61 ms·
U.S. military shoots down suspected Chinese surveillance balloon
- metadat 4y agoNarrator: "A job well done by the US Military" I'm glad we have sufficient technology and capability to shoot down a balloon. What happens next?
- zw123456 4y agoThe trick is to shoot it down in a way it falls slowly so you can retrieve it and see what is in it, although, I suspect our intelligence agencies have a pretty good idea already. I have no idea of course, but one thing I thought would be a Stingray, at that altitude you could intercept thousands of cell calls. I doubt that's what it is but the other thing is if it has any radio jamming capabilities or other things of offensive nature.
- mrandish 4y agoI doubt it was to get a day of cell phone intercepts since it would be far easier and stealthier for China simply send a Stingray-type device to one of their thousands of industrial espionage agents already operating in the U.S. to drive it around in a van in whatever area and time period they are targeting. In fact, I suspect they (and others) already do that. I think the purpose for sending the balloon was primarily to analyze the radar and RF environment on approach to U.S. airspace. The secondary purpose may have been as a test to see how and how quickly we would respond to the provocation. We may not learn much from the wreckage as I suspect we'll find a lot of wide-band software defined radio gear which already uploaded its recorded data via satellite and wiped its software.
- zw123456 4y agoTrue, although from up there you can collect a lot more than on the ground of course. The US does the same thing over international waters off China. The other concern would be if it has jamming capabilities, you can jam an earth station pretty easily from a balloon and effectively blind our satellites. Even if there is wreckage, you can tell if there is offensive signal equipment like that.
- unyttigfjelltol 4y ago> The US does the same thing over international waters off China. That's a good observation. Maybe the simplest explanation is China's "force majeure" claim was "true" and this was a wayward airship that was supposed to have transited the US west coast and Mexico or Latin America. Just like U.S. observational activities in international waters, just a little more invasive. Thus, when the military mentions they are tracking a similar balloon over Latin America-- what they mean is they know this balloon was intended to follow a different route too.
- zw123456 4y agoI suspect Hanlon's razor is operational here. China uses those things off in international waters all the time, the fact that this one almost perfectly followed the jet stream seems to indicate it may have had a malfunction of its propulsion system and it drifted with the wind. When the US uses them in the China sea they have the advantage that if there is a malfunction it usually would drift safely West away from China.
- epistemer 4y agoThe radar and RF on approach might make sense. I just don't see how a provocation test makes any sense though. It is hardly like America is not willing to use military force. Really, a mistake on the part of China feels like the Occam's razor explanation to me. It is just very hard to see the risk/reward calculation to do this intentionally with spy networks both on the ground and in space.
- crtified 4y agoIt would be fairly rudimentary (in context!) to fit such a device with sensors against certain intrusions (e.g. loss of balloon pressure) which would then trigger near-instant self destruction of electronics. I would be quite surprised if such a high tech spy device did not have such contingencies as part of it's design. And suspect it's probably one of the reasons why the risk of an overland shootdown wasn't taken - that is, there's no point risking collateral damage from falling debris, when you know the device will be programmed to wipe itself of most useful information upon being physically compromised.
- zw123456 4y agoTrue, although, evidence of offensive transmitters is difficult to completely destroy, heavy heat sinks and so forth. Simply erasing memory does not obliterate such clues.
- Merad 4y agoI’ve seen some unconfirmed claims that they show it with a missile whose warhead fuse was disabled. Normally anti-aircraft missiles are proximity fused and throw out lots of fragments when they explode, kind of like a giant shotgun blast. With the warhead disabled presumably it just punctured the balloon to deflate it and, as you say, hopefully let it come down intact.
- sarchertech 4y agoF-22s have a 20mm cannon, and they can operate at 65k feet. I don't know why they would need a disarmed missile just to poke a hole in it.
- metadat 4y agoPerhaps the quantity of holes from an aircraft cannon is harder to control and less surgical than a single ground based missile? Somehow I doubt wasted funds were at the top of the priority list (because intel is valuable, this whole incident has been a huge "WTF?" so far).
- Merad 4y agoThe official service ceiling of the F-22 is only 50,000 feet. There’s no doubt that it can fly higher (for example the F-15 set zoom climb records going up to nearly 100,000 ft) but at those altitudes controlling an aircraft gets a lot more difficult due to the thin air. If the F-22 _does_ have good control at those altitudes then using that capability for the shoot down would be revealing previously unknown (presumably classified) info about it. If it doesn’t, attempting a zoom climb close enough for a cannon shot would carry some risk… even if just risk of missing and having to try again while the whole world watches.
- anon7725 4y ago> What happens next? They retrieve the wreckage and analyze it. We hear nothing further.
- foverzar 4y agoDidn't they shoot it over the ocean? What's there to retrieve?
- skee8383 4y ago[flagged]
- honkler 4y agounironically this.
- unsupp0rted 4y agoThere’s no way this cost as little as $30k to handle, is there?
- chasd00 4y agoHeh I suspect a sparrow missile costs way more than $30k and an F22 Raptor probably costs over $30k/minute to operate
- selectodude 4y agoF22 is about $100k/hr.
- ascotan 4y agoNow we need to develop a high altitude needle gun for popping balloons. I knew all those games I played in school would come in handy one day.
- IAmGraydon 4y agoIt really is a shame that snarky posts that add nothing of value like this seem to be on the rise on HN. This used to be one of the few places on the internet you could go to avoid brain dead commentary from people who think they're clever and really belong with the children on Reddit. I really hope that the core group here gets a grip on this. In case you haven't read it in a while: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- metadat 4y agoI understand that some comments may not be what you are looking for in a discussion, but I believe it's important to keep an open mind, strive to be inclusive, and consider the purpose of feedback. Your input can be valuable in helping improve the thread, even if it's not directly actionable. Let's also keep in mind that the interpretation of "snark" is somewhat subjective, and if you feel a trailing question has some value despite a perceived "dumb preamble", perhaps consider leaving it un-upvoted (as I believe you have generously done in this case). Additionally, there are some helpful tools available to manage content that you find uninteresting or mildly offensive. These are the "[-]" collapse and "next" buttons. If you feel a comment strays too far, the staff at hn@ycombinator.com are very responsive and willing to assist.
- mushbino 4y agoWhat do you feel your comment adds to the discussion?
- blitzar 4y agoSuperbowl is in a week or so. The F-22 that shot down the Chinese Spy Balloon is going to do a flyby.
- ironyman 4y agoI actually think it might just be a stray weather balloon. If they considered it a security threat they would've downed it before it reached continental US. Overall it's a fair resolution. It's a good political move to raise public awareness of tensions with the PRC (you'd be surprised how many people don't know). Downing it is mostly symbollic and completes the safety narrative.
- ikekkdcjkfke 4y agoF35 signature probe
- riskpreneurship 4y agoSeems unlikely, considering the size of the payload and the presence of propellers to help it navigate.
- chitowneats 4y agoWere the balloons from China transiting over Guam and Hawaii also blown of course? There are enough of these incidents for it to not seem like a coincidence.
- neuralRiot 4y agoI’m not in the defense industry neither know how the Chinese spy agency works but I guess there are more covert ways to spy than sending a 20ft ballon half way around the world.
- chitowneats 4y agoOne theory is that the Chinese know that. This could be them sending a message: "If you defend Taiwan, we can get over your heads cheaply and easily". The only casualties on the U.S. mainland during WW2 were Japanese balloons dropping bombs on the west coast. I doubt that symbolism was lost on the military or the Biden administration.
- credit_guy 4y ago
- skee8383 4y ago[flagged]
- sebzim4500 4y agoEmbarassing for who? AFAICT the US did pretty much what you would expect them to do in this situation.
- Kibae 4y agoI wonder what the cost to take down the balloon was for the US (including monitoring it) vs. the cost of the balloon for China. If the ratio is something greater than 10:1, then I would say China got a pretty good ROI on a small investment.
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoIt was probably a much higher ratio than that. Wouldn't be surprised if it was actually 1000:1. On the other hand, the military is constantly in need of new drills to keep everyone's skills sharp. This was a pretty good one for them with no negative outcomes beyond whatever data might have been collected and sent back to China.
- treis 4y agoThe thing is gigantic. It's definitely not cheap and most likely more than the unit cost of a missile.
- iancmceachern 4y agoMissles are pretty expensive, the sidewinders they used to shoot out down cost between 200 and 400k
- ancientworldnow 4y agoA regular hot air balloon can cost 200-400k and this is substantially larger with more lift capability and had presumably expensive payload and propulsion. Worldview spent millions of dollars on a substantially smaller balloon that granted is capable of a few miles higher flight with less payload.
- iancmceachern 4y agoNot really, a regular hot air balloon usually costs 20-40k, a crazy fancy shaped balloon ised for advertising will maybe push 100.
- 7174n6 4y ago[flagged]
- rationalist 4y agoWhat information could the balloon collect that satellite or cars on the ground not collect? Air samples?
- Vecr 4y agoPossibly an Operation Sea-Spray[0] like biological weapons test? Not sure how they would do it exactly, but possibly some sort of stimulant in the form of an extremely fine powder. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Sea-Spray https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Sea-Spray
- Idk__Throwaway 4y agoIm almost certain that they would have heavily tested and analyzed the balloon and its payload as soon as it got near the US to ensure that there were no unusual emmisions coming from it.
- mysterydip 4y agoSomeone in another thread said "I think the purpose for sending the balloon was primarily to analyze the radar and RF environment on approach to U.S. airspace.", which would be something dependent on reference point and not able to be done from satellite or cars.
- mushbino 4y agoThey could much more easily do that with an actual commercial aircraft.
- aquova 4y agoWhat would you have them do? I know many people wanted it shot down over Montana, but even the most rural places have more people than you'd think. If they had shot it down and it had hit someone/something, or even come close to it, it would be a complete disaster.
- pyuser583 4y agoAm I the only one with “99 Luftballoons” in my head?
- Mountain_Skies 4y agoNena probably got an extra $5 in royalties this month from the large number of people who immediately thought of that song.
- DonHopkins 4y agoAnd Nina Hagen probably also got an extra $5000 royalties this month from the even larger number of people who immediately confused her with Nena. (Well deserved royalties, to compensate her for all the confusion!) https://auntie-anti.livejournal.com/576.html https://auntie-anti.livejournal.com/576.html >y'all look the same to me. >99 red balloons. Nina vs Nena: the continuing saga. >Nina Hagen= Nina Hagen. >Gabriele Susanne Kerner= Nena (nickname band name). >Yes, they are both german women who's music career heights were in the 80's, and their first "names" are very similar, but that does not make them the same person. >Nina Hagen= "The Mother of Punk". >Nena= some sweaty chick in a band that had one fluffy hit single, and yes, please know that i'm talking about "99 red balloons". psst...the german version is better. >Recently-ish photos of Nina Hagen were posted in a decent and somewhat elitist (in a good way) lj makeup community. She's a good example of outrageous makeup, and "known", or so I thought, for her style...as much as for her voice and music, since hers is not like anyone else's. I was terribly terribly terribly dead wrong. With the many-o-many comments that were being made, each stating a similar; "omfg i LOVE Nina Hagen and i loooove her song 99 red balloons!!! it's my most favourite retro song i love the 80's!" There was no correction in sight amongst the gathering list of commenters declaring their love and 'hoping for cool points' knowledge of Nina. >This is Nina Hagen... [...follow links for outrageous photos...] doesn't even scratch the surface of all the looks, but i'd be here all year posting photos to almost accomplish that. she's deliciously fucked. >And now pay close attention. This is Nena, the singer of "99 red/luftballoons"... um...yeah... And i even got a photo of them together. not the same person! https://img.photobucket.com/albums/v732/stabbings/ninanena.jpg https://img.photobucket.com/albums/v732/stabbings/ninanena.j... >The bigger difference is in their singing voices actually. >Nena= nice, normal, regular chick singing voice. >Nina Hagen= is a vocal genius. studied opera and incorporates that in her insane variety of deranged sweetness, down to an extreme that makes all death metal bands sound like a choir of girl scouts with mints thins in their nickers. https://www.last.fm/music/Nina+Hagen/_/99+Red+Balloons https://www.last.fm/music/Nina+Hagen/_/99+Red+Balloons https://songmeanings.com/songs/view/87616/ https://songmeanings.com/songs/view/87616/ https://twitter.com/optiblu2013/status/1466506526831611906 https://twitter.com/optiblu2013/status/1466506526831611906 https://songsear.ch/song/Nina-Hagen/99-Luft-Balloon/1481506 https://songsear.ch/song/Nina-Hagen/99-Luft-Balloon/1481506 https://teenage.cz/texty/nina-hagen/-/99-red-balloons-99-luftballons https://teenage.cz/texty/nina-hagen/-/99-red-balloons-99-luf... Herman Brood, Nina Hagen & Lene Lovich - Crocodile (1979) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xFIjlxl-DLI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xFIjlxl-DLI Nina Hagen New York New York https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oiscau0zJKc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oiscau0zJKc The closest she ever came to covering 99 Red Baboons was Auf'm Bahnhof Zoo: NINA HAGEN - Auf´m Bahnhof Zoo "Live" 1978 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oiscau0zJKc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oiscau0zJKc 99 Red Baboons https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wz-z_JV6wSE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wz-z_JV6wSE http://www.amiright.com/parody/80s/nana0.shtml http://www.amiright.com/parody/80s/nana0.shtml
- cududa 4y agoI had seen reports that the balloon was the length of 3-4 school busses but it appears that was misreported and just repeated. The PAYLOAD was the length of 3-4 school busses. I haven’t been following this much until today/ vaguely aware as an amusing background story. But, has anyone seen high res photos of the balloon or someone doing back of the envelope math on the size of the balloon portion? I ask simply because a payload the length of 3-4 school busses (apparently 45 feet) would be quite large and the ballon itself much much larger than I was imagining
- ricardobeat 4y agoMultiple people reported that it was visible to naked eye from the ground, it must have been huge for that.
- heartbreak 4y agoI saw it from my car today while driving before I knew it was going to be in my area. It was very visible to the naked eye. It was large enough that the perspective made it seem a lot lower altitude than it actually was.
- ineedasername 4y agoI think it was at 60,000 ft. It’s got to be pretty damn big to be so obvious to casual ground observers. It will be very interesting to see, to the extent that details are released to the public, the parameters and specs of this thing.
- za3faran 4y agoNot sure what the CCP is thinking. Are they simply trying to instigate a response with such a brazen display?
- mike_d 4y agoAs a data point: previously spotted surveillance blimps in the Asia Pacific theatre use a clear balloon. Either China wanted to see if it would be detected, or is woefully behind the US equivalents.
- dang 4y agoRecent and related: Chinese surveillance balloon spotted over U.S., Pentagon says - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34634304 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34634304 - Feb 2023 (404 comments)
- downvotetruth 4y agoMissile was way overkill - your tax dollars at work! It had been observed for days: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/chinese-spy-balloon-has-unexpected-maneuverability/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/chinese-spy-ballo... A balloon's surface is not rigid. Clipping it with a wing would have been enough to deflate it as there is minimal to no risk of damaging a metal wing. Let alone the week or so they had to prepare a M61 Vulcan Gatling gun on an F15 that can fly at 65k ft above the 60k ft flight altitude of the balloon. Lack of air retrieval was also very disappointing. Imagine if it had a secondary payload that dispersed in the water or near the ground.
- nocsi 4y agoDirected energy would be better. But then missles are something the general public can understand. It also falls in line with the US making a big drama about this
- innagadadavida 4y agoWhile these are all great points, I guess this has changed people’s perception of risks and we are now more open to spending billions of USD to close these perceived and real gaps. It won’t be surprising if there is a huge defense spending bill in congress with carve out for war in Ukraine and this time it will go through as the Republicans won’t hold back.
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoIt's a practical training exercise and a worthwhile experiment to confirm the inventory can be used against a novel threat. You realize millions of dollars get spent shooting missiles into target drones every year. One extra on a real target isn't an issue.
- djmips 4y agoAre you sure it was at an altitude they could safely fly a craft to carry out your plan?
- noodlesUK 4y agoHow else would you aim to shoot it down? The published flight ceiling for most fighter jets is somewhere around 60,000 feet (I’m sure they can go higher if they want to, but exactly how high is probably valuable intelligence). Weather balloons on the other hand fly much higher. This would have been likely (I don’t know) between 60,000 and 120,000 feet. You certainly couldn’t just do a gun run at that altitude. Clipping it with a wing is a great way of killing your pilot, as you’ve basically asked them to crash directly into an unknown object.
- nocsi 4y agoIn previous times, the US would ignore these balloons and quietly take them down. Instead they made a big deal out of it and milked it. Brilliant and opposite of what china expected
- anigbrowl 4y agoGiven that it was visible to the naked eye and people were talking about it, it's silly to blame this on the government.
- gruez 4y ago>Given that it was visible to the naked eye But why did this garner so much attention compared to the weather ballons that the US launches on a regular basis?
- anigbrowl 4y agoProbably because it was quite a bit larger than usual, going by initial reports. What do you want the government to do, lie and pretend it's one of theirs?
- jghn 4y agoIt also helps that one side of the political spectrum were able to use it to cast doubt and blame at the other side of the spectrum
- allisdust 4y agoThere is an enemy balloon flying in your sovereign space and all you could think about is it enables the other side of the politics? Would you say the same thing if its an enemy war plane. And there is no way to to tell which is which just because it looks cute and fluffy floating in the air. I'm not from the US but at this rate your country doesn't need any external enemies.
- sumoboy 4y agoF22 shooting this down is definitely a sign of strength. If this were a James bond movie, a predator drone would have just hooked that balloon and brought it back intact. What prevents China or anyone else to just launch dozens or hundreds of these?
- bamboozled 4y agoThe fact there would be no point ?
- gharman 4y agoCost differential is an interesting thing to consider if this were done at scale. That single missile cost ~$500K (plus flight time for the F22 isn't cheap). How much would each balloon be, especially if some were decoys without any real payload? That said, drones vs ships seems like a starker cost differential than this.
- bamboozled 4y agoOn the other hand, I’ll ask again, what’s the point ? We have balloons flying around ? Cool ?
- mushbino 4y agoTo get better weather info?
- mushbino 4y ago[flagged]
- honkler 4y ago[flagged]
- ricardobeat 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- awlkjlekrt 4y ago[flagged]
- awlkjlekrt 4y ago[flagged]
- awlkjlekrt 4y ago[flagged]
- xracy 4y agoThis seems like a worse idea than just collecting the thing and putting it in a faraday cage.
- cdot2 4y agoHow do you go about collect it from 65,000 feet?
- downvotetruth 4y agoShould have been pierced to start deflating over the Pacific when it entered the U.S. air defense zone north of the Aleutian Islands on Jan. 28: https://apnews.com/article/politics-united-states-government-antony-blinken-china-b1b03193b7abeb7bbeca169bbc7c2c53 https://apnews.com/article/politics-united-states-government.... See metal hook at the end of a rope from a helicopter: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3C6_pdSedow https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3C6_pdSedow
- cdot2 4y agoIt sounds like it wasnt detected until after it was already over the US and they shot it down over ~47ft deep water so it can be recovered pretty easily
- albntomat0 4y agoHelicopters can’t fly to 65000 ft, due to the low air density.
- cuteboy19 4y agoA ladder perhaps? Or ... another balloon!
- boredhedgehog 4y agoWith another balloon? You'd just want to cut off and grab the payload, right?
- xracy 4y agoNot gonna lie, I don't know. But I feel like it's probably more useful to gather information on it than to destroy it.
- pxc 4y agoI am so tired of China being used to stoke American jingoism, of politicians making a contest of who is really 'tough on China' and, most horrifyingly, of seeing other USians online practically salivate as they fantasize about a war with China. It's some cold war boogieman horseshit. And it's depressing to watch here on Hacker News, too, any comments that question the beating of those war drums go dead. Yesterday I heard someone bemoan the supposed lack of patriotism today, and wish we could be 'united' like we were after 9/11. You know, that time we rushed headlong into two useless forever wars that ended hundreds of thousands of human lives and brutally disrupted millions more. The time we saw Sikhs assaulted in the streets for daring to sort of look like Muslims in the eyes of uncultured hicks. And when the entire media apparatus, 'left' and 'right' rallied to pump out war propaganda for years and years. Disgusting and depressing. And it's where I fear we're headed every time I see China in US headlines anymore.
- stcroixx 4y ago[flagged]
- pokepim 4y ago[dead]
- unity1001 4y ago> their continued atrocities Before it comes to China's alleged atrocities that every single Muslim country's parliamentarians and diplomants say they dont exist: Have you yet persecuted and jailed those who murdered 1 million in Iraq?
- LarryMullins 4y agoAmerica voted for a president who said he would, but then reneged on that promise. https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/aug/31/obama-justice-department-immunity-bush-cia-torturer https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2012/aug/31/obama-... Fuck you Obama!
- FpUser 4y ago>"... size of three school busses..." Size of school bus in the US range anywhere from 20 to 45 feet. I surprised they did not measure it in anacondas.
- scotty79 4y agoConverting school buses to feet doesn't do much good for nearly everybody on this planet. Use metric.
- FpUser 4y agoI prefer furlongs.
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoWashing machines is the standard unit there isn't it?
- yazzku 4y agoIt was half the radius of a football field.
- amelius 4y agoSo they waited until the balloon was over sea. This raises the question: why didn't the military see it coming and destroy it before it crossed the border?
- luxuryballs 4y agothey claimed they started tracking it over the Pacific even, my guess is we just don’t have the full story, perhaps they didn’t want to fail at shooting it down quickly, succeed at responding the “real” way and give something away, or spring some other “trap card”, or it’s all a lie and was our own thing that got away or just a distraction and everything after that was reactionary and opportunistic, we may never know
- dsfyu404ed 4y agoBecause it wasn't a political kerfuffle then and they weren't gonna be the ones to make it into one.
- themodelplumber 4y agoI wonder...is there any value to: - IDing components, maybe even using some x-ray tech like US satellites have - Developing an idea of what this thing vacuums up, informationally - Switching our monitoring posture to also vacuuming up the same as it travels along, as if we are co-spying on our own stuff - Using the information product to help harden any sensitive information that was vacuumed, for counter-intel purposes This would fit the general parameters of what the public saw happening (almost nothing, then bang as soon as the balloon is floating over literally nothing).
- darkwraithcov 4y agoIf its anything like the cold war where we did this with the Russkies (and prior to that, The Nazis) it makes sense to me it would have significant electronic warfare value.
- ascotan 4y agoThis isn't the first balloon with equipment on it that has overflown US territory (which should also put to rest the 'rogue weather balloon' theory). China has been doing this ever since Trump started levying import taxes on Chinese goods. This particular balloon was brazen enough to be loitering over military targets for some time. It makes sense to do a shoot down over the ocean so you can have a better chance to recover the payload for analysis.
- dctoedt 4y agoThe video of the shoot-down shows flashes from the detached-and-falling payload, probably explosive self-destruct devices detonating. (It'd be shocking if the Chinese didn't include a self-destruct capability.)
- boomboomsubban 4y agoIsn't it a hydrogen balloon? Wouldn't some level of explosion be expected?
- mlindner 4y agoNo. This type of balloon uses helium.
- sebzim4500 4y agoYou'll probably still get some information from the wreckage even if a self destruct activated.
- chii 4y agoThen it's not a very good self-destruct!
- KennyBlanken 4y agoIt's pretty clearly pieces of solar panel tumbling and catching sunlight as they fall. China would not risk of flying explosives over the continental US given the US was "balloon bombed" by Japan during WW2. If the thing crashed in some farmer's field and then blew up when he went to poke it with a stick, it wouldn't start WW3, but would result in huge domestic political pressure to "do something". Even just video of the thing blowing up mid-air would be horrendous optics. "They were flying something really dangerous over us!"
- thickydementer 4y ago[flagged]
- 5m17h 4y agocreate:4 minutes ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- scotty79 4y agoWhy didn't they just down it safely harpooning it from a helicopter or something? Didn't they want to investigate the payload in detail rather than mangled remains? Was it really just a scientific baloon but US found it more useful to accuse Chinese of sending grotesquely large and not stealthy at all spy balloon? Otherwise why destroy it? EDIT: I stand corrected that USA just didn't have the technological capacity to do anything other than firing a missile at it from a fighter jet.
- popilewiz 4y agoIt was about 20km in the air. Helicopters don't fly that high
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- qbasic_forever 4y agoHelicopters can't fly up to 60k feet or so where the balloon was floating.
- sv123 4y ago60,000 feet up.
- throwmeaway1212 4y agoHow much experience do you think people have harpooning a spy balloon from a helicopter? and landing it safely.... I...can't believe there's many people who have experience in that...
- this_steve_j 4y agoThe balloon was traveling at an altitude of 60,000 ft., well above the 40,000 ft height a commercial aircraft or the highest experimental helicopter can fly. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_China_balloon_incident https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2023_China_balloon_incident
- Andrex 4y ago"Why didn't they just" If you ever start a sentence this way, please, just do 30 seconds of Googling instead of posting the comment.
- sabujp 4y agoSpy balloon cost : $3k - $50k , you can even buy them on alibaba and some other sites: https://www.alibaba.com/product-detail/China-hot-sale-surveillance-balloon-with_60454941082.html https://www.made-in-china.com/showroom/jennerjiang/product-list/catalog-1.html?view=0 Cost to shoot down balloon with F22 $400k for the AIM-9X, ~$85k for 1 hour of flight time, so ~$400 - $500k to shoot down one balloon that cost < $50k
- themodelplumber 4y agoQuite different if it's a one-off, this was nearly experimental expense for the US on various levels.
- scotty79 4y agoI guess China just discovered a strategy how to drain US of some resources. Just let out a lot of scientific baloons and let the dirft away.
- kcb 4y agoI don't think anyone considers the expenditure of 1 AIM-9, probably the most ubiquitous A2A missile platform in history, a drain of resources.
- pixl97 4y agoI mean if it became enough of an issue it would not be hard to deal with them with some other type of weapon. https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/pdfs/ADA425537.pdf https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/pdfs/ADA425537.pdf Laser weapons were not highly effective against fast objects like ICBMs, but a slow moving weak object like a balloon should represent a pretty easy target.
- Kukumber 4y ago[flagged]
- jahewson 4y agoFighter jets are the only planes even remotely close to capable of flying to 65,000ft. It’s physically impossible to send any other type of aircraft, there’s simply not enough air up there.
- Kukumber 4y agoThis doesn't answer my question, why not capture it? why destroy it? It's not "physically impossible" since the balloon is flying up there
- gonzo41 4y agoThe Us military only shot it down because of pr. Usually you ignore spy planes. The are easy to track, and the military and airforce know how to sit around and wait things out. America should retaliate with its own balloons with no Intel packages, instead the should be very visible, and at the ceiling of most fighters so China has to waste be anti satellite missiles on cheap balloons.
- ascotan 4y ago>>> America should retaliate with its own balloons I can imagine someone playing 99 luftballons in the background during the launch.
- pixl97 4y agoUm, it's kinda hard to do that to China especially in the winter. Prevailing winds would come out of Russia and more westerly countries. I don't think any of them are going to allow a launch or a flyover of a balloon to tease the Chinese government.
- gonzo41 4y agoActually I wouldn't be so sure. Western Navies are constantly doing freedom of navigation exercises.
- markus_zhang 4y agoChina did shoot down some balloons back in the day. This is 2019. https://weibo.com/tv/show/1034:4865451742920798?from=old_pc_videoshow https://weibo.com/tv/show/1034:4865451742920798?from=old_pc_...
- droptablemain 4y ago[flagged]
- JackFr 4y ago> The Pentagon, which badly wants a war with China That’s simply not true.
- droptablemain 4y ago[flagged]
- dang 4y agoPlease don't post flamewar comments. It's not what this site is for, and destroys what it is for. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- gnicholas 4y agoIf what China said was true, wouldn't it have notified the US when it was going to be entering our airspace? Was any notification made? The news (to the extent it would know and would accurately report such a fact) has indicated that the US was not notified.
- gamblor956 4y ago...across several thousand miles of ocean, and land, and curiously ended up right over another nation's capital even though the intervening stormfronts should have pushed it up into Canada or Mexico during the balloon's trip...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- spydum 4y agoI'm surprised nobody mentioned: we were already researching these ourselves: https://www.thedefensepost.com/2022/07/06/us-military-balloons/ https://www.thedefensepost.com/2022/07/06/us-military-balloo...
- turbobooster 4y agoFake Orwellian wars....just like fake conpetiton via price fixing that typical people won't admit to because they need to do a 2-minute hate on someone/something.
- snickerbockers 4y agoIm pretty impressed that it made it all the way across the continent in a couple days, i had no idea high altitude balloons could move that fast.
- pixl97 4y agoTechnically the ballon isn't moving itself in anyway at all, it instead is depending on the wind. As the atmospheric pressure lowers the maximum speed of the wind can increase greatly. For example the speed of the jet stream commonly exceeds 275 miles per hour. It looks like the strongest jet winds were closer to canada, had the jet been in the US it could have made it across the country in a day.
- ineedasername 4y agoThere was mention by the Chinese that is had some motive power of its own, or at least strongly implied when their PR said some the thing like “limited maneuvering capability”. That seems to indicate that it had some. It would a bit surprising if a payload the size of 2-3 school buses wasn’t outfitted with a reasonable amount of controllability, at least some control surfaces even if they inexplicably excluded even minimal and limited propulsion.
- NegativeLatency 4y agoProbably ballast control to select favorable winds at different altitudes A reserve of buoyant gas and/or some weights to drop
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kelnos 4y ago"Maneuvering capability" probably means that it can affect its course (probably by ascending or descending to find more favorable winds), not speed.
- seanmcdirmid 4y ago
- pieresqi 4y ago[flagged]
- ipnon 4y agoThis is technically the first combat kill by the F-22.
- ceejayoz 4y agoI wonder if the pilot gets to paint a balloon silhouette on his plane.
- themodelplumber 4y agoTo say nothing of the nicknames and jokes they'll hear for the rest of their life....
- DonHopkins 4y ago"Balloon Boy No Hoax" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JVbV_Sis99o&t=1s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JVbV_Sis99o&t=1s
- minikomi 4y agoDefinitely had a different theme in mind for this event https://youtu.be/qvfWRGzvP50 https://youtu.be/qvfWRGzvP50
- ttul 4y agoI don’t think F-22 pilots get to paint their aircraft. It would destroy the stealth coatings, which are so specialized they are measured to the milligram when removed (to ensure an adversary hasn’t taken some for analysis).
- jki275 4y agoWhere do stories like this come from? Simple logic would tell you there is no possible way to weigh an aircraft coating to a milligram and verify that it matches a somehow measured precise amount applied to the aircraft. The concept is ridiculous.
- pard68 4y agoI have been in "no politics, no news" mode for over a month. I try to do this about once a year. I have yet to tell my wife I do it, but when I am on this limited media consumption she always comments how pleasant I am to be around. I think it is a good thing for all of us to do once in a while, until 80 years ago most news was at best three or four days old, go back 120 years and you're getting only last weeks top ten stories. All that to say, I could not avoid this. Everyone has told me about this and the whole thing is just silly.
- SN76477 4y agoI ignore the majority of it myself. Maybe I'm a pessimist but there is little I can do to make an impact on geopolitics. I want to spend my energy on the things I can control and little energy on anything else. I'm much happier being completely unaware of whatever may be happening with the world.
- lettergram 4y ago> Maybe I'm a pessimist but there is little I can do to make an impact on geopolitics. I think quite the opposite — Geopolitics is impacted all the time by your actions. What you buy, what you say on forums like HN (where potentially tens of thousands read your comment), how you educate your kids, how many kids you have, how you influence co-workers. The reality, is the world is smaller than you think. What’s the phrase, “everyone with 6 connections away from anyone else”. If you can have a major or even minor impact in your local region of the graph, it’ll expand outward. I’m a cynical person by nature; but my cynicism comes from the lack of action / belief in action around me. You and everyone you know can really change the world in some way, if you push out your ideas and product(s) (like you are here btw, I’m not trying to claim you don’t) That said, I always focus locally to build the community I want to see. It influences geopolitics, but that starts at the coffee shop, book store, school, home, etc.
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoBeyond the local level, it seems like you’re conflating the “amount of influence an individual has” with “the amount of influence individuals can have [if they act at scale]”. Sorry for the short reply, I don’t mean to be dismissive; I hope that this makes sense.
- JoeDaDude 4y agoHow does a surveillance balloon get the collected data back to where it is analyzed and used? I suspect the data is relayed by satellite (unless there are collection sites within the US). Which Chinese satellites are able to cover the US?
- eddsh1994 4y agoI assume China has global coverage, as the US does?
- throwthere 4y agoAlmost certainly by satellite. To wit, every iPhone 14 now has an emergency text feature that works via satellite-- you could potentially just use one of those and send everything base64 encoded.
- idlewords 4y agoIt releases smaller data balloons.
- Rebelgecko 4y agoMost of China' communication satellites are in GEO over Asia, but they do have plenty of remote sensing and ELINT birds that fly over the US.
- 404mm 4y agoI feel like the balloon takedown was seriously mishandled. Imo it should have been shot down right after it crossed our borders and before it started move over populated areas. That way there would be no surveillance and you could examine the payload. Now that it’s in the water, you may not even find it.
- moomoo11 4y agoDo you really believe the USAF and rest of the military and 3 letter agencies had not already intercepted/jammed/hacked the comms link? By letting it saunter all the way across they also probably got a lot of good info on its capabilities.
- ck2 4y ago[flagged]
- moomoo11 4y agoMust be nice being so privileged to talk down the very thing that maintains global trade channels (diplomacy) and keeps most of the world in check. Most of the world is backwater nations who oppress the shit out of their population making whatever faults you find in the US seem trivial. And yes the world isn’t fair and entropy exists. EU is basically a forced alliance after thousand years of constant fighting that led to the Nazis and fascists rising to power who had to be put down, then having to maintain an eastern bulwark against the Russians (paid for by USA let’s be honest). Let’s see how well it holds. If anything I think the USA needs to double its military spending and increase the size of its navy and international dominance. North America is safe and will continue, even if the whole world burns or even ICBMs are deployed towards the major cities.
- ck2 4y agoThe idea people would still function while the entire east and west coast burns is the same fantasy at massive scale as people who walk around with guns thinking they are going to somehow defeat someone who has planned and already actively shooting at them. I believe great many ICBMs would definitely make it to major cities and that is the end of the world. We've already seen how people handle a pandemic, imagine active fallout but they cannot see the radiation. They'd be dropping like flies. Once the power and water is gone, 99% of American civilization is gone. Why do you think domestic terrorists are going after power stations (successfully so imagine national defense).
- DonHopkins 4y ago[flagged]
- mardifoufs 4y ago[flagged]
- sbaiddn 4y ago[flagged]
- andrewstuart 4y agoWhat could the balloon possibly have seen that was not visible to Chinese tourists and Chinese satellites. It was a weather balloon.
- davidw 4y agoIf I were more of a go-getter, I would have been hawking "Chinese Spy Balloon World Tour 2023" t-shirts.
- remarkEon 4y agoSidestepping the geopolitical issues with this for a moment ... What advantage is there to using a high altitude balloon for surveillance? I have to imagine there are some - like longer loiter time over a specific point, maybe better optics because you are still in atmosphere, it's obviously cheaper than launching a satellite - but I don't really know enough about this kind of hardware to say. Or maybe the point wasn't to actually look at anything, but instead see how the US would respond?
- fbdab103 4y agoSignificantly closer to the ground, so can capture better resolution pictures. If browsing Google Earth, the high-resolution data around cities originates from airplanes, not satellites.
- sandworm101 4y agoTurnaround/prototyping. Getting a sensor onto a spy sat is a multi-year process of testing and validating. But a new balloon can probably be built and flown in a matter of weeks. So any country trying to learn how to spy from above might want to build up the relevant corporate knowledge using balloons.
- SpicyP 4y agoWhy did they need to test it over the United States though? If the purpose was prototyping you’d think they could have done that locally
- tonymet 4y agoWhy not capture the device and confirm it was just a weather probe ?
- falsandtru 4y agoWhy didn't they use machine guns? Perhaps one reason was the risk that if they used machine guns, they would hit the balloon and crash the fighter. In that case, it would have provided China with the worst possible performance of shooting down a U.S. fighter with a Chinese balloon. On the other hand, if they used missiles and shot down the Chinese balloon with flair, we could advertise a strong and brave U.S. The U.S. successfully turned the humiliating situation of a Chinese airspace invasion into an opportunity for the best U.S. performance.
- thrill 4y agoThey probably wanted to bring the balloon down as quickly as possible once the decision to do so, and using an exploding warhead makes it easier to keep it in sight as it descended to make recovery easier. Projectile holes would likely just slowly leak for a while making descent take too long.
- falsandtru 4y agoI already see similar comments in other comments and agree with you and them.
- benmorris 4y agoHaven't verified it but former congressman Adam kinzinger claimed Canada did just that. It took over 1000 rounds and 4 hours to accomplish.
- jghn 4y agoPeople don’t seem to realize how high up this thing was
- Rebelgecko 4y agoHow high can a machine gun shoot?
- pokstad 4y agoImagine how expensive it was to shoot down this balloon. We sent an expensive F22 which burned a ton of fuel and then shot a very expensive missile at the balloon AND several ships had to clean up several miles of debris?? Send China the check.
- peeters 4y agoPilots burn a ton of fuel while training. The USAF probably welcomed the opportunity to conduct a novel mission with very little risk.
- BuyMyBitcoins 4y agoPlus, now the F-22 won’t go down in history as a fighter that had 0 kills.
- cjbgkagh 4y agoPart of me thinks that the US reaction to this was a 'trial balloon' to see how receptive the population is to further conflict. Judging from the sounds of it I'd say very receptive, which is worrying.
- georgeg23 4y agoThis is dumb. Same airship design has been seen around the world for years, https://twitter.com/BalloonSciDan/status/1479218147098038278 https://twitter.com/BalloonSciDan/status/1479218147098038278 There are many companies building and launching balloon airships of similar size. The US weather service alone puts hundreds of balloons over China, https://www.weather.gov/jetstream/radiosondes https://www.weather.gov/jetstream/radiosondes
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hackerlight 4y agoI probably agree. Allowing the rival to surveil you to an extent is not a bad thing. You want to reduce informational asymmetries because rival leadership often fills in the fog of war with assumptions of malevolence which then leads to escalation risk. It's a tale as old as time in the history of geopolitics and cold war rivalries. The fact they shot down the balloon after it left airspace rather than just as it entered suggests it was a response to the jingoistic media circus and domestic politicking, ie not wanting to look weak compared to hawkish Republicans, rather than anything with a real calculated military purpose.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoShooting a balloon down over land risks having it come down on someone. Though there really isn’t a lot in Kansas/Nebraska/South Dakota, they would probably not have gotten unlucky, but if they did the Republicans would have pounced also.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hackerlight 4y agoWhy couldn't they shoot it down before it flew over land but after if flew into airspace? What is the national security benefit of waiting for it to fly over the country first? My guess is they hoped it would pass over mostly unnoticed but then they saw people picking up on it and decided they had to get in front of the news story so as to not look incompetent. Then once the news story picked up steam their hand was forced by the jingoistic media circus and domestic political reality to take action.
- angry_octet 4y agoHow incredibly dumb. Imagine all the delicious ELINT that balloon relayed about the APG-81 RADAR and the missile, which assuredly coat much more than the balloon drone.
- mberning 4y agoHave to agree. Seems like we took a big risk using the F22 for this. I was expecting a super hornet or f15 to get the call on this one. At the same time, maybe we know that the balloon has no capabilities in this regard and decided to flex. Who knows.
- georgeg23 4y agoThere is no evidence it had any military purpose, and given a balloon of that size has very little control and easily spotted it would be a terrible platform for spying.
- angry_octet 4y agoNo evidence except the logic for it's existence. It is 100% military. It doesn't need precision control, it's been at 80kft and can see a long way. It isn't easily spotted at all, and launches are much more visible, but that is irrelevant because we already have non covert observation in the form of satellites.
- kylehotchkiss 4y agoI presume they had the ability to detect which bands this thing was transmitting on, entirely disable it with some sort of electronic warfare thingy, and then get close enough to shoot
- angry_octet 4y agoDifficult to jam what hasn't be observed before. If it used something spread spectrum you would have to have a very powerful noise jammer to saturate the satellite receiver, which would have to be precisely located. The short timeline from "we're not going to shoot this down" to "we shot it down" leads me to believe no in depth analysis occurred. But of course previous balloons may have been observed and even interdicted and we wouldn't necessarily know.
- w3tester 4y agoShould a country shoot down an airplane if it enters its airspace by mistake? ChatGPT: It is generally not considered appropriate for a country to shoot down an airplane that has entered its airspace by mistake. In such cases, the standard protocol is for the country to contact the aircraft and instruct it to leave its airspace. The use of military force should only be considered as a last resort in extreme circumstances, such as if the aircraft poses a clear and imminent threat to national security. International law and norms also dictate that aircraft should not be subjected to the use of force unless they are engaged in hostile acts or are carrying weapons of mass destruction.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- phendrenad2 4y agoDid they take it to Area 51?
- cjohnson318 4y agoMy man is over here asking the real questions.
- georgeg23 4y agoThis exact same balloon type was spotted floating over Japan in 2020 and India in 2022, https://twitter.com/BalloonSciDan/status/1479218147098038278 https://twitter.com/BalloonSciDan/status/1479218147098038278 Plenty of companies are working on airships including in China. Companies building airships of similar scale: https://aviationoutlook.com/airship-manufacturers/ https://aviationoutlook.com/airship-manufacturers/ The US puts hundreds of balloons over China, https://www.weather.gov/jetstream/radiosondes https://www.weather.gov/jetstream/radiosondes
- demodifier 4y agoRegarding the last point of US putting balloons over China, that page has the following two paragraphs: "Worldwide, there are about 1,300 upper-air stations. Observations are made by the NWS at 92 stations - 69 in the conterminous United States, 13 in Alaska, nine in the Pacific, and one in Puerto Rico. NWS supports the operation of 10 other stations in the Caribbean. Through international agreements data are exchanged between countries worldwide." This seems to suggest that NWS does not operate those over China but the map simply shows all the balloon weather stations that are part of this system.
- georgeg23 4y agoWhy would there be stations there if the balloons aren't flying over China?
- objectivetruth 4y ago[dead]
- Rebelgecko 4y agoIs this the first time that the something was shot down over the continental US (outside of training)?
- njharman 4y agoApparently not, civil war and WWII (both balloons btw) search for "down" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Union_Army_Balloon_Corps https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Union_Army_Balloon_Corps and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fu-Go_balloon_bomb https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fu-Go_balloon_bomb
- f5ve 4y agohaha, so the first military aircraft shot down over the US was a case of friendly-fire. The Union shot down it's own reconnaissance balloon, although technically the balloon was a civilian device.
- perryizgr8 4y agoSomeone should do a cost analysis of this incident. How much did the balloon cost to build and operate. And how much did it cost to get an F22 in the air and shoot a sidewinder rocket. I wouldn't be surprised if there is a 10x differential. Maybe this is a good DDoS strategy against the US military.
- AlbertCory 4y agoI'm surprised to find no mentions of Alan Eustace, former VP Eng. of Google, and his record-breaking jump from a balloon that was even higher: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0WmaZhpd3hI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0WmaZhpd3hI
- UltraViolence 4y agoI'm very surprised that China would take the risk of fueling a political firestorm when these balloons are only marginally more effective than the satellites they already have. These intrusions are clearly a violation of our airspace and could even be considered an act of war. What the hell was Xi thinking? Is he trying to communicate that China can do whatever it wants with impunity? Did he even authorize this flight or was this someone else's decision?
- landemva 4y ago> What the hell was Xi thinking? Pelosi visited Taiwan before last Chinese elections which ensured Xi would win. If it's meant to be, better for Xi to have USA attempt to fight multiple fronts concurrently.
- cuteboy19 4y agoSo are you saying there was a chance someone else would win? I don't understand your priors to be honest. Elections don't really matter all that much in China. And it's not as though he has much opposition inside the party either. Would love to know your thoughts
- landemva 4y agoDoes USA benefit from fighting multiple fronts concurrently: Russia, China, maybe Iran. The Ukraine conflict could be over in a week, but governments thrive on conflicts. 'German chancellor Angela Merkel said that the Minsk agreements had been an attempt to "give Ukraine time" to build up its defences.' https://www.reuters.com/world/putin-russia-may-have-make-ukraine-deal-one-day-partners-cheated-past-2022-12-09 https://www.reuters.com/world/putin-russia-may-have-make-ukr... World going into more cold war benefits which groups in governments?
- charlieyu1 4y ago> What the hell was Xi thinking? You are levelling yourself to think someone whose education ends with grade school to be actually thinking. He has done so many stupid things over the last decade. And in China, all foreign politics are internal politics. Playing strong against the rest of world, at least by how it looks, will bring more power to him within CCP.
- rmk 4y agoIs this balloon incident something the Space Force is mandated to deal with? The balloon was shot down by an F-22 and is being recovered by the Navy and Coast Guard, but there is no mention of the Space Force.
- deadlydose 4y ago> Is this balloon incident something the Space Force Because it wasn't in space. > shot down by an F-22 Because it was in the air. > is being recovered by the Navy and Coast Guard Because now it's in the water.
- steve76 4y ago[dead]
- sam0x17 4y agoWill be pretty funny in 50 years when we find out this was a DARPA project that malfunctioned
- alsodumb 4y agoExcept China already admitted it's theirs so ..
- wesleywt 4y agoWhile Americans panic. I think this is the dumbest way to do surveillance. Especially when China already has TicTok doing a great job.
- blitzar 4y agoFor the cost of a balloon tied to some plastic junk you just make Americans collectively lose their shit.
- user3939382 4y ago[flagged]
- MoSattler 4y agoSo you think the neocons are conspiring with CNBC?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- isubkhankulov 4y agomost news agencies blindly repeat what the local/state/federal government tells them. There’s very little primary research on stories like this.
- threeseed 4y agoDon't forget all of the international news agencies and people who took video on their phones. They are all in on the conspiracy as well.
- MoSattler 4y agoEven if that is true. I cannot really follow the argument that this would mean CNBC is conspiring with neocons to do a "Ukraine 2.0" in Taiwan. These kinds of claims require more evidence.
- user3939382 4y agoIt’s not conspiring because they aren’t two groups of people. CNBC is run by the same corporate interests, including especially the arms industry, as the uniparty in DC. The evidence is every single story they publish regarding war.
- threeseed 4y agoYou do know that ordinary people saw both the balloon and it being shot down. And the US government doesn't need ridiculous tactics like this to shore up support for protecting Taiwan. It is pretty much the only thing that almost every member of Congress supports.
- bxs24p 4y agoThe fact that this became a story at all is purely geopolitical in my opinion. Perhaps to do Blinkens up coming Beijing visit (which has since been canned). As far as I can tell the chinese dislike bad press like this. Having the balloon become a fiasco becomes a reason to cancel the trip. Can't exactly tell the why's but this is my guess.
- mlindner 4y agoThe cancellation came from the US side, not the Chinese side.
- bxs24p 4y agoExactly my point, having the balloon become a fiasco becomes reason to cancel the trip. There's some tit for tat that we don't know about.
- anonu 4y ago100%. If the balloon was a threat, why wasn't it shot down over Alaska? Or earlier on it's trip over the continental US. There was no threat... Here's an opportunity to drum up a lot of FUD and use it as a geopolitical lever.
- bxs24p 4y agoAlso painting China bad is a great method of painting yourselves in better light domestically. Both sides of politics in the US have vested interest in this narrative.
- rossmohax 4y agoIf it was flying at 80000ft as initially reported, how did they shot it down? No fighter planes can fly that high. Did they wait until it lowered to the operating altitude?
- sfeng 4y agoThe US has anti-satellite missiles, for example the RIM-161 [1]. That said, I would guess an AIM-120 [2] air-to-air missile wouldn't have any trouble given it can go Mach 4, I'm guessing a few miles up isn't the hardest thing. 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RIM-161_Standard_Missile_3 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RIM-161_Standard_Missile_3 2 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AIM-120_AMRAAM https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AIM-120_AMRAAM
- jusonchan81 4y agoDoesn’t regular flights from China fly into US everyday? How hard would it be to hide and survey the path with some equipment? I understand it won’t cover a lot given restrictions in flight path, but there are a lot of cities into which the international flights make its way into.
- aragonite 4y agoQuite apart from commercial flights, stratosphereic balloon overlight itself is something that happens fairly frequently. There's a reason we didn't hear about it the 4-5 times it happened before within the past several years. This is a Google balloon that recently fell out of the sky in the Congo: https://twitter.com/kambale/status/1621811081206439937 https://twitter.com/kambale/status/1621811081206439937
- torpfactory 4y agoThe big question is why China would send a balloon. My best guess is it carried electronic warfare sensors to try and collect specific information about US radar and missile capabilities. They may have in fact wanted us to shoot it down, ideally first painting it with advanced radar (both air and ground based) and then firing an advanced missile at it. Data could be streamed out until the moment of impact and used to create better ways to jam or avoid US missiles. Sending it over sensitive sites may have been an attempt to force the US to take such action. I’ve heard rumors that it was shot down by an AIM 9X, which is IR guided, a good choice as its seeker doesn’t use radar and thereby expose the terminal radar guidance information. I’m going to go way out on a limb here and theorize the delay was due to brand new upgrades required to the AIM 9X software to be able to lock on to and hit a balloon, which they probably were not originally capable of.
- pas 4y ago... why didn't they simply declared it a shooting range target? thousands of volunteers would have tried to shoot it down with bullets and various DIY things! it would have been endless streaming content! oh, well, maybe the next one. :(
- junon 4y agoThey explicitly asked the public not to do this. It was something like 60k feet in the air. People shooting up would have a laughably low chance of hitting it, plus create a rain of bullets somewhere else far away.
- mint2 4y agoRandomly Firing thousands of round at a target about ten miles up at an angle making the trajectories of misses to be something like 30 mi arcs sounds like a great idea doesn’t it? Does a ground fired bullet even go that high? They’ll obviously know their bullets are landing in safe areas right and no Minneapolis or wherever? Statistically unlikely to hit someone, but not surprising if it happened.
- 4y ago
- egberts1 4y agoIt was probably decided early on that the decision to down the balloon in question over non-populated area due to: 1. Balloon itself is filled with water vapor full of ABC material. 2. Payload has dispersal mechanism of dubious material Nonetheless, in spite of political wrangling, I find it disturbing that we haven’t made a retrieval system capable of snatching things at 60,000 feet.
- giardini 4y agoI wish they had: a) damaged the balloon lightly to cause it to leak and lower slowly, b) once at low altitude, perhaps drop a net tied to a float atop it to bog it down further, and c) once in the water, reel it in. I know the military can bring something like this balloon down in an orderly manner. Shooting it with a rocket seems crude and risky.