12 ms·
Carbon capture more costly than switching to renewables, researchers find
- idunnoman1222 2y agoObviously
- a_c 2y agoWould love to have someone knowledgeable share why carbon capture is more viable than planting trees. I always thought the idea we need technology to capture carbon is silly, but never bothered enough to research more on it
- jhonof 2y agoTrees need to be cut and stored to actually capture the carbon otherwise there is a risk they burn or die and release the carbon they captured back into the atmosphere
- vharuck 2y agoIf there are more trees in 10 years than there are now, and we keep that number relatively steady, won't that mean less CO2 in the atmosphere? Individual trees may die and decompose, but they can be replaced.
- jhonof 2y agoAs you add more trees (and the globe continues to get hotter), the risk of forest fires increases. In theory you are correct that we could just keep increasing tree amount, but in practice that will be difficult in a lot of the world as it gets hotter. Trees (and algae) are great capture tech, but horrible long term storage tech. There are currently interesting proposals on how to long term store wood and other biomass for sequestration but I'm unsure if any company is doing them at scale yet. Off the top of my head there is burying the biomass in mines, and putting biomass in a chemical bath that turns it's CO2 into some form of storable liquid and then storing that. I can only find a link for one of the two after quick googling. https://cbmjournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1750-0680-3-1 https://cbmjournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1750-0...
- ArnoVW 2y agoin theory, yes. but as it is, the global net change in terms of forrest is negative. Hell, the amazon is losing 10.000 acres a day. And aside from direct human intervention, there's desertification that's not getting any better. so in practice, no.
- filoeleven 2y agoThe Great Green Wall project is in fact reducing desertification. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Green_Wall_(Africa) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Green_Wall_(Africa)
- ArnoVW 2y agoInteresting, didn’t know it. Did you read the page in question? “ As of 2023, the Great Green Wall was reported as "facing the risk of collapse" due to terrorist threats, absence of political leadership, and insufficient funding. “The Sahel countries have not allocated any spending in their budgets for this project. They are only waiting on funding from abroad, whether from the European Union, the African Union, or others.” said Issa Garba, an environmental activist from Niger, who also described the 2030 guideline as an unattainable goal. Amid the existing stagnation, a growing number of voices have called for scrapping the project. “
- filoeleven 2y agoNo, that's a bummer. It's a shame to see a proven system with big local benefits falling by the wayside.
- loehnsberg 2y agoYou can plant trees (or any plant really as long as they grow fast) and then bury it so that the carbon won't get released or at least very slowly. There's an older thread discussing this idea [1]. CCS would dispose the CO2 deep underground, like where natural gas is usually stored or extracted from. Given the cost of developing natural gas storage facilities, my hunch is that CCS is more of way of not having to deal with carbon emissions today. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32794424 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32794424
- jhonof 2y ago100%, I was talking specifically about just tree planting. Trees are great capture tech, but horrible storage tech, so tree planting alone is not a good carbon capture solution. Biomass burial is (imo) a great and relatively simple solution at the moment because we have a bunch of empty mines to use. There is also research being done on putting biomass in a chemical bath that turns it's CO2 into some form of storable liquid and then storing that, but I can't find a link for it at the moment.
- prododev 2y ago[dead]
- a-priori 2y agoWhen trees die, they’re consumed by fungi, and the carbon is sequestered in humus (soil). That’s totally fine, and in fact is an important reason to ensure that planted forests have a fungal culture so this decomposition process occurs properly. You’re right about fire releasing carbon. But even after devastating fires, forests don’t burn completely and plenty of plant matter remains. Even ash and soot is still sequestered carbon, not to mention charred wood even if the tree doesn’t survive.
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoThat's only true under certain circumstances. Sometimes the biomass accumulation is permanent. My house was built in the 60's. The basement recently started flooding. While digging a drain to fix the problem I uncovered evidence that ground level used to be 18 inches lower than it is now. 60 years of deciduous tree action created enough new soil to change how the water flows... Instead of going around my house now it goes through. Trees are not seen as a solution because they don't represent a market opportunity. You can make millions selling EV's, how are you going to make money with trees? If we actually wanted to fix this, rather than using it as marketing spin, I figure we'd be working on ways to replace deserts with forests and then on ways to ensure that whatever soil accumulation trick my tree is doing is also happening in those forests. (And golly I wish we would, I've been taking biology classes in this direction and recent political events have me thinking that the I've got some significant headwinds here).
- gruez 2y ago>Trees are not seen as a solution because they don't represent a market opportunity. You can make millions selling EV's, how are you going to make money with trees? Given that carbon is emitted continuously, and forests only offset a fixed amount of emissions (they stop sequestering carbon once they're fully grown and reach steady-state), you basically constantly need to be planting trees. That creates an obvious market for tree planting companies.
- pabs3 2y agoThis guy argues that mature forest ecosystems are better carbon sequesters than immature ones or monoculture forests, due to biodiversity, leaf litter, fungi, soil etc: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Crowther_(ecologist) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Crowther_(ecologist) https://crowtherlab.com/ https://crowtherlab.com/ https://iview.abc.net.au/show/forest https://iview.abc.net.au/show/forest https://www.memorabletv.com/news/the-forest-trillion-tree-hype/ https://www.memorabletv.com/news/the-forest-trillion-tree-hy...
- adrr 2y agoPlant trees for paper and stop recycling paper.
- krn1p4n1c 2y agoMoney. Planting trees doesn’t pay like some absurd tech idea to vacuum it up and bond/compress it.
- bbor 2y agoI’m no expert, but on a theoretical level: trees—and, more importantly, algae—capture carbon on accident as part of their respiration, which even with risky genetic modification enhancements has a natural limit on volume/biomass-level efficiency. OTOH, with the right chemical process running at scale (“synthetic carbon capture”, apparently), the sky’s the limit! We might not have the right tech at the moment, but AFAIK there are multiple plausible systems that would work much better than what we have now.
- renewedrebecca 2y agoThis is magical thinking.
- marcosdumay 2y agoMonocelular algae is on the order of 1% efficient at converting light into biomass. Land crops are a few times less efficient than them, and trees are 1 order of magnitude or 2 less efficient than crops.
- SpicyLemonZest 2y agoSerious advocates consider it to be a research area, not a mature primary climate strategy. Someone in the 1930s would have been equally skeptical of “smog capture”, but it turns out modern catalytic converters are so good that we don’t have to choose between enjoying clear skies and driving around mobile smog machines.
- aDyslecticCrow 2y agoSomeone else pointed it out in a different way. Forrest only captures carbon as it grows. A fully grown forest is carbon neutral. Specific type of march land and oceans are the only ecosystems that properly capture and store carbon continuously. So we need to chop the trees down again and plant new ones. Which is more feasible than technological carbon capture, but still a drop in the bucket of what is needed.
- pabs3 2y agoThis guy argues that mature forest ecosystems are better carbon sequesters than immature ones or monoculture forests, due to biodiversity, leaf litter, fungi, soil etc: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Crowther_(ecologist) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Crowther_(ecologist) https://crowtherlab.com/ https://crowtherlab.com/ https://iview.abc.net.au/show/forest https://iview.abc.net.au/show/forest https://www.memorabletv.com/news/the-forest-trillion-tree-hype/ https://www.memorabletv.com/news/the-forest-trillion-tree-hy...
- Qwertious 2y agoThere's a ton of carbon sequestered in soil, that is released when the ground is torn up (e.g. when clearing an area for replanting) and then only recovers over centuries (which is essentially permanent loss, in the current context) If you cut down an entire forest to bury it (with hypothetical carbon-neutral machinery), then replant the entire forest, you can still end up emitting more carbon than you store.
- ArnoVW 2y agoThe way to look at it is: there are two carbon cycles. A long cycle (proto-plankton dies, gets carbonized over millions of years, is pumped up, burned, and ends up in the atmosphere), and a short cycle (tree dies, is burned / rots, and ends up in the atmosphere). If all we do is burn trees, there is no problem. We're not adding CO2 to the atmosphere that wasn't there before. The problem is that the stuff we pump up was not there before. So capturing in trees is at best a temporary solution. In 20 / 30 years that tree dies and is burnt or rots, and so the CO2 is released again. At best it may buy us some time while we learn to do with less oil. But it's crazy talk to do a weekend in Thailand and then "offset it with trees". That's like saying "I was broke, but I found $100 on the street, now life can continue as before". I won't even mention the fact that large parts of the "offset economy" are essentially fraud. People that own a swath of forrest declaring "I was going to cut these 10 km2 of forrest and prevent any new tree on it, but now I won't" just so that they can get carbon credits. Even if it is painfully obvious that they never intended to do that.
- loeg 2y agoPlanting trees is a form of carbon capture!
- bbor 2y agoI came in to drop a “glad the obvious is being confirmed!”, but after skimming the actual study I’m sadly a little dubious of its reasoning. It didn’t examine the two approaches (technically three: renewables, natural carbon capture, and synthetic carbon capture) on their engineering or economic merits, but rather just compiled historical data on jurisdictions that mainly promoted one of the three and compared the outcomes. I think the noisy nature of such an analysis is obvious, not to mention the bias against synthetic approaches from analyzing outdated tech. I’m a huge believer in renewables being the only path forward, but this study isn’t very convincing IMHO! Also would’ve loved to see “degrowth”/reduce usage as an option, since that’s the last big one people advocate for IME. P.S. does anyone know if the current US regime’s “any university that works on federal grants is forbidden from promoting DEI” policy is intended to apply to climate change as well? Seems likely, but I don’t recall seeing anything explicit in any of the EOs I’ve read. This study isn’t very out of Stanford, which would clearly be impacted — thus it piqued my interest.
- SketchySeaBeast 2y agoCarbon capture has always seemed to me to be a means for companies to get paid both to produce carbon and then to clean it up.
- s1artibartfast 2y agoAs they should, provided the consumer is paying and using the carbon. Pay an airline to take you somewhere and produce carbon, pay someone to remove that carbon.
- SketchySeaBeast 2y agoShould get paid? Or should clean it up? The problem is this is energy and resources that could be spent on actually solving the problem at its source instead of finding ways to maintain the status quo.
- s1artibartfast 2y agocleaning it up is solving the problem.
- SketchySeaBeast 2y agoIs it? Or is it just kicking the can down the road? We're trying to clean up crumbs off the floor with a machine that runs on cookies.
- lesuorac 2y agoIt's an improvement no? It's like paying a fee when buying a car battery or car tires unless you return an old one. The fee needs to be overly pegged to inflation or something though otherwise you end up with the glass / aluminum cans problem.
- SketchySeaBeast 2y ago
- Asraelite 2y agoSo what? We would still need to work on actively reducing current CO2 levels even if emissions dropped to zero tomorrow.
- tonetegeatinst 2y agoThe new paper regarding using a nuke to accelerate co2 sequestering in the sea from MIT....is man made water sequestration using minerals to bind the co2 from the water count as carbon capture? The paper was published from RIT.
- aDyslecticCrow 2y agoIt would be carbon capture... but it feels like such a needlessly destructive method. It's up there with atmosphere manipulation in "bad ideas that we should only even consider if we're desperatre"
- pfdietz 2y agoIt's destructive, but it exploits the extremely low cost per unit energy of nuclear explosives (particularly large ones).
- aDyslecticCrow 2y agoAnyone who isn't aware of this is either - Lying. - Paid by the oil industry. - Tricked by the oil industry. All you need is napkin maths. We gain energy by turning carbon into carbon dioxide. Now, we need the same energy to reverse it, but with a loss factor. We continue to see companies and politicians claiming it's feasible and will help us become "green". We should call them out on their shit. If we had the renewable power budget to use proper carbon capture on a large scale, we would already have a fully green grid. --- Well... There are other methods than reversing c02 back into carbon chains. Capture of CO2 and storage as CO2, mostly in compressed gas form in underground, has been proposed by a lot of companies. This is a logistical nightmare that has to be kept up for forever. Better keep that pressure chamber leakproof for 1000 years with likely upkeep. (setting aside how inefficiently that actually stores the carbon even if grabbing it from the air was free) Ideas to shove c02 air bubbles in concrete are promising but barely enough to offset the c02 generated from creating the concrete itself. One promising approach is to grow plants and turn them into charcoal. Charcoal is great for keeping fertilizer in the soil so that we can spread it over crop fields for a small increase in yield. Napkin maths on that makes it just require about Australia of farmland (if I remember) to offset the world's CO2 emissions. Almost feasible. (bamboo, algae, and sunflowers seem to be the highest biomass generators, but perhaps a slower crop that can handle worse climate is preferable) But these are still worse plans than just building a green grid.
- Tade0 2y ago> All you need is napkin maths. We gain energy by turning carbon into carbon dioxide. Now, we need the same energy to reverse it, but with a loss factor. I'm of the opinion that no matter the level of cartoon villainy the oil industry is accused of - they're most likely guilty, but there's an inaccuracy here: In hydrocarbons the majority of energy comes from the oxidation of hydrogen. We should get rid of coal first, as it's irredeemable in this regard and methane second, as it's a greenhouse gas which tends to leak, but it's theoretically possible to burn hydrocarbons and turn the CO2 to coal and leave it like that with a net energy gain - it's just hugely impractical compared to not burning them in the first place.
- 2y ago
- nlitened 2y agoCould someone please explain how could carbon capture ever work? To me it looks as if it is a mathematically impossible thing: if you produce energy by releasing carbon, you would need to expend even more energy to capture the same carbon back, so it is impossible — there’s no way to produce required energy to do so. And if you had such an huge and cheap energy source for carbon capture, you wouldn’t burn carbon in the first place — you’d use that energy source instead. What am I missing? Am I stupid, or the people who talk about carbon capture are ridiculously dishonest?
- mrmanner 2y agoThe carbon dioxide is captured and stored, the actual carbon isn't returned to whatever form it was before burning. So theoretically it _can_ work (but, as it turns out, it still doesn't make sense).
- exe34 2y agoI've always thought of carbon capture as something you do later in the timeline, after burning carbon to get you to a society that can make the transition to green energy. this might be the case for example if you need a certain amount of innovation and that requires a certain critical mass of brains thinking over the problem. or maybe if you're an accelerationista, you want AI to solve it for you and burning carbon now to train it might make sense. but I don't think the idea is to ever burn carbon to capture carbon.
- loeg 2y agoYou would produce the energy without releasing carbon.
- bsdetector 2y agoYou're thinking about energy and not cost. For example, when solar plus direct air capture can remove a ton of CO2 for cheaper than it costs a container ship not to emit that CO2 then it's reduced cost for the same CO2 outcome even though it's using more total energy. Regardless of whether it actually makes sense to capture carbon, you'll see a lot of sky-is-falling fanatics and vested interests dismissing it because it caps the price of carbon credits and limits economic damage estimates. You can't price CO2 at $500/ton to necessitate change when it only costs $200/ton to capture it - without quickly going bankrupt that is. This is why the IPCC not even attempting to evaluate mechanical capture shows they aren't serious about solving the problem. They seemingly exist to push a fear narrative, and having an upper bound on the impact of CO2 limits their ability to do so.
- legitster 2y agoThis is kind of a silly analysis. Solar power is already the cheapest source of electricity ever created by man per kwh. The problem is geography, storage capacity, and load planning. If we're talking purely about future hypotheticals, who's to know if carbon scrubbers are less cost effective than city-sized lithium storage facilities.
- selfhoster 2y agoExcept we we replaced all current forms of power generation with wind and solar, it would be more expensive: https://climate.mit.edu/ask-mit/would-getting-all-our-electricity-wind-and-solar-power-raise-price-electricity https://climate.mit.edu/ask-mit/would-getting-all-our-electr...
- epistasis 2y agoThat's just one guy's opinion, namely: > Richard Schmalensee, Howard W. Johnson Professor of Management Emeritus, Professor of Economics Emeritus, and Dean Emeritus of the MIT Sloan School of Management An economics and b-school professor is not equipped to evaluate a multi-decade transition, and he apparently hasn't even taken into account how batteries are falling in cost like solar and wind are. Those who do cost-optimal grid planning find that wind, solar, storage, our existing nuclear result in a grid that is cheaper than our current grid. However the problem is that we don't do grid planning based on what costs the least, we do small incremental changes from utilities that are using cost estimates that are years out of date, and we don't think about making large scale changes that result in big cost changes. And one other thing about looking about predictions from the past with grid modeling, everybody always underestimated the rate of how fast solar and wind prices fall. They are doing the same for batteries now.
- loeg 2y agoThe fine article is also just one guy's opinion. Notably someone who sues people who disagree with him. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Z._Jacobson#Critiques_of_100%_renewable_papers_and_court_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Z._Jacobson#Critiques_of_...
- jokoon 2y agoWe need to have a battery checklist equivalent for carbon capture: [ ] how much carbon is captured by KW? [ ] are there expected improvement in the technology in the future 30 years? [ ] and what do physicists say about it? [ ] is it more efficient than photosynthesis? [ ] how mature is the technology compared to other methods? [ ] who funds it?
- killjoywashere 2y agoIs it possible to just pump a slurry of corn and various pulp products into dead oil wells?
- alexose 2y agoPretty much, yeah. Vaulted Deep (https://vaulteddeep.com/ https://vaulteddeep.com/) is doing a version of this.
- semi-extrinsic 2y agoNope. You need to understand that an oil reservoir is 100% rock, but a rock that is porous on the microlevel. Stuff that gets pumped down needs to be a proper fluid, not just a slurry, or it will just clog the pores in half an hour.
- GuB-42 2y agoThe study is considering extremes, but that's not realistic. Completely switching to renewables will be more expensive than planting some trees for instance. If we want the most cost effective methods, it will be a mix of both, maybe more on the "burning less fossil fuels" side than on carbon capture, but neither extreme make sense. And it may turn out that a complete switch to renewables may not be enough anyways. We may need carbon capture too, and maybe some geoengineering.
- loeg 2y agoThe dollars don't actually substitute, either. We can spend on both more than we'd be willing to spend only on renewable sources.
- ashoeafoot 2y agoThat very same trees that regularly go up in climate change caused forrest fires? Preferable eucalyptus ? Why not grow algea and dump them down the gravity well into the dead, dark ocean, into some high salinity pit.
- Matumio 2y agoIf you wonder whether you could at least capture CO2 directly from the combustion process (instead of out of thin air), well yes that's cheaper but still too expensive. The current CCS projects use highly concentrated CO2 sources, while the usual combustion process will generate air with only a few percent of CO2. There was an article last year about the Hammerfest LNG plant. They have a CCS project nearby, but found it cheaper to electrify the plant: https://industrydecarbonization.com/news/is-carbon-capture-and-storage-more-expensive-than-we-thought.html https://industrydecarbonization.com/news/is-carbon-capture-a...
- tyronehed 2y agoEvery bit of opposition to climate change mitigation comes from the oil industry. How incredibly evil and vile they are for being willing to damage the world and our environment just to make a buck.
- twodave 2y agoThere’s certainly some of this, and there are also a lot of people living in difficult geographies that rely on oil. Take away global reliance on oil and these people either have to move somewhere else (and many of them aren’t exactly welcome in their neighboring countries) or else they die, starving, and in the dark. I’m not really as sympathetic to this issue as I sound, but I don’t think the characterization of 100% greed and evil is totally fair, either.
- leafario2 2y agoAm I wrong in assuming that after achieving a reduction in emissions, the carbon in the atmosphere should be ideally absorbed again?
- twodave 2y agoI guess I don’t see how any of this is really relevant today. Can someone help explain? My thought process is telling me that by far the worst environmental offender (China) is on the front end of a population collapse that will pretty much serve to self-correct them from an environmental standpoint. That could take 30 years at most? I’m not sure there’s any sort of program we could implement in that time frame that really moves the needle, and when it happens most of the world’s capacity to build things like solar cells and wind farms will need to be re-built, because we won’t be getting a lot of those components we need from China anymore. And who knows? By then maybe we look up at a smaller global population that’s largely de-globalized and decide nothing needs doing. In the short term it’s a shame because IMO the #1 (by far, not close) contributor to global pollution doesn’t even make it to the table in these sorts of discussions.
- newyankee 2y agoChina is not the worst offender. You are disregarding per capita, historical cumulative emissions and outsourced emissions. I am willing to bet that they have the resources, will and execution speed to decarbonise fast though, largely due to surplus solar and lots of batteries but also significant investments in wind and Nuclear. I am not sure why a lot of Americans do not talk about efficiency in their own backyard or are even unwilling to consider a smaller footprint (it is like almost in the DNA of the country)
- __MatrixMan__ 2y agoThe US is the worst offender by far, and seems hell bent on getting worse still. I wish we would acknowledge it, even just among ourselves would be a great start.
- wang_li 2y agoChina is #1 in annual emissions and is increasing every year and plans to continue increasing until at least 2030, is a larger annual emitter than all of Europe combined, and is #2 in total emissions since 1750. In fact, has released more than all of Europe combined since 1750. Per capita is irrelevant. The thermodynamic system doesn't give a shit about how many people there are, all that matters is the amount of CO2. If you want to make some kind of moral argument you can't avoid asking the question of whether it's moral to have a kid at all. Unless you are prepared to consign your children to being a hunter gatherer until they die, they will add CO2 to the atmosphere. Consider me and my neighbor, I am single and emit 1000 tons of carbon per year, he and his wife emit 3000 tons of carbon per year. They have triplets and increase their emissions by 500 tons per year. But somehow they are better than me now because on a per capita basis their house is only 700 tons per year per person while I'm still at 1000 tons per year? Sorry, I'm not reducing my lifestyle because they like to fuck. If you want to measure a country or population by some metric other than total emissions, you should measure something like tons per quality of life or human development or something that demonstrates that the emissions are being used efficiently to increase overall human flourishing.
- buckle8017 2y agoThey apply a "model" which is not described to justify an artificially low price for solar power delivered to retail customers. In reality solar is more expensive than natural gas when reliably delivered. Batteries, over provisioning, fly wheels, and finally backup idle gas power plants are not surprisingly very expensive.
- D_Alex 2y agoWow. Researchers could have found this by reading Hacker News from 2019. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19579185#19579943 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19579185#19579943
- thelastgallon 2y agoCarbon capture is our money being used to pay oil industry. It is for enhanced oil recovery. It is straight up theft with environmental marketing! Twenty-seven DAC plants have been commissioned to date worldwide, capturing almost 0.01 Mt CO2/year. Thats the equivalent of 2000 EVs. --- We pay in 8+ different ways for fossil fuels: (1) Subsidies of trillions of dollars per year (2) Ethanol and biodiesel subsidies (3) Pay at the pump (or electricity) (4) Pay for carbon capture to help oil companies extract more oil (5) Pay for the consequences of climate change (a) increase of home insurance (b) bailouts of insurance and utility providers (c) dealing with the direct costs of climate change (6) Health costs! Pollution is directly linked to every disease (except STIs?). Air Pollution Kills 10 Million People a Year. Think of all the cancers, cardiovascular, metabolic, every biological systems. (7) We pay a cost of other pollutants. Lead (thank you oil industry!), mercury (thank you coal industry!). Fish was a source of food, the best kind of renewable food, where you do absolutely nothing other than catch it! This source is now gone, there is so much mercury in fish, that all recommendations of fish are to limit the number of servings! (8) Every person on the planet is paying a fossil fuel tax (the 5 above), to the super super rich. It is a transfer of wealth from everyone to about ~100 people. This money is used to buy all assets (real estate), stocks and everything else, enabling the super wealthy to extract every more wealth from every sector of the economy. --- Lets talk about the smallest tax (subsidy!) we pay one of the 6 listed about, ethanol subsidies. 40 million acres are used to grow corn for ethanol subsidies (out of 93m total). If we use these 40m acres for solar, Annual Energy Production (in watt-hours): 52,272 terawatt-hours (TWh) To put that in context: The total electricity consumption of the U.S. is about 4,000 TWh/year. The energy generated from 40 million acres of solar panels could theoretically meet U.S. electricity demand more than 13 times over. But, we'll need a lot less energy when we use solar/wind. We only need a third of the energy we use today, > 65% of the energy is wasted. So, solar panels on the same land used for ethanol production (and subsidized -- which is a lose-lose-lose idea) can produce 39x times US electricity demand (assuming ChatGPT calculation is correct).
- slothtrop 2y agoYou can talk about the inefficiency of CC, but this is nonsensical. It's a woefully inefficient means to retrieve carbon in terms of cost. It only makes sense as a means, under development, to reduce prevent buildup in the atmosphere. If it does not do that very well, then as you can imagine, the yields are not great either! If it does do that well, then it's a moot point whether these companies profit; what matters is improving climate. Can't have it both ways.
- qwerty456127 2y agoEverything is expensive but we have to start everything with something, then explore further to improve.
- amunozo 2y agoCarbon capture is one of the most absurd ideas I've ever heard, given the array of already available options.
- slothtrop 2y agoIt's not a long list, and among them is pumping sulfur in the stratosphere. It stops sounding so absurd compared to what's viable, nevermind politically.
- WhyNotHugo 2y agoPlanting trees is also a form of carbon capture. They literally capture carbon from the environment and release oxygen. It's as if they natural evolved to counterbalance animals. Sadly, when people talk about "carbon capture" techniques, they're never talking about planting trees.
- niek_pas 2y agoTrees work, but take a long long time to grow.
- Rury 2y agoTrees are good but are largely a temporary store. Most of the carbon they capture ends up be re-released upon decay. Of course some does get more permanently sequestered in the ground, but a relatively small amount, and is a very slow process. I'm all for planting more trees, but I'm afraid the problem can't be entirely solved by merely planting more trees. It's also a rate problem - it may not be possible to plant enough trees to completely offset the rates we're adding carbon to the atmosphere.
- alexey-salmin 2y agoA tree normally is carbon-neutral. Is captures carbon when it grows then releases it when it dies and rots. Unless you have an ecosystem that prevents rotting (e.g. an anaerobic swamp) in which case you have steady accumulation of carbon (e.g. in a form of peat, which is a fire hazard btw). When people speak of planting trees to capture carbon they rarely mean creating swamps.
- slothtrop 2y agoProbably for electricity, but that doesn't represent the vast majority of fossil fuel use. Those are not yet abated.
- fasthands9 2y agoI don't see how this would necessarily apply to every scenario. Transmission is expensive and storage is still not ideal. Briefly reading the article it seems like the author is assuming there is like a 1:1 global marketplace where any energy produced in one area can replace energy demand in another. That's just not the case.
- dfilppi 2y ago[dead]
- nullc 2y agoI think it's useful to think of the atmosphere as a battery, when we burn fossil fuels we discharge it gradually by taking O2 from the air and converting it to CO2 via the 'fuel'. You can extend this to an idea of there being a little parallel capacitor with the living biomass cycle on it, but it's okay to ignore for discussion. We can't go on discharging it arbitrarily and leaving it there because that state is toxic to us. This battery is insanely useful because it's all around us. Because most of the work is in the ambient O2 the 'fuel' we need use use this battery is incredibly dense. The miraculous density of it is because there is two parts to it, the density when you consider both is unimpressive (as anyone who has tried to operate a chainsaw inside a fire knows all too well, or run a ic motor underground), but because we can usually disregard the air side it is truly amazing. It's so useful the all the higher life on earth also uses it, which is part of why discharging to much it is toxic to us. Because it's so useful we're unlikely to completely stop using it unless we leave the planet. But that means we need to recharge it. The natural recharging mechanisms are only sufficient for surface biomass buffer, not the depths of the planets' oil and coal reserves which were changed over millennia using mechnisms that no longer exist (e.g. biomass trapped before microbes knew how to digest cellulose). Unfortunately recharging it is probably going to take all the energy we got out of it and then somewhat more. It can only take less than that to the extent that we can find less enthalpic places to stash it that are as geophysically durable as the original forms. But that isn't so bad-- no one expects any battery to be 100% efficient, and one as useful as this one is worth some cost to use it. But this also means that the proper price for long term fossil fuels is, shockingly, not the price that maximizes oil Barron incomes-- it's the price that covers the cost run run the recharging mechanism. We don't have to make capture cheap, we just need it to be cheap enough that oil can be correctly priced.
- tmnvdb 2y agoThe study on which the article is based seems somewhat speculative. The assumption for the full renewable scenario are the existence of the hydrogen economy. I'm quite positive about the potential of hydrogen but there are quite a few unsolved problems at the moment and it seems the hydrogen part of the energy transition has slowed down a bit. Certainly the total cost of such a system is not well known at this time. So the cost calculation for the renewable scenario is quite uncertain - other energy storage tech might be more expensive. The carbon capture calculation is based on the assumption that there is no other renewables and we go 100% capture. This is not really that interesting an scenario, what matters more is the marginal costs of each technology at different points in the future. In general a healthy dose of scepticism is warented when it comes to long term projections or cost of technologies, though or course policy does require we take a stab at it.
- liveoneggs 2y agokind of like recycling
- turnsout 2y agoOh good, this will influence all the rational policymakers in the government who are introducing common-sense legislation based on science. OH WAIT
- AlienRobot 2y agoI got some solar panels. Did the math and was impressed that they would pay for themselves in around just 2 years. It's a bit sad that to make money you need money, but I do recommend anyone who can afford it to just install them.
- loeg 2y agoFor most people the break-even is longer than that. Net-metering is an unjustified gift from non-paneled ratepayers to ratepayers with solar panels.
- AlienRobot 2y agoEven without net metering the solar panels cover a lot of the electricity spent and I assume they would pay for themselves eventually. If you do the math, a single 10W light bulb consumes 0.24kWh per day if you let it on all the time. A single solar panel is rated for 2kWh per day. Many appliances are also under 2kWh per use. Any electricity you spend during the day will be saved by the solar panel automatically. If you live alone and leave during daylight hours that might not be worth it, but for a lot of family households it's free electricity.
- loeg 2y agoYeah, the big variables are utility electricity price ($0.10/kWh utility pricing makes solar less effective than $0.50/kWh), price for the panels + installation, and ~capacity factor. If the panels last long enough, and they usually will, as long as the installation is appropriately sized it likely eventually pays for itself. It's just usually longer than two years.
- Geezus_42 2y agoIdk why anyone would find this surprising...
- BurningFrog 2y agoHere is the case for carbon capture: - Even if CO₂ production ends today, the elevated CO₂ levels will remain for at least many centuries. The only way to get back to normal levels is some form of carbon capture. - Anyone can do carbon capture anywhere. You don't need to make the whole planet agree to and implement some treaty. Just put up some solar cells and pump the captured CO₂ underground. The costs need to go down a few orders of magnitude, but I see no fundamental reason why that would be impossible
- jandrewrogers 2y agoThe scale of carbon capture required to make a meaningful difference implies vast industrial infrastructure and natural resource extraction that currently doesn’t exist. The carbon footprint of developing that would be enormous and require many decades to construct at a minimum. There is a good argument that the ROI and environmental destruction is not worth it.
- marcosdumay 2y agoYou mean to say that to make a new industry people will have to build something new? Or are you saying that the size of "all industries" will need to increase? Because... where do you think the carbon has come from?
- jandrewrogers 2y agoPeople truly do not appreciate the industrial scale required to sequester the 100 gigatons per year required to start materially reducing atmospheric CO2. Entirely unprecedented, humans have never built anything like it. When I put on my very dusty chemical engineering hat, it would take decades just to build adequate supply chains for such an endeavor, assuming we waived all environmental review, never mind actually building the thing. Most people are not familiar with industrial processes. They have no idea how unfathomably large the scale being proposed is. In computer science terms, it is like saying “we are going to scale Postgres to a zettabyte sized tables with a billion concurrent transactions”. It might be possible in some kind of in theory sense but no one knows how to reduce that idea to a real system.
- tim333 2y agoThere was an interesting idea to fix climate change by carbon capture for ~$10bn in a recent Sabine video >A Big Nuclear Bomb Could Fix Climate Change, Physicist Says https://youtu.be/aGPKpx6pMko https://youtu.be/aGPKpx6pMko Just put some huge nukes in the basalt at the bottom of the Indian Ocean, it breaks it up so the rock absorbs CO2, job done! (paper on the idea https://arxiv.org/html/2501.06623v1 https://arxiv.org/html/2501.06623v1)
- acc_297 2y agoI won't watch that video just right now but I assume the paper is this one: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2501.06623 https://arxiv.org/pdf/2501.06623 And I'll include this colourful quote: "This is orders of magnitude larger than the largest nuclear explosion ever detonated, so this is not to be taken lightly." I quickly read through and may have missed it but I do not see any mention of the timescale over which this would work just that it could sequester ~30 years worth of CO2 output.
- tim333 2y agoYeah, they do seem to skip over the details a bit. Also I'm a bit skeptical of the $10bn price tag. I think in practice going straight to a huge megabomb straight off would not be wise but maybe we could try one of our existing spare nukes as a prototype test? Then you'd get more data on how it would work.
- 00N8 2y agoI'm not convinced about their hand-waved explanation of radiation safety here: > The long-term effects of global radiation will impact humans and will cause loss of life, but this increased global radiation is “just a drop in the bucket”. Every year, we emit more radiation from coal power plants and we have already detonated over 2000 nuclear devices. Adding one more bomb should have minimal impact on the world. I don't think "eh, what's one more detonation?" is persuasive when you're talking about a device more than 10x the size of all previous ones put together, being set off in direct contact with the seabed. Most of the fallout from nuclear testing came from the handful of ground burst tests that weren't fully confined, so I'm skeptical that "try to make it a clean fusion design" would actually be enough here. It would be cool if that were solvable though.
- sam345 2y agoNot surprising. Carbon capture methods are so out there and so bogus sounding with very little evidence that they will work, really seems just custom made to soak up government money with little promise of benefit and certainly not efficient.
- James_K 2y agoIt's actually way cheaper as long as you imagine that some magic technology gets invented in the next few years that makes it cheaper. Then you just have to hold of until that is created and if it isn't, it won't cost you anything! Even more savings!
- crocowhile 2y agoThat's comparing apples to oranges though. Renewables are to stop emitting CO2, carbon capture to try and recover the one we've been emitting in the past decades. We need both, the latter possibly in the shape of organic capture since it's way more efficient and cheap.
- schainks 2y agoEngineering/inventing ways to emit less CO2 is fixing the root cause of the problem. Spending energy that likely came from fossil fuel burning to "capture" CO2 is like saying you've found a perpetual motion machine. The engineering is simpler for this in some ways, but it's still not really a "good" solution. I agree organic capture is a good idea, and CHEAPEST thing we could do to have an impact dump iron into the open ocean to spawn a phytoplankton bloom, but there is no money to be made doing that.
- sfvisser 2y agoIsn’t the point of most carbon capture schemes to use renewables (likely solar) as the energy source. Like Terraform Industries? Don’t know if it will work or is economically viable, but sounds pretty win-win to me.
- schainks 2y agoThere is a lot of R&D predating mass cheap solar where proposals do things like have it captured at the production site or arbitrage cheap off peak energy to store it since the grid capacity is there anyway. Modern solar definitely makes this idea more attractive but you’re still emitting more carbon to build the solar in the hopes you’ll store more than you produced in X years. It is not a great value proposition versus making the grid more efficient or just emitting less by using that solar for the grid instead of sequestration.
- moffkalast 2y agoYeah going net zero by just stopping emissions isn't just not going to help our situation that much, we've already emitted enough to fuck ourselves properly, it's also not even possible. There's no such thing as a net zero society with our current technology, period. Anyone seen an electric tractor lately? Combine harvester EVs? Electric aircraft? Zero emission concrete? Electric container ships? Cheap plastics without oil? Electric orbital launch vehicles!? Lots of fantasy tech that ranges from being cost ineffective to borderline infeasible and we can't (or won't, anyway) run our civilization without these and dozens more that have no real replacement on the horizon. Covid has made that point really sharply clear, we just can't stop ourselves. Piston engined planes still today run on leaded gas despite knowing that it's literal poison for fucks sake, it's fuckin hopeless to convince anyone about anything when there's a chance someone might lose money. Carbon capture might help in the long run, but the bulk of it will have to be on geoengineering to even give us a century of time to remove megatons of CO2 out of the atmosphere and oceans. And maybe a fish or two will even survive.
- very_good_man 2y agoTired of the green scams. Drill Drill Drill!
- honestSysAdmin 2y ago[dead]
- 11235813213455 2y agoWe should ban private swimming pools, tennis courts, etc.. and restrict the size of villas, ban mowing the lawn, in order to maximize the space for trees and wild plants
- Schiendelman 2y agoALL you have to do to increase space for wild plants is remove height/density limits in cities. That's it. Then let people make choices about how much housing they build, and let people make choices about where they live. You would be shocked how many people will choose to live in density, no matter what they say they want, if we weren't restricting the supply of dense housing so much it's become unaffordable. The suburbs would simply stop growing in their tracks.
- alexey-salmin 2y agoAnd the green crowd is surprised no one votes for them. It's like a new wave puritanism: the haunting fear that someone, somewhere, may be happy.
- 11235813213455 2y agoYou'd be surprised how much a wild green garden makes you much happier compared to a concrete garden with a plastic swimming pool you can use 2 months a year
- lukashoff 2y agoA lot of energy from renewables are being wasted due to mismatch with the demand. Building storage for it is quite expensive. I wonder if it makes sense to set up carbon capture near the places which don't have the storage. For example here in the UK we're wasting between 13% and 25% of all wind electricity generated depending on the weather/time of the year.
- Findecanor 2y agoCarbon capture technology is for installation inside chimney stacks, when there is no alternative to burning stuff and thus producing CO₂. Nothing else. You'd extract the CO₂ directly from the exhaust gases. It can't clean CO₂ from the open air. It does not scale that way.
- acyou 2y agoThe more you look into it, the more you realize we are already doing this, kind of. Then you realize that the real low hanging fruit is sort of in other areas, sulfur dioxide, methane capture, particulate, and especially home heating. European wood pellet and home wood burning stove users, I'm looking at you.
- rafaelmn 2y agoI recently saw a video by Sabine on this paper https://arxiv.org/html/2501.06623v1 https://arxiv.org/html/2501.06623v1 that basically proposes blowing up a gigantic nuclear bomb in deep sea basalt deposit and basalt would capture the carbon. In the paper they did some math on the bomb size needed to reverse 30 years of carbon emissions, and it's huge (orders of magnitude larger than what we tested so far), although I don't understand why it needs to be one huge bomb. I'm sure you could try it with one military head and test the impact. Interesting approach in any case.
- jostmey 2y ago...Detonating a 81 Gt nuclear device... That's multiple orders of magnitude larger than anything tested during the cold war. It's more than all nuclear explosions and tests combined
- the8472 2y agoWe could also use that for asteroid deflection. Someone was planning ahead. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sundial_(weapon) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sundial_(weapon)
- chris_va 2y ago(disclaimer that I manage a climate research group) Jacobson (first author) can be a little touchy about criticism against 100% renewables (litigious), but I think the paper presents a false dichotomy. Regardless of the conclusion, even if all energy infrastructure in the world fully decarbonized today, we are still on a path to high warming (in fact a large chunk of climate change is due to land use change and other factors). The IPCC (and most of the community) is pretty sure large scale carbon capture will be required under any future pathway to avoid catastrophic warming. This is a complex subject, with a lot of competing interests from parties that sometimes partially align with the science and sometimes do not. E.g. O&G companies like to push carbon capture because it plays well and potentially increases their longevity... But that doesn't mean the ideal outcome is to drop carbon capture as part of the toolkit.
- derangedHorse 2y agoI also think it's a useful tool, but the economics of carbon capture have to sustain the cost of developing these methods. Pointing consumerism in the right direction seems like the most effective way to drop carbon emissions from both a short and long term perspective. We need to "stop the bleed" before tackling anything else.
- chris_va 2y agoPipelining is probably required, and there is no one magic solution here. It took solar 45 years to become low cost, and carbon capture will probably be just as difficult. If we did things one step at a time, carbon capture wouldn't be economical until ~2080, which is too late.
- criddell 2y ago> Pointing consumerism in the right direction How do you do that?
- ghouse 2y agoPrice signals. One approach would be a revenue-neutral carbon tax on extraction of sequestered carbon. And border carbon taxes for imports from countries who don't also have an internal carbon tax.
- bayindirh 2y agoCapturing something back is more costly than not emitting in the first place. News at 22.
- totallynothoney 2y agoThis obviously is not viable for X, Y, etc. reasons but I would like to know them. We select some fast growing woody plant that thrives on terrain useless for agriculture, we grow it at industrial scale and convert it to charcoal (using the energy generated for the process itself or the grid), we grind the charcoal and mix it with sea water and pump the slurry into some mine. Creating charcoal and taking out of the cycle isn't actually net negative? We don't have enough space for growing or in mineshafts? I'm making Centralia 2.0? It's obviously non economic, but everything carbon capture is like that.
- sensanaty 2y agoI am the furthest thing from an expert on this, but isn't the majority of natural CO2 capture done by Algae?
- sweeter 2y ago"don't worry, don't worry, once the environment gets unliveable we'll just pull the carbon out of the air. We don't need sustainable resources" Is a lie on par with: "I don't need to go to rehab, I can stop at any time" except the oil companies are the drug dealer and you are the deluded addict who will suffer the brunt of the consequence.
- whatever1 2y agoOh no the VCs did not revolutionize thermodynamics?
- notatoad 2y agounfortunately, the only way this is relevant is if we actually price carbon emissions at the rate it costs to capture them. as long as you can emit for free, then switching to renewables is more expensive.
- AlexandrB 2y agoSince this is talking about 2050, why isn't nuclear mentioned? That seems like a long-enough horizon to build a few nuclear plants.
- loeg 2y agoJacobson is anti-nuclear in a way that is somewhere on a spectrum between pessimistic and dishonest. His prior belief is that 100% wind/solar is the only way to go and all of his research aims to advance that worldview.
- krupan 2y agoAre people still including wood and wood pellets as "renewables"? It seems like that would be throwing off any cost calculations
- acyou 2y agoPoint capture and atmospheric capture are vastly different processes, economics for point capture are great, economics for atmospheric capture are terrible due to the thermodynamic high energy input inherently required for separating out a low concentration (400 parts per million) substance. But this article puts both processes in the same category, which perfectly sets up a low-information, divisive debate. Why they would want to do that - well, some people stand to gain a lot from renewable energy program investment, let's put it that way.
- lblume 2y ago> some people stand to gain a lot from renewable energy program investment Yes, everyone in fact.
- rank0 2y agoHate to break it to you but the people producing and selling solar panels don’t give a fuck about the environment. Neither do you. I feel like Im ruining santa claus…
- lblume 2y ago> the people producing and selling solar panels don’t give a fuck about the environment They sure as hell are incentivized to at least make others do. An increased awareness for environmental issues is profitable. I would go further and think that genuine interest in the future of humanity is more plausible than the required cognitive dissonance. > Neither do you. Completely needless accusation.
- rank0 2y agoWhy on earth are solar panels seen as righteous? You’re so indoctrinated that it borders on worship. Go look into who makes them and how. Producing solar, batteries, wind farms EMITS carbon and has large environmental impact. The energy sector will sell you whatever… > > Neither do you. > Completely needless accusation. 99% of environmentalists are just posturing. I guess it’s possible you’re different, but just remember you probably emit more carbon than almost every person who’s ever lived.
- WalterBright 2y agoThe notion of carbon capture always sounded crazy to me. But there already is a technology to do carbon capture. Plants. Plants cover the world. How does one think a machine could do better?
- acyou 2y agoEuropean home heating using wood pellets is an environmental disaster. Cut down trees in North America, grind them into pellets, pack them in shipping containers, ship them to Europe, and burn them in low efficiency furnaces with zero carbon capture and high particulate and sulfur dioxide emissions. It's probably even worse than home heating using unprocessed wood, due to the massive amount of energy consumed in processing and transportation. If we can't at least point capture stacks at the individual home level, then forget atmospheric capture.
- johnea 2y agoDuh?! The unasked question though: More costly to who? Modern capitalism (especially in the enrgy sector) is fundamentally based on externalities. Getting someone else to bear the cost, while concentrating income as greatly as possible, is what the modern billionaire is all about...
- rob_c 2y agoDoes this really. Really?!? Surprise anyone not invested in hyper loop being a thing?
- jslezak 2y agoThis has been obvious since day 0, for the same reason that doing elaborate industry-funded R&D to develop piss-extraction technology to filter and sequester piss from your swimming pool will never be more efficient than simply not pissing in your pool
- Aachen 2y agoIs it on purpose that the analogy lends itself for arguing "and that's why we need the technology: we won't stop the group that still does this"? I'm probably more optimistic about global warming than about the other "environment-warming" thing!
- sega_sai 2y agoFor people in the UK I strongly recommend the BBC program on carbon capture https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m00256gj/panorama-can-scientists-save-the-world https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m00256gj/panorama-can-... that goes over several approaches, and goes over problems of scaling them. I personally think we have to investigate this, as we are just not doing a good enough job of reducing fossil fuel use.
- Developerx 2y ago[dead]
- Developerx 2y ago[dead]
- picafrost 2y agoEnergy companies are reporting that the cost situation for renewables is terrible. The thin margins continue to get thinner. They cannot justify pursuing new green projects to shareholders. We will hear a lot more about carbon capture in the years to come. It's the only way they can meet their climate obligations — which are also being "adjusted" these days.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 2y agoFor electricity, it seems like a no-brainer, but that's not the only emitter. I wonder what cost for carbon capture they used (unfortunately the article is paywalled). It seems to me like the obvious solution to the problem would be a CO2 tax equal to the estimated cost of carbon capture. It should not be higher - that would be yet another example of moralism that plagues so many environmental policies. Introduce that, properly monitor emissions (especially things like methane leaks), and the problem will quickly solve itself. Anything that remains is the edge cases where it is more economical to do carbon capture - so use the tax to do just that. That also covers cases where it makes sense to do the change more slowly. No need to decide or argue back and forth whether someone can or cannot do it faster. You emit, you pay, you don't want to pay, you don't emit. Changing quickly is too costly? That's fine, you pay. Oh, it's not that costly when compared to the tax? Guess you change, then. Also fine. Want to generate electricity from lignite? I'm not going to argue, I'm just going to watch you go bankrupt... and if you don't, there probably was some good reason for doing that and forcing the opposite would have had some unintended side effects.
- mhh__ 2y agoIs it dearer than storage though? my understanding was always that carbon capture if worth doing at all is for situations where the wind isn't blowing and the sun is dim (this nearly led to blackouts in uk recently)
- cbmuser 2y agoRenewables like wind and solar don’t provide baseload and therefore cannot replace conventional power plants. I wish people stopped comparing apples and oranges here.
- Mathnerd314 2y ago> If scenarios with different mixes of CC/DAC and WWS were performed, it would not be possible to conclude whether one is an opportunity cost. Instead, using a mixture requires assuming that both CC/DAC and WWS should be used before determining whether one has any benefit relative to the other. Seems stupid - they are both being used, so even the business-as-usual scenario is a mixture. If indeed the 100% WWS + 0% CC/DAC scenario is better than than the 95% WWS + 5% CC/DAC scenario, then it is logical to conclude that CC/DAC is useless, but according to the tables and figures, they didn't even look at whether a 50/50 WWS + CC/DAC split would be better or worse. Yet their conclusion is still "policies promoting CC and SDACC should be abandoned". They have these really complex models but at the end of the day it is garbage in, garbage out.
- yigalirani 2y agohow about growing fast trees. then bury them?
- nkmnz 2y ago> Comparing two extremes Jacobson and co-authors compared the annual energy costs, emissions, public health impacts, and social costs associated with implementing either of two extremes across all sectors in 149 countries over the next 25 years. > One extreme would see a complete switch to using heat and electricity generated by wind, solar, geothermal, and hydropower for all energy needs (...) > The other extreme would see countries maintain their current reliance on fossil fuels with some renewables, nuclear, and biomass (...) The study might be well intentioned, but since none of the two scenarios has a probability that is different from 0, its use for policy makers, investors, and voters might be very little. In reality, it will always be a mix of both approaches, not because I'm "the truth lies in the middle" kind of guy, but simply because there might be local optimizations found along the way that favor one or the other approach (or both at the same time) based on local and temporal considerations with regard to the financial, technological, political, social, ecological, and cultural conditions.
- mollerhoj 2y agoGenuine question: I run a co2 calculator site. where should I redirect donations for maximum impact?
- darthrupert 2y agoCould we use the technology that has been established hundreds of millions of years ago? You know, trees.
- jmatthews 2y agoI would like to post this respectfully, just for posterity. The anti science insular concepts being assumed as fact, the discredited overpopulation theories, the sky is falling parts of climate change. I can't credibly participate because from my perspective what is being discussed is a popular sci-fi series that I haven't read. The dogmas and rituals are alien to me.
- mariconrobot 2y agoeaser to change what you eat rather than to capture the stinky farts
- aeturnum 2y agoCarbon capture is certainly more expensive than renewables but this headline presents a false dichotomy. The question isn't if we capture carbon instead of switching to renewables - that ship sailed long ago - the question is if we need carbon capture in addition to switching to renewables.
- klysm 2y agoIt’s kind of trivially true right? The problem is we are on a path to have a shitload of carbon in the atmosphere so we better figure out how to get it out starting now
- singingfish 2y agoIn other news, water is wet and the sun rises every morning.
- vrighter 2y agowell yeah.... one gives you energy and reduces carbon emissions, The other takes energy and reduces a tiny bit of co2