only one? Guys don't talk about this.
- xanaxagoras 5y agoGo in the stall?
- enw 5y agoFeels embarrassing to always go in the stall when I obviously only need to pee.
- dymk 5y agoGrab some granola bars from the snack counter, bring them into the stall, drop them into the toilet so your coworkers won't think anything's amiss
- bowmessage 5y agoMake sure to grab some coffee grounds too.
- LAC-Tech 5y agoI mean I can only speak for myself, but I don't look at another man going into a bathroom and stall and think "wait a minute.... is he NOT taking a shit?" then start getting my stopwatch out and cross-referencing that with studies of average defecation times. Surely no one really cares.
- dymk 5y agoExperiencing social anxiety has very little to do with what other people _actually_ think about what you're doing.
- 5y ago
- ggm 5y agoAn entire generation appears unaware of a QDU or delay and its effect on human communication. If we've re-learned what delay and jitter to tolerate in this last 10 years thats good, but personally I don't like the de-coherence from asymmetric delay with my companions online, and my own in-head foldback PA
- bckr 5y ago"QDU" returns nothing relevant on a google search. What does this mean? > and my own in-head foldback PA What is this? I think you're saying you don't like Zoom, and I'm with you on that.
- ggm 5y agoQuantified Distortion Unit. It's a telco measure of voice signal quality, from the 64kbps and before days. 1QDU was the maximum tolerated impact on a voice call, and was the goal for line card compression to try and mux voice calls together. It's not just zoom. All digital av processing ads delay. Some removes av sync. Decoherence of visual lip sync and sound interferes with any perceptual clues you get looking at people and beyond 50ms we start to detect it. In head bone conducted audio along with your own ear hears things as you say them. So your own speech is instantaneous unless you incur some DSP delay somehow wearing headphones and it then collides with bone conducted sound. Now in any teleconference system you have a visual of apparently local people and an actual of 200+ms of delay, loss of sync, and a confusing outcome. I do hate zoom. I hate all of it. I also know it's the way of the future.
- chii 5y ago> you have a visual of apparently local people and an actual of 200+ms of delay, loss of sync, and a confusing outcome. then how does a military use radio to communicate between platoons and companies properly?
- ggm 5y agoThey learn to cope. They use jargon, and clearly signal end -over and they demand ack, and repeat-back. tactical radio does probably do some lightweight stuff which works in the RF field they have. If its through LEO, or any kind of centrex, its got delay. I'm not MIL. ask a soldier what it's like.
- listenallyall 5y agoPersonally, I'm 100% down with a hybrid work week. However, I'd like to see companies introduce "remote weeks", i.e. just like ensuring people have vacation days, the company should enable, perhaps 8 weeks per year of remote/offsite work. I'd be a much happier worker knowing I had multiple opportunities to visit distant family for more than a long weekend, travel internationally, do some adventures, etc, as long as I logged in and worked. Usually when I'm doing those things anyway I have downtime that I tend to spend on things that are, at least, work-adjacent.
- asadlionpk 5y agoGoogle has announced these too. 4 weeks of work from anywhere, exactly as you described them.
- bowmessage 5y agoCould be even nicer if they're prescribed all-at-once for all employees, now that I think about it. Similar to how a global reset day is nicer in some ways than an extra day of PTO.
- listenallyall 5y agoFollow someone else's prescribed schedule? Wouldn't you rather visit relatives on their birthdays? Take a ski trip in January, instead of someone telling you the first off-week will be late March? What if you and your spouse/partner's companies define different weeks?
- rhacker 5y agoeerily similar to yahoo a bunch of years ago before they went on their death spiral.
- bendbro 5y agoI must be about the only person who is more productive remote. I suspect people who perform well in office are not doing work that requires deep concentration for long periods of time- programmers or otherwise. What I like about remote work: 1. No commute (4 hours a week saved!) 2. No idle chatter. 3. No shoulder tap interruptions. 4. Lunch, dinner, and snacks at fingertips 5. Midday exercise. 6. Flexible hours. 7. Better coffee. I want to work, not warm a seat or flirt with my workwife
- nunez 5y agoAnd, just like that, the real estate market is finally primed to calm the fuck down.
- tyingq 5y agoSadly, many places will use this as their justification to do the same.
- drtournier 5y ago"come back to the office we got kombucha on tap" https://twitter.com/Jobvo/status/1496507164445356032 https://twitter.com/Jobvo/status/1496507164445356032
- blinded 5y agoI predict more startups as people don't want to go back to offices in cities riddled with crime and homelessness.
- dymk 5y agoI'm never walking down 3rd and Pike again if I can help it.
- redisman 5y agoIt’s like 10x worse than before the pandemic too. One side of the street is a permanent homeless encampment / shooting up spot and I get more second hand meth smoke than vape juice walking down it these days.
- bowmessage 5y agoWhat causes you to continue walking here?
- mumblemumble 5y agoHot take: this is kind of non-news. I had a thrilling but ultimately abortive courtship with Google last fall, and at the time, the messaging on this subject was remarkably consistent: the plan was to go to a part-time model where people would go into the office 3 days a week, and they were hoping to be executing on that plan by the 2nd quarter of 2022. So to see now that they are going to having people in the office 3 days a week in the 2nd quarter of 2022 is certainly no surprise to me. I would guess that that also means it's no surprise to any current Googlers who've been paying attention? And also that this says nothing about Google's own level of success with fully remote work, because, at least as far as I'm aware, leadership never seriously considered it as anything other than a temporary business continuity measure in order to get through the pandemic, anyway.
- jonathankoren 5y agoI don’t think any of this has to due with productivity, collaboration, or whatever corporate says. Google (and Apple, and Facebook, and no doubt many others) have spent literally billions of dollars on real estate right before the pandemic. If people don’t fill those buildings, they’re going to look foolish. That’s it. It reminds me of when corporate says they need special employee shuttles instead of lowering costs by a shared shuttle. “We encourage collaborative conversations on the shuttles.” I’ve ridden them. No one speaks. It’s also not due to secrecy, otherwise they wouldn’t want employees to work on public transit.
- somehnacct3757 5y agoI have a friend in facilities at a BigCo and it does sound like their team is pushing to end remote work mostly because they signed long leases and remote work makes facilities jobs unnecessary.
- DataJunkie 5y agoBingo.
- me_me_mu_mu 5y agoMy opinion is that for a couple of years companies were able to coast on the retained employee knowledge while remote. However as people leave the company or new people join, it is pretty difficult to ramp people up to be as effective as their replacements. I don’t work at Google so maybe everyone who works there is a genius, but I’ve noticed this at my work where it takes quite a long time for people to be 100% effective and it’s mostly because people have meetings and other obligations that make it challenging to bring ppl up to speed.
- ThalesX 5y agoAnecdotal. My best friend, about 5 - 6 years ago was doing manual labor, hauling plastics around town basically. He had a break and found a tech support job. Progressed to level 1 then 2, then he started working (pre-COVID) as a sys admin. During COVID, he changed his job once to also sys admin, and just recently, he managed to land a DevOps job. He's now working with new people, new technologies, new infrastructures, new everything, and is praised for his onboarding speed; which I can attest to. Why did I write this entire story? I think it's about people more than institutional knowledge. I know my friend is smart and driven, and no matter what you'll throw at him, he'll somehow find a way to adapt and improve. There's also an argument against stale institutional knowledge. Ultimately, I think being agile as a company is a greater advantage than institutional knowledge, so I'm biased.
- WheelsAtLarge 5y agoHere come the never ending posts on how they(whoever they are) will quit rather than go back to the office. Yes, you can quit but there will be another body that will replace you in no time. People, keep in mind that 100% at home is both bad for your mental health and career, long term. I think a compromise of a few days at the office and a few at home is both good for employees and employers. We should all unite to make this happen.
- m0llusk 5y agoThere are rather authoritative studies in Singapore and the US that show remote work is associated with a significant productivity boost. But when software engineers evaluate technology it is all about the feels? Why is that?
- willjp 5y agoI seem to be the minority, but this makes me sad. Personally, I find it much less productive to work in an office, with all of the background chatter, interruptions, distractions, meetings. It's my fourth year of full remote work and I don't miss the office one bit. I really enjoy being able to prepare healthier/fresh lunches, and I probably work too much overtime either way.
- k4ch0w 5y agoYou're actually the majority, the people wanting to go back to the office are the minority. You'll see in the fine print Google allowed certain employee's the ability to go remote. Basically, the high performers and talent they can't afford to lose to their competition. People have had a taste of not having to spend time getting ready in the morning, can take their kids to school, and forget an hour commute. You would be hard pressed to find many banging on the door to go back to the office. I know of one person in my circle out of about 30 who want to go back. His reason is lack of boundaries with his family about when he's at work. I personally would never go back to an office, it's not worth my finite time.
- Apocryphon 5y agoEmployers need to think of more incentives for those who have to go back to the office, especially full-time. Here's an easy one: get rid of open offices, give people their own offices. Or at least set up cubicles or cubes so people have more privacy. Basically anything to chip away at the antemorbum state of work layouts.
- zippergz 5y agoSeems like people are eager to frame this as "see?! I told you remote would never last!" But when you look at the details, it's actually the opposite. Every Googler I know who wanted to go full-time remote was allowed to do so. Those who didn't choose to do that STILL don't have to be in the office every day; just a few days a week. Which I think is the right balance for most people. The only people who should be unhappy here are the ones who wanted everyone in the office 5 days a week. It's a win for everyone else.
- mancerayder 5y agoThere's pressure from cities and states since the economy is heavily dependent on consumer spending. Given that big business (rightly or wrongly) partners with government on policy frequently, this is not surprising. The days of being able to live on a mountain or in the woods while drawing an SV (or finance for NYC) salary were numbered for the vast majority. What's problematic is that rents have already spiked and that's before the Big Return.
- throwaway42000 5y ago
- fleddr 5y agoIt's fun to reason about location vs pay. For work that truly is location-based, it's obvious. I once read that a garbage truck driver in NYC earns as much as 100K. I don't know if that number is true, but it kind of makes sense. It's strictly location based and the driver has to live somewhat close to the inner city. Google was/is location-based, where being in an ultra high cost environment normally is a downside, so it must have unique upsides to counter this. I guess that would be the local talent pool and ecosystem. Whilst this factor will not be removed, for sure it will be weakened. In any given team, on any given day, there will be remote workers. The other 2 days of the week. Those with a permanent exception. Those with an extension. Things are going to get more flexible and complex which means your team by definition is hybrid. In practice, a hybrid team is quite similar to a fully remote team if you do it well. You should involve the remote workers in anything of any importance. If your team is hybrid/virtual by definition, the idea to pay based on location of the individual comes into play. The talented 200K engineer that moved to South Dakota to work fully remotely now is a 100K engineer. I guess 100K is the talent value, when location is stripped. But location hasn't been stripped yet. There's Europe, India, other places...so ultimately what remains may be 50K. Yes, I'm making up these numbers but you get my point. Those saying that it's bullshit to pay people based on location and think that this means that they can just keep that 200K and work from a different location are in for a rude awakening. It means you compete on talent only. If you're so top notch that purely on talent you continue to earn that pay, good for you. But be aware that you're in competition for that salary with the entire world now, and that world has armies of people hungry and willing to do anything. And if you think that downward spiral is unfair...no it isn't. This is how it works in the working class in the west and in every class everywhere else. What you consider low pay in developing countries has been the step up for those developing countries. Whilst the west is largely stagnant, they've been building up a better quality of life. As it should be.
- jmacd 5y agoI once flew in to the Bay Area from Europe for several meetings, but the most important one was with a team at Google. We were trying to finalize a deal and they really needed to be on board. I arrived, checked in and was shown to a meeting room. A few minutes after the meeting was supposed to start the receptionist came scurrying in and connected me to the meeting via that cube looking meeting machine they had in every office. Everyone appeared on the screen from various different offices, some at home, and one person in the same building as me. I regretted that trip the entire flight home.
- devoutsalsa 5y agoI got a job that was onsite. On the first day I learned no one in my team worked in the same office.
- MattGaiser 5y agoMy old company is this way. You can work from any of several offices, but work from the office you must. So even when I went in, I never dealt with team members.
- vanilla_nut 5y agoCouldn't you just... work from home, and pretend to be at an office? Unlikely that anyone would ever notice...
- MattGaiser 5y agoI got caught doing this, but yes, I tried many times.
- devoutsalsa 5y agoI worked from home on that job for weeks at a time and no one said anything. The funny thing was that when I was at the office, anytime I needed to speak w/ anyone, I had to leave my desk and find a quiet place. It was inane. The only upside was the free Diet Dr. Pepper.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- DataJunkie 5y agoCue the mass exodus! Backwards policy that is even worse than it was before (where managers could let people work on their own schedule, as an agreement between the manager and the report). But those magical hallway conversations...
- rob_c 5y agoAnd still another step back to normality. Money speaks and as we get into 2022 we get back to normal in time for 2023... About 2 years too late but nothing needs essentiality than a good old economic depression.
- cphoover 5y agoGreat now the rest of the tech industry will follow. The flexibility of remote work was nice while it lasted.
- DataJunkie 5y agoI think other companies will emerge as leaders with more progressive flexible policies. It just makes sense for that to happen. Don't be so quick to assume others will follow Google. Google has not been a leader in anything during COVID. I think the days of companies following Google ended long ago. Hell, Google mostly follows Meta's lead these days.
- pembrook 5y agoGoogle is a giant legacy company that has been around for decades now. All its executives have set their lives up around the idea of commanding a fiefdom of underlings, in person, in the Bay Area. Google execs have the ability to totally ignore the rational pull of a much cheaper distributed talent market, because Google is a Monopoly minting Monopoly-level profits. "Monopoly does what it wants" is not interesting, nor is it big news to me. What's more interesting is all the companies that are never going back, and all the companies started in the last 2 years that will be remote-native going forward. Given the tight market for talent right now, and falling stock prices for growth companies, I'm already pulling out the popcorn now. Google executives have never had to think seriously about silly things like "cost-structure" before. In this next market cycle where Growth takes a back seat, it will be very fun to watch decisions like these pile up to eventually bite them in the rear 5-10 years from now. I can see it now, investors tanking their stock price in 2026, wondering why an old company that hasn't innovated in 10 years is paying 50,000 engineers half a $million a year to sit inside the most expensive real estate on earth and do nothing.
- anaganisk 5y agoDuh, they’re definitely working so hard to show me more “suggestions” for the best toilet seat after I already bought one.
- cryptica 5y agoIt's easier to brainwash and gaslight the employees when you control their environment.
- buzzert 5y agoYep, certainly none of that happening on the Internet…
- cryptica 5y agoInternet mostly creates confusion. The first phase of brainwashing. Once the mind is confused and looking for answers, you need peer pressure and social reinforcement to create a sense of certainty around the radical new ideas you want to implant.
- throwaway_g00g 5y ago"Mandates" is too strong a word. All employees were given the choice to apply for remote work or transfer. It turned out to be only a small minority of employees who chose it, and almost all of them were approved. So there's been an effective option not to come back in person for folks who prefer it that way.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoAren't we still recording among the highest rates of covid deaths since the start of the pandemic, and it's still coming and going in waves? Hospital systems are still run on the brink of overload as they usually are. What's changed?
- redisman 5y agoCases have plummeted?
- throwawaylinux 5y agoNot sure how to answer your question, but US Covid 7-day average deaths is currently higher than at almost any point since the start of 2020. So nothing suddenly "changed" there, that I can see.
- redisman 5y agoCases. You can look at deaths if you want but those will lag cases by a few weeks.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoCases have plummeted many times. It's been going in waves since the beginning. What's really changed is that elections are coming up. Pretty obvious isn't it?
- buzzert 5y agoIt is now a preventable disease. It wasn't at the start of the pandemic, before vaccines.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoVaccines have been widely available and used for about a year though. What I'm asking is what has changed so recently as to make April 2022 okay to mandate a return to work while November 2021 for example was not.
- bobobob420 5y agoEveryone, it was a solid ride but we knew this day was coming. Upper management cannot sleep knowing employees have good work life balance. You need to be on the GRIND or these shares wont go up and you wont get your good equity.
- karmasimida 5y agoOther big techs to follow. I am irritated.
- lumost 5y agoAnecdotally there is a trend towards entropy and complacency on remote teams within big tech companies. In Big Tech, there are innumerable hard blockers that exist for reasons that almost all parties would think are stupid. Forward progress typically requires consensus or permission from potentially dozens of teams. In many cases the company doesn't view rocking the boat on a profitable product to be beneficial. To at least some extent, when you are in the office there is at least some push for folks to find a way forward - while remote there is a strong trend towards the "tune out" option.
- ignu 5y agoI'd prefer to work an environment where I can't get interrupted synchronously by someone wanting their problem resolved that moment. Also, one thing with those in person interactions is you have no artifact of the interaction. Slack or tickets are great for documenting how decisions are made. But ultimately, I have no desire to waste an extra 5 to 10 hours of my life just driving back and forth to sit at a different computer. I do think it's great to meet your coworkers so they're more than faces in Zoom, but I am absolutely never going back to rotting away in a car and office most of my waking week.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> I'd prefer to work an environment where I can't get interrupted synchronously by someone wanting their problem resolved that moment. FWIW, I found synchronous interruptions to be more of a problem when remote. Too many people used Slack messages or video calls for everything because it was only a click away, as opposed to having to get up and walk over to someone’s desk > Also, one thing with those in person interactions is you have no artifact of the interaction. Slack or tickets are great for documenting… Slack is terrible for documenting. It needs to be reserved for ephemeral communication. Forcing people to search through Slack archives works when the team is small and company is new, but it becomes useless at scale.
- scarface74 5y agoThe difference is when I work remotely, I can quit Slack, block my calendar and do “deep work”.
- lostcolony 5y agoSomeone messaging on Slack can be ignored quite easily, without it being rude. If someone is starting a video call with you without arranging a time with you first then I agree you need to get in physical proximity with that person, but only to smack them. Slack is not usefully searchable, true, but its purpose for documentation is not nearly as bad as you make it out to be. If you have a link to the conversation you have the whole conversation; that can be useful to share context. Likewise meetings; being able to record them is HUGE. But either way, you mention Slack should only be used for ephemeral communication...all in person communication is ephemeral. Slack at least has it saved, even if it's a pain to find; in person does not. I can share a Slack link; if you missed it, forgot it, or disagree about what was said, you're out of luck with in person.
- 01100011 5y agoI've been going back in to work 1-2 days a week and find it's been insanely productive and had allowed me to reconnect with coworkers in a more effective manner. I was previously sold on 100% WFH but now I understand the importance of some face time. That said, I will never voluntarily come back 5 days a week. For me, the office is for discussions, socializing, and working out problems in real time. Home is where I get actual work done. That would be different if I had an actual office at work, but I don't. Another factor to consider in the rush back to the office: gas prices may dramatically spike depending on the situation in the Ukraine. It will likely be a significant driver of inflation (and stagflation) and may keep folks from willingly commuting at pre pandemic levels.
- remote_only_eng 5y ago
- swayvil 5y agoNothing says respect like a mandate.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- abhinavm 5y agoI fail to understand the 3 days a week concept. If a company needs in-office interaction, why not make it 5 or 10 working days a month in office, and then let the team decide when they want to be there? Some teams might prefer being in office 5 days straight and then 25 days remote in their hometowns.
- smohare 5y ago
- smohare 5y ago
- wly_cdgr 5y agoBye Google lol
- siruncledrew 5y agoIf employees can apply for fully-remote or a closer office to them and, according to the article, about 85% of those applications are approved, then this doesn't seem as ominous as the headline makes it sound.
- akeck 5y agoAfter two years of mostly WFH, I think I'm ready to go back into the office. For me in particular, in the last six months, "work from home" has started to turn into "living at work". Work cadences are no longer meshing well with home cadences. I've gone in a few times a week in recent weeks and the structure of the day, including the quietude of driving home, is a relief. The only issue with returning to the office I'm running into is that drivers on the highways are considerably more aggressive now vs. pre-COVID.
- somehnacct3757 5y agoI do a simulated commute after a day of WFH to combat this. When my 8 hours is up I put on some podcasts and do chores, or go for a walk. Then after my commute time is over I can change into pajamas, flop on the couch, or whatever other unimportant thing I was excited to do and my brain is fully disconnected from work.
- uhtred 5y agoThe people advocating for a move back to the office are managers who's jobs seem more and more pointless the longer remote work is happening.
- anamax 5y agoIs Urs Hölzle coming back from New Zealand?
- foxhop 5y agoI bet that isn't going g to work & is also a mistake, remote 4 eva!
- foxhop 5y agoI bet that is the wrong move.
- splicer 5y agoThey should have chosen April 1st so most people would think it was a joke.
- LeicaLatte 5y agoYay no more zoom calls. :)
- heavyset_go 5y agoYet again, the desires and needs of workers are trumped by portfolios with commercial real estate and portfolios with companies that rely on commercial real estate.
- deviation 5y agoWhat's so special about April 4? Expedia Group has also mandated a start back at the office from this day... An email announced it to us about a month ago.
- redisman 5y agoFirst monday of April I guess? Our company went back to hybrid the first Monday of this month already
- Hardik_Shah 5y agoGoogle has joined a growing number of technology and financial firms in requiring employees to return to work. While some large employers have made voluntary work-from-home policies permanent, others, such as Google, believe that it is best to prioritise in-person interactions among colleagues. I personally believe working from office brings out more productivity than working from home.
- Hardik_Shah 5y agoGoogle has joined a growing number of technology and financial firms in requiring employees to return to work. While some large employers have made voluntary work-from-home policies permanent, others, such as Google, believe that it is best to prioritise in-person interactions among colleagues. I personally believe working from office brings more productivity than working from home.
- ehsankia 5y ago> voluntary work-from-home policies permanent It's the same at Google, you can apply to be fully remote.
- mikewarot 5y agoI suspect Google is going to have a lot of failures that day 4/04 - worker not found Seriously, it's not going to be a good day for management.
- bhewes 5y agoFrom the title I thought back to the five to six day in office work week. But instead is back in the office around three days a week. Huge difference.
- jurassic 5y agoI don't know why anyone would join Google at this point. Even before this return-to-office mandate, stinginess on PTO is a dealbreaker for me.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- xhrpost 5y agoI remember during the dot-com bubble of the late 90's there was talk of all the malls closing due to online shopping. At the time I thought it was silly, people want to get out, it's not all about just buying stuff online, etc. In the short term I seemed correct. Then eventually the great mall crash happened and concrete ghost towns were everywhere. Though I tend to be biased towards working in an office for my own personal reasons, I can't help but wonder if we're only half a generation away from bigger changes.
- isodev 5y agoI recently took part in a scrum planning meeting where the company mandated everyone to do it on site. The chaos was a stark contrast to anything we'd had virtually before that... People suddenly forgot they could look things up on their computers, stopped using established business vocabulary, and even small things like speaking one at a time were lost on them. During the meeting, someone decided to doodle on the paper board in the meeting room (vs. using the usual C4 format we have been using on Miro boards), creating confusion regarding what "this" and "that" block represents. There were no meeting minutes, and none of the conceptual decisions from the meeting ended up on the wiki... Of course, many of these can be resolved with better discipline, but it really feels like the medium invites chaos. That same team works very effectively in virtual meetings, with the ability to supplement the discussion with well-thought messages via Slack or Wiki comments. Meeting recordings and audio transcripts help for better meeting notes and recording the meeting conclusions and outputs in a way that's transparent and searchable. Also ... gifies, how can anyone stand a 1h meeting without emojis and gifies is beyond me :).
- bryanrasmussen 5y agoI would be calling up my manager three days earlier and saying can I come in today or do I have to wait to the 4th, I really want to come in! And then when they said sure come in, I'd yell April Fools! I don't feel I've been truly appreciated by management, really.
- bowmessage 5y agoYou should find a better manager that supports and appreciates you, it will make a difference.
- saos 5y agoWatch other companies follow lol
- jlarocco 5y agoFor the time being my company is essentially a hybrid, where people can choose whether or not they go into the office, and I don't know what management thinks, but I love it and I'll be disappointed if they ever tell us we have to start going in. It seems like the best of both worlds to me. Most days we have maybe 8-12 people in the office, so there's generally enough people to get collaborative office conversations, but not so not so many people that it's constantly noisy. And if the weather is bad, or I wake up late, or I just don't feel like going in, I work from home and I don't have to worry about it. We're a relatively small team, though, so I don't know how well it scales.
- cosmiccatnap 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zaargy 5y agoPeople argue about whether remote work is 'productive' but is 'productive' all we really care about? I understand this is Hacker News so productive is the guiding principle but what about community, friendship? Doesn't working remotely just force us more into our little bubbles? Especially for engineers I think it just reinforces natural tendencies and won't lead to the same sort of growth over time? There is an aspect of getting better socially as you age (hopefully) for example.
- hericium 5y agoThis particular company's main business is spying. It may have been harder to creep on cult members from a distance. Maybe Google employees are behaving less like "Googlers" at home when priorities shift to family and life. Behavioral changes are harder to enforce remotely when you cannot model cult member's personality by pointing out "ungoogley bahavior" multiple times a day and shaming them in other ways.
- zombiwoof 5y agoHow can you get to be an L6 if you aren't in a Google office? :-)
- alexanderbz 5y agowild
- ohthehugemanate 5y agoOne of the benefits of remote engineering teams, is that there's wag more pressure on their "hygene" practices like a well structured backlog and good documentation. As someone with a fully remote career, it always shocks me how onsite teams tend to let this stuff lapse in favor of implicit brainshare. I wonder, then, if the last two years will improve these kinds of project practices in onsite teams. Or maybe "hope" is a better word.
- deanCommie 5y agoAt my company, very much no. We've not changed any emphasis on additional backlog structure or documentation in the last 2 years. Tribal knowledge, and knowledge transfer presentations and video recordings remains the only way to share knowledge.
- 2dvisio 5y agoWould be interesting to see what Meta does especially after their latest announcements about focusing on building the Metaverse. Would seem like a contradiction to push people back into the office.
- Sateeshm 5y agoI got called into an onsite meeting today because supposedly the brainstorming would be more productive (even though this project has been launched successfully fully remote). But the meeting room they booked only seats 5 (strict seating restrictions) so a couple of people are going to Zoom in and will obviously be left out of the physical whiteboarding. So, not only onsite is not adding anything of value, it is excluding people that otherwise would have been fully involved. Looking at the comments here, i forsee an Onion headline "Ex convicts want to go back to prison because they can't make friends in regular society or miss the "structure" set by Warden."
- anigbrowl 5y agoUgh, I hope this doesn't mean the resumption of giant tour buses tearing through my residential neighborhood 50 times a day.
- zxcvbn4038 5y agoWow, I never would have pegged Google as the one to go this direction, they used to be such a progressive company, now they’ve thrown in their hats with old fogies JPMorgan, Citibank, and Goldmen Sachs. Is this the part where we start rueing?
- ditonal 5y agoGoogle spent 2 decades raving about the office, its perks, the "slides", how it re-creates the campus environment. Google made the office a huge part of its identity so this shouldn't be surprising.
- maxehmookau 5y agoJust like everything else, this is just another way to determine which companies I want to work for. For folks like me who are 100% on-board with remote work, I won't work for Google because it's a dealbreaker for me. (They probably wouldn't have me!) For others, it's not. That said, at this point I'd almost go as far as to say that city centre-based offices will eventually be consigned to the dustbin of history. Who thought the idea that spending 2 hours a day travelling to and from a physical location (and having to pay for it!) to generate larger profits for shareholders was a legitimate or sensible use of human time and capital? My health, both physical and mental are immeasurably higher as a remote worker. The biggest argument I hear is "But you don't get to socialise anymore!" but of course I do. I socialise with my colleagues both remotely and in-person and more importantly, I socialise with those I _want_ to socialise with. Members of my community, friends, family, people I choose. Not people who passed the same interview as me.
- taylorius 5y agoI don't think it's so much an issue of productivity, as company loyalty. Working from home you feel more autonomous - and more likely to consider your options.
- to-too-two 5y agoGrubHub's Boston office is also forcing employees to return to the office after 2 years of working from home. I think it's asinine. One of the few good things to come from this pandemic was showing how much work could be done remotely. I assumed we were going to continue in that direction, but I guess these major tech corps want to go back to the way things were.