55 ms·
Amazon to lay off 9,000 more workers after earlier cuts
- AlbertCory 4y ago.. and the hits just keep on coming: https://albertcory50.substack.com/p/whose-does-layoffs-better-ai-or-amazons https://albertcory50.substack.com/p/whose-does-layoffs-bette... What was really amazing to me was when I fed his email into Google Translate, had it translate to Mandarin, and then fed the output back to English.
- rossdavidh 4y agoWe have found one more thing, besides comedy, which AI's actually do better than humans, if you consider CxO's to be human.
- AlbertCory 4y agoYou'd think with all that money, they could hire some people who could write without plagiarizing.
- oblio 4y agoI don't think they're plagiarizing, per se, just spending too much time with similar people doing similar things, too often.
- sacnoradhq 4y agoA neighbor works high-up in procurement for AWS. I hope they're spared.
- lambo4bkfast 4y agoProviding my anecdata. I've been at amazon for a few years and I have been in a few teams. In each team I would see about 10-20% of the team were not a net benefit to the team. Especially in 2022 I saw this figure grow even larger. This isn't a charity, if you're not contributing to the benefit of the company you should be let go.
- hot_gril 4y agoBut did they let those people go?
- NovaDudely 4y agoJust to complete the math from the article - This makes for a total of 27,000 since last November. While this is about 2% of the global team, these are not coming from the warehouse team. It is all in the IT side.
- jscipione 4y agoJoe Biden and all Democrats have destroyed the US economy, this is all their fault.
- newaccount2023 4y ago[flagged]
- adoxyz 4y agoThe craze from 2019-2022 where "Learn to code" was parroted by everyone everywhere had to end somewhere.
- cyberlurker 4y agoI still think nearly everyone should learn to code. That is not why these layoffs are happening.
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoI think nearly everyone should learn how to manage their virtual environment on a technical level but idk about full on coding. Just being able to attach documents to an email or wrangle proper MFA and/or password management would be a godsend.
- dougmwne 4y agoBut now GPT can code. It’s possible the narrative is changing. I’m NOT saying that software engineers are getting replaced, but the kinds of things you learn in a boot camp, gluing APIs together and searching StackOverflow for code snippets, seems like it’s on more shaky ground than a few years ago.
- l33t233372 4y agoIt was already on enormously shaky ground a few years ago.
- siva7 4y agoThe craze was more like that everyone had to get a job in tech. Knowing a little bit how to code is important but those tutorials went over the board
- 4y ago
- realce 4y agoThe factory of the future will be a man and a dog...
- jjoonathan 4y ago...and an army of armed robots to keep the desperate and angry mobs of unemployed away.
- trgn 4y agoNot if the angry mobs owns the robots and pays the man to feed his dog.
- hinkley 4y agoSure buddy. Keep telling yourself that.
- ben_w 4y agoGiven how many furries work in tech, the dog wrote the code that controls the robots.
- ethanbond 4y agoWhy would the mob own the robots? The whole point of robots is to eliminate the mob’s power.
- trgn 4y agohmmm. Interesting. I see it the other way around. If the robot's ownership is concentrated in few hands, then there's indeed reason for the mob to arise. If the mob owns the robots instead, then there will be little reason for the mob to raise pitchforks, they'd just collect dividends. Mob can then go vacation in Florida or whatever.
- throwaway173738 4y agoMarx was right about what but wrong about when and how.
- leesec 4y agoSo basically big FAANG type companies are reverting the last year or two of hiring.
- throwawaysleep 4y ago[flagged]
- numbsafari 4y agoGross. If this is how you think, maybe DEI is needed for more than just legal cover.
- boringuser1 4y ago[dead]
- vuln 4y agoSo legal and virtue signaling? It appears these positions were NOT safe, so like the others they were cut. If companies _really_ cared about DEI they would look other places to cut. I guess, unfortunately, the ROI on DEI isn't apparent. I haven't seen many pitchforks about it. https://www.nbcnews.com/news/nbcblk/diversity-roles-disappear-three-years-george-floyd-protests-inspired-rcna72026 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/nbcblk/diversity-roles-disappea... https://www.businessinsider.com/layoffs-diversity-departments-some-ceos-talk-committed-racial-justice-2023-2 https://www.businessinsider.com/layoffs-diversity-department... https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-01-24/tech-layoffs-are-hitting-diversity-and-inclusion-jobs-hard https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-01-24/tech-layo...
- washywashy 4y agoYou sound like you’ve never worked in recruiting or spoken closely with someone who has.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI would not go that far.. they do serve a purpose. That said, I only interact that group about application/benefits/exit interview and the application part is almost uniformly bad in corporate world ( I effectively avoid applying blindly; I was mostly lucky that most of my recent jobs were referrals that bypassed HR screening ).
- ddulaney 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- margorczynski 4y agoSeems the halcyon days in tech are coming to an end pretty quickly. Maybe when the inflation starts dying down faster + the AI craze will continue to even greater heights then we'll see it coming back in full swing. Either way it is almost certain that a large amount of people working in these companies don't contribute much to the generated income and now the executives have been given an excuse to perform mass layoffs without scaring off the shareholders.
- roflyear 4y agoSure, but these things come and go. I would not be surprised if in 12-24 months Amazon has more engineers than they do today by a significant margin. And "in tech" is right. At my current company, we have more PMs than we do developers. This leads to a really poor feedback look where the PMs are trying to justify their jobs, so they "look busy" and start generating cruft that is probably not important (like changing text without really a great reason, sure maybe it is "polish" but ... there's real things to do and it distracts the engineers). We don't need more PMs than we have engineers!
- ryanbrunner 4y agoI've worked in this environment and it's always miserable. Developers are constantly frustrated by way too much upstream information and work and PMs feel like they have no ability to do anything. Even if a PM does the right thing by talking to customers and learning about their pain points, the giant bottleneck in dev capacity means that those customer pain points take forever to address, which often leads to more customer frustration than if you had never talked to them in the first place.
- im_down_w_otp 4y agoWhenever something that used to work fine suddenly inexplicably breaks here or changes and is made obviously worse for no discernible reason, the following exchange inevitably occurs… “What the heck happened? This was just working last week! Where’s the… ugh! Where did the button for this go?” “It got Product Managed.” Google Meets and Slack are repeat offenders.
- doctoboggan 4y agoDid all these companies that are going through multiple rounds of layoffs decide specifically to spread out the pain over multiple rounds, or did they just fail to predict how many people would need to be let go?
- klodolph 4y agoThe way it was worded—it sounds like a failure to predict how many roles they wanted to eliminate. I’m sure they also wanted to hedge—wait things out and see if conditions changed.
- shmatt 4y agoThey're only now (when this was decided, maybe a month or 2 ago) figuring out the natural attrition in the next couple of years will be extremely close to 0%, down from 15% or even higher
- TylerE 4y agoA cynical person might suggest that the 1st round was intended to tank morale and trigger mass resignations.
- ovis 4y agoAt least according to Amazon, "Some may ask why we didn’t announce these role reductions with the ones we announced a couple months ago. The short answer is that not all of the teams were done with their analyses in the late fall; and rather than rush through these assessments without the appropriate diligence, we chose to share these decisions as we’ve made them so people had the information as soon as possible." (From the announcement.)
- marcosdumay 4y agoEverything on any such announcement is a lie.
- TheSoftwareGuy 4y agoThis seems overly cynical. It makes a lot of sense to wait until teams have completed their planning. It allows the executives to sift through the proposed projects and decide specifically which ones to cut. Also, it is pretty easy to confirm with anybody who works at AWS that OP2 planning process did in fact complete recently
- quacked 4y agoI am curious about these layoffs; the number impacted in the past year seems to be between 100-250,000 tech employees. Are there that many good-paying jobs remaining within the tech industry that they can re-shuffle to? Are people finding placement? Are coders now competing for less-technical jobs as well? I've heard stories of recruiters who were seeing 1 resume per week now seeing 300 resumes per week, but I'm not noticing any sentiment of widespread panic on HN or even Reddit.
- fxd123 4y ago> the number impacted in the past year seems to be between 100-250,000 tech employees That's because companies announce layoffs but they usually don't announce mass hiring. While cloud sectors are laying off, healthcare and defense are hiring tons right now
- latchkey 4y agoWhat would panic look like to you?
- csomar 4y agoIn the crypto communities, it's usually posting the suicide number hotline. I don't think we'll ever be there yet. Tech people are still one of the richest in the US and the Earth.
- peruvian 4y agoI got laid off late January and was able to find a job within a month. I've got a senior title and 6.5 years of experience. Like most US tech workers, I was getting paid comfortably, but nowhere near the level of FAANG/fintech/top startups. I took a small pay increase with this new job. I've got friends who were part of the FAANG layoffs who have been struggling because they only want to work at FAANG or top tier fintech/startups. That said, they are also not trying too hard due to generous severance.
- desi_ninja 4y agoAssuming none of your friends are visa holders. Otherwise trying not too hard case wouldn't be there.
- davewritescode 4y agoAmazon along with Google and everyone else way overpaid for tech talent the last few years which has made it a lot harder for small companies to compete. My company lost a lot of engineers of varying quality to big tech companies.
- dontblink 4y agoGoogle famously underpays as it leverages it's name. Startups can't really compete on total compensation because so much is tied to equity which can be made liquid in the case of big tech. At the same time, startups don't want to give away their equity and are fairly conservative about it. I don't see this changing. The current situation will resolve itself in 1-2 yrs and we will be back again.
- VirusNewbie 4y agoG underpays compared to other FAANG and unicorns but does pay way more than microsoft and just about every other large and small company.
- Der_Einzige 4y agoG, combined with its benefits, does NOT underpay compared to Amazon. Amazon's vesting schedule is so toxic that 90% or more google engineers have higher total comp, better benefits, and better WLB than Amazon.
- mcqueenjordan 4y agoAmazon compensates your first year (the low % vesting year) with an entirely equivalent amount in full cash. Which is arguably better -- so I don't get your point.
- bradjohnson 4y agoDisclaimer: I currently work for Amazon but I would argue that their vesting schedule is their strongest selling point, especially in the current market. If you got into Amazon relatively recently, you're in a strong position for your take home pay. The backloaded stock gives you stability up front with their high signing bonus, and high growth potential for TC assuming stock growth in two years. My pay is basically equalized over 4 years at current stock prices when I began, so my expected 4 year outlook without raises/performance bonuses/stock appreciation is: Y1: ~70% Base, ~26% Bonus, ~4% Stock (5% total initial grant) Y2: ~70% Base, ~18% Bonus, ~12% Stock (15% total initial grant) Y3: ~70% Base, ~0% Bonus, ~30% Stock (40% total initial grant) Y4: ~70% Base, ~0% Bonus, ~30% Stock (40% total initial grant) Rough numbers, you get it. Not everyone has the same deal, but from what I've seen @ Amazon this is pretty standard and honestly significantly better than having to deal with the volatility of a 1 year initial vesting cliff like most public companies.
- walrus01 4y agoThey can't lay off everyone, someone still has to take care of the tropical jungle and polish the 6th Avenue spheres in Seattle.
- epberry 4y agoSurprised to see cloud computing will be affected, but then again some analysts reported that AWS growth slowed to only 20% at the end of Q4. But based on what we are seeing they are still having a lot of success with on-prem to cloud migration deals (Southwest Airlines being the most recently announced one). We've also been tracking the shift in cloud spending patterns that Amazon is describing on earnings calls and how that may be compressing margins. In Q4 this was particularly noticeable, https://www.vantage.sh/cloud-cost-report/2022-q4 https://www.vantage.sh/cloud-cost-report/2022-q4
- nimbius 4y agocloud computings darker secret is armies of overworked sysadmins and SRE's toiling in obscurity through exhausting oncall hours behind the scenes to keep everything running despite these sorts of cuts and mountains of tech debt.. anyone whos worked for a hosting provider can attest.
- spenczar5 4y agoIs that really a secret? I have worked both on the inside at AWS, and on the outside at groups which used AWS and Google Cloud. “They will do the huge amount of sysadmin toil” is, like, the number one selling point versus using on-prem systems, and its what justifies the prices.
- throwboatyface 4y agoThe cloud providers like to pretend their secret sauce is massive scale automation. They have tooling, alerting, etc. to make this all work with no people at all. Of course it's all BS, and the people I know who came from AWS were some of the worst for throwing bodies at problems and manually tweaking shit without trying to understand or automate solutions.
- wnolens 4y agoIt is their secret sauce and like a startup who licks and sticks envelopes initially while proving their business model, eventually it is automated. But the thirst for growth is never quenched, so there's always new features, new services. And maintenance of that automation. The work never ends. There's a 25-50% operations tax every AWS employee pays. But they're handling the operations load that several employees were 10y ago. I used to wake up in the middle of the night to restart individual machines. Now I'm alerted for much much more complex problems. But i'm still woken up :(
- strict9 4y agoI've been feeling a lot better about ignoring the countless recruiter contacts from the major tech companies the past couple years. On one hand I felt like I was blowing major opportunities by not trying. But something just felt off when receiving so many sudden contacts from the largest of companies offering remote work, despite working in tech for over a decade and never hearing from them before.
- cvhashim04 4y agoAmazon recruiters especially were hounding most of the people I know working in tech.
- btbuildem 4y agoI didn't have LinkedIn and I took down my personal site, and they were still somehow finding me...
- deltree7 4y agoGetting recruiter email is the same as getting spam, everyone gets it. FANG still has a very low (<1%) success rate. So, don't assume that just because you got a recruiter email you'd be qualified to make it
- sidfthec 4y ago> FANG still has a very low (<1%) success rate. That's misleading. If you're able to get an interview, the success rate is much much higher than 1%. Can you imagine the wasted effort if it was 1%? And I assume if you're getting a recruiter to email you, you can usually get an interview. The 1% number I always see should include those who try to apply without recruiters emailing them.
- deltree7 4y agoOnce again recruiters emails almost everyone with a pulse. I met a guy on a train, who was working as a server, but just had some HTML on his resume. Like OP, most of these people wear that as some badge and can get into FANG anytime. Reality hits when they actually do reply and actually make it through phone screen
- mproud 4y agoHow much of these layoffs are really just trying to keep investors and the stock price happy, as opposed to past over-hiring and stagnated profits?
- lbriner 4y agoThose are the same thing! Investors care about profits, which are dented by over-hiring.
- PartiallyTyped 4y agoIt is definitely to keep investors happy because it comes with RTO, which is another thing investors seem to like. AZ could have very well gone nearly 100% remote for SDEs and slash the office costs without messing up teams and deadlines.
- x86x87 4y agoHah. Now we're using logic? RTO is about control.
- avrionov 4y agoThe stock price is down 2.5% today. The investors didn't like it for some reason.
- hinkley 4y agoMy experience is that Wall Street loves a 1st round layoff, interpreting it as cutting fat. Anything after that they interpret as cutting into the meat of the business. They may or may not also see multiple rounds in the same light many of us do: as incompetence in the management team.
- stellalo 4y agoMeta jumped up 5% at their new layoffs announcement last week
- doomleika 4y agoLike 2 months ago in my circle said cloud sector going to see layoffs as most corps are very wasteful on cloud resources and they will likely to cut spending from there. I guess they were right. Hang in there, AI hype is just started, I think within a year things will be a lot better, assuming there's no WW3 or Credit Suisse creates another domino effect.
- widowlark 4y agobig if
- jadbox 4y agoPlease do not jynx the state of things. The last thing we all need right now is another economic downturn event.
- Aperocky 4y agoThere seem to be non-stop AI hype since 10 years ago, but it does not seem to be a field that has high barrier of entry. This time it does seem quite useful, but I think in a few years it will be commoditized and offered from all major cloud vendors, probably even get to choose the models.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- beebmam 4y ago> but it does not seem to be a field that has high barrier of entry Yeah for inferencing, sure. Try designing and training the models. It takes whole organizations to do that effectively.
- Aperocky 4y agoYes, but the most significant barrier is with the first, not for the followers. I think it's a Tesla situation. Tesla did very well, and I believe OpenAI will be too, but everyone else will catch up and then some. Once the first model rolls out, knowledge from that model would eventually disseminate. And it doesn't even need to be on a human level, industry and academia experts could probably make very good guesses on what's going on behind the curtains - and follow up. And we already have plenty of good models on our hands, some even open sourced.
- nabaraz 4y agoBlog announcing this cut: https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/company-news/update-from-ceo-andy-jassy-on-amazons-operating-plan-and-additional-role-eliminations https://www.aboutamazon.com/news/company-news/update-from-ce...
- aliljet 4y agoI'm very curious about this. Amazon appears to be squeezing more profitability from existing, very successful parts of the organization. In particular, AWS, Advertising, and Twitch are not loss leaders. I'm not really quite sure what "PXT" is as a lay person, but is Amazon essentially making a serious bet on slowing growth to squeeze profit?
- revlolz 4y agoPxt from what I gathered is like HR
- eysquared 4y agoPXT is their tech team supporting HR for Amazon. It grew a ton of the last 5+ years, but from the outside looking in it appears to be mainly empire building. The major initiatives I was aware of from my time there never seem to have been completed.
- aliljet 4y agoWhat exactly have they accomplished? Are they genuinely not building things that could result in improvements to Amazon's bottom line? I don't have a dog in this fight, but I think Amazon is screaming to investors, "wait, we can make money at the expense of our last twenty years of growth if that's what you want." That lens makes Amazon look like a very different company..
- eysquared 4y agoThe scale of HR at Amazon is huge. One data point was that they hired over 800,000 people in a single month. I'm sure that number is out of date. The idea was to build scalable solutions for HR to modernizing hiring, etc. and productize those. I'm not sure the external product piece ever panned out, but they were mainly focused on eliminated manual processes for HR inside of Amazon and migrating legacy systems to modern ones.
- htrp 4y agoDon't they have an automated resume hiring bot ?
- birdymcbird 4y agohr cuts and cuts to other “cost center” no surprise. from my time at amazon this feel like only small step in fixing so many issues. engineering has too many manager in promotion race..layer after layer of manager..empire building focus and not customer benefit. step 1 to rid these “professional” managers who not understand technology, installed themself at company for cushy job title and pay. many come from other uninnovative company like ibm.
- avgDev 4y agoI see IBM I feel the need to comment. IBM has to be shittiest company I had to interact with in a professional setting. We have an AS400 iSeries. It ran the company for many years but now we are building a lot of apps around it in C#/.net/blazor. So, in order to use entity framework with iSeries one needs a data provider. Most of the data providers are generally "free", for example if you have SQL, Oracle, MySql, PostgresSQL you don't have to pay anything. BUT not IBM. We tried getting a license for the iSeries data provider, and I literally gave up and said fuck them I will just use OleDb and write queries by hand. First, nobody could answer which license we needed for our use case. Then, I received a trial license, which didn't work....I spend days snooping around to realize it was for the wrong version of .Net core. IBM support was clueless. I finally received the correct version, but the instructions for the install had a link to a dead URL. IBM forums were full of IBM employees responding with "sent you a DM" when people were asking questions....followed by many replies "i have the same problem can you share the answer publicly"....followed by "sent you a DM". Seriously screw IBM, awful company.
- markus_zhang 4y agoBut with legacy support IBM can probably outlive many modern companies, sadly.
- eYrKEC2 4y agoWe wrappered the AS400 DB2 database with a django rest framework REST API using https://github.com/lionheart/django-pyodbc https://github.com/lionheart/django-pyodbc . I hated trying to use IBM documentation.
- doomlaser 4y agoIt's interesting. In the AI space all the big cloud providers are pairing off with an AI darling. Amazon AWS has partnered with Hugging Face: https://huggingface.co/blog/the-partnership-amazon-sagemaker-and-hugging-face https://huggingface.co/blog/the-partnership-amazon-sagemaker.... Microsoft Azure has OpenAI. Google has their own models for their own cloud, as does Facebook. (this makes me wonder what Apple's going to do)
- shmatt 4y agomake a phone bezel 23% thiner. making the dynamic island 15% wider. and call it the most advanced iPhone ever sold in stores and add another $15B of revenue growth
- doomlaser 4y agoYou joke, but Siri could definitely benefit from the integration of a competent large language model. I have no idea what Apple's AI strategy is. Maybe they should get behind models that run locally and find an opportunity there.
- hbn 4y agoI'm not convinced that going from "sorry, I don't understand" to confidently-asserted answers that seem like they're correct but are absolutely incorrect a high percentage of the time is an improvement.
- ActionHank 4y agoI wonder if Google will seize the opportunity to leverage their inhouse AI expertise to outmaneuver the competition. In theory having inhouse AI should mean they can more quickly iterate ideas, unless they truly are the corporate wasteland people believe them to be.
- madamelic 4y agoThe problem with Google is no one is going to build their house on Google's land because any product that doesn't make Google a super-mega-ultra-decacorn gets shut down after 18 months. Why would someone rely on Google when everything else is either better or good enough.
- Xeoncross 4y agoThose affected will be notified Mid-April. So the question on a lot of employees minds is: Do we try to relocate in time for the May 1st RTO and risk getting fired - or do we wait to see if we're part of the layoffs and then try to relocate with the remaining 2 weeks we have left.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoIf you’re good, you’re already looking. If you’re not good or you don’t think you’re good, you’re waiting. Severance, unemployment, etc. Broadly speaking of course, exceptions as always.
- melvinmelih 4y ago> If you’re good, you’re already looking. But.. where do you go as an overpaid FAANG employee? Amazon, Google, Microsoft etc all have layoffs
- toomuchtodo 4y agoYou’re likely not overpaid at Amazon vs other FAANGs based on changes to equity comp. If you’re somewhere where you were overpaid, I hope you saved accordingly now that you’re going back to a $150k-$200k/year job. As others have mentioned, you might not be able to find a $300k-$500k/year job, but you should be able to find something.
- closeparen 4y agoAt $150k in the Bay Area you’re going to be renting and spending 2 hours a day on public transit. Those roles made sense as a career stepping stone up to homeownership & family supporting roles. I don’t anticipate too many senior folks taking them unless they get exceptions to go remote or they already have mega home equity / rent control.
- jcadam 4y ago
- jdlyga 4y agoIt's crazy to see such a dramatic about-face. Amazon recruiters used to be banging down the door of everyone with software engineering experience not too long ago.
- x86x87 4y agoThey'll be back. People do not forget how they were treated and given other options will not want to work there anymore. Amazon had a lot of trouble hiring during a 'normal' market.
- oldstrangers 4y agoTwitch being impacted is interesting. YouTube is foaming at the mouth to eat Twitch's lunch, and Twitch seems to be doing everything imaginable to make that easier for them.
- TechnicolorByte 4y agoOn the other hand, YouTube seems to be doing virtually nothing to improve theor live streaming experience (UI) and increase their market share.
- oldstrangers 4y agoProbably realize they don't have to when Twitch is cutting creator profits and laying people off.
- Apocryphon 4y agoTech is so full of arms races where both sides do nothing.
- taeric 4y agoI remember in amateur sports, often keeping the ball in play was a winning move. It kept it going to have the opponent make a mistake. More, it wasn't about not making mistakes, as you did nothing but. You just didn't want to make the last mistake. Feels odd to see that play out in industry.
- Apocryphon 4y agoSo much for skating to where the puck is headed.
- fwlr 4y agoMore than a decade ago I was hanging out with the CEO and a few engineers from a startup I was working at. I don’t remember why but we started estimating what portion of Google’s revenue came from advertising. We settled on our estimates and then looked it up, and were surprised to find it was something wild like 95% - I don’t remember the exact number but essentially it was all of their revenue. We realized they could run every other Google service at a loss indefinitely, and started theorizing what this could mean. “Eventually, Email = Gmail” was one conclusion: their email offering was not just “the hardware resources of a paid product (gigabytes of storage, etc) for free”, but also “the feature development velocity of a paid product (teams of full-time well-paid engineers) for free”. So essentially, other email providers wouldn’t last very long being undercut so heavily, and Google’s ad revenue allowed them to undercut forever. One of us pointed out that you might not even get other email providers in the first place, since Google could just hire all the email developers to work on Gmail. Even if they didn’t add any value - even if they subtracted value - as long as AdWords kept ticking along Google could still afford to keep them on payroll at a higher rate than any competitor could offer. Our sobering conclusion was that Google could be this gigantic elephant sitting on top of dozens of different product markets, squeezing them all out by undercutting revenue streams and hiring all the talent - an elephant that would stay perched there based mostly on whether people kept buying ads elsewhere, and based not at all on whether they did a good job on the product or not. Things didn’t quite turn out like we worried (it became FANG/FAANG instead of Google, for instance) and it seems like our pessimism was somewhat unwarranted, although writing it out now, parts of it do certainly ring true. But! One thing we absolutely didn’t expect was that Google/FAANG would one day voluntarily decide to shed tens of thousands of “captive” developers! Many of these devs were doing no work, busywork, or redundant work, so these layoffs represent a huge and very real injection of talent back into the tech sphere (e.g. they were building a redesign of Gmail, but are now building the first design of a new product). I know there’s an impression that many of the layoffs are “people in tech” non-developers (talents in their own right, to be sure, but somewhat less relevant for engineer-hungry startups), but many of the layoffs are developers, and they will find work building new competitors instead of rebuilding/maintaining existing market leaders. Something to be happy about at the birds-eye view of tech progress, even while the layoffs themselves surely suck for the individuals affected.
- xipix 4y agoBetter than RTO, an annual or six monthly team meet up. Its enough to catalyse new and boost existing relationships without the pointless grind of daily commutes.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoI'm sorry this just reads like a pile of sad excuses for being bad at human resource management. (And I use the dehumanizing term "human resources" on purpose here...) "Some may ask why we didn’t announce these role reductions with the ones we announced a couple months ago. The short answer is that not all of the teams were done with their analyses in the late fall; and rather than rush through these assessments without the appropriate diligence, we chose to share these decisions as we’ve made them so people had the information as soon as possible. The same is true for this note as the impacted teams are not yet finished making final decisions on precisely which roles will be impacted. " So people [Amazon employees, the market] are just supposed to just excuse them not just for being crappy at analyzing project costing and the market and overhiring like crazy last year.. but also being crappy at their job at managing the layoffs this year, too? ... We're overstaffed... but we can't tell you who we're overstaffed with. (So just a hunch then?). But we have to do these layoffs. We, uh, just didn't want to rush who they, uh, were, uh, back then... before... so, trust us, we need this number of people gone. So we'll announce this, to put you on the edge of your seat that it might be you... because, y'know, it'd be rude to, announce who, uh, before we're ready? Barely even trying to hide that it's really just about making Stock Price # Go Up (it didn't go up enough with the last round, I guess) and keep employees on their toes.
- throwawayamzon 4y ago[flagged]
- FridayoLeary 4y agoMany tech giants have made huge layoffs recently. What's going on here? Does this spell the end of the era of tech growth and what will happen next?
- abhiminator 4y agoThese are all symptoms of the end of 'cheap' money essentially. World's been running on QE for a long time now, and most millennials and Gen Z folks (myself included) haven't seen/lived in a world without QE. This is all regression toward the mean. The next couple years should be interesting.
- FridayoLeary 4y ago>The next couple years should be interesting. A pity for those who enjoyed the calm of the last two years!
- yladiz 4y agoI doubt it's the end of tech growth long term but one of the main reasons that these companies are laying people off isn't that they need to (even if some departments are overstaffed), it's that the market is demanding it and they care about their share price. Once the market decides that it's fine to hire like crazy and grow again, they'll do huge rounds of hiring.
- erulabs 4y agoUnfortunately (or not, depending on your politics), the main mechanism here, the interest rate, is not up to the market to decide. It's up to a small group of folks who do not have to show their work. Speculation, but the "dollar milkshake theory" seems to fit the best here, which would imply we'll probably be stuck with high interest rates for quite awhile. It's entirely possibly we never see money move as freely as it did in the past 10 years in our lifetime.
- millzlane 4y ago
- yla92 4y agoI always thought AWS is profit center and won't be impacted by the layoffs. It's interesting to see it here. Compared this to Google, GCP was not impacted by the layoff.
- kypro 4y agoI don't know how many of you relate, but a personal level this last few years has left me quite shaken. In 2021 I remember thinking how tech really proved its worth by so quickly assisting our economies through the pandemic with e-commerce, video conferencing and work from home. Sure, things felt a bit crazy, but I remember thinking how lucky I was to land in tech as a career and that it was hard to see a future any time soon where the world wouldn't value tech workers highly. Skip to today and I'm honestly wondering how long I have. We've had a massive influx of new tech talent over the last few years and now we see this dramatic turnaround in hiring which will likely make it significantly harder to get a good tech job in the near future. And in addition to this we have tools like GPT potentially disrupting our careers on a timescale best viewed on the scale of months. It doesn't help that I'm going through a lot in my personal life at the moment too, but I've never felt so vulnerable about what the future holds. I guess I should just be grateful that we had a good run while it lasted, but it's hard to think like that when people depend on you to have things figured out. Anyway, I hope everyone involved in these layoffs lands on their feet.
- time_to_smile 4y ago> tools like GPT potentially disrupting our careers on a timescale best viewed on the scale of months. GPT is cool, and has a lot of potential uses, but don't be scared by the hype. The biggest impact GPT is going to have on most people's software careers is that everyone will have to include "Prompt engineering" on their resumes in the very near future, and data science/ML folks are going to have to answer a lot more questions about transformers by people who have never heard of "Attention is all you need", even though the deepest they'll have to dive into the subject in practice is a few api calls.
- TheKarateKid 4y agoWhat's so frustrating this time around is that almost all of the layoffs by Big Tech are being done on what appears to be entirely speculation with no concrete financial data to support their business decisions. Google, Amazon, Salesforce, etc. all have reported very healthy quarterly earnings and year-end results. Yet their actions are those of failing companies operating in the red for multiple quarters. Every company is giving the same excuses --ahem, I mean reasons-- ("overhiring", "economic downturn"), laying off the same amount of people, and making their announcements within days of each other. Have we ever seen such an industry-coordinated event like this? Especially with no public data supporting their actions? The real reasons many believe for these layoffs amount to taking back the power & control that employees gained in 2020 until early 2022: 1. Salary correction: Compensation boomed, with major tech companies offering new grads and junior engineers job offers high than employees 2 levels higher. Has there ever been a time that employee pay raised so quickly? 2. Corporate control: Leadership wanted everyone back in the office but employees collectively refused. Can you think of another time where companies had lost this much control over their own workforce? 3. Pay Wall St: The only public financial data to support layoffs of this kind are from the stock prices, which mostly plummeted. However, they did not plummet due to poor performance but rather due to the macroeconomic events out of their control. Even at their present day levels, they are still mostly above their pre-pandemic highs. And guess what? Almost every other company's stock price in most industries fell significantly as well. With the profits erased from the surged stock prices, layoffs are the quickest and easiest way to push up a company's value. I can only hope that employees continue to band together to know their worth and not settle for less.
- nazgulnarsil 4y agoThe memetic shift, in coordination with the MSM, has been successful. Companies can now lay off normal numbers of people (for their scale) in waves, and sustain a narrative that times are tough, removing employee motivation to unionize as well as discourage other employee pressures for better work conditions inside the company.
- jonny_eh 4y agoMaybe, but then again Apple hasn't announced any layoffs. So if there was collusion, did no one invite them?
- kyawzazaw 4y agoThere are always CEO retreats/meetups and founders groupchats (think SVB bank run). Also Apple is in a different league and a singular company. It has also been proven there had been collusion in regards to poaching employees before - https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-google-settlement/apple-google-reach-new-deal-to-end-u-s-lawsuit-over-poaching-idUSKBN0KN02Z20150114 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-apple-google-settlement/a... Why not this? Doesn't have to be a collusion setup that looks like UN resolution vote.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago> Apple hasn't announced any layoffs Apple didn't overhire and double its headcount during the Covid money printing bonanza like others did.
- jonny_eh 4y agoExactly my point, the layoffs seem to be (at least initially) a response to over-hiring.
- oytis 4y agoIf "tough times" is BS people will start new companies and benefit from all this talent being released and everyone is going to be happy again.
- thebitguru 4y agoSome may ask why we didn’t announce these role reductions with the ones we announced a couple months ago. The short answer is that not all of the teams were done with their analyses in the late fall; I am torn on this. How does the decision to have at least two layoffs affect employee morale? Is that not worth waiting?
- malfist 4y ago3 Layoffs now.
- throwway120385 4y agoThe layoffs will continue until performance improves.
- taeric 4y agoYeah, not to mention it ignores the questions of "how many teams still haven't finished" and "is it the same management that made the excess growth that is looking to explain where they should be?" That last is huge, btw. Leadership setup a disaster to require a few layoffs. I'm assuming leadership is having to take on some pain, as well?
- brainfog 4y agoWhere did all of these people even come from in the first place? Did the industry just have 50-100k at-least-somewhat-qualified people sloshing around doing nothing before they got picked up by FAANG?
- closeparen 4y agoSilicon Valley cloud and SaaS applications have been devouring an entire ecosystem of in-house and on-prem IT, small line-of-business software vendors, etc.
- k8si 4y agoCompanies have been hand-wringing about the tech labor shortage for the last 10 years. People went to school and got degrees in a job sector they thought would be pretty safe. Supply/demand.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoSo far, probably 80% of these roles have been non-engineering (wrt to all tech layoffs, not Amazon specifically). So these were probably just non-engineering people from other parts of the economy.
- whiplash451 4y agoDo you have hard data to back the 80%?
- sillypuddy 4y agoAttrition plays a role too, if you hire expecting 20% attrition and attrition comes in at 5% you have more employees than you budgeted.
- MaintenanceMode 4y agoJust one data point, but I recently talked to a guy that bounces between being a mortgage broker and a tech worker. When the housing business is booming he switches to mortgage work, then when that slows down he jumps back into technology. I think he said he was in some kind of pre-sales role in tech. Now that they're both slow at the same time, I'm not sure what he's planning.
- aliljet 4y ago"The same is true for this note as the impacted teams are not yet finished making final decisions on precisely which roles will be impacted. Once those decisions have been made (our goal is to have this complete by mid to late April), we will communicate with the impacted employees (or where applicable in Europe, with employee representative bodies)." What a terrible experience. Employees at Amazon are waiting to be terminated right now.
- malfist 4y agoAlso, great way to make the layoffs the fault of the team that's being laid off. One of our LPs is ownership. Jassy sure isn't owning anything here.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoWhat are they supposed to do? If they announce early, people are waiting for doom. If they don't announce early, people are caught off guard.
- svachalek 4y agoAnnounce late and give them enough severance to find work.
- herculity275 4y agoThose of us on work visas care about time much more than about money.
- nrook 4y agoWhen workers don't negotiate together, it's trivial for employers to reset compensation expectations like this. If you work for a company like Amazon, and you don't want to be laid off, the only thing you can do to move the needle is join a union. (You can also be a top performer, but it's not clear how big of a difference that makes; top performers with big salaries make big targets for layoffs as well.)
- esalman 4y agoI hardly think FAANG workers make good union members. One is about maximizing personal net worth, other is about making sacrifices for common good.
- slt2021 4y agounions are inefficient, because they promote mediocrity (regression to the mean) in terms of talent - and union bosses wield abnormal influence.
- bhouston 4y ago> unions are inefficient, because they promote mediocrity (regression to the mean) in terms of talent - and union bosses wield abnormal influence They do stifle the ability for ultra-rich CEOs from becoming even more ultra rich at the expense of their workers.
- slt2021 4y agohow exactly? looking at american unions I dont see a single effective at "stifling CEOs from becoming rich". american automakers produce one of the low quality cars, and heavy lobbying from lawmakers is the only thing that keeps them afloat.
- bhouston 4y ago> how exactly? looking at american unions I dont see a single effective at "stifling CEOs from becoming rich". You removed a major conditional. I do not care if the CEOs become rich, the dream of getting rich via business success is why capitalism works, what I care about is if they do it by underpaying their employees because of a power differential.
- benatkin 4y agoI really think they are using this as an opportunity to get people to sacrifice their work/life balance. Also it seems like unfortunately 35 hours a week is not the most output that can be extracted out of most people. Nor are 40 years in education/labor (from 20-65). This is despite the studies showing that people have trouble focusing after 35 hours being mostly true.
- whiplash451 4y agoThe problem isn’t with people being inefficient beyond 35 hours. The problem is with the large number of people who don’t even put in a serious 10h on the job.
- caconym_ 4y agoI totally buy the 35 hour thing, but I don't think these companies really have a reason to care. They can push workers to the breaking point to extract whatever diminished returns at no additional cost, then "manage out" the resulting burned-out husks and replace them with fresh meat. With a side of ageism in hiring to ensure that you're getting the freshest, least-distracted minds as grist for your CRUD app mill, it's win-win. Another win is that by focusing on attrition rather than sustainable retention, you can lag inflation in your compensation since you only have to match it at offer time.
- nemo44x 4y agoStack ranking has a bad reputation today so nobody admits to doing it. But it's what is happening right now more or less. In many ways it has been targeted at certain roles that aren't needed as much when facing recession. But it's really just cutting out the bottom 10%-20% and blame it on the economy (somewhat justified!) instead of saying they're just stack ranking.
- x86x87 4y agoit's stack ranking but with whole teams.
- Reason077 4y agoEvery time this happens at Amazon, I picture Gary Oldman's Zorg character in The 5th Element. Lackey: "Excuse me, sir. The council is worried about the economy heating up. They wondered if it'd be possible to fire 500000. Maybe from one of the smaller companies where no one would notice..." Zorg: "Fire one million." Lackey: "But 500000... One million. Fine, sir. Sorry to have disturbed you."
- Dyac 4y agoAt the time I remember that shocking me. Now, years later I think it's probably the right approach. Cut deeply ONCE and be done with it, these multiple rounds of cuts are totally demoralising and destroy goodwill, causing good people who weren't redundant to start looking for a new gig.
- whiplash451 4y agoTo be fair, these cuts are hard to anticipate. Hindsight is 20/20.
- wellthisisgreat 4y agoAt the risk of being downvoted and such.. It seems that going into a profession based on how secure it is or how much money you will make is at best a gamble, and at worst a recipe for existential disappointment. Looking back (and up to) the engineers of earlier years (1970s, etc.) they look like people driven by passion, going into the areas where they were to remain forever branded as “nerds”. And the sentiment I see related to layoffs is that people who are genuinely interested in the tech and love it for what it is are not affected as much or even if affected would be quickly welcomed to another place that has resources to appreciate what they have to offer. So yeah follow your passion and all.
- EGreg 4y agoIt’s right in front of you With automation, why do we need so many people to work? Even without Chat GPT or whatever… after Amazon builds an amazing framework to run X part of their business, they can just let the business intelligence and maintenance be mostly automated, fire 90% of the developers and have a few people be around to tweak and maintain it. I never understood why these tech companies needed so many people in the first place
- helen___keller 4y agoYou’re not wrong, but only in the long run. How much value has been built in the past 10 years? 20? 30? If you can accurately predict exactly what your customers want 30 years from now, you can take the approach you’ve mentioned. Otherwise you’re just waiting for someone to eat your lunch. Tech is not nearly stable enough yet. Too much value to add still.
- awesomegoat_com 4y agoThat won't be enough. I predict that AWS stopped growing this ongoing quarter and everything else is money loosing venture for Amazon. It will be interesting to watch if they can release the air without collapsing. The only thing that is growing are cloud cost optimization consultancies.
- yalogin 4y agoIt looks like the tech industry is cutting or has already cut about 150k jobs at this point. Is there really that much elasticity built into the features these companies are building? 30k is a really large number of employees to cut anywhere. They really have to shut down many many projects to achieve that. If that is the case, it should impact growth and revenues quite a bit. The implications of this are huge. For example -- 1. The management has so completely screwed up that they don't deserve a job. 2. Is the management approving projects that they don't believe will impact the bottom line? Did all of the companies mature at the same time and became risk averse? 3. What does it mean to immigration and cap on it?
- whiplash451 4y agoSoftware companies have a ridiculous amount of elasticity. Look at ebay and yahoo.
- nkjnlknlk 4y ago> 1. The management has so completely screwed up that they don't deserve a job. Yes and no? It feels a bit silly to look at things from a results perspective instead of a process one. Management everywhere was spending money to grow as fast as possible. Reality hit (and whether or not you think this reality was predictable is up to you--but I'd like to see if any money was put where your convictions were) and now these research/growth projects need to be cut down. For many, it was the correct decision at the time given the information they had at the time. Until laws are put into place to stop the boom/bust cycle the people being hit are always going to be the labourers.
- HDThoreaun 4y ago> The management has so completely screwed up that they don't deserve a job. These companies aren't employing fortune tellers, no one really knew what the future held when the pandemic hit. It was extremely reasonable to think that there was a chance that big tech's market size would massively increase. Even if that chance was only 10% the correct management decision is hiring as if it will happen and then laying people off in the case it doesn't, because catching up is hard, but firing people is easy.
- 4y ago
- javier_e06 4y agoFirst Meta, now Amazon. Both Jassy and Zuckerberg said it was a "difficult decision". It wasn't. US has inhumane labor laws. Labor laws should change in a way that all US workers laid off by a company should get 3 months salary indemnification and 6 months Insurance coverage. That way companies will think twice going in their "hiring sprees".
- aftergibson 4y agoIs this just affecting US workers?
- rytrix 4y agoNo, it's global. The employees in the EU will be notified some months after the US (likely because of stronger labor laws in the EU)
- awesomegoat_com 4y agoIt is amazing how badly managed they ended up being.
- saos 4y ago> prioritizing what matters most to customers and the long-term health of our businesses. Yeah right lol They meant billionaire shareholders
- wnolens 4y ago"Thousands of you will be fired.. soon. Back to work!" I think I'll drag my feet, thank you very much.
- ROTMetro 4y agoThank god they worried more about the stock's impact and dragged this out months as separate 'small' layoffs instead of caring about people and making it a single event. Who cares about employees anxiety, their trust in the company, etc, right Amazon? You deserve the mass exodus of talent coming.
- throw93 4y agoOne has to wonder whether these decisions are based on logic or on what Wall Street(investors) demands. Now is a high time for unionization among software devs irrespective of their pay scale.
- smarri 4y agoMy optimistic view says that we will see heaps of innovation and new companies emerge from all of the smart tech workers across the industry who are choosing to leave or are being made redundant.
- jossclimb 4y agoIf they can get funding, which is not easy to come by. Was speaking with someone working at one of the top 5 VC's and they are yet to fund a new company this year. Most of the work is dealing with those already in trouble or working with companies in later funding rounds.
- smarri 4y agoAh yes of course, good point indeed.
- newbie578 4y agoAnother reminder that you owe these companies no shred of loyalty, and should be willing to jump ship at first notice. I love it how the older generations today are astounded how employees have no loyalty towards the company, and are job hopping like crazy. Doesn't matter how good your team is, how nice your manager is, always look out for yourself first. And always squeeze as much as money as possible from companies.
- brokencode 4y agoDuring the pandemic, a different Amazon recruiter reached out to me at least once a month. I couldn’t understand how they could possibly need so many new engineers, and I guess the answer was that they didn’t. Management of big tech companies like to pretend they’re geniuses, but really they just wanted to ride the hype train to the moon. They made it hard for smaller companies to hire tech talent and have now had to put tens of thousands of employees through layoffs. I at least hope that some good comes from this in the form of reducing middle management and bureaucracy in the tech giants. Also, hopefully tech workers will be more willing to fill roles across the country at jobs where they might be able to make more of a positive impact. Getting people to waste time on social media is not exactly a benefit to our planet.
- deanCommie 4y agoJust to be clear, they're not laying off 9,000 engineers. There is always a need for more engineers. But at a company this size there is going to be parts that are more efficient than others.
- btbuildem 4y agoManagement of big tech companies are like sheep, one goes BAAAA and they all follow suit
- oort-cloud9 4y ago[dead]
- firstSpeaker 4y agoI cannot even imagine how people working at Amazon feel with the RTO in one side and the impending layoff notification on the other side pushing at them.
- enlyth 4y agoWhat's with all the sensationalist doom and gloom? The job market is still really strong, and Amazon for example hired 300k people from 2020 to 2021. These layoffs are a drop in the bucket, happening at Big Tech mostly. Corporate profits are still at all time highs.