32 ms·
iOS 17 app sideloading might only be available in Europe
- josephcsible 4y agoHasn't Apple always said the reason they don't allow sideloading was that it'd be impossible without compromising security? So are they claiming their European iDevices won't be secure anymore, or are they admitting they were lying before and that the real reason was nothing but greed?
- AniseAbyss 4y agoiPhones been hacked for ages already.
- danielheath 4y agoPerhaps "has it ever been hacked" is not the best metric, unless you prefer to keep your devices under armed guard, encased in several meters of concrete, without an internet connection. IMO, https://zerodium.com/program.html https://zerodium.com/program.html is a good indication of "what would it cost to hack me using a never-before-seen exploit".
- 0xy 4y agoYou wrongly assumed that zero days are single-use. Pegasus used the same exploits in dozens or hundreds of targets.
- danielheath 4y agoI didn't assume that at all - that's why I specified a never-before-seen vulnerability.
- 0xy 4y ago"seen" could not be true until after thousands are hacked.
- ec109685 4y agoStill surprising to me that AWS has firecracker and iOS still runs things like Javascript along side every other app on the system.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoWhy couldn't both be true?
- nomel 4y agoHow would app review work?
- EMIRELADERO 4y agoThe whole point is that there would be no app review for independent apps. It's not a technical change in who distributes the software, it's a radical change that results in developers being able to give apps to users without being in a contractual relationship with Apple period.
- nomel 4y agoI'm not sure I follow the chain of comments here. It seems that not having a review would result in less security, which is the context to my comment.
- kaba0 4y agoAppStore pretty much only does a “grep -r porn” on every app, hardly meaningful “security”. If anything, it’s best at mysteriously flagging competitor apps.
- ulfw 4y agoThey are required by European law to allow it, wether they see it as compromising security or not. This isn't Apple's decision.
- neximo64 4y agoHow they will do it likely is they will charge to install the App store app and assign it a CA and require it to sign the apps downloaded from that app store. The sideloading of apps will technically be an apple approved app but enforced by another app store. To put it another way you would not be able to randomly download an unsigned app.
- amelius 4y agoThey will probably put all the side loaded apps in the same sandbox. Yikes ...
- syrrim 4y agoThey're presumably claiming that european devices will be less secure.
- AlfeG 4y agoOr usability of this feature would be so frustrating, that no one will use. Constant security popups on every start, very limited available API for apps, etc...
- kaba0 4y agoThat would just give them a huge fine.
- toyg 4y agoThere is law and there is the spirit of the law. The ECJ can be pretty fast when they feel someone is taking the piss.
- amelius 4y agoThe cookie popups can be very annoying and confusing and they didn't do anything about that.
- jeroenhd 4y agoThey have actually fined several large tracking providers for their shady cookie popups because opting out was harder than opting in. European DPAs aren't getting enough funding to take on this problem, but they haven't been sitting still either.
- kuschku 4y agoThey're slowly working through the backlog. Even Google gave in and put a single, working "deny all tracking" button front and center.
- phatfish 4y agoRecently I've noticed more sites providing a visible "Deny All" button, rather than the dark pattern of going through and unchecking 5, 10, 50 tracking cookies individually, or having to dig out a button hidden somewhere. I assume this was how it was intended to function, but the kind people that run internet websites intentionally made it more difficult.
- charcircuit 4y agoSecurity isn't binary. European iDevices will likely have more malware installed on them on average than US iDevices.
- awestroke 4y agoI thought iPhone apps were sandboxed, making malware impossible?
- charcircuit 4y agoThat limits what they can do, but it doesn't mean they can't do anything malicious. Someone could make a YouTube app which removes ads, but steals your session so that they can viewbot or spam comment sections with legit accounts.
- jakub_jo 4y agoThis is something which would also work using an app store app -- where's the app store benefit in your point?
- charcircuit 4y agoDistribution is centralized and Apple can end distribution if the app gets reported and add the malware to their malware scanning. While possible, it should be more rare. When working on massive platforms it is typically the goal to minimize metrics like malware installs as opposed to trying to make them 0. The relative probabilities are important.
- pxoe 4y agoScanning apps for malware, preventing them from being installed or run, and warning about malicious apps, doesn't actually require centralized distribution or limiting sideloading. This malware problem with sideloading has already been solved, by Google with Play Protect on mobile, by every other system that allows 'sideloading' and has some kind of antivirus, and by Apple themselves in macOS. Compared to an antivirus (macos, windows, android, all have protection built-in), that could detect a malicious app, or receive a report about a malicious app and then block it from being run, having an app store in the chain might not even be that much help or be at all different in that process. If anything, giving potential malware apps a chance to be published on an app store, get that scale, visibility and access to an audience outright, and hang there even if for a little bit before getting taken down, could be kinda worse than if malware apps were distributed across smaller venues. Where, through what channel could a malware app get access to biggest amount of people? Through a centralized app store. (especially if it's the only one on the platform, and the only way to install apps*, forcing all users of the platform to be there.) An app store gives potential malware makers access to an existing audience, ready to be exploited, and a centralized app store ensures that it's the biggest audience possible.
- asddubs 4y agoI suppose it's true in the same way that having knives in your kitchen makes it more likely that you might cut yourself. but a kitchen without knives kind of sucks so
- chronogram 4y agoI don't think kitchens should have knives. I want my parents to be able to eat, but with knives in the kitchen they occasionally cut their fingers and I don't want to have to deal with that. You could make it optional but before you know it they'll get knives anyway. Besides, most people eat processed food and don't want to make meals from scratch so this is only a problem for a handful of people. (yes yes this is satire)
- webmobdev 4y agoIf Apple's social media team is hiring, you should apply - this is exactly the irritating kind of replies I get when I criticise some Apple product. :)
- hsbauauvhabzb 4y agoMy parents want to cook dinner with knives. They have no interest in side loading custom applications though.
- solarkraft 4y agoMy parents want to install applications of their choosing on their devices, but have no interest in knife-cooked dinner.
- hsbauauvhabzb 4y agoI find this hard to believe. Don’t get me wrong, freedom to sideload apps is a thing I believe in, but saying ‘it’s because my parents want more freedom’ is certainly a stretch.
- wiseowise 4y agoYou know what's the most secure device? The one that doesn't work.
- alerighi 4y agoThe claim is nonsense. If it was true Android devices would be full of malware, that is clearly not the case.
- jb1991 4y ago> there’s a far greater chance that hackers can make it onto the [Android] platform to distribute malware through malicious apps [compared to iPhone]. https://nordvpn.com/blog/ios-vs-android-security/ https://nordvpn.com/blog/ios-vs-android-security/
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoIs MacOS insecure then?
- simooooo 4y agoYou could probably argue yes, since a 3rd party app isn’t validated in any way by apple
- heavyset_go 4y ago3rd party apps are validated via OCSP on macOS when the apps are launched. A few years ago this was an issue, when millions of macOS users found that they couldn't launch any apps at all on their Macs, because Apple's OCSP servers were down[1]. [1] https://blog.cryptohack.org/macos-ocsp-disaster https://blog.cryptohack.org/macos-ocsp-disaster
- wrasee 4y agoI think most would accept that iOS is more secure than macOS. But to flip the logic the other way around and put as you did is a little disingenuous.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vbezhenar 4y agoIt's one thing to provide security in the kindergarden. It's another thing to provide security in the jail. So far Apple's track record is kindergarden security. They do have tech in place, but how that tech would resist big bad world outside the wall remains to be seen. My guess would be that there will be apps breaking the jails in the first years and 10 years later things will settle on and it'll become relatively safe to sideload untrusted apps. Of course if one's smart enough to only download apps from reputable websites, then the only worry will be privacy issues which are probably not important for most people
- fortuna86 4y ago[dead]
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoGood. I personally agree with Apple’s stance. I don’t want developers of popular apps to be able to bypass Apple’s reviews and push dark patterns on users. Before anyone talks about choice, I see this as akin to minimum wages and union memberships. There are some limitations of choices that often end up being beneficial to the average person. From the point of view of the user (if not the app developer) Apple’s walled garden provides me what I want. If I wanted something more open, I would have gone with Android. I am happy that Europe’s short-sightedness will not affect me.
- scrollaway 4y ago[flagged]
- sfe22 4y agoIt kind of makes sense. Both are closed systems that place rules what is good or bad for their members. If we cannot trust a person to choose whether a certain salary is good or bad for them, why would we trust them to decide what apps are good or bad for them?
- overthrow 4y agoThe minimum wage is beneficial because employers tend to have more leverage than employees in the relationship. It's actually similar to the leverage Apple has over its users. And they've used that leverage to control what apps people are allowed to use. So the EU forcing Apple to let users install apps serves a similar purpose as the minimum wage - both are curtailing potential abuses against a group of people with little power in their situation.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 4y agoThe same logic applies. Users have less leverage over popular apps. Hence they rely on someone who has more leverage over the app developers (Apple) to shift the balance on their favor. Note that most of the complaints about Apple’s ecosystem are from developers, not from actual users.
- Aeolun 4y agoThat’s dissapointing. Can I get the european firmware installed on my device then?
- 1letterunixname 4y agoSons of beaches! I'm moving to Europe across the pond. Swims faster I would expect it to be piloted in one region first and then phase across regions. It's not exactly something you want to YOLO and deploy to the entire world fleet all at once with customer devices and server infrastructure.
- fbdab103 4y agoI am wondering if I could take a trip to Europe, side-load an app, and return to the states. Would Apple suddenly geo-block my already installed application?
- superkuh 4y agoEven if this is small progress the headlines and framing of the story are still doublespeak. Installing applications on your computer is the normal state of things. Walled gardens and not having control of your computer is the new weird thing. The word "sideloading" is a feudal concept and it's unquestioned use is dangerous for society. Properly stated this story title is, "Installing applications on iOS 17 might be allowed Europe" which highlights the absurdity intrinsic in the practice of users not being able to install applications on their own computers as a default.
- gary_0 4y agoEven on Windows if I send an EXE or MSI of my software to someone they get a scary security warning that prevents them from running it. The only guaranteed way around that is to be a big company (or a big open-source project). If security really mattered, every OS would run applications in a proper sandbox, but why bother with that when you can just point your Web browser at a program running on someone else's server? Oh, but consent to these tracking cookies first.
- userbinator 4y agothey get a scary security warning that prevents them from running it. The huge difference is that's only a warning, and not a cryptographically locked-down system unlike Apple's.
- gary_0 4y agoCall me paranoid, but I see it as a slippery slope. And for most users that security warning is as good as a cryptographic lockdown anyways.
- userbinator 4y agoThey are certainly boiling the frog slowly. And for most users that security warning is as good as a cryptographic lockdown anyways. On the other hand, I find it ironic how a lot of "security professionals" will complain constantly about users accepting security warnings with no thought anyway (and they usually use this argument to justify their increasingly authoritarian measures of controlling them.)
- paxys 4y agoI anticipate a huge market developing for unlocked second hand European iPhones in the US.
- jacknews 4y agoThe feature will be tied to your apple id, obviously.
- 1over137 4y agoOh that would suck. I've had an iPhone since the week they were first released, but never associated an Apple ID with one. My whole beef with the App Store is it requires telling Apple who I am. If you have to associate your phone with an Apple ID to get sideloading then this is hardly progress for me.
- vxNsr 4y agoHow have you used an iPhone without an Apple ID? 90% of the features are useless without it…
- EMIRELADERO 4y agoThat would actually be illegal under the DMA: [...]gatekeepers shall: [...](f) refrain from requiring business users or end users to subscribe to or register with any other core platform services identified pursuant to Article 3 or which meets the thresholds in Article 3(2)(b) as a condition to access, sign up or register to any of their core platform services identified pursuant to that Article "Operating systems" is part of the "core platform services" definition. Locking the use of iOS or sideloading capabilities behind an Apple ID (another "core platform service") would be a violation of the provision.
- jacknews 4y agoBut that's the European law. Nothing stopping them locking sideloading for US Apple IDs I think? I mean they can't require an EU apple ID in order to access the sideloading feature, but they could deny it to US apple IDs.
- jacknews 4y ago"It's for your safety and security" Words that should send a chill down every spine. It's obviously just a monopoly. They could easily have an 'allow sideloading' option in the OS, and those that are happy with Apple's curation can leave it off, and everyone else can turn it on.
- gary_0 4y agoMonopoly? How about digital feudalism. "We've put ourselves in charge of protecting you, so we're going to help ourselves to a portion of everyone's gold, and make sure none of the serfs are up to anything we don't approve of."
- waboremo 4y agoYes this framing makes more sense, especially since many get stuck up on the definition of a monopoly when that doesn't quite keep up with new tactics being utilized (ie keeping competition going but only superficially).
- kevingadd 4y agoThe way they aggressively police things on their app store, including "inappropriate" subversive content like Project Gutenberg, while taking 30% of everyone's revenue definitely sells the feudalism angle.
- wruza 4y agoThis is incorrect. Apple doesn’t force you to buy iphone, and there is plenty of alternatives. Personally, I’d like to take full control over my iphone. And create apps for myself the way I see fit. But I’m afraid that with sideloading allowed, most software vendors will go sideloading-only. That means, nobody will have any control over their app’s privilege requests, behavior and other security related things. Basically my concern is that when I need a “ruler app”, I just install it and am sure it couldn’t even be published with sms access request. Now with wild-west sideloading this restriction is over, so everyone and their dog will nag you to allow access to AB, calls, mic, etc. All dark patterns will break loose.
- m3kw9 4y agoMove to Europe, get side loading
- MBCook 4y agoDuh? The EU has no jurisdiction over the US. So there will be no legal need for Apple to allow it here. Just like they don’t allow alternate payment methods for dating apps in the US like some other countries required and Apple had to comply with. The App Store is too critical to the way Apple sees things, they’re not going to just say “oh well”. I bet things are only open for EU residents with EU purchased phones. Buy an EU phone and activate with a US account? Bet it’s locked. Also expect them to make hay over any security/scam issues with 3rd party stores/side loading. Something WILL happen and when reporters ask Apple they’ll be more than happy to point out how great the App Store is suggest users stick to it and blame bad regulations for making EU users less safe.
- afavour 4y agoIt’s absolutely not as simple as “duh”. Not giving users a feature they want because it’s in your business interests to deny it is a difficult PR move, to put it mildly. Not to mention such a disparity in feature between different regions is pretty huge.
- heffer 4y ago> Not to mention such a disparity in feature between different regions is pretty huge. And at the same time not at all that uncommon. If you are in a market outside of the US I'm certain you will have experienced this first hand more than once. I have.
- MBCook 4y ago> Not giving users a feature they want because it’s in your business interests to deny it is a difficult PR move, to put it mildly. They’ve managed it for 15 years so far. It may be crumbling, but this isn’t a new restriction or something that wasn’t possible in the past.
- josephcsible 4y ago> there will be no legal need for Apple to allow it here. The point is that since Apple had to do the work to allow sideloading at all, most if not all of the lies they came up with for why they can't allow it for everyone won't work anymore.
- vivegi 4y agoFrom the article > In addition, developers may have to pay extra if they want their apps to be available outside of the iOS App Store, Gurman says. The statement is a bit ambiguous. Is it pay Apple extra or pay extra to the 3rd party to have their app listed in the 3rd party app store? The former doesn't sound right; It is probably FUD. Logically, a 3rd party app store could compete on significantly reduced fees relative to Apple (as one of the strategies). Those conscious of the quantum of current fees then have options of listing their app on both the Apple app store and the 3rd party store as part of their distribution strategy. Customers who trust the Apple appstore would get their app from there and those who like a 3rd party app store would get it from there. The app developer would have reduced their total fees (for distribution). Even if there are signup fees, the share of revenues that Apple is today taking away from the developer would go down in absolute terms with a 3rd party store. As far as the consumer is concerned, this becomes an OS setting like 'default browser/default text editor etc.,'. Apple sticking to only the Apple App Store stance is only raising the cost for consumers. Consumers in other geographies will also wake up. Eventually.
- thesuitonym 4y agoIf I were being extremely charitable on the phrasing, I think they might mean, for example, if you pay Apple 30% (or whatever the going rate is) you might have to pay an external app store an additional number. Or, it might mean Apple will charge higher rates for apps that are also available on other app stores? Not sure if that's entirely legal, but since when have pesky things like the law stopped companies as big as Apple?
- vivegi 4y agoI agree. As a dev, if I list my $3/mo subscription app on the Apple App store and they take 30% and I have 100k customers and I double-list the app in the 3rd party store + the Apple app store and gain 20k customers from the 3rd party store and the 3rd party store charges 10%, I have saved (30% - 10%) x 20k x $3/mo = $12k/mo on the new customers. If I release my next version update and post it to just the 3rd party app store, I could then theoretically move the 120k customers to download the update from the 3rd party store and then save $72k/mo. That is what Apple is afraid of. I think.
- edandersen 4y agoI wonder if they considered an "iPhone Europe Edition" - USB-C, side loading, physical SIM cards. Sounds like a good phone!
- kaba0 4y agoWhat’s good about physical SIMs? I do like apple for daring to improve the status quo there, so I want my European Edition with only e-simsz
- W4RH4WK55 4y agoThat I can just take the SIM out and put it in a different phone? what's the migration process for eSIMs?
- tshaddox 4y agoYou need the carrier to offer eSIM, of course, but then you can just store a bunch of eSIMs on your iPhone and switch which one is active in the Settings app.
- spockz 4y agoI think the GP question was how to migrate your eSIM to another phone. You can transfer the sim but it needs to be activated on the other phone. I have even seen reactivation charges of €5.
- tehlike 4y agoOpen app markets act and American innovation and choice online act cannot come soon enough
- nuker 4y agoI bet you a tenner Facebook immediately moves out of EU App Store and will be sideload only, with all privacy related permissions required for the app to run.
- simion314 4y agoThey did not done this on Android. But you know what is reality and not FUD? App Stores pushing legal apps out, at least people in EU could have an option when this will continue to happen.
- oefnak 4y agoSure, I'll take that bet. Can you definite 'immediately'? Would a month suffice?
- nuker 4y agoWhen the first iOS version with sideloading will roll out.
- Barrin92 4y agoGiven that this is Europe where the GDPR requires consent regardless of how any app is installed you stand to lose that bet (which is why this is not the case on Android). The Apple cartel protection-racket framing makes only sense in a market without privacy regulations, in the EU choice and privacy aren't mutually exclusive.
- jeffybefffy519 4y agoExactly!
- MikusR 4y agoAnd? It will also allow stuff like the smart voting app that apple removed because a dictator told them to.
- iaml 4y ago
- walterbell 4y agoOption 1: one-time cost for EU compliance, applied uniformly in other countries without geo-specific overhead, reducing ecosystem pressure for additional litigation and regulation. Option 2: minimal EU-only compliance, generate A/B economic data for antitrust lawyers and regulators in other countries to compete on platform neutrality, which can be incorporated by EU in a spiral of regulatory FOMO.
- arlcode 4y agoSince Option 1. require them to look further than the next 1 or 2 years it'll absolutely be Option 2 I think.
- hooby 4y agoI think the central question here is: .) whether you buy a phone as a piece of hardware and then own that hardware - which gives you certain rights regarding the usage of that owned hardware or .) whether you are just paying some sort of admission fee to a tightly controlled service, and are basically "lent" a piece of hardware that you have no ownership rights over. All the other stuff about walled gardens, monopolies and security is related - but still acts as a red herring when discussing what rights a person should get for a piece of hardware they bought.
- tpxl 4y agoAs far as I'm concerned if you 'bought' something, it should be yours to do as you please, including reselling and destroying it. If you didn't buy something, but rented it - for example a game on Steam or Epic Games store - then it should damned say so. It's a straight up lie to say you purchased something if you didn't.
- rTX5CMRXIfFG 4y agoHaven’t you always been able to resell and destroy the Apple products that you buy?
- vladvasiliu 4y agoI don't think those alternatives are the right ones. You can sell your iphone without any issue, there are plenty of stores around me offering to buy used models to resell. I'm actually contemplating buying a used model. Can't do that with steam games. I'm also pretty confident that if apple and their services disappeared tomorrow, my iphone would keep on working just like it does today. Sure, no more updates, no more new apps, it would be frozen in the state it's in. Therefore, I think the question is whether an iphone is a "general computing device", or "an appliance". I can see the arguments for both, even though I tend to treat mine as the latter.
- LMYahooTFY 4y ago> I'm also pretty confident that if apple and their services disappeared tomorrow, my iphone would keep on working just like it does today. Sure, no more updates, no more new apps, it would be frozen in the state it's in. You can hardly call that "working like it does today". It doesn't. When features on it inevitably cease to work or be interoperable, you're screwed. And every day, you're probably more vulnerable to crime. If I buy a house, I can learn to maintain it and keep it secured. I can't do that with my iPhone.
- FriedPickles 4y agoAs the developer of a subscription app, if unfettered side-loading is allowed I'd be worried about cracked versions of my app being distributed. We've done everything in the client for privacy and reliability, but the obvious countermeasure would be to move functionality over to a backend. This would be history echoing the transition from boxed software to SaaS.
- mrtksn 4y agoIsn’t it a bit like the movies and music? Those who will steal will steal and those who will pay will pay anyway. There are great pirate movie websites where you can watch all the movies at about the same user experience or even better but Netflix etc are doing just fine. Piracy isn’t what it used to be but I do enjoy these sites. The real problem is the subscription fatigue and fragmentation. I won’t subscribe to all the services and Even if I have a subscription it’s easier for me to find the movies in one place. However apps are different, you are expected to open different apps for different things anyway. In apps, the danger could be something like ChatGPT becoming the main UI and doing everything the user wants from there.
- bluesign 4y agoIt is same if you have big audience, it is very different if you are developing for a niche market.
- tonyedgecombe 4y ago>Those who will steal will steal and those who will pay will pay anyway. That's not been my experience. Every time a crack appeared for my software sales went down. Every time I strengthened the licensing software sales went up. This is for B2B software, god knows what it is like if you sell to consumers.
- shaky-carrousel 4y agoI lost the access to Rubymine and switched to vs code. If I can't have it free, I switch. I won't post for it, it's not worth it.
- xenonite 4y agoIngenious! What if a security incident happens just in Europe but not elsewhere? Then it becomes instantly clear that Apple’s argument against sideloading was not a strawman.
- tigrezno 4y agohasn't happened on android with sideloaded apps. Stop fearmongering.
- vultour 4y agoAndroid has so much malware in the play store the argument is moot.
- xenonite 4y agoAndroid is another system, and yes, there have been breaches. Lets say it like that, and I know I am simplifying quite a bit: Apple checks security at "compile time", during the App Store checks. Android checks security only (or mostly?) during "run time". "Compile time" can give good guarantees because the "compile time" can quite long. Then, during program execution, there need to be less run time checks (and a program can be much faster, by the way). What do you think happens when allowing sideloading on Apple iOS devices? Suppose there are much less run time checks available because compile time checks are expected?
- whazor 4y agoI am looking forward! I tried side loading the YouTube with sponsorblock and adblock, which worked but renewing the apps weekly is too much effort.
- ec109685 4y agoYouTube Premium is a pretty good deal and actually pays the creators when you watch their videos.
- tgv 4y agoExcept a lot of it isn’t theirs to publish.
- MikusR 4y agosponsorblock, sponsorblock, sponsorblock. YouTube Premium doesn't have it.
- Gareth321 4y agoI pay for Premium but creators still include sponsored content, and it's getting egregious. I will continue to pay for Premium, but I want ALL the ads gone. The only way to achieve this is with Sponsorblock.
- walterbell 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35553758 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35553758
- MikusR 4y agoAltstore does it automatically
- c-hendricks 4y agoI use Vinegar to remove ads and SponsorBlock, but just access youtube via the web interface. PIP, background audio, all those native OS features that Apple's developer terms forbid companies from charging for but let YouTube charge for, works.
- jpalomaki 4y agoI think Apple has also done good things with their strict app store policies (from my consumer point of view). Apple has been for example putting limits on data collection and tracking. The main mechanism is to kick apps out from Apps store if they don't play by the rules. I'm worried that side loading will be a step back here. Strong players, like Facebook, may just take their app away from the official store and distribute it through other ways. With their strong position I don't have much choice - it's not like there would be five competing apps serving the same purpose (connecting to the people and communities on Facebook).
- heywoodlh 4y ago> I don't have much choice I hope I don't come across as snarky -- I am genuinely curious -- but why don't you have a choice? Are you unable to contact friends, family, etc. any other way outside of FB? The phrasing seems so strong, I am second guessing if I am just privileged/lucky (location, friend/family circumstances, etc?) to be off of social media but still have friends and family that I stay connected to. EDIT: fixed grammar
- jb1991 4y agoI would normally agree with you, but a friend of mine is an immigrant from a south east Asian nation and the only way to easily communicate is through Facebook with the family there. It’s like saying, sure we can take away your phone and you can still write letters, but at some point communication is also about convenience.
- heywoodlh 4y agoThat makes perfect sense, definitely sheds light on the fortunate circumstance I am in of not needing FB to conveniently communicate with my connections. Because, I agree, you should be able to conveniently communicate if you can.
- pjerem 4y agoCan’t this friend install something else on his phone ? Signal maybe ?
- iamnotsure 4y agoWhat if Apple registered a religion with apps qualifying as pages of holy scriptures, should then they be allowed to have their walled gardens?
- zacksiri 4y ago[flagged]
- shrx 4y agoNo. Preventing people from doing something "for their own good" is never the right solution. Instead, we should strive to educate people on proper online safety measures so that they don't fall victim to fraudulent attempts.
- squeaky-clean 4y agoThat hasn't worked out for the past 30 years and with every passing year there's more to learn. Telling someone they need to spend several hours to learn how to safely use their device is a good way to market the competitor where that's not required.
- zacksiri 4y agoBelieve me the central bank puts out social media posts to inform the public on a regular basis, however a lot of people still fall for these frauds because the fraudsters prey on their greed and fear. I’ve seen even the most educated tech savvy people fall for these frauds. So I would say “educating people” is insufficient. Another problem is because the law works extremely slowly, by the time any legal action can be taken to take down the destination bank accounts the fraudsters have already gained and taken the money. Sideloading is the thing that works because the legal infrastructure simply can’t keep up with the fraudsters. I would be inclined to agree with you if I know that the legal system immediately stops fraudsters and returns the money to the people without damange. We’re far from that.
- tonylemesmer 4y agoEngineering disagrees. Having safety interlocks on machines is seen as necessary and sensible to prevent accidental harm. If you want to achieve something that you think sideloading is the only answer for then maybe try and find another solution? Btw. I’m not arguing we shouldn’t educate people about the dangers of phishing etc etc. just that engineers should find better solutions than shortcuts. Some people will never understand the need to be vigilant. And even vigilant people have momentary lapses of vigilance. [edit] i think we’re talking about deliberate sideloading but also accidental sideloading in the same breath here. One enables the other? Accidental sideloading is very much undesirable.
- hurtuvac78 4y agoApple being motivated by improving security are BS, and it pains me te see people in this forum falling for it or reapeating this. There is a great tool to increase security: the browser and its sandbox. You don't need to install anything fishy on your phone, and the sandbox rights coukd be sufficient for many apps. But as an example, Apple denies the full screen feature for websites and even PWA... only installed ones. There's no good reason except favoring apps/appstore. For security? Works great on Android. And you cannot use a third party browser, since they forbid that (all are Safari based) Thank you, EU!!
- amelius 4y agoI sometimes feel that some HN folks need to consider a job inside EU committees. It's probably boring work, but even if you spend 10% of your time in meetings and the remainder on a secret side project, you will be doing society a great service.
- KyeRussell 4y agoThis is a hilarious instance of the “I could build that in a weekend” mindset.
- timwis 4y agoHow would you recommend going about that?
- AniseAbyss 4y ago[dead]
- zeta0134 4y agoThe full screen feature works fine on websites for me? Well mostly fine, it's rubbish for games in particular due to a user hostile feature that forbids rapid screen taps, insisting that you might be using an on screen keyboard and denying you the autonomy to tell Safari to please not. But ignoring that, the feature seems to exist. What am I missing?
- seydor 4y agoApp tourism when
- hiram112 4y agoI imagine the real reason here is that EU companies want to avoid the 30% fee Apple collects on all online purchases with IOS apps. It's doubtful any savings will be passed on to consumers, anyway. It's likely Apple will do what Google does and instead tie their app store into various apis and services (e.g. Google Play) so that side-loaded apps have a very difficult if not impossible time integrating with the phone in a way that users expect and desire. Seems like the EU bureaucracy goes after big entrenched US tech companies again and again, but they never really obtain any W's. They spent years fighting against Microsoft's bundling of IE and Media Player, and all that ever happened was that MS released some Euro-only version of a few Windows releases without the bundling. But both IE and Media Player were displaced within a few years anyway, regardless of any EU rules. Likewise, all the GPDR rules seemed to have accomplished is that every site now has an annoying-as-hell "click here to accept all cookies" button that everyone has learned to just auto accept. I doubt Europeans have anymore actual privacy compared to the rest of us, especially since their own governments are far more interested in tracking their citizens online behavior with regard to tax avoidance, hate speech, etc - they absolutely require US Big Tech to keep track of all this info for them to quietly subpoena as needed.
- mirekrusin 4y agoThey should just allow installing other operating systems instead. If you want out of their platform, install Linux OS on your phone and have whatever you want there. Wouldn't that make everybody happy - Apple, EU and customers?
- Kwpolska 4y agoNobody wants Linux on an iPhone. People want both the Apple ecosystem, but also apps that do not want to participate in it or apps that Apple does not like.
- mirekrusin 4y agoPeople would also want to bring their own wine to every restaurant and some would love to bring their own eggs and ask kitchen to make it for them at a discount - isn't it better to just put few benches as picnic area outside to make everybody happy? You can't meet all demands of everybody at the same time because what they think they're entitled to is mutually exclusive. Let's not kid ourselves - Apple won't give full, unrestricted access for sideloaded code ever. It's going to run in some kind of highly isolated enclave at best, with grayed out icons, warning sign overlay, scary long list of permissions given when installing, untrusted code popups when launching, permission re-confirmations when running, without access to ie. background code execution, limited apis etc. - they must be brainstorming any loopholes left by snail speed EU bureaucracy as we speak to make it as user unfriendly and limited as possible. All that wasted energy could be channeled into something that actually is good for people, gives them freedom while preserving Apple's deserved profit participation in the market they've created themselves out of thin air.
- wiseowise 4y agoThat should be the next step, yes.
- mirekrusin 4y agoMy argument is that it should be the only step that is fair for both sides, efficient to implement, collapses bureaucratic policy to single sentence, doesn't create "issue created here - must be solved somewhere else" problems, nourishes progress, gives true freedom to purchased item owners, preserves good capitalistic incentives and many more. Sideloading will be full of complicated very important details sucking out live from all parties involved. I think we all agree that it should not be possible to unintentionally click or autoload link that downloads some settings app that looks like ie. iOS settings app but is developed by some shady party that has access to ie. your biometric security primitives, can look like/impersonate any built-in app/OS behavior etc.
- wildpeaks 4y agoI wouldn't be surprised if Google pushes its own iOS marketplace: first by making an exclusive Blink-based Chrome to get people to open up their phones if they want to download "the real Chrome". Then there is little friction to get people to install more (because the hard part is already done), and they could even merge Android and iOS into a single marketplace for mobile apps.
- wiseowise 4y ago> I wouldn't be surprised if Google pushes its own iOS marketplace: first by making an exclusive Blink-based Chrome to get people to open up their phones if they want to download "the real Chrome". Who even cares about Chrome on iOS? https://gs.statcounter.com/browser-market-share/mobile/north-america https://gs.statcounter.com/browser-market-share/mobile/north...
- Kwpolska 4y agoPeople who want their bookmarks and tabs synced between desktop Chrome and mobile?
- wiseowise 4y agoAnd that amounts to 5-10%?
- jeroenhd 4y agoThat's several million people.
- wiseowise 4y agoFortnite has that, it wasn't enough to threaten Google monopoly on Android.
- KaoruAoiShiho 4y ago
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoDo they determine that you are in Europe by the credit card you attached to the App store? Seems easy to fake.
- seydor 4y agoSideloading should be mandatory and opt-in. Arguing that it should be closed is basically people wanting to control other people's computers (even though that is a popular opinion in this "hacker" forum). It's going to be interesting when some sideloaded app starts becoming popular and e.g. americans miss out on it. I can already imagine a lot of AI and nsfw stuff in that category
- vrglvrglvrgl 4y ago[dead]
- anomaly_ 4y agoWall Europe off and let them suffer their government regulated mobile phone. Anyone cheering this has a short memory.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- peoplefromibiza 4y agothat's a textbook example of a punishment that in reality is a long awaited gift. Edit: funny that people on HN, that should be smart enough to know about the World, imagine that everything that it's not from the USA must be automatically coming from Stalin. Like no other place in the World has industries, it's either US products or the government making stuff. If Apple stops selling devices in Europe I will celebrate, for us Europeans that's the opposite of something we are worried about. We'll buy them from Samsung or some Chinese manufacturer, who cares.
- jeffybefffy519 4y agoI wonder how the apple store operates in the EU on devices that have sideloaded apps. Theres a bunch of liability apple can effectively shift to the end user everytime without question “sorry you sideloaded this app which may have given your malware, we cant help you”. It’s ridiculous i know but also seems plausible.
- jacquesm 4y agoThat's fine, as long as they stick to the hardware warranty requirements as spelled out in the law.
- AniseAbyss 4y ago[dead]
- flohofwoe 4y agoSince this is an example of increasing individual freedom at the cost of corporate freedom, I wonder about the silence of US citizens about the whole topic. I always thought the 'land of the free' slogan is about individuals, not companies ;)
- solarkraft 4y ago(american voice) You're free to buy another product!
- _piif 4y agoSo I have a choice between a walled garden (for my best interests of course) and straight up spyware - unless of course I'm willing to play a game of "where's waldo" where I find the perfect combination of android phone with a model number which does not have a locked bootloader, good prolonged community support, custom ROMs with a good reputation and not just a bunch of modifications thrown together by some random XDA user, no weird hardware attestation shenanigans and then participating in the eternal cat and mouse game of SafetyNet breaking my apps because I am not running on a supported configuration (again for my best interests). How flattering. I know your reply was meant to be satire but I've heard that argument used legit for this case many times. I just don't know how it can be taken seriously in a duopoly like this - unless they are seriously considering GNU/Linux phones to be ready as a primary daily driver or want me to carry around a dumb phone instead?
- solarkraft 4y ago(still american voice) You're free to make your own phone company! Just break the duopoly and get rich! (american voice off) I'm still on the lookout for an equivalent example of consumer friendly regulation that (even) americans are typically behind or at least indifferent towards.
- standing_user 4y agoIt's the land of the free until you touch the turf of some lobby or the interests of a big company then you can see the average Joe on social media, maybe not on HN, that would fight on the internet ring defending the same companies that are triyng to screw him over It's amusing to watch
- solarkraft 4y ago> In addition, developers may have to pay extra if they want their apps to be available outside of the iOS App Store If Apple gets a say in what I "sideload" (it's called installing), that's against the spirit of the law. Hopefully the EU lawmakers were competent enough to also make it against the text of the law. It would be outrageous.
- Vosporos 4y agoAnother W for Europe
- MagicMoonlight 4y agoIf you want to continue to browse this website, please download MetaBrowse from the Meta Store.
- jug 4y agoSo only Europeans get to play Secret of Monkey Island on ScummVM? Well I guess I'm grateful for being a Swede but this will feel weird...
- Sporktacular 4y agoI wonder if security code will now become region-specific too. It would be a terrible pity if stats go on to show EU devices got hacked more than their Apple Store-only equivalents right around the time they opened up. Not saying they would, but maybe something to watch out for.
- ly3xqhl8g9 4y agoThat's good and all but when can we expect such a revolutionary feature as listening to two apps at the same time? Or at least not having the Podcasts app stop because some video autoplays in the browser. The fact that Apple still stubbornly calls this 30% fee-generator pretext an "operating system", shameless. (Been using an iPhone only for 3-5 core apps, Phone/messaging, Camera, browser, Podcasts, for a decade)
- sdze 4y ago[dead]
- wahnfrieden 4y agoThis was reported months ago.
- culopatin 4y agoI hope we are able to develop a jvm for Apple so I can run Java apps. Probably a great thing for old enterprise apps but also for me to use an iPad to tune my ECU. The program runs on anything that runs Java but not iOS
- stainablesteel 4y agosad about the difference but glad to see all the EU laws won't necessarily screw up the internet again for everyone else
- kranke155 4y agoThe EU is bureaucratic and technocratic but it’s got more hits than misses for me. (Am European)
- counttheforks 4y agoMore proof that Apple should be broken up. Split them in two, a hardware company and a software company.
- leoh 4y agoSuperior functionality exclusively in the EU — USB-C, side-loading — is a good thing. It will remind US folks that the law is a powerful mechanism for making simple, non-controversial changes that improve everyone’s quality of life; but which corporations would otherwise refuse to accept. BTW — LAAS (lobbying-as-a-service) should probably exist.
- dagorenouf 4y agoUsb-c sounds cool for now. But what about when a new port comes out and Apple can’t use it because the EU still mandates to use the old one?
- herbstein 4y agoYou mean like when everyone moved from mini-USB to USB-C? It's also good to remember that lightning connectors are USB2 in a different form factor - outdated and slow.
- candiodari 4y agoOh you're giving lightning connectors too little credit. They also come with a LOT of logic to prevent people from charging their Apple devices with unapproved chargers. All added on top of USB 2 (and definitely against the standard, one might add) Like a lot of Apple and huge company stuff in general, it's a flimsy reason to change something and introduce many limitations the huge company thinks will make them more money. It sure as hell is not about reversible connectors.
- evilduck 4y agoWhat? I've plugged lightning cables into pretty much any imaginable sort of USB-A socket over than last decade and have never encountered one that wouldn't supply a charge specifically to a lightning cable. Please, be specific with what limitations you're referring to because this is counter to all evidence I've ever been witness to.
- hamilyon2 4y agoIs something like early days mobile app development gold rush likely to happen? There is likely an enormous market for unofficial clients, foss games, game engines, emulators, and of course torrenting of all kinds. Will European iPhone sales skyrocket? Will you be able to change region if you move to Europe? So many interesting questions.
- mrkramer 4y agoApple's exclusivity on allowing and deciding what goes on the AppStore and on the iOS was their way of controlling the user experience and their way to ensure future sales of iPhones. They didn't want that iOS, AppStore and iPhones get flooded with low quality apps. Similar way of thinking that I know of was Valve and Steam, where Steam users needed to Greenlit a game before it came to the Steam store. Imo Steam had a better approach because it was community based not exclusive like Apple had and has. The story of Jobs' and Apple's skyhigh care for privacy and security was more of a propaganda and a marketing strategy than a true care for users' safety.
- layer8 4y ago> They didn't want that iOS, AppStore and iPhones get flooded with low quality apps. Well, they failed in that.
- mikenew 4y agoThe major difference is that I can install whatever the hell I want on my own PC (including my Steam Deck!). Apple has an exclusive store and an exclusive device.
- mrkramer 4y agoI never used an iPhone and I don't really know how horrible it is but if people are annoyed with iOS and iPhone, they can always use Android devices. Android devices are on a par with iPhones unlike 10 years ago.
- ikurei 4y ago> Similar way of thinking that I know of was Valve and Steam, where Steam users needed to Greenlit a game before it came to the Steam store. Not the same at all. You can install whatever you want on the Steam Deck. I'd fine with Apple just curating their App Store; I am not fine with them deciding what software I can run on "my" device.
- mrkramer 4y ago
- fatBatman 4y ago[dead]
- jaChEWAg 4y agoI think once they allow sideloading, folks in the open source community will eventually figure out ways to unlock it for other regions.
- LoverKiddo12 4y ago[dead]
- LoverKiddo12 4y ago[dead]
- BadKarma234 4y ago[dead]
- BadKarma234 4y ago[dead]
- BadKarma234 4y ago[dead]
- BadKarma234 4y ago[dead]
- averagestudent3 4y ago[dead]
- YellowSnowman 4y ago[dead]
- chin_chillin 4y ago[dead]
- oprahwindfury 4y ago[dead]
- OP_rah 4y ago[dead]
- HeartTicker 4y ago[dead]
- YESIMFUNNY 4y ago[dead]
- unfriendme 4y ago[dead]
- babydoodles 4y ago[dead]
- fluffycookie 4y ago[dead]
- ManEatsPants 4y ago[dead]
- baeconandeggz 4y ago[dead]
- coolshirtbra 4y ago[dead]
- kim_chi 4y ago[dead]
- bigfootisreal 4y ago[dead]
- SaintBroseph 4y ago[dead]
- iNeed2p 4y ago[dead]
- FrostedCupcake 4y ago[dead]
- PaniniHead 4y ago[dead]
- catsordogs 4y ago[dead]
- FartnRoses 4y ago[dead]
- RedMonkeyButt 4y ago[dead]
- FreeHugz 4y ago[dead]
- actuallythedog 4y ago[dead]
- LtDansLegs 4y ago[dead]
- WookiesrPpl2 4y ago[dead]
- CountSwagula 4y ago[dead]
- Coco_loco 4y ago[dead]
- Coco_loco 4y ago[dead]
- Veranorooz 4y ago[dead]
- LaTatiana 4y ago[dead]
- DorkyDweeb 4y ago[dead]
- HilariousRed 4y ago[dead]
- MamaHuh 4y ago[dead]
- Jabbahutt 4y ago[dead]
- givemethrill 4y ago[dead]
- musclehuman 4y ago[dead]
- smokeygun 4y ago[dead]
- hulknsmash 4y ago[dead]
- hulknsmash 4y ago[dead]
- ruggedheart 4y ago[dead]
- fastflash 4y ago[dead]
- jockxxtreme 4y ago[dead]
- soulcreaper 4y ago[dead]
- tornadoxbattler 4y ago[dead]
- ziggyxstardust 4y ago[dead]
- viking2striking 4y ago[dead]
- PreciousPenny 4y ago[dead]
- PatootieRu 4y ago[dead]
- BlondieZ 4y ago[dead]
- Switcharoo 4y ago[dead]
- CheekyBum 4y ago[dead]
- SupDiana 4y ago[dead]
- GorgGorl 4y ago[dead]
- JollyJester 4y ago[dead]
- MagicMaker55 4y ago[dead]
- UniLove 4y ago[dead]