23 ms·
Europe is in danger of regulating its tech market out of existence
- djohnston 2y agoPretty sure they already did that. Isn’t their flagship SAP? Lol
- meiraleal 2y agoRegulating the tech Market is great for local tech só what happens is pretty the opposite. No country will lose GDP if meta or google leave
- jjtheblunt 2y agohow much of gdp is facilitated through the search abilities of meta and google, though?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- chmod775 2y agoAre you just counting on others being too exhausted to bring yet another moot argument to its predetermined conclusion? I'll finish it to save everyone some time: A: how much of gdp is facilitated through the search abilities of meta and google, though? B: It doesn't matter. A: Why not? B: There will be someone else who is willing to play by the local rules fulfilling the same function in their place, just like in many countries around the world already.
- threeseed 2y ago> There will be someone else who is willing to play by the local rules Building a competitive search engine or AI model requires VC investment. It's simply too expensive to do otherwise. VC investment requires a vibrant startup ecosystem, well crafted regulations and a risk-tolerant culture.
- chmod775 2y ago> Building a competitive search engine [..] requires VC investment. > VC investment requires a vibrant startup ecosystem, well crafted regulations and a risk-tolerant culture. Yandex, Baidu, and many other lesser-known local-only search engines exist. There's also nothing stopping an already existing technology company from entering search. The statement is incorrect. Meanwhile common sense tells us that obviously there's going to be investment into domestic search engines if Google voluntarily throws in the towel. Europe is a huge place and there's a lot of money to be made, even if it's merely with context-based advertising and no individual tracking. > Building a competitive [..] AI model requires VC investment [..] and a risk-tolerant culture. Training a large model anyways, since nobody has really figured out how to recoup that investment yet. Why are you trying to derail this from talking about search though?
- GreenWatermelon 2y agolol. Kagi exists and kicks the ever-loving shit of the garbage bin that is google search. So no, ot doesn't require VC cash to build something useful for people.
- jjtheblunt 2y agoKagi is wonderful: agreed!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jjtheblunt 2y ago> Are you just counting on others being too exhausted to bring yet another moot argument to its predetermined conclusion? Umm, nope. I’m conjecturing that there could be an enabling aspect of huge scale, and that some smaller economies may fall below the threshold. Personally i hope what you wrote works.
- Avamander 2y agoSearch abilities increasingly loathed for poor quality, blocked by providers, made useless by AI slop and superseded by the likes of even TikTok?
- 3np 2y agoFP tends to have pro-US spin. This article reads as propaganda attempting to protect US interests.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dnissley 2y agoTech is very interconnected though, and the article points out an example where what you state is very much not true: "How would Mistral, a leading AI firm, survive if Nvidia exits the French market due to regulatory concerns?"
- Vinnl 2y agoWould've been good if they had been able to come up with a realistic example that could be problematic, but they have not made the case at all while Nvidia would forego the EU market.
- dnissley 2y agoTheoretically it would just be the French market, due to: https://www.reuters.com/technology/french-antitrust-regulators-preparing-nvidia-charges-sources-say-2024-07-01/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/french-antitrust-regulato...
- Lichtso 2y ago> Regulating the tech Market is great for local tech Except, it is not. At least not in the situation that the EU is in. Because all regulations are a constant burden on business, small relative to big corporations, huge for medium companies and insurmountable for startups. The EU has no big players, not a single one! We have a few medium players like SAP and that is it. So, we are already far behind and every weight we load on to drag us down is another nail in the coffin.
- GreenWatermelon 2y agoIt's good the EU doesn't have a big player. Having big players is like having cancer. The EU has a functioning Immune system, the US is buckling under its immunu-comporomised ass. The resources ~~cancer cells~~ big players are extracting aren't going to the people.
- baal80spam 2y agoWe have a tech market?
- DataDaemon 2y agoEurope is a place to take social benefits; there is no tech, no innovation. It's better to sit on the couch and watch Netflix than start a business. There is too much risk, too many taxes, and too many regulations.
- ab5tract 2y agoAh yes, innovation can only emerge from glorious pits of pain and hellfire.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- radley 2y agoSpotify benefitted from starting in the EU.
- spongebobstoes 2y agoI haven't heard that perspective before, can you elaborate?
- radley 2y agoBy my understanding, they didn't have to pay for the exorbitant North American interactive music licenses during their first five year. The EU rates were much more reasonable (plus I think they got grants and govt support?), allowing them to test the market and grow before entering the US.
- paradox460 2y agoThey also let other companies prove the market had worth in North America, even if those companies failed Rdio, LastFM, Rhapsody, and Grooveshark all existed well before Spotify entered North America. Some of them actually predate Spotify
- lucaspm98 2y ago
- shreddit 2y agoAs always, empty space will be filled sooner or later. The question is, filled with better or worse?
- kredd 2y agoI might be talking out of my depth, as I don’t live in Europe, but I’ve heard the same paraphrased headlines like these since at least 2016. Has status quo been swayed one way or another since then? Theoretically speaking, wouldn’t legislating away the top US players open the market to the local companies a la Naver in SK, WeChat in China or Line in Japan? I understand I’m dumbing it down, but assuming such legislations are supported by the local residents. I don’t think I would support it, personally, but I can see their point as well.
- aranelsurion 2y agoI don't get this article. Title is "Europe Is in Danger of Regulating Its Tech Market Out of Existence". But then the subtitle says "Poorly designed laws are forcing *global firms* to leave." (emphasis mine) Then you see a picture of an Apple Vision Pro. I've only skimmed through the article and there are 11 mentions of Apple and 12 mentions of Meta, then some mentions of X and such. These aren't even "global" firms, they are all American ones. If anything, it sounds like they may be regulating away US products from the European market, and that's a big "maybe", which is different from what I understood from the title they chose.
- jeremyjh 2y agoYou seem to have confused "tech market" with "tech industry".
- aranelsurion 2y agoIDK, are local products and products from elsewhere other than US are not meant when one says "european tech market"? The title says the market is in danger of going out of existence, and the article solely mentions a handful of big US companies AFAICT. Or maybe it's a dig at Europe for having large parts of its market dominated by US companies, and I'm missing that.
- jeremyjh 2y agoThe market is defined by the buyers, not the sellers.
- gogasca 2y ago[dead]
- preya2k 2y agoOh the irony of this article being covered by a consent screen that starts with: „We & our 735 technology partners ask you to consent to the use of cookies to store and access personal data on your device.“
- lolinder 2y agoNormally I wouldn't upvote a reply like this, but here in the US I got this one instead: > There appears to be a technical issue with your browser > This issue is preventing our website from loading properly. Please review the following troubleshooting tips or contact us at support@foreignpolicy.com. I had to disable Firefox's Enhanced Tracking Protection in order to proceed. This is the first time since that feature was rolled out that I've had to remember where they put that disable switch. EDIT: This isn't just a generic error handler, there's a specific piece of code that detects if their analytics provider loaded or not and shows that message if it didn't load. More details here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41082004 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41082004
- _nalply 2y agoWhenever something changes on the screen while reading Reader Mode gets activated immediately and without remorse.
- golergka 2y agoDo you think it was deliberate or just a general reaction to an uncaught exception somewhere in the ad part of the app?
- lolinder 2y agoThis is the code that does it: // The tinypass.min.js script was blocked due to a browser content filter console.log('Piano Script was blocked'); // Show error modal to user FP.Utils.Piano.showBrowserCompatibilityErrorModal(); Looks like the code comes from their analytics provider: https://piano.io/ https://piano.io/ Link to the source: https://foreignpolicy.com/_static/??-eJy1lNtuwjAMhl9oIYCQGBfTHgWlwaRu07jECaV7+nmDsWkX0yjhJgdF/vz7FD30ylJIEJJONXTAek8R0AXVk0c7quV8sdaGGRJrjlazjdjLuYLaHJEi60PGt1nDT7oACzvjgG+g9bmSy5XUjfv+c5l1GKZjvgUF2Z1JSKE8UQUY2ENKEBWLfX6AasUt9spjaPkR8Fx9vFegkmmBjhBvdPJnM0h61IBhR4OCkyQpGH+J5P8OOIlSqxvWzlNl/CTTnNCz9mSN50RRWnQ6plRyLFGLoMSWp+rZ9pFO49ZYK5BJhOaQIY6zs5b7IjvnWBR1yEVQnCIGV4KU4y1t82tuvsSgbccazA7inYP4E8i1iVCZAlN3pl5sEznny9QTTaD7QCxVlE+SgjBZfsoHII1P6joFr93LYr1cbDab+eq5eQfeH6ZB https://foreignpolicy.com/_static/??-eJy1lNtuwjAMhl9oIYCQGBf...
- spongebobstoes 2y agoThe real problem is that the requirements for a social platform are getting very onerous, to the point that it takes at least several engineers working full time on the problem. That really hurts a startup's ability to initially launch in the market, especially one with less VC money. (Certain BigCo new products can be thought of as a startup too, with limited budgets.) This doesn't just affect social media companies, it affects almost any product where a user can upload data, or any product with a social feature, no matter how peripheral the feature is. Turns out that's a wide swathe of technology, and that social features are fairly valuable. Of course the big companies will eventually get around to launching in Europe anyway, it will just trail behind the rest of the world.
- betaby 2y agoIn other words - classic regulatory capture.
- zug_zug 2y agoIs that true though? Are there any 5-person startups with < 10k users getting sued/shutdown by this regulation?
- spongebobstoes 2y agoThat data point is very hard to provide any evidence for, and not sufficient to draw any conclusions from. For example, what if the company was never started? What if they pivoted after speaking to a lawyer?
- zug_zug 2y agoFrankly I'm not very convinced by that -- it seems that most social networks are already killed by winner-takes-all SV companies buying-out any possible threat. The situation in America is an absolute nightmare with data being sold through all sorts of mechanisms with zero oversight (your ISP, your car, most apps on your phone, whoever does your credit scores) -- I'm sure there's some way to make successful tech that isn't the hellscape America has.
- threeseed 2y ago[flagged]
- wmf 2y agoShort of the EU directly designing products there's always going to be ambiguity. Most of the "controversy" over GDPR and DMA appears to be completely artificial and caused by malicious compliance.
- threeseed 2y agoDMA was specifically designed to be flexible i.e. ambiguous: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4411743 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=4411743
- jmclnx 2y agoBecause the EU values their citizens privacy tech may leave. Personally I could live with that if that is the result of my privacy being protected.
- betaby 2y ago> Otherwise businesses have no ability to plan for the future and investment stops. And then there is a 'chat control' every year pushed relentlessly. Thus no, not at all. EU doesn't value citizens privacy.
- thrance 2y agoChat control still has not passed, and GDPR arguably contains a few articles in favor of citizens privacy. I wouldn't say "not at all".
- dijit 2y agoThe EU commission (made of elected statesmen from all over the EU) is free to propose as many laws as it wants, but these things never have broad appeal and do not pass parliament (the MEPs we directly elect). Chat control keeps being proposed by the same Swedish politician, and she will continue to do so and she will continue to fail- because politicians in the EU are already aware its stupid.
- rdm_blackhole 2y agoYou are wrong, most MEPs know that this will break encryption and are more than happy to go for the ride because they have exempted themselves from such regulation. Surveillance for thee not for me. Chat control is not just the love child from the Swedish politician, it is being pushed by US surveillance companies that convinced the commission members that CP can be detected and stopped only if Europol has access to all your messages, emails, photos and videos until the end of time without having any recourse as to what it will be used for or by whom it will be viewed. Then there is also Chat Control V1 which is currently extended each year despite being a temporary measure supposedly. Then there is also the data retention directive which everyone knows was illegal to start with and took 10 years to be overturned. The fact that people still associate EU with privacy is a joke. The EU wants your data just like Meta and Apple or Google. At least Meta is not trying to gaslight me into thinking that giving my data is to save the children or some other complete BS reason.
- _nalply 2y agoCould articles like this bemoaning Europe's state of regulation be opinion pieces? What if what Europe does is a good idea for the people but just inconvenient for companies? Europe is one of the power houses of the world but with low self-esteem I am afraid. In the long term what matters is the people's quality of life and diversity. Take China or the US: if a lot of people don't have purchasing power and leisure who are then buying stuff for themselves as end users?
- Terr_ 2y ago> Could articles like this bemoaning Europe's state of regulation be opinion pieces? I agree with the broader idea that a lot of this stuff is PR from vested interests, but this case it's not really secret, since the news outlet categorizes it as: > Argument - An expert's point of view on a current event.
- FredPret 2y agoAre you under the impression that people in the US don't have purchasing power? Also, Europe is a power house right now, but won't be a generation from now if trends continue. All forms of power are built on economic power or are a means to get economic power.
- thrance 2y agoAs an European, I heard that 60% of Americans live paycheck to paycheck. I don't think our laws should focus on tech companies' freedom since it doesn't seem to improve the people's lives.
- FredPret 2y agoNot sure where that stat comes from - median wealth in the USA compares extremely favourably with the rest of the world, while the average blows everyone except Switzerland out of the water. Also, living paycheck to paycheck != being poor. There are many people with high incomes but poor budgeting who live paycheck to paycheck, but will realistically be just fine if they have to tighten their braces.
- quitit 2y agoThe core issue with the DMA is that there is no kind of pre-vetting or assurances available. This is combined with a very wide set of interpretations from a vague set of texts. We've already seen the DMA being waged against a scenario which Margrethe Vestager¹ herself had originally stated would be an ideal outcome of the DMA.² When 10% of global revenue is on the line it makes adequate sense to tread carefully with EU releases until there is some legal precedent. (And 20% if the EU finds that compliance isn't being met.) Margrethe Vestager has stated that withholding features is proof of anti-competitive behaviour. Such a statement would be hilarious if it wasn't so obviously preordained, and patently tone-deaf from the consequences of her own statements. So what's the end game for the EU? In theory this should allow local and small competitors to fill the void since they're not beholden to the DMA. My expectation is that it'll just be the EU perpetually several steps behind the rest of the world and some types of tech involvement only available via US-based purchases/import basis. ¹ Margrethe Vestager: "I would like to have a Facebook in which I pay a fee each month, but I would have no tracking and advertising and the full benefits of privacy." https://www.euractiv.com/section/competition/interview/vestager-id-like-a-facebook-that-i-pay-with-full-privacy/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/competition/interview/vesta... ² Facebook and Instagram’s ‘pay or consent’ ad model violates the DMA, says the EU https://www.theverge.com/2024/7/1/24189796/eu-meta-dma-violation-pay-consent-ads-model https://www.theverge.com/2024/7/1/24189796/eu-meta-dma-viola...
- throwaway14356 2y agowhile we use it a lot apple is not our tech market.
- threeseed 2y agoNo but between Apple and Google they are the foundation of mobility. And if they are not going to bring AI SDKs to the EU because of the regulatory risk then an entire class of potential startups will never exist.
- guax 2y agoThere as much ai shenanigans going on here in Europe as in US. DMA rules do not apply to startups. GDPR is good and stings larger corporations more than smaller ones. Apple and Google are holding a beta risky feature and leveraging it as reason to get some sympathy.
- TekMol 2y agoI think it already did. I am an avid reader of Show HNs. And I remember many that became successful businesses. But not a single European one. All the "startups" that I see here in Europe are very classical businesses. They build software tools for local enterprises. It seems nobody in Europe is building something for the open web. Maybe because nobody here understands all the regulations that come with it. The GDPR alone is 100 pages of legal mumbo jumbo.
- jasonvorhe 2y agoThat's probably not a regulation issue that's mostly hitting US big tech, though. European schools and universities tend to drill people towards employment and not to take too many risks so starting companies isn't as widespread and considered too bureaucratic. Then there's the issue of multiple currencies and not every checkout SaaS supporting all of them and their various options of payment (afaik), which limits reach. That's a problem the US, India, China and Russia don't have.
- dang 2y agoI've noticed that European Show HNs tend to be open-source projects rather than startups. Not interpreting, just noticing.
- jinushaun 2y agoI wish there was more to the US tech industry than social networks and ads.
- sensanaty 2y agoMost show HNs are just some shitty wrapper around OpenAI APIs these days, from what I've noticed. "Searching for papers with AI!" Doesn't exactly sound like the next Google to me, but maybe I'm just out of touch.
- alephnerd 2y ago"Why use Dropbox when I can use rsync or FTP" [0] - HN in 2007 [0] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8863 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8863
- LorenPechtel 2y agoThey have some valid gripes but then they get to: Or consider the recent charges the EU levied against X. Under Elon Musk’s ownership, anyone can now purchase a blue check with a paid subscription, whereas blue checks were previously reserved for notable figures. EU regulators singled out the new system for blue checks as a deceptive business practice that violates the bloc’s Digital Services Act. What are they thinking?? The blue check mark is supposed to mean verified. They changed it to simply mean paid subscription. They took a symbol of trust and utterly ripped out the trust part. I don't care how much you publicize it, that's not acceptable. Would he be ok with my going and purchasing a SSL certificate for www.x.com???
- nradov 2y agoDon't be naive. It was never a symbol of trust. At most it was a symbol of prominence or notability as decided by a biased, unaccountable group of Twitter employees. Many of the old blue check mark accounts routinely posted inaccurate information or outright lies. The new X Community Notes system is far superior for establishing trust. https://www.hindustantimes.com/world-news/us-news/biden-claims-inflation-has-come-down-in-us-x-adds-a-context-to-the-tweet-with-many-americans-wondering-how-101701400588614.html https://www.hindustantimes.com/world-news/us-news/biden-clai... https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2024-05-22/elon-musk-s-community-notes-feature-on-x-is-working https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/articles/2024-05-22/elon-m... Fundamentally just because a software feature worked a certain way at one time doesn't create an obligation for tech companies to keep it working the same way. Whether you consider that acceptable is entirely irrelevant.
- johnthewise 2y ago>Many of the old blue check mark accounts routinely posted inaccurate information or outright lies. There are always going to be misinformation. It's crazy to think a company or any committee can determine these for us though. It's not even logical yet alone practical. then you need to determine whether said entity made any judgment errors in assessing a person or claim. Those who demand centralized 'truth' authorities are useful idiots for power seeking authoritarians.
- 2y ago
- mensetmanusman 2y agoIt’s probably smarter to only kick-in regulations after certain size thresholds are met. You can definitely strangle an organization with paperwork before it even has enough money to hire people to do the paperwork.
- Vinnl 2y agoLike the gatekeeper designation in the DMA, or the threshold for assigning a data privacy officer in GDPR, you mean?
- Denvercoder9 2y agoThat's the case for most, if not all, of the new European regulations, such as the Digital Markets Act. The number of companies to which it applies can be counted on your hands, and they all have tens of billions of dollars of revenue.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoEach country may have its own regulations though, which makes it difficult, because not all of them are threshold based.
- Avamander 2y agoI don't think safely handling data subject's data for example is something that should start only from a certain size. Let's only make the small bridges unsafe?
- phendrenad2 2y agoNah, not really. The EU will have a thriving tech market. It just won't have ad-supported sites. Because if anyone hasn't noticed, "data privacy" is just targeted ads. "This company was caught tracking which users visited each page" Yes, for targeted ads. "Cambridge Analytica was" Yes, for targeted ads. "3rd party" Yes, targeted ads. It's all targeted ads. They want to serve you targeted ads. Any attempt to paint "data privacy" as something other than this is irresponsible fearmongering.
- neonate 2y agohttps://archive.ph/sLsnW https://archive.ph/sLsnW
- kabes 2y agoTech is more than social networks though
- Loughla 2y agoYeah, it's advertising too.
- Vinnl 2y agoApparently the author founded the "Center for New Liberalism". I tried to find out how that's funded, but could only see memberships that gives access to a 700+-person Slack, and couldn't find what the dues are. Would be interested in learning more about that, if anyone knows more.
- TheChaplain 2y agoNot only the tech market, they're on a pace in destroying the agricultural market as well. Small, medium size farmers are disappearing fast, they quit or at best being absorbed by large farmcorps.
- threatofrain 2y agoFor agriculture at large I wonder if that's not going to be the final economic state everywhere in the world, regardless of government. That's just more efficient. Is there anywhere in the world where this trend is reversing and looking healthy?
- stfp 2y agoUnless you only look at the financial side of things, and only from the perspective of the larger corps benefiting from this trend, it's not healthy at all.
- threatofrain 2y agoI'm asking for counterexamples which are healthy. What is the leading example in your mind?
- silverquiet 2y agoIt's literal Econ 101 that economies of scale push towards monopolization. It's why we used to have anti-trust laws in the US.
- stvltvs 2y agoAmerican agriculture already went down that path. This might be a global pattern following the adoption of improved technology. Is there a reason to believe otherwise in the case of Europe? Or maybe it's a multifaceted phenomenon.
- kazen44 2y agothe agriculture market relies heavily on goverment intervention to even exist. The EU and its member states give out huge subsidies to keep food production local in the EU without being completely destroyed by cheaper crops from third world countries. The US does the same, and it is for good reason, to actually make sure a steady food supply exists inside the country/union.
- multimoon 2y agoI think we can debate regulations being productive or not all day and either side of the camp will never agree, however my biggest personal issue is that the government is removing the choice from anyone involved. As an adult you should be able to chose for yourself - if everyone chose no, then nobody would use these services and the companies wouldn’t do it. I think the effort needs to be focused on awareness and education, not restriction. If the average user is fine with their data being sold in exchange for a service, then why not let them? I’m personally not okay with it and I keep my data footprint as low as I can, but I know lots of people who just do not care if they get a service in return, and are fully understanding of what that means.
- Sakos 2y agoCompanies circumvent real choice all the time. Regulations prevent them from doing so. There's no equivalency here. EU has repeatedly made legislation that does something or anything to counteract the power these tech companies have over the lives of billions. The EU has an interest in serving the needs of EU citizens. Tech companies do not. Tech companies only care about their bottom line, regardless of the human or financial cost to anybody else. There is no option for individuals to do anything about these companies. That's what we need governments for. The US has largely decided that companies shouldn't be regulated at all (particularly with the recent Supreme Court decisions). This isn't a good thing. It will not benefit the vast majority of US citizens. There is no "choice" citizens can make that will undo the unraveling of government regulations on industry/business, unless it's voting for a political party that one that will reform the Supreme Court and revert their insane decisions, a party that isn't the GOP.
- multimoon 2y agoThen it sounds like what you’re saying is there’s a financial market for users like you and I who would rather pay a subscription fee than our data be sold? Or an ad supported tier? The problem with your argument is you’re removing any revenue source the company has. If you won’t pay a subscription, and you block all the ads, and they can’t sell data, how do they make money? Money is required to run the service, whether that leaves a sour taste or not. If you think you have a financially viable model that protects data, then you should start a company on that premise, I’d genuinely love to see someone make it work.
- smitty1e 2y agoThink of regulation as a higher form of tech. Then ask yourself how exactly the architects were self-medicating.
- thrance 2y agoI wish targeted advertising was made completely illegal here, I am sure our society would greatly benefit from that.
- _ink_ 2y agoI agree to the fullest
- AnarchismIsCool 2y agoI'd just say all advertising. It's effectively money time and effort we just light on fire.
- throwawayq3423 2y agoWhy not make Sales illegal too.
- ktosobcy 2y agoHappily. I'm not very fond of dumb calls from "sales" starting with "Let me introduce you to our new shiny product"...
- in_a_society 2y agoJust curious, what industry do you work in?
- ktosobcy 2y agoWhat's the relation to the outlook?
- thfuran 2y agoAll advertising is a step too far, I think. But banning accepting any remuneration to deliver, display, or cause to be viewed any advertisement, and limiting physical ads in places viewable from public areas seems like it would improve things. Buildings shouldn't be covered in ads, and the internet shouldn't be largely based around scamming as much information out of people as possible to jam ads down their throat, but a business should be allowed to put up flyers on their own storefront. I mean, if you're really pedantic about banning all ads, that probably precludes restaurants posting menus out front.
- KaiserPro 2y agoA company that provides a phone service (mobile or other) has to conform to a large amount of regulatory red tape. Why? because either a company before tried to monopolise the entire country, or they killed someone. Now, large tech companies haven't wholesale killed people (unlike say tobacco, or talc powder, 3M and half of their solvents, weed killer, most car makers, etc etc) but they have been trying desperately to stop all competition. They've also been trying to extract as much personal info as possible for profit. Because regulators in the USA are hamstrung, they are used to being able to basically doing stuff that would be illegal if it were in physical stores/pre-existing industries.
- onlyrealcuzzo 2y ago> but they have been trying desperately to stop all competition. Every large company in every industry wants to do this. > They've also been trying to extract as much personal info as possible for profit. Why would you expect a company not to pursue profits?
- ktosobcy 2y ago> Every large company in every industry wants to do this. And the point of regulation is to stop it and bring balance. Or are you happy with mono-/oligopolies?
- onlyrealcuzzo 2y agoI'm fine with regulation to prevent monopolies / duopolies. In practice, regulation almost never actually does that. Every major industry is a monopoly or duopoly if you're even a bit generous with the term. I'm just pointing out there is nothing unique here with tech or data. And the politics are mostly theater that often makes things more monopolistic, not less.
- shermantanktop 2y agoI read that as saying there's nothing to be done, monopolies are natural, we can't stop the order of things without making everything worse, we must just acquiesce and learn to live with them. Is that correct? I have a hard time thinking that is true.
- DyslexicAtheist 2y agodid goon lawyers in Silicon Valley write this?
- skywhopper 2y agoThis is silly. So a bunch of American companies are refusing to go along with EU regulations that cramp their own monopolistic style. That doesn’t mean they are killing the local tech market.
- nradov 2y agoIs the local tech market alive?
- helf 2y ago[dead]
- the_optimist 2y agoThe efficacy of bureaucratic destruction is explicit in warfare guidance [0]. We pretend peacetime is different. It’s not. So among non-EU-dwellers, let’s raise a glass to our fallen competitors and erstwhile comrades. Better than Nordstreaming them, or at least more subtle. Onward, toward a new vassal-state future! edit: It appears that EU subjects are distraught, or the topic is too raw. Let me know! [0] https://www.hsdl.org/c/abstract/?docid=750070 https://www.hsdl.org/c/abstract/?docid=750070
- marmaduke 2y agoThe Human Brain Project's final 3 year period could have actually delivered a platform for actually modeling real human brain data, and GDPR totally blew that possibility out of the water: no one had the budget to take on the legal risk, and everything was finished up with synthetic/augmented datasets or done "locally". our colleagues in the US and China are chuckling, so we'll just move our science there.
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 2y agoPlease don't dissuade them/us from doing so.
- tivert 2y agoI don't think big-tech companies exiting is a bad thing. They're so used to getting their own way and making the rules that it's probably signal that Europe is on the right track.
- localfirst 2y agoPretty much these articles from FP are notorious for their poor journalism and just a mouthpiece for billionaires In fact a huge chunk of American MSM is turning out to be unreliable and quick to deceive its readers who are still stuck in the "why would they lie to us". Europe is doing a good job and as are more sovereign countries waking up to the techno-colonialism at play. If Google or Facebook is in your country, they do not share your country's interest and instead pushing their own American ideologies. More and more countries should reject American tech companies that seek to interfere and spread their fcked up ideologies in the host country.
- tivert 2y ago> If Google or Facebook is in your country, they do not share your country's interest and instead pushing their own American ideologies. > More and more countries should reject American tech companies that seek to interfere and spread their fcked up ideologies in the host country. I'd go father: even in America they don't share their country's interest and instead are pushing their own Silicon Valley ideologies (e.g. they're all for solving problems, only so long as the solution means using more of their products, making them even more money, etc.).
- localfirst 2y agoto be exact, San Francisco ideology shaped by the images of their limitless compassion now spreading world wide and raising questions.
- tivert 2y ago> to be exact, San Francisco ideology shaped by the images of their limitless compassion now spreading world wide and raising questions. Are you talking about the homeless encampments? I suppose that's another part of it. But I was thinking about the ideology that says that more computerization (and less friction) is always more better. Basically, "We care about teen mental health, just as long as those teens are still glued all day to Instagram, even if Instagram itself is the problem."
- johnea 2y agoEliminating goggle, apple and meta could only be regarded as a good thing... Throw out bozo too for the win-win...
- autoexec 2y agoThe EU is free to pass laws preventing gatekeepers and insisting on interoperability requirements and Apple is free to refuse to do that and not offer their non-competitive gatekeeping products in the EU. There's zero reason to think that this will mean the EU won't have a tech market. It just won't have one that includes Apple products which refuse to follow the law. Seems like a massive win for the EU, and because Apple is the one deciding to pull their products rather than follow the law they can't really complain either, so win/win I guess.
- cheptsov 2y agoExcept EU doesn’t have big tech.
- dijit 2y agoAnything that gets close gets bought or killed by non-european giants. Tencent buys basically all game companies, microsoft buys basically all communication companies (skype, nokia come to mind), google buys basically everything. Even ARM is owned by Softbank after starting out in the UK. The Automotive industry and ASML are just about the only things resistant to this because they're so large already; Automotive acts a lot like big tech. (a clear similarity I saw after being in BMW R&D and Googles Zurich and SF campuses)
- carlosjobim 2y agoThey can't buy anything unless Europeans are willing to sell.
- dijit 2y agoVivendi and Tencent attempting to buy Ubisoft via shares might be one thing in living memory that disagrees. If you are publicly traded there is little you can do to prevent people buying shares - though you are right that people sell privately held companies a little too often. Ubisoft in particular created many poison pills to prevent companies getting too dug in, however that didn’t prevent anything except a total buyout. Their board is stacked with Microsoft and Tencent which causes weird, extremely harmful, decision making in the org.
- CAP_NET_ADMIN 2y agoTech sector pretending that the regulations that worked in all the other sectors don't and won't apply to them or they will upend the human civilization.
- jmyeet 2y agoNo, it's not. This is a not-so-thinly veiled argument for deregulation and rolling back consumer protections, pretty much like the US. It's common to use scare tactics when it comes to regulations and taxes. "Companies will leave". "You're killing companies". As long as the EU has 400+ million consumers and they have spending power a market will exist and companies will adapt. Take the example from the article of CUDA being a monopoly. Well, NVidia obviously isn't a European company but it will comply if the EU forces them to open CUDA because the alternative is to close themselves off to Europe. That's never going to happen. Stop believing this "companies will leave" propaganda.
- ponorin 2y agoYou know you're out of good arguments when you have to defend the eX-Twitter's blue checkmark fiasco
- sensanaty 2y agoAlways hilarious reading big tech propaganda. They're trying oh so hard to convince people that, no, us harvesting every single iota of information and selling it to data brokers is progress, actually!!! The best part, for me, is while they flail and scream about the big bad EU, Japan and India are following suit with similar laws and regulations. It's only a matter of time until more and more countries start adopting these laws, and the tears from the techbros is going to be delicious. The website the "article" (aka paid propaganda piece) is hosted on has over 700 partners that they'd like me to consent to having my data shared with. It also completely shits itself thanks to uBlock, meaning it's made so terribly that blocking the privacy-invasive trackers they have breaks the whole site. If this is their idea of innovation, they can keep it and shove it where the sun don't shine.
- segasaturn 2y agoQuite frankly I would prefer no tech industry over today's large, unregulated, monopolistic and aggressive tech industry. I feel like my life has not significantly improved at all relative to the enormous growth of the US tech industry in the last ten years, I'm no happier today than I was back then. Almost all of the gains have gone to a concentrated elite that I am not part of. Lately I've been looking at my phone and devices and other tech toys and asking "was any of this worth it?".
- jsnell 2y ago> But politicians such as Vestager don’t get to then act shocked and outraged when tech companies choose to leave. Much as I dislike Vestager, that is not an accurate description. This appears to be the original source: https://www.youtube.com/live/GmQ5SsMFbsU?si=IgTi-ezhulsCl6Gp&t=4613 https://www.youtube.com/live/GmQ5SsMFbsU?si=IgTi-ezhulsCl6Gp... That is not someone "shocked" or "outraged" at Apple not bringing the AI features to EU markets. Vestager doesn't give a fuck about whether iOS ships with AI features or not. She is just saying that by citing the DMA as the reason, Apple are pretty much admitting that the features as implemented are anti-competitive. And she is stunned that Apple would be stupid enough to make that admission. Like, you'd at least expect the Apple C-suite to pretend it's because of some technical reason, or because the cost structure isn't viable to support in Europe, or something other than that it's breaking competition laws.
- jlaporte 2y agoIt’s interesting to observe how detached the discussion here is from the issues created for Europe due to the DMA. A majority of the comments here make the implicit assumption that the DMA is good because it will penalize big tech companies and force them to change business models in the EU. This is not what is happening or will happen. What’s really being destroyed by the DMA is Europe’s access to new technologies and services. It’s almost like a self-embargo on the AI building blocks of their future economy. When Nvidia GPUs are supply constrained do you really think it matters to Nvidia if they need to redirect the small chunk of their supply constrained volume that they were previously selling into France? Who is harmed in this picture? The only EU AI player of note, Mistral, and other EU businesses. Does it really harm Apple if the DMA forces them to withhold new AI features in Europe? They still earn their device and services revenues. Who is harmed in this picture? EU consumers and businesses. We’ve now seen within just a couple months, Apple withhold AI features and Meta withhold multimodal AI models from the EU. Expect this cutting off of the EU from new features to become a recurring event over the next year. DMA-supporting voices are under a serious misapprehension of what the effect of the DMA is and will be over the next few years. It’s cutting off European access (consumer, business & government) to critical technologies which are all being developed outside the bloc. The DMA violates a number of longstanding principles of good legislation - it is vague, it’s written to enable arbitrary enforcement, it’s penalties are not designed to be proportionate to damages, or even require actual damages in order to be applied, the regulator’s actions stray into actual takings of property (European Commission opinion that Facebook cannot charge a subscription fee for its ad-free offering… so it must operate as a charity? This is a taking of property. European Commission opinion that Apple cannot charge a platform fee for use of its IP? This is a taking of property).
- Nathanba 2y agoI think the topic is hard to talk about because the EU is technically trying to do the right thing but reality often rewards the conquerors and the US, China etc. (aka the competitors) still believe in the right of tech conquest. They don't stop their companies from taking whatever they want whether it's properly licensed or not. So we are in a situation where the EU is dotting their i's and shaking hands in their moral superiority while not understanding that we have to compete with people who don't care if they steal something or rob you by force. It's similar in all these other areas like the DMA and GDPR... we are competing with markets who simply don't care that they are violating people's privacy and it's more profitable to rob people and sell their stuff. The EU in my opinion has to create regulations that understand this reality and create an even stronger wall for european companies. So please go create these regulations, fine.. but understand that you should make unfair exceptions for european companies. Let european companies that are situated here violate these regulations and make this explicit: As long as the US and China do not have equivalent regulations, EU companies are explicitly allowed to steal US and chinese content. Yes really, make that very explicit. Make laws with the full understanding of what reality we are living in. We are dealing with competitors who will take our last shirt by force, not friends and "partners" as they so lovingly put it in their press releases.
- orbital-decay 2y agoDidn't US lose most of its production capability for the same reason? US protected its workers' rights, but there are other places with cheap labor treating the workers like shit, so businesses are using factories in other places, which then build massive expertise at production. This is similar. EU is trying to protect the rights of its citizens for good, but there are also places like US where rights are less protected, or not at all. (and frankly, a sizeable amount of people there don't even give a crap about rights that seem ephemeral for them, like privacy). So naturally businesses go to those places. It's not poorly designed laws, or at least not just it. It's also a tragedy of commons in a global economy, moving too fast vs too slow, and many other things.
- jokethrowaway 2y agoThey're not rights, they're needs. They don't have space in regulation. If you want privacy, purchase the privacy conscious option. Don't force the entire market to make ads worthless, forcing companies to charge for things, forcing ME and my adblock to pay for crap I got for free until yesterday.
- alephnerd 2y ago> EU is trying to protect the rights of its citizens for good Western Europe is not the entire EU. Czechia, Romania, Bulgaria, Hungary, Poland, and the rest of Eastern Europe give plenty of leeway to businesses who bring FDI in. The Czech government indirectly pushed a former employer of mine to force employees back into the office from remote work by threatening to withhold tax credits they used to establish a tech/outsourcing center in Praha. Plenty of similar stories in Romania, Bulgaria, Poland, Hungary, Slovakia, etc. Oh, and the SEZs and Law Firms that the investment agencies made us use were always very closely connected to the incumbent poltical parties (and either indirectly or directly owned by them) You can take Eastern Europe out of the Warsaw Pact, but you can't take the Warsaw Pact out of Easrern Europe's political and business establishment
- snowpid 2y agoIn my little buble hanging around the Berlin start up scene (not founder) I've never heard about complains for DMA, Ai Act etc. (only GDPr for medical stuff , but that is tackled by new laws... With less privacy). Current stuff (other mentions): Germany's state of digitalisation and bureaucracy, investments. So this guy clearly gives an lousy tech lobbyist . Giving his initiative DMA is certainly pro market oriented. Why does he have a problem with it?
- Lariscus 2y agoIs it time for our 'tech companies complaining about EU regulation' article again? Must be a day ending in Y.
- tomxor 2y agoYes yes, we took away Apple's money funnel... Let me go find the thinnest violin, to match this thinly veiled tantrum.
- hintymad 2y agoI'm curious on why European people allow such heavy regulation. They really think that the Europe can enjoy their prosperity with little innovation for years to come?
- jokethrowaway 2y agoThere are too many layers of government. We have no way to influence what our leaders do in our own governments. Go figure how much our representative in the EU parliament will be able to represent the will of the people. Ask anyone in EU who is their country representative. They won't be able to tell you. Heck, ask who the president of the EU commission is. Nobody will be able to tell you and she's been ruining our lives for 5 years already. MEP are just partying with the lobbyist in Bruxelles and challenging each other who can get the bigger bribe.
- solenoid0937 2y agoI agree -- these comments are bizarre to me. Technology is the single biggest predictor of QoL in human history. You can only miss out on so many Industrial Revolutions before you begin to lose power (economic, military, financial, social) and fade into irrelevancy. That will certainly hurt QoL more than any short-term gain from preventing Memoji AI from existing in your region, or strangling your next AI startup in the cradle.
- voiceblue 2y agoThe comments here seem ignorant of how regulations in the EU have become and what the dynamic is. Regulation is being lionized [0] as a political badge of honor, and as TFA shows, things are getting ridiculous: it is not enough that you can a) not use facebook, b) pay for it, or c) consent to let them use your data -- you MUST have d) use facebook for free without letting them use your data. In other words, socialist values must be upheld by corporations, now everyone must be able to avail of your product at no cost, to be subsidized by the wealthy, which in this case is the corporation itself! Of course businesses are just going to stop operating in this environment! The comments here seem blind to this simple calculus. Then they will say, "nothing of value was lost": then think who is the arbitrator of value here? It is clearly not the consumer*, but the consumer's nanny. Was something of value lost in that philosophy? No? Perhaps China and North Korea are not so bad, then. [0] https://www.wsj.com/tech/apple-iphone-15-usb-c-eu-malta-4240a5b3 https://www.wsj.com/tech/apple-iphone-15-usb-c-eu-malta-4240... * Consumers vote with their wallet and their feet when it comes to products and establishments
- trinsic2 2y agoThe headline should be corporations are in danger of criminalizing themselves out of existence.
- yalok 2y agoOne of the clearest examples of this to me is the requirement to show consent to store cookies. This just simply ruined web surfing experience, where now every site has to show a popup of all kinds of shapes and forms. Why not let the users decide in whole-sale, if they wish? like with this extension - https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/accept-all-cookies/ofpnikijgfhlmmjlpkfaifhhdonchhoi?hl=en-US&pli=1 https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/accept-all-cookies/...
- Anamon 2y agoAFAIK there is no general requirement to ask for consent. For example, to store session tokens or language preferences. A lot of sites probably wouldn't have to show cookie consent prompts, if they don't share profiling data with third parties or do other shady stuff, but still show them because they're afraid of doing it wrong or because everybody else seems to be doing it. It's been a while since I read the text of the law, but I remember thinking that the line from which consent was required seemed reasonably drawn and that websites who cross it are right to be forced to declare what exactly they do. There was a post about this recently, titled something like "there is no cookie banner law". An option for a general setting may be nice. I personally approximate it by only accepting cookies from whitelisted domains, and using ad blocking filter lists to hide cookie consent prompts.
- totallywrong 2y agoWell done EU and good riddance to any company that doesn't like these laws.
- AzzyHN 2y agoNo they won't but okay.
- rty32 2y agoDid I miss anything? Subtitle says "Poorly designed laws are forcing global firms to leave." I didn't see anything in the article that elaborates on the "poorly designed" part or any company that is forced to leave. Instead, the article uses a number of totally irrelevant examples to argue... nothing. I am really confused.
- venkat223 2y agoEurope is correct.Taking initiative on the moonlighting of hyper cheating of common citizens by big tech firms.It is investing all conceptual strength on wayward money making by the four tech "giants" at the cost if people.They act as sentinels and gatekeeoers to prevent cheats from secret money making.
- COGlory 2y agoThe article doesn't list much in the way of tech. LLMs, social media, and advertising hegemons leaving Europe is hardly a tech flight. In fact, it sounds like a best case scenario. Someone call me when Zeiss moves out because they can't compete in Europe, and I'll be concerned Europe is actually losing something of value.
- kmeisthax 2y agoForeign Policy is pearl-clutching because they've seen what actually enforced antitrust law looks like for the first time since Borke and Reagan ratfucked it. The thing is, the tech business is uniquely conducive to generating monopolies, for a handful of reasons. The biggest being we're a copyright industry. Congress made the mistake of putting software under the same legal framework as Mickey Mouse, so the monopoly tech companies have over interoperability is government granted, has little bounds on its power, and lasts forever. And when tech and creative industries got together to enforce those legal rights through software, we got DMCA 1201, an awful law that gives anyone with a valid copyright veto rights over technological progress. The only way you get shit done in the tech industry is to get acquired so that you have enough market power to license and collaborate. Outside of copyright we have online services firms like Google and Facebook, who operate primarily through surveillance capitalism. In prior media landscapes, if you wanted to sell to New York Times readers, you had to buy inventory in the Times. Today, you ask Google and Facebook to put ads on anyone who went on nytimes.com in the past week, which is just as lucrative for the ad buyer but Google and Facebook can pay the other sites less than what an actual NYT ad would command. Targeted advertising moves money away from a diverse and distributed group of publishers towards a pair of ad networks who know exactly everything about everyone at all times. Facebook absolutely could be 'paid for' through nontargeted ads, but it makes Facebook a far less valuable business if they can't siphon data off you and sell it to other companies. Hell, Apple already proved this: iOS 14 moved ad tracking to opt-in[0], so nobody opted in, and Facebook had a revenue hit. Europe is not inhospitable to tech, but it is inhospitable to tech monopolization, which is predominantly how American firms operate. And to be honest, I don't think Europe is wrong to do this. In fact, I want America's government to start doing the same thing. I want a government that acts less like a rubber stamp for a handful of megacorporations and more like the villains in an Ayn Rand novel. Do you want to see what the alternative is? Simple: the end of democracy. Trump was just a preview. Democracy is not a given, it requires distributed political power, which requires distributed wealth and economic power. If a handful of firms can centralize economic power to themselves, then they become the economy, and they can start pulling the strings politically. We already saw this with oil in the 70s, but basically every American industry works this way. The only vestige of democracy left is that sometimes industries have conflicting economic interests and that sometimes the working class hurls an orange brick through everyone's windows. [0] Unless you're Apple, who can still track you. Related note: Google is basically being forced to keep third-party cookies in Chrome because they dragged their feet on removing them for far too long.
- dotcoma 2y agoFunny how any effort to limit Big Tech’s ability to do whatever they want is seen as a negative thing. IMHO attention to privacy and privacy regulations will help make Europe the leader in privacy-respecting services.
- kelnos 2y agoI don't live in Europe, but wish we had these sorts of regulations in the US. If tech companies cannot provide us a means to control our personal information, and require us to be locked into their gatekeep-y, nanny-state, walled gardens and submit to using locked-down devices that don't actually obey what we want them to do, then those tech companies should not exist. I've gotten a little bit of a taste of some of this stuff in the form of the CCPA/CPRA, and it's delightful. Getting to tell companies they're not allowed to sell any of my information to third parties is wonderful. I just wish that was the default and I didn't have to opt out. Big tech is far, far under-regulated, even in Europe, too, and that needs to change.
- ricardo81 2y agoIMHO the problem has been that FAANG has not been regulated enough. The sheer size of these companies and their market share means there's little chance of competition from anywhere. Though TBF when it comes to poorly thought out regulation, the amount of human time lost to clicking cookie consent/reject screens surely has to be a net loss to society.
- paulryanrogers 2y agoThe regulations don't require a banner. Just don't gather or share unnecessarily. No banner or notice required. Companies would rather hound users than stop selling them down the river, even their directly paying customers. And if people are better informed of how far and wide their data will be prostituted, then I'd call it a win.
- ricardo81 2y agoFair points. I guess browsing life would be much easier if something was implemented at the browser level and cookie pop ups become the exception.
- cynicalsecurity 2y agoThat's hilarious to see Apply trying to punish Europeans for standing up for their rights. Good luck with that, we don't care for your "intelligence".
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y ago"Europeans could end up living in an online backwater with out-of-date phones, cut off from the rest of the world's search engines and social media sites, unable to even access high-performance computer chips." Sounds like a paradise. More healthy lifestyle. For most people much of this stuff is unnecessary. If one wants to live life "online", glued a screen digesting garbage and propaganda 24/7, then one can relocate to some country where that's what people do. Chances are, tourists from such countries will want to visit Europe even more. We are all living in an "online backwater" in case the author hasn't noticed. The web is a sewer of surveillance, marketing and ads. Despite the information access possibilities the internet presents, the distribution of factual information seems to be at an all-time low, at least in the lifetime I am living. I have never seen people who were so detached from commonly shared reality as a result of "search engines and social media sites". To access facual information, cf. marketing and propaganda, worthless opinions, and "AI" generated garbage, one did not and does not need the latest "phone" or "high-performance computer chips". This stuff is not making people smarter. Is it is not making society better. I would be willing to bet the countries that have the populations that are most reliant on "search engines and social media sites" and "high performance computer chips" are going to have the highest rates of mental illness and other complications that arise from too much screen time, and the lowest test scores. These will be dumbed down, whacked out societies. They will have the worst quality of life. I was listening to an interview with Jonathan Kanter recently and the interviewer tried to get him to comment on Europe's approach to regulation of "Big Tech". He was hesitant to accept any comparison. But I am confident there are plenty of folks, generally _not people who comment on HN_, who are envious of the direction Europe is taking. The idea that regulating Apple and Meta, companies that exploit people commercially as they use computers, e.g., as data collection sources and ad targets, is going to contribute to cause "poverty" or deprive Europe of useful networking and computer technology, e.g., the type used for national defense, is absurd.
- dyauspitr 2y agoIt’s a short term paradise. You’re not going to be able to keep it that way when the rest of the world is more technologically advanced and you slip into poverty.
- m3kw9 2y agoEurope is very afraid, too much protectionism for the people. It will solve itself when it most definitely back fires in the form of the actual harm showing up because of it
- dash2 2y ago[flagged]
- pmlnr 2y agoGood. Tech needs to slow down; neither society has caught up, nor quality controls.
- ripped_britches 2y agoI think it should be remembered that the personalized ads are not just valuable for ad platforms - most of the personalization value actually accrues to advertisers themselves, who basically represent the entire economy. EU regulators think their enemy is big American tech companies, but they are hurting their domestic advertisers and domestic economies even more. I am saying this as someone who hates seeing ads and uses adblock, but I greatly appreciate the societal value. We should be making laws that foster competition and safety. I struggle to see how cross-site tracking and personalized advertising by itself is anti-competitive or unsafe. The bigger issues that need to be solved on these platforms are gatekeeper monopolies, social division, and mental health.
- QuietWatchtower 2y agoWith ads there is incentive for tech companies to harvest more and more data points for advertisers to use their magic orbs to find out whether you like Diet Coke or Diet Pepsi more. This in turn leads to powerful and concerning levels of understanding of a certain individuals personality and worse, behavior, that allows them to exploit those flaws in your personality, or exploit your emotion more than a billboard ever could. On top of this, it creates an unregulated sky-is-the-limit 3rd party economy of data brokers who will sell these bulk collections of data to whoever coughs up the money for it. Enter in governmental intelligence agencies, there now is a concern of governments either sidestepping laws on lawful intelligence collection or outright breaking them, as the NSA and FBI have already admitted too if I recall correctly. Edit: I'd also like to say, can you imagine how the intelligence agencies would pressure their legislators during attempts of reforming data brokers? "You can't take this away! We stopped this attack from happening with this! If you take this away, you'll cause 9/11 2.0!" That's exactly what they did for the FISA re-authorization this year in the US.
- Moldoteck 2y agoRegardless, personalized ads are evil and should be banned at least for granular types. People will survive with less personalized ads but we'll avoid a lot of problems by ditching them
- bigbacaloa 2y ago[dead]
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y agoWorks where archive.ph is blocked: x=https://foreignpolicy.com/2024/07/26/europe-tech-regulation-apple-meta-google-competition/ tnftp -4o"|(echo '<meta charset=utf-8>';grep -o '<p>.*</p>')" $x > 1.htm firefox ./1.htm links -force-html 1.htm or links $x It's interesting to me how the article looks great in a browser that does not auto-load resources or process CSS. But in a so-called "modern" browser, the kind worshipped by developers, the annoyance is so bad, the article is so difficult to read, that the forum moderator directs readers to use a different website. Others might not find it interesting but I do.
- hcfman 2y agoIt’s all European regulation really. The cyber resilience security act is another example. You are compelled to come out with security fixes for the life of the product. If this is embedded hardware this gets increasingly difficult. Imagine you come out with a secure boot product for the pi. Currently this is considered beta at the moment. In any case it’s quite possible that it could change, making it impossible to provide an update. So under this regulation do you think anyone will offer any extended warranties ? The small amount of extra money will not be worth the massive extra risk. 15 million euros fine or 2% of your income doesn’t make for a very attractive incentive on platforms where it’s complex and risky to perform low level upgrades for example. So expect increasingly shorter product lifetimes going forward and more and more products that just won’t be released in Europe, I expect even ones developed by European companies. And what do you think about small players who can’t even afford one court care for example ?
- kkfx 2y agoForcing global firms to leave is GOOD actually, but EU have essentially no domestic tech markets: most part of the ruling elite have no idea about IT and while they have made many wise choice in theory (eIDAS, e-billings, certified signed emails and so on) the implementation is obscene and mostly done on the shoulders of non-EU firms by not really competent local developers and the result is a practical MESS. All other the EU we almost have smart-card nfc IDs but using them is a pain because of crappy proprietary middlewaren and crapplications even more crappy on top, with public services designed by some mentally ill child with a keyboard. We have public accurate maps of the territory and no unified public way to access them, there is no public common conferencing decentralized/federated infra, some public body offer Big Blue Button or Jitsi meet based infra, others choose some USA private firm. Public money, public code is told everywhere but only told in most of the cases. The sole way we can fill the gap is MANDATE FLOSS, publicly funding existing FLOSS projects and offering them all the infra through public universities and research bodies to create an EU-FLOSS ecosystem because that's the future we need, where once spread everywhere (desktops, smartphones, cars, domestic IoT etc) will allow private sector to pick and evolve individual ideas. This is the European way and we know it works, IF DONE. Unfortunately most fails to understand IT at all so it's not done, simply. As a result no digital sovereignty is possible on scale.
- yokoprime 2y agoIf your company requires removing privacy laws and measures to stifle anti-competitive behavior, then by all means leave. I don’t want to live in a technological dystopia just to be “cutting edge”
- zelphirkalt 2y agoIf there is one thing we need to be afraid of, it is, that we don't regulate tech giants enough. That they can continue to exploit people. Maybe also, that GDPR continues to be violated by 90% of companies, because they think they will get away with it.
- Caius-Cosades 2y agoIt's not like europe has any viable economic future left anyways. They've regulated, taxed and sanctioned their own industries out of existence and tourism is an excessively poor substitute economically. Good luck having high-tech industry or market without domestic support for it. Pretty much only thing Europe is consistently producing nowadays is new legislations (EU and national, which are enforced incoherently and at the times contradictory)
- graemep 2y agoThe entire article keeps saying "Europe" when it means "EU". Many European countries, including some large ones (Russia, the UK, Norway, Switzerland, Ukraine...) are not EU members. The article makes a number of questionable assertions such as "Non-personalized ads cannot economically sustain Meta’s services". I do not know whether that is true or not. Apple has a history of malicious so. I think there are multiple reasons the US dominates tech, and I do not believe "the EU’s rules all but ensure there are no comparably successful European companies". There are many successful European tech companies, as the article mentions later on (it links to a list of the largest that is clearly out of date - for example that omits ARM). I also disagree with its analysis of why. If you look at their list of large tech companies, and there are a lot of Chinese ones which largely exist because China was protectionist and favoured domestic over US companies. I would argue, if anything, the EU (and other European companies) have not regulated American companies enough, to produce their own competitors. In particular they rarely block takeovers by established players of potential future competitors. I agree the EU's approach to regulation is often badly flawed, but the DMA seems to be a reasonable approach - as other comments have said it only targets businesses with a lot of market power.
- tdiff 2y agoI think that people outside EU who believe it does not need big tech may be unaware that average salary in EU IT is around 80k, and actually a lot of people (not only IT, but also doctors, for instance) relocate to US/UK/Swiss hoping to make much more money. Its not clear who will be running innovative companies here and how EU is going to compete with China's completely different work ethics.
- GreenWatermelon 2y agoBig tech didn't create linux or git. Big tech isn't working on Firefox or Kagi. Big tech created windows, chrome, and ads. Big tech puts ads in everything, everywhere, all the time. I'd say big tech going away is a good thing. We need more linixes, firefoxes, wnd Kagis.
- niemandhier 2y agoBefore you can innovate you need to level the playing field. Sure at the moment the amount of inner European Innovation in digital technologies is low, but local companies have to fight against foreign behemoths that simply disregard local regulations, or just buy the likes of Luxemburg or Ireland to get their own special law zones inside the single market. Let the big US companies leave, the vacuum left behind will foster competition and local solutions.
- CommanderData 2y ago1. Pay to play (tax) 2. Comply to play (regulation) These are big markets with massive winnings even with regulation and tax. Corps can either step aside and let someone else profit or comply and play.
- quitit 2y agoThe most telling feature of the DMA is that it doesn't include Spotify. Spotify would not be compliant under the DMA for the same reason why the EU has charged Meta with non-compliance: >Under Article 5(2) of the DMA, gatekeepers must seek users’ consent for combining their personal data between designated core platform services and other services, and if a user refuses such consent, they should have access to a less personalised but equivalent alternative. Gatekeepers cannot make use of the service or certain functionalities conditional on users’ consent. - Source: EC statement¹ However the EU doesn't deem there to be any gatekeepers for music.² YouTube has over 80 million music subscribers. To avoid this obvious conflict they label "YouTube" as a video sharing site, deliberately ignoring one of the largest drivers of youtube traffic is music videos. Something which Google themselves advertise.³ If the EU cared about privacy and user harm they'd make the DMA protections apply to every business, not just big foreign ones. Spotify's ads website actually brags about how it targets and tracks users and the various 3rd party data companies they partner with to extend that beyond Spotify.⁴ It's clear as day that the EU doesn't care about user harm or privacy, they just want that money for themselves. A view that is buttressed by what they're trying to do to encrypted chat communications. ¹ https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_24_3582 https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_24_... ² https://digital-markets-act.ec.europa.eu/gatekeepers_en https://digital-markets-act.ec.europa.eu/gatekeepers_en ³ https://www.youtube.com/trends/records/ https://www.youtube.com/trends/records/ ⁴ https://ads.spotify.com/en-US/goals/audience-targeting/ https://ads.spotify.com/en-US/goals/audience-targeting/ https://ads.spotify.com/en-US/partner-directory/ https://ads.spotify.com/en-US/partner-directory/
- aurareturn 2y agoI thought it was common knowledge that EU regulations target big foreign companies while ignoring big domestic ones? If they truly cared about monopolies/duopolies, they'd target LVMH, Luxottica.
- quitit 2y agoI note this because they're constantly lying that their goals are for the protection of users, when their actions send a different message. Here's the direct Twitter quote from Thierry Breton regarding the charge against Meta: The #DMA is here to give back users the power to decide over their #data #Meta has forced millions of users across EU into a binary choice : “pay or consent”. In our preliminary conclusion this is a breach of the DMA. Today we take an important step to ensure Meta complies. https://x.com/ThierryBreton/status/1807715743129043342 https://x.com/ThierryBreton/status/1807715743129043342 Meanwhile Spotify, all data brokers and any other non-DMA'd companies can take and exchange private user data. I believe the rule should apply to all companies because I don't see the point of "protecting" users from a handful of companies when that is a drop in the ocean of data collectors. He also makes strange bed fellows, such as frequently advocating for Fortnite, the game title which the FTC found to be deliberately tricking children into unwanted purchases, then killing their Fornite accounts in retaliation should they obtain a refund.¹ https://x.com/ThierryBreton/status/1766167580497117464 https://x.com/ThierryBreton/status/1766167580497117464 ¹ https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2023/03/ftc-finalizes-order-requiring-fortnite-maker-epic-games-pay-245-million-tricking-users-making https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2023/03/... Note this fine is finalised because Epic didn't challenge the FTC's claims.
- hepinhei 2y agoThe article seems unfounded to me. We need regulation because companies are gaining more power, money, and data. Social networks are shaping entire societies to behave in different ways. Android is able to comply with these rules when implementing AI why not Apple? Late? Poor implementation? . However, I hope that movements like this will push the EU to create conditions and finance channels to enable competition in the tech space. I agree that Europe is lagging more and more behind, but Apple not releasing their products here is not the problem. Not having big tech companies is the problem
- xtiansimon 2y agoInteresting they start the article using Apple. *In general* Apple has(had?) a reputation for creating smart and useful products which work in surprisingly simple and convenient ways. Apple is dogmatic (and aggressive), but the goal has been _something great_. Drawn into the article, you ask yourself--Why is the EU handcuffing Apple? The article wouldn't have the same momentum if you started with, say, Facebook. The rules described are perverse (ex. Twitter/X's blue checkbox). The imagined outcome is a shocking lack of products which people enjoy freely elsewhere in the world. Then I started thinking of this through the lens of B2B SaaS software I use in small business every day. The outside of the box makes promises. Sales reps make promises. Demos abound. Contracts are signed. Setup fees are paid. Setup manhours are invested. And then you start using these services and products. Support issues go unresolved--not supported at this time--and go on the 'wish list' void. What you thought of as a solution to your business needs turns to questions of sunk cost. Total frustration resulting from the obviously profit seeking economizing decisions not described on the box--devil is in the details. Who is the more naive? Businesses for having purchased these products or the companies who develop and market them as industry solutions (vs. just another product with hidden cost-benefit determinations)? Now think of the B2C environment the article is talking about where there are known deceptive practices working to profit on user's personal privacy. I have to laugh. Seems fitting to read about naive regulation against the decisions of manufacturers and developers making abhorrent conditions in the consumer market. I see the same frustrated naive decisions of business owners trying to get out of contracts for bad products and services they have chosen.
- ein0p 2y agoI wonder if Silicon Valley lobbyists are deliberately sabotaging the Eurozone regulatory environment. Technically there’s no reason why almost all huge Western tech companies have to be located in the US. European cost of labor in this space is much lower, and access to markets is much better, since they’re on the same continent. Their ineptitude in high tech can’t be coincidental
- udev4096 2y agoI find this extremely misleading. It's not surprising, given the average american publication is not aware of the fact that the "big tech" relies on so many obscure open source software from all around the world
- bestnameever 2y agoWhat does one have to do with the other?
- lincon127 2y agoIf only
- Log_out_ 2y agoActually if europe builds tech working well and delivering within regulations and the us sink into ccc capitalism caused civilunrest,europas overregulated tech may be the last man standing and the one trusted by the world for stability.
- account42 2y agoI would hope that the EU regulates a silicon-valley style tech market out of existence. That the US is more than happy to let their megacorporations go wild as long as it benefits their economy doesn't mean that others need to do do the same.
- Log_out_ 2y agoI used to not understand these aggressive "everything else is shit" articles, as in whats the value proposition for the audience.horra patriotism is not in the market dor analysis. Nowadays i understand better, these articles is the closest thing the us has to systemic self-doubt for deciders.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- silexia 2y agoI have noticed all the comments on HN now are pro socialist and pro regulation. I remember a time when they were mostly pro libertarian. What changed? Are these AI generated comments to push a specific viewpoint?