23 ms·
New iMac with M4
- bradfitz 2y agoI still miss the 27" iMacs. They were such a great form factor.
- bearjaws 2y ago27" is really the best screen size for productivity. Easily can find 1440p or 4k 27" monitors to pair, and they have come down a lot in price.
- tshaddox 2y agoThe 5K screen was the killer feature of the 27” iMac.
- thibaut_barrere 2y agoSo far the screens I've tested are more tiring to my eyes (I work both on a M1 13" with external screens, and on a legacy 27" iMac). What are the best 27" screens for coding comfort that work well with Macs these days?
- Joeri 2y agoI haven’t tried it myself but if you really want that 5K 27 inch form factor samsung’s viewfinity s9 is exactly that. Or apple’s studio display ofcourse.
- porphyra 2y agoApart from the Samsung Viewfinity that another commenter mentioned, there's also the LG Ultrafine 5K and the Huawei Mateview. The MateView is nicer than other 4K monitors because it has a taller aspect ratio of 3840 x 2560 so the extra 400 pixels of vertical space is nice for productivity work, although of course this is still fewer total pixels than a 5K display.
- sroussey 2y agoLG Ultrafine 5K Has burn-in issues. :/
- jq-r 2y agoI bought mine like 2 years ago and it's been rock solid. IIRC they had some revisions over the years. And being rock solid: that's a bit of a lie because the monitor is wobbly as hell. So I've propped it with two supports on each side. Apart from that, the picture is the nicest I ever had from a monitor, and I had a lot of good ones. Text is super sharp and has acres of pixels. Compared to 4K monitor I can have both a terminal client and a browser side by side all looking nice. Can't fit that on 4K unfortunately.
- tkuraku 2y agoI think this 43" screen is amazing for coding. Lots of vertical and horizontal space! https://www.dell.com/en-us/shop/dell-ultrasharp-43-4k-usb-c-hub-monitor-u4323qe/apd/210-bfpo/monitors-monitor-accessories https://www.dell.com/en-us/shop/dell-ultrasharp-43-4k-usb-c-...
- porphyra 2y agoIf only it had higher pixel density. If there was a 43" 6K or even 8K screen I'd buy it in a heartbeat. But with only 4K I have to use all sorts of weird tricks with raster fonts to make the text in my terminals sharp. Also, too bad all the TV makers stopped making 8K screens in 55" and below.
- bloopernova 2y agoIt really is, 4K 27" monitors that can do >=120Hz are perfect for me personally. I just wish that the base macbook pro models supported 3 external screens without resorting to a software-based video-over-usb DisplaySync (not DisplayPort) connection.
- vehemenz 2y agoI tend to agree but more because the market has settled on it. One thing about screen size is that it's easier to achieve an effective screen size with a smaller screen (by moving it slightly forward) than it is to do the reverse. So a 24" screen will work in more environments, e.g., smaller desks, than a 27" will. A dual screen setup with two 24's will require less neck movement. Of course, the market has also decided that decent aspect ratios aren't worth doing either. If there were 3:2, 4:3, or 5:4 options—more versatile for productivity—we'd probably settle on something between 21" and 24".
- minimaxir 2y agoNow that my 27" iMac from 2020 is starting to get old and Apple will likely deprecate support for all Intel Macs soon, I really wish there was an easy way to use it as an external monitor for a MacBook. Every implementation of streaming to an iMac is hacky at best.
- pier25 2y agoYeah those 5K panels are fantastic. When I switched to a MBP M2 I got an Asus ProArt 32'' 4K and really like it. Comes precalibrated out of the box.
- da02 2y agoWere you able to see a difference between the 5k panel and the ProArt?
- pier25 2y agoNot in terms of colors but the 5K panel (I assume from LG) was more uniform in the blacks and suffered from almost no IPS glow. Not a big deal. The Asus is great for the price paid. Obviously big difference in DPI too, but 4K still looks great at 32''. For reference, I'm using the PA329CV. I don't know if all ProArt monitors use the same quality of panel.
- peppers-ghost 2y agoThere's not a super easy way to do it but if you're willing to take it apart there's driver boards available on Aliexpress that convert 5k imacs into HDMI/DP monitors.
- bsimpson 2y agoI looked into this briefly when they announced that the iMac Pro is the oldest device that still gets the newest software. It's logically two displays crammed together, which apparently makes Linux support difficult. Someone posted on HN a link to a Chinese company whose sole purpose seems to be making boards that let you drive an iMac Pro display with a traditional display cable. It's left as an exercise to the reader how mad your company would be if you tried that on your corp device.
- thibaut_barrere 2y agoTyping this from a 27" iMac. I do love my 13" M1, but I would love to upgrade the 27" too...
- fourfour3 2y agoI've got one of the LG Ultrafine 5K monitors paired with a modern M1 Max macbook and it's a nice combination. Expensive, but I adore the pixel density considering I spend all day staring at text :) I'd be seriously tempted by an iMac if it had M4 Pro + a 27" 5K display. I just don't feel it's likely as they'll probably see it as cannibalising Mac Studio + Studio Display sales.
- bsimpson 2y agoThe Studio Display is priced as if it's an iMac. It's insane that we've had retina displays for over a decade, and Apple still seems to be more-or-less the only game in town for a 5k 27" display.
- andrewmcwatters 2y agoI will never purchase the Studio Display on principle. It's an idiot product.
- thecopy 2y agoFor what its worth, I am extremely satisfied with my Studio Display. The 5K resolution makes 2x pixel perfect scaling look great, built in webcam which fantatic for meetings, good speakers, and charges the MacBook Pro with the same cable, and acts as an USB-C hub.
- fourfour3 2y agoIt's a similar niche to the LG Ultrafine before it. That also had a webcam, tolerable speakers, 85W PD over the thunderbolt 3 port, and 4 USB-C ports. If I didn't already have the LG Ultrafine, I would have bought one of the studio displays.
- msisk6 2y agoI have both; I got the LG when they first came out and the Studio display last year during a good sale on Amazon. The panels seem the same but everything on the Apple one is better, as you would expect. But lately my LG is starting to have issues with ghosting and color shifts around the edges. It's still ok to use (I'm typing this on it) but I guess it's nearing the end of it's useful life.
- alberth 2y agoApple would rather you buy a Studio Display. If a 27" iMac did exist, it makes the comparison to the Studio Display now a bit odd - because they'd both cost roughly the same price but one has a computer and one doesn't.
- minimaxir 2y ago16GB base RAM, they finally did it. They also did move the Magic Keyboard and Magic Mouse to USB-C.
- pbreit 2y agoSeems strange that iMacs remain ~20% more expensive than MacBooks.
- alpaca128 2y agoMacbooks don't have 24 inch screens with 4.5K resolution.
- wwalexander 2y ago> They also did move the Magic Keyboard and Magic Mouse to USB-C. Only for the bundled peripherals, it seems. The Apple Store now only lists the full-size Lightning keyboard without Touch ID in white, which is even worse than before when you could get various permutations of tenkeyless, Touch ID, and black.
- t-sauer 2y agoI guess it was still getting updated. All peripherals are available in USB-C versions for me now.
- baron816 2y agoNow if only they could figure out how to allow charging the Magic Mouse while it’s being used. I guess that technology is still years away.
- square_usual 2y agoThe people who like the magic mouse (not me) don't care, and the people who even otherwise would never use a magic mouse get to keep making fun of it. Why would they bother?
- amelius 2y agoLet me guess, all USB connectors are on the back side again? Great thinking, Apple.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bearjaws 2y ago> the new iMac is up to 1.7x faster than iMac with M1 Now 4 generations in, they are still comparing performance to M1. I get that 15-20% improvements aren't too exciting but it feels old.
- hobo_in_library 2y agoAnd even with that they're still only boasting of < 2.0x speedups...
- 39896880 2y ago>Now 4 generations in, they are still comparing performance to M1. I get that 15-20% improvements aren't too exciting but it feels old. FTA: "Compared to the most popular 24-inch all-in-one PC with the latest Intel Core 7 processor, the new iMac is up to 4.5x faster.1"
- sigh_again 2y agoFirst off, "up to" is the most bullshit metric. I am also up to 10x more productive when I get coffee, but that's when comparing to days where I just play Satisfactory all day long. Secondly, "compared to a random HP AIO PC with a 5 year old CPU" (since there are approximately zero chances that the most popular PC in a market that is heavily Apple dominated would be a 2023 Raptor Lake) is just, once again, Apple's piss poor comparisons.
- dialup_sounds 2y agoNah, it's a Core 7 150U, which is Raptor Lake. The trick is they used a GPU accelerated benchmark (Affinity) that highlights how trash the Intel GPU is.
- seec 2y agoYes that's because they don't price match. If they would, the Apple computer would still some better things about it but it wouldn't win a lot of benchmarks, if any...
- Mainsail 2y agoSide note, is there anyone that uses a Magic Mouse? It looks uncomfortable to use for an extended period of time and curious if that's true.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- user68858788 2y agoYup, for years. It feels exactly the same as a MacBook track pad and lets you use all the same gestures. I like it better than a mouse for my work machine.
- emadabdulrahim 2y agoBeen using it for 10 years. It's my favorite mouse to use. Scrolling and tap gesture is the main reason I prefer it. I also like touching glass/aluminum over plastic.
- minimaxir 2y agoThe bigger issue with the Magic Mouse is moving it. It has rails instead of PFT feet and it tends to tire my wrist out. When I got an iMac I paid the $50 extra for the Magic Trackpad and it was worth it.
- pier25 2y agoIt has its fans but lots of people find it uncomfortable. My biggest issue with it is that it's way too heavy. Once you go back to 50-60g mice you can't go back.
- helloplanets 2y agoI use one for 8+ hours a day. I keep reading about the design being uncomfortable, but definitely hasn't been the case for me. I guess if I actually kept my hand directly in line with the mouse it'd be pretty painful. I just about always keep my hand in a slant, more similar to how you'd use a trackpad, or as if you were holding a sort of slanted mouse. I've stuck with it because of the well implemented 2d scrolling. Using a physical scrolling wheel feels off at this point.
- alberth 2y agoI'm glad to see Nano-Texture coming to their budget line. That was definitely unexpected.
- lapcat 2y agoHopefully they'll add an option for the M4 MacBook Pro too. I've been waiting 15 years for Apple to reintroduce a matte display to the MacBook Pro.
- tosh 2y agoAccessories are updated to USB-C instead of Lightning
- tosh 2y agoNot sure if they are purchasable separately yet though.
- artimaeis 2y agoLooks like they don't have the color-matched options for individual purchase, but the b/w trackpad, keyboard, and at least 1 keyboard variant are available. https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MXK93AM/A https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MXK93AM/A https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MXK53AM/A https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MXK53AM/A https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MXK73LL/A https://www.apple.com/shop/product/MXK73LL/A
- _yb2s 2y agoI see lots of people in this thread mentioning this, but am confused. I've never seen a lighting port on an Apple computer- only on iphones and ipads, and the cables that come with those are USB-C on the other end. Haven't all Apple computer accessories been USB-C for almost a decade now?
- kgwgk 2y agoThe past: https://support.apple.com/en-us/102292 https://support.apple.com/en-us/102292 > Recharge the built-in battery in your Apple keyboard, mouse, or trackpad [...] To charge your device's battery, connect a Lightning to USB cable to its Lightning port, The future: https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2024/10/apple-introduces-new-imac-supercharged-by-m4-and-apple-intelligence/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2024/10/apple-introduces-new-... > Every iMac comes with a color-matched Magic Keyboard and Magic Mouse or optional Magic Trackpad, all of which now feature a USB-C port, so users can charge their favorite devices with a single cable.
- _yb2s 2y ago
- mmastrac 2y agoIf 32GB is the max, why not just make that the one and only model and get rid of this weird segmentation. That's a ridiculously low minimum and only just barely adequate. 8GB was practically criminal. Or -- and I know this is crazy -- slottable RAM on a device that is designed for things other than portability. Wild, I know.
- stu2b50 2y agoThe ram is on the package for more than portability. It’s necessary for fast enough transfer speeds for the iGPU.
- candiddevmike 2y ago> necessary for fast enough transfer speeds Source?
- stu2b50 2y agoWhen was the last time you saw a GPU with slottable memory? For transfer speeds, look at the data sheets for the M series. Much faster than DDR4 or DDR5 RAM. In the ballpark of GPU memory.
- Wytwwww 2y agoWould the people who were buying the baseline 8GB model (presumably just for general computing/office work) care about the GPU being slightly slower, though? I bet that the extreme lag when you run out of memory because you have an Electron app or two, several browser tabs and something like Excel is way more noticeable. Hardly anyone is using Macs for gaming these days and almost anybody who does something GPU intense would need more than 16GB anyway.
- KoolKat23 2y agohttps://www.apple.com/ie/newsroom/2020/11/apple-unleashes-m1/ https://www.apple.com/ie/newsroom/2020/11/apple-unleashes-m1...
- piinbinary 2y agoIt's frustrating how disposable these are designed to be edit: e.g. screen replacements cost nearly as much as the entire computer
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- aqme28 2y agoAre you expected to replace your screen often? I don't think I upgrade and replace either one much faster than the other. Usually get a new monitor and a new PC every 4 or so years.
- mullsork 2y ago> Usually get a new monitor and a new PC every 4 or so years. Maybe you're not quite the average consumer that OP has in mind? Maybe you are, I don't know. Either way it's unsustainable and ridiculous that the _average consumer_ would need to replace something after 4 years when it COULD be built to last.
- Daz1 2y agoThey are built to last. I'm typing this comment on a 2015 MacBook Pro.
- hatsix 2y agoMy first LCD monitor is still actively used in our house, about 18 years old now. My mother has gone through several computers, kept the same screen for 15 years. Apple Consumers are not "Average Consumers". Starting at $1300, it's a luxury desktop.
- acdha 2y agoThat’s a mid-range desktop at most in a world where people pay more than that for individual components at the high-end, especially when you look at pricing for equivalent quality displays. The correct criticism of iMacs is that it links two parts with different lifespans. There should be a legal requirement that all-in-one computers have an external connector so that if some other component fails or simply becomes obsolete you can use the perfectly functional display with another system.
- phs2501 2y agoWhy does this still have the ridiculous iMac chin? Surely they can fit everything behind the screen at this point.
- fckgw 2y agoThey literally can't. They moved the headphone jack from the back to the side because it was too long. Now you could argue if it needs to be that thin but for the current configuration, there's nothing you can cram behind the screen.
- phs2501 2y agoFor something that's literally designed to sit on a desk, yes... it's ridiculous to make it thinner in a dimension you never see vs one that you see all the time.
- aabhay 2y agoAesthetics is also for the environment of the object rather than the primary user. That’s the reason the logo is on the back
- stu2b50 2y agoMany of these are customer service desks which are visible from the side.
- hengheng 2y agoiMac has always been a device to be seen with, if not for the user then for the manufacturer.
- ahmeneeroe-v2 2y agoOne more vote for aesthetics here. I put a lot of effort into making my home beautiful. iMacs respect/complement that effort for me.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- speedgoose 2y agoDo you think there is a chance that they will remove the huge bottom bezel one day? It may be part of the iMac design identity at this point, but I don’t like it since its appearance on the iMac G5.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- gatkinso 2y agoInteresting to roll out the M4 with the low end machine
- mjamesaustin 2y agoThey will be unveiling more M4 devices every day this week. Probably started with the least remarkable to build intensity.
- jshier 2y agoM4 already rolled out with the iPad Pro update in the spring.
- rsynnott 2y agoThey tend to do that; the M1 took some time to get from the Mini and Air to the other machines. _Years_ for the Pro.
- emadabdulrahim 2y agoCurious who uses iMac over a MBP with an external monitor? Is it mainly for front desk, businesses, and perhaps people with large homes and need stationary mac?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- PokestarFan 2y agoGreat "Family Computer"
- hoistbypetard 2y agoIt might also be a good choice for those who always work at one desk, have established a work/life balance such that they don't need a portable computer, and would prefer not to pay extra to have portability that they just don't require. An M4 iMac with 10 CPU cores, 10 GPU cores, 16GB RAM and 1TB SSD costs $1700. A 14" MBP with 8 CPU cores, 10 GPU cores, 16GB RAM and 1TB SSD costs $2000. Before you add a 27" monitor and desktop keyboard/pointing device. Why pay that premium if you don't actually need to carry your desktop PC around?
- munificent 2y agoI'm a typical software engineer nerd who uses a MacBook Pro for work. My last two home computers have been 27" iMacs. Each one has lasted me about 8 years and I've been happy with both of them. Nice big display, good specs, not a lot of clutter. Really good bang for the buck. At home, I use them for making music (Ableton Live), video production (DaVinci Resolve), photo processing (Photoshop and Lightroom), and programming (various IDEs and editors). I much prefer one good display over a pair of them. Long-term, maybe it would be more cost effective to get a Mac Mini so that I don't end up paying to replace the display when I replace the machine. But display technology seems to advance about as fast as other hardware specs do, so I suspect I'd want a new monitor at about that rate anyway. Going forward, though, I probably won't buy another iMac. That's largely because now that I make music with Ableton Live, I want a laptop that I can (aspirationally!) take to shows to play live on. But for well over a decade, I've been a happy iMac user. I don't care about upgradeability. I buy a machine that has the specs I want when I buy it.
- Eric_WVGG 2y ago> The iMac also features a new 12MP Center Stage camera with Desk View (from the marketing page) wait so this thing has the universally reviled Studio Display camera??
- amelius 2y agoQuestion. Is this "Apple Intelligence" phoning home all the time?
- fsflover 2y agoIt's worse: Any file you open results in phoning home, Intelligence or not, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25074959 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25074959
- dilap 2y agoI believe just executable files, right? (Still terrible of course.)
- acdha 2y agoThat’s overstating what happened there and what was sent. OCSP validation happened only for signed executables and the only bit of information is the hash of the developer certificate being verified, which was not logged in conjunction with your IP. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2020/11/mac-certificate-check-stokes-fears-apple-logs-every-app-you-run/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2020/11/mac-certificate-chec... Typically when there are concerns about phoning home it’s both more detailed information and something being traceable back to an individual.
- fsflover 2y agoThere are a lot of good explanations in my link why the current setup is outrageous, including the danger of deanonymization of Tor users by Apple.
- stevenAthompson 2y agoDo they sell matching monitors to go with these all in one style iMac's? I'm not really an Apple person, but I can't imagine having a single monitor in this day and age and any other color would look silly next to a weird pastel pink device.
- presbyterian 2y agoI don't use an iMac, but I do use a single display with a similar resolution, and I personally much prefer it to a multi-monitor setup
- nxobject 2y agoI agree... on the proviso that I can never afford 3 monitors, and I've never quite found 2-monitor setups comfortable because even with the very small bezels today I'm constantly shifting and turning away from the centre.
- stu2b50 2y agoNo. If you’re that kind of power user, the iMac isn’t for you. Get a Mac mini or studio.
- askafriend 2y agoA lot of people in this thread commenting without making an attempt to understand who this is for.
- stevenAthompson 2y ago> A lot of people in this thread commenting without making an attempt to understand who this is for. Why do you seem defensive? I asked a reasonable question of a group of people I thought might have product knowledge I lacked. I am not a Very Pink Apple Product SME, and stated as much in my question.
- 2y ago
- jfoster 2y agoI could never justify getting an iMac. All the downsides of a laptop & desktop in one; not upgradeable and not portable. Leaves me wondering how many of these Apple actually sell. A Mac Mini with a separate screen feels like it makes far more sense.
- fire_lake 2y agoVery low desk clutter though. Power cable, maybe a mouse. Nothing else.
- graeme 2y agoThe iMacs very much aren't their main seller. A couple of key demographics use it though: * Families with a shared computer in a common room. Super simple to setup, no fiddling, low price. In the video Apple showcased this use case. My parents have an M3 imac and it works great. They had their last iMac for ten years. * Businesses buy these for reception areas and customers see the Apple logo on the back. Easy solution for a business with no IT department, great marketing for Apple. Apple will probably always sell an iMac option as long as businesses buy and display them.
- 39896880 2y agoEducation as well. Main reason why that headphone jack has stuck around I suspect.
- graypegg 2y ago+1 for the business front desk. This is by far where I see them the most. They're very easy to deploy, and most of the software you're going to need it to be running works in a browser. A windows all-in-one PC is another option... but the chance of something going wrong/being annoying in the interim between "plunk it on the desk" and "open salesforce in chrome" is definitely higher.
- aphantastic 2y agoMy parents have had an iMac in their living room sitting quietly doing stuff (web apps, mainly) for 9 years now. Still works fine for all their use cases and the 5k screen remains a delight to behold.
- xyst 2y agoAn arbitrary limit of 32G of memory? Laughable. Glad I exited the Apple ecosystem long ago. Only have 2-3 year old machines now. Current phone is “free” from carrier due to trade ins. I think Apple should shift away from personal computing (iMac, MBP/A, iPhone) and focus on selling their SoC. Get these into data centers. Powering a data center with their chips would likely result in significant decrease in power consumption. I am running an “old” M1 as a small remote k8s cluster for personal dev work and home automation. Works wonderfully. Power consumption during peak load (20 W?) is very low compared to my Intel based computer (120-150W?) I use for occasional gaming.
- samatman 2y ago> I think Apple should shift away from personal computing (iMac, MBP/A, iPhone) This is going to be the most insane thing I read all day. > Get [their SoC] into data centers. This is a great idea. Apple discontinued servers a long time ago, and it's too bad, now that they've got the new silicon they could be crushing it in the sector.
- shrubble 2y agoApple has very little understanding of Enterprise and Datacenter markets. They proved that with the Xserve, despite having some success - they should have "owned" the market by driving down the costs of running, managing and maintaining hardware over the long term - but didn't, or got bored about it, and missed the opportunity.
- jauntywundrkind 2y agoForm factor isn't updated afaik, but man, I am just so so impressed with the form factor. It looks like a giant tablet. Makes me want to hold it and draw on it.
- vondur 2y agoHow about a bigger model? 24” is kinda small.
- DeathArrow 2y agoApple makes some dubious claims: > Gamers can enjoy incredibly smooth gameplay, with up to 2x higher frame rates5 than on iMac with M1. What games do run on the Mac? Certainly, most AAA titles do not. >Compared to the most popular 24-inch all-in-one PC with the latest Intel Core 7 processor, the new iMac is up to 4.5x faster. You can build PCs there are more powerful than that Mac, cheaper. And you can easily repair them.
- theflyinghorse 2y agoA few games do work on mac. Factorio, Baldur's Gate 3 etc
- vundercind 2y ago> You can build PCs there are more powerful than that Mac, cheaper. And you can easily repair them. Nobody’s buying a Mac to game. The gaming is a bonus for a segment of their market, is why they mention it at all. Zero Mac sales are motivated primarily by gaming. “Does this do enough gaming, well enough, that I can avoid buying a Steamdeck, or that I can get rid of this bulky PC that I use only for gaming?” are things their prospective buyers might wonder, not “should I buy this if I want a gaming computer?” (No, obviously)
- nox101 2y agoYes except so few games run. Even games I suspect don't need the power. Examples: Cocoon, ufo50, Outer wilds, Harold Halibut, Noita > “Does this do enough gaming, well enough, that I can avoid buying a Steamdeck, or that I can get rid of this bulky PC that I use only for gaming?” I think the answer is "No". I'm writing this from a Mac. In the last year, so many games I've wanted to play while traveling, someone tells me about it, I go check it out, no mac version. I just have to wait until I get home. Sometimes I get lucky, "A Short Hike", but more often than not there's no Mac version.
- vundercind 2y agoIf you want to play almost any possible game, yeah, you need a PC. (I have one. And a Steam Deck. I kinda half-regret taking up gaming as a hobby any time I touch either of those, but not quite enough to ditch them) If you’re flexible on what you play, it might be fine for gaming. Like someone with a Switch might be like “eh, sure I’d like to play the new Assassins Creed, but not enough to get a PlayStation—my kids want the Switch, and I don’t want two consoles, so I’ll just find stuff to play on here instead.” I think that’s the market-segment they’re talking to when they write ad or marketing copy about Mac gaming capabilities.
- ttul 2y agoNote: The 24” iMac is never going to be the platform of choice for HackerNews readers.
- declan_roberts 2y agoI recommend these to friends who want a simple computer setup. Many people have dramatically different needs and wants than I do as a software professional. Apple knows this, and so it markets it to them rather than to us.
- mixmastamyk 2y agoWith an M4 and 16gb+ ram it is more computer than anything I’ve ever owned. I write text files for a living. Might be able to limp along on a souped up 486, definitely a Pentium 90.
- mrweasel 2y agoI could do my work on one, but yeah, the screen size would be annoying long term. The sad part is that it's the exact form factor my dad wants. It's absolutely perfect for his needs, except it's wildly overpowered and overpriced. The 4K monitor is going to push up the price, and I'm all for giving everyone a high quality monitor, but I'd argue that the iMac is 30-40% over budget for those who'd like that type of computer. I think you could get away with having it be a $1000 computer, but not $1600, for the lowest spec'ed model.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- delfinom 2y agoMmm, in an era where monitors no longer need large bezels, apple sure decided to keep the neck fat on the iMac which to me makes it quite ugly.
- wffurr 2y agoWhat's with the green iMac picture? https://www.apple.com/newsroom/images/2024/10/apple-introduces-new-imac-supercharged-by-m4/article/Apple-iMac-M4-green-iMac_big.jpg.large.jpg https://www.apple.com/newsroom/images/2024/10/apple-introduc... It only shows two USB-C ports while further down the marketing material talks about "all four USB-C ports". EDIT: the low-end 8-core model for $1300 only has two ports. It also has what looks like a rear-facing camera in the stand cutout. What is that for? EDIT: It's the magnetic power connector. I did not expect that to be round. Supposedly there's a gigabit Ethernet port somewhere too. Not shown in any of the pictures on the site that I can find.
- goosedragons 2y agoThe base model iMac only has two Thunderbolt ports.
- traceroute66 2y ago> The base model iMac only has two Thunderbolt ports. Indeed, per specs [1] [1] https://www.apple.com/imac/specs/ https://www.apple.com/imac/specs/
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- traceroute66 2y ago> What's with the green iMac picture? The picture is of the base model. The upper model is featured on their main website[1], which shows this image [2] [1] https://www.apple.com/imac/ https://www.apple.com/imac/ [2] https://www.apple.com/v/imac/q/images/overview/closer-look/colors_pb_green__b6yo4td9rgxe_xlarge_2x.jpg https://www.apple.com/v/imac/q/images/overview/closer-look/c...
- fourfour3 2y agoThe gigabit ethernet port is in the power brick.
- 2y ago
- simonw 2y agoAs someone who mucks around with running LLMs and other large models on my computer the 32GB maximum RAM is a show-stopper for me. I'm on a M2 with 64GB at the moment and I'm already regretting not going for 96 or even 128. I want to be able to run a large model AND other apps at the same time.
- flemhans 2y agoWhen I first scanned your sentence I assumed you were gonna write that 32 GB is now the minimum, not the maximum.
- lynguist 2y agoBut that means the next Air will be upgrade worthy for those who want an Air and a memory uplift from 24 max to 32 max!
- klodolph 2y agoSure, but to be honest, I don’t think you should be shipping a high-spec computer with a built-in screen. Anything high-spec should be broken into at least a separate screen and computer. The screen is such a major point of failure. I’ve seen so many iMacs and MacBooks with broken screens where the end solution is to replace the entire device, which is a waste. It’s that much more of a waste if you are getting a high-spec version.
- simonw 2y agoYeah, that's my biggest complaint with iMacs: I want to be 100% certain I can repurpose them as monitors later in their lives. I have a ten year old iMac at the moment that would make an amazing second monitor... but it doesn't quite have the features I need to use it like that. An HDMI input would be great.
- lisper 2y ago> An HDMI input would be great. There is a reason that is difficult to do: the licensing terms for HDMI require manufacturers to put DRM in place to make it impossible (or at least not straightforward) to record from an HDMI source. It's nearly impossible to meet that requirement on a computer.
- yumashka 2y agoWill it blend?
- YegoBear 2y agoThey're just never gonna make a 32" one, huh?
- jeffbee 2y agoIt sucks that the TB4 ports still point out the back of the machine like that. It has never made sense! Every Thunderbolt cable has a bulky active electronic assembly that is at least a few centimeters long, followed by a cable strain relief. I hate having my cables hanging out like that. It seems like it would be possible to build a little port hutch on the back, with the ports pointing straight down.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- skybrian 2y agoI have a more than a decade-old iMac with a 27” display that I’m stil using as a monitor (though it’s seen better days), so that worked out well, but a Mac mini and an external monitor seems better in every way. Which monitor to get, though? Maybe Apple should sell a Mac mini bundled with a nice external monitor instead of iMacs.
- jprd 2y agoI love the innovation Apple has brought with their investment in ARM. That said, I can't imagine buying a computer in the 21st century that can't be opened and upgraded, especially with a price premium attached. I just don't get it. I am in no way trying to be combative, but I'd love to hear a counterpoint that makes sense for these machines.
- cududa 2y agoMost people don’t want to open up their computer. Ever. And for most people who dont want to open their computer, they’ll probably use these iMacs until their ancient, and replacing the whole thing makes more sense anyway
- 2arrs2ells 2y agoI bought an M2 iMac for my parents. It’ll last at least five years for them - likely closer to 10. At that point, I’m happy to recycle or donate it and get them a new iMac - likely with some major updates (form factor? Display? Etc?) that wouldn’t get with a RAM / CPU upgrade. Spending ~$150-$300/year for them to have an easy to use & fast computer feels very worth it for me. All that said - I would love for the machine to be upgradeable as well! Just explaining why it’s not a dealbreaker.
- sleepybrett 2y agoSame, I had to panic buy a 13" m1, i was remote working extra remotely and my laptop got destroyed. The 13" m1 was not an ideal machine, it had limited usb ports, limited ram.. but it was pretty quick and I wasn't going to buy intel. A few years later the m2pro/max's came out (i think technically in 14"). I picked one up and just handed my m1 down to family. Huge upgrade over their old intel air that had already lasted them like 10 years. My main bitch is the soldered in storage. It's a shitty optimization that has to punish apple as much as it punishes users. To have a machine that I can't just go buy a harddrive and slot in when i want more storage or when the drive fails is a total fucking nightmare.
- askafriend 2y agoI replace my computers before I ever feel a need to upgrade them. Computers are fast and performant for a long time now (4+ years, especially for non-professional use). And as someone who works with computers all day long, I never ever want to open one up unless I build one from scratch and want a personal project.
- bhouston 2y agoI guess it is just me, but I cannot stand working on small screens on the desktop. I will accept a small screen on a laptop because it is inconvenient carrying around something larger, but on a desktop, there is no reason to compromise. I use a 48" OLED with my MacBook Air M3 and for me that is a near ultimate web development experience both on desktop and when travelling: https://bsky.app/profile/benhouston3d.bsky.social/post/3l7linb6nzi2j https://bsky.app/profile/benhouston3d.bsky.social/post/3l7li...
- madeofpalk 2y agoWhat's the actual resolution of this? The idea of using something with such low pixel density seems really painful to me.
- bhouston 2y agoIt is 4K. I wish it was higher. But practically, I cannot find an affordable 6K OLED monitor. And 8K is both unaffordable as well as not supported by my MacBook Air: https://support.apple.com/en-ca/guide/macbook-air/apd8cdd74f57/mac#:~:text=Your%20MacBook%20Air%20can%20support%20one%20external%20display%20with%20up,4K%20resolution%20at%20144%20Hz https://support.apple.com/en-ca/guide/macbook-air/apd8cdd74f.... I do set my MacBook resolution to maximum and it works well.
- madeofpalk 2y agoSo you value just the physical size of things, not being able to display more 'stuff'? For example, a 27" 5k (5120 x 2880) display will give you more space/resolution for stuff than a 4k 48" display. I can't imagine how pleasent that would be, the display being so physically large with pixels the side of boulders. As long as it works for you, I guess! I'm with you in spirit though - I ditched dual monitors for an ultrawide and its now the only way I can work.
- bhouston 2y agoI do wish it was higher resolution for sure, but that isn't feasible this year. I would have to squint at a 27" 5K monitor to read the fonts if I put this much on screen at once.
- VyseofArcadia 2y agoI love in Apple product announcements when they show people doing tasks that not only don't require recent hardware, but in fact could have been done without much trouble 20 or 30 years ago. Specifically talking about the ice cream spreadsheet that I suppose was there to show off how small businesses can use the new iMac. I'm sure it's a fine machine, but it does to me highlight the upgrade treadmill.
- steve_adams_86 2y agoNo way, we need local LLMS to help us populate the spreadsheet!
- tylerrobinson 2y ago> iMac with M4 features the world’s fastest CPU core, making multitasking across apps like Safari and Excel lightning fast. This stuck out for me too, plus the examples of using Siri on the desktop. I reckon that invoking Siri to say, "Send Gema a text" and then having to proofread and approve the message is more effort than just sending Gema a text. Same for typing out "turn on do not disturb". You could imagine the argument being that there are a lot of deep settings or hidden controls that people would like to find, but then wouldn't a vector search that shows relevant settings be just about the same outcome?
- lotsofpulp 2y agoSiri is hot garbage, but having apps open and close near instantaneously is a productivity boost. Which was also helped by SSD, but I would say the next material change since SSD I have experienced is M processors. Amortize the time and “focus” savings over years of using the machine, and even a couple thousand extra dollars is worth it.
- Etheryte 2y agoYou can also talk to Siri, you don't need to type any of it. I know their demo shows typing, but that's an easier visualization since you don't really want the webpage to be playing video with sound out of the blue. In this case I think it is simply a trade off of making the presentation more clear for the audience.
- matt3210 2y agoHow much of the price is the AI tax
- dlevine 2y agoI'm surprised they are still shipping these with 256GB of storage base. I had a Macbook with a ~500GB SSD in 2012 (I installed it), and a 500GB spinning disk in like 2008 (also user installed). A 500GB SSD can be had for <$50 these days, and a 1TB for <$100. Still plenty of profit for Apple, even if they bump up the base storage to 512GB and make 1TB a $200 upgrade...
- slashdave 2y agoThese are not ordinary SSDs, which (via SATA) are dirt slow in comparison.
- wmf 2y agoOrdinary SSDs have been NVMe for years and have similar performance to Apple NVMe SSDs.
- brailsafe 2y agoIt depends what the person meant by ordinary, but if ordinary just generally refers to "off-the-shelf" or commodity SSDs, then we've been able to get equivalent or better performing NVMe SSDs for a long time, for a small fraction of the price. Within what you can get retail, I think you'd still want the higher end of it for comparable speeds and yields, but would still save A LOT doing so.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- anvuong 2y agoWhat year are you currently living in? A good 2TB Gen5 NVMe with W/R speed upto 7,000MB/s can be had for less than $200 during sales that happen multiple times a year. Go down 1 tier lower to 4,000-5,000MB/s and you can have one for just $120. Nobody puts SATA in premium laptops, hasn't been the case for quite the few years, you got brainwashed good by Apple.
- fennecbutt 2y ago
- WillPostForFood 2y agoRight now, the Apple computer lineup is totally out of alignment for me. The iMac is too small and the laptops are too big. I'd like a minimum 27" display for the iMac, maybe 31". For a laptop, give me something more portable, like the old 2 pound, 12" MacBook.
- el_benhameen 2y agoI love the idea and form of an ultraportable laptop, but I’ve had to face the reality that even a 13” monitor is just too small for me to be productive on complex development tasks. My eyesight isn’t good enough to handle tiny fonts, which could be part of the disconnect. What kind of work are you able to get done on a 12” screen?
- euroderf 2y agoAFAICT the 11" Mac Air failed in the market. It did not last long in the lineup.
- t3rabytes 2y agoIt was available for 6 years (2011-2017), that's hardly a failure relative to other Apple products that have only made it through 2 cycles (the most recently iPhone Mini sub-family that lasted 2 years).
- euroderf 2y agoOK, my bad.
- hartator 2y agoMacBook 12" was super sweet though. I bought 2 for professional engineering work. They were my main computers despite Intel CPUs being absyammal in term of performance.
- space_oddity 2y agoIt would be fantastic if Apple brought back that 27-inch or larger iMac for desktop users who don’t need a separate display
- aag 2y agoIt looks beautiful, but it's such a waste to bind the monitor to the computer this way. Monitors outlast many computers.
- thefz 2y ago> The M4 chip brings a boost in performance to iMac. Featuring a more capable CPU with the world’s fastest CPU core,(4) Then, deeper in the footnotes where no one ever reads > (4) Testing was conducted by Apple in October 2024 using shipping competitive systems and select industry-standard benchmarks. This is why I could never take this company seriously. Oh, and 1499€ for a computer with 256GB of storage. That you can't upgrade.
- pazimzadeh 2y ago2.1x faster than M1, but they tested an M4 with 32 Gb vs. an M1 with 16Gb. Sad to see this kind of comparison. I guess in "performance-per-"dollar it still stands since they just doubled the baseline RAM levels.
- yieldcrv 2y ago32gb RAM max? I don't understand, macbooks on battery power have 128gb, why this limitation on an always powered device
- nknealk 2y agoI believe it’s a limitation of the memory controller on the M4 chip. It can only address 32 gb of ram. Addressing more ram would require more die space
- yieldcrv 2y agoI hope not. This is a parallel product line instead of a successor then. Not what anyone was anticipating or looking forward to.
- wtallis 2y agoApple's on their fourth generation of in-house processors for Macs. By now, the pattern is quite clear: They have several tiers of processor. Not all products offer all tiers of chip. The iMac and MacBook Air have never been offered with anything other than the base M-whatever chip, and the Mac Studio has only been offered with the Max and Ultra processors.
- seshagiric 2y agoIt's almost becoming a bother of how accurate the rumors are becoming now a days. With this release they were spot on with the 16gb min ram and no change in screen size. I am not building LLMs on my computer (I wish :)) but I do use my iMac for both work and photography. Lightroom slugs big time on my 2019 iMac. My dream spec for the next iMac would be: - bring back the 27" form factor - dumb down use as monitor. My work computer has disabled file & screen sharing so current methods dont work. I just want to plug my work macbook using a cable or wireless and use the imac as a display.
- jjcm 2y agoSince this thread seems to be about niche asks for pro users, despite the product being targeted towards casual users who want an easy out of the box experience, I'll add my own to the mix. I'd love a bigger/better screen on these, specifically an ultrawide variety. An iMac Pro with an 8k ultrawide would be a near-instant purchase for me. I find the ultrawide form factor so good for productivity. I love the apple "it just works" approach to their hardware, so if something was fully integrated I'd jump on it immediately. Today I use a 49" CRG9, but the input and connection setup is somewhat finicky. Not a huge blocker, but it would be lovely to be able to simplify.
- giobox 2y agoI also use and love the exact same 49" CRG9, but if you do the 2x retina math, to deliver the pixel pitch Apple customers expect on desktop in the 32:9 display form, that would realistically have to be a 10240x2880 display at a minimum of 60fps. Not sure if there are bandwidth considerations over displayport or similar as this is essentially two 5k Studio Displays (5120x2880) side by side at that point. I love my CRG9 with MacOS, but there's no escaping the text rendering is significantly poorer than on Apple's own 2x retina stuff.
- blairbeckwith 2y agoTB4 should be able to handle that resolution – I am running 2x Studio Displays + gigabit ethernet + countless USD devices in to one TB4 port on my MacBook via a TB4 dock.
- peterldowns 2y agoWhich dock are you using? Looking to get one + a large display, and share both between my windows desktop and mac laptop.
- blairbeckwith 2y agoI am using the CalDigit TS4+. Expensive, but flawless.
- jxdxbx 2y agoI’ve been using an M1 iMac as my main home computer (with 16 GB RAM, 1 TB SSD) and have zero reason to upgrade. I’ve loved it. Exactly what I need, though I offload a lot of home server type tasks to a big tower PC, including messing with local AI stuff. BUT a new hockey puck Mac mini that shared a screen with my gaming PC would be a nice space-saver. If only the studio display could switch inputs—using macOS on a curved gaming monitor seems weird.
- phillco 2y agoThere are Thunderbolt 4 KVMs now (can't speak to any myself, but they exist!). DSC will give you quite a bit of spare bandwidth with the Studio Display.
- deadfa11 2y agoI've been using the Sabrent one for a year or so. It's worked quite reliably once I got the cables sorted. I was unintentionally using one TB3 cable in the mix, and that made it pretty flakey. It has been pretty solid since swapping that for a TB4 cable.
- yunohn 2y ago> the new iMac is up to 1.7x faster than iMac with M1 This seems like a much lower than expected speed bump for M1 to M4? Would’ve been nice to see something more for something designed to be non-upgradeable.
- thedangler 2y agoI'm waiting to replace my 2015 MBP with an M4 MBP. I bought the m2 Studio Max and love it. But I need a mobile computer. Working only at my desk sucks sometimes.
- School-Cotton 2y agoWhy wait? The M3 MBP is basically perfect.
- RomanPushkin 2y ago> iMac features a color-matched keyboard and mouse or trackpad... These accessories now come with USB-C ports, so users can charge all of their favorite devices with just a single cable WOW!
- mmaunder 2y agoOh thank god. Not a day goes by when I'm not thanking the powers that be in Europe for pressuring Apple to add USB-C to iphone.
- rootusrootus 2y agoPeople say this as if Apple hadn't already been adding USB-C to their iOS devices for several years. There were pretty good reasons for holding off USB-C for the iPhone. It was likely to alienate a good number of customers. I doubt Europe had anything to do with the timing.
- jmspring 2y ago"good reasons"? What would be those?
- colejohnson66 2y agoI've seen countless people upset that Apple is now "forcing" them to throw away their perfectly good cables again (to replace with USB-C).
- brendoelfrendo 2y agoPeople have crazy long memories to consider this as happening "again," seeing as the lightning connector has been around for 12 years. Who are the folks that only have one device, anyway? Surely almost everyone who owns a smartphone has at least one USB-C cable kicking around for something else?
- 2y ago
- SurgeArrest 2y agoReading this on 2017 iMac 27" - is the first 5k iMac that couldn't be used as a monitor after the computer inside is irrelevant. I hope EU will push for some law that requires all AIO computers to work in monitor-only mode if internal hardware is no longer good enough or no longer supported by software updates. I love the 5k screen on this iMac but the CPU is too old for photo or video editing as software got so much slower over the years. I could have used this screen for many more years, but now it will hit landfill... Apple is only "green" in their presentations - in reality they care more about inifite sales only.
- mikeatlas 2y agothey offer free recycling of old hardware https://www.apple.com/shop/open/free_recycling https://www.apple.com/shop/open/free_recycling when you buy new hw see also https://www.apple.com/me/recycling/ https://www.apple.com/me/recycling/
- mihaaly 2y agoI hope they also plant one or two small trees somewhere! And promote the use of refillable water botles on campus!!
- gljiva 2y agoI hope more companies start recycling their own products. It makes me sad to see so much valuable electronics, so many "totalled" cars just thrown away on the same heap as other rubbish (and old cars respectively). Such a waste of resources is surpassed only by war.
- rvense 2y agoRecycling electronics basically means crushing them and extracting some of the minerals inside. A lot of them can't really be recovered, and of course all the electricity that was used to create it is still gone and the water used is still tainted. If you make electronics you should be forced to do everything humanly possible to extend its useful life.
- LASR 2y agoI've been looking for an upgrade from my 2015 5k iMac 27. Might finally pull the trigger on this version. What I will miss is the 27 inch 5k display. Also, my use case is exactly what this iMac is meant for - shared family computer that takes up little space in the kitchen.
- thescriptkiddie 2y agostill no 27" display :(
- notinmykernel 2y agoIt'd be awesome if Apple could make skins for the iMac. That way it wouldn't look as dated in 3-5 yrs.
- abhayhegde 2y agoThe displays on these iMacs are so crisp, but disappointing that 24" only. Happy that the base RAM is increased, perhaps trying to pander to AI audience. But, who buys these at costs almost at Macbook Pros? Isn't this just a monitor?
- smcleod 2y agoOnly a maximum of 32GB shared RAM?! Surely that must be the minimum now?
- PeterCorless 2y agoI was really hoping they'd have announced a MacBook Pro based on M4. I had been waiting all year for it. https://www.macrumors.com/2024/03/11/apple-reportedly-developing-m4-macbook-pro/ https://www.macrumors.com/2024/03/11/apple-reportedly-develo... However, reading Nanoreview it looks like the performance of the M3 Max still actually beats the M4 for graphics and multicore performance. https://nanoreview.net/en/cpu-compare/apple-m4-vs-apple-m3-max https://nanoreview.net/en/cpu-compare/apple-m4-vs-apple-m3-m...
- 1123581321 2y agoThey are supposedly launching Macs all week, so you will probably get your M4 Pro and Max MBPs. M4 Max vs. M3 Max will be the apples-to-apples comparison to make.
- PeterCorless 2y agoAnd lo an behold! https://www.apple.com/macbook-pro/?afid=p238%7CstiyKw4MH-dc_mtid_20925top39173_pcrid_719341460098_pgrid_150351495530_pexid__ptid_kwd-1679665025_&cid=wwa-us-kwgo-mac-slid---NonCore-MacBookPro-Announce- https://www.apple.com/macbook-pro/?afid=p238%7CstiyKw4MH-dc_...
- madjam002 2y agoThat link you posted is comparing the M3 Max with the base M4, it has more CPU and GPU cores
- perching_aix 2y agoTheir commitment to absolutely god awful designs really makes it exceptionally easy for me to avoid buying any of their products, with iMacs being chief among them. It's baffling to me people tolerate (or even like!) those massive disgusting chins for example. Sure is a big world out there.
- exabrial 2y ago> M4, iMac is up to 1.7x faster for daily productivity, and up to 2.1x faster for demanding workflows like photo editing and gaming, compared to iMac with M1 Huh? how about than an M3?
- downrightmike 2y agoDon't care about anything other than Mac Mini
- Koshkin 2y agoI don't need another computer, but, hell, I want one of these...
- tintor 2y agoWhy are they not releasing it in 27" size that they had before?
- brundolf 2y agoI've not sure I've ever had so much product lust for something I had so little use for as the Apple Silicon iMacs. Gorgeous objects, but I've already got a MacBook Pro and a bigger monitor
- moatmoat 2y agoApple giving us 16GB base RAM in the iMac is like finally getting a decent cup of coffee after years of instant
- jasonventresca 2y agoIntegrating an LLM capabilities directly into the OS is pretty slick. I know it's just one less step than copy/pasting something into a ChatGPT tab in your browser, but that seamless experience makes it that much more accessible and lower friction. I'm excited to see where Apple Intelligence goes; though I do wonder if Apple choosing to partner with OpenAI will eventually put them in the backseat when other models like those from Anthropic surpass OpenAI's capabilities.
- Aaron2222 2y agoI recall reading that OpenAI was just the initial partner, and that they plan to offer other LLM integrations as well. Don't quote me on that though.
- aspenmayer 2y agoI think they already have a setting for choosing your AI provider on beta versions of iOS 18, so they’re looking forward to avoid lock-in.
- danso 2y agoI've held off replacing my MBP for about 5 years. In the meantime I built my own PC with an Nvidia card, but I have to admit it's been such a nuisance to get CUDA set up (I started doing it when WSL documentation wasn't quite fully baked) that I'm nostalgic for the days of doing `brew install everything`. The state of AI and other development in macOS seems like it's been pretty popular and solid for the past few years? Worth jumping in when the M4 laptops are announced, or better to get a deep discount on the M3s?
- AzzyHN 2y agoDeep discount on the M3, imo. That $500 ($1500 on sale vs $2000 new) is better spent on more RAM, or non-Apple products. If you're using an Intel-based Mac, it really is a huge jump. Intel Macs are basically just really poorly cooled laptops, making them worse, performance-wise
- fennecbutt 2y agoAn M chip will still not compare at all to any decent discrete GPU when it comes to AI stuff. Unless you're going cloud like runpod or something. Truth to be told what I'm likely going to continue to do is laptop as thin client and desktop with beefy gpu as workhorse, that's worked pretty well so far.
- thordenmark 2y agoGot the Mac Studio when it came out and while its speed was impressive at first, ultimately I've been disappointed, too many technical glitches and issues with peripherals and the like, and my several iMacs before it are all junk now. I'm done with Apple desktops. So I'll be passing on this iMac. They're laptops are still premium (better be for the price).
- kumarvvr 2y agoHow long will Apple put forth, and customers support this charade of massively inflated storage prices? Apple really does bend the reality field.
- ksynwa 2y agoSorry for this stupid tangential question. I had read that newer MacBooks with the M line of processors give a great battery life for a number of reasons like using ARM instruction set, the SoC architecture. I noticed that some Windows laptops now come with ARM processors too though they are touted as AI ready and not much else. Do these Windows laptop have improved battery life as well? Or have other manyfacturers not tried to catch up to Apple yet?
- yowlingcat 2y agoWhy is it being compared to an M1 rather than M2/M3? I think I can imagine the answer but it's disappointing.
- Daz1 2y agoLiterally every comment is nerds complaining
- tonyedgecombe 2y agoWelcome to Hacker News. Even the founder (Paul Graham) doesn't visit anymore because the tone is too negative.
- agnishom 2y ago> available in fresh colors Is this really so important that it needs to be in the title? We are talking about computers here, not a clothing brand!
- gepardi 2y agoApple doesn’t excite me anymore.
- ranit 2y agoHa! Loop back to Macintosh colors from 25 years ago.
- neilv 2y ago> A new 12MP Center Stage camera makes video calls even more engaging, perfectly centering users and those around them in the frame, even when moving around. For WFH, do you have a sense of what's potentially in-frame? In the video, the active frame expands automatically to include additional people -- showing parts of the background that it didn't initially. (Time to update the videoconf skills of not including messy kitchen doorway in frame, and of SOs estimating whether they can walk past out of the camera's field of view.)
- paulannesley 2y agoThere's a menubar UI that appears while the camera is in use, to control the digital zoom and pan/tilt; zooming all the way out to “0.5x” shows the extent that can be potentially in-frame. Anecdotally, the auto-tracking Center Stage feature is more distracting than useful, and best turned off.
- imac_dscreen 2y agoI will never consider an iMac again because the first iMac I purchased in 2021 (with the M1 chip) had a screen problem immediately after the warranty expired. Many users have reported this problem to Apple, but they have yet to acknowledge the problem. I am very disappointed in Apple. They lie about sustainability https://discussions.apple.com/thread/255220596?answerId=260461769022&sortBy=rank#260461769022 https://discussions.apple.com/thread/255220596?answerId=2604...
- seec 2y agoWelcome to reality. The one where most Apple products actually have a problem with them but for the most part many of their rich customers do not see them because they appear further down the line. Usually around 3 year mark and further. But you will find plenty of Apple aficionados who buy/resell their Apple stuff yearly or bi-annually who tells you they never have problems; not realizing they sold their problems. I have been buying Apple hardware since the early 2000 and I have way more issues than is reasonable for the price paid. It's like German cars, you pay more because they look cool, they run fast but not necessarily because they are more reliable. If anything, they are going to break down more and cost a lot more to repair...
- vegapulse 2y agoJust saw the picture of new mac. Don't see much need to upgrade.
- zombiwoof 2y agoWhat are some reasons these can’t be used as monitors? I’d imagine only upside if they could as I’d buy one in an instant if I could use it as a monitor for my MacBook
- fragmede 2y agoThere's no displayport/HDMI/dvi/vga port on the monitor. Apple did n't implement target monitor mode. OTOH, if you have a mac of some sort, you can use it as an airplay target and mirror/extend your desktop, so it can be used as an external monitor, just not generically.
- 00000z 2y agoThey need to bring back the 27 inch model.
- LewisShoults 2y ago[dead]
- therealdrag0 2y agoAm I the only one who thinks the colors are bad? Seems designed for a 4th grader.
- Isamu 2y ago>Gamers can enjoy incredibly smooth gameplay, with up to 2x higher frame rates5 than on iMac with M1. Serious question, is gaming relevant on iMac outside of Steam? My subjective view is that it’s all concentrated there.
- MaxDPS 2y agoIsn't that the same with Windows? I haven't used Windows as my main OS in a couple years, but all my games were on Steam.
- npteljes 2y agoEpic and Blizzard also very popular. And there are other distributors too, like GOG or itch.io, who serve a lot of users. And there are popular titles that come with their own launcher, like Genshin Impact.
- seec 2y agoSo basically it's the same thing but with M4 and more RAM at the baseline. I suppose Apple would like us to be gratefull for that. Yet since it comes with only 256Gb storage standard, the minimum viable model is just under 2k euros with still a paltry 512Gb storage. That just crazy. Considering there are report of the first generation having problem with the display (most likely because of heat generation) it's even more problematic because you can't expect it to last that long. And since M4 output a lot more heat, how much this thing is going to throttle and how much faster it's going to create display problem ? No large iMac of course, that would be too cost effective compared to the eggregeriously priced Studio Display. Not that you would want one with this terrible design. It is really a testament of modern Apple : form over function, in the name of design. Yet this design is really not good, dumb white bezel, external PSU, annoyingly placed ports (only USB4 anyway). Basically you need a USB4 dock and an external drive to make this worthwhile, completly rendering moot the point of an all-in-one. If you are going to having cable galore, why even bother with this form factor. In the end this thing is mostly a showroom computer or a luxury information appliance. For someone who just want a simple information appliance the price doesn't make a lot of sense, you can get something that works at half the price, the display won't be as good but it really doesn't matter that much. The display has this resolution because Apple has chosen the eazy for resolution scaling in order for them to claim to be first and "perfect". It really is a display of modern Apple: beautiful hardware but extremely impractical and absurd pricing. I guess they want to push for the Mini/Studio + studio display for workstation use cases but the pricing is just nuts.
- WorldWideWebb 2y agoI’m on a 2017 iMac 27” and the hardware issues aside, I’m also not upgrading yet because they got rid of decent screen sizes. Other than money/profit - why don’t they make a 27” anymore? Frustrating.
- seec 2y agoYeah I'm pretty sure it's all solely profit motivated. Under Tim Cook, Apple followed the religion of the minimum profit margin very carefully. They just don't sell stuff that they can't extract 50% margin of. With that in mind it's clear that a hypothetical big iMac would be priced at around 2.2K at least for the very entry level at that would be a ridiculously weak computer for at that price point. The minimum viable machine would be around the 3K mark and a comfortable setup would be bordering on 4k. Those kinds of price would make it an extremely niche product but would also clearly highlight the major inflation Apple products have suffered under Tim Cook. The iMac was good because it was reasonably priced, for this reason they sold a lot of them (I know that for a fact, I worked for an Apple Premium Service Provider) but the margin on those was not as good as the rest, in part because of the display but also other factors (transport, servicing). And thus, their "solution" is to offer a standalone display that costs the same as previously an entry level "big iMac", this way they ensure their profit margin on 2 front and encourage you to renew the mac part more often. In my opinion that last part is a bit nonsensical, I find that by the time you want to renew the computer (as a private owner, not a business), display tech has evolved enough that you would want to change it anyway. Because the big iMac had a useful supported life of almost 10 years and you can still use them and they still make decent Windows/Linux computers if you don't want to deal with Apple unsupported OS (becomes problematic after 3-4 releases). Everything Apple does nowadays is about profit first, and almost only profits. I wish they never had been that successful with the iPhone. I bought the first gen (imported from US), as well as first gen iPod and they were really great defining products. I did not expect the whole populace to pick up on it and make it a social status thing. It has tainted everything and now they make too much money to care about anything really. They still make good products but when you look at pricing/competition it is really not as appealing as it used to.
- zombot 2y agoLooks like everything below a Mac Pro has been relegated to be a toy. Apple is practising how to disappoint. Successfully.