35 ms·
Musk’s first email to Twitter staff ends remote work
- olliecornelia 4y agoLet that boy cook.
- ClassyJacket 4y agoThis is a great way to drive away your best talent and ensure those who stay are more tired, frustrated, and stressed.
- SillyUsername 4y agoIt also leads to more mistakes and cutting corners (usually hidden), so in the long term as they accumulate this will bite him in the ass when a particularly bad one gets out in the wild unnoticed. And I thought this guy had a high IQ, clearly he's not that bright after all.
- tjpnz 4y agoHaving a high IQ doesn't make you immune from cockups.
- blitzar 4y agoThese are not complicated decisions to navigate.
- SillyUsername 4y agoNo I guess not. His rants on social media have cost him in the past. I believe he may have psychopathic tendencies because he appears to be attempting to project his own work ethic (long hours etc) onto staff but cannot emphasize with them, or understand they aren't him/have his circumstances/have his ability. His goals are great and have certainly pushed our tech boundaries into near science fiction, but he really doesn't have the social and people skills, which is ironic given he's bought Twitter. If there was one thing I could tell him, it's that he should engage his brain before his mouth, a little (benevolent) social manipulation to get what he wants will be more successful before he barks orders for long hours or sacks people at short notice. Carrot before the stick.
- shadowfox 4y agoI generally agree with what you are saying. But: > certainly pushed our tech boundaries into near science fiction That bit seems a bit of an exaggeration to me.
- SillyUsername 4y agoThe reasoning: - Boeing laughed at SpaceX and their proposed rocket re-use and cheap(er) space flight. Now Boeing is the no.3 supplier to NASA, SpaceX at 2 and playing catch up. - Self driving cars were not an industry until Tesla pushed it, it is still the pioneer in this respect as no other car make has the same level of self driving features. How cool is a car that drives to you on button click? :) - No other US company has announced humanoid robots aside from Boston Dynamics, which are not for the general public. - Tesla has pushed for secondary industries such battery invovation and solar roof tiles (not regular panels on roofs). This in itself is not new but is a future green environment goal. - The Boring company goals may be a pipe dream (har har) but the intent is there to provide hyper transportation, akin to 50s trashy comic ideals. - How many non governmental industries can offer Ukraine help with something like Starlink? Can't be many... (honestly don't know but initially seems altruistic).
- stefan_ 4y agoI'm afraid you have drunk the kool aid. Self-driving cars are an idea as old as the car itself, and many companies are much further along than Tesla who are stuck on their "no LIDAR" stance when LIDAR is rapidly becoming cheaper and more available. Almost ironic from the company that bet on lithium batteries for cars. The robots are a demo gag (much like the smart summon, or the cybertruck, or the semi, or ..). The "solar tiles" are a fire hazard and the Tesla solar business a total shambles, which makes sense since it was just a nepotistic bailout of Solarcity. Hyperloop is dead and so is the Boring company.
- mensetmanusman 4y agoSpaceX alone succeeding is a once in a century event. Tesla kicking off EV for the world as well.
- fortuna86 4y agoSometimes it makes you less self aware that you might be wrong.
- omega3 4y agoTwitter doesn't need "best people" - it's not innovating and hasn't been for a very long time.
- crotho 4y agoHave you any idea what it takes simply to maintain a machine such as twitter, let alone make even minor alterations? There was a recent telling interview by someone who used to work there who thought it wouldn't be long until the whole thing collapses on its own because there were huge teams dedicated to simply keeping the thing running.
- thrown_22 4y agoBack of the envelope calculation: A billion users, each tweeting once an hour with 140 characters. That's 38.147 Megabytes/s. My laptop could handle that raw volume. Increase it by an order of magnitude for all the network nonsense and it can still run on my 4 year old desktop. Twitter is not some hypertech company, it shouldn't need more than a hundred engineers to run. I imagine that's the bet Musk is making too.
- cristiancavalli 4y agoWhat a terribly dishonest and overly-simplistic way of modeling of a distributed system much less a simple web service. found the engineer who, in their own words, “couldn’t code their way out of paper bag.”
- thrown_22 4y agoIf you're serving 40mb a second you don't _need_ a distributed system. Twitter isn't Netflix.
- cristiancavalli 4y agoIt’s pretty laughable you believe your own “math.” I guess even serving an actual front end doesn’t factor into your calculations. Hey go build something and you might find out what it actually takes to build/maintain a system of any real consequence instead of doing leet code exercises and smelling your own brain farts.
- _fat_santa 4y agoIt's fun to read about this stuff in the news and comment on it here and on Twitter but the reality couldn't be more different. If you're qualified enough to be in the running to work at Twitter, you likely have many options available to you (employment wise). None of those people are trying to go work at Twitter because there's just too much BS flying around over there. If this keeps up the only way Twitter is going to be able to attract talent IMO is by offering massive comp packages, because that's the only way you're going to get people that aren't die hard Twitter/Elon Musk fans to want to come there.
- thrown_22 4y agoAll tech companies have been hiring bottom of the barrel engineers who couldn't code their way out of a paper bag. This is just a realignment where where knowing how to put the lego pieces together isn't enough any more.
- jstx1 4y ago> Musk told workers in the email that he wants to see subscriptions account for half of Twitter’s revenue. Given the direction in which their advertising revenue is going, they might get there.
- shapefrog 4y ago> subscriptions account for half of Twitter’s revenue A lofty ambition indeed. Getting $5billion out of twitter users or an anual subscription of $15 out of 100% of the users sounds like hard work. However, if you drop the avertising revenue to $350 million you can do the WhatsApp $1 a year model.
- rdtwo 4y agoSeems dumb, ads pay more than users
- kevingadd 4y agoEven worse, they're offering reduced ads as a part of their new subscriptions, so every subscription actively decreases ad revenue.
- pelorat 4y agoHow is that different from YouTube premium, sure it's more than $8 but comes with zero ads.
- kevingadd 4y agoYouTube and Twitter are, at least currently, very different services. Even if it's the same, the fact is that this $8 needs to not only supplement existing ad revenue but replace it, which makes the financial challenges worse than if it were merely $8 for perks.
- whateveracct 4y agoLowering the denominator is a fun way to get to half ^_^
- whiskey14 4y agoIt seems that Musk at this point is completely unaware that he is a walking contradiction. On one hand, he is a technologist. Forward thinking and driving towards the future. On the other hand, he is an old fashioned factory owner. He views his workforce as pure labour and can't accept that he can't force his employees to work under his total control. He also can't accept the gain in life capital for his employees in working from home for his workforce and that the future of work for humanity is probably decentralised offices and WFH, not middle managed, over the shoulder, supervised, centralised offices.
- jstx1 4y agoCutting edge technologist for the investors, old school factory owner for managing people. Makes perfect sense if you're trying to extract the max amount of money.
- whiskey14 4y agoTrue, but the fact that technology is going to reinvent everything, including work seems to be an oversight. I'm not sure an old school factory owner is going to attract the best people in a highly skilled industry
- shapefrog 4y ago> Makes perfect sense if you're trying to extract the max amount of money Offshoring everything to the third world makes perfect sense to the old school factory owner too.
- SturgeonsLaw 4y agoSimilar to the formula Bezos is using. They are both making a lot of money doing it, just like the robber barons of the Gilded Age did.
- LegitShady 4y agoNot letting people work from home doesn't make you a robber baron.
- yummybear 4y agoAt this point why would anyone want to stay at twitter? The mood must be absolutely abysmal.
- shapefrog 4y agoOver summer, tech companies were offering wheelbarrows full of cash to potential employees. Love him or hate him, once he started f'ing around at twitter, why would anyone have stayed? Unless you really desperately wanted to be in the presence of the man himself, and maybe thought he was going to buy you a horse in exchange for something
- rdtwo 4y agoProbably because the people getting let go aren’t in high demand anywhere with current tech layoffs
- bawolff 4y agoProbably it takes more than a week to find a new job and people like to have the new job in hand before quiting the old one.
- _fat_santa 4y agoIt's been 2 weeks since he officially bought it, but working at twitter (and even as an outsider just reading the news), you see the writing on the wall. There were tons of reports of planned layoffs, and the changes that Elon wanted to see in the company. None of what he is doing is surprising, least of all to Twitter employees.
- mrguyorama 4y agoCompanies have always known that employees will put up with abysmal conditions to some level. The stress, effort, insecurity, and fear of finding a new job has always had an extreme value to most people.
- bawolff 4y ago
- jurassic 4y agoMany technical parts of the company had 80% layoffs last week. The people who quit or quiet quit over this senseless RTO mandate will push the company into an unrecoverable brain drain, if they're not already there.
- kypro 4y agoI am split on the remote work thing from a productivity / creativity perspective. I do think there are times when I'm less productivity working from home compared to the office. I also think as a team we're less creative. Some of the best stuff I've done in my career has come out of casual conversations with my team about the stuff we're building. I've noticed I don't think about what I'm building as much when working remote, I'm just building it. That said, I don't think 100% office is good either. That tends to just burn me out and I know other people I work with say the same thing. I think I'm at my best when it's 2-3 days in the office and the rest working from home. 40 hours in the office is really extreme these days. And any potential benefit of having employees working together in an office 24/7 is going to be negated by their dissatisfaction. Were I working at Twitter I'd probably be looking for a new job after this announcement. Not so much for the remote work decision either, but just the general lack of respect for how the employees prefer to work. This lack of flexibility probably means Musk won't just stop at remote work but he'll want keep track of your productivity, when you arriving in the morning, how long you take for lunch, etc. Working for these kinds of people in my experience is a living hell.
- aperson_hello 4y agoAnd the fact that Twitter employees aren't all near an office. If you live in Minneapolis, you're not exactly going to be happy that you have to go into the office (closest one is 6+ hours away in Chicago). It's not even a choice to go into the office or not at that point - it's an ultimatum of move immediately for a job where everything is on fire or be fired!
- schnable 4y agoI think the purely remote workers were already axed.
- whiskey14 4y agoI'm beginning to think that collective distributed satellite offices is going to be big. Like WeWork but for companies to house their local staff and far less culty. Would help if they had standing desks, folding treadmills, three screens and everything else for a superb dev experience that is a bit of a pain to set up at home.
- evbogue 4y agohttps://archive.ph/CN49N https://archive.ph/CN49N
- manuelabeledo 4y agoLay off a sizable chunk of your workforce, and then make a sizable chunk of those who kept their jobs miserable. Genius /s
- vagab0nd 4y agoOr quit voluntarily.
- BryantD 4y agoAs Musk and Calacanis discussed between themselves: https://finance.yahoo.com/news/elon-musk-jason-calacanis-messaged-213703298.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/elon-musk-jason-calacanis-mes...
- kridsdale2 4y agoEnsures that only the most hardcore mascohists remain, who you can abuse for huge productivity extraction vs the rest-and-vest type.
- jahlove 4y agoHacker News top search result for "Twitter", from two years ago: Twitter Will Allow Employees to Work at Home Forever https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23155647 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23155647 Forever is a long time...
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoAt the time people thought the pandemic would be forever…
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bigbillheck 4y agoIt's still killing hundreds of people every day.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- prottog 4y agoA hundred and twenty people die every minute in the US. How far will you go to ensure that doesn't happen? How many civil liberties will you suspend, and how many cherished norms of life will you cast aside in your goal?
- bigbillheck 4y agoYou might be shocked to realize that we as a society have already taken drastic and far-reaching steps in the name of stopping preventable deaths.
- kridsdale2 4y agoDepending on your definitions, it is.
- deleted 4y ago
- randomguy0 4y agoThe one-sidedness of the comments in this thread surprise me. If you want to work remotely, don’t work at Twitter. There’s absolutely nothing wrong with Musk thinking it’s more beneficial for his employees to work in the office. He has goals and methods of working towards them. He wants likeminded people to work towards those goals. Can you really not think of pros and cons of either situation? To give my opinion, if I ran a business that I was trying to grow or trying to meet lofty goals, I’d probably have people in the office too. However, I see upsides to working from home too. I’ve been working remotely since the beginning of COVID and currently work 2,000 miles away from my work.
- aaomidi 4y agoIt’s fair to critique someone who just upended the lives of all these people.
- ajkjk 4y agoYeah, but most of the posts here aren't really critique, they're just sarcastic scorn. We get it, HN, you like remote work a lot and can't imagine any alternative.
- happytoexplain 4y agoI'm reading the same comments, and there seems to be a reasonable amount of thoughtful writing too. In addition, there are sarcastic/scornful comments in the other direction too, yours included ("We get it, HN, you like remote work a lot and can't imagine any alternative."). Try not to get focused on individual snarky comments, because doing that makes those comments a bigger part of the conversation.
- dpkirchner 4y agoI'd wager most of us can imagine alternatives because we lived alternatives. We've figured out a method that works better for us and don't want to go back to losing hours a week for what we expect will have negative value (lower productivity, happiness, etc). Further, this edict is coming from someone that is presumable working remote now (for at least one company) and will continue to do so indefinitely. It's only natural to push back on that.
- jimmypoop 4y agoWhat are the chances that Musk composed and sent this email while working remotely? Very high I reckon.
- fortuna86 4y ago100%. Rules are for other people.
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoYou can't expect getting paid and set the rules. If you don't like it, stop receiving pay, that allowes you to ignore the rules. It's fair.
- bigfudge 4y agoSome rules are not allowed. Not allowing remote work is still allowed, but I don’t think it’s far away from being socially unacceptable. Being legally unacceptable is just one step beyond that.
- ben_w 4y agoWhile true, I don't think that's pertinent. This is more of a "if you don't like it, buy the company" situation.
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoNo need to buy the company, anyone can always start a new one, it's very affordable, just a few hundred bucks. Then you can set whatever rules you want for yourself and your employees.
- fortuna86 4y agoGetting paid doesn't change the fact that the employees are the ones actually making Twitter work. If Twitter were a car, it would have an owner.
- JoeyBananas 4y ago[flagged]
- cosmiccatnap 4y agoStrangely enough I think this is the first objectively bad decision he has made since owning Twitter. The others are questionable for sure but this is a good way to lose your best engineers to companies that will respect them.
- izzydata 4y agoI think blindly firing employees with low code counts is an objectively bad decision that ignores a lot of nuance and likely lost a lot of great engineers to companies that will respect them.
- e40 4y agoThe idea that all lines of code are equal (in difficulty) is so absurd as to (in my memory) have been never discussed on HN before. Everyone here knows it. How could Elon not?
- the_doctah 4y agoIs there any evidence that people were fired based on LoC?
- fragmede 4y agohttps://twitter.com/GergelyOrosz/status/1588907407002185729#m https://twitter.com/GergelyOrosz/status/1588907407002185729#...
- bitcharmer 4y agoI've heard this before but never backed by any reputable source. Mind sharing where you got that from?
- murphyslab 4y ago> “over the next few days, the absolute top priority is finding and suspending any verified bots/trolls/spam.” Is this goodbye to @ElonJet? Also, "troll" seems rather nebulous. Is it the end for anyone seen as a troublemaker?
- jsbg 4y ago> Is this goodbye to @ElonJet? No. [0] [0] https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1589414958508691456 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1589414958508691456
- ssnistfajen 4y agoI don't think the intention is to suspend ElonJet since Musk has already explicitly said he made the choice to not suspend it despite the alleged "personal safety risk". Trolls in this case probably refers to accounts that paid for new Twitter Blue and are now impersonating well-known figures/entities. The wording seems consistent with everything going on at Twitter so far, that he's just kinda winging it while everyone else is frozen in confusion over the abrupt changes. A $44B acquisition is quickly reverting into the volatility of a 2006 startup.
- wordsarelies 4y agoSurprise! That's when he last ran a software company.
- Gud 4y agoThere's a lot of software involved in both Tesla and SpaceX. Much more advanced software then a web app.
- notfromhere 4y agoEvery company has software. That doesn’t mean a car company operates like a social network
- int_19h 4y ago
- mrobins 4y agoSurely this is partially a calculated move to further reduce headcount/expenses.
- UncleOxidant 4y agoIt probably is, but it's kind of risky if you end up pissing off employees who are key to your operations and top performers. Those folks can easily find work elsewhere. You end up with the people who can't easily move elsewhere.
- mirekrusin 4y agoIf you are key top performer, surely you can get approval to work remotely, no?
- bigfudge 4y agoProbably. But you might not want to work at a place where this is at the whim of a manager. Or where your non rock star colleagues are treated like shit.
- mcgannon2007 4y agoNot necessarily... https://www.engadget.com/an-apple-machine-learning-director-resigned-over-its-office-return-policy-115040691.html https://www.engadget.com/an-apple-machine-learning-director-... And in this specific case, Elon's pride may make him see everyone as replaceable.
- boatsie 4y agoMany other companies are laying off now, and FAANG is in a hiring freeze. Sellers market right now for employment.
- greedo 4y agoDoes Musk value developers? Considering his "code review" the first week, and how poorly FSD at Tesla functions, (I know it's an extremely difficult, if not insurmountable problem) I think he has a very simplistic idea of how to both evaluate and motivate developers.
- thih9 4y agoThis can’t not result in some hidden maintenance or security problems. Half of the people left and the other half has been told to brace for difficult times, it doesn’t sound like good conditions for smooth continuous operation.
- manjose2018 4y agoWhatsapp had 1B users with far fewer eng, why is Twitter so big? Here is my back of the envelope math of how big I think the company should be for their main offering. Over the past years Twitter has acquired a ton of companies, but I'm going to leave them out of this equation. Eng (250) =========== Backend/Storage: 100 eng Subscriptions: 50 Front-End: 50 eng iOS App: 20 eng Android App: 20 eng UX: 10 Abuse/Moderation (200) ========================= Abuse: 100 Moderation: 100 Marketing/Sales (210) ======================= PR/Marketing: 30 Ad Sales: 180 Mgmt/overhead (40) ===================== Legal/GDPR/compliance: 20 HR/Recruiting : 10 CEO/CFO/etc.: 10 What do you think? How far off am I? If more people turn to subscriptions perhaps the abuse/moderation team will shrink in the future.
- ssnistfajen 4y agoTwitter isn't the same product(s) as Whatsapp. That difference is noticeable within 1 minute of opening both applications.
- mrweasel 4y agoYes, WhatsApp seem more complex. In all seriousness, I think many of us are falling into the trap that the PayPal guy fell into. Twitter isn't just the app and the website. So it's much harder to run and maintain than it seems like from the outside. If it was just the Tweets, why would they ever need more than 10 iOS developers for instance? If we cut Twitter into what it is on the surface, and perhaps lose some data retention, then sliming down the engineering organization significantly should be possible with the right people. Not to 50, that's really low for a platform the size of Twitter. That being said: 7500 employees is also way to many for what they do, or at least for how little money they make.
- ssnistfajen 4y ago>Yes, WhatsApp seem more complex. K. Nobody asked Musk to acquire the company. The only reason it went through is thanks to a long line of court rulings starting with Dodge v. Ford Motor Co. that prioritized shareholder interest over every other stakeholders. You can't expect to practically traumatize a company's culture like this and expect all the "right people" to still stay here and give their 100%.
- boredtofears 4y agoI have to admit if I was an executive and I watched one of those "day in the life of" tiktoks from twitter employees that show them spending maybe 20% of their day doing work and the other 80% enjoying company amenities I might be considering tightening things up as well.
- adwn 4y agoThat video was recorded while being at the office. If anything, it's evidence against the supposed effectiveness of forbidding remote work.
- boredtofears 4y agoRight. I mean, bringing back everyone to the office would just be a part of the tightening, which is quite obviously happening with Musk's reign.
- the_doctah 4y agoNot every office is a daycare for Gen Z complete with wine on tap. SV workers are spoiled.
- kevingadd 4y ago'20% of the day doing work and 80% enjoying company amenities' is ridiculous hyperbole. even if a hypothetical employee is doing that, putting them in the office clearly isn't enough to fix it since they supposedly put a tiktok video up saying 'i don't do my job' and they weren't fired
- boredtofears 4y agoIt's not hyperbole, unless whoever was recording was being hyperbolic. It's not exactly hard to find the videos I'm talking about.
- kweingar 4y agoIf we were watching the same videos, they showed themselves getting lunch, getting coffee, going to the gym, and hanging out on the roof. None of these videos suggested that these activities totaled anywhere close to 6 hours in a day. Maybe we're watching different videos though.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoThe job climate is such, with lots of SV layoffs, that this requirement will probably work now where it wouldn't have worked six months ago (engs would have jumped from Twitter to another SV co)
- slantedview 4y agoA lot of Twitter employees live nowhere near SV, or even an office. The only way to interpret this is that Musk either wants to force more people to leave, or doesn't realize that they're going to leave as a result of this move.
- the_doctah 4y agoAbsolutely. My employer weaponized the job market to force RTO in the same way. They were visibly terrified to force RTO when the market was hot.
- wordsarelies 4y agoThis kinda thing is great for the "remote work at all hours" is the erzats demon keeping software companies alive. If it is, we'll likely see some downtime, lots of typical E company results (burned out software folks, higher turnover than is industry standard, and much lower pay since Elon doesn't negotiate at silicon valley salary expectations at any of his companies... If in 2 years Twitter isn't significantly smaller (think 1500 people) and significantly cheaper to run I'd be surprised. If in 2 years twitter isn't the worst place to work in the valley I'd also be surprised.
- slantedview 4y agoAlso, if in 2 years, Twitter's revenue isn't a fraction of what it was just before the Musk takeover, I'd be surprised.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- voxl 4y agoTwitter is going to not exist in 2 years. The financials make no sense, and we already have influencers making fun of subscribers. Subscribing is not only going to create a dichotomy that drives away "economy-of-scale" users but it's going to quickly gain a reputation of being "lame."
- dusing 4y agoCare to wager?
- jimt1234 4y agoIf, in 1 year (or less), Twitter headquarters isn't moved to Texas, I'd be surprised.
- csmpltn 4y agoHere's a cool and perhaps unforeseen hypothetical turn-of-events: 100% of Twitter's staff give their resignation letter on Friday, and don't show up to work. Leadership wakes up to a collapsing platform, a 44 billion USD bill to pay, with no one to keep the lights on or answer the PagerDuty alerts. Play stupid games, win stupid prizes? No time for silly "knowledge transfers", or "onboarding new team members". You just wake up to learn everybody left and you're left with nothing.
- kleiba 4y agoFriday afternoon: 100% of Twitter's staff are competing with each other to find a new job.
- loloquwowndueo 4y agoCompeting with 11k people fired from Meta. FTFY
- jreese 4y ago... and everyone laid off from Meta this week ...
- csmpltn 4y agoHalf of them were already fired (more will probably follow), and the rest will be messed with for months (if not years) to come (as is evident by the email being discussed here). Having nothing to lose...
- grumple 4y ago370k software engineer jobs listed on linkedin right now. So each person laid off from these companies gets to choose between 10 open roles at other companies. And that's just what's listed on linkedin; most jobs aren't.
- cableshaft 4y agoThere aren't 370k jobs paying FAANG or near-FAANG compensation and benefits. Probably about 10% of that is paying anywhere near what Twitter employees are used to getting. I'm making close to the low end of an entry level software engineer at Twitter according to levels.fyi, and I'm making above average for senior software engineers in my region, based on recruiter/job posting salary ranges and posted salaries on these websites. Haven't gotten a regional recruiter offering anything competitive in the past year since I started this job. Also the unlisted jobs paying anywhere near Twitter level compensation is probably close to 0%, so no need to add them to the mix.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vooner 4y agoBorn with an emerald spoon in his mouth, it's no surprise that Musk has no empathy with the common worker. On top of his ridiculous level of wealth, he has an absurdly large ego to go with it, and an army of turd-polishers ready to laud everything he does. This guy is too big-headed to fail.
- philistine 4y agoLet's not mince words, and talk about his real world lived experience: he treats people like apartheid-era South Africa.
- renewiltord 4y agoAh yes. Little is known about apartheid-era SA but the one thing we all know is that when you were fired, they paid you for 2 months and provided healthcare.
- seaman1921 4y agotake people out of their comfy lives for 2 days and they feel their petty problems are comparable to apartheid-era SA
- renewiltord 4y agoIf you think about it, when Nelson Mandela was in Victor Verster Prison, even they didn't make him pay for a blue check.
- sirbutters 4y agoI know, right? We all know Musk is a good guy and would continue to offer generous packages, even if he could get away with not offering anything.
- coffeeblack 4y agoRemote work is about the only thing where I very much disagree with Musk. I get it for engineering physical things. But not for web software. In that area, remote works much better than in-office, at least for me.
- erulabs 4y agoI agree, but I think either full on-site or fully remote are both leagues better than partially remote. Partially remote is far worse than either - because now all the in-person tactics exclude the remote folks, and all the remote work tactics are an unnecessary burden to the in-office folks. An all-remote team of heads-down engineers is 99% as good as in-person, if not better, because now all the communication has been written down and recorded.
- chrisco255 4y agoNevermind that in a partial remote scenario, like anywhere from 20-80% of the staff are wfh on any given day.
- ghaff 4y agoIn fairness, that's on teams to manage. Coordination is possible.
- ben_w 4y agoIronically, the Tesla robots would (with a VR headset) enable physical-thing workers to work remotely.
- coffeeblack 4y agoThat would be really cool, but probably still a while before that actually works on a large scale. Let alone before the Tesla robot actually works. I am less optimistic about the time it takes to develop it.
- 4y ago
- cr4nberry 4y agowhy would anyone want to work for this asshole? It's not like the employees are well paid compared to other companies. If I wanted to get fisted, I'd just go to amazon and get a bigger check for it
- boatsie 4y agoExcept Amazon is in a hiring freeze. Musk knows now is the time to make “unreasonable” demands.
- kleiba 4y agoPrior to Musk’s arrival, Twitter had established a permanent work-from-anywhere arrangement for its workers ...for some definition of the word "permanent".
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoUpdated to "work-from-anywhere in the building" now. With half of the staff gone you can claim any empty desk or office in sight, I hear the CISO and chief compliance officer's spots are open!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- aeyes 4y agoDid you sign a new contract making your work location "remote"? If not then it was never going to be permanent.
- ghaff 4y agoIn the US at least, even if you're categorized as remote, the company can almost certainly pull you back to an office and fire you if you won’t. It probably wouldn't be considered as "for cause" (IANAL) but a company can pretty much unilaterally change work conditions, responsibilities, etc. so long as no labor laws are violated.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bogota 4y agoReally feel bad for anyone who went out and bought a house in another place or made life decisions based on this policy which is likely a lot of people. This is really showing that you don’t respect or care about your employees which is par for the course for musk. However i think what he is forgetting is that Twitter isn’t some amazing challenge to solve like self driving or rockets. I think you will see a very understaffed twitter in the future.
- esalman 4y agoTwitter is going down. The question is whether it will take Musk down with it.
- fundad 4y agoHe's been embarrassing himself for a minute already but the answer isn't definitely no. What I realized is he saw contraction in demand at Tesla and wanted a public pretense to sell some without triggering a panic. He had all the Tesla projections long before his tweet about feeling "super bad" about the economy. This deal turned funny money into feeling like a club promoter.
- viraptor 4y agoWhat do you mean about selling some? He didn't get anything out for himself by effectively putting them up for Twitter collateral. He's effectively setting them on fire and causing panic. He'd cause less panic by saying "I need to sell some because I wanted to buy a small country".
- elorant 4y agoTesla's stock is down 30% the last couple of months. So my guess is it probably will.
- dusing 4y agoWhile the rest of tech a d the stock market are way up this year!
- viraptor 4y agoThe real question is, will it last longer than the lettuce though... https://lettuce.wtf/ https://lettuce.wtf/
- sdze 4y agoI can only hope Elon goes bankrupt. He and his man-child-fans are the most obnoxious people on this planet.
- 4y ago
- throw__away7391 4y agoRegardless of the merits of remote/office or what this announcement would mean at a normal company, it sounds like it must be pure chaos at Twitter right now.
- mirekrusin 4y agoHalf the chaos, smart.
- Tomis02 4y agoIs this a running meme, where whenever people like Musk or Trump do something silly, someone comes along and spins it to something positive and then says "smart"? I've seen this happen several times and I wonder if I'm just out of the loop.
- bmitc 4y agoI'd imagine it's been chaos ever since Musk started this whole deal months ago.
- jdcaron 4y agoThis guy is a car salesman, no wonder he wants to force an in office working policy.
- madrox 4y agoI see we're still deep in the "fuck around" stage and have yet to reach "find out."
- marcosdumay 4y agoIt's good that he is throwing every known bad practice that managers keep practicing on it to ensure he will find out the correct result. But he has mixed so many stupid bullshit at this point that I expect people to refuse to learn any lesson from it, always blaming the problem at some different action.
- quotemstr 4y agoWhat if the allegedly bad result doesn't ensue?
- bombcar 4y agoKeep prophesying that it will or quietly drop it is the usual method.
- the_doctah 4y agoThis will all be memory holed and never spoken of again
- Exuma 4y ago
- sdd232332 4y ago
- Exuma 4y agoOk first comment guy
- DoctorDabadedoo 4y agoYou could do the same with your snarky and unpolite comments. This is not a place for free harassment.
- benlivengood 4y agoAmusing that as CEO/Owner of >1 company there's no way for Musk to "work in the office". Will he fire himself?
- rgovostes 4y ago> over the next few days, the absolute top priority is finding and suspending any verified bots/trolls/spam. Would it improve the situation to simply require a CAPTCHA once per day per non-subscriber to tweet? I would think it would greatly increase the cost to operate a troll farm, but have minimal impact on real users (setting aside accessibility and third-party clients a moment). If it causes attrition because some people decide it's not worth two seconds of clicking fire hydrants to voice their thought, nothing of value was lost.
- Balgair 4y agoNot a bad idea, but, like, Elon's just gonna change his mind again by next week.
- geoffeg 4y ago"We've dispatched a Tesla Model 3 to your current browser's location. To verify you are not a robot you must drive it for one hour and achieve a better Safety Score than the built-in autopilot is capable of achieving."
- Matheus28 4y agoCaptcha solvers charge less than $4 per 1000 solved captchas. It'd likely still be worth it to do that sort of spam.
- sergeym 4y ago
- Balgair 4y agoI think that the NYT article has the much better lede from the emails in it: Due to resignations by 3 top execs yesterday, engineers are now likely to have to make sure that their code is compliant with the FTC w.r.t. the 2011 judgement against Twitter. As in, there is a good chance that individual SWEs at Twitter are going to be legally culpable for violations. Even if I am totally misreading that quick lede about dense legalese (likely), it still says that Twitter currently has no reasonable way to stay in the FTC's good graces for the foreseeable future. Y'all, don't try to appease a billionaire and get yourself in legal trouble. Don't even try to chance it. Walk away.
- fermentation 4y agoHow does that work? If a SWE isn't aware of the gazillion laws surrounding their code, why isn't the company liable when X of those laws are inevitably violated? What about the people who review the code? Or the people who wrote the systems that push the code?
- badwolf 4y agoIt seems Musk's new legal "department" is wanting developers to self-certify - put their own name on the certification. https://www.theverge.com/2022/11/10/23451198/twitter-ftc-elon-musk-lawyer-changes-fine-warning https://www.theverge.com/2022/11/10/23451198/twitter-ftc-elo...
- leftcenterright 4y agoLooking at how complex Twitter's internal systems appear to be based on Mudge's report [1], I doubt informed developers would dare certify things they do not fully understand. Depends a bit on what entity (system, service, environment) they have to certify. > In January 2022, Mudge determined and reported to the executive team that (because of poor engineering architecture decisions that preceded Mudge's employment) Twitter had over 300 corporate systems and upwards of 10,000 services that might still be affected, but Twitter was unable to thoroughly assess its exposure to Log4j and did not have capacity, if pressed in a formal investigation, to show to the FTC that the company had properly remediated the problem. > Mudge knew that the actual underlying data showed that at the end of 2021, 51 % of the ~ 11 thousand full-time employees had privileged access to Twitter's production systems, a 5% increase from the 46% of total employees in February of 2021 that Mudge had shared in his initial findings delivered to the Board in early 2021 1. https://techpolicy.press/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/whistleblower_disclosure.pdf https://techpolicy.press/wp-content/uploads/2022/08/whistleb...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kisstheblade 4y agoWhat happened to Musk's claim "I don't care about the economics at all"? Sure seems to be top priority.
- rurp 4y agoMan, I'm starting to think that you can't take this guy at his word.
- p0pcult 4y agoThey should all quit, demonstrate who actually holds the power.
- thr0wawayf00 4y agoAccording to leaked email on CNBC, Musk said that Twitter needs 50% of its revenue to be subscriptions in order to surivive: > That is why the priority over the past ten days has been to develop and launch Twitter Blue Verified subscriptions (huge props to the team!). Without significant subscription revenue, there is a good chance Twitter will not survive the upcoming economic downturn. We need roughly half of our revenue to be subscription. Is that even remotely feasible? Based on the commentary I've seen, Twitter Blue is going to be a drop in the bucket compared to their total revenue.
- klodolph 4y agoRevenue of $5bn. Let’s say that you burn half of it down, so you’re making $2.5bn with ads, and $2.5bn with subscriptions. If there 200M DAU, then that means you want to make $12.5/year, per user, for subscriptions. I don’t see how that would be possible, even under the most wildly optimistic scenarios.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> According to leaked email on CNBC, Musk said that Twitter needs 50% of its revenue to be subscriptions in order to surivive [...] Is that even remotely feasible? Yes, Musk can plausibly drive off enough advertisers to get advertising revenue down to parity with subscription revenue. Don't see how it helps Twitter survive, though.
- rbetts 4y agoQ2 revenue was $1.18B on 237.8M mDAU. If they want $590M (50%) in subscription revenue, that's 24.5M subscriptons @ $24 per quarter. So they'd need to convert about 10% of the reported mDAU to subscribers? https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/twitter-announces-second-quarter-2022-results-301591530.html https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/twitter-announces-s...
- micromacrofoot 4y agoSome people at Twitter have remote work in their employment contract.
- cbtacy 4y agoAnd Musk has repeatedly demonstrated that he has no respect for legal contracts.
- gist 4y agoA legal contract is only as good as someone's ability to enforce it. Otherwise the idea that it's some kind of a bond and companies or people should or do just 'the right thing' is not unfortunately reality. I would not say he has any more or less respect for legal contracts than any other 'typical' company or business person (from my experience).
- s1artibartfast 4y agoThose same contracts allow that employees can be let go. It's not really the gotcha people think it is.
- micromacrofoot 4y agoThe couple people I knew with remote work in their contracts actually want to be let go at this point, wasn't saying it was a gotcha — but they'll need to renegotiate or be terminated.
- slg 4y agoLet's say you run a company and you want to reduce staff. Let's also say you want to make an unpopular decision (or multiple unpopular decisions) that you know will drive a certain percentage of your staff to leave the company. Wouldn't it make the most sense to announce those decisions before making layoffs? Let people self select whether they want to stay and work for you and then make your layoffs after to ensure all teams are properly staffed. Instead, Musk has already laid people off to the point that they are trying to hire back people previously laid off and current employees are sleeping in the office. Now he is pushing even more people out the door with no control over what teams will be hurt the hardest.
- boatsie 4y agoI think you have it backwards. This is how you accomplish a 75% reduction while only having to lay off (and pay severance for) 50%! Musk again playing 4d chess.
- warinukraine 4y agoNo, you have it backwards. If you wanted 75% reduction while only having to lay off 50%, you make the unpopular decision _first_, and then the lay offs.
- etothepii 4y agoIndeed, that means you only have to pay 25% while achieving a 75% reduction. Though it's hard to believe there's a game plan here. However, I have a suspicion that there is a certain type of person with low self esteem and high intelligence that will respond very well to being treated this badly.
- gamblor956 4y agoForcing people who were told they can work fully remote in their employment agreement to work in the office is treated as a constructive dismissal in the U.S. As this constructive dismissal is clearly part of the mass layoffs, they would also be subject to the 60 days notice under the WARN Act (or 60 days pay to waive notice).
- throwaway0x7E6 4y agocovid is over. it's been over the day we got something else we are supposed to be agitated about. at this point, it feels like a distant memory. nobody cares or pretends to care about it anymore. so why shouldn't we go back to the old normal?
- happytoexplain 4y ago"Why shouldn't we go back" doesn't have any more weight than "why shouldn't we stay". The old normal relies on the acceptance of a lot of life-time wasted and a certain amount of misery, and people were increasingly unwilling to accept it. The pandemic simply provided an impetus - that's all.
- nimih 4y agoIt's possible that a lot of office workers have decided they have good reasons to prefer working from home beyond the highly contagious airborne disease. I know that I personally have, but further research is probably necessary to determine whether this is a widespread trend.
- system2 4y agoMost companies already realized remote working doesn't work out. Hard to admit but it is the truth.
- watwut 4y ago> so why shouldn't we go back to the old normal? Because we like the new normal.
- c9da4a 4y agoLiving in a city is unpayable, roads are congested at peak hours, the environmental damage from commuting, etc
- spaniard89277 4y agoIve got covid last friday at my office. Large gathering of people without proper ventilation. Now my company has to pay me while I'm laying in bed writing this as I'm not capable of doing much useful. Im not a dev but a technician, I just solve tickets throug a computer. We never were more prodictive not had so much income. What was the point? I won't sabotage this company but honestly, all companies doing this feel like they play their employees because they can. If they want to treat me like this, then I don't see why should care about the business and not try to game the system as much as I can. It's been hard because I have a work ethic, but cmon.
- solardev 4y agoMaybe Musk just likes explosions. Rockets, batteries, Twitter...
- VLM 4y agoInteresting strategic window: You can't innovate and software engineer using 1950s style "butts in seats". Maybe this is a signal twitter isn't going to innovate, develop, and maybe even operate, internally, at least going forward. You need code for a new feature? Buy a startup that already wrote it. You need to keep something running? Contract out instead of employees. Very few companies have a full time plumber or carpenter or electrician on staff (except for obvious obscure exceptions of course). He might be planning bigger changes than people seem to think. What fundamentally does twitter do? Sell ads by moving data around using enormous first mover advantage of account numbers. And that needs a huge employee count why exactly? I am not asking that it did, or it did in the early days of the technology, or what the competitors do. All industries, after the heavy employment phase, move into a value extraction phase. He seems to be betting on the heavy employment phase being over for tweeting. Honestly the only question is timing, is he just right or too early? Maybe tweeting is now like railroads or heavy industry, no longer employs entire neighborhoods or even cities. Maybe SV is about to become the new Detroit.
- snapcaster 4y ago>Interesting strategic window: You can't innovate and software engineer using 1950s style "butts in seats" what is this statement based on?
- alfiedotwtf 4y agoFactory production lines
- jmiskovic 4y agoWhy call it 1950s style when it was most common mode of operation up to 2019? Elon already insisted Tesla engineers work on-site, so this move isn't too surprising. What leaves me puzzled is why would anyone decide to work there. Where's the carrot?
- muro 4y agoI guess the pay is the carrot. As long as they pay well for the requirements, there will be plenty people to take it. And if the job market deteriorates, they might not even need to pay that well...
- alistairSH 4y agoSo, he fires thousands of them while hob-knobbing with other billionaires on the other side of the country. And his first company-wide communication is rescinding previous WFH policies without much reason. What an absolute knob. Edit to add... He demanded a company-wide all-hands on one hours notice, then appeared 15 minute late. I hope every employee worth their salary walks, Twitter implodes, and Musk loses much of his fortune and all of his cachet. What a narcissistic asshole.
- VBprogrammer 4y agoIt's an interesting look from someone claiming to believe that climate change is one of the biggest threats to humanity. Better get those expensive developers working from the office again so they keep buying expensive electric cars...
- SQueeeeeL 4y agoIsn't the Hyperloop regularly derided by those in the environmental community for distracting from more useful/environmentally sustainable transit solutions. Tesla also bifurcated the charger ports on the market, which has slowed adoption of EV chargers by businesses. Definitely a more complicated relationship than a surface level analysis would imply
- afiori 4y ago> Tesla also bifurcated the charger ports on the market Not to defend Elon practices in general, but I believe Tesla chargers precede the standard ports in the US (and possibly in the EU) I do not know whether Elon refused to open the standard or whether that was even considered. the youTube channel Common Sense Skeptic has eloquent criticisms with little fluff: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCgKWj1pn3_7hRSFIypunYog https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCgKWj1pn3_7hRSFIypunYog
- bmitc 4y agoI saw a stat recently that an electric car removes about as much emissions as a meter of road adds. Electric cars are the most overblown response to climate change. They will help in a myopic way when comparing directly to combustion cars over several years (electric cars only start to save emissions somewhere between them being driven 6-24 months into their ownership), but I doubt it's much more than that and even possibly a net increase in emissions in terms of furthering the dominance of the car. Elon Musk doesn't care about anything other than his ego.
- ben7799 4y agoIt feels like remote work is a distraction here.. it's more like Musk realizes he bought a company that was in a lot more trouble than anyone out in the public can understand and he's scrambling for anything. Everyone is all worried about what this means for remote work at other companies when it might not mean anything at all since the other companies don't have the same circumstances as Twitter. Also we're all defensive cause we're attached to remote work.
- cragfar 4y agoIt's weird how people are trying to divine his actions. He's been against remote work at every point. He tried to keep the Tesla offices open when the Covid Lockdowns were starting.
- bmitc 4y agoI think he's been pretty against anything that doesn't treat workers as automatons.
- bink 4y ago> it's more like Musk realizes he bought a company that was in a lot more trouble than anyone out in the public can understand Or he bought a company and by doing so placed it in a lot more trouble than it was previously.
- ben7799 4y agoThis seems to be the popular view, everyone has been irrationally cheering for Twitter for 10+ years now but it ignores twitter's long term financial results as we head into an economic contraction. That's the whole thing.. Musk made his stupid public decision to buy Twitter before the economic winds shifted. By the time it closed things had changed. He harmed Twitter by the way the whole thing dragged out, but Twitter was damaged goods anyway and has become more damaged by the economic winds in addition to Musk. Twitter was betting the farm that investors would continue to ignore the bottom line and money would continue to be easy and valuations would continue to be decoupled from results.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 4y agoFrom the NYT article: "On Wednesday, three top Twitter executives responsible for security, privacy and compliance also resigned, according to two people familiar with the matter and internal documents seen by The Times. The departing executives include Lea Kissner, Twitter's chief information security officer; Damien Kieran, its chief privacy officer; and Marianne Fogarty, its chief compliance officer. Their resignations came a day ahead of a deadline for Twitter to submit a compliance report to the Federal Trade Commission, which is overseeing privacy practices at the company as part of a 2011 settlement. Twitter has typically reviewed its products for privacy problems before rolling them out to users, to avoid additional fines from the F.T.C. and remain in compliance with the settlement. But because of a rapid pace of product development under Mr. Musk, engineers could be forced to "self-certify" so that their projects meet privacy requirements, one employee wrote in an internal message seen by The Times. "Elon has shown that he cares only about recouping the losses he's incurring as a result of failing to get out of his binding obligation to buy Twitter," the employee wrote. The changes to Twitter's F.T.C. reviews could result in heavy fines and put people working for the company at risk, the person warned." https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/10/technology/elon-musk-twitter-employees.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/11/10/technology/elon-musk-twit... This may be the beginning of the end for "social media" because the constantly buried truths are coming to the surface. For example, 100% advertising and 0% journalism as a "business model", web user privacy, "tech" malfeasance, and the myth of "free". Noncommercial web users are not ready to pay fees to use websites. Not all web use is commercial, nor can all web use be commercialised. Noncommercial web use is real. However the web as imagined by "tech" companies, i.e., massive data harvesting websites that produce no content, where all web usage is surveilled and all data collected is purported to have commercial value, may be more fantasy than reality.
- shagie 4y agoSome other context from a WaPo article - https://wapo.st/3ht1DYu https://wapo.st/3ht1DYu > The agency said that it was “tracking the developments at Twitter with deep concern” and that it was prepared to take action to ensure the company was complying with a settlement known as a consent order, which requires Twitter to comply with certain privacy and security requirements because of allegations of past data misuse. > Twitter was first put under a consent order in 2011 and it agreed to a new order earlier this year. If the FTC finds Twitter is not complying with that order, it could fine the company hundreds of millions of dollars, potentially damaging the company’s already precarious financial state. > ... The new decree required Twitter to start enhanced privacy and security programs, which were to be audited by a third party. Under that decree, Twitter is required to conduct a privacy assessment of any new products it launches. > ... The meltdown of the security leadership is especially fraught because an FTC audit was expected by January, according to two people familiar with the schedule. One said that Kissner and other executives had been hiring, despite a company-wide freeze, in a frantic effort to meet compliance rules before then.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jmyeet 4y agoThere is a lot I love about the Elon Twitter saga. Scoping it to this issue (remote work): 1. We all know that "butts in seats" is a form of psychological control. Yes, there can be benefits to physical proximity. For software engineers, there can be benefit for collaboration, team-building and teaching. You can do this remotely but it's more difficult. However, for a lot of jobs however there is absolutely zero benefit to the employee. 2. This should remind people that your relationship with your employer is fundamentally adversarial. Remote work, despite it saving tech companies in particular, a lot of money for office space, onsite perks, equipment and so on, sold it to you as a "benefit". It started out of necessity in the pandemic. More recently it became a compeititve necessary to draw and retain talent in a tight labor market. In an era of mass layoffs in tech that advantage is no longer needed so companies can revert to their natural state of seeking control and not offering benefits they don't have to; 3. Elon is a very old school American (ironic, considering he's South African) boss who very much rules out of fear and for whom loyalty only flows in one direction: up (to him). He is not Tony Stark or Bruce Wayne. He's just another annoying, cringey, incredibly privileged fail-son. I'm honestly glad more people are realizing this as this is not the man to deify; 4. Morale among the remaining Twitter staff must be (I would guess) incredibly bad right now. Rather than extending these people an olive branch, the Bataan death march of reshaping Twitter into Musk's soulless image continues without respite, casulaties be damned; and 5. For many this will be there first downturn market as you could easily have been in the workforce for the last 12 years without ever experiencing it. You may have bought into the idea, particularly if you're an engineer or other highly specialized position, bought into the idea that tech companies are different and/or that you aren't expendable or replaceable. None of this is true. Unfortunately, people (Americans in particular) use such rationalizations to argue against any form of labor organization as being unnecessary or that somehow they'll all be dragged down to the "average" by collective bargaining. Such ideas are just highly effective propaganda. Sorry Tweeps for all you're going through.
- elorant 4y agoAccording to the email, Musk expects subscriptions to make up to 50% of revenue. Assuming that Twitter’s revenue is around $5bn, and the subscription is at $8/month that’s some 26M subscriptions, or 5,7% of its users. I don’t think that a number so high is achievable, unless they pull a rabbit out of their hat.
- datalopers 4y agoYou're making the assumption that annualized revenue hasn't already dropped precipitously due to a loss in advertising dollars, and the bar for subscriptions to reach 50% is rapidly lowering.
- elorant 4y agoEven if you cut the conversion at half it's still too high. Realistically speaking, anything above 1% is highly optimistic.
- greedo 4y agoI'm sure he's expecting growth in both ARPU and total users.
- sangnoir 4y agoAnother way to achieve Musk's target would be to drop ad revenue numbers precipitously until it is equal to subscriptions - a process that may well be under way.
- muaytimbo 4y agoI would make them fire me, then file for unemployment.
- ok_dad 4y agoEverytime a new Commanding Officer (CO) showed up when I was in the Navy we tried to bet which type it was: 1) The kind who investigated the goings-on in the ship, interviewed the officers and chiefs, and learned how the ship was being run, then made small changes over time to optimize the operations based on what they learned. Sometimes big changes in one specific area, if it was required (like fixing the ship's crypto key material protocols, if they are super fucked up). 2) The kind who came in and ran roughshod over the whole ship, made a bunch of big changes and policy decisions, and generally acted like they owned the place in order to fulfill a pre-concieved vision they had of how things should be. With 1, we were happy because there are always improvements to an org, but the best people to know those improvements are those who know the org. These commanders always resulted in a better command overall by the end of their tenure, bar none. With 2, we were sad, because suddenly mistakes were being made everywhere in order to try and fit into the "vision", and thus reduced morale due to the massive changes and the constant failures. I saw 2 of these and both failed miserably and brought the command down lower than it should/could have been. One of those was on a great ship that performed so flawlessly that we were always sent on the most important assignments, and after I left I learned the ship fell into disrepair and could no longer even get underway, due to mismanagement. That guy came in and basically made me decide to get an early re-assignment and 3 of my friends on that ship left the Navy completely because of him.
- hallway_monitor 4y agoThe difference here is the ship is not running smoothly at all according to the new commander. It is a change in course and I think it's pretty obvious Elon wants to get rid of the people who won't be on board with the new plan. This change is one more opportunity for those dissidents to leave and for those that stay to build a better team.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- adamredwoods 4y agoMarissa Mayers and Yahoo in 2013: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2013/feb/25/yahoo-chief-bans-working-home https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2013/feb/25/yahoo-chi... https://sg.finance.yahoo.com/news/marissa-mayer-defends-her-famous-002940476.html https://sg.finance.yahoo.com/news/marissa-mayer-defends-her-...
- sdze 4y agoInteresting aspect. So this could mean the beginning of the end of Twattr.
- nomagicbullet 4y agoI hope our leaders are measuring the right things. It's discouraging to read how Mayers came to her decision to ban remote work. > She said the decision stemmed from her first few months at Yahoo, when she was spending a couple of hours every day in the cafeteria talking to any employee who wanted to chat. Selection bias. > Mayer decided on the ban after spending months frustrated at how empty Yahoo parking lots were and consulting Yahoo’s VPN logs to see if remote employees were checking in enough. Confirmation bias. Both clear examples of cognitive bias: reading into easily accessible data as a proxy for relevant valid data and using it to justify decisions.
- sytelus 4y agoDuring pandemic there was published paper (in nature?) that collected and analyzed thousands of employee data and arrived at same conclusion. It’s hard to stay disciplined when working remotely, apparently. However, I don’t think remote-only startups suffers from same issue. Moving traditional office employee to remote suddenly would be problematic unless there was a proper training for setting up home office, meeting etiquette, setting up cultural expectations etc.
- smeagull 4y agoSeems like you'd end remote work before firing everybody, because now you have no idea if you're going to be able to keep the people you thought you could. If you were planning these moves of course.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Thorentis 4y agoIt's an employers market right now. With 11k laid off from Meta, and thousands more across tech, Twitter will have no issue finding staff if it needs them (assuming this decision causes even more to leave). I'm not convinced that Twitter actually needs more than 1k staff though. 100 infrastructure engineers, 600 platform engineers, and 300 support staff should be all it takes to run a lean ship doing what Twitter does.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI said before: "His company. He can do whatever he wants." That said, good luck with all that Elon. Unless the goal is to sink Twitter down, in which case it is a brilliant move, there is zero reason for RTO.
- FredPret 4y agoAka, “please resign en masse”
- codingdave 4y agoI've got to imagine that some of their revenue losses in advertising are due to the fact that various companies/brands simply don't want to be associated with Musk in the slightest. If he was serious about ad revenue, he'd also be serious about Twitter's branding. Note that I'm not saying there are no Musk fans in the world - there are. But he is divisive, which is a trait not beneficial when trying to strengthen your brand.
- PUSH_AX 4y agoI'm just confused why anyone would still want to work there. I don't know what the local markets are like but my priority would be to jump ship at all costs.
- abxytg 4y agoOr -- he's stupid.
- appleflaxen 4y agoHe is bipolar, which I think is a more plausible answer. Can a person really become the richest person on earth being stupid? Maybe, but I think it strains credulity a bit.
- scarface_74 4y agoSeeing that by no reasonably objective measure should Tesla be worth what it is, maybe he is just a good marketer. I’m not saying that “marketing” alone made Tesla successful. I am saying that it made the stock valuable.
- panick21_ 4y agoTesla made almost the same profit as Toyota last Quarter. While having a much, much better position in terms of debts and company value. And while the company is still growing at incredibly rates each quarter. All this while major competitors are shrinking. The Tesla stock really only went up when they had proved they had cracked mass production of the Model 3 and were making an electric vehicle at industry leading margins. One can argue Tesla stock is still to high, but its certainty not 'objective'. Good annalists disagree and you can reach almost any valuation depending on your future assumptions.
- poszlem 4y agoWhat's stupid is people thinking that someone who successfully rules over some of the most influential companies in the world is stupid. Reminds me of all those people who claim that Trump or Putin[1] are "stupid" where in reality they just mean "I don't like them". [1] You can be a murderous dictator and not stupid, I would actually wager a guess that those people tend to actually be cleverer than average. Some applies to blood-thirsty CEOs.
- 4y ago
- somecommit 4y agoDo not forget that twitter purchased Vine and shoot it off, just in order to enable Tiktok taking over. That's not a very smart company for sure.
- jedberg 4y agoThe number one result when you search for Twitter on HN: Twitter Will Allow Employees to Work at Home Forever (buzzfeednews.com) 2953 points by minimaxir on May 12, 2020 | hide | past | favorite | 1353 comments https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23155647 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23155647
- throwayyy479087 4y agoI’ve been told many times that Twitter is a private company and can do whatever it wants. Or does that only apply to the Red team?
- baobabKoodaa 4y agoDoes "whatever it wants" include making contractual promises and then breaking them? Because I wasn't aware private companies had the right to rescind contracts at will.
- paxys 4y agoWell legally speaking in the US they do have that right.
- baobabKoodaa 4y agoAha. What are contracts for, then, exactly?
- paxys 4y agoNo such thing as a contract in an at-will employment setting. The company can fire you at any time. They can amend your employment terms at any time. You can quit at any time.
- RavingGoat 4y agoLots of spineless throwaway accounts in these threads
- fnordpiglet 4y agoIs there any reason for anyone to stay at twitter? I’ve not seen Musk offer any upside anywhere to remaining. He’s laying out a stark plan of hard work and fewer benefits and a brutal management. What reason other than inability to find another job (perhaps due to visa status, the hiring freezes at end of year, and layoffs) does anyone have for working at twitter now? I’m shocked if they don’t see another 50+% voluntary attrition in 2023.
- bottlepalm 4y agoEven though the pay is lower and hours longer - at his other companies they offered stock options that at least 20x’d over the past 10 years at SpaceX and Tesla. If the employees at Twitter think under Musk’s leadership that they can grow the company to 200 billion or more - then yea it’d be worth staying to collect stock that no one else can get now. Hopefully they’re giving the remaining employees generous stock awards for staying. With the user base they have there’s no reason they can’t grow the company a lot with the the right strategy. Musk has already discussed attacking YouTube directly and it sounds like he wants to expand into other social network niches. The whole X.com thing. A lot of Twitter employees could come out pretty wealthy if successful. If it were me I’d stick around a year at least to see which way this whole thing is going.
- nickstinemates 4y agoWould be interesting to know if the company is recapitalized/option pool reset and what the new deal is for the remaining employees in terms of options like a traditional startup. Would lend credence to the belief to have outsized returns for the brutality. I'd also imagine if this ends in a positive financial turnaround, against all expectations of the peanut gallery, it would be a really impressive career achievement.
- bcoughlan 4y ago> New boss wants subscriptions to account for half of revenue Bahaha, be careful what you wish for!
- 0xbadcafebee 4y ago"at least 40 hours in the office" Why would anyone work for this douche? Even if you make a lot of money, you aren't going to get your time back later. There's no reward for killing yourself to appease a rich workaholic. The only prize you win is burning out or getting laid off.
- autospeaker22 4y agoI keep thinking it'd be much cheaper for Elon to have paid to build an entirely new Twitter that has the features he's looking for. Let's say Elon had set aside a budget to hire some of the best developers he's ever worked with or heard of, and lets give them an imaginary salary of 1.5 million total comp per year, at about 10 devs for easy math. And let's say another 500k for bennies. So our operating expense for top dev talent comes out to 20 million a year. You can have an elite tier dev team, for 20 million a year that could easily build a twitter. He could've tried to interview ex-Twitter and get feedback on technical debt, pain points, problems to have fixed in the newly architect-ed model. So then you need users. Elon has 115 million followers on Twitter. He'd get users no matter what he built, so he's solved that problem too. You're correct that he wouldn't have the existing Twitter user base, but if he built a better product that is more modern and cut out some of the dead-weight features, wouldn't this option still be significantly cheaper than acquiring a company for $44 billion who only deals in software? At least apple makes products, as does amazon and at least amazon is a distribution behemoth. I struggle to see the 44 billion in value for what appears to be a relatively mundane application. In my mind I don't see anyone even spending on the order of 1 billion to build a better Twitter from scratch.
- misiti3780 4y agoAll of the people (or most of the people) that matter would not have left Twitter for Elon's new company. Tons of people have tried this. Remember Dalton Caldwell's App.net. That didn't even get off the ground and it had a ton of YC press. Network affects are real.
- autospeaker22 4y agoI think for an insane comp and equity in a new company led by Elon, lots of people would consider leaving. Network affects are real and is probably a top 10 world individual as far as the power of his network is concerned. Having a ton of YC press is way different than being Elon. Even still he could pay people to use his application. Pay businesses $20 a month for a verified business account. Pay individual users $10-100 a month based on activity and engagement. Does it scale? Absolutely not but I still think it'd end up cheaper than $44 billion.
- jrochkind1 4y agoI actually have no strong opinions about whether remote work must be allowed or not... but presumably this is going to result in more people leaving, right? Presumably he knows this, right? (Maybe he's even counting on it?). I guess this is an interesting experiment in how much staff turnover you can have at a tech company like Twitter and still do fine. I personally would not expect it to go well. Losing everyone who knows how things work and starting over from scratch with all new employees in as short a time period as possible, or even doing your best to approach that asymptote... that can't be a good idea, can it?
- dmalvarado 4y agoMust be in office. Must work at least 40 hours per week. Eliminated days of rest. As if twitter's problems are caused by "employees not working enough".
- skc 4y ago>Musk expects subscriptions to make up to 50% of revenue I've seen a lot of people calculating how many subscriptions would be required to hit this number as of today, but they're all forgetting to factor in Apple's and/or Google's cut.
- pdx6 4y agoThis whole thing is SGI syndrome. The tight knit teams that were either let go or quit Twitter will go and found the next equivalent Nvidia or Adobe. Elon is making the classic Valley blunder of trying to make a company something it's not, in this case x.com. See also AOL, Yahoo!, and Tumber. If Elon turns brings Vine back from the dead, I might have to eat my shoe however.
- eb0la 4y agoI wasn't interested in buying a Tesla. Now I won't pay for Twitter.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- AtNightWeCode 4y agoSo, this is just to get rid of more people without having to lay them off. Coaching out people is not very 2022. Will cost Twitter more than it is worth for sure.
- elif 4y agoi guess this is one way to deflate the tech bubble
- ryanSrich 4y agoWe call this a soft layoff.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hsuduebc2 4y agoOfcourse it is his company so he can do whatever he want but this man turned out to be kinda douchebag in last few years.
- joshe 4y agoWould be wonderfully ironic if Elon saves downtown SF.
- valbaca 4y agoIt's pretty obvious that Musk is willfully (or ignorantly) forcing people out of the company in order to pre-filter before layoffs. If you're at Twitter and can get a job elsewhere, don't panic. Save up, apply elsewhere, quiet-quit but DO NOT QUIT. Make them fire you or lay you off. MAKE them payout the severance! Don't let Musk toss you out for free.
- dehrmann 4y ago> MAKE them payout the severance! Most states don't require any severance. The WARN act creates de facto 60 days, but if you can keep it below the threshold or show that the firing was with cause (like if you quiet quit), it won't even count against that.
- ADuckOnQuack 4y agoYou know that “quiet quitting” just means doing the absolute requirements of your job and nothing more above and beyond right? What cause could you use? “Employee only works exact amount of hours as required in employment contract and completes average number of tasks per day” is absolutely not a just cause.
- uptownfunk 4y agoIt's a blood bath out there folks. Stay safe.
- Zafira 4y ago“The truth is, these are not very bright guys, and things got out of hand.”—All the President’s Men (1976)
- ldbooth 4y agoThe timing of this is the content - not the ending of remote work issue. It's using the news cycle and a hot button issue (end remote work) to bury the regulatory liability of the headline of the 3 chief complaince officers resignation the day before a FTC complaince filing.
- wgj 4y agoWow, it worked on me. I didn't see this until I just now searched for it. https://www.cybersecuritydive.com/news/twitter-ciso-resigns/636315/ https://www.cybersecuritydive.com/news/twitter-ciso-resigns/...
- propogandist 4y agoit's almost like the headline that was buried about Twitter and Facebook colluding with Biden's DHS to "police disinformation", where social media companies were shills for government propaganda > the director of the Election Security Initiative at CISA, recommended the use of third-party information-sharing nonprofits as a “clearing house for information to avoid the appearance of government propaganda.” https://theintercept.com/2022/10/31/social-media-disinformation-dhs/ https://theintercept.com/2022/10/31/social-media-disinformat...
- joenathanone 4y agoOk propogandist
- electrondood 4y ago"propaganda" like "please wear a mask, we have a novel airborne virus that could overwhelm our healthcare system" lol You act like it's not a big problem that social media platforms are constantly exploited by bad actors spreading disinformation at scale.
- tvaughan 4y agoThis story has been debunked, https://www.techdirt.com/2022/11/02/bullshit-reporting-the-intercepts-story-about-government-policing-disinfo-is-absolute-garbage/ https://www.techdirt.com/2022/11/02/bullshit-reporting-the-i...
- jonnycomputer 4y agoI imagine he'll still "remote work" though.
- stephc_int13 4y agoI used to naively believe in the Elon Musk hype. I started to be suspicious about his super-human intellect a few years ago. The more I dig and the more I observe his behavior, the less impressed I am, there is a huge number of red flags. I think he is much closer to Elizabeth Holmes than most people realize. I will be a financial bloodbath when the fraud will be unmasked.
- jti107 4y agogood luck hiring new software engineers
- bastardoperator 4y agoHow to speedrun a business into the ground... by Elon Muskrat
- xyst 4y agoWhat’s with this guy and hating remote work? Does he just want people to be forced to hear his ranting bullshit in a workplace?
- linuxhansl 4y agoStep 1: Buy company, load it with debt in the process. Step 2: Claim company is not profitable (partially due to the interest payments you yourself loaded onto it) Step 3: Lay off 1/2 the staff. Step 4: Try to get some of these people back, because you need some projects done (that actually happened) Step 5: Enforce unpopular and useless work rules. Step 6: Profit... Maybe? I want to believe that he knows what he is doing, but it certainly does not look that way!
- dehrmann 4y agoStep 1 is more like he bought it with a corporate version of a mortgage.
- 1attice 4y agoI would suggest he is indeed brilliant, but also a fool. Fools are often brilliant, but they are parted from their money all the same. The question is: does Musk have enough brilliance to achieve escape velocity from his folly?
- larsonnn 4y agoPlease just ignore him. Humans shouldn’t have this much money. They do the same shitty deals like people with no money but with bigger consequences.
- msie 4y agoIs it me or has Twitter not been as responsive lately?
- 1letterunixname 4y agoBecause butt-in-seat mentality, working 80 hrs a week, and moving a rocking horse really fast equals morale and productivity. Any employee with self-respect should go on strike and put their resume in somewhere else. I have the feeling Elon only makes money off people who enable him to act like a bully.
- aiwv 4y agoThe key to understanding Musk is that he truly believes that he will be the most powerful person in the world (see https://web.archive.org/web/20200725103243/https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/25/style/elon-musk-maureen-dowd.html https://web.archive.org/web/20200725103243/https://www.nytim... for his friend's take) and that he is utterly shameless and will do whatever he thinks is best in service of that destiny. One cannot take anything that he says at face value. He is a repeated and proven liar (fully self driving cars in 6 months!). When he says he wants more free speech on twitter, I think it's fair to assume the opposite. Whatever the true Elon may be, his public persona has become that of a megalomaniacal bully, not unlike the ousted troll in chief. Whether this is cynical or authentic, I want no part of any organization with him at the top. My personal theory is that he bought twitter specifically to make it his private megaphone. Owning the platform will prevent him from being turned off ala Trump. It also will allow him to silence his critics. He won't outright ban them, but by removing content moderation, he will allow those who criticize him to be harassed by his human army of troll bots until the platform becomes so toxic that they all leave. The bankers love this because twitter is also the platform where the most people are directly criticizing corporate capitalism and challenging its bedrock assumptions. They win no matter what Musk does. In silencing his critics, he will also be silencing their critics. If driving them off of twitter somehow is good for business, then they get a return on their investment. If instead it kills the platform, they can just write off their losses on their taxes. The financiers are very unlikely to actually lose any money on the deal, but the silencing of their own critics would almost certainly be worth $40B to them anyway. Now that the deal has closed, twitter is in a liminal state between life and death. Its demise has been pretty much written into the terms of the acquisition. One question that I'd pose to everyone is do you want to live in a world in which Elon Musk is the most powerful person? Do you really believe in his vision? Is it a positive vision for the world or a dystopian one? Does it reflect the worst of us or the best of us?
- Rapzid 4y agoMusk bought Twitter as a bad deal. He's way upside down on the worth vs the debt to investors and bankers. He needs to squeeze blood from a stone. The end.
- TigeriusKirk 4y agoFrom his all hands today - Employee: Why is our leadership trying to increase attrition rate if we’re already understaffed and barely able to keep things running? Musk: I’m not trying to increase attrition, but I think we are not understaffed. I think we are overstaffed. That is my opinion, which you’re welcome to disagree with.
- the-anarchist 4y agoI wish there was a way to filter 'twitter' from all incoming HTTP.
- out-of-ideas 4y agowell now he can get buy-in from other companies wanting to flex their muscles and try to get employees to not work in a distributed fashion ... (maybe a repeat though in this number of comments)
- magundu 4y agoPeople are talking about mass layoff in Twitter. But remember that,Steve Jobs did the same thing 25 years ago (after he rejoined Apple). Steve has fired 4000 people right way to reduce the expenses and hired people needed for his mission.
- loceng 4y agoIt's the fastest way to purposefully destroy whatever culture has formed (arguably poorly if the company is in its present state), and then can quickly rehire based on new, arguably better, direction; risky bet IMHO to bet against Elon with his track record of making at least more good decisions than bad ones, so far, with Tesla, SpaceX, etc.
- itsdrewmiller 4y agoThat wasn't all that similar: https://money.cnn.com/1997/03/14/technology/apple/ https://money.cnn.com/1997/03/14/technology/apple/ It was a smaller fraction of workers (30%) and was the third layoff in the past year, with the previous two happening before Jobs had even rejoined the company (and he wouldn't become CEO for 6 more months, though likely he was shadow CEO only 4 months later).
- replwoacause 4y agoMan Elon Musk is just the worst.
- mlindner 4y agoGood. Remote work is on it's way out across the industry. It causes people to not perform very well and causes slacking off (I know this of myself from personal experience). It also makes it harder for newer people to learn things and makes it feel less like you are a team and more like you're a bunch of independent people with no connection to the company.
- Jemm 4y agoDifference between Musk and Zuckerberg's handling of layoffs is striking.
- ThinkBeat 4y ago(I am on the older side on here probably) Having come from a difficult background, worked some really Shitty jobs and served in the army before I got a degree and started in tech I have been a bit shocked and a bit amused at the endless stream of less than average developers running around demanding to be treated like kings. An extreme example of demanded privilege. There has been royalty for IT and slavery for the rest. Look at how Amazon treats their factory / wearhouse workers. They dont treat the IT staff better because they are such great people. Once developers become easy to replace (should that happen) then the whip will make much more of an impression on the deposed royalty. Or we just have some layoffs, and we have a lot of comapnies hiring still and it just continues just a little less fluffing I
- nurettin 4y agoI thought Elon was making it the literal hell to work at twitter and firing everyone left and right just to appease investors, but he delisted TWTR stock from NYSE? now I'm confused.