52 ms·
‘Breakthrough’ obesity drugs that have stunned researchers
- Tagbert 4y agoThat looks like a “one weird trick” headline.
- ceejayoz 4y agoSo do quite a few medical advances. "Cure any infection with this moldy bread!" "Don't want polio? Inject some polio!"
- gnicholas 4y ago> After decades of work, researchers are finally seeing signs of success: a new generation of anti-obesity medications that drastically diminish weight without the serious side effects that have plagued previous efforts. … > Nutter is concerned that people might start these treatments — whose side effects, such as nausea and vomiting, can be severe — to escape weight stigma, rather than to serve a true health need So the side effects aren’t “serious” — they’re just potentially “severe”? I’m confused.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ceejayoz 4y agoThey're substantially less severe (and reversible, and more controllable) than the "your heart might stop" ones of the past generation of weight loss meds. (For example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fenfluramine/phentermine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fenfluramine/phentermine)
- Izkata 4y agoLeaking medical jargon and mixing it with regular usage: "serious" means needing medical attention, "severe" means hospitalization/long-term disability or worse. They seem to be using medical "serious" and colloquial "severe", which gives the the appearance of reversing their meanings.
- derefr 4y agoSubtly different subjects to those two sentences: the former is talking about the new generation of medications (i.e. the general concept of medications targeting this new receptor); while the latter is talking about one specific treatment (i.e. one specific medication, at one specific dosage, via one specific route of administration, at one specific interval.) The side-effects of this particular treatment "can be severe", but that doesn't imply anything about the side-effects of any other treatment (combination of medication, dose, RoA, and interval) for drugs in this class. Heck, they could probably fix the nausea/vomiting just by making a pill that contains an adjunct anti-emetic like ondansetron, like they do for cancer drugs.
- gumby 4y ago> to escape weight stigma, rather than to serve a true health need This is an unfair framing by the researchers For a while I worked in pharma on a drug program for a harmless* "ailment", nail fungus. What I learned is that some people suffer serious psychological consequences, such as marital issues or avoiding situations where they might be barefoot, like the beach. People who have it in their hands may avoid social situations all together, which is even worse and reduces life expectancy. We have a natural cultural bias in this regard. It's not just the phantom of the opera: in films the hero usually has a clear complexion and the villain often does not (not always to the extent of Darth Vader of course). Now we understand more about disease etiology this bias is no longer helpful, and is in fact destructive. Losing weight addresses true health needs (increased rates of cancer, cardiac issues etc) but weight stigma has important side effects as well. * The various fungi that attack skin, scalp, nails etc eat a particular shape of squalene which some people make (referred to unfairly in the medical literature as a "squalene defect"). You're not going to catch it from another person -- there's a good chance you're breathing the spores right now. Either you're genetically predisposed or you're not. And all it does is munch on a tiny amount of your body and causes no other problem.
- jobs_throwaway 4y ago> The results astonished researchers: a weekly injection for almost 16 months, along with some lifestyle changes, reduced body weight by at least 20% in more than one-third of the participants Why would they introduce lifestyle changes alongside the drug? Doesn't that complicate the analysis?
- carbocation 4y agoProbably assigned both arms to lifestyle changes, since we know those are beneficial. Assuming that's the case, then yes to your point, but also it's the right thing to do since there is no equipoise about lifestyle.
- ceejayoz 4y agoThe control group will have been asked to make the same lifestyle changes, but with a placebo drug. https://www.nejm.org/doi/10.1056/NEJMoa2032183 https://www.nejm.org/doi/10.1056/NEJMoa2032183 > Participants were randomly assigned in a 2:1 ratio, through the use of an interactive Web-based response system, to receive semaglutide at a dose of 2.4 mg administered subcutaneously once a week for 68 weeks or matching placebo, in addition to lifestyle intervention...
- Tade0 4y agoI suppose it actually makes it simpler, because you control for lifestyle changes. Who says some participants wouldn't just start eating trash? I know I did after I lost some weight due to a bad case of something my child brought in from daycare.
- djur 4y agoOne of the expected benefits of the medication is to make it easier to comply with recommended lifestyle changes. It simplifies the analysis to recommend a specific set of changes rather than letting all of the participants improvise their own diet and exercise changes.
- jobs_throwaway 4y agoJesus christ, why is nature quoting a psychologist in an article about biology? > However, some researchers worry that these drugs play into some societies’ obsession with being thin. Body size isn’t always a good predictor of health. “I’m really hesitant to be excited about something that I think is potentially harmful from a weight stigma perspective”
- ethanbond 4y agoBecause this isn't an article about biology, it's about health, and health isn't unidimensional
- boxed 4y ago[flagged]
- jobs_throwaway 4y agoHelping obese people lose weight is unidimensionally a good thing
- ceejayoz 4y agoVery little in health is unidimensional. Suppose, for example, the presence of an effective weight loss treatment caused an increase in suicide rate in those who fail to benefit from the drug or can't access it for some reason?
- starkd 4y agoThat's an important consequence to consider. One that often gets omitted. Many drugs - like blood pressure drugs - often have depression as a side effect but it gets overlooked.
- spoiler 4y agoMy mother recently started taking these, and she doesn't have a very great mental health history to begin with. Do you have more information on this, and/or if this can somehow be mitigated?
- Izkata 4y ago> They described the details of an investigation of a promising anti-obesity medication in teenagers, a group that is notoriously resistant to such treatment. The results astonished researchers: a weekly injection for almost 16 months, along with some lifestyle changes, reduced body weight by at least 20% in more than one-third of the participants1. Previous studies2,3 had shown that the drug, semaglutide, was just as impressive in adults. Two immediate thoughts: How much of it was actually the lifestyle changes? It would be more interesting if there were no lifestyle changes... This apparently works by suppressing appetite, but doesn't cocaine do the same thing? Constant needle marks from weekly injections might result in more social complications than anything else...
- ceejayoz 4y ago> How much of it was actually the lifestyle changes? That's why the placebo group in the trial also gets the same lifestyle changes. > This apparently works by suppressing appetite, but doesn't cocaine do the same thing? Sure. If they were otherwise identical, that'd be a good point, but they're not. > Constant needle marks from weekly injections might result in more social complications than anything else... My daughter has to give herself growth hormone injections every day, and has for nearly a decade now. You don't get needle marks from these sorts of small dosage subcutaneous injection.
- Izkata 4y ago> You don't get needle marks from these sorts of small dosage subcutaneous injection. Ah, my only experience is with things like vaccines and drawing blood; those marks last around a week on me.
- ceejayoz 4y agoYeah, it's very different; vaccinations are generally much deeper (into muscle), and drawing blood punctures a vein causing leakage into the surrounding tissue. Daily injections can leave a little under-the-skin scarring (feels a little like cellulite) so you have to vary the site a bit, but for most folks that's the worst of it. Well worth it for these sorts of results.
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoHave we actually studied if the weight loss is resulting in better health outcomes for the people in question? Outside of diabetics (there is evidence that significant weight loss can relieve the effects of type 2 diabetes), I would like to know if just weight loss benefits the cardiovascular system, blood pressure, etc. These aren't as intuitive as we'd like, for example, it turns out that low fat diets didn't make people less fat, and cholesterol-lowering medication doesn't reduce heart disease. I'm hesitant to measure weight loss as a pure good in of itself because it isn't evident to me that just losing weight has a causative effect on reducing specific diseases.
- ceejayoz 4y agoMy wife lost a hundred pounds via bariatric surgery; resting heart rate dropped by 20, cholesterol dropped into normal range, knee and hip pain disappeared, and it even helped the chronic migraine substantially. We've got plenty of clear evidence that being significantly overweight has health impacts.
- mattbrewsbytes 4y agoYup. On a much lesser note, when I lost 10lbs I noticed acid reflux symptoms disappear and blood pressure was lowered. For someone that is borderline on need of medication, the doc basically said lose some weight and these issues could go away (for some time). Its incentive enough for me to keep losing so I can push off the major diseases until much later in life or never.
- nscalf 4y agoYeah, there are a lot of published studies showing this is very impactful. Within certain thresholds, losing weight has been shown to be the biggest change to all cause mortality rates. If you are obese, the most impactful thing on health is losing weight. This obviously isn't true for people with very low BMIs, but there have been a lot of population level studies looking at all cause mortality.
- PuppyTailWags 4y ago
- iammjm 4y agoAt a risk of being ignorant: Isn’t obesity a function of calories intake and calories burn rate? If so, why do we even need a drug for that? What should a possible drug target here? Assuming no changes in behaviour and thus a continued steady daily caloric surplus, would it even work?
- ceejayoz 4y ago> Isn’t obesity a function of calories intake and calories burn rate? If so, why do we even need a drug for that? Because calorie intake is substantially impacted by things like satiety. As the article's subtitle heavily hints at, "A class of drugs that quash hunger" is beneficial in moving that bit of the equation.
- iammjm 4y agoI understand, but appetite/hunger seems to be just a part of the issue. The second part being people (myself included) using food to comfort ourselves. I feel bad -> I seek tasty food to comfort myself, even if I am not hungry. The whole candy-market is built around. How are drugs to address this?
- ceejayoz 4y agoOne drug can't address every situation. You might add in an anti-depressant for this aspect, or some sort of behavioral therapy. Consider, though, that quite a few obese people "feel bad" at least in part because of the health and social impacts of their weight.
- djur 4y agoOne effect of these drugs appears to be weakening that "comfort -> food" urge. There's some evidence that it also affects similar urges for alcohol.
- starkd 4y agoBy using drugs that manipulate specific hormones to alter a person's appetite. So you consume less calories.
- 0xB31B1B 4y agoI’m currently taking one of these drugs and it has been no less than a miracle in my life. I became obese when I was around 5, topping out around a 34 BMI. When I was 20 I lost a substantial amount of weight the old fashioned way (diet and exercise), and within 8 months I was BMI 23. Losing weight was extremely challenging and socially isolating. 7 years later, I had a bad ankle injury and regained weight to about 29 BMI. This time I lost weight by doing an “eat every other day” diet. This was also extremely challenging, but easier than just counting calories and working out. After Covid and a lack of exercise I was back to BMI 30. I started taking tirzeparide this summer and have gone from BMI 31 to BMI 26 and still dropping. This is by far the easiest way to lose weight. The side effects for the first 3 months are quite bad, and include off and on strong nausea, extreme fatigue, brain fog, and constipation. I was eating <1k calories per day for a long time and feeling full. I expect to be on this drug long term. My blood work shows extreme improvements in cholesterol, BP, and other key health indicators. I believe that everyone, even the skinny folks, should be on GLP1 drugs for the longevity effects. They changed they induce in diet reduce the oxidative stress on the human body, even if the person is already thin.
- djur 4y agoHow was the process with insurance? About a year ago I tried to get on semaglutide and my insurer shut down every option. It was extremely demoralizing.
- drchickensalad 4y agoWhat's the drug?
- gadders 4y ago"The WHO recommends healthier diets and physical activity to reduce obesity, but medication might help when lifestyle changes aren’t enough. The new drugs mimic hormones known as incretins, which lower blood sugar and curb appetite." Isn't eating less food (whether your appetite is curbed or not) a lifestyle change? It's not that lifestyle changes aren't enough. It's that the size of your change wasn't big enough.
- ceejayoz 4y ago> It's not that lifestyle changes aren't enough. It's that the size of your change wasn't big enough. Sure, and one of the things we conclusively know about obesity is that people struggle enormously to sustain that sort of lifestyle change in the long term. Hence, medications that help with that. In this case, by reducing hunger.
- gadders 4y agoYeah. It would probably be more accurate to say that the medicine makes the lifestyle change easier, not that it replaces the lifestyle change.
- Communitivity 4y agoI think it's awesome that there's a new use for these drugs. However, obesity kills slowly, when it kills. Diabetes and Chronic Kidney Disease kill more quickly if not under control. These drugs keep diabetes under control..and diabetics like my wife are unable to get their meds because people are buying these off the shelf to lose weight. I don't pretend to know the solution, but I do think drug availability should be prioritized to those who need it the most, not those who can pay the most (the weight loss brand of the same drug is being marketed for 2x-5x the cost of the diabetic brand, or so I've been told).
- pjc50 4y agoI note the reverse applies: my dad was prescribed Metformin for diabetes, and began to lose weight at a significant rate to the point where it became unhealthy. > the weight loss brand of the same drug is being marketed for 2x-5x the cost of the diabetic brand, or so I've been told Drug pricing is a hell of a drug.
- jboy55 4y ago> Diabetes and Chronic Kidney Disease kill more quickly if not under control. These drugs keep diabetes under control..and diabetics like my wife are unable to get their meds because people are buying these off the shelf to lose weight. This seems to be a short term problem, and the solution is to simply make more of the drug to match demand.
- charlieflowers 4y ago> and the solution is to simply make more of the drug to match demand which unfortunately might not align with the incentives of capitalism.
- jboy55 4y agoIf "Capitalism" involved the conscious coordination of all industry to maximize consumption, perhaps not. But in the terms of, raise money to buy a factory, have factory produce goods, sell goods, there seems to be a huge market for these, quite expensive, goods. edit: You could even argue, in a conspiratorial mind, that by getting people addicted to sugar ($0.0002 / mg) in order to then get them addicted to a drug that costs ($10/mg) is peak "Capitalism"
- VikingCoder 4y agoI'm on semaglutide. Was on Saxenda, because I couldn't get access to Wegovy at the lowest dosage. But now I'm on Wegovy, for half a week so far. I was retching horribly one night at 2 am, but didn't throw up. I've felt clammy and dizzy a few times. (Possibly hypoglycemic?) I honestly feel like it's changing how I feel about food. I don't want to eat empty carbs, anywhere near as much. Because I feel like they make me feel sick. I'm eager to have more, smaller meals. I'm eager to have protein. I had previously done a keto diet, except maybe I wasn't really in ketosis? It was medically supervised, doing New Direction complete meal replacements. I lost a bunch of weight, but... gained it back. So now semaglutide. Dr urging surgery as a possibility. I'm eager to not do surgery. Fingers crossed for Wegovy.
- dmix 4y ago> I don't want to eat empty carbs, anywhere near as much. Because I feel like they make me feel sick. I did a keto diet obsessively for a while and I still have a psychological revulsion to drinking coke or eating cake even a year later. Those sorts of things are long term wins.
- VikingCoder 4y agoWhen I was trying to slowly increase my calories again, coming off of low-calorie keto, I definitely wanted coke and cake. I'm happy for you, but I didn't get that benefit you got.
- dmix 4y agoOh yeah, I wasn't really expecting it to be a general rule. I just built up "carbs = evil" so much in my head I developed a physical distaste for it, but I doubt most other people would.
- standardUser 4y agoI had the opposite outcome, several months of keto left me avoiding meat and cheese for a long time.
- rajin444 4y agoThis drug is a net good for society, but we have to fix the root problem. Much of the food we eat is filled with addictive ingredients (sugar, excess fats/oils, etc) that provide little nutritional value but are highly addictive. We’re subsidizing companies that create unhealthy addictive food and subsidizing companies to create drugs to counter the unhealthy addictive food. This is an enormous waste of resources.
- drjasonharrison 4y agoWhile we are drowning in quick to consume, non-nutritious, calories, we also have higher levels of anxiety, stress and more distractions. To your comment, maybe more countries should attempt to implement programs similar to the UK's success in lowering sodium intake by slowly adjusting the sodium content of all manufacturered foods. https://www.nature.com/articles/jhh2013105 https://www.nature.com/articles/jhh2013105
- WalterBright 4y ago> we also have higher levels of anxiety, stress Why should that be true? Your kids aren't going off to WW2 to die. You aren't going to starve if bugs ate your crops. You aren't going to get clubbed and robbed if you follow a forest path.
- pixl97 4y agoI would say our 'actual' stressors are far less, but our contrived stressors are far more. The fact I'm not going to die tomorrow from starvation is an actual reduction in stress. The fact that someone on the TV is screaming 24/7 that I'm going 'fucking die because THEY are out to get me' is a contrived stressor that has a real effect on everybody in society.
- Apocryphon 4y agoMaybe that's the point. A lack of overt threats leads to greater trepidation over covert threats. Wouldn't you think that there was more anxiety and stress in the Cold War among the civilian population than in WWII? Certainly societal upheavals seem to indicate so.
- twawaaay 4y agoJust making sure everybody understands that these drugs are not a solution to the problem. Assuming they work, they just make dieting easy. Look at people who successfully lost weight with diet -- studies show that almost all of them will regain most of their weight within 5 years. And the basic reason is because almost all dieting regimes are shitty, unsustainable way to live and at the end people are left tired of the diet and looking to get back to the eating habits they love and caused the problem in the first place. Also calorie restriction comes with a host of other problems. You need to provide better nutrition while on a diet -- your body still needs same things but now there is less food with which it has to be delivered. But if you got obese you probably don't know how to eat properly. Prolonged calorie restriction causes muscle wasting. You can counteract it to a certain degree for some time with exercise. Which if you are obese you probably don't know how to. Calorie restriction also typically causes basal metabolic rate drop. Which means you have to keep tightening the diet to see results. And when you are off the diet it will be extremely difficult to impossible to keep your weight. You can still cause a lot of damage to your body by snacking and eating wrong foods even if you are on calorie restricted diet. It is better to learn to not snack and keep your eating window to 4-6 hours every day rather than eat through entire day. I personally dislike meds like this. It is good it exists but I would never take them or recommend to anybody. There are a lot of medications that are supposed to help (like metformin) but all these meds do not address the main cause of the problem -- which is what you eat, how you eat and when you eat it. -- For background, I got obese once and lost weight. Then regained the weight over a decade. Being engineer and problem solver, I vowed to understand the shit out of the problem, loose the weight properly and never regain it back. Which seems to be working. Understanding how to loose weight allowed me to do fantastic things like loose weight at 3 times the rate I did it previously while not feeling hungry or cold. The previous time I was on calorie restricted diet loosing and I was completely miserable for almost entire year, cold, slow, irritated, unable to focus. This time I completed the same weight loss in 4 months while actually feeling better than ever (at least most of the time). Most important for me, it is not interfering with my work. I am also not taking any meds. I am not preaching any diets here. I am just suggesting that if you are feeling hungry throughout your diet you are probably doing something wrong and it would be worth the while to understand what and how to fix it. And the only way this happens is if you get interested. No drug is going to magically fix it for you.
- sfusato 4y ago> I believe that everyone, even the skinny folks, should be on GLP1 drugs for the longevity effects. Are you for real? Serious question.
- 0xB31B1B 4y agoI mean, if you have perfect bloodwork and a marvel movie body probably not necessary but otherwise yes. Heart disease, hypertension, high cholesterol, colon cancer rates are rising amongst everyone, even thin people. These drugs positively impact indicators of these things in everyone. Longevity makers have been betting on metformin for a long time and these drugs are like a supercharged metformin
- throwaway5959 4y agoAre they rising across the board or for certain ranges of BMI/weight?
- 0xB31B1B 4y agoAcross the board
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mcculley 4y agoI think I will wait for some version that does not cause "strong nausea, extreme fatigue, brain fog, and constipation".
- jboy55 4y agoI take a GLP-1, I do not feel any of these effects unless I eat poorly. I'm not saying these side-effects don't happen, but they aren't guaranteed. Testing has also shown these aren't prevalent in the majority of users.
- Beaver117 4y agoSo does this somehow burn fat or does it just lower your appetite? There are many others drugs that lower appetite, and yet we still have an obesity crisis. Why would this one solve it?
- ceejayoz 4y ago> So does this somehow burn fat or does it just lower your appetite? The article's subheadline is "A class of drugs that quash hunger". > There are many others drugs that lower appetite Not this well and/or not this safely.
- EamonnMR 4y agoDoctors are reluctant to prescribe stimulants to their patients for various reasons. Also you don't keep the weight off with those.
- contravariant 4y agoYou don't necessarily need a stimulant, you can also e.g. short the mitochondria using DNP. Doing so does have some fairly predictable downsides.
- EamonnMR 4y agoHa! This made me think of DNP too-the rare drug that modifies the O of CICO. But you can't beat thermodynamics.
- acuozzo 4y ago> There are many others drugs that lower appetite, and yet we still have an obesity crisis. Which ones are prescribed in the US, on label, to treat obesity?
- jboy55 4y agoThere is only one class of drugs that lowers appetite outside of these GLP hormone drugs, those are stimulants like amphetamines. As someone on one of the GLP drugs for 3-4 months, and whose body tolerates it well, this is simply turning off the hunger switch. I will miss meals because I'm not hungry, since starting I have never felt "hangry" and I am satiated with small meals and do not feel hungry later. If I overeat, I will feel nauseous and sick. I do not feel wired, foggy or feel like my personality or sleep cycle has been affected in the slightest.
- curation 4y agoObesity drugs treat a North American symptom - obesity. The cause remains untreated.
- partiallypro 4y agoObesity is now a global problem; I don't know why people view this as US centric.
- nextlevelwizard 4y agoIt will help millions of people in life changing ways. Of course we should also fix the causes, but that is no reason not to pursue easier treatment
- glonq 4y agoI lost 100 pounds "the hard way" (diet and exercise) a couple years ago. Gained back 30 and am fighting to burn that off again. It would be nice to have an affordable, low dose of one of these obesity drugs to make the fight a bit easier.
- dang 4y agoRecent and related: The FDA will likely approve the diabetes drug tirzepatide for weight loss - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34220996 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34220996 - Jan 2023 (100 comments) Tirzepatide delivered up to 22.5% weight loss in obese or overweight adults - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33221121 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33221121 - Oct 2022 (21 comments)
- LarryMullins 4y agoWhy does this headline from Nature read like a scam advert from Facebook?
- tptacek 4y agoBecause what's happening in this field is bananas right now, to the point where the results sound like scam adverts from Facebook.
- nindalf 4y agoBecause sometimes you’re dealing with the real article. This isn’t a boner pill made of rhino horn. This has been proven in double blind studies, FDA approved and has changed the lives of thousands of people. This could potentially halt the obesity epidemic, preventing many early deaths and improving the quality of life of countless others. At that point, such headlines are justified. What would you have written instead? Something lukewarm like “Obesity drugs show efficacy in many patients”?
- LarryMullins 4y agoI'm sure it's possible to formulate a headline for this story that doesn't sound like gutter-tier clickbait. Nature must be doing a poor job hiring / directing their editors.
- tptacek 4y agoToo much of this thread is debating whether these drugs are a good thing or a bad thing, and not enough is on the underlying science story, which is what HN "should" be interested in. What's happening with these drugs --- that you can replicate much of the effect of bariatric surgery with an injection --- is super interesting, and didn't seem to be on the horizon 10 years ago.
- nindalf 4y agoAgreed. I don’t think I’ll ever need these pills but I think in ten years we’ll think they’re the second most impactful thing to happen last year.
- makeworld 4y agoRelated: https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/semaglutidonomics https://astralcodexten.substack.com/p/semaglutidonomics
- psychphysic 4y agoYou really need to suppress appetite rather than avoid hunger. How many have of us have eaten despite not being hungry?
- tptacek 4y agoThat's what these drugs do.
- psychphysic 4y agoYou're probably right the common side effects are all reason to not eat (nausea, GI upset).
- tptacek 4y agoThe other effects (they're not a side effects, since they're the intended effects) are satiety and cessation of cravings. In the "appetite vs. hunger" dichotomy you set up, the drugs seem to be addressing mostly the former; in fact, it sounds like, from reports on this thread, pts on these meds very much still experience true hunger symptoms (weakness, headache, brain fog).
- psychphysic 4y agoIn the UK at least semiglutide is licensed only for diabetes. So it's appetite suppression is a side effect. That's good because it means it gets reported. Looking at the SPC[0] we can see decreased appetite is "common" (1~10%), while nausea is "very common"(>10% report). That means more people feel nauseated on semiglutide than feel less hungry. Add in other GI disturbances (diarrhoea is also "very common") and one can see why people lose weight with it. [0] https://www.medicines.org.uk/emc/product/9750/smpc https://www.medicines.org.uk/emc/product/9750/smpc
- nostrebored 4y agoVery weird to take a country that hasn’t kept pace with research here and use it as representative, especially with a sample of patients with chronic disease. Having been on semaglutide, it both makes you feel full with smaller portions and changes what you want to eat. The foods which make you feel nauseous are those that make you gain weight. However the change in desire isn’t only against foods which make you feel nauseous, but also towards foods that you might not eat. It’s truly very interesting.
- bitwize 4y agoWhy use drugs and lifestyle changes when lifestyle changes alone will do the trick? Everybody knows you're not a real Hackernews until you adopt a cold, calculating, "food is fuel" mentality toward eating, with extensive data collection, strict timing, data-driven portion control, and long fasting periods. Once you do that you don't need the drugs and can tell Big Pharma where to shove it.
- UI_at_80x24 4y agoLifestyle change alone is NOT all it takes. I've been fat all of my life, so has everybody in the last 3 generations of genetic contributors. I can easily drop 20-40lbs if I cut sugar out of my diet. Then it stops. I've cycled 15miles/day for 7 years (on non-snowy days). During that time I went on a water-only fast, (7days on, eat one day, then 14days eat one day, then 7 days more of fasting before I stopped.) I lost 13 lbs during that period. I was doing a keto diet before and after this period. I was killing myself trying to have a high energy output with minimal caloric intake. In the end, winter came and I stopped. Total weight loss during that time: 35lbs. There is no way I can lose the extra 160lbs that I need to drop. My body just won't drop it. I'm diabetic now. I take metformin and invokana. As of today I'm down almost 30lbs since august. Lifestyle changes maybe enough for you. That's awesome, good for you. Don't make blanket assumptions and think that they are true.
- donkarma 4y ago[dead]
- mensetmanusman 4y agoAnother option is to not sit at all, all day.
- obiefernandez 4y agoAnyone know offhand if these drugs are easily available in Mexico? Having a hard time googling the answer
- RedditKon 4y agoOzempic is widely available in Mexico (without prescription) and Canada (with prescription). It’s also available throughout Europe. Mounjaro is not widely available outside the US yet.
- thejackgoode 4y agoHow many of obesity cases are caused by eating disorders and addiction psyche in general? Treating the symptom in this case barely helps. You might lose weight, but it'll pop up in some other place in your life. See it as psychological side effect, a swap of coping mechanism. Often enough, IMO you need to go deeper than a pill.
- nextlevelwizard 4y agoThats such bullshit. Sure, yes, there is 100% mental aspect to every obese person, but some of that shit is old and already dealt with, but since you are already fucked you cant get out from the cycle. Of course we should deal with the mental side but it will be a million times easier to deal with after you aren’t a fat fuck.
- thejackgoode 4y agoCase in point, "fat fuck" and "old shit that's dealt with" shouldn't normally belong to the same argument
- nextlevelwizard 4y agoAnd why not?
- thejackgoode 4y agoFor one, it's a value judgement, and the mind that makes it more often than not applies the same judgements to oneself, leading to feelings that not everyone can convert to constructive action. Hence avoidance by addictions, one of which can be food. Also it implies disrespect and ignorance of the reasons why someone eats more than is considered healthy. It's a mockery of a person's perceived failure to adapt to abstract adversity. And someone who had psychological issues with addiction and dealt with them would be very unlikely to mock these things.
- 4y ago
- bioemerl 4y ago> In the past, scientists and the public often thought that those with obesity simply lacked the willpower to lose weight. But evidence is growing that most people’s bodies have a natural size that can be hard to change. In the context where we have gone from obesity rates of 13 percent to 40, to suggest that people have a natural weight and that's the cause of this seems absurd to me.
- viro 4y agoAnd it makes more logical sense to you that everyone is just weak-willed?
- nathas 4y agoHow many times do you check HN each day instead of doing work?
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoThat's bizarre. Should I be bending my will to exclusively work? I work better with breaks, that's not weakness, that's realism.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bioemerl 4y agoIt makes more sense to point to the fact that we have a far more calorie dense meal palette and a far less active lifestyle.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Cupertino95014 4y ago> “I’m really hesitant to be excited about something that I think is potentially harmful from a weight stigma perspective,” says Sarah Nutter, a psychologist at the University of Victoria in Canada, who specializes in weight stigma and body image. Putting the word "stigma" on things is a sure sign of a grifter. Instead of helping solve it, they're trying to make it a social science problem. Being overweight is unhealthy. There's no serious dispute about that. So people recognizing that fact is "stigma?"
- partiallypro 4y agoThe new idea (mostly in the West) that being obese is/can be a healthy lifestyle is absolutely maddening. People being obese (and I don't mean a few pounds overweight) raises everyone's healthcare cost, because it is incredibly unhealthy and obese people tend to have more complications which requires more treatment, workers and subsidizing. It's not just an individual problem, it's a societal problem. There's a new "Gatorade Fit" commercial with, easily, a 300lb woman in it...the brand is literally "Fit," being 300lbs is not fit in any way shape or form. Why is this happening? Even when/if I'm 10-20lbs overweight, I don't want someone patting me on the back saying I'm actually "fit" or anything close to it. It's such a weird lie that makes it feel like I'm living in a bizzarro world.
- oneoff786 4y agoIs the woman being shown as fit? Or as someone who would like the product with a goal to become more fit?
- notinfuriated 4y agoShe is wearing fitness clothing and doing what appears to be yoga. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cPgOCWbqjgo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cPgOCWbqjgo Advertisements used to be aspirational. They either still are and people's aspirations have changed, or they are not and there's some other more current explanation for why this ad and others act as a mirror showing a person who they already are (fat) rather than who they aspire to be (not fat). Said another way, there's nothing explicitly stating that the woman has a goal of becoming thinner. She is shown as well as two other thinner people. They're all doing their own form of exercising while clothed in activewear. The implication could be that the fat woman's goal is to become less fat or that she is comfortable as she is and fits in as part of Team Gatorade™. I suspect the message they're trying to convey is the latter.
- partiallypro 4y agoI'm not obese, but am not what I'd consider at my ideal weight. I wonder how/if doctors would even prescribe this to someone like me. I think I've read some Hollywood types are using this to lose weight, but those are edge cases. I imagine for normal people this would not be easy to get prescribed.
- happyopossum 4y agoPrevious GLP-1 meds are generally not prescribed if you have below a 30 BMI
- bedast 4y agoFDA approves these for use in most people above 30 BMI. Some people may be considered for it at 28 BMI. If you're looking for last mile weight loss, this may not actually be worth it. The side effects, especially getting started, can be really rough.
- haywood 4y agoThis is good news (probably?), but wanted to chime in with a tangent. Also going to preface this by saying I have struggled with weight my entire life and have lost and gained substantial weight through diet alone, always gaining it back and then some — but I think I found something that has worked for me and I have been reflecting on what I wish I was told a long time ago. It's not necessarily a problem to be "obese", meaning you can have extra fat on top of muscle but also be metabolically healthy. In those cases, the extra weight is just causing your calfs to be huge. Instead of focusing on getting skinny, I started focusing on getting strong. All of a sudden diet was a supplemental tool to this goal, and not the main thing. I just made sure to eat more protein, and if I had a "bad day" of eating, I chalked it up to my body having more energy to synthesize new muscle :) Before a bad day would "undo" days of suffering on an energy deficit, and I would just give up. But if you frame it as: look, you have struggled your entire life to be 'thin', when in reality, your ability to be obese was a hidden superpower. Stop fighting it and lift weights, you were probably _made_ for this! In this context I'm weirdly happy with my genetics? there are so many "hard gainers" that do everything in their power to put on 10bs so they can gain muscle. I'm gaining muscle without hardly trying. How many other obese, inactive people are like me and would respond amazingly to resistance training ALONE as well? I focused on strength training and protein for a long time when I started, that was fun and easy, and my body composition started to change. Then I started to notice the changes, and now I have purposeful short-duration "cuts" in my routine and it seems like at some point I'll eventually not be obese. Just trying to say that I wonder what would happen if people were told, "hey, you don't need to diet right now, just come in and train twice a week and eat more protein". Of course "energy toxicity" is absolutely real, but lean body mass can improve health markers A LOT before worrying about that.
- hsbauauvhabzb 4y agoI too found this valuable, I dropped 15-20kg doing this 5 years ago and slowly put it back on due to health problems. I’ve found recently that even cardio works - if I exercise, I don’t want to waste the effort by eating shitty food, if I do have a bad day or two (Xmas period) then it feels like a bank loan I must pay off before the interest kicks in.
- shepherdjerred 4y ago
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoI wonder if, given the cost of the drugs, we're only going to be able moreso to visibly see poorness, i.e. fat people's class will be well known and discrimination to follow.
- renewiltord 4y agoThere are startups that can simplify the process of getting this drug if you're eligible. They do require you to talk to a doctor and nutritionist to see if this is the best thing you should do first, but then they can get you the drug. e.g. https://joinmochi.com https://joinmochi.com
- glaucon 4y ago(From a position of significant ignorance) It seems there is not a strong consensus on what has caused the great increase in obesity of the past fifty years, perhaps throwing greater effort in that direction would be a better long term solution ? To my mind it's strange that there seems to be a circular argument which starts with sedentary life style and "bad" foods cause obesity so exercise and diet control seems like a fix but that is countered by exercise doesn't help (much) and dieting has only temporary effects. If my summary is reasonably correct it seems to me what's needed is more understanding of the outcome before using drugs to "fix it". I wonder if a drug is less likely to be lobbied against than the types of changes such investigations might suggest.
- luckylion 4y ago> If my summary is reasonably correct it seems to me what's needed is more understanding of the outcome before using drugs to "fix it". The likely reason is the changes in lifestyle thanks to the changes in technology. Is "let's just get rid of the past 70 years of technological advancement" something that we'll seriously consider?
- glaucon 4y ago| The likely reason is the changes in lifestyle Agreed, that's the commonly held reason but when one attempts to reverse what the changes seem to have been, by exercising more and eating less, that doesn't seem to work. My point is that perhaps we need to better understand what the changes have been, that perhaps they are more subtle than they are commonly held to be.
- luckylion 4y agoFrom what I understand (which is mostly second hand from a health journalist friend), "work out a bit more and eat a bit less" doesn't get you anywhere close to how people lived up until 1950. In 1920, Americans had 8million cars registered (at 106m people), today they have 276 million cars to 330m people, and that's basically the same for every aspect of life.
- 4y ago
- smooth_remmy 4y agoPetro Dobromylskyj is one of the foremost experts of fat metabolism. He has a blog called Hyperlipid where he's been blogging about fat metabolism and interpreting research for close to 10 years. He thinks the GLP-1 inhibitor drugs will be a disaster in the long term because they 1) cause weight loss but also 2) cause the body to create lots of new adipocyte (fat cells). Increasing the number of adipocytes is very unusual after puberty. As long as you are taking the GLP-1 inhibitor drugs you will lose or maintain weight, but as soon as you stop you will gain a lot of weight back. Here is the blog post: https://high-fat-nutrition.blogspot.com/2023/01/glp-1-agonists.html https://high-fat-nutrition.blogspot.com/2023/01/glp-1-agonis...
- post_break 4y agoSo drug companies should be seeing alarm bells going off. You can profit off this drug, and it's an endless supply of revenue.
- JamesBarney 4y agoWith every weight loss intervention when you stop you gain back the weight. GLP-1 agonists don't seem to be any different than another other intervention.
- smooth_remmy 4y agoThe point is that you could gain back the original weight plus more. Most adults who become obese have not increased their number of fat cells - their fat cells just become larger. The GLP-1 drugs literally increase the number of fat cells.
- Scoundreller 4y agoHow does liposuction fare in long term fat loss?
- Scalene2 4y ago> Weight gain was reported in 43 percent of the responders, with 56 percent of them gaining between 5 and 10 pounds 6 months after their surgery. Fat return was reported in 65 percent of the responders. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16651945/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16651945/
- halfmatthalfcat 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- 0xB31B1B 4y ago"Weight loss is a journey" -> it doesn't have to be, and it isn't for me anymore.
- halfmatthalfcat 4y agoWhether it's a pill a day or a run, you are still doing something and thus the journey. Some of us are blessed with hands-off metabolisms and some of us, it's a constant battle. Best of luck to you tho.
- MajimasEyepatch 4y agoThis is a ridiculous comment. Statistically, there is no weight loss strategy that has been found to work long term at the population level except for bariatric surgery (and now, apparently, these drugs, but we'll see how things look in a few years). Sure, one individual person can pull it off with enough willpower and support and luck. But at a population level, we know definitively that "grind it out with exercise, nutrition, and therapy" is not an effective public health strategy. We are biochemical machines that evolved in a food environment completely unlike the modern world, and that's before you get into possible chemical factors in the environment. If these drugs continue to prove safe—or even they just prove to be less bad than obesity and more effective than other techniques—then there's no reason to dismiss them. Congratulations on being better than the rest of us slobs, but what works for you may not work for everyone.
- raincom 4y agoEven people who had bariatric surgery regain weight substantially.
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- beloch 4y agoThought experiment: A drug* that reduces people's weight and massively boosts physical fitness with no negative side effects is discovered. The discoverer of that drug declines to patent it, making it a cheap generic available everywhere. What would your reaction be? Take a moment to consider what your reaction is before continuing. ... The comments I'm reading here are diverse and fascinating. Weight loss, diet, and fitness are almost quasi-religious issues that people tend to have strong and personal reactions to. The unfit are desperate for a solution, especially an easy one. The very fit subconsciously resent the notion that people could achieve, with a pill, what they have achieved through discipline and hard work (or genetic luck). Others are keen to point out diverse evils of modern society that they believe are the true culprits which must be tackled instead of masking their effect with a pill. Nutrition and fitness are classic examples of pseudo-science. Studies that would meet the bare minimum standards of scientific rigour in any other field are practically impossible. Getting a statistically significant sample of people to go on special diets or exercise regimens long term is just not feasible. Whenever an "expert" makes a tentative statement on what they think might be the case, media picks it up and amplifies it. Butter is bad for you. Butter is good for you. Blueberries are superfood. Keto diets. Crossfit. etc. Countless "experts", often with no credentials and no compelling data, are happy to write best-selling self-improvement books. They assume that what works for them (or didn't work, but seems like it should have) will work for everyone. Everyone wants to know how to be healthy, fit, and happy, so there is insatiable demand for books that are, by scientific standards, pure spit-balling. Then medicine and drug research, which are legally required to be at last somewhat scientific but are always profit-motivated, enter the fray. They can prove a drug meets safety standards and quantify certain specific effects, but interactions with the pseudo-science of the greater health industry eventually become unavoidable. Perhaps the first step to becoming more objective about drugs like this is to recognize that we really aren't. *a hypothetical one, not the one being discussed here
- uhtred 4y ago> Nutrition and fitness are classic examples of pseudo-science I think it's pretty well agreed upon in the medical community (and proven) that a healthy diet (lots of fruit and vegetables, not too much sugar, etc) and regular exercise leads to better health. It's not pseudo-science. Neither is the statement that consuming more calories than you burn will make you put on weight.
- jamesgill 4y agoThe best 'obesity drug' I've found is low-carb + intermittent fasting. 90 pounds later, I'm not hungry and every aspect of my health has improved dramatically.
- andbberger 4y agogood for you, but that's not a drug. behavioral interventions don't work clinically. GLP-1 agonists work incredibly well.
- 1024core 4y ago> they also carry a hefty price tag: the injections often cost upwards of US$1,000 each month. IMHO, it would be much easier to just stop eating processed foods and sugar (and sugar substitutes). I cut down on sugar drastically and started intermittent fasting, losing 20 lbs in about 5 months without doing anything else.
- orblivion 4y agoThe headline sounds like a YouTube ad
- mirekrusin 4y agoEat less shit food and excercise more doesn't work anymore nowadays?
- Gatsky 4y agoI have a theory that the Nature group, ostensibly a bunch of academic journals, actually wants to become the NYTimes. They have chosen a custom font, they publish increasingly editorialised political content, and they produce these hype train news pieces which really lack objectivism or scientific rigour. Scientists should consider carefully what is appearing alongside their research, and the ultimate result of an unassailable, centralised academic publisher with opaque editorial practices.
- anigbrowl 4y agoA class of drugs that quash hunger have shown striking results in trials and in practice. But can they help all people with obesity — and conquer weight stigma? Who cares? Helping half of people with a problem to overcome it is great. Journalists and editors need to push back against simplistic concepts like 'one size fits all' and the urge to rank everything, which just leads to bimodal distributions and the accompanying bad outcomes when they are imposed by economic force.
- fswd 4y agoIt appears you can do the same thing with 3g of cinnamon https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19158209/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19158209/ Conclusions: Ingestion of 3 g cinnamon reduced postprandial serum insulin and increased GLP-1 concentrations without significantly affecting blood glucose, GIP, the ghrelin concentration, satiety, or GER in healthy subjects.
- jumpman500 4y agoIsn’t that a dangerous amount?
- fswd 4y agoIt's about 1/3 of a tablespoon. It's dangerous to the bottom line of drug manufactures trying to sell a $1000 injection that does the same thing.
- exhilaration 4y agoIf anyone wants to try this, make sure you're NOT using what's usually passed off as cinnamon in America (Cassia), you want the real thing (Ceylon) -- and from a vendor you can trust. That amount of cassia cinnamon is likely to cause liver damage: https://www.consumerlab.com/answers/cinnamon-coumarin-liver-danger/cinnamon-liver-danger/ https://www.consumerlab.com/answers/cinnamon-coumarin-liver-...
- species9606 4y agoMeta comment, I love HN for comments like this. Collectively, this website is a super-brain that’s far more impressive than any language model.
- Ayesh 4y agoAs someone who is from Ceylon (Sri Lanka), I'd say to be careful of the most commercially available cinnamon that are meant to be used with food and tea too, because they may be flavored to dial down the otherwise strong taste/aroma of cinnamon. I know because one of my friends has a cinnamon farm, and what he makes at his place is nothing compared to the cinnamon I could buy from supermarkets when I was living in the Netherlands. Look for Sri Lankan markets if you are looking for unaltered stuff.
- foruhar 4y ago$1000/month seems like a decent amount of money for a lot of people. I'm guessing a large number of folks would love to lose weight miraculously. I wonder how long before we get a bootleg analog that can be bought in the non-medical drug market in the same way as testosterone can be bought. Now that the mechanism is known (GLP-1 inhibition) are these the kind of drug, e.g. LSD, valium, or morphine, that is easy to create a facsimile or analog of?
- RedditKon 4y agoWe already have it - you can buy Semaglutide easily on the clear net as it’s relatively easy / cheap to manufacture. r/peptides has more info. Disclaimer: I’m not advocating this - just sharing info.
- JamesBarney 4y agoThese drugs are way more difficult to manufacture than testosterone. I'm sure we'll see things branded as a knockoff but I doubt we'll see any true knockoffs.
- magwa101 4y ago[dead]
- maxrev17 4y agoA drug to fix what's on supermarket shelves? Lord help us!
- 2devnull 4y ago“when lifestyle changes aren’t enough.” People don’t want to hear it, but we do nobody any favors by pretending this is more complicated than it is. It’s actually pretty simple. The solution is to adjust calories in vs calories out. Fast a few days a week. Cut out bread, sugar and other simple carbs. We don’t help alcoholics or opioid addicts by enabling them with statements like “when not getting drunk isn’t enough…” The pharma industry will enable addicts because it wants money. Fat people need love, though love, and a home without good tasting, or high calorie foods.
- epgui 4y ago> The pharma industry will enable addicts because it wants money. This is a little over-simplistic. The "pharma industry" is not a monolith, and is made up in large part by academics who love spending their time thinking about how to make the world better, and by doctors who have no conflict of interest, etc etc.
- 2devnull 4y agoIt is an industry. It must therefore be optimized to maximize shareholder value, roi, revenue, etc… Gambling can be fun, and nothing wrong with casinos, but in the long run they are optimized for one thing. A casino that is not optimized for profit will disappear. Same is true for the healthcare industry. If a corporation is not optimized to make money they disappear. I think it’s valuable from a financial perspective to avoid casinos. I think it’s valuable from a health perspective to avoid drugs, to the extent possible. But, yes, casinos can be fun, and you can even profit from them if you play your cards right.
- mshake2 4y agoWhile I agree, you're right, nobody wants to hear it. There's no point telling people to have discipline, because discipline is not spread through strangers telling each other to have it. Someone either has the capacity to have discipline (instilled through upbringing or formative events), or they don't. These magic pills are for everyone who doesn't have discipline.
- zmmmmm 4y agoI am curious if drugs that reduce your appetite affect your enjoyment of the food you do eat? It would be incredibly sad if the price to pay for not becoming obese is not enjoying any food at all.
- r00tanon 4y agoUnfortunately just diagnosed type 2. Can't find Ozempic anywhere due to this crazy drug shortage and off label prescribing.
- matt3210 4y agoput it in the water!
- Vecr 4y agoNot a good idea. Some people are underweight or normal weight, or want to get stronger by lifting weights. Also, it's an injected drug.
- matt3210 4y agoConvincing people to not fool around never worked so the birth control pill was invented to allow people to indulge with less consequences. I recall someone (I forget who) said that things that prevent you from eating will never work and the only solution is something that allows you to indulge without the consequences. Does this drug allow you to indulge without consequences or does it make you not want to eat? If its the later, I bet that it won't have long term success. Edit: A drug that allows you to indulge without consequence in this context would be a bad thing. It would allow people to eat non-stop without the consequences and would increase the demand for food in the modern nations to unreasonable levels. If you think about it, this kind of drug would have the same outcome as bulimia (think, hunger games).
- deburo 4y ago>Does this drug allow you to indulge without consequences or does it make you not want to eat? Why wouldn't satiety drugs be helpful?
- matt3210 4y agoPeople WANT to indulge. A drug that kills sex drive would never work but the drug that lets you have a sex drive without consequences already works today. Edit: It might have novelty support but I'm confident that in the long run people will choose to indulge and get the dopamine.
- m_a_g 4y agoThere exists a drug like that called DNP, but it is extremely easy to overdose and die, so it's been banned for almost a century now
- jcbcn 4y agoWhy do the graphics mention total loss of bodyweight? Surely in those studies they scanned the patients for exact body fat percentages...
- totalhack 4y agoI'm curious to see what kind of shape all of these "diet doesn't matter" people are in, on average.
- nemo44x 4y agoI’m surprised insurance doesn’t want to cover it. I’d think the cost at scale would outweigh (pun intended) the longer term costs that fat people bring. Or do their hearts just explode at 50 and that’s it?
- RedditKon 4y agoMy guess is that they don’t want to cover a $1,000/month drug to save costs that you may not incur for many years / when you’re no longer insured by them. It only works if all the companies agree to cover it.
- karaterobot 4y agoIt's weird that insurance companies won't cover this, considering the cost of treating obesity-related illnesses like diabetes, heart disease, strokes, certain forms of cancer, etc. It's also weird that pharmaceutical manufacturers price this so high, considering the potential size of the market relative to the current size of the market. I guess what I'm saying is: the healthcare industry makes a lot of choices I don't understand. /shrug
- zug_zug 4y agoWell... another way of thinking about this is... if it costs 15,000 a year to treat, I wonder what percentage of those people could lose weight another way for less than $15,000 a year (e.g. free gym membership with classes, personal trainer, and $500 a month bonus if you show up twice a week)
- karaterobot 4y agoWe know the answer to that, though. Very few morbidly obese adults lose significant amounts of weight and keep it off long term, even with comprehensive lifestyle interventions like calorie counting, gym membership, and therapists. Even people who lose a lot of weight just gain it back at 1-2 kg a year. That's why there's an obesity epidemic.
- daniel-cussen 4y ago[dead]
- valachio 4y agoI discovered a breakthrough technique in fighting obesity. It's so simple anyone can do it and see results in weeks. The technique is "eat less"
- TEP_Kim_Il_Sung 4y agoI am currently on one of these regimes, and it has been miraculous for my life. I became obese when I was 27, topping a 32 BMI, when I was 35 I gained a substantial amount of mass by just pumping iron and doing cardio, brah. 5 years later, I had a bad knee, and lost most of my gains. Dr. Bronner put me on a steady diet of Carne Asada and Kale, and I've been a wiry lean pooping machine ever since! He's a miracle worker, send him all your money now!
- lonk11 4y agoRelated coverage with more graphs: https://erictopol.substack.com/p/the-new-obesity-breakthrough-drugs https://erictopol.substack.com/p/the-new-obesity-breakthroug...
- narrator 4y agoThe big elephant in the room is where did everyone's endogenous GLP-1 peptide go? A similar elephant in the room is why is synthetic thyroid hormone to replace all the missing endogenous thyroid hormones such a high selling drug? What in the environment is slowly poisoning everyone so their bodies don't work normally? Here's a clue, one of hundreds in the medical literature: "The endocrine disrupting potential of monosodium glutamate (MSG) on secretion of the glucagon-like peptide-1 (GLP-1) gut hormone and GLP-1 receptor interaction" https://twitter.com/hashtag/AtmosphericRiver?src=hashtag_click https://twitter.com/hashtag/AtmosphericRiver?src=hashtag_cli... There is a huge bias against anyone saying anything in food or otherwise causing anything more than a trivial negative health effect. Everyone says eat healthy, but there's so much more the government in the U.S could do to protect the average consumer from damaging unnecessary food additives. The EU is much better about these food additive issues.
- urthor 4y agoCertainly it's one of the largest issues in society today. We simply don't have much of an idea how the human hormone system works, or how it reacts to all the chemicals present in the "Standard American Diet."
- nervousvarun 4y agoVery interesting post but aren't obesity rates similarly increasing in EU countries?
- refurb 4y agoMSG is very common in Asia and has been for a while (you can buy it in 1 kg bags) yet Asia has low obesity.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lumb63 4y agoI’m sympathetic to anyone who feels they “need” to take these, and wants to encourage others to do the same. I’m sure they work wonders for obesity, and that’s great. But we cannot get something for nothing, so I have to wonder: at what cost? A poster below me said that, at a population level, diet and exercise do not work. That’s mostly true. Most people don’t permanently change their diet and other lifestyle long term. I think that ignoring that they do work in the short term, and could work in the long term if adherence were better, overlooks something important. Moving past that, we are an obese population. Or, at least, very overweight. Supposing diet and exercise do not work, what are we to do? I’d propose we look toward rectifying the causes. There are innumerable environmental factors today that make us fat: pollution, drug side effects, food advertising, alcohol, social pressure, widespread sedentary jobs and lifestyle, etc., etc., etc. If we focused on solving the problems that are making us obese, we wouldn’t need these drugs (or at least, not nearly to the extent we do). We used to live in a world like that. We know what it looks like. We know the consequences. We know our bodies and society can tolerate that world, and that it would solve our issues. Why not aim for a return? Instead we will opt for another technical solution to our technical problem of obesity, causing all manner of unknown risks later on, and falling back to another technical solution to that technical problem. We will continue to layer on technique after technique to patch holes in the solutions we left in our last layer of solutions. The holes will grow larger and larger as we stack on more layers with more holes, and solutions will grow smaller and smaller as technology grows ever more specialized. The cycle is not sustainable.
- ITB 4y agoThe whole idea that obesity is a “stigma” is overplayed. Obesity is unhealthy. If I see an obese young child, I might form a negative opinion about their parents. If an adult is obese, they should want to lose weight because it will make them healthier.
- jononomo 4y agoFor anyone that wants to lose weight without taking drugs, just try eating only eggs, liver, and ribeye steaks with salt and drinking only water. You can eat to satiety on this diet - in fact you can just stuff yourself as much as you want - and you will lose weight and get in shape. Also, you'll find that it is impossible to eat a more nutrient dense and nutritionally complete diet than liver, eggs, and ribeye steaks. Remember never to drink a calorie.
- unixbotnuke 4y agoYou fat fucks just eat less and go for a walk.
- dang 4y agoWe've banned this account for repeatedly breaking the site guidelines. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- elil17 4y agoAm I right that, if I (early twenties, 36 BMI) have no other health complications, it makes sense to wait to see what the long term effects of these drugs are? If I knew it was safe in the long term I’d take it in a heartbeat. However, I’m concerned that there could be long term issues with the drug (perhaps a resistance/“yo-yo” effect where the potency wears off and I gain back my original weight plus more than I would have otherwise over, say, 10 or 20 years). Is that the sort of thing that’s in the realm of the possible/plausible or is this more like a vaccine where there are some strong theoretical reasons why we don’t expect it to have long term issues?
- idealmedtech 4y agoAs a diabetes researcher, results like this don't surprise me one bit, but I'm glad they're getting national coverage! A publication in Nature is an incredible achievement, congrats to the teams involved. We think good glucose control is at the center of a whole host of medical issues, inside and outside the hospital. Bringing critically ill patients under control has been found to reduce mortality rates by up to 30%, results which have been repeated several times in thousands of patients. These drugs, which are less intense than insulin therapy, confer similar glucoregulatory effects, which has all sorts of cascading hormone benefits etc. Exciting stuff, thanks for sharing!
- hoseja 4y ago"conquer weight stigma"? No, it should be stigmatized.
- sacnoradhq 4y agoMy doc is trying to get me on these kind of meds. I'm on high dose (60 mg) mirtazapine motivates immense weight gain as a side-effect. I'm +30% overweight (260 lbs vs. 200 / 117 kg vs 90) and the hunger for carbs is beyond ravenous. Stimulants are nonstarters because I'm already on a beta blocker for inappropriate sinus tachycardia, and other meds for "physiological" anxiety (can never relax).
- zupa-hu 4y agoI’m a skinny / athletic person. The reason is a doctor told my parents not to feed me any sugar until age 2-3, as fat cells are created up to that age. After that, they only change in size. I don’t know if that’s a scientifically proven thing, but indeed i simply can not gain weight, whatever i eat. As if i had zero fat cells. The only downside is that I’m often cold, which is of course far easier to manage. I’m not a water person though, as its nontrivial to “dress up” for swimming. It’s a miracle, please spread it. The next generation could avoid the fatness problem alltogether.
- a4a4a4a4 4y ago> The reason is a doctor told my parents not to feed me any sugar until age 2-3 What I take from this is that the actual reason is, "I had parents that were concerned enough with my nutrition to not feed me much sugar as a child, and those healthy eating habits probably didn't stop after age 2-3. I now cannot gain weight, even if I eat what I perceive as a lot of food (because I grew up eating healthy food and portion sizes)." I was one of those "I can't gain weight/put on muscle" people for a long time. I eventually tried eating literally double what I would normally eat, and as expected, I started gaining weight.
- zupa-hu 4y agoOnce I was working in London as a contractor, a colleague looked at my lunch after a while of working together, shook his head and told me "you are going to kill yourself". I hope that was indeed the worst 6mo in my life pretty much living on fast food, but I did not gain a penny in weight. I think healthy eating habits would be the last thing that came to my friends minds when describing me. I totally agree I'm only a sample of one that I know of, but the fact that this doctor relative of ours told my parents the cause-and-effect relationship beforehand, and it worked out, makes me believe the theory. Either way, I keep recommending it to my friends getting babies, so I'll be able to collect more data in the next 50 years. ;) The thing is, that's the kind of gamble that costs nothing and might have immense upside, so it would be kinda silly not to apply it. My 2c.
- cstross 4y agoI'm 58, have type II diabetes, and BMI over 30, which is the criterion for NHS Scotland to offer semaglutide (currently in the formulation Rybelsus, which is a once-a-day tablet rather than an injection). I've been on Semaglutide for 6 months now. Weight is down from 97kg to 83kg, blood HbA1C is down into pre-diabetes levels. (Also, my knees don't hurt!) The down side of semaglutide: 1. Continuous low-grade nausea, as in, "am I going to throw up?" levels of stomach upset. Feeling nauseous for six months is No Fun Whatsoever. 2. Appetite suppression: it's like a chemical gastric band. My stomach capacity is way down. It makes family meal planning pretty much impossible: it makes the rare celebratory restaurant meal difficult (I'm limited to either two starter-sized portions or a main portion, and expect to leave some on the plate or feel bloated for 12-18 hours afterwards). 3. Muscle loss, not just fat loss. There's a pandemic surge and the health service here is in crisis so I'm not going to the swimming pool (my main form of exercise -- low joint impact). Consequently I'm not getting enough exercise. I have noticed that on semaglutide you lose weight from all tissues -- not just white adipose, so I'm losing muscle density as well. (New Year's Resolution: once the current COVID peak passes, go back to the pool during off-peak hours.) Upshot: I'm going to persist for a while longer then when the weight loss slows off I'll talk to my GP about a medication review and maybe reducing the dosage to a maintenance level (in hope of keeping the benefits and reducing the side-effects). I would not recommend this medication to someone who is only a bit overweight -- it's a first-generation GLP-1 agonist, and like H2 antagonists in the 1970s and 1980s there will be a deluge of me-too drugs over the next few years that are cheaper/better/have fewer side-effects. If you can wait, wait.
- bratwurst3000 4y agoMy diet pill is aderall. Works like charm.
- amai 4y agoDon‘t cigarettes and nicotine also suppress hunger quite effectively? It also has side effects, but are these more severe than from these drugs?
- MagicMoonlight 4y agoIf weight gain was genetic then we’d have fat ancestors. Nobody has fat ancestors. So sure we can drug everyone to try and fix it, but that’s not actually fixing the cause.
- TheGeminon 4y agoAvailable food/calorie supply has dramatically increased over time[0] so many ancestors probably didn’t have the opportunity to get fat even if they had the genes. [0] https://ourworldindata.org/food-supply https://ourworldindata.org/food-supply
- martin82 4y agoEat a keto diet and you won't be obese. Why does THAT not stun researchers? Oh... can't make any money from selling people unprocessed foods and even less from not selling carbs...