33 ms·
Apple to kill Epic’s accounts on Friday the 28th
- woofie11 6y agoThis clearly and unambiguously crosses the line into abuse of market power. Apple's actions before? Maybe? Sort of? Apple needed that 30 percent cut to monitor for fraud and quality or something, going above-and-beyond other payment processors. This? This has absolutely no basis in anything. It's simple retaliation designed to kneecap Epic from Apple's dominant control of a market. Apple can refuse to let Epic release games, without stopping Epic's Apple development dead in its tracks. That accomplishes all reasonable business purposes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tonyedgecombe 6y agoThis clearly and unambiguously crosses the line into abuse of market power. Epic is taking them to court. What did they expect, a nice thank you and a pat on the head.
- serioussecurity 6y agoYou don't get to use retaliatory behavior to discourage lawsuits, in this form, especially as a service provider. If they wanted to sue Epic back over frivolous patent violations, they're allowed, but if you're going to engage in retaliatory behavior you can't do it in a way that violates your own ToS.
- spzb 6y agoIt's not retaliation although that's how Epic are trying to portray it. It's a straightforward breach of contract on Epic's part and Apple are invoking the termination clause.
- danudey 6y agoApple has terms and conditions for developer accounts, which, if broken, result in account termination. Epic agreed to, and then broke, those terms and conditions. This results in account termination. I'm not sure how this is retaliatory behavior. If I had an app and snuck violations into my app to get past review, then had my app removed, then instantly released a PR campaign and filed a lawsuit, I think it would be pretty clear to most people that: 1. I broke the rules and having my account terminated is the obvious result. 2. I didn't break the rules accidentally, but instead broke them very deliberately. 3. I am not interested in discussing this through normal channels, and instead broke the rules to get my app removed as a PR power play so that I would look like the good guy. That's what happened here. Epic sneaking the IAP workaround into their app shows they broke the rules; Epic filing a lawsuit and launching a PR campaign instantaneously shows that they broke the rules deliberately, knowing the consequences, and are not interested in following the App Store T&C. Doing anything other than closing their developer accounts would be preferential treatment that other developers are unlikely to get in the same situation. Whether you agree with the rules or not (Epic obviously doesn't), according to the terms and conditions Apple is doing the correct and obvious thing.
- dade_ 6y agoTerms and conditions can say whatever they want, but illegal terms in a contract are not binding. The problem is that this type of dispute usually takes years to litigate, so I have to think there is much more to this strategy.
- TylerE 6y agoCompanies shouldn't be allowed to fire customers that blatantly break rules the customer agreed to?
- chrisacky 6y agoOf course they should. But, market dominance means agreement to such terms are not 'fair'.
- TylerE 6y agoYes, total market dominance with 10% market share.
- uncoder0 6y agoIn the US?
- bryanlarsen 6y ago60% market share by revenue in 2019. https://www.businessofapps.com/data/app-revenues/ https://www.businessofapps.com/data/app-revenues/
- baddox 6y agoIsn't that just because Apple's customers are more willing to spend money on apps than other customers?
- ayoisaiah 6y agoWilling is not the right word. They generally have a greater means to do so.
- baddox 6y agoOf course. My point is that this doesn't seem to be related to any anticompetitive behavior on Apple's part. If Apple was using market power to force smartphone competitors out of the market to increase Apple's own market share, that would be one thing. But to accuse Apple of anticompetitive behavior because their small smartphone market share spends more money on apps than other smartphone owners does not seem reasonable.
- elicash 6y agoI personally thought they were already in abuse of market power. But on this latest development, I want to hear Apple's argument first. That said, I didn't find their argument on the first action compelling so not optimistic. But maybe they discovered some abuse, for one random, made-up example -- my point isn't to trust Apple but just to see what the reasoning is first. This tweet doesn't say if they were given any reasoning for the latest action.
- mrgordon 6y agoYeah to be honest while I think Apple clearly has monopoly power here that should be reined in, I also get the feeling that Epic will have a pretty weak argument for why they purposely violated the Terms of Service and then expect to continue using the SDK tools.
- elicash 6y agoI'll still be on Epic's side if they didn't violate the terms AFTER Apple removed their app. But if they, for example, tried to upload another app or something then Apple would then of course need to remove their access. (I'm not REALLY on ANYBODY's side here. But I think App Store rules are unjust and bad for users and that Apple will lose this fight despite being able to take any losses financially for as long as they wish.)
- hrktb 6y agoIf you argue a company doesn’t allow behavior X, doing it and getting punished is the best course of action to prove the point. To your point, they have a whole lawsuit filling explaining why they think X should be allowed.
- mrgordon 6y agoAccording to the law, the best course of action is not to break the law to prove you don't like the law. While the Terms of Service are not the law, you agree to follow them when signing up and the terms didn't change after Epic signed up. Practically, you may be correct that this is the most expedient way to try to fix the problem but you can get burned as Epic has in the short term with a sharp drop in revenue as Apple & Google have both booted them and may refuse to work with them in the future.
- Bud 6y agoOn the contrary, there is a very solid basis. Epic has access to Apple's platform and dev tools because it has (or had) an agreement with Apple whereby it paid a percentage of profits earned in exchange for said access. Epic, btw, has the exact same kind of agreement with Sony, Microsoft, and Google, for access to their gaming platforms. All three of those companies are extracting the same 30% fee that Apple is. But now Epic has decided to grandstand and pretend that Apple has a "monopoly" and protest paying Apple, while still happily paying the exact same fees to its other gaming partners, including to Sony (for PlayStation), which just invested $250M in Epic. So to say that there is "absolutely no basis" for Apple's action just isn't true.
- thedz 6y ago> Epic, btw, has the exact same kind of agreement with Sony, Microsoft, and Google, for access to their gaming platforms. All three of those companies are extracting the same 30% fee that Apple is. You don't have to agree to Epic's terms to access the platforms from Sony, MS and Google. You do, however, have to agree to Apple's terms to access their Platform.
- Bud 6y agoNitpicking, and I'm not even sure that's correct. Regardless, it's not relevant. What Epic is griping about here is the 30% fee, but they're not acting or speaking in good faith about that. They're pretending that fee is somehow onerous, but they pay that exact same fee to every other platform, too.
- m-p-3 6y agoThe Epic Games Store takes a 12% commission on all games sales though. https://variety.com/2019/gaming/news/tim-sweeney-epic-games-store-1203195452/ https://variety.com/2019/gaming/news/tim-sweeney-epic-games-... And I'm sure they're not happy about the fees on other platforms, but they can't fight everyone at once.
- sushid 6y agoThey can believe that many actors are injust but can be simply choosing their battles. And phones > consoles in terms of impact. They're also less arbitrary about which purchases take a 30% cut or not compared to phones.
- Razengan 6y ago> Apple needed that 30 percent cut to monitor for fraud and quality or something, going above-and-beyond other payment processors. How much do Microsoft, Sony, Nintendo, Steam, Gog and etc. take from publishers on their stores?
- tsieling 6y agoRoughly the same, I think the variance is about 10% with Steam being an outlier working in tiers tied to revenue. At least one allows developers to name the cut (including 0%) but 30% is the most common number.
- ghostpepper 6y agoThis is a valid question - if the answer is a fraction of what Apple charges then it strengthens the case against Apple.
- objclxt 6y agoIt’s the same. Microsoft, Sony, and Nintendo all charge 30%. https://www.ign.com/articles/2019/10/07/report-steams-30-cut-is-actually-the-industry-standard https://www.ign.com/articles/2019/10/07/report-steams-30-cut...
- Razengan 6y ago> if the answer is a fraction of what Apple charges then it strengthens the case against Apple. The answer is the same. What now? Will you put down the pitchforks?
- ghostpepper 6y agoMy comment was actually intended to play a bit of devil's advocate - I'm not convinced that Apple has a monopoly, and I kind of don't mind living in the walled garden.
- coldpie 6y agoIt's all private, of course, but they're all generally in the 30% ballpark. There may be lower rates for big clients, but there's no way for us to know that. https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2020/08/as-epic-attacks-apple-and-google-it-ignores-the-same-problems-on-consoles/ https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2020/08/as-epic-attacks-apple...
- pjc50 6y agoThe thing is, this starts the taxi meter running; every dollar that Epic would have expected to make will get added to their demand for damages.
- sushid 6y agoSource? They specifically state that they're not suing for damages and I doubt they have changed their case in the last few days... > Apple’s conduct has caused and continues to cause Epic financial harm, but as noted above, Epic is not bringing this case to recover these damages; Epic is not seeking any monetary damages. https://cdn2.unrealengine.com/apple-complaint-734589783.pdf https://cdn2.unrealengine.com/apple-complaint-734589783.pdf
- pjc50 6y agoThat's in the middle of the document, but at the end: > C.Awarding any other equitable relief necessary to prevent and remedy Apple’s anti-competitive conduct;and > D.Granting such other and further relief as the Court deems just and proper It's also totally normal for a course of action that was deemed unlawful and resulted in losses for one party to be compensated. Anyway, we have a decade or so to find out; these cases are not quick.
- dragonwriter 6y agoOnly D is arguably on point, and probably wouldn't reverse a statement in the same filing that they are specifically not seeking a specified class of damages, instead it basically keeps open anything not specifically excluded tomwhich they might be entitled; equitable relief as mentioned in C is a legal term of art that does not overlap with money damages, so that certainly cannot be read as a claim for money damages.
- quotha 6y agoSo, Epic should get special treatment? They don't have to pay the fees? Just everyone else? How is apple supposed to run the app store? They kinda know what they are doing or why else would so many people buy their iphones?
- mcintyre1994 6y agoTheir app isn't on the store, so no they shouldn't pay fees beyond whatever Apple charge for the privelege of being a developer on their platform. Not sure why not paying App Store fees (because of not having an app on the store) would justify removing access to all developer accounts and tools.
- quotha 6y agoWell it used to be dude, that is the whole situation here.
- smilekzs 6y agoNo one should have to pay 30% as long as Apple also competes in the same "marketplace".
- gruez 6y ago> They kinda know what they are doing or why else would so many people buy their iphones? Or maybe it's something that people merely tolerate. Kind of like how ISPs are almost universally derided in the US for crappy service and high prices, yet everyone seems to be paying for their serivece. If you asked people when they're buying an iphone whether they want 30% of app and in-app purchases to go to apple, with no way around it, how much % of them would say yes?
- quotha 6y agoYes I see that, and you can apply that to all sorts of things in our lives. It’s still arbitrary where the line is that keeps everyone happy, I guess Epic thinks it’s < 30% but I am just not with them on this fight
- kmeisthax 6y agoThe thing is, Apple probably isn't the only one to do this. Apple is actually very graceful by the standards of platforms. Note that Epic did not attempt to surreptitiously introduce a "direct payment" feature into Microsoft, Sony, or Nintendo platforms. That's because you don't even get developer documentation without signing an NDA. Had Epic even thought about doing this on console, the question wouldn't be "will the console manufacturers retaliate", as much as it would be "how many months until the console manufacturers start banning new game submissions that use Unreal Engine"? Apple did this before, BTW. Remember "Thoughts on Flash"? That wasn't Jobs railing against an aging browser plugin. Adobe had figured out how to get Flash to export iOS apps, and that really pissed off Jobs. So it was really Jobs attacking a strawman (the buggy Flash Player) in order to justify banning all third-party development tools. The FTC threatened to sue and the rule was removed about 3 months later.
- jedberg 6y agoIt's fascinating to see the replies to the tweets. It appears most people don't care. They just want their game to work. A lesson in how your customers don't care about how your product is made.
- _the_inflator 6y agoI experienced that myself first hand. Players are no activists, only some who make a lot of noise. You simply mustn't instrumentalize them. As you said: people see that the game does not work anymore. Who is to blame? And what can we do about it? Install another game, because what they see is that other games are available and in the end, this is not about Epic, it is about fun for people.
- HeavenFox 6y agoA cursory scan of the Twitter thread suggests most people who have expressed an opinion are on team Apple, blaming Epic for violating Apple's term of service.
- save_ferris 6y agoThis is exactly what we get so mad at journalists about: we look at Twitter and just assume it accurately reflects reality, when there’s no evidence whatsoever that this is the case.
- quenix 6y agoDitto. Twitter and Reddit both.
- thrwn_frthr_awy 6y agoThat's right. Epic is trying to use it's user-base as pawns against Apple, but it isn't working. Is Epic planning on lowering the cost of games on iOS by 30% if the fee goes away? I don't believe they are. Edit: Thank you save_ferris for for correcting me. Here is the blog post announcing the discount. https://www.epicgames.com/fortnite/en-US/news/the-fortnite-mega-drop-permanent-discounts-up-to-20-percent https://www.epicgames.com/fortnite/en-US/news/the-fortnite-m...
- carabiner 6y agoEpic's "trap" seemed terribly tonedeaf. This will not end well for them.
- ajkjk 6y agoReally? I got the opposite impression. Apple's tonedeafness and developer hostility is finally being challenged by a (comparative) underdog.
- Bud 6y agoDo you think that Google, Microsoft, and Sony are also hostile and tone-deaf, then? One assumes so. All those platforms extract the same kinds of fees from Epic that Apple does. But mysteriously, Epic only wants to go after Apple.
- dbmikus 6y agoBecause on Android Epic can still have users install their games via a different app store.
- Bud 6y agoBut Google is still extracting the same 30% if users make in-app purchases.
- Alupis 6y agoOnly if it uses Google's built in payment system - which is what started all this (EPIC using their own).
- dbmikus 6y agoNot if you use a different payment processing infra. You are not obligated to use Google's app store or their in-app purchasing system if you install the app through a different channel.
- 6y ago
- fooey 6y agoSeems pretty straightforward to me. If you sue me, and go out of your way to publically attack me, I'm not willing to do business with you until it's settled, if ever again.
- throwaw4y-plate 6y agoBut can you be banned from doing business with millions of other people for offending the gatekeeper?
- hysan 6y agoApple's grudge with Nvidia comes to mind, so maybe yes?
- Razengan 6y agoWhy should Epic get to enjoy a market that Apple built without giving Apple anything or following the rules of the platform? Should anybody be able to post anything they want on HN or YouTube or Facebook etc.? They can't. Does Epic allow anyone to sell content for Fortnite without giving Epic any money? They don't.
- throwaw4y-plate 6y agoAll I can do is throw up my hands and say "Stallman was right."
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sjg007 6y agoConsumers bought the phone which can be be considered a general computing device.. so we should be free to run whatever software we want on it. That's the real argument.
- fooey 6y ago
- draw_down 6y agoI don’t have a side in this fight, but I do admire how Epic has clearly planned this out to wring every ounce of publicity and goodwill they can. I don’t find this particular measure (shutting down the accounts) particularly sinister. Epic has made it abundantly clear they don’t like the App Store’s rules and regulations. That’s fine but it means you won’t be selling on the App Store. I see this as Apple taking them seriously on that point. We are well past the point of negotiations here. And following from the planning point, there is zero chance Epic did not see this coming.
- fooey 6y agoI don't think they planned this well at all. It feels like rage fueled flailing they didn't think through. What is it going to do for Epic's cash flow if they're not allowed on any app stores for literal years while court cases filter through? What is it going to do for their game store and engine selling business to be indefinitely evicted from the Apple ecosystem entirely? Were I a company using Unreal Engine to develop a game, expecting to target Apple hardware, I would not be very happy about the stunts Tim Sweeney is pulling.
- draw_down 6y agoCmon, they had a lawsuit and a commercial ready to go on the day they made their move.
- whatever1 6y agoApple just showed that it is game developer hostile. Gamers will just migrate to whatever platform their games are available. Devs will lose tons of money, users will lose their investment in the ios ecosystem and apple will lose its cut. It’s a lose lose lose situation and Apple is the one to blame.
- philistine 6y agoAt this point in the fight, Epic has not fired its biggest cannon: announcing that Unreal Engine 5 will not support any Apple hardware. So at this point, there is uncertainty, but no clear harm done to any developer using Unreal engine and currently targeting Mac hardware.
- almost_usual 6y agoSo if the government doesn’t side with Epic or bail them out at this point are they done for? Seems like Epic put everything on the line.
- jhloa2 6y agoEpic has more revenue streams than just Apple's ecosystems.
- almost_usual 6y agoDidn’t Google just shut down their deal with OnePlus though? I mean if they’re no longer on good terms with Apple or Google that has to be a big chunk of their revenue stream?
- Alupis 6y agoEPIC does exist outside of the mobile space. They produce one of the top Cross Platform Game Engines, and produce many high quality games, including Fortnite which was massive well before any mobile version was produced.
- zucker42 6y agoIt could be really bad for Epic in the long term if Apple decides to completely and permantly prevent Unreal Engine from running on Mac and iOS. Game developers may be less likely to use Unreal Engine if they know it doesn't have support for Apple OSes.
- zaphar 6y agoYou can still play on PS4, XBox, and PC. I think Epic will be fine.
- fooey 6y agoIf Epic devs are running macs, do you need a developer license to run XCode? I'm not sure the repercussions of losing their Apple developer accounts, but I imagine it's not pleasant. https://twitter.com/Slasher/status/1295434558112960519 https://twitter.com/Slasher/status/1295434558112960519 > Epic says that included in the tools that Apple will revoke is the Unreal Engine that hundreds of third party developers use. "Apple’s actions will irreparably damage Epic’s reputation among Fortnite users and be catastrophic for the future of the separate Unreal Engine business"
- Solstinox 6y agoWhat the f*ck is going on at Apple?
- Bud 6y agoIt's more like, why did Epic decide to file a spurious legal action when their situation with Apple is exactly the same as their situation with Microsoft (for XBox) and with Sony (for PlayStation) and with Google (for Android). The only difference is that Sony just invested $250M in Epic. I'm sure that minor fact has no relevance here, though. (sarcasm most certainly intended)
- lokar 6y agoAre the various cuts (both sale, and in-game) for each platform known, either informally or publicly?
- fooey 6y agoEveryone is 30%, always has been Xbox, Playstation, Steam, Google, Apple, they're all 30%.
- papaf 6y agoEveryone is 30% Not everyone. Epic Games Store is 12%, Humble Store is 5% and itch.io lets the developer choose.
- SXX 6y agoDue to Epic's pressure Steam already offering lower fees for more than two years now. Both Sony and Microsoft are also likely to make custom deals for popular titles the same way as they allowed them to have cross-play. Tactics Epic using might look dishonest from outside, but it's will really help industry long-term.
- Solstinox 6y agoEpic's intent is clear. No need to ask why. Apple's handling of the situation is baffling. "Let's martyr the smaller company!"
- username3 6y agoApple doesn’t get 30% when retailers sell iTunes gift cards.
- joekrill 6y agoBut they do once the consumer spends that gift card. So charing 30% for the gift card would sort of be charging the Apple tax twice, wouldn't it?
- username3 6y agoIf retailers get 20% of a $100 iTunes gift card, then Apple gets $10, the developer gets $70, and the retailer gets $20. Epic should sell iTunes gift cards.
- caiobegotti 6y agoAs a game company I would expect Epic to have a massive strategy already laid out just waiting to unfold and win this one otherwise it will all feel very ironic.
- 0x402DF854 6y agoFrom a preliminary statement of Epic's motion: > Just over two weeks ago, Apple’s CEO Tim Cook was asked during a Congressional hearing whether Apple has “ever retaliated against or disadvantaged a developer who went public about their frustrations with the App Store”. Mr. Cook testified, “We do not retaliate or bully people. It’s strongly against our company culture.”
- pwinnski 6y agoSome might see a difference between "a developer who went public about their frustrations with the App Store" and a developer who deliberately violated the policies and then filed a lawsuit and started an extensive PR campaign.
- Despegar 6y agoEpic's antitrust case against Apple is very weak, but they're well within the right to sue Apple to resolve their dispute. The developer agreement actually stipulates the venue, Northern District of California, for any lawsuits. However, Epic demonstrated particularly bad faith in how they've dealt with this matter so I'm not surprised that Apple is terminating their relationship (which they're allowed to do under the terms of the developer agreement).
- coldcode 6y agoYes I also believe its a lousy case, but that what courts are for, to decide things. But Apple can easily point to all the times Epic agreed to the Agreement (my employer's large legal dept always reads any changes before agreeing), to the agreements Epic is fine with from the console companies paying the same percentage but did not sue, the long history of each and every clause in the agreement in the world of contract law (Apple has a billion lawyers I doubt they miss much). Winning such a case based on complaining its an antitrust violation is rather quixotic and normally only a government would do this. Maybe in the end both relent and the rate goes down, but I don't think Epic wants to pay anything and still be available.
- Wohlf 6y agoI believe Epic's entire case revolves around phones being a general computing device, so they'll be using the Microsoft antitrust case law.
- Despegar 6y ago>I believe Epic's entire case revolves around phones being a general computing device Legally this doesn't matter at all. It's just something for people to talk about on Twitter.
- ErikAugust 6y agoWhat if Epic had decided it didn't want to support iOS anymore... Is this all just something they may have wanted to achieve anyway?
- alienreborn 6y agoRelevant: https://cdn2.unrealengine.com/epic-v-apple-8-17-20-768927327.pdf https://cdn2.unrealengine.com/epic-v-apple-8-17-20-768927327...
- muska3 6y agoIs it bad that I hope they do kill Epic's account? Epic launches a preconceived plan with media attacks and the most ridiculous 1984 reference that actually doesn't make sense in the current context against Apple. If I'm Apple, even if this is a straight up attack on me, I just follow the rules in my TOS and block them like I do others who don't follow the TOS. If you don't like the TOS, fine you don't have to be on my platform and have access to my users. It's as simple as that. The fact that so many are rebelling against this, is actually good for consumers in the long run, they may flock to other platforms albeit there's now only two viable platforms, Apple and Android. Windows got bit by the dust, but I do wish they were still around to create a healthy three ecosystem battle. Epic's a billion dollar company with huge resources fighting another billion dollar company. It's kind of hilarious watching this pan out, with Epic pretending to be some small indie corporation fighting a huge conglomerate.
- wwadvisory 6y ago>the most ridiculous 1984 reference To be fair, it's a reference to Apple's own ad: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VtvjbmoDx-I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VtvjbmoDx-I
- klmadfejno 6y agoThat ad is incredibly dumb and incredibly awesome.
- bagels 6y agoHow doesn't it make sense? Seems pretty on-point. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1984_(advertisement) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1984_(advertisement) In his 1983 Apple keynote address, Steve Jobs read the following story before showcasing a preview of the commercial:[21] "[...] It is now 1984. It appears IBM wants it all. Apple is perceived to be the only hope to offer IBM a run for its money. Dealers initially welcoming IBM with open arms now fear an IBM dominated and controlled future. They are increasingly turning back to Apple as the only force that can ensure their future freedom. IBM wants it all and is aiming its guns on its last obstacle to industry control: Apple. Will Big Blue dominate the entire computer industry? The entire information age? Was George Orwell right about 1984?"
- davidg109 6y agoEpic is trying to shine a spotlight on what they think is unfair, and I flat out disagree. They want to now sue the same company that provides them tools to develop, as if it’s some inherent right? Apple owns the Apple store, and they can choose to charge what they want. Epic can choose to raise their pricing if they feel the millions they’re already making isn’t enough.
- davidg109 6y agoBring on those downvotes :) I’m looking forward to an ‘epic’ court ruling siding in Apple’s favour.
- jdhn 6y agoIf Apple really wanted to screw with Epic, they would do this while simultaneously encouraging Mediatonic to port Fall Guys to iOS.
- renewiltord 6y agoI wonder what the story is behind the scenes and why Epic felt the need to make this Hail Mary play.
- foogazi 6y agoSomeone looked at how much money they are making on iOS and multiplied it by 0.3 Imagine getting X% of everything you sell going forward without adding any extra features - just by complaining
- ascagnel_ 6y agoI saw somewhere that Epic earned $500MM from the iOS version of Fortnite alone in 2019 -- so Epic was looking at potentially $150MM USD/year.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ddorian43 6y agoApple takes 30%, in this case, like, $500M+.
- username3 6y agoApple doesn’t always get 30%. Retailers selling iTunes gift cards get a cut. You can guess their cut when they have 15% discounts.
- noxer 6y agoThe real question is why do they get a warning ahead? No indie dev would.
- quotha 6y agoDid you even see that stupid youtube? It kind of pissed them off!
- Jonnax 6y agoI don't understand the comparisons to game consoles. You buy an Xbox or a playstation, and it's a game playing machine. It just plays video games. You buy a mobile phone. And it's a general computing device. It's very much arguable that it's necessary for modern life.
- jdminhbg 6y agoThe only thing that makes a game console only a game playing machine is that it is limited by its producer. All the hardware is there for it to be a general computing device. So when you spool this argument out, it becomes: Google/Apple don't hobble their devices as much as Sony/Microsoft/Nintendo do, therefore Google/Apple should have to open them up more and Sony/Microsoft/Nintendo should not.
- Jonnax 6y agoWell it's what it is up front. A games consoles plays games and streams some video. A mobile phone is a camera, gps, web browser, telephone, messaging, food delivery, music listening, video watching, taxi calling, banking tool etc etc etc device. living your life, Apple and Google get 30% of your transactions.
- jkrems 6y ago> A mobile phone is a camera, gps, web browser, telephone, messaging, food delivery, music listening, video watching, taxi calling, banking tool etc etc etc device. I'm sure you know that you can do most if not all of those also from a game console. Sure, it doesn't always have a camera or GPS but that's true for many other general purpose computers as well. You can absolutely listen to music or watch videos or do online banking from an XBox or Playstation.
- ayoisaiah 6y agoYou're not seriously trying to equate Xbox and iPhone usage in the same category
- sircastor 6y agoA lot of this feels to me like Rpic thinks they’re a bigger deal than they are. No doubt they make a lot of money, and they’ve made Apple a lot of money. I think though that their attempt to take Apple in the court of Public opinion is going to fall flat, because there are a lot more iOS users than Fortnite on iOS players.
- username3 6y agoThis is all PR before Epic stops selling vbucks in-app. They can’t advertise where to buy in the app. This will get the word out that you can buy vbucks through their website.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoYou can't do that... Hey got taken down for exactly this.
- elicash 6y agoWhat I find confusing about Epic's approach is taking on Google at the same time. It seems like you'd have some leverage at forcing Apple to the table if you were exclusive on Google, for instance -- and then, after winning, you could be exclusive on Apple for a while to cut a similar deal with Google. All your leverage comes from kids wanting to only have a device that plays their favorite game where they hang out with their friends.
- s_dev 6y agoI think Epic are going to announce a new piece of hardware in the coming months. A phone that can play many games in their library. Both Google and Apple are trash at games and Epic know this. Theres a lucrative niche.
- selectodude 6y agoIs it going to be called "Nintendo Switch"? Because Fortnite is on there, plays really well, and I'm not sure what Epic is going to bring to the table to outclass it.
- namesbc 6y agoIt is so frustrating that Apple has gotten away with such developer and user hostility for so long. Maybe this will be the breaking point?
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoThis just seems like a dumb move on Apple's part. It's self-sabotaging. It hurts their legal case, it hurts their public image, and it hurts their platform, as Unreal Engine is used in both iOS and macOS games. Not that many people were getting Apple platforms for games before, but they've just shoved one of the most popular engines off the platform. If the judge grants Epic a TRO, Apple is going to be in deep crud. Should be a good early sign of how the judicial system sees the case.
- iJohnDoe 6y agoAgree 100%. I also think Apple should stop collecting commission fees from all App Store sales starting today. They have billions in the bank. What are those billions for if not to invest back into the company and its developers. Foregoing all commission fees is an easy way to do that and would make Apple a hero and help developers. I’m also willing to be there would be a resurgence in the App Store and bring in more sales and more developers.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoTo be fair, I think they should probably still charge reasonable payment processing fees. They need not depend on the App Store for profit though, they should be able to drop the rate, and they should at minimum allow alternative payment processors.
- kevincox 6y agoI think commissions are the smallest part of the problem. The problem is that you are buying what seems like a general computing platform, but then you will be prevented from using apps that Apple doesn't find helpful to their business. Not allowing another in-app payment solution is just one of the many things that they are preventing.
- cloudking 6y agoWill that break their existing installs?
- udev 6y agoThis reminds me of the Facebook vs Zynga debacle. It did not go well for Zynga.
- amaccuish 6y agoWhat took me aback was the withdrawing permission to notarise their apps for Mac. That was only meant to be a check for known vulnerabilities/malicious software. Apple was more within their rights to kick Fortnite until the dust has settled from the iOS store, that was the retaliation, but now a mechanism supposedly for security has been repurposed as punishment. That's a pretty nasty move and I feel the mask has slipped slightly here for Apple.
- Hamuko 6y agoYeah, it's fucked up if Apple is going to start disabling macOS apps regardless of distribution if the developer has violated their App Store rules in some way. Definitely undermines my trust in macOS.
- zeroimpl 6y agoThey are also being sued by Epic. Would you keep doing business with a company suing you?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- weixiyen 6y agoCurious to your thoughts regarding the mafia whacking witnesses who are about to testify in court.
- zeroimpl 6y agoWhat on earth are you talking about? My response was based on the OP suggesting the account closure was based purely on the App Store policy violation. I’m pretty sure it’s based on more than that, such as the fact that Epic is suing them in bad faith. There’s probably a million app developers which have violated the policies in some manner at some point and yet very few get blacklisted by Apple.
- kalleboo 6y ago
- pearjuice 6y agoFor years, people have applauded the walled garden of Apple and this is the end result. Without flamethrower you wil not get out of it. The walls have to go down. They are probably beting on that by this charade the entire industry turns against Apple and a boycott ensues, leaving them no choice to change their margins (and other marketplaces will adjust accordingly or the angry mob comes for them). I doubt Epic stands any chance in court. Apple's case seems to be water sealed as with every ToS signed, you waive any and all of your rights away. Clearly the ToS have been violated so they seem to be in their right.
- Xylakant 6y ago> For years, people have applauded the walled garden of Apple and this is the end result. Without flamethrower you wil not get out of it. I applaud apples walled garden on iOS and have no intention of getting out of it. I’m happy that at least one of my parents is in that garden, and my wife, too. There’s everything they need in that garden and at least it’s comparatively easy to keep up to date and safe. Otherwise I’d have to go play tech support even more often than I still need to.
- grumple 6y agoToS doesn't mean you can break federal antitrust laws.
- LaGravedad 6y agoDoesn't Epic ban kids when they violate the Fortnite TOS? Epic knew what they were doing. I have no sympathy for them.
- username3 6y agoEpic doesn’t allow kids to use custom community made skins either. Kids are afraid of getting banned.
- microtherion 6y agoI've been wondering about that. So, by Epic's logic, doesn't that make them a monopolist in the Fortnite in-app purchase market?
- bad_good_guy 6y agomy god you people are thick
- dx034 6y agoThose kids just create a new account. They're not businesses with thousands of employees that are dependent on TOS enforcement by Epic.
- qppo 6y agoWhat's the practical impact of this on Unreal support for MacOS/iOS?
- stunt 6y agoApple should allow alternative app stores. And they aren't going to do that for as long as they can. So, it's good that some customers are publicly complaining. I don't think they can force Apple to allow alternative payment methods. But, alternative app-store is reasonable.
- shiburizu 6y agoApple has been pushing for "services" under Cook ever since he took the helm. Being forced to allow secondary app stores would undo all of that work.
- Animats 6y agoNote that this applies to Mac systems, not just IOS. Apple is trying to prevent Unreal Engine from working on any Apple-controlled platform. So, if you're a gamer or a game developer, do not buy a Mac. Developers now using Macs need to be planning an exit strategy.
- spzb 6y agoOr switch to Unity
- umvi 6y agough... unity is a pain
- klmadfejno 6y agoThe engine is open source isn't it? They can't stop you from downloading the source and compiling it, right?
- l3s2d 6y agoSource available, not open source.
- klmadfejno 6y agoOk, but is the general point accurate?
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoNo. You would be free to compile your copy of the Unreal Engine, but without the ability to use Apple development software, it would be impossible for Epic to continue developing the engine on Mac. The end result is that the engine would not continue to develop on Mac, and would eventually likely stop functioning.
- 6y ago
- lindnertim23 6y agoIt seems to me Epic's goal here is to get Apple to allow side-loading on iOS. But I happen to disagree with this remedy. I see no reason to set aside Apple's Property rights with regard to their app store. My solution to this issue would require Apple to be forced disclose all technical documentation needed to write an independent operating system. Of course to be fair, this would apply to every computerized device sold in the USA.
- ping_pong 6y agoHow is this legal? Apple is so blinded by their arrogance that they don't see that this will lead to the App Store getting severely regulated. Look at Uber for a great example. It took years, but Uber and Lyft were finally handed a business-destroying law that will hurt them. It will only take a few months for the rest of the US to adopt similar strategies as well. After the congressional hearings a few weeks ago, Apple still doesn't understand what is going on around them. If they keep going this route, they will absolutely get themselves regulated and frankly I hope this happens. Their arrogance is disgusting to me and I hope this eventual come-to-Jesus moment will scare the shit out of them.
- quotha 6y agoI hear ya, but something smells real bad about how Epic decided to wage this war. They were clearly picking this fight, now I am not sure that was such a good idea.
- chillacy 6y agoIt's not dissimilar to how civil disobedience in the 60s thoroughly planned and tuned for maximum PR impact. Rosa Parks went on that bus knowing she'd make a scene. Does that change the reality being uncovered?
- quotha 6y agoReally? Sorry, that is not what I think of at all regarding this situation.
- chillacy 6y agoMaybe elaborate your comment further to prevent confusion? When you commented >"I hear ya, but something smells real bad about how Epic decided to wage this war" I read it as "I agree that the situation is unfair but I disagree with how they decided to uncover it because it was deliberate".
- wayneftw 6y agoThe enemy of my enemy is my friend. I'm going to buy all of Epic's games tonight for my PC. In the past, I was a bit annoyed that they plan to remove Rocket League from Steam but now that they're fighting Apple, I love this company. If this whole lawsuit thing doesn't work out, maybe they'll develop a phone so I can buy that too.
- AlexandrB 6y agoSpite's amazing. "I don't like Apple's walled garden, so I'm going to jump into Epic's (Tencent's) walled garden instead." At no point does using, or advocating for, a non-walled garden product come up as an alternative.
- wayneftw 6y agoWhat an extremely shallow and thoughtless comparison you've made. So, you don't think that supporting your enemies enemies is a good strategy?? Because it's a well-known and time-tested basic strategy that's been used the world over. Are you aware how much more impact Apple's products have on society than Epic's does?? Do you understand how big Apple is compared to Epic? Yes, I'm absolutely fine with a walled-garden for a bunch of games that are sold across many platforms. Not for a piece of basic infrastructure, for something that is so essential to all of our lives. As a user, I want to be able to compile and install software on a device that I own without having to re-up it every 7 days. As a developer, I want to give my customers software that they asked for without having to negotiate with a picky, asshole, power-hungry middle-man. I have nothing against Tencent. Apple's done so much more to limit my freedom while Tencent has hardly entered my thoughts for any amount of time.
- gridlockd 6y agoIt seems strategically stupid to cut off the company developing the engine that a lot of iOS games use to run from development tools. It's almost as if they want iOS to be the worst platform to develop for. As an iOS user, I hope Apple's stranglehold on the platform gets destroyed. I didn't practically care for the longest time, but I'm starting to lose self-respect here.
- BMSmnqXAE4yfe1 6y agoApple Damage Control team working hard here.
- jschenk 6y ago/s
- jimmaswell 6y agoI hope they become a martyr and this turns public opinion.
- quotha 6y agoDo you have any idea how annoying "Fortnite" is to the vast majority of sane adults?!
- dubious_one 6y agoAs someone who has not played Fortnite, I have a question. Can I as an independent developer create mods or addons equal to what Epic sells using their in game currency and have my mods, skins, etc work in the game? If not, then are they not acting even more egregiously than Apple since Epic has now a "Monopoly" on the Fortnite platform and refuses to allow others to monetize it?
- quotha 6y agoThis is not retaliation, it is consequences. First comes an action, then a re-action. (you can't switch 'em round for your own satisfaction)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bob1029 6y agoCan someone give me compelling reasons for disallowing side-loading of applications on iOS? Hypothetically, if side-loading were to be allowed it could be buried under a configuration+confirmation flag for security reasons just like with Android or Windows 10. Thinking more abstractly about this, I already do "sideload" iOS applications when I sign them with enterprise/developer certs and perform OTA installs from systems I control. Presumably, there is still some communication with the mothership going on (certificate revocation checks), but the principles are very similar...
- theshrike79 6y agoA single human is smart, people are stupid. They’ll install ANYTHING, no matter how hard it is and how shady the site is. They can’t help themselves. Then their phone is rooted by a bad actor and spreading malware. Who do they blame? Themselves? The shady site? The creator of the trojan? Nope. Apple. They’ll shout from the rooftops how Apple ruined their life and business and remand restitution. The easiest and most reliable way to prevent this is to lock people in a walled garden and make sure they don’t poke themselves with anything sharp. Yes, it sucks for the smart ones who know that shart things hurt, but that’s the way it’s gotta be.
- hu3 6y agoThat's hyperbole. People can sideload Android apps for a decade now and I have yet to see someone complain that sideloading did something bad let alone blame the OS for it. That is such a rare case that I have a hard time trying to justify the loss of freedom.
- theshrike79 6y agoThere are dozens of Android manufacturers. If an Android phone breaks, people complain about the manufacturer or maybe the telco they bought the phone from. Apple is a singular target, unlike anything in the Android ecosystem.
- 6y ago
- tpmx 6y ago"Epic flagrantly disobeyed Apple's terms." I keep reading this all over the Internet and it makes me so irrationally angry that so many people are so ignorant. Seriously, it seems like a very large part of people online think this behavior from Apple is okay "because they set the rules".
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoA large part of the population are bootlickers who want nothing more than for a strong authority figure tell them how the world should work.
- tpmx 6y agoThe same person then turns on a dime to protest Trump...
- lowbloodsugar 6y agoDon't see any evidence that this has actually occurred other than Epic saying so.
- fishywang 6y agoMy prediction is that this will backfire so badly for Apple. Apple clearly underestimated how popular Unreal Engine is to game developers. Apple probably expect developers to just switch to other engines when they took UE away from them, but in reality most of the developers currently using UE will just stop publishing on Apple's platforms because that's no longer a profitable platform (consider the investment for developing for Apple's platforms with new engine against the profit they can get there).
- tadzik_ 6y agoGiven that game porters currently chose Metal over alternatives specifically to support the lucrative Apple market better, I'm pretty sure they'd jump ship instantly to Unity or something else that isn't an engina non grata. People have been bending over to Apple in their choice of technologies for at least as long as OSX is a thing. A gaming engine (not even the most popular one on mobile) isn't gonna change that at all.
- strbean 6y agoJumping ship instantly from one engine to another isn't possible. You're talking about developers doing a full rewrite of their games. Sure, plenty of mobile games are crap that can be cranked out in a coke-fueled weekend (see Zynga). But there are also mobile games that required significant development effort to build.
- tadzik_ 6y agoOh, of course. I meant it more in case of newly written games. The ones that already run UE4 may likely meet a slow, neglected death.
- spoopyskelly 6y agoThey didn't take Unreal Engine away from anyone and every other platform also charges 30%.
- 6y ago
- rgovostes 6y agoFrom Epic's filing, here is an excerpt from Apple's notice listing the Developer Program features that Epic will lose access to when its membership is terminated: - All Apple software, SDKs, APIs, and developer tools - Pre-release versions of iOS, iPad OS, macOS, tvOS, watchOS - Pre-release versions of beta tools such as Reality Composer, Create ML, Apple Configurator, etc. - Notarization service for macOS apps - App Store Connect platform and support (for example, assistance with account transition, password reset, app name issues) - TestFlight - Access to provisioning portal for certificate generation, and provisioning profile generation - Ability to enable Apple services in-app (i.e. Apple Pay, CloudKit, PassKit, Music Kit, HomeKit, Push Notifications, Siri Shortcuts, Sign in with Apple, kernel extensions, FairPlay Streaming) - Access to Apple-issued keys for connecting to services such as MusicKit, DeviceCheck, APNs, CloudKit, Wallet - Access to Developer ID signing certificates and Kernel Extension signing certificates - Developer Technical Support - Participation in Universal App Quick Start Program, including the right to use the Developer Transition Kit (which must be returned to Apple) - Engineering efforts to improve hardware and software performance of Unreal Engine on Mac and iOS hardware; optimize Unreal Engine on the Mac for creative workflows, virtual sets and their CI/Build Systems; and adoption and support of ARKit features and future VR features into Unreal Engine by their XR team The final item is very specific to Unreal Engine so it is clear that this is not simply a template e-mail and was crafted specifically for Epic. Thus we can assume that Apple legal, marketing, the executive team, etc. have pored over every line intently (despite misspelling iPadOS). My guess is that this is intended to enumerate everything that Apple contributes to earn its 30% cut. Epic themselves have now entered this list into the legal record, claiming that it would be incredibly damaging for them to lose access to these features. Perhaps it is now harder for them to argue that Apple's cut is excessive.
- fooey 6y agoBesides the Unreal the game engine, Epic has been making huge inroads leveraging Unreal as a virtual movie set, as seen on Mandalorian. I would assume most of the hardware used in movie production is Mac hardware, so that entire initiative just went up in smoke.
- 6y ago
- redm 6y agoI'm not surprised by this. From Apples perspective, Epic meaningfully bypassed key terms of the App store which have been in force since the App store was created. Epic then turned around and sued Apple. It also became clear they were planning for this sequence to occur, in effect, trying to publicly shame Apple. I think I would be surprised if Apple DIDN'T suspend their accounts. The signing on Mac is just a side effect of loosing dev tools due to Epic's actions. Maybe they should have sued first before taking action that would get them suspended. That said, I am glad someone with the means is pushing back against the 30% App Store rates. I value what Apple provides, but it is excessive for a general computing device (unlike an XBOX, Leapfrog, etc).
- cma 6y agoIf you released an iOS app against the guidelines, such as counting up US drone strikes, wouldn't it suck to have your unrelated OS X apps unnotarized rather than just having your app removed? Notarization was supposed to be about security.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- muststopmyths 6y ago>That said, I do find one aspect of this second suit to be troubling for Epic: Apple is threatening to terminate Epic’s developer account only if Epic doesn’t revert Fortnite to the version that didn’t include its own in-app payment system.[0] Seems perfectly reasonable to me. But Epic's PR game is strong. [0] https://www.thurrott.com/apple/239199/apple-retaliates-against-epic https://www.thurrott.com/apple/239199/apple-retaliates-again...
- tobyhinloopen 6y agoI love a good drama. This is movie material
- mikl 6y agoHard to interpret this as anything but petty spite from Apple’s side. There’s no need to terminate their developer accounts for a violation of the App Store policy, nor does Apple usually do so. I don’t generally like Epic, and used to be a big Apple fanboy, but in this matter, I really hope the judge tears Apple a new one, this kind of abuse of monopoly power needs to end.
- munificent 6y agoThis feels like watching the tech business equivalent to the run-up to WWI. All these giants tangled up in contracts and economic leverage, bristling to carve each other up.
- drawkbox 6y ago> "Millions of developers rely on the Unreal Engine to develop software, and hundreds of millions of consumers use that software," argues Epic. > "Developers that intend to sell their apps for use on iOS or macOS devices will have to forgo the Unreal Engine in favor of other engines," reads the motion. That is what I was expecting after Epic went after Apple. They had to know it would hurt them and all the devs using the engine. Unity many times has feared not being able to build to Apple like in 2010 for the JIT/AOT item which led to more AOT and eventually C++ IL2CPP to get the requirement of native over virtual machine based engines (it was ultimately unnecessary and later Mono included AOT). [1] Epic had to know this would be VERY risky and now they have put all their devs at risk who target iOS. Who knows that type of fallout this will have long term. It is a battle of greed and not better products and that is what sucks. I don't like the way Epic is going about this at all. Not only is Epic being used by Tencent, they are using devs and their engine to mount a greed based attack on Apple. No one is happy fully with all the App Store rules, and likewise no one is happy with all the Epic Game Store rules, but the platform maker has immense power and Epic knew what would happen. They pull the same type of stuff like when they blocked Miguel de Icaza's Mono/C# extension to UnrealEngine. https://twitter.com/migueldeicaza/status/1294445857266372611 https://twitter.com/migueldeicaza/status/1294445857266372611 Yeah I mean look at what Epic/Tencent did, they baited Apple hard. This was a play all along. https://twitter.com/stroughtonsmith/status/1293917929365413895 https://twitter.com/stroughtonsmith/status/12939179293654138... The worst is Epic/Tencent is going about this like they are doing it altruisitcally when their end goal is more power/take. They want their own app store on Apple and they want to have their own approval and their own take (Epic store is 12% as they are trying to catch Steam/Origin/others). Thanks for thinking of the devs Tencent/Epic /s The biggest bummer is I really look up to Tim Sweeney and respect all he has done for gaming. I hate that he ok'd this. Epic has 3 seats on the board and Tencent has 2, with 2 "observers" which are probably Tencent loyal. So at some point along the line Sweeney had to ok this... Looks like the Tencent money leverage got to him. He knew this would cause problems for devs that chose HIS engine. Why Tim Why. The battle of the Tims but ultimately greed that I am sure will lead to regulation that makes it worse for devs long term. [1] https://blogs.unity3d.com/2010/07/02/unity-and-ios-4-0-update-iii/ https://blogs.unity3d.com/2010/07/02/unity-and-ios-4-0-updat...
- 6y ago
- 627467 6y agoWhen will they start erasing apps from people's devices? That's what I'm waiting for. App store is an utility in iOS users hands as such it should be regulated as utilities are.
- bfrog 6y agoApple is looking to squeeze coin out of a stone to keep their stock holders happy and financials looking good, rather than growing their products and customers.
- koiz 6y agocrocodile tears
- ffggvv 6y agoEpic should revoke Apple’s access to unreal engine ;)
- naikrovek 6y agoThe number of Apple fans who don't understand what is happening (I'm talking only about the facts, not opinion) is mind-blowing. "Fan" is short for "fanatic" in this context, and that is an apt description.
- jeffrallen 6y agoChrist, what assholes.
- TYPE_FASTER 6y agoI wonder if Epic could compile UE to WebGL in such a way that games would be playable via web in Safari, not requiring a native app to be installed. Are the limitations of WebGL too intractable for now?
- AlexandrB 6y agoAs usual in these corporate pissing matches, those harmed are the customers. Neither Epic nor Apple come out looking particularly good. Epic's publicity stunt amounts to a marketing ploy and an attempt at hardball negotiation of app store terms. But it does put the negative aspects of Apple's tight-fisted control of iOS software into sharp focus and demonstrates why consumers should be wary of total platform control by a vendor. Stuck in the middle is anyone who enjoys[1] playing Fortnite on their iPhone. I would love to see some kind of class action against both Apple and Epic if Fortnite becomes unusable on iOS as a result of this contract dispute. [1] Disclaimer: I think Fortnite sucks, but customers don't deserve to be used as pawns in a contract negotiation.
- NoPicklez 6y agoHow else do you propose they go after Apple? Go through this process without violating the app store? Then most people would turn a blind eye to the issue because it hasn't actually impacted them. Yes the customer is impacted, but by impacting the customer with the right message Epic can turn their customer base against Apple in the process. Not only does it hurt the customer, but it also hurts Epic by cutting off a massive chunk of their player base.
- AlexandrB 6y ago> How else do you propose they go after Apple? Go through this process without violating the app store? Epic is a huge company with hundreds of millions of dollars in revenue, not some 10-man operation. They can hire lawyers and try to negotiate with Apple for more favorable terms. > Then most people would turn a blind eye to the issue because it hasn't actually impacted them. Imagine if this was happening with Adobe and you're a professional that depends on Adobe products (that you pay a large monthly fee for) to do your job. Would you care who is "right" while your boss is breathing down your neck for that project you can't do because Adobe decided to get in a pissing match with Apple? I think you'd think twice about using Adobe products in the future. So why is it OK for Epic to harm their own customers in an effort to apply pressure on Apple? Personally, I'd feel pretty used. And don't forget. Epic seems OK with continuing to pay Sony/Microsoft 30% on their respective consoles.
- vlod 6y agoWouldn't it be REALLY interesting if Unity stood by Epic? i.e. if Epic is forced to stop making games, Unity will no longer support our engine on Mac either. This I think would put a huge dent in games on the Mac platform. I wonder if Apple would change their mind?
- phendrenad2 6y agoAfter crippling Mac gaming by refusing to allow Vulkan/OpenGL, isn't Mac already a niche platform for gaming? This is just Apple being petty in every way imaginable, even if it doesn't hurt Epic Games at all.
- brainless 6y agoWhen I buy an Apple device, it isn't a computer, it's a rented Apple shelf. That is what this roughly means. Imagine Microsoft saying that I can not install Steam because Steam doesn't agree to MS payment setup. You can't imagine because MS doesn't have that control, it wanted to though, long back. Apple has this control. It is bad for consumers.
- deevolution 6y agoI dont think government intervention is the solution to resolving the problem here. Epic is going to have to abandon Apple and suffer losses. What this exposes is deep centralization of devices and app platforms and its disgusting and I would expect a strong decentralized reaction to follow. It may not be immediate, but it will happen.
- deevolution 6y agoI'm done with Apple. They have lost me as a customer.
- qserasera 6y agoToo little too late. Now there are competing emotive arguments that bury the lede.
- gorgoiler 6y agoI know it’s incredibly wishful thinking, but perhaps an end result of this saga will be for Apple to massively reduce their payment fees. I would love to see Apple Pay deployed to more websites and online stores. It is a real pleasure to use. (The one downside is that it does mean I have to use the same email address for each vendor.)
- amoitnga 6y agoApple is abusive. long words, conversations. I bought a device but do not control it - it's not legal or it shouldn't be.
- captainmarble 6y agoTo bring up unfair issue, epic must first raise the issue legally, fight it in court.. NOT breach TOS first then claim got abused.
- dx034 6y agoThey created urgency. A case otherwise could've taken years for a first decision and would've been purely theoretical. They now need a decision within 14 days and can prove significant damage if the courts rule in Apple's favor (whereas Apple's damage is negligible if they're forced to leave Epic alone for a bit). The court case will be long either way but Epic can now show how harshly Apple reacts to enforcing the 30%, something they couldn't have done before.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fxtentacle 6y agoThis is a wake-up punch to the face for every indie game studio considering iOS. I mean if Apple kicks out Fortnite and rejects access to the Fortnite team, that seems like a reasonable retaliation for Epic breaking their rules. But no, Apple is happily throwing hundreds of thousands of unrelated indie developers under the bus, who started building their next game with the (previously praised by Apple) iOS Unreal Engine and are now unable to release updates and security fixes because Apple is actively preventing Epic from building such fixes for the Unreal Engine. Roughly 10 years ago, I used to be a happy Apple user and developer. Clearly, the current Apple leadership considers iOS developers to be nothing more than expendable minions.
- FriendlyNormie 6y agoShut up you whiny cunt. You should be grateful Apple allows you to distribute your garbage on their devices at all.
- systemBuilder 6y agoI give Apple 6 months before they get broken up as an antitrust Monopoly!
- powerapple 6y agoI can feel Epic's pain, the 30% matters a lot when you are making big money. Giving up 30% of 10 million feels very different than giving up 30% of 10k. Giving the fact that the cost of reviewing apps, maintaining app stores are fixed, Apple should have a cap for each app.
- avinoth 6y agoApple took the "Fire your bad customer" way too seriously...