43 ms·
No More Free Work from Marak: Pay Me or Fork This
- tannhaeuser 6y agoI guess a distinction has to be made wrt what kind of sw gets what license. In the forming years of F/OSS, it was mostly re-implementing Unix, compilers, and POSIX tools, guided by strong specs and portability requirements. Now with Linux almost the only server OS standing, questionable innovations such as containers, one-of-a-kind software being released as F/OSS, and the abundance of F/OSS directly responsible for the "cloud" (in the sense that selling services and integration is the only area left where to make a buck), the copyleft/non-copyleft taxonomy doesn't seem to work anymore.
- wh-uws 6y agoReminds me of this classic Goodfellas scene https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3XGAmPRxV48 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3XGAmPRxV48
- xenihn 6y agoIt's actually really sad that someone who has easily generated millions of dollars of value with their work gets nothing for it. Yeah yeah, it's open source, but it still sucks. I'm assuming they can't be compensated easily due to legal reasons?
- corty 6y agoThey won't be compensated easily due to cheapness reasons. Anything legal is just an excuse (assuming Marak isn't on some terrorist blacklist or something).
- xenihn 6y agoI'd be interested to know if that's really the case. Hopefully some people can weigh in. I really don't want to believe that what you think is true because it's upsetting.
- arthurcolle 6y agoInteresting you should mention that, New York Post claims he was arrested for having bomb-making materials in his apartment which may be related to the apartment fire he discusses on his Twitter! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25032426 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25032426
- corty 6y agoI'll have myself checked for psychic abilities...
- bdcravens 6y agoTrue, but is there anything new here? That's been an conundrum as long as open source has been a thing. There are also example of open source developers who have made a great living from their projects. That's on the developer to find a business model that works.
- Fordec 6y agoCan't or won't? He's literally saying "hire me if you want this". If that's too high a bar for "generating millions of dollars of value" then something is grossly wrong and headline worthy in of itself.
- lazyasciiart 6y agoLooks like he does get paid a little bit by half a dozen companies/employees - maybe $1200/month? https://opencollective.com/fakerjs#backer https://opencollective.com/fakerjs#backer But yea, people aren't paying because they don't want to pay. I've written something similar at work in the past, and the work required to support a single fixed scenario is so much less than the work required to support a generic tool that it would have felt hard to justify paying for something instead of building it, if I'd known about this at the time.
- trevyn 6y agoLooking at the Open Collective transaction log, looks more on the order of ~$20/month. (With some variation caused by one-time donations.)
- lazyasciiart 6y agoOops, I think I couldn’t tell the difference between onetime and recurring donations.
- noisy_boy 6y agoThere is a "Sponsor" link right at the top of the Github page. Companies sponsor all sorts of initiative so I don't see the what legal reasons would prohibit sponsoring here.
- marcus_holmes 6y agoThe problem is that adding some open source code to a project when it's free is simple, easy, and can be done without oversight (it shouldn't, but it can). If the code couldn't be added without paying the owner a sum of money and receiving a licence in return (i.e. something that would have to be archived and looked after), then it all gets more difficult. Budgets have to be allocated, spending authorised, receipts processed, etc. This would require approval from authority, and they would want assurances frrom the supplier that the code is well-maintained, does what it says it does, etc. Someone would have to review the code, and that costs time and more money. They might even have to review multiple alternatives to ensure that the project selected is the right project. At this point commercial suppliers get invited into the room, who send professional salesfolk to a meeting with management, and the whole ball game changes. This isn't "management bullshit". It's what should happen in a well-run organisation with a good procurement process. If you want to sell your software, that's the game you play, and you better hite professional salesfolk to get your cash. If you don't want to play that game, then give it away for free. But don't whine later that it created "millions in value" and you didn't get any of that.
- CravingLogic 6y agoI'm curious what the motivation was for doing this now after supporting faker.js for 8+ years. Also, isn't faker.js a completed project? What is there to maintain?
- chillfox 6y agoI am guessing it's the usual, either money or time problems. Could also be burnout I suppose.
- pmontra 6y agoOr a change of work environment. Too much paid work or no more JavaScript, who knows. I've been offered to take over the development and maintenance of a small Ruby gem many years ago. I think I contributed a patch or something. I needed that gem in my current Rails project, probably not in the next one. Furthermore I don't work only with Ruby. So I refused. Something like faker is useful in nearly every project and I contributed to the Elixir faker (my customer agreed to that, we needed it.) I learned a couple of things of the Elixir environment in the process. By the way, nice team and great tooling. Would I take over that package if offered? Again no, because I don't use Elixir full time and I'd rather drop another contribution whenever I need it. No time to work on fixes and look at issues not related to my work.
- aldanor 6y agoOr the apartment fire. See the comment above.
- bdcravens 6y agoWith 179 open issues, many of which seem related to bugs or out of date information, seems like there's quite a bit to maintain.
- sleepychu 6y ago179 open issues as of now https://github.com/Marak/faker.js/issues?page=1&q=is%3Aopen+is%3Aissue https://github.com/Marak/faker.js/issues?page=1&q=is%3Aopen+.... Looks like people want new data generation, new generation interfaces.
- bdcravens 6y agoCertainly his right; his project (though it has a very permissive license), his time. It sounds like he's tired of working on it, and he requires sponsorship to make it worthwhile. Let's say he doesn't, and the project is forked. This begs an interesting question: does he own the npm name? "faker" has mindshare, not just in JS; if he's unwilling to work on it, would it make sense for the NPM organization to reassign the name to whatever the active fork is?
- neltnerb 6y agoWhich corporation sponsoring the fork gets to be declared the active fork? It seems simplest to keep his original version and whatever updates he feels like doing as his own thing, and if a corporation feels like forking the project to add some feature they can add their name to it. If others prefer that version they can switch to it. It's reasonable given the people doing it are well versed in this stuff. He keeps doing what he's doing without being as annoyed, the project stays on trajectory, and individual users can switch if they feel like it to an alternative option.
- deepstack 6y agoHe ought to keep the name, however there should be some way to keep track of the public forks via something that is github oriented. Maybe something in DHT like IPFS. It maybe something npm/yarn can work out.
- dannyw 6y agoLet's just use domain names? ytld.org/youtube-dl google.com/rust_icu facebook.com/react Don't have a domain name? marak.github.io/faker Not everything needs to be reinvented.
- deepstack 6y agothe whole point is the original author may not want to publish the forks on his domain. There ought to be independent 3rd party to keep track of the fork or a npm name that is not the author and not github (aka Microsoft).
- mrmonkeyman 6y agoHe got exposure. If he wanted money he should've got a job or started an agency. This is childish and why would anybody give him a 6 figure contract for "maintaining" faker.js?
- Karupan 6y agoRight move IMO. The consulting firm a friend works for uses faker.js for almost all their projects. The consultants get paid $1500 a day and they haven’t even thought of donating as it “free and open source”. I also hope the license is more restricted for commercial use.
- aboringusername 6y ago[this comment was deleted as HN doesn't pay me to contribute to the discussion]
- _pmf_ 6y ago> Yet, we continue to pay for our daily basics; food, water, electric…Yet we’ve decided for some insane reason that all this programming work the world’s richest companies rely on is worth absolutely nothing. Stop making stuff open source, and there will be more paid jobs, and the paid jobs that exist will be valued more because they are no longer just "plumbing together open source components". Easy as that. Will the software be higher quality? No. But that does not seem to be a concern anyway.
- marcus_holmes 6y agoI realise what is happening. I realise there are thousands of people whose work contributed to being able to do this. I also realise that some of those people are getting pissed off and annoyed that their contribution isn't being recognised (see TFA for details). And those people have the ability to "inject code that steals secrets" into my code base and cause massive headaches for me. Which is why I'm extremely careful which dependencies I use, and don't use dependencies whenever possible.
- josuepeq 6y agoI wonder, how much shareholder value FOSS, either in a package manager or otherwise, has added to MFAANG and other technology companies over the years? A few years ago, someone did break a package that many companies cloned and integrated... the internet nearly broke... My guess; a disruption in services is one thing that’s not already “priced in” to the stock market.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoWell, Microsoft didn't spend $8G on Github out of the goodness of their hearts... As Neal Stephenson said two decades ago : it's not like Microsoft controls developer's means of production and distribution ! (/s now)
- ganafagol 6y agoYou sir have misunderstood the concept of open source software. As an open source author or maintainer you don't do the work for others and then expect some kind of compensation. The idea instead is to do the work that you would have done anyway because somebody else paid you or because you did it for fun, and then you publish it to use the community to help you fix issues. A philantropic motivation is nice but not necessary and just a minor side effect. And just as you don't have an obligation to help does nobody have an obligation to help you either. That's why I like the term "open source" better than the original "free software". If you get the root motivation that RMS had for the "freedom" aspect of it, then that's the same thing, but too many people read it as "for free". Like apparently the author of this article. And that's just wrong.
- dtech 6y agoIt's also fully his choice to no longer do that...
- ganafagol 6y agoAbsolutely. I would even encourage people to stop do this kind of thing. It's just that the rant demonstrates the misunderstanding, which is what I'm trying to point out.
- ludston 6y agoI don't know if there is "one true motivation" for working on open source software, and any other reasoning is a lack of understanding.
- SomeoneFromCA 6y agoOpen Source has nothing to do with Free Software. There is a plenty of OSS products which are not free to use.
- orangeshark 6y agoFree Software doesn't have to be free to use either (free as in free beer).
- echelon 6y agoSeriously. What's the point of open source if companies just steal it, build billion dollar industries on top, and then lock everything down? Apple is telling us we can't run our own software on their goddamned devices, yet they built their empire on open source. Look at Facebook, Google, Amazon. They've extracted all the blood they can and given us back scraps. AWS is repackaged software you pay more for. Yes, it's managed, but you're forever a renter. They've destroyed our open web, replaced RSS with DRM, left us with streaming and music options worse than cable and personal audio libraries. The web is bloated with ads and tracking, AMP is given preference, Facebook and Twitter are testing the limits of democracy and radicalizing everyone to cancel one another. Remember when the Internet was actually pleasant? When it was nice to build stuff for others to use? Stop giving your work away for free when the companies only take.
- part1of2 6y agoWhat billion dollar industry is built on top of faker.js?
- donmcronald 6y agoNone, but think of it in the context of time = money. Discussions about self hosting development environments will be filled with people claiming it's not worth the opportunity cost to spend the time setting up and maintaining anything yourself when you can pay $X per month and make it someone else's problem. In the same context, how long does it take to write something like faker.js? I've never used it, but I see commits that are at least 6 years old and there are 200+ contributors. Is that 1000s of hours? I honestly don't know. Let's say it's 1000 hours just for an example and that someone worth $100k / year could write it. At $50 / hour that's $50k if you have have to build it in house and you lose out on the value of having 200+ contributors that are familiar with part of the codebase plus tens of thousands of users exposing bugs and edge cases. So IMHO when you have codebases like this the corporate donations should be in $10k increments. I would never publish a line of code under the MIT license. It's great for companies that want to popularize their platforms (like Microsoft is doing), but it's terrible for small developers and you'll rarely get any value from those projects.
- LoSboccacc 6y ago> picks mit license > gets mad when people use the work under his license oh no!
- tlarkworthy 6y agoI am not religious but labourers in the vineyard stuck with me from school: The workers who were hired about five in the afternoon came and each received a denarius. 10 So when those came who were hired first, they expected to receive more. But each one of them also received a denarius. 11 When they received it, they began to grumble(D) against the landowner. 12 ‘These who were hired last worked only one hour,’ they said, ‘and you have made them equal to us who have borne the burden of the work and the heat(E) of the day.’ 13 “But he answered one of them, ‘I am not being unfair to you, friend.(F) Didn’t you agree to work for a denarius? 14 Take your pay and go. I want to give the one who was hired last the same as I gave you. 15 Don’t I have the right to do what I want with my own money? Or are you envious because I am generous?’(G) Matthew 20:9 (Marek has the right to renegotiate. The fortune 500s had the right to use the work he offered for free, as that was the terms set)
- pfortuny 6y agoYes. The problem with licensing your software one way or another is exactly that: you agree on sone terms NOBODY imposed upon you. Open Source developers need to take burn out into mind before committing themselves to such a labor.
- ajmadesc 6y agoMaking an ethical judgment based on religious text is a serious folly.
- llaolleh 6y agoYeah but there are some timeless truths in many religious texts. This one seems to be applicable.
- Igelau 6y agoYou can also mine out some awful stuff by plucking certain passages without the right context, and we have certainly seen hatred and violence justified that way through history. This story is also missing the larger context that explains what it's really about -- and the answer isn't labor and wages.
- lacker 6y agoI empathize with the sentiment, but if you want to get paid for your open source work, surely it would work better to set up a Patreon and point people to it, rather than write "send me a six figure contract or fork this!" in a GitHub issue. It's also weird to use a license that explicitly lets Fortune 500 companies use the code for free, and then write that you don't want them to do so in the issue. Just change the license if you don't want to license it freely to big companies!
- dehrmann 6y agoI think a better approach is make some of the corporate users making requests admins on repo and take a break from the project. Companies would rather not maintain a private fork, but there are ways other than saying "pay up" to get them involved.
- adwn 6y ago> Just change the license if you don't want to license it freely to big companies! Marak doesn't want to prevent big companies from using his (?) code, he's saying that he won't support them for free anymore. Read the Github issue again, carefully.
- tnli 6y agoI find that those companies that add issues and support requests _ought_ to have the decency to also donate to him. But, I guess, companies don't have any decency to donate unrequested, so maybe he should put up some sort of notice to request payment for any work they request from him. Oh, wait...
- mcintyre1994 6y agoThere's also probably distance between the arm of the company that donates to open source and the developers who are opening issues when they spot a bug. And that distance probably gets longer for companies with the most money to donate too.
- 6y ago
- gkoberger 6y agoI think this is fair for him to do, and well within his rights. He’s clearly frustrated. I wish there was a better way for open source projects to solicit donations. It’s hard to get your boss to pay for software; it’s extra hard when you get no additional value. I feel like open source would have more luck if Issues could have attached bounties. I may not think to donate to faker.js, however as someone with access to a company credit card, I’d definitely attach $100-$500 (or more!) to certain Issues. (Tobi from Shopify recently did a $10k bounty to get OBS working with Zoom, and someone claimed it.) I do wonder why GitHub hasn’t done more here (I know sponsorships exist). It feels like they have the opportunity to build an open source Upwork... an army of people who create software and get paid a living, except in this case they also contribute to good. GitHub already changed how people work, and now they could do it again. EDIT: after reading his Twitter, it seems something is going on with him. https://twitter.com/marak https://twitter.com/marak
- ganafagol 6y agoPlease stop painting open source as a donation-based development model. That's completely distorting what it is about.
- gkoberger 6y agoOkay? This particular project is soliciting donations: “Support us with a monthly donation and help us continue our activities.” I’m not really sure what your point is, because you never actually made one. You just said I was wrong.
- Robin_Message 6y agoOne issue is that donations implicitly promote a cost-plus pricing model (I'd like to earn 10k a year doing open source, so that's how many donations I need to fund me working on this). Whereas something like dual-licensing promotes a value-based pricing model (our fortune 500 doesn't need to pay 5 engineers for a year to build and maintain this distributed system; we would happily pay equivalent of an engineer per year for that.)
- chillee 6y agoOne issue with "getting paid for open source" is how much marginal value the project is generating. For example, take left-pad. At the time of its infamous removal, it was relied upon by thousands of packages, including Node and Babel. But does that mean that it was worth millions of dollars? Of course not. Because if it wasn't available, anybody could have replicated it in a few hours of work. I don't know if that's the case for this project, but just wanted to note that "being used by <multi billion dollar company>" does not necessarily mean that you're providing that much value.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoBut if I am not providing much value, why am I wasting time on the project? Like even if I am willing to work for free, I select a project thats more valuable and meaningfull. So if open source is all free, its hard to tell what is meaningfull. Also maybe fundamentally important packages should be more carefull with their dependencies.
- shermanmccoy 6y agoI think people initially work on some of these projects, at least in part, to beef up their CV and make themselves more hirable. Every second tech job advertisement these days brainlessly asks you about your 'open source contributions'.
- unishark 6y agoYes I've always found this off-putting. People in HR departments are literally earning six figure salaries in return for making job ads advising people to do a bunch of unpaid labor which, by the way, the company benefits from.
- shermanmccoy 6y agoHow many times in an interview has anyone even showed anything beyond a superficial level of interest in your hobby project? Just mindless box ticking
- Fordec 6y agoI've been noticing more push back against the open source bargain lately. Years ago software was fully build on the backs of a multitude of giants within their niche domain. But for a while now large companies have been adopting a model of taking from open source contributions and raking in billions. The original social bargain of "pay it on" has been broken by the Bezos of the world raking in billions. And yes, as others have pointed out, nobody owes you anything, this has down the line knock on effects of ingraining having to build widgets inhouse for the thousandth time because all the talent went and put it into their day-job instead of the community. Maybe a partial factor because the industry has expanded and matured so much in the past three decades that name recognition is harder to filter out among the noise by merely doing good work. Whatever the case, developers are starting to believe that voluntary free open source contribution is for smucks. Which will hamper innovation and morph the industry to how, well, every other industry operated before tech came along. Siloed and slow.
- unishark 6y agoyou mean the good ole days when Microsoft paid 50k for quickdos before making billions from it?
- sgift 6y agoThat's 50k more than most open source projects make, also: No one forced the owners of qdos to give Microsoft that license for 50k. Sellers remorse is a thing, but I'm not sure why we should feel sorry for them.
- OldHand2018 6y agoAs a really fun thought experiment, imagine that they took the $50,000 and put it into 30-year US Treasury bonds in 1981 and sold them in 1986 to buy Microsoft at the IPO. It would be worth about $212 million today. And that ignores dividends.
- austincheney 6y agoBut MS hired Tim Patterson and gave him equity. How is that not fair?
- aboringusername 6y ago[this comment was deleted as HN doesn't pay me to contribute to the discussion]
- ricardobeat 6y agoWhat is exploitative about the model? You explicitly license your code in a way that's free to use for anyone, with the intent of giving back to the community. The author of jQuery did fine as a book author. WordPress gave birth to a massive profitable company. PHP is alive and kicking with the backing of Zend. These are all perfectly fine ways to make a living out of OSS work.
- creato 6y agoEh, I don't really buy that these contributions are so huge. What is the replacement cost of tools like this? It's not that high. It actually seems like this kind of software negligibly impacts large businesses, but small businesses and individuals are the ones who really benefit, because even a small replacement cost is significant for them.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jprupp 6y agoYes, a company will pay you to work on open source projects that are considered valuable for that company. I am surprised that Marak hasn't been offered a satisfactory job that pays six figures already. Perhaps he makes some mistakes while applying, or luck hasn't been on his side.
- BuzzwordBingo 6y agoYou’d pay someone $100k a year to write a little JavaScript that generates a few random words? You wouldn’t be in business long.
- tasuki 6y agoOr perhaps he hasn't applied?
- krelian 6y agoIs this about not wanting to support bug and feature requests from big companies for free or does the developer can't find a day job? Surely someone who created some popular open source software wouldn't have a problem landing a high paying job?
- stblack 6y agoMarak sponsors me on Github. When I was thanking him I also asked, what’s your name? His reply: “I am marak.” Not a word more. Marak is a giver.
- waynesonfire 6y agoUsed the open source licence to get popular and now you're butt hurt? You would have zero users if your project was closed source.
- PartiallyTyped 6y agoAnd zero of the extra stress associated with maintaining a large project for free on your spare time.
- gohbgl 6y agoDoctor ...
- arthurcolle 6y agoOn Twitter, he claims that he was recently made homeless due to an apartment fire, and asks the community to send funds to help him avoid homelessness, which seems reasonable enough. He later goes on to describe "fake news written by the NY Post." I searched for this, and found an article that might be the article he describes (timing fits) [0] Pretty crazy story, all in all! He seems to be in some pretty dire straits, and is reacting to the perceived grievance of others profiting off of his work. All in all, I don't think this is the best way to handle the situation, although building some kind of SaaS API is probably not really possible for something that can be trivially implemented and operated locally. However, many other SaaS APIs have seemed equally trivial in the past and have been extremely successful, so it still might be a useful avenue to explore if he can sort out his legal troubles... [0] https://nypost.com/2020/09/16/resident-of-nyc-home-with-suspected-bomb-making-materials-charged/ https://nypost.com/2020/09/16/resident-of-nyc-home-with-susp...
- dehrmann 6y agoThis looks like a pretty popular project, so I assume he's decently talented. How does he not have a day job? Passion projects are great and all, but they're not known for paying the bills. Especially for solo maintainers, it's almost like playing a gig at a coffee shop for tips. Want to make a career out of it? You need talent, marketability, and be ready to compromise on your vision.
- trevyn 6y agoPlaying a gig at a coffee shop for tips and not compromising on your vision seems like a solid choice to me.
- Aeolun 6y agoUntil your house burns down.
- black_puppydog 6y ago> Making the world a better place by allowing big corporations to generate solid fake test data for their QA flows. --- Random Guy in a random Silicon Valley episode Not compromising your vision? Not to belittle Marak's work here, it's certainly valuable, but it doesn't sound like something that one does to make the world better, but like something that is useful (nearly) only in a corporate context and should be done for a decent salary. But you know, that's just like, my opinion...
- alangibson 6y agoHas anyone ever heard of a service that allows users to attach bounties to issues? So if the open source developer fixes an issue, the developer gets the money offered by the issue reporter. Edit: Answering my own question. https://gitpay.me https://gitpay.me Doesn't appear to be too popular though: "We paid $2547 USD in bounties " Edit 2: No wonder it's not popular https://github.com/gitpay/website/pull/4 https://github.com/gitpay/website/pull/4
- wichert 6y agohttps://www.bountysource.com https://www.bountysource.com is one. I have used a few times to sponsor features in Weblate.
- alangibson 6y agoLooking at the Bountysource docs, it looks like users can offer bounties. Do you know if it has a Github integration that allows developers to post some sort of price schedule, or to request a bounty on a given issue? Edit: It looks like there are red flags around Bountysource too: https://blog.elementary.io/goodbye-bountysource-hello-github-sponsors/ https://blog.elementary.io/goodbye-bountysource-hello-github... "If no Solution is accepted within two years after a Bounty is posted, then the Bounty will be withdrawn and the amount posted for the Bounty will be retained by Bountysource." "In December, 2017, Bountysource was acquired by a cryptocurrency company called CanYa who redesigned the Bountysource site and service with a new cryptocoin focus."
- imtringued 6y agohttps://issuehunt.io/ https://issuehunt.io/
- alangibson 6y agoThis one looks interesting. The top project has gotten $7,858.50. Not too shabby. The docs are pretty thin though, so it's not clear if it's possible for devs to attach a price to feature requests themselves. I've been looking for service with a flow like 1. User opens feature request 2. Dev responds with "Not useful to me, so I'll do it for $200. Click this button to pay." Edit: Issuehunt.io seems to be a side project of the people that make Boost Note. That may explain why BoostIO/Boostnote is the most funded project, and why there doesn't seem to be much ongoing effort to promote the service. I get that "we made it for us, but you can use it too" vibe from their site.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jgilias 6y agoSo you've made something cool and it's time to release it. These seem to be the options at hand: 1. Release under a permissive license (MIT, BSD) and: - Have everyone and their grandma use it. - Die poor 2. Release under a copyleft license (GPL) and: - No company is going to use or contribute to it, unless they can somehow clearly separate it from what they see as their intellectual property. Or just hide it where nobody sees it. - Die poor 3. Release it under a commercial license and: - Get bashed on HN for doing so - Nobody uses it - Probably die poor 4. Dual license it as GPL and commercial and: - Sue everybody as they are just taking the GPL version and never looking back. Especially if they can hide it somewhere. - Die poor Pick your poison.
- drran 6y ago5. Do nothing. - Die poor
- makerofthings 6y ago6. Get a job that pays the bills, write code in your spare time for the joy of writing code, publish code as PD to help others learn. Maybe blog about it. Die happy.
- D2187645 6y ago7. Get a job that pays the bills, write code in your spare time for the joy of writing code, or not write any code in your spare time at all. Die happy.
- skrtskrt 6y agoYeah - I write open source code to learn things that I won't get to or be forced to learn from a day job (currently a data platform in Python) - implementing authn/authz, network programming, creating a small framework. I enjoy it and I expect it to help me become a more well-rounded and therefore more employable developer.
- t0astbread 6y ago6. Quit IT, buy a farm - Get crushed by the market - Die poor
- salamimonger 6y agoAnyone wanna make a stock market for free/open source software? I'd like to be able to invest in software that have a chance of becoming acquired or adopted by big corporations that make them a lot of money, and then get some kind of ROI for it :P
- cblconfederate 6y agowasnt that the model of ICOs?
- toomuchtodo 6y agohttps://carta.com/ https://carta.com/ is most of the way there.
- cblconfederate 6y agoWhat i find weird is people always ask if "you are going to open source this and that". It's a bit rude, like asking strangers to give you their car. I get the trust aspect but still
- aembleton 6y agoMost people I know, don't ask that. Some other developers do and I can just answer with a firm no, as I don't want to.
- allenu 6y agoI've gotten that question before and I agree it's a bit rude. I wonder if questioner has any understanding of how much dev work things take or if they just think that it's trivial and so why not just share it with everyone.
- siscia 6y agoI tried (not very hard) and failed to life out of open source. The real problem that I see, is that, the more I mature as engineer, the more my work improve, the more it is valuable, the less time I got to do it. Often the choice is between time with my family and coding, and for how much I love coding, it won't beat time with the family. It is a shame because there is a lot of open source work that we could do in a lot of area, even fundamental area like storage that is suppose to be stable and mature.
- rhindi 6y agoJust dual license your code with an AGPL and commercial license. Proprietary software companies hate AGPL, and won’t take the risk to use it, instead preferring to pay your commercial license. MongoDB does that very successfully!
- donmcronald 6y agoFrom the MongoDB blog [1]: > AGPL fixes this “loophole” in GPL by saying that if you use the software over a network, you are bound by the copyleft. Isn't that basically everything? Loopback is a network, right? I like the general idea and I think AWS really cheated them (ethically), but I wonder if there's something better that's completely safe for small business to ignore as easily as something like the MIT license while forbidding use by huge providers like AWS. 1. https://www.mongodb.com/blog/post/the-agpl https://www.mongodb.com/blog/post/the-agpl
- BuzzwordBingo 6y agoYou can choose to get paid with money or choose “payment by other means” which is what open source licenses extract from the people who use the code. Asking for one then petulantly demanding the other is childish.
- lollmao 6y agoUnrelated, but why do people prefer to assume gender over just using gender-neutral pronouns? Not a native English speaker but I've seen this a lot, especially on HN even when there's no indication of subject's gender whatsoever. Or is it just weird to use they/them? Thanks
- imtringued 6y agoA lot of people simply know that he is male. The nypost article is pretty high up and refers to "him" and "he".
- lollmao 6y agoNote that the user I replied to didn't seem to be sure of it.
- maccard 6y agoA quarter of that article is an elderly neighbor saying "he definitely was up to something" because "he never let his young son play outside". I wouldn't put too much faith in the article having done the diligence to figure out what Marak's preferred pronoun is.
- adwn 6y agoIf I had written "Marak doesn't want to prevent big companies from using their code [...]", the gender-neutral "their" could have refered to the companies' code, giving the sentence a different, incorrect meaning. I would have had to completely restructure the sentence just to avoid the sin of accidentally misgendering someone; instead, I placed a "(?)" after the pronoun, to be on the safe side.
- lollmao 6y agoYes I see now, it does seem to not sit well in many cases. Thanks for clarifying :)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- orlandohill 6y agoDual-licensing with a suitable public license would allow him to build a viable business. https://duallicensing.com/ https://duallicensing.com/ https://indieopensource.com/public-private/indies https://indieopensource.com/public-private/indies EPPlus was relicensed earlier this year, and it's already generating enough revenue to pay two full-time developer salaries in Sweden. https://blog.meilisearch.com/value-in-open-2-epplus/ https://blog.meilisearch.com/value-in-open-2-epplus/ The Parity Public License would be a suitable choice of public license. It's a strong copy-left license that requires licensees to open source the code they develop with the software. This means that developers of proprietary software would need to buy a private license. Parity hasn't been approved by the OSI due to their dysfunctional, inconsistent license review process, but it clearly fits the Open Source Definition. https://paritylicense.com/ https://paritylicense.com/ For source-available licenses that don't fit the OSD, there are many options: * Polyform Small Business License https://polyformproject.org/licenses/small-business/1.0.0 https://polyformproject.org/licenses/small-business/1.0.0 * Polyform Non-Commercial License https://polyformproject.org/licenses/noncommercial/1.0.0 https://polyformproject.org/licenses/noncommercial/1.0.0 * Prosperity Public License https://prosperitylicense.com/ https://prosperitylicense.com/ * strictEq Free License https://stricteq.com/free/1.1.0 https://stricteq.com/free/1.1.0 All of the licences mentioned above are flipped forms. They are short and written in every day language, so don't hesitate to read them. https://flippedform.com/ https://flippedform.com/ Kyle Mitchell has been putting great effort into helping developers get paid for their work. See also strictEq and License Zero. https://stricteq.com/ https://stricteq.com/ https://licensezero.com/ https://licensezero.com/
- hvasilev 6y agoI'm pretty convinced at this point that as an individual developer there is no open source / free software license that is your friend. Especially the GPL ones seem like they are pushing a lot of ideology, instead of focusing on the well-being of the individual developer. I think that open source developers can benefit from a few business classes and a few philosophy classes in general.
- cercatrova 6y agoWhy do people create something and explicitly license it under an open source license and are then surprised when it's used as the license permits? I can see a few possible reasons: 1. Culture: GitHub seems to have the culture of people using and putting out their code as open source just because everyone else is doing it, or they just don't know or care to do enough research about software licenses. 2. Promotion: open source seems to be used as a way to promote your product and you simply hope that no one will "screw you over" by using the license as it permits, even by big companies. They'll use open source to build their product but will cry foul when corporations do the same exact thing the open source creators were doing in the first place! These two factors seem to account for a significant portion of the open source license based posts on Hacker News in the past several years. What will happen in the future? It seems that people will create more proprietary software in the form of ostensibly "open source" licenses such as the SSPL by MongoDB or others. People will say that they're not truly open source, just another variation on proprietary source available licenses, which is true but the problem isn't a moral one, it's a practical one. GPL was started because the end user freedoms were eroded, and these licenses also fall into that, where people will soon discover that a proprietary license isn't great when they want to expand the original software but are encumbered by the license, such as if they work for a large company or other such restriction. Having no restrictions is always better than having even small ones. But how will open source creators make money, one may ask. The simple answer is, they don't, and they shouldn't expect to. The more complex answer is, open source is not a business model, it is merely a licensing and distribution model. You must compete not on the code but the problems your code solves. Your product must also include marketing, sales, branding, and other business skills. Treat your product as a startup. Amazon could open source all of its code and infrastructure and it would still be the dominant player in cloud computing as well as buying stuff online. Why? They are not in the business of selling code, they are in the business of selling convenience (as every business is actually, you don't hunt your own meat, a grocery store sells you the convenience of buying food, with money rather than time and effort; business is just commoditized convenience). Moreover, people know and trust Amazon, they don't know your other site, even if you took their source code and made your own website. At the end of the day, people need to understand that a product is not a business. If you want to make money, you probably shouldn't make a free product. There are ways to leverage a free product into a business, as seen with TailwindCSS (free, open source) to Tailwind UI (paid, proprietary) or Laravel to Laravel Spark and Forge, but don't expect people to spontaneously pay you when they could use your product for free, unless, again, you have the business skills to make your product stand out via marketing and having product-market fit.
- robinduckett 6y agoMark aka JimBastard aka Node.js Rap guy
- elcritch 6y agoMakes me wonder if GitHub could add a “paid support ticket” as an add-on to their donation buttons. A repo owner could offer paid support tickets by setting an option. A bit of a combination of bounty program and consulting, but simpler and streamlined using GitHubs clout.
- realty_geek 6y agoTimely post, I'm just about to embark on an experiment with my open source project where I will restrict access to the newer versions. Not what I wanted to do when I initially open sourced it but seems like the only way I'll be able to keep it sustainable: https://medium.com/@weebrix/the-future-for-propertywebbuilder-my-open-source-real-estate-website-builder-83edf159a486 https://medium.com/@weebrix/the-future-for-propertywebbuilde...
- lumberjack 6y agoI think the more tactful way to go about this is to create a subscription support program, and ask all commercial users to sign up to get priority support. Or just create separate commercial licenses for commercial use.
- tlocke 6y ago> Seriously. What's the point of open source if companies just steal it, build billion dollar industries on top, and then lock everything down? I work on pg8000 https://github.com/tlocke/pg8000 https://github.com/tlocke/pg8000 which is used by Amazon, Google etc. I'd argue that pg8000 and any Open Source software doesn't give them a competitive advantage, because in order to have a competitive advantage you have to have something that your competitors don't have. It's more that they'd be at a competitive disadvantage if they didn't use Open Source software. That's not to say there aren't problems with the big tech companies, but I'd say that Open Source isn't where the problems lie. In my view the problems stem from the nature of the web, in that it is a centralized architecture that inevitably concentrates power. Something like IPFS https://ipfs.io https://ipfs.io would help liberate the web?
- BlueTemplar 6y agoHow is the Web a centralized architecture ??
- tlocke 6y agoIn a URL, say https://www.example.com/ https://www.example.com/ a particular location is specified for the content. In contrast, with a decentralized system a hash of the content would be used to find the actual content, so-called content-addressable. See https://ipfs.io https://ipfs.io for more info.
- raverbashing 6y agoGood attitude in spirit, but bad professional attitude If F500 companies are asking for you to do work propose a support/sponsoring deal, not complain on a Github issue
- csala 6y agoI am honestly surprised at the amount of people here trying to say that open sourcing your work and making money out of it is incompatible. While the OP may have plenty of reasons and be totally entitled to make this decision, I do not thing their case can be directly compared to all the different open source projects out there. Being myself a full-time open source developer, I have seen several cases in which businesses are built around free software, either because multi-billion companies hire third party teams to build software for them under the conditions (imposed by the hired team) of open sourcing what is built, or by developing free software while offering high-end paid support for it, or even by wrapping the open source software in commercial enterprise-level, services-oriented applications. So no, I do not think that it is reasonable to paint open sourcing is an equivalent to being stolen by big tech companies. It is just a particular way of doing things, originally based on certain principles and which sometimes succeeds as a business strategy and some other times does not, just like any other business strategy out there! Having said that, I wish the best of luck to Marak and I hope they figure out the way to remake their life after what happened and continue to push on their awesome work on open source software while managing to make a living out it!
- habosa 6y agoSome more context: https://twitter.com/marak/status/1320465599319990272 https://twitter.com/marak/status/1320465599319990272 The author lost all of their stuff in an an apartment fire. If you value the open source work (I love faker.js) and want to donate, PayPal paypal@marak.com
- yamrzou 6y agoIt looks like this is what triggered it: https://twitter.com/marak/status/1325612104808886274 https://twitter.com/marak/status/1325612104808886274 "There has been a data leak somewhere in FAANG and I can tell you with certainty billions of dollars are being made off our work and there are multi-millionaires literally laughing at us."
- jannes 6y agoI am really wondering why NonCommercial (NC) software licenses aren't more popular. Of course, the FSF would not consider them "free", but does that matter? As far as I can tell, the Creative Commons NC and BY-NC licenses are pretty popular for (non-software) creative works. Why doesn't the same thing exist for software? You could then dual-license a paid version.
- FeepingCreature 6y agoThe point of open source is that you can't make money off of (selling) it (directly).¹ Neal Stephenson memorably described open source as a tar pit that eats up opportunities for profit in software development. I realize that sucks if you need an income, but if you write open-source software, that is what you are supporting. (And I say that as an open source dev.) When you license a piece of code under the GPL, you are saying "people who write opensource code should not have to put effort into remaking this." When you license a piece of code under BSD, you are saying "Nobody should have to put either effort or money into remaking this." Like it or not, that's what the license means. ¹ Yes yes, distribution fee, I know. And you know damn well that's not a workable commercialization strategy.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- nmstoker 6y agoMy experience is reasonably narrow but it strikes me that whilst this scenario is frustrating for Marek, an overall worse issue comes from naive time wasters being disruptive with issues. It's a balance and one shouldn't have unrealistic expectations of the pubic but lots of the culprits seem to combine a poor understanding of software basics and ridiculous expectations for what they could do with a project, for how little effort they can put into it and how much service they think they ought to get from maintainers and contributors. Some form of screening would be handy and whilst I welcome efforts GitHub and other tools provide to nudge people in the right direction it seems more could be done.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI know a couple of comments have mentioned this already, but this apparently grows out of him being in a pickle financially at the moment and resenting the time he has put into doing free work: https://twitter.com/marak/status/1320465599319990272 https://twitter.com/marak/status/1320465599319990272 I'm sympathetic. I don't have any funds to spare to help him out. I'm chronically broke myself. I've done lots of nice things for people over the years for free. A lot of the things I'm good at are inherently hard to monetize (most moderating positions are unpaid, for example). I was homeless for years. I still write about homelessness and try to provide other forms of support for people who are homeless or at risk of homelessness. Some of the things that would help: 1. Universal health care coverage in the US. ("free"/provided by the government) 2. Fix our housing policy issues such that more small housing in walkable neighborhoods becomes available. If those two things were done, a single adult could potentially support themselves on part-time minimum wage work while renting a single room until they get back on their feet. That's currently not feasible. I am not against open source. (I just submitted my first pull request to open source a few hours ago.) But I do recognize that there are systemic issues and we need to make it easier for people to make their lives work so they don't wind up all pissed off over what they have done for free when something goes sideways.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoThe 'Automating Inequality' book is 1/3 about homelessness issues, you might be interested : https://virginia-eubanks.com/ https://virginia-eubanks.com/
- DoreenMichele 6y agoThank you. There's a summary here (I downloaded the linked PDF and read it): https://www.researchgate.net/publication/337578410_Virginia_Eubanks_2018_Automating_Inequality_How_High-Tech_Tools_Profile_Police_and_Punish_the_Poor_New_York_Picador_St_Martin%27s_Press https://www.researchgate.net/publication/337578410_Virginia_... I've made a note of your comment someplace I have hope of finding it again.
- ChickeNES 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- shaicoleman 6y agoThe solution needs to be cultural, not legal. The culture change needs to come bottom up within the company. Employees in those companies need to advocate for active contribution in open-source, not just in a parasitic form. This can come in many forms, building groups/guilds to advocate open source, mentioning it in one-to-one, setting expectations around open-source in job interviews, and requesting time and money to contributing to open source. People need to stand up and say "this is not okay", and stand up for what they believe in. The only way things will change is if the cost of contributing to open source is lesser than the cost of losing talent because of it.
- yourapostasy 6y agoHanlon's Razor applies here, I believe, as in: "relax, not everyone is out to get you". The open source ingestion governance process at every client I've been involved with making such decisions is completely divorced from the procurement process. Technical leads everywhere should be pushing to integrate them as a single entwined process like with closed-source software, for prioritized support of code put into operational production pipelines. As a designer, it is a huge risk in my eyes to select open source software, put millions of dollars per hour/day of 24x7x365 processing onto it, and ignore the 24x7x365 support question. Within most big companies, getting governance sign off to onboard open source that touches production pipelines is grueling enough, and there is a culture where if procurement isn't involved from the beginning of the governance discussions as a stakeholder, procurement will hassle you to no end because they have their own liability concerns to address for the company ("how do we know we'll get the support we pay for?", "what recourse do we have if we don't?", "what are their terms?", "how do we logistically pay them?", etc.). Most employees at big corporations will choose the path of least resistance; I'm only sometimes successful at getting payment to open source teams by pointing out the risk and audit liabilities of putting into production open source with no solid support story, the inertia is so great. When the business asks for clarification ("Wait, I thought this is open source so it's free and we don't have to pay?"), make a clear, simple case to make that when you pay a regular amount each year on par with closed-source support contracts, the key developers/maintainers respond prioritizing your support requests, with no worse or better response results on average than closed-source support organizations. Show the numbers of what is put at risk when (not if, never, ever if) it breaks, and the value of domain experts to fix the break (do not ever fall for the jibe, "Aren't you good enough a programmer to fix this open source code?" [1]). And stop with the open source proselytizing in front of the procurement people; help them get their job done, translate into terms they speak. The open source benefit within a for-profit company should never be about the pecuniary; it is faster innovation and problem-solving, forming a better overall solution delivery than closed-source alternatives. Sell procurement on how open source is a frictionless evaluation and onboarding experience compared with closed source. No more "call for pricing". No more expensive shelfware. An adopting company gets more of a guarantee it will be a fit for purpose before payment than they get from the vast majority of closed-source vendors on their master list. On the other side, the open source community needs to meet corporations halfway if they want routine compensation for open source work. There are lots, and lots, and lots of forms to fill out. Companies really hate publishing these forms out in public, but 98% of the content in these forms ask the same questions between different companies. Start building standards for open source teams to follow of what questions to anticipate to fill out. Start creating standards of support procedures to publish to inquiring companies' procurement departments trying to gauge whether they can trust their production support to an open source team. There's lots more to add here, but in general open source teams make procurement departments really work extra hard to pay money, and procurement officers really, really hate that. It already rubs many procurement agents the wrong way that software solutions in general are not super-fungible due to the power law and network effects we tend to take for granted in the industry; they are used to a highly-asymmetric relationship where vendors come hat in hand through their doors as one of many near-identical competitors, and these procurement professionals strongly dislike vendors with strong negotiating leverage because in their world, everyone is out to get their company. Lots of open source teams who want to be paid for their work shoot themselves in the feet, multiple times, by not spending the time it takes to find out what the procurement people need and delivering that with a smile. I've seen this discussion at the beginning of open source, and I know all the rebuttals. My favorite is, "if I wanted a business to make money, I would have set one up, DUH. I just want to code, put it out there, and get paid for it." Think of it as handshaking a protocol. We're used to UDP, TCP, HTTPS, TLS, etc., but there is an entire business language out there to interface with, consisting of just as intricate rules. They come dressed in meetings, contracts, forms, questionnaires, and so on, and are part of the story of how humans build enormous loosely-coupled organizations that still get amazing accomplishments done despite all the error faults we witness every day. If you want to access money, then you engage those protocols, just like if Grandma wants to access cat pictures, she engages the user protocols with her smartphone (log in, pick an app, etc.). [1] One possible response is, "I'm an expert at fixing [our company]'s internal systems' problems. That open source team are the world experts at fixing [open source project]'s problems that would take me 100x more time to come up to speed, as if I was starting a new job, because it is so large and addresses such a large problem domain for us."
- rendall 6y agoThis is terrible news! Just this morning I came up with more chores for Marak to do.
- gameswithgo 6y agoGood. Too many people compelled to work for free for the profit for others under a misguided philosophy. Open source is a great thing, and doing it for free is a fine thing if you want to do so. I do some free open source work. But I hate that people are pressured to do it, or get crap if they chose not to.
- LockAndLol 6y agoWe're a bunch of smart people here. What kind of a system can we come up with that cannot be ignored by multinationals to reap the benefits of FLOSS? Do people really care about licenses? Large companies will bury you in costs before you get paid, right? I think by that time it's too late. The obligation to reach towards the wallet should be earlier. As somebody mentioned somewhere, I think bounties would make sense. The dev can work in anything they like, but can be incentivised to work on something specific if a bounty is on it. For that however, we would need a third party system where people can pay into a pot for a specific goal, define the key items that have to be fulfilled, and only when they are fulfilled + validated by a third party, is the money paid out. Or something like that. What other ideas do you smart folk have?
- tubularhells 6y agoAnyone arguing how 'this is not the way to do it', 'lol open source Dev what did he expect' or explains how they have been using his software 'but it's not that important' are the Republicans of the development community. Fucking shameful to see people talk like this about folks who do good, open and free work to make things better. Go and look yourself in the mirror and repeate those words. One day your corporate owners might so the same to you.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jiofih 6y agoYay for binary thinking.
- dang 6y agoHey, can you please not break the HN guidelines like this? They specifically say "Have curious conversation" and "Please don't fulminate". https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html (Edit: It looks like you've been doing a good job of sticking to the guidelines in your other comments and we appreciate that.)
- tubularhells 6y agoI do try, but this got me furious as someone putting in the work to make free software, and corporate clowns playing devil's advocate for their own peacocking.
- phendrenad2 6y agoProblem: You want to make money for all the work you do your open-source project. But no one pays for it. Reason: Developers choose your project, and developers are at the bottom of the food chain. They have no authority to spend money, usually, or they get pushback and delays if they do. Solution: Band together with the authors of related projects and create a new closed-source product, taking bits of your various codebases. For instance, what if Faker.js and other similar libraries banded together into a corporation, and sold a multi-language mocking/stubbing/faking toolset? It would be easier to go to your boss, show them the product, and convince them to pay for it, since it now encompasses multiple things your dev team needs.
- andai 6y agoAt the bottom of the food chain, maybe. But let's see them develop anything without us! Unionization when?
- treis 6y ago>For instance, what if Faker.js and other similar libraries banded together into a corporation, and sold a multi-language mocking/stubbing/faking toolset? Nobody would use them. Ultimately they would lose out to someone like Thoughtbot that puts out open source tools as a loss leader to drive consulting business.
- Spivak 6y agoThat only works if Thoughbot's open source tools are good enough. People seem very happy to pay for JetBrain's suite of tools. Postman's collaborative offering makes good money. Sublime is still doing well. There are people still selling standalone pieces of software to developers and doing okay. It's hard to compete with huge companies with a build-over-buy culture but that's just their nature. It's way cheaper to just built it themselves and have control of the project than to pay the licensing fees.
- treis 6y agoTools are an easier sell. You can always switch to a different one without too much fuss. That's a lot different than writing five years worth of test cases and then having to go for a license renewal.
- throwaway7281 6y agoI calculated that so far I saved with my pro-bono work in open source and documentation around 2,085,000 million hours of professional labor. Now my hourly rate is 100 bucks, so that's about 200M worth of labor that ended up in other peoples pockets. I could probably retire now. In a just world, we might give people credit for this kind of work or we would organize our commons more sensibly. But in the world today, value is siphoned up - and the siphon is a very well tuned siphon.
- aantix 6y agoAlong these lines, I wonder if a progressive pricing structure would ever work for SAAS? Larger companies pay more, solo devs pay less. All based on the email domain they register with. https://twitter.com/aantix/status/1299773332699721730 https://twitter.com/aantix/status/1299773332699721730
- jiofih 6y agoThat’s how nearly every SaaS offering already works. Enterprise pricing.
- simoneau 6y agoCompanies I've worked at make it fairly easy for me to expense a purchase, with just manager sign-off or similar. I just need some sort of up-front price for pre-approval, and a receipt afterward to send to accounting. As soon as you get any contracts involved, this becomes very difficult to get through the system. Are there open source projects out there which successfully make enhancement requests look like "purchases", rather than consulting?
- gtsop 6y agoThere a couple of categories of comments on this thread that I think are missleading. 1) Judging the author's decision based on his previous behaviour or current speculation over his situation 2) Judging the author's decision to write OS and "demand" to be paid. Both categories, imho, are missleading the real issue at hand which is this: We, as developers, as companies and as a society, who decided to depend uppon one man's work to make a living, our interest is to keep maintaining this library to keep our software running and evolving properly. Time (thus money) has to be spent for that. So the question is for the rest of us here: Do we want to keep replacing various OS libraries on our depedency trees because some people can't keep maintaining them? Or shall we pay them? Or shall we maintain them ourselves? Somethint has to give. To me, his point is at it's core very correct: pay me or fork it. The rest is chit chat
- carapace 6y agoYou know the Bash shell is maintained by a single unpaid volunteer? He also maintains the GNU readline library.
- gtsop 6y agoWhat is your point? He can maintain it without pay. Good for him, good for us, good for all. This case is different.
- carapace 6y agoWell I guess I have a few points: 1) We all depend on Chet Ramsey and don't spare a moment to think about it. How many people have emailed him a thank you note, let alone sent him money? 2) Is that good or bad? or both? 3) Mature software has low low maintenance costs (that's almost the definition of "mature software", eh?) 4) The real problem might be that we keep writing new code. If you restrict yourself to mature code your costs go way down, since you're not paying to write new code nor to maintain it. (It might read like I'm saying Marak should be like Ramsey, that's NOT my point.)
- 6y ago
- batt4good 6y agoSo he was smart enough to write this but not smart enough to sock away $15k in emergency funds?
- gbrindisi 6y agoThis is such a low comment not worth of this community. Hardness happens to everyone, have some empathy please.
- emerged 6y agoWhen you provide things to people for free for a long period of time, they will become entitled to it. This is true in all contexts. It's up to you to work in a way for it to be valuable enough to yourself to continue.
- asimjalis 6y agoWhy not use this model? Open source away basic MVP version and give it away for free. Have a second version based on customer requests that is closed source and commercial. Could this work model work for faker.js?
- tommica 6y agoWhy is there no donation-as-a-service that allows me to pay 10usd month, and add registered people that the money is split between? Just a lump sum per month, split between all chosen items
- todd3834 6y agoI remember Marak from the very early days of Node.js on IRC. He was extremely active answering tons of people's questions. I don't know him personally, although he helped me a lot on IRC back in the day. I was excited watching Nodejitsu startup and sad to see it kind of disappear. In a lot of ways people like Marak and TJ Holowaychuk have done so much for the community that it wouldn't look the same without them. Let's not forget about the infamous node.js rap https://soundcloud.com/marak/marak-the-node-js-rap https://soundcloud.com/marak/marak-the-node-js-rap We often talk about the responsibilities of companies to pay open source engineers. I think this would be great but in my experience companies are very often looking for ways to cut costs to meet goals. Giving money to open source is likely one of the first things that would get cut in these situations. I'm not saying that is a good thing but a reality. That being said if the donations are so small that they aren't going to move the needle for a goal either way then it is unlikely to be cut. I don't know what the sweet spot is but it would be cool if it became standard for software companies to expect to give some portion of their budget to open source. This also leaves the question open for what the responsibility for individuals are. I'm not proud to say it but I haven't given very much money to open source developers. However, I have a list of about 10 that have had a very positive influence on my career. I would bet I'm not alone. I do feel conviction over this and posts like this are helping me re-evaluate this.
- tyrex2017 6y agototally fine, but I really believe he would see 10x the job offers if he had phrased it more politely. 6 figures should be easy for his skill level. i am afraid many super cool bosses will avoid him because he reminds them of people who are pissed off and cause issues.
- carapace 6y agoI don't think you should write FOSS software if you want to get paid for copies of it or the use of copies of it. That kind of defeats the whole point[1]. Either: 1) Be comfortable being extremely poor. This was the route I initially took: I was homeless during the time I learned UNIX and Python, etc. and had plenty of free time to work on writing code. 2) Be wealthy already. The easiest is to be born to wealth, but if that didn't work out for you you'll have to acquire wealth yourself. There is a wealth (pun intended) of information on this already, and it's beyond the scope of this comment, but I'll recommend "The Art of Money Getting or, Golden Rules for Making Money" by P. T. Barnum (Yes, that P. T. Barnum!) esp. the last chapter: https://www.gutenberg.org/files/8581/8581-h/8581-h.htm https://www.gutenberg.org/files/8581/8581-h/8581-h.htm and "The Richest Man in Babylon" which "remains in print almost a century after the parables were originally published, and is regarded as a classic of personal financial advice." ~ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Richest_Man_in_Babylon_%28book%29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Richest_Man_in_Babylon_%28... 3) Get paid for the writing itself (which is hopefully solving someone's immediate problem, eh?) (This is what RMS himself does, FWIW.) (Can be combined with option #2 to bootstrap wealth.) [1] The "whole point" being something like, "Let's accelerate the techno-singularity and go live in Star Trek with cool aliens who like us." yeah?
- say_it_as_it_is 6y ago459 closed pull requests, 85 open pull requests. 211 contributors. There's your payment, Marak. You didn't work alone.
- anuila 6y agoI figure you've never received any pull requests. PRs RARELY are good to go, most of the time I have to put as much work as they did to accept them. Except for a few contributors, most just pushed a single PR, which means they never get to learn how to contribute autonomously. I've turned to reject PRs that are half-assed and ask me to finish their work. They don't help me, they only push me to work more for free for something that they want.
- nickjj 6y agoThis reminds me of a lot of DHH's keynote about open source from last year: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBwWbFpkltg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VBwWbFpkltg Even if you're not a Rails developer it's worth watching. From what I remember from the talk he is totally fine with and doesn't hold any grudges against Twitter, GitHub or Shopify making hundreds of millions of dollars off Ruby on Rails while getting zero compensation in return. Mainly because he open sourced Rails with no monetary / fame expectations and then worried about generating income from services around his open source project. I don't know Marak's history but I do know developing a good faker library definitely isn't trivial, so I'm sure his work is very much appreciated by the folks who use it but I think if you're doing open source work for money and other non-pure byproducts you're only setting your self up for disappointment.
- nix23 6y ago>Take this as an opportunity to send me a six figure yearly contract or fork the project and have someone else work on it. Oh yeah, for sure i would hire someone with that attitude.
- leib 6y agoSeriously, he should just inform people to send him feature requests and in return he'll send an quote estimation; no need to be petulant.
- nix23 6y agoYes! That's a good idea, feature and customization based Pricing. Just imagine Linus would be such a winy Rumpelstiltskin...well he is, but not a winy one ;) BTW: Whats with the 211 others that help him?
- makecheck 6y agoNot limited to software but modern society has a REALLY serious entitlement problem. (To the point where if I see a video on Reddit of someone screaming at a retail employee, it is not even surprising anymore.) I’ve had free and open projects for years, with evidence of thousands of users. Yet I could count on one hand the number of times anyone has bothered to thank me, much less donate. I do occasionally get E-mail requests for support but sadly at least half of them have had a complaining/entitled tone as if I am not doing every last bit of this for free. I have had zero offers to help with development, documentation, or really anything else. And interestingly, some of those E-mails have come from some pretty well-known large entities, be they government departments or large companies — organizations that should have more than enough resources to give a damn. Sadly, it is not better in the for-pay universe. After publishing apps, I have found that essentially no one will outright “pay once” for something anymore, no matter how cheap (leaving things at the insultingly-low price of $0.99 for weeks does nothing). Similarly, people usually will not contribute even a rating to help you out, much less a review. The E-mail/web info links on the store have never been used by anyone to reach me. And App Stores make it impossible to know who your customers even are, otherwise. So a silent relationship is maintained, where random unknown people update their apps over time, continuing to benefit and all I can assume is that they are still happy or something. So my conclusion after decades is this: you do the projects you like to do for your own benefit, and no one else’s. They are résumé builders so you have something to show when looking for a corporate job that actually pays. If anyone doesn’t like what you’ve built, you are 1000% allowed to ignore them. If someone happens to appreciate it, that is a bonus but not a certainty. And you must be prepared to receive no money at all from these projects, much less enough to live on.
- pontus 6y agoI think one of the problems is the interface through which we access these tools. I know when I walk into a Walmart that I'm dealing with a huge organization and if I accidentally break something while I'm walking through an aisle, I don't necessarily feel that bad. If instead I was walking around in a mom-and-pop store and broke something, I would apologize profusely and demand that I pay them for their troubles. When accessing open source projects, there's no visual trigger that makes me subconsciously distinguish between downloading tensor flow that's being developed by Google or some small personal project. It all looks the same. The same thing goes for music, graphics (e.g. iconography, fonts, ...), and even things like physical products on Amazon - it all feels the same.
- wernercd 6y agoReminds me of Fuck You, Pay Me. https://creativemornings.com/talks/mike-monteiro--2/1 https://creativemornings.com/talks/mike-monteiro--2/1
- johnjboren 6y agoThere is a small-cap Crypto project that is coming out of Japan. Dev Protocol. https://devprtcl.com/ https://devprtcl.com/ Making open activities sustainable with staking They allow people to stake the Dev Protocol token and split the rewards with the Open Source project. They are already integrated with GitHub. This doesn't answer immediate concerns, but supporting Open Source is their entire angle.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 6y agoI wonder whether it would be possible to have a licensing scheme that was compatible with a package manager config to help solve these problems. # new environment with explicit config pyenv virtualenv myEnv —-licensing=personal pip install some-free-package # Success vs # new environment defaults to restrictive pyenv virtualenv myEnv pip install some-free-package # failure ERROR: PACKAGE LICENSE INCOMPATIBLE WITH PIP CONFIG It would be just as much on the honor system as things are today, but I think people are generally honest. If a package I want isn’t compatible with my license config at work, I think I’m more likely to find a different package or try to get a license than I am to change my package manager confit away from the team sanctioned settings, potentially opening my employer to what I now explicitly know to be legal risk. I’m thinking about the packages I usually use and I don’t know their licenses. Pandas? Pytorch? I assume I can use them at work because everyone else does. If my package manager told me otherwise, I don’t have to be proactive.
- darepublic 6y agoAs an aside, I keep trying to get my team to stop using faker so maybe this will help with that
- ponker 6y agoWhy the indignation and the "snapping"? Build this in from Day 1. Set the terms of your license to reflect what you want people to do with the software.
- Touche 6y agoIf you want to sell your efforts producing software you are going to be spending most of your time doing sales and a minority of your time writing software. Too many developers have this idea that people should just throw money at them while they have fun crafting some OS library. We could only be so lucky! In reality only a small minority of open source projects (the type that are near ubiquitous) garner enough from donations to fund the project. So you have a choice: become a salesperson first, or treat your project as a hobby and don't kill yourself working on it.
- easytiger 6y agoI'll be honest, that's not how open source worked ever. You solve your own problem. If other people share the problem they will help. Entitlement is thinking that people owe you something. If you don't want corporations to fork, use GNU licensing. If you don't find their feedback on modification useful... Ignore it
- shruubi 6y agoI've always thought the struggle of people not wanting to pay for software or expecting you to go out of your way for free comes primarily from the fact that for things like software (but this also applies to art) there is no physical product. Of course, this is just unfounded speculation on my part, but I feel as though there is some kind of sub-conscious thought, brought about by years of being taught that generally speaking, things that are larger or have fancier packaging are more valuable, and that exchanging money should result in something that you can hold and take stock of. Software (or really anything in the digital space), while being something that we can cognitively see, is not something we can hold or even try to accurately value using any rough method we usually come up with to do so. On top of that, digital goods are only ever seen as a finished product, and the average person can't fully comprehend the effort and time that goes into producing that finished product, meaning that effort expectations range from "click a button and it's done", to "I reckon I could make this in a weekend". Personally, I think this dissonance between better valuing something physical can be seen in peoples willingness to pay hundreds to thousands of dollars for an iPhone, but absolutely refusing to pay 99 cents for an app for the iPhone you just bought.
- musicale 6y agoHaha, I know the feeling right? It's amazing to work on a project that either saves or brings in millions of dollars to multiple companies, but none of them are willing to support or hire any of the developers, because they don't want to pay for something as long as they can get it for free, which of course makes total sense.
- rvr_ 6y agoThere is an issue not being discussed here. The guy is almost homeless. He is probably angry and has nothing left to lose. Now think about all the damage he can do by having his open source project being used by so many people and companies. He can deploy a malware or ransonware and even if he doesn't make a penny, he can create some chaos. This is the real risk of relying on a fragmented open source ecosystem, especially the NPM platform. Pinning is not enough when every Node project uses so many dependencies coming from so many developers.
- alexellisuk 6y agoI can sympathise with this on so many levels having dozens of large companies using OpenFaaS as part of their product or internally and not paying a dollar in sponsorships or for custom development. I wrote up my experiences last year and the options for building OSS projects in terms of funding. https://blog.alexellis.io/the-5-pressures-of-leadership/ https://blog.alexellis.io/the-5-pressures-of-leadership/ Since writing that I think that building an indie company is possible, even funding it with a micro-SaaS as seems to be the trend. The core lesson here is: if you want to have people pay, then make them. Either hold features back, create a managed version, try to sell them support (good luck), or create a product based-upon your project which is not free. You can hear a little about how that's going for me here -> https://kubernetespodcast.com/episode/116-independent-open-source/ https://kubernetespodcast.com/episode/116-independent-open-s...
- tripu 6y agoFor anyone out there using Faker and interested in its development & maintenance, let me share my own fork! GitHub project: https://github.com/tripu/faker.js https://github.com/tripu/faker.js Updated npm package: https://www.npmjs.com/package/phaker https://www.npmjs.com/package/phaker
- mbrodersen 6y agoThis is exactly what you get when you give your work away for free: your work will have zero value. Why are open source developers surprised by this simple fact? If somebody started giving away toilet paper for free then the value of toilet paper would go to zero. When you copy a commercial application and give it away for free (what most successful open source software does) then the value of those types of applications will go to zero. Which means that the value of the work (your work) goes to zero. Surprise surprise.
- mbrodersen 6y agoSo the author doesn’t have the biz skills necessary to turn his open source project into a commercial product, instead relying on the kindness of faceless corporations or strangers to recognise his value and reward him. Yeah good luck with that.
- mbrodersen 6y agoGive the source away for free. Get paid for any support.
- lobo_tuerto 6y agoIf you want to help check this out: https://twitter.com/marak/status/1320465599319990272 https://twitter.com/marak/status/1320465599319990272
- bibryam 6y agoThere tens of different platforms for OSS monetization options https://www.oss.fund/ https://www.oss.fund/