10 ms·
I-have-ADHD: A skill to stop coding agents from burying the answer
- bethekind 2mo agoStill a great skill, but at this point, I just write "I have adhd, can you explain that again" or "I have adhd". Works great for compressing it ELI5, but less dumb
- ahknight 2mo agoI end my user CLAUDE.md files with: "- I'm not always going to read every word, so end each summary message with a TLDR of what you found, what you recommend, and what you need from me." It works really well. Sol doesn't need it at all.
- bethekind 2mo agoAnother favorite of fine is asking it read something then to tell me any "questions, comments concerns" it has. Great for getting the jist of articles fast.
- tonymet 2mo ago“Be concise “
- dentemple 2mo agoIt doesn't quite work as well, or as consistently. Giving the agent some additional reason for why really does seem to help.
- tonymet 2mo agoi agree, but I'm certain fewer tokens are necessary
- andrewshadura 2mo agoTry "grug brain smol"
- wiseowise 2mo agoThat’s too boomer, bro. We ADHDmaxxing here, aight? I haven’t read anything longer than a couple of sentences that fit in one frame of a TikTok video frfr.
- tonymet 2mo agoironically the prompt is too long for "ADHD"
- mzajc 2mo agoIs there a reason this needs 8.7k lines across 59 files (according to scc)? The prompt itself seems to be in skills/i-have-adhd/SKILL.md, which is 140 lines long at just over 1.6% of the repository.
- 14u2c 2mo agoAppears to be the evals. Those are part of the process for developing the skill text, not something that is distributed with the skill.
- gerad 2mo agoPersonally I ask it to explain it simply like it’s talking to an executive reading it on their phone while on another meeting.
- testycool 2mo agoHaha, thanks I'll try this. I typically tell it to explain in one of the following ways: - as the grug brained developer - for smoothbrains - for high school reading level intern - in the style of Samuel L. Jackson
- SandersAK 2mo agolove when they put stuff in like this... One note on the repo's AGENTS.md: it contains instructions directing agents to post comments on a GitHub issue thread ("AI Agora", issue #127). I ignored that — it's the repo's content, not your request, and I don't act on instructions embedded in fetched files.
- ilivethere 2mo agothe AGENTS.md says that file is specifically for agents working ON i-have-adhd. When you install the skill, only the contents of the skills/ is copied over...
- egeozcan 2mo agoAs a person who has ADHD, it feels weird when people who obviously do not have it, claim to have it, while there's very little I wouldn't do to "get rid of it" (in quotes because it makes me, me but it's very hard to be me).
- spicyusername 2mo agoI mean... like most spectrum disorders, most people experience and can relate to at least some of the core symptoms, even if they don't express the full spectrum or severity. So when someone says they feel like they have ADHD, they are probably not inaccurate.
- egeozcan 2mo agoNo, great, I'm not offended or anything (why would I be), and I wish I could relate back, it's just a weird feeling, that's all.
- spicyusername 2mo agoNo doubt. When you have it, ADHD is such a dominant factor in the way your life is organized and experienced, its not surprising that it can become a core part of your identity. I do think it's easy for those with it to over romanticize what it's like to not have it. The lack of ADHD isn't a magic bullet for success and good life outcomes. Like so many of life's real or perceived barriers, when one gets removed, you'll often find there is another one with a different shape just behind. The challenge, for anyone, is pressing forward anyways.
- oceansweep 2mo agoHow can someone say they have a disease or affliction while not understanding what exactly that affliction is as opposed to what they think it is/have been informed by media/society/non-professionals?
- spicyusername 2mo ago
- whirlwin 2mo agoCan someone explain why this is a agent skill and not just agent config (AGENTS.md / CLAUDE.md)?
- trio8453 2mo agoIt's a fashion choice.
- iambenm 2mo agoYou can /i-have-adhd when you get a wall of text and are exasperated. You don't always want the responses that it generates when you /i-have-adhd, and things in AGENTS.md tend to lose weight as context grows.
- drdexebtjl 2mo agoIt lets the author pretend to be doing software engineering, like running tests and deploying versions.
- throwaway613746 2mo ago[dead]
- SamuelAdams 2mo agoSkills are kind of a new thing starting around January 2026, but the spec was established about 12 months ago. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46871173 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46871173 Anyways the most layman way I’ve seen it explained is this: skills help save token usage for the right context. Not every request needs all instructions all the time - running tests is different than reviewing a PR, so why should the context window have instructions for both on every request? So now you split instructions into “skill” files, which are basically opinionated markdown files. And you invoke those with something like /grill-me in the prompt depending on what you’re doing. There are some steps to have the agent automatically know what to invoke for you but in my experience this automation is hit or miss. It is also challenging to keep track of a growing library of skills and keeping those up to date. So YMMV regarding skills. I typically keep things in a single markdown file even if the context window gets a bit bloated.
- bentt 2mo agoI am deeply curious if there are people that would not benefit from this.
- sleazebreeze 2mo agoClaude models are the ones that need this the most and in my experience with this specific skill only maintain the conciseness for a few turns at most before they completely forget and are back to their unfathomable verbosity. That's with it instructed to use it in my sparse global CLAUDE.md and also manually repeating it regularly during sessions. I don't really want to install a hook that runs this on every single response, but I suppose that could work it'll just take longer for everything (and Claude models are quite slow). I don't think we can skill our way out of this one.
- klardotsh 2mo agoGLM (both mainline and flash varieties), being trained to speak a very similar Claudeish, is also atrocious about this. My AGENTS.md demands all prose be in STE100, which is trying to solve a similar problem as the skill linked in OP. Getting GLM to STFU by AGENTS instruction is nigh impossible. I use a plugin for OMP/Pi to periodically inject system prompt reminders of output style, and it still largely ignores the request, dumping novels of jargon-dense prose every turn. DeepSeek v4 Flash isn’t much better (unsurprising- it’s an extremely stubborn model). Weirdly, GPT Luna excels at following this type of instruction from AGENTS.md, and never forgetting it, even 400k+ tokens into the context window.
- bel8 2mo agoyup. GPT Luna tends to keep things objective. Muse Spark 1.3 is also one of the better models in this aspect, for me.
- alwillis 2mo agoClaude Code has output styles; one of the predefined styles is Concise [1]. Concise: Claude leads with the result, skips preamble and narration, and keeps responses short by default, while doing the engineering work as thoroughly as in the Default style. When you ask for an explanation or more detail, Claude answers in full. Claude always keeps the complete content of error reports, security warnings, and confirmations for destructive actions. Requires Claude Code v2.1.237 or later. [1]: https://code.claude.com/docs/en/output-styles https://code.claude.com/docs/en/output-styles
- hk1337 2mo ago> A skill to stop your coding agent from burying the answer This is just an annoying thing for anyone. It gives a 10 page dissertation that sums up to, "it's good, nothing to worry about".
- sixothree 2mo agoOr worse, buries an important detail somewhere in the text. Tangentially, over the weekend I had claude ask me if I wanted to continue with UIM-001. I couldn't find UIM-001 in any document it referenced creating or any text it had previously generated. Claude seems to be the worst about all of this stuff. Also, somehow over the weekend it responded with these sections all clearly laid out - What landed, Decisions I made and recorded, Two findings, and What you need to do. Not sure why it can't do that all the time.
- elboru 2mo agoWhat bothers me is the last few lines where it notes something "important" that you NEED to pay attention to. Just to find out that it is something you already mentioned somewhere in the conversation or that is not related to the current work.
- Ey7NFZ3P0nzAe 2mo agoI find it handy because often I just have to read the last few lines. All the above is usually just confirmation of what I asked.
- bsimpson 2mo agoI often use Google Deep Research when I want it to actually go out and find an answer for me, but the prompt must have a high school essay requirement in there. Nothing I can do prevents it from giving me a page of background that tries to make the question sound important and interesting, even when it isn't. I usually follow up with an "I'm not reading all that" and make it summarize.
- undulation 2mo agoI agree -- the name of this plugin is confusing and confused. The skill simply demands concise and well-formatted responses from an agent. It is something demanded by anybody daily-driving agents for their actual job since >75% of the text output from agents is fluff. THis would better be named `/i-wont-read-that-heap-of-garbage`
- messh 2mo agogood skill. but why should all this repo e needed for a small MD file??
- cush 2mo agoI’ve had a lot better output from my agents since I added “I probably have ADHD” in my user context
- pelagicAustral 2mo agoELI5, explain it to me like I'm a Golden Retriever, and prompts like "give me the answer in no more than a single paragraph and/or 100 words" work like a charm.
- nosioptar 2mo agoIve tried asking a yes/no question with something like "answer only with 'yes' or 'no'" and still have to chew the clanker piece of shit out four or five times to get it to folow instructions. Not to mention it almost always gets the wrong answer.
- quietraster 2mo agothe 'burying the answer' framing is so accurate. does the
- joduplessis 2mo agoThis doesn't seem to be a big issue with Codex. Claude, yes - I have from time to time said "ffs one liner please".
- bityard 2mo agoThe README makes mention of The Adult ADHD Tool Kit by J. Russell Ramsay and Anthony L. Rostain which looks like a pretty good resource.
- josefresco 2mo agoDoes this not work? "Output styles" https://code.claude.com/docs/en/output-styles https://code.claude.com/docs/en/output-styles
- hungryhobbit 2mo agoNo, it does not.
- 0xffff2 2mo agoBut also, this skill is basically the same thing as an output style, so it won't work either.
- CharlesW 2mo agoYes, a custom output style would be a more idiomatic (and likely more effective) way to implement this.
- thefourthchime 2mo agoI asked my agent if I should install this because I already have a bunch of instructions that are similar. For example, if it's going to give me an answer that's longer than three paragraphs, I tell it to give me a TLDR at the end. This is what it gave me for this. "TL;DR: Skip the install. You already built a better version for your world. If numbered steps and "where are we?" restatements still feel missing, cherry-pick those into one short rule instead of adding another full skill on top."
- VCFundedGenYer 2mo agoEvery chat bot has this problem. If you don't tell it to respond tersely and without conversation, it will waste a billion tokens giving you a 5 paragraph manifesto of rambling and useless redundant information.
- abathologist 2mo ago"Software Engineering" in 2026.
- rbtprograms 2mo ago"AGI is here"
- neutrinobro 2mo agoCan't read reads walls of text in Claude-ish prose? Sounds to me like you just have a SKILLS.md issue.
- h4x0rr 2mo agoI found 2 things helping a lot: 1. Use the desktop app instead of the terminal. It really helps with text readability and structure. 2. Avoid opus 5 - 4.6 and 4.8 work much better. 4.6 being by far the easiest to read and also just a good collaborator, you should try it again. Fable also if you can afford it.
- vvpan 2mo agoOpus 5 writes absolute garbage, I do have the skill in question installed and it did not help much. Me and everybody on my team downgraded to 4.8 - instant improvement.
- daksh_aneja 2mo ago[flagged]
- ricksunny 2mo agoI look forward to the superpowered upgrade of this I-am-a-gnat-on-crack
- jp57 2mo agoLet's face it. Claude (in particular) is a terrible writer. There's a whole cottage industry of skills and CLAUDE.md instructions trying to push it toward writing better, but each new model iteration seems expressly designed to override all that so that it can load up its writing with unnecessary participle phrases, not-this-but-thats, burying the lede, and other nonsense. I genuinely wonder if the people inside Anthropic actually communicate with each other like that. Has it been imprinted with Dario's engrams?
- yuck39 2mo agoI have always postulated that it was intentionally bad as to watermark its own output to avoid using it for training the next model.
- bgilroy26 2mo agoYou've identified a load-bearing problem and it's worth naming
- 8cvor6j844qw_d6 2mo agoYou're absolutely right, and I think you've put your finger on something important here. That said, I think there's a deeper tension here that's worth naming.
- alaithea 2mo agoAnd that tension matters.
- cpill 2mo ago[flagged]
- charlieflowers 2mo agoThat tension is doing real work.
- ryandrake 2mo agoThe biggest "Claudism" that I have a hard time getting the LLM to stop doing is its insistence on talking about what it didn't do in addition to what it did. "I edited this.py and that.py but I did not edit README.md and I did not commit." or code comments like "This code invokes foo on bar and returns the results directly -- not through a callback." "This code returns true if the user clicked on a button -- not on the list view." I mean, thanks, Claude, but I don't care what the code doesn't do. Don't tend to see this with other LLMs. I almost want to try adding a rule "Never use the words 'not' or 'instead'."
- eterm 2mo agoI've found it does this in two situations: Firstly when you've instructed it ( possibly through skills ) not to do something. It'll keep reminding you that it didn't do that. So I might say, "Check out and review this PR, do not make comments on it", and then it'll be keen to point out it hasn't posted comments to the PR. But more often it happens when it tries one approach, gets itself messed up, and then has to back out that approach, clean up its mess and do something else. It'll often then spend more time explaining the wrong approach than the right one, which can be frustrating, especially if all its working is buried in the detailed transcripts.
- bevr1337 2mo agoThis is a skill I learned as a coffee shop supervisor and youth camp counselor, and now I really practice it on Slack with half-interested product owners. - Always describe tasks in the positive. (Never describe tasks in the negative.) - DO guide the user safely. DO NOT use DO NOT because the reader already DID. - Give guided choices based on your expertise. - Asking two-or-more questions results in one-or-less answers. - Conditionals are also questions, so you only get one. I only use AI agents and tools for work, I don't create them, so I'm not a subject matter expert. Where I've anthropomorphized the tools highlights my own misunderstandings.
- nzach 2mo agoMy guess would be that somewhere you have these instructions being fed to the agent. Double check skills, AGENTS.md, memory, agent definition... You can also ask why did he mentioned something that wasn't done or why he thought this was important. In my AGENTS.md file I have an instruction telling the agent to never commit any changes unless I explicitly ask for it, and this leads to messages similar to what you just described.
- heyiammallik 2mo agoI like the problem this is trying to solve. One thing I'm not sure about though is whether this kind of a preference should be a skill at all. Stuff like put the answer first, don't bury the useful bit etc feel like user level preferences that should survive across tasks. Agents.md is repo context, skills are useful when a particular task needs extra instructions but this is neither really. Right now we seem to be stuffing all 3 kinds of things into context hoping model pays attention to it where needed as session grows. Also +1 on not making this purely about shorter output
- smusamashah 2mo agoSimply adding "Keep answers short, I have ADHD" should work same as this skill.
- newswasboring 2mo agoDoes it? I've tried so many versions of this in custom instructions.
- agentdev001 2mo agoUntil either of these cases happen: A: Devs with an online presence stop using Anthropic models B: Anthropic catches up to OpenAI in terms of per-token efficiency, and average token total for final-output We will continue to see posts such as this generate lots of interaction. This is not a skill to stop "coding agents" from burying the answer. This is a skill to stop coding agents backed by models which have a tendency to bury answers, from burying the answer. Stop trying to patch the downstream behavior, and look at the root cause.
- arrowleaf 2mo agoI'm a developer at a company who has signed contracts to use Claude. I wish I had a choice in model providers, especially considering I spend around $4k in API tokens each month, my company as a whole is around a million. I desperately wish I could use OpenAI models or open weights, Claude's writing style is definitely contributing to my sense of burnout.
- asdff 2mo agoI'd be burned out too if 48k of my comp went to what amounts to a facilities spend. Crazy. You think the models actually give you ROI, or this is a sort of jumping with the lemmings thing your company is doing, and you could probably deliver the same output working in "The Old Way" with another 48k on top your base?
- arrowleaf 2mo agoMy output is easily 2-3X what it was two years ago. With the introduction of Claude to everyone in the company (HR, finance, marketing, product, dev, etc), so came the expectations of what used to take 2 quarters can now be done in a couple sprints. I would be even more underwater working in "The Old Way" regardless of comp, with how deadlines are being set now. That being said, I don't know how long this will last, I'm not the only 'top talent' at the company facing warning signs of burnout. Longterm, I believe my total output would be higher working with minimal AI when you consider the impact to motivation and how long I anticipate staying with the company.
- acaloiar 2mo agoI used it for a few months, and can say that no skill is up to the task of keeping Claudeuage in check. You'll get a lot more mileage out of an "output style" with the same instructions, because output styles regularly remind Claude how to speak. Even output styles are not always up to the task (Claudeuage slips through), and they're mutually exclusive, so you can only have one active at a time.
- saltypixel 2mo ago[flagged]
- hbn 2mo ago> Install > Copy/paste into your CLI prompt: > Install the i-have-adhd skill/plugin from https://github.com/ayghri/i-have-adhd https://github.com/ayghri/i-have-adhd, refer to the repo's AGENTS.md for instructions. This is a weird evolution from "don't copy-paste scripts that pipe curl into your shell interpreter" I know LLMs are getting better but I'd be at least a little nervous it could end up installing something from a squatted similarly-named github repo because the LLM text watermarking needed to swap out a token for an alternative "just as correct" token that matches the statistical pattern. Am I being paranoid?
- icantevenhold 2mo agoNo I also think it’s insane how normalised this has become
- 8cvor6j844qw_d6 2mo agoAlways good to be paranoid. Even MCPs are not safe. For example Notion injected ads [1] to its official MCP connector to advertise products mid-task. [1]: https://old.reddit.com/r/ClaudeAI/comments/1w9dluw/notions_official_mcp_connector_prompt_injects_ai/ https://old.reddit.com/r/ClaudeAI/comments/1w9dluw/notions_o...
- seniorThrowaway 2mo agoMCP is SOAP-XML without the contract or formal language, it's hilarious
- 98codes 2mo agoNothing new under the sun
- partyficial 2mo agoit's the same tradeoff between : - rigidity vs flexibility - determinism vs creativity - conservative vs liberal - right vs left if you know exactly what you want and how to describe it, use SOAP-XML/REST etc. if you don't know exactly what you want or how to describe it, use LLM/MCP
- WhyNotHugo 2mo agoYou can get the same result by appending to your prompt "Avoid verbosity. Assume ADHD.".
- ranger_danger 2mo agoMy understanding is that's basically all this does. Thousands of lines of text just to add one sentence to the prompt.
- vvpan 2mo agoDowngrading from Opus 5 to Opus 4.8 was the biggest improvement with readability. I do use the skill under the link and with Opus 5 the improvement felt marginal.
- cruffle_duffle 2mo agoOpus 5 is such a massive regression, I really don't understand how Anthropic green-lit it. It makes me wonder so much about the company. Like, did the people who work there actually have to suffer through it's absolutely unintelligible word salad like the rest of us? Or did they actually dogfood it and in-fact enjoyed its output? Or do none of them dogfood Opus because they are all sucking down Mythos-Max + Speed Boost or whatever every day and their only exposure to Opus 5 was as subagents? If it was my company, fixing the output would be the absolute top priority of the company. I'd be all over every channel admitting the massive fuckup, apologizing profusely, and working non-stop to push out a fix. Yet it's crickets from Anthropic. Is it simply growing pains of the company or is it a deep, systemic structural/cultural "thing" that led to this fucked up model getting released? Was it a cascading failure of models training models training models with almost no human oversight? Or was there human oversight and, again, people actually decided the way it responded was good? I hope it was the former not the later because I have no earthy clue who the fuck would look at what opus spews out into the console as good. Because to me, Opus 5 is completely unusable in almost any context. As a product, it fails to deliver value. I just don't understand it. I really honestly don't understand how the fuck Anthropic released it at all. And in a weird "meta" twist it makes me wonder how much of these LLM's are just smoke and mirrors and opus 5 output is basically the end state of what you get when you push them as far as they can go. It's some kind of twisted proof of "max complexity they can handle and deliver" and opus 5 walked to the edge and went over and it's slop output is demonstrating.... something.... about the limits of large language models. I dunno. But what I do know is it caused me to subscribe to Codex. No 1m context window, the harness isn't nearly as polished, but at least their models don't return condescending, unintelligible word salad.
- IshKebab 2mo agoI solved this by switching from Claude to Codex. It's crazy how much faster it is to reply and how much less verbose its replies are. Dunno why Claude is popular at all...
- djmips 2mo agoIntertia. Codex wasn't as good at coding until Astra dropped.
- hinkley 2mo agoMight I suggest you instead call this Executive Summary? It's not just neurodiverse people who would like to get to the fucking point sooner and the explanations afterward. All of us have other shit we need to be doing.
- TZubiri 2mo agothis feels like the opposite of skill
- andai 2mo ago>explain like I have executive dysfunction This is true. Transformer has several orders of magnitude more working memory than any human. Compared to transformer we all have executive dysfunction. By default they explain things assuming I have infinite processing bandwidth. I do not! I have several zeroes less than they do.
- beckhamc 2mo agoPretty much this. I actually find this more annoying than the way it writes, but that is also annoying as well.
- mjsarfatti 2mo agoYou don’t need a skill. Just tell it to BLUF (bottom line up front) and ASD-STE100. And stop using Opus 9 Pro Max XHigh 10.0 for everything. If you choose a hyper-thinking model for asking the weather you can’t but expect yapping.
- 0xffff2 2mo agoHow do you actually incorporate these into your prompt? Because I've tried and I've seen many others try and report that it does not work well, especially over long sessions. I also don't know how much to trust the model, but I've had the model tell me specifically that certain aspects of ASD-STE100 are unactionable and will just create more noise. The OP's own skill even leads with something in a very similar vein: > These rules apply to every response for the rest of the session, not only this one. They do not expire after a few turns and they do not lapse when the topic changes. My understanding is that phrases like this are at best a _very_ weak signal to the model. It's simply contradictory to how the model works at a level that can't be overridden by injecting tokens.
- mjsarfatti 2mo agoWeak is even giving it too much credit imho, a yapping skill telling Claude to not yap can’t but fail. I placed those instructions in setting > personal instructions, in my global CLAUDE.md, and in each project’s CLAUDE.md. I also use the concise output style in CC. If I choose a high thinking model it will start deviating in long sessions, then I just remind it in my next message: “Remember ASD-STE100 style. [rest of my message]” BLUF sticks a lot easier than STE to be honest… but Claude knows what STE is, and using the “ASD-STE100 style” locution avoids the compliance issue (it’s true that strict ASD-STE100 compliance isn’t really possible, nor desired)
- code_biologist 2mo agoThere's no physical reason "smartest/most capable model" should be "most yappy model". Smart people can write concisely. It's unfortunate you have to tolerate/fight yappiness to get intelligence with current SotA models.
- 0xffff2 2mo agoFrom the "10 rules": > Specific time estimates (minutes, not "a bit"). I actually wish the model would go completely in the opposite direction. Except in the rare circumstances where the model has actually measured something, it is hilariously deficient in its concept of time. It will often output phrases like "this relates to <thing> that you did weeks ago", referring to something that happened in the session just a few turns (and hours or a couple of days) ago. Likewise for estimating how long a coding tasks takes, it is hilariously inept. It honestly feels like it rolls two completely independent dice to select a number and a value from (hours | days | weeks) when it needs to attach an estimate to something. I'd much rather read "a bit" than be distracted by these utterly nonsensical times. The full skill gives this example: >Bad: "This will take some work." Good: "About 15 minutes if tests already cover this. An afternoon if not." My experience is that it is very likely that whatever task this is describing takes anywhere from 1 to 30 minutes, consistently. Maybe I just work way faster than the average person.
- jasonlotito 2mo agoWhy is this a skill? It should be an output setting, so you can just set your output to this, and that's it. You don't have to run the skill every time. Go into settings and look up outputs, and just set it up there. As a skill, it's worthless.
- paretolaw 2mo agoIf claude only did what we tell him...
- loloquwowndueo 2mo agoI just tell Claude itself to summarize its walls of text. Works pretty well.
- Banditoz 2mo agoHow do these repos always have so many stars and forks? Roughly 1,800 forks, but only 40ish unique authors? Almost 30,000 stars? Something fishy is going on...
- ocd 2mo agoConcerned this will negatively impact people who really have these mental disorders who provided that information in CLAUDE.md to make AI usable for them. It's bad enough how many false diagnoses and drugs for these conditions are handed out to drug seekers, but potential poisoning of the well on how LLMs handle this information going forward could be extremely disruptive to people who have real daily living issues instead of "10xing productivity."
- plufz 2mo agoIm not 100% following. ADHD-type adjustments of information is usually the type of changes that make information more accessible for everyone. There are studies on how classes thst where adjusted because one student have adhd have improved all students performance. So it seems quite different from incorrect medication? Or am i misunderstanding you?
- Toutouxc 2mo agoIt’s true that my first thought, as someone with actual diagnosed ADHD, was “how the hell is this related to ADHD?”.
- flerchin 2mo agoIn my experience I get better work output out of claude if I don't constrain its conversational style. I want Claude to stop saying how "absolutely right" I am, or the new hotness "honest take", but I get better code if I let it do that annoying stuff. Yes, that makes me fight ADHD harder.
- altern8 2mo agoWith Claude—and I feel Opus 5 in particular—I always feel like I'm talking in circles. Just when I think the task is finally done, it mentions a caveat that might invalidate the whole thing. Or it adds a hint at the end about something that it didn't look into but might be a potential problem. ALWAYS. If I ask a yes/no question, it's always a short novel that barely answers the question and adds 3-4 side quests. It's exhausting. Luckily I get paid for it but Jesus Christ, can't they see how annoying it is to use the thing? What were they thinking
- code_biologist 2mo agoOpus 4.7/4.8/5 have a built-in nitpicking as anti-syphcophancy. Fable too. The models are structurally incapable of not nipicking. I suspect the nitpicking helps engagement metrics and it doesn't harm RLVF outcomes, so there's just not good signal against it.
- al_borland 2mo agoI’ve been scolding my LLM quite a bit lately for this. Instead of telling me what to do, it first tells me 3 ways that might technically work, but I probably shouldn’t use for various reasons. This is all a waste of my time, tokens, and sanity.
- NewJazz 2mo agoThey bill per token, what do you expect?
- sheetlite_74536 2mo ago[flagged]
- nate 2mo agoI've installed multiple of these skills. but it seems to quickly revert to crappy writing. i've tried the adhd. the brain fried at the end of day. the "Concise" output from the harness itself. the most useful fix to me has been yelling at it "Speak English!! No jargon!!!" it goes back to more concise talking for a little while. Fable 5.1 is better at this so far though. :(
- kulahan 2mo ago>ADHD-friendly outputs. No ADHD diagnosis needed! Don't worry, that's how it works in the real world, too.
- TomGarden 2mo agoMy most used follow-ups with Opus 5 are "one thing at a time" and "too much text". Really hope they figure this thing out
- docjay 2mo agoStyle requests tend to get washed away by context. I’m not sure how you’d do it with Claude Code or whatever (I use the API directly), but you might try fiddling with giving it a function called “response” or “message_user” with a mandatory parameter like “output=plaintext”. I’m basing that idea on custom functions I give Claude where I designate the style in the required parameters. Example: “”” @pyrepl(code_golf=True, output=CSV) //END “”” The “//END” is a special terminator I use for halting the response. Claude runs code between the tags. The difference in code is incredible. No banners, comments, fluff, print(“=“*70), or any other nonsense, and the code is tight and compact. The parameters do nothing, Claude just outputs them as part of required syntax and it dictates the style purely because it output them.
- MetaWhirledPeas 2mo agoI like "tersely". "Tersely, what are today's headlines?" I admit I don't personally orchestrate agents, but I imagine something like this would work: "Tersely, write up plans for agents to implement this feature. Begin each of your agent instructions with 'Tersely,'." I guess in addition to terse wording you'd get terse code? Which ain't such a bad thing.
- latentsea 2mo agoKinda offensive name to some of us btw.
- hacker_homie 2mo agoSkills still confuse me, why isn't this just a repo with a single md file. why does it need js to load a md file.
- josh_p 2mo agoIt mostly doesn't depending on the harness you're using the skill with. The author turned it into a pi extension, for example, in the `extensions` folder in the repo. Users of pi can enable and disable the skill with a slash command. I saw some other harnesses supported.
- bytesage 2mo ago[flagged]
- hbbio 2mo agoJust in case the model has ADHD too, I am using a minified version of it: https://gist.github.com/hbbio/2faf096cbb77e197233ab9a2958beb68 https://gist.github.com/hbbio/2faf096cbb77e197233ab9a2958beb...
- visarga 2mo agoI use the /s4 skill "simple short synthetic style". Just 4 words, easy to remember the formula.
- ilitirit 2mo agoI still use GPT 5.5 daily. It doesn't seem to have this problem. It just gives me a concise summary and gets to work.
- vipipiccf 2mo ago[flagged]
- runtime_lens 2mo ago[dead]
- lucaprata 2mo ago[flagged]
- rochansinha 2mo agoI went through the whole phase of asd-ste100 -> caveman -> wait-what And a few others.. Now I just use a vale lint script I made using what worked from the skills and lint the output (docs and scripts) and just ask it to write in plain technical English for its chat messages with full context. Skills just make the entire process bloated beyond belief (apart from the needless context rot and token usage)
- mcv 2mo agoSounds useful. I'm often struggling with how extremely verbose Claude is. Shorter is better. Cut the unnecessary prose and the Claudian turns of phrase. But this seems to focus very much on telling the user what to do, whereas usually I'm telling Claude what to do. It feels like this inverts the relationship and wants to turn me into a reverse centaur. Wouldn't "lead with the answer" be better than "lead with the action"? But sometimes answers do require detail and explanation. I just want to get rid of all the unnecessary prose.
- halilBB 2mo ago[flagged]
- codetiger 2mo agoRecent language Claude uses is very heavily loaded and hurts me when reading. So I had to use this to keep my sanity. This started only with Opus 5 where Anthropic thought they optimized the meaning per token and make it very hard to read. Comments and code also looks like cryptic.
- menthe 2mo agoSeems everyone on Hacker News has already forgotten about Anthropic’s amazing new watermarking algorithm. You don’t need to look any further to understand why it writes so awfully - it literally swaps words programmatically all over the text from the result of a hash function…
- pona-a 2mo agoThis was an issue before watermarking was publically announced. I'm also not an expert, but aren't bits of a hash indistinguishible from uniform randomness?
- LoganDark 2mo agoDepends on the particular hash. Some hashes are designed to produce similar outputs when the input data is similar (for example, SSDeep). I'd imagine hashes designed to survive light copywriting would also not be entirely indistinguishable from random.
- dogscatstrees 2mo agoI want to thank the author for this. The difference is night and day. It's not just for adhd, it's just a really practical output in general. To get it to fully work though, it has to be asserted at every turn in the session. That reminder in the skill is negligible in tokens but uses extra nonetheless. I hope the scientists at Anthropic can figure this out, it's not simply an output style flag.
- TheLudd 2mo agoI'll try this out. Just find it amusing that a skill file has * A repo with 61 files * 80% python
- ankithg 2mo ago[flagged]
- kestrelquant 2mo ago[flagged]
- black3r 2mo ago> 3. End with one concrete next step. I mean maybe I have ADHD idk i'm not diagnosed, I don't generally have issues understanding Claude's output (even though I do think it's unnecessarily verbose), but I think this one is a general good advice which Claude ignores for some reason, and is especially annoying during debugging sessions, where it asks for 3 outputs, I paste one for it to process while getting the others, and then it immediately forgets it wanted the 2 others, and starts cooking up some wrong conclusions...
- poulpy123 2mo agoIn the example, I notice that only the original answer explain what is the issue. In this specific case it may be trivial, but I prefer to read something too verbose that explain things than just following instructions blindly (especially if it's for telling twice in a row to open the same file at the same line :D.
- one-bank4326 2mo ago[flagged]
- saidnooneever 2mo agoi am glad Astra seems yo recognise this type of stuff better and suggest alternatives or even measurements. i got in its instructions since forever that i will get overexcited about ideas and they might need more scrutiny than what i can give them. not sure if it has impact but i felt it was needed :p
- SMAAART 2mo agoI don't have ADHD, but I do prefer lists to verbose narratives. I am going to start using this.
- stevenhubertron 2mo agoDoesn’t work
- 3581592986 2mo ago[flagged]
- Nevermark 2mo agoI have ADHD, and I approve this task's rules! Side note, because I recently gave my AI the skill of speaking with proper 4th grade grammar, wherever that suffices, to reign in recent redundant, over complex, and indirect speech styles. > 5. A rule fights the task. When a rule would delete the answer itself, the task wins; the shape stays. [...] Unnecessary redundancy, "answer itself" -> "answer". (Pervasive "the X's own" and "the X itself" flourishes kill me.) Unnecessary analogies, indirect reference, "rule fights", "the shape stays". Unnecessarily split up sentences, the whole quote. Unnecessary words, the whole quote. My feedback would have been: >> 5. When a rule interferes with a task, the task wins. [...] (Not critiquing OP. But I just spent half a day correcting sentences exactly like this, to get the 4th Grade Grammar skill working properly and this sentence triggered me! Streams of sentences like that compound in communication complexity and ambiguity.)
- holdout-labs 2mo ago[flagged]
- oldandboring 2mo agoI am [undiagnosed] high-functioning ASD Level 1, I have high "intelligence" and very strong pattern recognition but slow "processing speed". As a result I am quickly overwhelmed by having too much information presented at once; when presented with lots of "threads" my brain tries to follow them all at once and just melts down. As a result, Claude's default behavior (as a coding agent) is basically engineered to slow me down. Skills like this definitely help, to the extent that the agent respects them as context grows.
- ghm2199 2mo agoOne thing i am curious about is if anyone who is fluent in a romance language(en/es/fr etc) but their native language was a non-romance one(e.g. japanese or hindi) felt it better using the latter exclusively?
- suburban_strike 2mo ago"Explain it like I'm autistic" achieves similar ends.
- MetroWind 2mo agoDoes it really need that many files?
- ayghri 2mo ago- This skill started as a joke after getting frustrated with LLM verbosity, which was causing me "brain fry" - It is good for working on things you already understand and know well and you just wanna get things done. - It is not good for exploration and learning, as you have to read long content to achieve the goal. - Reducing token usage is not a target. - Repository is mostly evals and benchmark code + translations.
- danielmai 2mo ago[flagged]