18 ms·
The anti-abundance critique on housing is wrong
- donatj 1y agoThe bigger problem, at least in my neck of the woods, is they're not building affordable housing. By-and-large they are building luxury apartments and luxury homes. We've torn down half the city to build luxury apartments that sit at 20-30% occupancy. Building luxury housing won't help the housing crisis until the sellers are on the brink of bankruptcy and forced to sell their properties at a reasonable price.
- Ericson2314 1y agoAsking why they don't build affordable housing is like asking why don't they build used cars
- bsder 1y agoThe problem is that you don't generally destroy the used car in order to build a new one. So increasing the new cars on the road eventually also increases the number of used cars on the road.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> you don't generally destroy the used car in order to build a new one There is very little de-densification construction happening in hot housing markets.
- elgenie 1y agoDe-densification isn't required; a one-for-one knocking down and rebuilding of a single family residence suffices.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> De-densification isn't required; a one-for-one knocking down and rebuilding of a single family residence suffices Sure. The only reason developers do that is because land-use restrictions prevent the construction of denser, more-profitable and more-efficient housing.
- tiahura 1y agoWhy don't they build $10,000 Ford Rangers anymore?
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> Why don't they build $10,000 Ford Rangers anymore? Fleet economy standards.
- bullfightonmars 1y agoThe same reason housing isn't being built, it was regulated out of existence.
- proggy 1y agoThis is the real answer, not the pat “no one builds new used cars” nonsense. It is entirely possible to build new, no-frills apartments that are 100% habitable and to code. But because of all the regulatory boxes one needs to check — namely all the fees spent, and time spent waiting for seemingly endless approvals — it is simply not possible to rent out bottom-dollar builds at a low market rate. The same logic applies for single family homes sold for purchase. The startup costs are just too damn high.
- SideburnsOfDoom 1y agoIt's simplistic to say that the US car market is "regulated out of existence". Consider how huge trucks that mow down children because they can't even be seen over the hood are unregulated, even incentivised. (1) Wrong regulation, maybe. But not merely "too much regulation". 1) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36480122 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36480122 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/americas-cars-trucks-are-getting-bigger-are-front-blind-zones-children-rcna52109 https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/americas-cars-trucks-ar... https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/24139147/suvs-trucks-popularity-federal-policy-pollution https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/24139147/suvs-trucks-popu...
- bullfightonmars 1y ago
- PaulHoule 1y agoThe project to build https://www.libraryplaceithaca.com/ https://www.libraryplaceithaca.com/ was almost a decade late, like a nuclear reactor, and they realized only after it was built that there is no market in our town for "luxury senior housing" because seniors with money go to Florida or Arizona. If they could fill the places you might say that it's better business to build expensive rather than cheap apartments but when these places are vacant you start to wonder if they are farming tax writeoffs or something https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9wfblqh9icQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9wfblqh9icQ What you expect first is they are going to tell the local town they can't pay the property taxes, in a few years they'll tell the bank they can't afford the loans they took out to build it. Other "luxury apartment" projects outside of Collegetown usually have some segment of subsidized "affordable" units, one of these has at least two police calls to it a day and in the last few weeks these have included murder and arson.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- kccqzy 1y agoHow are they still able to live in subsidized affordable housing after they are convicted of murder or arson? Don't we have jails for this kind of criminals?
- galangalalgol 1y agoExcept that outside of Japan, it is unusual for detached homes to depreciate in value. Apartments though you do have a point. Unless the location adds the value they will depreciate over time.
- freddie_mercury 1y agoIt's not unusual at all. Here's a bunch in America just over the past 12 months and during a huge economic expansion with low unemployment. https://www.realtor.com/news/trends/zip-codes-cities-home-prices-falling/ https://www.realtor.com/news/trends/zip-codes-cities-home-pr...
- nradov 1y agoDetached houses almost always depreciate in value everywhere and require constant maintenance expenses just to keep from falling apart. It's the land under the house that appreciates in value. People often mix those two numbers up.
- s1artibartfast 1y agoNot my experience. Cost to rebuild and cost/sqft seem to outpace inflation.
- infotainment 1y agoExactly -- all new housing is going to be marketed as "luxury". Who is going to build a brand-new apartment and say "well, this is janky low-quality housing, you might want to live here if you're poor or something"?
- donatj 1y agoI go outside and look at my neighborhood of bungalows largely built immediately after the war, they were not sold as luxury. They were sold as affordable housing.
- elliotec 1y agoNo… it’s like asking why they don’t build cheap cars. Which they do.
- kfajdsl 1y agoDo they? Are there any production cars under 20k? Plenty of used ones for that.
- lanfeust6 1y agoThis is a fair point, but the analogies to vehicles don't really work anyway: they're a depreciating asset, houses are not. Even a tiny rundown place can cost millions owing to location. But all things held equal, if you have a new house that's big and a new house that's small, the smaller one is cheaper. And further, mixed density builds will be cheaper than single detached homes. Beyond that there's nothing caked-in to the walls that makes a house cheaper or expensive. Shitty houses are just unmaintained, dilapidated. Flooding the market with houses will drop prices.
- lambda 1y agoThis is a perfectly succinct way to put it. New housing is simply more expensive; so it's marketed as "luxury", and it's sold at a premium to the higher end of the housing market. This reduces demand for the older, more affordable existing housing stock, and with depreciation and wear and tear, the new housing will become more affordable as time goes on. If you're in a market with a shortage of housing, those with more money will simply outbid those with less, even for older, less desirable housing. I've seen it, where when I moved out of my last apartment before I bought a house, my landlady raised rent considerably when looking for a new tenant, and even then she got a tenant who wanted to pay her over the rate that she was asking for to ensure that they were able to get the apartment over all of the other applicants. Wealthy empty-nesters who were downsizing, and willing to pay a premium for an older apartment in a desirable neighborhood, forcing out anyone who might have otherwise been able to afford it. So yes, while it does help for there to be some push to build more affordable housing, if taken to an extreme building only luxury housing will leave an unbalanced market, in a lot of cases building luxury housing is exactly what you want to do to reduce the competition for the existing, more affordable housing stock.
- JumpCrisscross 1y ago> New housing is simply more expensive There is no natural reason for this to be the case. If anything, learning curves and economies of scale should result in new units costing less, not more, than ones built by artisans.
- supertrope 1y agoBaumol’s Cost Disease means construction labor cost rises faster than productivity. We’re allergic to prefab construction - banks and insurance companies block it. A lot of construction workers left the industry after 2007. Baby Boomers are retiring and told their kids to not get a blue collar job. New housing has to be ADA compliant. People expect to give each kid their own bedroom and have two car garage instead of one car or no garage at all. Recent immigration crackdowns and trade wars are the icing on the cake.
- 1y ago
- steveBK123 1y agoExactly Plus housing you are mostly paying for the land. The land is expensive because it is finite and because zoning constrains how much housing you can build on it. In many places the land is 2/3 the cost of the housing. The cost difference in building what left nimbys deride luxury and what would be considered affordable is really marginal. It’s like $100k in finishes in a $1.5M condo type difference.
- 111111IIIIIII 1y ago[dead]
- Der_Einzige 1y agor/cars swears up and down that they'd buy a brown manual wagon pre-used from the factory!
- donatj 1y agoBecause most people are out here driving used Ferraris and Koenigseggs and living in old mansions? Your argument falls apart when you realize they manufacture and sell explicitly affordable cars. It's nearly half the market.
- AlexandrB 1y agoToronto's housing market has a similar problem, except they also mostly built one bedroom shoeboxes for investors. Will be interesting to see how this unwinds[1]. [1] https://financialpost.com/news/toronto-condo-market-falls-off-cliff https://financialpost.com/news/toronto-condo-market-falls-of...
- JumpCrisscross 1y agoAffordable housing is NIMBY whitewashing of reducing supply through rationining. (Note the supporters of affordable housing programmes count the largest landowning families in San Francisco and New York among their ranks.) There is an article on the front page, right now, about Denver moderating its rents through construction [1]. We've also seen this in Montana [2]. [1] https://denverite.com/2025/07/25/denver-rent-prices-drop-q2/ https://denverite.com/2025/07/25/denver-rent-prices-drop-q2/ [2] https://montanafreepress.org/2024/09/09/can-bozeman-find-relief-from-its-burgeoning-rental-market/ https://montanafreepress.org/2024/09/09/can-bozeman-find-rel...
- echelon 1y ago100% "Supply and Demand" is a law of nature. If you build infinite luxury apartments, in the limit their value is zero. Build more luxury housing and the inventory increases. If you've met the city's housing demands (which you probably won't since nearly every city is behind on meeting demand), then it follows that typically less desirable inventory experiences less demand and will subsequently experience a price drop. The problem is nobody is building enough. The equations of taxes, property value, and developer profit all balance each other out and control the rate of building. Regulations slow this equilibrium even more. A few policies that can help: - Remove stupid regulations against building dense housing. Keep the fire safety regulations, but nix the multifamily zoning regulations, the building height regulations, curb space and parking space minimums, etc. There are so many NIMBY and outdated 1950's era regulations that make it costly and time consuming to break ground. - Tax unproductive land use, eg. storage units and parking garages. This will convert those plots into housing and businesses. - Heavily tax unused and dilapidated land that is not currently occupied by businesses or residents. Burned out houses have no place in the city. Tax these properties to the point that they fall into foreclosure and give cities the power to take over the land and sell it at a profit to developers. Give owners the chance to cure the issue, but make quick work of clearing these useless plots. - More controversially, tax single family housing more than multi-family housing. Tax it proportional to how many people could live on the plot if it were occupied by a 10-story development. Or if you don't want to raise taxes, lower taxes on multi-family housing. This will encourage density. - Give tax breaks to developers, apartment and condo complexes, and businesses that help underwrite development. Note that these policies only make sense in dense metropolitan cities. Suburbs and rural areas don't need to operate in this way.
- kccqzy 1y agoBuilding only affordable housing is how you get cities into a downward spiral. The people who want luxury housing are the well-to-do. They probably contribute 10x the sales tax per capita than the people who live in affordable housing. And almost by definition luxury housing causes more property tax to be paid to cities than affordable housing. Both sales tax and property tax revenues shrink. And the city gets into a fiscal crisis. The city reduces services. People leave. Housing becomes more affordable but also more undesirable.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- supertrope 1y agoIf US car sales were capped at 10 million cars per year manufacturers would immediately focus on their luxury brands and leave their regular brands out of stock. When you keep strict zoning, give NIMBYs veto power, let environmental review be weaponized as a delay tactic, you are capping new construction.
- xnx 1y agoThey did exactly this when supply chain disruptions limited the amount of cars they could produce.
- davidw 1y agoBuilding "luxury" apartments dropped rents in Bozeman, Montana, which is one of those cities that "everyone wants to move to" https://montanafreepress.org/2025/06/23/has-bozemans-rental-market-finally-flipped/ https://montanafreepress.org/2025/06/23/has-bozemans-rental-...
- Gigachad 1y agoLuxury is just a realestate buzzword that means newly built and has stone countertops. Nothing that actually meaningfully impacts the pricing.
- nielsbot 1y agoNo matter, it comes down to what people will pay for. At the very least they're selling/renting to people with more wealth.
- Gigachad 1y agoYes, new builds are targeting wealthier people. Those wealthy people then move out of their previous housing and that becomes the affordable housing. Like another commenter pointed out, you can't get affordable used cars without producing new cars.
- bardak 1y agoThe vast majority of "luxury" properties are just regular property that spend a marginal amount on nicer appliances and finishing.
- JKCalhoun 1y agoAgree. I am not seeing starter homes being built in Omaha. They keep moving further out west, north and south — there's nothing there but fields and fields. I'm not sure that they're in anyone's "back yard". And yet, they build expensive homes because (I assume) that is where the bigger profits are.
- xnx 1y agoToday's affordable housing are the "luxury" units from 30 years ago. If you want to decrease the cost of housing you need to build more of whatever people will buy.
- bwanab 1y agoPresumably, if they're sitting at 20-30% occupancy, somebody (like the developer) is going to be having trouble paying their bank loans. You understand what happens next? (hint: prices plummet). If that isn't happening then your diagnosis of the problem is very likely wrong.
- appreciatorBus 1y agoWhen housing is scarce, all housing, even 100 year old dumps, will sell or rent at luxury prices. No one is building apartments made of solid gold or concrete mixed with diamonds. They are building thoroughly ordinary buildings of concrete, wood and drywall. They fetch "luxury" prices & rents because for each one that exists, there are 40 ppl trying to live where, so they raise the price or rent to capture the riches of the 40, despite there being nothing particularly special or expensive about the physical structure. You can do this with non-profit/govt/social/public housing too - if there isn't enough of it, every unit will require a "luxury" of time to wait for it to become available, even if the nominal price or rent is affordable.
- s1artibartfast 1y agoWhere is this city with 20% occupancy?
- tptacek 1y agoSo much of the journalism we read is heavily processed and barely-reported and it's startling to see how much of a superpower simple shoe-leather reporting actually is. Derek Thompson's an incredibly sharp writer, but not really a subject matter expert on housing economics; all he did here was read papers and call up the authorities they cited, and the narrative behind those papers collapsed. We're often so down on journalism on HN, and I believe a big part of that is we tend to read so much opinion and analysis and so little basic reporting. I've been loving Thompson's substack (which is mostly not about housing policy so far).
- wodenokoto 1y agoWhat does it mean that “so much of what we read is […] barely reported”?
- tptacek 1y agoThat the people writing it do very little of their own reporting. "Reporting" isn't writing or thinking; it's the act of collecting external facts. Calling a primary source on the phone is reporting; traveling to a location and observing events is reporting. Synthesizing existing facts and reporting is not reporting. It's still journalism! Reporting is a specific practice within journalism.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 1y agoIt's copy-pasted from Twitter, or it's explicitly a press release from a company with minor rewording. There is no digging for the truth because the news can't afford any labor
- pydry 1y ago[flagged]
- GuardianCaveman 1y agoYou can be aligned with a group who benefits from the same position without being associated with that group or lobbying FOR that group i.e. the KKK members probably want cheaper electricity and I want cheaper electricity but that doesn't mean when I lobby for it, I'm lobbying for the KKK.
- evil-olive 1y ago> The sharpest criticisms of the book Abundance have sometimes come from the antitrust movement. This group, mostly on the left, insists that the biggest problems in America typically come from monopolies and the corruption of big business. ctrl-F "RealPage" - nothing. hmm. ctrl-F "rent" - also nothing. really? from about a year ago: Justice Department Sues RealPage for Algorithmic Pricing Scheme that Harms Millions of American Renters [0] > The Justice Department, together with the Attorneys General of North Carolina, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Minnesota, Oregon, Tennessee, and Washington, filed a civil antitrust lawsuit today against RealPage Inc. for its unlawful scheme to decrease competition among landlords in apartment pricing and to monopolize the market for commercial revenue management software that landlords use to price apartments. > ... > Another landlord commented about RealPage’s product, “I always liked this product because your algorithm uses proprietary data from other subscribers to suggest rents and term. That’s classic price fixing…” if I hear about antitrust in the context of housing policy, RealPage making it easier for apartment buildings to collude on rent prices is the very first thing that leaps to mind. it seems like Thompson is being awfully selective about which antitrust-related criticisms he's responding to here. he seems to be focusing exclusively on building single-family homes, and completely ignoring the concrete example of monopoly power being used for apartment rentals, and antitrust laws being used to address that. 0: https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/justice-department-sues-realpage-algorithmic-pricing-scheme-harms-millions-american-renters https://www.justice.gov/archives/opa/pr/justice-department-s...
- freddie_mercury 1y agoThompson is responding to a specific paper. 'One of the most detailed articles in this space is an analysis of the Dallas, Texas, housing market by the lawyer and writer Basel Musharbash. In “Messing With Texas: How Big Homebuilders and Private Equity Made American Cities Unaffordable”' Musharbash doesn't mention RealPage either, so go blame him, since he doesn't think RealPage contributes to Dallas's problems.
- smcg 1y agoThompson writes these articles to deflect valid criticism.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ThinkBeat 1y agoThere is an incredibly large lobby group who is fully invested in house prices rising or at least not falling, namely homeowners. and since most politicians at a high level usually own one or more houses, they are fully invested in it as well.
- jerlam 1y agoIt's a much bigger group than homeowners. Banks don't want housing prices to fall, since then homeowners start foreclosing and then banks lose interest payments and own undesired property. Cities don't want housing prices to fall, since they were counting on money from developers and property taxes.
- waldohatesyou 1y agoI don’t agree with this take, we’re overly simplifying the nature of housing here. It depends on the housing mix as well. If the vast majority of the pro-housing prices crowd is heavily invested in single family residential then they should favour widespread upzoning and deregulation of apartments because that would increase the value of their SFHs through two mechanisms: 1) presumably single family homes will be destroyed so any remaining single family homes become more valuable and 2) every single family home is now a potential townhouse or high density building which increases the value a developer would pay for it. Are there any serious objections to that line of reasoning?
- jerlam 1y agoNo, what you said is mostly correct; but I'm mostly talking about not having home prices go down, which is different but related. There are different kinds of homeowners. There are those who are flipping houses and directly betting that the values go up, which is the crowd that you're describing. But at least in my area of the world, the majority of the anti-housing crowd is just old and is more anti-change than anything else. Even if the value of their home skyrockets even more, they won't sell and move. Their complaints are more about noise, traffic, and "quality of life" than home values.
- 1y ago
- simpaticoder 1y agoWhat about wealth inequality as the root cause of housing shortage? Even if supply is eased, the wealthy (those who have enough capital to earn passive income) will buy the extra supply and rent to the poor. The Piketty effect takes over, they invest their profit in more housing, wealth inequality continues to get worse, and while more housing exists, it owned by an increasingly small cohort. Personally I'd like to see legal constraints on investment in primary, single-family homes, and fewer legal constraints on building them.
- burnt-resistor 1y ago[flagged]
- tptacek 1y ago"Trickle-down" economics is a direct subsidy for high-income earners meant to spur demand. That's the opposite of what increasing the housing supply does.
- burnt-resistor 1y agoTotally wrong strawman missing the bigger point. It's still a vague, misguided utopian ideology focused on helping the rich supposedly "overproduce" while doing nothing for everyone else. That's trickle-down economics 101.
- tptacek 1y agoWell, you have the economics wrong, and our ability to handwave at each other about whose policy is "miguided" and "utopian" seems like a pretty boring conversation. Regardless: it's obviously not "trickle-down economics". Trickle-down economics are policies that deliberately and directly subsidize the wealthy in the hopes of spurring demand.
- jeromegv 1y agoSupply and demand is not an ideology, it’s the most fundamental way that pricing works in a capitalist society. Has been studied for centuries. To think that supply and demand would not apply to housing and instead be trickle down economics is a hell of a statement.
- denimnerd42 1y agoi hope the next part of his article covers the zoning issues. because I'm certainly not seeing the zoning issues making the homes be on bigger lots or requiring things like 3 car garages? If anything the lots in new tract developments in dallas fort worth are smaller and have less land using features like they don't have alleys. and then in Dallas city limits any small slice of land that can possibly be used for new houses have way smaller lots than any neighboring decades old homes. the only instance I can think of that I know of is there as a historical black neighborhood near love field airport where Dallas changed the zoning to make redevelopment less profitable by requiring the houses take up less of the lot. This way developers can't build huge houses to offset the fact that the land is expensive or they can't build duplexes big enough to make them worth selling either. In fact there were a few duplexes going in to replace detached SFH and the developers were left in the lurch. I think even had to tear them down? I never followed up on the story. This was basically a policy to prevent gentrification by making the land less valuable by policy. Unfortunately gentrification and yimbyism seem like they go hand in hand because if you can develop bigger or more dense the property value goes up and people scream. Where I can see regulation getting in the way is in the new codes. You can't build a house like you could in the 50s-70s anymore The code today is insanely expensive. Now those 70s houses weren't great. But they aren't didn't cost $200-300+/sqft at the low end. in my view new single family housing can never be affordable because the cost is just so high. in fact. generic home ownership is as unaffordable as ever due to inflation. call a plumber to fix a leaky faucet? That will be $300. A new fence? $10k. A new HVAC system? $20k. A roof? $12k. These are all real costs for "small" homes. At least in the rental scenario the costs are controlled because not every single thing is a one-off. There are efficiencies at scale. If it's a housing rental company your maintenance guy is on a route, if it's an apartment you have building maintenance, etc.. The roof repair is a contract worth a million bucks where every roof is only $8000 instead of $12000.
- pixl97 1y agoI feel lucky in the sense that I have both the physical ability and the skill to do almost all of my own maintenance myself. With what I saved on landscaping alone I was able to buy all the tools I needed for almost any project.
- whoknowsidont 1y agoIncredibly dishonest article. It's shocking to see people support this. And I love the way it's framed in a conspiratorial tone, and uses coded language to make you doubt this is a quantifiable problem. All while he ignored many parts of the text he allegedly was critiquing. I'm still shocked that this is getting upvoted. The very first sentence in the article is this: >This group, mostly on the left, insists that the biggest problems in America typically come from monopolies and the corruption of big business. "Insists" is doing a lot of work here to support the rest of the article. But it's lies through omission. >At a high level, I have never found these arguments persuasive Irrelevant if it persuades you. This isn't a high school debate class, facts and metrics are what matters. >One hallmark of a monopolistic market is rising profits. Not even close to true in theory or practice. In theory, monopolies have ever way in order to set prices for whatever goal their after. They may also lower supply thereby lowering aggregate profits. Long term profits can justify anything now. Anti competitive practices are mainstays of monopolies. Not whatever the author just made up. >The Musharbash essay on Dallas—like too much of the antitrust left’s work on housing Oh boy here we go! The boogeyman has been setup, the ominous "they" is out.. checks notes... make housing available for average people. >is filled with out-of-context quotes, overconfident assertions lacking evidence, and generally misguided claims. Pot. Kettle. Black. The next 5 paragraphs are about him talking to Quintero. He starts by framing the issue saying Dallas is not a good fit for Quintero’s theoretical model or previous research, which Quintero agrees with. He then uses this agreement to act like he's right about everything else and even misquotes his "100%". It was shocking to see how we just kind took one affirmative agreement for one thing and turned it into an agreement about another. Talk about hearing what you want! But that's not the rub. The rub is that the Musharbash's essay isn't referencing the John Hopkin's research paper (Quintero) to say DFW fits it's described model, it's that the use of a market intelligence broker has effectively made the firms act as single (or a few) unit(s), enough to make the DFW's conclusions relevant. Here's the snippet from Musharbash: >Over the past two decades, most — if not all — significant builders in DFW have converged on the same source of market intelligence to drive their decision-making: a consulting firm named Residential Strategies, Inc. (“RSI” for short). [0] > [...] While RSI is reportedly careful not to share sensitive information or facilitate explicit collusion among builders, it does not have to do so to play a role in limiting competition. [1] Moving back (unfortunately) to the Thompson article, here's his next little "misquote": >Claim #2: Dallas housing experts say local homebuilders are monopolies who are “devouring” the market. The article didn't even claim this. The quote the source articles quote DIRECTLY below the claim from Musharbash's article really highlights how far out of the way Thompson went to misquote it: From Musharbash's article, whihch again Thompson also hilariously quotes: >Indeed, “[t]he scale and sway of market leaders” — particularly D.R. Horton and Lennar — means they “often monopolize access to trades and vendor resources” in local markets, constraining the ability of smaller builders to build at all, according Unless D.R. Horton is a "local", "Dallas" builder I'm not even sure Thompson misread this piece so badly. If he wasn't an established journalist I'd call into question his reading comprehension skills. So I have to assume it's not stupidity, it's malice. There's also a subtext claim here where he continues to talk with McManus about land use regulations. McManus says land use regulation is the primary and SINGULAR cause of the housing issue, but what Musharbash's article points out is that land use regulations and zoning laws really have changed while the issue continues to intensify: > I discovered that pretty much the same dynamics afflicting blue states are also afflicting red ones — a fact that should have important implications for how we think about housing politics and policy in this country. [2] > [...] not of land use regulations, which have remained relatively stable in recent decades, but of two critical segments of the housing supply chain: The homebuilding industry that builds new houses, and the resale market in which people buy and sell existing housing stock. Both have experienced dramatic changes over the past four decades [3] This is exhausting, not going to lie. But let's continue. >Claim #3: Industry experts have data proving that homebuilding oligopolies are holding back national housing construction [...] Did Lambert agree with the antitrust folks, who love to quote him so much, that the consolidation of big homebuilding companies was hurting housing supply? No. Nope. No again. That's not what was written. Here's what was written: >By facilitating high-priced home sales with these cut-rate mortgages, large homebuilders impose a double handicap on small builders while inflating property valuations in the region as a whole. [4] > [...] The largest homebuilders benefit from this dynamic because they sit on large amounts of real estate whose valuations they want to maintain or raise, but it makes it that much more expensive for small builders to buy land to build on in the first place.[5] >>By tying home sales and mortgages, Dominant homebuilders can sell their houses at higher prices with higher gross margins, while issuing bigger mortgages with bigger origination fees and bigger resale values on the securitization market. As their below-market mortgages get buyers to accept higher sticker prices, these inflated prices feed high-priced comps into local property databases — pushing land and home valuations up market-wide. The largest homebuilders benefit from this dynamic because they sit on large amounts of real estate whose valuations they want to maintain or raise, but it makes it that much more expensive for small builders to buy land to build on in the first place. [6] The picture being painted here is not one of "no one is building houses" but people are building the wrong houses for the wrong reasons. And smaller, local builders aren't able to build the houses people WANT and NEED because the system is let's just say... self-fulfilling. The big builder's aren't going to build you your affordable home. It's not just that they don't have to, but it benefits them not to. More homes at the appropriate market prices would cause their stranglehold to completely unravel. Let me just tab back over to the article yet again and continue. >Claim #4: “X companies account for Y percent of this industry” is a smart way to think about market concentration. You know what, I'm actually done. Terrible article. Terrible journalist. I would say he should feel ashamed but the fact that he's willing to be so dishonest on paper with his name stamped over it tells me he couldn't give a shit. Full on Bullshit Asymmetry Principle (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandolini%27s_law) on display here. Links: [0]: https://www.thebignewsletter.com/p/messing-with-texas-how-big-homebuilders#:~:text=While%20RSI%20is%20reportedly%20careful%20not%20to%20share%20sensitive%20information%20or%20facilitate%20explicit%20collusion%20among%20builders%2C%20it%20does%20not%20have%20to%20do%20so%20to%20play%20a%20role%20in%20limiting%20competition https://www.thebignewsletter.com/p/messing-with-texas-how-bi... [1]: https://www.thebignewsletter.com/p/messing-with-texas-how-big-homebuilders#:~:text=As%20Figure%205%20above%20shows,6.5%20per%20thousand%20DFW%20residents https://www.thebignewsletter.com/p/messing-with-texas-how-bi... [2]: https://www.thebignewsletter.com/p/messing-with-texas-how-big-homebuilders#:~:text=I%20discovered%20that%20pretty%20much%20the%20same%20dynamics%20afflicting%20blue%20states%20are%20also%20afflicting%20red%20ones%20%E2%80%94%20a%20fact%20that%20should%20have%20important%20implications%20for%20how%20we%20think%20about%20housing%20politics%20and%20policy%20in%20this%20country. https://www.thebignewsletter.com/p/messing-with-texas-how-bi... [3]: https://www.thebignewsletter.com/p/messing-with-texas-how-big-homebuilders#:~:text=not%20of%20land,past%20four%20decades https://www.thebignewsletter.com/p/messing-with-texas-how-bi... [4]: https://www.thebignewsletter.com/p/messing-with-texas-how-big-homebuilders#:~:text=By%20facilitating%20high%2Dpriced%20home%20sales%20with%20these%20cut%2Drate%20mortgages%2C%20large%20homebuilders%20impose%20a%20double%20handicap%20on%20small%20builders%20while%20inflating%20property%20valuations%20in%20the%20region%20as%20a%20whole. https://www.thebignewsletter.com/p/messing-with-texas-how-bi... [5] https://www.thebignewsletter.com/p/messing-with-texas-how-big-homebuilders#:~:text=The%20largest%20homebuilders%20benefit%20from%20this%20dynamic%20because%20they%20sit%20on%20large%20amounts%20of%20real%20estate%20whose%20valuations%20they%20want%20to%20maintain%20or%20raise%2C%20but%20it%20makes%20it%20that%20much%20more%20expensive%20for%20small%20builders%20to%20buy%20land%20to%20build%20on%20in%20the%20first%20place. https://www.thebignewsletter.com/p/messing-with-texas-how-bi...
- johndhi 1y agoI know this isn't how our political system works, but if I were king of America I'd try to solve the problem of expensive housing like this: -Confirm housing is too expensive (for whom, where) -Ask people why they think housing is too expensive and read some books on the topic -Come up with a list of a few reasonable reasons from said reading -try addressing those reasons with experiments in different locations to see what works (or check if someone has already done this) -apply learnings broadly. Instead our system is more like: -try to get elected and win points by criticizing others' ideas -do nothing or spend a trillion dollars trying to solve it based on an idea a lobbying group told me is the reason housing is expensive -be replaced by someone who disagree with me completely in 2 or 4 years
- tyleo 1y agoThe first part of this may be overly simplistic but I got a good chuckle reading the second part.
- rahimnathwani 1y agoIf you like instances of people calling out citation misrepresentation, you may enjoy Brian Conrad's report about drafts of the California Math Framework: https://sites.google.com/view/publiccommentsonthecmf/#h.ko8ql1hqpzxf https://sites.google.com/view/publiccommentsonthecmf/#h.ko8q... Sadly, many of the issues he called out remain in the final, approved version.
- deckar01 1y agoI find the term “anti-abundance left” odd. He wrote a book called “Abundance” laying out the case for deregulating zoning laws. Claiming global monopolies in aggregate seems more like a conspiracy theory. I thought the mainstream (left) opposition to deregulation was to subsidize affordable housing regardless of the cause.
- tptacek 1y agoRestating something I said upthread, but I think the right way to think about Thompson's rhetorical adversary here is "people on the political left who believe that antitrust is the high-order bit on housing affordability and that zoning reform shouldn't occur until after antitrust issues are addressed". He's arguing with people who are pushing back on legalizing housing density. He is not arguing broadly against the political left; in a reasonable US macro view of politics, he is part of that political left; there are people much further to his left that are nonetheless in lock step with him on housing, all of whom I believe he'd be thrilled to endorse.
- specialist 1y agoParaphrasing: along with a dozen other pressing issues, anti-trust was out of scope for this book. > He is not arguing broadly against the political left... Yes and: NIMBY vs YIMBY is (mostly) olds vs youngs, rather than partisanship. Witness the coalition behind the Montana Miracle (recent pro-housing legislation). So far. As you know, most positions eventually get coded as left or right, as needed, to defend the corptacracy.
- tptacek 1y agoThere really is an internal struggle in the Democratic party (totally natural after a major election loss!) and people are just inclined to read everything as taking one side or the other in it. Ironically, Klein and Thompson really tried to go out of their way not to take either side; in fact, most of the oxen that get gored in the book are establishment Democrats!
- mlhpdx 1y ago> … profit margins as a share of overall home-sale prices actually declined slightly So the profit in real terms more than doubled? At a constant percentage home building and gas pumping both become more profitable when unit prices increase faster than inflation. The vapid arguments around this topic are tiring.
- chrisg23 1y agoAll I know is I moved to the Dallas area 4 years ago, and I'm still shocked at the housing affordability compared to where I moved from. Both in terms of absolute price and general overall cost of living.
- whatever1 1y agoHousing crisis is just a result of increasing income inequality and the resulting real estate investment craze. The population of America (real demand) did not suddenly double at any state/city. Rich have become so much richer that can afford bidding wars at unattainable prices. They can buy investment homes and be cashflow negative for decades in anticipation of the increased market bidding prices. Of course they oppose any sort of legislation that would increase competition.
- appreciatorBus 1y agoThe population of a place doesn't have to double, or even change at all, for prices to go up. All that is necessary is for more people to want to live in a place. Those with the $ to satisfy that desire will outbid those who don't and you can easily double/triple/10x prices with no change in population.
- whatever1 1y agoHow come more people want to live in the entire US if the population is relatively flat? Prices are up everywhere. The only answer is that the increased observed demand is a result of the increased investment demand (rather than native demand)
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- loeg 1y agoYour factual statements are wrong. The US population isn't flat over time, and housing (supply) decays over time. Prices aren't up everywhere, just the places people actually want to live.
- whatever1 1y agoLet’s see some data: https://jabberwocking.com/we-dont-have-a-housing-shortage/ https://jabberwocking.com/we-dont-have-a-housing-shortage/ Housing construction exceeds the population growth for the past 20 years. But housing prices are skyrocketing especially the last 10 years.
- jmyeet 1y agoThis "Abundance" nonsense is simply liberal repackaging of Reagan's trickle down economics and deregulation. That's all it is. Reagan's policies were designed to transfer wealth from the young and the poor to the old and the wealthy. Abundance will do (more of) exactly the same. The very best case fo housing deregulation as per this Abundance nonsense is Houston. And that's only if you have essentially unlimited land. Private industry simply will not lower house prices long term. We need to stop with this nonsense of looking for market-based solutions and public-private partnerships. The only solution to housing is for the government to maintain a sufficient stock of quality housing such that the private sector simply cannot corner the market to drive up prices. The example I always come back to is Vienna where ~60% of the housing stock is owned by the government. Residents essentially have permanent leases. It's affordable and accessible. Vienna has some of the lowest rents in a European city. The purpose of the modern Democratic Party in the US is support American imperialism and to not upset their corporate donors. "Abundance" only exists so Ezra Klein can get invited to all the cool parties, get speaking engagements and generally curry the favor of the billionaire class and the Democratic establishment. It's just a liberal face on Reaganism.
- ajmurmann 1y ago"your margin is my opportunity" will lower prices and does so in all areas of the economy that aren't highly regulated. The exception are of course cartels but Thompson shows here that those aren't present
- specialist 1y agoHow would government go about creating that additionl housing?
- jjk166 1y ago> So, Dallas doesn’t meet Quintero’s oligopoly threshold. Now let’s consider the rest of the country. I tracked down a complete listing of the country’s 50 largest homebuilding markets, from #1 Dallas to #50 Cincinnati. How many meet Quintero’s first oligopoly threshold (two companies = 90 percent of the market)? Zero out of 50. And how many meet his second threshold (six companies = 90 percent of the market)? One: Cincinnati. It turns out that the largest homebuilding markets just aren’t that concentrated > I wanted to know how a careful monopoly-hunter like Roberts would answer the question: If six firms account for 90 percent of a local industry, is that automatic proof of a monopoly? “No, it’s not,” Roberts said. “The statistic isn’t totally vacuous, but there’s basically no useful information about market power in that statistic alone.” --- > the number of new single-family houses permitted per capita in the Dallas metro area rose steadily between 2010 and 2022. (This is illustrated in the graph below[1].) I mentioned to Quintero that steadily rising construction per capita in a fast-growing city seemed like a weird example of monopolistic abuse. > First, he uses 2006 as his baseline. This was a highly atypical year in housing. Just before the housing crash that triggered the Great Recession, May 2006 was the peak of 21st century construction employment. That very month was construction's single highest share of total employment since the postwar era. Using a bubble year as a baseline could easily throw off the overall findings of any economic analysis. [1] graph clearly shows long term downward trend, with growth from 2010 to 2022 being entirely recovery post 2008 crash and still being below late 90s levels. --- > The whole thing looks like a lawyer who arrived in Dallas with a conviction in hand and shaped the evidence to fit the indictment. *spends entire article cherry picking evidence in an attempt to discredit one article specifically to advance a competing narrative.
- whoknowsidont 1y ago>spends entire article cherry picking evidence in an attempt to discredit one article specifically to advance a competing narrative. Worse than that. He's lying about what the article claims. Straw-man is too generous of a term, he's blatantly just making shit up.
- mactrey 1y agoDo you have an example?
- pembrook 1y agoWhile we’re debunking that can we debunk the weird leftist conspiracy theories around index fund companies like Blackrock “buying up all the residential homes.” Yes, the largest index fund company that sells investment products that allow people to invest in indexes (entire markets) is going to defacto be a custodian on holdings across the entire economy, including homes. Operating the funds offered in your 401k doesn’t mean they own the companies that invest in residential real estate. It means you actually do. If you have a 401k it’s actually you who is in this “secret evil cabal.”
- whoknowsidont 1y ago>While we’re debunking The entire article is just blatantly lying about what the source article says lol.
- dinkumthinkum 1y agoWhile, I am not onboard with leftist conspiracy theories, I find the defense of BlackRock a little odd: "You have to force behaviors. At BlackRock, we are forcing behaviors." - Larry Fink, CEO of BlackRock.
- pembrook 1y agoI won't defend Fink's role in pushing the whole 2010s ESG mania, but they were ultimately toothless in that too, because they are a glorified custodian of funds...nothing more.
- huitzitziltzin 1y agoNot surprising at all to hear that Matt Stoller got the economics of an antitrust issue wrong. I appreciate the attention he brings to the topic and his diligence in digging up stories but his own analysis is often just totally wrong. I don’t think he’s worth taking seriously as an analyst. Maybe as a reporter at best.
- whoknowsidont 1y ago>Not surprising at all to hear that Matt Stoller got the economics of an antitrust issue wrong. I mean he didn't. The article is legitimately straw-manning. All of his claims are not present in the source article. It's a disgusting, sleazy piece of journalism. So no, you didn't hear he got it wrong. You were lied to by the author.
- huitzitziltzin 1y agoI have a PhD in economics with a specialization in antitrust policy. Fact: “Matt stoller gets big, important issues wrong in antitrust all the time and his analysis shouldn’t be taken seriously.” Source: me You are welcome to cite that.
- whoknowsidont 1y agoBut he doesn't get them wrong. Your opinion on this is like a doctor saying the COVID vaccines don't work. Sure you _might_ be a doctor, but your position is objectively deficient on this topic. ALSO WEIRDLY, it's noticeable you didn't have anything to say about the fact that he's strawmanning. You don't need a hyper focus in any field to see that's exactly what the author did. Or the fact that you don't seem to care about it. Want to explain that one buddy?
- scoofy 1y agoIt’s difficult to get a man to understand something when the value of his home depends on his not understanding it.
- cyberax 1y agoSigh. The whole housing narrative has been hopelessly taken off the rails by well-meaning but clueless urbanists. And quite predictably, once the poisoned fruits of their labors start to bloom, it's always the fault of capitalism. Or maybe foreign investors and private equity.
- IFC_LLC 1y agoPretty much any criticism of a current housing market can't happen without mentioning the quality of said housing. I have just come back from one of the apartments I was looking at to see an abysmally small shoebox with some sort of doors and windows installed in there. I live in a house with 9-foot ceilings and I feel like a king. But this is insane. Recently I've visited a rental property to find shallow, not sound-proofed walls, askew doors made of something that looks like paper and not a single straight corner. And this is a 2023 build! It's brand new. And still looks awful. I have an article about that. https://medium.com/@ifcllc/qualification-f33ec8fcb736 https://medium.com/@ifcllc/qualification-f33ec8fcb736 but man, it's getting worse and worse. Just to have a 2-room apartment that I used to live in 30 years ago would cost over 1.5 mil today. Adjusted for that inflation of quality.
- Schiendelman 1y agoThat's right, and that's caused by restrictions on supply. Almost every problem we have with housing comes down to us restricting how much can be built so much that extremely low quality units are competitive. If you allowed 10 times as much construction, those units wouldn't be able to compete, because other builders would offer better units for the same price.
- ajkjk 1y agoIt seems like fewer restrictions would mean more garbage getting built.
- chiefofstuffs 1y agoDepends on the restrictions. Not being allowed to cast a shadow on the neighbor’s zucchini garden or having to pay off permit expediters has no impact on building quality, mandating wood vs cardboard does.
- jagged-chisel 1y agoThe idea is that there will be more competition.
- BrenBarn 1y agoThis makes sense, but as far as I can tell it doesn't really answer the question of whether the housing crisis is driven by "monopolies and the corruption of big business". It just rebuts a particular article's claims about whether the housing market is driven by monopolies in the homebuilding industry. But I would say the issue is larger than that. Monopolies and corruption in general have led to great wealth inequality and that is at least exacerbating (if not driving) a housing crisis in many places.
- phendrenad2 1y agoToo often people hear that some lions escaped from the zoo, and then hear that shoplifting went up, and decide that the lions must be robbing convenience stores. Sometimes a problem and a cause don't snap together so obviously. I'm no fan of private equity but I've tried to inject some perspective into discussions on HN where people automatically assume that "private equity has operated in a space" and "there are problems in the space" form a complete mathematical equation and we don't need to look beyond them for any other factors.
- throwawaybob420 1y ago“Abundance” is neoliberal BS. Typical centrism, half measures that don’t actually make anything better and manage to make everyone angry.
- didibus 1y agoI just couldn't keep reading with the constant "antitrust left" being refered to on every sentence. The issue, is that for me, the reader, it framed the piece as the author seemingly positioning themselves as the "the other side", the one that knows best and isn't those "antitrust left". It felt like it was creating a strawman and was engaging in tribal signaling. And when you consider the rest of the piece was them claiming they called the sources, and that the sources said that the "antitrust left" had misquoted them and misrepresented their findings, but the author somehow is this unbiased truth, and definitely really for real called the the sources and didn't at all misconstrue or anything, no they wouldn't do that, unlike the "antitrust left".
- shazbotter 1y agoI'm about as far left as you can be, as a syndicalist anarchist, and I definitely perceived a bit of what you described. But I'm not super worried about it because he didn't say "the left", but rather a specific lefty position. But also, the left isn't uniform on housing policy. Some folks want anti trust and limited capital ownership. Some folks want to de commodify housing. Some folks want all housing to be government built and owned. The left is a very diverse place (and the joke is no one hates leftists more than other leftists).
- gwd 1y agoThen why even bother calling it "left" at this point? Just say they're anti-monopoly. Is there really nobody on the right who are also anti-monopoly?
- shazbotter 1y agoPresumably because anti monopoly right is much less common? Or because the anti monopoly right is concerned with different aspects of monopoly? If someone said they were anti monopoly, that the government should do something to prevent businesses from operating like that, I'd never expect them to be from the right to be honest.
- energy123 1y agoHere's the political solution: Do both public housing and zoning reform. Unlike zero-sum political disputes where there is a winner and loser, this is a rare issue where both camps can win without impacting the other camp. What we should not do is give the left their worst ideas, like rent control or stopping AirBNB. Give them their best idea, which is public housing.
- rcpt 1y agoYou realize that local busybodies hate both of those things and they're the only political group that matters
- lanfeust6 1y ago> Here's the political solution: Do both public housing and zoning reform. You just described the Abundance agenda. Do whatever is politically viable to build more.
- didibus 1y agoMost interesting proposal I heard on this topic, is that the solution to housing prices is to ban renting altogether. It's so radical that it's almost impossible to predict if it would be better or worse. But at least it had the moral ground that rent is one of the last remnant of pre-capitalist lords and barons economies. The idea being it would commoditize housing. Millions of units would now be for sale, prices would drop, tons of people would now be able to afford buying. Home builders would be incentivize to build nicer, cheaper, as the competition would move entirely to the selling/buying market. It's radical for sure, but I've always found the thought experiment fascinating.
- cyberlurker 1y agoPrices would drop where homes are commonly rented. I suppose rent could turn into lease to own in the interim period. It’s an interesting idea, I wonder if any economists have played it out. What about those people that have homes but rent out a room? Or a townhouse that has 3 units, but the landlord lives in one? I guess they could sell the units or move to a smaller place, but I think there may be an adverse effect of potential housing staying locked up because there isn’t a legal way to preserve options of ownership. It may decrease housing in some instances. Which force is more powerful though, I am not sure.
- dinkumthinkum 1y agoIt wouldn't work. Good luck trying to enact that. Also, the amount of leftism in this thread is like a pure-sugar-diet for Marxists. When houses have no value, people don't value them. Look at what happens when you give large amounts of people free housing, what do they do with it?
- didibus 1y agoI don't know about the left/right. But like I said, when I read this idea, it was presented as an argument that the housing market was not capitalist enough, and that was the issue. In order to properly make it capitalist, so it can act like our other markets, you need to ban rent-seeking and landlordism which are pre-capitalism models that date from the old days. It would not allow for example the government to hand out "cheap to rent housing either".
- matthest 1y ago"Abundance" is really just supply and demand 101. Which has proven to work over and over and over and over again throughout human history.
- robertclaus 1y agoQuote: "I don’t see the value in discussing a “national” crisis in homebuilding oligopoly from which the 49 biggest metros are exempt." I enjoyed most of this article, but it did slide into opinions periodically. This quote in particular stood out given the issues rural communities face regarding availability of competition in a lot of other services.
- michaelmior 1y agoAgreed. Especially since more than 50% of the population lives outside those areas.
- mayneack 1y agoThis is a very online oriented debate. Derek Thompson might hear mostly from left coded anti-trust types on twitter, but I really don't think that's the main opponent to abundance. If you spend time in the individual communities where this battle happens, the voice of the classic NIMBY (worried about property values and crime) drowns out the left-NIMBYs that worry about "greedy developers" and gentrification. At least that's been my experience in West LA. Many of the less-online left critics eventually come around to realize that upzoning type solutions and public housing type solutions aren't actually in conflict with each other even if they disagree on relative priority and impact.
- cyberlurker 1y agoAm I wrong, or is this kind of a silly date range considering the housing crash was in the middle? > According to the National Association of Home Builders, profit margins as a share of overall home-sale prices actually declined slightly between 2002 and 2024.
- asta123 1y agoIn Australia most of the narrative on the housing affordability crisis is around lack of supply and nimbyism. In the meantime Melbourne has dropped to 4th most expensive city in the country and becoming more affordable. Most likely reason - land tax change in that state which is turning off accumulating multiple properties through investment and investors turning to other states where prices are still going up. So, while supply is relevant, I would say it is investor demand that is driving prices up.
- jondwillis 1y agoIt’s not a coincidence that many abundists see nothing wrong with rent-seeking. They’re incentivized by it. Rent-seeking has corrupted market forces. Mao 2.0 will arrive eventually.
- pitaj 1y agoThis reverses causation. Investors are involved because prices are going up, not the other way around. "Investors buying up housing" is a common explanation alongside "short term rentals taking over" but neither make up a large enough portion of the demand to explain prices.
- dv_dt 1y agoIn a feedback loop, every element in the loop is both a cause and an effect. The way to stop the feedback is to shift one or more relationships in the loop. If you are lucky there can sometimes be arranged some convenient control elements- but in many difficult problems a lever that you can pull that only affects that one thing doesn't exist. You have choices of levers that affect a multitude of things, maybe many of which go counter to the desired independent effect
- h2zizzle 1y agoI don't know what's so hard to understand about the idea that prices are high because the people who have the most influence over the prices want the prices high.
- 999900000999 1y agoExcessive regulation is 90% of it. Here's how a rational market works. If I build an apartment complex, eventually those apartments will get older and more affordable. And even before that upper middle class folks will move in, freeing up their previous homes. But that's not how many in local governments see it. So you have affordable housing quotas on new developments. You have developers building units for the homeless at 600k each. https://abc7news.com/post/new-high-rise-building-house-skid-row-homeless/14976180/ https://abc7news.com/post/new-high-rise-building-house-skid-... Affordable housing vouchers, section 8, etc, become a dystopian nightmare. 11 year waiting list. https://laist.com/news/section-8-waiting-list https://laist.com/news/section-8-waiting-list The problem is twofold, first it's too difficult to build homes. In California you can literally just claim a new highrise will block your sunlight and make you sad. That's enough to delay a construction. Parking requirements ensure space that could be occupied by people is instead reserved for vehicles. Plus the parking structure itself drives up the cost to build, 30% of your construction cost isn't unreasonable. On a macro level, many cities should of fixed their issues with inadequate housing construction decades ago. On a personal level, you need to go where you can afford. After about 4 generations of living in LA about half my family has left. It's more than possible to make it off a middle class salary, but you need to make that choice. If you stay in an unaffordable city you can't wait around waiting for politicians to fix it.
- imgabe 1y agoFor years in Washington DC there was one single crank who went to every community engagement meeting and prevented hundreds of units of housing from getting built.
- mjvmroz 1y agoI’ll be so interested to see what happens to this kind of thing. I feel like we saw the absurd version of it over the past decade, where society at large had acted as though highly online reactionaries are quality signals of an underlying current. It seems as though market share in that model is failing. I predict the pendulum will swing the other way across the board, and loud minorities in in-person forums will be given less credence… for good (by my estimation in this case) and bad.
- jrflowers 1y agoThis is one of the funniest articles I’ve read in a a long time. I’m not sure what is better, the “I quite literally set out to find support for my narrative and find exactly one (1) guy that’s both willing to call himself an expert and give me my desired answer for each of my individual points” thing or the lazy neocon virtue signaling > The antitrust left I love this phrasing. Derek Thompson has done some Serious Journalism and has discovered that if you support competition between homebuilders you are a Leftist. Also there isn’t a concentration of homebuilders (in Dallas) but even if there was it doesn’t affect prices (in Dallas). Well there may be a concentration of homebuilders nationally, but Thomson spoke to a guy that doesn’t care about that. Anyway, wasn’t the takeaway from the Great Recession that monopolies are good? But then I’m not sure he knows what a monopoly is > If a homebuilding monopoly purposefully made crappy new homes, they’d be out-competed quickly Or what is a good outcome or a bad outcome > Can big companies hurt subcontractors by forcing them to accept lower prices? > “Maybe, but if big homebuilders can offer trades longer guaranteed contracts” Hmm… they can force subcontractors to accept lower rates, but that’s not that big of a deal because they can force them to accept lower rates for a longer period of time. Like for example it would suck to have your paycheck cut in half but knowing that there’s no chance of it going back up for several years would take the sting out of it. This is the reasoning of somebody that took a Hat Man dose of Benadryl
- moneycantbuy 1y agoGary's Economics claims wealth inequality is at the root of housing unaffordability. Basically as wealth concentration grows, the ultra-rich bid up the assets. See the price of gold doubling in the past few years. Government stimulus is also captured by the richest. It's also a global phenomenon, i.e., every major city is now unaffordable for most people. https://youtu.be/BTlUyS-T-_4?si=P0mdHxtq1F7DV4jo https://youtu.be/BTlUyS-T-_4?si=P0mdHxtq1F7DV4jo
- imgabe 1y agoThis doesn't make sense. Each wealthy family can only live in one house at a time. Yes, they might have multiple homes, but a billionaire having a luxury vacation home in Lake Tahoe or a penthouse in Manhattan are not the reason housing is unaffordable. The type of home a billionaire would buy would never be affordable anyway.
- moneycantbuy 1y agoBill Gates owns 275,000 acres in the USA. I doubt he's even gazed upon half of it. The billionaires aren't buying homes to live in like us proles, they're buying lots of finite land and water rights and such.
- imgabe 1y agoThat is about .01% of the US land area, and I’m guessing it’s not downtown in major cities or other places that people want to live. It’s probably mostly undeveloped wilderness for conservation, right? That has zero effect on home prices. There is no shortage of land in the US. There are huge, huge empty spaces. There is only a shortage of housing in places where people want to live because local governments won’t let anyone build new housing. Edit: Looked this up, and Bill Gates owns farmland, which is producing food, so this also wouldn't be available for people to live on anyway.
- shazbotter 1y agoYou assume they are buying homes to live in. I don't think that's a reasonable assumption. Maybe they buy real estate because it's a useful part of a portfolio. They can rent it or just sit on it and sell it later.
- Atlas667 1y agoY'all are discovering how censorship in capitalism works... It's about volume(loudness), access(to data) and exposure(visibility).
- herf 1y agoCorrelation isn't causation - the post here says smaller homebuilders can't get financing right now, and so a supply shortage is correlated with larger actors who can, but it isn't caused by concentration directly. The question is if government can have remedies for broken markets other than breaking up companies, because here it sounds like "fixing builder financing" would help: https://x.com/NewsLambert/status/1951100530341847343 https://x.com/NewsLambert/status/1951100530341847343
- DeathArrow 1y agoOver reglementation and over regulation is also destroying housing markets in Europe. In some European cities new homes are scarce and prices are skyrocketing. While politicians claim they are protecting the people and the environment.
- ZeroGravitas 1y ago> The Builder’s Daily sounds like an anti-monopoly shop. But in our conversation, McManus sounded like a straight-up YIMBY. This is a false dichotomy. His opponents are clearly claiming that oligopolies restrict supply. Therefore they are intending to be YIMBY even if they might be wrong about the cause of the restriction. So this is a weird rhetorical attack that undermines the claims in the rest of the piece. And now I think about it, it applies to the title too.
- camgunz 1y agoThe housing crisis is a cultural problem. We don't want to build density, and we don't want to build transportation, because this all lowers housing values, and besides the millions of homeowners you'll piss off, you'll destabilize an economy primarily built on the mortgage. Not a good reelection plan. The places you're seeing growth are places where we could buy the land for cheap: suburbs and exurbs. We build huge ass subdivisions and then we run highways to them. This fucks no one's housing value, it bails out struggling/dying land owners, the auto industry loves it, the energy industry loves it, people love their faux-castles with lawn moats, it's a full employment plan to developers, and it's essentially all middle/upper-middle class housing so it's thoroughly unobjectionable to the voting majority. The reason cities in Texas are out building blue cities is that they just do the suburb/exurb thing. Blue cities don't: where are the workable SF or NYC exurbs? Abundance gets so close, it more or less blames bureaucrats and the Jane Jacobs veto points built into the liberal building process. But these things arise out of the culture on the left, and whether we admit it or not, we like the walled gardens we built. We like our multi-million dollar castles we've got something like $80k in. We like people not driving/riding trams/buses through our neighborhoods, and we vote accordingly. I personally think this is intractable. I think SF/NYC/etc have reached the ceiling and if we're gonna fix the housing crisis we need to build density elsewhere. I think we should lean heavily into remote work, lighten the infra grid costs with off-grid tech like solar, lighten the construction costs with low-car built environments (few if any parking requirements, rail instead of huge highways for shipping/transit, etc), invest heavily in the schools, and subsidize people moving to these areas--like with cash, not tax rebates. This is essentially "build the exurbs", but the progressive version of it that better meets health and climate goals, while also building communities we know are better for human flourishing (less isolation, more eyes on the street, etc). Focusing on permitting reform or democratic veto points is way, way too small a vision here.
- solatic 1y agoSF is surrounded by water on three sides. Palo Alto was the suburb. San Jose was the exurb. You could build 50 story towers all over San Francisco and it wouldn't suddenly make it feasible to build on water. New York has a similar story. You can't build on the Atlantic. Brooklyn and Queens were the suburbs. Long Island and Hartford were the exurbs. The US simply needs to build new cities, and link them with high-speed rail. You do that by taking federal spending (military bases, universities and research labs, tax cuts for large industries) and directing it to places that would fit according to a high-speed-rail master plan. Opportunity Zones have shown a lot of promise at helping to direct capital to under-developed regions, but the lack of a larger master plan in helping link these regions with better transportation links and job creation has prevented them from reaching their full potential.
- rob_c 1y agoSo the simple easy to digest lie ends up wrong... There's a common theme emerging here.
- DaveZale 1y agoFor the Western US? It's all about water scarcity.
- thrance 1y agoAbundance liberalism still seems like a poor attempt to curb the populist left to me. Let's look at it from a high-level. "Fixing" the housing criris would require a major depreciation of housing assets. Does anyone believe the companies and individuals holding onto multiple homes will accept this without fighting? Of course not. The same people that are arguably responsible (directly or indirectly) for the housing crisis have a vested interest in it persisting. And we know how powerful their voices are with the establishment democrats, the ones this ad-hoc "abundance" movement defends. There is no simple solution to this crisis, it will require something more radical than just tweaking some numbers on a spreadsheet.
- wilkommen 1y agoI have the same view on it as you. The "abundance" people are carrying water for the establishment while trying to co-opt disaffected voters (who might otherwise find their way to the populist left) into a way of seeing things that won't meaningfully alter the status quo. Any solution to the real problems our nation is facing will require a shift of who holds power. The "abundance" folks are doing anything to distract people from the fact that this is all about power.
- wilkommen 1y agoMonopolistic activity and corporate consolidation are driving up prices in many industries in the United States. Why wouldn't corporate consolidation be a major factor in driving up housing prices, like it is in so many other sectors? I am suspicious of journalists like Derek Thompson and Ezra Klein because their solutions seem to punch down on municipal governments and homeowners instead of punching up at our nation's corporate masters and elite class, who would be much more threatened by effective antitrust action against homebuilders than they would by a movement to deregulate zoning in cities. I am open to the idea that excessively restrictive zoning could be a part of the problem, maybe even a big part. But I am skeptical of anyone who wants to act like excessive regulation is the sole driver of skyrocketing housing prices. It doesn't hold water to me.
- tvier 1y agoThis opinion sets up corporate consolidation as the cause of all issue in the US. I don't think it makes sense for that to be the null hypothesis that needs to be disproven. For this specific issue, homebuilding, and construction in general, are very regional businesses. There just aren't a few giant homebuilders controlling the industry across the nation. There are certainly some antitrust issues with rentals, but they don't seem to be nearly as widespread as the housing issue in general. I don't think the punching down vs up lense is a particularly effective way to analyz this issue. Nor do I think its easy to figure out who's "down" and who's "up".
- adammarples 1y agoFrom the article: a) there is not really monopolistic activity going on, and b) homes have a fierce second hand market which pushes down on this
- ph1sch3r 1y agoA contributing factor to housing costs I don't often see mentioned is urbanization. In the 21st century, population density has increased faster in major cities than rural areas. The picture is probably more nuanced in the last half decade (post COVID), with many people moving to the countryside.
- mactrey 1y agoAnother factor is smaller households. People are staying single longer and waiting longer to move in with partners, creating more demand for housing even without population growth.
- talkingtab 1y agoFish Tank Thinking is where your thinking is so constrained by some artificial walls that you cannot actually ... well actually think. It is the wages stupid. Let me repeat that. It is the wages stupid. What happens when a society is so brain washed that it cannot even consider that if you don't pay people they can't afford housing. Or cars. Or medical care. Or food. If you actually have some desire to consider the problem rather than discuss how many angels can dance on a pin head, start with considering why "Inflation" is not a measure of anything thing, but rather the sound of one hand clapping. What is the other hand? Wages. In this country rather than fixing wages we are discussing solutions that make things worse. Let us add tariffs so that people can buy less. Let's create tax incentives that create more housing people cannot afford, with the tax incentives coming out of the pockets of the people who cannot afford that housing.
- tvier 1y agoWhile I 100% agree that there are wage issues, the question with housing is why it's growing faster than general inflation. House prices seem to be increasing fastest in places with high incomes. This leads me to believe increasing incomes wouldn't solve this particular problem.
- LargeWu 1y agoYou seem to be guilty of Fish Tank Thinking here yourself. Housing costs are not divorced from the laws of supply and demand. Raising wages creates increased demand for housing, but you still need the supply! Raising wages without increasing housing supply will just make housing more expensive.
- zkelvin 1y agoExactly! This video goes into this phenomenon more in-depth: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N_GLfxaYTYI&t=2s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N_GLfxaYTYI&t=2s This has actually been a known issue for over a century with Winston Churchill even commenting on it.
- magicmicah85 1y agoIf wages go up, housing will assuredly go up as people outbid each other. Wage stagnation is a problem, but it's not the solution to the housing crisis. People would still be unable to afford homes as they get outbid by people who have slightly more than them.
- NiloCK 1y agoThe antitrust pushback against regulatory efforts to increase housing development is approaching a reversal of that New Yorker cartoon. [ set in an urban tent city ] "Sure, we destroyed the expectation of dignified living standards, but the glorious fact remains that we've capped returns to certain shareholders."
- amosslade 1y agoAs someone whose built houses as a contractor and subcontractor for 20+ years, I’d say these article has it mostly right, but misses two major factors in increased costs. And that is permitting time/costs and the costs of complying with ever more stringent codes. If we could build homes to the codes of 1990 and the permitting process was the same as it was in 1990, you’d immediately knock 20-30% off of the cost of construction. What leftists and bureaucrats (and most people in general) never understand is the time value of money. Every extra day added to the construction of a $500K project is a few hundred dollars of interest costs, risk costs, and lost opportunity costs. Those numbers add up quickly. And nowadays, projects take much longer from idea to completion than they used to.
- ben7799 1y agoYou are agreeing with abundance theory here 100%. The author of the article is one of the Abundance folks. The issues with code and permitting and environmental review take up a substantial portion of the book.
- abvdasker 1y agoIt's always pretty suspect when you first hear about the opposition to something in its rebuttal. I've heard lots of critiques of the abundance movement and this is my first time hearing anything about housing cartels. Maybe someone had this critique but it isn't the dominant strain of criticism of the abundance people. It feels like Thompson picked the weakest argument to debunk rather than one of the many stronger ones.
- mactrey 1y agoWhat are some of the many other, stronger criticisms of the abundance agenda? Maybe Thompson has replied to some of those, too.
- austin-cheney 1y agoWhere I live the city has gained 90,000 people in the past 5 years. It’s about 68 new residents a day or about 30 families. They have been building houses as fast as possible here. When single family houses weren’t springing up fast enough then came the explosion of giant apartment complexes. I am not discounting the actual economic causes mentioned in the article, but securing financing appears to be a major factor that slows things down.
- Nevermark 1y agoThree major problems with housing economics. The first two go hand in hand, and could elegantly be solved together: 1 & 2. Pervasively (and perversely), "property taxes" greatly undertax negative externalities, and then heavily (punitively) tax positive externalities. 1. The undertax is that only a fraction of property taxes are just for the land. Land is a limited resource, and "ownership" of land is exclusionary. Exclusion is a negative externality, which is ok as long as that is economically accounted for. So taxing land more, would encourage more efficient and effective use of it. 2. Property on land is the positive externality. We all benefit when land enables higher active value. More housing, office space, etc. But it requires investment to improve the usefulness of land, and we not only tax that, but tax it annually, an annual wealth tax! This is highly perverse, in that it undermines the economics of increasing the productivity of land. Whether a land owner is rich or poor, the economics of putting work or capital into improving one's property come at the cost of being taxed on that improvement - every year - forever. The solution is to only tax land, not property on it, so land is incentivized to be used efficiently, and investments that improve its active usefulness, are not economically disincentivized. Making that change and renormalizing "property taxes", not just land taxes, for neutral public revenue, solves both problems with one stone. A decade or so transition, would allow this change to happen, while giving land and property owners who have made investments under today's regime, time to adapt. But the end result would be better for everyone. More efficient, parsimonious, effective use of land. More investments and innovation in increasing property's useful for everyone. Unlocked growth in real estate returns, as a market primarily based on improving net usefulness, with higher returns, than passive ownership. The latter providing no net benefit to society or the net real estate market. Credit for the above analysis: Economist Henry George [0] The third problem significantly compounds the problems of the first two, but would go away naturally if they were solved: 3. Markets take advantage of anything, even inefficiencies. Given that land is a limited resource, that the value of land increases as investments are made in adjacent properties, even without investments in one's own land, buying up land (with whatever property is on it), and letting others invest in neighboring land is a very good way to get a reliable return on capital. Because demand for land is always going to up, even when used inefficiently, with the current tax regime. This is an economically parasitical way to make money. It treats land like Bitcoin or gold, in prioritizing its use for passive returns, instead of investment in increasing its active value. And "parking" of money, for its passive returns, is so reliable, that the financial instrument demand for land drives up prices. Not just by a percentage, but in a self-sustaining and compounding circle of ever rising prices. For an investment "use" that has no net benefit to society. Resolving problems 1 and 2 would greatly reduce the passive return on land. Which would not only make land use more efficient, but eliminate the compounding pricing problems of near universal use of land as a passive parking place for wealth. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_George https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Henry_George
- salynchnew 1y agoThis article appears to be focused mostly on the line of argument that there is some cabal of builders that keep housing prices high. This also mostly seems to use Dallas as a case study, which is weird, b/c you can't test a lot of other argument about the effects of building/permitting requirements. It should probably instead be titled something like "This one anti-abundance critique on housing is wrong"
- theincredulousk 1y ago> Small companies can have downsides, and big companies can have benefits. A virtue of scale is that it can provide resilience in an age of crisis. Nassim Taleb would argue the polar opposite of this. I like the article. Starting to make assertions about benefits seems premature.
- biimugan 1y agoThat builders can't construct housing in whatever form-factor they want and whatever part of a municipality they want might be a problem. But the analysis of why these kinds of restrictions exist, to my mind, is not correct. Do niche interest groups have influence on housing policy? Sure. But these niche interest groups don't usually have a monetary interest in the outcomes they're promoting. But individual homeowners (who often band into interest groups of their own) and large real estate conglomerates do have such a monetary interest. They consider certain types of housing built in a certain way to have *more value* and be worth more. So they promote politicians who introduce zoning and other rules to protect that value. For someone looking to make a profit off of housing (or even to invest in housing), what is more appealing? A traditional U.S. suburb? Or a Kowloon walled city? One is denser, cheaper per capita, and (if you're not careful) unappealing to look at. In other words, it's worth less. So there is a great monetary pressure from people who already own homes to prevent "mixing" this type of housing into existing planned communities. People who need homes, on the other hand, are a little bit less discerning (to say the least). They don't have a monetary interest necessarily. They're primarily looking for a permanent residence. So I just don't buy this "abundance" stuff in general. If you remove all of these restrictions, will some companies start building housing? Some will. But my guess is most will say the juice is not worth the squeeze -- the profit margins and the long-term values of these properties will make it unappealing. Just like it's unappealing for grocery stores to set up in big urban areas. Or for hospital providers to set up in rural areas. Food deserts don't exist because of too much government intervention. A lack of rural hospitals is not a problem because of too much government intervention. It's because those things are not profitable. So in my opinion, if you want to reform zoning rules or things of that nature, it's only really going to be effective if you *force* (or if you want to be politically correct, "incentivize") housing companies to build in these areas too. I don't really consider this an "anti-trust" argument. It can be equally true if there's a lot of competition in the housing market and if there's next to no competition. It's more of an incentives argument. This is an argument that, like with medical care, we're treating something that is a fundamental need of every living human to have a stable and peaceful and fruitful life as if it were a standard market commodity. And when you do that, you get poor outcomes. We need to support the building of housing *even if* it's unaffordable or has low (or even non-existent) profit margins