29 ms·
GitHub Copilot X – Sign up for technical preview
- winstonprivacy 4y agoNo support for jetbrains? Having a chat plugin directly in the IDE would save me a crazy amount of time.
- veec_cas_tant 4y agoThe video[1] shows JetBrains at 31 seconds: "All in your favorite editor" [1] https://youtu.be/4RfD5JiXt3A?t=31 https://youtu.be/4RfD5JiXt3A?t=31
- mikkelam 4y agoI have absolutely loved copilot so far. I especially love how fast it handles indexing complex n-dimensional arrays, which I'm really bad at. I also feel like often pushes me to more formal solutions instead of hacking. I'd estimate a 10% velocity increase for me with it. Super excited for GPT-4 behind it.
- retrocryptid 4y agoI was going to say "blergh. that doesn't sound too complex." But... we all are better at some things than others and I really like that you've highlighted a specific issue where you find it valuable.
- knodi123 4y agoMy team was freaking out about copilot because we're conducting tech interviews right now, with a take home exam and some pairing sessions, and they're worried we'll hire a bonehead because he can make copilot spit out reasonable stuff in our contrived and simple interview scenarios. But we finally had a guy whose take home test had tons of handling in the controller for cases we weren't even using, and test coverage of things that couldn't possibly fail, or were actually part of the core language and not our own code. It was really obvious! And when I wanted him to fix an SQL Injection problem in our pairing, copilot carefully preserved the bug while he was moving code around. Made me chuckle.
- hislaziness 4y agoCopilot with GPT-4 model, chat and voice, pull requests, command line, and docs to answer questions.
- nico 4y agoAre you doing that? Any specific tools/services you use for it?
- retinaros 4y agodo you see this as a tool to increase productivity in a way that shareholders ask for leaner team or in a way that it creates more demand for products and devs?
- swader999 4y agoOne should expect both.
- digdugdirk 4y agoBut since the question was asked about shareholders specifically, the guaranteed bottom line improvement is going to come from cutting labor and running leaner teams. That's where large corporations will go first.
- geraneum 4y agoThat's the main idea behind developing such systems. It's telling execs: Hey, look, you are paying a lot of money to those pesky workers (i.e. developers) and we like that number. Give us a cut and we save you a lot of money. This is nothing new actually. Has happened over and over in other industries and is not really surprising. What happens is that a lot of added value that the developers were generating will be consolidated into the pockets of a few and the rest will be automated. They businesses cannot be upset about this because the ultimate goal of a business is not be your friend but to generate more money and one way is to reduce costs.
- dangerwill 4y agoIncreased productivity usually leads to cutting team size instead of expanding scope. A lot easier to justify doing the same work you have been doing with less, as opposed to doing new work with the same number of people.
- anticensor 4y agoYes, possibly because it is riskier to get to more fields of work than do the same work with less effort.
- digdugdirk 4y agoHere. We. Go. I made the analogy a few days ago about how all modern manufacturing and machining processes were essentially bootstrapped from two fairly flat stones. Its going to be interesting to see how the acceleration in improvement of the tools for "making things" changes in the LLM age.
- hobs 4y agoI love the "Origins of Precision" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gNRnrn5DE58 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gNRnrn5DE58 that goes into this very topic.
- dw_arthur 4y agoThere's something really satisfying about using a tool that makes you more productive, even more so if you built the tool.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoStochastic Markov Monte Carlo cut and paste is clearly more powerful than deterministic cut and paste.
- retrocryptid 4y agoI think the gnu emacs code base is proof of this statement. I'm fairly certain they fed the source into disassociated press and kept doing it until it compiled.
- danielvaughn 4y agoAgreed, I think we're entering the 4th era of the internet (as I see it). The first era was pre-consumer (arpanet etc). The second era had internet installed in several homes across the country, but it still wasn't clear what the internet was going to become, and it was still considered an oddity. This was roughly 1990-the mid aughts. The third era saw the internet become socially viable - myspace, facebook, twitter, instagram all took over peoples lives. This roughly coincided with the release of smart phones, as well as the increased computing power of browsers, spurred mostly by V8. For the last few years there's been this implicit expectation that we're entering into a new era, but it wasn't clear what that era would be. For a minute, people thought it was crypto/metaverse, but that was always kind of a silly idea. It's now clear that AI is going to be the catalyst, and I think it's ushering in something equivalent to the industrial revolution, but starting from where we are now. It's just impossible to fathom where we're going to go from here.
- BratishkaErik 4y agoAnother reason to switch from GitHub, I don't want to strengthen this ecosystem. AI-generated description for PR? gg. IMHO it will drastically reduce real productivity for those who will remain on this platform (but still increasing whatever fake metric [accepted pull requests? stars?] people love to check)
- sebzim4500 4y ago>IMHO it will drastically reduce real productivity for those who will remain on this platform Why do you believe this? Everyone I know who has used copilot has found it made them more productive. Admittedly, reports differ wildly on how much more productive from ~10% to ~100%.
- BratishkaErik 4y agosorry if i was unclear, by "real productivity" i meant something that requires more creativity than copypasting stackoverflow/copilot to your code, not measured in "lines of code" but rather in how much it is unique. Highly subjective, yes...
- elil17 4y agoRight, but the idea is that copilot frees up more of your time for the creative part. That is what I have found in practice.
- yunohn 4y ago> rather in how much it is unique IRL a lot of what people do is rehashing or gluing together things as others may have done before. We all stand on the shoulder of giants - code is a tool to enable an outcome. I don’t agree with your definition of “code uniqueness is productivity”.
- jwhiles 4y agoWhat's the reason to think that it reduces the amount of creative code that's written. Doesn't it just let you get through the copypastable stuff faster - all things being equal I'd assume it means you spend more time on the creative parts.
- amelius 4y agoStackoverflow should be afraid.
- erdaniels 4y agoIf you think about it, it's likely that much of the code Copilot is trained on comes from stackoverflow Q/A that made its way into open source GtiHub projects
- la64710 4y agoThis is clearly a case when an idea is oversold and everybody starts to blabber the same thing. Lose all the arguments to git cli because of an AI chat interface?
- ren_engineer 4y agoMicrosoft really seems to have wrapped up the developer ecosystem with VS Code and the Github acquisition combined with OpenAI. They are going to have an absurd amount of data to optimize their models thanks to that, not sure how other AI focused companies can overcome that have to wonder at what point developers remember how anti-developer Microsoft used to be and potentially move away from their ecosystem. Credit to Microsoft's PR team for somehow managing to turn around public opinion about them, it's an all timer
- gonehome 4y agoMicrosoft is a so well positioned on this I think Silicon Valley has forgotten what it looks like when they don’t have a horrible CEO. When Microsoft executes well, they’re a scary force. They were exceptional under Gates and it looks like they are again. There’s a massive paradigm shift we’re just at the beginning of and Microsoft has been putting pieces in place for the last couple of years. Nadella has really turned things around for them. Google and meta are scrambling. Things should get interesting.
- bredren 4y agoIf it were not for the impending headset, Apple would look a wee bit caught out as well. I suspect once Apple turns toward gen ai, all of its other advantages (infra, hw, instal base, services, etc) will propel it to forefront.
- gonehome 4y agoApple has always had its own hardware based silo to some extent (excellent products and design, fully integrated). Still, I suspect the AI stuff will be hard for them. They were first to market with Siri and it’s still trash 13yrs(?!) later. It’s always been what they’re weakest at, I’m not sure LLMs will be different for them. The headset could still give them a nice hardware platform advantage though if that UX becomes the main new interface.
- 4y ago
- erdaniels 4y agoHow have people been thinking about licensing and attribution when it comes to using AI code assistance tools like this? In my personal work, I'm avoiding it since being trained on "publicly available code from GitHub" feels too risky for me if I were to say accidentally pull in GPL code to a private project.
- mnd999 4y agoI wouldn’t touch it with a barge pole for this reason.
- _bohm 4y agoI have been using it on a fairly large project, and in practice I find it rarely, if ever, spits out anything other than something that resembles what I would have written next anyways, taking context clues from the file I'm editing.
- packetlost 4y agoYeah, this is my experience too. You can prod it into generating code that exactly matches something from the training data, but it seems like you have to really try.
- netr0ute 4y agoThat's exactly why my projects are GPL, so I don't have to worry about that.
- mnd999 4y agoNot all public code on GitHub is licensed in a GPL compatible way.
- dijit 4y agoSomeone asked me to pay for a team subscription for Copilot. As I'm CTO (and thus legally responsible for those agreements that you normally just click through); I read the terms of service, and they do not actually grant license to the code. They say in very clear terms: YOU ARE RESPONSIBLE FOR TAKING SUGGESTIONS. So, as I don't want to encourage people to think that they can simply copy over copilot solutions I decided against buying access to it, even though I am quite certain it would have boosted developer productivity. (and goodwill, people like shiny!). I was also a little concerned because it is additionally the case that a AI is confidently incorrect sometimes, so there are suggestions that have subtle and hard to see bugs. I really don't really want to hear that a bug is caused by AI, since from my perspective the whole point of you being paid a handsome salary comparable to a doctor is because you take responsibility for the code you write; which is actually somewhat in-line with the Copilot license agreement[0] [0]: https://github.com/customer-terms/github-copilot-product-specific-terms https://github.com/customer-terms/github-copilot-product-spe...
- digdugdirk 4y agoWith increases in productivity from systems like this, and a guaranteed bottom line improvement from cutting labor and running leaner teams, has anyone here heard of any large corporations using LLM's as an excuse for headcount reduction yet? In all honesty, I wouldn't be surprised if this has already played a large behind the scenes role in the layoffs at Google/Microsoft.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoEveryone I know is understaffed. I think the outcome is roadmaps deliver more reliably not reduce headcount.
- moneywoes 4y agoSeems strange with all the layoffs
- fnordpiglet 4y agoThat’s companies preparing for the artificial recession the fed is launching us into to ensure Twinkie’s don’t cost $0.05 more.
- zeroonetwothree 4y agoSometimes thinking that you are understaffed is actually caused by being overstaffed. The reason is that having a lot of people introduces tons of overheads and coordination costs, that reduce your time for your main work.
- symlinkk 4y agoLol the cope here is unbelievable. Let me guess, the people that are “just overhead” and “reduces time for main work” are everyone else, not you, right?
- shmatt 4y agoI work at a big tech company and there is a complete ban on coding using LLMs. The fear is sending our code for the model to learn in the future. This is also why then hype around GTP4-powered Office is overhyped. Very rarely will a corporation be OK with GPT-4 running inferences on their internal documents and excel sheets Until an on-prem solution is offered, many of these companies won't get anything out of the technology The layoffs at big tech are caused by un-even profit generating, Where 5% or 20% of the company generate 99.9% of income. The rest are essentially startups being funded by rich VCs. Eventually if you don't find PMF the VC cuts the funding
- yanis_t 4y agoGod, only yesterday there was a comment by someone, that Copilot will eventually move to gpt4. So eventually = just 1 day. Things move so fast these days.
- bpodgursky 4y agoNo JetBrains in the preview :(
- gbuckingham89 4y agoThis is a big disappointment
- mewmew07 4y agohow is this big? it's a preview for new features, calm down
- bpodgursky 4y agoIt's big because I want it now!
- eawlot3000 4y agothe future is here. lets gooo
- cpb 4y agoBetter PR descriptions explain why.
- elil17 4y agoYesterday, Copilot could not write a program with SymPy, which is a library for doing symbolic math in Python. (e.g., it would consistently confuse symbols in equations with Python variables). Today it uses SymPy as well as it uses NumPy (occasional mistakes, but overall it has the right idea). Absolutely astounding.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoI don’t think people understand the hockey stick we’re on. Don’t focus too hard on the failings, look at the scaffolding being rapidly deployed that makes the iterative improvement process exceptionally tight.
- brookst 4y agoIt’s the same with every paradigm shift. “GUIs are pretty but slow. Ok, they’re faster but just glued on to CLI programs. Ok, they’re native but less information dense. Ok, that’s a good thing, but…” “The internet is nice but you still have to go to the store/bank. Ok, you can shop/bank online but you still have to call airlines. Ok you can buy airline tickets but you still have to go to the library to research. Ok, you can research but you still have to drive in to work. Ok…” Maybe it’s a half empty / half full thing, but there is some portion of the populace that can’t acknowledge the promise of anything until it is perfect and comprehensive. And, yes, there’s another portion that can’t acknowledge gaps or flaws of the promise is sufficiently huge. But it’s the former that grinds my gears.
- darkwater 4y agoI'm speaking more generally but > Maybe it’s a half empty / half full thing, but there is some portion of the populace that can’t acknowledge the promise of anything until it is perfect and comprehensive. Probably because paradigm shifts or new ways of doing things come with a lot of trade-offs that can be seen only after the change has been absorbed more. Early adopters are usually blind to these issues (or decide to be blind at them), conservatives don't look at the improvements but think that there might be something not that good in the future by projecting past experiences.
- aldarisbm 4y agoAt which point do we not need to understand what is in front of us? eg: The Code. I was using chatgpt, with a groovy project (havent used groovy in years), I prompted chatgpt for an answer, and it gave me a solution. The solution (to me) was a bit obfuscated, but it worked. Since I'm only using groovy to figure out this one task, it would've been extremely easy for me to not check what the solution did, and just keep going with my day. Luckily, I'm curious and wanted to know how things worked. What if we increasingly stop to care, because of the confidence instilled by the media. "It can make errors" but also "This show SIGNIFICANT improvements over last generation (which tbh was pretty okay)" A lot of dis/misinformation. I like using copilot/chatgpt, but it's incredibly hard to believe that we wont just become 100% reliant on this tool, and coding will be something akin to assembly code to engineers.
- jnovek 4y agoOne hypothesis I have is that the future of programming is natural language and the “compiler” is a LLM. This would be no different from the days when C took over for asm.
- NeuNeurosis 4y agoThis was my take on the tech. Ultimately it will need to be prompted. Now the form that prompt takes is open to a bunch of speculation but even if it gets superhuman at producing code or any output it is directionless by itself, for now. We are what direct its ability, which I think is really cool. I think getting good at extracting exact outputs from the LLM will be the new engineer.
- layer8 4y agoThe difference is that natural language doesn't have a well-defined semantics and is open to interpretation. Programming languages being compiled, on the other hand, have precise, well-defined semantics (excluding UB I guess) that you can formally reason about. Using an LLM for programming is not like compiling, it's like employing a developer you either have to trust how they may happen to interpret your instructions, or to manually double-check their work.
- elevenoh 4y ago[dead]
- w-m 4y agoI tried getting myself on the CLI waitlist (https://githubnext.com/projects/copilot-cli/ https://githubnext.com/projects/copilot-cli/). That they use ffmpeg as the example hits a huge pain point for me. But: "Next Waitlist by GitHub Next would like permission to: Act on your behalf Not owned or operated by GitHub" Why does signing up for a waitlist require me to give permissions to an app to act in my account? An app that isn't even officially from GitHub? This sets a bad example for permission requests, getting people to just click through the dialog, which requests too much access, and from the wrong domain.
- Bedon292 4y agoI was wondering the same thing. It seems like it is labeled weirdly since it is part of GitHub, but definitely was triple checking what was going on with that.
- envy2 4y agoI think this is just a standard API access prompt. The GitHub Next page clearly indicates it is (C) GitHub Inc and the blog post makes GitHub's control clear.
- retrocryptid 4y agoWell. That's what the AI wants you to believe.
- madeofpalk 4y ago> The GitHub Next page clearly indicates it is (C) GitHub Inc and the blog post makes GitHub's control clear. This is not clear at all. Phishing websites always say (C) Bank of America. That doesn't make it legit.
- macNchz 4y agoIt's interesting because the Copilot for PRs preview uses an app that does say "Owned and Operated by GitHub". Probably just an oversight, but I'm pretty sensitive about what access GitHub apps have, especially given the list of major attacks that have happened in recent years that were initiated by someone sneaking malicious payloads in somewhere along the development pipeline. Curious why they'd use a totally different domain in the first place–how much access do you think you could get to private repos just by cloning that page onto githubfuture.com (available) and spearphishing interesting targets?
- dougmwne 4y agoSomething interesting is that there is no mention of fine-tuning. Is GPT-4 so good at general tasks out of the box that fine-tuning is obsolete? Can one model really be equally good at Python and poetry?
- famouswaffles 4y agoFinetuning has been more or less obsolete for LLMs since the introduction of GPT-3. This was a major discovery of the original paper. Codex-Davinci only existed because the original gpt wasn't trained on much code not because a version trained on sufficient code would need special code optimizations/fine-tuning. and yes, LLMs are general intelligences. there is nothing narrow about them at all
- flangola7 4y ago>Is GPT-4 so good at general tasks out of the box that fine-tuning is obsolete? Can one model really be equally good at Python and poetry? This is correct. It is able to generalize across domains intelligently. Given the results of fine tuning in earlier models, fine tuning GPT-4 for a specific purpose will probably produce super-human ability.
- throwaway4good 4y agoVoice support? Can I get this thing to call into a teams meeting? (Asking for a friend.)
- m_ke 4y agoPeople should keep in mind that these human in the loop AI systems are built to learn from the human until they’re good enough to replace them.
- jnovek 4y agoDo you have evidence to back these claims? Specifically that AI will be replacing software engineers any time soon and that Copilot exists explicitly to gather data towards that purpose.
- m_ke 4y agoI’ve been working on ML systems like that for the last 10 years, usually as tools to automate boring data entry tasks like tagging photos, automating food logging, giving dietary advice. At first these tools offer suggestions, but as more data comes in they start to do parts of the work autonomously, until they can handle all cases. Stable diffusion will replace a ton of paid design work, self driving cars will at some point replace most drivers.
- make3 4y agoWell it's hard to argue against the idea that the final aim of Copilot is to automate as much of software engineering as possible. I don't think that their aim is explicitly to replace humans, but to be as helpful as possible to developers, but doing that does exactly the other thing
- highwaylights 4y agoUntil they're good enough to liquidate them for fuel. FTFY.
- ilaksh 4y agoI am building my system https://aidev.codes https://aidev.codes and adding virtual servers to allow back-end code with the explicit goal of selling this service to end-users as an alternative to hiring software engineers. In the niche I have previously been working in, there is a huge demand to build fairly complex integrations (such as with my other service) without an adequate budget to hire a person. I already know at least one designer who previously would have considered hiring me for something but now has explained that they are achieving tasks with ChatGPT. Especially when you start to understand the reasoning ability of GPT-4, what the 32k context window and ability to understand images means, any software engineer who thinks their job will remain safe is in complete denial. In fact, with this release you will start to see quite a lot of non-programmers start using Github. Within X months or a few years, its quite feasible that Microsoft will have a software engineer built into Windows.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yanis_t 4y agoOn the negative side, no mentions of the Vim plugin update so far.
- simonvc 4y agovim mode in vscode is good enough honestly. i've not booted vim for anything other than quick hacks in ages. 99% of the time i `code` now instead of `vi`
- eterps 4y agoI am guessing that at some point a class of programming languages will be designed that is both optimal to generate by LLMs and easy to read/understand for humans. Right now most PLs are optimized for writing code by humans.
- gwoolhurme 4y agoThat is what makes them also optimal for LLMs as is. It would be more efficient to have something that is direct machine code, but LLMs are Large <Language> Models right?
- AlexandrB 4y ago> easy to read/understand for humans I think many languages are actually already optimized for this. Where "reading" means reasoning about what the program does and not just reading text.
- brookst 4y agoDo we even need such a language, beyond just English / other human languages? IMO we’ll see LLM interpreters / compilers where the spec is the code, and whatever the LLM does in the background is opaque to the “programmer”.
- stuckinhell 4y agoI have some interesting stories from writing a report about a couple teams using AI pair programming for development at my firm. I'm seeing experienced senior developers use the AI to context switch like lightning. They know when the AI is bullshitting them, but they can use that seed to "jumpstart" their memories. Junior developers doing very domain specific tasks are taking longer to develop using the AI. However boilerplate work is speed up significantly.
- nixpulvis 4y agoThe first video in this post is a perfect example of the problems I see in this space. First the programmer asks the AI to nebulously "fix the bug". Then the AI spits out an answer faster than anyone can read and prompts you to integrate it. Sure I can pause the video... but this is terrible marketing and dangerous practice. The PR autocomplete is just braindead development at it's conclusion.
- nixpulvis 4y agoGitHub Copilot for CLI however, seems exciting. Ask a question for how to execute a command, get an answer with description of the options needed. Explicit and easy, cool. Still doesn't build the muscle/mind memory of finding it yourself, but could serve as a reasonable substitute for `tldr`.
- endisneigh 4y agoit's interesting to try and reconcile the anti-big-tech zeitgeist with the pro big-tech AI offerings such as this. fun times
- fwlr 4y ago“developers can verbally give natural language prompts.” One more reason to demand remote work. I really do not want to be sitting next to the guy who spends 8 hours talking to his computer.
- nlh 4y agoI think you may be missing the intended audience for this — it’s aimed at folks who are visually or otherwise impaired and cannot type using a traditional keyboard/input device.
- adzm 4y agoThe accessibility potential of AI is vastly understated. I expect this to fill that niche perfectly. The difference would be life changing for millions of people.
- polyterative 4y agoI suffer from chronic pain in my hands because I have been programming non stop for the past five years. this really gives me hope to recover without losing my job
- fwlr 4y agoSpeaking to your computer is just as valid as typing into it! I have auditory processing issues, mentally processing speech takes up a significant fraction of my cognitive resources and I don’t really have the ability to just tune it out. Constantly hearing one half of a conversation would impair my ability to work almost as much as being forced to use a keyboard would impair the person who’s talking. I would be asking to work remote or private so that my needs aren’t in conflict with their needs. (Not that you could have guessed this was the case just from my comment, but that’s why I said “I really don’t want…” and not “People really shouldn’t be…”.)
- ImaCake 4y agoI use noise cancelling headphones for this. It's not perfect, but it helps a lot.
- mmaia 4y agoHuge impact for commercial open source projects. I'm thinking that it could even change incentives for companies to open source more projects.
- lovasoa 4y agoGitHub Copilot X is currently a representation of GitHub’s vision for the future rather than an available product offering of GitHub Copilot. As we continue to design, test, and build features that fall into the GitHub Copilot X vision, we are also taking the time to determine the best way to provide them to our customers.
- sqs 4y agoFrom https://github.com/features/preview/copilot-x https://github.com/features/preview/copilot-x (FAQ: When will GitHub Copilot X be available and how much does it cost?)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- retrocryptid 4y agoBut for the fact that it would likely get me permabanned, I would suggest making HackerNews Copilot X, the system that responds to HN posts and comments on your behalf and in a manner guaranteed to get more upvotes from other AIbots hanging out in internet comments forums.
- retrocryptid 4y agoI see that the AI bot has already down-voted this comment.
- w-m 4y agoWhat I'd love to see in the future is a proper refactoring UX. This new chat interface is probably a good start, as it seems able to replace code blocks in your original source file. But most code changes in the real world require changes in multiple locations. And I don't usually have questions for the AI, I have small tasks for it to do. I hope we can get to a point where I can give quick commands to a Copilot-like system to do more complex changes. Changes which traditional refactoring tools balk at. Stuff you would discuss with other humans. Like "this value needs to be calculated once, move the code to the constructor", which then requires code being removed in one method, a member variable being created, and possibly a constructor, and some code being moved there, and perhaps a few changes in method parameter lists. The jump from single-point edits to multi-point edits is obviously a huge one, not only for the AI part, but also for the UI (being able to understand, accept or modify the changes, for the human). That for me would be truly next level (up from the amazing place where we are already with Copilot), and I can't wait for it to get there.
- ilaksh 4y agoThere are multiple startups for this. You can test the concept on my site https://aidev.codes https://aidev.codes although I don't have github integration yet.
- salt4034 4y agoI agree. Before finalizing the changes, the AI could show you the diff and ask "is this what you had in mind or would you like me to change anything else?"
- jchw 4y agoNot very impressed with either Copilot or ChatGPT for programming purposes. I'm sure it will be interesting for some people, but whenever I really feel like I could benefit from an intelligent AI, it usually falls flat. Most commonly, it will just generate calls that don't exist, and if you try to get it to implement them, it will write bullshit. Now the thing is, maybe it really does improve developer productivity by virtue of letting the developer autocomplete boring things. To be fair, I did see some opportunity here. But on the other hand, it also seemed to harm productivity, as I had to carefully review everything it did, and eventually had to disable Copilot so that it would stop annoying me with nonsense completions every time I stopped typing. I'm not really sure if language models are actually getting closer to what we really want, or if they're getting closer to some other maxima that just looks similar. Clearly they're doing something that is novel and probably even useful, but with increasing parameter counts it seems that the underlying problems are not changing. Something certainly seems like it must be fundamentally wrong...
- thebackup 4y agoI second this. My impressions so far are pretty much the same. Have been trying to get ChatGPT to generate code for some algorithms that are pretty close to well known implementations but with some twists and it absolutely fails no matter how much I tried to provide hints to change the suggestions it gave me. In the end I just went back to hand coding them since it actually saves me the frustration of trying to get ChatGPT to bend in the direction I need.
- retrocryptid 4y agoSo if MSFT's message here is "software engineers don't have to know how to code," what's the value of knowing how to code? Seems at odds with their core customers' self interests.
- make3 4y agoit's totally not the message, weird that you would say this; this is a tool just to make the developers' lives easier
- retrocryptid 4y agoThat doesn't seem (to me) to be how it's being advertised to corporate clients.
- hu3 4y agoScary. For the first time in my life, I feel like my expertise is at risk of being rendered obsolete. Maybe not this year, but the writing is on the wall. Soon coding without an AI will feel as antiquated as delivering food by horse. And resistance is futile because markets will punish those who refuse. We'll probably need less and less developers as AI advance. Just like we need less manual labor in farms today. And coding is just one of the many applications where AI can replace brains. Governments will have to ponder about what to do with a world of people who became inferior to machines at almost everything. Universal Basic Income? It's amazing and terrifying at the same time. Perhaps our first contact with an alien will be with one we created ourselves.
- cidergal 4y agoThere is something to say about how we will not push UBI until automation comes for our job.
- fn-mote 4y ago> For the first time in my life, I feel like my expertise is at risk of being rendered obsolete. Maybe not this year, but the writing is on the wall. My expertise is in designing, understanding, and debugging complex systems. I will just apply my expertise to the AI. Another angle: just think of how many mom and pop shops are still contracting out to get web sites, and not getting what we consider quality. Now maybe you're going to see a larger and larger gap between F500 companies and the rest (surely you do already), but playing out the consequences is a long and interesting story. > coding without AI will feel as antiquated and inefficient [...]. And resistance is futile because markets will punish those who refuse. Fortunately, the "punishment" by the market will just be reduced salaries. Move out of the Bay Area now. :) > And coding is just one of the many applications where AI an replace brains. And writing about those is interesting. With the development of DALL-E (etc), I would say coding isn't even the primary interesting application. (If "it's not AI", whatever... that's not the point.) Or not yet.
- teaearlgraycold 4y agoNah, I’ll leave the bay once salaries drop. Not years before.
- azemetre 4y agoIt doesn't say it in the blog post, but sign up to the preview does require a paid subscription to copilot. Unsure if this applies to those who are given copilot for free (doesn't apply to me as I pay).
- cristiioan 4y agoI was able to apply with my student account(it has copilot and pro for free).
- vbezhenar 4y agoI'm not impressed with this announcement. What I miss with Copilot is not reflected there: 1. Separate hotkeys to accept either single token from the suggestion or single line. Often Copilot tries to autocomplete 50 lines method which I'm not happy with. 2. Ability to edit existing text. It only inserts new text. I'd like something like multiple cursors or macroses working automagically by recognising similar text patterns below current position and applying similar edits. 3. AI linting. If some code looks obviously wrong, I'd like to know about it.
- kumarvvr 4y agoA curious question. Would it be possible to build LLMs off of bytecode / compiled code, and then translate it back to different programming language codes? Is that a viable way to get more fine-tuned outputs from these models?
- mad0 4y agoI don't think so, bytecode / machine code must be really precise, while LLMs are producing nondeterministic outputs (at least GPT). Add "hallucinating" of the output to the pile and right now I think it's infeasible.
- Someone1234 4y agoJust to save others from wasting their time (and free trial): The Copilot extension in full Visual Studio (i.e. NOT VS Code) is super terrible, broken, and buggy. It is so bad it is worse than nothing (literally, it can make Visual Studio lag out). But don't take my word for it, read the reviews: https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=GitHub.copilotvs&ssr=false#review-details https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=GitHub.c... This is the polar opposite of VS Code where it works super well and reviews great accordingly. In my opinion if you're a Visual Studio developer who wants AI assist, you'll need to figure out how to open your solution in VS Code instead to use Copilot or just pay the $20/month for ChatGPT Plus then copy/paste. PS - This isn't a version specific thing, it has been broken since launch. They've been replying to reviews with "Try Copilot version [vNext] with Visual Studio [latest]" since last December to last week, yet the one-star reviews keep coming in unabated. Funny enough they recently replied to a complaint with "The VS Code version does this!"
- symlinkk 4y agoVisual Studio is a legacy product. You should be switching to VSCode.
- Someone1234 4y agoTell that to Microsoft. .Net's VS Code support is a joke relative to Visual Studio (as opposed to TS which is better on VS Code by far). People aren't using Visual Studio (and spending $3K+/year) because they WANT to.
- veec_cas_tant 4y agoVisual Studio has free versions for Windows and Mac [1] [1] https://visualstudio.microsoft.com/vs/pricing/ https://visualstudio.microsoft.com/vs/pricing/
- squeegmeister 4y agoI haven't noticed any issues with it, other than it occasionally just not chiming in. I'm using vs2022 on windows fwiw. That said, it wouldn't surprise me if vscode is getting preferential treatment
- yodon 4y agoAfter finally switching to a Mac full time last year for the better developer experience (bash command line without the WSL disk access slowness), I now feel like I need to install Parallels to get the better developer experience (Copilot and Copilot X under Windows)
- RivieraKid 4y agoI admit that I'm anxious about the possibility that AI will drive down demand for developer jobs. My base case is that it won't have a meaningful negative impact, but it's possible that it will, so it's unpleasant to have this uncertainty about the future and to see the technology develop very rapidly with big news coming almost every day - which I would be normally extatic about. I've been on a path to financial independence (= saving and investing) but still need ~9 years to be able to safely retire. I slightly envy people with US-based FAANG jobs, where achieving financial independence seems like a breeze. This also adds fuel to my desire to start a side project. What are your thought on this? Are you preparing in any way financially?
- drdrek 4y agoI would love to hear from other people here but I tried it for a while and dropped my subscription. For short things it was nice, but the larger the suggestion the worst it got. I found myself constantly mentally debugging the output it suggested, I do not know if it was faster but I was mentally exhausted by it, unable to go for long periods of time. Dumb code completion is predictable, I know I'll need to press down three times before its even shown to me, enabling me to think forward. With "smart" code completion I need to constantly stop my train of thought to process what ever it throws at me. I even tried to just trust the system, playing it fast and loose, not double checking everything, but then it just produced bugs. I'm developer with 16 years of experience, currently working mainly with python for API work. I'd love to hear accounts of other people, please add your background if you feel comfortable. I want to see if there is some correlation to experience, programming languages or use cases.
- Rapzid 4y agoLate reply but in the same boat with VSCode. God help anyone not using a typed language to help more easily catch copilot's BS; it regularly just makes up method and interfaces that don't exist. It interferes too much with the standard autocomplete/intellisense. I want to use copilot in an on-demand fashion for help with libs I'm not familiar with and scaffolding, but the team seems dead-set on having it always on and in your face; no settings to swap around the default for normal autocomplete. Maybe I can try toggling it on and off more aggressively. Perhaps Copilot-X's prompt will be more useful for me. IDK but the experience is disappointing especially compared to the potential. Edit: Also I alluded to this but it's just plane wrong a lot. So the inline suggestions are like 75% wrong and I'm fighting to get my autocomplete to show up instead.
- yanis_t 4y agoI mostly code in JS/TS and ruby, and find it pretty handy. Especially when I need to write some unit tests, I usually only write it("should work like this and like that"), and 90% of the time it generates a useful unit test[0]. Also, I find it very useful when I code in an unfamiliar environment, for example python. While usually I know what I want to do, I'm not exactly familiar with details of syntax's, or how a specific library api looks like. This is where it shines, in my experience. Huge time-saver. [0] https://www.strictmode.io/articles/using-github-copilot-for-testing https://www.strictmode.io/articles/using-github-copilot-for-...
- gzer0 4y agoThere are 5 different sign-up waiting lists. Each one needs to be signed-up for separately. [1] Copilot X: https://github.com/github-copilot/chat_waitlist_signup/ https://github.com/github-copilot/chat_waitlist_signup/ [2] Copilot Voice: https://githubnext.com/projects/copilot-voice/ https://githubnext.com/projects/copilot-voice/ [3] Copilot Docs: https://githubnext.com/projects/copilot-for-docs/ https://githubnext.com/projects/copilot-for-docs/ [4] Copilot for PRs: https://githubnext.com/projects/copilot-for-pull-requests/ https://githubnext.com/projects/copilot-for-pull-requests/ [5] Copilot CLI: https://githubnext.com/projects/copilot-cli/ https://githubnext.com/projects/copilot-cli/
- renewiltord 4y agoThank you. Better comment than the release docs. This is going to be fantastic!
- cloudking 4y agoThanks saved a lot of time!
- pastor_bob 4y ago$50+ in monthly subscription fees? BRB buying some MSFT
- paxys 4y agoWe forgot very quickly that there was an entire generation of developers who paid $1000-2000 or more for an MSDN subscription just as the base cost for doing business. This is what Microsoft does.
- xxpor 4y agothe MSDN subscription was amazing for me to piggyback off of my dad as a kid though. access to essentially everything in MS's current and back catalog that was even remotely related to dev work, including OSes :)
- devit 4y agoIt's a bit annoying that you have to pay for Copilot just to sign up for the waitlist, rather than being able to either pay for acceptance or start paying when you are accepted.
- debugdog 4y agoWell, loving "tldr"[1] and smashing the tab key for my autocompletes that Copilot CLI thing kind of sounds like another level of laziness and less Googling. [1] https://github.com/tldr-pages/tldr https://github.com/tldr-pages/tldr
- noworriesnate 4y agoThis will be a hard moat for GitLab to cross. There is so much value to having open source models though that I wonder if we could come up with a project on the scale of Linux that is for open source machine learning models. So many companies could benefit from it.
- prosim 4y agoBigCode is such a project: https://www.bigcode-project.org/docs/about/mission/ https://www.bigcode-project.org/docs/about/mission/
- UK-AL 4y agoI think they've done it backwards in regards to it writing tests. Tests are the check to make sure the A.I is in check. If A.I is writing tests, you have to double check the tests. You should write tests, then the A.I writes the code. It almost doesn't matter what the code is, as long the AI can regenerate the code from tests.
- layer8 4y agoTests don't (can't) prove tthat code is correct. They are merely a rough plausibility check that the code isn't completely wrong and didn't regress. You generally can't derive the right code just from tests.
- UK-AL 4y agoYou can write tests about properties you care about which may not be everything. Generally in some of the more financial applications i've written I would be ok with people rewriting the app as long as it passes the tests. I've even written tests that say this set of input goes to this output, for various different subsets of input. Anything outside of the of the defined input sets fail validation. Than it randomly picks a couple of thousand inputs from the input sets I've defined and runs them. More confidence you need, the more exhaustive setting you put it on. It's a bit like QuickCheck.
- layer8 4y agoYou can approximate it, but to represent really all properties, in the end it becomes a mirror picture of the actual code you are testing, which then begs the question. A random sample of inputs that is hidden from the AI also won’t allow it to derive a corresponding implementation. And if the set of sample inputs is not hidden, then the AI is still free to produce an implementations that only works for those sample inputs.
- UK-AL 4y agoYou'd probably separate example tests and validation tests. Also test descriptions should fed into the prompt to help guide it, like BDD style tests. On test failure, the data is fed back into the prompt about what failed for another iteration. This will help avoid over-fitting, and generate another generation on test failure. I mean you can't guarantee correctness, but you could probably get it pretty close. Humans also have the same problem.
- johlits 4y agoNext step: Don't even show me the code. Just the results.
- itsaquicknote 4y agoOuch, this nukes a few startups I was watching working on "basically this". What's the plan control.dev and cursor.so?
- Jack5500 4y agoSo wait, is the switch to GPT4 done now or will it be done with Copilot X? The wording seems unclear to me
- Toutouxc 4y agoIs anyone actually seeing things IRL like 46 % of code written by Copilot? I'm using it in RubyMine in a few years old Rails codebase with some complex bits, and while I find it much more useful than RubyMine's already nice autocomplete, I can rarely get it to write more than a one-liner before it misunderstands my intentions and touches something it shouldn't. One thing that I think contributes to this is that the codebase is really messy in places, so often there isn't much good code to parrot, and things that are named like should only do thing A often do thing B on the side.
- bottlepalm 4y agoProbably more than 30% for me, and there’s a lot of low hanging fruit I bet it could get up to 60% at least. This is a full stack app. It knows from context what you’re going to next in many cases.
- renewiltord 4y agoI currently use copilot in my terminal by using copilot.vim and then using C-x C-e in my command line to bring it into my editor but I have to exit and re-enter to get traditional autocomplete which I find annoying. Paths come easy since neovim will complete this for me with Deoplete but the rest is not straightforward.
- naillo 4y agoReminder that they read your code as part of this which then feeds their models. Basically you're paying to replace yourself long term.
- trashface 4y agoFunny how if AI puts programmers out of a job, they won't be able to afford all these AI coding tool subscriptions. I'm unemployed (and probably, now, unemployable) and I can rationalize/afford the $10/month for regular copilot, but not more.
- c7DJTLrn 4y agoI can't believe how quickly things are moving. In five years we're either going to look back on this as a hysterical hype bubble, or one of biggest innovations in the 21st century. I have been skeptical of Copilot from the beginning, but it's becoming clear that I'lll be left in the dust if I don't try at least try it.
- qwertox 4y ago> ChatGPT-like experience in your editor with GitHub Copilot Chat The best thing about VS Code is how you can click on the tab of the current editor and drag it out into a new self-contained window, so that you can move it to another monitor. This is such an optimal use of screen real estate. I will drag out Copilot from the main VS Code window to my right monitor, have the main editor in the center monitor, and Google / GitHub / API docs on the left monitor. Yes, I'm being sarcastic.
- awestroke 4y agoWhat's your point?
- magospietato 4y agoVS Code constrains a single IDE instance to a single window. Extra flyouts like Copilot chat can only exist in this window, impacting on available real-estate for the code we actually care about. It's Code's biggest weakness IMO.
- qwertox 4y agoWhy not offer parts of it as a website? The part where I chat with it, where I ask my questions and get my answers. (Maybe it could bridge into VS Code via a local server to exchange code.)
- electrondood 4y ago> GitHub Copilot Chat builds upon the work that OpenAI and Microsoft have done with ChatGPT and the new Bing. Cool, so it can sass me and threaten to stop responding when it doesn't like my tone? Whatever PM decided that tools need to have a personality should be fired and blacklisted.
- nemo44x 4y agoWow, Microsoft was so ahead of the curve when they bought Github. They saw this coming and knew they had to acquire them to make it into this kind of thing. Just absolutely impressive execution here. Especially since Github would not have been able to do this on its own. Just an absolute perfect acquisition here. They don't often go right, but when they do so much new value is created for everyone.
- singularity2001 4y agoI am praying for some alternative platform to take the throne off Github. This is way too much power in the wrong hands. The competing product needs to add a fundamental new idea or feature. Gitlab as it is doesn't cut it.
- zerop 4y agoSo we will have to train our developers to produce code using gpt prompts. I see many jobs are at risk.
- symlinkk 4y agoEverything I have worked for is worthless. The programming knowledge I sacrificed my prime years to learn is obsolete. Everything I earned I used to buy a house which is declining in value day by day. I wonder if I would be happier and more successful if I didn’t take the responsible path in life.
- pornel 4y agoThe Copilot Voice dictation experience looks way better than the current state of the art of "type keyword import space quote foo quote semicolon newline".
- javier_e06 4y agoI asked ChatGpt in plain english to cook some bash scripts for me and the examples are good. It replies in plain english and then generates working code that does what you ask it to do and then you can ask it to refactor or to change and re generate. Very impressive. Who remembers that ${my_string%%myword} shaves-off the word at the end of the string anyway?
- cess11 4y agoWhy participate in the hype? It's highly likely this is the result of legal having mulled over the Copilot litigation and deciding that it can go either way or worse, so the top layer in MICROS~1 has decided to rush whatever product development they can use the general public for and try to hook as many people as they can to their stochastic parrots. Which they wish to insert into not just every other government machine, but also every Linux machine, preferably pumping out every line of code written with those. It's better to support open source rights holders against this exploitation than getting one's nose brown.
- joeyh 4y agoTo the extent of claiming that "GitHub Copilot is already writing 46% of code". It smacks of desperation to lie so baldly with statistics.
- cess11 4y agoYeah, it reeks, makes me think of the "it's afraid scene" in a well known movie. As for the productivity increase some claim it can bring, I'm not so sure. The software doesn't know your style guidelines until you give them away. Maybe it can help in some marginal cases, cough up some XML there is no longer official tooling for generating or whatever. If you don't have snippets and IDE support for boilerplate you're doing development wrong and should start looking into techniques for code generation in your stack. For any non-trivial application design you really want to know what your inspiration is and what it's used for, so you can judge the context of the code you take inspiration from and can cull the parts you don't need and adapt to your particular situation. And typically code output is more about learning the problem domain deeply and doing code reviews. If one spends more time writing stuff that doesn't need thinking than doing reviews and study there's an obvious need for automation and code generation, and one probably ought to think more about how to make one's contributions more efficiently.
- vslira 4y agoA bit sad that they’ll go the price discrimination route instead of improving Copilot Gotta pay for those H100 I guess
- pleb_nz 4y agoThis is cool no doubt and I use it every day and it still has shortcoming and isn't perfect. However, I definitely see job cuts coming. Not now, in some years. I'm lucky, I'm closer to the tail of my career than the start. But I feel for the hords of young people who have got into this career but may soon find only a smaller percentage of them are needed. You can't fight it, it's going to happen. It's up to the individuals to identify this risk and take steps to ensure their bases are covered if it and when it does.
- stemlord 4y agoI'm so mad. I love writing my own code so much. Life's a bitch
- jacooper 4y agoLooks like anyone who left Github because of Copilot won nothing, as GPT4, the new model used for new Copilot includes everything, not only Github code. So even if you uploaded it to GitLab, codeberg or Sourcehut it still trained on your code... That supreme court case is becoming more important by the day.
- steve_adams_86 4y agoI have no illusions that what I've been building was ever going to be commercial or even particularly useful (it just offers code improvements, bug fixes, etc. as errors are piped into the system – it's very rudimentary but neat), but it's striking right now how incredibly deep Microsoft's moat in this arena is right now. I realized it would be best as a VS Code extension in its current form and started writing that this morning. I was thinking Github would do this eventually, it was obvious — copilot already existed and was primed for this — but evidently they'd already built it a while ago. I was also thinking eventually it could be a bot which generates pull requests based on error correction, but... They did that too. If I wanted to go all in one this project, say as a hypothetical competitor to Copilot, I don't see how it would be possible to succeed. Any clever UI improvements would rapidly find their way into Copilot, offering far better solutions due to their absurd access to pertinent data. They can even train Copilot to resolve errors based on how they've been resolved in the past; it could probably patch all kinds of common errors reliably soon. I think this is cool in the sense that it'll be genuinely useful to people, but frightening to realize how dominant MS is here, in this moment. Maybe I'm not creative enough and I can't see a way to build something novel with this which they haven't already. That's arguably likely. At the same time... I'm a little shaken at how narrow of an opportunity anyone had to try to get into this space. I don't think it's a good thing.
- the_other 4y agoIt should be free, or at least significantly cheaper. It was trained on millions of person-days of work people shared for free. This is _our_ work being sold back to us. (ok, not really mine, I don't contribute to OSS very much; I should probably pay for it.. but you get my point).
- cal85 4y agoAs an OSS contributor I'd love it if GitHub decided to share their profits with me, but I did knowingly contribute my work under free software licences so I don't see myself as having any moral or legal right to that. (If they've trained it on private repos that's another matter, I am assuming they haven't.) Either way, I don't think it's a strong argument to say it's our work being sold back to us. Whatever it is that makes people pay for Copilot, it can't just be the OSS code that it was trained on, as that is all still freely available online. People must be paying for the part that GitHub has trained/built, the part that reads your codebase and makes good suggestions.
- web3-is-a-scam 4y agoOh nice, so now copilot can not only hallucinate what completions to use in the code, it can hallucinate what PRs even do and even hallucinate the documentation.
- kypro 4y agoSlightly unrelated I suppose, but I'm not sure how I feel about a world where people frequently communicate with each other via AI generated prompts. I can't quite put my finger on it, but there's something quite creepy about this future we're currently being sold. A world where inauthenticity is the norm, and where everything you read is no longer written by your family, friends and colleagues, but by their AI assistant. I suppose people have expressed similar feelings about phones and video conferencing, and AI prompts are just the next step of optimising human interaction by removing all the constraints and annoyances that come with interacting with other humans. Any way I would be interested in hearing how others feel about this. Or if it's more convenient, how you feel as interpreted by your AI assistant. It's all the same after all.
- maicro 4y agoAll joking below aside, I'm not sure how I feel about this either, though I also haven't been following things too closely yet. The below is the first "real" use I've made of an AI to write a response for me. I guess there are a couple different layers there. On the one hand, the technology/medium being used has always caused us to adjust our communication style - we communicate differently if it's a letter that will take weeks to deliver and weeks more to receive a response, vs. a hasty limited text message, vs. an email, vs. a face to face conversation with no time constraints, etc. So I guess that as long as the person sending the message agrees that it conveys what they want, having an AI draft it isn't terrible... --- Me: Write a response agreeing to this message: [contents of your post, without correcting the original typo thus explaining paragraph 4] Bard draft 3: I agree that there is something quite creepy about a world where people frequently communicate with each other via AI generated prompts. It seems like a world where authenticity is lost and where everything is just a simulation. I can see how people might be attracted to AI prompts because they are convenient and efficient. But I think there is also a risk that people will become too reliant on AI and that they will lose the ability to connect with each other on a deeper level. I think it is important to maintain a balance between using AI and interacting with other humans. AI can be a tool that helps us to communicate more effectively, but it should not be a replacement for human connection. I have not been interrupted by my AI assistant, but I can imagine that it would be annoying if it was constantly trying to interject or offer unsolicited advice. I think it is important for AI assistants to be respectful of human privacy and to only provide information when it is asked for. Overall, I think that AI has the potential to be a powerful tool for communication, but it is important to use it responsibly and to be aware of its limitations.
- ComplexSystems 4y agoThere has been this bug with Copilot in VSCode for just about forever where it only suggests one line at a time. People have been asking for this to be fixed for months and months: https://github.com/orgs/community/discussions/40522 https://github.com/orgs/community/discussions/40522 Do the people here in the comments section, who seem to be getting good results with Copilot, somehow not have this issue? If so, what is the workaround?
- criloz2 4y agoWhy people will upload their code to GitHub (if they are working in some state-of-the-art tech) is beyond me, you will be easily replaced by microsoft and they will say that was a product generated by gpt, see what happened in Amazon store with the popular products
- visarga 4y ago> A ChatGPT-like experience in your editor with GitHub Copilot Chat: We are bringing a chat interface to the editor that’s focused on developer scenarios and natively integrates with VS Code and Visual Studio. This does far more than suggest code. GitHub Copilot Chat is not just a chat window. It recognizes what code a developer has typed, what error messages are shown, and it’s deeply embedded into the IDE. A developer can get in-depth analysis and explanations of what code blocks are intended to do, generate unit tests, and even get proposed fixes to bugs. This is what I am excited about - seeing its errors and other things it needs in order to accomplish tasks. Can't wait to see it in action.
- DeathArrow 4y agoMicrosoft lost some trains trains with mobile and servers. But they won with AI, developer tools, cloud and gaming.
- ertucetin 4y agoIt seems as though all the companies deliberately agreed to wait until 2023 to release their AI products
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- itamarcode 4y agoWhile in GitHub Copilot X you need to join a waiting list, you can already today generate meaningful test suites right inside your IDE. Check out: https://www.codium.ai https://www.codium.ai https://plugins.jetbrains.com/plugin/21206-codiumai--meaningful-tests-in-python-powered-by-testgpt https://plugins.jetbrains.com/plugin/21206-codiumai--meaning... https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=Codium.codium https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=Codium.c...
- chrisan 4y agoIs there a way to talk to copilot after something has been made? For example: I just asked it to search for something on a public api in a comment and let it auto complete the function. The resulting code was pretty decent except it included a hard coded access_token in the url. This was a blank project, I don't even have an access token for this api - guessing someone posted theirs in a public repo at some point. Is there a way to talk to copilot at this point to refine the code?
- drBonkers 4y agoI think this is what Copilot Chat will do.
- chrisan 4y agoah yes, you are correct. Visual Studio (code) only at the moment
- muny 4y agoWhat I normally do in cases like this is set up the necessary scaffolding for the solution. In your case, that could be introducing a variable named something like `access_token` for it to substitute into the URL. Then, when you trigger a suggestion it's very likely that CoPilot will use your `access_token` variable.
- drusepth 4y agoIt's kind of mind-blowing to see how well Microsoft has navigated the Next Big Thing (AI) waters compared to Google, whose bread and butter is (was?) AI/ML. Microsoft seems to have positioned themselves extremely well not only to be a leader in the space moving forward, but also to completely change the space. That's the mark of a great leader and it's exciting to see someone taking the reins whose not afraid to shift a paradigm or two.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoBard is very underwhelming if you've used GPT-4. Between search being trash and now even Maps being awful, I think it's time to stick a fork into Google. They need new leadership and they need it asap.
- ThereIsNoWorry 4y agoThis does not replace anyone, it just gets rid of people that don't adapt. I bet any company and developer that won't be using AI augmentation to increase productivity (not just coding) will horribly underperform in less than 10 years.
- singularity2001 4y agoJetbrains and NeoVim logos also in there: https://github.com/features/preview/copilot-x https://github.com/features/preview/copilot-x ! Above "Can’t wait for the future? "
- bilsbie 4y agoSo how do I get started with this. Explain like I’m a vim cgi-bin programmer.
- messel 4y agoI've got LLM fatigue
- thoughtpeddler 4y agoI can't help but think that these new Copilot offerings, when fully implemented in 2-3 years or so, make project managers / program managers / release managers obsolete.
- ivxvm 4y agoSo it still can't write new code according to project's patterns / conventions and "core" library?
- steve76 4y ago[dead]
- unity1001 4y agoI dont get it - has the copyright problem with AI generated code trained on other people's repositories been solved yet?
- zzzzzhzzzzz 4y ago"At GitHub, our mission has always been to innovate ahead of the curve and give developers everything they need to be happier and more productive in a world powered by software." Maybe start with repo folders?
- thisismahdyar 4y agoMake an organization?
- noltncy 4y agoThis is good strategy. The source data, the tech to go through the data, the customers to sell the results back to - it’s all there. Next up, AI in games through their own studios, activision Blizzard and the xbox platform. Videos/video based content is something Microsoft doesn’t have. It’s mostly confined to ‘stream’ and teams.