29 ms·
Cousins are disappearing. Is this reshaping the experience of childhood?
- ronaldoCR 3y ago[flagged]
- ronaldoCR 3y agopeople are missing out. this is sad
- stevekemp 3y agoI guess it depends, I had to draw a family tree when I was at school, many years ago, and I stopped once I hit around fifty cousins. So on the one hand I have a huge family, but on the other hand, the practical hand, most of those cousins I never met. I've heard their names, I've sometimes seen pictures of them, and family gossip means I generally know what is going on with them but that's all. I think there were 3-5 cousins who were similarly aged to myself, and who I saw every week or two, or daily during summer holidays. But the rest? I'm not sure what people would be missing out on there ..
- maxdoop 3y agoThere are studies that show quote plainly that people with kids are unholier than those without. The difference is much later on life when the happiness “winner” switches to the group with children. One theory aside from the obvious is that the brain makes sense of whatever might happen to it, over time. Like how you miss out on some big opportunity, but years later you say, “ah, that’s ok because it led me to where I am today.” No idea if that was coherent as I’m a bit tired, but wanted to share
- somanystudied 3y ago[dead]
- paulryanrogers 3y agoUnholier?
- piperswe 3y agoAh yes, studies about... holiness? I don't think we have a way to quantify what a hypothetical deity thinks about us.
- shagie 3y agoRelated: The Great Cousin Decline --- https://www.theatlantic.com/family/archive/2023/12/cousin-relationships-fertility-rate/676892/ https://www.theatlantic.com/family/archive/2023/12/cousin-re... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38719249 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38719249 (169 points | 52 days ago | 332 comments)
- 7thaccount 3y agoIt's all pretty crazy. My wife has quite a few brothers and a bazillion cousins. I have a sister and several cousins. We're the only ones of her family and until very recently the only ones in my family to have a kid (and just one). I think the population is maybe going down harder in the US than we think. It also took us like 2 years to conceive.
- irrational 3y agoI have 11 siblings and 75 first cousins. But, we lived thousands of miles away from any of those cousins, so I never got to know them very well and now have no contact with them. In the other hand, my daughter has a single cousin around her same age who lived about three hours away growing up, so they saw each other a few times a year, Now, as adults, even though they live in different countries, they still maintain their friendship and are frequently in contact. Bottom line, you can have a lot of cousins or few, but what matters more is how frequently you see each other.
- justrealist 3y agoHow did your daughter only end up with 1 cousin from your 11 siblings? That's a catastrophically low TFR.
- x1ph0z 3y agoFew scenarios, could be that they are the oldest and the rest of their siblings aren’t ready to have a family.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- MBCook 3y agoI could be 1 in the same age range.
- em-bee 3y agomy dad was the youngest of 7. and he had kids late. so almost all my cousins on my dads side are at least a decade older than me, and we barely had any contact with them growing up. on the other hand, cousins on my mothers side are all my age, and i have the best relationship with at least one of them despite only seeing each other every few years.
- masklinn 3y ago
- jdalgetty 3y agoNeither my brother nor my sister has kids.
- jojobas 3y agoThat's an interesting way to say "the West largely stopped breeding a while ago".
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoLate stage capitalism driven extinction
- jojobas 3y agoBullshit. USSR did the same thing about the same time.
- whatshisface 3y agoPeople stop having kids when economic forces work against them. It doesn't matter how the forces were put there. At least it's not like it was in Adam Smith's time, when the downward pressure was a result of children failing to reach adulthood. Thanks to birth control and modern medicine, people can decline to have children when they know the conditions are not right.
- jojobas 3y agoPeople stop having kids when they choose something else. Yes, career for one. Thanks to birth control and modern values, Western people can bring themselves to extinction.
- defrost 3y ago> Western people can bring themselves to extinction. Sounds like pearl clutching with bated breath. It's a long way to extinction with many chances to stabilise before zero. The only options are not continuous growth or death.
- solveit 3y agoAll evidence suggests that people stop having kids when their society gets richer and better educated.
- chaostheory 3y agoThe bigger issue is still the age depopulation bomb, which is when retired non-working seniors begin to outnumber working adults. This is made worse by both liberals and conservatives being against immigration. https://www.barrons.com/amp/articles/beware-depopulation-bomb-birthrates-c0c39497 https://www.barrons.com/amp/articles/beware-depopulation-bom... Yes, the cost of living affects this but even when the economy was great, Canada was already below the 2.1 birthrate in 1972. One explanation is declining male fertility (and yes, they accounted for socioeconomic factors.) https://www.cnn.com/2022/11/18/health/sperm-counts-decline-debate/index.html# https://www.cnn.com/2022/11/18/health/sperm-counts-decline-d...
- whatshisface 3y agoI have never understood how this is a "bomb," western cultures are so good at distancing the elderly, nobody will notice if conditions in care facilities become worse. How exactly will all of the unsupported old people overthrow society? By selling their IRAs? Will China's over-working-age-population get a second wind just long enough to take down the Party? I think realpolitik has so permeated our way of thinking that an impending moral crisis or holocaust can only be brought into discourse as a nonexistent threat to stability. If there's any explanation for why people think an inverted population pyramid is an economic crisis, it is that their hearts are in the right place.
- timeagain 3y agoif the majority of the public is much older they will likely vote for measures that favor them. Millennials look like they will be pretty left-leaning. The US could divert 10% of its military budget and ensure seniors live in relative comfort. I’m not saying these things will come to pass, only that it isn’t obvious to me that there is a coming crash. The economy will morph to reflect the forces that exist within it.
- whatshisface 3y agoIf there is enough money around for that to be possible, I don't see how people could call that a crisis.
- gentleman11 3y agoI’d say half my friends have had trouble conceiving, many probably will not ever have kids, and a decent chunk of my cousins as well had trouble or weren’t able to. It’s not just that people don’t have cousins
- SoftTalker 3y agoA lot of people wait way too long to have kids these days. Prime fertility is your 20s. After 30 more and more people will have trouble conceiving.
- dalyons 3y agoWhy do you think that is? People waiting I mean
- SoftTalker 3y agoIncreasingly people feel pressure or obligation to go to college and spend their 20s getting established in a career. By the time they feel ready to have kids it's more likely they'll have trouble.
- dalyons 3y agoI don’t think they are mistaken though? Housing and childcare are multiples more expensive than a generation ago, makes sense people need to feel established.
- anon84873628 3y agoI get that but I think the other point is equally significant. After college it's fun to make money, travel, date around... generally continue exploring yourself and the world and having few responsibilities.
- piperswe 3y agoAs someone in my early 20s, I can barely even take care of myself (and that's pushing it). At this stage of my life, I can't imagine being able to give a child everything a parent needs to give them.
- shermantanktop 3y agoBetteridge’s Law says no, it is not reshaping the experience of childhood. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge's_law_of_headlines https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge's_law_of_headline...
- 7thaccount 3y agoThis is one area where it's wrong. Instead of having 10 or more cousins...it's now common for kids to have 0 or close to it. My kid doesn't know what a cousin is. Kinda bonkers.
- shermantanktop 3y agoThe headline didn’t say “reshaping the cousin experience”. It said “childhood”. Unless we’re ready to say any change is dramatic, this is the type of unprovable puffery in a headline that Betteridge’s Law was made for. FWIW, it’s true of my kids too. But growing up, my cousins were in a different country and I wasn’t close. So my kids didn’t have an experience much different than mine.
- 7thaccount 3y agoIt is still important to a lot of kids that live close by and even those that rarely saw each other (like mine due to similar isolation) still learned from the experience when we were together. Yes, headlines are meant to grab your attention, but equating this one with the garbage that usually gets a quick Betteridge Law link is a bit drastic. People pondering the societal implications of rapid population decline is very relevant. I'm not going to get too upset over the title.
- shermantanktop 3y agoOk, fair, maybe I'm overreacting to it - i find headlines like that annoying. If you have ever seen the early Seven Up movies (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Up_(film_series) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Up_(film_series) ) - the sheer mass of Baby Boom children all growing up together is incredible. No doubt peer influence was crucial for many of them. But humans grow up in many situations, including remote farms, small villages full of old people, etc. Lack of cousins or same-age peers might be more common now, but it's been happening forever.
- atomicnumber3 3y agoAnecdata: I am 31 and have 3 young kids. They have 0 cousins and, on top of that, 0... second cousins? Cousins-once-removed? Whatever the one is for my cousin's kids. My kids are my grandma's only great-grandkids. And I have... 6 cousins. On top of that, at my last job, on my team of 15, I was the only one with kids, and only 1 of those 15 engineers were under the age of 30. At my current job, my team is 8, and again we're all about 30, and nobody is even thinking about kids at all. It baffles me. And it's also a bit inconvenient that nobody else at work has such pressing obligations, it makes me feel bad (though not too bad at this point) that I *have* to log off at quittin' time, sharp, to go relieve my wife of some childcare and make a family dinner.
- nolongerthere 3y agoOn my team of 15 only 3 don’t have kids, though there is a wide age range (24-55) the ones without kids are in their 30s but have indicated no interest. But only 2 have more than 2 kids (3). One has two of her own and now that they’re grown up she just adopted 2 high school age kids, which is very commendable, (and a huge undertaking) but I don’t really count it in terms of procreation.
- silverquiet 3y ago> It baffles me. Frankly, I never really got why people wanted children in the first place, so this turnabout is amusing. Perhaps you can ask some of these people that you are close with as to their reasoning.
- justahuman74 3y agoFor me it's like this: https://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/hf0rf/for_reasons_unexplained/ https://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/hf0rf/for_reasons_une... (third square)
- dgfitz 3y agoHeh, maybe if people were having more kids the US political landscape wouldn’t be so fucked.
- LoganDark 3y agoI wish the world weren't so bad that potential parents don't want to bring new lives into it... honestly, if I were a mother considering whether to have a child, I wouldn't want them to have to grow up in this terrible day and age. They'd end up more traumatized than I am. I wouldn't be able to live with myself.
- samatman 3y ago[flagged]
- LoganDark 3y agoWhat do you mean? Would I want my children to be at risk of school shootings? Would I want my children to have to deal with the fact that I can't afford to pay for health care in the only country where it's not free? Would I want my children to have to deal with the current state of the internet, with TikTok and other predatory social media running rampant? When they get older do I want them to have to deal with how hard it is to get a job and make a living? The housing crisis? No I don't want to bring children into this world. These are not everyday struggles to be overcome. Today's world is extremely ugly, extremely unfair and I would not under any circumstances want to make a child suffer through it all... Would I want to bring children into the world if it weren't this terrible? Maybe. I don't know. I'm not a potential mother, so I obviously don't get to make the decision of whether to give birth or not, but right now there are just too many obvious, overwhelming reasons not to.
- foobarian 3y agoI'm pretty sure the world was at least as terrible at any given point in the past, we were just much less informed/aware of it thanks to the lack of Internet like mass-communication.
- SoftTalker 3y agoIt was far worse. Imagine having kids when they could get polio. Or taken from you and sold as slaves. Or conscripted and sent to war.
- oaththrowaway 3y agoI grew up 2 states away from my parents siblings, I couldn't pick out most of my aunt's/uncles from a lineup let alone my cousins. My kids live close to the same distance away from their cousins, but we make a huge deal to make time to see them. My kids and their cousins are all great friends and it's well worth the sacrifice
- djha-skin 3y agoMy father had 10 siblings and my mother had seven. I had seven siblings myself with over 30 cousins on both sides of my family. I have four children and my and most of my siblings each have six children or so. My mother has about 24 grandkids at the last count Maybe. Further, I live on the same street as two of my sisters and I have another sister that lives down the street, with my brother living 3 mi away. Only two siblings live out of town. My children routinely play with and enjoy being with their cousins. My daughter has a hard time making friends but she says it's okay because at least she has her cousins. I have had a very rich experience with many of my cousins and I think these cousins are growing up even closer together both physically and emotionally. Would highly recommend the lifestyle. Large families are such a blessing when you get older. Kids are an awful lot of work for the first about 10 years but boy are they awesome every year after that. When my grandmother is interacting with her children and grandchildren at reunions it's like she's holding court, the queen of an empire.
- toasterlovin 3y agoYou have to be religious, right? This is the dream for us. We reverted to Catholicism after it became apparent that the secular world was incompatible with us, then eventually found our way to a high fertility parish. It’s incredible. Kids everywhere. Average family size is 5-6 kids. Really hoping our kids choose to remain in this lifestyle and we get to enjoy dozens of grandkids.
- pinkmuffinere 3y agoI initially read this comment to mean “we wanted larger family, the secular world doesn’t do that, we became religious and we’re happy”. Am I understanding that correctly? If so, this strikes me as a very novel argument in favor of religion, and is more convincing to me than most others. I do wonder what I’d say if/when people question the fervor of my belief though, if I truly converted just for a community with larger families. I imagine “I believe in big families” wouldn’t cut it.
- shepherdjerred 3y ago
- SoftTalker 3y agoGrew up in the 1970s. I had one sibling and no cousins (well we did, but they lived so far away we almost never saw them).
- bongodongobob 3y agoYou're baffled people aren't having kids? What bubble do you live in? People straight up can't afford housing much less children. The avg American is completely priced out of owning a home right now. Edit: the replies - y'all are out of touch. Visit an average family in the Midwest with a household income of < $100k/yr that doesn't own a home yet.
- nradov 3y agoThe average American owns a home. Current homeownership rate it 66%. Some states such as Iowa and Minnesota are particularly high. If you're referring to people of child bearing age though the rate is lower.
- atomicnumber3 3y agoI'm baffled my peers, who absolutely could afford to, still have no interest. These are people making 150-200k (and at my prior job, 200-400k).
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2021/11/19/growing-share-of-childless-adults-in-u-s-dont-expect-to-ever-have-children/ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2021/11/19/growing-s... https://msutoday.msu.edu/news/2023/childfree-study-confirmed-April2023 https://msutoday.msu.edu/news/2023/childfree-study-confirmed...
- ekianjo 3y ago[flagged]
- plasticsoprano 3y agoMy father is 14 years younger than the next oldest sibling. My mother is 12 years younger than the next oldest sibling. Because of this my cousins were all much older than me and not people I interacted with. My little brother, my only sibling, is 14 years younger than me. My oldest is 11 and by the time my brother does have kids, if he has kids, my children will be probably be close to adults. Fortunately my ex-wife has a lot of cousins she is close to and her sister has a daughter right in the middle of my 2 kids so they have 1 first cousin they are very close with but they have no interactions with second cousins outside of seeing them every few years at holidays. Regardless, having no real interaction with my cousins growing up, I can't say if my life would have been better if I had.
- pfannkuchen 3y agoIs it not totally obvious that the low birth rate is directly caused by availability and social acceptance of contraceptives and related technologies? People didn’t really “choose” to have that many kids in the past. It turns out that even if you don’t really want to have kids, not having sex is a very, very hard thing to do. Nature’s solution to making humans have kids despite being able to reason themselves out of it is to make them incredibly horny compared to most other animals. Or, put another way, the less horny humans were filtered out along the way since they didn’t produce enough offspring and were outcompeted by the more horny.
- xyzelement 3y agoI think this is a naive view. I didn't have a sense that my grandmother's generation (and all children prior to that) were perceived by their parents as unwelcome consequences of their unrestrained hornyness. Old literature starting with the bible is full of examples of people lamenting infertility, they clearly wanted kids. Also, today the only people who have children are the religious, which are also people that have objectively got the greatest control and ability to restrain their sexuality, which kind of goes against what you're saying. And finally, people forever back had ways to not get pregnant if they didn't want to.
- silverquiet 3y ago> the religious, which are also people that have objectively got the greatest control and ability to restrain their sexuality I cannot properly put into words how different the reality you live in must be different from the one I do.
- xyzelement 3y agoYou could give it a whirl I guess. The folks that I know who have many (5+) kids are religious jews, catholics, muslims and mormons. I don't know if all of these people have defered sex till marriage but they are certainly not the ones racking up tripple or even double digit bodycounts. Are you saying you have a line of reasoning that people who maintain religious adherence today are doing it so they can have unrestrained sex?
- xyzelement 3y agoI was lucky that my wife convinced me to move close to her family (it would have never occurred to me.) Now we live just a few doors down from her brother who's got 4 kids, and we have 2. Watching the cousins intermingle is an amazing and unique experience. It's kinda sad but it's also obvious that people are majorly missing out. On having kids, on living close to family, on all of it. Ironically, this is evolution in action. The folks that "remember" how to have a family and raise kids have an uncontested claim to the future. The "it's too hard to have kids" crew is selecting against themselves, evolutionary speaking. That won't last.
- dotnet00 3y agoThat would only make sense if the issue was biological and not socioeconomic. No one's getting selected out when the issue isn't a biological predisposition to avoiding procreation.
- xyzelement 3y agoI genuinely haven’t met anyone who deeply wanted children and then didn’t because of “socioeconomics”. I met plenty of ppl who talk about the climate or cost of housing as the reason for other ppl but I never knew of anyone making a decision this way. You know someone?
- dotnet00 3y agoBy socioeconomics, I'm referring to all those different factors. The point is that "I don't want to have children because I'm worried about the impact of climate change" (social) or "I don't want to have children because I think it'll be too expensive" (economic) is not caused by biology and thus there is no selecting such concerns out of the gene pool. Not even mentioning that evolution doesn't even meaningfully work at these short timescales. Modern humans are essentially identical to ~40,000 years ago, simply not enough time and pressure for evolution to do its thing.
- xyzelement 3y ago
- danielvaughn 3y agoInteresting to hear this. My personal experience is the complete opposite. My sister has 2 kids, my wife’s sister and husband have 2 kids, my wife’s brother has 3 kids with one on the way, and we’re having our first in about 3 weeks. That’s 12 cousins just in our little circle.
- kelnos 3y agoI think based on the data and projections in the article, your family is still pretty small, cousin-wise. So you're in some ways illustrating the point they're making.
- ojbyrne 3y agoThis is looking at trends starting from 1950, which is right in the middle of an event known as the “baby boom.” I guess there’s some usefulness to that analysis, but it seems a little shallow.
- bruhbruh78 3y ago[flagged]
- mindslight 3y agoShit, I thought the terrible twos were supposed to end some time.
- rs_rs_rs_rs_rs 3y agoWhat a great comment! LMAO
- seydor 3y agosoon enough we ll have AI cousins
- darkhorse13 3y agoI had a really rough time at school growing up, because I was a runt and got bullied pretty badly. My actual friends growing up were definitely my cousins, especially my brothers. The older ones always looked out for me, and I played outside all day with the ones close to my age. Seriously, if I did not have them in my life, I suspect I would be pretty fucked up as an adult. For me, blood has always been thicker than water.
- ardaoweo 3y agoHere in Finland apparently 50% of 35yo males, and 35% of 35yo females have no children. Fertility rate in 2023 was 1.26. In comparison, 2015 saw fertility rate of 1.65, and it has been below replacement level since 1969. 61% of under 40yo people live in rental apartments, this share having risen about 10% from 2010. Also, apartments built today are about 9 square meters smaller on average compares to 10 years ago. I live in a two bedroom apartment of about 55 squares, and today this would be a typical three bedroom apartment size. Housing has certainly become more expensive and lower quality in larger cities where most jobs are, and working life has become more unstable. Still, in my opinion cultural factors are a more significant reason for falling birth rates.
- jonasdegendt 3y ago3 bedrooms plus a bath on 55 sq/m sounds pretty tightly packed huh, mind sharing a listing? I’m quite curious as to the layout. I’m in Belgium where we’ve historically built larger than necessary apartments (and houses) so there’s a decent amount of housing stock to raise a family in, but the tides have turned and new apartments are also mostly smaller 1 and 2 bedrooms targeting singles. The latter sucks because if you’re a young family looking for an affordable but modern place (read: energy efficient) your options are slim.
- ardaoweo 3y agoActually I meant a three room apartment (three rooms + bathroom), so I guess that's really a two bedroom apartment using US definition. Anyway, here's an example of a three room apartment packed into 41.5 square meters excluding balcony. https://www.etuovi.com/kohde/38837797?haku=M2075336606 https://www.etuovi.com/kohde/38837797?haku=M2075336606 Another typical example with 4 rooms + bathroom packed into 65.5 squares: https://www.etuovi.com/kohde/u24978?haku=M2075340353 https://www.etuovi.com/kohde/u24978?haku=M2075340353
- pzo 3y agoI'm just always wondering why the ratio is not more close 50% / 50% between males and woman? On birth male/female ratio is pretty much 50/50. So at any stage (except older >70 because woman usually lives longer) ratio should be similar. LGBT are just 10% of population and distribution between gays/lesbians seems also 50/50. Based on that if there is a single male there is another single female somewhere. The only reason that comes to my mind that more female migrated from Finland somewhere else or there is a big immigration of males into Finland.
- conradludgate 3y agoWhy are people so obsessed about it I have children? I'm married and we've decided we don't want to have kids. It really bothers me when people say "oh you're missing out, that's such a shame". Please think about what you are saying. It doesn't matter if I'm gay, infertile, poor, depressed, or just don't want them. Please keep your judgements to yourself or even just stop judging others.
- khazhoux 3y ago> It really bothers me when people say "oh you're missing out, that's such a shame" Do you have any friends or relatives who refuse to try ramen or pho, no matter how many times you tell them that it's the best food ever, and that you also thought it seemed weird to put steak in a broth with noodles until you finally gave it a try and then you couldn't believe how delicious it was and you wish you'd tried it years earlier... but they still think it sounds gross? It's exactly like that. :-)
- bowsamic 3y agoRamen and pho isn't that good though. I've had gross ramen. I don't understand your analogy.
- aqme28 3y agoSome kids are also not good, so at least that part of the analogy tracks.
- vander_elst 3y agoExcept that kids change your life in major significant ways and there's basically no going back. So it's not exactly like that.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoKids don't always change ones life for the better. Some people deeply regret it regardless of how the kids turn out.
- epivosism 3y agoIt applies to all types of kin relations. Dramatically fewer people have a same- sex sibling. The number is probably down from say 0.9 to 0.4 or less. Few people have friends with brothers and sisters to compare them to, to understand heritability. We are becoming more and more tolerant of obviously unrelated people playing relatives on tv. I say that because when you see a real family resemblance in person, it's intense. The only experience of having g a much older or younger sibling must be nearly nothing, now, too. It's sad that all these effects seem to make people even more likely to perpetuate the trend when their own time comes.
- guythedudebro 3y agoWhat
- coldtea 3y agoIt changes the experience of being human, from what once was a solitude for orphans, and refugees, to a common experience. There's no extended family (and increasingly, no base family either, e.g. no siblings, or divorced or indifferent narcissistic parents) to take refuge to, strengh from, and so on: you're on your own. Even your friends, if you get to have any, will be a more shallow, and mostly online presence (what with the "loneliness epidemic" and everything), and will increasingly be people who have not learned the art of being with others, unless it's fully on their own terms (think spoiled single children vs children growing up with siblings). You get to cling and bow to careers, employers, state, trends, peer groups, and so on, as a survival mechanism. [1] We can spin it as a good thing, by cherry-picking families which did terrible things to their kids as representative of family life at large.
- MrBuddyCasino 3y ago[flagged]
- megamix 3y agoNothing in the article aims at explaining or moving the attention to why. Just a collection of statements, without looking back at why this is. Women have to pick a career, this has an effect on family building.
- ensocode 3y agoMaybe for some it is that easy: Why leading complicated lives with kids, pressure, responsibilities an uncertainties, when it is so much more comfortable and flexible without? Watching netflix and scrolling insta could be enough. The thing is, that life is that thing that starts beyond the comfort zone.
- kelnos 3y agoI think there are a lot of ways to get out of your comfort zone that don't involve kids. Failing to find them is either laziness or a lack of imagination. The thing about having kids is that once you make the leap, you don't get to step back. A single decision to drop the birth control for a bit, and bam -- you're a parent with daily responsibilities for at least 18 years. That'll certainly get you out of your comfort zone, permanently. But other things you can do are more or less entirely voluntary, and you can stop doing them at any time. So it takes more willpower to maintain, even if doing those things is strictly less work than raising a child.
- Night_Thastus 3y agoSeconding the other comment, this is a pretty narrow view. A person can do a lot with their life. There's an entire world to explore out there. Culture and history and math and science and art and philosophy. So many meaningful, fulfilling ways to spend a life that don't involve kids. Not saying that kids cannot offer their own experience, they absolutely can. But it's not the only one that has value.
- Jakesbeb 3y ago[flagged]
- miningape 3y agoAnecdata: I am 22 and I have a bunch of cousins but they are all from generations older than me, so while my half-siblings had a bunch of cousins to hang out with - I don't really have any. The closest I have that are my age are 3 2nd cousins (cousin's children), and we see each other once every 2-3 years. Every time we see each other we end up complaining about how few people are in our family in our generation. On the other hand, all of my actual cousins are now having children, so it seems the next generation won't be having this problem (in my family).
- wtcactus 3y agoUnfortunately, I'm the only child in my family. I do have 7 cousins, though. And 2 of them (the ones raised by my grandmother that lived next to my house and that I saw almost everyday during my childhood) are the family closer to siblings that I've got.
- vsnf 3y agoThe vibe in this thread is so hostile, and the most vociferous posts are from the pro-children side of the debate. I have no deeper comment to make here, I just find it a little shocking how aggressive half the posts are.
- rightbyte 3y agoI didn't find any amount of "so hostile" comments. I think what makes the vibe hostile it that this is the sound of social cohesion tearing apart and there is the implied worry that "it might get hostile" unless things are fixed. But that is not the same thing as hostile. It is discussing a problem.
- vsnf 3y agoI regret not coming in my original post armed with evidence. Accusation of being inhuman: > The - natural - way - of - being - a - human!!! (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39343369 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39343369) > Biological organisms not procreating despite living in material and caloric abundance is cosmically weird. (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39341358 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39341358) (less hostile, still a swipe) Attack on one's validity as a member of society: > Whenever I encounter this attitude I like to remind that person that they should have no voice, whatsoever, in what happens in government and politics anymore (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39342079 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39342079) > but don’t expect the rest of us to give much credence to his opinions since he very well doesn’t care about our society. (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39342977 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39342977) Implication of social malignancy: > that makes you a sort of parasite (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39342021 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39342021) > It's fucking weird. [...] I'm guessing they are just hitting up sex workers. (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39341263 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39341263) Implication that one's chosen lifestyle is inferior: > People are just too selfish and think of kids as costing lattes and ruining their free time (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39342822 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39342822) > Kids aren't expensive. They're a distraction from dopamine and career advancement. [...] they'd rather jet set than settle down. [...] Instagram and the endless feed of social media, internet, and things to do. [...] Nobody I know wants to give that up. (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39341734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39341734) (this one is not hostile, but it's still in put-down territory) Whether one views these as hostile can perhaps be a matter of perspective, but these posts do not invite cordial, level-headed debate.
- HPsquared 3y agoBetter to have kids and be poor, than rich with no kids. People are so materialistic these days.
- Night_Thastus 3y agoThat is a pretty terrible take. Having kids is basically never going to cause someone to go from rich (excess wealth and luxury) to actually poor (struggling to survive). However, it definitely can be enough to take someone who is just barely getting by, making their car payments, enough food on their plate, etc. to start to struggle. Kids are very expensive. No-one is not having kids because they want a second yacht. But there are a lot of people who genuinely cannot afford to survive with a child.
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y agoI have 2 siblings. We have over 30 cousins on one side of the family and 2 on the other side. Only 1 of the 3 of us has kids, so my niblings don't have any cousins on my side of the family, and they only have a few on the other side. I haven't thought about how different that is compared to what I grew up with until seeing this post
- dghughes 3y agoThe families of my father and mother each have nine siblings. Most of their siblings married and had children. Some of those sibling usually the oldest ones had six children. I grew up knowing at least 40 cousins. I'm not married or in a relations ship and I don't have any children. My sister is married but no children. I see much of my generation (GenX) are in a similar state.
- anonymousDan 3y agoInteresting article. It is something that saddens me a little for my own kids, who have 2 first cousins and maybe 15-20 second cousins. In comparison my 4 grandparents collectively had over 60 _siblings_ (no idea how many cousins!).
- TomK32 3y agoMy daughter is an only child but has eight cousins (that I know of, most are in her age range) but barely spends time with them. She's not missing out on anything because she has a large circle of friends her age, be it from the public playground when they only started walking, kindergarden or now the first three years in school. It takes some effort as a parent and tbh dumping-the-child-at-her-friends-and-vice-versa but she's got a much better social life than I had at her age and she'll continue that even though she'll move 4hrs away to the country-side this summer. Her best friend actually moved away two years ago, we still make sure they meet up and have sleep-overs and such. Lots of people here write about the number of cousins, but those are often of a different age, it was the same with my two cousins. Also missing from the article: Kids being pushed into extra-curricula after school, be it soccer or music, those might not necessarily lead to friendships? Lastly, our environment has changed a lot. It's just not safe to let kids run wild outside with all those cars. The number of kids killed by cars didn't sink over the past 40 years because cars got safe, it sunk because kids get basically locked in. In my city (in Austria) we have quite a lot of older and newer building complexes where cars are kept outside, those are much better for kids.
- postexitus 3y agoI am not sure if friends replace (at least my experience of) cousins. With couisins, you spend days, nights, sleepovers sometimes a whole summer together. You share grandparents, your parents are siblings - you never leave each other's side. It's like sibling minus one. With friends, yes you get very good friends and they are your "chosen family" but you don't spend half as much time together even to the best of your efforts (unless living next door) at the same time, things force you to fall apart - moving, schools, preferences etc.
- TomK32 3y agoUnlike your friends, you can't choose your family and sleepovers with friends is what my daughter has more than once a month.
- postexitus 3y ago
- bowsamic 3y agoI grew up with a fair few cousins but I can't really say that I think it would be missing out if I didn't. I'm ambivalent to the whole thing
- alexpotato 3y agoMy dad was one of 5 and my mom was one of 6. I grew up with 20+ cousins ranging from 10 years older than me to almost 30 years younger than me. It was simultaneously like having lots of older brothers and sisters but also having multiple siblings only a couple months older or younger than me. It also meant I got a LOT of experience being around small children which carried over well to being a parent. On the flip side, my father-in-law has 7 grandkids and they were all born in a 5 year window. I also worked with woman from China and due to the "1 child" policy, the first baby she ever held was her own baby b/c she had no cousins, nieces/nephews etc.
- JeremyNT 3y agoPrevious discussion on a similar article from the Atlantic (2023) [0] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38719249 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38719249
- ubermonkey 3y agoI'm an Old (53), and always felt a little weird because I had very little cousin interaction growing up. I mean, I'm from a small, mostly rural state; most people I knew had cousins out the wazoo -- but not me. I think the real reason is that both my parents were from two-child families, and they were also very much older than their younger siblings; my mom is 7 years older than her brother, and my father was a full decade older than his sister. Both my Aunt and my Uncle had families, but necessarily later. My aunt went first, and had a daughter about the age of my little sister -- 5 years after me -- and then another daughter a couple years later. However, they lived a couple towns over, and my father and his sister weren't especially close, so we didn't spend much time with them. My uncle and his wife didn't start their family until I was 17, so obviously there was zero childhood overlap there. I see and talk to those cousins more often than the two from my father's side, mostly because we have more in common, but it's still not very often.
- crabbone 3y agoWe have very good relationship with our neighbor, who's French (this will become relevant later). We met at the playground both babysitting our kids. We know each other well enough to come visit, eat lunch together, go to various children-related activities etc. About a month ago, when we came to visit our neighbor, she had a guest, whom she introduced as her cousin. Couple days ago, she had another guest, and what do you know: it's another cousin! I asked how many cousins does she have. Her and her cousin started to reminiscent and came up with an estimate of around fifty. My jaw dropped. Then they went down the memory lane, recalling their childhood and how they'd spend summers in the family house: legion of kids with few adults in sight. My father had two brothers. One had (at least one that I know of) son. The other one had a son and a daughter. No two brothers live in the same country. I've only ever met one of my cousins, once. My mother was the only child. But this was also the very common situation in my childhood years. Everyone I went to school with barely had any extended family. And once I started to think about what might have caused the difference: well, these things come to mind: my maternal grandmother had 11 siblings. One or two died in the war. A better half escaped the Communist regime. Those who didn't were sentenced to exile in Siberia. She and her sister were what's left of the family. That sister never married and had no children. Similar, on my father's side, a bunch of relatives died in Holocaust. And even later on, through the Soviet times, the situation wasn't conducive to having many children. My parents, already, grew up in the world where cousins were rare. It looks though like in some places in Europe, the war didn't affect the siblings situation so much, and even my generation had a chance to meet a bunch of cousins. The US seems to be similar in this respect, at least according to my wife's testimony, who would every now and then mention he cousin who is an architect / drug addict / screwed up by 'Nam / fashion model etc. There seems to be no shortage of cousins to draw on. Our kid, in total, has three cousins. And there's unlikely to be more. Which is a new thing for the Western world, I guess, especially the parts not so much affected by the war. But this is how things have been for at least a generation in the East.
- prismatix 3y agoCousins are great if you stay close, but generally as you get older you drift apart and then you're left with no one again. Anecdotally: as someone who was the youngest by 5+ years in a family of dozens of cousins, I feel like I got a little bit of both worlds. It was fantastic as a kid to be running around with the posse, but as I entered late-childhood that pretty much dissolved. Now, as an adult, I no longer see my cousins on a regular basis. We don't have much history beyond my 7th/8th year and they're not the type of people I would want to be friends with by choice. This estrangement was a big source of mental struggle for me throughout my early 20s, especially since I lost my actual sibling and didn't feel like I had anyone to relate to in my "supposed" family. I almost think it's better to start off life with not much extended family, because it's not easy to make friends that you consider family when you're already a fully-fledged adult.
- lizknope 3y agoI've got over 30 first cousins. Not joking. My mom was 1 of 12 children and my father was 1 of 8 children. They were born in India during the 1930's to 1950's when modern medicine was saving people's lives but modern birth control wasn't widespread. Most of them had 2 children so that's over 30. We have 2 huge WhatsApp group chats and every week it is someone's birthday or anniversary. It's cool having so many relatives and places to stay for free when you travel but it can be a little exhausting too!
- pkphilip 3y agoAbsolutely. It is not just that the number of cousins available has dropped drastically with more and more people choosing not have kids or have very few kids, the connections between the cousins is also much less strong in my family than it has ever been because the families now live so far away from each other in a different part of the world that the chances of face-to-face meetups is now reduced to perhaps once every couple of years or so and even then for very short periods of time. I do feel very strongly that my kids are not going to have much of a relationship with their cousins - if at all.
- racl101 3y agoNot just cousins also, uncles and aunts. With a lot of single child families of today, a lot of children's eventual children will have no uncles and aunts. Alas, such is life.
- AlwaysRock 3y agoMeh. I have ~17 cousins on one side of my family I spent 2 weeks with almost every summer of my childhood. Never got really close to them. Dont really see them or talk to them now. I guess if said cousins lived in the same town as we did or really close by this would ring more true. Seems like this is more an issue with losing community than cousins.
- throwaway_2573 3y agoI know this thread is mostly about a lack of cousins, rather than being distant from your cousins, but I feel like I have to ask: How many people have cousins, or other relatives, that they want to interact with? My extended family is a complete disaster. On my mother's side there's two brothers who are borderline abusive to their wives and children. On father's side I had a total of 10 cousins, the oldest of whom would be in their 40s, the youngest in their late 20s. Only 6 of them are still alive. One of them is in prison. These are all people that I want nothing to do with. My siblings are not bad per say, but not people I consider myself close to. We're all too different in age from each other, and never had much more in common that living in the same house. Now we are scattered across North America. If I had had children, they likely would have never met any of their cousins more than a dozen times before adulthood.
- jasongrout 3y agoAnother data point: My wife's grandparents have 10 children, 81 grandchildren (mostly adults), and around 300 and counting great-grandchildren. It's wonderful! When we go on trips around the U.S., we are almost always staying with a cousin. Our children really enjoy meeting and getting to know cousins their age. That said, I do notice that the younger generations typically are having smaller families (like 3-6 children instead of 8-12 children). It's a lot of work to keep in touch and visit cousins, but my wife and I feel it's totally worth it. At times, we've decided where to live based on proximity to cousins, and we decided early on to regularly visit cousins who lived within a couple of hours. When we were married, we decided we'd try to go to reunions, funerals, and weddings, and we've largely done that for the last 19 years. There is a big family reunion for a few days every other year, with about half the family coming (so hundreds of people of all ages). We also have monthly dinners with typically 20-30 local cousins joining. We regularly tell family history stories, and we have a screensaver rotating through our pictures, including many from cousin visits and reunions, so cousins are regularly coming up in daily conversations. One thing I've noticed is that the more often we go to reunions and visit other families, the more excited the children are to go to see cousins again (as opposed to another family branch, where reunions are every 5-10 years, the children just don't have the same connection with that much growing up in between reunions). Another thing I've noticed is that our children seem to feel very grounded in their experiences - they often are relating their experiences to a story from an ancestor and pulling lessons from that. To address a comment elsewhere on this topic, yes, we are religious, the family is predominantly active members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and a significant portion live in the intermountain west area of the U.S.
- kridsdale3 3y ago> we are religious, the family is predominantly active members of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, and a significant portion live in the intermountain west area of the U.S. Everybody in America would know to fill in all that information if you simply said "We are Mormon". I'm glad you're enjoying your rich family!
- ngngngng 3y ago
- Bobbyben 3y ago[flagged]
- hakdbha 3y ago[dead]
- hi41 3y agoI found daycare very expensive. It was close to $1200 per month. With two kids, it was forbiddingly expensive. My wife wanted a 3rd child but I did not because of high cost having babies. Then there is college fee when they grow up. I van empathize with people who are not able to have kids due to coat.
- silexia 3y agoThis is the death of our species if it is allowed to continue. Ban birth control.
- newzisforsukas 3y agohttps://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2743184/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2743184/