33 ms·
Twitch will ban users for 'severe misconduct' that occurs away from its site
- salawat 6y agoI'm still waiting for the inevitable shitstorm that'll ensue when someone "innovates" a Relationship Management platform that is effectively a Shunning-as-a-Service (Read: Online Presence Surveillance and Data Broker interface) offering and suddenly discovers they've re-invented corporate organized blacklisting, which has been illegal for years. Yes, technically only for employment purposes, but the practice is generally abhored wherever it rears it's ugly head outside of that that comes down to just defending yourself from bad actors, where bad actors is defined as "Those seeking to cause direct harm for financial or other gain." Things that aren't just able to be chocked up to "having a controversial viewpoint". I really wish people would wake up to the fact that right now, computing is still in its "enumerative innovation" phase where the computer will get thrown at every human problem under the sun to see what sticks, or what causes complete outrage and cannot be allowed.
- monkeybutton 6y ago>corporate organized blacklisting, which has been illegal for years. Does that mean Uber and Lyft sharing lists of drivers that have been banned from their platforms is illegal?
- trutannus 6y agoUber and Lyft drivers are technically external contractors. Not employees. As far ask I know, there's no law about sharing bad contractors names.
- letitbeirie 6y agoDepends why they've been banned, probably. Corporate blacklisting is illegal, but there have been substantial carve-outs in the name of safety. DISA [1] is a great example of this - fail a drug test and you're banned from about 10% of the US economy for 7 years. [1] https://disa.com/why-disa https://disa.com/why-disa
- Nadya 6y ago>I'm still waiting for the inevitable shitstorm that'll ensue when someone "innovates" a Relationship Management platform that is effectively a Shunning-as-a-Service This had existed, for Twitter at least. Apparently it shut down last year. I had ended up on several blocklists or at least one commonly shared once because I'm blocked by a good 20-30% of Twitter's blue checkmarked journalists that I've never once interacted with or Tweeted at before. https://blocktogether.org/ https://blocktogether.org/ I could easily see being randomly blacklisted/blocked with no real understanding as to why you are blocked other than some well-connected person that you peeved off once had added to a shared blacklist. This likely already happens.
- makomk 6y agoIt's funny you should mention that. A few years back, the operation of the shared Twitter ban list used by the Twitter left was, ah, slightly disrupted by the fact that it was being run by a British person who thought the Data Protection Act didn't apply to them and eventually received a polite official letter pointing out how completely wrong they are. (For context, their justification for why it didn't apply were that they were storing the data on a US service which had no contractual obligation to protect the data, and the list contained just about every kind of information categorized as sensitive under the DPA in the comments field... sexual orientation, political affiliation, all sorts.) Anyway, I remember pointing out at the time that the Data Protection Act had been used to shut down corporate blacklisting efforts run by people with very good lawyers and much cleverer attempted loopholes than theirs, and that their chances of somehow finding a loophole where everyone else had failed were basically zero.
- post_break 6y agoTwitch doesn't enforce their own rules. It's the reason why Amouranth is the highest paid female streamer.
- challengly 6y agoWhat rule is she breaking?
- gamblor956 6y agoShe frequently violates Twitch's clothing rules, and her account has been suspended many times as a result of Twitch enforcing its rules.
- gamblor956 6y agoMys statement was not a value judgement, it was statement of what actually happened. Twitch has suspended her several times for what it viewed as rule-breaking. Twitch modified its rules several times, and she kept breaking the less restrictive rules, until Twitch finally created the NSFW category. If you have an issue with this, take it up with Twitch for having unnecessarily restrict rules.
- madamelic 6y agoI don't believe she is breaking any rules. Having seen some of her streams, her behavior belongs more on a porn cam site than Twitch. She constantly is like "Stop objectifying me, I am just playing video games" but she wears extremely sexualized clothing, bends over into the camera and from seeing her streams multiple times, seems to only play dance games (if you see where this is going.) She isn't breaking any rules but Jesus Christ she is a really bad look for the platform. I have nothing wrong with sexualization. Heck, Twitch should add an 18+ category. Do it. But you can't have people like Amo and say you prohibit sexual content. I would not feel at all comfortable watching her streams at work if that's a metric. Go to 43m57 seconds in this video: https://www.twitch.tv/videos/972822254 https://www.twitch.tv/videos/972822254 (Partial nudity, sexualized behavior). "Don't mind me, innocently shaking my protein shake in my bra on camera" 1h05m34s: "Don't mind me doing splits and checking that the camera is well-positioned" Oh and she is wearing a sports bra for a sit-down gaming stream, then at ~5h she moves her stream to a kiddie pool wearing a pretty loose bikini top. I mean, absolutely get that money. She is absolutely in her rights to do this and I genuinely support her, but you can't have her on the same platform as streamers like SodaPoppin getting scared for showing a dildo on camera.
- cik 6y agoIs there any doubt that we've entered the era of approved, or not free speech. 'Severe misconduct' today means racist behaviour, perhaps tomorrow it means support for the NRA, or anti-environmental behaviour. The thought police have finally invaded ever part of society.
- vsareto 6y agoCompanies were already willing to fire you for posting racist stuff before Twitch made this decision.
- secondcoming 6y agoPosting racist stuff just means you're stupid and the company made a mistake in hiring you.
- zionic 6y agoWe're already way beyond that. I saw someone get fired because their wife tweeted something that wasn't PC 10 years ago and a coworker found it.
- dimgl 6y agoThe issue with this sentiment is that while some things are blatantly racist, there are other things that aren't so black and white. This is one of those slippery slopes where if left unchecked, anything and everything will be considered racist. Also, you don't have to have good morals or even be intelligent to be good at your job. Some people are fantastic at their job, but are pretty damn "stupid" as you put it.
- TameAntelope 6y agoIsn't this slippery slope argument technically a logical fallacy? Wouldn't we just not accept the unacceptable change?
- 6y ago
- redm 6y ago"The company said users will be able to report such behaviors but it may also investigate cases proactively, for instance if there is a verified news report that a user has been arrested." So we've arrived at "innocent until accused" instead of "innocent until proven guilty"? And if proven guilty, they will both be punished under the law, and again by companies like Twitch? If proven innocent will they be restored? What a slippery slope. It's hard to argue with the goal of removing sexual predators or terrorists, but the reality is these are subjective standards being applied. It's just as toxic as cancel culture. :/
- JumpCrisscross 6y ago> we've arrived at "innocent until accused" instead of "innocent until proven guilty" For a platform like Twitch, this is fine. They have a brand. They’re akin to a modern television channel, and television has always been this ruthless. There are lots of other streaming sites.
- fX0rObfoMN4 6y agoIf someone who stream on Twitch does something bad off of Twitch, would people blame Twitch for that? I know I wouldn't.
- Analemma_ 6y agoPeople can, and do. At any given moment you can probably find at least one hashtag campaign excoriating Twitch for having not banned some streamer for something for other.
- beej71 6y agoDepends on what they did. If Twitch lets, say, the Unibomber stream video, it looks bad to advertisers (Twitch's customers). They don't want to be associated with that. It all makes sense when you look at it from a money angle rather than an ethical angle.
- rodgerd 6y agoThe context is that the last six months or so have been a shitstorm of prominent streamers caught in various forms of grooming, sexual assault, and so on. Much of this has happened off-Twitch, but it's certainly affected the reputation of Twitch to be associate with such. It's no different to the owners of M:TG banning people for serious misconduct, for example.
- challengly 6y agoAre corporations the new government? New form of legal or justice system?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dgellow 6y agoThat's of course a stretch, no corporations aren't governments and aren't a new form of legal system. They are still subject to regulation. But I get your sentiment. I see an interesting point here: corporations like Twitch, while registered in a specific country (here the US) have a global reach. But their culture and set of rules is generally uniform, and heavily influenced by the country the company is from. Twitch is a US company, their way to analyze cultural/moral issues is with an American point of view and framing, but they are applied globally. In some ways that extends the reach of US systems in a way even the US government cannot do, unless Twitch starts to create versions of their platform siloed by country.
- alacombe 6y ago> They are still subject to regulation Not according to Section 230.
- Jonnax 6y agoI presume you're unfamiliar with the East India Company.
- dporter 6y ago> The company said users will be able to report such behaviors but it may also investigate cases proactively, for instance if there is a verified news report that a user has been arrested. > ... > The new standards will apply even if the target of the offline behaviors is not a Twitch user or if the perpetrator was not a user when they committed the acts. Perpetrators would also be banned from registering a Twitch account, it said. > Twitch said it would take action only when there was evidence, such as screen shots, videos of off-Twitch behavior or police filings, verified by its internal team or third-party investigators. Users who submit a large amount of frivolous reports will face suspension. If you are accused of a crime you will be banned from Twitch?
- LinuxBender 6y agoQuite a few Twitch and Youtube streamers are moving to their own platform. I think the only thing holding them back was finding a way for people to make payments or to have advertising. Apparently people are finding ways around this obstacle?
- Beached 6y agosponsored content, their own advertisements in their content, and patreon?
- jrockway 6y agoI think that part is easy, but making the tech stack affordable is the problem. Serving a 5Mbps stream to 10,000 users for 8 hours a day is 120TB of data, and if you do the naive thing and just use AWS for that, you're looking at egress costs in the range of $180,000 per month (that's 5 cents per gigabyte). So you need some specialized solution, and that spirals into being a hard problem for content creators to solve. Having said that, you can certainly build a CDN that pays less than $200k/month in transit costs (the ISP I worked at charged $1000/month for 10Gbps IP transit) -- obviously that's not what it costs Twitch to provide the service. But then you start hiring software engineers and network engineers to build all that, maybe take some VC funding because you have an actual business model and tech stack now, maybe sign some advertising deals to placate your board and attract more streamers that want revenue share, and then the advertisers start being upset about content, and you create a content policing team, and boom! You're Twitch! You ban someone, the Internet hates you, and all you have to show for it is a 8 million dollar per month AWS bill :) Thought long and hard about how to build an open source tech stack for streaming video and somehow monetize it, and it always seemed like either I would become Twitch, or I'd just be UNIX helpdesk for some gamers with million dollar AWS bills. Didn't do it, but I wish those who are doing it the best of luck.
- ipaddr 6y agoPeople are learning to start on youtube and twitch but if you want to make money you have to transfer your audience over.
- klmadfejno 6y agoBeing shunned is the oldest, most effective social strategy for enforcing conformance that's worked for thousands of years. It's lost a lot of teeth recently as everyone can now find supportive communities for whatever dumb ass opinions they come to support and a lack of need for communal support to literally survive. I tend not to buy into slippery slope arguments. I'm not going to bat an eye here.
- crisdux 6y agoMy employer can fire me for severe misconduct that occurs away from the office. Is that any different? Isn't this normal at most companies?
- elric 6y agoDepends on where in the world you live. Also depends on the kind of misconduct. In general I'm of a mind that it isn't any of my employer's business what I get up to when I'm off the clock. If they can define "misconduct" in a sensible way they're probably free to add it to my employment contract, in which case I can decide for myself whether or not to work for them. Anything less is arbitrary nonsense and will likely result in legal action.
- kstrauser 6y agoThere's such a huge grey area, though. On one extreme: I work at a desk job and it'd be insane for my employer to fire me for getting a speeding ticket doing 70 in a 65 zone. On the other: if I were shown in a CNN video carrying a swastika flag in a parade, I absolutely 100% expect I'd be jobless by the time I got home. I wouldn't pause for a moment at an employment contract that says the latter violates their rules.
- kevinpet 6y agoNot in California. Political activity off the clock is legally protected. Because it isn't ever actually carrying a swastika flag. It's supporting the opposite side of a current contentious issue like abortion.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoMaking a hostile environment at work probably isn't protected, though, and that's what carrying a swastika flag on national television will make. As soon as I know a coworker is running about carrying a swastika flag, I can never feel safe around that coworker again.
- voldacar 6y agoThe infantile hyper-moralization of online discourse, on social media but also elsewhere, is starting to get really, really tiring. Is there any solution other than total anonymity, keeping one's online and IRL personae hermetically sealed off from one another? What do you all think? Is this atmosphere here to stay or do you expect the winds of culture to shift anytime soon?
- Bud 6y agoPrivate companies reacting to hate crimes is "infantile", now? Banning people for making credible threats of mass violence is "infantile"? No it's not. And you should retract that.
- banmyip 6y agoIf they were credible threats you think we might have seen, oh, any "mass violence" at all. (cue "Jan 6th was mass violence)
- falcolas 6y agoHow about we do something silly like letting the police and justice system handle things like "credible threats of mass violence" and "hate crimes", since both are fairly illegal, at least in the US.
- Bud 6y agoHow about we also defend the rights of people and companies to react in the way they see fit, to such actions, as well. As an aside, our police, to put it rather mildly, have historically sucked, in regard to such issues. And they suck right now, too. Badly. For hints on this, tune in to the Derek Chauvin trial, now in progress. Our "justice system" doesn't have a great record, either.
- falcolas 6y agoHistory tells us quite clearly that extra-legal justice systems as a response to even some of the worst justice systems creates more problems, not fewer. So no we shouldn't, to use your phrasing, react as we see fit. That's how humanity has historically justified lynching.
- Aerroon 6y agoImagine if ISPs had rules like this. Oh, somebody from your company said or did something we don't like? We will suspend services for your company to combat this behavior.
- falcolas 6y agoGood to know what witch-hunt enabling policies are still in full force. I was getting a bit worried there with all this talk of free-speech and forgiveness. Burn them all! /s
- ronsor 6y agoBecause this is always brought up, I will remark that I believe what the majority of commenters likely mean by free speech is the principle itself, and not the restrictions imposed on the government by the First Amendment. First and foremost, free speech is a moral principle. Secondly, while private companies can do what they want, that does not mean they should. Private companies like Apple can avoid taxes, yet many here would not say they should. Morals and ethics are often divorced from what the law requires.
- tssva 6y agoFree speech is several principles. One is that you should be free to express yourself. Another is that others should not be able to coerce you into forced speech. Many commenters on HN like to forget that 2nd part because most of their 'solutions" to the first principle violate the 2nd.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y agoSo if I say bad things on Twitch OR ELSEWHERE, that this is “their speech”? I disagree, but what you are saying is Twitch is a publisher, not a platform? If Twitch can’t be compelled to publish my unpopular comments, then any comments they do publish should be legally theirs, and if illegal be held liable for them? Something tells me you aren’t on board anymore. Are you trying to have it all-the-ways? That Citizens United is wrong and companies don’t have free speech, but also that companies don’t need to recognize free speech but can retain their platform status (when convenient), then also Citizen’s United is right and companies have any speech they want if it means restricting yours? Quick question... socially, what do we do when I’m banned from Twitch for saying something NOT ON TWITCH that was at the time unpopular but eventually proven correct? Or similarly let’s say I quote the CDC website but am banned because the data is unpopular. Or lastly I quote something that was true at the time according to “official sources” (sarcasm detectable) but later incorrect and I’m retro actively banned? Instead of all this shifting convenience and liquid enforceability... maybe we just stick to free speech and take the small bad with the giant good? Seems morally just and logically reasonable to me.
- HanayamaTriplet 6y ago
- benja123 6y agoI have a hard time with this. Don’t get me wrong overall I am for banning terrorists, pedophiles etc. from services like twitch, but, it needs to be done in a smart way. The concerns I have around this is that 1. It’s not clear where you draw the line of what counts as severe misconduct 2. What happens if someone did something that counts as severe misconduct five years ago and today they are a completely different person. Will services like twitch take this into account when deciding whether someone should be banned? 3. How easy will it be for people to abuse this system and get innocent people they don’t like banned from using services like Twitch. Will they put in place a proper appeal process or will it be similar to the appeal processes we see in other big companies in which there is no one you can actually speak to. Banning people from a service is an often necessary but extreme action that needs to be done with care. When it is for something that someone did while using your system it is easier to be confident that the ban is justified. Banning people for actions outside of your system is really uncharted territory so it will be interesting to see how this plays out and to see how many false positives there are.
- mrguyorama 6y agoSpecifically, when it comes to entertainment and mass market stuff like this, the rules have always been crystal clear: 1. Make us money. Make us so much goddamned money. If you don't, we'll probably just get rid of you at some point 2. Don't embarrass us, cost us money, waste our resources, bring media scrutiny upon us, make literally any small part of our life even a little bit more difficult, or screw with us. Rule 2 is a very flexible scale that depends on rule 1. Wasn't there that streamer that abused her cat live on stream and she still is a golden child of the platform?
- benja123 6y agoI agree about rule number 2 although that has seemed to have changed a bit more recently with the banning of Trump and other extremely popular right wing social media users from multiple platforms
- ipaddr 6y ago#3 is the interesting outcome. Many valid and not valid complaints will be made. Twitch will pick favourites and ban. Things will be unfair. Good people will leave and unwanted people will find a way to stay under new names. Revenge clans will be organized. Sounds ugly.
- Areibman 6y agoIt's strange to see a company that once prided itself on active engagement with its users to find product-market fit antagonize its content creators so much. And as a user, it gives me the perception that the platform is just plainly unfair. (Plus the platform is unusable without Adblock). Top streamers have been banned or lost partnerships for playing their own music[0], stating controversial political opinions[1][2], getting trolled by users who "snipe" streamers and shout vulgarities, or just accidentally showing movie clips with nudity [3]. From what I gather, the ban appeal process is byzantine and is heavily biased towards inaction. Oftentimes appeals are never even considered, or partnership staff plainly doesn't respond. The upsetting part is Twitch is such a great platform technology wise, and its competitors can't seem to recreate the same magic. I guess we're stuck with lousy moderation until the streaming fad dies down. [0] https://www.sportskeeda.com/esports/twitch-reportedly-suspends-guitarist-playing-music-the-hypocrisy-dmca https://www.sportskeeda.com/esports/twitch-reportedly-suspen... [1] https://dotesports.com/streaming/news/hasanabi-banned-from-twitch-after-saying-america-deserved-9-11 https://dotesports.com/streaming/news/hasanabi-banned-from-t... [2] https://win.gg/news/5496/destiny-loses-twitch-partnership-for-encouraging-violence https://win.gg/news/5496/destiny-loses-twitch-partnership-fo... [3] https://www.ginx.tv/en/twitch/vinesauce-banned-on-twitch-over-naked-hologram-girl-from-blade-runner https://www.ginx.tv/en/twitch/vinesauce-banned-on-twitch-ove...
- analognoise 6y agoIt's because those "creators" are absolutely replaceable - there's no reason not to simply jettison them if there's any issue. There's an army of people willing to try their hand at being a similar "creator", and the vacuum caused by the loss of one of these "creators" is so miniscule people will just watch the next available stream. The replacement cost is so low and with such low impact, you can save even more money by not spending someone's time to review the appeal.
- neaden 6y agoFirst link: DMCA problems, this is super common but Twitch is reacting to a very poorly written law. Second link: Someone got in trouble for saying "America Deserved 9/11" which is a bit beyond a controversial political opinion. Third link: Person advocated that people start shooting protestors, a literal call for violence once again beyond a controversial political opinion. Fourth Link: Played a game (not a movie) that included nudity. Twitch has pretty clear policy on that and while it wasn't intentional on the streamers part, not allowing nudity is a pretty standard thing. None of your links back up the idea that Twitch is cracking down on free speech.
- lgleason 6y agoI'd be fine with this if they would strip companies like this from having section 230 protections and allowed anybody to sue for liable for anything on their platform. The banning for conduct off the platform should be seen for what it is, namely discrimination that will not be applied equally to everyone. If you are a right wing person, the bar will be low for bans, but if you are an active Antifa type the bar for being banned with be much higher.
- mondoshawan 6y ago> "Twitch said it would rely more heavily on law enforcement in “off-service” cases and is partnering with an investigative law firm to support its internal team." So if a user becomes noteworthy, expect to have investigative checks periodically done by the agency? What an insane concept -- this is how we end up with corporate governance and unjust punishment without societal review by fiat, without review by our peers. Consider that Twitch is owned by Amazon. If Amazon were to start doing things like this, suddenly someone so accused can't walk into Whole Foods?
- mustbedreaming 6y agoYour point about corporate governance being a generally bad thing is valid, but I don’t think this case is anywhere near that. A “user” and a “streamer” are two different things. Anyone can create an account and be a viewer who consumes content on Twitch. That’s not the same as being a content creator who draws viewers to the platform and implicitly represents the brand. You can go scream racist nonsense in the town square and then quietly shop at Whole Foods. But if a Whole Foods employee was found screaming racist nonsense in the town square, Whole Foods might fire them for it, and they are well within their rights to do so. Obligatory “I know streamers aren’t employees.” Their relationship to Twitch is similar enough to that of an employee that the same logic applies.
- DarkByte8 6y agoIt is similar enough that they don't get any benefits for being employee just the responsibility of being employee. What a shit deal. The idea that any employee is representing the company is dumb in my opinion. The person that cleans Whole Foods toilets should not be considered a representing of the company. The only people that represent the company should be C-suits, VPs and other upper managers, not a mindless drone. And the concern is not about the guy who is screaming racist nonsense in the town square, it is about who judges what is racist nonsense and what is not.
- deft 6y agoInteresting, but this policy already exists. Nairo a top 10 Smash Bros competitor was banned after false accusations of pedophilia months ago. He remains banned to this day.
- pgsimp 6y agoTranslation: SJWs are in full control and can cancel you at any time.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- someonehere 6y agoHere come the deepfakes for streamers to be deplatformed by their rivals/competitors!
- sneak 6y agoPerhaps we should all stop donating free content to platforms operated by those that built an entire custom datacenter for the CIA to store its drone murder and torture videos in. I'm not sure how continuing to donate content to enrich such an organization can in any way be worth it, even if they do give you free bandwidth.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mlindner 6y agoDoes anyone know of any good software libraries for independent streaming? Say I wanted to set up a low res/low bandwidth video stream from my own website, how would I go about doing that?
- newbie789 6y agoComing from the perspective of someone that was an admin of a medium-large forum back in the vBulletin heyday of the early 2000s, I’m somewhat amused by people getting angry at moderation decisions. The rules were pretty clear: This is my website. I pay the bills and maintain it. Here are some clear rules that if you break them, you will be punished with a ban/suspension/shadow an/redirect to goatse upon login/etc. at my/the admin team’s discretion. I can also ban you if I don’t like you. Or if I think it’s funny, or really any other reason. I was happy, my mods and admins were happy and the users (aside from some banned grumps) were happy. This is literally how the internet has worked forever. There are users, mods and admins on websites. Twitch is a website. People getting into deep nuanced discussions about moral good and government over/underreach as an outlet for being angry at the mods never changes. Note: I am not affiliated with twitch, nor have I ever been a user.
- BitwiseFool 6y ago>medium-large forum That's the key. You were not operating a massive media platform with a significant marketshare that many people use to make a living with.
- ed25519FUUU 6y agoExactly. The difference is a platform that controls 0.001% of the market and a platform which controls 90% of the market.
- z3ncyberpunk 6y agothat is a risk the people using platforms to make money with should have taken into account
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gentleman11 6y agoIt’s not just some site when you have no credible alternative because it killed all the competition years ago. The network effects are too strong
- kodah 6y agoI had to type in this box more times than I'm willing to admit to produce something that didn't violate the guidelines. Let's examine why this is problematic: - This will absolutely be leveraged on anyone in a precarious position. It's their ultimate out. Minority groups, majority groups, it doesn't matter - you're in trouble and need a platform to tell your story? Not happening on Twitch. Expect more to sign on to this idea; it is the ultimate tool for cancel culture proponents. - Foreword: I am not making a constitutional argument. Private companies now own most of the highways we use for speech, much less widespread speech. Sure, Newspapers and mail can be argued, but there's plenty of examples where they had to tolerate nasty messages for some self-imposed access to speech principles. Secondarily, nobody used a newspaper to talk to their auntie, while Twitch isn't Facebook or Twitter self-expression is not limited to certain platforms. That is lost on tech companies. This new stage of American moralism is pretty tiring no matter what group or direction it comes from. I can't imagine staying in this country much longer.
- TameAntelope 6y agoI think it's an interesting consequence of accountability, that the people being held accountable tend to vocally dislike being held accountable, but don't want to say so for some reason. It'd honestly be pretty refreshing for a leader to come out and say, "I don't think my actions should be held against me like your actions should be held against you because I'm special/different." Insane, but refreshingly honest. For what it's worth, I'm increasingly with you re: leaving the US, for what basically amount to the opposite reason. I'm tired of people not being responsible for themselves, their actions, and the outcomes that happen beyond the first order consequences.
- kodah 6y agoI think people generally mention accountability when it suits them, specifically when it suits their group morals. Accountability to me is that the government teaches them a lesson, some company doesn't need to jump in line to punish them for me to feel satiated -- that job is done by the government. Moral communities are just that though, tiny groups that would like to exercise their power and worldliness on others in pursuit of their utopian society free from democracy and government oversight. Having come from a repressive religion, I have no argument against why this paradigm is flawed, but maybe it takes the eyes of someone who has lived that to see it.
- notyourday 6y agoThis is actually creating an opportunity for a reasonable competitor to show up - with Twitch deciding they are going to play "Internet police" their competitor does not actually need to be "Wild west", it simply needs to offer "We only police our service" while providing similar quality of experience.
- Ekaros 6y agoHave a clear set of rules. And apply those equally. I don't ask much, like if you stream outright porn on platform and that is banned, maybe you should stay banned... Or if someone gets a pass everyone should get a pass...
- ricardoplouis 6y ago> Live-streaming service Twitch will ban users for offenses such as hate-group membership or credible threats of mass violence that occur entirely away from the site, in a new approach to moderating the platform, the company said on Wednesday. Can't be part of a hate group or threaten violence no a mass scale. I believe the only reason that banning these two things are considered an infringement on free speech are because they are core to American ideals. If we viewed hate groups or mass violence with the same contempt we view something like child grooming for example then I don't think we would be having the free speech discussion, but here we are.
- Lammy 6y ago*Amazon will ban users from their Twitch property
- rajin444 6y agoIt would be much better if they stated they have sole discretion of who can use their site while adhering to the law. No other justifications needed. People get upset when these policies are put in place but selectively applied. Companies try to appear unbiased, but it's too lofty of a goal (for technical and ideological reasons). Why they are not straightforward about their policies probably has something to do with why google dropped "Don't be evil".
- omgwtfbbq 6y ago>How different is that from at-will employment though? You can be fired at any time and for more or less any non-federally-protected reason (and can quit any time too). That seems pretty uncontroversial in the US at least. Most Europeans would be horrified by this concept so I'm not sure it supports your argument.
- rootusrootus 6y ago> Most Europeans would be horrified by this concept But they'd be really happy to earn the same level of income.
- yoz-y 6y agoWhen speaking about SV tech salaries maybe. But for majority of people, most definitely not.
- rootusrootus 6y agoEven in the midwest, tech people earn a lot more in the US than in almost any European country. Sure, for the lower income levels it might be a different story, but I live in the HN bubble like everyone else here.
- gambiting 6y agoThat's a really shitty argument though. Would I be happy to earn $100k a year? Sure I would. Would I give up my 28 days of paid holidays per year, unlimited sick leave, year long maternity leave, free healthcare, free education for my children, and yes, 3 months of notice that gives me incredible amount of stability in my life for that higher pay? Absolutely not. At will employment is an abomination of the American employment system just like a lot of other things about that country. High salaries don't make up for it in the slightest.
- rootusrootus 6y agoI make a lot more than 100K, I have unlimited vacation, unlimited sick leave. Only 12 weeks of FMLA, so there's that. And healthcare isn't free anywhere in the world, just financed differently. I pay for my insurance from my paycheck, but the paycheck is so much larger that it works out fine. My deductible is zero, out-of-pocket maximum is zero, so it's not effectively much different than 'free' healthcare. I am well aware of how much Europeans hate America. It's readily apparent on HN.
- clarifier123 6y agoAfter reddit started banning people for upvoting the wrong things, this is a logical next step. Contrary to the popular belief, slippery slope isn't a logical fallacy. Anonymity is the only way to combat this. Make sure your online identity isn't connected to your real name. Ideally, you should have separate identities for each website. Using Tor or a VPN is also a good idea.
- Diederich 6y ago> After reddit started banning people for upvoting the wrong things As a daily reddit user, I wasn't aware of this: "Users who consistently upvote policy-breaking content within quarantined communities will receive automated warnings, followed by further consequences like a temporary or permanent suspension. We hope this will encourage healthier behavior across these communities." > Make sure your online identity isn't connected to your real name. Yeah, well, my userid here, on reddit, twitter, twitch, github.....is my last name, so I guess I'm stuck. (:
- oth001 6y agoIf you want to earn income via Twitch, Patreon, etc., you have to provide your real identity though, no?
- sudosysgen 6y ago>After reddit started banning people for upvoting the wrong things, this is a logical next step. Contrary to the popular belief, slippery slope isn't a logical fallacy. People might read this and think that people were banned for upvoting things that were insanely bigoted, or personal attacks. While I'm sure that was the case, the slope was indeed slippery, and reddit ended up banning people for upvoting posts such as "John Brown did nothing wrong" and "it is justifiable to kill slave-owners". Moderators that agreed that this was unreasonable then saw their subreddits (some fairly major) banned for advocating violations of reddit policy. All in order to score PR points and do some both-sidesisms. The actual ethical good didn't matter, it was all PR to Reddit.
- ct0 6y agoI was unaware that mods can see the users who upvote a post. That seams borderline too much power of for a basic reddit moderator.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- baud147258 6y agoso now you can go look for any controversial comment made by a streamer you dislike, on any platform and Twitch will gladly deplatform them, leaving them with the usual byzantine ban appeal process to get back on the platform?
- dmitrygr 6y agoYup, the usual debate of innocent-till-probven-guilty vs private-companies-wcan-do-what-they-want. I propose a simple solution: iff company owns > X% of the market (for some TBD value of X, maybe 80%), then it must follow the same laws as federal gvmnt (respect freedom of speech, proper due process, etc). Reasoning: if they own that much of the market, they may be unavoidable (like gvmnt) and thus must follow the same restrictions to make them palatable to the public.
- tonfreed 6y agoI don't have an issue with this in theory, but the problem with this kind of policy is that they never actually release a full set of rules to follow. I see a ton of breadtubers advocating for pedophilia and bestiality on Twitch itself sites, can guarantee those won't run afoul of the hidden rules. However, calling someone a simp is a bannable offense on Twitch now. Any company implementing this kind of rule now ultimately does it at the behest of a very loud and cuntish section of the internet that'll brigade any and all wrongthink. This will probably be the beginning of the end of Twitch, because the demands on good behavior are going to be completely unfollowable.
- madeofpalk 6y agoTwitch has a reasonably thorough "community guidelines", a few pages https://www.twitch.tv/p/en/legal/community-guidelines/ https://www.twitch.tv/p/en/legal/community-guidelines/
- DavidVoid 6y agoThey already have banned people for this kind of stuff -- as they should. The groomer and sexual abuser Ryan Haywood was permanently banned from the site when he tried to start a career on Twitch after he got fired from Rooster Teeth. That ban was certainly earned considering how much of terrible human being he is and how supplying him with an audience would likely lead to more abuse in the future.
- geraneum 6y agoThe point which is sometimes missing is that it does not matter if you believe a user (i.e. Donald Trump or anyone to whom these policies may apply) deserves to be banned or not. What matters IMO is that a certain individual lost access to a service or product based on a ToS (not the democratic law) of a company which may change at any time to reflect the corporation's interest (morally or otherwise). Also, these companies happen to intertwine with today's social fabric. There are no checks or balances on the amount of power these companies hold. Even if you believe, for example, Donald Trump deserved to be banned, you might think for yourself what will stop them to come for you next? Do you believe companies play a moral rule book? Imagine you lose access to your important email address, or your phone number (which is perhaps operated by a private corporation). Do you also have a podium in your house to fix it? Now you see where I am going with this. I don't want to take a side in a political argument. That's not the point here. With all that said, it's hard to not address the elephant in the room. Which is the "free market". Unfortunately, this is a difficult problem to solve which I don't have the expertise to propose a solution for. But what I can observe is that this phenomenon is not new and not exclusive to tech companies. Take banks, for example, you get a credit score that is shared between banks and you can be denied service. If you make insurance claims your premium may go up even if you switch providers. You can be denied coverage with a pre-existing condition. An airliner can deny you service based on a policy exclusive to them, a company abuses your private data, etc. In most of the instances I (an individual), have been denied service from a powerful minority and they decide to do so following their interest (fair or unfair). While there are a ton of arguments by different political, philosophical, and sociological views for these examples pro/against, I wonder if this problem can be solved in the current system without some fundamental changes/enhancements?
- Ekaros 6y agoI wonder what are the data protection implications of such actions. Like can they really store your name and perceived actions somewhere if you aren't even associated with their service yet? Is that legal in EU? Should it even be?
- twobitshifter 6y ago> It said examples of this “severe misconduct” include terrorist activities, child sexual exploitation, violent extremism, credible threats of mass violence, carrying out or deliberately acting as an accomplice to sexual assault and threatening Twitch or its staff. What points here will not already lead to jail time and an outright ban from all social activities? The bans are for criminal acts that are outside of free speech protections.
- ngokevin 6y agoYeah, I think many people speaking out against "cancel culture" did not read the article. Few people would argue that Twitch would be wrong to ban a pedophile sharing CP or a domestic terrorist.
- sneak 6y agoI would argue that Twitch would be wrong for banning even a convicted criminal whose publications themselves were legal. Censorship is abhorrent regardless of who you are censoring. Mein Kampf is available on amazon.com, for example.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ngokevin 6y agoI'm curious. If you are in charge of a public company with a platform. There's a pedophile known for trafficking CP (or even more vile offenses). There are headlines that you're giving them exposure. You don't consider not letting them on your platform?
- GauntletWizard 6y agoNo, Twitch would hire them as a content moderator, as they have in the past. [1]https://kotaku.com/twitch-apologizes-over-recent-abuse-of-power-by-staff-1469301896 https://kotaku.com/twitch-apologizes-over-recent-abuse-of-po... [2]https://boundingintocomics.com/2020/05/20/twitch-ceo-emmett-shear-issues-statement-on-ferociouslysteph-and-the-safety-advisory-councils-role-its-lie-after-lie/ https://boundingintocomics.com/2020/05/20/twitch-ceo-emmett-...
- ttt0 6y ago> Twitch said it would rely more heavily on law enforcement in “off-service” cases and is partnering with an investigative law firm to support its internal team. It declined to name the firm. So they're hiring investigation firms to spy on their users. Thank you Twitch, very cool.
- imgabe 6y ago> It said examples of this “severe misconduct” include terrorist activities, child sexual exploitation, violent extremism, credible threats of mass violence, carrying out or deliberately acting as an accomplice to sexual assault and threatening Twitch or its staff. The thing is, most of these are crimes. If there is credible evidence that you engaged in terrorist activities, you should be in jail, making a ban from Twitch moot because you wouldn't be able to access it anyway. Why does Twitch feel they have to form a vigilante justice system that is outside of normal due process and has no right to a fair trial?
- koluna 6y agoWhat’s being missed in this thread is that nobody (streamers) is an employee of Twitch - Twitch graciously offers them their platform, but that’s like your local fruit stand offering you a place to juggle next to it. They can take that away at any point because you are not their employee. If you had some legally enforceable contract, maybe there was a leg to stand on. Otherwise, twitch is under no obligation to give anyone a platform.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- reificator 6y ago> If you had some legally enforceable contract, maybe there was a leg to stand on. Otherwise, twitch is under no obligation to give anyone a platform. Twitch partners (I.E. most of the people who make a living on the platform) absolutely have a contract with Twitch. Twitch affiliates don't as far as I know, but those are (mostly) the people in the awkward stage between hobby and profession, and most of them are trying to achieve "partner" status.
- ativzzz 6y agoAnd I assume that contract has a clause in it that says Twitch can revoke their streaming status for any reason, otherwise they would have been sued to death by now.
- RedComet 6y agoBy severe misconduct, they mean having political views anywhere to the right of 'free market capitalism'.
- oth001 6y agoPatreon recently banned journalist Whitney Webb for something that somebody else posted on her website. This policy is already being used nefariously, against journalists nonetheless.
- rangewookie 6y agoTwitch doesn't see itself as a platform for creative freedom even though everyone wants to perceive them as such (because they market it that way). Twitch wants to become a network, like cable TV. It's easier, and more predictable. Pros: maintain control of the brand perception, market to their target demographic with simple messaging, everyone in the inevitable echo chamber is satisfied (including employees). Cons: Some people are mad and move to create an opposing "rival" network. (which is likely to happen anyways) This logic can be applied to other major social media networks, the surviving ones anyway.
- thephyber 6y agoMy concern isn’t that a site/platform can ban you for your actions. This is fairly similar to how employers already have the legal right to fire employees/contractors for subjective reasons (eg. Decency clauses). That part is not new. My worry is that Twitch is owned by Amazon. What happens if what I do something not on any Amazon property, but some Twitch PR decision leads to degraded access on my AWS account or my Amazon shopping account or “Login with Amazon” or “Checkout with Amazon”? The fact that successful tech companies are collecting+building companies coupled with these “shoot first and maybe ask questions later” policies means there is more risk in using multiple services from one of these monolith companies than from choosing unaffiliated vendors.
- noahbradley 6y agoAnecdotal, but I was banned from Twitch for "violent content," despite the fact that I only streamed tame art content and hadn't streamed in years. I had just been cancelled on twitter, etc., though, so presumably they just had to check some box when they were banning me from their platform. It's a weird internet these days.
- _carbyau_ 6y agoWhat I find weird is why does anyone think ANY of these companies are meant to uphold free speech in the American sense? Does Abercrombie and Fitch (or most fashion companies) make clothes of all sizes? No? Because what they produce is part of their brand as much as their marketing. They don't want overweight people wearing their stuff, it makes the brand not what they want it to be. Whether that is good or not is another debate. Same with Twitch, Twitter, Facebook, Google, Parler or ANY other media platform. What they show publicly is part of their brand, along with their marketing etc. The real issue is that society has come to see these brand platforms as being an inherent part of their ability to communicate. But they are borrowed megaphones at best.
- ssivark 6y agoSee SCOTUS justice Clarence Thomas’ comments on why this such an alarming problem. (Was on HN front page recently) https://www.protocol.com/bulletins/thomas-scotus-twitter-trump-ban https://www.protocol.com/bulletins/thomas-scotus-twitter-tru... and https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/20579870/order-list-04_05_2021.pdf https://assets.documentcloud.org/documents/20579870/order-li...
- ct0 6y agoThe problem that I see in the logic is that Twitch is kicking people off of the platform that were at one point of their lives too fat to fit into an Abercrombie and Fitch T-shirt. If they are no longer fat, they still cant be part of the community or buy the t-shirt if it was up to Twitch.
- _carbyau_ 6y agoCompanies do dumb stuff to their branding ALL the time. See the Wix article where they shoot themselves in their own foot. (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26728471 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26728471) I am NOT saying Twitch is doing a good job. But it is the company's platform, not society's, and they can do whatever stupid thing they want with it.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoUntil Twitch is a public service owned by the government this is all perfectly legal and fine. There are other platforms if you want to be "bad" (in Twitch's estimation) and post your opinion. They don't owe anyone a platform.
- cblconfederate 6y agoThe internet IS the social credit system. Maybe i should get out of the internet?
- armchairhacker 6y agoAgree or disagree I don't really see how this is news. Companies like Twitch will ban people they don't like anyways, they don't need an explicit rule. It seems obvious that someone who commits violence or hate crimes will get banned from popular social media platforms. Also all of the "severe misconduct" that they state are obviously bad things, like bigotry or actual crimes. Of course they could call "severe misconduct" anything they want, like supporting the Amazon unions. But they could ban the supporters and give whatever explanation they want anyways.
- akagusu 6y agoHow long to private companies to own our lives? One by one, companies are taking control of our lives, deciding what we can do, what we can say, what to eat, what to wear, what to read, where we can go, with whom and more. We know it and allow it. For what?
- sunsipples 6y agotough times for those who like political discourse and cat boys. twitch is a cesspit, with money. all of the streamers will just keep up with boobystreaming and accidental nudes and avoid anything too tawdry offline. got to keep the tens of dollars coming in.
- c1ccccc1 6y ago> "evidence, such as screen shots" document.body.contentEditable = 'true'; document.designMode = 'on';
- anothernewdude 6y agoPerhaps they could turn it into a score, so users can see how they're doing, and Twitch could just admit they've become China.
- pacerwpg 6y agoThis is probably directly related to harassment that streamer/youtuber Drift0r was subjected to at the hands of another streamer. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NqQLSCnUCVU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NqQLSCnUCVU
- sillysaurusx 6y agoThank you for the context!
- throwawaysea 6y agoAmazon wants to inflict thought control just as it does on employees engaging in lawful activities outside of work. They’re not the only ones either. We need to boycott companies that adopt such policies for either their customers or employees. Otherwise institutions, which are run by a few people and can be subverted by activist ideologues as well (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_long_march_through_the_institutions https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_long_march_through_the_i...), will become tyrants that control and restrict others’ thoughts and actions. We are already most of the way there. For my part, I’m stopping my use of Twitch right away and cancelling Prime.
- Jerry2 6y agoThat sounds like "social credit score" to me.
- OptionX 6y agoRegardless if you think this is good or bad one things I think bears pointing out. Twitch banning process has no accountability. They can ban you for however slight or even perceived and for a lot of people it means a loss of their livelihood and they don't have to justify to anyone. And it not very hard to frame it on breaking some deliberately vague rule. Now I don't think that is much of leap to understand the chilling effect that would have. And you can be okay with that. It all to fight wrongthink anyway. But remember twitch is owned by amazon, a company the is running at the moment a disinformation campaign against its own workers effort to unionize. So twitch may enforce rules that align with your own beliefs right now, but they are not on anyone's side but their own and if suits them to go against those very same believe there is no one to stop them. I don't really want such a entity presiding over the morality of my life, would you?
- judge2020 6y ago> I don't really want such a entity presiding over the morality of my life, would you? You typing in twitch.com is a choice, you're not forced to watch it or acknowledge its presence. People want Twitch accountability for their bans, and they might succeed, but the reality is that Twitch is currently the biggest gaming livestream platform simply because they already have everything that streamers and viewers want - live chat, monetization, moderation tools, etc. Live streaming is pretty easy to bootstrap with nginx-rtmp (maybe not as easy to turn a profit on[0]), so it's not like there's no way for competition to enter the market. Floatplane.com also does live streaming so they're going to end up as a sizable competitor within then next few years hopefully. 0: https://www.theverge.com/2020/6/22/21299032/microsoft-mixer-closing-facebook-gaming-partnership-xcloud-features https://www.theverge.com/2020/6/22/21299032/microsoft-mixer-...
- kansface 6y agoRight, I’d concede you have a point if it weren’t the entire fucking US Internet hell-bent on doing this. This comment exists in every thread every time yet another company acquiesces to the new moral police. I’m not personally interested in reimplementing Twitch, Amazon, Twitter, Stripe, email, and a bank. It is extraordinarily unhealthy for society to completely bifurcate into two mutually exclusive enclaves that ban their political opponents wrongthoughts and seek to destroy the lives of those who transgress. That is the path we are on and it will not end well.
- chmod600 6y agoImagine 50 years from today, how will we look back on the 2020s? How culture, free speech, and big tech are intertwined may be the most significant. Covid and Trump will just be quaint "when I was your age" stories by comparison. The decisions we make today about how we communicate with each other, how the channels of communication are controlled, and standards of behavior (for enforcers as well as transgressors) will have the real lasting impact.
- perryizgr8 6y agoThere are only two positions on free speech. You are either for, or against it. Twitch has made it clear which one they hold.
- Grimlock 6y agoFor anybody interested in a self-hosted alternative to twitch, owncast (https://github.com/owncast/owncast https://github.com/owncast/owncast) is pretty easy to use and has a web interface that's rather twitch-like.
- account42 6y ago> evidence, such as screen shots This is seriously disturbing considering how easy it is to doctor screenshots - especially for web-based platforms.