14 ms·
If you tax them, will they leave?
- carlosjobim 10mo agoThe tax system is made with large incentives for all business owners (from billionaires to small businesses to shareholders like retirees) to invest all profit into expanding their business. If an owner takes out profit, they are punished with high income taxes. So they reinvest in their business, and this is what the government wants because it creates jobs, innovation, products and services, and tax income. So they've been doing what they have been forced to do by the government. And as a consequence their companies are worth a lot. Now the government wants to tax them on the company value?
- michaelsshaw 10mo agoI guess I just totally imagined that $1 trillion pay package for Elon Musk.
- carlosjobim 10mo agoIt's not in the form of salary, if you look it up. So the money is still locked within the company, not taken out as profit.
- ricardonunez 10mo agoIn most recent years they stopped doing part of that equation.
- _1 10mo agoTaxes are not a punishment.
- wiseowise 10mo agoThey are. Look at the Netherlands, they want to implement taxes on unrealized gains.
- jdiff 10mo agoThat's not a punishment.
- danslo 10mo agoIt is as long as they're not refunding you when you make a loss.
- zbentley 10mo agoCouldn’t it just as easily be equivalent to saying “you grew this year, so contribute some money back to society for enabling you to have the educated hiring base/financial infrastructure/physical infrastructure that enabled you to grow”? Like, sure, you don’t owe growth taxes for a quarter when you didn’t grow. But why should you be refunded just because prior taxable growth isn’t denominated in money in a bank account?
- wiseowise 10mo ago> you grew this year, so contribute some money back to society for enabling you to have the educated hiring base/financial infrastructure/physical infrastructure that enabled you to grow Apparently paying for gas, water, electricity, property taxes, taxes on everything you buy isn’t enough, now you have to “contribute for enabling”. What’s next? Pay because they “enable you to breathe”?
- robocat 10mo agoPlus ignoring that our society depends on businesses. I have low opinions about unbalanced one sided arguments.
- wiseowise 10mo agoWhat is it if not a punishment? If you’re a high earner (not obscene earner, mind you) you already pay 50+% in taxes, on top of that you now have to pay even more?
- dolni 10mo agoWhen a significant share of the taxes you pay are mishandled or lost to fraud, yes it is a punishment. That's been happening for a long time in the US. Staggering military industrial complex. Tens of billions lost in COVID relief. Billions lost in Minnesota due to unchecked privatized social welfare fraud (which has been known about for a decade). Some mistakes will happen. What we have is unacceptable. If the government can't handle the money responsibly, it has no business collecting the money.
- jdiff 10mo agoDo you have any sources for either or both of "billions" and "known about for a decade" that aren't a figurehead of the current US administration? Because this all smells a lot like "the immigrants are catching and eating cats and geese" story which also turned out to be a lie.
- germinalphrase 10mo agoThe fraud in Minnesota is upsetting. Fraud also appears to be nationally prevalent: “New federal data released by the U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) shows the overall rate of improper payment in Minnesota’s Medicaid program is far below national averages. In the review released this week, CMS found an error rate of slightly over 2.1%, compared to a national average of 6.1%. The data for the review was compiled before the Minnesota Department of Human Services began implementing new strategies to minimize the risk of fraud and harden its systems against bad actors.” https://mn.gov/dhs/media/news/?id=1053-720779 https://mn.gov/dhs/media/news/?id=1053-720779
- rswail 10mo agoMinnesota is only a drop in the ocean compared to Florida and other states. One of the current FL senators was CEO of one of the companies convicted of a much larger fraud. That's more an indictment of the way you (the US) starve your public services of proper regulatory power with the right level of personnel to handle it. But your Congress voted last year to defund the IRS and the administration are busy gutting the SEC and other regulators. Oh and government fraud has nothing on the commercial and rent-seeker frauds extracting wealth for no benefit from their positions of control. But anti-trust prosecutions are basically a dead path for rectification. Blaming the "government" for what happens from obvious policy failures is the fault of the policies and those that set them, not the "government" as some nameless bureaucracy.
- w4yai 10mo agosay that to trump
- lucaspm98 10mo agoTaxes are often used as either incentives or disincentives for certain behaviors. Examples of incentives are the Child and Dependent Care Credit and EV Tax Credits. An example of a disincentive is a Mansion Tax.
- softwaredoug 10mo agoArguably these and billionaires have become a social menace. They undermine democracy, destroy our environment, and prioritize shareholder value over long term well being of the economy they live in. If they all had unified in one voice against the administration, Trump might be more constrained. They might not be so hated. If they realized, like Henry Ford, that a strong middle class actually is good for THEM too, all this could be avoided. Instead they’re showing up at Melania screenings while average citizens are getting shot in the streets. I don’t think they realize the fire they’re playing with my stomping on the social contract that made them so wealth.
- yetihehe 10mo ago> I don’t think they realize the fire they’re playing with my stomping on the social contract that made them so wealth. Some of them do: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42335797 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42335797 But the pitchforks are coming for 12 years already. They got accustomed to the sight and even put some measures to redirect the masses so they fight each-other.
- Grisu_FTP 10mo agoI just googled confused what a "Melania screening" (Thought it was like a sort of security screening, maybe all the ICE is messing with my head) is. First time i heard about the Movie. This feels like one more step the Trump fam. took to become some sort of celebrity-king thing.
- rswail 10mo agoIt's just grifting, bribery, and extortion. Bezos gave $40m to make the movie. It was a way to maintain his companies position. It's standard oligarch tribute to the godfather. See Russia or Hungary for further examples. The movie cost nowhere near that much to make. Melania got the money. It was her very own little grift, while her husband and his children have been extracting literally billions.
- cucumber3732842 10mo ago>Arguably these and billionaires have become a social menace. They undermine democracy, destroy our environment, and prioritize shareholder value over long term well being of the economy they live in. Sadly, I'm far more worried about a thousand people who make a million bucks than I am about one guy who makes a billion. You don't get to the B number by not being pretty darn shrewd and sociopathic so those guys must be pretty evil but man have the "upper middle class" or "professional managerial class" or whatever you wanna call the "comfortable enough to not think about the harsh economic realities of their ideas" class been an unmitigated disaster for western society over the past 20-70yr depending on how you wanna measure.
- RGamma 10mo agoAnd not investing in society has some consequences as well... Increasingly it seems big business is bad business (again).
- mhitza 10mo agoThe double irish, single malt, capital allowances for intangible assets. If everyone would be able to play these tax avoidance schemes I'm sure society would collapse. For big players these are easy schemes and somewhere this untaxed wealth must be recaptured. Just favoring the rich further accelerates the wealth imbalance.
- carlosjobim 10mo agoThat of course depends on what you mean by "society". But everybody is able to reinvest profits into a business they have, whether that's an industry giant, or a tiny one-man shop. There is no government on planet Earth which considers that to be "tax avoidance". Governments want profits to be reinvested and not paid out to owners, even the most socialist governments you can find. If you're against this, then you shouldn't talk about taxes. You should rather talk about abolishing private property completely.
- igogq425 10mo ago> That of course depends on what you mean by "society". Yes, that is the old discrepancy between society in the true sense and society as imagined by libertarians. A few strangers waiting together for the bus do not constitute a community. If the bus is canceled and they organize a carpool, then a community has formed. If you scale this up and replace personal relationships with institutions, you have a useful concept of society. For libertarians, society is any large gathering of people who interact with each other in some way (or not), even if they rape and devour each other. If you understand society in this way, it cannot collapse (or is constantly collapsing).
- carlosjobim 10mo agoIf we remove from life everything that people have access to by industrialization and mass production, then many or most people would say that "society" has collapsed. That would be the consequence of taxing ownership in companies, since there would be no reason to invest to create big companies. And for industrial society you need big companies. You need giant companies, and taxing owners on the size of the company means that people will not invest their money or effort build industrial scale companies. The other way to have industrialization is to instead have a command economy, where the government mandates what is to be done.
- zbentley 10mo ago> Now the government wants to tax them on the company value? I’m genuinely baffled at the incredulous tone here. Yes, that is exactly what should happen: laws, subsidies, and incentives enable a company to grow and flourish. Then, as the company grows, other laws incentivize it to give some of its state-sponsored affluence back to benefit the country. Like, sure, the execution of that process is often dysfunctional, but the fundamental contract there does not seem like it should be surprising to people: we don’t have (many) socialist state-owned businesses, but the point of a functioning country is still to provide good things to the people living in it. Not to benefit businesses or a tiny sliver of the population. That’s why we have everything from income taxes to interstate highways: to distribute wealth and resources to (a flawed approximation of, but it’s still the goal) everyone in the country. That’s just how non-corrupt governments are supposed to work!
- carlosjobim 10mo ago> give some of its state-sponsored affluence back Then why not tax the military? They are surely the most affluent company of them all, if you take a tally of all their inventory. If you tax companies based on their size rather than their profits, then you're not going to have any big companies. Any investor or entrepreneur would be a fool to invest in making a big company. But many endeavours need big companies and big investments. For example power plants. That's a whole lot of value to tax, such affluence! Better redistribute this wealth, and instead have a hundred thousand non-affluent hot dog stands. > That’s just how non-corrupt governments are supposed to work! In practice, every government in the world does not tax companies reinvesting their profit into growth.
- zbentley 10mo ago> why not tax the military? Narrowly: because they're a utility funded by taxes, not an independent entity benefiting from tax-funded infrastructure. Having a military for defense/power projection/whatnot is one of the infrastructural benefits of being part of a state (and one of the things that a company that grows in that state "owes" the state tax money for--whether that's owed on growth or just capital). Like, do I personally think my country's military should have a vastly different funding profile, incentives, and behavior? Absolutely. But that doesn't change the fundamental dynamic: $state provides $thing (security, clean water, cheap gas, whatever) that makes being in $state good for many people, people who do well financially within $state owe it money back on the basis that their doing well is at least partially a result of $thing being available to them. > Any investor or entrepreneur would be a fool to invest in making a big company. Not true. A growth tax need not be a 100% tax, so growth would still be an advantageous thing to do. Many countries have tax brackets today; that doesn't discourage people from getting rich.
- igogq425 10mo agoUltimately, an economy is all about the side effects you describe (goods and services for the population). The fact that, while producing these side effects, the machine also leads to massive wealth accumulation among a small number of people is another side effect that basically has nothing to do with the core tasks of the economy. The question now is how to evaluate this additional side effect. If it does not have any negative consequences, it can be ignored. If it does, it should be counteracted. It's like in a combustion engine. Oil has to be added for the engine to work. But over time, dirt particles, metal abrasion, soot, and combustion residues accumulate in the oil, overwhelming the oil filter and reducing its lubricating ability. If you don't reset it to a “healthy” basic state at regular intervals, it gets so bad that it prevents the engine from operating and ultimately even destroys it. Does the massive wealth inequality we see today cause problems that lead to the erosion of society itself? I would say yes, definitely. Of course, it is frustrating for these people when the money they have generated is taken away from them. But let's look at it realistically: if someone has $100 billion and $99 billion is taken away from them, they are still in a situation where they lack nothing financially. At some point, you've played capitalism through to the final level. And then you should put down the controller and go outside to listen to the birds chirping instead of frantically chasing after the growth of a number that, due to its sheer size, no longer has any concrete meaning, apart from the fact that there may be two other people whose numbers are bigger or who are hot on your heels.
- carlosjobim 10mo ago> Does the massive wealth inequality we see today cause problems that lead to the erosion of society itself? I would say yes, definitely. On a side note. Yes, the massive wealth inequality is eroding society. But billionaires aren't the source of this problem. They are outliers, freaks if you so will. The real problem is the massive wealth inequality is the gigantic prices of real estate and rent, created by the monetary system being based on real estate instead of productivity. That means it is very hard for a person to claw and scratch her way to equality if they're not born with real estate or gets that benefit at an early age. For most, their irredeemable mistake in life was choosing to be born in the wrong decade. At the same time a huge percentage of the population who has never made any effort in life and generally have no talent or any admirable qualities, get great wealth and comfort by having been born at the right time. For every billionaire there is a a hundred thousand of the kind of person described above. Most of us have them not far away, and they have a hundred fold bigger impact on our lives than any billionaire. And at least many billionaires have at least accomplished or done - something - in their life. > At some point, you've played capitalism through to the final level. And then you should put down the controller and go outside to listen to the birds chirping instead of frantically chasing after the growth of a number that, due to its sheer size, no longer has any concrete meaning, apart from the fact that there may be two other people whose numbers are bigger or who are hot on your heels. Wouldn't building a rocket to go to Mars for example be such an endeavour, which is bigger than chasing the imaginary dollar number? Or the philanthropic endeavours of other famous billionaires? Or even exacting political influence in the shadows, which is probably something all known and unknown billionaires do?
- meekrosoft42 10mo agoThey certainly have had that effect in Norway: https://www.brusselsreport.eu/2024/09/11/the-failure-of-norways-wealth-tax-hike-as-a-warning-signal/ https://www.brusselsreport.eu/2024/09/11/the-failure-of-norw...
- mcny 10mo agoMeh. Good riddance.
- WithinReason 10mo ago$146M expected increase in tax revenue turned into $594M loss, good riddance to taxes as well I guess?
- dv_dt 10mo agoNorway also ranks as seventh happiest nation in the world. Correlation or causation? https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/happiest-countries-in-the-world https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/happiest-...
- antonymoose 10mo agoSmall, homogenous, a generous welfare system, and with a massive sovereign wealth fund thanks to wise oil exploitation.
- 10mo ago
- rvz 10mo agoTLDR: yes. Case study: New York City, United Kingdom, France, Germany, Denmark… The list goes on until they choose; Texas, Florida, Singapore and Dubai.
- ReluctantLaser 10mo agoPerhaps I missed it, but your TL;DR seems like a personal view rather than what is in the article. Do you have sources for your claims?
- coderjames 10mo agoNot OP, but one example I can think of: Jeff Bezos moved from Washington state to Florida two years after Washington enacted a 7% capital gains tax "on the sale or exchange of long-term capital assets such as stocks, bonds, business interests, or other investments and tangible assets"[1] which "reportedly helped him save $1 billion in taxes."[2] [1]: https://dor.wa.gov/taxes-rates/other-taxes/capital-gains-tax https://dor.wa.gov/taxes-rates/other-taxes/capital-gains-tax [2]: https://finance.yahoo.com/news/jeff-bezos-moved-florida-impacted-104522418.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/jeff-bezos-moved-florida-impa...
- rvz 10mo agoIt’s not really hard to see such a migration if you simply follow the money. See [0] and [1] [0] https://www.forthcapital.com/uk/articles/2025-wealth-migration-why-a-record-16-500-millionaires-are-leaving-the-uk-and-where-theyre-going https://www.forthcapital.com/uk/articles/2025-wealth-migrati... [1] https://www.henleyglobal.com/publications/henley-private-wealth-migration-report-2025/country-wealth-flows https://www.henleyglobal.com/publications/henley-private-wea...
- lucaspm98 10mo agoThere's plenty of studies on this. There's unsurprisingly a modest but statistically significant migration of millionaires from high-tax to low-tax jurisdictions. https://www.asanet.org/wp-content/uploads/attach/journals/jun16asrfeature.pdf https://www.asanet.org/wp-content/uploads/attach/journals/ju...
- michaelsshaw 10mo agoHere's a better question: do we need them? I'll answer it for you: no. Let them leave. We still have the resources and the productivity. The fact that some asshat that doesn't do fuck all doesn't get to scrape profits for himself is just another advantage, aside from just not having these annoying billionaires around. People need to open their minds to the idea of us just taking their shit for ourselves.
- TheChaplain 10mo agoI believe the level will simply be adjusted then, the middle class end up being heavier taxed. But that is usually a fairly large group, and if they feel taxes are too much, they will listen to any politician that promises a solution. Then it can become pretty nasty...
- koe123 10mo agoThis question is always strikes me as a false dichotomy, i.e. "we have to tax them, or else they leave". The issue is in my view is that constructing a system where the existence of such a rich class has become necessary to raise enough tax revenue. Organizing your country with more sustainable growth where income disparities aren't so high means you don't have this problem to this extent.
- chipgap98 10mo agoWho said "we have to tax them, or else they leave"? That doesn't seem to be what anyone is saying. The issue is that this group is threatening to leave if they are taxed. I agree you should want to avoid having an income disparity like this, but we are where we are. The goal of this tax is to help correct that disparity.
- oklahomasports 10mo agoNot a legitimate goal. But yeah if the government needs revenue they should raise it.
- drorco 10mo agoThen the next question is why does wealth, in practically all industrious countries seem to distribute disproportionally and not uniformly? One argument could be that maybe entrepreneurial personality traits aren't normally distributed, and unless you find a way change people's personalities in mass, the imbalance in wealth attraction will remain inherent. Then you might ask, if that's true, do you I want to enforce equality, potentially dragging down the economy to mediocracy (for example many stagnating European economies) or maybe accept that current nature does not meet our societal desire for equality.
- mcntsh 10mo ago> Then the next question is why does wealth, in practically all industrious countries seem to distribute disproportionally and not uniformly? It's simply because money is compoundable. The more money you have the more you can make, and the more you make means less other people have.
- dzonga 10mo agoat one point Taxes in the US were 70-90%. did the people ever leave ? NO
- m463 10mo agoyou can leave state taxes. For example GWB "lived" in texas the whole time he worked in washington.
- dzonga 10mo agonow that's next level scumbaggery
- mcntsh 10mo agoYou could argue that the world is way more globalized today.
- servo_sausage 10mo agoKind of a false statement; on paper it was higher, but the exemptions were also significantly much bigger and more nakedly biased. So it's not like it was actually a tax on the wealthiest, more a targeted tool to apply state power.
- gruez 10mo ago>at one point Taxes in the US were 70-90%. That figure is highly misleading to cite by itself because the high tax rate also came with a bunch of loopholes and exemptions. That's why despite the drop in the headline rate of 70-90% or whatever, the actual tax take as % of GDP has remained remarkably steady in the past 7 decades. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFRGDA188S https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FYFRGDA188S
- jungturk 10mo agoThis chart shows total tax receipts as a percent of GDP, which doesn't seem to address the poster's contention that historically the rich paid a higher share of those receipts through elevated marginal tax rates.
- sschueller 10mo agoIf the OECD decided collectively to tax them there is no where to leave to. They decided on a minimum global cooperate tax, then they can do that same for those 1%. Of course there are still countries where one could park their money outside the OECD members but many of those are not exactly a "safe" place for such assets.
- rswail 10mo agoThey tried, Trump rolled it back.
- shrubby 10mo agoLocal wealth tax works to some extent, but some will dodge as long as this is not universal. But universal is what we need as humanity. The will seems to be building up, even in the UK (Polanski) and US (Mamdani, AOC, Sanders). I'm betting that the success will be replicated in other countries soon and after that its only a matter of time for this to go global. But this will be interesting show.
- uqual 10mo agoIMHO "this seems to be building up" in the US is a bit of an overstatement. Mandami, AOC, and Sanders are the laughing stock of much of the electorate in the US. They are fairly popular in progressive population centers but not elsewhere. There have been activists promoting much the same ideas for my entire life (and I'm not young!) and they rarely if ever get national traction. The "silent majority" in the US is just that - they don't make the news because they, in most cases, don't go out and protest and engage in battles with law enforcement. They have jobs, go to work, go home to their families, and vote - but they rarely are seen in the news any more than the fact the sun came up in the East and set in the West yesterday is "newsworthy" enough to be promoted in the media. "If it bleeds, it leads" is the criteria for being newsworthy.
- shrubby 10mo agoThe silent majority, also know as the banality of the evil, is waking up. Until masks and Musks we're taken off this year it was possible to pretend that the normal would play into their hands, as long as they stayed silent and played along. Now pretending that the middle class can survive under the zillionaires Reich is only possible for very delusional minority. My hunch is that Mamdani and Polanski have struck this nerve. Already before the events in Minneapolis, but now the support for this is dwindling. I've done some experiments here in the normal and even the well off people are seeing the root cause. And it being the narcissist individuals holding godlike power, instead of the good ole "rule based" or "value based realism" or "systemic change" or even the latest "superorganism". But remains to be seen, I might be wrong or even worse the power can be so centralized to zillionaire cliques.
- 10mo ago
- samiv 10mo agoIn a healthy economy flow of money is like the flow of blood in the arteries. It is what stimulates the economic activity. You can't earn a dollar without someone spending that dollar. Spending = earning = economic activity. People are always defending rich people (capital owners) that they invest their wealth. But actually if someone has a billion in the bank the fact that they have that billion is a proof that they didn't invest it. (If they did spend it or invest it the would not have it, now would they?) A billion that circulates in the economy is much better than a billion that sits in someones bank account. Someone who spends 100% of their income is much better economic citizen than someone who doesn't.
- trollbridge 10mo agoA billion in the bank is invested - that's how fractional-reserve banking works. And people that wealthy don't really just put their money "in the bank". They usually invest it in riskier things. I would hesitate to call consumption "better" than investment.
- Tarq0n 10mo agoSort of, with at least two caveats. 1) velocity of money matters, some spending creates more economic activity than others due to re-spending. 2) Investment is not the same as having your money sitting idle. Investment makes certain activities possible because of scale, payment made with the expectation of future value, financing capital goods or R&D, etc.
- deleted 10mo ago[deleted]
- TheOtherHobbes 10mo agoThere are literally two economies - the one most people live in, and the asset owning economy which deals exclusively in land, property, resources, and shares. The health of an economy is defined by the permeability of the border between those two classes, and the direction of flow. If the flow is mostly one way, you're getting wealth extraction, not investment. But assets are not easy to move. So if you tax assets and not income, it doesn't matter where the owners are. It only matters where the assets are.
- nsoonhui 10mo agoLet's do a thought experiment and take it to the extreme: why not tax at the maximum? We have already tried that in human history, it's called communism. No one is allowed to take private profit, everyone contributes to the best of their own ability, and everyone consumes according to their needs. It should be utopia because there is no wealth gap and wealth is maximally redistributed. Which is exactly what taxation is designed to do, only to the most extreme. And I think everyone will agree with me that communism is a miserable failure. The rich may not leave physically but mentally they are checkout -- not willing to work as hard or take as much risk. So the answer is yes, if you tax them, most certainly they will leave physically for haven with lower tax, all things being equalled. Or leave mentally. But not all things are equalled, so you can still tax them at a somewhat higher rate provided that you can provide other incentives. But still, too much tax will make it more likely for those who are able to to leave. This is almost an axiom.
- samiv 10mo agoCommunism has never been tried at a large scale. Soviet Union didn't have it. China doesn't have it. Just because someone has "communism" on paper doesn't mean the society actually functions according to the communist idea. Social democracy has been tried in many places and it has produced things such as the Nordic Model and the Nordic states that have been very successful. After the 2nd World War USA was very close to socialism. High wealth taxes, workers unions etc. As a result your average worker had a lot of purchasing power which of course fuels economic strength. In fact many if the world's best performing companies are a kind of exercise in socialism since the RSU programs share ownership and results of the company to the workers (even if it's a small share)
- RGamma 10mo agoOkay so there is a globally optimal point/region of taxation that is not "maximum taxation". Where is it?
- jbboehr 10mo agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laffer_curve https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laffer_curve
- sschueller 10mo agoHow about instead of taxing them any differently than now, we prevent them from borrowing against their assets? Force them to sell their assets and pay capital gains.
- romanovcode 10mo agoThe book about rules and regulations on this law would be larger than divorce law book.
- jermaustin1 10mo agoOr better than that, loans backed by assets above some "jumbo" threshold ($10M?) triggers a capital gain on those assets in the collateral. So if you get a $150M loan off of your amazon shares that on paper are worth $150M, but you paid $100M, you have a cap-gain of $40M, and at 20% tax, $8M fills the IRS's coffers.
- uqual 10mo agoThis is something I've been in favor of for some time. Obviously the tax basis in the assets would also be stepped up by this action. The US should also get rid of the step up in basis at death. The recipient of an illiquid asset such as a family business should have a period of time (perhaps five or ten years from the triggering death depending on the type of asset) to "pay up" the tax basis "to market" at the time of death. Gains in liquid assets (such as publicly traded stock) should be taxed at the market value at the time of death by the estate or trust and passed on to beneficiaries with that adjusted tax basis.
- jermaustin1 10mo ago> The US should also get rid of the step up in basis at death. This would actually fix the issue without my suggestion, but it is a harder pill to swallow for the "soon to be rich" Americans that tend to vote against their current economic interests.
- 10mo ago
- MSFT_Edging 10mo agoThe greater issue is we allow the richest to basically print money via their stock based compensation, which allows them to turn unrealized gains into loans backed by these stocks. They can spend that all they want to influence politics and wield illegitimate power. If they can spend this wealth, they can be taxed on it. Make stock buybacks illegal again too. Overturn Citizen's United unless the head of the company can face charges for the actions of their company. The concentration of wealth into the highest strata is a recipe for societal collapse seen multiple times in history.
- gruez 10mo ago>The greater issue is we allow the richest to basically print money via their stock based compensation, which allows them to turn unrealized gains into loans backed by these stocks. How's this different than if CEOs or whatever were paid in cash, and then they immediately bought stocks with the cash?
- MSFT_Edging 10mo agoBecause you had an income to tax. The stock compensation is to avoid paying taxes on their income.
- jonas21 10mo agoYou owe the same amount in income taxes regardless of whether you're paid in stock or cash. I think you're confusing this with the case where founders or early employees own large amounts of stock that they received early on in the company. They paid little to no taxes when they received it because it was worth basically nothing at the time. Later, the company has grown and it's worth a lot, so they have a large unrealized gain that they can use as collateral for loans. But that certainly wasn't guaranteed to happen. Most startups fail.
- knollimar 10mo agoDon't you pay taxes on those when they vest?
- 10mo ago
- ifwinterco 10mo agoShort term: no Long term: yes, especially if you combine really high taxes in the 40+% range with consistently rubbish public services But the real question is not whether people will leave, the question is how many talented hard working people chose not to move to your country in the first place because your taxes were too high. It won't show up in any data, you'll just experience worse economic growth and have to tax everyone else more
- thinkingtoilet 10mo agoThe answer is just no. Massachusetts passed a tax on income over a million dollars and despite the ads that were obvious lies, we have more millionaires now than we did a few years ago. Turns out, rich people like to live in places that have well funded infrastructure, good schools, a thriving art scene, etc...
- ifwinterco 10mo agoYep people will pay rates in "high tax" US states where you're still only paying ~40% ish total income tax and they're really nice places to live. That would still be considered a fair and reasonable level of tax by european standards. Obviously there is a level though - if you made it 95% then people would leave. I don't think there's any reasonable argument that the level doesn't exist, the question is where is it for a specific place at a specific time
- thinkingtoilet 10mo ago95% on what? Income over a million dollars. Income over 10 million dollars? If you like living in a super liberal state and super liberal city like Boston, you're not going to move to Texas just because you're getting taxed higher. Rich people are still absurdly rich, I feel like that gets lost in these discussions. These taxes don't materially effect them in anyway but have massive benefits for society.
- ifwinterco 10mo ago
- ksec 10mo agoThe problem with this question is they never mentioned or specified who is "they". Especially in UK where The Rich that dont belongs to UK in the first place will of course move and leave. Those who are born and raised are highly unlikely to move. And perhaps most importantly the question completely ignore the real problem. There isn't a lack of Tax revenue, but the government incompetence to allocate and use it wisely. To raise tax is just saying what we are doing now is absolutely correct and we will continue to do so.
- Finnucane 10mo agoMass. passed a high-income surtax a few years ago, with the result that we raied a lot of funds for schools & infrastructure, and we atill have plenty of rich people. Wealthy people hate paying taxes, but after paying, they're still pretty wealthy. And, some of them like living in a state with decent schools, health care, etc. https://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2025/11/17/do-millionaire-surtaxes-lead-to-millionaire-exodus/ https://www.peoplespolicyproject.org/2025/11/17/do-millionai...
- mercutio2 10mo agoWealth taxes are very, very different from higher income taxes. People are mad about buy-borrow-die, so they’re proposing extraordinary new measures. Personally, I’d just make capital gains taxes apply at the “borrow” stage to actually fix the problem. That would have a host of compliance issues but they’d be localized in the finance industry which already has an army of people figuring out compliance.
- Finnucane 10mo agoBut they made exactly the same arguments against it, and it was bullshit.
- SilverElfin 10mo agoThere needs to be less concentration of wealth and power for our societies to work. Taxing the ultra wealthy should be a nationwide bipartisan project. At the same time, California isn’t the right place for this experiment because it will not solve the fundamentals problem of their government spending and wastefulness.
- fzeindl 10mo agoThey probably won‘t. I recently watched a talk (in german) with Julia Friedrichs, who wrote a book about millionaires and billionaires and did many interviews with them: https://www.youtube.com/live/4HpJKPywXqY?si=bb-p558jl_otP25I https://www.youtube.com/live/4HpJKPywXqY?si=bb-p558jl_otP25I In her research she found that many of the ultra-rich people actually have deep/patriotic/nostalgic ties to their home/community and want to invest there. They often use certain tax-evasion measures because everybody else does and she argued that those few ultra-rich people who really just care about minimizing their taxes have already moved everything abroad.
- epolanski 10mo agoThis made me research how much taxes would a wealthy californian pay assuming: - 2.5M worth of real estate bought recently - 1M of job income - 1M selling shares that 10xed (some stock option idk) - driving a 150k $ car - spending 150k $ over the years in taxable goods It came around 840'000 $ or around 40.1 %. I wouldn't say it's that bad, this even includes sales taxes (probably the fairest of all taxes). With even basic tax optimization (401k, federal deductions) you get that number down to 780'000 $, with something a bit more sophisticated depending on circumstances you can get it easily lower than 600k or 32% ish. The biggest problem is that people above that tier end up effectively paying less sometimes even in absolute terms just by borrowing against their equity and not triggering taxable events. Honestly taxes are complicated to implement, I'm not sure how can you implement a progressive yet fair system without loopholes and without severely degrading services (roads, infrastructure, education, healthcare, military, etc, etc). And every time you decide to cut on services, you are just moving money elsewhere: more inequality -> more social tensions and criminality, you just end up paying way more to live in a safe place and pay for private and public security and prisons. It's really difficult.
- Yizahi 10mo agoI can't say how much such a person should pay in taxes, but it is kinda funny that I'm paying the same amount 39.5-40% with my five digit salary and no property. I don't know who should pay what amount, but I'm pretty sure that me and that millionaire should have different tax brackets. Let alone people with tens, hundreds of millions or more. PS: I'm in EU, not USA, but here I'm in a highest tax bracket so the point still stands, my tax rate is the same as for any local millionaire. Maybe even more, since those people are aggressively utilizing tax loopholes, shell corporations and offshore tax havens.
- apelapan 10mo agoYou pay the same proportion, not the same amount. 40% of 1M is 10x more than 40% of 100k. Disregarding all technicalities about what proportion people actually end up paying after performing clever tax planning. Why are you sure that someone earning 1M should have higher proportion of their income taken away than someone earning 100k? At some sufficiently low level of income I think it stops making sense collecting taxes, but beyond that I'm not so sure from a fairness-perspeective. I could perhaps get on board with a hard cap on wealth, for preserving democracy. It is dangerous to have single individuals and families attain too much power. But up to that cap, I don't see any inherent unfairness or inefficiency in that people of moderate to high wealth pay the same proportional rate.
- fundatus 10mo agoDo people move solely because of property taxes? They rarely do unless they are in financial distress. So I'd say: Give it a try.
- interestpiqued 10mo agoBillionaires tend to have multiple properties in multiple states/countries. This is more a residency issue and probably low friction for them to change states personally. The thing holding back would be where their business and employees are located.
- JKCalhoun 10mo agoIf they're not paying their fair share of taxes in the state anyway… then okay, goodbye, I guess?
- Hizonner 10mo agoIt's worth a shot.
- mlhpdx 10mo agoI don’t want to believe for a second anyone would walk away from Silicon Valley because of being taxed. The impact on the calculus of reward simply doesn’t make sense. On the other hand I am always surprised by people and the strange things we do.
- uqual 10mo agoMost people, by count, of course would not leave because of the wealth tax currently being proposed in California as it targets just a tiny segment of the population - current estimates are that less than 250 Californians, or less than 0.001%, would pay the currently proposed statewide wealth tax. The other 99.999+% would not (yet) have to pay a wealth tax. However, the <0.001% that (esp. the wealthiest among them) who would pay the wealth tax would be motivated to move. Unfortunately for California about 40% of the total state income tax collected (which accounts for about 65% of the state general fund) is paid by the top 1% of income earners -- which includes those 0.001% who will be motivated to move by a wealth tax (or even merely the threat of one). The <0.001% number appears to be based on population _before_ several billionaires moved out before Jan 1, 2026 - likely at least partially motivated by the small, but real, risk of the "billionaire's tax" qualifying for the ballot and passing (and that proposed tax is only "temporary" and is only a total of 5% over three years so isn't nearly as alarming to the wealthy as a "permanent" tax would be). If it looks like this measure will end up on the ballot and have a chance of passing, expect many more to leave. This will, even if it does not ultimately pass, erode the income tax base. California has rebelled against wealth taxes in the past - most notably by the passage of Prop 13 almost 50 years ago (a property tax is a wealth tax). They are not popular except when the hit "the other guy" -- but "the other guy" is the one most able to avoid the tax. Wealthy people are typically very flexible as to where they live. They often already own multiple homes and often spend a lot of time out of the state they "live" in. When they move, they are not packing and labeling their own boxes or are likely even present on "moving day". They also are more likely to set up HQ and shop near where they spend a lot of their time. Even if they have family in California, they can still get together with them for Thanksgiving dinner -- either by flying the family to them on their private and chartered jets or by themselves flying to California for the weekend on one of their jets. They can conduct most business very efficiently remotely and often do so now to a significant extent. It only takes a few to leave to tank the California budget - likely causing the progressive income and wealth taxes to reach deeper and deeper into the upper middle classes as California desperately tries to balance their budget without cutting yet more programs. Other states are loving this though and will cut tax deals to attract these very billionaires that California are encouraging to leave.
- klasko 10mo agoyes
- rayiner 10mo agoThe article asserts that, since this is a one-time tax, billionaires will have no incentive to leave: "The tax’s designers, however, think they’ve come up with a clever solution to capital flight: a one-off tax that is retroactive, based on a billionaire’s residency status on January 1, 2026. In other words, unless they’ve already fled the state, billionaires won’t be able to move to avoid paying the tax. 'At this point, there’s no financial incentive to leave California,' Zucman said. 'You’re going to pay the same amount either way.'" That misses the point. A one-time wealth tax to plug holes in the state's finances reeks of short-termism and desperation, like Chicago selling off its parking meters. Even if I wasn't affected by the tax, I'd be alarmed at the implication. It would have been much better to implement a well thought out and orderly recurring tax on capital gains or whatever.
- jleyank 10mo agoState taxes can be dodged by moving. Federal (US) taxes are supposed to be filed each year no matter where US-ians live. They can work games to not pay the US but that either requires "no formal income" or living where taxes are higher than the US. Or, I guess, just don't deal with the US and either don't go there, or hope to not get caught.
- junofan 10mo agoIf you read the article, the author frames the discussion around a retroactive tax in California applying to those resident in California as of January 1, 2026 so that it cannot be dodged by moving. Also, the words “US”, “US-ian”, “American” appear zero times. The word “federal” appears one time. I think this comment is a little off-topic.
- everybodyknows 10mo agoThose who pay the tax will assume the "one-off" label is false: if it works once, it will be repeated. On my block alone, are the houses of (at least) two "49-percenters". 183 or a few more days of the year the owners are at their second homes in Arizona or Nevada, and gathering gas station receipts to prove it, while their California houses sit empty -- all just to avoid our state income tax. How about that as a poster-child for misallocation of physical capital?
- marcosdumay 10mo agoLast time I checked, rich people tended to not be very cost sensitive.
- rdtsc 10mo ago> Start-ups and venture-capital investment could begin to flow to lower-tax states; the next hub of technological innovation may end up being seeded in Austin or Miami instead of Silicon Valley. There is another agent (group of agents) in this game and that's other states. Those states are often modeled as passive background places one can move to, but they are often not. They can, and do, react to tax laws in other states. For example, TX could encourage capital flight by offering tax breaks. I've seen this happen with some companies in Midwest: as the states had to raise taxes some Southern states decide to poach individual companies and offered them to move their HQs there with a bunch of tax rebates and credits and such. > The tax’s designers, however, think they’ve come up with a clever solution to capital flight: a one-off tax that is retroactive, based on a billionaire’s residency status on January 1, 2026. That is pretty clever. They could also have an "exit tax" -- "leave but if you've been here for 10 years making your billions, we'll keep some of those billions" kind of a deal.
- jibal 10mo agoCorporations and billionaires routinely lie in order to maximize their wealth. After all, why not ... they aren't bound by scruples.
- ggfdh 10mo ago> That left a roughly $20 billion annual shortfall in California’s health-care budget. … In response, one of the state’s largest health-care-employee unions teamed up with a group of progressive economists and lawyers to come up with a way to make up the difference: impose a one-off 5 percent wealth tax on California’s billionaires. It’s wild how dominant this proposal is. Not reducing costs. Not cutting benefits. Not a broader tax increase. Not a combination of ideas. Just “f*k these guys in particular.” If this is what passes for governance in California I’d leave too.
- knowitnone3 10mo ago[flagged]
- tomhow 10mo agoWe asked you only a few days ago to observe the guidelines. HN is for curious conversation, not political battle. We have to ban accounts that keep posting like this. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- thunderfork 10mo agoWhy would a state's worth of people give up health care so that billionaires could retain more assets?
- theendisney 10mo agoSeems a good investment. ROI is obvious and guranteed. Some might prefer progressing [say] add/fin tech over heathcare but it seems fine to ignore. Its not like they are really suffering. There is a disrupt joke inthere but i cant think of it right now.
- gamblor956 10mo agoYears ago I had a client, a European billionaire, who moved to California because the taxes were "so low" compared to his home country. (The difference was only a few percent, and yes he had lived in Vegas with its 0% income tax before moving to California.) He's still here, and unlike the PAB SV billionaires, he has no plans to leave because he's seen what places with no/low taxes are like. (TLDR: they have low taxes because nobody would want to live there otherwise. )
- Acrobatic_Road 10mo agoHe doesn't sound very smart.
- mips_avatar 10mo agoAll these billionaires are comparing their problem to difficulties Norwegians have managing their finances with the wealth tax there. The difference being that the wealth tax in Norway kicks in after a few hundred thousand dollars of wealth so regular people actually contend with it. Like even the most successful startup founders likely won’t ever pay the wealth tax before reaching a liquidity event.
- rekabis 10mo agoAmerica in the 1950s had a 90% tax on the top tier. No-one of consequence fled the country. No matter how you tax, the asset-owning class is almost guaranteed to remain in place, because the vast majority of their assets are physical, and cannot be easily moved except at much greater expense than any tax. I mean, if offshoring took 75 years to achieve, what makes you think that any member of the Parasite Class will be able to pack up and leave within a decade, much less a half decade? It costs ridiculously insane amounts of money to move a business down the street, and you’re keeping the same employees, and not re-training an entirely new batch of replacements in the new location. About the only “asset” that can “leave” with anything approaching sub-decade immediacy are the purely digital ones, with a business that is 100% Internet-based and without any physical assets of any kind, where you can spin up a new offshore server and migrate the services to it with just a few mouse clicks. And those are vanishingly few in number. Most so-called “Internet companies” still have oodles of physical assets, from offices (where return-to-office mandates force employees back into) to land to physical servers sitting in data centres. And in the end, we have the most telling question: what is the difference with the wealthy leaving due to a tax, and failing to implement that tax in the first place? NOTHING. There are no downsides, only upsides. Either they leave and open up room for another entrepreneur to thrive in that spot, or they stay and pay the tax. Either way, nothing of value is lost by wealth taxation.
- ImJamal 10mo agoWhat percentage of those in the top tier paid anywhere close to 90%?
- lwhalen 10mo agoWhy not abolish all taxes and have the Treasury/Fed print the difference every year?
- jaimex2 10mo agoIf their accountants and financial advisers tell them to of coarse they will. Furthermore given whats at stake you would divert 1/10th of those funds to making sure that act never passes.
- weare138 10mo agoNo they won't, at least not for long. Every company that tries it immediately learns what those taxes were paying for. Go ahead, try running your tech company in a state with no infrastructure and see how that works out for you.
- angelfangs 10mo agoIt's all fun and games until it affects one's bottom line. Similarly to AI, only now are progressives in the position of being the naysayers because it affects them directly. Everyone has their agenda (and that's okay to a point), but the moral posturing about these types of issues is sickening.
- kghrhgf 10mo agosure is easy to get sickened by strawmen