12 ms·
BMW Group to deploy humanoid robots in production in Germany for the first time
- dataviz1000 9mo agoHere is a 60 Minutes piece showing Boston Dynamics Atlas working in a car factory in the United States. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n6ISdRkS37I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n6ISdRkS37I
- u1hcw9nx 9mo agoHyundai vs BMW, where is Tesla?
- tw-20260303-001 9mo agoIt's coming, next year, there will be a million of them.
- baxtr 9mo agoOn the moon or on Mars?
- warkdarrior 9mo agoThere are already 2M robots on Mars, Elon is working on a space mission to bring 1M back.
- cpursley 9mo agoIn the mountains of Iran and stepps of Ukraine, I fear… and before you downvote, consider that starlink are in both, already.
- simondotau 9mo agoTesla beat Hyundai and BMW to this meaningless announcement a year ago, and have already progressed from that to the inevitable “oh yeah, this doesn’t actually work yet.” Give Hyundai and BMW time.
- hnburnsy 9mo agoPosted elsewhere in this discussion... >The Automation Factor Tesla’s response to labor pressure has always been more automation. In 2026, Giga Berlin is the pilot site for the "Optimus" Gen-3 integration—humanoid robots performing repetitive tasks in the battery pack assembly area. https://www.teslaacessories.com/blogs/news/the-giga-berlin-standoff-ig-metall%E2%80%99s-final-push-and-the-future-of-tesla-in-germany https://www.teslaacessories.com/blogs/news/the-giga-berlin-s...
- downrightmike 9mo agoHow they work? Without indication
- lifestyleguru 9mo agoThey communicate through tailing each other and flashing bright lights from behind.
- givemeethekeys 9mo agoThat's excellent! I look forward to much cheaper cars now that the robots will be making them for the masses.
- Flavius 9mo agoOh, absolutely. Because history clearly shows that when multi-billion dollar corporations save money on labor, they immediately pass those savings directly to the consumer.
- Zqwlpaj 9mo agoIt is a pilot project. German pilot projects rarely go anywhere. If this succeeds against all odds, I hope for BMW that the robots are buying cars, too.
- notahacker 9mo agoYeah. Feels kind of insignificant considering the amount of non-humanoid robots they've used on production lines for the last few decades and lack of any claims to be "fully autonomous" or for the humanoid robots to be performing particularly advanced tasks
- s3p 9mo agoIt'll be the first time a BMW ever used turn signals!
- rafaelmn 9mo agoNot if they trained on driver data. Will come with tailgating, lane swerving and flashing high beams as standard. Sonar will be used to judge the minimum distance you can ram behind someone and when to activate high beams.
- ItsYan 9mo agoPeople like to hate on BMW drivers but a BMW driver was the only person in a hardware store parking lot to help me with jump-starting my car.
- amelius 9mo agoMeanwhile China has dark factories.
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- weinzierl 9mo agoIn a sense BMW has factories in China too (through Brilliance). I once heard the story that they built a 1:1 clone of the Dingolfing plant there. The owner family did the right thing at the right time. If the Europe and US business tanks they will be fine. BMW as a brand not necessarily.
- torginus 9mo agoI think this is a myth - Chinese factories don't seem to be automated to a higher degree than European ones, and in any case are still full of Kuka, Fanuc and ABB robots. I think there's a domestic brand or two that's gaining marketshare, but they're not there yet. There's a myth of Chinese high-tech (esp in cars), that is not to say their stuff isn't technologically advanced, but the characterization that Chinese tech has left Europeans' behind just does not pass muster when one looks at mechanic videos of Chinese EVs. Their cars look fancy and are full of futuristic screens and sensors, but the suspension setup and lot of engineering behind them is not exactly cutting edge. That's why a lot of car reviewers say that a lot of their EVs don't drive particularly well
- ricardobeat 9mo agoThis take might have been true years ago, especially for cheaper makes, but modern EVs from china use high-quality components and designs that often surpass european automakers. The premium brands - Nio, Zeekr, Polestar, Lotus, etc - have design and R&D offices in Europe, and source parts from suppliers all over the world. Nio uses Nvidia Orin chips, Qualcomm SoCs, Brembo brakes, Bosch controllers, ZF suspension systems, Continental/Pirelli tires, and ClearMotion (in their flagship model); can't get any better than that. The driving feel is definitely a thing, the chinese cars are very soft and 'boaty' which is not as desirable elsewhere. They are also on average much larger and heavier than their western counterparts, cities in China have road infrastructure built in the past 20-30 years with spacious lanes.
- pinkmuffinere 9mo agoI think this is going to be bad for BMW, and bad for the current robotics-summer. I _hope_ that’s not the case, I’d love for robotics to get deployed more widely in manufacturing. But I’m pretty sure it will be. I think the chances of meaningful success would be higher with non-humanoid robotics
- krona 9mo agoThis is top-tier vagueposting.
- pinkmuffinere 9mo agoFeel free to ask for more details if you have specific questions! I worked in robotics for many years, I have some decent familiarity with this space. Here’s some more detailed thoughts “for free”: Humanoid robotics are largely a publicity stunt. Our actuators, sensors, and algorithms are better adapted to other form factors. The nice thing about humanoids is that you (in theory) don’t have to change the interface, since they can use the same interface humans can use. In practice that doesn’t hold well, because we don’t have great force/pressure sensors to cover large areas like human skin. Likewise, it’s difficult to apply the fine forces that are sometimes needed (grabbing an egg, moving a joystick, etc). And there’s risk of the robot doing something unpredictable, so you always have to set a good safety bound around it anyways. In the end it’s often better to adapt the process to modern robotics, rather than the other way around. There are many good practitioners that write about these and other limitations, I think Rodney Brooks has some good discussion of it, eg. https://rodneybrooks.com/why-todays-humanoids-wont-learn-dexterity/ https://rodneybrooks.com/why-todays-humanoids-wont-learn-dex...
- bitwize 9mo agoThere's also the idea that a humanoid robot can learn to imitate human action just by watching it, thanks to AI magic!
- barrkel 9mo agoApart from dexterity, bipedal machines are unstable and require dynamic adjustment to stay upright, as I understand it. The mechanism humans use to stay upright after an unexpected loss of balance, flailing etc., would not be safe to be around when a robot employs them.
- r33b33 9mo agoSo their cars will get cheaper, right... right???
- tirant 9mo agoWhy cheaper? BMW does not focus on providing cheap cars but highly performing ones. So probably the reduction in costs will be used to improve performance, features and perceived quality. BMW has pretty low margins, like around 7-12% usually. A 10% reduction in manufacturing costs is not much.
- moogly 9mo agoWill they dance? I've yet to see someone demo a humanoid robot doing something useful. Clearly, making them dance can't be that difficult.
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- javiramos 9mo agoAccording to Figure, their robots had already been deployed in production
- newppc 9mo agoTheir founder is a billionaire now because of BMW alone.
- ge96 9mo agoNot sure what the drawers are on the robot but one of the humanoid robots I saw changed its own battery that was pretty cool (I think it had 2).
- Maxion 9mo agoWhenever I hear german companies mention digitalisation, I get reminded that they still use pen and pencil in production environments to log data, pass those sheets to secreteries who enter the data into legacy systems so data analysts can enter it into another system that then has an integration with SAP. Data from SAP then flows onwards to some buzzword filled Azure product that costs a few million a month from which someone downloads an xls file and uploads it to Tableau where they run some simple calculations. Someone else downloads it as an xls and manually writes (not copy pastes) the numbers into a power point presentation and makes graphs by drawing shapes. This is then presented at some bi-monthly meeting. I wish I was making this stuff up.
- FrustratedMonky 9mo agoThat might actually describe a pretty good implementation of an interface to SAP. I think pencil is more efficient than SAP.
- hypeatei 9mo agoI agree and it's quite resilient to digital outages/downtime (at least in terms of hours, probably not more than a few days) so your manufacturing productivity won't drop to zero when the ERP system goes down. The paper logs can also be entered later when the system comes back up. As we've seen in the Iran conflict, datacenters are a target and result in extended outages.
- fHr 9mo ago
- dmix 9mo agoSeems to be this European robotics company https://robotics.hexagon.com/product/ https://robotics.hexagon.com/product/ https://blogs.nvidia.com/blog/hexagon-robotics-ai-software-aeon-humanoid/ https://blogs.nvidia.com/blog/hexagon-robotics-ai-software-a...
- skgough 9mo agoHexagon is very prominent in precision manufacturing through their dimensional measurement robots (CMM Coordinate Measurement Machine) and other metrology software/hardware. This is most likely why they were chosen by BMW, as I imagine they already have a working relationship together, although the EU aspect could have contributed as well. I wonder if this is a newly acquired subsidiary producing these robots (they've been doing a lot of acquisitions recently), or if these have been in development in-house for a while.
- torginus 9mo agoMy prediction is that by the time humanoid robots actually make it to the factory floor, they'll be pretty un-humanoid. 90% of car manufacturing is done by oldschool industrial robots, and I've had people point out that heavy use of industrial robots are basically unique to the car industry. You might see a robot arm here and there in other industries, but it's somewhat rare, usually its all purpose-built machines or humans.
- df2dfs 9mo agoI agree and for me personally this is very easy to see and understand. Why do you think the vast majority of people fail to see it like this? Guys like Musk obvious hype it up as he now has tied the valuation of the firms he owns and operates to this story.
- georgeecollins 9mo agoBecause so much infrastructure is in humanoid form. If you can make something that can manipulate two hands on arms that are positioned and moved like human arms, you could just put that torso into a lot of situations to replace a human without a lot of retooling. That's the dream I think.
- numpad0 9mo agoWhy doesn't anybody do the shoulder complex right? It gives me itches to scratch.
- deleted 9mo ago[deleted]
- okokwhatever 9mo agoAnd this is how it starts in EU
- fHr 9mo agoabsolute short on EU source: I'm from EU
- maxglute 9mo agoThis doesn't feel like it needs to be humanoid shaped. It does not appear ambulatory. Why not just tracked chassis with some robot arms. That said, humanoid robots with food tracks very anime.
- drnick1 9mo agoLooking forward to using one of those robots as a butler.
- asdff 9mo agoSeems so funny to me that we are building llms to write in english code for computers. And building robots to perform some automated processes in the shape of humans. When are we going to rip the bandaid off, and skip bothering with the ux layer built for humans? I guess that is just old fashioned 20th century factory style automation that doesn't get headlines written about it, at least not in these decades.
- Shitty-kitty 9mo agoThe humanoid-like robots are designed for existing prouction-lines that can't be easily shut-down and retooled/reconfigured.
- RealityVoid 9mo agoSo... a dwindling, dying market?
- cuvinny 9mo agoLooks like they already have been testing it in the Spartanburg, SC, USA plant (just outside of Greenville SC [also I think the largest BMW factory in the world making most of their SUVs]). Still I don't get why a humanoid robot would be a thing for car making, a robot arm seems like it'd almost always be more efficient.
- carefree-bob 9mo agoAuto manufacturers have been using robots for decades to paint, weld, machine, cast, and manufacture critical automobile components and even entire chassis. Some auto robot porn: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/Zi8EWZptTfA https://www.youtube.com/shorts/Zi8EWZptTfA The idea of humanoid looking robots shuffling around a factory floor seems like a gimmick to me.
- avaer 9mo agoNot sure this counts as "humanoid" any more than the robots we've had in factories for a century... the hands and feet are nothing like a human's, and would not be improved by being more human. It seems they just made the shape of their machine have a vaguely human silhouette so they could ride a hype wave. I'm all for programmable humanoid robots, humans are an awesome human interface, but this ain't it.
- MBCook 9mo agoThat’s generally what it seemed like to me too. Seemed to be human shaped so they could say it’s humanoid… and nothing else. Nothing in the video looked like it couldn’t be done by a more industrial robot shaped robot. And I bet that would be cheaper or easier to make. Then I started reading the text. When I got to the part very early on about deploying “Physical AI” that confirmed it to me. This all seems to be “humanoid washing”. Nothing terribly interesting that someone put a special coat of paint on to get attention. I’d love to be proven wrong. But the video certainly didn’t show it. And I didn’t notice it in the press release, though it was hard to parse past the ridiculously over the top language that did nothing but obscure what was actually going on. Probably because there’s not much going on.
- throwaway2037 9mo agoI agree with your opening paragraph -- hot take! What would be more interesting, would be to see humanoid robots un/packing and moving boxes in their warehouses. That to me seems like one of the first logical places to deploy humanoid robots to replace (or assist) human workers.
- afewquarks 9mo ago[dead]
- jimnotgym 9mo agoAnd the speed it is working is much slower than a human
- 9mo ago
- excalibur 9mo agoThe robots featured in the embedded promotional video appear to be mostly useless. This is the opposite of impressive.
- maxdo 9mo agoThey will deploy robots , but their infotainment system is crap. Entire pricing model is to sell extra volume in engine for $10k on each measurable step , even though electric cars has a solved performance that is only limited by tires. Not to mention their gas cars are way more complex vs electric. Sure that will save bmw .
- jonnypaceman 9mo ago[dead]
- ofrzeta 9mo agoLet me first comment that this is just another publicity stunt and that there will be no useful humanoids in BMW factories in the near future. Then I will read TFA and get back here.
- ofrzeta 9mo agoSo, nothing to see here. From what I understand the robots are doing pick and place. In the video the robot also gets passed a part from a human worker. So nothing here makes any sense and the tasks could solved with conventional robotics. I guess it is good that the robot can be moved but for this you don't need a two-legged humanoid balancing.
- tonyedgecombe 9mo ago>Then I will read TFA and get back here. I don’t know which is worse, your comment or the original article.
- ofrzeta 9mo agoFair enough.
- hnburnsy 9mo agoA union in Germany is fighting Tesla over this same thing... >. In 2026, Giga Berlin is the pilot site for the "Optimus" Gen-3 integration—humanoid robots performing repetitive tasks in the battery pack assembly area. IG Metall views this not as progress, but as a threat to job security. https://www.teslaacessories.com/blogs/news/the-giga-berlin-standoff-ig-metall%E2%80%99s-final-push-and-the-future-of-tesla-in-germany https://www.teslaacessories.com/blogs/news/the-giga-berlin-s...
- umpalumpaaa 9mo agoI always found German unions pretty good. I mean the union is correct in this case. Robots will replace jobs. A union’s job is to make sure there are jobs for people in the company they are already in. Usually unions would speak the truth (“robots = jobs go away”) but pair this with some suggestions: eg trying to upskill the affected worker so that they can be moved to a different department). While I was working in Germany I always felt better at a company with a strong union.
- tirant 9mo agoThe main problem with unions in Germany is that they block companies from adapting to changes in the environment quickly. Companies become heavy behemoths and end up suffering from it, which ends up damaging their own employees as well.
- moooo99 9mo agoI‘ve read this frequently, but I have yet to be convinced. The union presence seems to be more of a correlation than a causation to me. Larger companies move slower, larger companies also tend to have a stronger union presence than SMBs
- lnsru 9mo agoI can try convince you. In unionized companies one can’t fire employees from the 53rd birthday. That makes them similar to care home at the end. Young folks come and go and are minority at the end. Dynamics decrease not from the size, but from getting old. Since the salaries are more or less the same the oldtimers have maxed out bonuses. What do young guys get? Basically nothing since the bonus pool must be distributed equally in the company. I like the concept of the union, but I think that IG Metall is not the good implementation of that. At least not for white collar workers.
- LarsDu88 9mo agoThese humanoid robots making cars is always a bit disappointing. If you look at videos of an assembly line the humans do manually dexterous complex tasks like bolting in car seats which are move in by hand, or helping place windshields into position. The problem humanoid robots solve would be addressed better by simply altering the design of the car to not require humans to do that stuff. What we actually see is humanoid robots deployed to do tasks that can already be done with simpler robot arms...
- GuestFAUniverse 9mo agoWhat advantages has a humanoid robot compared to automation for the tasks in a factory? I mean: yeah, it's easier to think for a human how to operate a human. Is this the Pareto optimum? No low hanging fruits left? Does anyone here with years of experience in robotics have a better explanation? (I hope so, because all the domain experts I met, always could tackle questions that pop into the mind of a layman without even breaking a sweat. Experts being experts, obviously)
- hybridtupel 9mo agoThe first question I had when watching this was how this robot doesn’t fall over with just these two tiny wheels. The center of mass is much higher than on a Segway, for example, isn’t it?
- attheicearcade 9mo agoIt’s dynamically balancing so wheel size doesn’t really matter as long as the wheels are responsive enough. Segways have big wheels to deal with bumps, this has smooth concrete floors to roll around on.
- shellfishgene 9mo agoBalancing gets easier when the center of mass is high. Compare balancing a pencil on your hand vs a broomstick.
- rvz 9mo agoSo not Figure AI?
- mtct88 9mo agoI still don’t understand how this can be considered cheaper or more productive than using a human. I’m all for automation in industry, but the "human simulation" approach (where a robot mimics a human on a production line instead of using a process optimized for machine operation) just doesn’t make sense to me.
- ReptileMan 9mo agoA cheap humanoid robots will do wonders to alleviate the need for migration. And they can be plugged anywhere you have existing humans working.
- menaerus 9mo agoIt makes sense when you find out that there's only so much humans who want to do and are capable of doing that type of work. Also, robots are cheaper, and they are the opposite of humans - theyt are not emotional, lazy, feeling fatigue or any other spectrum of feelings or behavior ...
- pocksuppet 9mo agoBut why humanoid robots, instead of robots optimized for the task at hand?
- menaerus 9mo agoYou have to rebuild the factory and manufacturing process I guess. Humanoid robot is a drop in replacement for human requiring no intervention
- MagicMoonlight 9mo agoBecause humans can do any task. A fixed robot can only do one task.
- jillesvangurp 9mo agoMost manufacturing operations have a long tail of stuff that is done by people because it's just not worth buying/designing a specialized machine for. That's exactly the stuff that people do currently that humanoid robots might step in and do cheaper. Employees cost roughly 70-120K per year. A lot of work in automotive is skilled work that pays relatively well. So, the economic case is easy to understand. That's why there are lots of companies trying to produce humanoid robots. If they get good enough, lots of companies would buy them. A humanoid robot costing about 100K that can work around the clock (minus charging, battery swaps, servicing, etc.) doing work that otherwise would be done by a person could earn itself back in well under a year. Maybe it will cost a bit more or a bit less. Will they be able to do anything? Not right away probably. But they'll probably be able to do useful things which means people don't need to do these things and can do more valuable things with their time.
- khalic 9mo agoI see the industry found its new buzzword: humanoid robots Slap a "head" on an industrial machines and watch investors go brrrrrrrrr
- amai 9mo agoNow they can produce even more cars nobody wants. BMW really needs to change its strategy to build cars for the future ( battery electric vehicles ) and stop churning out all those heavy diesel SUVs. Because it doesn't matter how efficient you produce something, if it is the wrong thing you produce. Actually producing the wrong product highly efficiently makes matters even worse. It's like running in the wrong direction, but faster.
- oblio 9mo agoBMW makes a lot of EVs: https://www.press.bmwgroup.com/global/article/detail/T0454859EN/bmw-group-vehicle-sales-grew-in-2025-%E2%80%93-strong-performance-particularly-in-europe-and-the-us-and-with-electrified-models?language=en https://www.press.bmwgroup.com/global/article/detail/T045485... Almost half a million sold in 2025 (out of 2.5 million).
- amai 9mo agoSo only 20% of the cars they produce are electric. That is not enough. In China 50% of all sold cars are electric nowadays. In Norway it is even 90%. BMW is way behind these numbers. They are not producing for the future, they are producing for the past.
- oblio 9mo agoThe EV market is stalling: https://www.theatlantic.com/international/2025/11/china-electric-cars-market/684887/ https://www.theatlantic.com/international/2025/11/china-elec... The German car brands are better positioned than especially Americans are giving them credit for, especially people affected by Tesla's reality distortion field. Heck, Toyota is better positioned than many believe. They are just being cautious but they all have access to the relevant tech. EVs will become the majority of cars sold in major markets in maybe 5 years, and BMW, VW, Mercedes, etc. all have relevant EVs and many types, and they will have even more by then. They can't compete with subsidized Chinese EVs, but that will be solved soon as nobody wants to see a repeat of phone/smartphone industry destruction, but this time with cars. Yes, through tariffs and trade barriers.
- Zigurd 9mo agoI would place a bet that there are dozens to hundreds of German engineers gnashing their teeth over this travesty. This is a pure FOMO driven exercise, and the insulting thing is that BMWs management didn't even learn from Hyundai who ended up buying Boston Dynamics who started all of this madness with Atlas, which despite being the best humanoid robot still has no business case. It's especially funny to have a demo of human shaped robots doing low productivity tasks in a staged environment in a factory that has dozens of real robots doing real work faster and more productively than humans. Real robots work behind barriers because they are strong enough to be dangerous. But that hasn't got a sci-fi narrative for the public to latch on to.
- generic92034 9mo ago> Real robots work behind barriers because they are strong enough to be dangerous. But that hasn't got a sci-fi narrative for the public to latch on to. Wait till they are controlled by ASI - there is your sci-fi for real.
- specialist 9mo agoThis is BMW's clever attack on Tesla's overvaluation, partially based on Optimus hype. The use of (general purpose) humanoid robots in manufacturing will fail. BMW is just accelerating that outcome. Then Tesla's market cap will implode. Note that Tesla's business is pivoting to batteries. Demand is basically infinite. They'll kill it, basically printing money, if they survive the transition. Pass the popcorn.
- joelthelion 9mo agoI wonder if it's for real and at a meaningful scale, or if it's for the press release.
- CommenterPerson 9mo agoThe video screams demo and stupid stuff.
- tsoukase 9mo agoBMW was always aiming to theoretically reduce their number of workers to 0. So not surprising they prepare these next level robots to approach this. They take the opportunity now as others pushed the competition recently (Tesla, China and Japan) and so hardly anyone will accuse them as worker-killers. But this doesn't mean anyone else will follow in the EU.
- assaddayinh 9mo ago[dead]
- chili_rica 9mo agoJust a reminder: Bavaria government only had their fax machines phased out in 2024. Not 2004, not 2014, but 2024…
- niemandhier 9mo agoThis is surprisingly honest, let’s see if they can scale.
- Rummelj 9mo agoread this book if you want to feel really uneasy about this whole topic... https://www.amazon.com/Total-Optimization-Meridian-Book-1-ebook/dp/B0GRBVSF8H https://www.amazon.com/Total-Optimization-Meridian-Book-1-eb...