24 ms·
Sora is here
- sjm 2y agoAnyone else find this stuff extremely distasteful? "Disrupting" creativity and art feels like it goes against our humanity.
- ganzuul 2y agoIt is like an attempt to do psychic battle over the meaning of "disruption".
- ronsor 2y agoI'm glad someone else said this. Hopefully we can get rid of that terrible disruptive camera too.
- quenix 2y agoThe past few years' innovation in AI has roughly been split into two camps for me. LLMs -- Awesome and useful. Disruptive, and somewhat dangerous, but probably more good than harm if we do it right. 'Generative art' (i.e. music generation, image generation, video generation) -- Why? Just why? The 'art' is always good enough to trick most humans at a glance but clearly fake, plastic, and soulless when you look a bit closer. It has instilled somewhat of a paranoia in me when browsing images and genuinely worsened my experience consuming art on the internet overall. I've just recently found out that a jazz mix I found on YouTube and thought was pretty neat is fully AI generated, and the same happens when I browse niche artstyles on Instagram. Don't get me started on what this Sora release will do... It changed my relationship consuming art online in general. When I see something that looks cool on the surface, my reaction is adversarial, one of suspicion. If it's recent, I default to assuming the piece is AI, and most of the time I don't have time or effort to sleuth the creator down and check. It's only been like a year, and it's already exhausting. No one asked for AI art. I don't understand why corporations keep pushing it so much.
- WXLCKNO 2y agoI understand your take but it's only going to get better and incredibly fast. I'm a huge film nerd and I can only dream of a future where I could use these type of tools (but more advanced) to create short films about ideas I've had. It's very exciting to me
- huehehue 2y agoThere's this FinTech ad on the NYC subway right now. I can't remember the company, but the entire ad is just a picture of a guitar and some text. Anyway, the guitar is AI generated, and it's really bad. There are 5 strings, which morph into 6 at the headstock. There's a trem bar jammed under the pickguard, somehow. There's a randomly placed blob on the guitar that is supposed to be a knob/button, but clearly is not. The pickups are visually distorted. It's repulsive. You're trying to sell me on something, why would you put so little effort into your advertising? Why would you not just...take a picture of a real guitar? I so badly want to cover it up.
- DebtDeflation 2y agoJust need to add a hand with 6 fingers strumming it and it could be a meme.
- wumeow 2y agoReminds me of the new Coca Cola Christmas ad which is equally off-putting.
- moralestapia 2y ago"And then everyone clapped ..." There's nothing wrong with technology going forward and this doesn't go against "creativity and art", to the contrary, it will enhance it.
- TheAlchemist 2y agoThat's the optimistic version and in theory I would agree - it will be a great enhancer of creativity for some poeple. But mostly it will end up like the smartphones - we carry more computing power in our pockets that was used to send man to the moon, and instead of taking advantage of it to do great things, we are glued to this small screen several hours / day scrolling social medias nonsense. It's just human nature.
- tim333 2y agoThere's some of that but it produces some cool stuff too. I mean you have these new virtual worlds like this that didn't exist before https://youtu.be/y_4Kv_Xy7vs?t=13 https://youtu.be/y_4Kv_Xy7vs?t=13 The video there is kind of a combination of human design and AI which produces something beyond that which either would come up with on their own.
- joshdavham 2y agoCurious, what kinds of things are you all gonna make with Sora? Personally, I think I'll just be making weird memes to send to my friends!
- PunchTornado 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- owenpalmer 2y agoMKBHD's review of the new Sora release: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OY2x0TyKzIQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OY2x0TyKzIQ
- laweijfmvo 2y agoLove the callout of them definitely training on his own videos
- danpalmer 2y ago...which they shouldn't have been able to get? I had thought that it was against the YouTube ToS? (my personal understanding, unrelated to my employer)
- Havoc 2y agoAI companies don’t give a shit about ToS. Hell most of the big players actively ignored copyright entirely in bulk. See thousand upon thousands of pirated books in the pile dataset. And right after that news broke they “fixed” the problem by stopping to disclose training data sources. Thats why early models had papers eg Llama 1 listed this and now nobody does. It’s just an unspoken yet open secret now.
- paxys 2y agoIf AI companies respected ToS there would be no AI
- toomuchtodo 2y agoFrom "12 Days of OpenAI: Day 3" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2jKVx2vyZOY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2jKVx2vyZOY (live as of this comment)
- bbor 2y agoOver now, and pretty short/light on info AFAICT. That said, knowing what we know now about Altman made me physically unable to watch while he engages in sustained eye contact with the camera, so maybe missed something while skimming! On the upside, I'm so glad we have three billionaires cultivating three different cinema-supervillain vibes (Musk, Altman, & Zuckerberg). Much more fresh than the usual "oil baron" aesthetic that we know from the gilded age
- optimalsolver 2y agoWish they’d followed their previous MO of releasing stuff with no warning or buildup. Results won’t match the hype.
- cooper_ganglia 2y agoI feel like announcing a new product in the same vein as your main product as an established company is almost always a bad idea. If you're going to improve your product, don't announce the improvements 6-12 months ahead of time and grow the hype to unmanageable levels, just announce a great product and tell them it's available starting today.
- echelon 2y agoThey're already too slow. Hunyuan Video came out a few days ago and beats them on every metric. Hunyuan is 100% open source and it's set to become the Stable Diffusion / Flux of AI video. https://github.com/Tencent/HunyuanVideo/ https://github.com/Tencent/HunyuanVideo/
- transformi 2y agoNot impressive compare to the opensource video models out there, I anticipated some physics/VR capabilities, but it's basically just a marketing promotion to "stay in the game"...
- Geee 2y agoWhat's the best open source video model right now?
- minimaxir 2y agoHunyan (https://replicate.com/tencent/hunyuan-video https://replicate.com/tencent/hunyuan-video , $0.70/video) is the best but somewhat expensive. LTX (https://replicate.com/fofr/ltx-video https://replicate.com/fofr/ltx-video , $0.10) is cheaper/faster but less capable. Both are permissively licensed.
- treesciencebot 2y agoHunyuan at other providers like fal.ai is cheaper than SORA for the same resolution (720p 5 seconds gets you ~15 videos for $20 vs almost 50 videos at fal). It is slower than SORA (~3 minutes for a 720p video) but faster than replicate's hunyuan (by 6-7x for the same settings). https://fal.ai/models/fal-ai/hunyuan-video https://fal.ai/models/fal-ai/hunyuan-video
- cooper_ganglia 2y agoHunyuan is a recent one that has looked pretty good.
- bbor 2y agoI... can you explain, or point to some competitors...? To me this looks leagues ahead of everything else. But maybe I'm behind the game? AFAIK based on HuggingFace trending[1], the competitors are: - bytedance/animatediff-lightning: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12706 https://arxiv.org/pdf/2403.12706 (2.7M downloads in the past 30d, released in March) - genmo/mochi-1-preview: https://github-production-user-asset-6210df.s3.amazonaws.com/164923711/378799737-4d268d02-906d-4cb0-87cc-f467f1497108.mp4 https://github-production-user-asset-6210df.s3.amazonaws.com... (21k downloads, released in October) - thudm/cogvideox-5b: https://huggingface.co/THUDM/CogVideoX-5b https://huggingface.co/THUDM/CogVideoX-5b (128k downloads, released in August) Is there a better place to go? I'm very much not plugged into this part of LLMs, partially because it's just so damn spooky... EDIT: I now see the reply above referencing Hunyuan, which I didn't even know was its own model. Fair enough! I guess, like always, we'll just need to wait for release so people can run their own human-preference tests to definitively say which is better. Hunyuan does indeed seem good
- yeknoda 2y agoI've found using these and similar tools that the amount of prompts and iteration required to create my vision (image or video in my mind) is very large and often is not able to create what I had originally wanted. A way to test this is to take a piece of footage or an image which is the ground truth, and test how much prompting and editing it takes to get the same or similar ground truth starting from scratch. It is basically not possible with the current tech and finite amounts of time and iterations.
- cube2222 2y agoAgreed. It’s still much better than what I could do myself without it, though. (Talking about visual generative AI in general)
- JKCalhoun 2y agoYeah, but if I handed you a Maxfield Parrish it would be better than either of us can do — but not what I asked for. I find generative AI frustrating because I know what I want. To this point I have been trying but then ultimately sitting it out — waiting for the one that really works the way I want.
- cube2222 2y agoFor me even if I know what I want, if I’m using gen AI I’m happy to compromise and get good enough (which again, is so much better than I could do otherwise). If you want higher quality/precision, you’ll likely want to ask a professional, and I don’t expect that to change in the near future.
- fngjdflmdflg 2y agoSerious question: is this better than current text-to-video models like Hailuo?
- TheRealPomax 2y ago[flagged]
- fngjdflmdflg 2y agoThe page says "coming soon." I guess I'm wondering if there are any benchmarks or other way to compare this to current models.
- barbazoo 2y agoWe'll probably know once they release it.
- TheRealPomax 2y agoeven if there were supposed benchmarks or comparisons, you wouldn't know if they were reliably until you can actually try it and see what it does how you'd use it.
- meetpateltech 2y agoPricing: Plus Tier (20$/month) - Up to 50 priority videos (1,000 credits) - Up to 720p resolution and 5s duration Pro Tier (200$/month) - Up to 500 priority videos (10,000 credits) - Unlimited relaxed videos - Up to 1080p resolution, 20s duration and 5 concurrent generations - Download without watermark more info: https://help.openai.com/en/articles/10245774-sora-billing-credits-faq https://help.openai.com/en/articles/10245774-sora-billing-cr...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- cube2222 2y agoWorth noting here that this is the existing ChatGPT subscription, you don’t need a separate one.
- jsheard 2y agoCalled it, they were sitting on Sora until the $200 tier launched. Between the watermarking and 50 video limit the $20 tier is functionally a trial.
- dbspin 2y agoWow they're watermarking videos and limiting them to 720 at the 20 dollar price point? That's a bold move, considering their competition's pricing... https://www.klingai.com/membership/membership-plan https://www.klingai.com/membership/membership-plan Quality seems relatively similar based on the samples I've seen. With the same issues - object permanence, temporal stability, physics comprehension etc, being present in both. Kling has no qualms about copyright violation however.
- minimaxir 2y agoAt OpenAI's $20/mo price point, you can also only generate 16 720p 5s videos per month. Kling doesn't seem to have more granular information publically but I suspect it allows for more than 16 videos per month.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pearjuice 2y agoThough I like the novelty of AI generated content, it kind of sucks dead internet theory is becoming more and more prevalent. YouTube (and all of the web) is already being spammed with AI generated slop and "better" video/text/audio models only make this worse. At some point we will cross the threshold of "real" and "generated" content being posted on the web and there's no stopping that.
- xena 2y agoMy hope was that AI would make it easier for people to create new things that haven't been done before, but my fear was that it would just be an endless slop machine. We're living in the endless slop machine timeline and even genuine attempts to make something artistic end up just coming off as more slop. I love this timeline.
- visarga 2y agoEven if it's made with AI, it is slop only if you don't add anything original in your prompt, and don't spend much time selecting. The real competition of any new work is the backlog of decades of content that is instantly accessible. Of course it makes all content less valuable, you can always find something else. Hence the race for attention and the slop machine. It was actually invented by the ad driven revenue model. We should not project on AI something invented elsewhere. Even if gen AI could make original interesting works, the social network feeds would prioritize slop back again. So the problem is the way we let them control our feeds.
- minimaxir 2y ago> if you don't add anything original in your prompt Define "original". You could generate a pregnant Spongebob Squarepants and that would be original, but it would still be noise that doesn't inherently expand the creative space. > don't spend much time selecting That's the unexpected issue with the proliferation of generative AI now being accessible to nontechnical people. Most are lazy and go with the first generation that matches the vibe, which is the main reason why we have slop.
- 2y ago
- minimaxir 2y agoNo API/per video generation? Huh.
- owenpalmer 2y agoIt's probably because they're relying heavily on their new editing UI to make the model useful. You can cut out weird parts of the videos and append a newly generated potion with a new prompt.
- Tiberium 2y agoOpenAI almost always waits a few months before adding new features or models to the API, the same happened to DALL-E 3, advanced voice mode, and lots of smaller model updates and releases.
- rvz 2y agoThat’s around more than 20+ VC-backed AI video generation startups destroyed in a microsecond and scrambling to compete against Sora in the race to zero. Many of them will die, but may the AI slop continue anyway.
- hagbarth 2y agoNot really a microsecond. Sora was announced months ago.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoIt’s a race to zero margin. The people who win will have lots of existing distribution channels (customers) or lots of money or control over data. Those who innovate but don’t have these things will be copied and run out of money eventually, as sad is it is. The competition between those startups and bigger players isn’t fair.
- marban 2y agoNot available in the EU: https://help.openai.com/en/articles/10250692-sora-supported-countries https://help.openai.com/en/articles/10250692-sora-supported-...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- blfr 2y agoWhat did the EU do this time?
- mnau 2y agoProbably this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_Intelligence_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Artificial_Intelligence_Act, possibl this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Markets_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Markets_Act
- tomschwiha 2y agoI believe Sora is also not available in the UK, so it's rather maybe a decision to handle load better?
- therealmarv 2y agoDoes VPN solves the problem? I'm living in an EU country and I don't like that the EU decides for me (and companies like OpenAI or Meta don't give out their models to me)! I'm an old enough adult to decide for myself what I want...
- ionwake 2y agoI used a Japanese protonVPN , I got past the "Not in the EU" thing but it said "no new signups are allowed atm". Perhaps just best to wait
- cube2222 2y agoThere’s an ongoing related livestream[0]. [0]: https://youtu.be/2jKVx2vyZOY https://youtu.be/2jKVx2vyZOY
- patrick0d 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- acureau 2y agoI hope we get unlimited access for the reasonable price of a car note
- mhh__ 2y agoUnless they drop something mega in the next few months can't help but think that openai's moat is basically gone for now at least.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- anonzzzies 2y agoYep, haven't used chatgpt seriously in many months; I check it with our coding toolkit every so often, but it just performs so much worse than Claude on everything we do...
- gzer0 2y agoFor the $20/month subscription: you get 50 generations a month. So it is included in your subscription already! Nice. For the Pro $200/month subscription: you get unlimited generations a month (on a slower que).
- system2 2y agoI wonder what I will be doing with 20 garbage videos. And this probably includes revisions too. It takes 10 attempts to get something remotely useful as an image (and that's just for a blog post).
- iamleppert 2y agoYawn, there are literally 10 different apps and wannabe startups that do video generation and AI videos have already flooded social media. This doesn't look any better than what is and has been already available to the masses. OpenAI announced this ages ago and never did give people access, now competitors have already captured the AI generated video for social media slop market. We have yet to see any kind of AI created movie, like Toy Story was for computer 3D animation. OpenAI isn't a player in the video AI game, but certainly has bagged most of the money for it already (somehow).
- keiferski 2y agoDon't just critique - link. What other video generation tools have you used and recommend?
- Workaccount2 2y agoThe subreddit /r/aivideo has tons of videos all tagged with what model was used to generate them.
- LanceJones 2y agoSo you're saying there is literally nothing good about Sora?
- einsteinx2 2y agoUnless we’re reading completely different comments, that’s not at all what they said. They said OpenAI waited too long to release it and their competitors beat them to the punch with similar quality offerings and have already cornered the social media AI slop market.
- vunderba 2y agoFrom the few videos that I've seen, I would agree that it doesn't seem to be better than any of the major competitors such as Kling, Hailuo, Runway, etc.
- petercooper 2y agoI wonder what it is about EU and UK law, in particular, that restricts its availability there. Their FAQs don't mention this. If it's about training models on potentially personal information, the GDPR (EU and UK variants) kicks in, but then that hasn't restricted OpenAI's ability to deploy (Chat)GPT there. The same applies to broader copyright regulations around platforms needing to proactively prevent copyright violation, something GPT could also theoretically accomplish. Any (planned) EU-specific regulations don't apply to the UK, so I doubt it's those either. The only thing that leaves, perhaps, is laws around the generation of deepfakes which both the UK and EU have laws about? But then why didn't that affect DALL-E? Anyone with a more detailed understanding of this space have any ideas?
- ilaksh 2y agoPart of it might also be capacity problems.
- Stevvo 2y agoIt's a capacity related constraint, not a legal one.
- simicd 2y agoHmm enough capacity for the rest of the world but not EU: https://help.openai.com/en/articles/10250692-sora-supported-countries https://help.openai.com/en/articles/10250692-sora-supported-...
- MrKristopher 2y agoA lot has changed since ChatGPT was released. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Markets_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Markets_Act wasn't in effect back then. Microsoft hadn't made their big investment yet either. OpenAi is a growing target, and the laws are becoming more strict, so they need to be more cautious from a legal perspective, and they need to consider that compliance with EU laws will slow down their product development.
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoLink should be annoucement post: https://openai.com/index/sora-is-here/ https://openai.com/index/sora-is-here/
- aspenmayer 2y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42368981 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42368981
- dang 2y agoOk, we changed the URL to that from https://sora.com/ https://sora.com/ above.
- chefandy 2y agoIf you're looking for video for casual personal projects or fill-ins for vlog posts, or something to make your PowerPoint look neat, this seems like a rad tool. It has a looong way to go before it's taking anyone's movie VFX job.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- MyFirstSass 2y agoWow this is bad. And by bad i mean worse than leading open source and existing alternatives. Is it me or does it seem like OpenAI revolutionized with both chatGPT and Sora, but they've completely hit the ceiling? Honestly a bit surprised it happened so fast!
- kranke155 2y agoSora was not really that big of a revolution, it was just catching up with competitors. I would even say in gen video they are behind right now.
- pawelduda 2y agoWhat is the best model in your opinion right now?
- ElectroNomad 2y agoRunwayML
- echelon 2y agoHunYuan by Tencent. It's 100% open source too.
- kranke155 2y agoThere are a lot of them, but Runway seems to have good controls and they are aligned with people who will actually use it - filmmakers and content creators. In terms of image quality. Runway, Luma, and a few of the Chinese models all give "ok" results. I haven't seen anything from Sora to convince me they have done any kind of significant leap. The issue there is alignment. It's cheap for Runway or Luma to continue in this path since it's their only path to profitability, they do nothing else. But for OpenAI, I don't think this is near their top list of priorities. I doubt that they will be able to keep adding features like their competitors. Seems to me like this is the equivalent of a side project for them. edit after watching direct comparison videos, I've changed my mind. Sora is ahead.
- 2y ago
- rushingcreek 2y agoAs there was no mention of an API for either Sora or o1 Pro, I think this launch further marks OpenAI’s transition from an infrastructure company to a product company.
- metzpapa 2y agoIt seems like there going that direction - especially the way they setup the Sora interface, It feels its nearing a video editing product.
- colesantiago 2y agoHollywood's days are numbered. If you are a creative in this industry, start preparing to transition to another industry or adapt. Your boss is highly likely to be toying around with this. The first entirely AI generated film (with Sora or other AI video tools) to win an Oscar will be less than 5 years away.
- smithcoin 2y ago> entirely What would you like to wager on this?
- do_not_redeem 2y agoI'd take that bet at 10:1 odds.
- onlyrealcuzzo 2y agoI'd be careful. OpenAI could be a big enough bubble in less than 5 years to buy the Oscar winner, even if the film is terrible. Also, OP only said "an Oscar". The Oscar committee could easily get themselves hyped enough on the AI bubble, to create an AI Oscar Film award. No one said anything about making a "good" movie.
- mdp2021 2y ago> OP only said "an Oscar" ...For soundtrack. (Sorry.) But seriously: like the democratization which made music production cheap brought some interesting or commercially successful endavours, the increased effort from people who could not bring their dreams to reality because of the basic constraint of budget will probably bring some very good results, even anthology worth - and lots of trash.
- whynotminot 2y agoNothing I'm seeing here looks like it's going to destroy Hollywood. I could see this tool maybe being used for generating establishing shots (generate a sweeping drone shot of a lighthouse looking out over a stormy sea), but then the actual talent work in a scene will be way more sensitive. The little details matter so much, and this feels so far from getting all of that right. Sure, this is the worst it will ever be, things will improve, etc, but if we've learned anything with AI, it's that the last mile is often the hardest.
- droidrat 2y ago[dead]
- neom 2y agoIn July I made this 3 minute little content marketing video for Canada Day. Took me about 40 minutes using a combo of midjourney + pika, suno for the music. Honestly I had a lot of fun making it, I can see these tools with be fun for creative teams to hammer out little things for social media and stuff: https://x.com/ascent_hi/status/1807871799302279372 https://x.com/ascent_hi/status/1807871799302279372 I don't see sora being THAT much better than pika now that I'm trying both, except that it's included in my openai subscription, but I do think people who do discreet parts of the "modal stack" are going to be able to compete on their merits (be it pika for vid or suno for music etc)
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pen2l 2y agoEvery day that passes I grow fonder of Google's decision to delay or otherwise keep a lot of this under the wraps. The other day I was scrolling down on YouTube shorts and a couple videos invoked an uncanny valley response from me (I think it was a clip of an unrealistically large snake covering some hut) which was somehow fascinating and strange and captivating, and then scrolling down a few more, again I saw something kind of "unbelievable"... I saw a comment or two saying it's fake, and upon closer inspection: yeah, there were enough AI'esque artifacts that one could confidently conclude it's fake. We'd known about AI slop permeating Facebook -- usually a Jesus figure made out of unlikely set of things (like shrimp!) and we'd known that it grips eyeballs. And I don't even know in which box to categorize this, in my mind it conjures the image of those people on slot machines, mechanically and soullessly pulling levers because they are addicted. It's just so strange. I can imagine now some of the conversations that might have happened at Google when they choose to keep a lot of innovations related to genAI under the wraps (I'm being charitable here of their motives), and I can't help but agree. And I can't help but be saddened about OpenAI's decisions to unload a lot of this before recognizing the results of unleashing this to humanity, because I'm almost certain it'll be used more for bad things than good things, I'm certain its application on bad things will secure more eyeballs than on good things.
- quenix 2y agoIt saddens me. Innovations in AI 'art' generation (music, audio, photo) have been a net negative to society and are already actively harming the Internet and our media sphere. Like I said in another comment, LLMs are cool and useful, but who in the hell asked for AI art? It's good enough to fool people and break the fragile trust relationship we had with online content, but is also extremely shit and carries no meaning or depth whatsoever.
- mojuba 2y agoI think AI "art" can be as useful as the text generators, i.e. only within certain limits of dull and stupid stuff that needs to exist but has little to no value. For example, you need to generate a landing page for your boring company: text, images, videos and the overall design (as well as code!) can be and should be generated because... who cares about your boring company's landing page, right?
- ren_engineer 2y agoforced to finally release after that new open source model came out that was equal or better?
- remoquete 2y agoAh, yes. We definitely needed another bad dreams generator.
- andybak 2y agoInteresting creative people will produce interesting creative output. People with no taste will produce tasteless content. The mountain of slop will grow. And some of us have no intention of publishing any output whatsoever but just find the existence of these tools fascinating and inspiring.
- remoquete 2y agoWhile it's indeed fascinating, part of me finds the sheer energy expenditure to be problematic, not to mention the "Hollywood is dead" innuendos.
- gburdell3 2y agoAnd some of us have no intention of publishing any output and find the existence of these tools extremely worrying and problematic.
- crakhamster01 2y agoInteresting creative people are currently creating interesting output _without_ generative AI. These tools are fascinating, though I can't help but feel that the main benefactor after all is said and done will be venture capitalists and tech/entertainment execs.
- LeoPanthera 2y agoThis seems pretty broken at the moment, I haven't actually managed to create a video, every prompt results in "There was an unexpected error running this prompt".
- knicholes 2y agoAt least you get to even see the page! I'm seeing "Sign ups are temporarily unavailable We’re currently experiencing heavy traffic and have temporarily disabled sign ups. We’re working to get them back up shortly so check back soon."
- ilaksh 2y agoI can't even sign up. I assume it's a capacity issue.
- tacticalturtle 2y agoSomething about that image of the spinning coffee cup with sailing ships is giving me severe trypophobia: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trypophobia https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trypophobia It’s a like a spider’s eyes… and also not what I would expect a latte to look like.
- throw4321 2y agoOne of the problems with a 10-month preannouncement is that the competition is ready to trash the actual announcement. Half an hour in, I already see half a dozen barely-concealed posts ranging from downplays to over-demands to non-user criticism.
- rtsil 2y agoI think that's just the typical HN cynicism.
- abenga 2y agoI don't think you can reduce it to this. Even on the showcase videos on the home page I can see weird artifacts, like the red car in the video of the guy walking through a market. The car is driving on a pedestrian walkway (through pedestrians), and just suddenly disappears from one frame to another.
- manquer 2y agoAlso the tennis player walking through the net
- minimaxir 2y agoThe competition is ready to trash the announcement because the 10-month delay gave rise to several viable competitors, and that would still be the case if OpenAI never did the preannouncement. If OpenAI released Sora 10 months ago, there wouldn't be as much cynicism.
- madihaa 2y agoAccount creation currently unavailable
- topherjaynes 2y agoyea just that that too. Did anyone get in or did they get overwhelemed?
- HaZeust 2y agoDoesn't look like you will. "We’re currently experiencing heavy traffic and have temporarily disabled sign ups. We’re working to get them back up shortly so check back soon."
- zb3 2y agono API = not good enough no pay per use = overpriced
- zb3 2y agonot available in the EU = might use everything you did there against you, sell that data to the higgest bidder
- einsteinx2 2y agoI was under the impression that the EU had other regulations related to AI generated content that affects OpenAI and presumably Sora other than just privacy stuff.
- ulrischa 2y agoIt will not be available in the EU for now. I always feel disadvantaged when I read that sentence
- simicd 2y agoAnd in the UK and Switzerland unfortunately https://help.openai.com/en/articles/10250692-sora-supported-countries https://help.openai.com/en/articles/10250692-sora-supported-...
- andz 2y agois it a regulatory issue?
- simicd 2y agoI suspect so, OpenAI is subject to the EU AI Act [0]. Last time they released the Advanced Voice Mode it also took some time before it became available in the EU. Not sure why UK and Switzerland are delayed as well, they are not in the European Union. [0] https://openai.com/global-affairs/a-primer-on-the-eu-ai-act/ https://openai.com/global-affairs/a-primer-on-the-eu-ai-act/
- hmmm-i-wonder 2y agoI'm not in the EU, but when I see something that is US only, I tend to assume its doing something with privacy/user data/otherwise that is restricted in the EU. Which means I generally avoid things that are not EU available even if they are available to me. Its not 100% but its a fairly decent measure of how much companies care about users to ensure they meet EU privacy laws from the start, vs if they provide some limited version or delayed version to the EU.
- xvector 2y ago[flagged]
- 2y ago
- joshstrange 2y agoOpenAI is a masterclass in pissing off paying customers. I'm just about ready to cancel my ChatGPT subscription and move fully over to Claude because OpenAI has spit in my face one too many times. I'm tired of announcements of things being available only to find out "No, they aren't" or "It's rolling out slowly" where "slowly" can mean days, weeks, or month (no exaggeration). I'm tired of shit like this: Sign ups are temporarily unavailable We’re currently experiencing heavy traffic and have temporarily disabled sign ups. We’re working to get them back up shortly so check back soon. Sign up? I'm already signed up, I've had a paid account for a year now or so. > We’re releasing it today as a standalone product at Sora.com to ChatGPT Plus and Pro users. No you aren't, you might be rolling it out (see above for what that means) but it's not released, I'm a ChatGPT Plus user and I can't use it.
- EliBullockPapa 2y agoI really don't think it's reasonable to expect them to onboard what is likely tens of thousands of sign ups in the first hour.
- minimaxir 2y agoChatGPT has far, far more concurrent users than tens of thousands. Sora is not a small hobby project by an amateur hacker that blew up.
- joshstrange 2y agoI don't disagree, what I'm asking for is "truth in advertising". I'm not saying they need to give everyone access on day 1, I'm saying don't _say_ you've given everyone access if you haven't.
- zlies 2y agoIs there information when it will be available in other countries, like Germany for example?
- LukaD 2y agoWhat do you mean? “Sora is here” is not enough? Sorry for the sarcasm but I’m just tired of this fuck Germany attitude by certain companies.
- null_investor 2y agoI hope somebody pays 100.000 pro subscriptions and uses AI to request Sora to generate videos 24/7. Maybe Elon? Even if they use queues, I'm sure they are running at a loss and the GPU time is going to cost 100x more than what they charge. Creating false demand for AI can easily bankrupt their business, as they will believe people actually want to use that crap for that purpose.
- adultsthroaway 2y agoGenuinely curious who is doing this for adult content? Complaints about Sora's quality and prompt complexity likely not as important to auteur's in that category, especially with ability to load a custom character etc
- minimaxir 2y agoSora (along with DALL-E 2 well before it) specifically has safeguards against NSFW content.
- fosterfriends 2y agoAnyone else feeling their servers melt a bit on sora.com?
- seydor 2y agoeven in this mammoths demo, the dust clouds keep popping behind them even after they have moved forward
- Imnimo 2y agoI feel like there is a sweet spot for AI generation of images and videos that I would describe as "charmingly bad", like the stuff we got from the old CLIP+VQGAN models. I feel like Sora has jumped past that into the valley of "unappealingly bad".
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- halyconWays 2y agoI think that's why humor and memes are such good targets for this type of stuff. If you look up videos like "luma memes compilation," it takes well-known memes and distorts them in uncanny, freaky, and bizarre ways. Yet the fact the original subject is a meme somehow bypasses the uncanny valley repulsion. We seem to accept that much more readily, for whatever reason.
- ilaksh 2y agoThis is actually a different version from what they had before. What they released today is Sora Turbo.
- therein 2y agoAccount creation not available. Login to see more videos. Classic OpenAI. I don't care, there are so many better alternatives to everything they do. Funny how quickly they have become irrelevant and lost their moat.
- natvert 2y agoanyone done a comparison with the open-source hunyuanvideoai.com?
- tetris11 2y ago0 stars, and no comments the last time this was posted. Maybe too good to be true?
- natvert 2y agoI've ran hunyuanvideoai from their GitHub and it seems to generate realistic videos. It is a bit slow (30-60min per video clip) and requires ~50GB VRAM. I wonder how the quality compares though?
- natvert 2y agooh, and the output videos that are generated are 5sec clips at 554x960px. this is on a single A6000
- tetris11 2y agoIt looks good, I'm just wondering why it has no attention from the ML community
- echelon 2y agoHunYuan is all everybody on Banodoco and the broader comfy ecosystem are talking about. And that's with Lightricks' LTX model having just been announced too. HunYuan is seriously amazing and it looks like it'll be the Flux/Stable Diffusion of AI video. Sora is cooked.
- msp26 2y agoIt depends on where you're looking haha.
- echelon 2y ago
- dartos 2y agoThe most impressive part is the temporal consistency in the demo videos. He flower one is the best looking.
- jrflowers 2y ago“Right before the TikTok ban goes into effect” is incredible market timing for the release of a tool that is useless for anything other than terrible TikTok spam videos
- jeroenhd 2y agoHey now, no need to downplay the product here, it's also useful for spamming other video sharing platforms! Think Facebook timelines, which are already full of AI image barf, Twitter feeds, which mostly consist of AI text barf, and Youtube Shorts, which is full of existing AI animation barf! Soon, lots of people can pay a modest sum to make the internet just a worse for everyone in exchange for a chance to make their money back!
- simonw 2y agoI got lucky and got in moments after it launched, managed to get a video of "A pelican riding a bicycle along a coastal path overlooking a harbor" and then the queue times jumped up (my second video has been in the queue for 20+ minutes already) and the https://sora.com https://sora.com site now says "account creation currently unavailable" Here's my pelican video: https://simonwillison.net/2024/Dec/9/sora/ https://simonwillison.net/2024/Dec/9/sora/
- ByThyGrace 2y agoDid you notice the frame rate (so to speak) of what's happening down the lake is much lower than the pelican's bicycle animation?
- vletal 2y agoImage details 9/10 Animation 3/10 Temporal consistency 2/10 Verdict 4/10
- rjtavares 2y agoOne of the highlights of any model release for me is checking your "pelican riding a bicycle" test.
- echelon 2y agoFor those who can't try Sora out, Tencent's super recent HunYuan is 100% open source and outperforms Sora. It's compatible with fine tuning, ComfyUI development, and is getting all manner of ControlNets and plugins. I don't see how Sora can stay in this race. The open source commoditization is going to hit hard, and OpenAI probably doesn't have the product DNA or focus to bark up this tree too. Tencent isn't the only company releasing open weights. Genmo, Black Forest Labs, and Lightricks are developing completely open source video models, and that's . Even if there weren't open source competitors, there are a dozen closed source foundation video companies: Runway, Pika, Kling, Hailuo, etc. I don't think OpenAI can afford to divert attention and win in this space. It'll be another Dall-E vs. Midjourney, Flux, Stable Diffusion. https://github.com/Tencent/HunyuanVideo https://github.com/Tencent/HunyuanVideo https://x.com/kennethlynne/status/1865528133807386666 https://x.com/kennethlynne/status/1865528133807386666 https://fal.ai/models/fal-ai/hunyuan-video https://fal.ai/models/fal-ai/hunyuan-video
- cryptozeus 2y agoRaises billion dollar, claims of agi by 2025, cannot handle new user sign up traffic.
- manquer 2y agoBillion is table stakes , OpenAI has raised over 6 billion dollars this year alone
- sota_pop 2y agoWhy has “table stakes” become such a popular phrase in the last 12-24 months?
- manquer 2y agoHas it? It is a gambling term, most VC funded startups are gambles, AI ones particularly so, it felt apt. perhaps it correlates to a raise in investing that no longer is based on sound fundamentals in both traditional and new age assets(like crypto) perhaps makes people identify more with gambling.
- sota_pop 2y agoI was neither criticizing your comment nor choice of words - I actually agree with both. Was just curious about the phrase. Your guess seems like a good one!
- iLoveOncall 2y agoThis is by design, they want the news articles saying "this is so popular it crashed their website!"
- cryptozeus 2y agoStrange way to advertise no ?
- pritambarhate 2y ago
- exe34 2y agoregarding all the comments about physics, I wonder if a hybrid approach would work better, with an llm generating 3d objects that interact in a physics simulation with guiding forces from the LLM and then another model generating photo realistic rendering.
- topaz0 2y agoGentle reminder that it's important to boycott this kind of thing.
- tgv 2y agoThis, and similar tools, make the world a worse place, just so a handful can get the big bucks. This is not technological progress, it's greed. Ethics is a dirty word.
- gavindean90 2y agoWhy?
- lacoolj 2y agoA little worried how young children watching these videos may develop inaccurate impressions of physics in nature. For instance, that ladybug looks pretty natural, but there's a little glitch in there that an unwitting observer, who's never seen a ladybug move before, may mistake as being normal. And maybe it is! And maybe it isn't? The sailing ship - are those water movements correct? The sinking of the elephant into snow - how deep is too deep? Should there be snow on the elephant or would it have melted from body heat? Should some of the snow fall off during movement or is it maybe packed down too tightly already? There's no way to know because they aren't actual recordings, and if you don't know that, and this tech improves leaps and bounds (as we know it will), it will eventually become published and will be taken at face value by many. Hopefully I'm just overthinking it.
- highwaylights 2y agoI’d be more worried about the inevitable “we’re under nuclear attack, head for shelter” CNN deepfakes.
- evan_ 2y agoOr “go kill every member of $marginalized_group you can find”
- icepat 2y ago> The sinking of the elephant into snow - how deep is too deep? Should there be snow on the elephant or would it have melted from body heat? Should some of the snow fall off during movement or is it maybe packed down too tightly already? Should there be an elephant in the snow? The layers of possible confusion, and subtle incorrect understandings go much deeper.
- m3kw9 2y agoA minimum setting video took an hour 480p 5s 1:1. Servers getting cooked
- unraveller 2y agoIs it better or just more distracting away from it's flaws and using flaws to advantage? I only see repulsive mouth movements to induce fear, face coverings to hide the uncanniness, dreamy physics sim to distract. Not so out of place in present day hollywood but never any coherence of feeling.
- jack_pp 2y agoI'm surprised they put in 2 legged poodles
- goykasi 2y agoA bit off-topic, but how much does a 4-letter (or less) .com go for these days? I wonder if they bought this via an intermediary so that the seller wouldnt see "OpenAI" and tack on a few zeros. edit: previously, this thread pointed to sora.com
- silvestrov 2y agoHis review video is so much better than the announcement video at explaining what has been released.
- geor9e 2y agoPretty off-topic, but yes, domains and land are often bought via shell companies for this reason. They probably didn't settle upon the name Sora until they already secured the .com . That's a famous YC piece of advice. If you can't get the .com then rename. But for domains that everyone wants, like chat.com, OpenAI paid 8 figures for that one.
- midasz 2y agoHuh didn't realize chat.com redirected to chatgpt
- wslh 2y ago"We are currently experiencing heavy loads..."
- inoffensivename 2y agoGreat. In a world awash with disinformation, we're making it easier to create even more of it. I don't see any good coming from tools like these.
- sergiotapia 2y agosorry for the tangent: can't remember a launch they've had where you could just use it. it's always "rollout", "later this quarter", "select users", what's the deal here? it's given openai this tinge to me that i probably won't ever manage to forget.
- vinni2 2y agoAccount creation currently unavailable
- adregan 2y agoWhy keep building AI to do the things that people find fun to do rather than the mundane bullshit? All we’ll be left with is cleaning, folding laundry, and doing the dishes while AI does all the interesting things.
- amelius 2y agoBecause we don't have as much data about mundane bullshit.
- bronco21016 2y agoHow do we get it? Serious question. The take makes sense but how do we digitize doing the dishes?
- sandwichsphinx 2y agonot dishes but the other day I saw this recent papers for clothes >RoboHanger: Learning Generalizable Robotic Hanger Insertion for Diverse Garments https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.01083 https://arxiv.org/abs/2412.01083 >To overcome the challenge of limited data, we build our own simulator and create 144 synthetic clothing assets to effectively collect high-quality training data. the strategy is simulation
- andrewstuart 2y agoSo we are now a few years into the AI video thing. I'm curious to know - is it actually useful for real world tasks that people/companies need videos for?
- siliconc0w 2y agoI may be the only one but this kinda breaks my brain in that I notice weird physics anomalies in these but then I start to look for those in non-AI produced video and start to question everything. Hopefully this a short term situation.
- okdood64 2y agoSo when's the lawsuit from Google coming?
- system2 2y agoI wonder when in the future ai images and videos will be remotely useful and easy to create. These are still weird and garbage quality.
- lossolo 2y agoIf we take HunyuanVideo, which is similar to Sora, as an example, they state that generating a 5-second video requires 5 minutes on 8xH100 GPUs. Therefore, if 10,000 users simultaneously want to generate a 5-second video within the same 5-minute window, you would need 80,000 H100 GPUs, which would cost around 2 billion USD in GPUs alone.
- IanCal 2y agoNot available in > the United Kingdom, Switzerland and the European Economic Area. We are working to expand access further in the coming months Excellent to announce this lack of access after the launch of pro. At least I have no business reason for sora so it's not a loss there so much but annoying nonetheless.
- aglione 2y agook, so gpt pro with some extra power and sora. This means that gtp5 and generally speaking AGI can wait
- advael 2y agoPeople really worry about fake video and images and whatever but I have to say, the correct heuristics both already exist and have existed for a long time: 1. Anything on the internet can be fake 2. Trust is interpersonal, and trusting content should be predicated first and foremost on trusting its source to not deceive you This is imperfect but also the best people ever really do in the general case, and just orders of magnitude better than most people are currently doing The issue isn't models like this, it's that people are eating a ton of information but have been strongly encouraged to be credulous, and a lion's share of that training is directly coming from the tech grift industrial complex I wouldn't even say this is the most compelling kind of tool for plausible-looking disinformation out there by a long shot for the record, but without actually examining why people are gullible there is no technology that's going to make people accepting fiction as fact substantially worse, or better, really. Scams target people on the order of their life savings every day and there are robust technologies and protocols for vetting communications, but people have to know to use them, care to use them, and be able to use them, for that to matter at all
- jiggawatts 2y ago“The version of Sora we are deploying has many limitations. It often generates unrealistic physics and struggles with complex actions over long durations. Although Sora Turbo is much faster than the February preview, we’re still working to make the technology affordable for everyone.” So they demo the full model and release the quantised and censored model. Does anyone else find this kind of bait & switch distasteful?
- mewpmewp2 2y agoMaybe, but alternative would be to not demo results with state of the art processing at all, which I wouldn't like either.
- echelon 2y agoYou don't need to worry. Open source video is already pulling ahead of closed source. Hunyuan [1] is better than Sora Turbo and is 100% open source. It's got fine tuning code, LoRA training code, multiple modalities, controlnets, ComfyUI compatibility, and is rapidly growing an ecosystem around it. Hunyuan is going to be the Stable Diffusion / Flux for video, and that doesn't bode well for Sora. Nobody even uses Dall-E in conversation anymore, and I expect the same to hold true for closed source foundation video models. And if one company developing foundation video models in the open isn't good enough, then Lightricks' LTX and Genmo's Mochi should provide additional reassurance that this is going to be commoditized and made readily available to everyone. I've even heard from the Banodoco [2] grapevine that Meta is considering releasing their foundation video model as open source. [1] https://github.com/Tencent/HunyuanVideo/ https://github.com/Tencent/HunyuanVideo/ [2] Banodoco is one of the best communities for open source foundation AI video; https://banodoco.ai/ https://banodoco.ai/
- jedberg 2y ago> We’re introducing our video generation technology now to give society time to explore its possibilities and co-develop norms and safeguards that ensure it’s used responsibly as the field advances. That's an interesting way of saying "we're probably gonna miss some stuff in our safety tools, so hopefully society picks up the slack for us". :)
- FrustratedMonky 2y ago"to give society time to explore its possibilities and co-develop norms and safeguards" Or, "this safety stuff is harder than we thought, we're just going to call 'tag you're it' on society" Or, -Oppenheimer : speaking "man, this nuclear safety stuff is hard, I'm just going to put it all out there and let society explore developing norms and safeguards". -Society : Bombs Japan -Oppenheimer : "No, not like that, oops".
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Arnt 2y agoAren't you kind of saying that you don't have any answers so therefore OpenAI should have provided the answers?
- usrnm 2y agoOppenheimer was making a bomb from day 1, he knew exactly what he was doing and how it would be used. There aren't so many different use cases for a bomb, after all. It was a nice movie, but it does not absolve him
- xvector 2y agoEh, society did a pretty good job overall. The bomb was the end of conventional warfare between nuclear nations. MAD has created an era of peace unlike anything our species has ever seen before.
- rurp 2y ago
- vinay_ys 2y agoco-develop := we are in f** around and f** out mode, please bear with us.
- karmasimida 2y agoI am not impressed by it at all ... Is it actually better than the competitors?
- belter 2y ago"...I felt a great disturbance in the algorithm... as if millions of influencers, OnlyFans stars, and video creators suddenly cried out in terror..."
- submeta 2y agoWhat I desperately need is a model that generates perfectly made PowerPoint slides. I have to create many presentations for management, and it’s a very time consuming task. It’s easy to outline my train of thoughts and let an LLM write the full text, but then to create a convincing presentation slide by slide takes days. I know there is Beautiful.ai or Copilot for PowerPoint, but none of the existing tools really work for me because the results and the user flow aren’t convincing.
- buzzy_hacker 2y agoHave you checked out Marp? https://marp.app/ https://marp.app/ Basically it generates slides from markdown, which is great even without LLMs. But you can get LLMs to output in markdown/Marp format and then use Marp to generate the slides. I haven't looked into complicated slides, but works well for text-based ones.
- agnishom 2y agoLooks interesting. I am on the hunt for clean tools for producing presentations. I really like Powerpoint, mainly because of their animation and vector editing features. However, I don't want to keep using a proprietary tool.
- brcmthrowaway 2y agoSora? More like r/ShittyHDR
- TiredOfLife 2y ago“I've come up with a set of rules that describe our reactions to technologies: 1. Anything that is in the world when you’re born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works. 2. Anything that's invented between when you’re fifteen and thirty-five is new and exciting and revolutionary and you can probably get a career in it. 3. Anything invented after you're thirty-five is against the natural order of things.” ― Douglas Adams, The Salmon of Doubt: Hitchhiking the Galaxy One Last Time
- SillyUsername 2y agoNo integration with ChatGPT is a lost opportunity and illustrates no joined up thinking in all senses of that phrase. Demonstrations, helping people with learning difficulties visualise things, education purposes, story telling...
- beeskneecaps 2y agoChatGPT isn't even aware of Sora when I asked it to generate a video. Like why not combine the interface for prompting? Sounds like their having issues scaling a common interface so each team is making their own.
- esskay 2y agoGreat. More tools to continue the enshitification of everything on the web.
- matthewmorgan 2y ago"Sora is not available in The United Kingdom yet". Available elsewhere, from Albania to Zimbabwe. Any particular reason why?
- dcchambers 2y agoMeh. It's a cool POC and immediately useful for abstract imagery, but not for anything realistic. Looking forward to the onslaught of AI-generated slop filling every video feed on the Internet. Maybe it's finally what's going to kill things like TikTok, YT Shorts, Reels, etc. One can hope...anyway.
- ngd 2y agoWhat’s next, Tiagra?
- purplezooey 2y agoI'm holding out for 105
- bitkrieg 2y agocan't wait to see what Dura Ace has to offer
- mkaic 2y agoA friendly reminder: if you have tech-illiterate people in your life (parents, grandparents, friends, etc), please reach out to them and inform them about advances in AI text, image, audio, and (as of very recently) video generation. Many folks are not aware of what modern algorithms are capable of, and this puts them at risk. GenAI makes it easier and cheaper than ever for bad actors to create targeted, believable scams. Let your loved ones know that it is possible to create believable images, audio, and videos which may depict anything from “Politician Says OUTRAGEOUS Thing!” to “a member of your own family is begging you for money.” The best defense you can give them is to make them aware of what they’re up against. These tools are currently the worst they will ever be, and their capabilities will only grow in the coming months and years. They are already widely used by scammers.
- kylehotchkiss 2y agoWho is the audience for this product? A lot of people like video because it's a way of experience something they currently cannot for one reason or another. People don't want to see arbitrary fake worlds or places on earth that aren't real. Unless it's video game or something. But I see this product being used primarily to trick Facebook users I guess the CGI industry implications are interesting, but look at the waves behind the AI generated man. They don't break so much as dissolving into each other. There's always a tell. These aren't GPU generated versions of reality with thought behind the effects.
- danielbln 2y ago> People don't want to see arbitrary fake worlds or places on earth that aren't real. Isn't there a multi-billion dollar industry in California somewhere that caters exactly to that demand?
- Klonoar 2y ago> Unless it's video game or something. The "or something" pretty much covers the gotcha you're trying to use. OP is acknowledging that fantasy media is a thing before going on to their actual point.
- themagician 2y ago"People don't want to see arbitrary fake worlds or places on earth that aren't real." What? This is 90% of the Instagram/TikTok experience, and has been for years. No one cares if something is real. They care how it makes them feel. The audience for this is every "creator" or "influecner". No one cares if the content is fake. They'll sell you a vacation package to a destination that doesn't exist and people will still rate it 3/5 stars for a $15 Starbucks gift card.
- jrflowers 2y ago> Who is the audience for this product? Infants, people just coming out of anesthesia, the concussed, the hypoxic, the mortally febrile and so on
- 2y ago
- robomartin 2y agoHere's something I find interesting: We have multiple paid accounts with OpenAI. In other words, we are paying customers. I have yet to see a single announcement or new development that we learn about through email. In most cases we learn these things when they get covered by some online outfit, posted on HN, etc. OpenAI isn't the only company that seems to act in this manner. I find this to be interesting. Your paying customers actively want to know about what you are doing and, more than likely, would love to get a heads-up before the word goes out to the world. Hearing about things from third parties can make you feel like a company takes your business for grant it or does not deem it important enough to feed you news when it happens. Another example of this is Kickstarter, although, their problem is different. I have only ever backed technology projects on KS. That's all I am interested in. And yet, every single email they send is full of projects that don't even begin to approach my profile (built over dozens of backed projects). As a result of this, KS emails have become spam to be deleted without even reading them. This also means I have not backed projects I would have seriously considered and I don't frequent the site as much as I used to. Getting back on topic: It will be interesting to see how Sora usage evolves.
- shlomo_z 2y agoYes, they do seem to take your business for granted. In my case, I will keep paying for it. I need OpenAI's tools more than OpenAI needs my business, and probably yours too.
- exodust 2y agoI'd be interested to know how many people around here pay for ChatGPT. Is it common? I would have thought technical people would be choosing AI tools other than chatGPT. So you use it mainly for coding? Or are you chatting with it and doing all those "fun" things?
- robomartin 2y agoWe are developing with agents and tools with these technologies, so full immersion is a necessity. There's so much going on it is almost impossible to stay on top of it. Regarding paying for access, for me it is about a combination of reasons. I want to support their efforts and that of others, so we have paid accounts where possible. Beyond that, it is about being up to date on the state of the art. Some of it is paid, and some is FOSS.
- matco11 2y agoForget video. Imagine what this going to do for video-gaming
- beeskneecaps 2y agoI actually can't imagine what it will do for video gaming. Maybe enhancing cut-scenes, but then why can't they just do the performance and rendering using the gaming engine in realtime?
- exodust 2y agoPerhaps AI will help with procedural generation of environmental details within a pre-built game world. This way the AI isn't burdened with generating the whole scene, but only the clutter of objects and textures - things that usually take a long time to build by hand. For example in Train or Truck Simulators, I see examples where someone has put effort into making that farmhouse in the distance nicely detailed, but other times it's just a simple structure. If AI were tasked with "distant details", the whole game could look more polished.
- azinman2 2y agoTechnically it's amazing that this is possible at all. Yet I don't see how the world is better off for it on net. Aside from eliminating jobs in FX/filming/acting/set design/etc, what do we really gain? Amateur filmmakers can be more powerful? How about we put the same money into a fund for filmmakers to access. The negatives are plentiful, from the mundane reduction of our media to monolithic simulacra to putting the nail in the coffin for truth to exist unchallenged, let alone the 'fine tunes' that will continue to come for deepfakes that are literal (sexual) harassment. Humans are not built for this power to be in the hands of everyone with low friction.
- JPKab 2y ago[flagged]
- jjmarr 2y agoThe Ancient Egyptian god Thoth invented writing and presented it to the King: "This invention, O king," said Thoth, "will make the Egyptians wiser and will improve their memories; for it is an elixir of memory and wisdom that I have discovered." The king replied: "This invention will produce forgetfulness in the minds of those who learn to use it, because they will not practice their memory. Their trust in writing, produced by external characters which are no part of themselves, will discourage the use of their own memory within them. "You have invented an elixir not of memory, but of reminding; and you offer your pupils the appearance of wisdom, not true wisdom, for they will read many things without instruction and will therefore seem to know many things, when they are for the most part ignorant and hard to get along with, since they are not wise, but only appear wise."
- bamboozled 2y agoHumans are not built for this power to be in the hands of everyone with low friction Now we have this with social media, everyone is their own little FSB propaganda machine…yay
- washadjeffmad 2y agoI've taken to calling the digital artists I work with "the old masters" in light of the flood of inexpert, low effort AGI content. And they do use generative AI, pretty liberally for concept work and reference, but they know what they're doing and can turn it into great things. I thought we lost a lot in the transition from analog to digital media, but that doesn't mean there's not a peak to any modern craft, just that there hasn't been a unified or named movement highlighting the best and worst, outside of social media algorithms.
- khushy 2y agoI can't wait for the safety features because I know there are those in society that would do bad things. But not me, though. I'd like the unlocked version.
- ruskyrubble 2y ago[flagged]
- soheil 2y agoThat's now how the world is supposed to work, I wonder if there is going to be long-term psychological effects if being exposed to videos like these regularly. If our neurons are unable to receive a stable stream of reality like we have for millions of years will our brains become dysfunctional over time?
- nox101 2y agowhat in particular is better as about this than https://civitai.com/videos https://civitai.com/videos
- ta2112 2y agoThe mammoths are walking over some pre-existing footprints, but they don't leave any prints of their own. I guess I'm getting hung up on little things. For a prompt of a few words, it looks pretty nice!
- brianhama 2y agoSort of messed up that I’m paying for ChatGPT pro and still can’t access it.
- shlomo_z 2y agoUhh... no. The $20 you pay to OpenAI every month does not require them to give you access to sora.
- monktastic1 2y agoCan't even log in. I get "Unexpected token '<', "<!DOCTYPE "... is not valid JSON"
- qwe----3 2y agoWas this the one trained on YouTube?
- salsa_catsup 2y ago[flagged]
- throwaway314155 2y agoThey have NSFW filters. They also seem to have "contains a human" filters.
- Daniela4565 2y ago[flagged]
- Daniela4565 2y ago[flagged]
- han00 2y agoI think this would be fitting use case for niche stock video.
- ruskyrubble 2y ago[flagged]
- qntmfred 2y ago> You all understand that Sam, the gaylord of OpenAI, is here to control you, correct? I see this kind of comment from time to time. do you have any evidence to support this claim, or just paranoia vibes?
- ruskyrubble 2y ago[flagged]
- wavewrangler 2y agoGod. These AI tools are really showing just how f’d up people are. AI is a scapegoat for the absurdity of society. We are a a scourge! Well, aren’t we? Look at what we’re doing and the way we use this to instinctively conduct psychological warfare on each other! People are facetious. People will kill each other, and people want to lie, steal, and cheat. God almighty. How depressing… This is a problem that highlights the apparent either lack of effect, or lack of care for, consequences, period. The current consequences in place to deter this abysmal and abhorrent behavior simply aren’t enough. I look around and the world is going nuts, and failing, it seems, to attribute the cause with the effect. Shitty people doing shitty things. We don’t need new laws or regulations, when people aren’t willing or able to abide by the ones currently in place! What good will that do?
- roughly 2y agoGod, I hate this crap. Every damn thing on the internet now is some variety of AI slop. Every image is some generative garbage, half the text is the kind of stilted half-accurate wordy gpt garbage, and now I get to dodge a gazillion generated videos of things that would be interesting if they were real and followed the laws of physics and continuity, and I get to do all that while living in a post-truth society, because there’s just too much bullshit out there for the average person to bother to sort through. You’d think after 20 years of this crap nerds would have some notion that technology has consequences, but nope, there’s a shiny thing we could build, so we’ve gotta build it.
- zombiwoof 2y agoWin me an Academy Award
- sylware 2y ago"Enable JavaScript and cookies to continue" mmmmh...
- mrcwinn 2y agoIt's worth remembering, in the end, humans still created it. Just remarkable.
- rossjudson 2y agoSora makes movies less interesting, regardless of how they're created. The part made by Sora? About as interesting as the latest chess programs doing well at chess. woohoo/nice job. The overall effect? Now we spend mental energy trying to figure out which parts are machine generated, and hence not worth anything. That mental energy is gone, sucked out of the cultural economy, and fed to the machinery of mediocrity.
- SideQuark 2y agoIf you have to spend mental energy trying to figure out which is which solely to blindly and automatically disregard something, maybe there’s useful stuff there to enjoy instead. I certainly don’t dislike all the cool movies where special effects are CG just because the old time stop motion artists from 1950s Flash Gordon aren’t using sparklers. Similarly I’m not going to discount new creation that can be enjoyable no matter the provenance.
- avree 2y agoStar Wars? Not worth anything, huge reliance on "machine-generated" imagery. Lord of the Rings? Useless film, uses "machine-generated" imagery. Don't even get me started on anything by Pixar. /s
- rossjudson 2y agoYou know what I mean, ChatGPTWhatever. Stay out of human business.
- lmm 2y agoHuh? AI chess is much more interesting to watch than human chess.
- steveoscaro 2y agoWelp I can't even login with my existing ChatGPT account because their servers are overloaded
- nycdatasci 2y ago“Sora is here” No it’s not. I’ve been trying to access all day: “Sora account creation is temporarily unavailable We're currently experiencing heavy traffic and have temporarily disabled Sora account creation. If you've never logged into Sora before, please check back again soon.”
- throwaway314155 2y agoI finally got access. Generated roughly 15 videos. Quality ranged from okay to very very bad. I wouldn't get your hopes up - it's not at all as good as they've hyped it.
- feverzsj 2y agoSeems as shitty as others.
- billfruit 2y agoIs there no way to try it even without subscribing? After you log in, it goes straight to a screen asking for subscription to create videos.
- itsdev 2y agoWho legitimately asked for, or wants this? It's cool on it's face, sure. What legitimate problem does it solve? Isn't AI supposed to make our lives easier, or is that just "not what it's supposed to be bro", or whatever. I've lost track at this point with all the hallucinations and poor/bad/really fucking bad responses. It's not 100% of the time, but that's the point of companies like OpenAI releasing stuff like this to the public... to be helpful and believable. Deep fakes were bad enough. Shit like this is not helpful when given to the largely ignorant public. It's not going to be used for anything helpful, conducive, or otherwise beneficial. It's impressive. Sure. I just fail to see what it's the solution to.
- akomtu 2y agoSorat? https://anthroposophy.eu/Sorat https://anthroposophy.eu/Sorat
- pparanoidd 2y agoIt's not a solution to anything, it's simply just money. If they don't release a for-profit video generator, someone else will
- mhb 2y agoWhat is a "System Card"?
- gloosx 2y agoSo in the end, was it all classic hype pumping and heavily edited marketing material? Can't create account but from what I see on the front-page, every video looks kinda strange, almost in everyone of them something is instantly off to my eye. Anyone got decent results yet?
- throwaway314155 2y agoAs far as I can tell, this is not Sora, but a distilled model that runs in a reasonable amount of time, with a reasonable amount of compute. It's pretty likely that's resulted in degradation of quality. Further, the marketing/demo-ing for Sora for the past year has been heavily curated videos from OpenAI and it's not clear what was generate using Sora and what was being generated using Sora "Turbo" (this distilled model). It wouldn't surprise me if some or much of it was from the original Sora model, leading to mismatched expectations and hype fatigue. Mostly hunches from me. It could very well be that the original Sora is also plagued with outputs that aren't just subjectively "bad", but which aren't _useful_ (not adhering to the prompt, for instance). There's some cool ideas here. The storyboard thing is nifty - kind of the refined synthetic captions that ChatGPT uses for DALLE3 on crack. Perhaps after people get over the prompting learning curve it will output better results. But it seems tougher to prompt than simple text-to-image, requiring generally longer prompts that aim to steer the model away from whatever strange thing it's doing that you don't need it to do. In my case, using the "image as the first frame" approach, the model generated cuts between newly imagined cameras consistently, when I simply wanted a single continuous shot from the POV of the camera of the photo. We'll see, but I'm sort of over it. The UX is fancy for sure, and the scale they're pulling off with this is unprecedented even if there's already decent competitors.
- gloosx 2y agoRead few other reviews as well, the general feeling seems to be more or less the same. People also complain that it often imagines faces on reference pictures and after some substantial delay denies generating, which is a big game-ender.
- 2y ago
- telenardo 2y agoFor those curious (and still locked out) here’s direct a comparison of Sora vs. the open-source leaders (HunyuanVideo, Mochi and LTX): https://app.checkbin.dev/snapshots/1f0f3ce3-6a30-4c1a-870e-2c73adbd942e https://app.checkbin.dev/snapshots/1f0f3ce3-6a30-4c1a-870e-2... Pros: - Some of the Sora results are absolutely stunning. Check out the detail on the lion, for example! - The landscapes and aerial shots are absolutely incredible. - Quality is much better than Mochi & LTX out of the box. Mochi/LTX seem to require specifically optimized workflows (I've seen great img2vid LTX results on Reddit that start with Flux image generations, for example). Hunyuan seems comparable to Sora! Cons: - Still nearly impossible to access Sora despite the “launch”. My generations today were in the 2000s, implying that it’s only open to a very small number of people. There’s no api yet, so it’s not an option for developers. - Sora struggles with physical interactions. Watch the dancers moonwalk, or the ball goes through the dog. HunyuanVideo seems to be a bit better in this regard. - Can't run it locally mode (obviously) - I haven't tested this, but I think it's safe to assume Sora will be censored extensively. HunyuanVideo is surprisingly open (I've seen NSFW generations!) - I’m getting weird camera angles from Sora, but that could likely be solved with better prompting. Overall, I’d say it’s the best model I've played with, though I haven’t spent much time on other non-open-source ones. Hunyuan gives it a run for its money, though!
- CSMastermind 2y agoBased on this it really seems like Hunyuan is a significantly better model. In nearly every example I preferred its output.
- spondyl 2y agoI can't speak to any of those videos in a technical sense but personally, I don't feel like any of them are good? The vibe they give me is similar to the iPhone photography commercials where yes, in theory, a picnic in the park could look exactly like this except for all the parts that seem movie perfect. I guess it's really more of a colour grading question where most of the Sora colour grading triggers that part of my brain that says "I'm watching a movie and this isn't real" without quite realising why. A few of the Hunyuan videos in contrast seem a bit more believable even though they have some obvious glitches at times. The other thing I think Sora has is that thing in commercials where no one else except the protagonist exists and nothing is ever inconvenient. The video of the teacher in a classroom with no students reminds me of that as well as the picnic in the park where there's wide open space with no one around. I suppose it depends if the goal is to generate believable video and how you define believable.
- kelseyzachow84 2y ago[dead]
- kelseyzachow84 2y ago[dead]
- phtrivier 2y agoNot available in France yet, I'd we interested to know if it's a matter of progressive rollout, or some form of legislation (EU or otherwise ?) that's making OpenAI cautious ? Something like the EU AI Act [1] ? In a sane world, any video produced by Sora would be required to have a form of watermarking that's on par with what intellectual property owners require. We've put people in jail for sharing copyrighted movies, and don't see why we would refrain from mandating that AI generated videos have some caption that says, I don't know, "This video was generated with AI" ? People would not respect the mandate, and we would consider that illegal, and use the monopoly on force to take money out of their bank account. I know, it sounds mad and soooo 20th century - maybe that's why OpenAI overlords are not deeming peasants in France worthy of "a cat in a suit drinking coffee in an office" and "you'll never believe what the other candidate is doing to your kids". [1] https://www.imatag.com/blog/ai-act-legal-requirement-to-label-ai-generated-content https://www.imatag.com/blog/ai-act-legal-requirement-to-labe... EDIT: apparently some form of watermarking is built in (but it's not obvious in the examples, for some reason.) > While imperfect, we’ve added safeguards like visible watermarks by default, and built an internal search tool that uses technical attributes of generations to help verify if content came from Sora. [2] https://openai.com/index/sora-is-here/ https://openai.com/index/sora-is-here/
- FrozenSynapse 2y agoNot gonna happen in EU too soon, imo. It still works with a VPN so the fence is not so protected.
- BoorishBears 2y ago> People would not respect the mandate, and we would consider that illegal, and use the monopoly on force to take money out of their bank account. Imagine a culture that would harness their frustration at being left out in the direction of innovating on their own. Defining the status quo on things like watermarks by leading the field and then demonstrating how to act from the front. Seems like they'd be more effective than one that settles for derision and calling for taxes and rules from the back of the pack, so they can presumably profit off the terrible evil things being built.
- b0a04gl 2y ago[dead]
- vault 2y agoI wish that after Sora and Sora Turbo they would release Sora Lella
- nicodds 2y agoNot to be picky, but Sora is here: https://geohack.toolforge.org/geohack.php?pagename=Sora,_Lazio¶ms=41_43_N_13_37_E_region:IT_type:city https://geohack.toolforge.org/geohack.php?pagename=Sora,_Laz...
- ivjw 2y agoI was searching recently for a photograph of Arthur Rimbaud in his later years, and noticed that already Google Images was flooded with AI-generated stuff from websites that do not require marking it as such. Authentic material will soon be much harder to find for people who don't know the sources.
- jcutrell 2y agoNot downplaying the amazing progress, but even the video showcases have some weird uncanny valley effects. The winged horse one in particular - the wings and legs morph, the wing on the left disappears and reappears through the tail. This stuff is a little ways off, but still some amazing effects here. I think it will be a little bit before it is sufficient for production use in any real commercial situation. There's something unsettling about all of the videos generated here.
- gadders 2y ago"Here" depends on where you live. Not available in the UK.
- jas39 2y agoSo they released it in Afghanistan but not in Sweden? Is this an EU ban?
- 1kaizen 2y ago[flagged]
- liendolucas 2y agoIn a not so distant future we might need to have some sort of regulation that forces uploaders (or content creators) to declare if videos have been generated with ai tech or not and depending on the content such declaration might carry legal consequences. On the other side hosting platforms should display clearly if such content was declared ai generated or not as well. Right now I can't see a simple and good enough solution as this that could mitigate the spread of malicious content.
- i5heu 2y agoOr we will have some cryptographic going on that is connected with your ID to prove that you are indeed human. Trust on a society level is some other beast of difficult problem.
- jusonchan81 2y agoMy hunch is that it should be easy to decipher if it’s a AI video based on how the frames transitions.
- thomastraum 2y ago"a tool never made an artist" so incredible ugly.
- eileen-stars 2y agosharing a paper of Sora: https://www.openread.academy/en/paper/reading?corpusId=503433499 https://www.openread.academy/en/paper/reading?corpusId=50343...
- floppiplopp 2y agoIs it just me or do all the clips on the official page feel just creepily wrong? Everything seems so wrong, movements, proportions, light, color... everything's almost correct, but barely and noticeable not so. To me it looks like some horror from beyond, something inter-dimensional beings would dream up to simulate the idea of the something that's similar to reality. And it creeps me the fuck out.
- NoNotTheDuo 2y agoTheir example videos: https://openai.com/sora/ https://openai.com/sora/, of the doors opening, are hilarious. 1. The first set of doors doesn't have any doorknobs or handles. https://ibb.co/PwqfzBq https://ibb.co/PwqfzBq 2. The second set of doors has handles, and some very large/random hinges on the left door. https://ibb.co/JkDtc6r https://ibb.co/JkDtc6r 3. The third set doesn't have any handles, but I can forgive that, because we're in a spaceship now. The problem is that the inside of the doors seem to have windows, but the outside of the doors, doesn't have any windows. https://ibb.co/nwpXmtq https://ibb.co/nwpXmtq & https://ibb.co/wr6v2g1 https://ibb.co/wr6v2g1 4. The best/most hilarious part for me. The doors have handles, but they are on the hinge side of the door. No idea how this would work. https://ibb.co/gWXDcfr https://ibb.co/gWXDcfr
- ckcheng 2y agoI think they trained on one too many closet bifold doors [1]. If you look at the edge of the doors as they swing open, it seems their movement resembles bifold door movement (there's a wiggle to it common to bifold doors that normal doors never have). Plus they seem to magically reveal an inner fold that wasn't there before. [1]: https://duckduckgo.com/?t=h_&q=interior+bifold+closet+doors&iax=images&ia=images https://duckduckgo.com/?t=h_&q=interior+bifold+closet+doors&...
- neop1x 2y agoThere are more examples of its limitations. The video with dogs shows three taxis transforming into one, the number of people under the tree changing https://player.vimeo.com/video/1037090356?h=07432076b5&loop=1&controls=1 https://player.vimeo.com/video/1037090356?h=07432076b5&loop=... An example from the HunyuanVideo is terrible as well. Look at that awful tongue: https://hunyuanvideoai.com/part-1-3.mp4 https://hunyuanvideoai.com/part-1-3.mp4 And what we see in that marketing is probably the best they could generate. And I suppose it took a lot of prompt tweaking and regenerations. The internet is already full of junk shorts and useless videos and soon there will be even more junk content everywhere. :(
- chrsw 2y agoAt least we don't have to worry about AI taking over any time soon
- iamleppert 2y agoHow long until they fix the sign up issue? What an embarrassment. Why release something if you know it can't work properly? And why do we need to sign up when we already have an account with ChatGPT? It was cool when they announced it but the novelty of generating a piece of AI video clipart is quickly fading, especially when it takes months or years to just get a demo in users' hands.
- EternalFury 2y agoMany people say: > these things will get bigger and better much faster than we can learn to discern I would like to ask “Why?” Clearly, these models are just one case of “NN can learn to map anything from one domain to another” and with enough training/overfitting they can approximate reality to a high degree. But, why would it get better to any significant extent? Because we can collect an infinite amount of video? Because we can train models to the point where they become generative video compression algorithms that have seen it all?
- herval 2y ago> But, why would it get better to any significant extent? Two years ago, the very best closed-source image model was unable to represent anything remotely realistic. Today, there's hundreds of open source models that can generate images that are literally indistinguishable from reality (like Flux). Not only that, there's an entire collection of tools and techniques around style transfer, facial reconstruction, pose control, etc. It's mindblowing, and every week there's a new paper making it even better. Some of that could have been more training data. Most of it wasn't. I guess it's fair to extrapolate that same trend to video, since it's the arc text, audio and images have taken? No reason it would be different.
- EternalFury 2y agoI get that. But, let’s say you have a glass, you fill it to one third, then to half, then to three quarter, then to full. Can you expect to fill it beyond full? Not every process has an infinite ramp. It seems frontier labs have been throwing all the compute and all the data they could get their hands on at model training for at least the past 2 years. Is that glass a third full or is it nearly full already? Is the process of filling that particular glass linear or does the top 20% of the glass require X times as much water to fill as the bottom 20%?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- herval 2y ago
- cush 2y agoI like that the contributors are presented as movie credits
- Nina1000 2y agoThe competition in text-to-video tools is heating up, but a key challenge remains: achieving desired results without exhausting resources. Runway, for instance, often consumes all your credits before producing something usable, even if you stick to their guidelines. Hailuo AI shows better consistency, while Sora Turbo sounds promising with potentially more mature generations. Progress is clear, but there’s still a way to go in perfecting these tools.
- domid 2y agoI've been thinking about your point regarding credit consumption with these tools. I started exploring this at https://liveimage.ai https://liveimage.ai (an AI video avatar generator) with a low-res preview system first. I'm curious if you think this kind of approach would be more useful - generating quick low-res previews that use minimal credits, then only processing high-res versions once you're happy with the result? Seems like it could help avoid wasting resources on full quality generations that don't match what you're looking for. I often wonder if jumping straight to high-res without previewing is partly why people burn through credits so quickly. Would love to hear if you've encountered other tools taking this kind of approach.
- mark_l_watson 2y agoI have been subscribing to ChatGPT Plus for a long time. I just cancelled my subscription today because every time I try to login to sora.com, I get the too busy message. I have never been able to try it. Pissed me off. Tencent has a comparable open weight model dropped in the last week that looks at least as good.
- pama 2y agoPatience. I understand the frustration. I hope this transient login problem gets fixed soon.
- Anna654 2y agoI am so intrigued with the new sora release. I hope it turns out well.
- Cloudbase 2y ago[flagged]