18 ms·
AirDrop is now limited to 10 minutes
- throwaway23597 4y agoApple: where it's totally fine to build products with what amounts to slave labor, and aiding the CCP in censorship is totally cool too, but Twitter is far too dangerous to be allowed on the app store because a meanie is in charge of it.
- mildmotive 4y ago
- mhoad 4y agoOnce again we have a situation where the only person making that final claim is a known serial liar and shit poster. Just like how last week he made that ridiculous claim about the promises he thought brand safety groups had made to him and then everybody else who was in the meeting said he was making shit up. Again.
- friedman23 4y ago> Once again we have a situation where the only person making that final claim is a known serial liar and shit poster. No, it's not just Elon. It is common knowledge that Apple uses this abusive behavior to censor and restrict app makers.
- AustinDev 4y agoDefinitely not just him. It's also very subjective they took Parler off in 2021 but didn't do anything to Discord which has huge child abuse and extremist problems. Apple seems to only act when it's politically expedient for them.
- jmuguy 4y agoExcept Discord views that content as a problem and Parler views it as a feature.
- kmeisthax 4y agoParler got shut down because the entire tech industry was in full-scale panic mode at potentially having helped Trump incite a riot to interfere with the US presidential election. As for Discord, Apple actually has special privileges to ban certain NSFW servers they don't like from being viewed on an iOS device. If they were to act "more" to stop child abuse and extremism, then we'd be talking about how Apple is censoring Discord for Android users. For good measure let's also point out that an App Store reviewer found CSAM on Tumblr and browbeat the company into banning all nudity and porn. The only constant of tech company moderation is that it's consistently inconsistent. Strictly speaking, Apple cannot permanently cut off every competing social network, because nobody would buy a phone with no social networking apps on them. But they can whisper in the companies' ears and demand they do a certain thing (e.g. Discord's banned-from-Apple toggle). The really big events (Parler, Tumblr) happen because of breakdown of process, not because Apple only acts when people are looking.
- AustinDev 4y agoYou expanded my viewpoint on these topics, thanks. I also didn't know about the Discord's 'banned-from-Apple' toggle.
- elicash 4y agoSpeaking of twitter, it's weird Musk hasn't commented yet on the protests in China. Looking forward to him taking on censorship and standing for free speech around the globe, particularly in China.
- Rebelgecko 4y agoTwitter is already blocked in China
- elicash 4y agoThat does not stop him from speaking out about it, thankfully. I hope to see him doing so soon. I don't expect that his work with Tesla will stop him, given his views on free speech.
- PakG1 4y agoYou're probably being sarcastic? I would say that's not likely to happen with how he's already bowed to China multiple times in order to get benefits for Tesla. edit: I see you commented regarding Tesla below. I'm not confident that his respect for free speech is universal. He seems to care more about the free speech that he prefers at times, mostly related to what impacts him on a personal level. That being said, that's unfortunately normal for most people too.
- kennywinker 4y agohttps://twitter.com/TinaDesireeBerg/status/1595526214935904256 https://twitter.com/TinaDesireeBerg/status/15955262149359042... To summarize: Elon Musk: "No far left accounts have been banned from twitter" Commenter: "False, here are four examples" Elon Musk: Suspends commenters account. Champion of free speech indeed. Here is same info summarized in newsweek, since we've all learned how trustworthy twitter screenshots are in recent weeks https://www.newsweek.com/activists-accuse-elon-musk-banning-anti-fascist-accounts-twitter-1761957 https://www.newsweek.com/activists-accuse-elon-musk-banning-...
- 1234letshaveatw 4y ago
- nonameiguess 4y agoWhat is this a reference to? Twitter is currently not only available in the Apple App Store, but is an Editor's Choice award winner.
- Mistletoe 4y agoApple has threatened to remove it from the App Store and I would love to see that happen just for the chaos of it all.
- Mistletoe 4y agoWhy not both? This is a false equivalence, they can be and are all bad.
- pessimizer 4y ago> This is a false equivalence > they can be and are all bad. This sentence is arguing against itself, because you felt like you had to stick two twitter cliches in. Por que no los dos? Porque cuando dos cosas no son identicas, no son identicas tampoco.
- api 4y agoMusk is also in China's pocket via Tesla. Anything to the contrary is posturing. Look into how much China factors into Tesla's bottom line. The fact is that we are all in China's pocket to some extent. We are addicted to cheap Chinese labor.
- throwaway23597 4y agoIt's true, and it won't stop me from buying iPhones. I just wish Apple could recognize this and drop the ridiculous self-righteous moral facade. Same with pretty much all companies.
- anigbrowl 4y agoTwitter is far too dangerous to be allowed on the app store Has this actually happened, or is just another attention-seeking rumor being misrepresented as fact?
- nostromo 4y agohttps://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1597300125243944961 https://twitter.com/elonmusk/status/1597300125243944961
- anigbrowl 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33779111 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33779111
- adam_arthur 4y agoThe fact that Apple has threatened to withhold it at all is answer enough. But feel free to live life with your head in the sand
- anigbrowl 4y agoI'm not convinced that it is a fact, though.
- jjtheblunt 4y agowhat the product you typed that with built by a different contract manufacturer than whatever Apple uses? (I don't know the set of all such)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- photoGrant 4y agoI want to believe this is just badly timed. I don't know, I very often want to AirDrop with someone I don't know or have a contact for -- clients of clients, usually... And I've found I set it to 'Everyone' and forget. Which isn't ideal on the odd plane-trip with people trying to be funny...
- pcl 4y agoThere’s a big difference between adding a 10-min option and removing the permanent option though. Plus, it’s notable that apple didn’t use the same 1 hour / end of day / forever system that they use for location sharing.
- mrtksn 4y agoSooner or later Apple will have to losen its grip on the device because if they not, counties will simply try to use Apple as enforcer. Just as with privacy the best road being "We don't have that data", the best road with this is to be able to say "We don't have control over it".
- onetimeusename 4y agoit already has in China. I don't know how much is known to the public but in order to do business in China, Apple has created a parallel Chinese app store/icloud/etc.[1][2] I imagine even the operating systems and possibly hardware differ from what they sell elsewhere. [1]: https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208351 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208351 [2]: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/17/technology/apple-china-censorship-data.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/05/17/technology/apple-china-ce...
- mrtksn 4y agoI'm aware. My guess is, it mostly flies under the radar because this is not happening in Europe or the USA but for how long? What happens when Italy&Hungary starts demanding modifications to protect their citizens against godlessness, abortion, sex out of wedlock, political organisations against them or whatever agenda the far right has? You might say its the same about the "woke culture censorship" but it is not, in the case of the trends that are in mission to design society those people don't shame people out of society or they don't boycott - they physically target people. Many people lost their lives since 2016(The year of Brexit&Trump).
- jrochkind1 4y agoI don't know if a third-party app might be able to duplicate this functionality, but even if so the problem is third party apps can be banned, and can be seen on phones by authorities and used as a reason for suspicion. People have to be bold enough to install it to receive messages too.
- jsnell 4y agoThis seems to have been announced a couple of weeks ago, so we don't need to just trust the tweet: https://www.macworld.com/article/1377200/apple-to-limit-airdrop-everyone-setting-to-10-minutes.html https://www.macworld.com/article/1377200/apple-to-limit-aird... Having it open to everyone for only a limited amount of time actually kind of seems like the right thing, but it's hard to come up with a legit explanation for why they rushed that change to China first.
- brandur 4y agoTo be fair: (1) it seems like the update landed recently, and (2) the article you linked does cite the same reasoning as the Twitter posts. Even if was a little ahead of the more recent Zero Covid protests, it seems like AirDrop's been a known vector in China to share government criticism, which is why Apple's cracking down.
- jsnell 4y agoSure, I didn't mean this in the "this is old news" sense, but in the "this has been verified by Apple themselves, not just a random Twitter account".
- snoot 4y ago> which is why Apple's cracking down. This is absurd. Apple is doing this because of government pressure, not because of their own desire to crack down.
- johnbellone 4y agoYou're both saying the same thing.
- snoot 4y agoNope. They were taking about Apple cracking down. That’s not the same as being forced to make a software change at the governments demand.
- mhoad 4y agoI don’t ever want to hear again how Apple is some champion of privacy and ethics. I’ve lost count of how many scandals have come out of their relationship with China from the suicide nets to the repeated investigations showing their supply chain was riddled with slave labor that they would later campaign against protections that would prevent it. Now this. They are fucked as a company, I can’t get out of their ecosystem fast enough.
- Tijdreiziger 4y agoThe problem is that the alternative (Google) is worse.
- alphabetting 4y agoPretty sure Google has been mostly out of China since Operation Aurora.
- falcolas 4y agoThey're still trying to get back in. See project Dragonfly for example.
- DashAnimal 4y agoDragonfly was discontinued in 2018, MAYBE mid 2019. That is 3-4 years ago.
- falcolas 4y agoAnd? They were booted out of China over 12 years ago. 3 years ago isn't that long, in that timeline. Given their known attempts to get back in, it's likely there are other such secret initiatives we don't know about. China represents a huge potential market for Google that their investors won't let leadership forget about.
- 4y ago
- lazyeye 4y agoI guess this is the kind of blind obedience to an authoritarian regime that 275 billion dollars gets you https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2021/dec/07/apple-china-deal-tim-cook https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2021/dec/07/apple-chi... But never mind, they have rainbow hashtags and censor pepe memes so they are the good guys...
- lazyeye 4y agoI note the downvotes on this post. Silicon valley people are not our friends.
- adam_arthur 4y agoIt actually blows my mind how many Apple zombies exist out there. 99% of them would chastise Microsoft for doing similar things in the 90s/2000s with Windows.
- xpe 4y agoOr perhaps your comment is not considered useful. Be open to the possibility that you can share interests with people that criticize you. > I guess this is the kind of blind obedience to an authoritarian regime that 275 billion dollars gets you https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2021/dec/07/apple-chi https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2021/dec/07/apple-chi... But never mind, they have rainbow hashtags and censor pepe memes so they are the good guys... Speaking for myself (no comment on if I downvoted or not), I tend to not value exaggerations such as "blind obedience". That is not what is happening here. We are seeing parts of a complex power dynamic between a superpower and supercorporation. Dumbing it down is insulting to this audience.
- lazyeye 4y agoCan you provide examples where Apple has taken a stand (at their own personal cost) against China? Doesn't seem to be such a "complex power dynamic" at all maybe? Maybe some "dumbing down" might be useful to a crowd that is disconnected from reality and likes to hide behind language?
- elicash 4y agoI remember in Hong Kong that protesters used a bluetooth app (Bridgefy and maybe others) to communicate.
- tinglymintyfrsh 4y agoIIRC, Firechat was The Thing for PRC and Iran. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FireChat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FireChat Sessions is better than Signal since it doesn't require a phone number. IYAM, it should add Android + iOS serverless&internetless BT support.
- idlewords 4y agoAirDrop was frequently used in Hong Kong, but by far the most popular app for protest stuff was Telegram. There was also a widely used protest website. For what it's worth, Apple also took down a crowdsourced map from the app store that helped people avoid areas with tear gas and heavy police activity, on the grounds that it was somehow endangering the cops. Very shady stuff.
- friedman23 4y agoApple is a deeply evil company.
- jrochkind1 4y agoEven if they really did this motivated by avoiding spam, the fact that dissidents were (not just hypothetically) using it to organize is literally a reason to leave it. But rolling it out to China first is pretty damn suspicious of what their "true" motives were too.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mikysco 4y agoIt's difficult to defend Apple in this scenario but Apple's relationship with China is just like every other company's (western or otherwise) - at the end of the day, China holds all the cards. If you don't bow to their authoritarian edict, you are kicked out of the country. The energy and anger should (as per usual) be directed at China and the Chinese communist party to a much greater degree than Apple. I'm assuming, of course, that Apple was forced to make this update. Hard for me to believe they proactively made this freedom-violating, protest-suppressing change.
- josteink 4y ago> If you don't bow to their authoritarian edict, you are kicked out of the country. Apple, of all companies, can probably afford to do that though. But they keep on doing business there. That’s a bit depressing. (Written on my iPhone)
- falcolas 4y agoThe reason is the same one that most electronics companies (and certainly most cell phone brands) do business in China: It's cheap. Cheap labor, few/no penalties for pollution, abundant cheap electricity, inexpensive labor safety, etc. It's the dream of outsourcing realized.
- acdha 4y agoI don’t know how current it is, but Bunnie Huang wrote a series of posts in the 2000s about what it was like building things in China. It was more than just being cheap, and non-trivial to replicate elsewhere (one memorable quote: “I hadn’t seen blind dedication like this since I worked with the autonomous underwater robotics team at MIT”). Here’s the first one: https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=183 https://www.bunniestudios.com/blog/?p=183
- mhoad 4y agoThis is a breathtakingly naive take. Like yes sure, get mad at the CCP but Apple have a long history of shit like this. https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2020/11/20/apple-uighur/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2020/11/20/apple-u...
- asdff 4y agoThey should implement that in the U.S. too. Plenty of people are getting laughs sitting in public looking for phones to airdrop anything from dumb memes to straight up porn onto.
- falcolas 4y agoSounds like a fine option, but it should not be the only option (as it is displayed in the tweets).
- mensetmanusman 4y agoMore info: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33768185 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33768185
- sfusato 4y agoApple's relationship with China is a colossal liability.
- intrasight 4y agoChina's relationship with everyone else is a larger liability.
- xpe 4y agoYour suggested alternatives Apple should consider?
- InCityDreams 4y agoTaiwan.
- macinjosh 4y agoWhen I signed up for this site 12 years ago I was a huge Apple fan and almost steered my web dev career into iOS dev. Really glad I didn't do that, but also wish I could change my HN username now!
- MerelyMortal 4y agoLikewise. People should watch Apple's famous 1984 commercial. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zIE-5hg7FoA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zIE-5hg7FoA Apple is not the same company it claimed to be back then. Dare I say Apple today is now the company they were against back then.
- gruturo 4y agoWhile there's no UI for this, you can email the HN admins for a username change.
- huslage 4y agoIn what way does this censor anyone? Censorship would be Apple disabling Airdrop altogether, not coming up with some compromise so that its users could still do their work.
- blamazon 4y agoImagine you want to invite a lot of people you don't know, to a protest. This is generally really difficult to do in China without being spotted for re-education. In contrast, Airdrop was previously a good way to do this discreetly. Now it's useless. That is censorship.
- dymk 4y agoDoesn’t seem useless, seems like a good way to make sure people aren’t broadcasting PII by default if they leave “everybody” on.
- blamazon 4y agoIf it's an unalloyed good, why implement only in China right after protests arranged by airdrop?
- andromeduck 4y agoYour phone is always brodcasting PII when the goverment has unfettered access to cell logs.
- karaterobot 4y agoIf you buy Apple products and call for Apple to change their behavior, it will have much less of an effect on their decision making than if you stopped buying their products.
- xpe 4y agoI'm not sure I'm following the options you are comparing. (A) keep buying and criticize (B) stop buying Correct? What am I missing here? (B) has a bigger impact and sends a bigger signal. Right? Talk is cheap. Leaving the Apple ecosystem is hard and demonstrates a very serious complaint.
- karaterobot 4y agoA. Criticize but keep buying B. Criticize and stop buying
- exabrial 4y ago* Apple is not a green company * Apple is not a free speech advocate * Apple builds their products with unethical labor
- kmeisthax 4y agoNeither is Tesla. Musk does not give a shit about the free speech of left-wingers. Tesla's also even more in bed with China than Apple is; both in terms of exploitative labor practices and China owning their demand. And electric vehicles are just a way to greenwash suburbs. EDIT: Nevermind, I got confused with another thread that was talking about Tesla. Leaving this comment up for posterity.
- mym1990 4y agoMusk showed some true colors with the Twitter debacle, my interest in buying a Tesla went from an 8/10 to a 0.
- jansan 4y agoApple is about money, nothing else. Look at their quarterly reports, they are not a byproduct of a higher ethics or anything
- slig 4y agoBut, hey, at least they removed the phone charger and there's no plastic inside their product's boxes.
- xpe 4y agoNothing else? The profit motive ("money") drives a _lot_, but does not explain everything. Different companies make different trade-offs; there are various ways to optimize profit for different audiences with different risk profiles. My point? Don't oversimplify. Few (any?) people here are claiming that ethics are the key driver. We know the PR and ads are a veneer. But there is no need to exaggerate. It is clear that in addition to making money, Apple wants to project a certain brand and ethos, not to mention a penchant for big moves. At times, they are willing to risk some profit in order to invest in, say, a new processor technology. WRT "explanation" / ie interpreting the why behind actions ... Not all large companies make those kind of investments or take these kind of risks. Saying "money" is the only driver fails to account for much of Apple's storied history. Not to mention prediction... Saying that the profit motive is the best or only way to explain Apple (and many other companies) defies multivariate statistics and won't serve well to predict the future.
- nichohel 4y agoIs this possibly protective to the user?
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoIt is plausible to track people using airdrop. This move does also protect protest attendees who can still turn airdrop on when they think they want to receive things. But cause and effect and consequence is for other people to jabber about. I’m not some massive hypocrite like others here. I have Apple products, I don’t need to love Apple. I think the alternative is worse, but that doesn’t mean I need to get into an off-topic rant about how Elon is being mean… because somehow that organically keeps coming up. I would Apple to act in the best interest of their customers. This move is at least some percentage that.
- khazhoux 4y agoI got AirDrop spammed at the airport just recently, after accidentally leaving it enabled for Everyone. I can only imagine what the video contained if I'd clicked on it...
- gorkish 4y agoI have to admit that when you actually look at the details this is a rather perplexing change. Ditto for reading the comments here. Is Apple being Pro-CCP with this change? If you open airdrop to everyone, your device can be tracked and identified individually. When this setting is disabled, this becomes far harder. I'm of the opinion that this change is good and actually increases security across the board, including for the people who are using it to exchange information during protests since it disables a vector for tracking devices.
- droopyEyelids 4y agoAlso, anyone who rides public transportation in a major metropolitan area has probably experienced perverts airdropping them pornography, and this would fix that issue.
- HDThoreaun 4y agoI have not experienced this in my 10 years on the subway.
- warunsl 4y agoI am not sure if you are a man or a woman. Try changing the name of your iPhone to something like "Heather's iPhone" and then turn on AirDrop to "Everyone" on your subway rides. I am sure your experience will be vastly different.
- dymk 4y agoAre you just guessing or do you actually have a reason to believe this?
- Terretta 4y agoCommuting in NYC on Subway. My wife's phone is actually "Heather's iPhone" and it happened any time she accidentally left "Everyone" after e.g. a conference. While she's more amused than offended, she thinks it's a good idea this promiscuous mode will now turn itself back off if she forgets.
- miguelazo 4y agoHow does this actually limit the dissemination of information? You have 10 minutes, and then can reinitiate? Seems like a reasonable security precaution.
- ChicagoBoy11 4y agoI'm an educator and one thing that's actually been happening is some of our older kids will see school buses out on the road and will just try to airdrop obscene content to kids ON the bus. We had literally talked about hoping there could be some default "off" behavior for airdrop, so this actually will (at least for me) be a welcome change in behavior!
- mym1990 4y agoI am wondering if there is pattern recognition that the Chinese government can access where you can see people constantly toggling AirDrop and identify them for prosecution.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mikkelam 4y agoI assume that this is the CCP asking apple to do this or get banned from China. What should apple do instead? I'm curious what people think, it's a tough spot to be in obviously.
- 2muchcoffeeman 4y agoWe heard about this over 2 weeks ago https://www.macrumors.com/2022/11/10/airdrop-10-minute-limit-to-expand-globally/ https://www.macrumors.com/2022/11/10/airdrop-10-minute-limit... This is not in response to this particular protest. iOS16 just dropped, so the timing was coincidental I guess.
- ed25519FUUU 4y agoIf you don’t believe this is in response to protest then how do you explain it being rushed out ONLY IN CHINA?
- 2muchcoffeeman 4y agoI said "This is not in response to this particular protest." This already existed. They did not see the current protest and then suddenly released it.
- fishywang 4y agoNothing in the original tweet suggested it to be in response to this _particular_ protest either. There have been protests via airdrop in china for months.
- 2muchcoffeeman 4y agoI think it could be interpreted that they pushed it out because of these protests. Most people won’t know about the feature until it matters and it’s too late.
- lopkeny12ko 4y agoWhen you work on software available globally, it's very normal to deploy or roll out features region-by-region. This seems par for the course.
- gtirloni 4y ago
- jdmoreira 4y agoare people really surprised the world biggest corporation has to cave to the worlds second largest economy? What do people expect really? Do people even understand the kind of incentives at play here? What does this have to do with the quality of their products? Apple is an artificial entity, a corporation and it's only loyalty by design is with the wallets of it's shareholders. What's surprising about this?
- lemondice 4y agoIn actual practice corporations are only loyal to the board of directors and the officers. Shareholders are just the suckers used to jack up the share price.
- jdmoreira 4y agoYou are right of course. But by definition of the law / "algorithm", it should be all shareholders
- cageface 4y agoThe difference is Apple insists on removing most of the user's control over their device, which makes it an ideal target for authoritarian regimes. Android gives you more control and more options.
- rurp 4y agoWell for one thing, many people seem to believe Tim Cook and other individuals at Apple when they say things like "We believe privacy is a human right". It's worthwhile to point out some of the examples of their actions being contrary to their words.
- jdmoreira 4y agoThose people are naive and have never heard of PR and "spin"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kkfx 4y agoTwo notes: before scream against Apple remember a thing: a company MUST legally comply with States rules where it exists. Witch means: Apple, based in USA, must allow USA authority access anything on their servers AND Apple in China must respect local laws, EVENTUALLY doing various gimmick to respect both. The lesson here is not finger point "someone evil" but finger point the use of proprietary software and services. Theater like "Apple do not decrypt phones for FBI" or "Apple censor Chinese Citizens" etc are theater. The reality is that IF you are a company you comply with local laws. If you just publish free software, NOT services, the end user must, formally, comply with local laws. Sorry for my poor English, not my mother tongue, but I think the concept is pretty simple and anyone with a bit of IT knowledge must know that AND HAVE ALREADY accepted such reality. For Democracy we can't allow proprietary software nor black boxes. No matter if domestically made or not. Is someone with an IT background do find this as extreme and even criticize Apple for it's choice must stop and think a bit: it's an hypocritical behavior even if genuine.
- shellcromancer 4y agoRegardless of where it's rolled out first, this is a good example of reducing the attack surface from remote exploits (which China is known to have and use at contests like Tianfu Cup). Seems in line with changes they made with "Lockdown Mode" that users can opt into.
- travisgriggs 4y agoI'm a little confused by the "Apple's doing bad here" sentiment. The easier to implement, and definitely more effective solution would have been to just disable the Everyone feature completely. Just remove it from the menu. This would have been something like action.isEnabled = self.isInChina Instead, they went through the effort to actually make it still there, but time bombed. They had to add a timeout function, and record the time it was enabled, etc. And at the end of the day, the activist/protestor at a street gathering now has the inconvenience of re-enabling "everyone" 6 times an hour. For me, this basically feels like lip service to the Chinese government, but otherwise a finger. Maybe I'm beeing too myopic.
- killjoywashere 4y agoYeah, I quite agree. Reposting my comment from above here because this makes a better thread ... I think this 10 minute delay might actually be intended to be protective for the protestors. Any radio transmitter is a beacon that can be localized and destroyed. In serious warfare this is a major issue. "I'm up, they see me, I'm down" is drilled into military operators early and often.
- randyrand 4y agoYou think Apple is trying to protect protestors? Do you know which country manufactures the iPhone? Apple is not suicidal.
- xpe 4y agoThere is a delicate balance of action and phrasing in China, no? It seems two contradictory ideas can coexist for significant lengths of time; e.g. see the complexities around Taiwan's relationship with China. Perhaps someone with a deeper knowledge of the culture can explain it better.
- ralfd 4y ago> For me, this basically feels like lip service to the Chinese government, but otherwise a finger. Maybe I'm beeing too myopic. Plus they led everyone know about China in rolling the feature change there first.
- baxtr 4y agoOk, so people jump directly to the conclusion that this was introduced because the CCP asked for it. Yet, if that was the case why limit it only? Why not ask for a complete stop? Is there a case where a protestor benefits from AirDrop but only if it’s more than 10 minutes?
- blamazon 4y agoIt's pretty simple: sometimes people do want to receive airdrops from anybody in a state approved way - when someone is not your contact, but you want them to send you something. Your distant uncle took a photo at a family gathering, for example. Thus, previously, users in China could set their phone to be able to receive airdrops from anybody, all the time. But, problem! Now they can receive information antithetical to CCP propaganda, anywhere they go. On a bus, on a train, at the supermarket, at a grocery store, literally anywhere, they could be exposed to ad-hoc free thought via airdrop. Perhaps something like: "protest tonight at the grocery store! They can't arrest all of us!" In response, now iPhone users in China can still choose to receive airdrops from anybody, preserving the valid use case, but only for 10 minutes after pressing the button. They are now safe from uncensored information for the rest of the day. Train, bus, supermarket, etc. The airdrop protest invite is now dead. A complete ban of receiving airdrops from anyone would cause outrage - it would be removing a useful feature entirely. But the timer is a clever way to neuter its position as a social communication platform without taking the useful feature away. This is how effective social control works - you can't just shackle everyone, you have to give them the impression of freedom.
- baxtr 4y agoSorry. That’s not convincing. How can a 10min limit suppress protests? You’re not answering the question, just telling a story.
- blamazon 4y agoOkay. Let's make it more concrete. Imagine theres a bus full of people and you want to invite them to a protest, discreetly. Before state: some of them have airdrop set to open always and you can just airdrop to them. Move on to the next bus. New state: some of them may have had airdrop set to open always, but it timed out. You cannot airdrop it to them. Protest quashed. I'm still telling the same story but perhaps this makes the mechanism more obvious to you. The fact that you genuinely don't seem to see the censorship shows how effective this strategy is.
- tinus_hn 4y agoOh, the good ole days, when Apple was bad because they allowed people to Airdrop crash pictures to random people, like pilots and fellow passengers
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- victorbstan 4y agoAnother reply said it was coming because of spam. Can this be verified. I’m suspicious of triggered woke/knee jer reaction twitter posts as any source of reliable info.
- rib3ye 4y agoJust google "airdrop spam". It's well-publicized.
- rib3ye 4y agoThis is in response to people spamming AirDrop, a common complaint. Don't jump to conclusions.
- throwaway829 4y agoIf that were true, Apple would just add limiting Airdrop to 10 minutes as an additional default option. Removing Always on airdrop was done because it's the only form of community communications that doesn't go through the Censors.
- throwaway29812 4y agoYou could just turn it off (as it is by default).
- smoldesu 4y agoJust a coincidence that this gets rolled out 9 years after Airdrop debuted.
- rchaud 4y agoTime for a new operating system (if we didn't already hit that mark with the 2013 NSA leaks). Apple, Google, Samsung, Huawei: they all exist at the pleasure of the state. Please ignore their glitzy PR-laden presentations about protecting people's privacy and upholding human rights. They will sell you out in a second if it's convenient. On the mobile side of things, we need, at the barest minimum: - a web based OS with granular permissions for any application that needs to access hardware APIs (just like a web browser) - a general-purpose mobile SOC that hasn't hitched its wagon to Samsung/Apple/Huawei orders. - FairPhone style modular, user replaceable parts, and to encourage an interest in self-repair. - no native-app lock-ins. it's not 2007, the majority of apps people use run fine on a mobile web browser. - significant efforts to fund tech literacy. More than a billion people have smartphones as their first computing device. They don't have the benefit of past knowledge, so they simply accept the locked-down nature of smartphones without question. Meanwhile in 2011, we could openly port Windows Phone 7, Android OS and the original Windows Mobile 6.5 on the same phone.
- Mikeb85 4y agoAt least Google and Samsung don't give in to dictatorships. Yes, hypothetically the US and South Korea hold some power over them... However Google has stood up to Russia, China and others. Unlike Apple...
- yuy910616 4y agoI'd somewhat hesitate to give out credit like that. It's more of that China kicked out Google, thus freeing Google to "stand up" to the CCP. I would love to see more of an example where a company had a lot on the line and still oppose the CCP
- Mikeb85 4y agoGoogle was kicked out for not censoring certain things lol. That's literally standing up to China...
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- neodypsis 4y agoShould all iOS users enable Lockdown-mode in protest?
- pshirshov 4y agoWell, after that image scanning story I've switched to Android with CalyxOS and later migrated to GrapheneOS. Also migrated most of my workflows from MacOS to NixOS. Can't be happier. It's not painful at all to drop Apple phones. And the only thing which is constantly bugging me on NixOS desktop is totally inconsistent hotkeys system. So, it's not that hard drop Apple, just do it.
- fimdomeio 4y agoHere’s to the crazy ones, the misfits, the rebels, the troublemakers, the round pegs in the square holes… the ones who see things differently...
- grumple 4y agoAirDrop to everyone seems like a great idea until your teenager gets airdropped genital pics on an airplane [0]. 0. https://jezebel.com/passengers-keep-airdropping-nudes-and-airlines-apparen-1849483005 https://jezebel.com/passengers-keep-airdropping-nudes-and-ai...
- buildbot 4y agoSomeone did this to me, jokes on them, I know where they live now- airdrop does not strip exif location unless you tell it too :)
- zanethomas 4y agokow-tow to xi jing ping
- Markoff 4y agoit's been like this for weeks, this is not news
- gnicholas 4y agoCan someone make an automation that enables AirDrop for Everyone, waits 10 minutes, and then repeats?
- dkokelley 4y agoThe power dynamic between China and Apple doesn't get enough attention. Apple needs China, but China doesn't need Apple. There are few if any places capable of manufacturing the amount of products China does for Apple, especially at the price. China is also an enormous market to Apple. I don't agree with the treatment of protestors or the use of technology to surveil its citizens, but the bottom line is that in China, China calls the shots. Apple can either get in line or manufacture its phones elsewhere.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lazyeye 4y agoAgreed. And maybe they should not take the high moral ground on other issues, telling others how to think and behave, when they themselves are happy to accept filthy lucre in return for compromising their own ethics. I personally cannot stand these sleazy companies, happy to "take a stand" when it costs them nothing (cheap public relations!!!) but it's a "complicated world" and these issues are not simple, when they themselves bear the cost. Seriously, they can go F themselves.
- hellfish 4y agoI'm sick to death of seeing these corporations pretending to care about human rights, then doing stuff like this Or pretending to care about the environment, then forcing people to buy new devices (with packaging) instead of repairing the ones they already own Or pretending to care about privacy, then scanning local files for "undesirable content" (it doesn't matter what the content is, once the infra is there, it's there to stay) If there's one thing I've learned, it's that whenever a corporation says something that sounds good, it's probably a lie. The only thing that will ever force Apple's hand with regard to this human rights issue is legislation, they've lost the right to trust long ago
- fleddr 4y agoThink Differently...and we will erase you.
- fleddr 4y agoAs they erased themselves, all their tweets deleted since somewhere in October :)
- jbombadil 4y agoBit of a sidenote but I heard that in China iOS has a setting to disallow an app from accessing the internet (either wifi, cellular or both). Why can't that feature make it to the the rest of the world?
- smoldesu 4y agoBecause only China has the means to effectively backdoor it.
- concinds 4y agoFor context: AirDrop was one of the only ways protesters had to communicate en-masse. Signal is unsafe for Chinese protesters, since it requires SMS verification upon signup and is therefore linked to your identity.[0] Mesh networks are the only real solution there, and AirDrop is about the only mainstream one. AirDrop has been used by Asian protesters for years.[1] I highly recomment you read the full China Digital Times article, which gives excellent context, and lets these protesters explain the value of AirDrop in their own words.[1] Apple's timing is unmistakeably suspicious; keep in mind that there have been protests for weeks, which preceded the iOS update. It must also be pointed out that Apple issued an official statement to Western media outlets that the goal was to prevent spam.[2] At no point did Apple ever admit that this was done to follow any government demand. It's unknown whether Apple could be under a Chinese gag-order, but we shouldn't speculate that it's the case unless experts say it's likely. If Apple is complying with a Chinese government orders, then it has an ethical duty to make that public, and again, we have, as of yet, no reason to assume there are gag orders related to this. Apple deserves criticism for the update, and for trying to hide its true purpose. [0]: https://twitter.com/RealSexyCyborg/status/1597072556628279296 https://twitter.com/RealSexyCyborg/status/159707255662827929... [1]: https://chinadigitaltimes.net/2022/11/netizen-voices-apple-restricts-airdrop-in-china-after-sitong-bridge-protest/?amp https://chinadigitaltimes.net/2022/11/netizen-voices-apple-r... [2]: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-11-10/apple-limits-iphone-file-sharing-tool-used-for-protests-in-china https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-11-10/apple-lim...
- jinseokim 4y agoNote: AirDrop is unsafe for broadcasting message anonymously. It will also broadcast your hashed phone number and email[1], which can be reversed by rainbow table. [1]: https://privatedrop.github.io/ https://privatedrop.github.io/
- LinkLink 4y agoTrue, but invalidated by burner and jailbroken phones which are widespread in China. They can definitely catch somebody with a concerted effort but I'd be surprised if the average Chinese teenager couldnt figure out how to make a burner email
- phendrenad2 4y agoAlright, who changed the title? It's now completely incorrect, because AirDrop is only limited to 10 minutes _in China_.
- khazhoux 4y agoAny Apple employee (or really, any large-company employee) would agree that this change is months of work. From the original problem statement (people get spammed when they leave AirDrop set to Everyone), to many strongly-opinionated discussions on how to solve (There's not a problem; Pop up a reminder to disable after an hour; Enable only for some period of time [5 minutes, 10 minutes, 1 hour, user-configured]), and then arguments about how to phrase the UI (yes, even for something this small) and mock-ups and product reviews, and then development + QA and internal/Livability testing, and then coordinating for the actual iOS release. It's a mountain of work, which would have kicked off a long time before any of these protests.
- randyrand 4y agoI worked at Apple. It really depends on how big a change this is under the hood. iOS already has similar infrastructure for bluetooth toggles. If it is low risk, it could make it into a dot release with minimal effort. But yes, minimum time frame a month standard, maybe a couple weeks if it came from high up (which it did) and was time sensitive.
- jsnell 4y agoAnd is it standard procedure for Apple to release these kinds of changes only in China? They're clearly putting massive priority on this change launching in that geography ASAP (for one reason or another), so it doesn't seem hard to believe that this bypassed most of their other process as well.
- ipsum2 4y agoNormally it would be several months of work, but if it was a top level company directive (e.g. from the CEO) it would probably take 3-4 weeks at minimum. Note that protests have been going on sporadically for this entire year. See this article about a protest from Peking university from May 2022: https://apnews.com/article/covid-health-shanghai-china-cbcac582b7d8a92af0ce76e14847b1af https://apnews.com/article/covid-health-shanghai-china-cbcac... and Shanghai in April 2022: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/shanghai-videos-residents-clash-police-china-covid-protest-rcna24520 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/world/shanghai-videos-residents... And in Henan in June 2022: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-61793149 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-61793149
- stereoradonc 4y agoWhen will the world Apple's duplicity? They are NOT private, secure or consumer friendly.
- fishywang 4y agoThe apple apologists in this thread is weird. Sure the timing of this tweet is weird, as people pointed out, that the change actually happened a few weeks ago (there were tweets about it then, but those are mainly in Chinese). But protesting via airdrop has been happening in China for months before this change. Even if we give Apple the benefit of doubt, that they actually planned this change long time ago unrelated to any protests (spams maybe), and the plan is to roll it out to a market for testing before roll out to all markets, with the protests they _should_ change the market for the test. Not changing the plan (that's _assuming_ they really have good intention aka fight spams behind it) will make themselves look bad and they have no one else to blame.
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- ThinkBeat 4y agoHow are they using it? Airdrop is based on proximity as measured by NFC and/or Bluetooth (?), and you can't use it as an ad hoc network mesh to route messages across it.(?) So Activist Organizer 1 can't coordinate with Activist Organizer 2 3 km away using Airdrop unless activists in the space between forwards / routes messages in the right physical direction. If they are well organized from the beginning, then each person (node) can forward each message to 3 - 5 contacts but that requires them to maintain physical formation during the activities. I am not an expert on AirDrop, I am just trying to figure out how it helps out.
- andromeduck 4y agocore organizers typically work in small cells, when an event is decided, that infor needs to filter out first artists/promoters which make the materials then to general public. airdrop is used for the last step, helping an event go viral by spreading material horizontally at high traffic areas like transit hubs and malls with some palusible deniablity. after a recipient recieves that info, they can then airdrop it to their own circle/cell or via word of mouth like normal.
- diebeforei485 4y agoWhy 10 minutes? Why not "until tomorrow", which is how disconnecting from Wi-Fi and Bluetooth works from Control Center?
- sneakerblack 4y agoIt says on the tweet: the aim of the update is to prevent people from sharing protest materials at protests. If you set it "until tomorrow", then they would still be able to share materials
- maxdo 4y agoAnd yet, all the media will be posting every day about Elon Musk decisions and how evil they are :)
- roody15 4y ago