27 ms·
M4 MacBook Pro
- commandersaki 2y agoNew 12MP Center Stage Camera. Will it support 4k?
- perfect-blue 2y agoI don't think so. They would have made that a huge deal.
- Almondsetat 2y agoThe 12MP will be used for better framing, there is still almost no use case for 4k quality video conferencing
- bearjaws 2y agoIt is truly sad how bad Zoom / Google Meet / Teams are when it comes to video quality. I look at my local source vs the recording, and I am baffled. After a decade of online meeting software, we still stream 480p quality it seems.
- fellowniusmonk 2y agoI mean you can easily create your own fully meshed P2P group video chat in your browser just using a little bit of JS that would support everyone running 4k, but it will fail the moment you get more than 3-8 people as each persons video stream is eating 25mbps for every side of a peer connection (or 2x per edge in the graph.) A huge part of group video chat is still "hacks" like downsampling non-speaking participants so the bandwidth doesn't kill the connection. As we get fatter pipes and faster GPUs streaming will become better. edit: I mean... I could see a future where realtime video feeds never get super high resolution and everything effectively becomes a relatively seemless AI recreation where only facial movement data is transmitted similar to how game engines work now.
- bearjaws 2y agoI'm not asking for 4k. I am asking for good 720p... With how static cam footage is it would be less than 8mbps probably.
- sroussey 2y agoFaceTime has great quality. Unfortunately, as you age you start to hate the quality.
- Almondsetat 2y agoWhen I have a full team of people with 1080p webcams and a solid connection I can notice the quality. Most of the time not everyone fulfills those requirements and the orchestrator system has to make do
- musictubes 2y ago4k for videoconferencing is nuts. The new camera should be an improvement over the old. Plus, being able to show your actual, physical desktop can be Andy too. Using your iPhone as the webcam will still probably give you the best quality especially if you are in a lower light situation.
- minimaxir 2y agoTech specs confirm only 1080p recording.
- vid 2y ago[flagged]
- acyou 2y agoIf you're willing to play, here are plenty of lenders who will finance this purchase. If it affects your earning power to that extent, you should probably pony up and save in the long run, probably just a few years until you see returns. Caste system usually can't be bypassed by paying a monthly subscription fee. I will note that making it a subscription will tend to increase the overall costs, not decrease. In an environment with ready access to credit, I think offering on a subscription basis is worse for consumers?
- infecto 2y agoHuh? My m1 is still kicking strong with little to no reason to upgrade. If it matters that much to you just sell the old one and buy the new. That's your subscription.
- mjlee 2y agoI'm not sure about the caste system enforcement idea you have, but plenty of places (including Apple) lease MacBook Pros to businesses.
- Ancapistani 2y agoThey have a business lease program - it's super easy to sign up for, and it's not like you have to have an LLC or something.
- vid 2y agoTo all these comments, I'm not talking practically for myself, I'm talking about what a revolutionary "think different" company would do for its users and projection into the world. Starting with taking away the friction of changing models and the impact of all these product lines, which sometimes instantly become less valuable (2023's "8GB is more than enough"), would be a good start, and Apple if anyone could amortize this on behalf of their userbase. Another observation; I've travelled the world and rarely see people who could use robust, secure products the most (vulnerable people) using Apple products. They're all packing second-tier Samsung or LG Androids and old Windows notebooks (there are decent Samsung, LG, Android, Windows products, but that's not what they have access to).
- scrlk 2y agoNano-texture option for the display is nice. IIRC it's the first time since the 2012 15" MBP that a matte option has been offered? I hope that the response times have improved, because it has been quite poor for a 120 Hz panel.
- ant6n 2y agoThey brought back the matte screen! Omg. The question is, will they have that for the air. (I tend to feel if you want something specialized, you gotta pay for the expensive model)
- pcdoodle 2y agoYes. It's finally back.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- lapcat 2y ago> IIRC it's the first time since the 2012 15" MBP that a matte option has been offered? The so-called "antiglare" option wasn't true matte. You'd really have to go back to 2008.
- lapcat 2y agoCorrection: I think I actually misremembered that, sorry!
- Eric_WVGG 2y agoLove the nano-texture on the Studio Display, but my MacBooks have always suffered from finger oil rubbing the screen from the keys. Fingerprint oil on nano-texture sounds like a recipe for disaster. For my current laptop, I finally broke down and bought a tempered glass screen protector. It adds a bit of glare, but wipes clean — and for the first time I have a one-year-old MacBook that still looks as good as new.
- jonah 2y ago
- dcchambers 2y ago> Now available in space black and silver finishes. No space grey?!
- billti 2y agoI don't think they had Space Grey on the M3 models either. That was initially my preference, but I went with the Black and quite like it.
- matsz 2y agoWonder how good are those for LLMs (compared to M3 Pro/Max)... They talk about the Neural Engine a lot in the press release.
- Lalabadie 2y agoI'm not sure we can leverage the neural cores for now, but they're already rather good for LLMs, depending on what metrics you value most. A specced out Mac Studio (M2 being the latest model as of today) isn't cheap, but it can run 180B models, run them fast for the price, and use <300W of power doing it. It idles below 10W as well.
- opjjf 2y agoIt seems they also update the base memory on MacBook Air: > MacBook Air: The World’s Most Popular Laptop Now Starts at 16GB > MacBook Air is the world’s most popular laptop, and with Apple Intelligence, it’s even better. Now, models with M2 and M3 double the starting memory to 16GB, while keeping the starting price at just $999 — a terrific value for the world’s best-selling laptop.
- twilo 2y agoGreat news. The pro is kinda of heavy for my liking so the Air is the way to go
- Analemma_ 2y agoI think spec-wise the Air is good enough for almost everyone who isn't doing video production or running local LLMs, I just wish it had the much nicer screen that the Pro has. But I suppose they have to segregate the product lines somehow.
- kruxigt 2y ago[dead]
- int_19h 2y agoIt's not just the weight - Air is also fanless (and still runs cold). And yes, with enough RAM, it is a surprisingly good dev laptop.
- jq-r 2y agoReally too bad you cannot upgrade to 32GB RAM though =(
- alsetmusic 2y agoOhh, good catch. Sneaking that into the MBP announcement. I skimmed the page and missed that. So a fourth announcement couched within the biggest of the three days.
- abnry 2y agoHow viable is Asani Linux these days? MacBook hardware looks amazing.
- dcchambers 2y agoNo support for M3 or M4 powered machines currently. > All Apple Silicon Macs are in scope, as well as future generations as development time permits. We currently have support for most machines of the M1 and M2 generations.[^1][^2] [^1]: https://asahilinux.org/about/ https://asahilinux.org/about/ [^2]: https://asahilinux.org/fedora/#device-support https://asahilinux.org/fedora/#device-support
- kristofferR 2y agoHave anyone tried it recently, specifically the trackpad? I tried the Fedora variant a few months ago on my M1 Macbook and it was horrible to use the trackpad, it felt totally foreign and wrong.
- philistine 2y agoI feel you, but Apple's trackpad prowess is not an easy thing to copy. It's one of those things I never expect anyone else to be able to replicate the level of deep integration between the hardware and software. It's 2024, and I still see most Windows users carrying a mouse to use with their laptop.
- drhodes 2y agobtw, there is a recent interview with an Asani dev focusing on GPUs, worth a listen for those interested in linux on apple silicon. The reverse engineering effort required to pin down the GPU hardware was one of the main topics. https://softwareengineeringdaily.com/2024/10/15/linux-apple-silicon-alyssa-rosenzweig/ https://softwareengineeringdaily.com/2024/10/15/linux-apple-...
- jitl 2y agoFor many years I treated Windows or macOS as a hypervisor - if you love Linux but want the Mac hardware, instant sleep & wake, etc, putting a full screen VM in Parallels or similar is imo better than running Linux in terms of productivity, although it falls short on “freedom”.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- BrentOzar 2y agoThe M4 Max goes up to 128GB RAM, and "over half a terabyte per second of unified memory bandwidth" - LLM users rejoice.
- manaskarekar 2y agoThe M3 Max was 400GBps, this is 540GBps. Truly an outstanding case for unified memory. DDR5 doesn't come anywhere near.
- vid 2y agoIt's not "DDR5" on its own, it's a few factors. Bandwidth (GB/s) = (Data Rate (MT/s) * Channel Width (bits) * Number of Channels) / 8 / 1000 (8800 MT/s * 64 bits * 8 channels) / 8 / 1000 = 563.2 GB/s This is still half the speed of a consumer NVidia card, but the large amounts of memory is great, if you don't mind running things more slowly and with fewer libraries.
- cjbprime 2y agoRight, the nvidia card maxes out at 24GB.
- vid 2y agoA 24gb model is fast and ranks 3. A 70b model is slow and 8. A top tier hosted model is fast and 100. Past what specialized models can do, it's about a mixture/agentic approach and next level, nuclear power scale. Having a computer with lots of relatively fast RAM is not magic.
- manaskarekar 2y agoThanks, but just to put things into perspective, this calculation has counted 8 channels which is 4 DIMMs and that's mostly desktops (not dismissing desktops, just highlighting that it's a different beast). Most laptops will be 2 DIMMS (probably soldered).
- jfoster 2y agoHave they published this ahead of other pages or is it just me? The linked Apple Store page says "MacBook Pro blasts forward with the M3, M3 Pro, and M3 Max chips" so it seems like the old version of the page still?
- jerojero 2y agoFinally they're doing starting memory at 16gb. Looking at how long the 8gb lasted it's a pretty sure bet that now you won't need to upgrade for a good few years. I mean, I have a MacBook air with 16gb of ram and it's honestly working pretty well to this day. I don't do "much" on it though but not many people do. I'd say the one incentive a MacBook Pro has over the air is the better a screens and better speakers. Not sure if it's worth the money.
- efields 2y agoMy hypothesis is Apple is mostly right about their base model offerings. > I mean, I have a MacBook air with 16gb of ram and it's honestly working pretty well to this day. I don't do "much" on it though but not many people do. If an HN user can get along with 16gb on their MacBook Air for the last X years, most users were able to get by with 8gb.
- skellington 2y agoIt's just a tactic to get a higher average price while being able to advertise a lower price. What makes it infuriating is memory is dirt cheap. That extra 8GB probably costs them $10 at most, but would add to utility and longevity of their hardware quite a bit. They are supposed to be "green" but they encourage obsolescence.
- Spooky23 2y agoThey align need with more CPU and margin. Apple wants as few SKUs as possible and as much margin as possible. 8GB is fine for most use cases. Part of my gig is managing a huge global enterprise with six figures of devices. Metrics demonstrate that the lower quartile is ok with 8GB, even now. Those devices are being retired as part of the normal lifecycle with 16GB, which is better. Laptops are 2-6 year devices. Higher end devices always get replaced sooner - you buy a high end device because the productivity is worth spending $. Low end tend to live longer.
- carlosjobim 2y agoPeople looking for low prices buy PC, they don't even consider Mac. Then they can have a computer with all the "higher numbers", which is more important than getting stuff done.
- fsflover 2y ago> while protecting their privacy This is misleading: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25074959 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25074959 "macOS sends hashes of every opened executable to some server of theirs"
- whynotminot 2y ago[flagged]
- ilikepi 2y ago> This is misleading: ... To be fair, the link in this story is to a press release. Arguably there are probably many things in it that can be considered "misleading" in certain contexts.
- moffkalast 2y agoWhat's the deal with running Linux on these anyway? Could one conceivably set up an M4 mini as headless server? I presume Metal would be impossible to get working if MacOS uses proprietary drivers for it...
- wmf 2y agoMetal doesn't exist under Linux but OpenGL and Vulkan work.
- tomrod 2y agoThis is the first compelling Mac to me. I've used Macs for a few clients and muscle memory is very deeply ingrained for linux desktops. But with local LLMs finally on the verge of usability along with sufficient memory... I might need to make the jump! Wish I could spin up a Linux OS on the hardware though. Not a bright spot for me.
- d1str0 2y agoCheck out Asahi linux
- aidenfoxivey 2y agoYou totally can after a little bit of time waiting for M4 bringup! https://asahilinux.org https://asahilinux.org It won't have all the niceties / hardware support of MacOS, but it seamlessly coexists with MacOS, can handle the GPU/CPU/RAM with no issues, and can provide you a good GNU/Linux environment.
- p_j_w 2y agoAsahi doesn't work on M3 yet after a year. It's gonna be a bit before M4 support is here.
- quux 2y agoIIRC one of the major factors holding back M3 support was the lack of a M3 mini for use in their CI environment. Now that there's an M4 mini hopefully there aren't any obstacles to them adding M4 support
- mmcnl 2y agoWhy would that matter? You can use a MacBook in CI too?
- School-Cotton 2y agoHow? What cloud providers offer it? MacStadium and AWS don't. I guess you could have a physical MBP in your house and connect it to some bring-your-own-infrastructure CI setup, but most people wouldn't want to do that.
- jcmontx 2y ago> "up to 1.8x faster when compared to the 16-inch MacBook Pro with M1 Pro" I insist my 2020 Macbook M1 was the best purchase I ever made
- d1str0 2y agoSame. My MBP and M1 Air are amazing machines. But I’m now also excited that any future M chip replacement will be faster and just as nice. The battery performance is incredible too.
- BenFranklin100 2y agoI got a refurbed M1 iPad Pro 12.9” for $900 a couple years ago and have been quite pleased. I still have a couple of years life in it I estimate.
- stetrain 2y agoYep. That's roughly 20% per generation improvement which ain't half-bad these days, but the really huge cliff was going from Intel to the M1 generation. M1 series machines are going to be fine for years to come.
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoIt feels like M1 was the revolution, subsequent ones evolution - smaller fabrication process for improved energy efficiency, more cores for more power, higher memory (storage?) bandwidth, more displays (that was a major and valid criticism for the M1 even though in practice >1 external screens is a relatively rare use case for <5% of users). Actually wasn't M1 itself an evolution / upscale of their A series CPUS that by now they've been working on since... before 2010, the iPhone 4 was the first one with their own CPU, although the design was from Samsung + Intrinsity, it was only the A6 that they claimed was custom designed by Apple.
- drewbitt 2y agoAnd my 2020 Intel Macbook Air was a bad purchase. Cruelly, the Intel and M1 Macbook Air released within 6 months of each other.
- shrubble 2y agoDisingenuous to mention the x86 based MacBooks as a basis for comparison in their benchmarks; they are trying to conflate current-gen Intel with what they shipped more than 4 years ago. Are they going to claim that 16GB RAM is equivalent to 32GB on Intel laptops? (/sarc)
- wiremine 2y agoIt could see it as disingenuous, or a targeted message to those users still on those older x86 machines.
- Yabood 2y agoExactly how I read it. I have an intel model, and the press release felt like a targeted ad.
- alsetmusic 2y agoLot's of people don't upgrade on the cadence that users on this forum do. Someone was mentioning yesterday that they are trying to sell their Intel Mac {edit: on this forum] and asking advice on getting the best price. Someone else replied that they still had a 2017 model. I spoke to someone at my job (I'm IT) who told me they'd just ordered a new iMac to replace one that is 11 years old. There's no smoke and mirrors in letting such users know what they're in for.
- izacus 2y agoRight, it's obviously that, not a marketing trick to make numbers look much bigger while comparing to old CPUs and laptops :)
- alsetmusic 2y agoGiven that they also compare it to an M1 in the same aside, I'd say you're wrong. > Up to 23.8x faster basecalling for DNA sequencing in Oxford Nanopore MinKNOW when compared to the 16-inch MacBook Pro with Core i9, and up to 1.8x faster when compared to the 16-inch MacBook Pro with M1 Pro.
- throw0101a 2y ago> All MacBook Pro models feature an HDMI port that supports up to 8K resolution, a SDXC card slot, a MagSafe 3 port for charging, and a headphone jack, along with support for Wi-Fi 6E and Bluetooth 5.3. No Wifi 7. So you get access to the 6 GHz band, but not some of the other features (preamble punching, OFDMA): * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wi-Fi_7 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wi-Fi_7 * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wi-Fi_6E https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wi-Fi_6E The iPhone 16s do have Wifi 7. Curious to know why they skipped it (and I wonder if the chipsets perhaps do support it, but it's a firmware/software-not-yet-ready thing).
- sroussey 2y agoYeah, this threw me as well. When the iMac didn’t support WiFi 7, I got a bit worried. I have an M2, so not going to get this, but the spouse needs a new Air and I figure that everything would have WiFi 7 by then, and now I don’t think so.
- carstenhag 2y agoFaster is always nice, makes sense. But do you really need WiFi 7 features/speed? I don't know when I would notice a difference (on a laptop) between 600 or 1500 Mbit/s (just as an example). Can't download much anyhow as the storage will get full in minutes.
- iknowstuff 2y agoCall of Duty is 200GB
- nightski 2y agoI find it very odd that the new iMac has WiFi 7 but this does not... Also it is so aggravating they compare to 3 generations ago and not the previous generation in the marketing stats. It makes the entire post nearly useless.
- parsimo2010 2y agoIt is very aggravating, but if they advertised a comparison to last year's model and showed you small performance gains you might not want to buy it. A more charitable interpretation is that Apple only thinks that people with computers a few years old need to upgrade, and they aren't advertising to people with a <1 year old MacBook Pro.
- klausa 2y agoThe iMac doesn’t have WiFi 7.
- zurfer 2y agoIf I remember correctly, the claim was that M3 is 1.6x faster than M1. M4 is now 1.8x faster than M1. It sounds more exciting than M4 is 12.5% faster than M3.
- tonygiorgio 2y agoSo far I’m only reading comments here about people wow’d by a lot of things it seemed that M3 pretty much also had. Not seeing anything new besides “little bit better specs”
- MBCook 2y agoThe M4 is architecturally better than the M3, especially on GPU features IIRC, but you’re right it’s not a total blow out. Not all products got the M3, so in some lines this week is the first update in quite a while. In others like MBP it’s just the yearly bump. A good performing one, but the yearly bump.
- sliken 2y agoYes, upgrading from a m3 max to a m4 max would be a waste.
- jumping_frog 2y agoMaybe they are highlighting stats which will help people upgrade. Few will upgrade from M3 to M4. Many from M1 to M4. That's my guess.
- azinman2 2y agoMost people buying a new MacBook don’t have the previous version, they’re going much further back. That’s why you see both intel and m1 comparisons.
- IshKebab 2y agoNo it isn't. It's because 1.8x faster sounds better than 12% faster. Back when Moore's law was still working they didn't skip generations like this.
- smallstepforman 2y ago[flagged]
- Veen 2y agoI'm not sure Russel Brand is the best ambassador for plain English.
- astrange 2y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o6p0W4ZsLXw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o6p0W4ZsLXw
- empath75 2y agoMost people buying macs don't care about specs, they care about _what they can do_.
- fckgw 2y agoI don't think you understand what a press release is.
- kps 2y agoWhile we're bashing Apple marketing: `:prefers-color-scheme` is a11y. Take your fucking fashion statements elsewhere.
- david_allison 2y ago> MacBook Pro with M4 Max enables: > Up to 4.6x faster build performance when compiling code in Xcode when compared to the 16‑inch MacBook Pro with Intel Core i9, and up to 2.2x faster when compared to the 16‑inch MacBook Pro with M1 Max. OK, that's finally a reason to upgrade from my M1.
- dagmx 2y agoAnnouncement video as well https://youtu.be/G0cmfY7qdmY?si=vbgIr8zn9EzB2Xam https://youtu.be/G0cmfY7qdmY?si=vbgIr8zn9EzB2Xam
- adgxh 2y ago[flagged]
- LeifCarrotson 2y agoI'm pleased that the Pro's base memory starts at 16 GB, but surprised they top out at 32 GB: > ...the new MacBook Pro starts with 16GB of faster unified memory with support for up to 32GB, along with 120GB/s of memory bandwidth... I haven't been an Apple user since 2012 when I graduated from college and retired my first computer, a mid-2007 Core2 Duo Macbook Pro, which I'd upgraded with a 2.5" SSD and 6GB of RAM with DDR2 SODIMMs. I switched to Dell Precision and Lenovo P-series workstations with user-upgradeable storage and memory... but I've got 64GB of RAM in the old 2019 Thinkpad P53 I'm using right now. A unified memory space is neat, but is it worth sacrificing that much space? I typically have a VM or two running, and in the host OS and VMs, today's software is hungry for RAM and it's typically cheap and upgradeable outside of the Apple ecosystem.
- jsheard 2y ago> I'm pleased that the Pro's base memory starts at 16 GB, but surprised they top out at 32 GB: That's an architectural limitation of the base M4 chip, if you go up to the M4 Pro version you can get up to 48GB, and the M4 Max goes up to 128GB.
- FireBeyond 2y agoThe "base level" Max is limited at 36GB. You have to get the bigger Max to get more.
- latortuga 2y agoThe new mac mini also has an M4 Pro that goes up to 64GB.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Octoth0rpe 2y agoThe max memory is dependent on which tier M4 chip you get. The M4 max chip will let you configure up to 128gb of ram
- 2y ago
- wslh 2y agoI really like these new devices, but I’ve found that the latest MacBook Air (M3) is sufficient for my needs as a manager and casual developer. My MacBook Pro M1 Max has essentially become a desktop due to its support for multiple monitors, but since the Mac Mini M4 Pro can also support up to three external displays, I’m considering selling the MacBook Pro and switching to the Mini. I’ve also noticed that the MacBook Pro’s battery, as a portable device, is less efficient in terms of performance/battery (for my usage) compared to the MacBook Air. Regarding LLMs, the hottest topic here nowadays, I plan to either use the cloud or return to a bare-metal PC.
- doctoboggan 2y agoDoes anyone know of any good deals on the older models of apple laptops? Now is usually a great time to purchase (a still very capable) older model.
- 2wrist 2y agoThe refurbished store is always a good place to have a look through.
- fckgw 2y agoMost retailers have had the older models on closeout for a few weeks now. Best Buy, Amazon and Costco have had the M3 models for a few hundred off depending on models.
- tencentshill 2y agoThe M-series macbooks depreciate in value far slower than any of the Intel models. M1 base models can still sell for nearly $1k. It's difficult to find a really good deal.
- bigtex 2y agoWatch SlickDeals. I think it was this time last year where lots of refurbs/2 generation old machines were going for massive discounts. Granted they were M1 machines, but some had 64GB RAM and 4TB drives for like $2700. Microcenter and B&H are good ones to watch as well.
- commandersaki 2y agoHm, the M3 MacBook Pro had a 96GB of ram model (which is what I have). I wonder why it's not an option with the M4.
- maxioatic 2y agoIt is interesting they only support 64gb and then jump to 128gb. It seems like a money play since it's $1,000 to upgrade for 128, and if you're running something that needs more than 64 (like LLMs?) you kind of have no choice.
- sliken 2y agoM2 pro has 256 bit wide memory, mostly benefiting the GPU perf. M3 pro has 192 bit wide memory, GPU improvements mostly offset the decrease in memory bandwidth. This leads to memory options like 96GB. M4 pro has 256 bit wide memory, thus the factor of 2 memory options.
- wtallis 2y agoThe 96GB option was with the M2 Max and M3 Max chips, not the M2 Pro or M3 Pro. DRAM chips don't just come in power of two sizes anymore. You can even buy 24GB DDR5 DIMMs.
- thimabi 2y agoNice to see they increased the number of performance cores in the M4 Pro, compared to the M3 Pro. Though I am worried about the impact of this change on battery life on the MBPs. Another positive development was bumping up baseline amounts of RAM. They kept selling machines with just 8 gigabytes of RAM for way longer than they should have. It might be fine for many workflows, but feels weird on “pro” machines at their price points. I’m sure Apple has been coerced to up its game because of AI. Yet we can rejoice in seeing their laptop hardware, which already surpassed the competition, become even better.
- snjnlsn 2y agoI'm curious why they decided to go this route, but glad to see it. Perhaps ~4 efficiency cores is simply just enough for the average MBP user's standard compute? In January, after researching, I bought an apple restored MBP with an M2 Max over an M3 Pro/Max machine because of the performance/efficiency core ratio. I do a lot of music production in DAWs, and many, even Apple's Logic Pro don't really make use of efficiency cores. I'm curious about what restraints have led to this.. but perhaps this also factors into Apple's choice to increase the ratio of performance/efficiency cores.
- thimabi 2y ago> Perhaps ~4 efficiency cores is simply just enough for the average MBP user's standard compute? I believe that’s the case. Most times, the performance cores on my M3 Pro laptop remain idle. What I don’t understand is why battery life isn’t more like that of the MacBook Airs when not using the full power of the SOC. Maybe that’s the downside of having a better display.
- School-Cotton 2y ago> Most times, the performance cores on my M3 Pro laptop remain idle. Curious how you're measuring this. Can you see it in Activity Monitor? > Maybe that’s the downside of having a better display. Yes I think so. Display is a huge fraction of power consumption in typical light (browsing/word processing/email) desktop workloads.
- mcculley 2y agoStill, no matter how much you are willing to spend, you cannot buy a MacBook Pro with an LTE modem, like the ones in the iPhone, iPad, and Watch.
- trogdor 2y agoI wonder if one of the obstacles is the amount of data that would likely be used. Most cellular carriers offer unlimited on-device data plans, but they cap data for tethering. Integrating an LTE modem into a laptop essentially requires a mobile data plan with unlimited tethering - which, AFAIK, doesn’t exist at the moment. I’m not sure why.
- mcculley 2y agoI think the biggest obstacle is the Qualcomm patents. There is no good reason why a MacBook Pro cannot have a feature that Dells have.
- wpm 2y agoIntegrating an LTE modem into an iPad requires a mobile data plan, and thats about it. It's not "tethered" if its built into the device. I've always heard that patent disputes were at the root of the lack of a modem option. Apple had a prototype MacBook Pro back in the early Intel days IIRC but it was never released. Maybe if Apple ever gets their in-house modems working, we'll see them on all of the product lines, but until then, it's a niche use case that likely isn't causing them to lose a ton of sales.
- trogdor 2y ago> It's not "tethered" if its built into the device. I understand that. My point is that I think an LTE modem in a laptop might reasonably use far more data than an LTE modem in a phone or tablet. Most people who download and/or upload very large files do so on their computer rather than their mobile devices.
- mcculley 2y ago
- azinman2 2y agoNo wifi 7? Are others shipping it?
- kristofferR 2y agoYup, Wi-Fi 7 devices have been shipping for over a year. My Odin 2 portable game console has Wi-Fi 7.
- electriclove 2y agoStrange because their latest iPhones do have Wifi 7
- TIPSIO 2y agoThese chips are incredible. Even my M1 MBP from 2020 still feels so ridiculously fast for everyday basic use and coding. Is an upgrade really worth it?
- thimabi 2y agoI guess it’s only worth it for people who would really benefit from the speed bump — those who push their machines to the limit and work under tight schedules. I myself don’t need so much performance, so I tend to keep my devices for many, many years.
- jitl 2y agoI don’t think it will “feel” much faster like the Intel -> M1 where overall system latency especially around swap & memory pressure got much much better. If you do any amount of 100% CPU work that blocks your workflow, like waiting for a compiler or typechecker, I think M1 -> M4 is going to be worth it. A few of my peers at the office went M1->M3 and like the faster compile times. Like, a 20 minute build on M1 becoming a 10 minute build on M4, or a 2 minute build on M1 becoming a 1 minute build on M4, is nothing to scoff at.
- htk 2y agoI have a MBP M1 16GB at home, and a MBP M3 128GB at work. They feel the same: very fast. When I benchmark things I can see the difference (or when fiddling with larger LLM models), other than that, the M1 is still great and feels faster and more enjoyable than any Windows machine I interact with.
- sib 2y agoI do a lot of (high-end mirrorless camera, ~45MP, 14 bits/pixel raw files) photo processing. There are many individual steps in Photoshop, Lightroom, or various plug-ins that take ~10 seconds on my M1 Max MBP. It definitely doesn't feel fast. I'm planning to upgrade to one of these.
- carlgreene 2y agoWhat’s amazing is that in the past I’ve felt the need to upgrade within a few years. New video format or more demanding music software is released that slows the machine down, or battery life craters. Well, I haven’t had even a tinge of feeling that I need to upgrade after getting my M1 Pro MBP. I can’t remember it ever skipping a beat running a serious Ableton project, or editing in Resolve. Can stuff be faster? Technically of course. But this is the first machine that even after several years I’ve not caught myself once wishing that it was faster or had more RAM. Not once. Perhaps it’s my age, or perhaps it’s just the architecture of these new Mac chips are just so damn good.
- OskarS 2y agoYep, the same, M1 Pro from 2021. It's remarkable how snappy it still feels years later, and I still virtually never hear the fan. The M-series of chips is a really remarkable achievement in hardware.
- extr 2y agoI've owned an M1 MBP base model since 2021 and I just got an M3 Max for work. I was curious to see if it "felt" different and was contemplating an upgrade to M4. You know what? It doesn't really feel different. I think my browser opens about 1 second faster from a cold start. But other than that, no perceptible difference day to day.
- charliebwrites 2y agoThis is how I feel about the last few iPhones as well I upgraded from a 13 pro to a 15 pro expecting zippier performance and it feels almost identical if not weirdly a bit slower in rendering and typing I wonder what it will take to make Mac/iOS feel faster
- alwillis 2y ago> I upgraded from a 13 pro to a 15 pro expecting zippier performance and it feels almost identical if not weirdly a bit slower in rendering and typing I went from an iPhone 13 mini to an iPhone 16 and it's a significant speed boost.
- bhouston 2y agoDoes anyone have benchmarks for the M4 Pro or M4 Max CPUs yet? Would love to see Geekbench scores for those.
- vishnugupta 2y agoCan someone please help me out with this? I'm torn between Mac mini and and MacBook Pro, specifically the CPU spec difference. MBP: Apple M4 Max chip with 16‑core CPU, 40‑core GPU and 16‑core Neural Engine Mac mini: Apple M4 Pro chip with 14‑core CPU, 20‑core GPU, 16-core Neural Engine What kind of workload would make me regret not having bought MBP over Mac mini given the above. Thanks!
- bhouston 2y agoFor normal web dev, any M4 CPU is good as it is mostly dependent on single core speed. If you need to compile Unreal Engine (C++ with lots of threads), video processing or 3D rendering, more cores is important. I think you need to pick the form factor that you need combined with the use case: - Mobility and fast single core speeds: MacBook Air - Mobility and multi-core: MacBook Pro with M4 Max - Desktop with lots of cores: Mac Studio - Desktop for single core: Mac mini I really enjoy my MacBook Air M3 24GB for desktop + mobile use for webdev: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41988340 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41988340
- alberth 2y agoSince the only real difference is number of GPUs, it'd be: - photo/video editing - games, or - AI (training / inference) that would benefit from the extra GPUs.
- mixmastamyk 2y ago^3D work - Maya, Blender, etc. Probably would be best on a Studio or workstation if/when those are available again.
- ColonelPhantom 2y agoThe Max also has much more memory bandwidth. Especially for running local LLMs, that is the limiting factor much more than the number of GPU cores is.
- subarctic 2y agoDoesn't it make a bigger difference that one of them is a laptop and one of them is a mini computer that you have to leave plugged in?
- TIPSIO 2y agoThe keyboard touch button (top right) is objectively hideous and looks cheap. My current TouchBar may be useless but at least looks nice.
- bloopernova 2y agoTrying to find how many external displays the base model supports. Because corps almost always buy the base model #firstworldproblems The base model doesn't support thunderbolt 5. And the base model still doesn't support more than 2 external displays without the DisplaySync (not DisplayPort!) hardware+software.
- fckgw 2y agohttps://www.apple.com/macbook-pro/specs/ https://www.apple.com/macbook-pro/specs/ "M4 and M4 Pro Simultaneously supports full native resolution on the built-in display at 1 billion colors and: Up to two external displays with up to 6K resolution at 60Hz over Thunderbolt, or one external display with up to 6K resolution at 60Hz over Thunderbolt and one external display with up to 4K resolution at 144Hz over HDMI One external display supported at 8K resolution at 60Hz or one external display at 4K resolution at 240Hz over HDMI"
- mmcnl 2y agoTwo displays with the lid open. "The display engine of the M4 family is enhanced to support two external displays in addition to a built-in display." https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2024/10/apple-introduces-m4-pro-and-m4-max/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2024/10/apple-introduces-m4-p...
- iluvcommunism 2y agoI have an m3 ultra. I don’t think I need to upgrade. I also find it amusing they’re comparing the m4 to the m1 and i7 processors.
- sroussey 2y agoThere is no M3 Ultra.
- iluvcommunism 2y agoI meant pro. My mistake. I was going to maybe upgrade it but it appears m4 isn’t much better.
- roopepal 2y agoI find it amusing how you answer your own "question" before asking it. Why would they target the marketing material at people who already know they aren't going to need to upgrade?
- iluvcommunism 2y agoRoopepal did someone piss in your coffee this morning? I had no questions. I’m merely saying that it’s funny they’re comparing to old technology instead of last year’s. It’s a valid criticism. Take a breath.
- doublebind 2y agoApple knows an M4 is a hard sell for M2/3 owners. Except if you have specific workflows that can take advantage of the newer silicon, you'll spend a lot of money on something you probably don't need. I have an M1 32GB with multiple software packages running, and I see no reason to replace this machine. This is why Apple is comparing against M1: M1 owners are the potential buyers for this computer. (And yes, the marketing folks know the performance comparison graphs look nicer as well :)
- RobinL 2y agoCan anyone comment on the viability of using an external SSD rather than upgrading storage? Specifically for data analysis (e.g. storing/analysing parquet files using Python/duckdb, or video editing using divinci resolve). Also, any recommendations for suitable ssds, ideally not too expensive? Thank you!
- DrBenCarson 2y agoGet something with Thunderbolt and you’ll likely never notice a difference
- thejazzman 2y agoi go with the acasis thunderbolt enclosure and then pop in an nvme of your choice, but generic USB drives are pretty viable too ... thunderbolt can be booted from, while USB can't i tried another brand or 2 of enclosures and they were HUGE while the acasis was credit card sized (except thickness)
- rbanffy 2y agoThe USB-C ports should be quite enough for that. If you are using a desktop Mac, such as an iMac, Mini, or the Studio and Pro that will be released later this week, this is a no-brainer - everything works perfectly.
- rbanffy 2y agoSorry. No Studios or Pros this turn. I’m as disappointed as everyone else.
- Tepix 2y agoRun your current workload on internal storage and check how fast it is reading and writing. For video editing - even 8K RAW - you don't need insanely fast storage. A 10GBit/s external SSD will not slow you down.
- AlphaWeaver 2y agoI've used a Samsung T5 SSD as my CacheClip location in Resolve and it works decently well! Resolve doesn't always tolerate disconnects very well, but when it's plugged in things are very smooth.
- dr_kiszonka 2y ago> "Up to 7x faster image processing in Affinity Photo" Great to see Affinity becoming so popular that it gets acknowledged by Apple.
- sunnybeetroot 2y agoAffinity has been mentioned many times by Apple in their product videos
- teaearlgraycold 2y agoI’m a fan of their software and pricing.
- Brajeshwar 2y agoAffinity is now part of Canva. https://www.canva.com/newsroom/news/affinity/ https://www.canva.com/newsroom/news/affinity/
- prmoustache 2y ago[flagged]
- mathfailure 2y agoOnly if you work on your hobbies.
- smokey_the_bear 2y agoI have an M2 Max now, and it's incredible. But it still can't handle running xcode's Instruments. I'd upgrade if the M4s could run the leaks tool seamlessly, but I doubt any computer could.
- mattfrommars 2y agoDoes anyone know if there is a way to use Mac without the Apple bloatware? I genuinely want to use it as primary machine but with this Intel MacBook Pro I have, I absolutely dislike FaceTime, IMessage, the need to use AppStore, Apple always asking me have a Apple user name password (which I don't and have zero intention), block Siri, and all telemetry stuff Apple has backed in, stop the machine calling home, etc. This is to mirror tools available in Windows to disable and remove Microsoft bloatware and ad tracing built in.
- WesolyKubeczek 2y agoYou can totally use it without ever signing in to Apple account. You cannot delete Siri etc, but you can disable parts of it and not use the rest.
- philistine 2y agoThere used to be this whole contingent of people who were adamant that Apple's software was too opinionated, bloated, that you couldn't adapt its OS to your needs, and that Apple was far too ingrained in your relationship with your device. That Linux was true freedom, but at least that Windows respected its users Then Windows 11 came out.
- mixmastamyk 2y agoHappened a lot earlier than 11.
- int_19h 2y agoI belong to that contingent, and I still stand by the assertion that Apple's software is too opinionated, configurability is unreasonably low, and you have to stick to the Apple ecosystem for many thing to get the most out of it. My primary desktop & laptop are now both Macs because of all the malarkey in Win11. Reappearance of ads in Start and Windows Recall were the last straws. It's clear that Microsoft is actively trying to monetize Windows in ways that are inherently detrimental to UX. I do have to say, though, that Win11 is still more customizable overall, even though it - amazingly! - regressed below macOS level in some respects (e.g. no vertical taskbar option anymore). Gaming is another major sticking point - the situation with non-casual games on macOS is dismal.
- sroussey 2y agoNo WiFi 7! :/
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- unsupp0rted 2y agoI have a 16" M1 Pro with 16 gigs of ram, and it regularly struggles under the "load" of Firebase emulator. You can tell not because the system temp rises, but because suddenly Spotify audio begins to pop, constantly and irregularly. It took me a year to figure out that the system audio popping wasn't hardware and indeed wasn't software, except in the sense that memory (or CPU?) pressure seems to be the culprit.
- maxioatic 2y agoI have a 14" M1 Max with 32gb of ram for work, and it does that popping noise every once it a while too! I've always wondered what was causing it.
- SSLy 2y agoIm relatively surprised modern Macs have same buffer underrun issue I had on intel laptops with pulseaudio 7+ years back.
- silvr 2y agoWhoa! I've been so annoyed by this for years, so interesting that you figured it out. It's the kind of inelegance in design that would have had Steve Jobs yelling at everyone to fix, just ruins immersion in music and had no obvious way to fix.
- zaptrem 2y ago
- twalla 2y agoThey're really burying the lede here - magic trackpad and magic keyboard finally have USB-C :)
- DerekL 2y agoThat was announced on Monday, with the new iMacs.
- AdamJacobMuller 2y agoThat's annoying. I really want to fully remove lightning connectors from my life, but, my existing magic* devices work fine and will probably work fine for another decade or two.
- aquir 2y agoWould it make sense to upgrade from M2 Pro 16 to M4 Pro 16? (both base models) I mean it terms of numbers, more cores, more RAM but everything else is pretty much the same. I am looking forward to see some benchmarks!
- School-Cotton 2y agoCompletely depends on what your workflow is.
- sliken 2y agoNo.
- gigatexal 2y agoLolz the M4 max doesn’t get anything more than 128GB ram in the MacBook? Weird
- gigatexal 2y agoCuz of this: was expecting 256GB https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41971726#41972721 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41971726#41972721
- mrcwinn 2y agoQuestion without judgement: why would I want to run LLM locally? Say I'm building a SaaS app and connecting to Anthropic using the `ai` package. Would I want to cut over to ollama+something for local dev?
- andrewmunsell 2y agoData privacy-- some stuff, like all my personal notes I use with a RAG system, just don't need to be sent to some cloud provider to be data mined and/or have AI trained on them
- gonesurfing 2y agoI’ve been thinking about the local notes use case, but know zero about doing it. Do you have a good setup you could point me at?
- jwitthuhn 2y agoFor me it is consistency. I control the model and the software so I know a local LLM will remain exactly the same until I want to change it. It also avoids the trouble of using a hosted LLM that decides to double their price overnight, costs are very predictable.
- satvikpendem 2y agoLack of censorship.
- thesurlydev 2y agoMy wallet is trembling. On a side note, anyone know what database software was shown during the announcement?
- duckmysick 2y agoWhat's the timestamp? At 3:43 there's Luna Modeler. https://www.datensen.com/data-modeling/luna-modeler-for-relational-databases.html https://www.datensen.com/data-modeling/luna-modeler-for-rela...
- thesurlydev 2y agoThanks. That's it. Coincidentally, I found out what it was by looking at the actual press release where they had a screenshot of it too.
- alexnewman 2y agoI recently switched back to using homemade desktops for most of my work. I’ve been running Debian on them . Still have my Mac laptop for working on the go
- wkyleg 2y agoWhat's the consensus regarding best MacBooks for AI/ML? I've heard it's easier to just use cloud options, but I sill like the idea of being able to run actual models and train them on my laptop. I have a M1 MacBook now and I'm considering trading in to upgrade. I've seen somewhat conflicting things regarding what you get for the money. For instance, some reports recommending a M2 Pro for the money IIRC.
- ZeroCool2u 2y agoTraining is not practical. For inference they're pretty great though, especially if you go up in the specs and add a bunch of memory.
- the_king 2y agoTo run LLMs locally (Ollama/LLM Notebook), you want as much memory as you can afford. For actually training toy models yourself for learning/experiments in my experience it doesn't matter much. PyTorch is flexible.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gjvc 2y agoAs a proud user of an ARM3 in 1992, I'm pleased to be able to see and say that ARM won in the end.
- astrange 2y agoARMv8 is not much like previous ARMs. But it has won - Intel's latest x86 extension basically turns it into ARMv8. https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/developer/articles/technical/advanced-performance-extensions-apx.html https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/developer/articles/t...
- rowanG077 2y agoI couldn't disagree more, the defining difference between ARMv8 and x86 is the memory model.
- astrange 2y agoHmm, I think the difference between x86 and anything else is variable length two-operand instructions. APX changes one of those but not the other. The difference between ARM and anything else is that ARM has successfully shipped all of its security features (PAC, BTI, MTE) and Intel has not.
- daveisfera 2y agoOnce they get a MacBook Air with an M4, it will become a viable option for developers and other users that want/need 2 external monitors. Definitely looking forward to that happening.
- uriah 2y agoThe M3 Air does support 2 but only with the lid closed
- brailsafe 2y agoThe base M4 Max only has an option for 36gb of ram!? They're doing some sus things with that pricing ladder again. No more 96gb option, and then to go beyond 48gb I'd have to spend another $1250 CAD on a processor upgrade first, and in doing so lose the option to have the now baseline 512gb ssd
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- brailsafe 2y agoI'd add that although I find it a bit dirty, the computers are obviously still amazing. It's just a bit bizarre that the lower spec cpu offers the customer the option to change the ram quantity. More specifically, going from the M4 Pro to the M4 Max removes the option to change the ram from 36gb, whereas sticking with the Pro lets you select 48gb or 24gb, unless you choose the max Max. If I pre-order the Mac Mini with the same processor, I can select 64gb for the insane price of an additional $750cad, but it's just not available on the macbook pro M4 Pro. It would indeed have been nice to see a faster response rate screen, even though I value picture quality more, and it also would have been nice to see even vaguely different colors like the iMac supposedly got, but it seems like a nice spec bump year anyway.
- _wire_ 2y agoI think any idea that Apple doesn't thoroughly understand the capacity, value, market, price tradeoff is untenable. The most obvious view is that Apple price gouges on storage. But this seems too simplistic. My conjecture is that there's an inescapable tension between supply (availabilty/cost) sales forecasts, technological churn, and roadmaps that leads them to want to somewhat subsidize the lowest end, and place a bit of back-pressure on consumption at the high-end. The trick is finding the tipping point on the curve between growth and over commitment by suppliers. Especially, for tightly vertically integrated products. The PC industry is more diffuse and horizontal and so more tolerant of fluctuations in supply and demand across a broader network of providers and consumers, leading to a lower, more even cost structure for components and modules. In real terms, Apple's products keep costing less, just like all computer products. They seem to make a point of holding prices on an appearance point of latest tech that's held steady since the first Macs: about $2500 for a unit that meets the expectations of space right behind the bleeding edge while being reliable, useful and a vanguard of trends.
- lenerdenator 2y agoI'm just some dude, looking at a press release, wondering when Tim Apple is gonna be a cool dude and release the MBP in all of the colors that they make the iMac in. APPARENTLY NOT TODAY. C'mon mannnnn. The 90s/y2k are back in! People want the colorful consumer electronics! It doesn't have to be translucent plastic like it was back then but give us at least something that doesn't make me wonder if I live in the novel The Giver every time I walk into a meetup filled with MacBook Pros. I'm sure the specs are great.
- magarnicle 2y agoIn Apple world black means pro. That's why they give you black stickers with pro models and white for everything else.
- hartator 2y agoI’m really excited about the nano-texture display option. It’s essentially a matte coating, but the execution on iPad displays is excellent. While it doesn’t match the e-ink experience of devices like the Kindle or ReMarkable, it’s about 20-30% easier on the eyes. The texture feels also great (even though it’s less relevant for a laptop), and the glare reduction is a welcome feature. I prefer working on the MacBook screen, but I nearly bought an Apple Studio Display XDR or an iPad as a secondary screen just for that nano-texture finish. It's super good news that this is coming to the MacBook Pro.
- cedws 2y agoDoes it make much difference for looking at code?
- hartator 2y agoYes, the main goal is to be easier on the eyes IMO. It's easier to read on it.
- dkarbayev 2y agoDo you actually have to wipe the screen with the included special cloth? The screen on all of the macbooks that I've had usually get oily patches because of the contact with keycaps, so I have to wipe the screen regularly.
- hartator 2y agoI wipe all my devices with regular paper towels with a tad of water. Including my $5k Apple XDR display. I am probably not the best example to emulate lol.
- radicality 2y agoI have Pro Display XDR with nano coating and the manual definitely says to only use their special cleaning cloth (or with some isopropyl alcohol). The standard coating might not need it though.
- wcski 2y agobut does it have touch screen -_-
- zaptrem 2y agoI used a Surface Pro for 6 years and and haven’t missed the touch screen once since switching back to MBP 3 years ago. I would have missed the handwriting input but that’s what a low end iPad is for.
- e63f67dd-065b 2y ago> MacBook Air with M2 and M3 comes standard with 16GB of unified memory, and is available in midnight, starlight, silver, and space gray, starting at $999 (U.S.) and $899 (U.S.) for education. At long last, I can safely recommend the base model macbook air to my friends and family again. At $1000 ($900 with edu pricing on the m2 model) it really is an amazing package overall.
- daco 2y agoUpgraded to a M1 Pro 14 in December 2021, and I still rock it everyday for dev purpose. Apple does great laptop. The only downsides is that I see a kind of "burnt?" transparent spot on my screen. When connecting to an HDMI cable, the sound does not ouput properly to the TV screen, and makes the video I plat laggy. Wondering if I go to the Apple Store, would fix it?
- david_allison 2y agoIf you're still under AppleCare+, definitely give it a try before it expires. Personal anecdote: don't get your hopes up. I've had my issues rejected as 'no fault found', but it's definitely worth spending a bit of time on.
- alexashka 2y agoThe software stack has gotten so bad that no amount of hardware can make up for it. The compile times for Swift, the gigabytes of RAM everything seems to eat up. I closed all my apps and I'm at 10gb of RAM being used - I have nothing open. Does this mean the Macbook Air 8gb model I had 10 years ago would basically be unable to just run the operating system alone? It's disconcerting. Ozempic for terrible food and car-centric infrastructure we've created, cloud super-computing and 'AI' for coping with this frankenstein software stack. The year of the Linux desktop is just around the corner to save the day, right? Right? :)
- carstenhag 2y agoMemory doesn't need to be freed until a different software needs it.
- alexashka 2y agoI'm referring to what Activity Monitor app tells me in its memory tab - not the underlying malloc/whatever implementation being used. It tells me my computer is using 8gb of RAM after a restart and I haven't begun to open or close anything. Yikes?
- astrange 2y agoIt's very hard to measure memory use because it's reactive to how much RAM you have; if you have more then it's going to use it. That doesn't necessarily mean there are any issues.
- Aloisius 2y agoActivity Monitor counts everything from I/O buffer caches to frame buffers in the "memory used" metric. Add in that MacOS won't free pages until it hits a certain memory pressure and you get a high usage with no desktop apps open. This also means that cleanly booted machine with 16 GB will show more memory used than a machine with 8 GB. Apple suggests you use the memory pressure graph instead to determine whether you're low on memory for this reason.
- zja 2y ago> MacBook Air is the world’s most popular laptop, and with Apple Intelligence, it’s even better. Now, models with M2 and M3 double the starting memory to 16GB, while keeping the starting price at just $999 — a terrific value for the world’s best-selling laptop. This is nice, and long overdue.
- cebert 2y agoI wish Apple would let me max out the RAM on a lower performance chip. That’s more valuable to me than more compute.
- dcchambers 2y agoI think it's just one of the tradeoffs of having everything on one SOC. They can only realistically and efficiently make so many versions.
- lightoverhead 2y agoThe machine is great! How is its performance for AI model training? A lot of library and tools are not built for M series chip
- treprinum 2y agoPoor. My M3 Max/128GB is about 20x slower than 4090. For inference it's much better, still much slower than 4090 but it enables working with much larger LLMs albeit at ~10t/s (in comparison, Threadripper 2990WX/256GB does like 0.25t/s). M4 Max is likely going to be ~25% faster than M3 Max based on CPU perf and memory bandwidth.
- rTX5CMRXIfFG 2y agoThat ad reveal at the end. Someone in the marketing team must have started doing CrossFit
- Vayu 2y agoAs it goes for the section where they demoed the assistance from apple intelligence to the researcher creating an abstract and adding pictures to their paper. Is it better or worse to do this? People are already complaining so heavily about dead internet theory with the 'AI voice' being so prominent..
- philodeon 2y agoTo sum up the HN wisdom on Apple Silicon Macs: Before the M4 models: omg, Apple only gives you 8GB RAM in the base model? Garbage! After the M4 models: the previous laptops were so good, why would you upgrade?
- hbn 2y agoWe'll be sure to run our future comments by you to make sure no one contradicts anyone else.
- pw6hv 2y agoJust replaced for the first time battery on my Macbook Pro 2015 Retina. Feel so good using such an old piece of hardware.
- switch007 2y agoWhich MacOS version? I upgraded to a newer one and it crawled to a halt, it's unusable now. UI is insanely laggy. It's sitting in a drawer gathering dust now
- zubiaur 2y agoI love mine, it has a fresh battery OEM battery as well. Runs the latest OS with OpenCore Legacy. But it's starting to get a bit annoying. Usable, but it is starting to feel slowish, the fan kicks up frequently. I might still keep it another year or so, which is a testament to how good it is and how relative little progress has happened in almost 10 years.
- talldayo 2y agoIf it's got a full function row, it will probably work just fine under Linux. My 2014 MBP chugged pretty hard with OpenCore but handles modern Linux distros much better.
- magarnicle 2y agoSame, the jump to the last few OS versions is not pleasant. Do you get good battery life on Linux with it?
- a2l3aQ 2y agoIf I still had my 2015 I would have applied some liquid metal TIM by now, I did a paste refresh and that worked very well to get the fan under control.
- swiftuser 2y agoDid you disassemble the fan assembly? And applied new thermal paste? I'm not using mine any more, but I noticed a big difference when I replaced the battery and got all the dust out this spring. Also installed a new battery. Still quite a hard sell on the used market :)
- mattegan 2y agoIt pains me deeply that they used Autodesk Fusion in one of the app screenshots. It is by far the worst piece of software I use on Mac OS. Wish the nano-texture display was available when I upgraded last year. The last MacBook I personally bought was in 2012 when the first retina MBP had just released. I opted for the "thick" 15" high-res matte option. Those were the days...
- flkiwi 2y agoThe weird thing about these Apple product videos in the last few years is that there are all these beautiful shots of Apple's campus with nobody there other than the presenter. It's a beautiful stage for these videos, but it's eerie and disconcerting, particularly given Apple's RTO approach.
- davidczech 2y agoI think it’s usually filmed on weekends
- monocasa 2y agoYou would just think that with a brand so intrinsically wrapped around the concept of technology working for and with the people that use it, you'd want to show the people who made it if you're going to show the apple campus at all. It kind of just comes off as one of those YouTube liminal space horror videos when it's that empty.
- hammock 2y agoThe Apple brand is - foundationally - pretty solitary. Think about the early ipod ads, just individuals dancing to music by themselves. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_dSgBsCVpqo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_dSgBsCVpqo You can even go back to 1983 "Two kinds of people": a solitary man walks into an empty office, works by himself on the computer and then goes home for breakfast. https://youtu.be/4xmMYeFmc2Q https://youtu.be/4xmMYeFmc2Q
- flkiwi 2y agoIt's a strange conflict. So much of their other stuff is about togetherness mediated by technology (eg, facetime). And their Jobs-era presentations always ended with a note of appreciation for the folks who worked so hard to make the launch happen. But you're right that much of the brand imagery is solitary, right up to the whole "Here's to the crazy ones" vibe. It's weirdly dystopian. I didn't realize it bothered me until moments before my comment, but now I can't get it out of my head.
- xyst 2y ago> … advanced 12MP … camera wot, m8? Only Apple will call a 12 megapixel camera “advanced”. Same MPs as an old iPhone 6 rear camera. Aside from that, it’s pretty much the same as the prior generation. Same thickness in form factor. Slightly better SoC. Only worth it if you jump from M1 (or any Intel mbp) to M4. Would be godlike if Apple could make the chip swappable. Buy a Mac Studio M2 Ultra Max Plus. Then just upgrade SoC on an as needed basis. Would probably meet their carbon neutral/negative goals much faster. Reduce e-waste. Unfortunately this is an American company and got to turn profit. Profit over environment and consumer interests.
- hypercube33 2y agoI feel like if they pushed Win32/Gaming on Apple Mx hardware it'd give at least a single reason for people to adopt or upgrade their devices to new models. I know for sure I'd be on board if everything that ran on my steam deck ran on a mac game wise, since that's holding me back from dropping the cash. I still think I'll get a mini though.
- optymizer 2y agoMy only explanations for the lack of gaming support (see historical lack of proper OpenGL support) while still supporting high end graphics use cases (film editing, CAD, visual effects) are: 1) Either Apple wants to maintain the image of the Macbook as a "serious device", and not associate itself with the likes of "WoW players in their mom's basement". 2) Microsoft worked something out with Apple, where Apple would not step significantly on the gaming market (Windows, Xbox). I can't think of another reason why gaming on iOS would be just fine, but abysmal on MacOS. Developers release games on MacOS _despite_ the platform.
- Epicism 2y agoSteve Jobs was historically against gaming on apple devices and, I believe, went so far as to try to remove them from the Apple Store. Apple is only recently starting to introduce gaming seriously back into the platform.
- hit8run 2y agoBest time to buy a frame.work Linux Laptop without fomo. I’m done with Apple.
- resters 2y agoIt's hard to imagine ay reason why I would not want to keep upgrading to a new MPB every few years -- my M3 MBP is by far the best laptop I've owned thanks to the incredible battery life. Of course I'm rooting for competition, but Apple seems to be establishing a bigger and bigger lead with each iteration.
- spease 2y agoI don’t see the yearly releases as saying you have to upgrade. Rather, having a consistent cadence makes it easier for the supply chain, and the short iteration time means there’s less pressure to rush something in half-baked or delay a release.
- resters 2y agoI agree. my comment was not meant to suggest that I believe otherwise.
- telesilla 2y agoMy M1 laptop from early 2022 is too good for me to care about upgrading right now, I loaded it up with 64GB ram and it's still blazing. What benefit would I really notice? My heavy apps loading a couple of seconds faster?
- resters 2y agoI agree. I also have an M1 mini with 8GB of RAM and while I wish I'd bought one with more RAM, it work nicely when the task doesn't require much RAM. The incremental benefits of the M2-M4 are nice, but they do not obsolete the M1 by any stretch of the imagination.
- nwhnwh 2y agoThe notch makes me sad.
- mixmastamyk 2y agoIt's really two extra flaps. Feel better now?
- Aaron2222 2y agoYou can just turn it off. macOS lets you change the resolution to use just the screen below the notch, and because it's mini-LED, the now unused "flaps" to the sides of the notch are indistinguishable from the rest of the bezel.
- henry2023 2y agoThe real question is. Can I plug two monitors to it?
- michelb 2y agoYou can. And use your laptop screen as the third one.
- matrix87 2y ago> starting with 16GB of memory yeah it's about time
- emahhh 2y agoI'm fighting the urge to get the M4 Pro model so bad right now.
- _7acn 2y agoNo OLED yet :(
- nitsky 2y agoI'm waiting for OLED. Will purchase as soon as they do it.
- lukev 2y agoI really respect Apple's privacy focused engineering. They didn't roll out _any_ AI features until they were capable of running them locally, and before doing any cloud-based AI they designed and rolled out Private Cloud Compute. You can argue about whether it's actually bulletproof or not but the fact is, nobody else is even trying, and have lost sight of all privacy-focused features in their rush to ship anything and everything on my device to OpenAI or Gemini. I am thrilled to shell out thousands and thousands of dollars to purchase a machine that feels like it really belongs to me, from a company that respects my data and has aligned incentives.
- paulryanrogers 2y ago> to purchase a machine that feels like it really belongs to me How true is this when they devices are increasingly hostile to user repair and upgrades? MacOS also tightens the screws on what you can run and from where, or at least require more hoop jumping over time.
- arzke 2y ago> How true is this when they devices are increasingly hostile to user repair and upgrades? Not sure what you mean exactly by this, but to me their Self Service Repair program is a step in the right direction.
- sqeaky 2y agoIt was mandated by right to repair laws, it provides the absolute minimum, and they've attempted the price out people wanting to do repairs. The only way it could be more hostile to users is by literally being illegal. They could go out of their way to make things actually easy to work on and service, but that has never been the Apple Way. Compare to framework or building your own PC, or even repairing a laptop from another OEM.
- superb_dev 2y agoApple also left a very convenient hole in their boot loader to allow running another OS. Linux works pretty well these days
- hackerbeat 2y agoCan we just get a 32 inch iMac, please? I'm getting tired of everything else being updated yet the product most needed is completely being neglected, and for years already. And no, I don't wanna buy a separate tiny screen for thousands of dollars. I'm also not interested in these tiny cubes you deem to be cool.
- hermitcrab 2y agoDoes it still come with a crappy 1 year warranty?
- kristianp 2y ago> MacBook Pro with M4 Pro is up to 3x faster than M1 Pro (13) > (13) Testing conducted by Apple from August to October 2024 using preproduction 16-inch MacBook Pro systems with Apple M4 Pro, 14-core CPU, 20-core GPU, 48GB of RAM and 4TB SSD, and production 16-inch MacBook Pro systems with Apple M1 Pro, 10-core CPU, 16-core GPU, 32GB of RAM and 8TB SSD. Prerelease Redshift v2025.0.0 tested using a 29.2MB scene utilising hardware-accelerated ray tracing on systems with M4 Pro. Performance tests are conducted using specific computer systems and reflect the approximate performance of MacBook Pro. So they're comparing software that uses raytracing present in the M3 and M4, but not in the M1. This is really misleading. The true performance increase for most workloads is likely to be around 15% over the M3. We'll have to wait for benchmarks from other websites to get a true picture of the differences. Edit: If you click on the "go deeper on M4 chips", you'll get some comparisons that are less inflated, for example, code compilation on pro: 14-inch MacBook Pro with M4 4.5x 14-inch MacBook Pro with M3 3.8x 13-inch MacBook Pro with M1 2.7x So here the M4 Pro is 67% faster than the M1 Pro, and 18% faster than the M3 Pro. It varies by workload of course. No benchmarks yet, but this article gives some tables of comparative core counts, max RAM and RAM bandwidths: https://arstechnica.com/apple/2024/10/apples-m4-m4-pro-and-m4-max-compared-to-past-generations-and-to-each-other/ https://arstechnica.com/apple/2024/10/apples-m4-m4-pro-and-m...
- the_king 2y agoThe single core performance looks really fast. Chip | Geekbench Score (Process) ---- | ------------------------ M1 | 2,419 (5nm) M2 | 2,658 (5nm) M3 | 3,076 (3nm) M4* | 3,810 (3nm) In my experience, single-core CPU is the best all-around indicator of how "fast" a machine feels. I feel like Apple kind of buried this in their press release. M4 benchmark source: https://browser.geekbench.com/v6/cpu/8171874 https://browser.geekbench.com/v6/cpu/8171874
- tomcam 2y agoI don't know much about modern Geekbench scores, but it that chart seems to show that M1s are still pretty good? It appears that M4 is only about 50% faster. Somehow I would expect more like 100% improvement. Flameproof suit donned. Please correct me because I'm pretty ignorant about modern hardware. My main interest is playing lots of tracks live in Logic Pro.
- mjlee 2y agoApple claim up to 1.8x in the press release. They're cherry picking so 50% in a benchmark seems about right.
- tomcam 2y agoAppreciate the sanity check.
- the_king 2y agoThat's only single core. I think Logic is pretty optimized to use multiple cores (Apple demoed it on the 20 core Xeon Mac Pro back in 2019). But if the M1 isn't the bottleneck, no reason to upgrade.
- tomcam 2y agoVery good to know, thanks.
- giantrobot 2y ago
- cjbprime 2y agoDoes anyone understand this claim from the press release? > M4 Max supports up to 128GB of fast unified memory and up to 546GB/s of memory bandwidth, which is 4x the bandwidth of the latest AI PC chip. This allows developers to easily interact with large language models that have nearly 200 billion parameters. Having more memory bandwidth is not directly helpful in using larger LLM models. A 200B param model requires at least 200GB RAM quantized down from the original precision (e.g. "bf16") to "q8" (8 bits per parameter), and these laptops don't even have the 200GB RAM that would be required to run inference over that quantized version. How can you "easily interact with" 200GB of data, in real-time, on a machine with 128GB of memory??
- kristianp 2y agoq4 or q5 quantization. Edit: Actually you'd want q3 to fit a 200B model into 128GB of RAM. e.g. this one is about 140GB https://huggingface.co/lmstudio-community/DeepSeek-V2.5-GGUF/tree/main https://huggingface.co/lmstudio-community/DeepSeek-V2.5-GGUF...
- cjbprime 2y agoWouldn't it be incredibly misleading to say you can interact with an LLM, when they really mean that you can lossy-compress it to like 25% size where it becomes way less useful and then interact with that? (Isn't that kind of like saying you can do real-time 4k encoding when you actually mean it can do real-time 720p encoding and then interpolate the missing pixels?)
- kristianp 2y agoYes the size is much reduced, and you do have reduced quality as a result, but it isn't as bad as what you're implying. Just a few days ago Meta released q4 versions of their llama models. It's an active research topic.
- joshdavham 2y agoQuestion to more senior Mac users: how do you usually decide when to upgrade? I bought my first Macbook pro about a year and a half ago and it's still working great.
- y7 2y agoWhen it stops working great. My 2014 Macbook is about due for an upgrade, mostly due to the GPU struggling with a 4K screen.
- sequoia 2y agoThe 2014 model I bought in early 2015 still works, though the battery is dodgy. I did get the motherboard replaced in 2020 which was pricey, but much cheaper than a new machine. Is there some reason your current computer isn't working for you? If not, why upgrade? Use it as long as you can do so practically & easily. On the other extreme, I knew someone who bought a new MBP with maximum RAM specs each year. She'd sell the old one for a few hundred less than she paid, then she always had new hardware with applecare. It was basically like leasing a machine for $400/yr.
- aequitas 2y agoMy previous Macbook was a Pro model from 2015, I waited 6 years to finally upgrade to an M1 Air because of the awful touchbar models they had in between (though I'm still using the 2015 Pro for personal stuff, in fact right now. It's upgraded to the latest macOS using OpenCore and it still runs great). But I would say upgrade every 3-5 years depending on heavy a professional user you are.
- AdamJacobMuller 2y agoThe touchbar was useful in one important way. Because it made the esc key useless for touch typists and because, as a vi user, I hit esc approximately a bazillion times per day I mapped caps lock to esc. Now my fingers don't travel as far to hit esc. I still use that mapping even on my regular keyboards and my current non-touch-bar macs. Thanks touchbar macs, rest in peace.
- EugeneOZ 2y agoNo OLED = skip. Your microBlaBla just causes headeaches.
- joeevans1000 2y agoInsane cost for the amount of storage and RAM. I mean, year over year for Apple, awesome! Compared to the rest of the brands... so ridiculously expensive. Watching the price climb to 5K as you add in the new normal for hardware specs is absurd.
- phs318u 2y agoThe single most annoying thing about this announcement for me is the fact that I literally just paid for an Asus ProArt P16 [0] on the basis that the Apple offerings I was looking at were too expensive. Argh! [0] https://au.store.asus.com/proart-p16-h7606wi-me124xs.html https://au.store.asus.com/proart-p16-h7606wi-me124xs.html
- semiinfinitely 2y agoGreat I cant wait for the software bloat to expand and make these the only machines that feel fast
- dgellow 2y agoDamn, I just bought an M3
- timothyduong 2y agoCan return it if you bought it recently.
- crossroadsguy 2y agoThis is the first time they have not obscenely limited their starter offerings with 8GB RAM. The time it took them to do that is just pathetic. Now I guess this will happen until how long? Maybe 2034 - and starting RAM 16GB. I wish I could say it's a welcome change but in 2024 for such overpriced machine if they are starting with 16GB RAM then that's anything but special. Also, I am sure the SSDs and RAMs are still soldered tight :) If only they could allow their iPads to be used as a Mac screen natively I might buy a Mini and an iPad and get done with it two use cases but why would Apple want users to be able to do that without extra expense.
- userbinator 2y agoAt least it appears they didn't hide the power button on the bottom.
- treprinum 2y agoI hoped for at least 192GB of RAM for LLMs as 48GB DDR5 are pretty normal nowadays.
- xcv123 2y agoThey want you to buy a Mac Pro or Studio for that
- rldjbpin 2y agosaw very little discourse in the fact that apple silicon is following a "tick-tock" approach, very much like intel in the 2010s. for the sake of annual releases we get a new number, but besides increased silicon area, the major architectural changes seem to come every couple years. about time 16gb was the default on something that costs four figures. the on-device ai craze in this lineup has finally pushed the company to give adequate memory.
- aorth 2y agoFour generations into the new platform and there is no answer from anyone else in the industry. Incredible.
- BossingAround 2y agoIntel's Core 5/Core 7/Core 9 are an answer.
- aorth 2y agoI dunno. Four years ago the MacBook M1 Pro was able to compile WebKit nearly as fast as the Mac Pro, and nearly twice as fast as the Intel-based MacBook Pro, and still had 91% battery versus 24% in the Intel-based MacBook Pro. Incredible. https://techcrunch.com/2020/11/17/yeah-apples-m1-macbook-pro-is-powerful-but-its-the-battery-life-that-will-blow-you-away/ https://techcrunch.com/2020/11/17/yeah-apples-m1-macbook-pro...
- zuhsetaqi 2y agoBut now its four years later
- preisschild 2y agoI switched my work M1 Max with an AMD Ryzen 9 7940HS Framework 16 running Linux and am happier since. I guess it depends on the person which computer is better for them.
- ElCapitanMarkla 2y agoI wish I could get that option but I'm still waiting for an NZ release :(
- greggroth 2y agoI'm torn between the new M4 MBP and a Framework laptop with Linux for my personal computer. Can you share some deciding factors for you? Does it mostly come down to the OS? How is the battery life with the Framework?
- fredgrott 2y agoYou probably missed this.... If you look at the top of line Apple mini at 64gig ram it seems to replace Apple Studio for certain use cases...
- consumerx 2y agoBeen using Pro products for almost 15 years and I just switched to a Lenovo Thinkpad and Ubuntu. This is so much more fun and innovative. Apple reached a plato, you can like it or not.
- nobodyandproud 2y agoI suspect that like many here, I’m often tech support for my family. I found a Mac to be just as simple and troublefree to support as a Chromebook, but more capable. I was very pleasantly surprised, coming from mostly Windows (and a dash of Linux).
- baggachipz 2y agoMy parents simply refuse to consider anything but Windows, even though the ever-changing Windows UI keeps pissing them off. It's like a mental block or something.
- bjelkeman-again 2y agoI stopped supporting Windows. Mom had to swap if she wanted support from me.
- xandrius 2y agoNo support then. But when I gave my mom OSX, she used it and managed to survive. Even Ubuntu was ok for her. And if she managed, I'm sure most people can.
- sfmike 2y agoI wonder if apple intelligence will be resource heavy and this is the reason for the RAM increase across the board.
- munksbeer 2y agoFor the gamers amongst you, do any of you game on your MacBook Pro Ms? If so, which one? Is there a noticeable difference in game quality between the M1 Pro vs M3 Pro for example?
- AtlasBarfed 2y agoIs the SSD still soldered, so if your macbook dies so does your data?
- r_hanz 2y agoDoes iCloud mitigate this? It’s always confused me that iCloud is intended only as a data sync and not back-up… If one device goes down and the rest still work, could you still access data from the dead device?
- ethagknight 2y agoI wish Apple would include a USB-C data port or 2 on their big charger brick for the same single-cord bliss that the iMac enjoys (while plugged in). My little USB hubs that I carry around cant sufficiently power the MacBook pro