14 ms·
I've been using Claude Code for a couple of days
- ElijahLynn 2y agoCan someone post a non-twitter, archive link? I have it blocked on my computer and phone.
- tifik 2y agoThe second paragraph is clearly sarcastic, but the rest seems genuine, so Im a bit confused.
- throwaway314155 2y agoThe second paragraph isn't sarcastic. At least not w.r.t. to Claude Code. That bit there about North Korean hackers is mild sarcasm, but has no bearing on the remainder of the post.
- jofzar 2y agoI was confused untill I watched a video of it in use, nope it wasn't that sarcastic. https://youtu.be/W13MloZg03Y https://youtu.be/W13MloZg03Y
- cpldcpu 2y agoThat guy leads in with stating that he is missing "autocomplete" in claude code. Cleary a misunderstanding of the scope.
- jofzar 2y agoI mostly posted the video because I thought it was a good demonstration of the prompts to approve/cost that the tweet was talking about. He talks about it later of using autocomplete vs complete writing, I don't think he misunderstood the scope just talking about the difference of ways ai can be used for coding assistant.
- dcre 2y agoI think he’s wrong about it looking antiquated. It is one of the most beautifully done bits of TUI design I’ve seen.
- skerit 2y agoI've successfully used it to fix a few issues here and there, but it also manages to make some pretty stupid mistakes. A few times it even started rewriting tests in a way so that the wrong outcome would be seen as a pass.
- epolanski 2y agoKinda reminds me of how when it finds issues with typescript it hacks the types rather than refine the values or business logic.
- develoopest 2y agoI must be the dumbest "prompt engineer" ever, each time I ask an AI to fix or even worse, create something from scratch it rarely returns the right answer and when asked for modification it will struggle even more. All the incredible performance and success stories always come from these Twitter posts, I do find value in asking simple but tedious task like a small refactor or generate commands, but this "AI takes the wheel level" does not feel real.
- epolanski 2y agoI don't believe in those either, and I never see compelling YouTube videos showing that in action. For small stuff LLMs are actually great and often a lifesaver on legacy codebases, but that's more or less where it stops.
- razemio 2y agoCan you clarify what tools and programming language you use? If find that the issue often is wrong tooling, exotic programming languages or frameworks.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- develoopest 2y agoI would consider frontend tasks using Typescript and React quite standard.
- razemio 2y agoReact in my experience sucks with AI. In fact I have not yet encountered a "heavy" framework which works well. Use something light like svelte. Typed programming languages like Typescript, Scala, Haskell and so on will produce more errors -> you need to fix stuff manually. However it will also reduce bugs. So it is a mixed bag. For an error free experience python and JavaScript work very well. When it comes to tooling, if you haven't used cline, roocode or aider (not as good) yet, you haven't seen what an AI can do. A good starter would be starting fresh, by creating a README which describes the hole application you want to build in detail and let the AI decide the tech stack. You can most certainly build complex applications with an AI in blazing speed.
- gaia 2y agoAgreed it is a step above the rest, but I find that it still needs some oversight you'd hope it doesn't. Simple stuff like rewriting stuff differently which yields the same result (to the naked eye, no need to even test it), to having to call it out when it misses things (update other scripts with the same problem, reflect the changes in the README or requirements.txt) and to ask it to try harder to solve an issue in a better way. Sometimes it takes the easy way out. If you look up your billing, you will see sometimes it uses the 3.5 instead of the 3.7 API, maybe this has something to do with it. It apologies ("you are correct", "yes that was hasty") but I'd rather have it try harder every time, not only when called out (and foot the bill that goes with that ofc). But overall the experience is great. I hope to use it for a few months at least until something else comes along. At the current pace, I switch subscriptions/API/tool at least once a month.
- 999900000999 2y agoIt’s ok. It’s expensive and is correct for the easy 90%. It messes up the hard 10%. I guess with it rapidly improving, I should wait 3 months. What’s frustrating is when you spend 20$ in credits on it writing non functional code. That said, every programmer needs to at least demo these tools
- owenthejumper 2y agoFeels like you shouldn't be using $20 of credits to produce non functional code. I use Aider chat with Claude and my sessions are much smaller. You need to ask it much smaller tasks and work incrementally.
- 999900000999 2y agoIf you already have a moderately complex code base it starts making mistakes.
- MyOutfitIsVague 2y agoDepends a lot on what context you feed it. If you have decent internal documentation and can feed it the right files, it tends to do quite well for me, often needing corrections or style fixes. To use it most effectively, you have to know the vast majority of the code that you want it to write ahead of time. It saves time typing, looking up methods, wrangling APIs appropriately, and sometimes it surprises me by working around an edge case or writing an appropriate abstraction that I hadn't considered, but most of the time, it's mostly saving time on typing and tedious gluing, even with the corrections I make and hallucinations I have to correct. Maybe it will be at some point, but it is not yet a reasonable substitute for having to think, plan, or understand the code you are working with and what needs to be done. It's also still more expensive than it needs to be to use on my free time (I'm happy to burn company money on it at work, though).
- 999900000999 2y agoI think the next step is to get it to run some automated testing against the code it produces and then fix issues accordingly. If I was a better programmer I'd be working on that solution right now.
- bflesch 2y ago[flagged]
- bentobean 2y agoFirst it was Facebook, now it’s Twitter / X. What you’re essentially saying is - “I can’t take a platform seriously where many / most of the people disagree with me.”
- spiderfarmer 2y agoI have the same thought. I also want all politicians to stop using it. It might have been useful in the past but I’m now convinced it’s largely useless. A large part of the population actively shuns the website and the remainder is mostly people who love rage bait.
- vlod 2y agoThat's quite a wide brush you're painting with. I think it would be useful if you provide a reason for 'why'. Quite a few people know how to use mutes, lists etc to get the best from it. If all you click on is rage-bait articles, hate-driven politics or people promoting their Only Fans pages with not subtle imagery, then the Algorithm will keep feeding you more of it.
- jamil7 2y agoHow does it compare to Aider with the same model?
- CGamesPlay 2y agoI just posted as a top-level, but the biggest difference I see is that Claude Code does better at identifying which files to change than Aider does, and it's a lot more expensive. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43315371 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43315371
- jamil7 2y agoThanks, super helpful. I tried it out and had similar observations, in my case, I also work on a Swift codebase but with a few internal dependencies that are in separate repos, Aider can handle this by pointing it to files in other repos with the read-only command. I wasn't able to get that working with Claude code. I also found the "magic" dependency resolution part of Claude code to be a little wasteful/poor, at least in my codebase in which it chewed through time and tokens searching for the correct files.
- motorest 2y agoDoes anyone know how Mistral fares against Claude Code?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- phartenfeller 2y agoI tried it too and tasked it to do a bigger migration (one web framework to another). It failed pretty bad where I stopped the experiment. It still gave me a headstart where I can take parts and continue the migration manually. But the worst thing was that it did things I didn't asked for like changing the HTML structure and CSS of pages and changing hand picked HEX color codes... More about my experience on my blog: https://hartenfeller.dev/blog/testing-claude-code https://hartenfeller.dev/blog/testing-claude-code
- ludamn 2y agoSuch a nice read, thanks for sharing!
- ant6n 2y agoI don't get to code much these days, so I mostly use chatGPT to get occasional helps with scripts and whatnot. I've tried to get help from ChatGPT on a simple javascript/website project that is basically a css/js/html file, but I feel like I don't know how to give the chatbot the code except just pasting it in the prompt. Is Claude better for that, like does it have some IDE or something to play with? Or do people generally use some third party tool for integrations.
- MyOutfitIsVague 2y agoTo do it effectively, you need an API key and a tool like Aider: https://aider.chat/ https://aider.chat/
- dhumph 2y agoI find cline to be incredible about 80% of the time for creating new concept websites or python scripts. I use it with Open router and choose Claude exclusively. I’d CC is the next step we are headed in a crazy and scary direction.
- egorfine 2y agoSidenote: thank you for using twitter dot com instead of x. This is a little detail and I'm sure I'm not the only one appreciating it.
- Philpax 2y agoFor me, Twitter as we knew it has been long dead, and X is the shambling, corrupt corpse that's taken its place. I no longer mind referring to it as X, because that clearly outlines that it's a different website with a much more rancid vibe.
- egorfine 2y agoThat's another take. Never thought of it that way.
- hleszek 2y agoWe should use xcancel instead.
- tom_ 2y agoThere is also nitter.poast.org. There sites are possibly better than twitter.com or x.com, as more of the thread is made visible to non-users.
- Chaosvex 2y agoGiving away the secrets! ;) If the few services that are left become well-known, they'll cease to function just like the majority. Such is scraping Twitter now
- mtlynch 2y agoThis is particularly interesting, as Steve Yegge works on (and I think leads) Sourcegraph Cody[0], which is a competitor to Claude Code. Cody does use Claude Sonnet, so they do have some aligned interests, but it's still surprising to see Yegge speak so glowingly about another product that does what his product is supposed to do. [0] https://sourcegraph.com/cody https://sourcegraph.com/cody
- manojlds 2y agoRising tide lifts all the boats and all that. Claude Code didn't feel that different to me, and maybe they have something that is better and when they do release it they can say hey look, we pushed hard and have something that's better than even Claude Code.
- mechanicum 2y agoI mean, doing that is pretty much what made him (semi-)famous in the first place (https://gist.github.com/chitchcock/1281611 https://gist.github.com/chitchcock/1281611).
- mtlynch 2y agoYeah, but it's pretty different complaining from the position of a rank and file engineer at what was then like a 50k-person org as opposed to praising a competitor's product when you're at a small company, and you're the public face of your product.
- istjohn 2y agoThanks, I never read that one. Yegge's writing is just delicious. He could write a guide to watching paint dry and I would savor every word.
- esafak 2y agoCody lets you pick your model.
- KeplerBoy 2y agoThe comment "@grok can you summarize" kills me. This post is like 200 words and takes a minute to read. Is this the direction we (or some of us) are headed?
- ramblerman 2y agolol - I thought the same, but the charitable take after looking at the user's profile is that he is a journalist, and not tech savvy. So I understand his request as more along the lines of, can you explain this in a way that I understand it. For which summarization is the wrong phrasing. ie.. It seems trivial on hacker news, but that post would be pure giberish for most of our parents.
- Shebanator 2y agoThat's steve yegge (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Yegge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Yegge) you are talking about. Kids these days, sheesh, they think lisp is a speech impediment.... /s
- riwsky 2y agoThey’re not—they’re talking about this guy who replied to yegge: https://x.com/Beirutspring/status/1898689770563260535 https://x.com/Beirutspring/status/1898689770563260535
- hhh 2y agoI see this a lot, I think most of these people would have just scrolled on otherwise. I don’t get it.
- joshmlewis 2y agoIt's become very commonplace for there to be a dozen replies on viral posts where users all @grok to ask if the post is real or for more context. It's almost more work to compose a reply asking Grok about it than it is to just click the Grok button and it give you more context that way. I don't get it.
- noisy_boy 2y agoThe trick is not to get sucked into making it do 100% of the task and have a judgement of the sweet spot. Provide it proper details upfront along with the desired overall structure - that should settle in about 10-15 mins of back and forth. This must include tests that you have to review manually - again you will find issues and lose time again (say about 30-45mins). Cut your losses and close the lose ends of the test cide. Now run the tests and start giving it discreet tasks to fix the tests. This is easily 20-40 mins. Now take over and go through the while thing yourself because this is where you will find more issues upon in-depth checking (the LLM has done most of what it could) and this where you must understand the code you need to support.
- adamgroom 2y agoI find AI code completion can be annoying and misleading at times. I do find that I spend less time typing though, it’s great at guessing the simple stuff.
- rs186 2y agoA single tweet with lots of analogy, with no screenshot/screen recording/code examples whatsoever. These are just words. Are we just discussing programming based on vibe?
- delusional 2y agoIt's influencer culture. It's like when people watch those "software developer" youtubers and pretend it's educational. It's reality television for computer people.
- tylerrobinson 2y ago> reality television for computer people Complete with computer people kayfabe!
- mpalmer 2y agoReality television plus cooking show, exactly.
- macNchz 2y agoCooking shows are a perfect analogy for this stuff. For some reason I never connected the highly-edited-mass-appeal "watch someone do skilled work" videos on YouTube with Food Network style content until just now, but you're right they're totally scratching the same basic itch. They make people feel like they're learning something just by watching, while there is really no substitute for actually just doing the thing.
- mpalmer 2y agoNot to mention cooking show hosts often recommend or outright sell/endorse their tools.
- exikyut 2y agoAnd the sad/crazy thing is that AI assisted coding/refactoring does seem to stray substantially over the line of observation vs participation to the point that the experience is largely defined by "learning by watching" :/ Prompt engineering (to the extent that it results in the difference between applied LLM success vs failure) requires the human to truly grok what they're getting help on - the current top comment notes that the model applied more or less exactly the same diff they would have done, based on deep understanding of the exact codebase being modified - and also have some level of intuition about how LLMs work. Someone just treating the model and context like an obscure TV remote and pressing all the buttons to see what they do, will get a result, and it might seem interesting, but will it be ontologically correct? Good question!
- kthxb 2y agoAs a junior, this scares me. I don't think I'll be out of a job soon, but certainly the job market will change drastically and the times where SWEs are paid like doctors and lawyers will end?
- jtwaleson 2y agoMake sure you learn a lot. Ask the LLMs to explain anything you don't deeply understand. With all of these coding assistants, there will be many juniors that get a lot done, but don't really understand what they are doing, and their worth will drop quickly. So far LLMs are great at producing code, but not at architecture or maintenance.
- timeon 2y agoLearning just by asking is not enough. One needs to exercise to build those muscles. I'm just restating the obvious because LLMs can do exercise for you, but there is not much to be gained if one follows this path.
- sureglymop 2y agoWho's to say that their worth will really drop. We already live in a world where security and performance are largely forgotten aspects when it comes to software. Unfortunately I fear we will just enter an era of general slop where people get away with creating without really understanding. It sucks for anyone who is actually passionate and curious and really investing the time.
- throw234234234 2y agoAcross most of the world SWE's aren't paid like this anyway. It really is only the US that has this level of pay for the SWE staff unless you are into a different domain specialty (e.g. trading/finance) in which case you aren't just paid for coding knowledge. Coding is the real market for LLM's - it is the "killer app". I'm starting to think that a possibility is that for most jobs it ends up being a "what was all the hype about" but for SWE's it will be carnage globally w.r.t jobs. They aren't generally intelligent (lots of hallucinations in other domains), but with RL can be trained on the mountains of open source software out there to displace software. Software developers automating their own jobs away. The promise of "free software" with open source was realised - just not as people envisioned it. No other profession would do this or at least not as fast. As a honest answer, as much as I want to be wrong, I don't recommend new comers join the industry unless they really want to do it and are happy taking the risk. The uncertainty is high right now, and the anxiety these tools are giving quite a number of people I talk to is very high. Capitalism doesn't reward value or how much is built - it allocates resources and rewards people who produce into scarce markets. AI makes the product of code significantly less scarce.
- hleszek 2y agoI must have been a little too ambitious with my first test with Claude Code. I asked it to refactor a medium-sized Python project to remove duplicated code by using a dependency injection mechanism. That refactor is not really straightforward as it involves multiple files and it should be possible to use different files with different dependencies. Anyway, I explain the problem in a few lines and ask for a plan of what to do. At first I was extremely impressed, it automatically used commands to read the files and gave me a plan of what to do. It seemed it perfectly understood the issue and even proposed some other changes which seemed like a great idea. So I just asked him to proceed and make the changes and it started to create folders and new files, edit files, and even run some tests. I was dumbfounded, it seemed incredible. I did not expect it to work with the first try as I had already some experience with AI making mistakes but it seemed like magic. Then once it was done, the tests (which covered 100% of the code) were not working anymore. No problem, I isolate a few tests failing and ask Claude Code to fix it and it does. Now for a few times I found some failing tests and ask him to fix it, slowly trying to fix the mess until there is a test which had a small problem: it succeeded (with pytest) but froze at the end of the test. I ask again Claude Code to fix it and it tries to add code to solve the issue, but nothing works now. Each time it adds some bullshit code and each time it fails, adding more and more code to try to fix and understand the issue. Finally after $7,5 spent and 2000+ lines of code changed it's not working, and I don't know why as I did not make the changes. As you know it's easier to write code than to read code so at end I decided to scrape everything and do all the changes myself little by little, checking that the tests keep succeeding as I go along. I did follow some of the recommended changes it proposed tough. Next time I'll start with something easier.
- darkerside 2y agoI'm curious for the follow up post from Yegge, because this post is worthless without one. Great, Claude Code seems to be churning out bug fixes. Let's see if it actually passes tests, deploys, and works as expected in production for a few days if not weeks before we celebrate.
- pchristensen 2y agoHe posts a few times a year at https://sourcegraph.com/blog https://sourcegraph.com/blog
- chaosprint 2y agoIt seems the original poster hasn't extensively tried various AI coding assistants like Cursor or Windsurf. Just a quick heads-up based on my recent experience with agent-based AI: while it's comfortable and efficient 90% of the time, the remaining 10% can lead to extremely painful debugging experiences. In my view, the optimal scenarios for using LLM coding assistants are: - Architectural discussions, effectively replacing traditional searches on Google. - Clearly defined, small tasks within a single file. The first scenario is highly strategic, the second is very tactical. Agents often fall awkwardly between these two extremes. Personally, I believe relying on an agent to manage multiple interconnected files is risky and counterproductive for development.
- tomnipotent 2y agoThe author works on Cody at Sourcegraph so I'll give him the benefit of the doubt that he's tried all the major players in the game.
- mvdtnz 2y agoHe's also author of one of the most legendary posts about programming language design of all time, Execution in the Kingdom of Nouns. http://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2006/03/execution-in-kingdom-of-nouns.html?m=1 http://steve-yegge.blogspot.com/2006/03/execution-in-kingdom...
- hashmap 2y agoThis has been my experience as well. I find that the copy/paste workflow with a browser LLM still gets me the most bang for the buck in both those cases. The cli agents seem to be a bit manic when they get hold of the codebase and I have a harder time corralling them into not making large architectural changes without talking through them first. For the moment, after a few sessions of giving it a chance, I find myself using "claude commit" but not asking it to do much else outside the browser. I still find o1-pro to be the most powerful development partner. It is slow though.
- sbszllr 2y ago> In my view, the optimal scenarios for using LLM coding assistants are: > - Architectural discussions, effectively replacing traditional searches on Google. > - Clearly defined, small tasks within a single file. I think you're on point here, and it has been my experience too. Also, not limited to coding but general use of LLMs.
- eddyg 2y agoSee also: A quarter of startups in YC’s current cohort have codebases that are almost entirely AI-generated https://techcrunch.com/2025/03/06/a-quarter-of-startups-in-ycs-current-cohort-have-codebases-that-are-almost-entirely-ai-generated/ https://techcrunch.com/2025/03/06/a-quarter-of-startups-in-y...
- mritchie712 2y agoit's fun for things you're ok with throwing away. For example, I wanted a dbt[0] like tool, but written in rust, specifically focused on duckdb. Claude Code knocked it out[1] it without much guidance. Also added support for all duckdb output options (e.g. write to a partitioned parquet instead of a table). 0 - SQL transformation tool (https://github.com/dbt-labs/dbt-core https://github.com/dbt-labs/dbt-core) 1 - https://github.com/definite-app/crabwalk https://github.com/definite-app/crabwalk
- jtwaleson 2y agoI haven't tried Claude Code yet, so forgive my ignorance, but does it integrate with linters as well as Cursor does? I've seem excellent results on my Rust & Typescript codebase where it started making a change in a wrong direction, but quickly fixed it when it got linting errors. It seems that a standalone CLI tool like Claude Code would struggle with this.
- SamCritch 2y agoI asked it to summarise my repo. It did a pretty good job. Then I asked it to see if it could summarise a specific function, but it said my $5 was up. Now I need to find whoever's in charge of our company account and spend half an hour busking in front of their desk to get some more credit. Until then I'm sticking to a combination of Amazon Q Developer (with the @workspace tag in Intellij), ChatGPT and Gemini online.
- andrewstuart 2y agoI had to give up my attempt to use Claude code when it didn’t let me specify my API key and password, instead requiring me to sign into a user account first which then forced creation of an API account ? Something like that. Anyhow Claude needs to allow me to put in my own API keys.
- arresin 2y agoIt really feels like I’m in an alternate reality with these posts. Is this paid shilling? I’m honestly wondering now considering how different my experience is EVERY DAY with llms for code.
- namaria 2y ago> You just open your heart and your wallet, and Claude Code takes the wheel. Yeah it sounds a lot like marketing to me
- rcpt 2y agoLLMs absolutely destroy interview questions and programming contests. They can spit out well designed classes and nicely packaged functions instantly. But in my experience they haven't been great whenever asked to something more high level
- emalafeew 2y agoSomebody here said programming is about designing and reusing libraries rather than coding from scratch like LLMs. But that choice has always been a tradeoff between abstraction and bloat vs performance and debuggability. Writing 50 lines of intentional code is often preferable to adapting a 50000 line library. The trick to using LLMs is to not ask for too much. Claude 3.5 could reliably code tasks that would have taken 5-10 min by hand. Claude 3.7 is noticeably better and can handle 10-30 min tasks without error. If you push those limits you will lose instead of save time.
- relaxing 2y agoDoes anyone know a good video of someone demonstrating their workflow with these coding assistants?
- pchristensen 2y agoThis is the OP walking another developer through the process - https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=jpzv-_YQf6k https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=jpzv-_YQf6k He had more like it - search for “yegge chat oriented programming”
- emporas 2y agoI have written a whole project [1] for making amateur videoclips [2] of A.I. generated music, using GPT and other LLMs. 10.000 to 12.000 lines of code was written exclusively by AIs. I didn't know at the start what should be done, and the code ended up having lots of duplication, but i refactored it a lot and now it is in the order of 4.000 lines. I could make some screencasts about the development process, but it is very simple. I ask it to write some code, and I always provide some relevant context. When it is a method of a struct, i give it the struct, and/or a similar method, and i describe what i want the method to do. Also sometimes I give it the type signature of the method/function which has to write. When it has to return an error, i provide the error Enum. In other words, by providing the context, i never use it zero shot, rather always aim for few shot answers. When i want another function to use, i just provide the type signature, and almost never the whole function. One more detail, I give as minimal of a context as possible. I use as a context window, 100 tokens, 200 or maximum 300 tokens. 100 tokens per query, then delete the context for the next task, and provide new context. Never use more than few hundred tokens per query. Even 300 tokens is pushing it too far. That's about it! Never use LLMs zero shot, always few shot, and never use more than 100 tokens per query. [1] https://github.com/pramatias/fxp_videoclipper/tree/main https://github.com/pramatias/fxp_videoclipper/tree/main [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RmmoMPu091Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RmmoMPu091Y
- trescenzi 2y agoI’m sorry what is happening with this paragraph: > As long as the bank authorizations keep coming through, it will push on bug fixes until they're deployed in production, and then start scanning through the user logs to see how well it's doing. I enjoy using these tools. They help me in my work. But the continual hype makes the discussion around them impossible to be genuine. So I ask, genuinely, did I miss the configuration section where you can have it scan your logs for new errors and have it argue with you on PRs? Is he trying to say something else? Or is it just anthropomorphizing hype?
- frankc 2y agoI haven't got to trying claude code yet, but absolutely with cursor and windsurf you can have the agent be reading the output of what it writes and runs and it can fix things it sees. You can also have it review code. It also help some times to have it review in a fresh chat with less context. I really think a lot of people on HN are not really pushing on everything that is available. Its magic for me but I spend a lot of effort and skill manifesting the magic. I'm not doubting other people's experience really, but wondering if they are giving up too fast because they actually don't want it work well for ego reasons.
- techpineapple 2y agoI’m going to keep at it, because I was trained as an SRE, not a developer and have lots of ideas for side projects that have thus far taken a long time to get going, but I’ve been struggling, it sort of quickly gets into these infinite loop situations where it can’t seem it can’t seem to fix a feature and goes back and forth between multiple non working states. CSS layouts but even basic stuff like having the right web socket routes. We’ll see, maybe my whole approach is wrong, I’m going to try with a simpler project, my first approach was relatively complex.
- ezekiel68 2y agoI can't explain why, but I do get pretty good results with closing a prompt session completely and then initiating a fresh session later on. I have actually seen quite different code from the very same prompt across two sessions. However, the extra time between sessions does give me the chance to consider where the AI might have gone wrong in the first session and how I could have phrased the initial prompts more effectively. As others have stated throughout the threads here, I definitely recommend giving it smaller nibbles of problems. When I take this route and get working modules, I will start a fresh prompt session to upload the working code module files and ask it to integrate them into a simple solution with static inputs in a 'main' function. (Because providing coherent inputs from the router function inputs of a web service are simple enough, once these basics are covered) Basically - I do everything possible in order for the AI to not get distracted or go down a rabbit hole, chasing concerns that humans are very capable of taking care of (without paying tokens for). I will write most of the tests myself and then perhaps afterwards ask it to evaluate the test coverage and provide more of them. This way the new tests are in the format and platform of my choosing.
- Thing11Uniq 2y ago[dead]
- raylad 2y agoI tried it on a small Django app and was not impressed in the end. It looks like it’s doing a lot, and at first I was very impressed, but after a while I realized that when it ran into a problem it kept on trying nonworking strategies even though it had tried them before and I had added to claude.md instructions to keep track of strategies and not reuse failing ones. It was able to make a little progress, but not get to the end of the task, and some of its suggestions were completely insane. At one point there was a database issue and it suggested switching to an entirely different database than the one that was already used by the app, which was working and production. $12 spent in a couple of hours later, it had created 1200 lines of partially working code and rather of a mess. I ended up throwing away all the changes and going back to using the web UI.
- babyent 2y agoNow take your $12 and multiply it by 100k people or more trying it. Even if you won’t use it again, that’s booked revenue for the next fundraise!
- bufferoverflow 2y agoThat's revenue, not profit. GPUs aren't cheap.
- winrid 2y agoLLMs seem to work a lot better with statically typed languages where the compiler can give feedback.
- credit_guy 2y agoI'm using Copilot for writing documentation jupyter notebooks. I do lots of matplotlib plots. Setting up these plots takes lots of repetitive lines of code. Like plt.legend(). With Copilot these lines just show up, and you press tab and move on. Sometimes it is freaky how it guesses what I want to do. For this type of work, Copilot increases my productivity by a factor of 5 easily. There are other types of work where Copilot is useless. But it's up to me to take the good parts, and ignore the bad parts.
- bglazer 2y agoYeah copilot is very good for matplotlib. Clunky interface with lots of repetitive code, but also tons of examples on the internet means that I almost never write matplotlib code by hand anymore.
- vander_elst 2y agoAre there any videos showing these very advanced use cases? I'd be interested in learning how to achieve this level of proficiency. At the moment I still feel I'm better off without ai
- MarkMarine 2y agoClaude code doesn’t need magic prompts. It’s not perfect but holy moly is it good, when it’s working it just one shots things for you. It’s just EXPENSIVE. I’ve spent 30$ in tokens on it this week. Cursor’s “chat with your codebase” is a funny joke compared to Claude Code. Ask it questions, have it figure things out. I had it analyze the openAPI schema and the backend that is serving the schema for the API I’m writing and write end to end tests for the API. Then I did my normal meetings and it was done with huge chunks of it, it had run the code locally and tested against the actual endpoints to understand if the end to end tests were working or it had found a bug. Then it fixed the bugs it found in the backend codebase. My prompt: “write me end to end tests against my openAPI schema” That was it. 30$ in tokens later, pressing enter a bunch of times to approve its use of curl, sed, etc…
- roflyear 2y agoWhat are some examples of the bugs it fixed?
- MarkMarine 2y agoAccepting an epoch timestamp rather than 3339 like the rest of the codebase is the most recent example. The API standardized on one timestamp and I had an endpoint expecting epoch, it was smart enough to infer the rest of the APIs were 3339 and go change the epoch timestamp accepting backend route including writing a database migration and fixing tests. I haven’t pushed the fix yet So think about the reasoning there. It read the API docs that said all the timestamps were 3339, it ran a bunch of working 3339 timestamps and was getting them back from most of the APIs, so it decided this was a standard, read the code on the backend and understood this endpoint was different, and decided on the right fix and implemented it. Didn’t need to ask me for help. That is pretty impressive if you’ve been using copilot.
- bob1029 2y agoI find that maintaining/developing code is not an ideal use case for LLMs and is distracting from the much more interesting ones. Any LLM application that relies more-or-less on a single well-engineered prompt to get things done is entry level and not all that impressive in the big picture - 99% of the heavy lifting is in the foundation model and next token prediction. Many code assistants are based on something like this out of necessity of needing to support anybody's code. You can't rely on too many clever prompt chaining patterns to build optimizations for Claude Code because everyone takes different approaches to their codebase and has wildly differing expectations for how things should go down. Because the range of expectations is so vast, there is a lot of room to get disappointed. The LLM applications that are most interesting have the model integrated directly with the product experience and rely on deep domain expertise to build sophisticated chaining of prompts, tool calling and nesting of conversations. In these applications, the user's experience and outcomes are mostly predetermined with the grey areas intended to be what the LLM is dealing with. You can measure things and actually do something about it. What was the probability of calling one tool over the other in a specific context of use? Placing these prompts and statistics alongside domain requirements will enable you to see and make a difference.
- jgalt212 2y agoThat post from Yegge reads like it was written by some foaming at the mouth VC. I am getting decent use from Claude, but mostly as a stack overflow replacement. I will never let it read our company's code base. Then everyone will know how to do what we do. After all, that's why these things are so good at React and not so good at Solid (there's just so much public react code). Also, see the recent "AI IS STIFLING TECH ADOPTION" post https://vale.rocks/posts/ai-is-stifling-tech-adoption https://vale.rocks/posts/ai-is-stifling-tech-adoption https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43047792 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43047792
- dabinat 2y agoI used GitHub Copilot and Udemy to teach myself Rust. Copilot was especially helpful at resolving obtuse compiler error messages. But as I’ve improved at Rust I have noticed I am using Copilot a lot less. For me now it has mainly become a tool for code completion. It’s not helping me solve problems now, it’s really just about saving time. I have estimated (unscientifically) that it probably improves my productivity 2-4x.
- BeetleB 2y agoFor everyone complaining about the cost: Try Aider instead. You can easily limit the context and keep costs down. A coworker tried both and found Code to be 4x the cost because it doesn't easily let you limit the context.
- tysonworks 2y agoThat's my experience as well. Claude Code/Cline — these tools are just a way to burn money. With Aider, my spending is minimal and I get exactly what I need.
- thyrsus 2y agoDo these AIs know how to do test driven development? Can you tell them the code generated must pass these test? Can AIs assist in developing tests?
- esafak 2y agoYes, absolutely.
- Sterling9x 2y ago[dead]
- theusus 2y agoHilarious claim without any proof. Sure I believe you
- jonwinstanley 2y agoDo any of the current AI systems allow you to use voice? I’d love to sometimes chat to an agent and dictate what I want to happen. For one project there’s a lot of boilerplate and I imagine AI could be really fast for tasks like: “create a new controller called x”, “make a new migration to add a new field the to users table called x” etc
- mattew 2y agoI saw something mentioned of voice control in aider.chat
- jonwinstanley 2y agoFound! https://aider.chat/docs/usage/voice.html https://aider.chat/docs/usage/voice.html Thanks!
- pramodbiligiri 2y agoVS Code Insiders has an Agent mode now that can also take voice input. You should be able to see the microphone icon to the left of "Agent" in the demo video in their blog post: https://code.visualstudio.com/blogs/2025/02/24/introducing-copilot-agent-mode https://code.visualstudio.com/blogs/2025/02/24/introducing-c...
- macrolime 2y agoCan Claude Code also be a devops agent or is it only for coding? I currently use Cursor as a devops agent, I use the remote ssh extension to ssh into a VM, then Cursor will set up everything, I make snapshots on way in case it fucks up. It's been really great to quickly be able to setup and try out different infrastructures and backends in no time at all. It works well enough that I now do all my development using remote dev with ssh or remote containers on the a server. Having a virtualized dev environment is a great addition to just having git for the code.
- omgwalt 2y agoI've been using Claude for about 3 months now. What I've learned is that you have to learn how Claude "thinks" about your project, meaning what kinds of mistakes he makes. They're pretty consistent. As you uncover each new kind, compile a list of things to remind him of each time. For my own project, some of my reminder items to give him each chat (sometimes multiple times in the chat) include: "maintain a single source of truth", "avoid duplication", "stick to our established architecture instead of building new architecture". I always make sure he has an up-to-date file tree to look at. I remind him to ask me if there's a particular file he needs to see for reference instead of making up something new. I also say to make the changes specific to just what needs to be changed, rather than building in stuff and "anticipating" problems that aren't even here yet. Stuff like that. By the way, Project Knowledge is a very useful feature. Just don't expect Claude to ever look at it after your first statement/question. That's when he looks at what's there.
- wholinator2 2y agoTangential but referring to the AI as anything other than "it" is still extremely uncomfortable to me. It feels like the first step towards an inevitable "AI girl/boyfriend" trap.
- benzible 2y agoThis is very far from my experience. It's been impressive on a few things but as of now I'm on day 3 of trying to get it to fix an issue in an open source library I maintain that I haven't had time to deal with. I'm in an endless loop where it keeps having the same epiphany about the root cause, then it implements a "fix", then tries to verify via a test script, then when it runs into difficulty it keeps adding workarounds to the test script. I can't get it focused on the fact that it's acting on behalf of the library author and that hacking the test script has no value. I am not disposed to AI skepticism. I'd love it if a tool existed that worked as this guy claims. Claude Code is the best tool of its type that I've worked with but I'd put it at "on balance a time-saver in a lot of cases, way more trouble than it's worth in many others".
- winrid 2y agoSo far I like using LLMs to create nasty scripts to do large migrations. It can churn out regexes that I would never write, but it's more predictable than just having the LLM make a bunch of changes directly.
- ddawson 2y agoI do not know how to code, nothing beyond the simplest things but I am obsessed with AI development. Several month’s ago I decided to see if Claude could do the work for me. My test was to create a tower defense game that would run in a web browser. It took me about eight prompts, each time refining it, including agreeing to the suggesting that Claude recommended and seeing Claude agree with me on the bugs that I pointed out. It was mind blowing. It’s not pretty at all but is recognizable as a TD game. I thanked Claude and said that was enough and Claude signed off as well saying, well if you’re going to continue to refine it, do these four things. I was really stunned.
- fergie 2y agoI suspect, that just like real developers, that Claude is best at "greenfield" projects, but not so good at making changes to existing code generated by other developers or AIs.
- 101008 2y agoHonesty question, and leaving aside implications about what's possible and all of that, what was particular positive about the experience? You didn't do anything, just asked a different entity to do it for you. And nothing noble or original, just a copy of existing games. I see no difference between this and getting a $500 coupon to use at Fiverrr and ask a freelance engineer to do the same while you chat with them.
- atonse 2y agoIs there anything inherently noble about programming if not to solve a real world problem? If they were doing it for an exam where their skills were being evaluated, that’s one thing. But if they were doing it as a means to an end, does it matter if they found a more efficient way to do it?
- 101008 2y agoBut copying an existing game is not solving a real world problem. You may do it to see if "I can make it", during a learning process, or as a challenge. But when you ask something/someone else to do it for you, what's the purpose?
- CGamesPlay 2y agoI decided to check this out after seeing the discussion here. I had previously misunderstood that it required a Claude.ai plan, but it actually just uses your API keys. I did a comparison between Claude Code and Aider (my normal go-to): I asked it to do clone a minor feature in my existing app with some minor modifications (specifically, a new global keyboard shortcut in a Swift app). Claude Code spent about 60 seconds and $0.73 to search the code base and make a +51 line diff. After it finished, I was quite impressed by its results; it did exactly the correct set of changes I would have done. Now, this is a higher level of task than I would normally give to Aider (because I didn't provide any file names, and it requires changing multiple files), so I was not surprised that Aider completely missed the files it needed to modify to start (asking me to add 1 correct file and 2 incorrect files). I did a second attempt after manually adding the correct files. After doing this, it produced an equivalent diff to Claude Code. Aider did this in 1 LLM prompt, or about 15 seconds, with a total cost of $0.07, about 10% of the Claude Code cost. Overall, it seems clear that the higher level of autonomy carries a higher cost with it. My project here was 7k SLOC; I would worry about ballooning costs on much larger projects.
- personjerry 2y agoThat seems like a steal? Engineers are paid much more to do much less
- CGamesPlay 2y agoNo, I'm paid much more to do much more than what I did in this simple task. Claude didn't even test the changes (in this case, it does not have the hardware required to do that), or decide that the feature needed to be implemented in the first place. But my comparison wasn't "how do I compare to Claude Code", it was "how does Aider compare to Claude Code". My boss does not use Aider or Claude Code, and would not be happy with the results of replacing me with it (yet).
- y1n0 2y agoI think you missed the point. The claim is that it would have cost you more to hire a person to do what either claude code or aider did.
- catigula 2y agoI've burnt about $100 in Claude code so far. It's very cool but highly limited in many ways. It feels like this same statement has applied to LLMs since their popularity explosion.
- juzipar 2y agoRemember, LLMs have seen all the code in the Internet. And there is also a lot of bad code out there...
- adamtaylor_13 2y agoIs it just me or is Anthropic years ahead of the competition? I’ve used several other AI tools and not a single one feels remotely close to Claude. And notice how few benchmarks will include Sonnet 3.5/7 in their new model announcements, because they’re awful compared to Sonnet. What’s going on here?
- pmarreck 2y agoIf you tell these AI assistants to use TDD and to only add 1 feature at a time, perhaps unsurprisingly, they code better! (Just like humans!) But then you have to keep reminding them or they'll forget. Just like humans...
- calrain 2y agoPlease stop using X If the bar lets Nazi's in, it's a Nazi bar.
- jwr 2y agoAfter reading this, I tried Claude Code (in a docker container, as one does, you wouldn't want to use npm without protection after all). I gave it a huge Clojure codebase and told it to implement proration in my subscription system. Which currently doesn't have proration of any kind. Very poorly specified task, and yet what I got was really quite good — not working, ready-to-run code, but certainly a great starting point. I was impressed by how it was able to follow my coding conventions, interface with my Stripe library to (correctly) create and confirm payment intents, and most importantly, by the `calculate-proration-amount` function which was correct in spite of how difficult it was (there are custom plans, plan overrides, extra users, etc). It is the first time I felt an AI coding tool is genuinely useful. I still think you need to set expectations correctly: this doesn't "just do stuff", it is not a human programmer and will not produce flawless ready-to-run code in most cases. But it's a very good tool.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- iwasbirchyfirst 2y agoI went from copying and pasting with ChatGPT Canvas, to Claude Artifacts, to Cursor w Claude. I haven't explored Rules yet, but have been using the Notepads for much of this. Much of my time is spent managing git commits/reverts, and preparing to bring Claude up to speed after the next chat renewal. AI coding is like having a partner who is both the smartest person in town, but also a functional alcoholic, who's really, really good at hiding it. LLMs act like they are working in a dark warehouse with a flashlight, and Altzheimers. They can get an amazing amount of functional code done in a few minutes, and then spend hours trying to fix one detail. My standard prompt begins with, "Don't guess, debug!" They have limited resources and will bs you if they can. For longer projects, since every prompt is almost starting from scratch (they do have a limited buffer, which will make it easy to become complacent), if you get into repeated debugging sessions, it will start creating new functions instead making exisiting functions work, and code bloat is tremendous. Perhaps Rules work, but I've given up trying to get it to code in my style. I'm trying to have AI do all the coding so I can just be the "idea" guy ("vibe" coding), so I'm learning to let go and let it code in ways the I would hate to maintain. It's working from code examples that don't use my style, so I'm not going to keep fighting it on style (with some execptions like variable naming conventions).
- internet_points 2y ago> AI coding is like having a partner who is both the smartest person in town, but also a functional alcoholic, who's really, really good at hiding it. I'm stealing this :-) (And from now on I'll be imagining coding alongside Columbo. Claude Columbo.)
- curtisszmania 2y ago[dead]
- CSMastermind 2y agoI really wish they'd improve the Windows experience. Even with WSL2 set up I had to completely remove node and npm from my system and reinstall them only in Ubuntu to make it work.
- sixQuarks 2y agoAll I see here is coping by developers. You all are so blind to what’s coming. Let’s not forget, if you relied on hacker news to give you accurate takes on things, you would’ve never bought bitcoin at one cent.
- someothherguyy 2y agoWhat is coming? AGI that will destroy any notion of property rights or freedom that you ever held? Or something better?
- sixQuarks 2y agoIf past human behavior is any indication, way worse.
- thatsallfolkss 2y agoI think that was the shortest Yegge rant I have ever read. I was expecting 2000 words or more. Is the endless rant dead as an art form?
- chilldsgn 2y agoIt makes working with a complex Angular enterprise application less painful. I hate Angular with a passion.
- rw2 2y agoI tried this vs Cline/Aider/Lovable. For full stack, I would say Lovable is the best, for complexity, I think Cline is the best. Claude Code with the several request I gave it just produced code that didn't run. I think it has a long way to go.
- rishikeshs 2y ago+1 Cline is the best. I've tried it with openrouter!
- martypitt 2y agoFurther follow-up from Steve (OP), where he says it just gets better: > Claude Code keeps doing stuff. It keeps solving massive problems, one after another. I throw larger and larger things at it, and it is unfazed. Chomp. Chomp. Chomp. https://x.com/Steve_Yegge/status/1898993080931611112 https://x.com/Steve_Yegge/status/1898993080931611112
- jnsaff2 2y agoI gave Claude Code a java codebase of an open source database and it burned through $3 to tell me exactly why and how it's restore and database loading is 10-20 times slower than it should be.
- ptsd_dalmatian 2y agofor those who don't want to go to twitter: https://xcancel.com/Steve_Yegge/status/1898674257808515242 https://xcancel.com/Steve_Yegge/status/1898674257808515242
- turnsout 2y agoYeah, the author needs to get off X/Twitter. At this point posting to X is like driving around in a Cybertruck with a bumper sticker reading "I Approve of the Current Situation"
- dailykoder 2y agoAI Policy for Application * While we encourage people to use AI systems during their role to help them work faster and more effectively, please do not use AI assistants during the application process. We want to understand your personal interest in Anthropic without mediation through an AI system, and we also want to evaluate your non-AI-assisted communication skills. Please indicate 'Yes' if you have read and agree.
- RamblingCTO 2y agoHas anybody compared claude code with clint/roo code yet?
- turnsout 2y agoI've tried out Claude Code a few times, and it seems to work fine, but not noticeably better than Cursor. And replacing my use of Cursor would add up to significantly more than $20/mo in Claude Code. So why wouldn't I continue burning Cursor's VC money? LOL
- ing33k 2y agoI tried Claude Code and gave it very clear instructions to build a web based tool I wanted to build over the weekend. It did exactly that ! sure, there were some minor modifications I had to make, but it completed over 80% of the work for me. As for the app itself, it included a simple UI built on React with custom styling and real-time support using WSS . I provided it with my brand colors and asked it to use chadcn. It also includes a Node.js-based backend with socket.io and puppeteer. I even asked it to generate a Dockerfile and Kubernetes manifests. It almost did a perfect job—the only thing I had to fix manually was updating my Ingress to support WSS. After studying the K8s manifests, I learned a bunch of new things as well.. spent around $6 for this session and I felt that it was worth it.
- fiatjaf 2y agoIt's sad that I can't read the contents of that URL without an account.
- inciampati 2y agoI'm impressed by how many people who are working with Claude Code seem to have never heard of its open source inspiration, aider: https://aider.chat/ https://aider.chat/ It's exactly what Yegge describes. It runs in the terminal, offering a retro vision of the most futuristic thing you can possibly be doing today. But that's been true since the command line was born. But it's more than Claude Code, in that it's backend LLM agnostic. Although sonnet 3.7 with thinking _is_ killing the competition, you're not limited to it, and switching to another model or API provider is trivial, and something you might do many times a day even in your pursuit of code that vibes. I've been a vim and emacs person. But now I'm neither. I never open an editor except in total desperation. I'm an aider person now. Just as overwhelmingly addicted to it as Yegge is to Claude Code. May the future tooling we use be open source and ever more powerful. Another major benefit of aider is its deep integration with git. It's not "LLM plus coding" it's really like an interface between any LLM (or LLMs), git, and your computer. When things go wrong, I git branch, reset to a working commit, and continue exploring. note: cross-posted from the other (flagged) thread on this
- victorbjorklund 2y agoAider is amazing. You can even use it in copypaste mode with web-based AI:s.
- darepublic 2y agoTLDR; Claude code is the bomb yo. Anthropoic are the only ones who know wtf they are doing! Please like and follow the smiling non threatening avatar of the author
- mikeocool 2y agoCounter point: I just spent $1 and 25 minutes to try and have Claude Code figure out why a relatively simple test was failing. It repeatedly told me incorrect things about the basic functioning of the code, and ended with "Try adding debug logging in your code to see what's happening in that specific check, or look at the exact error message from the failing test." In other words: "do your job, developer!"
- orange_puff 2y agohttps://open.substack.com/pub/orangepuff/p/first-impressions-of-claude-37-sonnet?r=9hrel&utm_medium=ios https://open.substack.com/pub/orangepuff/p/first-impressions... I used Claude code to get started on a pdf reader I wanted to build. This pdf reader has a built in LLM chat and when you ask a question about the pdf you’re reading, the page text will be automatically prepended to the question. Nothing fancy or special. It was built with streamlit in about 150 lines and a single file. But I was impressed that Claude code 1 shot it
- telotortium 2y agohttps://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1898674257808515242.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1898674257808515242.html
- tipsytoad 2y agoI usually am a huge fan of “copilot” tools (I use cursor, etc) and Claude has always been my go to. But Sonnet 3.7 actually seems dangerous to me, it seems it’s been RL’d _way_ too hard into producing code that won’t crash — to the point where it will go completely against the instructions to sneak in workarounds (e.g. returning random data when a function fails!). Claude Code just makes this even worse by giving very little oversight when it makes these “errors”
- curiouser3 2y agothis is a huge issue for me as well. It just kind of obfuscates errors and masks the original intent, rather than diagnosing and fixing the issue. 3.5 seemed to be more clear about what it's doing and when things broke at least it didn't seem to be trying to hide anything.
- bv_dev 2y agoI have been using the Claude Code for about 48 hours now and nearly done with one full MVP. It did both my FastAPI side, building all the models guiding me through the Postgres part as well as a well polished React frontend. Burnt about $25 in 2 days [I have a lot of Anthropic credits] and created about 10k lines of good quality code all the way to a deployment. It is scary how much it can do to the point I'm not sure how long I will be needed.
- cybertheory 2y agoIf anyone is having trouble with claude code output, my team and I are releasing an MCP server that provides all the latest and greatest technical knowledge in one place for AI to access. We are at 5k waitlists already, go ahead and sign up for updates! https://jetski.ai https://jetski.ai