49 ms·
The global chip shortage is starting to have consequences
- throwaway3699 6y agoI've always wondered what it would be like to suddenly lose the ability to build higher technology like computer chips. Obviously this is just a shortage and not the same as manufacturing just vanishing, but the effects will be interesting to observe.
- rightbyte 6y agoMany products like water boilers, ovens or toasters can be built more robust without digital chips. I would argue we would see a overall quality improvement from having a bad chip shortage.
- jpm_sd 6y agoLOL nobody remembers how to design analog control systems anymore
- tomxor 6y agoI would be careful to conflate internet connected trash with enough ARM cores and LoC to make your brain melt with the likes of a well placed humble microcontroller.. the mechanical or analogue components they replaced were usually far more temperamental, bulky, expensive and bad at their job. There are exceptional environments like in nuclear power, but for most purposes integrated electronics have improved reliability when done well.
- cfn 6y agoAnyone who ever tried to fix a broken washing machine mechanical timer/programmer agrees with you. I did try and failed miserably, those things were a nightmare to fix and broke quite easily.
- betamaxthetape 6y agoI'd agree that mechanical mechanisms may break more easily than microprocessor equivalents, but I'm not sure about the argument that they are more difficult to repair. With microprocessor-driven systems, the solutions seems to be to replace the entire PCB, which is often completely custom to the manufacturer or even the specific model of machine. Trying to source a reasonably priced replacement is often difficult, and there's no easy way to diagnose and repair a broken PCB.
- SilverRed 6y agoRight to repair should come in to fix this. My off the top of the head thoughts would be * For a device like washing machine, parts should be supplied for a time of about 10 years. * Every part should be available to purchase either on its own or as part of a replacement kit like a PCB. * The sum of the cost of all replacement parts shouldn't be above x% of the initial item price. * If an OEM physically can not get you a replacement part (Chip discontinued, etc) and your product breaks, the OEM pays you for the remaining expected lifetime. (If it was 5 years old they pay you 50% of the initial cost) So in theory you should be able to build an entirely new product from parts and it would only cost you x% more than a pre built one which stops OEMs setting insane prices on replacements. The end result would likely be that OEMs would have to slim down on their product variations and sell the same designs for longer rather than releasing a new model of printer every year since this would make it much easier to stock parts. Some companies already do this, I have noticed Brevile has sold the same kettle and coffee machine models for almost 10 years now.
- salawat 6y agoDone so, still prefer analog up until things get so small or fragile they can't hold up anymore. As long as the part is still manufactured, you're good. PCB's? Forget it. E-waste central.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- huseyinkeles 6y agoGenuine question: how is the lack of digital chips going to make a toaster more robust?
- logicalmonster 6y agoAs an easy answer: the fewer parts there are, usually the less there is to potentially break down. A more classic style of toaster can be as simple as a heating element that's triggered by some kind of mechanical timer you set contained within some kind of container. There's much less that can possibly break down with age and burn out. There's no internal sensors, multiple buttons and electronics that can burn out, maybe some sort of WiFi component that might mess up, and more that can go wrong. Additionally with fewer parts, the manufacturing quality can hypothetically (but not always) be better. It seems easier to get the manufacturing right on a machine with 10 separate components versus say 60.
- HelloNurse 6y agoNot internet connected, no unsafe touch screen, no chance of software glitches or reprogramming... the list is long. A humble analog toaster is normal, a digital toaster is a step backwards.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoYeah. What I need from a toaster is that it makes toast. I don't need it to order the bread from Amazon Home Delivery. I even more don't need it to open the house door when the delivery arrives. Just make my toast. And when you're not doing that, just sit there and be a paperweight. That's all I need.
- CRConrad 6y agoYouTuber Technology Connections was featured in the recent discussion on diswashing machines and detergents. He's done a video on a lovely ancient toaster, too: https://youtu.be/1OfxlSG6q5Y https://youtu.be/1OfxlSG6q5Y Fully automatic brownness selection, and hands-free insertion and pop-up -- all without any electronic chips at all.
- batty_alex 6y agoNo need to wonder, it's not the first time something like this has happened: https://tedium.co/2016/11/24/1988-ram-shortage-history/ https://tedium.co/2016/11/24/1988-ram-shortage-history/ https://www.theverge.com/2012/4/19/2960606/qualcomm-snapdragon-chip-shortage-2012 https://www.theverge.com/2012/4/19/2960606/qualcomm-snapdrag...
- BlueTemplar 6y agoThere's an OS for that : http://collapseos.org/ http://collapseos.org/
- baybal2 6y agoThe industry has largely forgotten how to make stuff without chips. That's why I am telling people that a global chip shortage, if something happens to Taiwan, would bring the industry not back into fifties, but into the iron age. The further the tech ladder you go, the harder you fall if somebody takes out your engineering bay.
- noahtallen 6y agoI don’t think that would happen. Firstly, the US government and army (like it or not) has an interest in not falling behind technologically. Additionally, Intel has most of its fabs in the US already. Samsung and TSMC are currently building fabs in the US too. Finally, the US still has a strong tech culture. So I think it would not take long with an increased demand (and higher salaries) for computer engineers to attract a lot of good talent. I mean, I agree it wouldn’t be good. But back to the 50s? Or even the “Iron Age”? That seems awfully pessimistic. Like, I get that Intel is not doing great, but it’s only like a handful of years bad, not decades bad
- baybal2 6y agoNo Intel fab will run more than a few weeks without consumables coming from Asia. A giant lot of semi supplies are single vendor globally, and much of them are in Taiwan. It's likely that no fab in the West past the I-line era will be able to resume, and continue production with local supplies, even with immediate nation-state level effort to recreate the supply chain.
- shrimpx 6y ago> if something happens to Taiwan TSMC is building a megafactory in Phoenix AZ which should help distribute that risk. It will take several years to complete however.
- rajacombinator 6y agoWhat could happen to Taiwan? I’m interested.
- 6y ago
- golemiprague 6y agoAt the end of the bronze age there was a shortage of tin to create the bronze (with copper). This caused the beginning of the iron age as people were looking for alternatives to bronze and once tin was back in the market it was not valuable anymore. The whole process was coincided with falling of civilisations, disruption of trade and general reorganisation of world powers, so expect some of that.
- ferros 6y ago> Production of low-margin processors, such as those used to weigh clothes in a washing machine or toast bread in a smart toaster, has also been hit. While most retailers are still able to get their hands on these products at the moment, they may face issues in the months ahead. I understand why the new advanced chips could face shortages, but why are there shortages for these basic chips. Can’t they be made anywhere, and more easily?
- jamiek88 6y agoMy understanding is there is a substrate shortage as well as a foundry slot shortage.
- jpm_sd 6y agoThis is correct. The industry is currently constrained on everything from water to wafers, in addition to fab time slots. Everyone is panic buying too, so shortages are getting amplified.
- formerly_proven 6y ago... and while there is lots of "real" demand we also get the cryptocrazies exerting additional pressure not just on the finest and best silicon available, but now even on HDD/SSDs. Prices have already risen 50+ % in the last few weeks. F--- t---- m-----.
- im3w1l 6y agoI'm a bit out of the loop. What is the cause of this? Since they are hitting multiple constraints at once I guess it's a demand spike?
- smaryjerry 6y agoNot who you responded to but newly released consoles are tons of chips, having to stay home meant more people buyer gaming PCs as well, everyone who started working from home required tons of new hardware while their desktops at work go unused, and money flowed from governments like water so everyone has money to buy all these things at once. Then on the supply side you had basically everyone stop working for at least a couple months some longer not only out of restrictions on the ability to work but restrictions that make a lot of processes much less efficient plus fear of going to work on top, then you had no one willing to return to many jobs because unemployment benefits have lasted for over a year (rather than normally a few months) and unemployment pays higher than your typical minimum wage job anyways with even the current the extra $300 per week, which was an extra $600 per week for a long time as well. This also means people that used to spend their time on higher wage and producing jobs end up spending a lot of their time doing things they would normally delegate off because no one wants to work those jobs. If you look at chips they are just one of many industries all with shortages for similar reasons, chips are just the worst shortage of all, mainly from all the work from home needs. In 2020 last year my computers power supply died.. there wasn’t one available with 100 miles. I drove to every store within about 20 miles to try to get back online same day. Even online Newegg and Amazon were all sold out, I had to spend about triple normal to by a power supply that was way too much for what I needed and pay extra for shipping it quickly. Not the same as chips but it was a similar need and far fewer people are needing power supplies versus chips.
- jfoster 6y agoWhy is there a shortage rather than a price hike, similar to what would happen with fuel? Long term contracts?
- stingraycharles 6y agoWell if I take a look at the GPU market the prices have nearly doubled over the past 6 months and there still isn’t any supply. In other words, the price hiked to a point where people will otherwise say “I’ll just wait longer”, and this is what’s happening.
- cortesoft 6y agoThat is always what happens when prices go up. The whole point is to reduce the number of buyers who want the product at that price so that there is enough supply to fill the remaining demand. That is how a supply and demand curve works.
- mort96 6y agoBut you still have a shortage, right? People still want microchips. In ideal conditions, the price will stabilize at the level where every chip gets sold, but nobody who wants to pay that price has to wait in line for too long. But if you reach that point, you still have a whole lot of buyers who still want a microchip, but who are unable to pay for them at those elevated prices - i.e a shortage. With fuel, you can reduce your car usage for a while and when prices get back down you can just go back to your old level of fuel consumption. But with microchips, a reduction in "consumption" results in pent-up demand; people who have been waiting a while to buy a new GPU still want to buy that GPU when the prices go down.
- cortesoft 6y agoThe idea is that if you need it bad enough, you can find one at the higher price. If prices didn’t go up, you wouldn’t be able to find one at any price. Some of the people who would want a chip at $x don’t want it at $x*2, and will just never buy one unless the price drops. If the price never drops because supply is never increased, then they will simply never purchase it.
- FredPret 6y agoI run into this in Factorio all the time
- nthj 6y agoIt's fascinating: because Factorio is deterministic, I always build out one massive, consolidated chip factory and distribute chips to other factories from there. But as we see here, in the real world, with droughts and pandemics, this is a risky strategy.
- skybrian 6y agoMaybe Factorio needs some random disasters like SimCity or RimWorld?
- bombcar 6y agoBiters effectively do this though it’s technically entirely deterministic - and you can build a defense strong enough to make it not an issue, but that’s quite involved. The most common “production” disasters are caused by an oversupply of one item, which stockpiled, and you go into under supply but don’t notice until you’re off doing something else (and that can cause critical self-defense mechanisms to shut down at bad times).
- nostrademons 6y agoRunning out of plastic production because the productivity of your oilfields dropped effectively simulates this.
- swiley 6y agoI love clicking on the power poles and watching the interference for segments of the network. It's awesome how quickly the noise emerges from the deterministic rules.
- devney 6y agoFor years I've been asking: Why does my toothbrush have to connect to bluetooth? Why does my refrigerator twitter? These were always useless mis-features and we can hope some of them can get pared down now with the shortage. Bring back old style dumb appliances!
- mhh__ 6y agoConnected devices are a good thing - i.e. I should be able to make the washing machine scriptable from my computer, but I bet these solutions are always crap because they are implemented in a hurry by engineers who don't understand either the hardware or software well enough to make it work, so you end up with quasi-useless boss-pleasers like we have now.
- tolbish 6y agoWhy should you be able to connect to run a script on a washing machine? Don't you need physically be there anyway to move the clothes around? The only use case I can see is a notification when the cycle is done, but I think there are better ways to go about that than using an SoC.
- slver 6y agoThe world isn't driven by "I should have all the nice things I can imagine". How are you gonna script the washing machine to take the underwear off your bottom and put it in the drum? You'll have to do that yourself. And when you do it, you might as well "script the washing machine" by pushing the buttons on it. I'm a programmer and honestly I can't wait for this IoT fad to die down a little. Sure, maybe it's cool to have LAN connected lightbulbs as a novelty product. But this kind of shit will never ever be the norm, simply because it makes no damn sense in terms of value proposition.
- brink 6y agoLet's hope we start making chips domestically after this.
- neogodless 6y agoWhat country are you in? I know I can eliminate Taiwan and the United States from the list, as they both have semiconductor fabs!
- fsflover 6y agoSo how much do USA-made mobile phones cost?
- neogodless 6y agoThe Librem costs a lot! BLU was more reasonably priced. Not sure if they're still putting out new products. https://shop.puri.sm/shop/librem-5-usa/ https://shop.puri.sm/shop/librem-5-usa/ https://www.bluproducts.com/home/ https://www.bluproducts.com/home/ Also relevant (since most iPhone manufacturing is not done in the US.) https://fee.org/articles/a-made-in-america-iphone-would-cost-2-000-studies-show/ https://fee.org/articles/a-made-in-america-iphone-would-cost... Of course, that's a different goal from "making chips in the USA", which is done today, including the best-selling personal computer chips.
- MangoCoffee 6y agoare we talking about assemble in the USA? any low labors cost country can assemble the phone. it doesn't have to be China. Foxconn already have a factory in India and Samsung in Vietnam. design can be done in the USA like Apple. component like corning gorilla glass is made in the USA. chips can be produce in the USA with Intel IDM 2.0 or TSMC in Taiwan. it will cost the same since you can outsource assembly
- fsflover 6y ago> are we talking about assemble in the USA? No. Did you read the thread before asking? > they both have semiconductor fabs!
- ArkanExplorer 6y agoBan cryptocurrency exchanges and some of the wafer capacity currently being dedicated to mining will return to regular use (or we can just wait for the ETH2 merge, then ban the purchase of PoW cyrpto). Secondly get workers back to work by ending COVID-era unemployment payments and workplace restrictions.
- kova12 6y agoAlso ban activists whos solution to everything is to ban stuff. Like war on drugs didn't teach them anything
- leesalminen 6y agoLet’s just ban the banning of things. It’ll work out.
- mort96 6y agoThat sounds really simplistic? There are some problems for which banning isn't a solution, but there are some problems for which banning is actually a viable solution. Should we "learn" from the war on drugs and reverse the ban on CFCs? Should we avoid banning toxic substances from food? You're gonna need a better argument than "activists who want to ban stuff should have learned from the war on drugs". You're gonna need to argue why banning cryptocurrencies is more like banning weed and not like banning CFCs.
- not_really 6y agoBan this, ban that. Surrre. No problem.
- kristofferR 6y agoDoes Bitcoin ASICs really "steal" wafer capacity from regular GPUs? Pretty different technology, I think?
- henvic 6y agoI hate cryptocurrency, but trying to ban them is just dumb. It's not going to work. Ban where? How? What are the side-effects? What about people's liberty? Cryptocurrency is stupid and depletes natural resources, but trying to use the law to ban it is only going to make it stronger.
- tyingq 6y agoUsed car prices going up 10% very suddenly is interesting...see the chart within this: https://www.businessinsider.com/used-car-prices-saw-their-biggest-monthly-price-increase-ubs-2021-5 https://www.businessinsider.com/used-car-prices-saw-their-bi...
- f6v 6y agoThere's useful technology, like computer controlling your engine to make it more fuel-efficient or whatever. And then there're "smart appliances", like a fridge with a screen. Do we really need it? The companies try to sell us more useless stuff, that's what it is.
- michaelmcdonald 6y agoI think it's rather short-sighted to refer to one application of technology as useful and another as not needed. Is the computer controlling the engine to be more fuel-efficient needed? No. Is the car even needed? No. But we have found a use for that technology that improves our daily lives. Perhaps for you a fridge with a screen is not useful; however for others it may be.
- f6v 6y ago> Is the computer controlling the engine to be more fuel-efficient needed? No. Is the car even needed? No. We can continue ad absurdum, but it's clear that more screens is added to our lives to: 1. Consume more content 2. As a result, see more ads 3. Finally, buy more stuff I'm not against technology, but electronics producers have been going out of their way to continue growth. That's fine, but I'd love to have a robot doing dishes and cooking for me. Instead, there's a fridge that "Cameras recognize the food in your fridge so you can search for recipes based on what you have." [0]. That's such a marginal benefit. [0] https://www.samsung.com/us/connected-appliances/#get-app https://www.samsung.com/us/connected-appliances/#get-app
- tazjin 6y agoWith those gimmicky features there's also only a slim chance that anyone is actually using them because it's often hard to impossible, especially for people with less interest in tech. For example, in a large company like Samsung some product manager might show up and require that users of the food scanning feature have a Samsung account. Now you have to register for a Samsung account on your fridge, but the embedded web view is being redirected to a new thing with 35% heavier Javascript which doesn't really run on your fridge anymore and that's the end of that. This example is made up but it wouldn't surprise me if things very close to this have happened on these fridges, and they definitely happen all the time in consumer electronics.
- smiley1437 6y agoInterestingly, there is an embedded video in that article that explains the issue specific to the automotive shortage - it's because the automotive industry cancelled a lot of chip orders in anticipation of low vehicle demand and that caused chip makers to reduce their production for the kinds of chips that go into cars, and now it takes time to ramp back up: https://www.cnbc.com/video/2021/03/02/how-the-global-computer-chip-shortage-happened.html https://www.cnbc.com/video/2021/03/02/how-the-global-compute... It's at the 4m15s part of the video I think a facepalm is in order.
- bredren 6y agoSince 14% of renters are behind on rent and evictions begin June 30, aren’t vehicle repossessions going to kick in July / August? Presumably, due in part to eviction protection, they have been able to divert all or a portion of their rent payments to keeping up with bad car loans for commute vehicles that often will not be needed. These folks need them for housing unfortunately. If repossessed cars start showing up that should put downward pressure on people wanting to buy new ones. Most new cars still suck / Do not offer meaningful new features. And of those who do buy new, that will be another fresh supply of used cars. How long is this chip shortage due to vehicles going to last given these circumstances? https://news.berkeley.edu/2021/05/07/are-renters-and-the-u-s-economy-hurtling-toward-an-eviction-cliff/ https://news.berkeley.edu/2021/05/07/are-renters-and-the-u-s...
- zitterbewegung 6y agoThe issue is that supply is greatly exceeding demand. It also isn't constrained to Vehicles. Apple's Q2 guidance has said that iPads and Macs supplies have been constrained. [1]. Also, if you get reposessed cars that doesn't mean you will be able to resell them. Sure the automakers made a mistake in their orders for chips but since everyone is now trying to get foundries making chips and we are still having logistic problems with Air and Ocean freight no one really knows the answer to your question. [2] [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-04-29/apple-finally-feels-the-global-semiconductor-shortage?sref=wLyKPDtZ https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-04-29/apple-fin... [2] https://unctad.org/news/shipping-during-covid-19-why-container-freight-rates-have-surged https://unctad.org/news/shipping-during-covid-19-why-contain...
- kingsuper20 6y agoSo what happens when Moore's Other Law(tm), the one that says that the size/cost of the manufacturing facility doubles every few years, continues on? The endgame is single sourcing from one giant company and place (or nearly so) that no one else can compete with but is inherently brittle.
- CameronNemo 6y agoAnd when there are few suppliers, they have an incentive to dial back supply to manufacture demand. When the market is not in equilibrium, they are making the most profit. https://open.lib.umn.edu/principleseconomics/chapter/10-2-the-monopoly-model/ https://open.lib.umn.edu/principleseconomics/chapter/10-2-th...
- elorant 6y agoIs there any kind of organization where we can donate old and unused cpus? I have at least half a dozen chips in a drawer sitting and collecting dust. Some are even a decade old but I'm sure they're more than OK to run a toaster or a washing machine.
- Goz3rr 6y agoIt's basically not worth it to incorporate salvaged parts into mass production assembly lines, and even if it was those things don't use CPUs, they use tiny microcontrollers.
- enkid 6y agoIs there enough overlap in architecture, packaging, etc., Where collection and distribution of unused chips really makes sense?
- JessicaWade 6y agoNow we have more legitimate reasons to hate miners. Right?
- jfoutz 6y agoI think a lot of folks underestimate how fabulously complicated it is to fab a chip. Yes, you can diy it in your garage, here's a wonderful implementation. http://sam.zeloof.xyz/first-ic/ http://sam.zeloof.xyz/first-ic/ But take a look at the specialized tools they used. Heck, think about proper handling of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrofluoric_acid https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hydrofluoric_acid and this is just a simple amp. imagine trying to make something with lots of gates? Making a single chip is _hard_. And that's just for a one off. doing that at scale requires an amazing amount of process control. And that diy chip is, according to the author "5µm (1975 tech. level)" Anyway, yes, you could make a chip in your garage, but it'd take a lot of time to ramp up, and you'd only have 1.
- amelius 6y agoIf making a chip is so hard, then why do the FAANG companies own this world, not e.g. TSMC or Samsung?
- hans-moleman 6y agoI think this year has proven that TSMC does have a very dominant position in the industry.
- pstrateman 6y agoI think your comment is being misunderstood because of the ambiguity of "this world".
- jfoutz 6y agoI'm not quite sure I follow. I guess the same reason AMF isn't really much of a thing anymore? I don't think making a pinsetter would be a big deal now with ready access to parts and tools, but I'd imagine it was quite a feat in the 40's. I think I need more description around "owning the world". Sure, those leisure focused companies are pocketing big dollars, good for them! But they don't really do much, they're only meaningful given the backdrop of the larger economy.
- baybal2 6y agoTSMC, and Samsung are both very glad at FAANG trying to "own the world" — more business for them! I don't see Morris Chang running to open an advertising shop, webhosting company, or mine bitcoins, thought the later was much speculated.
- ineedasername 6y agoMy wife just needed to get a new car, and the salesman was complaining that just as demand was starting to increase the chip shortage means they're barely getting any new ones in stock. And of course the popular models are the ones that are selling out the fastest, meaning people are holding off on purchases because they can't get what they want. My wife's was one of maybe 8 in the entire state that had the features she wanted. Even that one we had to wait about a week because it was in transit from the factory to the dealership, and the other ones in the state were at dealerships a bit further away. I know car salesman don't get a whole lot of sympathy, but they still need to make a living and that industry got hit hard by Covid, and now is getting hit again.
- fukmbas 6y agoCar salesman won't be a job in 20 years
- Der_Einzige 6y agoCar sales have been through the roof this entire pandemic. Car sales people haven't had to listen to customers "negotiate" in over a year (because the answer is always to take the higher than MSRP offer or pound sand since 20 others will) . I couldn't get a single salesperson to budge even 500$ across no less than 10 Lexus dealerships on anything at all. Car sales people are doing the best they have ever done during the pandemic. They don't need your sympathy.
- ineedasername 6y agoI don't know where you're getting this impression from, but sales figures do no support your opinion. Sales were down about 15% in 2020, [0] and that was with a normal first quarter and sales inching back up in the 4th quarter. For large parts of 2020 sales were down as much as 40%. Your experience with Lexus dealerships is not generalizable to the whole industry. The economic fallout of 2020 was not evenly distributed, and the only thing your personal experience tells me is that the audience for luxury cars may have had the better end of things last year. [0] https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.forbes.com/wheels/news/2020-truck-suv-car-sales-winners-and-losers/%3famp https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.forbes.com/wheels/news/2020...
- macspoofing 6y agoThis also feels like inflation.
- seltzered_ 6y agoRegarding cars: "Some carmakers are now leaving out high-end features as a result of the chip shortage, according to a Bloomberg report on Thursday. Nissan is reportedly leaving navigation systems out of cars that would normally have them, while Ram Trucks has stopped equipping its 1500 pickups with a standard “intelligent” rearview mirror that monitors for blind spots" I have an unpopular opinion, especially when we start to look at the increase of safety features and increase in pedestrian injuries, that we may be better off going back to smaller trucks designed for good visibility and less reliance on features. (bias: I drive a 16 year old wagon, and feel panicked around bicycling with what feels like more trucks in the US) --- "Hertz said it is “supplementing” its fleet “by purchasing low-mileage, preowned vehicles” from auctions and dealerships." I find it wild that just a year ago Hertz filed for bankruptcy [0] and was selling vehicles by end of year [1]. [0]: https://www.cnn.com/2020/05/22/business/hertz-bankruptcy/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/05/22/business/hertz-bankruptcy/ind... [1]: https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/hertz-must-offload-almost-200000-cars-by-the-end-of-2020-as-part-of-its-bankruptcy-deal/ar-BB17waZL https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/companies/hertz-must-offload...
- epistasis 6y agoYeah, the size of these trucks has completely put me off ever wanting one. I miss the small ones from a few decades ago... great for surfing, hauling the ver occasional bit of stuff, just as useful as the ugly beasts of today but far cheaper and more maneuverable and safer. I think we need to start requiring commercial drivers licenses on some of these beasts. They are intentionally designed to be difficult to see out of, difficult to see around. And the high point of contact on a human body means that they are deadly. Definitely should not be allowed on a residential street without an explicit commercial purpose, IMHO.
- istjohn 6y agoI don't disagree, but there would be a political shitstorm if you tried to take away their trucks.
- 6y ago
- oblak 6y agoSo, even though Intel has been incredibly profitable for many years, they Gelsinger is asking for US and EU government support because... uh, uncertain times? That it? How much did they ask Isreal for this 600 million investment? [0] [0] https://www.israel21c.org/intel-announces-600-million-boost-to-israel-operations/ https://www.israel21c.org/intel-announces-600-million-boost-... The EU should invest in AMD and build fabs without Intel if we are to be "independent"
- jandrese 6y agoIt’s not hard to see Intel struggling in the future as AMD has produced a better architecture and Apple is starting to compete in the space.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- baq 6y agostarting a fab business from scratch to something like current 7-5nm nodes is a multi-decade, likely high multiples of 10B€ endeavor. while I agree having such capacity is a matter of EU security, paying Intel and TSMC to build their fabs on EU ground in ~2 years for less money is an attractive proposition and not mutually exclusive with the former to boot.
- stadium 6y agoCould recycled smartphones be used as a source for chips?
- undeadcomment 6y agoNo...
- thomasjudge 6y ago"Electronic dog washing booth"?
- varispeed 6y agoIt's weird that you can buy chips on Chinese sites in their thousands and western usual suppliers have no stock and the lead times are more than a year on some parts. Unfortunately you cannot just buy these Chinese parts and use in the products as they will likely have no certification or may even be fake. At least can be useful for prototyping although risky as well. I know many projects are on hold because of that.
- salawat 6y agoThis is the legacy of offshoring most production. We've lost the ability to drive our own supply chains based on nowhere for talent to work or land. Once you lose that as a nation, the tail wags the dog.
- dcolkitt 6y agoHow hard would it be to fly an engineer to Shenzen and physically test the supply? I get it. Chinese vendors are not as reliable as Western suppliers. But it's not like ICs are black magic, it certainly wouldn't be that to enforce third-party quality control on them. Sure every now and then you'll pay for a batch you gotta throw out. But that sure as hell beats business killing 52-week lead times.
- 11thEarlOfMar 6y agoIf you have a taste for irony, my company makes critical components for semiconductor equipment. If we can't ship, they can't ship. If they can't ship, semiconductor fabs can't increase capacity to meet the demand and solve the shortage. We went line down last week due to shortage of a critical chip for our component. In reality, the shortage is likely self-inflicted, like toilet paper a year ago, but for whatever combination of real demand + hoarding, we can't get them.
- FinanceAnon 6y agoInteresting. I always imagined supply chains as a flow in one direction, with each further step of the chain making more complicated stuff. But your comment made me realise that supply chains can be more like a loop, with the more complicated components going back to make the earlier steps more efficient. And a semiconductor factory requires lots of semiconductors themselves. It's like bootstraping a compiler.
- amelius 6y agoI guess it will always be possible to make critical components by delaying a customer's batch that would have been delayed anyway.
- HelloNurse 6y agoThe TV news version I've heard is that there is a car chip shortage because people in lockdown and working from home buy more computers. If journalists don't question this bullshit, there is little hope for the general public.
- Vaslo 6y agoWe will continue to have these issues as long as companies run risky levels of cash to make investors happy. Lower inventory means more capital for your business to invest elsewhere. But one catastrophe and all that onetime cash infusion is worthless.
- xyst 6y agoThis is what happens when the entire world relies on a few countries for manufacturing of computer chips. All manufactured goods should be produced and consumed in the same country. In theory, if the manufacturing is efficiently distributed the supply chain should be immune to the effects of a pandemic or even country specific issues. I am still baffled that an electronic device produced in some province of China and shipped thousands of miles away (and incurring tariffs) is cheaper than keeping the manufacturing in the same country and shipping at a much shorter distance and not incur any import fees/taxes.
- cerved 6y agoare you an 18th century economist?
- dboreham 6y ago16th c. surely.
- x0x0 6y agoChina is massively subsidizing local manufacturing, in at least two ways: currency stabilization and lack of / lack of enforcement of environmental protections.
- dehrmann 6y agoConsolidated production has benefits like economies of scale and world peace, but at the cost of redundancy and national security. Chip production isn't actually that bad; Micron is in the US, Intel is in the US, China, Israel, Ireland, TSMC is in China and Taiwan. What we're seeing here has nothing to do with consolidation of manufacturing; it's entirely JIT logistics. Decentralization doesn't solve that; surplus capacity and/or inventory solve that.
- d136o 6y agoI recommend this read about the origins of the semiconductor industry in Silicon Valley: They Would Be Gods [1]. Making a chip has been something that has been done completely methodically since their invention (I wonder if the less disciplined or less methodical and messy shops simply went out of business). Add decades of automation and scaling in every part of that process and we get to AMSL machines sold for hundreds of millions of dollars. Making software can feel so ad-hoc in comparison. I am also reminded of the Such Great Heights music video by Postal Service filmed in a clean room. [2] [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=71705 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=71705 [2] https://youtu.be/0wrsZog8qXg https://youtu.be/0wrsZog8qXg
- tpmx 6y ago> Making a chip has been something that has been done completely methodically since their invention The yield improvement process seems like it has a lot common with e.g. baking and intuition.
- framecowbird 6y ago> Elsewhere, Renault is no longer putting an oversized digital screen behind the steering wheel of certain models At least there is one benefit of the chip shortage...
- honkycat 6y agoI've eyeing a gaming PC for a while. I game, do music production, amd also do i die game dev. If I buy an all in one I'll pay a $500 premium but I'll be able to actually acquire all the components. Hackernews, please tell me: should I pull the trigger before it's too late, or hold off for the panic to subside?
- f6v 6y agoI’d join the secret laptop club if I was in the us https://youtu.be/cFyka8Vp62Y https://youtu.be/cFyka8Vp62Y
- cerved 6y agoATM it's mainly affecting GPUs so it depends on which GPU is included and the Delta to the prince on the secondhand market. Like one where I'm at, the 6700xt is going at about MSRP +$500
- TedShiller 6y agoInflation. It’s everywhere. It’s not a shortage.
- anticristi 6y agoWhat does this actually mean? Will we be forced to produce less electro junk in the near future? I see no urgency to change car, toothbrush, washing machine, dishwasher, headphones, laptop, etc. anytime soon.
- booleanbetrayal 6y agoWhat new fab facilities are currently being spun up in the US? And if the answer is "few," then why?
- gizmodo59 6y agoBuilding a fab takes lot of time. Plus you need to hire the right talent in the same region. And by the time you can do it may be we will be past this supply issue. (Or may be that’s why we don’t do it now? Not sure)
- whatgoodisaroad 6y agoA little afraid to ask what may be an obvious question, but what exactly does the shortage consist of? Computer chips aren't generally interchangeable and I assume they're mostly purpose-built. Is there a shortage of raw materials? Or is there a drop in fab capacity?
- 11thEarlOfMar 6y agoIt's pretty straightforward. The demand for chips increased much faster than the manufacturers could increase capacity and meet demand. The COVID shift in working, socializing and learning from in-person to digital drove a huge demand spike for computers and telecommunications gear. The chip fabs hit capacity and it takes a long time to increase capacity. The equipment companies are running flat out to ship additional equipment, but so far, the fabs haven't gotten back to equilibrium.
- miked85 6y agoThis is a great time to sell a car you do not need. Prices have gone up significantly just since last month on sites like carvana, carmax, etc.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoThis idea would have been unforeseen a century ago when they were contemplating guano shortages: https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.atlasobscura.com/articles/when-the-western-world-ran-on-guano.amp https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.atlasobscura.com/articles/w... It’s fun to imagine a shortage 100 years from now that isn’t even an iota of an idea yet.
- cerved 6y agonice, de-amped https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/when-the-western-world-ran-on-guano https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/when-the-western-world...
- andrekandre 6y agoU.S. tech giant Intel has offered to help but it reportedly wants 8 billion euros in public subsidies toward building a semiconductor factory in Europe. wow.... my immediate reaction is "then it should be a public foundry, if payed for by the public"... but maybe im missing some detail/nuance...
- geitir 6y agoI guess it's a case of "if you hold the cards..."
- VWWHFSfQ 6y ago> "then it should be a public foundry, if payed for by the public" It sounds to me like Intel is willing to set up a fab in Europe, and they've stated their asking price. Why does this immediately result in people saying that it should be a public foundry just because it would ultimately be paid for by the public?
- jessermeyer 6y agoBecause it would ultimately be paid for by the public.
- VWWHFSfQ 6y agoI guess this would be similar to the way a lot of sports arenas are built. The public foots the bill to build it, and the team gets a cheap 20-year lease to use it. And the public the gets a sports team.
- RodgerTheGreat 6y agoThe public foots the bill, and the owners of the team profit handsomely from selling the public the chance to watch the team play in the stadium they already paid for. Sports arenas built with public money are a scam, and so is the idea of having taxpayers subsidize the construction of for-profit privately-owned chip fabs.
- mastazi 6y ago> Everyday appliances at risk > Production of low-margin processors, such as those used to weigh clothes in a washing machine or toast bread in a smart toaster, has also been hit. Maybe the silver lining of this situation is that the current push to make every appliance "smart" will slow down? I will take a "dumb" bread toaster any day over the "smart" version. And finally @internetofshit will be able to take some time off.
- de6u99er 6y agoFunny, because I am saying since many years that Europe needs it's own semiconductor production and Silicon Valley. But no, we must rely on our American friends who not only spy on us, but constantly rip us off, while themselves producing in Chine and Taiean.
- cerved 6y agoWhy do we need semiconductor production? It's a global shortage, not a European shortage
- machiaweliczny 6y agoI think there was news that EU wants to invest €150B into fabs
- kosma 6y ago"Starting to have consequences"? The situation is absolutely dire. Shelves are empty; common parts like DC/DC converters have lead times of 52 weeks. Maybe big companies who can afford to hoard parts are fine... the small ones are absolutely screwed. You can't even get enough parts to build prototypes. I'm in the position where I have to cannibalize rev A boards just to be able to build and test rev B boards.
- webinvest 6y agoStarting? The semiconductor issue has been going on since at least March and is only getting worse every week. The stocks of solar companies, car makers, cryptocurrency miners, appliance makers, and anyone else relying on semiconductors has been dropping since February. Some like the solar company ENPH have been cut in half. Shipments on products with semiconductors have gone from an ETA of 6-8 month from April 2021 to “12 months or more” from this month, May 2021. I heard a rumor that it takes 2 years for a new semiconductor plant to be built so we may be in for a quite a wait for the supply to catch up to the demand…
- sharklazer 6y agoAnd this is the sort of thing that kills Bitcoin (long-term). At some point you are faced with sustaining the security of your network at a cost of doing real work, if silicon manufacture were ever that scarce. Worse, if Bitcoin is the dominant currency... paying for hardware is, a weird Ouroboros of power.
- chupchap 6y agoI expected more dumb high-res TVs as a result of chip shortage, but strangely that has not happened.
- Zingler 6y ago> “What we’re asking from both the U.S. and the European governments is to make it competitive for us to do it here compared to in Asia,” Intel wanting subsidies to help be competitive, priceless.
- qwerty456127 6y agoWho cares about smatrphones and TVs (and cars also)? I always wanted something to happen to force people stop throwing them to landfills and getting new ones every couple years. And smart TVs (with manufacturer-implanted ads, analytics, etc) are abomination. Also the less cars there are - the better. IMHO.
- fuzzer37 6y ago> Production of low-margin processors, such as those used to weigh clothes in a washing machine or toast bread in a smart toaster Oh no! What will we ever do? Have to toast bread by pushing down the lever? How barbaric.
- desperate 6y ago"The vast majority of the world’s chips are made in China, while the U.S. is the second biggest producer. " I guess CNBC doesn't recognize Taiwan?