17 ms·
To make a fortune, target bored young men who want to make a fortune
- bix6 3y agoIs this any surprise? High levels of income inequality combined with DINK needed for a house. Everyone is looking for a quick flip.
- nytesky 3y agoNot only that, but women are going to college in greater numbers, many are out earning men. Dating can be challenging under those conditions.
- high_na_euv 3y agoHow many women out-earn men?
- walthamstow 3y agoAnecdata: 3 men on my 7-man Engineering team are outearned by their wives. London millennials for reference.
- zeroonetwothree 3y agoSeems to be around 26% outearn their partners
- caddemon 3y agoSome of that is just social conditioning though, or maybe an innate instinct but an irrational one in today's day and age. There's no reason a woman can't be the primary breadwinner, and most high earning women I know are very open to dating someone with a much lower salary as long as they are a good partner. But more often than not the guy has a hang up about the situation or is otherwise unwilling to contribute enough around the house. So instead you end up with dual high income paying for cleaning service, daycare, etc.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoYeah when I read all these comments about how hard dating is for men now, how impossible it is and think about the professional women I know and their dating experiences.... They have very reasonable standards in how they expect men to treat them, and the men they date are overwhelmingly not willing to rise to those standards. These standards are maybe much higher than they would have been even a generation ago but for the most part they are still very reasonable! And I am not even talking about money here.
- llm_trw 3y agoThis seems backwards. If your friends can't find men that meet their standards by definition their standards aren't reasonable since they aren't being met. Were they reasonable they would be met. Let's not pretend that social media hasn't had a much worse impact on women than on men.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoThis is implicitly assuming men's expectations are valid and correct, but not women's. The standards I'm talking about here are things like "will not mock or belittle me" and "will consider me an equal participant in the relationship and value my desires accordingly." They haven't misunderstood the situation or made a mistake. Their BATNA is to not have a spouse and they are taking it. Where a generation or two they might have settled for someone who treated them dismissively, but not abusively.
- llm_trw 3y ago>The standards I'm talking about here are things like "will not mock or belittle me" and "will consider me an equal participant in the relationship and value my desires accordingly." What you're describing there is a woman's expectation of a man. A man's expectations of a woman have nothing to do with the above. >Their BATNA is to not have a spouse and they are taking it. Interesting claim, let's revisit it when they are in their 50s.
- martinky24 3y agoYou are implying more men are left single, unable to afford a house, because they can't find a partner, because the pool of available women isn't available in them? Hmm...
- meowfly 3y agoIf you're a young man in your prime without rich parents and you slacked or lack the ability to compete in the job market, unless you are very charismatic, you won't make a particularly interesting partner. 20 years ago your dating pool was far more limited to location and social circles you were in. Online dating has decimated that. The illusion that you are a big win away from achieving a fast track to status is the allure.
- BitwiseFool 3y agoNot just a quick flip, the old-school days of working hard and being a loyal employee are long over. When the more steady routes of gaining wealth are increasingly out of reach, gambling becomes more enticing.
- gherkinnn 3y agoWhy be a loyal employee if you get fucked the first chance the org gets? I know plenty of old-school companies that treat their people remarkably well and loyalty goes both ways. But I struggle to think of a new-schools tech company that won't exploit an employee's naivety.
- hiatus 3y agoWhen I was younger and worked as a cashier at a grocer, I had a pension given to me by the employer. As a cashier! Now, that same job at the same exact store does not offer a pension. The employer/employee relationship has changed dramatically over the past 20 years (or more).
- fullshark 3y agoIt's a surprise to our leadership class who has absolutely zero idea what it's like to be a middle class high school / college graduate without premium skills and almost no savings in the 2024 global economy.
- pseudolus 3y agohttps://archive.ph/0ZNx8 https://archive.ph/0ZNx8
- jimberlage 3y agoA prediction - by 2030 there will be another temperance movement. This time it will be disaffected wives who don't want their husbands betting on sports. 75% confidence
- BitwiseFool 3y agoAt the rate we're going I suspect there will be far fewer married couples.
- interludead 3y agoThere are some tendencies in that field too...
- htrp 3y agoWe're just going to speedrun the UK's gambling problems. https://www.bbc.com/news/health-50828086 https://www.bbc.com/news/health-50828086
- danpalmer 3y agoIn the UK it's highly community specific. I don't gamble, I don't know anyone who does, I don't think I even know anyone who's buying lottery tickets and they're about the most normalised form of gambling. However, you do see a lot of gambling shops around, and we get news stories of it being a huge problem. I think if you're not based in the UK it would seem like it's a much bigger deal than it really is to many of the population. It's a big deal to a (small?) subset of the population.
- htrp 3y agoI'd venture it was highly community specific when you had to go to the local paddypower (pre-smartphone gambling), but now you have canary wharf traders putting in bets on their phone in between trades on their terminals.
- 3y ago
- ruined 3y agoof course. it's not like there's anything they could possibly save it for
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoSarcasm? If not: The future belongs to those who believe there will be one, and who act constructively. Or, negatively, those who believe there won't be a future often act in ways that sabotage any possibility that there could be one.
- realce 3y ago> The future belongs to those who believe there will be one, and who act constructively. Bootstraps?
- ziddoap 3y ago>The future belongs to those who believe there will be one, and who act constructively. This sounds very nice, poetic even. Too bad you can't believe your way into a house when working at a near minimum wage job with tens of thousands of dollars of student debt and being one health crisis away from living on the streets. How does one work constructively out of that? Take on more debt to get more education? Apply for the 700th job this year, and hope it's the one? Move away from your support structure to somewhere "affordable" (where?) and hope you land a job there? Statements like yours tend to ruffle my feathers. I can't help but picture someone who already has a comfortable life looking at the people who don't, saying "I'm fine, you should be too. Just believe in yourself and work". That is not how you intended it, I'm sure. But that's how it reads to many of the people who are struggling.
- TheFreim 3y agoBelief preceeds action. If someone believes there is no future for them they won't take action to build a better future for themselves. I don't quite understand how you think encouraging laziness and attacking employment is going to improve things. Promoting despair in others won't help you with yours.
- LUmBULtERA 3y agoThe article seems to lack the time series analysis to support the conclusion that "America's young men are blowing their money like never before."
- jliptzin 3y agoBut they make the shocking claim that sports betting skews towards young men.
- tombert 3y agoI was about to mention this; it doesn’t appear to have proper statistical analysis, just kind of showing examples of some young men who gamble. Anecdata, but me and all of my friends started to pretty aggressively save money at around age 25. It’s probably not coincidental that that’s also when we all started to get reasonably high paying jobs.
- itishappy 3y agoAnecdata #2, I was under the same impression until I learned that "saving money" for many of my peers meant day trading Robinhood stocks.
- tombert 3y agoI don't have access to their portfolios or anything, so they could be lying, but at least of the friends I've talked to have told me that the only thing that they buy on Robinhood is stuff like VOO and VTI.
- sanderjd 3y agoIf that's true, they should just transfer all of that into a Vanguard account. Robinhood isn't giving them anything in their use case, but they have every incentive to try to "gamify" their trading behavior, which Vanguard has neither the incentive nor, frankly, the software agility to do.
- hmmmcurious1 3y agoTbh due to social media and the current economic situation , we're creating an entire generation of lottery ticket buyers. Whats the point in saving if the average job will never let you buy a home in a decent location and the currency is depreciating at an ever increasing pace. Theres a lot of desperate people nowadays so theyre stuck chasing dreams
- cqqxo4zV46cp 3y agoKinda feel like you’re putting those in the wrong order.
- hiddencost 3y agoNope
- pc86 3y agoOh great point, you've convinced us :) Why is it a foregone conclusion that these things are only occurring in one direction? What evidence is there to support that (or not)?
- WrongAssumption 3y agoWhy didn’t you respond like this to the other comment? They gave no reasoning on order, so why should this person? And why did only this one elicit a response from you?
- hmmmcurious1 3y agoThere has never been such a pressure to succeed and appear rich as it is today. Social media is at the forefront of this by weaponizing insecurity and keeping up with the joneses. I'd wager a medieval serf had better peace of mind than 90% of people today
- brk 3y ago
- throw1234651234 3y agoThe ycombinator title is made misleading by swapping "gambling" for "blowing" money - these are not the same words at all. One implies they are just living in the moment, the other implies they are trying to get rich quick at high risk.
- karaterobot 3y agoAn interesting distinction. My view of gambling is that it is basically investing with an expectation of negative return. In other words, donating at least a few pennies of every dollar you wager to a casino or sports bookie, in the long run. I think the numbers support that. Given that mental model, the only difference I can see between gambling and blowing money is that some people enjoy the experience of gambling, and say they're paying for that experience. But you can make that argument about anything, I guess, and if you make that argument I don't think it's even possible to think of yourself as blowing money, no matter what.
- nfriedly 3y agoI wonder if the publisher is A/B testing various titles? For me, the title is "The big new way to get rich" with a sub-heading of "Want to make a fortune? Target bored young men who want to make a fortune." Looks like the HN post title has now been updated to that subheading.
- abeppu 3y agoMy understanding is that a bunch of cognitive psychology research related to risk-taking and motivation etc is funded by casinos and gambling-related businesses, which I vaguely remember as being an obligation created by some Nevada law? I wonder if it makes sense for some consumer-facing financial services companies to have a similar obligation. [1] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31691069/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31691069/
- andai 3y agoMy first thought is it's the same as how studies on the safety of phone towers are funded by their manufacturers, the safety of chemicals by theirs, etc. https://www.nytimes.com/1997/12/19/us/cia-says-it-has-found-no-link-between-itself-and-crack-trade.html https://www.nytimes.com/1997/12/19/us/cia-says-it-has-found-...
- k8svet 3y agoI spend my "political advocacy" bucks on trying to convince older generations around me just how much they and their peers pulled the ladder up behind them. And at the same time, I find conversations about money with younger generations to be very hostile (btw, I still consider myself young). Accusations, assumptions, and name-calling start circulating quickly if you dare to ask 'the youth of reddit' as it were, if they understand compound interest, how much money they spend on food delivery, vapes, weed, and booze. And then there's this pervasive social media messaging that it doesn't matter. Well, if you doom-scroll and ... don't believe? in compound interest, then I guess that is a hard narrative to escape.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> how much money they spend on food delivery, vapes, weed, and booze. The one that is mind-blowing to me is giving money to streamers. Utterly, utterly wasted money.
- nickthegreek 3y agoAgreed. Onlyfans is at least a more honest exchange.
- rhdunn 3y agoLike spending money on other forms of entertainment? Going to the cinema, theatre, a concert, renting a movie, etc. will either cost about the same or more.
- brk 3y agoTrue, and I can't relate directly, but I think part of that is the desire themselves to become streamers with big income streams. If you refuse to support that vision, then that is like admitting it is not possible for yourself?
- jcranmer 3y agoI spend as much money on streamers as I would have spent on a cable TV, were I to actually subscribe to cable TV. It's just an entertainment budget item. If the generation isn't spending that money on traditional forms of entertainment--concerts, cable, movies, sports games--then how is it wasting to spend it on the form of entertainment you don't like?
- bni 3y agoGambling used to be heavily regulated in the US. What happened?
- ghaff 3y agoGambling is still regulated. But it is generally much more accessible and visible than it used to be (probably sports betting in particular).
- Clubber 3y agoCorruption and moral decay.
- realce 3y agoAmerica has deeply endorsed the philosophy that it's more profitable to monetize despair than to fix it.
- vel0city 3y agoThe Supreme Court struck down the federal Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act of 1992 which prevented states from legalizing it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murphy_v._National_Collegiate_Athletic_Association https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murphy_v._National_Collegiate_...
- zeroonetwothree 3y agoI guess the question is why wasn’t it big before 1992?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jjice 3y agoAs a mid-twenties man, I see this constantly among my friends. It started a few years ago when sports betting was legalized in my home state and when I was at a bar before Thanksgiving to see some friends, half of them were watching a basketball game involving teams they've never cared about. They showed me that they were betting some wild parlays to hit on this game they had no interest in watching otherwise. They showed me that the apps keep track of your net earnings (I assume this is a legal requirement) and _all_ of them were in the negative between $400 and $800. Keep in mind that these are young men who just graduated college and we were all pretty broke. Flash forward, a lot of them still sports bet regularly with regular losses. I live in a different state now, but a group of my friends around here recently go into going to a casino near by. I was blown away by the justifications on their gambling habits. "I usually win" or "I only gamble what I come in with", but the latter isn't true and I've seen it with my own eyes. I met up with them (not to gamble, but to see a friend), and thirty minutes in one of them was asking the other for $40 so he could "win it all back" at the roulette table. It blows my mind. We know so well that gambling is a losing battle. Some can have fun and call it the price of fun, but it's such a slippery slope to find yourself losing way more than you intended. Anecdotally, I notice that the women in my life gamble less.
- giancarlostoro 3y agoI rarely go to Casinos, but usually go in with $20, if I lose it, that's basically it for me. I can't imagine justifying throwing more money after losing it all, only in video games where gambling is allowed.
- 3a2d29 3y agoThe key (and way easier said then done) is to take a small amount of money out, accept that its likely all going to be gone, and try to milk it slowly so all the free drinks you get are worth the money. I like in NYC, so achieving the typical cost of drinks is not hard.
- giancarlostoro 3y agoNot a bad tip! I will keep that in mind.
- delichon 3y agoThis is the demographic most likely to explore and take risks and this is the modern venue for that. Once it was hunting mammoths or gold rushes. My brother left home at 18, hitch hiked to northern Alaska and worked on oil rigs. I'm the slightly exceptional one who stayed home and can't even bring myself to buy crypto. So while the crypto market is like never before the jeopardy isn't.
- ravenstine 3y agoWith the rate of sexlessness being what it is and the ever increasing cost of living, why shouldn't men take risks with their money? The ability of a man to take great risks for great reward has been significantly reduced in practically every other aspect of life. Let them have this one thing.
- gamepsys 3y agoMale, 30s reporting. I'm often seen as the more successful and stable member of friend groups. The number of people that come to me talking about their puts, calls, crypto, and other high risk investment play is way to high. I always tell them "I invest long, so I don't know anything about that" and try to steer them towards more predictable investment options. No matter how many people I point to real estate deals they could feasibly get into, and talk about how much I've made on real estate, not one of these people have gone down that route. In the way they talk, they actually want to gamble and don't want to grow wealth. I think it might also be the marshmallow experiment, because they also don't want to discuss any play that I measure in years. I'm seeing this in more demographics than just young male. I was looking into a business plan and talking to a trusted boomer about the business plan. They have more experience in some specific aspects, and I was looking to identify more risks. Towards the end of the conversation they told me "of course, I was never a gambler", to which I replay "neither am I, that's why I'm talking to you and doing my homework."
- hiddencost 3y agoPlease just steer them to VTSAX.
- maxioatic 3y agoVTI and chill
- throw1234651234 3y agoReal Estate is in a bubble and as much of a scam as everything else. Your age, with two older acquaintances who made millions from RE. The environment is NOT the same as when they were doing it. Every garbage house gets picked up by "investors" now that either scam (pain rotting drywall and put a new heater in, bump price 40%) or lose money on it. Or it gets picked up by real investors that have crews that can gut it entirely cost effectively. It's the same for flipping cars - the profit margins are razor thin. The only RE investing that still works is buy, rent, have retirement equity in 30 years, maybe. Occasionally put some money IN. Potentially lose a lot of money mid term and hold paper losses if RE bubble pops. And guess what? Maybe not even that with the current rates. It's funny to see people acting like RE is some bastion of stability. Stock market is inflated atm too.
- outside1234 3y agoSo painful to watch. Folks, just put your money in a stock market index fund. I know that sounds insanely boring - but the magic of compounding is real. I have never been a big saver - but I have been a consistent one - and at 50 I am looking at retiring next year early. This also enabled me to buy a house (stock market is growing faster than housing market). If there is one piece of advice you take, save early, save consistently, put your savings in index funds (I target my portfolio at 50% VTI, 25% VEA, and 25% VCSH).
- scarmig 3y ago1000x. Moreover, the best piece of financial advice I ever got was that combined with automatically depositing as much of my paycheck as I could afford into an investment account with auto purchase set up. Simplicity trumps optimality. And VTI is close to optimal for most people, even (perhaps especially) people who think they can do better than it.
- master-lincoln 3y agoI don't think extrapolating from the past to the future will work here. Also the biggest companies are most often the least societal beneficial ones, so it's morally more difficult for me to justify investing at a stock exchange.
- DiggyJohnson 3y agoIt really seems like you're arguing against "save money, make safe investments", no?
- coldpie 3y ago> Also the biggest companies are most often the least societal beneficial ones, so it's morally more difficult for me to justify investing at a stock exchange. Yeah, this is a hard one. There a handful of funds out there that invest in less damaging companies, obviously with a somewhat smaller return. I ended up choosing PAXWX, for example, though there are others. I'd be happy to hear others' ideas for ethical investing (preferably without a lot of effort).
- deleted 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fortran77 3y agoI hope the President doesn’t try to forgive gambling debt, too, with taxpayer money.
- carlosjobim 3y agoThat would honestly be so funny that I hope he does.
- barrenko 3y agoNo one will care about a damn thing (in the West) until that WW3 starts.
- scarmig 3y agoIt's just entertainment. Is blowing $100 on sports betting really any worse than $500 on a designer handbag? Which isn't to say it's not an issue--both are. But despair driving people to spend increasingly on short-term endorphin hits is universal. The most meaningful metric would be the proportion of income that's saved and invested.
- alphabettsy 3y agoIn practical terms I would say it is. Designer handbags are still handbags and can be resold and used potentially forever. You cannot recover gambling losses or store your things in them. Despair is certainly an issue.
- scarmig 3y agoYou could also end up winning $100 from gambling $100. Or, on the other end, you could buy a $50 handbag instead of a $500 one. Both are tossing money into a fire.
- meepmorp 3y ago> You could also end up winning $100 from gambling $100. Or you could lose it all, whereas buying a designer hand bag has a 100% chance of you ending up with a designer handbag afterwards.
- scarmig 3y agoWith a designer handbag, you get something that's worth $50 for a cost of $500. That's a 100% chance of a $450 loss. But, you say, it gives me pleasure! Well, so does gambling. And spending money for pleasure is fine, so long as you can afford it. And if you can't, it's equally bad.
- alphabettsy 3y agoThey actually can hold their value quite well or go up in value. The value of something is what someone else would pay for it. The relatively utility of a $500 bag is no more than a $50 one, that’s for sure. The effect on pleasure between gambling and a handbag are immeasurable and maybe equal so in some sense you’re right. I’ll never buy one, but it seems like you’re distorting reality to make your point.
- ta240416 3y ago[dead]
- exabrial 3y agoI've tried to advised younger men and women on this, but I'm met with really well practiced lines from reddit career and money advice, or straight sarcastic replies, likely sourced from the same website. I've helped a ton of my friends stop living paycheck to paycheck (even adults in their 50s); my journey to this was not easy, and I really just needed a mentor. The difference between a young 20s and the older generations is thirst. The older generations have experienced drought and hardship in a way that Gen-Z might not ever experience, leading to a seemingly entitled response to everything. Another commenter said Boomers, Silents, Gen-X, Millennials, etc, "rolled up the ladder behind them" and I think that's accurate; I'm bit a tired of trying to help and being met with insult... so someone I've 'rolled up the ladder', in a way by not offering as much advice.
- ziddoap 3y ago>I'm bit a tired of trying to help and being met with insult... so someone I've 'rolled up the ladder', in a way by not offering as much advice. >The difference between a young 20s and the older generations is thirst. If your version of "helping" is telling them that they're fine, other generations had it harder, and that they lack 'thirst'... No wonder they respond negatively.
- exabrial 3y agoThat would be what is called 'attacking a straw man'
- DangitBobby 3y agoIn response to your pre-edit comment: the "good times" are kind of gone already for younger people, thanks to pulling up the ladder. That's why there's so much hate towards older generations, the only generations who apparently intentionally made things worse for those who followed instead of better.
- paxys 3y agoThe problem extends way beyond sports gambling. There's an entire culture that's just about moving from one bubble to another hoping to get rich and get out before it collapses. Crypto, WSB, meme stocks, Airbnb rentals, Amazon/Etsy drop shipping, financial influencers on YouTube/Instagram/Tiktok, "hustle culture"...there's a new grift popping up online every day. And of course the people benefiting most are the ones selling shovels. I don't think the 9-5 job is going to survive another generation.
- tmpm 3y agoThe article discusses the culture surrounding crypto and meme stocks at length. I don’t really see though how increased financial risk among certain people would kill the 9-5, though.
- tombert 3y agoI've never really gambled; I've bought two lottery tickets my entire life, I've spent less than $10 at casinos, and I don't like sports so never bothered with sports betting. I did buy some crypto during the hype in 2021, but that's basically the extent of it, and I never got into "debt" or anything with it. I do buy stock, but it's almost exclusively ETFs pegged to the S&P500 or something, not exactly a huge risk. It's easy for me to sit here with righteous indignation, acting like I'm super smart for not blowing my money on gambling, and for a long time I did just that, but recently I've kind of realized that my cowardice towards losing money is also why I'll never be wealthy. I gravitate towards decent-but-not-amazing-paying W2 jobs. I like them fine, I'm comfortable enough, and that's the safe, nearly-zero-risk path. It's certainly not a bad life or anything, but you also do kind of top-out fairly early. By age 27, I was a senior engineer at Apple. I didn't really have any intention of becoming a manager, so I was only like two promotions away from seemingly maxing out my career. I absolutely hated my job, and it depressed me because it felt like this was the end goal, and I was miserable; there was no more substantial path "upwards", and the top was just not a place I was happy. If I weren't such a coward, and had a higher tolerance for risk, I almost certainly would have started a real business. Starting a business is basically a fancy gamble; most businesses don't succeed. It's kind of hard for me to condemn gamblers at that point.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 1_1xdev1 3y agoEquating starting a business with gambling in a casino is asinine. You have a lot more impact as a founder over whether that business succeeds than you would ever have over a wager in roulette or a 4 game NFL parlay on Sunday. Both are risks. Only one is a gamble.
- tombert 3y agoI don't know that I made my point as clear as I should, but what I was saying is that starting a business does require a mindset that is more tolerant to risk. I do think that there's a bit of overlap in that part of the mentality of people who gamble and people who start businesses. You have to accept that there's a good chunk of luck with starting a business, and also acknowledge that if you don't have that luck that the business will likely go belly-up. What I was getting at is I am personally a coward. I don't say this with pride, and this isn't some attempt at humble-bragging or anything, it's a dig at myself, not entrepreneurs. Sometimes being a coward isn't a bad thing, if nothing else I don't waste my money at casinos, so that's good. But because I'm so terrified of losing money, and so terrified of anything involving "risk", I feel like I took the cowards way out by working for BigCos at a desk job instead of trying to build my own thing. Sometimes I'm a little jealous of the people who can throw caution to the wind.
- baerrie 3y agoOnce I got some “disposable” income I spent it mostly on music equipment and other hobbies. A lot of that stuff holds its value somewhat as well which is nice
- kjkjadksj 3y agoMusic equipment has to be the only type of consumer electronics that hardly depreciate. 25 year old scratched up guitar pedal? You can move it for like $25 off todays new price on reverb just fine.
- xyst 3y agoNothing has changed besides current generation having more accessibility to the stock market, casinos, and other forms of gambling. It all comes down to biology. The dopamine hit you get when your 0DTE you bought for pennies per option skyrockets the next day for a 1,000% return. It’s a dopamine hit unlike anything before it. Forget heroin, methamphetamine, cocaine. That hit of dopamine from just 1 successful “trade”/gamble is enough to wipe out the previous 100 failed trades. Some people in the drug addiction trade would call this “chasing the high”. Same thing for casinos. Same reason why your grandparents might spend hours pulling the lever of a penny or nickel slot. Also probably why insurance companies tend to rate new drivers, especially young men, as “risky”
- PokestarFan 3y agoNobody mentions how similar options trading are to an actual casino. I am a victim, as I made a dumb options bet for $8 and ended up with $70 in one day. From there I tried to make it more and more and eventually ended up losing more money than I put in, and a friend convinced me to just disable options and keep them disabled.
- neilk 3y agoMany young men are no longer trying to succeed within capitalism. They are trying to exit it. Faith in this system is dwindling, and whatever your political inclinations, that is dangerous. Fewer people believe that putting in a solid eight hours of honest labor is going to assure a decent lifestyle. Gambling is one potential path out, maybe not even that irrational if you perceive it’s your only shot.
- realce 3y agoGambling/GRODT is a fake version of class mobility. When your society isn't willing to afford actual class mobility, you'll get these facsimiles of it instead. A person's urge to climb still exists, but there are very few ladders available to them, so various other schemes are used to scratch the itch. The harder it is to climb the ladder, the more vulnerable an individual is to "invest" in the various schemes, and the more profitable orchestrating the schemes becomes. It's a blatant signal that your society is stalling and cannot produce actual value.
- maerF0x0 3y agoOn one hand she's right, and on the other she's completely off base. This really should be titled about exploitation of young men who feel they have no real opportunities. "To make a fortune, coach young men to their benefit" -- Good market economy stuff "To make a fortune, exploit the depression/negativity of young men to your benefit" -- What this article is actually about.
- jononomo 3y agoMy mother, who was born in 1935, will not even buy a entry for a church fundraising raffle because that is "gambling" and she was raised by good Presbyterian teetotalers who absolutely did not approve of gambling in any form whatsoever. A bit of that attitude leached off on me as well, but I have noticed that it is almost completely vanished from American culture. Gambling used to be something that whole swaths of society looked upon with absolute contempt as nothing but an unmitigated vice.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoIn your moms day casinos were openly ran by organized crime. Today you can buy stock in draft kings and vegas is like disneyworld instead of a grimy ash tray. The world of gambling had changed and so has peoples opinions about it.
- jononomo 3y agoPeople looked down on gambling in the old days not because the casinos were run by organized crime but because there was an understanding that gambling was motivated by greed and often caused people to waste a lot of time and lose all their money and there was no upside to it for society.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throw0101b 3y agoI've heard the term "financial nihilism": * https://kyla.substack.com/p/gen-z-and-financial-nihilism https://kyla.substack.com/p/gen-z-and-financial-nihilism A lot of people don't see a bright (financial) future for themselves, and that working hard won't get them anything meaningful. So long shots are perceived the only way that you can improve your lot in life, as otherwise The System™ is stacked against you (student loans, housing costs, etc).
- lm28469 3y agoI have the same postulate but the complete opposite reaction, if the future is going to suck I better do the right choices with my money while it's not so bad rather than blowing all of it on useless things.
- throw0101b 3y agoThe nihilism comes in when (it is perceived that) it doesn't matter that even if you do the right things (get educated, learn a skill/trade, work hard, don't spend too much), things are in such a state that that won't help, so why not YOLO?
- meowfly 3y agoMoreover, lots of people already feel like they've lost right when they've started. Imagine if you get a degree in the wrong field, like business administration, and find yourself working as a entry level marketing manager making 50k. Rent eats up half your take home pay and while you're not terrible with money, you are also not super frugal. So you are ultimately saving a few thousand a year. At this point road to being rich is half a century away and pretty narrow. You better not get sick, or have to take care of an injured family member, or scammed, or divorced, or laid off for an extended period of time. And all around you is a media, political, and social ecosystem telling you the good times are over. It makes sense why some people just decide to lie-flat.
- jackallis 3y agoemden the title to say ... who want to make a fortune, quickly.
- amadeuspagel 3y ago> And while not explicitly gambling, free trading apps such as Robinhood have gotten an increasing number of ordinary people into investing — for fun, to alleviate boredom, to try to make some extra cash. While many people have used the apps to build a stable portfolio, a good chunk of people are doing high-risk day trading or piling into meme stocks like GameStop, AMC, or, as Donald Trump's people are hoping, his newly public social-media company. Even investing meme stocks is better then gambling, because it's a positive sum game.
- jmbwell 3y agoThe story is about gambling, but the headline is applicable all over the place, not least here on HN, even. And if you liked this content, you might be interested in my book based on my seminars based on my podcast. Be sure to like and subscribe.
- unstatusthequo 3y agoNice. Long time options trader. I just bought into the Definace ETFs that play the opposite side of this to get monthly returns. I did QQQY and IWMY. Returns per share last month were $0.80 and $1.10, respectively.
- parpfish 3y agoFrom the lens of behavioral economics (e.g., cumulative prospect theory) is there a situation where somebody can accurately understand the expected outcomes of any particular bet BUT still come to the conclusion that taking the bet is rational? If there's some combo of a floor effect (if they don't have much now, they don't have much to lose) and pessimism about the future (they think this is the only way they can manage to get ahead), I can see people deciding that gambling is worth it.
- semanticjudo 3y agoyes, when the odds of winning are in my favor... But I assume you know that so you must be asking, "Is there a situation where somebody can accurately understand the expected outcomes of any particular bet where the odds are against them winning and still come to the conclusion that taking the bet is rational?" And one answer comes immediately to mind although I'm sure there are several: when I'm willing to lose for the entertainment value of having the chance to win and knowing that short term variance means I may in fact win.
- seydor 3y agoBut what's the adverse effects of this? Are there terrible outcomes for this generation? For sure behavioral addictions are strong with younger generations, social media, gambling etc. Oddly, physical addictions like drugs and sex dont seem to be much in vogue
- commandlinefan 3y agoOr lonely young men who want to find somebody to make a life with.
- rmbyrro 3y agoA profitable business to target gamblers with ~zero legal risk is selling courses that teach how to make money. As a social bonus, you can call yourself an "educator", instead of a gambling business owner.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- luckyou 3y ago- Hi! We are starting the course "How to earn a million dollars in one day". Question for the audience. How much did the ticket to the course cost? - One thousand dollars. - And how many seats are there in this hall? - One thousand. - Thank you, the course is over.
- HeyLaughingBoy 3y agoNow repeat that for a Tony Robbins course :-)
- semanticjudo 3y agoThere always has been and always will be a “tax” on those who cannot or will not apply math to their financial decisions. Of course the degree to which we provide opportunities to collect this tax is a societal decision and we’ve almost certainly increased the opportunities for tax collectors in the last ten to fifteen years quite dramatically. And of course, de facto the under educated folks, who also are likely to be poor, will tend to be taxed at a disproportionate rate. Yet another wealth transfer. I wonder what societal attitudes led us down this road?
- JeremyNT 3y agoOn HN it has been fascinating to watch the rise of "line go up" financial vehicles. It seems that the appetite for such things as NFTs, shitcoins, meme stocks, etc is nearly insatiable. This article nails down some things about this phenomenon - at least concretely identifying the demographics - but it doesn't really give any satisfying answers or propose any solutions. We've made it so easy for people with addictive personalities to click "gamble" that it's unsurprising to see it on the rise. With stuff like crypto we've normalized - even glamorized - the behaviors. Gambling is "useless" in an economic sense - it doesn't create any real value, it only provides "entertainment." The problem is that not every gambler is going to be entertained, especially if they light a bunch of money on fire and suffer real negative economic consequences. It seems like we should be doing something to mitigate this...
- koromak 3y agoAt least on the Robinhood and crypto side, I think 20-somethings are just absolutely desperate. They look at their parents generation and see everything they aren't allowed to have. Working harder won't buy them a house. So they look for the jackpot somewhere else.
- sanderjd 3y agoFWIW, we super felt this same way in our 20s at the end of the 2000s when the financial crisis happened. But it turned out that through working and saving we actually were eventually "allowed" to have the things like houses and weddings and families that our parents' generation were able to have. It did take more and it did take longer, but it didn't require winning a jackpot. (Speaking in population-level averages here. The "elder millenials" that came of age into the financial crisis are now own homes and have families to a large extent, though of course many individuals still can't afford homes or families.) I despise that this has only gotten worse for today's young people (after getting better for awhile, I think). But even still, working and saving continues to have much higher "expected value" than gambling.
- djaouen 3y agoUhh, I guess you can do that if you want to sell out? Lol
- Phiwise_ 3y agoAh yes, because no young woman has ever fallen for a beauty goods ponzi scheme, or older man or woman ever raided their savings for a get rich quick stunt or 419 scam. Business Insider is such clickbait trash these days.
- Kwinnoble10 3y ago[flagged]