39 ms·
Google have declared Droidscript is malware
- blakesterz 6y agoI had to go look to see what this was: "DroidScript is an easy to use, portable coding tool which simplifies mobile App development. It dramatically improves productivity by speeding up development by as much as 10x compared with using the standard development tools. It’s also an ideal tool for learning JavaScript, you can literally code anywhere with DroidScript, it’s not cloud based and doesn’t require an internet connection. Unlike other development tools which take hours to install and eat up gigabytes of disk space, you can install DroidScript start using it within 30 seconds!"
- kbelder 6y agoThis is my primary hacking tool for throwing little scripts together on Android. You can bring up an IDE in chrome on your PC and interactively execute it on your phone. I hope this gets fixed. I wouldn't really be surprised if EVERY scripting/programming app in the play store technically violates some play store rules, though.
- narwally 6y agoWell damn, now I want to download it. I've never gotten into mobile development because getting started always seemed like a chore, but this sounds like it would be fun to play around with.
- stevewodil 6y agoTry Flutter! Great SDK to get started with mobile development, and dart is a really nice language
- Steltek 6y agoHaving tried neither, Flutter sounds like the polar opposite of both the experience and capability that GP mentioned. I'm sure it's nice but can it be developed interactively in a PC browser as described above?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- judge2020 6y agoFlutter is hacking just your own app, Droidscript sounds like it could be used for anything in other apps (maybe even ad click fraud).
- loa_in_ 6y agoWhatever you choose, moving to mobile development is extremely fun once set up. Usually IDE if your choice reloads the app on the phone over the cable for you, so the feedback loop is really nice.
- TheRealSteel 6y agoTry making a React Native app using Expo. You write JavaScript on your PC (but you can access native functions) and the app will automatically refresh on your phone near instantly. You can later eject it to an Android Studio/Xcode project if you want.
- yaur 6y agoDo these scripts run as the IDE? If so it seems like they could be held responsible for any bad behavior engaged in by their users.
- teknopaul 6y agoLet's be clear: for Google's definition of bad.
- ehsankia 6y ago> I hope this gets fixed. Define "fixed", it was removed from Play Store but anyone can still install from APK or F-Droid, right?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- matoro 6y agoIt's closed-source and paid. Not allowed on F-Droid.
- ajross 6y agoTime for one of these again. So... having read through their marketing material, this is an on-device tool that opens up what appears to be most of the Android application API to at least the user of the device, and potentially to any Droidscript applications they grab from other sources, and... maybe to other apps on the device? It's not clear from a quick read how extensive the runtime control is. So just right out of the gate this is defeating basically the entirety of the Play Store vetting process. Droidscript itself may not be engaged in advertising fraud, but it makes advertising fraud trivial to deploy. (And it needs to be said: this is the kind of app that would never have been legal at all on any version of iOS.) Add to that that it's a closed source IDE for an open platform, and my intuition sides with Google here. My guess is that when details come out it will turn out that at-least-plausibly harmful Droidscript garbage was being pushed to users and Google decided to kill it.
- dtx1 6y agoI think your thoughts on this are plausible, if not likely. However, the usual complete lack of communication by google is the actual problem. Perhaps droidscripts could mitigate googles concerns, if they had the decency to explain them.
- ajross 6y ago> However, the usual complete lack of communication by google is the actual problem. Uh... Seems like the actual problem (given that scenario) is that adware is being pushed to users, not whether or not Google defended its ban in public. Complaints about customer service (from everyone, not just Google) are a dime a dozen, actual user security is clearly more important, right? Your answer presupposes a frame where Droidscript is innocent. What if it's not, and it knowingly nodded to a community of junkware being pushed to its users (again, I have no evidence!). In that case you'd want it banned without "decency", right?
- dtx1 6y agoBanning it first is fine. banning it first, then not giving a reply to the concerns they have is not. Even if they have reasonable believe or proof that droidscript is indeed malware, it looks like at least a chunk of their userbase uses it for legitimate usecases and the devs, who likely invested at least a few hundred hours of work in it, deserve at least some communication.
- simias 6y agoWas it used to publish malware? Given that it's a general purpose scripting tool I can imagine that some people would abuse it and use it as some sort of backdoor to get clueless users to run malware without having to publish it on the app store. If that's the argument I can sort of see Google's point here. The Play Store is supposed to be curated and the application should follow certain guidelines. This tool as I understand it effectively provides a loophole that lets people run non-curated code without jailbreak. I know that Apple removed apps for similar reasons in the past. TFA is a bit misleading, the whole "AD FRAUD" angle is frankly irrelevant, it's just that since Google considers that the app violates the guidelines it can't be eligible for the ad program.
- franga2000 6y ago> This tool as I understand it effectively provides a loophole that lets people run non-curated code without jailbreak. Installing non-curated apps has always been supported on Android - no jailbreaking required. Just get an APK either straight from the developer or through any number of alternative app stores, open it, click the "yes, I'm sure" option in the security popup and you've got yourself an app.
- MadWombat 6y agoOne of the specific features of DroidScript is that it is a remote IDE. That is, when you start DroidScript on your phone it will serve the IDE UI via HTTP and you can then connect it by using your phones IP address (DroidScript conveniently gives you a URL to use). Maybe that is the reason for Google's decision. Also, according to DroidScript itself, Google accused them of ad fraud, so maybe there is something there.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoSounds too good to be true. Is this open source and available on F-Droid. If not, it should be.
- vntok 6y agoWell, is it? The linked post is obviously biased, so I'd rather wait for more information instead of getting my pitchfork out immediately.
- Jaygles 6y agoIt seems to me that the nature of the app is whats causing the issue. From one of the emails they got from Google: > We don't allow apps with any code that could put a user, a user’s data, or a device at risk. Maybe they think the ability to execute arbitrary code is too powerful of a feature?
- ivoras 6y agoHistorically, that has been a major reason for banning apps for both Apple and Google. IIRC Apple even went to extremes and banned browsers which do not use their own JavaScript interpreter.
- CogitoCogito 6y agoThat could be the issue. It could also be something else entirely. It's a bit unfortunate that they are left guessing as to what the problem is.
- pjerem 6y ago> Maybe they think the ability to execute arbitrary code is too powerful of a feature? Yes, probably. But maybe they can act and speak like humans, maybe even make a phone call before just deleting without notice a well established 7 years old app with more than 100k users, cancelling all revenue from user's subscriptions, and all that while sending bot-like mails just saying that they can't give more information about why they are killing an organisation. I think this is really serious. A respected business is going to be shut down, real people are going to be fired and Google isn't even able to answer to an email asking why it's happening ?
- richardwhiuk 6y agoMaybe the business should have read the policy guidelines.
- thereddaikon 6y agoGoogle is pretty infamous for the over reliance on automation for customer service. But ultimately the reason why they persist is because they can afford get away with it.
- teamspirit 6y agoI think one day there will eventually be a class action lawsuit filed against one of these companies for their opaque customer response process. How did it get this way? How did we allow it and for so long? I really don't know. Here we are, the community involved yet somehow this method of customer [non]interaction grew out from underneath us. *spelling edit: fire -> for
- Taylor_OD 6y agoWhat are you going to do? Stop using Google products? Good luck.
- pjerem 6y agoDone. And it was way easier than i tought.
- lainga 6y agoI could... take my travellers' cheques to a competing resort...
- tomjen3 6y agoI run firefox and use DDG.
- heywherelogingo 6y agoYes. Android and gmail are my last two to get rid of. I was wanting to play with mail in a box, but this morning had an alert on my phone demanding my birthdate within 14 days. So, I'll be expediting google out of my life within the next 14 days.
- Zillion 6y agoI can think of at least two other apps that do this—which I won't name in case Google is watching. 'Not to mention Termux, which I can't live without. Why is Droidscript being singled out? Off topic: I won't be buying a new phone for a looong time so I can keep Termux's functionality.
- SeriousM 6y agoWhy not just publish it on f-droid?
- thisisjustmine 6y agoThey have a subscription model and ads which are not allowed on FDroid. FDroid also requires the software to be opensource.
- AlstZam 6y agoThis is true for the official FDroid repository but independent repo can be created [0]. This helps manage independent signing as well. [0] : https://www.f-droid.org/en/docs/Setup_an_F-Droid_App_Repo/ https://www.f-droid.org/en/docs/Setup_an_F-Droid_App_Repo/
- ZiiS 6y agoFDroid do allow subscriptions and ads. They label them 'AntiFeatures' which is not as bad as it sounds; many people will still happy install the App. However FDroid to strictly insist all code is free and open source; this dose mean you are rolling your own Ad and Subscription libraries.
- Aachen 6y agoCorrect. Newpipe on f-droid has the anti-feature of promoting a nonfree network service (YouTube) but that doesn't mean people don't install it or that it's banned from f-droid.
- darksaints 6y agoFunny, the entire google android ecosystem is malware IMO. No I don't consent to your data harvesting...at the very least give me an optout.
- darkwater 6y agoAnd, ironically enough, they publish the announcement on Google Groups.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoLiterally the second post is somebody suggesting that they really should move the forum ASAP.
- ericol 6y agoTL;DR: They are being accused of ad fraud, without any evidence provided, and they are asked to reply with an analysis of why they think their traffic ?? is legit (when they have no idea what is it that Google considered "not legitimate"). The biggest issue here I don't think is the malware tag, but the ad fraud accusation. Even thought as somebody pointed out the page linked can be biased, based only on what they state and the emails from Google, this is another case of David Against (automated) Goliath. From my point of view this is just another drop in the pound of what is already being built as a case against Google (and also Apple) for monopoly. P.S.: I've used Droidscript in the past, and I do think it's too powerful an app that can be abused. But that happens to a lot of things in life, right?
- shadowgovt 6y agoIt is extremely possible that from Google's point of view, an inability to give such an analysis is itself justification to remove the app from the Play Store. If Droidscript is flexible enough to allow end-users to create an ad fraud engine, it's too flexible for the store. Play Store is relatively consistent in its position that a tool that bootstraps policy violations is itself a policy violation. But it would be great if Google could offer a concrete reproduction case, and from a developer-service standpoint it completely sucks that they don't.
- cwkoss 6y agoIs there a service where I can host a raspi on my network and let people send it instructions about which ads should be clicked on and it gradually earns crypto over time? I'd love to make some money while fucking with ad networks... :)
- shadowgovt 6y agoI'm not sure, but I'm going to note that click-fraud already exists and Google (as well as other ad networks) have countermeasures to determine whether your raspi is likely "clicking for fun" and chargeback the advertisers for the non-human clicks. Whether those countermeasures can be reliably defeated is left as an exercise for the raspi owner. ;)
- ben509 6y agoThe writing style of the piece looks like a political mailer. > The Google Play system has declared DroidScript is Malware and accused us of committing Ad Fraud! Needless to say, we are extremely upset and totally flabbergasted at this shocking allegation! That kind of hyperbole sets off all my BS detectors. As I go through the back and forth, DroidScript speculates this: > Our main guess was that one of our users was experimenting with our AdMob ID after extracting it from our APK... What I don't see is that they ever went back to the policies to check if that was legit. If it wasn't and you tell Google, "right, that was totally a feature but we've removed it," then, you just indicated that you deliberately implemented a feature that violated the terms of your agreement. > How can they expect people to build organisations or businesses supported by advertising revenue, when they might be subject to this type of summary execution at any moment! I agree that Google's communication with their customers is awful, but this is not a new problem: _you have to read your contract_. And that means get a lawyer to go over it and explain to you what it really means and not what you'd like it to mean.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y ago> What I don't see is that they ever went back to the policies to check if that was legit. If it wasn't and you tell Google, "right, that was totally a feature but we've removed it," then, you just indicated that you deliberately implemented a feature that violated the terms of your agreement. A user reverse-engineering your app to pull out its AdMob ID is neither a feature nor something the app dev can reasonably be faulted for.
- fmajid 6y agoIt happens a lot more often than people think. By some estimates more than half of all ad clicks are bot-driven fraud.
- indymike 6y agoPerhaps the problem here is the monetization model (ads) is a mismatch? Perhaps try a subscription or just let users buy the app?
- exikyut 6y agoI can't find it now, but I read a story that's been repeatedly posted here about someone who got an idea, dropped everything, built an MVP, showed it to potential customers who loved it... and was told "I definitely need this, but I wouldn't pay for it." And then the person realized that the customer was right (the worst kind of right), and that the idea was both awesome and unmonetizable. In the same vein... question. Google is absolutely terrible at customer support and handling these kinds of issues. I once read in a comment posted here that they apparently don't even regard issues as valid signal unless 10,000 users are affected. (I've personally always instinctively shied away from app/site feedback buttons myself, and now I know why.) I'm guessing it's because con$i$tent ridiculou$ adverti$ing revenue ("we can do no wrong") has caused the death/deselection of normal customer support feedback loops. Sooo... could a startup, or startups, fill the absolutely massive vacuum that is being created here? For every story that trends on HN, how many more false negatives of people being bankrupted are there that never see the light of day? :( I can only think that this number is probably remarkably high given that stories have to trend on social media and/or popular websites, for multiple days, before a connection is made and the problem can be fixed. Once again, the more I look at this, the more I get the impression that this is a huge hole that could be filled to great benefit. But thinking about it, I don't think it would be monetisable: - It would ultimately be a company taking people's money to leverage a few private contacts. It doesn't take much squinting to see this as extortion and gatekeeping, which happens everywhere but would legally be very interesting to defend (especially against a company the size of Google). :/ - The contact issues only exist because of process and organizational failure, so even if private contacts were successfully established, the signal/noise ratio was ideal, and this company did perfect triage, it wouldn't take long for manglement to hear of the situation and decree that no Google employee were allowed to interact with the company professionally - The whole thing would have to operate under the radar to operate at all... and maybe such operations exist and are successful, we've just never heard of them. Problem. Running the whole thing as a volunteer operation maybe sounds like it could work though. And if issues don't get fixed until >10,000 people "notice" maybe such an operation could have noticeable presence before being acknowledged. Just thinking out loud. What think?
- richardwhiuk 6y agoThe signal to noise ratio would still be terrible. The company would have no mechanism to work out who was actually being honest. For every story that trends on HN, 9 times out of 10, it turns out Apple/Google/Microsoft/Facebook were right, and the company was doing something dodgy.
- eplanit 6y agoIt's seriously time to re-embrace the idea of ownership and control of our devices, and reject Android and iOS altogether. Developing for those platforms has become worse and more restrictive over the years, and this kind of crap is now just everyday news. How good are Pinephones[1]? Are there better alternatives? [1] https://www.pine64.org/pinephone/ https://www.pine64.org/pinephone/
- Aperocky 6y agoMaybe it's just time to see phones as what they are - a phone. I don't really care what software is ran in my truck, as long as it works (And that's why I'll not buy a Tesla). It's a phone, use it to call text and guide and browse some internet. That's it.
- goda90 6y agoPhones are the only pocket computers that see quick advances in performance and battery use. For someone who wants a pocket sized computer, it's just most convenient to combine it with your phone.
- Aperocky 6y agoBut they are horrible as production machines, at least until when our brain is no longer using our body as interfaces. For pure pocket sized computing, why not use RPi? It's both much cheaper, more customizable, and it runs Linux. With enough tweaking you can make it run completely headless, plug-and-run mini computer that you can ssh over local network. I think the biggest problem with the combining idea is that computing in general is about productivity, and phone is about phone stuff.
- dividedbyzero 6y agoPhones are kinda too small, but iPads (which are, in essence, oversized phones) are just fine for production machines if you don't equate productivity with programming. With a Pencil and Procreate, it's really hard to beat for drawing and illustrating. With an external keyboard and some kind of stand writing is a joy, I like it better than on a proper computer because of a ton of little things that help me keep focused and because the device is so portable and doesn't have the laptop form factor with a permanently attached keyboard, with bluetooth periphery it's more like a wireless battery-powered external screen. Light to medium spreadsheet work is also totally doable, and I've build dozens of slide decks in various apps, with hand-drawn illustrations. I use a Pi as a mini server, but doing creative work on one, I can't imagine that to be as nice and slick as on the iPad. Last time I tried the PiOS desktop, it definitely wasn't.
- nromiun 6y ago> We don't allow apps with any code that could put a user, a user’s data, or a device at risk. If Google thinks the ability to execute arbitrary code puts users' data at risk why don't they go the full iOS route and ban everything, from scripting apps to other JS engines beside Chromium? I am so sick of their behaviour, the only reason I am still on Android because things like F-Droid still exists and iOS is even more closely guarded.
- yjftsjthsd-h 6y agoGiven the issues that termux has hit, they're certainly moving that way. https://github.com/termux/termux-packages/wiki/Termux-and-Android-10 https://github.com/termux/termux-packages/wiki/Termux-and-An...
- nromiun 6y agoYep, Termux is the most used app on my phone and I don't know what I will do when they have to migrate to SDK 29. I will probably buy another phone and install LineageOS.
- diogenesjunior 6y ago>I don't know what I will do >I will probably buy another phone and install LineageOS
- nromiun 6y agoIt was just a figure of speech and if you know how Termux works even a rooted phone is no alternative. (Termux exposes Android APIs, like camera and GPS.)
- femiagbabiaka 6y agoCurious, is the Librem 5 an alternative you would consider?
- 6y ago
- ddtaylor 6y agoGoogle bans thing. Ban gets attention on HN and a few other social media sites. Google unbans thing. Repeat.
- pudmaidai 6y agoYou wish they unbanned things. I think content blocking will still suck in future Chrome versions.
- kjrose 6y agoThe second step only happens for a small select group of "things." There are myriad apps, people and organizations that Google has blindly banned with no recourse or reasonable appeal that we will never hear about. The bigger point is the system is clearly broken, but how in the world can you fix it?
- ddtaylor 6y agoThe problem is really just a matter of scale and the unwillingness of Google to sacrifice any of it's margins. There are plenty of other companies that have many more humans in the chain where problems like these eventually get resolved once proper appeals are conducted or someone physically walks into a business and participates in whatever verification method is required. The idea that Google is somehow special is laughable. Compared to some other industries that are directly consumer facing the number of apps and developers is actually small. Also, they're not doing it without pay. They're taking a 30% cut from an industry approaching a trillion dollars in annual revenue. Again, the idea they can't solve this problem if they were willing to spend the money is absurd.
- kjrose 6y agoWell, when it's to purchase Google Adwords, there really isn't any competition on that front. As well, Google Play pretty much monopolizes the Android market for the general public.
- Aachen 6y agoNot just Google, also Microsoft and others (see youtube-dl). The question is how we can break the cycle in favor of hackers rather than in favor of big corporations.
- cblconfederate 6y ago> DroidScript has a user base of over 100,000 people world wide a user base built on such foundations is no base at all. unfortunately , only open platforms can be considered a solid enough base for building any kind of community
- NiceWayToDoIT 6y agoIt seems this is not a rare case, I know that my friend lost great portion of his investment in the app at the point when number of users on his app was enough to start getting braking even, Google just decided that some of his users are deliberately clicking on ads. I guess that is way when you deal with company with too much power, there is no way to appall, complain, or do anything that will save your business. So, I guess, and from few stories I read if they find out that you have type of business that is interesting for them, they can simply suffocate your business by standard mafia means, like in the movies first they send a "negotiator", then they beat you a bit, and if you do not comply they "burn" your place down. So, company that had slogan "Don't be evil!" what a joke...
- segfaultbuserr 6y agoThe keyword here is had. Google wasn't that evil when it hasn't acquired today's power yet.
- pdkl95 6y agoThe War On General Purpose Computing[1][2] is escalating. The war has moved past trivial fights over copyright/"DRM", and is now directly targeting programming environments. [1] https://boingboing.net/2012/01/10/lockdown.html https://boingboing.net/2012/01/10/lockdown.html [2] https://boingboing.net/2012/08/23/civilwar.html https://boingboing.net/2012/08/23/civilwar.html edit: fixed link - thanks for the bug report
- overgard 6y agoThis seems so self-defeating by these companies. All this will do is push people to learn to develop on the web (arguably where they already are learning), while completely bypassing any built-in API's and stores. Sure, there's stuff you can't access without native code, but at a certain point why would anyone want to risk making their primary codebase dependent on one of these stores? When FOSS tablets and phones become competitive, I'm really interested in getting one. Maybe even before they're realistically competitive.
- e3bc54b2 6y agoWeb is being crippled too. Google is clenching its iron grip from both sides (search and browser), while Apple leaves it crippled on its own devices for obvious reasons.
- salawat 6y agoIt won't become so without your help, join the fight and make a stand. Every user lost by proprietary platforms tilts the scales more in FLOSS/H's favor. Scale makes all the difference.
- oblio 6y agoYou've posted the same link twice.
- cube00 6y agoSearch the phrase "I made sure to include all the information available to me" and the tail of woe is incredible, all 79,000 hits of it.
- auiya 6y agoThe rest of industry have declared most Google products spyware... so I guess it all evens out?
- cortexio 6y agoi hope one day someone hacks google and puts all their servers offline and puts a text saying: this service is not inline with our guidelines. Even if it's for 1 day, just to give them a small taste of their own non-sense. If you buy something, it should be yours to control. If i buy a plate, you dont get to decide what food i eat. The phone space is currently completely controlled by 2 giants... it's sad.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- barneygale 6y agoFuck google.
- antman 6y agoAt this point Google is the malware. Bait and switch, I miss the era that I could freely customize with termux, now waiting for a decent linux phone.
- clownpenis_fart 6y agoClassifying javascript code execution as malware makes sense
- hilbert42 6y agoWhat else can you expect from a monopoly that knows its above the law—as there isn't any that's either applicable or enforceable? Thus, being above the law Google has no need to concern itself with bothersome matters such as fairness, justice and one being considered innocent before the Law until proven otherwise by due process. Do we really have to go demonstrate on the streets before our legislators will act to stop this out-of-control monster?
- warent 6y agoOn one side I'm being bombarded with news about Google's anticompetitive greedy practices and disregard for customers. On the other side I'm being bombarded with news about Apple's anticompetitive greedy practices and disregard for customers. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. Which to choose? About ready to just burn all of my electronics and live in a damn cabin.
- Causality1 6y agoOur main guess was that one of our users was experimenting with our AdMob ID after extracting it from our APK Is this mean anybody with a grudge has an easy way of destroying any developer's revenue stream?
- neop1x 6y agoApparently not only the revenue stream but a ban from the store and maybe other Google services. Seems like a good tool to take down a competitor's app.
- tjpnz 6y agoThe only thing approaching malware I've experienced on Android was delivered via Google's own ad network. Given what little happened after reporting said malware one can only assume that they apply a very different set of rules to app developers.
- qwertox 6y agoWhatever their reasons may be, they may be legitimate. But using this sentence is simply not OK: > Because this information could be used to circumvent our proprietary detection system, we’re unable to provide our publishers with information about specific account activity. The developer/publisher must be given a chance to correct the issues. This is simply not fair. I'm pretty sure Google can do better than to rely on security by obscurity. --- > Unfortunately we also have to inform our users that we could no longer support AdMob for use in their own apps either, because we can't test it anymore and can't guarantee that Google won't treat them in the same brutal way. Couldn't it be possible that one of those users was using AdMob in a fraudulent way, and that this was then linked to Droidscript? I don't know how Droidscript works, how it creates those apps, but it could be possible that Droidscript then was responsible for the fraudulent use a user did.
- victornomad 6y agoThis is very upsetting. Hopefully they could fix it soon! I worked on a very similar Open Source tool for really long time called PHONK https://phonk.app https://phonk.app (priorly called Protocoder) It started around the same time as Droidscript but PHONK has been always a hobby project rather than a business. I can imagine how painful might be for the Droidscript devs if that's a part of their monthly income... This type of actions by big actors should keep us awake to protect the web with tech, companies and user diversity.
- swiley 6y agoI've declared Android is malware then: The whole point of an OS is to run code for the user but Google has turned it into an additive adware delivery platform.
- jedberg 6y agoAny time there is an article about Google just cutting someone off for no reason, I like to bring this up: 20 years ago my AdSense account was frozen for click fraud -- my appeal is still pending. Ironically the website it was on was shut down 19 years ago.
- progfix 6y agoHow convenient for Google.
- Arjuna144 6y agoOutch, they have done this sort of thing since quite a while now. A good friend of mine had a very big website (among top 200 Alexa raiting in ~2010) with adrevenue around 10k per month. Google just terminated the website without supplying additional much helpful information. Just an automatic generated email saying: you are done.... (that page was https://kriyayoga.com https://kriyayoga.com, which since has been closed down and made available for free download, only the tomb-site remains)
- canada_dry 6y agoThe Streisand effect at work. I'd never heard of Droidscript before, but now I want it. Thanks Google.
- rjmunro 6y agoCould Droidscript's remote IDE features have a security hole that is allowing people to remote install malware into Droidscript users? Google would see this malware coming from Droidscript; Droidscript would not see anything in their code that could be causing it.
- DarkmSparks 6y agosimple solution for anyone considering funding their apps with advertising. Don't.
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoSimple solution for anyone considering to build a business on top of the Google ecosystem. Don't.
- throwaway823882 6y agoSo, what would be needed to start a real, honest-to-god replacement for Android/iOS? You'd need a whole governance structure for your project so it wasn't controlled by a sole entity. There would need to be assurances that using your project was stable long-term. That there were adults driving the bus, and that everyone could use the bus, etc. You'd need to provide a roadmap for everything needed to be built to replace Android, piece by piece. (I guess you could re-use sections of open source code, but some would need to be rewritten from scratch?) You'd need to contact developers, vendors, service providers, etc, the whole ecosystem existing around smart phones, and get them on board with your project. Sell it to them as "no longer being answerable only to Google and Apple". You'll also have to provide alternative revenue sources, as they may depend heavily on Google and Apple services for their revenue. And then you need to find people to do the work, and get paid for it. I'm guessing all this would take at least 6-12 months to get off the ground and some serious capital.
- ur-whale 6y agoHere's a prediction: Within 20 years, you will need the equivalent of a concealed carry permit to run Linux on a computer connected to the internet.
- melff 6y agonah, you don't need a permit for that... you'd just need a computer without a boot chain of trust, too bad those things exist only in museums and landfills nowadays, have fun digging through trash to find your slow-ass 5 year old 18-core RISC-V 256G RAM SoC for witch there is an exploit to break it's chain of trust. Oh and make sure nobody notices, breaking the chain of trust is obviously illegal, and for good reason you could try to break the DRM of a Neuralink-Entertainment-Stream, we can't have that.
- Decabytes 6y agoI feel like we see these stories more and more often. Where an App is removed from an App store for nebulous reasons. I feel for the developers. This is their lively hood. I would also like to stress that this is why we should give more effort to alternative platforms, even if they are "worse than the current offerings". For example I don't see people jumping ship off of YouTube and managing their own PeerTube instances anytime soon, but it is sooo important that something like that exists, and it should be looked at by people making content on YouTube more seriously.
- freeFromGoog 6y agoThis thread got me to try fdroid and bromite. Highly recommend. I'm ready for the detachment from Google. This is why I got an Android.
- timnetworks 6y agoChrome.exe has been breaking the internet for years. There is no bigger malware producer than Google itself.
- sequoia 6y ago> ...after taking into consideration the information that you have provided, we have confirmed that we are unable to reinstate your publisher account. I hate when using euphemism slides into flat out lying like this. They are not "unable" to reinstate the account, in fact they are the only party able to reinstate the account, that's why the account holder was contacting them instead of someone else. They are "unwilling" to reinstate the account. I know it's all just bullshit but it bothers me anyway.
- joemi 6y agoIt's not lying because there is some implicit information in the "we are unable" statement. What is implied in statements like this is that they're unable due to their policies. If not for implications like this, almost every single use of "unable" (or "can't", for that matter) ever in a sentence would be "lying" unless something is against the laws of physics.
- sequoia 6y agoI disagree. If you buy a product from me with 30 day warranty and it breaks on day 31 and you contact me, I will not give you a refund because: a) I haven't agreed to do so b) I'm not bound to do so c) I don't think it's warranted in this case. But I'm not "unable" to issue a refund. In another case I may say "hm it's out of warranty but you know what, it really shouldn't have broken like that and you're a good customer, so I'll give a refund anyway." I can do that because I am able to issue a refund. As for their policy, they are both the authors and interpreters of their own policy, so the "my hands are tied" argument is pure BS. If they are unable to reinstate accounts, why do they have an appeals process at all?
- bipson 6y ago"I can't agree with you" "I cannot continue this relationship" "I can't kill this guy" "I just can't eat meat anymore" "I cannot continue like this" These are all examples where someone clearly could for physical reasons, but they can't for other reasons they are bound to, whatever these reasons are.
- drummer 6y agoBuilding and relying on Google and then complain when they pull the rug from under you. My fellow devs, when will you learn? Avoid Apple and Google.
- kseifried 6y agoAssigned CVE-2021-1000040 for this issue because a minimum DroidScript can no longer get updates out to users. They may also be doing bad things, as claimed by Google, but either way the ecosystem will start to get stale and security issues can't be easily fixed right now.
- tobyjsullivan 6y agoI have no prior knowledge of Droidscript or even android development. I did, however, manage to find this page https://symdstools.github.io/Docs/docs/app/CreateAdView.htm https://symdstools.github.io/Docs/docs/app/CreateAdView.htm This presents a component which Droidscript developers can use to display AdMob ads in their apps. AdMob appears to be a Google property. Some interesting quotes: > The AdView shows advertisement banners from the popular AdMob platform. > Ads are not touchable when running in the DroidScript IDE. So there's a confirmed experience where actual ads are displayed in a non-standard way? Any guesses if this violates Google's ad fraud policy? > Warning: Don't repeatedly click on your own ads unless you are using a valid testId, or Google may suspend your Admob account! So it's the responsibility of individual users to correctly configure their ads to avoid committing click fraud (accidental or otherwise). I can see how Google might come to the conclusion that Droidscript has built a platform for committing click fraud, whether that's their intention or not. This seems incongruent with the wording in the original post: > they ask you for a "complete analysis of your traffic or other reasons that may have led to invalid activity in your appeal". Well, we had no idea what could have caused this and couldn't think of anything we could do Really? No idea? Edit to add: I get that there's a larger debate here around the general fight over device ownership and access to general purpose computing. I'm side-stepping that because I don't have much to add. What I do believe is that this particular piece is hardly concrete enough to bolster the case against Google.
- unexaminedlife 6y agoI like most people don't like the idea of a few large groups controlling entire ecosystems. Especially in technology if these companies have a complete stranglehold on the entire system it's not good. HOWEVER, I really don't think that's the case. I mean look at Hacker News! They built up their brand and product through grass roots efforts. Large ecosystems take notice and recognize, I think, reputation in smaller ecosystems. When a group gets banned like this and feel it's their only hope, I'm skeptical. My guess is either these guys are playing dumb or they don't understand why the best software engineers in the world think they're doing malicious stuff. Either way they don't appear to be ready for the "big time".
- EricE 6y agoNeither Google or Apple have demonstrated they deserve continued trust to be the sole gatekeepers of their respective platforms :(
- coffeecat 6y ago> In your case, we have detected invalid traffic or activity on your account (Publisher Code: pub-********) and as a result it has been disabled. Because of this, the ability to serve and monetise through all products which depend on AdSense will also be disabled (for example, AdMob and YouTube). > We understand that you may want to know more about the issues that we’ve detected. Because this information could be used to circumvent our proprietary detection system, we’re unable to provide our publishers with information about specific account activity. > Once you’ve made changes to your site(s), app(s) or channel(s) to comply with our programme policies and terms of service, you can reach out to us using our appeal process. Please make sure that you provide a complete analysis of your traffic or other reasons that may have led to invalid activity in your appeal. I realize that the term Kafka-esque is a bit overused nowadays... but this sounds exactly like a plot summary of Der Process.
- danudey 6y ago"We've noticed that you're violating our policies." "Which policies?" "That's none of your business." "How are we violating them?" "I'm not going to tell you." "What can we do?" "Fix the issues, and then appeal." "Which issues?" "I've said too much already."
- breakingcups 6y agoSeeing it spelled out like this really puts things even more in perspective.
- obviouslynotme 6y agoI am going to save this and print it out with the title "This is why we don't do business with Google."
- mike_d 6y agoI used to work detecting ad fraud. Publishers would do bad things, call in, and try to get their account rep to get details. Obviously I can't say "of the last 2500 ad clicks zero of them had any mouse movement over the ad before the click event" because then the publisher obviously just fixes their fraud software. This isn't specific to Google or even advertising. Every company has figured out when dealing with abuse and fraud sharing the minimum amount of information is beneficial to the health of the ecosystem as a whole.
- mlindner 6y agoThis piece of software (based on the comments) sounds absolutely like malware, or at least a malware-enabler. Glad such things aren't possible on iOS.
- sjbr 6y agothe title has to be 'Google has ...'
- dewert 6y agoProbably a British English speaker. Not 100% sure on the rules, but see, for example, https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/1338/are-collective-nouns-always-plural-or-are-certain-ones-singular https://english.stackexchange.com/questions/1338/are-collect...
- qyi 6y agoWe live in a world where people unironically put comments on top of every file in their projects (but only the ones they can easily insert a meaningless string into) like "you cannot disclose this file blah blah blah" and call themselves "grown ups". What's this Android nonsense, can't it just run programs like a normal computer? At the very least if it purports to not be a general purpose computer, then there should be no excuse for security vulnerabilities.
- CivBase 6y agoPart of me is amazed that so many apps continue to rely exclusively on the Google Play Store for distribution and monetization. With Google's track record, it's practically negligent to build a business which is completely dependent on their proprietary services. That said, there's also probably no money in Android apps it isn't on the Google Play Store. I doubt most Android users know how to install apps from anywhere else, much less search other app catalogs. So I guess I really shouldn't be amazed at all.
- unexaminedlife 6y agoHere's a thought. One of the most frustrating things to me about this kind of thing is that Google (or any other major tech company) could just ignore me and just tell me "you're malware". I get it. Technology people cost a lot of money, so I would propose that companies who the public depend on MUST offer consulting out-of-band at an hourly (or daily?) rate. This way the real issues are squashed. Now I know that I can get the guidance I need to fix the problems my product is having. Also this helps reassure the public about the big companies intentions in that these FUD stories will become instantly irrelevant. You want your stuff fixed? Pay for the guidance. You don't want to spend the time fixing the issues? So be it. But don't expect anyone to listen to your problems. On top of this, if it's a small open-source project, create a way to streamline funding for the guidance. If a lot of people depend on your project they'll almost certainly chip in a small sum per person for the guidance you need.
- jedimastert 6y agoExcept that ties access to these companies depend on to people who have the money to do so, which creates a huge imbalance
- unexaminedlife 6y agoWe're not talking a huge amount of money. I'm saying let these companies recoup the balance of the cost. For a small company it might seem unreasonable for a Google to bill them $100/hr for consulting services. Then again if 1,000,000 people are asking for those services at 8 hrs a pop. You do the math.
- thih9 6y agoWouldn't that encourage the big company to find more issues in apps, and then tell devs to buy consulting hours to figure out how to solve them?
- unexaminedlife 6y agoWell, if that started happening I'm sure people would start posting stories of how disingenuous the company's practices had become. If they flagged some software as malware they should already know exactly what the reasons are. So we'll call that maybe a 1-2 hr session to get up to speed on exactly what the issues are. How someone goes about fixing it is another story. I'd say by default those sessions should be posted online for public viewing just so everyone can learn from the mistakes of the original team, or to make a judgment of how disingenuous Google is being about the issues. At the request of the project requesting those services they could make those sessions private. Also this could lead to real innovation in the tooling for example Google consultants could write unit tests that would need to pass in order to be allowed on the Google App store. Those unit tests would then, potentially become public so everyone could just download the unit tests from Github in order to confirm their software meets requirements. The other thing is Google would almost certainly see this as a cost center. Billing people at-cost (or slightly above that) for consulting services is way more labor intensive and tbh annoying for companies with a trillion dollar + market cap.
- flyagaric 6y agoIf you think you have a business by relying on Google. You will learn it the hard way. You can’t have business with Google when all the rules of engagement are set by them.
- j_barbossa 6y agoAs still so many people don't get it: 1) Don't make your business dependent on Google 2) Don't make any of your data dependent on Google (don't use Gmail, Workspace etc) 3) Don't make applications you build dependent on Google Hint: If you can't migrate away from Google within a working day, you're doing it wrong.
- JasonFruit 6y agoAnd 'Google' here is shorthand for any entity from which you have no reasonable expectation of customer support which is both human and humane — so don't make your business dependent on Google, Facebook, PayPal, or any similar entity.
- Dylan16807 6y ago"Don't make a phone app, anyone, ever." is the absolute lowest tier of advice.
- TrianguloY 6y agoI don't like the tone of the comment (feels like a tantrum) but unfortunately this happens more often that people think. What I find interesting is the little information they give you after a ban. Apparently if they explained the reasons of the banning then other people could use that information to find flaws and 'game the system'. This means that, if you deliberately made something against the rules and were banned, you can then 'explain your mistake and the measures to not do it again'. But if you don't do anything unusual and simply break one of the crazy rules they have by mistake, it's game over. P.S. If you have a blog and practically all of your visits come from a single source (perhaps a link in something popular) don't EVER use admob on that blog. You will be banned.
- arp242 6y agoYou're not wrong that it's a bit of a tantrum, but after spending years working on a app and then being banned out of the blue without any recourse or even information, I think the author is entitled to a bit of a tantrum. It's true that giving all details might lead to people gaming the system, but c'mon, a bit of details wouldn't be so bad. This isn't some sort of fairly inconsequential website like HN or Reddit we're talking about, but literally people's livelihoods. This is like the cops walking in to your house to arrest you for theft, but they won't tell you what you stole, where you stole it, or how they know it was you. You now go to prison, have a nice day. Perhaps they're right 95% of the cases. But in 5% of cases they're wrong, and bye-bye livelihood and many years of work down the drain.
- luismedinautah 6y agoTest1
- fctorial 6y agoSo they created an app that works as a programming environment, one of their users abused the google play services and they are getting the flak for it.
- 7OVO7 6y agothe problem of a free market in the management of the important hubs of a sector (as is Google for most of the services of its type on the internet) is that they (the big names in the sector, those who reach the top with the free market), are which then once they arrive they can do as they prefer. the problem of a non-free market, in this matter, would be a government monopoly, with the same problem: they can do as they like. the alternative to this currently is not easily applicable, and does not give the current advantages of the "big" (whether they are companies or governments the result does not change; really, it is the same). if you think that Russia and its coming private Internet, or the American NSA security system, or even that I know ... Amazon and eBay, or Facebook and its network (not just the Social Network site, but all its additional services, and where it gets to manage what it manages), or even Chinese censorships on the Internet, are different from each other (to give random examples), think again. then of course comes troll-boss Trump (they ban him from Twitter and other similar sites) and everyone thinks (confused) that this is not real wath I am writing in this comment. we are beyond the conspiracy, here the conspiracy comes to life by itself, randomly, without anyone creating it; now in its own life. who is at the top decides for who is below the top, obviously the developers of Droidscript appeal, they do not like this decision, but they are like everyone else they are subject and subject to the "big". if you don't want big problems from the "bigs", don't support them, don't use them.
- blacklight 6y agoThis is the same story that HN readers have read hundreds of times over the past couple of years, just with different subjects. Independent developer/small organization gets their app/YouTube channel/Google account shut down overnight because of false positives triggered by their system. It takes weeks and insistence with bots to just get to speak to a human. When you get to speak to a human, they usually respond with template responses and refuse to provide further information. Rinse and repeat the same kafkanian process again and again. In all honesty, what the hell is everyone waiting to get off Google? Gmail accounts, app stores, YouTube, ad networks... Alternatives exist nowadays for all of the products developed by a shapeless and faceless corporation that listens to nobody. I wish a long and successful journey for the Droidscript guys on F-Droid or any alternative store. Time for Google to understand that without the content uploaded by us (users, creators and developers) they are nothing but a useless empty box.
- chalst 6y agoI hope the Droidscript devs do take it to F-Droid, but as it stands, the app faces a few hurdles before the F-Droid team will accept it.
- mleonhard 6y agoGoogle is 1/2 of the mobile duopoly. No app developer can avoid Google Play Store (for publishing their apps) and Firebase Cloud Messaging (for sending push notifications to their apps).
- sanxiyn 6y agoSure they can. They just chose not to. Do not support Apple. Do not support Google. Support freedom.
- serial_dev 6y agoAnd if you are a mobile developer, change career?
- Mistri 6y agoSetting aside all of the other absurdities that Google has been throwing out here, the one thing that really gets to me is the concept that "ad fraud" is even a type of punishment for Google. I run an site with Google Ads, and users of my site have, in the past, realized this and purposefully ran autoclickers on my ads in order to get me banned from AdSense. I don't understand how they can blame the publisher for this type of action. I understand they obviously can't pay out for the fraudulent clicks, but instead of banning the account, simply don't count the fraudulent clicks! What's so difficult about that?
- antasvara 6y agoI think you then run into the issue of companies trying to sneak fraudulent clicks past Google. If I knew there was little to no chance of repercussions, I would absolutely try a bunch of programs to try and sneak fraudulent clicks past. It's like if you told a student that there was no punishment for cheating, the questions they cheated on just wouldn't count. This doesn't hurt that bad, because if you were cheating on a question you (most likely) didn't know the answer.
- Mistri 6y agoSure, but in this analogy, if other students cheat off your test, you're punished for it.
- antasvara 6y agoIt's not a perfect analogy because advertising doesn't have a limited number of "questions." If someone adds fraudulent clicks to your site, there's no downside to your business. Worst case, these clicks are ignored. Best case, these clicks are actually counted. Either way, your business is unaffected.
- masswerk 6y agoThis really shows the issues with the private business model in conjunction with critical infrastructure as an oligopoly (as this poses crucial questions with regard to ownership of any reliant products). I know no way out of this short of turning tables. E.g., have a thorough public review process as a last resort (most nations are investing in cyber security anyway and this may provide a valuable proving ground) and force app-store providers to comply. Providers may oppose the verdict, but will have to provide detailed proof and concise reasoning in an appeal process.
- dfabulich 6y agoThis article is big news, because it shows that Google will permanently yank your Android app if your website violates AdSense's secret fraud detector! If you're running Google AdSense ads and you have an Android app that you care about, take down the ads immediately and switch to another vendor. AdSense is the product where Google pays you for running banner ads; they can and frequently do kick people off of it for secret reasons. When my company was kicked off of AdSense back in 2010, I wrote about it extensively. https://www.choiceofgames.com/2010/08/were-banned-from-google-adsense/ https://www.choiceofgames.com/2010/08/were-banned-from-googl... Google will never tell you why they ban people from AdSense, and there's no effective way to appeal. (They have an "appeal" process, but what are you supposed to write in the appeal when the charges against you are secret?!) At least we can still publish Android apps, right? (We now run Facebook ads instead.) But Google's email to DroidScript saying that the DroidScript app was removed from Google Play Store for "Ad Fraud" says otherwise. Publishing status: Suspended Your app has been suspended and removed due to a policy violation. Reasons of violation APK:206 Ad Fraud App violates Ad Fraud policy. Surely Google could have just revoked DroidScript's access to Google ads, while allowing DroidScript to ship on the store, like they did for us. If Google ever yanked our Android app over "ad fraud," we'd have no recourse. We've appealed our AdSense rejection a dozen times over the last 10 years and we always get a form letter rejection. We have no idea what they think we did wrong, and we never will, so we can never fix it. Thank god we don't run AdSense ads anymore. Based on this, I never want to run them again!
- chii 6y agoif you don't interlink your app account and your website's adsense google account, then this _shouldn't_ really be an issue right? So i say always maintain separate google accounts for individual apps, for individual usages. Separate your personal google account from your business account, from your ad-network account etc. And i would argue that each individual app should own their own account (you pay for this of course, because of the fee per account i guess).
- scatters 6y agoGoogle are wise to this; they'll hit you with an "associated account" ban. All your company accounts, app accounts, ad accounts, personal accounts, your spouse's, dog's, dentist's account - all banned.
- pschastain 6y agoHonestly this kind of behavior from Google should surprise no one at this point.
- noduerme 6y ago> Unfortunately we also have to inform our users that we could no longer support AdMob for use in their own apps either Does this imply that Google is holding them responsible for apps originating from their platform which might also have been sources of bad traffic ...separately from their own in-app advertising?
- MrDresden 6y agoAfter 10 years working as a mobile developer predominantly on Android and having had a had in publishing roughly 17x fully fledged commercial applications (under the employ of others) I have yet to take the plunge and try to create a viable business through one personally. I simply don't trust Google to be fair in anyway, and not crush the little guy without reason.
- the-angry-dome 6y agoGoogle did something similar to me and my ads account about a year back. Nothing short of hiring a lawyer seemed a way forward. I would support a class action against Google.
- intellix 6y agoThe lack of humans behind anything Google related shows how dangerous it is to depend on them for your business
- AtNightWeCode 6y agoWhen I had a small scale business Google was difficult to work with. Practically impossible to start advertising for amounts around a couple of hundreds of dollars a month. The support organization even gave advises for the wrong services. I still own some apps that Google Play removed because they don't fit some "programs". The thing is that the apps never opted in on those "programs". For companies I work with that spend 1 000 000+ Euros monthly on Google services it is the opposite way around. Staff from Google more or less are fixing everything, even setting up Google Analytics reports and so on. Google will be the tell when it is time to sell all these insanely overrated stocks that we all own.
- darepublic 6y agoWow this makes the blood boil. My condolences. Can't build a company using their platform as a foundation (as far as it is possible)
- nelsonenzo 6y agoSo, essentially AdSense is defined as malware by googles own definition. If you ship your app with it - malware - remove it, no longer malware.
- asdfk-12 6y agoWhat happened to google? Rhetorical