27 ms·
LK-99 isn’t a superconductor
- leesec 3y agoNot sure why this is presented as so conclusive, the sample they have exhibits none of the floating properties and the recipe is different. Of course testing whatever this is isn't a superconductor.
- thinkingkong 3y agoIt’s disappointing news but the excitement and amount of replication on this paper was pretty fun to witness and experience. To me the most interesting part was everyone talking about potential consequences, uses, the order of magnitude improvements we’d see in certain costs or areas. Pumps, MRIs, power grids, chips, etc. Great reminder what materials science can do to some underlying economics.
- Waterluvian 3y agoAgreed! There's this bizarre reaction I see from many where they see the excitement and curiosity and hopefulness as a form of error and source of embarrassment. When mixed with an open mind and reasonable skepticism, it's a powerful opportunity to get people engaged in imagining a different world. I had all kinds of exciting conversations about what a validated, commercially viable LK-99 could produce. Why would I ever be inclined to feel that there's pie on my face now that we've got fairly strong evidence refuting the claims?
- archepyx 3y agoHN discussion did not particlarly have "reasonable skepticism". This is probably because people (i) were not aware that there had been many other hypes about RTSC before but less publicly visible all proved to be false, (ii) not being able to accurately judge the technical quality of the initial evidence, (iii) uncritically believing that the data in the initial preprints was proof for superconductivity because their authors said so.
- Waterluvian 3y agoI find it perilous to treat an entire community as it if has one voice. Ie. "the HN discussion" as a singular entity with a singular binary state on its skepticism. Someone else could equally claim that the HN community was super pessimistic and skeptical about it, because I certainly saw a lot of that too! While a convenient abstraction, it plays into our biases to notice and remember only some of the discourse. Plus I don't think it's really relevant to what I'm saying given I'm not making a claim about how any specific individual or group reacted, but that it's odd when there's people who treat an optimistic outlook as an error.
- archepyx 3y agoOptimistic outlook without reasonable skepticism is probably at least something you should not strive to achieve.
- MichaelZuo 3y ago> Plus I don't think it's really relevant to what I'm saying given I'm not making a claim about how any specific individual or group reacted, but that it's odd when there's people who treat an optimistic outlook as an error. An optimistic outlook without a semi-plausible basis that you can convincingly elaborate on, or link a vaguely credible source doing so, IS an error, at least going by HN norms.
- Nevermark 3y agoOptimism isn’t gullibility! It is just an attitude that values positive possibilities over fretting about negative possibilities. Especially in cases where there is a small chance of a huge upside, relative to virtually no downside. We didn’t lose any superconductors. :) I don’t recall anyone on HN erroneously declaring the material was definitely a new superconductor before subsequent evidence arrived at a consistent conclusion. There is nothing wrong with optimism.
- MichaelZuo 3y ago
- 0xbadcafebee 3y agoTo understand the skeptic's perspective: imagine watching people excitedly discussing a sighting of bigfoot.
- SanderNL 3y agoIn a world where true dreamers are often sidelined, where the embrace of change is met with resistance, and where society prioritizes incremental economic evolution over the visions of genuine pioneers, we find ourselves amidst signs and patterns all too indicative of a … culture in decline! rock music
- lolinder 3y agoIn this case, I think the excitement and hopefulness was not dangerous or wrong, but I do see a risk to this kind of preprint hype in other contexts. During COVID there were multiple cases like this where a study got a lot of hype and discussion from non-experts and turned into "the science says X", when in fact the science was as of yet extremely unsettled. Sure enough, as the experts came to a consensus it rarely matched the public's initial perception, which led to a lot of confusion, conspiracy theories, and fingerpointing. Science-as-spectator-sport is fun, but I worry about the impact it will have on society as a whole and on the execution of science in particular. How many research decisions will be influenced by the possibility of going viral? How many bad decisions will be made as a result of pressure from millions of non-experts who briefly become armchair X-ologists?
- okamiueru 3y agoI think this kind of excitement followed up with "wasn't anything after all" is both dangerous and wrong. When science is done badly (which arguably shouldn't be considered science), which then leads the public to have elevated expectations, only then for science to be done right and disprove and reject the original "findings", public trust in science is ever so slightly damaged.
- tysam_and 3y agoI think you're conflating PR with the science underneath. PR is something we cannot control -- and avoiding releasing results in a (semi-vain?) attempt to control PR arguably does more harm than releasing them does. The sea makes waves as it will. We can moderate as much as we are able. I think the rest is simply a matter of accepting that things happen as they do out of our control. We can only truly impact ---- and even then, not necessarily guaranteed! D: ---- -- in some potentially very small part -- whatever sphere is around us, and I feel that that's a collective individual responsibility.
- _lqaf 3y agoFurthermore, preemptively reacting to expected third-party behaviors is doomed. Journalists are going to write nonsense, hype-filled science articles. PR flacks are going to hype puff newswire blurbs. Why? Because that's what they're paid to do. You can curse the existence of bad incentives, if you want annoying ideologues to call you a communist. Or you can hire your own PR flacks. Because worrying about how people will react to what you're doing is PR, and going up against professionals without your own is like going to court without a lawyer. Or you can just, you know, do science, accept that people suck sometimes, and get on with your life.
- BaseballPhysics 3y ago> There's this bizarre reaction I see from many where they see the excitement and curiosity and hopefulness as a form of error and source of embarrassment. When mixed with an open mind and reasonable skepticism... Kinda buried the lede there. A lot of folks around here and in my own orbit were practicing the former while excluding the latter, or worse, were taking shots at people trying to inject some level of rationality into the conversation. Heck, some folks even went so far as to refer to those types of counterpoints/comments as just a "bizarre reaction"...
- kergonath 3y ago> There's this bizarre reaction I see from many where they see the excitement and curiosity and hopefulness as a form of error and source of embarrassment. What the general public does not see it the regular flood of papers that pretend to change the world and that turn out to be bogus. So, from an insider point of view, the issue is that what we are supposed to avoid (crack pot theories becoming mainstream or getting too much traction) happened in a spectacular fashion. So a lot of people get excited about nothing and then end up distrusting the scientific process itself (“they don’t know what they’re doing”, “they make everything up”, “they write a lot of nonsense”, etc). In this case, I think it turned out to be a good thing. People got excited, some of them thought about possible implication, others managed to pick up some notions of material science. The enthusiasm and activity from people trying to replicate and investigate the material was heart-warming. But yeah, it was bound to finish like that. > Why would I ever be inclined to feel that there's pie on my face now that we've got fairly strong evidence refuting the claims? You really, really don’t want to be seen as a crack pot when your funding and career depend on how external people evaluate your work. You also really, really don’t want to have to retract a paper because you’ve missed something obvious. Retraction is a traumatic process even if you are in good faith. This is sidestepped by releasing preprints (so no peer review and no risk of retraction). But at the same time this is a reason why outlandish preprints tend not to be taken too seriously. There is less incentives to get it right.
- marginalia_nu 3y ago> There's this bizarre reaction I see from many where they see the excitement and curiosity and hopefulness as a form of error and source of embarrassment. When mixed with an open mind and reasonable skepticism, it's a powerful opportunity to get people engaged in imagining a different world. This should be taken in the context of room temperature superconductors being notorious physics vaporware along with practically useful advances in quantum computers and useful fusion. What these have in common is a sort of holy grail status, where it's obvious they'd be a revolutionary complete game changer. Not that any of these things are obviously impossible, there's just been so many instances of discoveries in these areas that have failed to replicate that there's inevitably a lot of eye rolling in physics when these types of findings are announced.
- JeremyNT 3y ago> When mixed with an open mind and reasonable skepticism, it's a powerful opportunity to get people engaged in imagining a different world. I feel like this line is doing a lot of lifting in your comment. The problem is that as lay people we are completely unequipped to gauge a claim like this. I followed along on HN and there were plenty of posts by people who were giving LK-99 crazy odds of success, fueled in no small part by viral videos of outright hoaxes from pseudonymous "researchers." It's fun, in a science fiction-y way, to speculate on what a material with the supposed properties might have meant for the world, but the degree of skepticism that should have been applied was lacking for many. There's a tendency on HN and similar forums to devour new developments - almost a fanaticism about learning the newest/latest/best before the general public. But in this case, a truly extraordinary claim had been proposed, and it was even published without the researchers' consent. There was precious little reason to give it any attention at all at that phase. If people had viewed LK-99's properties as "almost surely science fiction" all along, I could find myself agreeing with you, but that's really not how this played out. Sadly this event showed there's a market for hyping up weak claims that people will be poor at evaluating, and I guess we can probably expect more of them.
- acqq 3y ago> Sadly this event showed there's a market for hyping up weak claims that people will be poor at evaluating I don't see it as in any way an unique event, and also not unique for the enthusiasm seen on this site. The "believers" in most of the hypes typically aren't cured fast, as the article notes: "While some commentators have pointed to the LK-99 saga as a model for reproducibility in science, others say that it’s an unusually swift resolution of a high-profile puzzle. "Often these things die this very slow death...""
- ummonk 3y agoWhat's "crazy odds of success" to you?
- hackerlight 3y agoThe tone here on HN was very similar to the tone of a lot of credible physicists. Just because it turned out to be not superconducting doesn't mean that the people you are criticising were wrong to think what they thought given the available information at the time.
- ryanSrich 3y agoMy only gripe was the VCs declaring superconductivity without any evidence. They’re so quick to follow the heard and jump on trends that they do zero diligence in just waiting to see if something is legitimate or not. People being hopefully and discussing possible solutions is not a problem. But VCs declaring that it’s the future and you’re falling behind if you’re not working on it is the problem.
- fasterik 3y agoExcitement and curiosity about science is a good thing, but hyping up dubious claims and low quality research is not. I don't know who to blame in this case; I'm not sure whether it's the researchers, science journalism, social media dynamics, or a combination of all those things. But it doesn't seem healthy to have the general public incentivizing scientists to rush out early results with sensationalist claims. Real science takes years to validate results and a lot of that happens behind closed doors, as it should. I think the public reaction in this case is a symptom of a problem with our information ecosystem that extends beyond science. Just because something is fun to participate in in the moment doesn't mean it's not harmful to the underlying scientific/political/social process.
- araes 3y agoAnother point is: It's properties might still be interesting (possibly amazing, just not a superconductor). A significant reduction in room temperature resistance would still be incredible, even if it wasn't a "room temperature superconductor." Might still enable a lot of those "exciting conversations." Just not some binary yes/no computer holy grail. Also, big effect was scientists went "Whoa. There's a whole mode/regime of resistance change we never really looked at." The modeling papers that came out almost immediately were really interesting. Might still have cool applications.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- earthboundkid 3y agoThe real superconductors were the friends we made along the way.
- baron816 3y agoIt was kind of like thinking about winning the lottery—the fun is in the fantasy of it.
- imtringued 3y agoI don't know what you are talking about. This material was never going to revolutionize anything even if it was a superconductor. What you call fun to witness was to me just another episode of "Mat Ferrell's Undecided" except on HN. Also, you can't solve the most important economic problems through technology anyway. How is a superconductor going to decrease your rent?
- dekhn 3y agoRoom temp Superconductors, along with fusion, would affect the economy profoundly. What the exact effect on rent would be is hard to predict but under the "post-scarcity society" mental construct, having infinite energy at zero cost (amortized) would presumably make the price of housing change.
- consilient 3y agoRoom temperature superconductors would not give us zero-cost energy any time soon. Even if one had a high enough critical current to be used in transmission lines (which is not a given), transmission losses are under 10% in modern grids.
- Dan_Sylveste 3y ago> transmission losses are under 10% in modern grids Modern grids are designed to keep those losses down. If the losses weren't a factor the grids would be designed differently. Very differently. As in, North Africa would be so full of solar panels the generating fields would be visible from space.
- maleldil 3y agoHow would room temperature superconductors lead to a post-scarcity society?
- dekhn 3y agomakes it easy to deliver power from huge centralized fusion reactors to the edge. It is neither sufficient, nor necessary, but could be a useful thing to have.
- MiguelHudnandez 3y agoI enjoy the optimistic takes as well. I think it's really fun to imagine incredible new materials that change our baseline capabilities in design and manufacturing. All that said, there's also a case for saving all that energy by seeking out skeptical points of view. See thunderf00t's video from 5 days ago: https://youtu.be/p3hubvTsf3Y https://youtu.be/p3hubvTsf3Y All in all, I appreciate that so many people are enthusiastic about one thing in particular: replicating results. So many people will take a press release or an academic paper at face value. But the real value is in replicating the results.
- gus_massa 3y agoThe analysis in the video is good, like most of his videos. But I hope someone makes a roge tldwthunderf00t channel, that cut all the parts he repeats and when he laugh of people. A video with the same content and 1/2 of the length would be better.
- baby 3y ago+1. I’m wondering how many people will become physicist due to this wave of exciting news :) we’re not getting superconductors today, but we might get less “oh my god the earth is doomed humans are horrible” and more “I’m optimistic about the future of the human race”
- kergonath 3y agoAs a practising material physicist, I am very enthusiastic about the progress of knowledge in my field and human curiosity and ingenuity, and also very pessimistic about the outlook for our various civilisations and appalled by human carelessness, shortsightedness, and selfishness. My long term pessimism comes partly from the fact that I know what is behind the magical technologies that are supposed to save us, which is why I am very skeptical about them. I am also very doubtful about our ability to make the right decisions in difficult times and under severe constraints. But hey, I do have a cool, interesting, and enjoyable job.
- slashdev 3y agoI think it’s fair to say that even as a failure, it’s likely to stimulate much more attention, funding, and research in the area of high temperature superconductors going forward. That’s great.
- hcks 3y agoPlease explain the mechanism by which a short lived twitter craze among web developers will translate into increased “attention funding and research”
- xwdv 3y agoI disagree. I get pissed off when revolutionary scientific news is brought to me only to turn out to be some bogus crap. I don’t care about the replication and peer review process, it’s not fun, it’s banal. I would much rather have preferred to learn about LK-99 once it was confirmed to be a room temp superconductor, and if it wasn’t then I’d rather never hear about it. Now I have to walk back explanations I gave to various people and explain LK-99 actually isn’t special at all. I will look like a god damn idiot. The whole time LK-99 was in the news, we were wringing our hands about potential uses and the impact it would have on our world. For once it seemed maybe there was hope that we’d see exciting times again with exponential advances in technology. That dream has now been thoroughly eradicated. By the time a true room temp superconductor comes out, it probably won’t be in our lifetimes.
- hirsin 3y agoIt sounds like you were explaining it to people before it was confirmed - why did you do that? I don't really grok the emotional connection you seem to be talking about - how does someone pin their mental state so much on something like this (unconfirmed research)? Is it the idea that there might be something great happening, and that we might get the chance to live in exciting times? I could see people wanting to believe in that opportunity.
- penjelly 3y agowe already live in exciting times. I wouldnt blame someone for explaining an idea that the scientists themselves came forward and claimed it as a valid result either. Blind optimism is NOT good in my opinion even if intentions are good
- imchillyb 3y ago> I will look like a god damn idiot. Pride isn’t a good look or smell. Try humility instead. You may not like to eat humble pie, but others love to watch that. Also, perhaps some introspection would give nuance to why being wrong bothers you so much.
- DirkH 3y ago
- dheera 3y ago> were responsible for the sharp drops in electrical resistivity and partial levitation over a magnet Are these properties still useful? If something can levitate without being a superconductor it is already useful for a LOT of things.
- penjelly 3y agodiamagnetic material exist, and no theyre not nearly as useful as a superconductor with 0 resistance.
- dheera 3y agoDiamagnetic levitation is extremely weak, which makes it much less practically useful, and also reduces its entertainment value (if you can levitate things 2 cm above the surface the 2 billion children in the world will be all over the stuff; the 1-2 mm you can get with bismuth diamagnetism isn't particularly impressive.
- hgsgm 3y agoI don't know all these subtleties, but maglev trains are awesome.
- kergonath 3y agoMaglev trains do not use diamagnetism or this kind of permanent magnets. They use electromagnets and sometimes much stronger rare-earth magnets, which are much more convenient and effective. Some of them do use superconductors, though, AFAIK.
- tsimionescu 3y agoNot really, what really matters is what weight it can actually support. Most of these materials can barely levitate a few grams - way below any kind of useful application except for maybe gimmicky toys.
- kergonath 3y ago
- godelski 3y ago> but the excitement and amount of replication on this paper was pretty fun to witness and experience. I was really elated to see how people were so interested and getting to see what peer review in science actually looks like. How in the real world it is done outside of journals and conferences, which people frequently give the misnomer "peer review." I hope people will walk away from this experience with a better understanding of how science works and why replication is such a critical aspect of it. Because the truth is that our academic incentive structure has generally fallen out of alignment with the actual goals of science.
- freedomben 3y agoUnfortunately I don't think we got "to see what peer review in science actually looks like" because this was such an unusual deal. The amount of interest and excitement gave us the ideal amount of peer review/reproduction. For the vast majority of things nobody even tries to reproduce it, and many of the publishers don't even provide the tools needed to do so.
- godelski 3y agoYeah, I agree that for the vast majority of things most people don't try. Or at least publicly demonstrate that they tried (key phrasing). But it is also silly to think that 3-5 people sitting at a desk reading a summary of work can validate said work. Really they can only invalidate or specify that it is indeterminate, but neither of these are validation. Which that's a key difference from the general public understanding of "peer review" (meaning journal publication). But it might also be worth noting that often reproduction happens behind the scene. People point to big works like that which comes out of CERN, LIGO, or other massive projects and state that such works cannot be replicated. But actually those have high rates of replication, which is why there are hundreds of authors on the work. For LK-99, people got to see a lot of what is typically done by grad students who never tell the public what they did (or even their community). That the communication between scientists is happening through preprints, email, twitter, and other methods that are not journal publications. Because science happens faster than the journal cycle. Most scientists are reading preprints, and letting the work dictate the signal of validity long before a journal can. But what I was alluding to, which you might have picked up on, is that the reward system we have in place ("publish or perish", h-index, journals, etc) are misaligned as they do not reward this cornerstone of science -- replication -- (typically discourages is) unless there are credible claims of breakthroughs of the highest kind. Maybe we should rethink this system, and I hope that the timing of this along with the other discussions of academic fraud can help people to question the system and metrics that we use to evaluate, and ask if they are actually aligned with the original goals.
- amelius 3y agoThis invention almost saved our generation. I mean, our parents invented radar, semiconductors, nuclear energy, etc. For us it's back to building social media, adtech, and similar "technology", I guess.
- gus_massa 3y agoWhite LEDs? When I was young, I wanted tu buy a blue LED but it was too expensive. Now I have white LEDs everywhere. Laser pointers are nice too.
- penjelly 3y agodisagree, the excitement led nowhere. We already have high temp superconductors so even if it was real these applications can/are already handled. Its not harmless either, people invested time, money, and effort. its great to be excited for real science discoveries but hoaxes are not good, and can potentially cripple, crush the industry thats actually developing these things.
- gus_massa 3y agoA researcher wasting his/her time in a promising result is business as usual. An important part of the work is to read papers and decide if they are promising enough to try to informaly replicate them and extend them. There are a lot of details to consider. Does it makes sense? Who published it? Did that team has a gopd track record? Where was it published? Did somepne else used the paper as a base for a new paper? How long/much would it take to try? Only after that, researches decide to try it or just send it to the paper bin.
- consilient 3y ago> its great to be excited for real science discoveries but hoaxes are not good, There's absolutely no evidence of a hoax. The original authors were sloppy and overeager, not malicious.
- hilbert42 3y ago"The original authors were sloppy and overeager, not malicious" Reckon so, but if they believed they were on the brink of a great discovery and thought they could be beaten to it at any moment, then it's understandable.
- oreilles 3y ago> [...] There was nothing missing from so many beautiful works, except that it was true that the tooth was made of gold. When a goldsmith had examined it, it was found to be gold leaf applied to the tooth with great skill; but books were written before the goldsmith was consulted. > I am not so convinced of our ignorance by the things that are, and whose reason is unknown to us, than by those that are not, and whose reason we find. This means that not only do we not have the principles that lead to the truth, but that we also have others that accommodate the false very well. Bernard Le Bouyer de Fontenelle, Histoire des Oracles 1687. Translated with Deepl.
- gabagaul 3y ago[flagged]
- jschveibinz 3y agoOn the bright side: when people say “believe in the science,” this is exactly what they should be thinking: challenge. This whole process has been super healthy and similar challenges are important and needed for everything published, not just this particular research area. I might be out in left field, but I read so often that researchers are running out of ideas. What’s wrong with getting a PhD for challenging something already published? It is incredibly valuable to society.
- 93po 3y agoDoes this extend to climate change science too?
- salty_biscuits 3y agoYes.
- belthesar 3y agoSure, but there's a level of entry to the "challenge" call to action. When folks are saying "believe in the science", it also means to believe in the scientific method, which does include challenging observations and independently validating conclusions. A proper challenge requires coming up to the plate, proposing a challenging hypothesis to a given conclusion, and then going through the work required to test your hypothesis, documenting the inputs, the variables, and showcasing your outputs. What this doesn't mean is the average human who does not like the conclusion producing a statement saying "I don't think that's real", or even going so far as to cite data which could appear to refute the conclusion, are producing a challenge to the conclusion. They're just stating an opinion. This isn't designed to be exclusionary, but to ensure that challengers are going through the effort that the producer of the conclusion did. If one is not willing to learn the problem space enough to reasonably challenge the effort, then that challenge is moot.
- hackerlight 3y agoNot too long ago, a creationist would have sarcastically asked "Does this extend to biology too?", and gone away thinking they had made an actual argument.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aklwiehjra 3y agoOne of the few things I actually remember from undergrad was a presentation freshman year where some famous person said "almost all major leaps in engineering ability come from one of three things: economics of scale, something else (maybe new algorithm? not sure), or a new material that simply has better properties". I don't want to be a materials scientist, but that line got me very interested in materials science and gave me a lot of respect for it. If you find a new material that is 3x better than any other in some way, that unlocks entirely new doors.
- hunson_abadeer 3y agoThis is precisely what put me off in these discussions. Not the idea that we might have found a room-temperature superconductor - that part was exciting. It's the part where people confidently talked about its applications without realizing that they probably wouldn't revolutionize CPU performance (Josephson junctions don't seem to work well as non-cryogenic temperatures for reasons unrelated to superconductivity), power grid transmission (transmission lines are already pretty efficient and we already choose less efficient materials for cost), or energy storage (LK-99 would likely have a fairly modest current limit before it stops superconducting). LK-99 would have interesting applications, known and unknown, but we have a pretty good understanding of superconductors based on 100 years of practical research, and I find this kind of instant punditry pretty tiresome.
- burnished 3y agoInteresting, from what I saw a lot of people got informed on why those overly confident predictions were drek - I don't know that I have seen a claim go unchallenged. Which seems ideal to me. Very educational.
- cogman10 3y agoIt was like stomping out weeds and it wasn't always well received. I hope that those that got dashed (and observed the dashing) take a step back the next time something from "FuturistSuperScienceNews.com" or whatever pops up touting a revolutionary XYZ. Those sites are like 99% trash that train their readers to distrust science when their clickbate articles don't pan out. If I were conspiracy minded, I'd swear they exist to build out a mistrust in institutions.
- raphlinus 3y agoAmen. When someone does the math and adds up the winners and losers in all this, one clear winner will be this video from Asianometry, entitled The History of Superconductors (Before LK-99)[1]. It only lightly touched on LK-99 itself, but did an excellent job going through the actual science-based history of superconductors, covering in particular detail previous hype waves. A major point is that the YBCO superconductors, while an amazing scientific discovery, haven't had revolutionary applications, and have only lightly displaced lower temperature (niobium-titanium metal alloy) superconductors in applications requiring generating strong magnetic fields, including MRI machines. For the curious, [2] goes into considerable detail on potential applications and challenges for HTSC in MRI. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wUczYHyOhLM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wUczYHyOhLM [2]: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5472374/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5472374/
- oblio 3y ago> Great reminder what materials science can do to some underlying economics. Just economics? :-)) Materials science is practically <<civilization>>. The Stone Age, the Bronze Age, the Iron Age. The other axes are: energy production, transportation improvements. But even those frequently come from materials science. The steam engine needed mass production of high quality steel, etc.
- xattt 3y agoIt sounds a lot like the thoughts that one might have before the draw for a large lottery jackpot. It’s a fun exercise, but it’s fantastical thinking.
- knodi123 3y ago> the excitement and amount of replication on this paper was pretty fun to witness and experience I understand a lot of people were more cautious and jaded, but this was my first go-round on the science news hype-mobile. I was really, really excited! It was a real emotional rollercoaster (if you imagine a rollercoaster that takes a couple of weeks to get anywhere).
- Accujack 3y agoIt's not over yet, at least not definitively. Nature Magazine like every other source so far is basing its comments on the attempted replications using the leaked paper. It's considered fairly certain at this point that the paper was incomplete/not enough to duplicate the material. The full paper with the original samples were reportedly sent to Korea University of Science and Technology for examination. That lab group has only so far verified the structure of the material, no word on whether they've replicated it or its actual properties based on replicated samples or the original samples. Until we hear from them, everyone (including Nature) is just guessing.
- hilbert42 3y agoOf course there's some sour grapes in Nature's article, as arxiv.org has had the best exposure it's likely to get in years. The more that publish there, the fewer who publish behind firewalls, etc. For starters, Nature's reprints are hellishly expensive.
- pbmonster 3y ago> arxiv.org has had the best exposure it's likely to get in years. The more that publish there, the fewer who publish behind firewalls We're talking about condensed matter physics here, arxiv needs zero exposure in this field. It is extremely common to publish on arxiv first and only then begin the process of submitting the same manuscript to be published (and peer reviewed) in a journal. And while there are still some authors that skip over publishing pre-prints at all, there's no serious arxiv competitor if you do decide to publish pre-prints. It is a de-facto monopoly in this field.
- hilbert42 3y agoTrue, but it's given the site more exposure in the general sense, it's now quoted by outlets that probably hadn't heard of it before this 'excitement'. (That can only help in the long run, one day Elbakyan mightn't need to do what she does.)
- jacquesm 3y ago
- NovaDudely 3y agoWhile I was very skeptical of the base claims of LK99 (extrodinary evidence required), I did sort of fall a little bit for the hype of what this kind of material could be used for. Mostly in terms of computer clock rates and used in batteries. Turns out what seemed intuitive at first was mostly wrong. But then that is what happens a lot in various fields. Something that seems obvious isn't done because those that actually know the field can explain all the details you didn't know. Anyone here in programming have had that battle with upper management... Hey lesson learned in this case. Don't always assume you have a grasp of all the details.
- jacquesm 3y agoI'd settle for regular evidence: a nice paper from a reputable lab that replicates the findings of the original team. Extraordinary evidence would be required for non standard model physics or aliens or something like that.
- throwawaymaths 3y agoSerious question: why is extraordinary evidence required? Room temperature superconductivity doesn't break any (known) laws of physics, doesn't introduce new particles or fields, etc, doesn't require an unprecedentedly sensitive instrument (like LIGO/VIRGO)... There's a lot of modern physics, chemistry, biology that is uncritically accepted which I think deserves a somewhat higher bar of skepticism than RTSC
- Nurbek-F 3y agoI told my brother too, the point is he doesn't even remember anymore or care. Most people are, until they see it in a real application
- ergocoder 3y agoThe most interesting part is one of the researchers believed it was Nobel's prize worthy, went rogue, and submitted a paper with only 3 authors to claim the credit of this invention. Coincidentally, Nobel's prize only awards at max 3 people. Soon after the other researchers realized and published a 6-author paper only hours after. What a drama.
- michelb 3y agoYes, this really showed me what a great deal of science is nowadays. Backstabbing to publish, get credit/funding, rinse/repeat, so you can continue to marginally exist. Would be nice if we could just return to do actual science, for, you know, science and the advancement of our species.
- cf141q5325 3y ago>Great reminder what materials science can do to some underlying economics. I had a similar experience when reading up on the history of gyroscopes recently. Its absolutely amazing to watch the advances and miniaturization from mechanical to optical to now micro-electro-mechanical systems (MEMS). Watching the giant machines from the space race first shrink, then get replaced by light traveling fiber optics to now vibrating bits of silicone. With the prices imploding as a result. Still havent fully grasped the implications of older lithography systems being now usable for electro, mechanical and optical applications. Especially as they seem to be quite affordable, especially with multi-project wafers. With open source project even getting chips for free via google.
- al_be_back 3y ago>> to me the most interesting part was everyone talking about potential consequences no need for a science paper for that, they should've written science fiction or created an educational documentary.
- wayvey 3y agoWhat are the practical implications of this?
- tareqak 3y agoPerhaps scientists will create a checklist for performing experiments on potential superconductive materials with caveats and gotchas. A team going down the checklist would either demonstrate one of 1. They performed the step in the checklist and provide the corresponding sufficient/exhaustive evidence of having done so. 2. An explanation as to why that step is not applicable allowing them to skip said step. An afterthought: 3. The following will not always be possible for any given experiment. However, the LK-99 experiment used cheap materials and a relatively straightforward process to create the material (from my readings of what others have said), I think the scientists in question should have attempted to reproduce the results of their experiment and document the number of successful attempts versus total attempts.
- EvgeniyZh 3y ago1. Check that it actually superconducts
- OJFord 3y agoThat's not trivial, because if it's known to be impure then you expect some resistance in your measurement, you already know it won't be 0R. And if you think it is pure and superconducting then how low does your test equipment go anyway? I'm not an expert in the field at all, but aiui that's why they would have been looking at what seem like roundabout tests etc. that don't seem like they're actually addressing what's interesting.
- EvgeniyZh 3y agoImpurities shouldn't increase resistance unless you have no supercondting path between your probes. If you don't, other tests will be hardly conclusive either. And yeah, you want the equipment sensitive enough to see that it is better than good metal like copper, which may be nontrivial in case your critical current is low. After that, you can move on to other measurements
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chubot 3y agoWell I'm kinda glad I missed this whole news cycle IMO this phenomenon seems to be kind of an artifact of modern media -- I feel like in the old days, peers would have settled it among themselves, and we would have never heard about it The same thing happens in tech -- there is a lot of stuff that people talk about, that ends up being worth ignoring ... I always bring up that whole news cycle in 2017 about a potential war with North Korea. How many people spent time and energy on that, and how do they feel about that now? Media is adversarial
- RationPhantoms 3y agoYou're arguing for less transparency here? I think one of the side benefits to witnessing the LK-99 discussion is people from all walks (sure, Twitter/X isn't the end all/be-all of global communication) discussing/following/listening to actual science happen. Do you know how much of that is worth to the world with knock-on effects? Maybe there were future material scientists sitting in the room with their parents listening to the discussion? I feel like that's equally as important as peer review/replication.
- HaZeust 3y agoYou cannot please these people, simply put. These folks STILL want the ESSENCE of a shared respect and excitement from the common man for scientific progression - and these folks are the same people, mind you, that speak loudly on the ignorance of the cluster groups within the "anti-science" big tent. But when these same folks see a glimpse of collective curiosity for science and methodologies among a lot of people, they long for the days of opacity and "mature handling of scientific consensus". Which, ironically, was the path in which almost ALL scientific progressions that spawned anti-science sentiments had taken. You can't win.
- haswell 3y agoI think a different way to frame this is that an Internet discussion will involve people with opinions across the spectrum. I don’t think this is about pleasing “these people”, but about recognizing which attitudes are useful and which are not. Encountering some mix of all of the above is a product of the diversity of people involved in the conversation, and not necessarily “these people” wanting it both ways.
- 1-6 3y agoOnce again, South Korea's academia overwhelms/overpromises but under-delivers. This is surely going to be a 'boy who cried wolf' moment for Korean schools.
- RicoElectrico 3y agoYeah, stem cell capital of the world and all that.
- dmboyd 3y agoOn root-cause, I wonder if it’s some variation or combination of “publish or perish” linked to failure averse political and cultural structures? I don’t think the circumstances are unique to SK as you see similar effect globally where success is measured purely quantitatively (I.e X number of published papers for promotion, X% score on a test to avoid military service). One thing I can’t get my head around is how the surrounding narrative was so bizarre. Particularly the “death bed dying wish”. Is this a result of 20+ years of lead poisoning combined with aforementioned political issues?
- zephyrthenoble 3y agoWatching this unfold on HN has been eerily similar to watching r/UFOs whenever someone comes forward with "proof" of UFOs/coverups/whatever. I never want to rain on anyone's parade, as proof of ETs or room temperature superconductors would be great, but the hype only serves to obfuscate the truth. At this point, I'm prepped to disbelieve because of the obvious over-hyping. People want these things to be true so bad that they will twist every detail to fit the narrative they want. It would be funny, if it weren't so sad.
- postalrat 3y ago"but the hype only serves to obfuscate the truth" Is that true? Do you think the Koreans or anyone would have made more progress finding the truth without the hype?
- zephyrthenoble 3y agoAre you implying that people on Hacker News saying LK-99 is a superconductor helped the scientific community in some way?
- hackinthebochs 3y agoWho on HN said that with enough confidence and credibility to do enough damage to the conversation such that it would be better had the conversation not happen at all?
- chpatrick 3y agoDid it "obfuscate the truth"? The truth was only discovered because the hype made a lot of scientists investigate the material.
- malux85 3y agoStrawman argument - You are reducing the comment to "Hacker News" when thats not at all what they said, they said "The hype". For sure the hype caused a lot more focus on reproducability attempts than it would have got otherwise.
- popilewiz 3y ago[dead]
- JohnDeHope 3y agoWhich is more likely in our lifetime: aliens, or an ambient superconductor?
- mindcrime 3y agoI'm going to vote for "ambient superconductor" even after this. At least we know superconductors actually exist at all, and the history of the field reflects incremental progress in terms of increasing the threshold temperature for superconductivity. With "aliens" we don't have much to go on at all, aside from vague Fermi-equation'esque appeals to "There must be aliens because the universe is so big[1]" or whatever. [1]: I actually agree that it's very likely that alien life either has existed, does exist, or will exist somewhere in the universe. My skepticism is towards the possibility of that life visiting Earth. And mostly for the exact same reason: because the universe is so damn big.
- valine 3y agoGood science takes time. Anyone making definitive claims, including this article, is full of it. LK-99 is probably not a super conductor, key word probably. It’ll be definitive when the original samples have been independently tested.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vecter 3y agoIn their preprint, the Korean authors note one particular temperature at which LK-99’s showed a tenfold drop in resistivity, from about 0.02 ohms per centimetre to 0.002 ohms per cm. “They were very precise about it. 104.8ºC,” says Prashant Jain, a chemist at the University of Illinois Urbana–Champaign. “I was like, wait a minute, I know this temperature.” The reaction that synthesizes LK-99 uses an unbalanced recipe: for every 1 part copper-doped lead phosphate crystal — pure LK-99 — it makes, it produces 17 parts copper and 5 parts sulfur. These leftovers lead to numerous impurities — especially copper sulfide, which the Korean team reported in its sample. Jain, a copper-sulfide expert, remembered 104ºC as the temperature at which Cu2S undergoes a phase transition if exposed to air. Below that temperature, Cu2S’s resistivity drops dramatically — a signal almost identical to LK-99’s purported superconducting phase transition. “I was almost in disbelief that they missed it.” Jain published a preprint on the important confounding effect on 7 August. [...] “That was the moment where I said, ‘Well, obviously, that’s what made them think this was a superconductor,’” says Fuhrer. “The nail in the coffin was this copper sulfide thing.” Science is hard. Kudos to everyone involved for trying to replicate it and figuring this puzzle out.
- darth_avocado 3y ago> Jain, a copper-sulfide expert I would have never known that people are actual experts in one material. This is impressive.
- lm28469 3y agoSome fields are so advanced that people are expert in one single material in very specific settings. There are some really exotic things out there that are barely used/studied
- morelisp 3y agoHe is likely an expert in many other materials too.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoI work with people who have basically researched amorphous silicon for decades.
- tonycoco 3y ago"70% CuS impurity"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 1970-01-01 3y agoWhat about L and K, the original scientists? Lots of speculation that LK-99 would be a career ending paper if it turned out that it wasn't a room temperature superconductor.
- jcarrano 3y agoIf 20 years of horsing around with a material that does not work did not end their careers, neither will this.
- throw-ru-938 3y agoDidn't they only get funding to horse around with that material several years ago?
- hedora 3y agoWell, yes, but their prototype time machine let them put in more years per year than you'd expect. (Someone anonymously claimed they have a time machine on social media, so it must be true!) Seriously though, it sounds like the research group is doing interesting work, and also being careful about the claims they make (even if the internet hype cycle is not), so kudos to them.
- seewhydee 3y agoNo, they were not careful about their claims. Putting aside the drama around the arxiv postings, they had previously explicitly made the "discovered a room temperature ambient pressure superconductor" claim in a Korean language journal, in a 2020 submission to Nature that was rejected, and on multiple patent applications. There is no evidence of them doing interesting work, either. If reporting is to be believed, their company mostly does unrelated consulting odd-jobs for the chaebols, and this was a passion project for Lee and Kim. But you know what? I'm glad there are oddballs like this on the fringe of science. They're mostly harmless, occasionally entertaining, and maybe once in an epoch they might come up with something real.
- kergonath 3y agoJust a reminder that’s not everything one can find in a paper (never mind a preprint) is true. The response from the community was great. Modellers doing some electronic structure calculations, synthesis experts trying to re-create the material, people doing all sorts of characterisation. The closest parallel I can think of is the faster-than-light neutrinos from a couple of years ago. Except that this time there were many teams and individuals all over the world trying to replicate the results. The material was supposedly easy to make, the reagents were quite easy to find, room-temperature conductivity measurements are not too difficult. There was a lot of enthusiasm and activity, which was really motivating. The fact that it could not be replicated is not surprising, considering the sloppiness of the original preprint. But still, it was a very public example of science in action. What was also interesting is the response from some corners of the Internet who were more than happy to bash scientists who were supposedly trying to cover up their own incompetence by debunking the plucky researchers from a brave private institution. Well, most often if something sounds too good to be true, that’s because it is.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- calderknight 3y ago>bash scientists who were supposedly trying to cover up their own incompetence by debunking the plucky researchers from a brave private institution Has this really been happening?
- seewhydee 3y agoI'd add that the 3-4 preprints that put the final nails in the coffin for LK-99 --- the ones that showed how ferromagnetic samples produce half-levitation, pointed out the Cu2S structural phase transition, explaining why the flat bands are not conducive to superconductivity, and the creation and characterization of a pure single crystal --- were all good showcases of scientific ingenuity. It was particularly impressive to see some groups putting together high-quality, publication-ready preprints from scratch in the span of a month. Especially crazy when you think about the shoddy original papers that the Korean group spent years working on...
- harha_ 3y agoI don't understand how did LK-99 create such wuss in the first place.
- usrbinbash 3y agoBecause a room-temp, amb-press superconductor, that can be made from readly available cheap materials, would be almost on par with the discovery of fire in terms of importance for our species technological capabilities. Even the simplest example of what that would mean is already amazing to our society: Imagine a power-grid that no longer loses power to electrical resistence in the wires.
- Dylan16807 3y agoCheap doesn't mean free. We can already reduce resistance by piling in more cheap metal, but it becomes more effort than it's worth. And superconductors have limits on how much power they can carry. But most importantly, the power grid doesn't lose all that much to resistance. And you'd still lose power to transmission line capacitance against the ground.
- usrbinbash 3y ago> Cheap doesn't mean free Means cheap enough to be mass produced, and available. > But most importantly, the power grid doesn't lose all that much to resistance Laws of scaling, even a small percentage of power lost to resistence is a hige overall loss, the avoidance of which is desirable. And as I said, this is only the simplest example.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> Means cheap enough to be mass produced, and available. But so are all our existing cables. > Laws of scaling, even a small percentage of power lost to resistence is a hige overall loss, the avoidance of which is desirable. We could cut those losses right now by making the existing cables thicker. But we don't. Even a cheap superconductor might not be used at all in electrical grids, because the benefit isn't worth the cost. > And as I said, this is only the simplest example. What are the better examples?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Moomoomoo309 3y agoI found Thunderf00t's video on LK-99 to be funny because he pointed out something no one else did: In almost all applications of superconductors, they don't use high-temperature ones for one simple reason: Material properties. Most high-temp superconductors (including LK-99, he was assuming it was one, since he's not qualified to say one way or the other) are a ceramic. The ones that see use in the LHC, for instance, aren't. They're metallic, so you can form them into the shape you need without having to manufacture it in that shape to begin with, since you'd need another superconductor to join pieces like glue, which we don't have. That alone doomed LK-99 to the department of "cool, but not super useful", since most of the really interesting uses were for large things, not small ones.
- reportingsjr 3y agoThe current generation of mass manufactured high temperature superconducting tape is based on YBCO, which is a crystalline material (presumably what is meant here when saying ceramic). So the argument that superconductors need to be metallic/malleable to be useful doesn't really make a lot of sense.
- kergonath 3y ago> presumably what is meant here when saying ceramic Probably not. Being crystalline and being a ceramic are completely unrelated. Standard superconductors like niobium-tin and niobium-titanium are crystalline metals (intermetallic alloys). The vast majority of metals are crystalline, to the point that when a company tried to make a metallic glass a couple of years ago (under the name Liquid Metal), it made quite a bit of noise.
- calibas 3y ago> By contrast, superconductors that levitate over magnets can be spun and even held upside-down. “None of those behaviors look like what we see in the LK-99 videos,” van Gennep says. Aren't they confusing Type-I and Type-II superconductors?
- nullc 3y agohm? "superconductors that levitate over magnets" == type-II, type-II can be spun and held upside-down.
- chmod600 3y agoNone of the earlier articles mentioned ferromagnetic levitation vs superconducting levitation and how to tell them apart.
- adrian_b 3y agoThere is no such thing as ferromagnetic levitation (i.e. there is no stable position). Nevertheless, a piece of ferromagnetic material which has a permanent remanent magnetization (which is possible only for a subset of the ferromagnetic materials) when put on a magnet may take a position close to vertical, with one edge pressed on the magnet. It is very easy to verify if this is what you see by moving the piece of material to the other pole of the magnet, where it must take a reversed position, with the other edge pressed on the magnet. A diamagnetic material will be equally repelled by both poles of the magnet, so moving it between the poles will not change its behavior. A soft ferromagnetic material, like iron, will be equally attracted by both poles of the magnet. The explanations that iron impurities could be present in quantities so great as to form some unknown iron compounds with high coercivity and some unknown experimental circumstances could magnetize permanently the samples, are not significantly more credible than the claims that room-temperature superconductors do exist. In any case, anyone who has made some samples can verify easily whether they are ferromagnetic or diamagnetic. It would be more credible that someone has made fake claims, than that they have mistaken a ferromagnetic material for a diamagnetic material.
- chmod600 3y agoThank you for the informative reply. Given that it's so easy for the experimenter to verify, you are saying that the most credible explanation is scientific fraud?
- themagician 3y agoBecause all of the people publishing information about this were playing the options market. There was no need to actually educate anyone on anything. This was a scam. It worked. One person sees the opportunity it creating a hype train and gets a few buddies on board. Loads up on $1 calls for something they feel could be the next meme stock, like AMSC. Options start to load up on 7/18, just a few days before the 7/22 original drop on arxiv. You get the 7/22 drop and then uploads of grainy videos start to show up. Bank a few million in options contracts as the price of AMSC doubles overnight. Other people see the hype train leaving the station and start their own, using the same strategy. It's how you end up with a dozen potato quality videos and very specific information attached to the comment threads, "This is going to be HUGE for quantum computing @IonQ_Inc if true." We have seen these types of market manipulation scams in the past. This was the first time we've seen someone use something like arxiv to do this. Brilliant idea, really. We will see more in the future no doubt.
- usrbinbash 3y agoOne of the good things that came out of this whole story: A very public demonstration, transported through mass and even social media channels, how empiricism and the principle of falsification work, and why they are the only known reliable process for generating knowledge.
- morelisp 3y agoNo, mass and social media stopped paying attention days ago because Trump or Hawai'i or whatever. In a few years some might have a flashback, Google "what happened stupor conduct", and after a few sentences conclude science isn't really worth paying attention to after all.
- Dylan16807 3y agoStopping paying attention in the sense of "waiting for news" sense, sure.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoI would charitabily read the parent's comment as referring to the middle brow 'mass media' aimed at those moderately above average in terms of paying attention to these topics. It overlaps with a sizable majority of the HN readerbase. Not the mass media of grocery store checkout aisle magazines.
- morelisp 3y agoWe have wildly diverging views of the average HNer. I'm thinking the median is much closer to "Russian catgirl home-cook on X" than "studious reader of The Atlantic".
- themagician 3y agoThe people who made millions off this saw something positive from it.
- arcticfox 3y ago
- dralley 3y agoHonestly, I feel bad for the original authors, who were correctly holding out for stronger evidence but were forced into publishing early by the actions of a third party going behind their backs. I hope they don't experience undue blowback because of this.
- mi_lk 3y agoI'm not aware of it, anything to read about the said third party?
- zulban 3y agoI suspect the third party is the one that will mostly suffer the career consequences.
- Gud 3y agoFor sure! The original researchers showed remarkable restraint considering what they were potentially sitting on. Kudos to them!
- KaoruAoiShiho 3y agoI think the story might be more complicated than that, I remember reading that the "third party" was the one paying the bills for the experiment so pushing it out early and even publicly failing would've been preferable to getting it dragged out infinitely for an unlikely hope of it being successful.
- hgsgm 3y agoThis funder-rushed science exactly what created Doc Ock and the Green Goblin.
- pnt12 3y agoNow I'm even more disappointed in the outcome!
- gundamdoubleO 3y ago
- alkibiades 3y agolol at those internet idiots boosting it. they will fall for anything. see: gamestop/crypto
- optimalsolver 3y agoHype boys once again btfo by establishment science.
- _yb2s 3y agoI would like to remind/point out how many people on here were bashing on American scientists for failing to replicate this in the first few days when labs around the world were confirming replication- saying they had lost their touch, and are no longer relevant.
- lamontcg 3y agoYeah that was one of the worst hottakes. Then getting called racist over having the opinion that the original authors sounded like amateurs. Then seeing that briefly turn on a dime and the Beijing University preprint being instantly discredited in favor of "wait for western institutions to weigh in".
- LanceH 3y agoI assume the apologies for calling skeptics racists will be going out shortly.
- m3kw9 3y agoThats the first news that really torpedo this sc claim.(a Cooper sulphide expert recognizing the main claim of 104c of a resistance drop was in fact a know property of a non superconductor). It’s too much of a coincidence plus the guy wouldn’t lie.
- hinkley 3y agoWas anything novel discovered in this material? Is there some more boring application waiting in the wings?
- nickelpro 3y agoNovel for material science? Not really. Novel for social media of sensationalist scientific news? Perhaps.
- dtx1 3y agoUnfortunate news but i'm glad i was there for the ride.
- koreanguy 3y ago[dead]
- kitanata 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- psychphysic 3y agoI've quite enjoyed this story and it's resolution. It does seem that the doomsayers who predicted the Earth would stop spinning because of lay public speculating about LK-99 were wrong. The system works. Yay!
- cwillu 3y agoIt's mildly amusing to see the commentary elsewhere that this whole event proves they were _right_ that the lay public speculating is somehow harmful.
- graypegg 3y agoYou know what? I needed that saga. That was fun. I don’t think I’ve been this interested in any research project since being a kid skimming thru popular science or something :) It’s been so cool to see all of the replication studies, people talking about the latest news and all of that. Kind of a peek behind the scientific curtain to see all of the work that goes into confirming claims.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- agrippanux 3y agoMy wife will be very happy. When I explained to her the potential if it truly was the breakthrough being reported, her first reaction was: "I hope we establish a government agency to regulate everything floating around because I don't want to get bumped into by random stuff".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- banq 3y agoshe need GOD
- vietvu 3y agoWhen I told my wife about this, all she replied was how it's gonna be monopolized by big countries/big tech and our third world country like ours will never use it. It's a point, but well human need to push the limit, no matter what.
- science4sail 3y ago"Never" is a strong word - smartphones were once monopolized by rich countries, but are now a worldwide phenomenon. Even explicitly-banned/controlled technologies like nuclear weapons managed to eventually diffuse around the world.
- vietvu 3y agoYes, it is never absolute. But I get her points, always mean majority. Like for her I am always late for dinner. The days that I was early does not count, even if it's like 20%.
- onion2k 3y agoWhen I told my wife about this, all she replied was how it's gonna be monopolized by big countries/big tech and our third world country like ours will never use it. The materials and hardware required to make LK-99 are within the reach of a high school. It's really simple and doesn't require anything more than a very hot oven (hotter than a domestic one, but still very common). If it'd turned out to be a real superconductor anyone who wanted to make it could have done.
- dkroy 3y agoHow did all of these labs in China end up replicating the results of the paper? Were they just not reputable labs?
- philomath_mn 3y agoHere is a list of replication attempts from another comment [0]. Looks like most of the replications were only on the weak levitation property, which could be explained by diamagnetism or impurities. [0] https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/claims-of-room-temperature-and-ambient-pressure-superconductor.1106083/ https://forums.spacebattles.com/threads/claims-of-room-tempe...
- jauco 3y ago(I am very much a layperson) So does this mean that the videos that showed LK-99 hovering but not rotating are fake? Or can you have that static hover effect without being a superconductor?
- stetrain 3y ago> In the video, the same edge of the sample seemed to stick to the magnet, and it seemed delicately balanced. By contrast, superconductors that levitate over magnets can be spun and even held upside-down. “None of those behaviors look like what we see in the LK-99 videos,” van Gennep says. > He thought LK-99’s properties were more likely the result of ferromagnetism. So he constructed a pellet of compressed graphite shavings with iron filings glued to it. A video made by Van Gennep shows that his disc — made of non-superconducting, ferromagnetic materials — mimicked LK-99’s behaviour.
- shawabawa3 3y agoThat explains the half levitation A few videos came out of full levitation, but it's pretty certain they are fake
- DarkmSparks 3y ago"The science is settled." Proceeds to quote a guy who studied chemistry at university and now works in finance. Now, Im not saying it is a superconductor. But please, don't insult my intelligence with garbage like that, I'm more inclined to believe that kind of reporting is evidence that serious scientists are not willing to go on record as saying it isn't.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- threeseed 3y ago"The science is settled." - No idea what exactly the original replication process was. - Limited number of replication attempts globally. - No comments or samples analysed from the original authors.
- rvz 3y agoThis only proves that you shouldn't believe such random 'breakthroughs' on the internet, these days. What a shame, but the attention seeking and hype clearly worked and duped many here. Even though they won't admit that they fell for the hype. Be a bit skeptical next time.
- philomath_mn 3y ago> hype clearly worked and duped many here What was the benefit to those doing the hype? What was the harm to those being "duped"? I certainly went through periods of waxing and waning belief, but now that the dust is settled I don't think I am any worse for the wear. It's not like this was a garden variety pump-and-dump or anything like that.
- iraqmtpizza 3y agoI don't see how 0.002 ohms per cm could be confused with superconductivity. Is that not orders of magnitude too high? Or there are no instruments which can directly measure resistance more precisely?
- deepspace 3y agoYes, that was my first thought. There are absolutely instruments which can directly measure resistance down to 10E-8 ohms/m or lower, and I would expect any lab doing research into superconductivity to at least have one of those.
- iraqmtpizza 3y agoAlso, "not a superconductor" means that it can't superconduct at any temperature. Where is the evidence of that? Or it's just clickbait?
- shawabawa3 3y agoBy that logic we might as well say that wood is a superconductor Nobody has tested it at 0.0000000000000K after all
- floxy 3y agoOne group claimed that their sample of LK-99 went superconducting at ~110K: https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.01192 https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.01192
- zamadatix 3y agoThe conclusion is a bit clearer: they think they observed what seemed like zero resistance at the temperature but they are unsure it was actually superconducting, hence the title being the measured resistivity instead of superconductivity directly. It's also possible (and far more likely IMO) them reaching the noise floor of the instrument was not the same as the sample actually having 0 resistance. Superconductors have a sharp dropoff at the critical temperature whereas their sample seemed to just continually have less resistance until the noise floor of the tool. It'd be cool to find it was superconducting at a temperature near that high though. That'd still be one of the best high temperature superconductors we've found.
- MBCook 3y agoSo is LK-99 still something that may be useful in some other way due to some confirmed property? Or was all this just a mistake, from a usefulness perspective. It was fun to watch, nice to get hope of something so cool, and good to see the scientific process in action. But is there any reason to keep researching LK-99 over some other random compound?
- scythe 3y agoOne of the papers that argued that LK-99's levitation was due to mixed diamagnetism and weak ferromagnetism also assigned it a very strong diamagnetism: -2•10^-4, which would make it the second-strongest such material known, beating out bismuth. Probably not that useful, but interesting if confirmed. I read some of the papers linked in this article, but they use different units and don't identify a diamagnetic susceptibility in the way that I'm used to, so I'm not sure if that was confirmed (and I have stuff to do).
- platz 3y agoBut, a lot of those studies weren't using pure LK-99 but samples with lots of copper sulfide mixed in.
- scythe 3y agoCopper sulfide's diamagnetism is not that high. It would be notable if it were. So that isn't a possible explanation. Cu2S was suggested as a culprit for the observed conductivity changes. The preprint reporting the high value of diamagnetism is here: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03110.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/2308.03110.pdf >The subtracted diamagnetic susceptibility is larger than that of Bismuth and water but smaller than that of Pyrolytic carbon (page 3, bottom left)
- samhuk 3y ago> When copper oxide superconductors were discovered in 1986, researchers leapt to probe their properties. But nearly four decades later, there is still debate over the material’s superconducting mechanism, says Vishik. Efforts to explain LK-99 came readily. To me, the interesting take-away is that, right at the end. All too often we see peer-review as this slow, inching, excruciating process, particularly in social sciences where it's a de-facto afterthought. It was great to see science chugging ferociously away like a (somewhat!) well-oiled machine, such as the electronic analysis via slightly different methods (e.g. DFT) and the material synthesis efforts by the Argonne NL and Max Planck Institute. Farewell for now, RTSC. Side-note: Pure LK-99 is visually beautiful! Who would-a known from those crumbly grey flakes, huh?
- seewhydee 3y agoThat German lab should sell LK-99 crystals. I wouldn't mind buying a souvenir for this whole episode!
- challenger-derp 3y agoI'd like to second this. Bonus points if a magnet were included so that the sample could be "levitated" over it. This is definitely a kind of novelty gift suitable for science-y and geeky friends.
- cynusx 3y agoI'm curious (but not really qualified to understand) if the theoretical calculations on viable superconducting structures was a new insight on its own. If there is a theoretical model for ambient temperature superconductivity, then that should help us zoom in on potential materials that could be an actual superconductor someday?
- paxys 3y ago[flagged]
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoAgreed: > going viral on TikTok isn't the new peer review Not so sure: > science is still best done the old fashioned way It's not surprising that social networks designed to serve ads aren't outperforming scientific journals at deriving scientific consensus. But it would be interesting to see how the journals stack up to a social network that was designed for deriving scientific consensus.
- gataca 3y ago> HN commenters who were incessantly bringing up the failed Western scientific and political order in a hundred threads about this This especially was simultaneously comical and cringe-worthy
- coolspot 3y ago> -1 to (…) Russian anime cat girls Don’t you dare!
- jklinger410 3y agoThis was absolutely a fun and worthwhile experience for everyone involved. A lot of people got more interested in current materials science because of this. We watched a large community spring up out of nowhere to investigate a new discovery. It was really an incredible thing to witness, and I see only good things came of it. I can't really understand the sour grapes commenters in this thread. Not sure if they just want to feel smarter/better than everyone else who went along for this ride, or if they really hold the belief that the best science should be gate-kept in universities and not discussed in a wider context. Strong get off my lawn energy.
- ShamelessC 3y agoFor me personally it is just general (mild) annoyance with a community that somewhat consistently likes to think it is smarter and better than others and which is then only ever willing to admit they were wrong in roundabout ways like "well this was all fun, anyone who thinks it was a waste of resources or what-have-you doesn't see how much impact it had". You can see this wild speculation play out _commonly_ for lots of will-be fads like cryptocurrency, metaverse, prompt engineering, vector databases, "autoGPT"/langchain, GPT3/4 performance degradation, GPT4 architecture, and more. People here dress it all up in well-written prose, citing their past experience at big tech or the ivy league, but at the end of the day much of it is as misinformed as a viral 4chan post. And then, as I said, there is very little postmortem from those same posters (although to be fair, I have seen several cryptocurrency people finally admit they were wrong). edit: For clarity, I am not encouraging a shame-based "admit you're wrong and I'm right!" attitude. That just results in more of the same but from the other side. I am merely condoning a healthy amount of humility and acceptance that it is _absolutely_ okay to be wrong, but that it is quite important to _admit_ it (if only to yourself) in fairly clear terms. My frustrations are largely related to social media in general and the notion that scientists are gatekeeping seems to forget about the very real effects of misinformation. None of us like to realize it, but some people really have begun to take the word of internet comments over the word of credentialed takes and it is _ruining_ society in my opinion.
- penjelly 3y ago
- throwaway4220 3y ago“ Derrick van Gennep, a former condensed-matter researcher at Harvard University in Cambridge, Massachusetts, who now works in finance ” This is always sad to see but I get it
- philomath_mn 3y agoMany such cases (most of the quants at my last job had PhDs in Physics or Chemistry)
- OJFord 3y agoAnd I get why you say that, but also way more people want PhDs (or even to work in academic research) than the system supports. i.e. you have not only to resist the industry moneybags, but also defy odds anyway It's like being a former actor (of undisclosed repute) turned waiter if Hollywood A-list pay was not great (and B-list awful).
- vagab0nd 3y agoIs it really sad though? On the surface it seems the society heavily incentivizes smart people to work on "less impactful" things. But if every smart person becomes a condensed-matter researcher then obviously we have a problem. So what's the right amount of people that should work on condensed matter physics? Who should decide on such amount? Currently the market decides. But maybe there's a better way?
- Lockal 3y agoI'm more upset that it was possible to successfully register a patent on the LK-99. On the one hand, patent services seem to be not obliged to check the workability of the patents, but on the other hand this is absolutely malicious activity, as it is a direct road to patent trolling and fraud on non-existent intellectual property.
- pbj1968 3y agoI still remember the flailing I got around here when I dared to mention South Korean labs have a long history of making bold claims.
- sorenjan 3y agoSixty Symbols released a video about this yesterday, and in it professor Philip Moriarty is less than impressed with the whole ordeal. I haven't been paying attention, I'm too jaded and skeptical and assumed from the start that there was something wrong and much hype about nothing. Bad Science and Room Temperature Superconductors - Sixty Symbols: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zl-AgmoZ5mo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zl-AgmoZ5mo
- penjelly 3y agoeveryone in this thread should watch this, instead of "the excitement was good for everyone" they might realize these hoaxes harm scientific integrity. The audacity of HN to state something is good, without listening to scientists give their take on it.
- hn_throwaway_99 3y ago> instead of "the excitement was good for everyone" they might realize these hoaxes harm scientific integrity. Totally disagree. If anything, this whole episode (debacle?) reinforced the fact that science works and the process played out exactly how the scientific process should work: 1. First, the paper was originally posted on arxiv, meaning it was a pre-print and didn't go through any peer review. So the vast majority of comments I saw on it was "Wow, this would be really cool, if it turns out to be true." 2. Immediately many labs around the world started trying to replicate the results. And very quickly there were some negative results that came back. 3. The thing that I think is so cool is not only did negative results come back, but from TFA people now have a very good understanding of why the initial analysis was incorrect. That's great science. One may argue that this was really a failure in media communication vs. the actual underlying science, but if anything it teaches appropriate skepticism, especially when a report is initially published, without peer review, without yet being replicated, that ends with the sentence "We believe that our new development will be a brand-new historical event that opens a new era for humankind."
- penjelly 3y agogood points. I can agree to that. However, I do think something did break down and I think your assessment below is more accurate than my initial take. > One may argue that this was really a failure in media communication vs. the actual underlying science the scientific process and scientists here are innocent, media not so much in my eyes.
- gumby 3y agoI worried less as to whether LK-99 was a superconductor or not when I thought that the 'flat band' theory might hold water. That could have led to all sorts of interesting results, but alas it appears not to work after all.
- duringmath 3y agoIt was interesting seeing real peer reviewed science from accredited labs like LLNL and Fermi get brushed aside and almost dismissed while people were cheering on this LK-99 thing. Not sure what to make of that but that's what I'll remember most about this debacle.
- chrononaut 3y agoThat's what I most remember too from this.
- carabiner 3y agoLLNL and Fermi did peer reviewed research on LK-99? Links?
- duringmath 3y agoThey published followup papers on fusion ignition and strange muon behavior respectively.
- carabiner 3y agoOh ok. Mainstream media reported on fusion ignition #2 while (rightfully) ignoring LK-99. I think the takeaway here is just how bad techbros are at evaluating hard science.
- mellosouls 3y agoIts kind of like a "nice/fun" flip-side of the anti-science internet experts we saw during covid, although I think the people at the forefront this time were genuinely pro-science and positively motivated.
- winwang 3y agoThat's an interesting take. Crackpots and overhyped layman being a dual of anti-science. What would we call that? Well, I guess we'd normally talk about that stuff as science fiction.
- progrus 3y ago[flagged]
- pistachiopro 3y agoYou can publish an article with a title like this and probably not end up embarrassed. Room temperature and pressure super conductors seem hard enough to find that chances are any given paper claiming to have found one will end up with a more mundane explanation. And I do think the information about the phase change of Cu2S is highly relevant, as it points at a way the original researches my have fooled themselves. The dismissal of the partial levitation as ferromagnetism, on the other hand, doesn't strike me as especially robust. Ferromagnetism explains the partial levitation of tiny fragments of material generated by people trying to reproduce LK-99. Very light and thin pieces of ferromagnetic material will align themselves with a magnetic field. For example, Andrew McCalip (who streamed himself attempting to reproduce the material in his rocket startup's lab) generated a partially levitating fragment and sent it into USC, where they determined it was ferromagnetic. But bulk pieces of ferromagnetic material will just stick to magnets (or if they are magnetized, they will stick to one side and be unstably repelled from the other). Ferromagnetism doesn't explain the levitation demonstrated in the videos put out by the original researches, though. Barring fraud, the most likely explanation for that kind of levitation is diamagnetism. The article mentions Derrick van Gennep recreating the partial levitation video with a chunk of pyrolytic graphite (one of the most diamagnetic materials we know of, other than superconductors), supergluing iron filings to a corner of it to anchor it to the magnet. The levitation in that video comes from diamagnetism, not ferromagnetism. LK-99 is primarily made of lead, not graphite, which is 5-10 times denser, so the diamagnetic effect must be at least that much stronger than pure pyrolytic graphite. The thing is, as the rest of the article points out, the supposed main constituents of LK-99 have now been extensively studied, and none of them appear to be especially diamagnetic, so something in those samples the original team recorded must be extremely diamagnetic to make up for it!
- floxy 3y ago>so something in those samples the original team recorded must be extremely diamagnetic to make up for it! I wonder what would have happened if they would have pushed a paper out talking about anomalously high diamagnetism and skipped any mentions of superconducting. And let people speculate if it is a superconductor. I suppose we wouldn't be talking about it. But I hope that we see some group try to replicate the diamagnetic material properties.
- vondur 3y agoGotta love that one of the scientists quoted in the article now works in the finance field. Probably pays a bit more than a research scientist.
- floxy 3y agoSo it sounds like the purple crystal isn't repelled by magnets. So what part of the samples was causing the magnetic properties? Or are we saying that all of those videos and images were faked?
- flatline 3y agoSays it right there: CuS. You should read the whole thing, it’s really well-written and thorough.
- floxy 3y agoThe Cu₂S was responsible for the temperature dependent resistivity measurement caused by a phase change at 104 °C, not the magnet properties. If you have some more information on the ferromagnetic properties of copper sulfides, I'd like to learn more.
- zamadatix 3y agoThe varda shards found to be responsive to magnetic fields had trace amounts of iron impurity as well which was given as the expected reason in that case. Not sure about every other case of course.
- legohead 3y agoCompany that has already lied in the past lies again, and everyone eats it up, again... The internet has taught me to never trust material science advancements at face value. Batteries, solar power, superconductors, nanomaterials.. Even when they legit work, there is usually a straight forward reason why it just isn't feasible, and that is conveniently left out of the press release. I have to go to the HN comment section to get disappointed once again.
- lIl-IIIl 3y ago"Company that has already lied in the past lies again, and everyone eats it up, again" - what are you referring to?
- mike00632 3y agoSome members of the LK-99 team published a claim of superconductivity and it included falsified data. Nature published it and had to retract it. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-05294-9 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-022-05294-9 https://www.science.org/content/article/something-seriously-wrong-room-temperature-superconductivity-study-retracted https://www.science.org/content/article/something-seriously-...
- fsh 3y agoThe paper with the falsified data is from an american team and has absolutely nothing to do with LK-99.
- hospitalJail 3y agoI love how quickly replication happened. This is science. Medicine/psychology/sociology and their inability to do replication is not science.
- LanceH 3y agoNo replication in medicine? It's biology and messy, but how many do you know with polio? Lots of science going on there.
- bandyaboot 3y ago> in particular, copper sulfide — were responsible for the sharp drops in electrical resistivity and partial levitation over a magnet, which looked similar to properties exhibited by superconductors. Is this effect novel and/or potentially useful as a material?
- nwiswell 3y agoNot novel. Very much the opposite. The article mentions that the original Cu2S resistivity measurements date from 1951.
- gfodor 3y agoThe substance produced from the paper isn't a superconductor. While extremely unlikely, there is still a chance that LK-99 is a superconductor, but the paper itself did not sufficiently describe the method needed to make it so as to replicate it properly. We will know the resolution to this once the sample from the original researchers is assessed by a third party, of which there are presently at least two to my understanding doing this right now.
- gilgoomesh 3y agoThe German team produced a crystal of pure LK-99 and tested it. From the article: > LK-99 is not a superconductor, but an insulator with a resistance in the millions of ohms And furthermore, the graphs from the original pre-print article are just graphs of the resistivity of Cu2S. It sounds like there's nearly zero chance of any further science here (beyond confirmation).
- postalrat 3y agoA pure crystal of lk-99 is about as useful as a pure crystal of cake.
- ricardobeat 3y agoThe point is that the original team did not produce a pure crystal, and impurities can be the source of novel properties in a material - you’ll know it as “doping” in the semiconductor industry. Other comments from more informed people indicate it’s unlikely that this will yield anything useful though.
- fouc 3y agoSeems like there's a chance the preprint for LK-99 described the material wrongly, so it was not accurately replicated.
- gfodor 3y ago"A crystal of pure LK-99" is an oxymoron, LK-99, the physical substance in Korea, is not a pure crystal.
- 3y ago
- TwoFactor 3y agoWhile there's certainly a lot of evidence that its not a superconductor, no one can make the definitive statement that this article does without testing the original sample.
- sdenton4 3y agoIn summary, "Fucking magnets, how do they work?" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_-agl0pOQfs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_-agl0pOQfs
- Gibbon1 3y agoOne time I was listening to that and the next thing that played was https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MO0r930Sn_8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MO0r930Sn_8
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ok123456 3y agoThis shows that the properties that were observed aren't as a result of a pure single crystal. If the observed properties can be explained and controlled by dislocation dynamics or other mechanisms of the impurities, then it may still be of interest.
- sethbannon 3y agoI felt like folks were getting too optimistic in the early days and now I feel folks are getting way to pessimistic. We don't know if any of these failed replication experiments actually made the same LK-99 the Korean team did. The only way of knowing for sure if LK-99 is a room temp superconductor is if outside labs test the samples the Korean team has made. It's entirely possible that the exact impurities in their material caused by their exact manufacturing process are required for superconducting properties to emerge. Seems like that will be done in the next few weeks. Still betting against it working but keeping my fingers crossed.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- drcode 3y agoExtraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence Now, this extraordinary claim doesn't even have weak evidence I think pessimism is warranted at this point
- dekhn 3y agomy only criticism is to the people who, without real background in the area, read the paper, thought the synthesis was "easy", raced to get the reagents only to realize that you can't easily order somet things without a prior relationship and trust with a chemical supplier, and then showed some antimagnetism in their shitty examples, without understanding that that phenomenon isn't conclusive evidence. It's sort of an example of the "why don't you just...." phenomenon where a noob tells an expert that solving a problem is easy... I guess I also criticize whomever published the original paper. They did just a bad enough job to get people excited, but experts pretty quickly noticed major flaws in the article which cast enough doubt to pretty much reject even attemptiong a replication. Well, i suppose to be fair, I should also criticize the theorists who came out and made crazy claims saying that theory supports this being a superconductor- Konerding's 27th law, amended, says: "Given a ridiculous experimental claim, there will always be at least 3 theorists who publish a paper saying that the theory supports the claim". Anybody who lived through Fleishman and Pons (and fusion in general) has learned to be highly skeptical, up front, and the expectation is that the publisher/author of the article has done an excellent job making their findings reproducible.
- acedTrex 3y agoThe original paper wasn't published, it was leaked
- bacon_waffle 3y agoWhy criticize? People spend their time and money on pointless pursuits all the time.
- dekhn 3y agoMy goal in criticism is to guide interested players towards more fruitful pursuits. I don't want to see invalid science sucking up all the attention and crowding out legitimate but boring science.
- bacon_waffle 3y agoNegative experimental results are valid science, aren't they? If you believe attention is a 0-sum game (I don't, but am trying to understand), why not focus criticism on those people spending time on any number of other pursuits that are even further from fruitful. It just seems like, for whatever your idea of "fruitful" is, there are entire industries and institutions that are focused on taking attention away from fruitful pursuits.
- zuminator 3y agoA good time to remind everyone that for almost 2 decades now it's been determined that the majority of published scientific findings are wrong. [0][1] Including possibly even the very determination that the majority of published scientific findings are wrong.[2] ([3]) So, if that's the case, when a new result comes out, the appropriate reaction is to assume there's a better than average likelihood it will be refuted. And honestly that's what makes science great. Unlike with some other fields of human endeavor, it is possible to firmly refute bad science. And often learn something new in the process. [0] https://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/journal.pmed.0020124 https://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/jo... [1] https://www.annualreviews.org/doi/10.1146/annurev-statistics-060116-054104 https://www.annualreviews.org/doi/10.1146/annurev-statistics... [2] https://replicationindex.com/2019/01/15/ioannidis-2005-was-wrong-most-published-research-findings-are-not-false/ https://replicationindex.com/2019/01/15/ioannidis-2005-was-w... [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epimenides_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epimenides_paradox
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throwawaymaths 3y agoIt's pretty wild that the scientific community can make such a judgement on a reasonably difficult to assess result in 2 weeks. This is not proper peer review (lower case p).
- samstave 3y agoCan one make a micro-fluidic-slurry that is pumped through a tube surrounded by a C style cup of magnets. The slurry is passed through super cooling nodes to keep it at sub temp. and an a reverse C shape coupler is the drive - so you draw the lead/push the lead but you can maintain the coolant in a much more pulsed way? Middle out. C meets C in the CC (but with mirrors)((and magnets)) [Assume you have never evaluated how a roller-coaster works]
- eutropia 3y ago> Separated from impurities, LK-99 is not a superconductor, but an insulator with a resistance in the millions of ohms — too high to run a standard conductivity test. Not quite a superinsulator, but ironic.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- beders 3y agoWell, maybe this is the beginning of another cold fusion story. Despite failures to reproduce the Pons/Fleischmann results, it spawned a whole new field: LENR which has very interesting yearly conferences.
- kergonath 3y agoNot exactly. Cold fusion was contradicted by our knowledge of Physics at the time. Room-temperature superconductors are a field of active study, because even though we don’t know one, we think they might exist and the industrial applications could be world-changing. The response was not “room-temperature superconductors cannot exist”, as with cold fusion, but more “this sounds implausible and your preprint is dodgy; nevertheless we’ll try to replicate it”.
- ACV001 3y agoimagine this - the government took over and covered up with "not working" theory. Maybe a key ingredient is missing which was not mentioned in the original paper.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- shekispeaks 3y agoThey should have also included a quote from CISR an Indian lab that go there about the same time as many of the American labs https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03544 https://arxiv.org/abs/2308.03544
- seewhydee 3y agoYes, I noticed that this article disproportionately quoted American scientists who played relatively minor roles in the replication efforts. I guess the reporter just found it more convenient to reach out to them for comments.
- jokoon 3y agoThis type of story is fueled by techno-optimists who want to believe that humans can always "figure out" the universe and take advantage of the laws of physics to master their environment. I don't understand where this belief comes from, but to think that research + time = innovation is really ignorant of how technology works. It seems it's really rooted in prophetic or religious way to look at technology. Cornucopianism is a really better word for it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cornucopianism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cornucopianism
- RhodesianHunter 3y ago>I don't understand where this belief comes from Probably the last 100 or so years where we have largely done exactly that.
- timeon 3y agoNow we are going to pay for that.
- RhodesianHunter 3y agoWe'd be paying had we not done it.
- jabedude 3y ago> I don't understand where this belief comes from For me it comes from a survey of the previous 2 millennia of human history and witnessing constant technological advancements that produce higher and higher standards of living
- CatWChainsaw 3y ago2 millennia of human history. Out of the 10 that have had anything resembling civilization. Out of the 100 since "humans" began to walk the earth. So which condition, exactly, is the anomaly? :)
- deleted 3y ago
- devilsAdv0cate 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- BurningFrog 3y agoOK, but I have a real good feeling about LK-100!
- feralderyl 3y agoHas anyone ever worked out a "proof" that a room temperature/ambient pressure superconductor can even be made? Like is there a formula or something that can be pointed to that says, according to everything we know its even possible?
- spott 3y agoNo. We don’t understand superconductivity well enough to even attempt something like that. I think we can say that some of the current superconductor mechanisms don’t allow it at room temperature, but we don’t have enough of an overarching theory of superconductivity to say something like that more generally.
- choeger 3y agoWhat an amazing time we live in. It took weeks for the world to investigate this "discovery". Weeks. Not months, years, or decades. We will see spectacular results from this kind of global scientific collaboration. I am confident that there will be an actual scientific breakthrough confirmed like this report got debunked.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- terrib1e 3y agoI was waiting for the first line of the article to be 'LK-99 is not a superconductor... It's an ultraconductor!' Alas, today is just not my day.
- perth 3y ago[flagged]
- chmod600 3y agoIf the video showed ferromagnetism, which parts of the material and/or impurities are ferromagnetic enough for that to happen? If none, does that mean scientific fraud (e.g. adding an impurity intentionally), or is there another credible explanation?
- calderknight 3y agoArticle fails to establish title's claim. Yeah the pure crystal isn't a superconductor - but guess what? the Koreans never claimed that substituting in copper atoms in a random fashion would work.
- ken47 3y agoYou're stating something that should be obvious. How are there so many software and software-adjacent people who take headlines at face value?
- stilwelldotdev 3y agoWaiting for more labs to weigh in. Every scientist whose name we know was called an idiot by a room full of experts first.
- dfasdfa32423 3y agoCould be true, but there will more tests for sure.
- k2718281828y 3y agoFounders- note, you just experienced a mini-bubble. It is good to learn from this because it has commonalities to other bubbles. Fortunately, the cost of this bubble was only time and attention. Unfortunately, time and attention are scarce and precious.
- lost_tourist 3y agoI was hopeful the first couple of days when it hit twitter but it became pretty obvious after that it just hopium and decided to wait for the paper. I wonder if they'll even bother to try and publish now...
- vietvu 3y agoIt's a wild ride.
- dudeinjapan 3y agoParty like it's LK-99!
- fnordpiglet 3y agoI think it’s a fairly interesting story over all, and it feels like exactly how science should happen. We are humans and easily deluded. We fall easily for things we wish to be true. The fascinating story behind LK99 is incredibly human - including the rushing a preprint out to secure a noble prize by one of the researchers who was being excluded. The fascinating part to me was the fact engineers and scientists could on their own time try to replicate and did so in the open. People were excited and eager for it to be true and found hope in the ambiguity and excitement in the partial successes, and dreamed of what could be. Then, through careful analysis by experts who know their subjects well, we learned it was not the magic we dreamed it might be but a magic that we already knew about. A negative result of something so many people wished to be true is an ultimate victory of science, and to me more exciting than a positive result in many ways. It tells me we are on the right track on a great many things in the world, when it feels often we are on a wrong track on most things.
- laserbeam 3y agoI disagree. The paper should never have been published. Science should not happen in the news with people making wild claims about non peer reviewed papers. More so about papers that were getting lots of negative public peer review in real time. The only reason this story has a happy ending is the authors included manufacturing instructions. But everything else about the paper is not a good model of how to publish (wild claims that you will revolutionise the world, the title, the bad graphs, the 2nd paper that was published with different authors...). The fact that papers get retracted is nothing new. Science as a field is already generally good at retractions. Science is generally bad at incentivising reproduction... But this case was extreme and not a good model. It should not require sensationalist news and dozens of labs to reproduce a paper that was failing peer review.
- nickelpro 3y ago> The paper should never have been published. The paper wasn't published, despite the phrasing in the nature article. arXiv is effectively a moderated blog
- 3y ago
- dougSF70 3y agoThank God, this means I can stop pretending to be a twitter expert on superconductivity.
- CliffStoll 3y agoN-Rays Neo-Lamarckian Midwife Toads Polywater Cold Fusion Schön's Single Molecule Organic Transistors Cloned human stem cells Faster-than-light Neutrinos
- tw1984 3y agoThose Korean researchers who consistently refused to share samples now has the moral obligation to come out and explain what is really going on. I call it corruption - if you claim you have the sample that is a room temp supercondutor and you want the attention of the research community, how about just get some 3rd party to access your bloody sample? what we got was excuses after excuses.
- forward-slashed 3y agoIt's sad to see people accept the credibility of this article simply because it's from Nature. The author himself is a freelance science journalist (with no real expertise in the field), so this article is not worth any more of our attention than many twitter threads. You can gauge the trustworthiness yourself here: https://x.com/dangaristo?s=21&t=lI9nNO9bkbL1YKFrdIw_Tg https://x.com/dangaristo?s=21&t=lI9nNO9bkbL1YKFrdIw_Tg
- firtoz 3y agoIs it right or is it wrong?
- forward-slashed 3y agoI care about the process of determining truth. If one does expert deferral, then they should do so properly. Sadly Nature is expending their social capital as a scientific journal to pivot to a typical news organization. If one is up to date with sc news, this article should not affect their beliefs. But maybe some people are happy that they can share an article from Nature to convince their friends.
- Forgotthepass8 3y agoIt is sad to see that even nature may be a victim of sociological decay.
- wesleywt 3y agoWhat did Nature do wrong in this case. Be specific. And show us where the findings are replicated. That should be easy.
- fsh 3y agoNature has had a news section since 1869 [1]. There are many things to criticise about them, but the science journalism is not one of them. [1] https://www.nature.com/nature/volumes/1/issues/2#News https://www.nature.com/nature/volumes/1/issues/2#News
- 3y ago
- sanroot99 3y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p3hubvTsf3Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p3hubvTsf3Y , reality check
- vbezhenar 3y agoStill not explaining the levitation.
- ayakang31415 3y agoI'm still going to wait for the final version of the paper that is being peer-reviewed for APL material publication
- wenyuanyu 3y agoI'm inclined to think that LK et al might eventually decide to withdraw the submission themselves, or likely got rejected directly, given the various factors at play. Alternatively, they may continue to keep the arXiv pre-print updated with each round of revisions to transparently address issues raised by peer reviewers. However, based on the current situation and the rigorous standards of APL Materials, I find it challenging to envision this work being accepted for publication in that journal.
- yarrak 3y agoTheir entire career is over.
- svara 3y agoAll those "peer review must die and be replaced by a Twitter mob" comments sound even more stupid now, and yet it will be the same thing next round. This is leaving a really unpleasant aftertaste for me, seeing how dismissive this community got about the opinion and work of people with actual expertise, based mostly on repeating memes picked up from social media.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- globular-toast 3y agoWhat this really showed is just how pathetic our current situation is. We have a way of life that is unsustainable but instead of changing it we all pray that science will save us. LK99 was basically like the coming of Christ. Really sad to see so many intelligent people so eager to believe.
- nologic01 3y agoWe do have a "superconductor" but its not the one we wanted. It is the best description for the behavior of online (social) media: no longer exhibits any resistance and the tiniest spark leads to amplification and a system meltdown. These collective hysterias are a combination of people desperate for technological solutions to (typically) social problems and a system that eagerly exploits that for the benefit of a few. Of course there are countless mysteries still remaining to be uncovered in materials science, just like there is an infinity of algorithmic advances to be made in processing information. But the more important invention of all might be to find the checks and balances, feedback loops and regulators that will prevent people from behaving like panicked apes. At best this uncontrolled lemming instinct of ours is a huge waste of time. At worst it undermines society and our welfare.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- totorovirus 3y agoAs a Korean, I had a feeling this might unfold in this way. It's truly disheartening to witness Korean academia repeating a familiar pattern – this rush to make a splash globally, it's like history repeating itself. We remember back in 2009, when Dr. Woo Suk Hwang claimed the first successful human embryo cloning, only for it to unravel as a fraud (source: https://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/27/world/asia/27clone.html https://www.nytimes.com/2009/10/27/world/asia/27clone.html). With LK-99, I couldn't help but notice the same signs that triggered my skepticism back then. The tale is familiar – researchers hungry for funding, limited interaction with the global scientific community, and bold declarations of "innovation" that likely could have occurred despite less-than-ideal research conditions. Their bold claims to their break through resonates with the typical korean cinderella narrative - overcoming harsh conditions, through relentless determination to achieve the goal, just like we made such a rapid growth from basically ruins to OECD membership in less than a century. It is a common pattern in research proposals in korea to tout the patriotism of government officials in this manner. I see this incident as a extension of that research culture in korea. I too have enjoyed the hype and hoped it to be true but sadly it turned out to be another false pursuit for attention.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- AltruisticGapHN 3y agoI think the positive take here is "an unusually swift resolution of a high-profile puzzle". So it sounds like the leak was in fact a positive and that overall rewarding people with nobel prizes is detrimental to science. edit: it's OK to make mistakes. If science focused on EXPERIMENTING instead of trying to be the arbiter of truth on how the world is, we'd progress much farther. Maybe there is a reason why it seems physics has been stuck for the past 50+ years... maybe it is a shift in culture, driven social media, the fear of being wrong, of being shamed by the collective, of using the improper labels, etc. that is holding everyone back.
- boobalyboo 3y ago[flagged]
- andy_ppp 3y agoI did wonder if we suddenly could produce loads of room temperature super conductors if eventually we’d start to affect earth’s magnetic field; I learned that super conductors basically force magnetic fields around them and do not allow them to pass through. If they started to be used everywhere from power lines to train lines to computer chips we might start to cause unintended consequences. Does anyone have an idea if this is a real concern?
- avidiax 3y agoWe already make so many magnetic fields that are at least locally stronger than the Earth's field.
- 8teapi 3y agoI still think it’s a room temperature and ambient pressure superconductor. I’m amazed at how bad Nature, Scientific American and the mainstream press are. Let’s see.
- curvx 3y agoOof! > LK-99 is not a superconductor, but an insulator with a resistance in the millions of ohms — too high to run a standard conductivity test.
- calderknight 3y ago(note that this is a very different LK-99 to the one that is claimed to be a superconductor)
- johnchals 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- whatsakandr 3y agoI think the big takeaway if something like this happens in the future is half float ain't a miesner effect. Makes me increasing skeptical of Taj Quantums claim to a super conductor. https://tajquantum.com/art-t2sc/ https://tajquantum.com/art-t2sc/
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gonzo 3y ago> "They were very precise about it. 104.8ºC," says Prashant Jain, a chemist at the University of Illinois Urbana–Champaign. "I was like, wait a minute, I know this temperature." Their favorite radio station in IL? 104.8 KCRF, all phase transitions, all the time.
- woliveirajr 3y ago> studies have shown that impurities in the material — in particular, copper sulfide — were responsible for the sharp drops in electrical resistivity and partial levitation over a magnet, which looked similar to properties exhibited by superconductors. So, make a material with impurities only? :-)
- pagutierrezn 3y agoUnbelieveble the effort invested in demonstrating that LK-99 is not a superconductor. Humans work like crazy when the oportunity arises to ridiculize others. If only...
- accrual 3y agoSo in your view a bunch of scientists got together and produced an enormous effort for the purpose of ridiculing other scientists? It wasn't perhaps because of an opportunity to significantly change the world?
- hcks 3y agoLK-99 was actually an amazing litmus test. You can absolutely dismiss the opinions of anyone who acted excited about it.
- barbegal 3y agoSo I can understand how having a phase change causes the material to have a critical temperature but why does it also have a critical current and a critical magnetic field. A simple phase change material wouldn't have a variable critical temperature dependent on current?
- sMarsIntruder 3y agoI’m pretty sure this isn’t the end of the saga.
- negative_zero 3y agoBit late to the thread, but for those interested I found this interview with two scientists trying to reproduce LK99 insightful: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jFnA8gwnLms https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jFnA8gwnLms Lots of interesting nitty gritty details. Also raises an interesting point about how lot of labs trying to reproduce LK99 are probably not doing it correctly.
- riow 3y ago> in particular, copper sulfide — were responsible for sharp drops in its electrical resistivity and a display of partial levitation over a magnet, properties similar to those exhibited by superconductors.