28 ms·
Yellen and the FDIC is in a tough spot. This is the important line, "Any losses to the Deposit Insurance Fund to support uninsured depositors will be recovered
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
Yellen and the FDIC is in a tough spot. This is the important line, "Any losses to the Deposit Insurance Fund to support uninsured depositors will be recovered by a special assessment on banks, as required by law."
Thus, on one hand, I'm glad they're doing this, as it should help prevent wider bank runs, and it ensures that banks are the ones that are actually paying for it.
At the same time, this is yet another example of changing the rules in the middle of the game. Yellen has just broadcast that FDIC insurance is essentially unlimited, as long as you can threaten wider disruption to the economy.
I understand part of this is human nature but I really wish we could plan for these entirely foreseeable events ahead of time so that it's not just cases of "selective justice" with regards to who gets bailed out.
- bruiseralmighty 4y ago> Yellen has just broadcast that FDIC insurance is essentially unlimited Although I agree with the Treasury's actions here so far, this is a potential issue. They should instantiate more stringent rules for banks that who cater to business accounts and then raise the cap for insurance on those accounts to a number that makes sense for small businesses across the country. Too many CEOs and CFOs were allowing their business checking accounts to sit in dangerously uninsured positions. Headliner being Roku with nearly a half a billion dollars sitting in a single checking account with SVB. But plenty of smaller businesses leave ten million plus dollars in their accounts as a course of business as well. The actual amount those accounts can be insured for needs to be formalized and it should probably be higher than the standard quarter million for consumer accounts as this is way too low for business larger than a half dozen employees.
- ttfkam 4y ago> but I really wish we could plan for these entirely foreseeable events ahead of time We did with Dodd-Frank after the 2008 housing crisis, signed into law by Obama. Would have stopped over leveraging found at SVB. Then it was rolled back in 2018, signed by Trump. Wasn't a hard sell to Trump at the time. "Obama did it? Okay, let's undo it!"
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mgraczyk 4y agoIn cases where you can't predict the future appropriately, sometimes it's better to make prudent decisions that help everyone instead of attempting to punish the sinful. Keep in mind that bank shareholders and senior management are going to get wiped out and fired.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hypothesis 4y ago>senior management are going to get wiped out and fired Wasn’t one of executives working at Lehman Brothers or some such before? This is just failing upwards and doing same thing.
- mitthrowaway2 4y ago"Punishing the sinful" isn't about morals, it's about incentives, and ensuring a level playing field where sinning doesn't improve your long-term competitiveness. Will senior management have to return their 2021 performance bonuses? If not, successful sinning is just a matter of ensuring you cash out early.
- mgraczyk 4y agoWho are you trying to disincentivize? How would it dissuade the bank's management if depositors took a haircut? What behavior do you think punishing depositors would prevent? Do you think depositors should hire an accountant and economist to review their bank's balance sheet every quarter?
- Uvix 4y agoIf they have more than $250K in the one institution: yes, they should. Better yet would be spreading their deposits around, but if they don't want to do that, they should take the necessary steps to evaluate the risk appropriately.
- 4y ago
- notmindthegap 4y agoDid you foresee this?
- twelve40 4y agosurely it's not on HN throwaway to do all the foreseeing here? there are people whose fulltime job is to monitor the banks.
- belter 4y agoThose people normally claim they don't know how the economy works. "Greenspan - I was wrong about the economy. Sort of" - https://www.theguardian.com/business/2008/oct/24/economics-creditcrunch-federal-reserve-greenspan https://www.theguardian.com/business/2008/oct/24/economics-c...
- mrangle 4y agoError is the easiest and most common government excuse for inexcusable malice. Which means that people shouldn't allow for that excuse in the context of grand scale failures like 2008, 2003, etc.
- chejazi 4y agoThose who did foresee it made highly profitable trades: https://twitter.com/notmrmanziel/status/1633940364460474372 https://twitter.com/notmrmanziel/status/1633940364460474372
- fortenforge 4y agoThere is some sense in which this is true, but the systemic risk exception which they are invoking was always on the books.
- belter 4y ago"...recovered by a special assessment on banks, as required by law..." - Would love to know what law/regulatory framework she is referring to. Janet Yellen is ready to become a US based Liz Truss... Now expect a contagion effect next week, if SVB liabilities are shown worst than currently known, and made to bare on other banks capital requirements... "US banks sitting on unrealized losses of $620 billion" - https://edition.cnn.com/2023/03/12/investing/stocks-week-ahead/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2023/03/12/investing/stocks-week-ahe...
- mixdup 4y agothe systemic risk exceptions/procedures they're using were put in place after 2008
- jen20 4y ago… are you sure you understand who Liz Truss is and what she did?
- belter 4y agoYes.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago> Would love to know what law/regulatory framework she is referring to. This is not some conspiratorial secret. Banks pay premiums to the FDIC for their insurance, and it's a requirement of all chartered banks. The FDIC has the right to backstop deposits in excess of the deposit limit by invoking a "systemic risk" clause (I'm not sure exactly which law this comes under, whether it's some of the original laws that created the FDIC, or more recent post-financial crisis updates). When the FDIC fund gets depleted, they have the right to invoke a special assessment against banks. > Now expect a contagion effect it next week The whole point of doing this is to prevent a contagion. The reason there was a bank run against SVB was a mix not just that their asset values had deteriorated (that was well known for some time), it's that their non-diversified deposit base of VC-funded start ups have gradually needed to up their withdrawals since early 2022. SVB would have survived if there wasn't a run on the bank, and the whole purpose of this action was to prevent further runs by saying that deposits will be protected.
- grey-area 4y agoWell one way to do this would be to regulate banks more, like we used to: https://www.cnbc.com/2018/05/24/trump-signs-bank-bill-rolling-back-some-dodd-frank-regulations.html https://www.cnbc.com/2018/05/24/trump-signs-bank-bill-rollin... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass–Steagall_legislation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass–Steagall_legislation
- Donald 4y agoThis isn’t necessarily a Glass–Steagall issue as SVB was primarily in government bonds and mortgage-backed securities.
- junofan 4y agoYou’re saying SVB should’ve been designated “too big to fail?”
- DANmode 4y agoOther way around.
- lmm 4y agoWell, apparently they are too big to fail, given that the FDIC is covering them. So they should've been subject to the extra capital requirements that too big to fail banks have.
- grey-area 4y agoShould have had more regulation - more stringent reporting and capital requirements (easy to say in retrospect, but they were covered by laws repealed in 2018). It should not be possible for a consumer bank to get into this sort of state so that they are so far from being able to return customer funds.
- mixdup 4y agoWell, paying for it by a special assessment on banks means the banks aren't going to get a free ride. They, as a group, have to get their shit together otherwise they will pay dearly
- saurik 4y agoI think (but am honestly not 100% sure here) that the argument is if other banks are going to have to pay for SVB being greedy, it is in some sense punishing banks for not being greedy enough; as while, sure, the SVB investors are getting hit: 1) a lot of them already made a lot of money years ago (and potentially exited), 2) many of the executives apparently literally sold out last month, and 3) they were hoarding a lot of deposits that other banks couldn't get because they weren't being risky enough. But so like, saying banks are paying dearly for this is strange, as it is the wrong banks... and, by extension, the customers at those banks, who are in turn making decisions about what bank to use in the future.
- tialaramex 4y agoYou probably can't hope for better under the US system. Maybe other banks will push hard to not allow more SVBs in the future after seeing this. Suppose I'm a Utah bank that is mostly lending money to diverse local businesses and home owners, and mostly taking deposits from other businesses, some local and some not, and would-be future home owners. Last week I probably didn't care that SVB wasn't required to be as risk-averse as I was, if they failed what do I care? Today, seeing this news, I care a great deal, and I don't want to see other banks allowed to take risks I wouldn't have been permitted unless they're paying a lot more than I am for the privilege, because when they fail - and they will fail - I don't want to pay for that.
- elliekelly 4y ago“Riskier” and more complex banks do have higher FDIC fees: https://www.fdic.gov/resources/deposit-insurance/deposit-insurance-fund/dif-assessments.html https://www.fdic.gov/resources/deposit-insurance/deposit-ins...
- consumer451 4y agoAs mentioned in other threads here, Germany and the UK have operated like this in the past as well. If it's not a loss to the tax payers, then it seems like good governance to me.
- Uvix 4y agoBut it is a loss to taxpayers. Anybody with money in an unaffected bank will end up footing the bill.
- astrange 4y agoSince SVB's deposits were solvent, there isn't an actual loss here as long as it encourages people to not withdraw money early. They collapsed because everyone asked for it too fast. What would be expensive would be paying for everyone getting laid off after SVB depositors can't make payroll.
- Uvix 4y agoSVB was solvent before the run. Is that still the case even after Wednesday/Thursday's fire sales, where they had to sell a bunch at a loss?
- cherioo 4y agoSVB had more asset than liability, at least on paper. They were not able to be solvent selling on open market in the time it had, but perhaps that can be done by a bigger bank over longer period of time?
- s1artibartfast 4y ago>there isn't an actual loss here as long as it encourages people to not withdraw money early. This is like saying you loaning me 50B for ten years is zero cost as long as you get it back at the end. It ignores the fact that you have to come up with the money, and once you have it, you could put it somewhere with an actual return. This is the exact reason SVB failed. Their 10 year investments were worth 70 cents on the dollar because there are better returns elsewhere.
- beebmam 4y agoHow do you square this statement of yours: > Yellen has just broadcast that FDIC insurance is essentially unlimited, as long as you can threaten wider disruption to the economy. with this quote from the Treasury Dept statement? > "No losses associated with the resolution of Silicon Valley Bank will be borne by the taxpayer."
- unethical_ban 4y ago"Any losses to the Deposit Insurance Fund to support uninsured depositors will be recovered by a special assessment on banks, as required by law." The fungibility of money aside, my personal taxes will not pay for this.
- Uvix 4y agoIf you have any money in any other bank, you're paying for this.
- toughlover917 4y agoEXACTLY! This will be born by the taxpayer. What were all the VCs f*cking thinking concentrating all their portfolio companies in one financial institution? This was terrible decision making on their part (and by the portfolio companies). Why does this all of a sudden become a taxpayer liability? Because All-In bros got on Twitter and started spamming people?
- notfromhere 4y agoFDIC gets its money by a fee charged to banks. Tax money isn’t going into this
- toomuchtodo 4y agoWhere do banks get their revenue and profits from? It’s really immaterial; if depositors weren’t taking a haircut, all of us do in some form or another, it’s simply the optics that change (banks, the Treasury, the Fed, whatever). C'est la vie.
- roflyear 4y agoPerfect policy doesn't exist. I prefer this to hard line actions that cause massive harm because it's impossible to account for all situations.
- vishal0123 4y ago> Thus, on one hand, I'm glad they're doing this, as it should help prevent wider bank runs Could you expand? My first thought was that the bank who is in verge of crisis could tip over with additional burden.
- pmorici 4y agoBecause a major component of this is human nature causing bank runs they are betting that by doing this upfront it will be cheaper than not doing it and risking a high number of similar bank runs in the coming month as word spreads it isn't safe to keep money over the insurance limit in banks because of the unrealized loses on bonds.
- luckylion 4y agoAt the same time, they've essentially raised the insurance limit to infinity. Depositors will be made whole, and if they aren't the next time something happens, they'll need some very good arguments for why the 9th largest bank is now also too big too fail but e.g. the 11th largest isn't.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> At the same time, they’ve essentially raised the insurance limit to infinity. No, they haven’t. The systemic risk exception was used during the last financial crisis for some banks and not others, so using it now doesn’t raise the insurance limit, actually or “essentially”. There is (still) no guarantee that it will be used for any particular failure in the future, just like there wasn’t after the last financial crisis, and people have lost funds in excess of the $250K insurance limit since the last use of the systemic risk exception.
- bink 4y agoOne could argue that SVB depositors would not be expecting the be made whole if it weren't for the bailouts of 2008. The precedent has been set and reinforced. It's hard to argue that this will not encourage more risk taking and moral hazard.
- pmorici 4y agoThat precedent was set at least as far back in the early 90's when they made depositors of Bank of New England Bank whole after it failed in 1991. This isn't something that started with the financial crisis of '08 https://www.nytimes.com/1991/01/07/business/us-is-taking-over-a-group-of-banks-to-head-off-a-run.html https://www.nytimes.com/1991/01/07/business/us-is-taking-ove...
- swatcoder 4y agoMy read is that they see the shortage at SVB as relatively small and that they may be closing some marginal banks like Signature ahead of true insolvency/illiquidity to both protect depositors and minimize reactionary withdrawals across the broader market. And it sounds like they have the authority to just do this on a Sunday, so it doesn’t sound like any rules being changed. If I was a banker with a marginal portfolio, I wouldn’t be encouraged by this. Depositors are making it out, but banks are being aggressively shuttered to make that happen.
- hammock 4y ago>they may be closing some marginal banks like Signature ahead of true insolvency/illiquidity That seems unjust and probably illegal. What makes you think Signature isn’t actually insolvent?
- swatcoder 4y agoMaybe they are. I would assume that the government has some discretion over when to intervene, since financial status is dynamic, but I don’t know.
- lmm 4y agoThe government can't generally arbitrarily seize an operating business. (Indeed, in the recent Johnson & Johnson court case we saw the opposite: they asked to undertake bankruptcy proceedings early because they're facing a large liability, the government said no, not until you're proven to be actually bankrupt)
- nullc 4y agoSounds like a bit of a hazard: the difference between insolvent or not for many entities is just accounting conventions. Lock in some non-MTM losses-- wham!-- insolvent. Why should bankruptcy protection be denied to any entity that would be unquestionably qualified if they simply took an additional legitimate action that would make their creditors worse off?
- siavosh 4y agoI view it kind of like parenting. Depending on what kind of kid you’ve raised you may not want to signal to them that no matter what you’ll financially bail them out. Hoping they’ll make the right choices.
- apendleton 4y agoWho are the kids in this analogy? It seems like what's at issue is whether or not depositors are protected (executives, shareholders, and creditors are all getting the shaft). Do you think depositors should have made different choices, and if so, which?
- lmm 4y agoDepositors shouldn't have piled all their assets into one bank because it was paying slightly more interest. Not saying every depositor did that here, but many did.
- astrange 4y agoNobody used SVB because it paid more interest. (It didn't pay interest at all in fact.) They did it because the name was cool or because other banks wouldn't give you an account for your startup at all. It's normal to go for a regional bank when regular ones don't understand your business.
- siavosh 4y agoI wouldn't take the analogy too literally. But the 'kids' are all market participants in the system the government is trying to regulate. My point being is there is a reason certain entities don't communicate with full transparency and sometimes they find ambiguity a tool. Now whether this is the right or wrong thing to do in this case in the short and long terms...I'll have to leave that judgement to the history books.
- dehrmann 4y agoThis probably sealed the deal: > We are also announcing a similar systemic risk exception for Signature Bank, New York, New York, which was closed today by its state chartering authority. Two closures in three days is a sign that you have to take this very seriously.
- radicaldreamer 4y agoThis is going to put every regional bank on the map for short sellers as equity holders are being wiped out in these cases without depositors being affected. Why would anyone invest in any regional bank with the risk of a equity wipeout day to day?
- swatcoder 4y ago> Why would anyone invest in any regional bank with the risk of a equity wipeout day to day? Because some have better books and management than others and will be underpriced because of reactionary selloffs like you describe?
- bagels 4y agoHuge opportunity tomorrow to buy if you are able to actually find them.
- tedivm 4y agoThey're also taking action to prevent this kind of thing from happening again- > The Fed facility will offer loans of up to one year to banks, saving associations, credit unions and other institutions. Those taking advantage of the facility will be asked to pledge high-quality collateral such as Treasurys, agency debt and mortgage-backed securities. > “This action will bolster the capacity of the banking system to safeguard deposits and ensure the ongoing provision of money and credit to the economy,” the Fed said in a statement. “The Federal Reserve is prepared to address any liquidity pressures that may arise.” https://www.cnbc.com/2023/03/12/regulators-unveil-plan-to-stem-damage-from-svb-collapse.html https://www.cnbc.com/2023/03/12/regulators-unveil-plan-to-st...
- ahepp 4y agoDoes this statement reflect any shift in policy? Haven’t depositors always been first on the list to get paid, even their uninsured deposits? I don’t know if charging a special assessment to member banks is standard operating procedure, but that doesn’t sound like government intervention. It just sounds like reasonable operation of the FDIC.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Uvix 4y agoNot sure how "taxing depositors at other banks to pay for uninsured deposits" is "reasonable operation of the FDIC". (And yes, it's taxing the depositors. Because even if it's "officially" a fee to the other banks, it will be trickled down to their customers through lower interest rates and higher fees rather than absorbed.) If this was necessary to recover insured deposits, that would be reasonable. But instead, the people who made poor decisions aren't going to lose anything, because the extra money is coming out of the pockets of everybody else with money in banks.
- elliekelly 4y agoThey invoked this exception repeatedly during the financial crisis and fees did not go up in response. In fact, they all but disappeared.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Does this statement reflect any shift in policy? It’s a decision of how to apply existing policy to a specific situation, not a policy change. Existing policy is nonspecific enough that reasonable people could disagree on how best to apply it here without changing it. > Haven’t depositors always been first on the list to get paid, even their uninsured deposits? Yes. > I don’t know if charging a special assessment to member banks is standard operating procedure It isn’t routine, which is why it requires invoking the systemic risk exception. > but that doesn’t sound like government intervention. It’s a government decision to intervene in a particular way, so… > It just sounds like reasonable operation of the FDIC. It’s not just “reasonable operation of the FDIC”, since both Fed and Treasury actions are involved. And, even if it was, FDIC is a government corporation, so its actions are government intervention. Its reasonable operation is reasonable government intervention, but its still government intervention.
- notfromhere 4y agoThe FDIC can waive limits if it feels the deposits are of a systemic nature. It has had this power for a long time
- ajross 4y ago> I really wish we could plan for these entirely foreseeable events ahead of time That's exactly what Dodd-Frank did. The audit and stress testing requirements got rolled back in the Trump administration. "Planning" is not the problem here.
- drdec 4y ago> Yellen has just broadcast that FDIC insurance is essentially unlimited, as long as you can threaten wider disruption to the economy. No offense, but I thought we all learned the principle underlying this in 2008.
- patientplatypus 4y agoI was reading this and came across "No losses associated with the resolution of Silicon Valley Bank will be borne by the taxpayer." What does this "special assessment on banks" mean in practice? Do they just go to all the bulge bracket banks and demand that they buy the outdated Treasuries at a loss? How does this work?
- mtremsal 4y agoIIRC banks pay a fee to the FDIC in exchange for providing insurance, and because the FDIC is not funded by taxpayer money, the fee simply goes up when needed.
- nerdponx 4y agoRight. You do stupid reckless stuff that causes a loss? Fine, your insurance premiums go up. Same as with homes and cars. The only outcome I'd like to see better are bonus clawbacks for the "removed" senior management.
- mtremsal 4y agoI don’t know about clawbacks on bonuses, but part of their comp is equity and shareholders are getting wiped, so you’re pretty much getting your wish anyway.
- patientplatypus 4y agoSo there is SVB and Signature bank that have both collapsed in terms of $300 billion. If what you are saying is correct, does that mean that the banks are required to pay hire fees across the industry upwards of $300 amortized over a certain amount of years? If that's the case then the taxpayer will most definitely be on the hook. I don't know if spread across all taxpayers this fee would be negligible, and I also don't know how this would affect the CD rate that banks would offer to clients. Presumably it would force them to lower it, which would be counter to the anti-inflationary moves of the Federal Reserve, but that might not matter given that this is a current issue. It's possible this might also affect banks willingness to raise rates in the future in response to Fed tightening if they thought there was a risk to the banking sector. Given the size and how quickly the banks are failing I'd hazard a guess (this is not financial advice) that in order for the FDIC to maintain it's own portfolio it would have to raise rates enough to be noticeable to consumers, even given the number of FDIC accounts. Can someone comment on if this is the case and how much this might affect forward guidance for banks and consumers?
- JamisonM 4y agoTHEY ARE NOT IN A TOUGH SPOT!!!! They know (and it is obvious) that all deposits are going to be fine without any extra funds, wacko VC's and nutjob politicians are stoking the sort of flames that might cause a contagion so they are forced to make statements like this. The fact that the statement is so milquetoast is certainly on them, but being uber-conservative in your promises is generally a failing/asset for bank regulators.
- woeirua 4y ago… which is why Signature Bank was also placed in receivership this weekend. The contagion was spreading, if they did nothing there would be runs on a number of banks tomorrow. There still may be runs tomorrow.
- MrMan 4y agothere is no contagion except that spread by these fucking criminal VCs on twitter.
- JamisonM 4y agoLooking at other banks that maybe be in a similar position and taking prompt action is competence to be celebrated, I view it as more evidence that despite weaknesses in the regulatory framework they are not in a tough spot at all. They know they can act decisively without fear. A tough spot would be an environment where they let the SVB situation drag out and didn't act on Signature until a run was in motion and had both to deal with at once.. then they would be fighting to restore confidence. If you look at the numbers from 2007-08 and this stuff, plus the much tougher regulatory environment (despite SVB's ability to fall under a lot of thresholds) there just isn't the sort of systemic risk at play here that folks seem to be implying. Also this isn't a replay of the S&L Crisis of the 1980's because those lessons were actually learned but some institutions are still going to screw up because a rising interest rate environment is still challenging in the current regulatory regime.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 4y ago> At the same time, this is yet another example of changing the rules in the middle of the game. No, its not. The “rules” of the “game” authorize systemic risk exceptions, so applying them is not a change to the rules of the game. Moreover, civilization is one continuous game, changing the rules in the middle is the only way to ever change the rules.
- chank 4y ago> changing the rules in the middle of the game. That's literally how legal systems work.
- metalspot 4y agonot credible ones. google "ex post facto law" if you are confused about this.
- chank 4y agoNo, all credible ones work by updating "rules" on the fly. That's literally how most laws are made in general. Something bad happens and appointed agencies and legislators rule and/or pass laws to cover that bad thing from happening again. Ex post facto only deals with retroactive aspects. Which isn't happening here. Just because the government acted one way in the past and not the same way in this instance does not equate to the retroactive definition of ex facto law.
- yibg 4y agoIsn't the systemic risk exception exactly planning for cases like this ahead of time?
- Waterluvian 4y agoHow can they change the rules? Surely it’s already written into law… right? Are they actually able to unilaterally decide to tax banks to fill up their rainy day fund? My guess is that they’re not changing the rules, they’re utilizing them. Either that, or they have far too much executive power over banks. Which would be shocking.
- rjzzleep 4y agoI never thought Mnuchin was the most competent of all people but regardless of how this particular SVB saga plays out, Yellen has to be one of, if not, the most incompetent treasury Secretary of the recent past. She came into power and the first thing she did was suggest a global minimum tax rate, as if that would have fixed the accounting tricks that companies use to reduce the actual tax they pay. Disconnecting the Russian central bank from swift and an oil and gas price cap have been immensely damaging for the western financial system and the international standing of the dollar(and the euro). We now have countries increasingly integrating with alternative bank messaging systems and an accelerating of US reserve sell offs, along with what seems like the initial steps of the creation of something like an OPEC alternative for gas. Not only that, it seems that because they never coordinated the sanctions with the banks it seems like only ~30 billion of the supposed 300 billion of frozen Russian assets can be accounted for, meaning they got to pull their money out and meanwhile the Russian on the other just from 150 billion in return. Get this incompetent person out the door before she destroys more of the USs financial system. “We economists don't know much, but we do know how to create a shortage. If you want to create a shortage of tomatoes, for example, just pass a law that retailers can't sell tomatoes for more than two cents per pound. Instantly you'll have a tomato shortage. It's the same with oil or gas.” - Milton Friedman
- Eumenes 4y agoAgreed 100% Yellen sucks. She would be bad in "good" financial times, but in our current times, its even worse. Mismanaged inflation (or at least perception of it) and is offering the US as a personal bank to Ukraine (among 100x other things).
- dpweb 4y agoNot much of a choice. Guarantee of the system takes highest precedence. Although this problem was caused by bank malfeasance and yes this does imply de facto unlimited insurance, unlimited depositor insurance is kinda the whole point and is not itself a bad thing. Yes, moral hazard is a huge consideration, but I don’t see depositor protection as encouraging future failures of this type, by encouraging bad risk taking by mgmt. Rather, if banks bet their customers money unhedged on endless zero rate policy, as SVB did, there should be regulations that prevent it. Trace back to lobbying to exclude SVB from dodd frank regulations also at the heart of the crisis.
- karmasimida 4y ago> I really wish we could plan for these entirely foreseeable events ahead of time. This is unlikely TBH. When a system this complex and a global clear visibility if offered to no one on the planet, foreseeing ALL risks isn't a possibility.
- anonytrary 4y agoVivek Ramaswamy? Is that you? He's currently on Mario Nawfal's Twitter space saying this exact thing lmao.
- nabla9 4y ago> FDIC insurance is essentially unlimited, as long as you can threaten wider disruption to the economy. I think you misunderstand. Unlike bailout, FDIC insurance means that 1. Shareholders owners are wiped out, 2. Senior management is removed. 3. Unsecured debtholders *will not be protected*. They are made whole only when it's possible using banks assets.
- dev_tty01 4y ago>At the same time, this is yet another example of changing the rules in the middle of the game. Yellen has just broadcast that FDIC insurance is essentially unlimited, as long as you can threaten wider disruption to the economy. No, there are systemic risk exceptions within the rules. If a bank is large enough, then the systemic risk to the economy as a whole is large enough to warrant this step. "Too big to fail" is typically a derisive comment, but it is not without practical reason. Governments are supposed to act in the best interest of the governed. I hope it is clear to all of us that avoiding the economic disruption of a cascade of bank failures is in our interest. Smaller bank failures do not pose systemic risk and so they will not be backstopped in the same way. Might seem like unfair treatment, but practical concerns often outweigh the theoretical. By the way, SVB is still a failure and as a company is now gone. Some other entity will take over its assets, debts, and customer services. All senior management has been removed. >I understand part of this is human nature but I really wish we could plan for these entirely foreseeable events ahead of time so that it's not just cases of "selective justice" with regards to who gets bailed out. We did. That is why we have the FDIC, the Federal Reserve, and the Treasury department. They did their job and did it quickly and effectively. SVB did not get bailed out, the depositors did.
- lamontcg 4y ago> I hope it is clear to all of us that avoiding the economic disruption of a cascade of bank failures is in our interest. Very clearly there is a large chuck of this forum that doesn't understand that.
- 88913527 4y agoIs it though? I think there's a proportion of readers who might feel grifted by regulatory capture (eg: unable to get on the housing ladder due to draconian zoning policy) and reasonably feel that some of the moral hazard has to be addressed to stop what has been unstoppable growth to give them a chance to establish financial security. It's a fallacy to see it as zero sum, but a temporary crisis in confidence might produce the only opportunity in a lifetime to create the conditions needed for affordable housing to be available for purchase for folks who can keep their jobs during the crisis. Many feel economically abandoned.
- stuckinhell 4y agoYellen and the FDIC have just made a disastrous long term mistake for the country. 1. By next month banks and companies will realize there is no limit to the printer at all. After 2008, we've seen the banks and financial sector misbehave constantly, so expect massive deliberate tanking of entire sectors of the economy because why work when infinity bail money exists. 2. People in the country are already agitated by many social and economic grievances. The average American savings account balance is $4,500. This will one million percent cause a social backlash that will make the Trump movement seem like a child's party. Both the left and right radicals view silicon valley as the center of fascism/wokism, and the average person is barely scrapping by in a time of rampant grocery store inflation. Twitter/Reddit/Etc are full of people taking pictures of their grocery store carts and comparing costs. Examples need to be made to restore faith in the system, Yellen and the Biden could have used this moment to restore faith by punishing the banking executives. Political instability and extremism will now increase dramatically.
- richiebful1 4y ago> "Any losses to the Deposit Insurance Fund to support uninsured depositors will be recovered by a special assessment on banks, as required by law." This has happened before in 2008. Secretary Yellen's announcement is important to secure depositor confidence, so the contagion doesn't spread to more banks. If depositors are confident that the government has their back, there's no reason to pull money out.
- JumpinJack_Cash 4y ago> > If depositors are confident that the government has their back, there's no reason to pull money out. There is also no reason to put the money in. You go through the trouble of protecting your money because you deem them scarce and irreplaceable. If tomorrow a commercial bank insured with the FDIC starts offering a product promising 20% interest, then by all means people should get together and apply in mass, get a couple of big political donors on board and all of a sudden there is no downside. If the wacky bank keeps its promise then it's a 20% gain, if not then the FDIC will have depositors backs anyway to the full amount
- joe_the_user 4y agoAt the same time, this is yet another example of changing the rules in the middle of the game. Yellen has just broadcast that FDIC insurance is essentially unlimited, as long as you can threaten wider disruption to the economy. No, that's been the implicit rule since 2008 at least (arguably earlier). If anything, not supporting all depositors would have been changing the rules mid game and so would have lead to massive disruption. The thing a lot of people aren't getting is that the rules of the game haven't been the law but what the Fed does for a while. Certainly, the game as it's played favors the wealthy, yes. That should be changed. Knocking everything over by suddenly changing expectation wouldn't change things, just disrupt everything. But also, it wouldn't happen anyway 'cause the game is too important.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> No, that’s been the implicit rule since 2008 at least (arguably earlier). No, depositors have lost money in failures since 2008. Its true that, for a long time, the FDIC has tried to resolve failures in a way which protects as much of the uninsured deposits as possible, but it has very much not been a guarantee. The systemic risk exception invoked here is an exception.
- joe_the_user 4y ago"The systemic risk exception invoked here is an exception." Yes but it's not a new exception. The OP claims Yellen implicitly announced something new. She didn't. She's following the playbook from 2008+. The policy isn't new, it's not unexpected, it's kind of like ... a rule. And whether a new rule is being created matters for moral hazard purposes and all. Edit: My above quote could have been read as talking about all depositors in all banks but I meant all depositors in the SVB.
- YZF 4y agoWhere does the money that the banks are going to use to pay for this come from?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- beezle 4y agoWorse, it is also a lie that the cost will not be paid by taxpayer. Of course it will be - the remaining banks are going to pass the cost on via fees, higher loan rates and lower deposit rates? Yellen is not clueless. She knows exactly how this will play out but as it will be spread over time and to many counterparts she simply does not care. This is terrible moral hazard. Uninsured depositors should have taken whatever haircut would result after the auction. That is, after all, the meaning of uninsured.
- ketzo 4y agoLol. If every depositor at SVB just instantly took the straight-up haircut — to the tune of -20% or worse - 50 more banks would fail in the next week. Feds are averting national crisis here.
- hellojesus 4y agoThe crisis needs to happen to correct badly allocated capital.
- xupybd 4y agoThey really need regulation that requires banks to hold more funds. They have to be able to withstand small runs.
- dalyons 4y agoThat wouldn’t have helped here? The run was something like 30% of all deposits at the time of halt
- tick_tock_tick 4y ago> At the same time, this is yet another example of changing the rules in the middle of the game Every time the FDIC has stepped in like this they have made all depositors whole. This is not new behavior.
- mlyle 4y ago> Every time the FDIC has stepped in like this they have made all depositors whole. This is a false assertion. Usually depositors end up losing some of their money above the insurance limits-- only not doing so if the amount of remaining assets proves sufficient to pay the liabilities.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pmarreck 4y ago> Yellen has just broadcast that FDIC insurance is essentially unlimited, as long as you can threaten wider disruption to the economy "If you owe the bank $100 that's your problem. If you owe the bank $100 million, that's the bank's problem." - J. Paul Getty (Or as I heard it more aptly paraphrased, "if you owe the bank a million dollars, the bank owns you. If you owe the bank a billion dollars, you own the bank.")
- ProjectArcturis 4y agoUnlimited FDIC insurance has been the unofficial rule for some time now. No depositor has lost money since 1933, not even when Lehman went bankrupt.
- selimthegrim 4y agoIndyMac depositors lost money IIRC
- sinzone 4y agoThe was a way to get AHEAD of time. The bank regulatory [Liquidity Coverage Ratio] should have never been pushed to $250B in Deposits threshold. It was at $50B for a reason since 2008. But Trump administration lifted to $250B in 2018.
- dixie_land 4y agoWho put them in charge? Like literally, the institution of a central bank is unconstitutional
- MangoCoffee 4y ago> Yellen has just broadcast that FDIC insurance is essentially unlimited, as long as you can threaten wider disruption to the economy. yup. it doesn't matter how big you fuck up if you are too big a risk to US economy. the US govrt (American tax payers) will bail you out.
- bjt 4y agoThe bank shareholders are not getting made whole, and the bank management have lost their jobs. The only people being bailed out are the depositors, who were not being irresponsibly risky.
- FpUser 4y ago>"At the same time, this is yet another example of changing the rules in the middle of the game. Yellen has just broadcast that FDIC insurance is essentially unlimited, as long as you can threaten wider disruption to the economy." Rules exist to serve a purpose. If one risks fucking up the economy with the only goal that the rules are preserved - it could end up with pitchforks.
- tomato_123 4y agoNot bailing out some VCs who hold equity in these depositor-companies would not fuck up the economy. Completely absurd and outrageous.
- FpUser 4y agoI was not talking about bailing out shareholder. Just the depositors.
- tomato_123 4y agoBailing out the depositors is bailing out the VCs who own the depositors.
- treis 4y ago> changing the rules in the middle of the game Part of the rules are that the regulators are supposed to shut down a bank before the run happens. They're not supposed to let the run happen and let the poor saps that were too slow moving their money bear the brunt of the losses.
- tz192045 4y agoYes, and had SVB (among others) not successfully lobbied Congress in 2018 to get big regional banks excluded from more stringent "stress test" requirements, perhaps the regulators could've detected faults in SVB's capital before it was too late.
- treis 4y agoIsn't that between SVB (among others) and the regulators?
- MichaelMoser123 4y ago> Yellen has just broadcast that FDIC insurance is essentially unlimited This is like a hotfix. I don't think that the pile of money is unlimited - all bets are off if something happens to a big bank. Or they stop raising interest rates, and then inflation goes up. Don't know how the banks will cope (or anyone else for that matter...) I guess the banks know that, so they may be afraid to take up new risks in the near future.
- machina_ex_deus 4y agoThis is going to be the beginning of the end of the banking system. I foresee a huge dollar collapse, the US banking system has just lost its final shred of credibility. It's only a facade of a bank at this point. It's just privileged people with a government mandate to leverage on everyone else's money with no consequences.
- tppiotrowski 4y agoCrypto undergoes hard-forks when "special" circumstances arise. It's not immune to unpredictable events.
- machina_ex_deus 4y agoIt's more immune to moral hazards. But I'm not really into crypto, I'm just purely frustrated by the current system. It's an absolute joke at this point.
- twblalock 4y ago> Yellen has just broadcast that FDIC insurance is essentially unlimited, as long as you can threaten wider disruption to the economy. I think everyone knew that already. Since 2008 at least. It's very possible that if this is not done, the only banks left at the end of the week will be the "too big to fail" ones. A domino effect is very hard to prevent when it's based entirely on consumer confidence and those consumers can very easily create a bank run on literally anything if they freak out.
- H8crilA 4y agoAnd perhaps there's no other way? The Japanese did the same with their overpriced real estate provlem, Europe did the same with their almost defaulting countries.
- twblalock 4y agoThink about who gets hurt if the banking system collapses. It ripples out into the rest of the economy, because in fact the economy runs on debt. It would be harder to maintain existing businesses and start new ones if there was a credit crunch -- we lived through a credit crunch after 2008 and it was very bad for everyone. Even if you want certain people to get hurt by this (and there is definitely a baying mob that seems to want to cause as much suffering as possible because they just don't like certain classes of people), keep in mind that this could cause a 2008-style recession that hurts everyone. Who do you think gets hurt more by an economic downturn? The billionaires who lose millions and end up still being rich, or the working people who lose their jobs and can't afford housing? This isn't a theoretical question, we know the answer because it happened before.
- xeromal 4y agoSounds similar to when people were rooting for airlines and auto manufactures to just die in 2008 to say "fuck the rich". I'm glad they were all saved.
- deleted 4y ago
- tropicaljacket 4y agoHow does this "special assessment on banks" work? Does the FDIC charge all US banks to cover the missing amount? How are the charges distributed? And what law is this? Also if this option was available, why did they just bring it up now?
- politician 4y agoIt’s almost certainly going to manifest as tax that will be passed on to customers in the form of lower interest rates on deposits.
- hd95489 4y agoPoor people will get no interest on deposits to bail out the rich.
- ec109685 4y agoRevenue comes from a fee banks pay based on insured deposits. It’s been around 8 cents per $100 insured: https://www.fdic.gov/analysis/quarterly-banking-profile/fdic-quarterly/2010-vol4-4/fdic-quarterly-v4n4-fundmgmt-121610.pdf https://www.fdic.gov/analysis/quarterly-banking-profile/fdic...
- bubbleRefuge 4y agoIts incredible incompetence that the fed doesn't fully guarantee all deposits at FDIC member banks. The liability side of banking is not the place for disciple. MMT founders and Bill Black have been saying this since 2008. Insure depositors and blow out shareholders and management for making bad investments.
- dclowd9901 4y ago1) why shouldn’t it be unlimited and 2) if it is, why are banks private? This is exactly the way I’d expect a good government to respond: protect the people who could not have known better and fuck the rest.
- mikewarot 4y ago>At the same time, this is yet another example of changing the rules in the middle of the game. Yellen has just broadcast that FDIC insurance is essentially unlimited, as long as you can threaten wider disruption to the economy. If this wasn't done... nobody in the world is going to trust their bank within a few days (possibly faster than that thanks to twitter, et al), which would trigger Global Depression II If someone in 1930 overheard a time traveler referring to World War 2.... the shock would have been overwhelming. In the same way, seeing the start of World Depression II isn't something I could bear. It must be true that bank deposits are safe.
- im_down_w_otp 4y agoI don't get it. The FDIC insurance threshold is the bare minimum provided by law. SVB's assets are being sold off or restructured to protect depositors. This is literally the whole point of the receivership process. This appears at this point to be a fairly pedestrian FDIC bank take-over, save for all the culture war B.S. that's cropped up around it.
- hypothesis 4y agoSo, at least two banks failed this week, 16th largest and a smaller one. Then Fed panics and effectively institutes an “unlimited” insurance/backstop policy, as a direct result. I don’t know if I would call those events “pedestrian”.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- justin66 4y ago> This appears at this point to be a fairly pedestrian FDIC bank take-over, You believe invocation of the systemic risk exception is the norm?
- po 4y agoI just posted this on mastodon but I think maybe the community here knows better: If you ran a bank that required insurance on all deposits over the $250k FDIC coverage, and then offered 3rd-party insurance as a convenience for those who wanted it... your bank would be much less likely to suffer a blow up due to a bank run and therefore that insurance should be relatively cheap. Furthermore, people should prefer to bank someplace where all of the depositors are covered. Why is this not commonplace? Simply because the additional fee discourages it? I think if Yellen announced this as a requirement it would remove that incentive to treat FDIC like free unlimited insurance.
- ljf 4y agoWhich apartment block do you thing a most people would rather live in, the one that charges you an extra 10 percent a year but promises to replace all your belongings if it ever burns down, or one that tells you it will never burn down?
- barrkel 4y agoAnd FDIC insurance is more on the order of a couple of percent, varying depending on your investment structure.
- polygamous_bat 4y ago> Why is this not commonplace? Simply because the additional fee discourages it? You actually answer this question in the second half, because banks have been treating the government as free unlimited insurance.
- po 4y agoI guess all the more reason for Yellen to mandate it.
- samch 4y agoThe “ahead of time” component is partially addressed by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency which conducts period stress tests of banks. The people doing the testing know their stuff. These bank evaluations have likely caught and mitigated many issues like SVB ahead of time, and we will never know how many more failures would’ve occurred if it weren’t for their efforts and those of other auditors. Source: https://www.occ.treas.gov/topics/supervision-and-examination/examinations/examinations-overview/index-examinations-overview.html https://www.occ.treas.gov/topics/supervision-and-examination...
- Cipater 4y agoWhy didn't they catch it in this case?
- machina_ex_deus 4y agoBanks have lost all excuses to be making money out of other people's deposits. If those deposits are guaranteed by the government, and backstopped by the government, then there's absolutely no reason banks should be able to invest any of them. There's absolutely no excuse left for why banks get to invest any of their clients money. They get free leverage from their clients for free. They can send it to zero and the entire risk will be held by the government. That's absurd. Revoke banks ability to invest deposits. They can't get to have the cake and eat it too. They could offer higher interest rates for non guaranteed accounts which bear risk, or zero risk for the already zero interest rates.
- ashwagary 4y ago>If those deposits are guaranteed by the government, and backstopped by the government "Any losses to the Deposit Insurance Fund to support uninsured depositors will be recovered by a special assessment on banks, as required by law." Does this mean all American banks (indirectly bank customers) will pay to cover depositor losses that exceed insurance funds?
- Godel_unicode 4y agoNot sure why you’re being downvoted, that analysis is correct.
- ashwagary 4y ago"It's not all tax payers, just all tax payers with bank accounts", which is basically all tax payers. Sounds like word games played by people in charge to have tax payer bailouts using two layers of obfuscation.
- muzz 4y agoAnd also "people with bank accounts who don't make enough to pay taxes" like my grandma.
- HWR_14 4y agoIn every other FDIC bailout, all depositors have been made whole. I don't think any depositor (of standard accounts) has lost money.
- aunterste 4y ago"Any losses to the Deposit Insurance Fund to support uninsured depositors will be recovered by a special assessment on banks, as required by law." Yeah, all corporate customers that have seen an FDIC charge on their statement, based on Q-end balances will have a "special" laugh at this. It's going to be passed through and not be bourn by the surviving banks - that benefit from this 'bailout' of their customers....
- voisin 4y ago> broadcast that FDIC insurance is essentially unlimited Shouldn’t it be? The government is in the best position to regulate and manage the risk of these institutions. We cannot expect average depositors to be financial analysts with the capacity to assess financial institutions.
- xmonkee 4y agowhat’s stopping a bank from making really risky loans, give super high yields? Everyone will go to that bank since there is no risk to them?
- bandrami 4y agoBecause that's not how modern banking works. This isn't George Bailey lending out deposits; retail banks don't use deposited money at all it just kind of disappears.
- dumdumdumdum 4y ago> At the same time, this is yet another example of changing the rules in the middle of the game. Yellen has just broadcast that FDIC insurance is essentially unlimited, as long as you can threaten wider disruption to the economy. The criteria isn't threatening a "wider disruption to the economy", it's threatening the quality of life of a certain class of people. When unions threaten a wider disruption to the economy for maintaining their quality of life, they'll do their damnedest to not give in. They'll pass laws outlawing strikes. Or send in "law-enforcement". As the saying goes, laws are for the poor.
- Godel_unicode 4y agoSVB was publicly traded, and it’s not being bailed out. Who do you think owns the now-worthless stock?
- muzz 4y agoThe market cap of SVB on Friday was $6 B The amount of uninsured deposits was $150 B The value of all the stock is 4% of the amount of uninsured deposits
- mattbillenstein 4y agoWhat is the shortfall once all the assets of the bank are sold though? It's not like anyone is putting $150B into this to make sure those deposits are made whole.
- Phlarp 4y agoYou can't say that right now, I'm not sure anyone can. The government is literally writing a blank check because they don't yet know how much it's going to cost to fix. Everyone seems to be operating under the idea that while their liquidity came into question the underlying assets were and are strong-- if that were true they would have found a private sector solution early in the weekend. Waiting until 6pm on Sunday and a second regional bank collapsing to announce "oops, all bailouts!" seems like an open admission we're in the early stages of another banking crises.
- j16sdiz 4y agoI guess liquidity problem should be treated differently from solvency problem. With FDIC take over the bank asset, this is not paying from taxpayer's money ..
- matheusmoreira 4y agoHuh. Looks like there's gonna be a bailout after all. Guess who's gonna pay for it.
- animex 4y agoThis is exactly how crypto exchanges recover after hacks/losses. Interesting.
- baidifnaoxi 4y ago[dead]
- throwawaaarrgh 4y ago> this is yet another example of changing the rules in the middle of the game. welcome to democracy bro. also, economies are literally black magic. if anyone claims to know how to make them work right, they are either lying or a witch. Edit: oh shit I'm getting downvoted to hell. Was it my suggestion that economists are full of shit, or denigrating witches? Because I have nothing against witches.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- svnt 4y ago> Yellen has just broadcast that FDIC insurance is essentially unlimited, as long as you can threaten wider disruption to the economy. You are almost certainly misreading that signal. Probably since Friday they have assessed that the depositors can be covered once the assets can be liquidated, and that they may even be able to make money doing it. If they can’t, they can assess the rest of the losses to the system, and those losses once divided up are likely to be inconsequential, even if not considered in relation to a broader run on the banking system.
- hellojesus 4y ago> Probably since Friday they have assessed that the depositors can be covered once the assets can be liquidated, and that they may even be able to make money doing it. The same assets that are yielding <4% interest against a market rate of 5%+ or 7%+ or whatever it is? Seems like it's going to take a long while before those papers are trading at or above cost when you account for inflationary devaluation and their yield horizon. There is certainly a cost here. The insolvency of the paper is the entire reason the bank failed in the first place.
- wolverine876 4y ago> changing the rules in the middle of the game I'm pretty sure that rules is already established. What makes you say they just changed it?
- arcticbull 4y agoIt's not though, SVB equity holders are getting zeroed out. Raiding the DIF to pay out depositors in extraordinary circumstances and then recovering it through a special assessment is basically the whole point of having an FDIC. The justice is that SVB equity went to $0.
- Lazare 4y ago> At the same time, this is yet another example of changing the rules in the middle of the game. Not exactly. Or rather yes, but the rules changed in 2008, not this week. Specifically after IndyMac failed in 2008, there was significant blowback on the FDIC from Congress, and an unoficial, unnounced policy was put in place to ignore the $250k limit and ensure uninsured depositors took no losses in (almost) all cases. From https://www.americanbanker.com/opinion/will-fdic-keep-protecting-failed-banks-uninsured-deposits https://www.americanbanker.com/opinion/will-fdic-keep-protec...: > Of the 127 banks and thrifts that failed from Jan. 1, 1993, to the last bank that failed before IndyMac was closed [...] 71% of the total deposits of the 127 failures were in institutions where uninsured depositors suffered a loss, while 29% of the deposits were in institutions resolved through a P&A that fully protected uninsured depositors from any loss whatsoever. Whereas: > Since IndyMac, there have been 522 failures, excluding Washington Mutual [...] Of the 522 failures, just 31, or 5.9%, were resolved in a manner that only protected insured deposits — uninsured depositors were therefore put at risk of a loss. Those 31 banks and thrifts held just 4.9% of the deposits of the post-IndyMac failures. (Washington Mutual is excluded because it was enormous compared to the other failed banks - although since uninsured depositors were protected, including it just skews the stats even further.) So for the past 15 years, we've had a system where the overwhelming majority (well over 95%) of uninsured deposits were protected, and thus, it would have been legitimately very surprising if recovery for uninsured deposits in SVB wasn't 100%, because it's very clear that unstated FDIC policy is to aim for that, and they've got a strong track record of achieving it. (I will state that I find the hidden nature of this policy problematic, however.) The only thing surprising about events so far is that there's been enough noise that some new policies had to be announced, instead of it all just being quietly resolved like normal.
- antonvs 4y ago> I really wish we could plan for these entirely foreseeable events ahead of time so that it's not just cases of "selective justice" with regards to who gets bailed out. That’s an unrealistic utopian fantasy. The real world doesn’t even remotely lend itself to that kind of planning. Even calling it “selective justice” involves an unrealistic bias. What is happening is that the particular circumstances are being weighed an a suitable response is being formulated. The rulebook for planning for all such events ahead of time would not be that much shorter than the future history of human civilization.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 4y agoI can't pinpoint anything specific they did wrong, compared to peers. Their operating expenses were not that large, for example. So what happened to them, can happen to any bank now. That's why FED are worried.
- hackerlight 4y agoChanging the rules is good if evidence emerges that the rules are bad. In this case, the $250k guarantee was thought to be enough to prevent this kind of thing from occurring. We now know it was insufficient. The world has changed since that was implemented. Namely, social contagion, which is one of the causes of bank runs, can act harder and faster in the age of social media.
- JustSomeNobody 4y agoTech company lays off 10K workers, HN is like, well, they have a fiduciary responsibility to their investors! SVB takes a dive and wants a bailout, HN is like, think of the workers! WTF?
- rayiner 4y ago> At the same time, this is yet another example of changing the rules in the middle of the game. Yellen has just broadcast that FDIC insurance is essentially unlimited, as long as you can threaten wider disruption to the economy And it doesn’t have to be that wide a threat. The threat here was pretty localized. Aside from blue chips that everyone has their pensions invested in (which don’t seem to be at risk) the rest of the country doesn’t have much exposure to this. Maybe I’m wrong but that seems like a significant shift in policy, where the government will change the rules to respond to a localized crisis.
- j0hnyl 4y agoIf it didn't happen so fast they probably would have gotten some kind of bailout before fdic stepped in.
- varelse 4y ago[dead]
- JPKab 4y agoYellen is an incompetent ideologue. I studied applied economics in university, and the first code I wrote for a real application were inflation simulations. When she and the Fed made the claim a few years ago that "inflation was transitory" I ended up calling several of my smartest classmates. It was a nice excuse to reconnect, and universally all of us were asking what she was smoking. It wasn't just us. Larry Summers was prominently and publicly stating that the inflation was definitely not transitory. But the banks believed her, and continued in 2021 to buy these securities as if interest rates were going to be going low again in the near future.
- hellojesus 4y ago> But the banks believed her, and continued in 2021 to buy these securities as if interest rates were going to be going low again in the near future. The banks most certainly didn't believe her. The banks rightfully took it as a signal that the US gov would step in to cut losses if banks continued to loan. The Fed wanted banks to continue to loan so they didn't grind the overall economy to a halt instantly and send us into stagflation. But everyone knew it would happen. The Fed knew they were playing a losing strategy. And they still know it. But they refuse to play the strategy that would win the inflation game because it would bankrupt the country. The only way out now is through severe tax hikes + gov spending cuts OR war with China in the hope to reset debt at its conclusion. The political elite seem to be signaling the latter.
- neovialogistics 4y agoHave you considered the hypothesis that she is competent and was lying and/or bullshitting? Hypothetically, if I ran a government that was engaged in geopolitical competition, I wouldn't want people to tell the truth to my detriment when alternatives could be gotten away with.
- JPKab 4y agoIt's too depressing for me to take that hypothesis. It's far easier for me to believe that Yellen is a deeply intelligent and talented economist who lacked the ability to protect her cognitive processes from optimism bias. People think that when you say incompetent you are saying they aren't intelligent enough for the job. I think she was temperamentally unfit. I want people in the Federal reserve that don't care at all if they get invited to cocktail parties or get job offers. I want them to be people who don't mind being hated by everyone. I want Paul fucking Volcker level of tolerance to everybody hating you. All that being said, the thing that undermines my desire to not believe your theory is that she made the terrible mistake of going straight to work for the Biden administration from the Fed. Even if this was done for noble reasons it just makes the Federal Reserve look partisan which is a really bad place for it to be.
- cryptonector 4y agoI thought the old $100k limit was statutory. Then in 2008 it was changed by the executive w/o Congress approving it (or has it, since?). Now it's being changed no limit and fees are being raised. These are fees charged by a government entity, so one would expect Congress to have to be involved. Can a depositor sue to have the old fees restored? Can a bank sue to have the old fees restored?
- bjornsing 4y agoThe “run with the herd” crowd likes it this way sine it means they will be bailed out, but not their independent-minded competitors.
- partiallypro 4y agoIf this were a middle America community bank failure with deposits from a bunch of farmers and factory workers that is a 0% chance they would have changed the rules. This happened because the tech industry has massive lobbying power.
- sgregnt 4y agoCommunism