29 ms·
FTC sues Adobe for hiding fees and inhibiting cancellations
- nnurmanov 2y agoI have only one question. Why did it take them so long?
- some-unique-x 2y agoSo awful! For anyone facing this issue, an angry email to customer support citing the lawsuit is sufficient to obtain an immediate cost-free cancellation.
- extr 2y agoGood IMO. Adobe is a uniquely bad actor here, I can't think of many other services that operate in a similar way.
- dboreham 2y agoTry canceling SirriusXM.
- aaomidi 2y agoLet’s sue them too.
- davisr 2y agoWay ahead of you. https://lite.cnn.com/2023/12/20/media/siriusxm-cancellation-lawsuit/index.html https://lite.cnn.com/2023/12/20/media/siriusxm-cancellation-...
- terinjokes 2y agoI did so at the beginning of last year. I was on and off the phone within 5 minutes and they refunded the last month. I was canceling a several years old standalone radio subscription, and not trying to cancel at the end of a car's free trial, and I wonder if that's why I had such difference experience.
- PNewling 2y agoI feel like something must have changed, because when we went to cancel ours on a previous car ~3 years ago it was a long-ish process, but only because they kept offering more and more discounts until it was essentially free. A couple months ago when the trial ran out on a different car it was like you said, over and done with in 5 minutes.
- judge2020 2y agoIf you call to cancel every time, you'll probably end up with a subscription equal to $10/yr every year.
- heywire 2y agoIt’s not hard at all. In fact, I use an iPhone, and they have an iMessage “service” or whatever it is called where I just text them for account related things. Every year I text them for a discounted renewal on my wife’s car. Last year I cancelled service on my car because I just wasn’t using it often enough. Of course they started offering a discounted price, but when I countered that I’m just not using it, they completed the cancellation without issue. Guess I’ve been lucky.
- meowster 2y agoI never paid them, but used to receive their mailers. I once called them to stop sending me mailers, and they said they'll stop for two years, I said no, stop forever. I took my vehicle to a place that sold my information to SiriusXM and they resumed the mailers. But this time... I just created an account on their website and changed my address to their headquarters and phone number to their phone number. They can spam themselves for all I care! (I've done this with other businesses that don't respect their potential customers with great success! Often the people I speak with don't seem to recognize it when I give them their company's address or the 800-number that I called them at.)
- kstrauser 2y agoOne time I was at a mall with my dad. There was a nice new car on display and he wanted to go look at it. The salesman said if Dad filled out a postcard to register to win, we could sit in the car and check it out. Dad took the card and filled it out as “Tom” something-or-another. I watched this and kept my mouth shut. Afterward I asked him about it. He laughed. Tom was Dad’s favorite cousin’s ex-husband. Whenever something like this came up, Dad would give them Tom’s info. He’d been doing this for years, and occasionally updated the address as needed. Dad’s no longer with us but I still Tom up for things to this day. Should I ever start getting SiriusXM spam, so will Tom.
- cityofdelusion 2y agoSirius is easy these days, it’s a 2 minute phone call. They’ll offer a discount rate, decline it, canceled and refunded. Gym memberships and newspaper subscriptions is what needs to get targeted next. They are aggressive and lots of gyms will only cancel in-person, even if you move away.
- bogwog 2y ago> Sirius is easy these days, it’s a 2 minute phone call. That's still 2 minutes and one phone call too much.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoI don't know, 2 minutes is about the time to cancel an online subscription.
- broodbucket 2y agoA lot of people, including myself, consider a phone call an extremely unwanted barrier. If you can sign up without speaking to a person then you should be able to cancel without speaking to a person, no matter what. Phone call anxiety is a real thing. No idea why I have it, but I do
- bogwog 2y agoNot at all. You can go to a website and click a button in less than a minute, and you don't have to do it during business hours, sit on hold, or deal with a pushy sales rep trying to convince you not to cancel (well, unless they do what Adobe is getting sued for). There is no legitimate reason to limit the options for canceling a subscription or adding barriers to the process. It's always an anti-consumer move. If you don't want your customers to cancel, then don't give them a reason to.
- Sohcahtoa82 2y agoI successfully canceled a newspaper subscription in like 2005, but for a few months, they'd call. The first couple times, I said I wasn't interested and hung up. Then I just stopped answering, but they still called. Then I finally answered once and said "Stop calling me" and they tried to say "If you want to be removed from our call list, you'll need to call our customer service line" and I said "No, that's not how this works. I asked you to stop calling me, so stop calling me." and hung up. Surprisingly, they actually did stop calling. SiriusXM never called me, but I got mail from them every damn week. I had even tried telling them to stop sending me mail, but still got it until I just changed my address to some bullshit fake address that didn't exist.
- rockinghigh 2y agoCanceling SiriusXM is pretty easy via phone. Adobe makes the process confusing to make you believe you canceled even you haven't yet. It also charges high cancellation fees and has threatening wording.
- georgeecollins 2y agoI was just having a terrible experience trying to uninstall the "Adobe Creative Cloud". I have used it and paid for it. It's full of anti-patterns to make it difficult to uninstall, and now that I don't pay for it any more it just exists on my computer to nag me to renew my subscriptions. They have good products and I gladly pay for software I use. But the whole cloud service experience has not been good for me. Cory Doctorow coined a word for this that I am too polite to use.
- beretguy 2y agoReinstall OS.
- spike021 2y agoNew York Times. Last year I wanted to cancel my Athletic subscription and not only do they use the positively colored buttons to cancel the cancellation flow rather than continue with cancelling, once you get to what seems like a final confirmation, it doesn't show anything to confirm it actually was cancelled. I ended up needing to wait until the next bill date to make sure I wasn't charged again. Their support was useless too.
- gabinator 2y agoSeveral years ago, the only way to cancel was over the phone. Hallmark of scumbag business. Planet Fitness requires in-person or a mailed note for cancellation (unless you “move” to California which legally requires companies to provide online cancellation if you can sign up online)
- jcotton42 2y agoStories like this make me thankful for my locally-owned gym, which won't even renew your membership without explicit verbal permission over the phone or in person.
- lelandfe 2y agoMy local gym ducked my calls, ignored my emails, and then after finally canceling, actually restarted my membership two months later. Gyms thrive on those bad with finances, people who don’t know what services they subscribe to.
- ehsankia 2y agoUgh that pissed me off so much! Thankfully I used paypal to subscribe, and Paypal allows me to just not pay anymore for a subscription, so I just did that. Good to know that's not a thing anymore, i don't know how that was ever legal to allow someone to subscribe through one medium, and not allow them to unsubscribe through the same medium.
- selimthegrim 2y agoIf you pay via Apple Pay, they can’t do that
- Yodel0914 2y agoAudible is similarly bad. The only notification of my 12mth subscription renewal was after it had occurred. If I cancel, I lose any unused credits plus access the the included-in-subscription content immediately. There's no way to cancel auto-renewal - you're either subscribed or you're not. I have a reminder set to cancel close to the renewal date. I find it strange because the rest of Amazon seems pretty good in this regard.
- barbariangrunge 2y agoAmazon accounts are really hard to delete too. You have to talk to a retention person and jump through says of hoops
- baal80spam 2y agoGood.
- martinky24 2y agoWould love to get the money I wasted on this problem back. Who knows if that's on the table... Class action lawsuits can result in payouts though.
- strictnein 2y ago$17 coupon for future Adobe services coming your way!
- gyudin 2y agoFrom personal experience they refused to cancel subscription or close account as they failed to charge my card after a trial period. So I just blocked their emails for good :D
- altacc 2y agoAbout 25 years ago, working at one of those dot com bubble internet consultancy firms, I was told by an Adobe rep that they knew everyone at home had a pirated copy of their software but the company view was that they thought that was a good thing. It meant people learnt their software at home and then insisted on using it at work, where it would be a paid for license. It seems their attitudes changed soon after, perhaps due to their almost total market dominance, and they became aggressive towards their users in the pursuit of profits. The last Adobe software I really used was Lightroom as that was one of the last pay-once software titles. Now the only Adobe product most of us at work have is except Acrobat Reader. We were quite glad when the Figma purchase failed.
- whywhywhywhy 2y agoFigma’s pricing is extremely exploitative too, it’s essentially designed in a way were trivial actions can instantiate new subscription seats that have to be manually removed.
- dylan604 2y agoThe number of graphic artists working from home well before COVID definitely put a kibosh to that theory.
- robertlagrant 2y agoWere they not working for a company?
- nickff 2y agoMany graphic artists operate as independent contractors/consultants.
- imabotbeep2937 2y agoPresumably they mean gig economy aka artists are vastly undervalued. For instance. It's not that AI is replacing artists. It's that people think you don't need to pay a license for generated images, even when they were clearly and provably stolen from copyright material. The bar was just lowered. If "AI" is used to remove the watermark from Shutterstock people think that's legal now. So WHEN gig economy workers get picked up by a company. Yes they pay for a software license as a "tax" on going pro. But from personal experience. A vast amount of art and content is made by people from developing economies on Fiver or whatever. Many of those licenses are stolen. And now everyone thinks you don't need to pay artists anymore. So nobody will generate licenses. Adobe was basically right. They're just going at it in the maximally enshittified manner.
- ncr100 2y agoDoes working at Adobe impact the individual 's ethics? This seems like a case where Adobe is behaving unethically. I wonder if long-term Adobe employees have the sense about their ethics being more flexible now, versus when they started at Adobe?
- dylan604 2y agoDoes working at Facebook, Twitt...er,X, TikTok, or any of the other soulless companies?
- CobrastanJorji 2y agoIt's easy for things like Adobe or Facebook or Twitter because they're mostly one thing. The others are kind of complicated to me. They're so large that the sins kinda get diluted. How many products does Microsoft have? How many dark patterns do they need to make use of among those products before you can no longer justify working for the corporation as a whole? Can you work on Microsoft Research because the XBox Game Pass subscription cancellation is problematic? I think I could justify that to myself just fine, but I imagine that's a personal call.
- dylan604 2y agoI get the gist of your comment, but your specifically chosen example of Microsoft is a bad one. It's not just MS's XBox subscription is bad by itself. The recent news about the forced inclusion of Recall. The forced inclusion of ads into the OS. The horrendous data collection by MS. The list goes on and on that would put Microsoft on a egregiously morally bankrupt company on all levels. A novel idea let down by a poor example.
- haiku2077 2y agoI worked for Adobe and it was very much _not_ "one thing". My work there involved literally tens of thousands of software services across three major segments and hundreds of products.
- dogleash 2y ago
- otar 2y agoLong overdue
- rightbyte 2y agoThe bank should just have some sort of interface where you can cancel recurring charges on the card. Changing card is a bit to blunt.
- teeray 2y agoThe problem is that that does not release you from your contractual obligation to pay every month. The company is still free to (and often does) send you to collections.
- esotericimpl 2y ago[dead]
- dylan604 2y agoThat's fine with me. We can then let that "debt" linger until it is bought up by some company willing to settle for pennies on the dollar
- teeray 2y agoMeanwhile, you can’t get a mortgage or a car loan because your SiriusXM bill remains unpaid because you “fixed the glitch.”
- dylan604 2y agoSure, caveats are always included, but if you don't need a mortgage or a car loan, fuck 'em.
- ryandrake 2y agoNot just a mortgage or car loan. Credit checks[1] are being used by landlords to decide whether or not to allow you to rent. They are being used by employers to decide whether or not to hire you. They are being used by utility companies and insurance companies to decide whether or not to do business with you. It's slowly getting to the point where a low credit score will bar you from participating in major areas of the economy. 1: https://www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/what-is-credit-check/ https://www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/what-is-credit-c...
- brink 2y agoWhile we're at it, can we sue Apple for making it too hard for us to export our data off of their cloud?
- tempnow987 2y agoNo - because that's clearly an attack vector to steal information as well.
- stavros 2y agoWhat attack vector could that possibly enable for a session with a valid login?
- tempnow987 2y agoThe regulations generally have required businesses to respond to written requests. While GPDR and others vary, at least with CCPA two data points are enough to get a release of data. What's done is if general info on you has leaked (say email address / date of birth / social etc) then someone can use that to go to Apple and now request a full dump of everything they have on you. So you can leverage one dump / leak, and now go after lots of players that have to comply with a data export request to get everything you want to know about someone. Google / Microsoft / Apple / etc can have a surprising amount of sensitive data (every photo you have taken or that's been shared with you) and even though you've been hit by one data leak, you may not want those folks to be able to leverage that for more leaks. https://dataprivacy.foxrothschild.com/2019/02/articles/european-union/gdpr-watch-out-for-fake-requests-for-access-of-deletion-of-information/ https://dataprivacy.foxrothschild.com/2019/02/articles/europ... The liability is usually very high if the companies DON'T release data - so the bias moves to releasing data (there are folks who go around putting requests in and complaining if the data dump is not easy to get).
- stavros 2y agoBut this seems trivial to stop: "you can find the 'Download Everything' button in your account settings".
- imzadi 2y agoSo, this might be fixed, but you could get around the cancellation fee by changing your plan to the Dreamweaver monthly plan and then cancelling that. You'd get a prorated refund when you changed plans and then an additional refund for the monthly plan when you cancelled it.
- tempnow987 2y agoA reminder that like all good companies adept at scamming folks they have HUGE ethics policies :) Ethics and Integrity At Adobe, good business begins with our commitment to the highest ethical standards. We adhere to the following core principles: Integrity, by conducting business according to high ethical standards Respect for our employees, customers, vendors, partners, stockholders and the communities in which we work and live Honesty in our internal and external communications and all business transactions Quality in our products and services, striving to deliver the highest value to our customers and partners Responsibility for our words and actions, confirming our commitment to do what we say Fairness through adherence to applicable laws, regulations, policies and a high standard of behavior We encourage you to read our policies to learn more about the legal and ethical standards we embrace. AI ethics at Adobe Australia Modern Slavery Act Statement California Transparency in Supply Chains Act Statement Code of Business Conduct Code of Ethics Conflicts of Interest Global Anti-Corruption Policy Partner Code of Conduct Public Policy and Government Relations Policy UK Slavery and Human Trafficking Statement Adobe Whistleblowing Privacy Notice
- diego_sandoval 2y agoIn Spanish se have a saying: "Dime de qué presumes y te diré de qué careces". Tell me what you brag about and I'll tell you what you lack.
- personalityson 2y agoLeaked messages show Adobe employees worry AI could kill the jobs of their own customers, reducing the number of Creative Cloud subscriptions. https://petapixel.com/2023/07/31/adobe-staff-worry-their-ai-could-kill-the-jobs-of-their-own-customers/ https://petapixel.com/2023/07/31/adobe-staff-worry-their-ai-...
- BHSPitMonkey 2y agoAI will eliminate a lot of creative industry jobs regardless of what people at Adobe say.
- CobrastanJorji 2y agoAdobe says "Make amazing transformations in seconds with tools powered by Firefly generative AI! Create images with just a few words, unlock endless color combinations, and make eye-popping text effects! You have to try it to believe it! See what generative AI can do for your business!"
- paradite 2y agoIf you buy or still have the perpetual license of Lightroom, can you use it to process raws from newly released cameras?
- perfectstorm 2y agoi tried activating my old Lightroom software (purchased in 2015 or 2016) and they wouldn't let me activate it. Adobe customer service said their activation servers are taken offline for my Lightoom version.
- jkaplowitz 2y agoWhy does the version of the complaint embedded in the article have so many redactions? Any idea what kind of information those would contain and why they would be redacted?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- dagmx 2y agoPro-tip if you ever want cheaper Adobe subscriptions is to cancel your sub and they’ll send you repeat offers at lower prices up to 60% off. Though, obviously as per the article, this is a pain to do. It’s really a shame there’s nothing comparable to Adobe’s products on the really pro-artist end of things. Companies like Serif have tried with Affinity but it’s lackluster when you really need to do some high end work. OSS stuff like Krita, Inkscape and Gimp have improved a lot but there’s still a huge gulf. Photoshop is perhaps the easiest to replace, but the rest of the suite like Illustrator really has no competition when it comes to functionality. Affinity Designer lacks so many of the gradient tools, shape repetition, and even certain alignment tools. InDesign similarly has many QoL features that Affinity Publisher lack. After Effects has some competition but nowhere near the ecosystem it provides. I guess premiere and animate (previously flash) have a lot of competition but that’s about it? For reference of where I’m coming from , I own licenses to the full Adobe suite and the full affinity suite. I have professionally done art and programmed for features in multiple domains for a decade and my work has shipped with major products from FAANG-like companies. I totally think the alternatives can replace Adobe products at some level, but the level of tooling I need and that Adobe has provided, is currently unmatched. It would be great to see better alternatives someday.
- imabotbeep2937 2y agoThis is true of literally everything in the new economy. Internet? Wait until the moment your "promo" cost ends and your bill goes from $80 to $150, threaten to quit, oh wow magically you can have $80 again and a free mobile phone line. Any subscription service is like this. I sometimes grab a Blue Apron when it's 65+% off which is anytime I want. My ex used to do this with clothing subscriptions, up to 80% off. There are laws against things being "always on sale". But now they're just being used to punish lazy customers who don't keep up on their promos. Only lazy or ignorant people pay the "real" price. Oh hey would you look at that, another billion dollar IPO with no plan for profitability went bankrupt. Weird.
- nkozyra 2y agoI had T-Mobile starting in ~2003 and it included unlimited tethering. After they introduced the Netflix included offer I inquired and they offered an "upgrade" that they swore up and down would not change my current service. After agreeing, I was traveling and tried to tether and boom nothing. Their upgrade that would change nothing got me out of this grandfathered situation. Over time the cost of Netflix resulted in a higher fee for Netflix and ultimately I pay more for less. Can't trust any company not to do anything in their power to squeeze another dime out of you.
- mcpar-land 2y ago"FTC charges Adobe their annual Business Practices fee" Not to be a pessimist, but what's the chance this is just another suit that's a rounding error compared to the revenue Adobe gains from these unethical business practices in the first place?
- wmf 2y agoPresumably Adobe will have to stop these practices to settle the case.
- bachmeier 2y agoYes - and the penalties would not be a rounding error the next time.
- josephcsible 2y agoIMO, fines for deceptive or unfair business practices should never be less than the total revenue resulting from them.
- bogwog 2y agoThe FTC has been more aggressive and actually doing their job under this administration. Idk if this particular case will have a satisfying conclusion, but I'd say the chances are as good as they've ever been.
- amne 2y agoI see the complaint naming individuals by name. I wonder how far the chain one can go to punish individuals for something like this .. can a dev or qa tester get fined for this? Should they get fined?
- lagniappe 2y agoTo be a fly on the wall at Planet Fitness HQ right now..
- katangafor 2y agoOr any gym I've tried. Washington sports club kept charging me after email/verbal confirmations that the account was closed. Trying to do it in the app resulted in a "server error" lmao. Had to pester them so many times, and of course they never refunded me for the months where they lied to me and I thought the account was canceled
- ProllyInfamous 2y agoMy local-to-Chatt gym (unfranchised) allows no-hassle cancelation, pro-rated. I now only attend the county's free gym, which is actually decent (and true athletes, not just social meetups); or buy a daypass to local college facility ($5).
- slater 2y agoDid anything ever come of those proposed "cancelling subscriptions must be as easy as setting up the initial subscription" laws? I kept hearing about them in discussions about the infamously impossible-to-unsub NYTimes subscriptions, then nothing happens.
- nottorp 2y agoHmm. So the FTC has no power to enforce the rules it makes? Has to resort to lawsuits? How about the other US government agencies regulating ... something? Is the FDA as toothless as the FTC?
- acdha 2y agoAgencies have the powers specifically delegated to them by Congress. That’s different in every case because there are different politicians in power when various laws are passed and the political factors vary. In cases like this, you really want to contact your congressional representatives because they will hear a lot from the companies who see enough revenue to make it a lobbying point and might figure that the general public doesn’t really see it as a priority.
- nottorp 2y agoAs an outsider, I'm just surprised to find out another weirdness of the US system :) I have no congresscritter to contact. Around here if an agency is regulating something it also has the power to impose changes and/or fine. Those can be contested in court but involving the legal system for years isn't the first step.
- acdha 2y agoThey often do here as well. It’s just very situational whether they have the ability to levy a fine directly, force action (e.g. the FAA can decide that an airplane is unsafe and they’re immediately grounded), or sue. Consistency would be nice, but every time someone proposes changes they’re going to hit industry opposition unless there was just a big failure, at which point they’ll probably try to let it go forward enough for the initial news to fade and then water it down.
- kbolino 2y agoCivil action is enforcement. The standards of proof and costs involved are lower than for criminal prosecution.
- zinga124 2y agoVery much welcome this!
- dynjo 2y agoTotally deserved for a morally corrupt business.
- EncomLab 2y agoWent to GIMP years ago and never looked back.
- powersj 2y agoCancelled my lightroom cloud account last night and was very surprised at the "early cancellation fee". Only made me upset and more determined to move off to something else! Very happy to see this post this morning.
- uptown 2y agoWhat'd you switch to?
- powersj 2y agoDarkroom [1], my scenario is I am editing my photos on my iPad and it can do all the same basic edits and modifications with it and I can use my photo library to organize things rather than have them in Adobe's cloud [1] https://darkroom.co/ https://darkroom.co/
- uptown 2y agoGave it a try. Seems to be very lacking for any type of bulk operations, and little things like saving your edits requires too many steps. For instance, I wanted to modify the coloration of a set of photos that I'd shot in one session. Yes, I can apply the adjustments, then copy and paste those to another photo, but I can't do that in-bulk, so you need to apply it to each individual photo. Then the save workflow requires that you popup the save modal, then choose what type of save you wish to perform. Unfortunately too clunky for my use-case.
- focusedone 2y agoPlease do share what you moved to. Lightroom is the only Adobe product I'm still on the hook for.
- gorkish 2y agoWhen creative cloud was very first released, it was excellent value. I was actually quite supportive of Adobe's initial SaaS strategy. It was well and truly a "why would anyone ever pirate photoshop ever again?" type of product. Fast forward a decade and that $19.99/mo product has become $89.99/mo and the value prop has plummeted on top of it. The big difference today is that instead of people returning to the high seas and continuing to use adobe software, they are just moving to different ecosystems -- procreate, davinci, foxit, etc.
- Eji1700 2y ago> When creative cloud was very first released, it was excellent value. I was actually quite supportive of Adobe's initial SaaS strategy. It was well and truly a "why would anyone ever pirate photoshop ever again?" type of product. This is the entire issue with these kinds of things. They always launch at a good value because they know they can capture the market. Yes if they were benevolent or whatever it'd be fine, but these things almost ALWAYS turn into cluster fucks. They couldn't launch at worse value than the current product line because they need full adoption before they can put the screws to you.
- mistrial9 2y agoagree but I would reverse the cause and effect.. launch great experience on the web+cloud to gain traction.. then Because it is so Easy to Do It, change the terms of service, the benefits, the longevity, the billing practices, the prices.. etc IMO pathetic to see a well-loved brand degenerate in the public.. especially while Apple counts that cash (and ways they ran rough over their former "friend" )
- Topgamer7 2y agoI don't want to pay for a subscription for software I use thrice a year. I was looking forward to having Affinity's suite be the replacement, where I could buy it, and use it. However I don't want to support another company that is inevitably going to go subscription. Since they've been bought by canva, it's just a matter of time. I even went so far as to get Affinity Photo being able to start on Wine. But lost interest since their acquisition. (I'm sure people will question why I don't just use inkscape, krita, or gimp. And its because all of them have a subpar vector experience IMO)
- tombert 2y agoCorel's (or whatever they call themselves now) stuff is generally pretty ok, and most of their stuff still lets you buy it outright. I don't know much about Affinity Photo but Paint Shop Pro and Aftershot have been "good enough" for the limited uses I have for photo editing (though I'm definitely far from a professional). CorelDraw is, I think, a very decent vector drawing program if nothing else.
- SomeCallMeTim 2y agoCorelDraw is great, but for years they were also subscription-only. In the last six months or so they finally started offering a single-price license again--at a prohibitive level. I bought the previous single-price version years ago, and it's so stale that I prefer to use Inkscape, despite the more limited feature set, and I've been using the Affinity suite as a more professional replacement. Now it looks like they let you buy it again, but at $550, I'm still giving them the finger. Their upgrade price used to be ~$200; I would pay that once ever 3-4 years or so, and consider that a reasonable expense to get a good product and have it available when I did need it. But for $550, I'd need to be planning on keeping it for something like a decade to get a similar value--and it's too much to justify buying at my limited usage level. All of these subscription services should get over themselves and allow you to rent them for occasional usage for a reasonable amount of money. If I could give them $20 for intermittent (time-limited? operation-limited?) use, with no "auto-renewal", I might do that every time I actually needed the product. But no, they need to be greedy and demand that you pay for a year of usage in advance (or by using deceptive practices like Adobe above). I've used Paint Shop Pro, and I really don't like it. I can use Corel PhotoPaint and Affinity Photo, and they're fine, but PSP makes me crazy when I try to use it. I'd almost rather use Gimp.
- BoredPositron 2y agoIf affinity would just get their act together and release their suite for linux we could all get over adobe real quick.
- kstrauser 2y agoHas Adobe released their suite for Linux?
- BoredPositron 2y agoThat's not the point. Industries such as VFX and game studios often either run dual-boot systems or provide two workstations per artist. If there is a usable equivalent for Linux, they will adopt it because the rest of their tooling runs on Linux anyways. Currently, they have no incentive to switch.
- kstrauser 2y agoAh, I see what you're saying. It's not that Linux users can't switch off an existing Adobe setup to Affinity, as that having a native Affinity build on Linux would enable people to switch off Adobe.
- Capricorn2481 2y agoI have never heard of any VFX artist running linux. Is that really true?
- SSLy 2y agohttps://www.autodesk.com/support/technical/article/caas/sfdcarticles/sfdcarticles/flame-2025-sysreqs.html https://www.autodesk.com/support/technical/article/caas/sfdc... Operating System Rocky Linux 9.3 Rocky Linux 8.7 Rocky Linux 8.5
- Capricorn2481 2y agoI meant more are most VFX artists actually using Linux like the commenter claims. There are DAWs for linux too but everyone is using mac or windows in music.
- djbusby 2y agoI had similar issues with OVH. Got an annual contract, didn't like their service, went to cancel but it had already renewed into second year and I had to cancel 30 days before that. So I missed my small window. Now stuck with another year because to cancel means just pay out the rest of the contract. Grrr.
- aliasxneo 2y agoI recently used Privacy card to purchase a monthly subscription to Adobe Acrobat for a one-time need. They've been failing to charge me $30 for weeks now. Sad that I have to resort to this kind of stuff to protect myself from businesses.
- ceejayoz 2y agoBe aware that they sometimes send folks to collections (with the corresponding credit hit) over this; most of the subscriptions are worded as annual commitments.
- tombert 2y agoI haven't used any Adobe products since they started doing the subscription-only model. I want to use it, they typically make good enough software, but I have a line in the sand that I will not pay for a subscription. I want to buy my software and own it and use it for as long as I want. Basically my options if I don't want top pay a license fee for forever is to find alternatives, or pirate the software. I've opted for the former, but either leads to Adobe getting $0 from me, where they could have gotten >$0 if they had had a "pay outright" program. I have generally found good enough alternatives with their competitors (Toonboom is generally good enough for basic animation, Krita is good enough for artsy stuff, Final Cut Pro is good enough for video editing).
- johndhi 2y agoYou'd pay $1500 or whatever for a perpetual Photoshop license? I wouldn't
- tombert 2y agoI mean, sure, there's probably an upper bound of a number I'd pay, and I don't do enough photo editing to justify paying really any amount of money for Photoshop. For software I'd actually use though? Upper bound is probably $600 judging by what I paid for Toonboom Harmony. Honestly if I had known about Moho at the time I probably would have gotten that since it's considerably cheaper and on Humble Bundle fairly often. I'm not in a creative industry so it's tough for me to know "fair" numbers, just "what can I justify as a toy" numbers. I like to occasionally whip out an animation tool and draw stuff with stick figures, and I like having that readily available, and I don't want my tool to change from under me so I don't want transparent updates. I just want to buy my software once.
- bobim 2y agoThat's dirt cheap for a software you can make a living off. For FEA or CFD one would need to shell off in the order of 50-100k plus 20k per year. 1500? I would.
- SomeCallMeTim 2y ago
- jmount 2y agoI was at a party once and was introduced to a nice person who worked for Adobe. At the time I was heavily into photography, and I started praising Adobe Photoshop. Unfortunately (due to a lack of editor) I continued with how Photoshop was great, unlike so many other Adobe products. Then I attempted to apologize by saying I was wrong and rude, but it is just that Adobe policies are so nasty. Saw the guy on BART the next day, he didn't make eye contact. I still feel both bad and right.
- ProllyInfamous 2y ago>I still feel both bad and right. Stand tall for your righteousness. It's time to bring shame back to inherently-sociopathic corporate NPCs.
- iamleppert 2y agoCustomers should be required to pay out the FULL contract enterprise value under force of law.
- twosheep 2y ago"annual contract billed monthly" is a dark pattern - it's not monthly, it's annual, and deliberately confusing
- terpimost 2y agoAs a happy paying customer of Photopea (photoshop in a browser by not Adobe) I’m glad Figma isn’t under Adobe but there is a revenue/investors pressure and Figma is becoming more and more affected by it. I would be fine paying for Adobe if their software would be the beat example of UX and performance. But sluggish brush stroke on M1 is just not acceptable.
- returnInfinity 2y agoFigma is VC funded, and will soon IPO. It will soon be owned by the same people that own Adobe.
- ProllyInfamous 2y agoThey're "figma" find out about Adobe's best practices.
- kaetemi 2y agoI had the "cancel anytime after the first year" plan, and after that first year was over, they tried charging another whole year as cancellation fee.
- drra 2y agoI own an ancient box copy of Adobe Photoshop CS4 and use it just because of muscle memory. Since a year or so, periodically it bullies me with a popup that my unlicensed software is going to be disabled and it shows every 15 minutes regardless if I run Photoshop or not. Can't close it without going to Adobe website. I'll never going to buy or support anyone in buying anything produced by Adobe. Not going to cry if they go down either.
- focusedone 2y agoI'm also nursing along CS4 but (very fortunately) haven't seen that error. I'm woefully out of date, so maybe got lucky with that. After many sleepless nights fighting with Adobe's licensing servers, which had erroneously declared my installation no longer valid, I keep an extra desktop offline with my 2nd licensed install ready for their next round of shenanigans.
- rglover 2y agoThe funny part of this behavior is (I'd imagine) Adobe would make far more money if they just offered simple plans and a "cancel any time" option alongside a "pay once for one year of upgrades and then that version works/is supported until the support window ends" option. So many great businesses have been ruined by the need for endless growth leading to dark patterns.
- crazygringo 2y agoOh no, I guarantee you the current way is making Adobe more money. They wouldn't be doing it otherwise. It's not a mistake.
- CobrastanJorji 2y agoIt absolutely can be a mistake. It's probably making them significantly more money in the short term, but it can be a total self-own on the scale of years, and perhaps not even that many years.
- fendy3002 2y agoShort term is what matters to them. CEOs want to cash out the bonus
- crazygringo 2y agoThank goodness, it's about time! My only question is, what the heck took the FTC this long? Why didn't they do this years ago? The problems with cancelling Adobe CC are well known: - Consumers think they've subscribed to a monthly plan only to discover it's yearly - If they cancel before the year is over they still have to pay 50% of the remaining time, while the software stops working immediately, and they had no idea - But worst of all, if you want to set it to NOT autorenew at the end of the year, YOU CAN'T [1]. You can't cancel renewal but keep the existing subscription through the end of the year. Which is insane. You have to wait until some brief "cancellation window" period at the end of your year, and cancel it AFTER the window has opened up but BEFORE it actually renews. Again, this is INSANE And all this is on top of the complaints that people try to cancel over the phone even within the cancellation window, and either can't do it, or think they've done it but it hasn't. There's no way the FTC won't win here. And I hope the FTC levies a truly massive fine on Adobe, ON TOP OF refunds to consumers of all previous cancellation fees. It's absolutely despicable behavior, and there's no way Adobe would be able to get away with it if they didn't have network lock-in effects from what have become the industry file formats of Photoshop, Illustrator, Premiere, etc. If you collaborate in the graphics space you need to use their tools period, so you can edit files people send you and vice-versa. Conversion tools never work perfectly, or even well, when they even exist at all. [1] https://helpx.adobe.com/manage-account/using/manage-auto-renewal-settings.html https://helpx.adobe.com/manage-account/using/manage-auto-ren...
- hparadiz 2y agoI hope they get the book thrown at them. Absolute scum.
- Night_Thastus 2y ago>My only question is, what took the FTC this long? Why didn't they do this years ago? In general, the government and its agencies move very slowly. Compared to the FTC, Adobe's move over to subscription is quite recent. Adobe's only been doing subscriptions for what, maybe 10 years? And these problems are even more recent than that. It also takes time to build up a case, even if they had looked into it immediately. Get a nice long paper trail, lots of documentation, consumer complaints, etc. That can take years. As they get more familiar with the modern world of software, I think cases like this will take less and less time to deal with.
- 0xcde4c3db 2y agoBill Gates once expressed a similar view about rampant piracy of Microsoft software in China [1]: > Although about 3 million computers get sold every year in China, people don’t pay for the software. Someday they will, though. And as long as they’re going to steal it, we want them to steal ours. They’ll get sort of addicted, and then we’ll somehow figure out how to collect sometime in the next decade. [1] https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2006-apr-09-fi-micropiracy9-story.html https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2006-apr-09-fi-micro...
- jpeter 2y agoWell did they figure it out?
- shuckles 2y agoMy feeling is this logic only holds if your product is being pirated because it’s the best. Windows was certainly better than Linux, but ultimately when a consumer can afford it they’d rather buy a Mac.
- DSMan195276 2y agoI don't think it's that simple. Plenty of people won't buy a Mac because it's "different", which of them is 'better' never factors into it. While I don't use Photoshop I'd assume that logic holds even stronger - if you know how to use Photoshop you're going to ask for that rather than a tool you don't know how to use.
- shuckles 2y agoIf people were pirating Photoshop only because it was easy to pirate, my guess is when it came to professional work or another occasion where they had the funds to pay for image editing software, they would overcome whatever friction necessary to buy the best. That definitely happens in other cases like video editing where easy to access software is different than what studios pay for. As a thought experiment: if Photoshop was means tested and free to anyone who couldn’t afford it, would that actually convert users when they had money?
- michael_vo 2y agoMy dad was accidentally paying 89.99$ a month and hasn't used their service for a year. I cancelled it for him after going through his taxes/finances. They use all sorts of dark UX practices at signup and cancellation. Honestly there should be a law where if you haven't logged into your account in 3 months you should get a notification asking if you want to cancel. It's one thing if the company is storing your data (like google photos) as that has an associated cost, but inactive accounts just feels like corporate theft.
- ryandrake 2y agoI've never really understood how someone could "forget" they were paying for something. Like, doesn't everyone check their bank balances and purchase histories at least once a month? Or at least just skim their credit card bills? How do you even make sure you have enough money for things? I have Quicken open pretty much constantly, and refresh at least once a day. Of course not everyone is as anal as me, but you'd think at a bare minimum most people took a peek at their finances once a month? Once a year even? How do people just stay on autopilot for months/years and just wing it?
- beretguy 2y agoSome people are rich.
- popcalc 2y agoLet's say most Americans wouldn't question a $5 unrecognized charge showing up every month because the statement delta isn't enough to peek their suspicion. Especially true if they're not paying statement balance every month. In the consumer's mind, they treat their credit card balance like casino chips. Fostering mental fiscal compartmentalization and cognitive dissonance is your best bet in screwing over the American consumer for that $$$. Meanwhile, an Eastern European grandma would show up at the branch office of the company with a pitchfork.
- johnnyanmac 2y ago
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoThey absolutely deserve it. A number of these companies have started abusing their customers in illegal ways by forcing them to accept new terms and conditions before they can even login to cancel subscriptions or access things they have already paid for. This needs to be ended through legislation, but also needs to be retroactive, with fines and jail time for the senior most executives. Adobe is not the only problem company. Blizzard and Roku and TP Link and Sonos are all recent examples.
- docmars 2y agoAdobe Color me absolutely shocked! ;)
- gist 2y agoNot a fan of HN posts like this that devolve into a bunch of pile on anecdotes which end up creating chatter which obscures the non anecdotes.
- deliveryboyman 2y agoUnfortunately this is the epitome of the HN comment section. Instead of comments by users who have read the linked article, you have comments by people using the discussion as their personal diary.
- qwertox 2y agoAfter letting them do their shenanigans for over a decade...
- datahack 2y agoHonestly, cancelling Adobe after getting my kids school account shadow billed for 6 months was a nightmare and obscenely difficult. I really think Adobe has gone full vulture on their users and they need a change of leadership of a breakup. I was so relieved when the Figma acquisition fell through — the only serious competitor to their ecosystem almost died in that deal.
- unsignedint 2y agoThe concept of “annual paid monthly” subscriptions is similar to other services offering annual payments at a discounted rate compared to monthly subscriptions. However, the presentation can be somewhat deceptive. Adobe’s challenge lies in its relatively steep pricing, which may cause consumers to experience sticker shock upon seeing the total amount. A pricing model akin to JetBrains, with more reasonable options to individual, could potentially be more appealing to customers.
- RRWagner 2y agoI tried to block Adobe from automatically billing my account for a monthly fee, Adobe phone support said if I couldn't tell them the email that was billing my bank account, they wouldn't cancel it. I then told the bank to block further billing. Then the billing name started changing on my statement: Adobe -> Adobe Inc. -> Adobe Creative C -> Adobe Stock, so the "new name(s)" didn't get blocked. The bank eventually refunded a portion because I had called the first time. Wonder if the bank would have a claim against Adobe in addition to the FTC?
- slater 2y agoI'd forward screenshots of those shenanigans to the DOJ folks on this case, sounds like they'd want to know about that too.
- bowsamic 2y agoThat’s honestly insane
- mixtureoftakes 2y agothey really know what they're doing don't they I imagine the implementatioin of this as some executive saying "surely we can't get away with that" and then of course, them getting away with that
- CoastalCoder 2y agoIf you're in the US, I wonder if you could get your state's AG to charge Adobe with wire fraud.
- rm_-rf_slash 2y agoThreatening to call my state AG and the AG of a company’s incorporating state for fraud has 100% always cut the bullshit and gotten me to rightful resolution when customer service gives me the runaround. I’ve never had to make the calls. It’s a bluff but the cost of legal compliance to answer AG calls always outweighs the cost of rightful resolution.
- nycdatasci 2y ago
- vardump 2y agoI didn't actually dare to subscribe due to horror stories I've heard about Adobe. Luckily Open Source tools have been sufficient for my limited needs. Like Krita, Inkscape and Gimp.
- FredPret 2y agoThe subscription model is awful because of the dark patterns in cancelling. But it does open up their product suite to people who would be hesitant to shell out a couple of hundred bucks upfront. Adobe was a stagnant business until 2014. Revenue is up 500% since then: https://valustox.com/ADBE https://valustox.com/ADBE
- cjensen 2y agoVery interesting here is the charges against a pair of specific executives who are _not_ at all C-Suite level. Makes me wonder why them, specifically. E.g. could it have been something like emails between them suggesting the illegal activity, but no evidence they told anyone above them?
- whatever1 2y agoThe first saas with a hidden cancellation fee! When I first saw it I ran away.
- gjs4786 2y agoI just recently went through this nonsense sand that was just getting my money back after canceling on day 3 of their 7 day trial. it had been years since I last used photoshop, so I wanted to see what they had don on the generative side.their tactics from the perspective of someone in the maze is unflattering to say the least. they deserve this
- holler 2y agoAbout six months ago I was auditing my bank statements and realized I've been paying Adobe ~$40 for the past 5-6 years or so, almost $3,000 for software I very seldom used if at all in recent times. Closed my account, downloaded gimp, and won't be using Adobe in the future.
- jb1991 2y agoI'm just curious how you miss something like this for 5+ years?
- Sohcahtoa82 2y agoAn alarming number of people don't check their bank/credit card statements. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40709523 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40709523
- ProllyInfamous 2y agoJust as an example: I didn't notice a former landlord had immediately placed a STOP PAYMENT on my rental deposit return (with no notice/reason given, $thousands) until ten months after I had moved out! I have spent the majority of my blue collar adult life earning <$50k/yr.
- rpastuszak 2y agoA list of Adobe alternatives: https://untested.sonnet.io/Alternatives+to+Adobe https://untested.sonnet.io/Alternatives+to+Adobe
- Osiris 2y agoThe FTC is on a rampage lately.
- Slow_Hand 2y agoI'm not a professional designer but I do quite a bit of design, photo, and typography work these days. The Affinity suite of programs (Photo, Designer, and Publisher) have been the perfect alternative for someone like me who does casual work, isn't locked into the Adobe ecosystem, and doesn't want to spend $60+/month on a subscription. Their programs are full-featured, blazing fast, integrate with one another, and are - most importantly - pay once per license. Funnily, they're doing a 50% sale right now, which brings the entire line of products to a one-time payment of $83. Likely to capitalize on the Adobe's bad press cycle. The value of this package is undeniable. I'm a very happy user. The only caveat is that they don't yet have all of the cutting-edge high-end features that Adobe offers (AI integration, etc). But the nuts and bolts functionality is rock solid and they are adding more and more features each day. I find the lack of bloat and a massive codebase really help to streamline the performance. It's been flawless for me.
- bentt 2y agoI'm a game developer and Affinity Photo is missing a couple key features which make it nearly useless for us. In particular, it doesn't have individual channel editing. This is sort of baffling because it's only a UX issue... the tech to edit individual channels (including Alpha) is innate in image editing.
- misswaterfairy 2y agoIs this the feature you're referring to? https://affinity.help/photo/en-US.lproj/index.html?page=pages/GetStarted/channels.html&title=Using https://affinity.help/photo/en-US.lproj/index.html?page=page... channels https://affinity.help/photo2/en-US.lproj/index.html?page=pages/Channels/channelsSelectingEditing.html&title=Editing https://affinity.help/photo2/en-US.lproj/index.html?page=pag... channels Although not as feature rich as Photoshop, they are quickly catching up.
- bentt 2y agoYou got me to upgrade to V2! They are running a 50% off deal that's pretty sweet. The channel editing so far looks like it's pretty ok?
- silcoon 2y agoI subscribed for a month for try photoshop and got locked for an entire year with costo growing after few months. I was able to terminate my subscription by changing payment to an empty prepaid card.
- teekert 2y agoThe law in the Netherlands says you can only prolong subscriptions by a month after the first year. I was only able to cancel my 2.5 year Adobe subscription after speaking to 3 people, in English arguing they are breaking local laws (not many people here can have the discussions I had to have in English). I never used anything from adobe again after that. I filed an official complaint with our government after someone here in HN suggested it, never heard anything about it anymore. Glad someone is doing something about it now.
- jarbus 2y agoLina Kahn, once again, is the greatest thing to happen to America I’ve ever seen in my short time alive.
- nabaraz 2y agoI did a trial of Creative Suite on my mac. When it was time to uninstall, I couldn't do it using Creative Cloud Uninstaller. Because, Apparently I have to uninstall photoshop and other softwares from Creative Cloud App before uninstalling Creative Suite. I couldn't uninstall Photoshop etc. because my login to Creative Suite App didn't work. So, I contacted Adobe, there was some issue with getting 2FA to my email for some reason. So I couldn't login to CC to uninstall Photoshop to uninstall Creative Suite. I had to reset my mac just to get rid of Adobe spywares.
- bentt 2y agoI would love to know if and how Adobe has obstructed a FOSS competitor to Photoshop (akin to Blender in 3D). There must be a good reason that nothing has emerged over the years. My guess is there are some features they get territorial over and then start to lawyer scare programmers who tread too closely.
- fritzo 2y agoI haven't used photoshop since the 1990s, GIMP has plenty of features.
- solfox 2y agoGood, I’ve had such bad experiences with this company. Adobe is the king of dark patterns.
- davidmurdoch 2y agoAdobe F-ed around for soooooo long. Too bad the "find out" part won't effect those who have been making the decisions to put these practices in effect.
- ClassyJacket 2y agoOr anyone outside the US.
- poopcat 2y agoI am just glad that I finally learned that I do not, in fact, have to pay for Adobe Acrobat to be able to edit a PDF and can do it for free in Preview on Mac.
- einpoklum 2y agoFor me this is another example of why, all things said and done, we need free software for image processing and for final-form document processing - not Photoshop and Acrobat. For Acrobat, at least, a combination of tool sorta-kinda-mostly gets the job done; look at Xournal++, qpdf, and the various PDF printers (gradually being superseded by library-based PDF export filters). For image processing, we have simple programs like Paint.Net or Krita, and we have GIMP - which is quite featureful but I don't know if it's a "match" for Photoshop.
- chipsdip 2y agoUntil recently, I was using the Adobe suite extensively. I decided to switch to a competing software exactly because of the practices mentioned in the article. I don't want to elaborate unnecessarily, but I can confirm that these accusations are absolutely valid, and I even recently told my friends about how unfair Adobe's practices towards consumers are. I also personally know someone who decided to block their payment card at the bank because it was the only way they knew to free themselves from Adobe's subscription.
- polak84 2y agoThanks.
- sinecure 2y agoPhotoshop is, unfortunately, the most comfortable art application out there for a lot of art related workflows. The pattern preview mode allows for painting tiling textures easily (a feature oddly lacking from all competitors--except asperite oddly), the filters are all top notch, the ability to do non-destructive adjustments is insanely useful and not seen anywhere else, and the brush engine is the industry standard. There are a lot of nice things about how Photoshop approaches art that others are missing. The fact that Photoshop can manipulate images as easily as it can create them is what makes it special. Procreate is great for painting, but lacks even 10% of the features Photoshop has. Gimp is a decent photo editor with terrible painting tools. There is a massive opportunity in the market for Procreate to come out with a desktop version that expands on its functionality, but my theory is that it is probably the #1 iPad selling point for many people and Apple is paying them to keep it iPadOS / iOS only. Some big name Japanese anime studios are now working a big percentage of their workflow on iPads with Procreate.
- polak84 2y agoThanks
- ryanmccullagh 2y agoI hope FTC gets DirectTV next -- which also fails to adequately disclose to consumers that by signing up for a subscription your're agreeing to a 2 year contract.
- nbzso 2y agoThe biggest problem for design and collaborative canvas software companies is AI. How to inform your professional audience that their Figma, Miro, Adobe files are used for training, a result which will remove them from the work market and give their knowledge to the unprofessional masses. As a professional designer with more of 20 years experience, moving through graphic, web, UX, PM I have a strong disdain with all Adobe connected software. In the past, when Macromedia started eating their market by introducing more affordable and capable software, I jumped on a bandwagon and supported Freehand, Firefox, Flash and Director. Only to be again in Adobe hell. When moved from Sketch to Figma, the news of possible acquisition made me mad. The Adobe products are total bloatware, and nothing of substance or innovation in their base offering has never materialized. They are the epitome of corporate greed, dark patterns and monopolistic hell. But now we have a lot of monsters around. Microsoft. Apple. Google. Meta. And the new kid under the block: Closed AI. The same type of illness but in a new form. They appointed NSA head for security and announced that will pursue profit first. Surpassing in speed, Googles transition from "Don't be evil" to "Be evil at any cost". The software industry is eating the world, killing careers, stealing copyrighted data, centralizing and integrating in a monster of deals to deliver nothing of substance. Just food for shareholders who have no ability of systemic thinking and did not see the elephant in the room: Communistic Tech driven Dystopia. Propaganda of empty promises and no government control. Future for the people who trust the machine more than a professionals and experts. What bright future for humanity will deliver AI art? The delimiting factor when removing technical skill set will be taste. So how the next generations will form this taste without a curriculum and practice? They will prompt the taste? Good luck with this. Here is a list of alternatives for the Adobe crapware. Vector illustration: Learn Inkscape, aside of instability under macOS, the software is capable and has fine tools which will deliver everything you need as a designer. Affinity will become a subscription based software eaten by Canva and AI "art". For digital painting: Apple Pencil removed 60 percent of my Wacom workflow, and Procreate is a monster of an app. For the desktop stuff, I use Krita. 3d: Blender for polygonal modelling, animation, rendering, sculpting (Plasticity if you are into mixed workflow), Rhino 3d for surfacing and generative modelling (The price is high only at a first glance). Photography: I learned that all the one app solutions are not future-proof. Moved my workflow into a system of folders and markdown notes. The capability of Raw Therapy combined with Krita are more than enough. Video editing, compositing and Mogrpaph There is a champion: Blackmagic Design with DaVinci Resolve and Fusion. You can use Unreal Engine and Blender for Mograph to escape After Effects black hole. Rive is a mix between After and Flash which is gaining popularity (sadly subscription based). For UX/UI design, we have a real contender to Sketch and Figma in the face of Penpot. Free. Open source. Possible enterprise goals with option of self-host installation. Baked in interface for token centric design process, real grid and flex box implementation (not the fake auto-layout) and developer friendly without Figma upselling strategies or mac only dungeon of Sketch.
- capital_guy 2y agoGood. Adobe is one of the most annoying subscriptions to cancel. Lina Khan continues to do great work.
- 65 2y agoI was able to get around Adobe's cancellation fees by switching my subscription to the cheapest subscription option they had, then cancelling that subscription (which, for whatever reason, didn't have cancellation fees most likely because I was a "new" subscriber).
- kopirgan 2y agoAbout time. Hopefully they'll pay a fine that'll deter others too. In any case spend billions on lawyers.
- shortformblog 2y agoTip for anyone looking to get an Adobe subscription without any BS: Buy a yearly subscription from Amazon. If you have an Amazon store card, it’s expensive enough that you can actually put it on a 0% APR plan for six months or a year, so you have some flexibility in paying it back. Plus, Adobe never gets your credit card.
- janeerie 2y agoWw wa
- hunter-gatherer 2y agoA few years ago I ran a gambit with my wife's lightroom subscription. We kept cancelling and getting confirmations that we had cancelled but they kept charging our card. Eventually I had to get screenshots of a chat conversation between myself and Adobe where the Adobe rep suggested I send our correspondence to my credit card company and have them put a block on it. Lol
- BeautifulOrb 2y agoI'm a professional graphic designer and I think everyone I know pirates it. It's an insane amount of money to spend if you're freelancing. Freelance creative work is often a tough life with thin margins. The price point is egregious. I regularly use Photoshop, Illustrator, and After Effects. None of the software has had any meaningful update in over a decade, except for maybe some masking/selection tools. The AI stuff is trash and no professional would use it.
- FrozenSynapse 2y agoyou make money of it, it's scummy to pirate. I would understand someone who uses the software once a month to pirate it, but you literally make money of it.
- meow_mix 2y agoFTC is cooking lately
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gepardi 2y agoImagine being the company that people hate, but feel the need to keep using said companies software simply because of market dominance.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- danpalmer 2y agoIn my previous role an Adobe representative attempted to bribe me with a free personal Creative Cloud subscription if I dropped my attempt to cancel a bunch of company licences. Horrifying practices, I hope they get enough of a fine to force real change.
- nox101 2y agoAs a spoiled tech worker, $120 for a year of Photoshop is about worth less than 1 hour of my time. But, if there's one thing I wish I could get rid if is effing Adobe Cloud. I only need the apps (Photoshop, Lightroom). I don't need or want any cloud integration nor do I want any services running on my machine.
- Marietta040 2y ago[dead]
- throwaway4837 2y agoI tend to think this is a pattern with needless subscription models. They likely have a semi-bimodal distribution of users: full-price payers vs. discount/promo payers, so they probably increase the price for the full-price payers to compensate for the people taking advantage of crazy promos. Making it hard to cancel also compensates for the discounts they offer to rope people in. I hypothesize that a company that offers excessive discounting probably also has a sketchy way of compensating for it, and they are probably fabricating margin that could've been priced out by competition (if sufficient competition exists). Therefore, I would bet that Adobe is an overpriced product. Reminds me of typical gym memberships. It once took me months to cancel a Crunch subscription. My card expired and they had the audacity to send me a letter stating they will collect unless I enter a new card instead of just cancelling for me. They constantly gave me the runaround in person and over email; eventually I just sent an email to their legal/management team and threatened to escalate with the bank if there's another charge and it worked. Sadly, I was never refunded for the 3-4 months they charged me for during this period. You'd think these sorts of subscription filibusters would be scrutinized more by the FTC to protect consumers. Glad to see it being looked at in this case, but seriously gym memberships need some attention too.
- 3lit3krew 2y agoThis is unfair to Adobe, if you can't take two minutes to learn the excruciatingly minute differences between Photoshop and GIMP, you deserve to pay the idiot fee.
- megamix 2y agoI miss the buy-once-option
- refurb 2y agoRather than going after individual companies, seems like a nice solution would be federal legislation that says "All subscription services must provide: mailing address, email and phone number. Subscriptions can be cancelled by contacting the company through any method by including: a) request to cancel, b) name, email. Cancellation is effective immediately." Companies seem to respond very quickly when you forward legal code to them that they need to follow.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- RamblingCTO 2y agoThat was really about time. Such a scammy company. They deserve to be destroyed.
- ratsimihah 2y agoThis is great. I've lost a significant amount of money to that scam.
- maksyd 2y agoGood to see this! I've personally experienced their unfair early termination fee. It's about time companies are held accountable for these deceptive practices.
- Blammar 2y agoApologies if this has been posted already, but my search fu failed to find a similar post. 1. Start the cancellation process for your current license 2. When offered a discount or to switch to another plan, choose the cheapest new plan 3. Once your membership is updated, start the cancellation process again immediately 4. The cancellation fee is now $0. (Source: https://ui.dev/rwd/articles/cancel-adobe-without-paying-the-cancellation-fee https://ui.dev/rwd/articles/cancel-adobe-without-paying-the-... ) I can vouch that this worked earlier this year.
- _0j9w 2y agobut then you have been charged for the cheapest new plan lol.
- andy_ppp 2y agoI was being charged monthly for 2 years and the subscription didn't actually appear in their UI but somehow I was still being charged. Some sort of update/bug fix must have happened and I could finally cancel. The process was obviously horrendous in that I think I had to talk to someone on Text Chat but at least both of us could see the subscription to be able to cancel it. I don't think companies should be allowed to charge for subscriptions that people aren't using personally.
- HenryBemis 2y agoIf I remember well, when I was living in the UK I could block/stop a recurring payment. I am now using Revolut, and it does give you the option to block all future payments to a specific account/charge. So, if they don't listen, you can always send them a nice FU message for their "bug" which costs you real money, and block the payment. And when they start bitching about the missed payments refer to the (ignored) message and move on with your life.
- andy_ppp 2y agoI did try talking to Barclays and they were less than helpful...
- montag 2y agoThe more benign version happened to me. Over $1k for an Illustrator subscription that I forgot to cancel and didn't touch for 2 years. No email from them that might have reminded me. When I went to support, they offered me nothing. Say what you will about personal responsibility, but I won't pay for an Adobe product again. edit: Also want to mention that I used a couple different subscription trackers like Trim, and they didn't identify the Adobe charges. Weird.
- esskay 2y agoI'm just so glad they didn't get thier hands on Figma. Screw Adobe, they're complete parasites.
- eitland 2y agoGood. After that, go after Google and Microsoft for abusing their market positions other markets to destroy the browser market (again in Microsofts case).
- josephd79 2y agoOn a consumer level this is the first time I've heard of a software company charging you an early termination fee. What other b2c software companies do this?
- rootlocus 2y agoI think all who offer a discount if you buy a license for a whole year but pay by month. I don't see the problem with them requesting you pay the original amount for the months you used the product if you cancel before the year is out. You entered a contract where you promised to pay for a year, and they gave you a smaller fee. You cancel the contract, so they should cancel the discount.
- quitit 2y agoIt's interesting to me that this isn't a wider complaint by the ftc. Like here's some examples that I think also deserve some attention: - Adobe released a stock image service, then bundled this deeply into their products. This could be considered anti-competitive bundling. There's also other examples of bundling which could be considered here as well. - Adobe's file formats create not just lock-in for people willingly using their tools, but also require other agencies to use the adobe software to be able to work with the files. There is also limited backwards compatibility and limited ability to export to earlier versions while maintaining compatibility, this forces people into the subscription product. A similar issue was brought against Microsoft Office's formats. - Adobe shutters apps/services on short notice while providing no migration off-ramp, or an off-ramp that requires the user to subscribe to a more expensive product. This is seen repeatedly with their own experiments, but also with acquisitions.
- xkbarkar 2y agoI remember 15 or so years ago a colleague of mine ( in the nordics outside of EU ) wanted to purchase a photoshop licence for personal use. It was a crazy expensive licence ( I do not remember how much but it was more than I made a month at that time I remember ) but she is a woman of principals and refuses to run pirated software. It took her weeks to get the licence as Adobe did not distribute to personal user licences in our area at the time. Only crazy enterprise fee. She managed to get a personal license through US after weeks of emails and phone calls. I however pirated until the subscription model came out, initially I thought the monthly fee was kinda brilliant as it allowed me to actually legally run photoshop for a price I could afford. Just buy the occasional month when I actually need it and then cancel for all the 10 months a year that I don't use it. Seemed like a win/win to me. Sadly someone at Adobe considers this a worse crime than pirating it seems and casual users are tricked into these insane contracts. I sincerely hope this practice of a hidden cancellation fee is not only banned but heftily fined.
- duk 2y ago“Subscription services are convenient, flexible and cost effective to allow users to choose the plan that best fits their needs, timeline and budget. Our priority is to always ensure our customers have a positive experience. We are transparent with the terms and conditions of our subscription agreements and have a simple cancellation process. We will refute the FTC’s claims in court.” - Dana Rao, General Counsel and Chief Trust Officer https://news.adobe.com/news/news-details/2024/Adobes-Statement-Regarding-Federal-Trade-Commission-Complaint/default.aspx https://news.adobe.com/news/news-details/2024/Adobes-Stateme...
- jaimex2 2y agoGlad I resisted SaaS all these years. I use older versions of owned Adobe and Macromedia products still, I got them for almost nothing and best of all they work really well through Wine on Linux. I can't really see any must have features in the newer releases. If anything some of their products deteriorated.
- Ylpertnodi 2y agoI have photoshopLE from at least 92...still using it.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- inquist 2y agoAn obvious example of platform enshittification https://americandialect.org/2023-word-of-the-year-is-enshittification/ https://americandialect.org/2023-word-of-the-year-is-enshitt...
- sarimkx 2y agoFigma dodged a bullet. Dylan Field was initially very anti-Adobe, I don't know why he even agreed to sell to them. Its completely okay to sell your company and cash out but I still don't understand, why Adobe?
- xutopia 2y agoHopefully they can sue Amazon next.
- baby 2y agoI thought America loved hidden fees
- j45 2y agoI had this experience with Adobe as well. Cancelled inside my account, but credit card charges continuned. Adobe and others use services that provide them with your new credit card expiry dates so they keep billing. Adobe can be messaged on twitter to document them not fixing things. Companies can actually reverse 18-24 months of charges.
- gradientsrneat 2y agoSometimes, all it takes is one large bad actor in the space to poison the well for consumer trust in that industry for years. Doesn't even have to be something very unethical or illegal, although Adobe certainly qualifies. There are good reasons for subscription-based business models. But fear of rug pulls has personally damaged my trust in subscription software, and even "pay once" software. See also "Killed by Google."
- nowandlater 2y agoJust FYI, Adobe's website will port scan you on 16494, 35693, and 57923 after you login.
- lacoolj 2y agoAwesome! Next, let's take on Geico for the cancellation thing.
- tshubbard 2y agoI spent 2 hours on Adobe customer support chat just this morning trying to decrease my company license count.
- punkbit 2y agoGood news! I’ve moved to Affinity many years ago but recently was purchased by Canva which is extremely worrying and sad.