43 ms·
EU reaches deal to make USB-C a common charger for most electronic devices
- konschubert 4y agoIs this really what we as a society should spend our focus on? What percentage of landfills are phone chargers? 0.01% maybe?
- mmastrac 4y agoDon't forget random wall warts, random laptop power supplies, etc. All of these random DC power standards have been brutal for creating e-waste. I try to keep my power supplies organized and I have a few boxes full of them with various voltages, currents, etc. The forcing function of laptops and other hardware needing to work off the common USB-C PD levels will drastically improve the situation. GaN tech is getting cheaper all the time, and the PD chips required to make all of this tech work are super cheap. Eventually I hope we end up with USB-C-at-the-wall alongside power ports as a standard.
- r0snd0 4y ago
- sakutea 4y agoIt prevents Apple from becoming a Cable Sales Company
- qalmakka 4y ago2024? There's still plenty of time for them to remove the port altogether and go with just MagSafe/Qi. Which they control, and they still can get fees from. Trust me when I say that Apple will NEVER submit to this legislation, they will find every sort of obscure or arcane tricks to comply with it without actually doing it. It would set a precedent that legislating can change Apple's behaviour, which they clearly do not want to give. If they show the EU Parliament it's pointless to go after them, maybe they will not try to dismantle their monopoly on the App Store, which is clearly the next thing they will go after this.
- rbanffy 4y agoThey already use USB-C in the iPad line. What I imagine as the most likely outcome is keeping USB-C as an option for charging (as it already is - you don't need to use MagSafe for charging any supported) and offering USB-C and/or wireless-only charging on phones. Being wireless-only on phones makes a lot of sense for ruggedness - a completely sealed iPhone could be easily used underwater.
- lekevicius 4y agoI don't think this is the right take. - We already have reliable rumors that next-next iPhone (not this Sept, but next) will have USB-C port. - Qi is not a standard they control like Lightning either way. - Portless phone would be very unpopular (no fast charging), USB-C would be very popular. Apple would not choose to be unpopular just to watch the world hate them.
- glogla 4y ago> - Portless phone would be very unpopular (no fast charging), USB-C would be very popular. Apple would not choose to be unpopular just to watch the world hate them. The same Apple which removed headphone jack so they can sell more dongles and wireless headphones? I can see them making portless phone just out of pure spite (maybe having cheaper version with port and not selling that in EU).
- kaba0 4y agoThe headphone jack did take up a considerable amount of space and made waterproofing quite a bit harder. It't not like it was not a well-considered tradeoff. Companies don't work based on spite, but based on profit.
- spacexsucks 4y ago
- mattnewton 4y agoThe existence of waterproof Samsung phones of the same thickness seems to disprove this line for me; it’s not a coincidence that AirPods were released at the same time. Removing the headphone jack and was at least in part about the upsell to wireless headphones apple also makes.
- baisq 4y agoNo more innovation: USB-C or else.
- Nextgrid 4y agoIt seems like all that's mandated is that a USB-C charger would be compatible. You can still run a proprietary protocol on top of it if you wanted or use a hybrid, proprietary connector as long as a standard USB-C charger would still work.
- rbanffy 4y agoNo more e-waste as well. And, as the regulation moved from micro USB to USB-C, it's clear that innovation is still possible, within regulations. That's also why you can't have jet-engine powered cars on the streets.
- frizlab 4y agoExcept for the millions of lightning cable already in prod?
- withinboredom 4y agoWe have 5 apple devices and 3 lightning cables remaining. I have some 18-20 usb-c cables lying around.
- Adraghast 4y agoNo worries, there are also millions of iPhones with Lightning ports for them to be used with. (:
- lm28469 4y agoSo no more innovation either ? if we can't move out of existing tech because they're still in production
- frizlab 4y agoIt wasn’t needed. There are no benefits of usb-c over lightning for the usage it has. It’s not an evolution it’s a change.
- frizlab 4y agoAs an European, I’m so mad at this law.
- messe 4y agoWhy?
- frizlab 4y agoLightning is a far superior plug than usb-c (don’t tell me about data transfer, I don’t care, I care about the durability and ease of plugging of the plug itself), I have MANY lightning cables (that I will have to throw away, how is that good for e-waste?), and in a more general sense the law basically forbids evolution. I am livid that they’d do something like that instead of working on actual stuff like forbidding mining which actually actively harms the environment, and depletes primary resources for idiotic reasons.
- rojcyk 4y ago
- lm28469 4y agoSo Apple should share its proprietary connector (good luck with that) for free (?) and everyone else should adopt it (good luck with that too) because _you_ bought a bunch of cables ? I don't see Samsung and the other big ones investing in a whole new connector for their entire lineup to please Europe, whereas apple already has usb-c devices They're both equally easy to use, lightning is just slower. Seems like it's just your personal case, I have 0 lightning cables and maybe 5 usb-c, it would be equally a waste to throw them away. Also, nothing forbids evolution, usb-c evolved a lot already, you just have to make it backward compatible. I haven't bought a usb cable since I got my pixel 3 and everything works just fine
- frizlab 4y agoI never said I wanted lightning enforced though. I’m talking about evolution of the design of the plug, not its software specs.
- maccard 4y agoThe problem with USB-C is that you can't just pick up a device cable and power brick and expect them to work together. As an example, my Apple 96W USB-C charger doesn't charge my nintendo switch. The cable that came with my phone doesn't charge said fully Mac when used with the 96w charger. There is no indication of incompatibility between these devices until you realise they don't work. This is going back to the dc jack era where you end up with these [0] guys with various tips and dials that all meet the USB-C "standard" for a connector but don't work. [0] https://www.amazon.co.uk/EFISH-Multifunctional-Transformer-2A-Electronics-3V-12V-8Plugs/dp/B0829R1GD7 https://www.amazon.co.uk/EFISH-Multifunctional-Transformer-2...
- samiru 4y ago> The problem with USB-C is that you can't just pick up a device cable and power brick and expect them to work together. We clearly need more regulation.
- maccard 4y agoIndeed, but this isn't the regulation we need unfortunately
- varajelle 4y agoWe need more color codes and symbols maybe?
- maccard 4y agoHonestly I think we need different ports. My laptop can already draw more power than the charger that came with it can provide, it's insulting for it to pretend it is charging when I plug a 5w a to c charger into it. Enforcing USB pd as a standard would be another acceptable one.
- stewx 4y agoThe issue with the Nintendo Switch is that Nintendo designed their own faulty USB-C charging implementation rather than merely using the reference design. It's not a failure of the spec, it's a failure to adhere to the spec. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16706803 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16706803
- dontbenebby 4y agoAwesome! I recently put off buying an adapter I lost for one device, and just started using an old USB battery with the correct connector to charge it up outside my home instead, I was THAT annoyed with the fact I need to hurt my back and stress my mind dealing with all these... ports. This is a positive example of the EU influencing American technology companies. (I say that as someone considering getting an EU passport though, so I might be biased.)
- lekevicius 4y agoAs a European, I'm very happy. USB-A has been with us for over 20 years. It's only disappearing because of USB-C, and USB-C seems to have room to grow. I wouldn't be surprised if it will still be the most popular connector in 2035, and not just because "legislation stops innovation". Making sure there are no weird exceptions to a very good port is reasonable and good.
- 2000UltraDeluxe 4y agoThe idea's nice. I'll still have about 30 unusable micro-USB chargers lying around, though.
- asutekku 4y agoSure, doesn't still mean we should stagnate and be forced to use tech that is basically obsolete for a modern world's requirements.
- rob_c 4y agoI wouldn't stand on the hill of this is obsolete tech, there should be more devices built with power efficiency from the ground up as well as less focus on the USBC charges your phone faster. This is more about usbc will charge every device you have in a few years so no reaching for custom chargers. Usbc->X cables however are another matter nothing is stopping HP making a custom usbc->HP port for their laptops for instance
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- spacexsucks 4y agoBasically obsolete. As someone who uses a 7 yr old ipad, a 10 yr old windows phone and a 9 yr old Nexus 7 this is hot garbage
- 4y ago
- rob_c 4y agoThere is little to no incentive to stop tiktok streamers and vapid tech fans throwing out their 6 month old devices and upgrading. But it's a start. Whilst important, we have done much better to FORCE the industry to provide security support and updates as part of the sale of devices for a minimum of 5 years on all products. This is one of the biggest insurmountable reasons I see for people who don't even want to, to have to upgrade because of the locked down nature of phones/watches/washing-machines/hoovers/etc... Although I doubt it'll be the EU project to push through something so bold that will have enough of an impact.
- edent 4y agoWhat's interesting is that nearly all of my recent electronics purchases have used USB-C. Headphones, thermal printer, neck-cooler, rechargable screwdriver - all USB-C. What's weird are the few things which don't. Amazon Alexa use a barrel charger. Brand new HP printer has the old square style USB plug. Pulse Oximeter user micro-USB. So C is certainly getting there. Appearing in cheap and expensive products. And, I'm happy to say, works well. Just needs a few laggards to update!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- basisword 4y ago>> What's interesting is that nearly all of my recent electronics purchases have used USB-C. I've started noticing this recently. It's taken longer than I thought but the only devices remaining I have that I need to search for cables for are my iPhone/Apple Watch/old iPod. Everything else, including laptops, I usually have a USB-C charger already plugged in and ready to go no matter what room I'm in. It makes sense that there should be a standard for this, just like we do (although it varies by country) for our plugs.
- ProZsolt 4y agoI usually try to buy devices with detachable IEC 60320[1] mains cable. So when I move to a different country I only need to change the cables and not the devices. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEC_60320 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEC_60320
- qalmakka 4y agoThe "old square style USB plug" is USB-B. It's the counterpart of USB-A, the ubiquitous microUSB-B connector is meant to be a tiny version of it (there's also miniUSB-B, which now is mostly dead, and mini and micro A, which no one ever used).
- causi 4y agoI wish USB-C was more robust, or at least had the option of being more robust. I miss not being scared of accidentally stepping on my laptop charge connector and crushing it flat. I'd pay good money for a type-C un-flattener.
- vanattab 4y agoYeah. Type c is worse then micro or mini in this regard but still no where as bad as type A. I can't tell you how many USB cables I have thrown away because office chairs have run over the ends.
- causi 4y agoThe only advantage with type A is that it's large enough you can use a set of flat pliers to straighten it out. Type-C is nearly impossible to do that with.
- danaris 4y agoIs there a halfway-modern port that is more robust? Hell, is it possible to make a port/adapter that you can't destroy by stepping on it? I've personally destroyed VGA, PS/2, and ADB adapters by stepping on them in the past. (I've since gotten somewhat more careful, and haven't yet destroyed any USB or Lightning adapters the same way.) How, exactly, do you propose that they design a port that you can't accidentally crush, aside from something dirt-simple like an 8mm headphone jack...?
- PinguTS 4y agoEverybody who is frenetically celebrating this as the end of the manufacturer-specific power brick, does simply not know that USB-C is not USB-C. There is no single USB-C. USB-C is a bunch of specifications that may can be combined or may not. USB-C is only the physical connector. USB-C PD (Power delivery) does support many different modes. There are at least 11 different modes with at least 4 of them are optional. I haven't read the latest version of the specification, but I would bet that there are optionally also some implementation-specific options aka manufacturer-specific. All that combined with the many different cable definitions for the different use cases, makes it for the average consumer a nightmare.
- plonk 4y agoI've never seen a USB-C cable that didn't charge all my devices with all my chargers. OK, maybe one that came with an HP screen and was clearly labeled as "data only". I think this will make cables interchangeable in most cases. Fast charging and fast transfers are nice to have but rarely vital.
- PinguTS 4y agoYou haven't brought any of those cheap Chinese cables, haven't you? I have such cables, which can't be really used for charging as well as for fast data transfer. They are good for my development hardware kits, I have. Because those kits don't have any high power requirements. But I cannot use them to power my notebook.
- rbanffy 4y ago> You haven't brought any of those cheap Chinese cables, haven't you? Do you expect them to follow standards while being impossibly cheap to pay for the licensing of said standards?
- PinguTS 4y agoWhat you expect will average Joe buy at Amazon? What will be the key of comparing one cable with another?
- jl6 4y agoI want to like this, but I charge my iPhone with a cable that has lightning on one end and USB-C on the other, and I know from extensive direct experience that the lightning end is the better physical design. Supporting this is tantamount to believing that there will never need to be a USB-D that improves upon USB-C, and I just can’t believe that.
- torginus 4y agoThe problem with lightning is that the springs that fix the plug in place are on the port, not the cable. This is the part that wears out, and when it does, the port will need to be replaced, not the cable.
- vladvasiliu 4y agoHow often does this happen in practice, though? My 6 year-old iPhone that I plug and unplug a bunch of times a day still keeps the plugs in very snuggly. They basically don't move. And I've pulled on the connector many, many times, by stepping on the cord and pulling the phone up. Contrast this with my 2 month-old laptop in which the usb-c cables move around, even though it spends 90% on the time plugged in. --- Edit: I did have connection issues at one point, but it was due to pocket lint that had accumulated inside the port. It was easily removable with a toothpick, and the connector went back to working like new.
- dundarious 4y agoI had the same issue with the same toothpick solution, then 1 year later the spring really did fail and I essentially had to buy a new phone.
- plonk 4y ago> I know from extensive direct experience that the lightning end is the better physical design. What's so great about it? USB-C is just as easy to plug in and these cables usually last longer. The only difference for me is that Lightning eventually ends up with black pins and I have to buy another cable. Also, is it really worth the few technical advantages if the alternative is a good-enough plug that works with absolutely everything?
- viktorcode 4y agoIn case if you didn't know, all modern Apple lightning chargers are USB-C chargers. It's the cable which is different.
- jjcm 4y agoOne thing I would love to see here is an end of life for this ruling. I.e. “effective as of 2024, but not enforced after 2030 without renewal”. Market saturation of the standard alone should be enough to get alignment on a single connector, following which it will require significant effort to deviate from it regardless of legislation. I’m still happy with this in the short term - very tired of having to juggle two types of charging cables. I just wish there was a bit of forward thinking involved here.
- kaba0 4y agoThat would be indeed a worthwhile addition, though hopefully the legislation won't kill off a potential better update without it either.
- krageon 4y ago> Market saturation of the standard alone should be enough to get alignment on a single connector Sure, but it's not. So this is not smart.
- mrjin 4y agoOh well. I just returned 3 USB-C hubs in a row, one almost fried my computer. Since the introduce of USB-C, I have more cables than ever. There are virtually so many types of USB-C cables with different capabilities and all looks almost exactly the same. Some cannot handle charging current of 2A or less. Some might be able to do 3A, some maybe 5A. And some of it is USB 2.0, some are USB 3.x 5Gbps, 10Gbps, 20 Gbps or maybe even 40 Gbps. Some have DP-Alt mode, some don't. It's simply a random combination of any of the previous stuff. I wish I had read the specs and labeled them correctly. Now I have a whole bunch of them and I cannot tell which can do what except very few long thick ones for my monitors.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- microtonal 4y agoIt's simply a random combination of any of the previous stuff. [...] Now I have a whole bunch of them and I cannot tell which can do what except very few long thick ones for my monitors. Get a Thunderbolt 4 cable, they can carry Thunderbolt 3, Thunderbolt 4, every USB protocol up to and including 4, DP alt-mode, and 100W power delivery. Moreover, most of them are clearly marked. The Apple cables are expensive, but some other good brands (like CalDigit) offer them at reasonable prices. I just returned 3 USB-C hubs in a row, one almost fried my computer. Most USB USB-C hubs (USB-C is only the connector) are terrible. Even many premium brands (like Satechi) often use cheap Chinese reference designs that will fry themselves pretty quickly, cause a lot of interference, and have all kinds of annoying limitations (mostly because they use 5 or 10 GBit/s USB 3 standards). Since I have switched to quality Thunderbolt Docks, I haven't had any issues.
- thorncorona 4y ago> Since I have switched to quality Thunderbolt Docks, I haven't had any issues. Do you have a list of quality docks? Or how you determine what a quality dock is?
- Wohlf 4y ago
- chenzhekl 4y agoJust curious. If there is a seemingly better connector emerged in the future, could vendors experiment it on new devices on their own? Or do they have to first submit a proposal to the regulator and then deploy it to the device after the proposal has been accepted? I am afraid that the latter could harm innovation.
- gardaani 4y agoApple is already doing that on MacBooks. They have USB-C connectors for charging (that will be mandated by the EU law in the future) and they have a MagSafe connector (their innovation). They can do the same for iPhone: one USB-C connector for charging and one innovation connector.
- AndrewDucker 4y agoFrom the FAQ: "Any technological developments in wired charging can be reflected in a timely adjustment of technical requirements/ specific standards under the Radio Equipment Directive. This would ensure that the technology used is not outdated. At the same time, the implementation of any new standards in further revisions of Radio Equipment Directive would need to be developed in a harmonised manner, respecting the objectives of full interoperability. Industry is therefore expected to continue the work already undertaken on the standardised interface, led by the USB-IF organisation, in view of developing new interoperable, open and non-controversial solutions." https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/QANDA_21_4614 https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/QANDA_...
- xenadu02 4y agoIn other words: no, you can't make certain kinds of innovations without begging permission first.
- simondanerd 4y agoWill that have an effect on the devices sold on the US market? I would love an iPhone with USB-C.
- spywaregorilla 4y agoSeems probable. I'm hopeful as well.
- akmarinov 4y agoEither (sorted most likely to least likely): 1. All iPhones get USB-C 2. Only EU iPhones get USB-C, US sticks with lightning 3. iPhones become portless with wireless charging only
- tyingq 4y agoI imagine there's also some option where you can charge your iPhone with any USB-C charger, but the special Apple charger will charge it up faster.
- rootusrootus 4y agoThey provide a USB-C charger already, and it's not magically faster than good quality third-party chargers. It's top-end, for sure, but not proprietary.
- tyingq 4y agoRight, the idea being the EU mandate would reduce sales of their charger, and eliminate sales of their USB-C -> Lightning cable. And how they might respond.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bluescrn 4y agoPortless could be a pain for developers, if the only way to deploy/debug is wifi, and the only way to charge is a wireless charger (which may not be able to keep up with the discharge rate of a device being used to test a game/app all day)
- marban 4y agoGiven that it took more than a decade, I'm just glad they didn't go with FireWire 400.
- bluescrn 4y agoSo will USB-D be announced before then?
- marticode 4y agoUSB-C is highly extensible (some would say way too much), I doubt we will need to make a connector that is physically incompatible anytime soon (although I'm sure the standard will be upgraded for more speed/uses)
- rootusrootus 4y ago> I doubt we will need to make a connector that is physically incompatible anytime soon Didn't USB-C already do that to itself? I suppose that depends on how narrow the definition of "physically incompatible" is. But IIRC you can't buy a perfect do-everything USB-C cable today, because some USB-C use cases are flat out incompatible with others.
- matthewmacleod 4y agoYou can – AFAIK a real Thunderbolt 4 cable will carry anything that can be carried over a USB-C port.
- cesarb 4y agoAt the cost of being shorter and stiffer; a cable which can only use USB 2.0 and 3A charging can be longer and thinner. And there are also buggy devices (like the first hardware revision of the Raspberry Pi 4) which incorrectly short the two configuration pins together and can only work with less capable cables. But other than that, I agree: a passive Thunderbolt 4 cable can be considered a "perfect do-everything USB-C cable".
- xeromal 4y agoI believe those are just shitty implementations of the spec. If you buy high quality gear with high quality specs, it should work ok. The Nintendo switch is a pile of shit though.
- akmarinov 4y agoThat's very interesting, not because the new iPhone would have a USB-C, but due to the fact that Apple continues selling older phones. Currently they sell the SE, 11, 12 and 13 By 2024 they will be selling a SE, 13, 14 and 15. Will they rework the SE, 13 and 14 to get USB-C? Will they stop selling them just in Europe? That's potentially a lot of money left on the table.
- dan1234 4y agoAs I read it, the new laws are concerned with the chargers more than the devices being charged - if Apple just includes a lightning to USB-C cable (as they already do for the 12), wouldn’t that be enough to satisfy the legislation?
- ajmurmann 4y agoI keep hearing that this is about waste, primarily chargers, as you point out. I wonder if the best solution is to just include neither a charger nor a cable. At this point I have USB chargers and cables for every situation in my life and any additional cable or charger would just be a waste, no matter if USB-C or -A. Have just the people who still need more chargers or cables buy those (or maybe reverb outlet covers with chargers built-in). Everyone else can safe some money and reduce future garbage.
- sxg 4y agoThey will almost certainly be grandfathered in. Legislation nearly never retroactively applies to things created before the legislation itself.
- ryathal 4y agoThat's a pretty huge leap. Just because a design existed before regulation doesn't mean you can keep making it after the regulation. I would be surprised if Apple was allowed to keep selling non-USB-C phones manufactured in winter 2024 or 2025. They will likely be allowed to sell existing inventory, maybe offer refurbished phones that aren't compliant.
- 4y ago
- kingsleyopara 4y agoThis all seems pretty short sighted. Great in the short term (I want a USB-C iPhone and for everything today to be USB-C) but will surely be a pain going forward - where would USB-C be if this policy had standardised on micro USB earlier? Some will say wireless is the future but I’m not convinced. Maybe the best solution would be to have this policy expire after a certain number of years?
- rubyfan 4y agoThe baked in expiration seems like a great idea.
- RGamma 4y agoMicro USB was the standardized smartphone port for years (around the time of the feature phone->smartphone transition): https://techcrunch.com/2009/06/29/micro-usb-to-be-the-standard-phone-charging-port-of-europe/ https://techcrunch.com/2009/06/29/micro-usb-to-be-the-standa...
- hoistbypetard 4y agoIt wasn't that standardized. Between my house and the office around that time, I had a mix of micro USB, mini USB and barrel ports. And always had the wrong adapter with me, it seemed.
- rootusrootus 4y agoAgree, I still have a gaggle of random USB cables for various devices. Micro USB was common, but far from standardized. And on top of that, it sucks. I keep a bunch of spares around because it's such a fragile connector.
- Quanttek 4y agoThe article already hints at it, but lawmakers are not completely dense and allow for relatively easy amendments by the Commission. From the legislation [1]: > "With respect to radio equipment capable of being recharged via wired charging, the Commission is empowered to adopt delegated acts in accordance with Article 44 to amend Annex Ia in the light of technical progress, and to ensure the minimum common interoperability between radio equipment and their charging devices, by: (a) modifying, adding or removing categories or classes of radio equipment; (b) modifying, adding or removing technical specifications, including references and descriptions, in relation to the charging receptacle(s) and charging communication protocol(s), for each category or class of radio equipment concerned." [1] https://ec.europa.eu/docsroom/documents/46755 https://ec.europa.eu/docsroom/documents/46755
- jamil7 4y agoWasn't Apple probably going to do this anyway?
- rtkwe 4y agoUSB-C has been out and stable for years and they haven't so I'm not certain they're going to drop lightning for their phones any time soon. It's been a few generations of iPhone since they went with C on the iPad and I would have expected those to move together or more closely if they were interested in moving to USB-C on their phones.
- gadders 4y agoI don't have an apple phone, but my daughter does, and I've always thought that mechanically at least the Apple connector was better because it had less bits to go wrong. USB C, like micro USB has that "tongue" piece that has to fit inside the end of the cable which always looks like it could snap off. The Apple connector is just a solid piece that goes in the end of the phone. No fiddly interlock pieces.
- 369548684892826 4y agoThe lightning connection does seem to have interlocking pieces, but the moving parts are in the socket rather than on the plug. The plug has grooves on the side to lock into the sprung clips in the socket.
- scrumper 4y agoThe socket half of the lightning connector is actually pretty delicate inside: there are little tiny fingers that contact the strips on the plug. It's quite easy to damage those fingers and ruin the port when cleaning it out after exposure to dust or sand. Mind you my 7 year old broke the USB C connector on his Switch in much the same way. There's only so strong you can make something that small and dense with contacts.
- cesarb 4y agoIn all the discussions I've seen where people complain about USB-C, not once have I read about that tab snapping off, so it does not seem to be a problem in practice. The reason USB-C has the tab on the device is to have the springs, which are the bits which can go wrong the most, on the cable instead of the device. When they start to become loose, you only have to replace an inexpensive cable, instead of having to replace or repair the device. It also better protects the contacts on both the cable and the device (the contacts on Apple's lightning cable are exposed).
- snorlaxle 4y agoIt happened to me once. It was a cheap no-name hub so I don't really blame type c for it. I also haven't heard it happen to anyone else and most of my friends and family have an android.
- mrtksn 4y agoBy the way, that's also how Tesla and all other cars have the same electric plug in EU(not the USB mandate but the car plug standardisation mandate). Of course, the first thing that comes to mind is what happens if better solutions are found. Will EU block innovation? That question is addressed in the Q&A: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/QANDA_21_4614 https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/QANDA_... In essence, they seem to believe that wired charging is mature enough for standardisation but further technologies can be implemented through "Radio Equipment Directive". In the same time, it appears that the wireless charging is unaffected because the tech is new and fast changing, therefore the manufacturers can include whatever wireless charging they see fit. It really boils down to "No funny cables, why don't you try wireless charging of your liking if USB-C doesn't cut it for you?".
- bluGill 4y agoThe constitution gives US congress the right to set standards for weights and measures, which unless you use a very strict reading says they can set charging standards. I wish they would. Tesla (and Nissan) as early movers 10 years ago can be forgiven for not adopting a standard charger, but now they need to update to the standard. (IIRC both are planning on it)
- golemotron 4y agoReading charging standards as "weights and measures" is on par with classifying bumblebees as fish. Not only aren't these strict readings, they aren't even sensible.
- kube-system 4y agoStandardization of metering devices used in commerce is directly in the purview of Weights and Measures regulation. For example, NIST Weights and Measures division regulates the nozzle on the dispenser used for gasoline in the US. > Each retail dispensing device from which fuel products are sold shall be equipped with a nozzle spout having a diameter that conforms with the latest version of SAE J285, “Dispenser Nozzle Spouts for Liquid Fuel Intended for Use with Spark-Ignition and Compression Ignition Engines.” https://www.nist.gov/system/files/documents/2019/12/06/00-20-h130-iv-g-final-12.pdf https://www.nist.gov/system/files/documents/2019/12/06/00-20... A metering devices that dispenses electrical power is no different. https://www.nist.gov/pml/weights-and-measures/legal-metrology-devices/electric-vehicle-fueling-and-submetering https://www.nist.gov/pml/weights-and-measures/legal-metrolog...
- orangepanda 4y agoOh I hope iPhone 8 will support iOs 17. Would be less than nice upgrading a year too early and being stuck on lighting for the next 7 years.
- ubermonkey 4y agoIt's just really not clear to me that regulators need to be mandating product design. I have no expectation, for example, that these same regulators will stay on top of this and revise it when USB-C stops being the preferred or best choice. Twenty years ago, we really DID have a snarl of competing and proprietary phone ports. It was a mess -- Blackberry chargers didn't work with Palm; most WinMo devices had their own ports; etc. It was ugly. Now, pretty much everything is either USB or Lightning. This is good! What problem is the EU solving here?
- jonwinstanley 4y agoExactly. So silly. Plus Apple Watches have always been only charged via conductive, so it’s likely phones could have gone that way too within a short space of time if the lack of a data cable was deemed acceptable.
- jonwinstanley 4y agoActually, if they go wireless then they don’t need to have USB-C. Only devices charged by cable need to have USB-C.
- doikor 4y agoEven devices that charge with a cable do not need USB-C if they are too small to physically fit a USB-C port. Though at that point they wont fit a Lightning port either but instead some weird exposed charging pins or wireless charging.
- morsch 4y agoMaybe, but I wouldn't hold my breath. The fastest charging Android phones charge at >100 W, while wireless charging is currently at 10-15 W.
- rootusrootus 4y agoI routinely charge my iPhone on a wireless charger. When I'm in a hurry, I plug it in. I don't want that option taken away, wireless is nowhere near fast enough yet.
- happy_path 4y agoCan't they give a free adapter when selling an iPhone?
- mojuba 4y agoExactly my thought. That would save many kilotonnes of lightning chargers and cables from being thrown away (and replaced with USB-C ones for no good reason really).
- easton 4y agoWell, there's at least one good reason: I can use my MacBook charger to charge my iPhone without having to carry two cables around.
- thinkindie 4y agoWhat I don't understand from Apple - they have already made the move to USB-C with laptops (ditching the Magsafe - that was way more practical than the USB-C connector), why resisting this much for the iPhone/iPad/etc? I understand that they have additional revenue streams by licensing lighting to accessories manufactures, but still...
- hoistbypetard 4y agoThey've moved most of their laptops back to Magsafe now.
- nuccy 4y agoThey didn't move, they added an option to select: USB-C or Magsafe-2 (it is incompatible with original Magsafe BTW), both work fine. I've actually switched to Macs already when USB-C was introduced (late 2016), so I totally missed the original Magsafe. I recently got a new Macbook Pro 16, which has Magsafe-2. I never used it before and for my use-case I don't see much use for it now either. At least at home and in the office I have external displays, which with single USB-C cable get the signal and charge the Mac. Before it was definitely better than any other laptop charging connector, but advantages USB-C provides overwhelm Magsafe use for me.
- hoistbypetard 4y agoGood point. I forgot they still charged over USB-C as well. I need to work, not infrequently, from the dining table with a laptop plugged into the wall. I have two large boisterous dogs and two not-so-large but still boisterous children. They occasionally tear around the house, and the dogs have snagged a cord and destroyed a laptop by pulling it off the table back in the old pre-magsafe days. Magsafe prevented damage to multiple laptops for me. While I love the single-cable docking angle of USB-C, I'd give it up for magnets if I needed to. For my thinkpad, I actually have one of those magnetic USB-C cables to use at that table.
- tempoponet 4y agoTo clarify: Magsafe 2 was introduced in 2012. You missed the original Magsafe _and_ Magsafe 2. Old adapters (but not the oldest) will work with the latest Macbooks.
- whiddershins 4y ago“How quickly the world owes you something you only found out existed 5 minutes ago.”
- Angostura 4y agoCan't Apple ship the phone with a USBC adapter and claim it is part of the phone?
- manuelabeledo 4y agoWouldn’t that be a bad faith interpretation of the directive?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- seydor 4y agoWhy would they do that?
- Angostura 4y agoTo circumvent the impact of the regulations
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- alexb_ 4y agoinb4 the next iphone has no ports, and the excuse they give involves being waterproof or something
- rootusrootus 4y agoThat would be foolish, wireless charging is far too slow to replace cables anytime soon.
- alexb_ 4y agoFoolish to YOU, maybe, but if it makes Apple more money then it's almost a certainty it would happen.
- manuelabeledo 4y agoI see a lot of negativity and nitpicking in the comments, and I for one welcome the idea. Wired charging is a mature technology, USB-C is extensible enough, and most manufacturers have already adopted it as a de facto standard. Only Apple seems to be reluctant, and only on their cellphones and perhaps some of their headphones.
- bilekas 4y agoI really have no idea other than financial reasons why Apple have not already moved over, considering (IIRC) USB-C is ~100x faster than lightning and even supports higher wattage too ?
- sylware 4y agowait, we need 3 USB-ports: one for the external displayport panel, one for charging, one for the mouse and the keyboard.
- tzs 4y ago> “Today we have made the common charger a reality in Europe!” said the European Parliament’s rapporteur Alex Agius Saliba in a press statement. “European consumers were frustrated long with multiple chargers piling up with every new device. Now they will be able to use a single charger for all their portable electronics.” The devices this covers, those rechargeable by a wired cable according to the EU press release, have pretty much all used USB chargers for a long time so I don't see how this addresses the issue of multiple chargers piling up. At most it addresses the issue of multiple USB to X cables piling up, where X is most commonly Lightning. Unless they also prohibit selling devices with USB chargers I have doubts that this will stop the bundling. Apple has tried to stop including chargers on the theory that nearly everyone already has a bunch lying around, and has drawn a lot of complaints over that, and fines in Brazil where the government regulators have decided that not bundling chargers with every phone is anti-consumer.
- agilob 4y agoUSB-C is still copyrighted so it's really just forcing customers to pay for proprietary connectors? This also bans cheap phones like these https://www.androidpolice.com/nokias-newest-android-go-phones-include-a-removable-battery/ https://www.androidpolice.com/nokias-newest-android-go-phone...
- warmwaffles 4y agoIs this really that surprising?
- lights0123 4y agoWhat do you mean? USB-C is covered by the same trademark licensing scheme (that isn't technically needed if you don't use the USB logo and use your chip's default vendor ID) as USB-A is, a $6000 one-time + $5000/year payment to USB-IF.
- bearjaws 4y agoYou only need to pay for the logo & trademark usage, not the port. Even if you do pay, at $3500 for 2 years, spread across millions of devices, this amounts to pennies.
- modo_mario 4y agoI don't think there's any licensing fees for the spec itself no? Only a small fee to the USB-IF non profit every year or 2 years (and there's sublicensers) for the logo and vendor id which shows spec compliance (Which is the same for micro USB I believe so i can't think of any non proprietary connectors customers would go for regardless.) >This also bans cheap phones like these I'd assume those new phones get a new iteration or 2 or 3 by that time regardless. It tends to go quite fast in the phone market.
- rattlesnakedave 4y agoNot a fan of this. I really like lightning. What happens when we have a new USB or connector standard?
- samatman 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ho_schi 4y agoInstead of "enforcement" I would appreciate good "standards". This allows for improvement and reasonable exceptions. I would provide a "customer traffic light" informing about specific features. More specifically I would shift from implementation (How?) to actual requirements (What?). The implementation is a decision of the manufacturer. Examples: * User-replaceable batteries # By Screw? Coin? Flip/Notch on outside? Behind Backcover? Whatever. * Hardware-maintenance-manuals # Explosion Diagrams? Text? Step-by-Step? Whatever. * Locally user replaceable firm- and software! # By Thumbdrive? SD-Card? USB-Cable? Whatever. Historic example. Do we want enforce a specific engine type {turbojet, turbofan, turboprop) on planes or a specific noise level? The later! Similar for the EU-Cookie-Directive. They should have stated that tracking of users is forbidden (What) and not how to handle Cookies (How).
- hcal 4y agoI'm probably overlooking an obvious answer, I'm not sure how you define this clearly. Using your noise level example, we know how to measure noise levels. It is straight forward to say your new technology complies with a noise regulation. How do you do that for a regulation like standardized connectors? Just say you can't use any non-open-standard connectors?
- jokabrink 4y agoThe whole discussion reminds me a bit of the similar move the EU did back in 2009: Introduce a (voluntary) common external power supply (Micro-USB). Now, I feel the same arguments are brought in again. 1) Hinders innovation 2) Lock on a single technology 3) Creates trash by soon obsolete "deprecated" connector types My bet: 2024 (!) onwards, nearly nobody will be affected by the "downsides".
- garaetjjte 4y agoAlternative history: EU actually makes micro-B mandatory back in 2009, and as a result USB-C never gained traction because all phones were forced by law to use micro-B.
- enragedcacti 4y agoThe regulation as written specifically accounts for advancements in standards and includes options to switch to a new mandatory port over a period of years. It also specifically mentions USB-IF as an organization to work with for such future standards. Safe to say we would probably have standardized on USB-C even sooner had they passed this law for micro-B in 2009.
- badpun 4y agoI wonder if nowadays it’s really that much of a problem though. Modern cellphone chargers are mostly transformers with an USB 2 socket. So, even if you have an iphone and an usb-c decice, you only need to have two cables with an usb 2 connector and not full two chargers.
- ospzfmbbzr 4y agoI'm all for stopping Apple,Sony, or other nasty megacorps from including deliberately 'unique' cables that cost a fortune to replace -- but when the bureaucrats get involved in anything, particularily technology, it frequently ends up being a disaster. This is for a few reasons not the least of which is that the types who are in government are not the types who can make anything useful let alone novel. Even worse the types who influence government are also mostly useless except for their ability to influence government.
- lesuorac 4y agoAnd that's why the EU in 2009 got all the companies to agree to make a common charger [1]. However, then the companies didn't so that left the Gov 2 choices: Ignore the idea of a common charger or force a common charger. [1]: https://www.macrumors.com/guide/eu-charging-standard-proposals-and-apple/ https://www.macrumors.com/guide/eu-charging-standard-proposa...
- ryathal 4y agoEvery useful technology has some level of Bureaucratic regulations attached to it. there are very few exceptions and they don't hurt any sort of growth or innovation. Cars, planes, electric outlets, the internet, radio, television, railways, and more are all regulated to some degree. There are as many examples of regulations driving innovation as there are limiting it.
- alligatorplum 4y agoI am still on the fence on this. On one hand this is a good pro consumer move while also being environmentally friendly but this will likely hinder innovation in the field. If a new way charger standard was found which was a fraction of the cost of USBC and double the speed, the fact that companies would be forced to still use USBC is tough. I also found this tidbit pretty funny. > The legislation has been under development for more than a decade, but an agreement on its scope was reached this morning following negotiations between different EU bodies. > The EU denies this will be the case, and says it will update the legislation as new technology is developed. > “Don’t think we’re setting something in stone for the next 10 years,” said Breton at the press conference.
- specialist 4y agoHoorah! This will accelerate adoption of wireless charging. With each mfg doing its own thing. Lather, rinse, repeat.
- aristofun 4y agoWe need to create some "Reasonable & smart people against stupidity & politics" global comitee. We need to stop allowing stupid but loudly screaming minority to make bad decisions. First this idiotic cookie warning on each goddamn page, now this. Another small step to totalitarianism.
- Vladimof 4y agoI'm still waiting for a round USB connector... But either way, that's good... it means that Apple will have to keep a connector on their devices and not go 100% wireless (not that I would ever use one of their devices)
- cmckn 4y agoI kind of understand this from an e-waste angle, but why (as a consumer) do I care if different phones use the same cable? I only have one phone. Even if I get a new phone every year, unless I’m switching back and forth between iPhones and Androids, I’m not having to buy new cables. If I go to a public place, and need to plug my phone in, I can already do that regardless of the connector on the phone end. If a friend is over and they need a phone charger, there’s only two possible needs, and I’ve already filled them. Apple charges license fees on Lightning, but I can already buy a nice third party cable for like $10. Why is this so important as to require a large scale device maker to redesign their entire product line, and make millions of existing cables obsolete? Genuinely interested in the reasoning behind this, what problems is it solving?
- pkulak 4y agoDo you own a tablet and a laptop, by chance? Maybe have 3 other family members, each with some combination of said three devices? That can quickly become a lot of household chargers if they are all different.
- Aerroon 4y agoBut the problem will still be exactly the same, because not all USB-C cables are created equal. We've basically set in stone a standard that is so varied that the standardization means nothing. And that's before you get into any component actually wearing out and giving you degraded performance on the device or cable.
- mort96 4y agoBut you can get an USB-C power supply and cable which can charge all of your USB-C devices.
- pkulak 4y agoThat hasn't been my experience. I have a bunch of 30w USB-C chargers that charge everything in my house. They are built in to my wall outlets and support (at least) 5v, 9v and 15v. I don't know where you're getting this idea that the standard is "so varied that the standardization means nothing". Those three profiles are enough for me. If I buy a 100W laptop, I may need one more charger, but that's just because I chose not to pay to have 100W available everywhere. It seems reasonable that a tiny phone charger won't work so great on a gaming laptop. EDIT: Guess I'm not allowed to reply to sagarm? That's annoying. But yeah, it's the Leviton one. I love it. Cleans up so many ugly wall warts.
- theptip 4y agoSo every upgrading iPhone user in the world needs to discard every single charging device they own, including expensive multi-device chargers like phone+watch. In the short-term this clearly produces _more_ e-waste. I wonder if anyone made an estimate of the break-even time here. One year? Ten? Will everyone be discarding their chargers and switching to wireless before break-even is achieved? How much money does it cost for the USB-D spec to get approved by the EU if/when that is released? (How much did the USB-C industry groups spend on lobbying to get this done)? This seems like a much less significant concern but I am curious what order of magnitude we are dealing with here. This legislation would have been great twenty years ago when there were lots of proprietary plugs on phones, but it seems much less substantial of an issue now in my experience.
- metalliqaz 4y agoNo reason to toss everything until your current phone is no longer used. And Apple isn't exactly shy about changing their connectors, so such might already be the case for upcoming phones. In any case, I'm pretty sure Apple will go to to full wireless before long.
- theptip 4y agoRight, like I said, every _upgrading_ user needs to replace.
- kstenerud 4y agoAlright, so before more folks freak out even more at this, there are a number of knee-jerk reactions that could be mitigated by reading up on this a bit before tossing thunderbolts. The main reasoning for this is to cut down on waste from incompatible chargers. This will bring charging more in line with other standardized products such as AC power cords, twisted pair networking, SD cards, M.2 SSDs, and all of those wonderful things that come from standards that everyone follows. Can no one continue to sell charging products for stuff that's already out there? Obviously you can continue to support existing stuff. This rule applies to power drawing products, not the chargers (products sold in 2024 must charge from USB-C, but you can continue selling non-USB-C chargers for older stuff already in consumer hands). Will it stop innovation? Of course not. New innovations can be brought forth in the same way they are with the other standards mentioned above: developed in a harmonised manner, respecting the objectives of full interoperability (in this case led by the USB-IF organisation). Is USB-C a complicated standard? Yep, but then again most companies manage to produce working and interoperable stuff just fine. Are there companies that break the standard? Yes of course - there are always bad actors and careless implementations. But consumer laws will prevent them from selling their crap in the European market. This is what standards enforcement is for (the CE marking, for example). Are HNers going to look for extreme and unlikely cases and anecdata to ride their hobby horses on this? It wouldn't be HN without it!
- theptip 4y agoI think your analogy isn’t right. None of those standards are mandatory. Would M.2 have come out when it did if you needed to change the law to permit it to be used over SATA? USB-C is already a standard just like all your other examples. This law forbids using other standards. > New innovations can be brought forth in the same way they are with the other standards mentioned above: developed in a harmonised manner I think you are confused about how consumer product innovation happens in the real world. You don’t form a committee and convince them that your new product is better. You bring something new to market and if it succeeds, you make money and gain market share; like Apple did when they brought out Lightning. Even if you are building a new standard like M.2, you are still competing with other standards, all of which can be chosen by your customers as they deem appropriate. By definition it is now harder to innovate on charging cables simply because you can’t try something new. It is perfectly fine to say “I don’t think we need to prioritize innovation in this sector any more; eWaste is more important than innovation”. I wouldn’t even argue with that claim in the short term. But it’s not credible to deny that this will have a negative effect on innovation. That is always the impact of regulation like this. If nothing else, startups are now forbidden from experimenting with this variable.
- mlindner 4y agoImagine they had made this dumb decision back when Micro USB was the standard. We would have never gotten anything better than Micro USB. Governments shouldn't be in the market of mandating that a specific technical standards must be used as it freezes innovation. Also purely in terms of usability, the Apple thunderbolt plug is easier to clean and less error prone on insertion as it self-centers.
- samzub 4y agoIt looks like they did at the time : https://www.engadget.com/2010-12-29-european-standardization-bodies-formalize-micro-usb-cellphone-ch.html?guccounter=1&guce_referrer=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuZ29vZ2xlLmNvbS8&guce_referrer_sig=AQAAANvj0L1eIxdN2UTp0Vz-fuqYEsN-vcv1N0G6TLR4zuZe4GyX1-7uRNhItuJmH9EaUskRp4c2ae5UCuScSb5dDgyt20jIO6uAhLIpnVZapD7BFNrNqolGkYNrXbON3qxulUS_vQDwMHeXIm_YamFpBV5iTtdUcF8EatRR2IqksF6S https://www.engadget.com/2010-12-29-european-standardization... I think standardization does not harm innovation. With more actors working on the same standard, it can evolve and get better while consumers are able to reuse hardware (here, phone chargers)
- mlindner 4y ago> I think standardization does not harm innovation. Standardization isn't the problem. Enforced standardization is the problem. Standardization is beneficial when done by the industry because it's a collaborative process where everyone works together to create standards that are mutually beneficial. When the government comes in and enforces an already created industry standard it becomes impossible to change or improve it. This has happened in many industries where things are now done "just because" as the law enforced a now very outdated standard. And no, the government doesn't create standards, they all come from industry originally.
- nayuki 4y agoThunderbolt has the same connector as USB-C. Surely you mean Apple Lightning.
- mlindner 4y ago
- option 4y agoBureaucrats gonna bureaucrat … What will happen when a company (outside EU for obvious reasons) introduces clearly superior standard? The EU will wait for its bureaucracy to catch up?
- dundarious 4y agoThere is no benefit to new standards coming out all the time in this domain. There is major benefit to standardizing for many years at a time.
- hda2 4y agoThe same was once believed in south Korea with regards to online commerce and ActiveX. Their law left their infrastructure rigid, less secure, and incompatible with the rest of the world when everyone moved on.
- dundarious 4y agoThe USB standard and the processes and groups governing it are quite unlike those for ActiveX.
- kmlx 4y ago> There is no benefit to new standards coming out all the time in this domain. actually, there are huge potential benefits for both the users and the company that launches them. faster charging, better ports, smarter cables etc etc etc
- macinjosh 4y agoI’d love to see Apple just leave the EU market or only offer a single old phone model with USB-C added. They have enough money to do it. Bullies like the EU should be stood up to.
- dedzycide 4y agoHuh? Why is EU the bad guy lol? Every single company except Apple switched to USB-C. Apple is just milking money out of their customers with overpriced Lightning cables. It's sad to see people defend this predatory behavior.
- bloppe 4y agoA lot of people saying "USB-C cables aren't even compatible with each other!" (Nintendo switch etc.) Guess what: that's exactly the problem this regulation is intended to solve. Fake USB-C cables like Nintendo's that have the right shape but do not adhere to spec should gradually disappear along with lightning cables. The regulation actually says that cables can no longer be bundled with the devices themselves, so Nintendo would stop sending you that fake cable with your switch, and you would just buy a real one to work with all your devices. Other people saying "what about innovation!?" That's fine. Let's say the USB consortium releases USB-D with input from Apple, Google, and many other stakeholders. The EU can set another deadline for newly released devices to adhere to the new version instead of the old one. The transition will involve a period of time where older devices are still on C and newer ones on D, which is totally compatible with the regulation and is necessary with or without regulation. It's ludicrous to think companies won't be able to "iterate": you would be crazy to go to market with any cable technology that isn't already very mature. Apple spent years designing lighting chargers because they knew that once they were released they'd be around for a long time (and they have been!)
- leadingthenet 4y ago> Let's say the USB consortium releases USB-D with input from Apple, Google, and many other stakeholders [...] If you have to make such an argument, you've already lost. Innovation, particularly disruptive and / or breakthrough innovation, does not happen by committee, no matter how many times over history people tried deluding themselves into thinking that it does. So no, it's not fine.
- tankenmate 4y agoThe directive is designed to make things easier for customers and the environment, not OEMs per se (even though there will be benefits for a number of companies).
- Bayart 4y agoStandards happen by committee. They're not disruptive and that's the point.
- onphonenow 4y agoI thought they'd made Micro-USB a standard. Funny to see them go to a "new" standard based on market I like lighting better (audio latency on lighting is fantastic) than USB-C.
- mig39 4y agoThe funny thing is that when this was first proposed by the EU, the connector they proposed was the USB-Mini connector. Imagine if that had been successful.
- onphonenow 4y agoYowks! Bullet dodged. I do remember a lot of companies had to include little adapters in the EU. So it'd be like lighting to some weird urb. Was this to the USB mini spec or Mico USB? I just ignored them and used the chargers and cables apple provided or my usb-a chargers
- Starlevel001 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- IvanK_net 4y agoI wish EU standardizes a single electric socket for all EU countries. Germany, France, Switzerland and Italy - each has a different socket (although German and French are very similar to each other). More here: https://www.plugsocketmuseum.nl/EuropePlugsSockets.html https://www.plugsocketmuseum.nl/EuropePlugsSockets.html
- fy20 4y agoCEE 7/7 plugs will fit into all sockets in the EU, except Italy (where they can be bent slightly to fit), Malta and Ireland. The only issue is grounding, but things like phone chargers wouldn't be grounded anyway.
- qalmakka 4y ago> where they can be bent slightly to fit Oh god please don't. Lots of Italian plugs are 10A only, and you would not get grounding by shoving an E/F combo plug into an L socket. This comes without saying that it would probably wreck the shutters in the plug and the contacts inside.
- qalmakka 4y agoPlease don't make me start complaining about the utter sheet stupidity of the Italian electrical plug (type L). It's pure and utter shite. 1. The C plug was fine. It doesn't carry more than 10A, and that is fine because it does not support grounding, so it would be unwise to use it for very powerful appliances, but it's well enough for bed lamps and phone chargers. 2. We Italians are famous for finding half-assed solutions to problems, so instead of developing a decent plug we just shoved a ground prong on the C type plug, so the 10A L connector was born. 3. Given that 10A plugs can only carry AFAIK a maximum of ~1500W, the 16A L connector was created as a chunkier version of the 10A one. 4. Given this whole nonsensical situation, companies catering to the EU single market largely ignore the L connector. Every single device sold in Italy either uses the C type ungrounded connector (Europlug) or the E/F "Schuko"-French combo connector. 5. Italian houses have either 10A plugs WITH 10A WIRING or 16A plugs (usually with combo 10/16A plugs, have I mentioned the two sockets are incompatible despite both being L?). This means that F "Schuko" adapters to L are a common fixture in Italian homes. 6. People buy devices with F plugs, which they then have to plug into their sockets using adapters. Adapters can either adapt to 16A plugs, or, unfortunately, to 10A, which is extremely dangerous given that Schuko is a 16A connector and 10A plugs often do not have the proper wire gauge for that. The fact that no Schuko adapter supports nominally over 1500W doesn't help either. Long story short: Italian homes are full of high power devices, such as microwave ovens, air friers, hairdryers, kettles, ... plugged in 10A wall sockets through adapters that do not allow more than 1500W of power. It's absolutely stupid and moronic. Yes they get hot. Yes they are a hazard. The solution would be to mandate everywhere the C/F/L combo socket in new buildings, but given that 16A wires are more expensive and the Italian government has been historically extremely pro-business, it will never happen.
- markstos 4y agoThe USB-C spec has 24 pins, making it considerably more complex than USB-A connections, which 4 pins. Only 4 of those 24 pins are used for power delivery. If all you need from the USB-C connection is charging, is OK to implement a 4 pin connection to keep the design simpler and cheaper?
- mmis1000 4y agoI think you also need the CC pin or you aren't going to have PD fast charging. The pin is required to handshake a higher Voltage and Current outside of standard 5C1A. And that literally exists. Most charge wire don't have full 24 line. (Unless it is specifically marked as USB3 compatible)
- danhor 4y agoFirst of all, 8 pins are used for power delivery for just VBUS & GND. Furthermore, you need the two CC pins or otherwise you won't get any voltage from USB-C chargers. USB 2.0 data pins are needed for backward compatible charging (otherwise a compliant device could only pull 500mA from a USB-A to C cable). The spec defines such a receptacle connector for USB 2.0-only support (also including the two sideband channels, but that's only 2 out of 16 pins, so probably not noticeably more expensive).
- kashyapc 4y agoUSB-C for laptop power ports seems to be incredibly flaky. :-( Let me share my ongoing horror story (excuse the verbosity): I've got a barely 3-months old Lenovo X1 Carbon (Gen-9) work laptop. A week ago I noticed the battery draining while the power cord is plugged in! Nothing worked: reset via the pinhole at the back, trying out different chargers, BIOS update, charging while the OS (Linux) is shut down, "to eliminate 'rogue' applications". The battery just doesn't charge. We've got premium support, so a Lenovo technician came two days later and replaced the motherboard. Great! The root cause: USB-C power port got short-circuited somehow. "This is a common problem with USB-C for power ports; I go around replacing 2 motherboards a week," the technician said. Now, the laptop's new motherboard worked fine for a week ... and I woke up this morning to notice the laptop's battery not charging at all (yes, again!), while the power cord is plugged in. I call up Lenovo, and the support guy confirms: "the power port seems to be short-circuited again, this time let's replace both the motherboard and also the power adapter". FFS, tomorrow morning I have long-distance travel, and I'm left with this bloody brick. Speak of timing. I want to think this is just plain bad luck, but the Lenovo support forums are full of similar problems, and two other colleagues independently confirmed the same issue. The Lenovo technician blamed this on USB-C. I wish they retained the more robust rectangular power port; but they're phasing them out to comply with EU regulation.
- helmholtz 4y agoTo me, the ideal solution is something that Apple had for ages, and now them and Microsoft both have. Magsafe. Use a nice, robust, safe laptop charger for most of your workdays, when things are routine and you have control over the environment. Then, if you're going to travel, and need to be ultralight, you carry your GaN compact, high-power travel power adapter with USB-C so you have one charger and one cable for all the things. I don't see why we have to give up magsafe for USB-C when we can have both.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- fuzzybear3965 4y agoIt seems that USB-C for _Lenovo_ laptop power ports seems to be incredibly flaky. I have 2 year-old HP Spectre x360 and a new Framework and I've had no problems with charging either of them from a number of different USB-C cables, wall adapters, and even a power delivery monitor (Dell U2520D).
- superb-owl 4y agoI currently own several USB-C devices (Laptop, phone, Remarkable, Switch, portable monitor) and I can't tell you how nice it is to only have to bring a single charger with me when I travel. The biggest thing holding me back from getting an iPhone is breaking this pattern.
- cromka 4y ago> The biggest thing holding me back from getting an iPhone is breaking this pattern. You wouldn't real this patter with an iPhone: you can still use the same charger, with Lightning <> USB-C cable. In fact, this is the official cable you get these days with new models.
- saiya-jin 4y agoYeah but thats another item to worry about, carry around, constantly or you are royally screwed. Definitely a drawback for Apple in 2022 if you are like OP or me. I was deciding between iphone 13 pro max and samsung s22 ultra few months back to have best possible camera that is always in the pocket. For somebody not in their ecosystem Apple connectors are a massive drawback and one of the reasons I decided against iphone.
- binarynate 4y agoAs an American, it's strange to see people applaud such overreaching regulation that will stifle innovation. This really underscores and makes me appreciate the differing regulatory philosophies between the EU and the US.
- binarynate 4y agoAlso reminds me of this Paul Graham tweet: https://twitter.com/paulg/status/1231699385525903360 https://twitter.com/paulg/status/1231699385525903360
- phabricator 4y agoAs an American, I'm surprised to see so much lip service paid to reducing waste in our country and then describing a universal plug as "overreaching regulation that will stifle innovation." Want to roll back the styrofoam ban too? Lots of new innovative (and greener) packaging resulted. (you could have just edited your first reply to include the appeal to authority)
- binarynate 4y agoThe plug itself its fine, it's the government mandating that it's illegal to use alternatives that's overreaching. I believe people should have the choice to decide and try better alternatives. That's how innovations are made. > Want to roll back the styrofoam ban too? That's different because it bans one thing rather than declaring a single material as the only legal one. A better analogy would be if a state passed a law declaring cardboard as the only legal packing material and outlawing everything else. Also, the styrofoam ban is a state law, not a federal law. I don't personally feel strongly about a styrofoam ban, but if your state wants to try that, that's fine with me. > (you could have just edited your first reply to include the appeal to authority) Who cares?
- jwilk 4y agoArchived copy without GDPR nag screen: https://web.archive.org/web/20220607105048/https://www.engadget.com/eu-reaches-deal-to-make-usb-c-a-common-charger-for-most-electronic-devices-104605067.html https://web.archive.org/web/20220607105048/https://www.engad...
- stevenalowe 4y ago“EU reaches deal” is misleading. “EU politicians made a deal over the objections of manufacturers” would be more accurate. What happens when your awesome new product won’t work with mere usb-c? You get to lobby politicians for a decade to update the standard This is a destructive decision that unfortunately will effectively bury evidence against it, ie all the things that won’t happen because of it
- bencollier49 4y agoThis was already done once for micro-USB 12 years ago: https://www.wired.com/2010/08/europe-univeral-phone-charger/ https://www.wired.com/2010/08/europe-univeral-phone-charger/
- DocTomoe 4y agoComing from the same European Union in which virtually every single member state has different wall sockets. This does not inspire confidence.
- akrymski 4y agoThis will finally make me seriously consider moving back to iPhones. I'm simply not willing to give up being able to charge my Android phone, M1 laptop, headphones, vape, shaver, oculus, etc with the same cable. I travel with 1 cable. It's life changing.
- ponow 4y agoI don't accept the right of governments to intervene in what I and a seller agree to transact. It's an inalienable right where people care about such things. Definitely not in the EU. If you have a problem with pollution, then properly cost that pollution on an even basis, instead of picking and choosing deep pockets and other politically palatable targets. Man, the 2nd amendment is there for a reason.
- enkid 4y agoThe second amendment has absolutely nothing to do with this. This is the EU and the second amendment is about "bearing arms," not selling electronic equipment.
- ponow 4y agoYes, it does: an armed populace is harder to push around.
- ponow 4y agoAlso, that isn't my main point, about the (lack of) justice of such action by the EU. I am actually annoyed by incompatible cabling, but understand that the remedy is almost always worse than the disease, so reserve intervention to clear natural rights violations. The EU is an inadequate alternative to Consumer Reports, product reviews, and experience. Also, not everyone has the same values, so the EU is picking priorities for us, which is immoral.
- Melatonic 4y agoFINALLY
- cannabis_sam 4y agoI would gladly pay extra to get lighting and magsafe connectors on my devices, but I guess that this stupid legislation will force me to use the substandard usb connectors.
- INTPenis 4y agoIt's good, but also worth mentioning that they're just now proposing to end the subventioned airplane fuel, and in that proposal they still want an exception for private business aircraft. Keep the pressure on your EU MEP.
- midasuni 4y agoI’d have preferred the requirement to be something that can be implemented with no parents or other controls. Invent lightning v2, great, you can use it as soon as the requirements for competitors to implement it are lodged in the appropriate place.
- kanetw 4y agoAs a user, I liked USB-C. Until I had to implement this ridiculously overcomplicated garbage. To be spec-conform, you need at least 1 IC. You can theoretically hack a solution together with some resistors, but it's not spec conform. If you need the high-speed lanes, add a mux/redriver to un-flip it. If you want power delivery (>15W), you need a PD controller and port protection (or a user will fry your data lines when they unplug the connector and put 20V on the data pins). 2 ICs right there, and one of them is basically a microcontroller, so you need to deal with more programming. If you want alternate mode, you need to implement the entire PD stack and a redriver/mux. That's 2-3 ICs right there that have to work together (so usually a single vendor). And not all of them support alt mode. Which, ok, fine. I'm not building a cost optimized product, I just want it to work well. Except literally none of the ICs are available. Because USB-C requires ICs for everything, it's all sold out (or total garbage that's not worth designing into a product, or requires vendor support to design the firmware, or or or).
- danhor 4y agoBut the two CC line resistors are spec-conform? That's how 5V sinks are supposed to work. I agree that the whole USB PD stack is way over complicated, I still don't get why the electrical layer and the on-the-wire protocol is so complex. Wouldn't a 3.3 V bidir UART with a CRC at the end do a fine job?
- kanetw 4y agoWithout CC line sensing, you don't know how much current you're allowed to draw. Screenshot from the standard: https://i.kane.cx/EI4HtM https://i.kane.cx/EI4HtM Specifically, the sink has to detect vRd to determine how much current it can actually draw. E: sorry, to clarify: 2 resistors is fine, but you also need line sensing. So that's at least a few comparators or an ADC or whatever. Or a dedicated IC.
- danhor 4y agoAh, the good 'ol legacy USB issue (for anything under 1.5A). The standard provides a way for simple devices (page 218, PSD), to just draw up to 500mA [0]. But TBH, legacy USB charging is such a mess, I'd just always assume 1.5A and hope for the best. (for USB 3.0 900mA you at least need a USB Device to detect it, I'm not sure if a 3.0 device is needed). [0]: 500mA in default current and the other options provide more current. EDIT: Mmh, you still need to detect above vRa voltage in "AttachWait.SNK", but you can assume default USB Current after that without specifically detecting it. I think no one cares about vRa. Still better than USB 2.0 (where without being a USB device you could only pull 100mA) or not much different than USB BC for DCPs (detect 200 Ω or smaller resistor between D+ and D-).
- WatchDog 4y agoDoes anyone have more information about how this is enforced, and how non-compliance is penalized? Can a manufacturer be non-compliant and pay a per-device penalty?
- derelicto 4y agoThis is an amazing move by the EU that could benefit the entire world. Something that in the US would have been perceived as “stifling innovation and big government”.
- briandear 4y agoWhy should the government be involved in this?
- perilunar 4y agoThere's a lot of Apple hate here. It's worth remembering that 1) Apple was the first PC company to standardise on USB-A, and 2) Apple iPhone and iPad chargers have always had USB-A sockets until the recent change to USB-C — the chargers have always used non-proprietary sockets; only the cables were different. (Some of The early iPod chargers had a Firewire 400 socket.)
- docmars 4y agoI'm curious what this would mean for OnePlus who is completely blowing away the competition in charging speeds, and doing it safely.
- wbsss4412 4y agoCreating standards is a fundamental part of what governments do, and have done forever. We take for granted things like common definitions for weights and measures, imagine if “the market” could just decide it didn’t want to use the metric system anymore and invented whatever system it felt like to weigh things. Innovation has its place, but some things just need to be reliable and well understood so we can move on in our lives and focus on building on top of what’s already established.
- fennecfoxy 4y agoI have never, not once, replaced a USB C cable. To charge my phone (S21 Ultra) I still use the fat (high amps) cable that came with my Oneplus 6T! Besides the fact that I have a drawer full of usb C cables that have come with other products, I have enough to last me into retirement pretty much. Whereas every single person I've known who's owned an Apple product has replaced their cable multiple times (heatshrink and or cable coming apart from connector) and they used to get charged $50 for the privilege of buying a replacement!