14 ms·
Apple will soon receive 'made in America' chips from TSMC's Arizona fab
- datadrivenangel 2y agoThese chips are still sent to Taiwan for packing, so it's a good step but not a complete step.
- m348e912 2y agoHow does this make any financial sense?
- _aavaa_ 2y agoThis is how most modern supply chains look like. Plus, chips are small in size and cost a lot so you can fit a lot in a container. Per unit shipping costs probably come out to be pretty low. Especially when compared to the political costs and risks associated with not onshoring.
- CPLX 2y ago> you can fit a lot in a container Guys these are microchips on wafers. You can put a million dollars worth in your jacket pocket. They aren't being shipped in containers.
- arcticbull 2y agoMarine shipping is just about the most fuel efficient way of moving things between any two places, by a lot. A 100,000 dwt ship can get 1050 miles per gallon per ton of cargo. It takes about a teaspoon full of fuel to move an iPhone sized device across the pacific when I ran the numbers last.
- Vt71fcAqt7 2y agoInteresting. Could you give a brief description of how you got that number? Eg. what factors were considered.
- eric-hu 2y agoThose numbers match what comes up with a quick search: https://www.extension.iastate.edu/grain/topics/EstimatesofTotalFuelConsumption.htm https://www.extension.iastate.edu/grain/topics/EstimatesofTo... That study uses 1,043.4 mpg for the fuel economy of a 100,000 dwt ship. Videos of transportation ship engines are cool. Each cylinder is wide enough for a person to lay down inside it. https://youtu.be/G0eMyA388bE https://youtu.be/G0eMyA388bE
- School-Cotton 2y agoTo ship things to/from these fabs by sea you have to add the cost of shipping by truck between Phoenix and (presumably) LA. Not sure how big of a difference that makes.
- nine_k 2y agoChips are small, so one truck once a few days may suffice.
- CPLX 2y agoAirplanes. They use airplanes. We are talking about microchips here, possibly the highest dollar per gram substance that exists on the planet. The interest you'd pay just losing a couple days in transit time would exceed the cost of purchasing a dedicated private jet and the crew to fly it.
- jocaal 2y agoImagine the insurance...
- kstrauser 2y agoA semi truck carries +- 15 tons of cargo and gets an average of about 6 MPG, so about 90 MPG/ton.
- snakeyjake 2y agoThe machines and processes needed to package the individual integrated circuits are fantastically expensive but the margins are so low in that step that it's only profitable at massive scales. So you put the fantastically expensive machines near where most of the customers are and most of the customers are in Asia. Works the same way with fiber optic cables. Making the long skinny bits is hard and high-margin. Actually turning them into cables is easy and low-margin. So Corning makes huge spools of fiber optic cable in Arizona, North Carolina, and New York (I think) and ships it off to Taiwan and China where it is made into the cables that you plug into stuff.
- fblp 2y agoI'm suprised they can't ship (flat) packaging that could be used in Arizona with a simple assembly line. If they had that packaging design then for this to make financial sense the two way shipping (and loading, unloading, custom clearance etc) would have to be less than shipping the packaging, the setup cost per unit cost of putting the chip in a box
- krisoft 2y agoWait, wait. In the context of semiconductor manufacturing packaging does not mean what you think it means. It is not putting the product in a paper box. It is about cutting the wafer into individual chips, wire bonding the silicone to pins, and covering the whole thing with epoxy. Here is a video which explains it better: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7gg2eVVayA4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7gg2eVVayA4 It would be indeed crazy if they would ship the ready chips to Taiwan just to be put in a paper box. basically the input of the process is a wafer which looks like this: https://waferpro.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/Patterned-Low-Anti-Reflective-Low-Defect-Ctg-on-silicon-Wafer-300x242.jpg.webp https://waferpro.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/08/Patterned-Lo... And the output of the process is something which looks like this: https://res.cloudinary.com/rsc/image/upload/b_rgb:FFFFFF,c_pad,dpr_2.625,f_auto,h_214,q_auto,w_380/c_pad,h_214,w_380/F1310270-01?pgw=1 https://res.cloudinary.com/rsc/image/upload/b_rgb:FFFFFF,c_p...
- zeusk 2y agoThe packaging in this context is not wire bonding but CoWoS - chip-wafer and wafer-wafer bonding.
- krisoft 2y agoYou are correct. I was just illustrating what kind of processes belong to the umbrella term "packaging" in the context of semiconductor manufacturing. Was not talking about what particular process are missing from the Arizona facility. But you are right on that it is CoWoS which is the missing ingredient.
- fblp 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- CPLX 2y agoThese are literally microchips. Tens of thousands of dollars of value in each gram. Shipping cost is fundamentally irrelevant, you can put $100MM worth on a direct flight and have room left over for your family and friends.
- School-Cotton 2y agoYour overall point is probably right, but "tens of thousands of dollars of value in each gram" seems like an exaggeration. How much does one CPU weigh?
- CPLX 2y agoOrder of magnitude it's within range. A single wafer for something higher end is worth tens of thousands of dollars. So whatever that weighs. It's not much.
- School-Cotton 2y agoBut surely a wafer weighs more than a gram, no?
- DougMerritt 2y agoYes. One source I just double checked says that a 300mm silicon wafer weighs 840 grams, which seems to be in the right range anyway.
- grues-dinner 2y agoI see that source too (universitywafer.com) which is sucked into the AI slop panel on Google. A 300mm wafer at 0.775mm thickness that weighs that much would be a density of 15g/cm³: midway between lead (11) and gold (19). Silicon is only 2.3g/cm³. A 300mm wafer should be much closer to 100g than 1kg. Another page (on the same website!) says 125g, which is pretty dead-on 2.3g/cm³.
- 2y ago
- hollow-moe 2y agowhat is involved in the packaging process ? I believe they don't ship fully assembled chips to Taiwan only to be put in a pretty box ?
- jsheard 2y agoI believe packaging in this context means taking the raw silicon dies and assembling them into a package which can be soldered onto a PCB (or put in a socket, but Apple doesn't socket anything).
- SSilver2k2 2y agoI'm making an educated guess but probably the cutting of chips from the wafers, placing them into the appropriate ceramic socket types (DIP, BFGA, SMD etc), soldering the line wires from chip to pin, encasing the chip, etc.
- a1o 2y ago> DIP I am happily imagining opening a recent Apple device and seeing 74 gates with through holes in green PCBs, with an Apple logo made in soldering lead marking in the corner of the board.
- virexene 2y agoI think "packaging" here refers to the process of putting the silicon die in its plastic casing and connecting the die's pad to the case's pins, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integrated_circuit_packaging https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Integrated_circuit_packaging
- mechagodzilla 2y ago"Packaging" in this context means taking the wafer of compute die (made in Arizona), dicing it up into individual die, mounting it onto a silicon interposer (an even bigger die, no idea where that's made, but probably taiwan) along with a bunch of HBM die, then mounting that Si interposer on a somewhat larger, very fine-pitched circuit board ('substrate') that is essentially a breakout for power and high-speed I/O from the compute die. That thing is the packaged 'CoWoS' system, where CoWoS==Chip-on-wafer-on-substrate, that eventually gets attached to a 'normal' PCB.
- dgfitz 2y agoUntil 2027, yes. https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/gpus/tsmc-is-reportedly-in-talks-with-nvidia-to-make-blackwell-gpus-in-arizona-blackwell-silicon-needs-to-be-shipped-back-to-taiwan-for-assembly https://www.tomshardware.com/pc-components/gpus/tsmc-is-repo... "TSMC does not have an advanced packaging facility in the U.S., and its partner Amkor will only start packaging chips in Arizona in 2027. As a result, Blackwell AI silicon produced in Arizona will need to be shipped back to Taiwan for final assembly, as all of TSMC's CoWoS packaging capacity remains in Taiwan."
- ttul 2y agoGiven that there may be a 25% chance that China invades Taiwan by 2030, having the ability to package SOTA chips in the US by 2027 seems "soon enough".
- coconut08 2y agowhere did you get that number from
- xeromal 2y agoThere's a window where China will have it max capability to invade for the next few years. After that their population is going to start shrinking and every year will be harder than the next to invade.
- bluGill 2y agoThe population of 18-30 year old males is generally what matters for an invasion and China has been shrinking that for a long time. The rest of the population can plan the invasion, but they rarely actually do it. (a few countries also invite young females to an invasion, but that is not normal)
- audunw 2y agoBut they don’t have energy independence or food security yet, which is kind of a hard requirement for an invasion. There’s not enough rail lines and gas pipelines from Russia to feed them with significant quantities of fossil fuels. Imagine how bad Russias invasion of Ukraine would’ve been without energy independence and food security. The invasion of Taiwan is an order of magnitude more difficult, and Taiwan now has the recipe for how to knock out the entire naval fleet of a more powerful nation (see how Ukraine has essentially incapacitated Russia in the Black Sea).
- rich_sasha 2y agoWhat does "packaging" mean in this context? I'm a total n00b when it comes to chips. What comes to my mind is wrapping a piece of electronics in some bubble wrap and cardboard, which doesn't sound that hard...
- bitsage 2y agoFunny enough, Fab 21 was announced in May 2020 and completed construction in July 2022, a month before the Chips Act was signed.
- j_walter 2y agoWhat makes you think construction was completed in July 2022? The shell of Phase 1 may have been completed, but even now the construction continues in Phase 1B and Phase 2.
- bitsage 2y agoI’m going off the purely structural construction of the first fab. There’s a timeline on TSMC’s site.
- mywittyname 2y agoThe announcement of this plant coincided with the announcement of the Endless Frontier Act and CHIPS for America act, which is what eventually became the bill we call CHIPS and Science Act. This plant was the foundation that the CHIPS act was built upon. The Secretary of State had to secure an agreement with TSMC to build this fab before the bills could be drafted, as a lot of the recipients of the funding are suppliers for this plant. It is completely truthful to assert that this is the result of the CHIPS act. Congress agreed to introduce the bills as a result of TSMC's agreement to build the fab in Arizona. If you have to avoid giving Biden credit, then you can point out that it was Trump's SoS who negotiated this original agreement.
- bitsage 2y agoI agree that the CHIPS Act was likely contingent on someone showing semiconductor manufacturing could actually be onshored. I’m not sure I buy that TSMC’s investment was contingent on an Act that was contingent on them investing in the first place. It’s not like TSMC was ever going to get a check to just reimburse themselves. Even now, their subsidies are only for new plans. Intel, on the other hand, is a great example of a how a company dependent on the government funding for semiconductor manufacturing behaves. Heck, look at the Foxconn debacle; companies prefer incentives up front. If you remember, TSMC had the immediate fear of losing ~15% of their revenue with the Huawei export ban. I wouldn’t be surprised if that influenced their decision to cozy up to America.
- lysace 2y agoMade using which process? The article doesn't mention this. https://www.tsmc.com/english/dedicatedFoundry/technology/logic https://www.tsmc.com/english/dedicatedFoundry/technology/log...
- choilive 2y ago4nm
- lysace 2y agoI thought Taiwan prohibited export of this kind of know-how? What did I miss?
- j_walter 2y agoThey have adopted a n-2 type of rule for advanaced tech...but as of yesterday they seem to have relaxed this rule and approved transfer of 2nm from Taiwan fabs to the AZ fab at some point in the near future. https://www.extremetech.com/computing/tsmc-cleared-for-2nm-production-in-us https://www.extremetech.com/computing/tsmc-cleared-for-2nm-p...
- lysace 2y agoI'd be extremely surprised if Apple is now able to source CPUs for current-gen high-end iPhones from a US fab. 2 gens ago, sure.
- andy_ppp 2y agoWow I did not know this and it is fantastic news, surprised Taiwan allowed this as they see chips as being the most important reason America would intervene if they were invaded.
- whimsicalism 2y agoI'm a China dove and I'd favor full-throated defense of Taiwan in any invasion (much more so than Ukraine) regardless of chips.
- digdigdag 2y ago- Over 50% of the workers flew in from Taiwan to work on this plant and make these chips. - The chips still need to fly back to Taiwan to be packaged as there are no facilities here with such a capability. Made in america is a hard sell. But at least showing the glaring STEM field gap in the U.S. is a start to finally addressing the brain drain.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- caycep 2y agoisn't packaging tech mostly from american companies like applied mat/lam research? or am I missing something?
- ge96 2y agobrain drain from where? thought a problem is influx of workers into us although more for software not sure of chip tech
- epicureanideal 2y ago> STEM field gap STEM salary gap I suspect the Taiwan workers have on average much lower salaries.
- lysace 2y agoYes, roughly speaking 1:4 compared to California. Edit: This is not news. This (combined with their higher EE education) is why Taiwan won IBM PC-clone-related manufacturing in the 80s. And why they now have TSMC.
- coliveira 2y agoSuch a great victory for American industry... the future is to bring workers from Taiwan with skills and willingness to receive a fraction of US salaries.
- 2y ago
- ashoeafoot 2y agoTaiwan exodus in 3..2..1
- duxup 2y agoSeems like this is actually happening. I saw so many predictions of how this couldn't happen and "yeah but" ... but it seems to be happening for the most part.
- CPLX 2y agoIndeed. It's just bullshit, propaganda. There's simply no real reason we can't have a deep and robust manufacturing base in America. Well except for the fact that some specific people made a whole lot of money while letting it fall apart, and have paid for decades of media relations trying to convince everyone otherwise. If you're reading this statement I just made and want to instinctively disagree with me, start by interrogating your own opinion. Why do you think America can't compete with China, for example, over the long term? What "well everyone knows" facts are you using to create that opinion that you don't have any first hand relationship to.
- tombert 2y ago> Why do you think America can't compete with China, for example, over the long term? Not saying I necessarily disagree with you, but just to give an example, the US has considerably better labor practices and labor laws than China. It's not perfect but there are protections about making sure people are paid what they're owed, how much you are allowed to work someone, safety protocols, etc. All of those things could, in theory, cost more money and make labor more expensive. Compare this to nations that don't have the same work protections, where they can pay people peanuts and have them work much longer shifts with effectively no protection (e.g. Foxconn in China [1]). This might translate to decreased cost, and Americans have made it excruciatingly clear that we're apparently fine with slave labor as long as it doesn't happen within the US. [1] https://www.dissentmagazine.org/article/chinese-workers-foxconned/ https://www.dissentmagazine.org/article/chinese-workers-foxc...
- bun_at_work 2y agoJust calling out that worker protections and increased labor costs seem to be the result of workers making more money. As the work force becomes wealthier, they _need_ less money, and their standards rise. This means their labor becomes more expensive and they demand safer workplaces. They demand more time off. This happened in the USA and is currently happening in China and other low-labor-cost nations. I think the person you responded to is right. The USA can and should restore its manufacturing base, for many reasons. The whole country would greatly benefit from the return of blue-collar jobs. I don't have sources for this, but the info is out there. Also, there are a lot of nuances around this topic that I'm not getting into here. Just want to acknowledge that...
- xattt 2y agoIs this the first “Made in USA” chip in Apple devices since the Fishkill PPC 970?
- hettygreen 2y agowith required NSA backdoor of course.
- sylware 2y agoThis is only the first (significant) step for the american continent to be able to build cutting edge chips (again).
- seethishat 2y agoOff topic... Taiwan also machines and heat treats some of the best cutlery steels in the world. Taichung City is famous for this. This is not as delicate a process as producing CPU chips, but it is hard to get right consistently. Most all major cutlery companies have product lines that are produced solely in Taiwan (Spyderco, Cold Steel, Demko, etc.) It would be nice to see Taiwanese steel industy move some production to the US as well.
- WillAdams 2y agoBuck Knives at least, mostly manufacture in the U.S., and their 110 model at least still arrives shaving sharp and keeps a decent edge.
- gonational 2y agoHigh-quality knives come from proper metallurgy, especially as it relates to proper hardening steps. If you don't get these things exactly right, the best machining on earth is not going to produce even mediocre knives.
- jenny91 2y agoSorry, don't think that's a national security priority.
- nottorp 2y agoAs an european, all I wonder is if this will make Apple devices even more expensive.
- yello_downunder 2y agoMy guess is no, it won't. This is US taxpayer money being used to increase the manufacturing capacity available to the market so that the US has domestic manufacturing when stuff goes sideways. A similar thing regularly occurs with auto manufacturing and manufacturing in country A usually frees up capacity for other countries, resulting in slightly lower prices. What could happen is that once the US has manufacturing capacity it decides to tariff imported chips, causing your country to retroactively do the same. This is decades away, and the US has a problem sourcing chips it can trust right now, so it's not currently on the radar. It's not something I'm going to worry about. Viewed through a pessimistic eye, the US finally is realizing that its arms production critically relies on chip production and it can't says its chips are US made when selling arms on the market. A change in mindset like this typically takes a generation and so even though this change in weapons really happened around the turn of the century, the people in power have mostly retired and the new generation now understands this reality.
- __loops__ 2y ago3nm? 5nm? What chips are being made? A chip isn’t a chip
- foxandmouse 2y agoIf memory serves me right, it's the Apple S8 chip used in their watches, built on a 7nm process.
- 123sereusername 2y ago[dead]
- hintymad 2y agoDo we know why the US government did not promise to buy chips but to give tax breaks (or investment thereof)? Wouldn't promise to buy create a better incentive to the manufacturers?
- kylehotchkiss 2y agoThere's just such a big shift between parties right now that when the current admin is done, you're not gonna know what to expect with the next. Especially with something that's more policy (purchase orders) than law (taxes). Better to just codify the benefits.
- zombiwoof 2y agoMake America good at slave labor again basically
- hintymad 2y agoMaybe this is the discussion worth having. Taiwanese engineers competed to get into TSMC. Their management practically lived in the factory to solve production issues when needed. The local workers in the Arizona factory said the pay was pretty good per another comment. Yet somehow we thought that we were slaving the labors? What is the fundamental difference here? Personally, if I were a worker who could find just a service job that pays $30K a year or less, I'd kill to work for TSMC for $50K+/year and learn everything I can about chip manufacturing in my capacity. It would be proud to do it, and I wouldn't mind some overtime.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hintymad 2y agoAnd I'm not sure why this got downvoted. Not that it matters, but I'm very curious about why people were not happy with the questions. My fundamental belief is that if someone chose to accept an offer and then work hard, it's not slavery but free will. But well, I guess American culture is interesting in the regard. If I study STEM hard in school, I'll be a "teacher's pet" or a nerd who knows only "how to cram". On the other hand, if I free throw under a hoop 4000 times a day, I'm DA man and it's worth the highest praise on the level of "have you seen the LA of 4:00am". Or if I'm a banker or a startup employee who worked 100hr+, I'm building the future of the US, yet if I worked in a fab 996 on my own will, I'll be a slave?
- alecco 2y agoThe same people downvoting you are likely the same who think doing 996 on the startup lottery is a good idea.
- bfrog 2y agoImagine TSMC not getting US funds to bring over a Taiwanese workforce large enough to result in "Little Taiwan" being constructed in the desert.
- throwaway-blaze 2y agoThey'll be flown from the US to Taiwan for packaging, at least until packaging services exist here. Then they'll be flown to China, Southeast Asia, India, or possibly Brazil for final assembly into an iPhone or computer, at least until lower cost assembly plants are built here or someplace cheaper like Mexico.
- alecco 2y agoYour comment is correct but this was already stated in earlier comments. This is probably why you are being downvoted.
- misiti3780 2y agoHow hard will this be to scale to up 50% of Taiwan production into the US?
- bobmcnamara 2y agoHard, given how many Taiwanese workers they had to bring in, and how all the dies has to go back to Taiwan for packaging.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoI like the idea of made in America and bringing manufacturing self sufficiency to the US. But I don’t like the idea of reducing dependency on Taiwan, which makes it so that the world may ignore their plight in face of increasing aggression from China. The CCP is an authoritarian dictatorial government that seeks illegitimate control over Hong Kong, Taiwan, Tibet, Xinjiang, and other areas. They need to be stopped and the solution isn’t to remove incentives to defend those areas.
- genidoi 2y agoThere's a need to be pragmatic here; In the event of any kinetic Chinese aggression, TSMC (and other co's) fabs are going to be rendered inoperable, regardless of how well executed a US response is.
- kombine 2y agoThe world will will not be able to help with their plight, just as it was not with Ukraine and more recently Palestine. Might as well secure the supply chain.
- adamc 2y agoWe can do lots of things to help. But we need to get our military operational in that case.
- alecco 2y agoProtecting Taiwan would mean WWIII. I hope the West and the Taiwanese figure this out ASAP and start moving as many people as possible out of there, and destroy all the fabs. China is building more warships than the rest of the world combined. And NATO can't even recruit enough people to man their existing fleet. But it seems the West is a victim of its own propaganda so there's no political will.
- bighoki2885000 2y ago[dead]
- bighoki2885000 2y ago[dead]
- rglover 2y agoThis is really exciting. It'd be awesome if the rebirth of American industrialism was tech hardware driven. It sounds like this being mass production ready is still a few years off, but kudos to Apple and TSMC for working to make this happen.
- souenzzo 2y agoHalf of the works are from Taiwan All machines were imported to build the factory. USA can't do anythings without immigrants. China was able to develop its own chip factory without immigrants and without buying machines (because USA blocked the 'free market') USA lost.
- artistic_regard 2y ago[dead]
- notepad0x90 2y agoI keep hearing about a skills gap in the US for fabs, what skills or jobs are actually suffering from this? people with masters in nanotech, compeng, EE? Perhaps there is a skill gap because nobody actually knows there is a demand? I have no idea what to recommend to people who are trying to choose a college degree. With my industry in infosec, at least there are certifications one can take, even proper masters degrees these days. In my experience, there is no skills gap in cybersec, despite what CEO's and linkedin-types' sentiment. They just don't want to pay market price for skilled talent. "skills gap" has meant "we need more talent so we can pay less", there is no actual shortage of people who can do the jobs adequately. Is it different for chip fabrication? and if so, how can regular people work/study to obtain these skills? If I, having read HN for years and reading about the fab process have no clue, how can regular people who don't visit HN? If you all can help me answer this, I'll try to recruit a few people into pursuing the right career to help meet this demand.
- bighoki2885000 2y ago[dead]
- bighoki2885000 2y ago[dead]
- disapointed 2y agoI'm not interested what Apple says. What they do in FB is so many posts they posting what ever they like even posts of almost naked women and girls, looks like prostitution in FB. They are saying is their right to do that and their policy. It is disgusting thing in my point of view. Used to be postings of my friends now is totally disaster.
- Havoc 2y agoSurprised they're going to apple rather than say military purposes
- bighoki2885000 2y ago[dead]
- bighoki2885000 2y ago[dead]
- bighoki2885000 2y ago[dead]