23 ms·
Judge orders government to begin refunding more than $130B in tariffs
- pwg 9mo agoPaywalled.
- mothballed 9mo ago... refunded to the importer of record. Not the people the costs were passed to. Essentially turning it retroactively into a tax to private businesses. This is the worst case of all scenarios for the consumer.
- bdangubic 9mo agothat was the plan all along
- davidw 9mo agoThese people are evil, but also bumbling idiots, so sometimes there is no evil plan, just incompetence.
- candiddevmike 9mo agoThere are direct ties from the administration to companies offering hedges against tariffs. There was absolutely an evil plan, IMO.
- JKCalhoun 9mo agoAgree. But a few sure scrambled when they read the tea leaves and saw a chance to profit by it.
- bdangubic 9mo agothey are everything except incompetent when it comes to massively looting us and profiting.
- candiddevmike 9mo agoIt's COVID PPP all over again... Expect more asset inflation.
- NuclearPM 9mo agoTax to businesses? You think the costs were only passed down once? Really?
- coldpie 9mo agoYet another successful Republican transfer of wealth from the people who do the work (employees) to the people who don't (owners).
- adampunk 9mo ago[flagged]
- mhb 9mo agoSince the cost was probably split between reduced profit and additional customer cost, it seems pretty impractical to determine who is due a refund - end users or businesses. Or the logistics of refunds to customers. One possibility would be for businesses to return the fraction of the tariff paid by customers to future customers by offering the items affected with a negative tax until the refund is used up.
- Larrikin 9mo agoMaking people spend more money to "save" money is just a sale to increase profits even more.
- JKCalhoun 9mo ago"Since the cost was probably split between reduced profit and additional customer cost…" Ha ha, that's a good one. I have yet to hear about reduced profits anywhere. Instead, as I said in another comment, I have actual physical receipts with the additional tariff cost (itemized!) in a pile on my workshop (which I'll never see refunded).
- pwg 9mo agoIf the amounts are under the limit you might sue the company who cut those invoices in small claims court for the amounts of the tariff line items on the invoices. The invoices give you slam dunk evidence that you paid that amount in tariffs, and the supreme court decision says the payment was illegally collected, so seems like an easy win for you.
- philipallstar 9mo ago> Instead, as I said in another comment, I have actual physical receipts with the additional tariff cost (itemized!) in a pile on my workshop (which I'll never see refunded). You could ask for a tariff refund from those suppliers.
- quickthrowman 9mo ago> Since the cost was probably split between reduced profit and additional customer As someone who prices and sells labor and material for a living, nobody ate increased tariffs. They were passed along to the ultimate consumer of the tariffed product. Everyone was facing the same tariffs so they’re all incentivized to pass the cost along, line iteming the tariffs on the invoice would make it abundantly clear. I passed along all increased costs with a note on my proposal that said “Any and all additional tariffs will be paid for by the customer.”
- magicalhippo 9mo ago> refunded to the importer of record. Not the people the costs were passed to I mean the importers were the ones who paid the duties. It's not a given they passed it on, and if it was then in many cases it was spread out. That is importer paid for one container of items, which in turn got sold to individuals which the government has no record of. If you ordered delivery by say FedEx and they paid the duty and passed it on to you, you should have a reasonable case to get it refunded from FedEx when they get the money back. Ideally they handle it automatically since they have all the necessary details. For manufacturing companies it's less clear, as some might have swallowed all or some of the duties, and multiple components might have been affected by different rates etc. Will be interesting to see how companies who passed it on will handle this, given it's a massive PITA to do anything but screw over their customers.
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- toast0 9mo ago> If you ordered delivery by say FedEx and they paid the duty and passed it on to you, you should have a reasonable case to get it refunded from FedEx when they get the money back. Ideally they handle it automatically since they have all the necessary details. I didn't have to deal with it, but from other comments, most of the international shippers also charged a hefty fee to broker the tarrifs. Expect not to get that refunded.
- andyfilms1 9mo agoI understand the frustration but I don't understand the logic. The businesses who paid the tariffs (who were literally sent an invoice that they paid) should be the ones refunded. How would the government even be able to determine if a business increased product prices due to tariffs vs other factors, or even if the business increased prices at all? What if the product is a loss leader and the company was fine just eating the expense? Or what about a nefarious company who manufacturers their stuff in Canada but used "tariffs" as an excuse to increase prices? What would they be refunded from?
- coldpie 9mo agoYes, you're almost there, just go one step further. Now you've got a big pile of money and no clear rules on where it should go. Who gets to decide where it will go? Given how this administration operates, where do you think it will go?
- giancarlostoro 9mo ago> I understand the frustration but I don't understand the logic. The businesses who paid the tariffs (who were literally sent an invoice that they paid) should be the ones refunded. So if I'm the owner of Uncle Billy Bobs Autoparts and I ship from Madeupcountry. I billed you $500 extra for some new car part. The US government refunds me on the tariffs they charged me to import my product to you, and now your taxes is going into my refund. Who wins in this scenario? They're effectively giving every country a free bonus. I wouldn't be surprised if some people got scammed by the tariffs by being overcharged. There's no serious paper trail to any of this to meaningfully return lost revenue to the American consumer, I would rather not waste tax dollars on refunds. I guess the only "winners" are maybe businesses that didn't pass on the revenue loss on to the consumer? But how do you even correctly refund those businesses?
- philipallstar 9mo agoYou just refund the people who pay the tariffs. You can't do any more than that.
- giancarlostoro 9mo agoOne thing that should happen moving forward, whether we keep tariffs in one way or the other, we need consumer protection laws. I assume companies abused the "oh yeah you owe us for the tariffs" as a way to overcharge consumers. I think additional costs driven by tariffs should be 100% spelled out to the consumer next to where you're shown the tax amount. This should allow for auditing later if companies overcharge. It also would make "refunding" more reasonable, since you could show a receipt if technically you paid for a tariff, otherwise, if the company swallows it, they would show the amount but 'discount' or 'omit' it as something they are choosing to pay for. Without a paper trail I don't see how refunding any of this is feasible.
- hypeatei 9mo ago[flagged]
- chuckadams 9mo agoYou could point out the inconsistency, but I really think the cognitive dissonance of constant and pervasive hypocrisy is the point. Truth is whatever the party tells you today, and we have always been at war with EastAsia.
- ModernMech 9mo ago> we have always been at war with EastAsia Isn’t the new line that we’ve been at war with Iran for 47 years?
- lawn 9mo agoYes, that is how cults operate.
- just-working 9mo agoIt's really more complicated than this. Onshoring manufacturing is something that has to be incentivized and that has positive externalities outside of dollars and cents. But some tariffs were really dumb, like on bananas. We can't grow bananas here...
- HumblyTossed 9mo ago> But some tariffs were really dumb, like on bananas. We can't grow bananas here... Trump and his cabinet don't understand this.
- SyneRyder 9mo agoHere's a gift link to access it if you don't have a subscription: https://www.wsj.com/politics/policy/judge-orders-government-to-begin-refunding-more-than-130-billion-in-tariffs-fdc1e62c?st=r8gwJt&reflink=desktopwebshare_permalink https://www.wsj.com/politics/policy/judge-orders-government-...
- jokoon 9mo agoWhat if this was the plan, so those importers can make money?
- recursivedoubts 9mo agoin other news: https://newrepublic.com/post/206882/trump-commerce-secretary-lutnick-sons-money-end-tariffs-supreme-court https://newrepublic.com/post/206882/trump-commerce-secretary...
- happyopossum 9mo agoAlso in other news: "Amid online claims Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick’s sons, Brandon and Kyle Lutnick, senior executives at Cantor Fitzgerald, could benefit from the Supreme Court’s tariff ruling, a firm spokesperson told Newsweek it has “never executed any transactions or taken risk on the legality of tariffs."" [0] https://www.newsweek.com/howard-lutnick-sons-may-make-money-supreme-court-ruling-tariffs-11558345 https://www.newsweek.com/howard-lutnick-sons-may-make-money-...
- WarmWash 9mo agoI have a few thousand dollars that I paid to a Chinese manufacturer who then used that money to pay an importer so that I could get my materials hassle free. Looks like the hassle will now be on the backend...
- JKCalhoun 9mo agoYeah, I got the receipts even—with tariffs itemized. I'll never see that money.
- JoblessWonder 9mo agoOne of our vendors started charging a 10% tariff fee for parts ordered from Switzerland... we passed that fee directly on to our customers as a line item. I can't imagine the headache when (not if) they come to us expecting a refund for that.
- dtech 9mo agoI work in the customs industry. What you are describing was a common scheme (DDP Incoterms) to evade the tariffs (partially), and there is a carve out of the refunds that explicitly says DDP will not be refunded. So there's s chance you get nothing back. Also contractually you didn't pay the duties so you wouldn't get refunds.
- general_reveal 9mo ago[flagged]
- estearum 9mo ago...? No, this is the consequence of having an actual stupid person in the Oval Office and the majority party being half coerced and half committed in cultlike devotion to POTUS. Obviously the US has economic weapons. It's the largest economy in the world. If anything this signals that POTUS himself cannot wield those weapons though, and the American public, political, and business apparatuses have little appetite for this use of those weapons.
- Covzire 9mo ago[flagged]
- general_reveal 9mo ago[flagged]
- estearum 9mo agoOkay, I'll entertain it. How would you distinguish between the brilliant move of using illegal tariffs to disclose limited power and appetite for tariffs, versus someone displaying a 3rd grader level of economic understanding and saying "well of course we should charge people to sell stuff in 'my store' and I am now the manager of 'the store', so I get to set the rate"? What specific pieces of evidence do you believe makes the former more likely than the latter? +1 on nukes, though MAD has worked for decades so far. I agree people think this risk is far more remote than it actually is. Especially the risk of a catastrophic accident as nukes proliferate and forces get put on higher readiness.
- satvikpendem 9mo agoCantor Fitzgerald, formerly led by Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and is now run by his son, went to various companies that were affected by tariffs and bought the rights to their potential tariff refunds for 20% of the value on the expectation that it'd be struck down by the courts. Now they stand to make huge returns of 3 to 5x for being correct on that bet, while, of course, consumers get nothing. Now if this isn't insider trading (by the literal Commerce Secretary), I don't know what is.
- rbanffy 9mo agoI believe, with huge disappointment, that this level of corruption has been normalised in this administration and that nothing will come out of this.
- candiddevmike 9mo agoYea, I'm done hearing "the wheels of justice turn slowly..." bullshit. People have had their lives ruined, far quicker, for far less.
- jacquesm 9mo agoThe wheels of justice don't turn at all once you reach $1B or so. Their speed is essentially inversely proportional to the net worth of the individual under scrutiny. And if you're really rich you get to buy your own laws through a thing called lobbying. So you will get even more rich.
- coldpie 9mo agoLife in prison for every single person working under this administration is the moderate position.
- amanaplanacanal 9mo agoAfter this is all over, we probably need to do something about presidential pardon power. Getting a constitutional amendment through is hard, but I don't see another option.
- NickC25 9mo agoPrivate businesses get refunded and a payday, prices for the consumer stay high (because consumers have proven that they can bear them), and inflation goes up. Clearly, this makes America great again. /s
- ranger_danger 9mo agoWhat if lowering prices actually resulted in enough extra sales that it provided more profit?
- yndoendo 9mo agoI recommend _Alchemy: The Surprising Power of Ideas That Don't Make Sense_ by Rory Sutherland [0]. It will help improve the understanding of marketing and hows business operate. This is an over simplified summary. There are mainly two reasons people buy something. 1) It is seen as good deal. 2) It is seen as luxury. Your premise hinges on only #1 and ignores #2. #1 is also limited to select products. How many bed sheets or cars do you need? It also rejects the Friedman doctrine [1]. The continual following of this doctrine is what has lead to the enshitification of many products and services. Non-living wages also came out of following it. Living wages harms profits. [0] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/26210508-alchemy https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/26210508-alchemy [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedman_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedman_doctrine
- mattas 9mo agoI wonder if brands will have a "tariff refund" sale. Make everything 20% off until all of the brand's tariff refund is passed on to customers. Of course, this wouldn't help the customers that already paid the tariff but it could be a good marketing ploy.
- bryant 9mo agoMuch more interesting would be if the tariffs were refunded equally to each person nationwide (interesting in that it very clearly then becomes an income redistribution scheme, even if on a limited basis). Possibly a refund of about $500 per social security number. Doesn't even have to be in cash, could just directly go towards the social security fund if legislated that way. Tons of ways to fix this quagmire in a way that's beneficial to people. But it won't happen.
- WesleyJohnson 9mo agoAnd then Trump can sign the checks again.... Sarcasm aside, I agree the refunds should go back to consumers, not the importers. I don't have a source, but I have to imagine the lion's share of companies that were hit with tariffs increased their prices, and the consumer paid the bill.
- muwtyhg 9mo agoHere is a source for you to use in the future: https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2026/02/who-is-paying-for-the-2025-u-s-tariffs/ https://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2026/02/who-is... The number the New York Fed came up with is 90% was passed onto the consumer.
- nubinetwork 9mo agoRelated https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47183719 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47183719
- johanyc 9mo agoI like this idea. It's a good pr move for the business too
- jerf 9mo agoNone of this matters; this is guaranteed to go to the Supreme Court. Too much money, too much precedent. The only thing being established now is the battleground as the procedure of getting up to the Supreme Court. The actual rulings on the way up to the Supreme Court are of minimal consequence.
- jtbayly 9mo agoThe Supreme Court already invalidated the tariffs. That’s the context of this order (and the subtitle of the article).
- abcd_f 9mo agoBut they didn't say anything about refunding them and you can bet Trump will oppose that and ask the SCOTUS to decide on it. They of course have an option to take their time to render the decision and then just dismiss the case without a comment. That's what the GP likely meant. The circus must go on.
- jtbayly 9mo agoThanks! I guess I wasn't understanding what jerf meant, and I hadn't read enough to be correcting people.
- AnimalMuppet 9mo agoBut (IIRC) the Supreme Court did not order that the tariffs be refunded. They left that issue open in their decision. So jerf may well be right.
- jerf 9mo agoAs sibling says, the Court very definitely did not order them to refund anything. They could have, and they didn't. The Court knew from the beginning that this was coming back to them. You may see other judges rule that the refunds don't have to be paid, for any of several reasons. Whatever your desired outcome is, none of it matters until this gets to the Supreme Court. Given the nature of money, it doesn't even matter if some higher court refuses to give an injunction against the refunds being issued until after the appeal is considered and some set of refunds goes all the way through... no company that gets any money from a pre-SC refund can really use it until the entire matter is resolved at the SC level.
- throwaway667555 9mo agoI'm gonna have a stroke. The Congressional Budget Office found that consumers paid 70-80% of the tariffs, totaling more than $1000 per household. Where is my refund?
- dionian 9mo agosame place where your refund is for congress rolling out 10%+ inflation for years and now your dollar is worth less. its theft actually
- jonlucc 9mo agoIn practice, the entities who gave money directly to the US government are the ones who paid the tariff. Those entities should be pressured to refund the consumers, but in practice, that's unlikely. I (unknowingly) ordered something on Etsy from another country. UPS delivered the items, then sent me a letter requiring I pay the tariff and an extra tariff handling fee. UPS paid the government, so UPS should get their money back from the government, then refund me. I'm not holding my breath.
- throwaway667555 9mo agoEconomically it is a direct redistribution of wealth. In crisis times, Congress acts swiftly to cure wrongs against corporations. What about this wrong against every single household?
- I-M-S 9mo ago"The West, so afraid of strong government, now has no government, only financial power."
- coldpie 9mo agoUPS is definitely pocketing most of whatever refund they get. And golly gee gosh what a shocker, the company supports Republicans. I'm afraid you've been robbed. > ‘Corporate and industry group political action committees have donated more than $44 million directly to the campaigns and leadership PACs of the 147 members of the Sedition Caucus. Companies and trade associations that pledged to suspend donations have given more than $12 million to the campaign and leadership PACs of the Sedition Caucus. > Koch Industries ($626,500), American Crystal Sugar ($530,000), Home Depot ($525,000), Boeing ($488,000), and UPS ($479,500) have contributed the most money to members of the Sedition Caucus through their corporate PACs.’ > Tomé’s reconciliation with representatives who legitimized Trump’s attempted presidential coup — and who may control Congress after the November midterm elections — shouldn’t surprise us. Trump lavished huge gifts on UPS and Corporate America that have made them richer.” > The second Trump presidency has the potential to be even more lucrative for UPS, given that the bulk of UPS’s unionized workers are Teamsters and led by prominent Trump ally Sean O’Brien https://joeallen-60224.medium.com/big-brown-and-the-fascists-an-update-54a6f2696f96 https://joeallen-60224.medium.com/big-brown-and-the-fascists...
- duxup 9mo agoAbsolutely absurd that we’re at this point. The courts / SCOTUS let the government roll out a massive and obviously illegal tax on citizens for a long time. They should have stepped in earlier. Now we the people probably don’t get our money back….
- Jeremy1026 9mo ago> probably Hah, we are 100% not getting our money back. And the higher, tariff level, prices aren't going to go back down either.
- commandlinefan 9mo agoDid they actually raise prices, though? I haven't noticed any significant jumps; my understanding was that they were absorbing (for the most part) the tariffs for the time being, but planned to raise prices in the near future.
- rootusrootus 9mo agoAverage family paid 1000 more last year due to tariffs. I definitely noticed things that jumped in price.
- thingscoledoes 9mo agoSource?
- Jeremy1026 9mo agoJoint Economic Committee a good enough source? https://www.jec.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/democrats/2026/2/updated-data-american-families-have-already-paid-more-than-1-700-each-in-tariff-costs-since-trump-entered-office https://www.jec.senate.gov/public/index.cfm/democrats/2026/2... Or Tax Foundation? https://taxfoundation.org/research/all/federal/trump-tariffs-trade-war/ https://taxfoundation.org/research/all/federal/trump-tariffs...
- shin_lao 9mo agoUnclear if the SC ruling is retro active. But of course, lawyers will try to make money out of this...
- bonsai_spool 9mo ago> Unclear if the SC ruling is retro active. But of course, lawyers will try to make money out of this... What do you mean unclear? The ruling says that certain of the tariffs were always illegal.
- SpicyLemonZest 9mo agoIt's 100% clear, and even if it weren't the government already conceded that the tariffs are refundable to get this far. If the tariffs were not refundable, that would mean that the injury from them is irreparable, and they would have had to be enjoined pending the decision.
- benrutter 9mo agoLots of comments along the lines that tarrifs were mostly passed down indirectly to consumers, who aren't entitled to refunds. I definitely agree on principle, it sounds pretty tricky to see how proving "I paid $x more for groceries because of tarrifs" would work in practice. Does anyone know of policy suggestions for how that could work?
- downrightmike 9mo agoMost everything was probably bought with credit/debit cards. The individual records exist. Just using your Amazon etc order history should be dead simple
- 9dev 9mo agoyou would need to prove what part of the amounts you paid were due to tariffs, and which were ordinary price changes. All vendors would need to publish that information, and be honest about it. Don't see it coming.
- crazygringo 9mo agoThe real thing is, price changes tend to be proportional to tariffs. If the tariff was $20, the consumer got charged $40 more. But not uniformly -- every price is different, there are other non-tariff price changes too, prices can increase before or after tariffs not exactly at the same time, etc. If companies want to try to refund customers and come up with their own formulas for that, that's great. But usually there isn't some objective right answer that can be imposed externally.
- benrutter 9mo agoI think the tricky bit is less proving you bought something, and more proving that the thing you bought cost more than it otherwise would. As I understand it (which isn't a lot), if you paid a tariff on an overseas order you're theoretically due it back, although that might require taking the government to court, which is gonna cost more than the settlement for most people.
- 9mo ago
- buellerbueller 9mo ago[flagged]
- freetonik 9mo agoThere was an interesting case in Finland. Finnish customs used to apply a 22% tax (ELV) on top of the car tax for imported used cars from other EU countries. On top of that, Finnish law required VAT to be charged on the car tax itself. There were multiple court cases and this practice was found unlawful (and actually against EU law). But the government did not issue automatic refunds, and instead requested that people "actively appeal" with some time limits. They also refused to pay interest on the money withheld. AFAIK, only about 50M Euro was paid back. A lot of funds gathered between 2002–2005 was never returned. I've been living in Finland for 10+ years, and this whole story was super surprising for me to learn because the prevailing notion among people here is that Finland is the land of law, and everything is done correctly and legally, always, and we can and should trust the authorities.
- redeeman 9mo ago[flagged]
- warkdarrior 9mo agoAh, yes, the whole world is against me. Do you have anything meaningful to say?
- undeveloper 9mo agoyeah that's the trade off of having a state. the alternative is getting mugged and having to pay ExxonMobil Police Task Force sponsored by Verizon to get your shit back (or deciding it's not worth the cash).
- svat 9mo agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vLfghLQE3F4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vLfghLQE3F4
- shevy-java 9mo agoHmm. The "active request" is quite common though. I agree that this is unfair, since it is theft, IMO, but Finland is not the only one forcing active engagement to get your money back. Even when the government stole that money from the people. > we can and should trust the authorities. Well, Finland has a fairly competent government usually for the most part. That mantra will not work in many other countries though - such as Germany. Just look at what Merz is doing; his left hand does not know what the right hand should do ...
- siliconc0w 9mo agoSCOTUS is entirely to blame for the chaos here, the courts quickly found the tariffs illegal but they used the shadow docket to stay the ruling causing the illegal behavior to continue for a year.
- eitau_1 9mo agoIt's even more to blame given that it stripped the NEA and IEEPA acts of legislative guardrails in 1987. [0] https://fivepoints.mattglassman.net/p/the-court-ieepa-and-the-legislative https://fivepoints.mattglassman.net/p/the-court-ieepa-and-th...
- joveian 9mo agoThanks, very interesting article! Also these two linked from that one: National emergencies: Chadha wasn't the problem https://prototypingpolitics.substack.com/p/national-emergencies-chadha-wasnt https://prototypingpolitics.substack.com/p/national-emergenc... Elizabeth Goiten (Brennan Center) testimony to a senate committee on May 22, 2024 (a nice summary of the general issue of executive use of emergencies) [PDF] https://www.hsgac.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/Testimony-Goitein-2024-05-22.pdf https://www.hsgac.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/Testimony-Go...
- flawn 9mo agoTo blame in a second order but this is the admin's work overall, they shouldn't have tried to fund their PACs and pocket this money into their family & friends' bank accounts. Just shows how broken the system is.
- scoofy 9mo agoAny sensible administration implementing such an obviously suspect tariff regime could have easily put the tariffs in a kind of escrow instead of just pretending it's novel policy was trivially constitutional. Blaming SCOTUS here is not out of the question, but they should not be "entirely" to blame, unless you think it's totally fine to run the Executive branch like you're trying to get away with something. It's not.
- ChoGGi 9mo agoSo corporations get refunds, I'm sure they'll issue refunds to consumers any day now.
- aurareturn 9mo agoIt's difficult because some companies ate all the tariffs, some passed the costs to consumers, and some split the costs between suppliers, themselves, and consumers. I think they should split it by giving a portion to companies and the rest to consumers.
- mgkimsal 9mo agoOne thing I don't see mentioned enough with the whole "the consumers paid these tariffs! we should get refunds!"... We "paid" not just in higher prices, but in many layoffs, reduction in working hours, skipped bonuses and raises. Companies that get 'refunds' will have an opportunity to use that money to rehire and repay workers. I'm cynical enough to think that will happen in large measures across the whole country, but I'm hopeful enough to want to see it happen nonetheless. Delayed refunds won't even start to repair the damage done by bankruptcies triggered by high tariffs, the snowballed cost of tariffs impacting multiple steps in the supply chain, the emotional toll on families and communities having to deal with less money and rising prices. But rehiring and getting some regions and communities back to work might be a step in the right direction. EXCEPT WE NOW HAVE A 15% GLOBAL TARIFF ONGOING. And a lunatic administration that will fight tooth and nail for years to keep this going as long as possible. Trump "loves" this country so much it hurts me.
- zoobab 9mo ago"use that money to rehire and repay workers" or give it to shareholders.
- philipallstar 9mo agoThey only do that after tax, so there'll be more tax paid if they do that.
- xp84 9mo agoEverything is taxed including payroll.
- crazygringo 9mo agoShareholders only want money when a company can't reinvest it effectively. Reinvesting it to generate more revenue now that prices are lower again is the obvious capitalist thing to do. The companies aren't going to rehire workers out of charity. They do it because it makes them more money.
- marcosdumay 9mo ago
- book_mike 9mo agoGood. Perhaps the administration should follow the law.
- titzer 9mo agoThe past 20 years have been an endless series of wealth transfers from commoners to the wealthy. This is Oligarchy.
- whh 9mo agoI don't usually like to get involved in US politics as I'm not American, nor do I live in the US. But I will say this: the dildo of consequences rarely arrives lubed. Read from that what you will... as a voter, or the POTUS.
- cheema33 9mo agoSome of us knew about the un-lubed dildo of consequences. And warned our fellow countrymen. But they appear to have joined a cult and were immune to reason. Now we are all riding the said dildo, whether we asked for it or not.
- SunshineTheCat 9mo agoI do find it kinda crazy that we had a specific policy surrounding tariffs (Smoot-Hawley) that was in the center of the worst economic collapse in US history. And now, less than 100 years later we're like "hey let's try that again!" https://www.visualcapitalist.com/the-average-u-s-tariff-rate-since-1890/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/the-average-u-s-tariff-rate...
- Spivak 9mo agoI mean honestly that's about right. As soon as it falls out of living memory people forget why the fence was there and tear it down. Expect rhymes from the 1930's—an economic depression, tension leading to another world war. Fun stuff ahead.
- righthand 9mo agoThere are more conflicts happening right now than in World War 2. Meaning, World War 3 is already here. I don't know why everyone is pretending it's not happening, the people doing it are calling themselves the Department of War.
- nekusar 9mo agoAnd notice that the refunds are TO THE COMPANIES. This was the plan from the get-go: 1. Illegal tariffs made 2. Companies pay tariffs 3. Companies sell goods with tariff passed on 4. tariffs deemed illegal 5. companies get refunds on tariffs 6. COMPANIES KEEP TARIFFS 7. The customers get fucked.
- trymas 9mo agoSide topic, but this number puts into how crazy it was for trump[0] to go on tariff war against enemies and friends alike. All the propaganda and extortionist language about how all countries will pay up to USA. Astronomical tariffs in some cases, trade wars and dramas, alienate all allies and from all of this they got only $130B ? $7T of spending, $1.77T in deficit[1] and they planned to fix this hole with $100B?! Masterminds! …and now they need to refund it. NB: also puts into perspective how numb I became about reading AI and AI related sums of money, and how crazy actually those numbers are. [0] off course many knew that it’s crazy way before it happened. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2025_United_States_federal_budget https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2025_United_States_federal_bud...
- aduffy 9mo agoThey need to refund it *with interest*, according to filings cited in the article.
- mejutoco 9mo ago6-7 percent interest.
- loeg 9mo agoSOFR is only around 3.7%. And it's, you know, an annualized rate. The earliest liberation day tariffs are only around 11 months old at this point.
- mejutoco 9mo agoMy source was: ``` The government has collected perhaps $180bn in IEEPA tariffs. Over the past year 1,800 companies—including Goodyear, a tyre-maker, and Costco, a retailer—have filed lawsuits to protect their right to a refund should the Supreme Court overturn them. They are now owed this money, equivalent to roughly 5% of the profits companies generated in America last year, or 0.6% of GDP—plus interest, compounded daily at an annual rate of 6-7%. ``` https://www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2026/02/26/americas-trade-chaos-is-just-beginning https://www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2026/02/26/a...
- jmward01 9mo agoThe people harmed here were the US public and they are just going to continue to be harmed. The right answer is people go to jail. Until people start going to jail, being disbarred, etc, this will keep happening. This isn't a remedy. This is continuing the cycle.
- ekjhgkejhgk 9mo agoBy "people go to jail" you mean Trump, right? Right?
- buzzerbetrayed 9mo ago[flagged]
- donkeybeer 9mo agoWhy not? I have no idea why people were thinking corporations are overpowered when twitter banned trump. I thought it was great and showed nobody is above the law/tos. Likewise if the president has done crimes, he should pay the time.
- TheDong 9mo agoUnfortunately, it has been ruled that the president is immune to legal prosecution on this matter, regardless of whether it is legal or not. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trump_v._United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trump_v._United_States > the Supreme Court ruled in a 6–3 decision that presidents have absolute immunity for acts committed as president within their core constitutional purview It turns out that "checks and balances" meant "the president is unchecked and unbalanced".
- bdangubic 9mo agoPredidency is an Institution which needs to be protected at all costs. The checks and balances wasn’t meant to setup a system where Presidents can be sent to prison but to prevent “crimes” (for the lack of a better word) to happen to begin with. Of course our current “party over Country” system has practically killed any semblance of checks and balances…
- TechSquidTV 9mo agoThe American people will be robbed blind and beaten into submission until there is a reason not to. It's that simple. They have NEVER been punished, why would they stop?
- chanitypham 9mo ago[dead]
- cmrdporcupine 9mo agoChaos is a ladder. Trump doesn't care who went bankrupt or lost money, he was able to create a whole pile of red number buying opportunities for his friends in the know. And for himself. It's now an age of oligarchy, stable corporate capitalism and gentlemanly bourgeois behaviour and the appearance of "rules based order" and equally brokered commerce is out, schoolyard bully attitude and "give me your lunch money" is in. If you still want to profit, you make friends with the right people, kiss the ring, and get permission to become a highwayman or parasite like the rest of them. At the bottom, is us. I don't think any election can put the cork back in this bottle. The only thing that will end this decline is an angry non-compliant populace that is sick of getting a very bad deal.
- softwaredoug 9mo agoHas anyone else noticed this? In our area, it seems in 2025 a lot of local businesses (ie local toy stores, etc) have closed. Presumably tariff pressures hurt (among other affordability issues). The big players can restructure supply chains. Small businesses can't. The mom and pops seem to suffer. I'm hoping there can be an infusion of $ into those companies and maybe stimulate a little growth, or at least survival through the Trump years.
- baggachipz 9mo ago> The big players can restructure supply chains. Small businesses can't. The mom and pops seem to suffer. This is by design. No doubt the large corporations who kissed the ring and gave gold statues will be the first to receive this money.
- bwb 9mo agoI ache for the day we were governed by people who were competent and wanted to govern.
- sriram_malhar 9mo agoWouldn't it be simpler to implement a 'spend-forward scheme' rather than returning? For example, spend that money on research grants and health care. It is returning the money to the people. A man can dream, no?
- padjo 9mo agoSounds like communism to me.
- sriram_malhar 9mo agoSocialism, you mean, not communism. This is a way of spending taxes on the public, the kind Denmark does. It isn't "no private property; everything belongs to the govt". Also, if we are redistributing taxes to fund endless wars and subsidizing almond/avocado farmers, and propping up public money to ensure banks don't collapse, we are already in socialist territory. Have always been. But God forbid we spend the money on healthcare ... that's "taking us back to Mao".
- padjo 9mo agoI was joking
- sriram_malhar 9mo agoAh! Sorry!
- yapyap 9mo agoWonder if the companies (who have been mostly passing on the tariffs to the end user) will just add the refunds to their profits or give back in some way
- smm11 9mo agoSo we don't have to pay taxes this year, right?
- devin 9mo agoJustice delayed is justice denied.
- Dwedit 9mo agoGood luck with that.
- WalterBright 9mo ago[flagged]
- platevoltage 9mo agoThis one needs a bit more time in the oven.
- tzs 9mo agoThe original sweeping plan that was blocked by the Supreme Court was blocked before it had forgiven any loans. They ruled it exceeded Presidential authority. That was replaced by several programs. Lower courts issued an injunction to halt one of those, and the Supreme Court declined to lift those injunctions. There never was a ruling on the merits, and in late 2025 there was a settlement between the Department of Education and one of the states that has sued with DoE agreeing to end the program and move current borrowers from it to other programs.
- WalterBright 9mo agoThanks for the correction.
- Sl1mb0 9mo ago[flagged]
- amelius 9mo agoAt least our president made a lot of lawyers happier.
- ex-aws-dude 9mo agoIf you're an American consumer who had the tarrifs passed on in higher prices wouldn't you feel totally robbed by this whole ordeal?
- Bloating 9mo agoIf consumers indirectly pay the cost of tariffs, who pays for the dead-weight loss of taxes on domestic employers?
- thayne 9mo agoTrump should be personally liable for this. He knew it was illegal but he still did it, to the harm of US citizens.
- gorbachev 9mo agoThey will never pay this without a fight. Good time to specialize in "tariff litigation", if you're a law firm.
- squeegmeister 9mo ago“We live in the age of computers,” Eaton said. “It must be possible for Customs Service to program its computers so it doesn’t need a manual review.” lol
- shevy-java 9mo agoTrump is not a competent person. How did he ever get rich?
- cindyllm 9mo ago[dead]
- ekjhgkejhgk 9mo agoSounds impossible. As everybody knows, you need to be competent to get rich.
- platevoltage 9mo agoHe won the sperm lottery. That’s how he got rich.
- sporkland 9mo agoSo the consumer ate the tariff (I saw somewhere that they just got passed on for the most part). Now the companies are just gonna get the money back and either enrich their exec staff or shareholders? It feels like a company should have to prove they didn't pass the tariff on to consumers in order to collect this.
- netfortius 9mo agoHa, ha, ha. Someone, somewhere, ordering government to do something. Thank you for the best laugh today.
- ElijahLynn 9mo agoLove this: The judge said the repayment process should be straightforward and grew impatient when a Justice Department lawyer said the government hadn’t yet formalized its position on refunding the tariffs, which President Trump imposed by citing a decades-old law. “Your position is clear,” the judge said. “The Supreme Court told you what your position is.”
- wat10000 9mo agoIf I illegally forced a bunch of people to give me $130 billion, the courts would not stop at making me pay them back. I and all my co-conspirators would go to prison forever. We should accept nothing less here.
- wiseowise 9mo agoBut hey, we’ve got to own the libs! I swear to God, the generation that voted the most for this stupid SoB will go down in history as the most stupid so far, like straight out of the Idiocracy. Trillions of world wide economic damage, irreparable damage to transatlantic cooperation, death of post ww2 order. All because McFuckity Fuck saw online that brown man bad and there’s inexplicable feminist agenda, also somehow America needs to become great again because being top world economy is not good enough. Also soyjack memes.
- mempko 9mo agoDid the people pay for the majority of the tariffs, like 80% percent? But the companies are getting this money? How is this now just a transfer of what I paid to these companies? They just get free money at my expense?
- solid_fuel 9mo agoPutting aside the discussions of who will actually see any money returned, I will note that this haul covers about 100 days of war with Iran. ($1 Billion per day is the initial assessment from the Pentagon.) [0] For anyone who was still under the illusion that the tariffs would make any impact on the government debt, hopefully this illustrates that both the tariffs and the ridiculous DOGE effort were never really about the budget. [0] https://iran-cost-ticker.com/ https://iran-cost-ticker.com/
- infinitewars 9mo agoDOGE was about funding Golden Dome back when Elon thought he was getting the contract
- omnimus 9mo agoDOGE was about breaking things as much as you can. Especially those that were working and not under Trumps control.
- skinpop 9mo agoit's about justifying tax cuts for the rich
- infinitewars 9mo agoWith these contracts, they want to give trillions to Musk. Cuts aren't good enough for oligarchy!
- 0xedd 9mo ago[dead]
- khat 9mo agoUS imposes tariffs, companies increase cost to offset price, consumers front the bill. Companies sue government, judge orders refunds, companies pocket money and keep prices at current rate. The people get screwed over twice.
- indigodaddy 9mo agoDo consumers get a refund too re: inflated prices for the items they bought?
- b00ty4breakfast 9mo agoIf we're optimistic and those refunds actually go out it's going to be us, the taxpayers, paying for them...again. Like the saying goes, they get you coming and going.
- booleanbetrayal 9mo agoThis is what sophisticated corporate welfare and wealth transfer looks like I guess.
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- aurareturn 9mo agoUse tariffs to tax the hundreds of millions of Americans, then give out tax breaks to the elites. Just crazy transfer of wealth in broad daylight.
- QuantumNoodle 9mo agoDo I understand correctly, that these companies applying for refunds, likely passed the costs onto consumers who paid a higher price for goods. Now the companies will claw back their refunds from the gov AND keep the markup they charged consumers?
- mullingitover 9mo agoI keep hearing this logic, but is not like the companies asked for it. The politicians did this. They could pass a law tomorrow forcing the companies to refund windfalls from the illegally levied taxes.
- QuantumNoodle 8mo ago> ... but is not like the companies asked for it. This doesn't justify them double dipping. Raising prices on consumers to cover tarrif costs and then getting refunded for tarrif costs isn't ethical no matter who caused the tariffs. Consumers didn't ask for this either, so are we going to see year-long sales from companies?
- vee-kay 9mo ago[dead]
- abruzzi 9mo agoI'd curious specifically about FedEx (and other parcel shippers like UPS if they filed suit as well.) They operated as a broker--they collected many of those fees from individuals who bought something overseas and when it was shipped in, FedEx paid the tariff then then billed the receiver. If FedEx wins a refund will I get paid back for the fee I paid them? I don't expect I'll see the "brokerage fee" because the labor was expended whether the tariff was legal or not and is not part of the refund they'd get, but I'd appreciate if I see the $79 I paid them to cover the tariffs for some Arca Swiss camera parts. I honestly haven't heard anything specific on that matter.
- ncallaway 9mo agoMost of them have promised to issue refunds to customers if and when they get refunded the money. FedEx: > Our intent is straightforward: if refunds are issued to FedEx, we will issue refunds to the shippers and consumers who originally bore those charges. When that will happen and the exact process for requesting and issuing refunds will depend in part on future guidance from the government and the court. https://www.fedex.com/en-us/shipping/international/us-tariffs-impact.html https://www.fedex.com/en-us/shipping/international/us-tariff...
- abruzzi 9mo agoThanks for that reference. I can only hope. Unfortunately, I just paid a UPS bill for the new tariffs.
- gmd63 9mo agoThis is just the citizenry paying double tariffs. First, we bought the higher priced goods. Now, the companies are trying to take our tariff payments again, this time from the government, to "make up" for the tariff money that we had already paid them in the first place. What should happen is that $X of the budget should be put into escrow for the next administration to use after these criminals make their way out.
- thrance 9mo agoToo bad the next guys will also be completely owned by capital.
- worik 9mo agoYes The system is capital. Unavoidable
- ckw 9mo agoSeems like China avoids it.
- AngryData 9mo agoEhh, they do a little better, but they are very much run by capital now. Most of their politicians are capitalist investors. And while individuals may get smacked down on occasion, as a whole they still follow the desires of capital holders above all else.
- sowbug 9mo agoMaybe triple. (1) paid higher prices, (2) the government will issue debt to refund the tariffs to importers who we already reimbursed through higher prices, and then (3) Congress will use the extra debt from the refunds as justification for higher individual taxes to pay for the 2025 tax cuts for businesses.
- NewJazz 9mo ago
- cpt1138 9mo agoI ordered something from a Chinese company and they quoted me 5USD per unit and 35USD shipping. I accepted and the units were shipped and delivered and of excellent quality. Sometime later FedEx sends me a weird bill for some random seeming amount of money I owed. They had a link or email or something to basically refuse to pay. I did refuse to pay. The shipper ended up communicating with me to determine I was going to refuse to pay and I found where Fedex had on the website that indicated the shipper was responsible for all fees. I assume the randomness of it was related to tariffs but I wasn't going to pay anything like what they sent me. I do hope that some repercussions come of these terrible economic policies and the shipper gets their money back from Fedex, but as a company or as an individual I don't think a company's policy to send random bills after delivery is valid either.
- pomian 9mo agoThis sounds familiar. Months after not receiving an order, UPS sent a letter from a pseudo(?) collection agency for a charge added to the order. But there was no way to pay for it - as there was a statement that only the shipper could pay, but still, the order didn't arrive - it was very confusing, the shipment disappeared in paperwork - and no one could figure it out. Customer was out the original purchase fee, producer never could reviver shipment. Complete mess.
- Steve16384 9mo agoI've had this before, a few years ago, and a quick google at the time seemed to show that a fair few other people have. I'm in the UK, and about 6 months after buying something small from China (iirc), we got an £10 invoice for a "disbursement fee" from Fedex. It was very vague as to what the fee was actually for. I assume it was just a "scam" by Fedex to get more money.
- jurschreuder 9mo ago“We live in the age of computers,” Eaton said. “It must be possible for Customs Service to program its computers so it doesn’t need a manual review.” In DHL the link to get tax documents is already broken for a year or so, so I cannot get VAT back on DHL shipments. With FedEx I can but it's a manual process of screenshotting a bank transaction and emailing a specific email address with a shipping number. When tariffs started all the servers of the shipping companies went down. So I highly doubt they will just do some computer magic. From experience I assume they will "accidentally" run into all kinds of technical difficulties making it a 274 step process to get the money back. For scale: Shopify, a software company by heart, with 170bn market cap and 3500 engineers employed, does not have native VAT support, required in the Europe which accounts for 15-20% of their revenue. All they would have to do to support this is add a checkout field "VAT number" that shows up on a pdf invoice. So to assume a shipping company will just work some computer magic is really far fetched. The FedEx page only lets you login after you refresh the page exactly once already for more than a year.
- Frieren 9mo ago> does not have native VAT support If citizens do not have access to high quality tools that allow them to exercise their rights that rights are "de facto" invalidated. If corporations are allowed to implement regulations in faulty ways the economic system stops working and fraud is easier than ever. Part of the problem is governments trying to look "pro businesses" have become just "anti regulation". Organized crime is rising in Europe as it is increasingly easy to move money around in uncontrolled ways thru big platforms. But asking big platforms to adhere to standards and If citizens do not have access to high quality tools that allow them to exercise their rights that rights are "de facto" invalidated. Part of the problem is governments trying to look "pro businesses" have become just "pro fraud". Organized crime is rising in Europe as it is increasingly easy to move money around in uncontrolled ways thru big platforms. But asking big platforms to adhere to standards and regulations is something that corruption does not allow for.
- ByThyGrace 9mo ago> Organized crime is rising in Europe as it is increasingly easy to move money around in uncontrolled ways thru big platforms. Even though it's a sensible claim, and since you're implying causal relationship, can you provide a source for this? I'm not European so I wouldn't know.
- nikanj 9mo agoJudge orders the government. The government does not obey. Now what?
- aurareturn 9mo agoCountry breaks down further since rule of law does not matter anymore. Protests are next, mid term elections will be furious.
- dabinat 9mo agoThe government raised taxes, consumers paid the costs, and companies will take the spoils. I don’t think this is what people voting MAGA intended, but will they realize that they got screwed?
- misja111 9mo agoMost likely they will put the blame on the 'disloyal' supreme court and not on Trump.
- misja111 9mo agoSo effectively US citizens have been paying an extra tax, which money flowed to certain companies. I can't wait to hear the justifications that will follow from the Trump government.
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- motbus3 9mo agoFor friends there, be strong. It seems it has not being an easy period. But also remember, no one wants a conflict. Good luck there!
- jongjong 9mo agoTrump should sign an executive order to appropriate the money for himself. Then all the other rich folks will learn what it feels like to be on be on the losing end of government wealth redistribution. I think Trump would deserve the money as tuition fee!
- orbisvicis 9mo agoWhat is it like purchasing consumer goods from the EU under the new 10% section 122 rates? Previously I could have expected 25% tariffs + UPS/govt fees equivalent to another 40%. But hearing the horrors of shippers (UPS, FedEx, DHL) charging import fees equivalent to 1000% with no recourse to refuse the shipment and recoup costs, I never pulled the trigger. Has anything changed with the section 122 rates, especially considering the $800 de minimus exception won't be reinstated?
- MetroWind 9mo agoOh cool. US people paid for the tariffs. Now they are going to pay for the refund
- kakacik 9mo agoWell US population voted, hence the results. Maybe there are some subtle lessons to be learned?