20 ms·
An account was suspended
- michaelmcdonald 4y agoBen's account is already un-suspended, but only because he has a major presence and large audience (I would be shocked if people at Twitter didn't see this minutes into it happening or if Ben didn't have some direct line to various high up employees there). For the rest of us peasants: good luck getting help.
- rgrieselhuber 4y agoEspecially if you ask the wrong questions.
- mschuster91 4y agoEven blue checkmarks don't help against trolls, far right and griefers running mass-report attacks. The problem at its core is that Twitter refuses to hire appropriate levels of moderation staff for the scale it has, and that it does nothing against raid instigators. Reddit at least has subreddit mods take care of most of the bullshit and at least the large subreddit mods have direct connections to Reddit, and Reddit itself fights back against communities that "raid" other subs, but even there it's common experience on subreddits like TwoX that women get reported to the Reddit Suicide Alert. Twitter however? Good luck if you're not in Germany where you can file for emergency civil injunctions against Twitter in the case of wrongful bans (Twitter and FB both learned the hard way to not ignore these) or have friends in media that can amplify your shitstorm. Twitter moderation teams only act on reports, they unlike Reddit don't seem to have any staff dedicated to monitoring sentiments and trends to detect abusive behavior.
- astura 4y agoWho is the "Reddit Suicide Alert?"
- haunter 4y agoYou can report any post or comment on reddit, an one option is "self-harm or suicide" https://i.imgur.com/aGLtTeW.png https://i.imgur.com/aGLtTeW.png I think it meant in a way that you are afraid of the person. If you are the one reported then you also get an automatic system message from reddit: someone thought you might have problems etc. Basically the suicide alert. Anyways people use it all the time in every single sub for any unrelated thing, just because they hate you, downvoting is not enough, trolling etc. In sport subs it's very common to report opposing fans with this option for example
- onionisafruit 4y agoI comment a lot on /r/cfb and /r/nfl and I wasn’t aware of this. I don’t really trash talk, but I’m surprised at least one of my thousands of comments hasn’t elicited a suicide alert.
- jffry 4y agoBasically a "feature" of Reddit which can be used to anonymously harass somebody on Reddit by having it send them a DM about suicide prevention. https://www.theverge.com/2020/3/4/21164687/reddit-new-suicide-prevention-tools-crisis-text-line https://www.theverge.com/2020/3/4/21164687/reddit-new-suicid...
- formerly_proven 4y agoWhich, just to be clear, is meant to convey the opposite obviously. "Reddit cares" is 99.99 % used by people to send others (I've seen mostly women raise this) a "kill yourself" message. Just like people who put "heartwarming" awards on posts about abuse, harassment etc. On some subreddits every other post will be reported like this. Meanwhile, Reddit tends to do very little about reports of even direct violence threats ala "I will find you and I will kill your children" etc. which are frequently found to "not be in violation of the terms of service".
- themoonisachees 4y agoYou can report someone if you think they're suicidal and they get a pm from reddit that says "we care about you, here's a suicide prevention hotline etc". It's used for trolling for some reason.
- somehnacct3757 4y agoThere's no such thing as appropriate moderation at Twitter scale. It's societal techology we as humans do not have. Underlying moderation is some shared vision of decency - morality claims that should be enforced via justice. These claims certainly don't exist across nation borders, and they barely exist within a given nation's borders. The bot moderation conundrum is a wholly second moderation question layered on top of the first. How do Twitter accounts map onto human bodies? Is it 1:1, like government ids? 1:many so brands can have accounts? many:1 so humans can amplify their voice? Until this is answered all moderation actions taken in the name of 'bot policy' is capricious. As is the assignment of blue checkmarks. Reddit struggles with these same problems at website-scale, where moderation must work across subreddits. They only appear to have a better solution because some topics at subreddit-scale make enough of the questions I raise irrelevant that you can install a goon and have them moderate via edict. Just like chat rooms and message boards did in the old days. To make that point a little clearer: you can be off-topic in a subreddit or an Orange Site thread, but you can't be off-topic anywhere on Twitter.
- efitz 4y agoI think the solution is opt-in curation. If someone (or 10k someones) watches and compiles quality items of interest, maybe i want one of those feeds INSTEAD of Twitter’s ML algorithm. Twitter can still monetize but now curations could monetize individually via including specific ad tweets. And i want to subscribe to multiple curations, not just one. Twitter could even have their own ML algorithm as a curation but I want it to be explicit opt in. You could browse curations by popularity or topic and opt in to the ones you like, or opt out if you don’t like one anymore. Trolls wouldn’t get included in curations that anyone cared about. The down side is that it magnifies the social media echo chamber effect, but it also makes everyone’s feed more personally relevant.
- bsnnkv 4y agoThis sounds a lot like what I'm working on with Notado Feeds[1]. Users can curate feeds (with RSS subscriptions) on specific topics from their libraries that get automatically populated. I haven't published a dedicated article on this feature yet, but it's coming. For an idea of what it looks like in practice, these are my feeds on software development[2] and capitalism[3]. Interested in one but not the other? No problem, ignore the capitalism feed and just sub to the software development feed; you don't have to be hit by a train of all of my thoughts on every little topic by subscribing to an all-encompassing feed. I'm currently working on a piece around feed discoverability that will integrate RSS subscription stats in few interesting late 90s/early 00s-web ways. [1]: https://notado.app https://notado.app [2]: https://notado.app/feeds/jado/software-development https://notado.app/feeds/jado/software-development [3]: https://notado.app/feeds/jado/capitalism https://notado.app/feeds/jado/capitalism
- lapcat 4y ago> The problem at its core is that Twitter refuses to hire appropriate levels of moderation staff for the scale it has I don't believe that anyone could moderate at Twitter's scale. More than 500 million tweets are published per day. How do you moderate that? It's like bringing an umbrella to a tsunami. Not to mention, Reddit moderation is crap. I've tried to use Reddit several times but gave up each time, because my innocent comments — mainly writing technical help — were getting moderated. I wasn't writing anything political; I couldn't even post on r/apple! They still use a lot of automation on Reddit in the bigger subreddits.
- rfrey 4y agoThe important thing is that humans review algorithmic bans, not review every tweet.
- lapcat 4y agoThat's still a huge number. Twitter doesn't make enough revenue to hire enough people to do that intelligently.
- mschuster91 4y agoThen they have to raise money? You can't operate a chemical factory without paying for adequate measures to prevent spewing toxic waste into common resources like air and water, so why should you be allowed to run a facility that spews toxic hate into societies without establishing adequate protection?! If there is one thing that made the internet so toxic, it was services labeled as "free" that in reality were nothing more than avenues for advertisers to shove ads down our throats, with the cost being our societies breaking apart as a result of all the lone village nutcases suddenly unifying themselves and no one paying for the virtual equivalent of the police to make sure the nutcases don't create chaos.
- lapcat 4y ago> Then they have to raise money? I think they're trying. ;-) To be clear, I'm not defending Twitter. If I was in charge, I would actually shut down Twitter for the benefit of the world. My point is just the basic financial fact that Twitter doesn't have enough money to do this, and thus they won't, indeed can't.
- coffeeblack 4y ago> Twitter and FB both learned the hard way to not ignore these Are there actual cases (plural)? I only know one lawyer and one case where that happened and was decided by the BGH (federal court).
- the_doctah 4y agoBlue checkmarks have been a joke for years. And imagine using Reddit as an example of "good" moderation.
- alfiedotwtf 4y agoYep. My account got suspended a few years ago. But to be honest, it was a blessing in disguise. Twitter for me was a huge time sink, even though I followed really interesting people talking about things I was really interesting. But once I got a forced detox, I realised I just gained back hours a week to do other things. Get off Twitter. Even better, turn off that TV.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoThat is basically how I feel about my LinkedIn. Now I am actually working on a personal replacement of that online presence piece. Frankly, it was high time.
- breck 4y agoI find Twitter amazing. (though I'm currently suspended again - https://twitter.com/breckyunits https://twitter.com/breckyunits). The trick is not to have a smart phone. When I'm coding I can pop in and out of Twitter. But then when I close the lid I'm unplugged.
- psychphysic 4y agoBut why do you keep getting suspended?
- htrp 4y agoNo smart phone... and no twitter app install.
- mikro2nd 4y agoNot so. I, too, have no smartphone and no Twitter app. Not ever been suspended (yet).
- commandlinefan 4y agoStratechery interviews?
- 4y ago
- matthewdgreen 4y agoYou're benefiting from a massive open, unpartitioned platform (meaning, anyone can join and form communities/reply-to tweets, without isolating things to friend-groups or creating 'subreddits' with human moderators gatekeeping them). The platform gives you unprecedented global reach, and most amazingly: it's still functional and hasn't been drowned in spam. I think people need to take a breath and realize that this is an incredible technical accomplishment in 2022 (or 2015, 2009, 2001) given the ambient noise level of the Internet. You are not going to keep a platform like this readable and still be able to apply loving, artisanal human decision-making to it: there aren't enough human beings in the world. If you start a new account that behaves like spam, there's a good chance that you'll get treated like spam -- and that's probably an acceptable tradeoff because the alternative is no working platform at all.
- rchaud 4y agoSounds like how complaints about Stripe magically get personal attention from company insiders, but only after being publicized to HN.
- mritchie712 4y agoto be fair, stripe has thousands of businesses and real money on the line. they are going to get some things wrong. My experience (in one of their target markets of b2b SaaS) has been flawless.
- rchaud 4y agoBut Stripe should provide timelier service than Twitter precisely because there is real money on the line. If Twitter suspends my account, I wouldn't expect much considering it's a free service with tens of millions more users than Stripe. They're definitely going to get more things wrong.
- adrr 4y agoYou can always get your own merchant account. Stripe is about being convenient since they don't due all the diligence of a bank when you sign up for a merchant account.
- shadowgovt 4y agoWhat are the practical alternatives? I'd imagine this is an issue one would see less often on a Mastodon node, as nodes tend to have fewer users per node so moderators / admins can respond more promptly to system failures, and if one doesn't like how an admin is running affairs, one can switch nodes.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JacobThreeThree 4y agoA federated system like Mastadon seems to be a good technical solution, but I think the more simple solution is to spend your valuable time on platforms that have better moderation, or invest in building your own website/platform.
- BitwiseFool 4y agoThe proposed solution is simple, but the problem has always been audience and discovery. Even if you managed to find a perfect platform with a decent userbase, you would still need to rely on people sharing links to your content on the more widely known platforms. Very rarely do people stumble upon blogs and niche social media sites.
- IshKebab 4y agoOffer reasonable options to get it reinstated of course.
- shadowgovt 4y agoI'm not sure what reasonable looks like when a system has 237 million daily active users and the reinstatement system itself would be intentionally gamed by adversaries. Do we have any examples to draw from operating at that scale? Due to the Musk purchase, we have a rare public disclosure of a major tech giant's internal workings where Twitter claims (https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/jul/07/twitter-says-it-suspends-1m-spam-users-a-day-as-elon-musk-dispute-deepens https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2022/jul/07/twitter-s...) it suspends half a million spam accounts a day. It's trivial to file an appeal, so (because the attackers are by no means disincentivized from appealing) that's probably on the order of 250,000 appeals a day if we assume even half the banned won't bother (and I think that assumption is low, since a reasonable system should probably make it trivial to file an appeal, therefore people will). How does one reasonably handle that? To scale up to thousands of humans handling it, you'd need strict rules to even approximate getting the same result across everyone, and if strict rules worked you could code them into the auto-ban system. One solution might actually be "Stop having 'get every human being on the service' as a goal," but then sucks for the people who can't use the thing.
- danso 4y agoI've played devil's advocate elsewhere in the thread, but this is such a petty and irrelevant kerfuffle, as far as Big-Tech-Censorship goes. By Ben's own description of how the @StratecheryINT account was operated [0] -- i.e. "a new account that has posted a bunch of links (all Stratechery interviews) in a short amount of time, from multiple locations around the world." -- this is exactly the kind of low-hanging fruit that we'd want Twitter spam-detectors to cull with minimal time and resources. Not only b/c of the obvious spam characteristics, but because it was a days-old account with few (if any) followers/followings. Even if it were a mistake, very little of value has been lost, since every tweet was the result of an automated script (i.e. simple to make a new account, and recreate the content that had thus far zero engagement). Do people seriously think every such case -- an empty days-old account suddenly doing spam-like activity -- should be manually reviewed? That's a daily waste of human resources for tens of thousands (edit: actually it's millions [1]) of trivial permaban decisions -- exactly the kind of thing that an autoban algorithm can efficiently handle. > For the rest of us peasants: good luck getting help. I have the same sentiment, but with a different angle. Verified accounts like Thompson's get a lot of leeway with bending/breaking the rules before facing actual punishment. If a lesser known user deployed a selenium-twitter-spam-bot on AWS, it's possible both their spam bot and their real account would be permanently suspended [0] https://twitter.com/benthompson/status/1583062865116041229 https://twitter.com/benthompson/status/1583062865116041229 [1] https://twitter.com/paraga/status/1526237583058952192?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1526237583058952192%7Ctwgr%5E9d286983482d1827f9533c9db48584f961510930%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.theguardian.com%2Ftechnology%2F2022%2Fjul%2F07%2Ftwitter-says-it-suspends-1m-spam-users-a-day-as-elon-musk-dispute-deepens https://twitter.com/paraga/status/1526237583058952192?ref_sr...
- lapcat 4y ago> Verified accounts like Thompson's get a lot of leeway with bending/breaking the rules before facing actual punishment. Which rules did he break?
- rjzzleep 4y agoIt doesn't have to be a lot of links, if you piss off the wrong people and they massreport you you're temporarily out. You can reach out to support, but I don't know that support actually ever responds to any requests. Apparently according to posts on reddit if you add your number to twitter and something happens you won't even be able to ever remove it. Similarly they have weird intransparent policies regarding what numbers are allowed on twitter. At the end of the day, most tech giants are unreachable. I hate to be that guy,but in a way it's kind of like the big chinese tech dystopia that all HN so adamantly complain about.
- shitlord 4y agoMy Twitter account was suspended for "spam" a year ago because I kept replying to someone with the same reaction image. They reverted the suspension pretty quickly after I appealed. I guess they handle appeals differently depending on the alleged infraction.
- celeritascelery 4y agoThis is another power imbalance that is so frustrating. The account was “permanently suspended”, which you think means permanently suspended. But that only applies to normies. All the words are meaningless if twitter says otherwise. It’s really like living under a medieval king who is a law unto himself.
- brazzy 4y agoWrong tree to bark up. "Permanently" only means there is no time limit with an automatic reactivation afterwards. It's absolutely possible for a "normie" to get a permanent ban reviewed and lifted.
- CharlesW 4y agoThe point is that they're using "permanently suspended" to mean "indefinitely suspended". They could also just say "suspended".
- Dylan16807 4y ago"Indefinitely" is reasonable, but doesn't make it clear that they have finished their current investigation. So it's also imperfect. Just "suspended" is not a good option at all, because it says nothing about duration.
- cgriswald 4y ago"Indefinitely suspended" implies that Twitter might, on its own, lift the suspension at some point in the future. "Permanently suspended" (with chance to appeal the suspension in the message) means exactly what happened here.
- creata 4y ago"Indefinitely suspended" might be better, but just "suspended" is probably going to be very confusing. In education, for example, "suspension" is a temporary ban, and "expulsion" is a permanent ban.
- 4y ago
- rogerallen 4y agoMy twitter evolutionary art bot @tweegeemee is going through a fiasco like this, but I don't have nearly the same presence as Ben. The account was suspended for 10 days and I'm still trying to get the app (separately suspended) that runs it unsuspended... They must be going through some kind of crazy time over there between nation-state trolls, the Musk fiasco and the run-up to midterm elections. Yeesh.
- maddynator 4y agoYeah completely matches my experience. Twitter banned my account for far less and unlike Ben, I dont have major presence or large audience. I wrote about my experience on the blog [0] so others can learn but what I learned is that there is an automated system to flag and automated system to respond to your questions and the later system rejects 99.99% of cases. You have to be in Ben's position to fall into that .01% [0] https://thinkingthrough.substack.com/p/twitter-ban https://thinkingthrough.substack.com/p/twitter-ban
- hintymad 4y agoI was wondering why Twitter does not tell account owners what exactly violates their Twitter Rules. Isn't this exactly the same as the very censorship of those totalitarian countries: they tell you break some rules but they never tell you which rules, so you're forced to self censor, and they can interpret their rules however they like. It is this kind of behavior that make me lose my trust with Twitter (or YouTube or FB, and etc).
- excerionsforte 4y agohttps://twitter.com/benthompson/status/1583062865116041229?cxt=HHwWmsDUxbrSlfgrAAAA https://twitter.com/benthompson/status/1583062865116041229?c... gives an idea why it happened. He'll get it back.
- TotempaaltJ 4y agoThis sounds like a very reasonable suspension to me.
- shadowgovt 4y agoExactly. A new account showing up out of nowhere posting nothing but links is basically exemplar spambot material.
- Semaphor 4y agoNote that he goes into detail why he is so pissed: > It’s the “after careful review” line that has me riled up tbh. I can understand why an automated system suspended it. Don’t lie to me! -- https://nitter.kavin.rocks/benthompson/status/1583063313948499969#m https://nitter.kavin.rocks/benthompson/status/15830633139484...
- iLoveOncall 4y agoHonest question: why would the account in question not be suspended after review by a human? It's a new account that posted 75 tweets in less than 20 minutes, all linking to the same website, and with high-profile names in the title of the tweets. This looks like spam to me, I would have banned it too.
- inanutshellus 4y ago> why would the account in question not be suspended after review by a human? A human would have. He's just pointing out something to redirect the ire. Specifically, that it says "careful", and yet a robot did the work, and presumably robots can't be full of care.
- 4y ago
- OJFord 4y ago'permanently suspended' is weird in itself isn't it? Just avoiding the word 'banned' or similar.. but butchering other words into meaning the same thing?
- hairofadog 4y agoGood catch. “Suspended” by definition is temporary.
- true_religion 4y agoThat and it’s not permanent, it’s indefinite. All suspensions can be reversed manually.
- PopAlongKid 4y agoBack in high school, I think everyone understood the difference between a student being suspended and being expelled.
- jacobriis 4y agoIt's such a power move to dictate things that don't make sense or that are internally inconsistent. Suspended: Caused to stop for a while; interrupted or delayed. You are permanently stopped for a while. Unfortunately: Happening through bad luck Through bad luck (not an intentional decision we are making), our policy prohibits that. Unfortunately, your account has been permanently suspended.
- Izkata 4y agoAlso, > has been "we didn't do it, it just sort of happened"
- Karliss 4y agoThat actually somewhat correct description of situation. Computer heuristic randomly banning users, with "careful review" not involving any humans or at least humans who care about results. They did make the system but afterwards it just does stuff by itself.
- tosh 4y agoSpam (and scam) detection in social networks is hard. Yet it is fascinating how "random" suspensions like these (sometimes without recourse if you aren't famous or know the right people) feel like they come straight out of a dystopian sci-fi script.
- tosh 4y agoQuick improvement for Twitter: rephrase/defuse the wording to show that mistakes happen and that "permanent" might not be like … permanent.
- logicalmonster 4y ago> Spam (and scam) detection in social networks is hard. Just a question. What's the true harm in letting even obvious spammers spam as much as they want on their social media profiles? Let them waste their time. Social media is a bit different than a message board where everybody is burdened by any spam that's posted because you have to follow somebody intentionally to see their idiocy on social media. If somebody wants to post 100 ads for viagra a day on some dumb Twitter bot profile, who is actually going to follow them other than maybe other bots? You really only have to worry about cleaning up the search results to ensure that the spam is hidden from standard searches. The only person who should be upset about random bot spam on social media is the advertiser that might have paid a lot of money for loads of low-quality ad impressions. Well, doesn't it follow that the advertising payment system and business model is the real issue here, not automating spam detection? Somewhere in the process, social media has to ensure that advertisers aren't paying for bot impressions. It's not necessarily the spam itself that's the real issue.
- lapcat 4y ago> You really only have to worry about cleaning up the search results to ensure that the spam is hidden from standard searches. I agree, profile spam only seems harmful to the search results. Reply spam, on the other hand, is a big problem. But there was no reply spam in Ben's suspended account.
- Nextgrid 4y ago
- Tade0 4y agoI wonder why is the ban permanent right off the bat? To me it sounds reasonable to ban an alleged spam account for a limited period e.g. 24h - spammers won't bother waiting and will just create another account just like they normally do. An abandoned account can then be deleted. Can anyone point out any obvious flaws in my reasoning?
- true_religion 4y agoBecause spammers will just come back and use the account after 24 hours. They’re just using bots, so coding into it that you should come back to an account after 1 day is simple. They already have delays in postings to try and evade flood spam checks.
- hk__2 4y ago> I wonder why is the ban permanent right off the bat? Because that’s simpler? > spammers won't bother waiting and will just create another account just like they normally do What makes you think they will not bother waiting 24h? If I were managing a spambots farm I guess I would rather wait 24h than go through the hassle of re-creating a Twitter account.
- rchaud 4y agoYou could do both. Time is money, so you could create a new account and start spamming right away, and log back in to the old one after 24h to see if the suspension has been lifted.
- Zak 4y agoI suspect this kind of problem is unavoidable when a large fraction of the world uses a centralized many-to-many communication platform. Moderation is always going to be a cost center for such a platform and there's a big gap between good enough moderation to prevent a mass exodus and what most of us would likely call good. Using decentralized tools might improve the situation.
- nfriedly 4y agoI think the problem is less that they temporarily banned his account, it's more that the language of the message was completely false. There was no "careful review", and it was not permanent. Also, as others have pointed out, "suspension" implies that the interruption is temporary, so "permanently suspended" doesn't even make sense.
- themitigating 4y agoIf you wanted to suspend a user's account for a period of time you would say "suspended for two weeks". What if you wanted to suspend a user forever but it might have been a mistake or you might change your mind?
- nfriedly 4y agoI think that just "suspended" would be more appropriate than "permanently suspended". Although, it seems that the reality of the situation is closer to "your account is permanently banned unless you manage to raise enough fuss that an actual human looks at it."
- Zak 4y agoIt just reads like generic corporate speak to me. All corporate decisions are "careful" and adverse actions have names that sound milder than they are.
- impossiblefork 4y agoIt doesn't need to be centralized though, and I think centralization is the cause of both the moral problems (political bans, censorship, etc.) and the difficulties running these things. Without centralization it's just some kind of trust network, and since the messages are open it's a much easier problem to filter away unwanted material than to deal with things like e-mail spam. The reason people don't is simply that they want power over political discourse, so they accept what part of these problems are problems for them and are then happy for the other problems.
- Lendal 4y agoDo we really need to surface every bug/bot report in Twitter's backlog and then assume villainous intent? Come on. Aren't we better than this?
- adtac 4y agohttps://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc9225.html https://www.rfc-editor.org/rfc/rfc9225.html
- jimcavel888 4y ago
- andirk 4y agoI commented on a Fauci video where he said every1 will likely eventually be exposed to the virus. I said "and eventually we will all die" which was marked as misinformation and I was cancelled.
- jonathanstrange 4y agoPersonally, I think this might have been the right decision, though not for the reason given. If you remove accounts of people who frequently do not contribute anything useful to discussions, you'll get overall better discussions.
- tb_technical 4y agoThe same could be said for your contributions, and in my enlightened post-truth regime people like you would be the foundation of my new space program. You would be enlisted (by force) to be the first astronauts to visit the sun.
- jonathanstrange 4y agoI hear you, but have to point out that sending people into the sun is more drastic than merely suspending their accounts.
- andirk 4y agoWhat I said was true. I challenge any1 to say a more true statement. And I commented it bc he said "we'll all likely eventually be exposed to the virus". That isnt useful information.
- jonathanstrange 4y agoYou were obviously trolling and Fauci made a meaningful statement in the context. It's sad that you pretend to not see the difference in order not to lose face in front of a pseudonymous internet audience. You deserve to be more honest with yourself.
- imhoguy 4y agoWell, automated banning is going beyond absurd. OT but just yesterday I finally decided to join Discord fad for some open-source communities, but my freshly created account got instantly disabled after successful validation with email and phone, that without sending any message. Unfortunately I don't own a second phone number to register another one. I better stick with my veteran ways - IRC, mail-lists, forums. Matrix is on my list to check.
- formerly_proven 4y agoIt's actually remarkable how many users discord has considering how difficult it is to register an account that's not instantly shadowbanned or disabled.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoThere is no consistency to any of it. Some people sign up using mainstream KYC email accounts like gmail, give their phone numbers, connect from their residential IP with the desktop client, and get instabanned. Other people, like myself, sign up with shady throwaway email accounts like cock.li, provide no phone number, only connect from VPN IPs with a browser, and don't get banned even after two years.
- imhoguy 4y agoUpdate: I appealed and Discord just reenabled my account. They blamed antispam mechanisms. I guess it didn't like my Firefox with uBlock orgin as the other commenter mentioned.
- throwup 4y agoI had a Discord account created in 2015 that I had always used with their Android app. Then one day I logged in with Firefox and boom, suddenly and permanently banned. I'm not sure what the lesson is here... maybe avoid uBlock and submit to the surveillance?
- luckylion 4y ago> avoid uBlock and submit to the surveillance I think that's what PayPal is trying to teach me, where logins will randomly fail with an adblocker and 2fa enabled.
- Semaphor 4y agoHe goes into detail: > It’s the “after careful review” line that has me riled up tbh. I can understand why an automated system suspended it. Don’t lie to me! -- https://twitter.com/benthompson/status/1583063313948499969 https://twitter.com/benthompson/status/1583063313948499969 And yeah, I have to agree. I absolutely hate it when providers (shipping companies are great at this) tell me obvious lies. Hey, I can handle issues and problems. What I can’t handle are lies.
- themitigating 4y agoI'm confused about what he means. "After careful review" means that a human double checked it right?
- BenjiWiebe 4y agoIt should mean that, but apparently doesn't mean that. Hence getting riled up.
- josephcsible 4y agoYes, that's what that means. He's upset because a human didn't actually double check it, so Twitter is lying by saying that.
- TheCapn 4y agoI went through an entire ban appeal process with Electronic Arts over my Apex Legends account and was treated similarly. According to one EA Forum Moderator, there are actual people reviewing appeals, but the fact that they upheld my ban saying it was correct only to revert it 2 weeks after I stopped fighting them tells me their process is flawed. My best guess is bans are handed out automatically based on whatever heuristic, but the human review merely checks the log generated by the automated system for rudimentary errors. Was my account the one flagged and not a different user by mistake? Yes. Ban upheld. (except not, when they gave my account back with no apology)
- 4y ago
- Kiro 4y agoThe biggest takeaway is that his name is actually not Stratechery. Why on earth would you name your site something so extremely hard to parse?
- prepend 4y agoIt’s a portmanteau of the authors two favorite things: Stratego by MiltonBradley and Treachery. Something about cheating at board games. (And the domain was available)
- kilovoltaire 4y agoI thought it was based on the Bush-ism "strategery" - https://stratechery.com/2013/strategery/ https://stratechery.com/2013/strategery/ Or was that a later change?
- mns 4y agoCan't wait for the AI to replace middle management, like the other link from the front-page claimed will happen. I can finally get fired by some black box algorithm so no one has to take responsibility.
- mikro2nd 4y agoIt has already, and long ago. It's just not very intelligent. Have you had any serious (non-routine) dealings with a bank or phone co. lately? Nobody you can talk to has any agency, any authority to do anything other than what the algorithm (which includes their internal rules, guidelines, etc.) tells them to do.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoI'm a big fan of Ben Thompson, and I'm not necessarily on Twitter's side here, but this to me seems more like a case of Ben whining about "Spam is when someone else sends it". From his own words, this "Stratechery Interviews" account was a new account that only sent out tweets of links from multiple locations around the world. In other words, the only thing really distinguishing it from spam on a technical level is that Ben liked the content it was tweeting about. Sure, I'd be annoyed too, but Ben's rage tweets just show to me that even the most rational among us become emotional when we don't get something want.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lapcat 4y agoIt's important to note that the suspended account didn't send any replies, or even retweet or like any other accounts. Presumably it didn't send any unsolicited DMs either. The account was not harming or annoying anyone. Does it even qualify as "spam"?
- ajmurmann 4y agoAgreed on this point. This easily could have been a bot farming reputation by retweeting someone else's content. It is shocking though how much much more blatant spam goes unchecked. Pretty much every tweet by popular accounts has a slew of crypto spam replies.
- dpcx 4y ago
- bell-cot 4y agoSad, but... Other than cyber-utopian hype, social media sales pitches, and the human love for "a deal too good to be true...while it lasts", is there any reason to expect competent, reliable customer service from any large social media company which is based on free accounts? Let alone a company which shows ~no evidence of being able to break even (financially, over time)?
- pyuser583 4y agoHad my account suspended from FB for no apparent reason. I just stopped using FB.
- negamax 4y agoAt this stage I wonder what will Elon found when he takes over Twitter. There seems to be a lot of dubious policies at play.
- simple-thoughts 4y agoIf you’re struggling with account suspensions, you can ask around in telegram. You can hire people from India to create a new account for a few dollars for you.
- seydor 4y agoDamn i thought it was my account
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- honksillet 4y agoThis is why most people think any management would be better than twitters current managers.
- themitigating 4y agoSimilar situations occur on aws, cloudflare, gmail, etc.
- jagtesh 4y agoFacebook (the social app) and Google (Ads, Play Store, etc) are no different. I’ve read countless accounts from many individuals and small/independent app developers about their accounts being suspended or terminated with little to no means of redressal. I will go on to say that this remains a generally unsolved problem for companies working at scale that are under scrutiny and dealing with financial or social fraud. They are willing to accept false negatives instead of false positives. I worked in an organization that prided itself with great customer service, and they did deliver. The cost of doing so (resolving each case manually, often giving benefit to the customer) is significant. Amazon is another prime example of a company that does customer service well - though that might have some consequences on their work culture (mistakes are not easily forgiven - since the cost is so high). Not an apples to apples comparison though, Twitter is ad based (much higher volume/users needed for revenue) unlike Amazon. More users = more challenges with the same level of staff. That’s how you end up with a cheap processes (lots of automation, outsourced reviews) designed to handle 90% cases vs. an expensive/more thorough process (manual checks by experts along the way) that can handle 99% cases.
- rurban 4y ago> Amazon is another prime example of a company that does customer service well - though that might have some consequences on their work culture (mistakes are not easily forgiven - since the cost is so high). Certainly not. In fact they have one of the most incompetent customer services. When I changed my bank account, they didn't change my bank account, but rather created a new user with the new bank data. Then when I asked them to remove the old wrong account, they were very nice confirming that they will do that. But instead they deleted my new account, with only the old account remaining. When complaining about that they ignored it, so I just deleted my old account also, and am a happy non-Amazon customer since.
- chimprich 4y agoI'm sure there are counter-examples, but Amazon generally do have quite good customer service. When I've had a problem with a delivery I've been amazed to be able to contact a human quite quickly and have them investigate. Just being able to talk to a human is startling compared to certain other tech behemoths.
- fareesh 4y agoThe Joe Rogan podcast with Vijaya Gadde, Jack Dorsey and Tim Pool gives the outside world a good look at how Twitter is run. They should have been able to wipe the floor with every concern that was raised. Instead Jack Dorsey comes off looking lost and Vijaya Gadde comes off looking like a bad lawyer.
- rchaud 4y agoNot surprising, Dorsey has tried his hardest to pretend that Twitter isn't his baby for several years. He'd much rather be thought of as a payments guy (Square) crossed with bitcoin shaman.
- esotericimpl 4y agoIt's odd seeing this on hacker news. When people on hacker news are literally shadow banned, have their comments hidden with zero feedback or notice. In fact i guarantee this comment cant be seen either.
- dang 4y agoYou're banned, but not shadowbanned. We told you we were banning you and why: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24797166 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24797166 On HN, shadowbanning (i.e. banning accounts without telling them) is nearly always for accounts that don't have much posting history—either spam accounts or ones that show signs of having abused HN in the past, such as serial trolls. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32040389 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32040389 has links back to a bunch of longer explanations, if anyone wants more. p.s. After a quick look, I'd say HN's system is working reasonably well in your case because most of your good comments are getting vouched for by users, which unkills them, and most of your bad (for HN) comments are rightfully staying killed. There are cases of banned accounts that shouldn't stay banned, but this isn't one of them.
- esotericimpl 4y ago
- em1sar 4y ago
- VexorLoophole 4y agoUsing the web and it's services really feels more and more like tedious work which is simply not worth it anymore. I don't want to sound like some old grunt (not even 30 yet), but every modern service uses some kind of automatic banning system and everything you invested can be gone in seconds. To spice things up, all these services also stopped providing any kind of support regarding these kind of problems. Ever tried to get into contact with anybody about a banned account? Just some weeks ago Discord decided to ban my 6 year old account out of nowhere. I didn't used Discord for 4 weeks, since I was on vacation. Also I am pretty sure, that it wasn't hacked, because I used MFA and no other account was affected. I tried to contact the support, but only got a template response, that they don't talk about reasons and my account data will also be deleted in 14 days. I tried to contact them again, but they simply blocked my mail after that. I didn't do any suspicious on discord ever. So I really had no clue why this happened. While talking with friends and coworker I've heard similar stories. And everybody of us changed their hardware multiple times beforehand (for example to test a specific component or for overclocking). Gotta love automatic banning systems...
- akudha 4y agoLast year, some idiot opened a bank account in my name. I was lucky to find out - I tried to get in touch with the bank. Zero human contact - the only way to communicate with them is via email. No phones, no chat, no in-person - nothing. Just email. Ultimately they closed the account (at least they claim they did). If this is the situation in a highly regulated (supposedly?) industry like banking, then how can we expect social media companies to fare any better? I don't know what the solution is. I don't use social media (except HN, I don't know if it falls under social media category) and I don't feel the need to. It is super easy to not use Facebook, Twitter etc. But I have to use banks, insurance etc - there is no way to vote with wallet there, as almost every bank is as bad as the next one. I know of at least one college who post their class schedule, events etc only on Facebook, forcing their students to have a FB account. The level of stupidity...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- miloignis 4y ago
- adam_arthur 4y agoSeparating data from UI solves all the concentration problem with social media, as well as making markets much more competitive (good for consumers). I suspect eventually this idea will catch on, and it will be perceived as monopolistic, at a certain scale, to couple data and UI, thus creating an unbreakable network effect. YouTube, Twitter etc
- akrymski 4y agoI can live without Twitter. But being suspended from Gmail is a different ball game altogether.
- jimcavel888 4y ago
- jeffwask 4y ago
- WaitWaitWha 4y agoQuestion - if a business permanently suspends a user, will the user ever be able to come back to the account? (of course, theoretically no). Then, why not just delete the account, why only suspend? What benefit is it to the suspended user, more importantly to the business?
- Huh1337 4y agoFor example: Keeping a record of the user getting a ban. Keeping the data that led to the ban. Keeping the user data in case the ban needs to be repelled.
- rossdavidh 4y agoSo, this all falls under the category heading of "this private company's product or service is now too important to have it denied for arbitrary or unclear reasons". This is, in fact, not a new problem; we even have a word for this kind of good or service: "utility". There was a time when phone service, electricity, etc. was just an ordinary private company that you contracted with, who could do whatever private companies can do. Eventually, we placed these kinds of companies in a special category, distinct from ordinary private companies, where they were subject to special rules (in those cases where they were not taken over by the government outright). Eventually, we will turn social media companies which are as large as Twitter under the "utility" category, and access to them will be subject to a process with all the bureaucratic checks and balances. It won't be perfect, but it will be less bad, on balance. Also, like almost all utilities, its profit margin will be tightly regulated, and often it will run at a (taxpayer-subsidised) loss.
- giansegato 4y agoI know reasonably well some ex FB people from the early days (early 2010s, well before IPO). They explicitly defined FB as a 'utility' - based on how users react during outages and usage patterns. I think that your definition is not only spot on, but actually what social media platforms themselves interpret their role.
- rchaud 4y agoSo Twitter would be treated like PBS? I'd love the see the faces of those 'free speech absolutists' if that ended up happening. If they thought Twitter censors too much now...
- JulianHC 4y agoIt is the official channel of many governments and worldwide organizations. The Royal Family twitter account posted the news about Queen Elizabeth's death before BBC announcement.
- sfvegandude 4y ago
- danso 4y agoFrom a tweet later in the thread: https://twitter.com/benthompson/status/1583062865116041229 https://twitter.com/benthompson/status/1583062865116041229 > For the record, this is a new account that has posted a bunch of links (all Stratechery interviews) in a short amount of time, from multiple locations around the world. So on one hand, I get it. I think everyone can agree that Twitter's bot detection could be a bit more diligent, but what Ben describes seems like exactly the kind of thing an automated system should detect and ban without prejudice: - A day old account - A brand new account tweeting at a rate as fast as 1 per minute - every tweet has a outbound URL - while Twitter allows you to register automated bots [0] that use the developer's API, the StratecheryINT account apparently sent its tweets using the standard "Twitter Web App" -- e.g. likely an automated script using Selenium. If Ben had gone the approved bot route, I wonder if the account would've been sanctioned. As it is, faking web submissions probably triggers Twitter's auto detection even worse. > Crypto spamming with Elon Musk's avatar? Not a bot! Stratechery Interviews? NO TWEET FOR YOU As someone who's been an occasional reply guy to Elon over the years, I can say that the spambot filtering has gotten much better. Even when I send out a loaded tweet (i.e. mentioning "hacked wallet opensea NFT where can i buy the tshirt"), very few bots will show up, as opposed to dozens within the first 15 seconds. I humbly submit that Ben hasn't looked in closely at what he thinks is bot activity. A lot of crypto spam tweets are either hacked legitimate accounts, or if relatively new, sent via iPhone/Android. Also a lot of spammy activity is actually real people -- a lot of humans don't take twitter seriously, or thoughtfully. Either way, all of this is much less obvious to filter out than how Ben describes StratecheryINT was operated. edit: You can play the spam detection game yourself. Do a search "to:elonmusk url:https://\ https://\" and sort by latest [1] For example, this @hameedforreal [2] account is almost definitely a crypto spammer, and likely was never a "real" person. But you can see that the account at least tweets from "Twitter for iPhone" (don't know if there's a way to fake that other than operating an actual iPhone). If it's from an authentic single iphone (as opposed to a selenium script via distributed AWS), what would the very obvious and scalable heuristics be for auto-banning this account on tweet activity alone? The fact that so many of the tweets are replies with the exact same content? Well, there are a lot of real people who have burst activity like that -- think of fundraisers and activism. Avoiding false positives over millions of possible "bots" is very hard. [0] https://techcrunch.com/2022/02/16/twitter-officially-launches-labels-to-identify-the-good-bots/ https://techcrunch.com/2022/02/16/twitter-officially-launche... [1] https://twitter.com/search?q=to%3Aelonmusk%20url%3Ahttps%3A%2F%2F*&src=typed_query&f=live https://twitter.com/search?q=to%3Aelonmusk%20url%3Ahttps%3A%... [2] https://twitter.com/hameedforreal\ https://twitter.com/hameedforreal\
- jsnell 4y ago> On the other hand, how does all of the obvious spam not get caught? The vast majority of the obvious spam is almost certainly getting caught. Ben is making the elementary error only judging things based on what he sees (what makes it through), and totally forgetting to consider not what he doesn't see (the stuff that was blocked). Being annoyed at the "after careful review" bit in a situation where no human review would have happened is fair though.
- px43 4y ago> Crypto spamming with Elon Musk's avatar? Not a bot! > Stratechery Interviews? NO TWEET FOR YOU Pretty derpy take. People understand the math on this right? There are literally teams of hundreds or thousands of people who, day in and day out, are spinning up bots in the desperate hope that one will get seen by an actual user, and every once in a while, they break through. On the other hand, if you say anything controversial to any audience, it's trivial to whip up a brigade of people to report the content, and when enough people report something, it's going to cause a suspension, at least temporarily, no matter how benign it is.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- VyseofArcadia 4y agoIt's become pretty clear to me that then solution is to just not have an account. If you aren't already on a service that's eager about automated bans, don't start now. If you are, keep your head low. Just lurk. Maybe as more and more people lurk, Twitter et al will be incentivized to do something.
- codesurgeon 4y agoThe repercussions of the occasional community shitstorm don't seem to warrant any investment into the scalability of support and remediation mechanisms. If this type of stuff would either drive traffic, interaction or another means of revenue generation, we'd probably see more creativity and better results.
- xwowsersx 4y agoIn that thread, someone replied with: > Twitter management is a joke. @paraga doesn’t use twitter and hasn’t tweeted since July. He's not included retweets in that, but this seems like a good point. How can the CEO not post his own tweets in the last 109 days? Or do you all feel "well, the CEO is busy and has better things to be doing than tweeting"?
- wexomania 4y agoI made an instagram account 20 minutes ago, and was permabanned on my first ever login...
- wexomania 4y agoSuffice to say, the onboarding process was terrible.
- duxup 4y agoOne aspect I'm not 100% sure about is if every silly ban is in fact just an automated system. I have no doubt a lot of them are. But it is possible it was reviewed by a human and an inexplicable decision was made. I've moderated large forums before, the variety of misunderstandings and confusion a moderator can experience is nearly infinite ...
- lapcat 4y agoAs a longtime Twitter user, I personally feel that the Twitter spam problem is vastly overstated. I'm not talking about the total amount of spam, I'm talking about its effect on individual users. I occasionally get spam replies, but not very often. I just block the account, problem solved. I don't feel it affects my overall Twitter experience much. In fact, I'm vastly more annoyed by real humans who reply to me with insults. Or real human Twitter "influencers" who start quote tweet memes that everyone obsequiously follows, "spamming" my timeline with the same tweet over and over. In other words, IMO the humans are worse than the bots. ;-) I'm not Twitter famous. I've got several thousand followers, which is significant but not huge. Maybe if you have millions of followers, bot replies are a much bigger problem for you. But then again, if you have millions of followers, nasty real human replies are also a much bigger problem for you. Fame is a no-win scenario, except just ignoring replies entirely. If you use the reverse chronological timeline, you only see tweets from the people you intentionally follow. (I wouldn't advise anyone to use the algorithmic timeline, unless you're into masochism.) So I literally never see bot spam in my timeline. Spam isn't really affecting me. OTOH I never tweet about "crypto"...
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoThere is a lot of spam you don't see that affects you: bot rings that push topics in trending and lastest tweets that end up in your time line for example. Or voting bots that reinforce the outrage culture. Scam bots that prey on weak users in popular accounts (read any elo musk tweet responses for a sample). And bot oushing empty publication to hashtags that makes parsing it with a python script terrible. Just because you don't see it doesn't mean it doesn't make the experience worst.
- lapcat 4y ago> bot rings that push topics in trending I have a browser extension that hides trending topics, so I don't see that at all. > tweets that end up in your time line for example I just said that I use the reverse chronological timeline that only shows tweets from my follows. > Or voting bots that reinforce the outrage culture. "I'm vastly more annoyed by real humans who reply to me with insults." > read any elo musk tweet responses for a sample I've blocked that account. > And bot oushing empty publication to hashtags Why would you even read hashtags? > Just because you don't see it doesn't mean it doesn't make the experience worst. What I see on Twitter is my experience. It's largely your own choice what you see on Twitter.
- giarc 4y agoThis is much ado about nothing. I'm glad the account was banned, it means the system is working. Even he admits it makes sense "For the record, this is a new account that has posted a bunch of links (all Stratechery interviews) in a short amount of time, from multiple locations around the world." So all of this is because some copywriter at Twitter wrote "After careful review" instead of something like "after automated review". He claims in his bio "home on the internet" but then gets upset over some copy like this? Come on!
- nkko 4y agoAutomated banning is becoming absurd. I have recently been banned from Deezer cause I have used Revolut card for payment. And they had it flagged, while Revolut probably recycles the card numbers. If you are in EU you have legal grounds for objection in Art. 22 of GDPR. Where it is stated "The data subject shall have the right not to be subject to a decision based solely on automated processing, including profiling, which produces legal effects concerning him or her or similarly significantly affects him or her." I have not exercised this but out of revolt returned to my offline music collection for the time being.
- zone411 4y agoI posted this example a month ago: https://twitter.com/willsasso https://twitter.com/willsasso. A verified account of a Canadian actor with 150k followers that got hacked and started to post crypto spam: https://twitter.com/WillSasso/status/1573830892367257603 https://twitter.com/WillSasso/status/1573830892367257603. It's still live, these posts are still up, and even the hacker can't believe it: https://twitter.com/WillSasso/status/1574065661751468034 https://twitter.com/WillSasso/status/1574065661751468034.
- unboxingelf 4y agoCrypto spamming with Elon Musk's avatar? Not a bot! Maybe twitter just lets these highly obvious crypto scams ride.
- insane_dreamer 4y agoshouldn't a human-directed account that exhibits spam/bot-like behavior be treated the same as a non-human-directed account that exhibits spam/bot-like behavior? Not sure Ben's rage is warranted in this case.
- heckerhut 4y agoWe need web3 to unbreak the web. Hear me out before you rage-downvote me. “Web3” most of all means a functioning identity model that is platform-independent, user-owned and thus scales the solution to the bot problem beyond the limitations of a single platform.
- heckerhut 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Dove 4y agoI can't decide whether to be darkly amused or just depressed, watching millions of humans learn together, as if for the first time, that Government Is Hard. Much ink has been spilled on the topic of governing well. It could fairly be called the entire output of now risen and fallen civilizations. Institutions such as laws, rights, courts, judges, and citizenship are many millenia old, and people have always been willing to pay to get them. Yes, these digital empires are a new beast, but surely there are better options than running around, reacting to emergencies, helping out people with inner circle access, laying down really ineffective law for everyone else, like some sort of overworked bronze age monarch?
- 1970-01-01 4y agoIts hard, but there are known ways to fix this process that Twitter just doesn't care to implement. Placing the banhammer into one all-knowing judge, jury, and executioner algorithm is a really stupid idea. Twitter's auto-banhammer power should be spread across multiple algorithms, with each one reporting back how it voted and exactly why it made its decision. The decisions should be completely transparent to everyone.
- Dove 4y agoI think saying that Twitter doesn't care is too lazy a take. It has always been true, to some degree, that the aristocrats really don't care about the fate of individual peasants - they can't. They are outnumbered and don't have the capacity. But at the same time, everyone cares about acting justly. Even the most vile communist dictators who casually kill millions find it necessary to hold mock trials and explain themselves in propaganda. Leaders want to do a good job by their people. They want to believe they are just, and be seen that way. They all do. It makes more sense to me to see these people as overworked and laboring under bad ideas, than to see them as callous. There are a lot of competing considerations - security, legal obligations, this or that socially powerful group making demands! I don't think it's so much that they callously don't care as that they are so vastly outnumbered and can only deal with so many problems. When the internet was young, we thought very little about security. Wide open telnet ports, http without any sort of certificates, software and websites laughably exploitable. As time has gone on, we have started to realize that security is a necessary part of the price of building something, and to factor it in. No one now simply throws a service on the web without making a serious security effort. I feel like we're going through the same process with government. We learned, via hard knocks, that even tight knit communities can't get along without at least a moderator. Now we're learning that really big communities, comparable to nations, can't really function without some of the institutions that they have historically required. I hope that we will learn the lesson and price it in; right now, we seem to be in the stone age tarpit, the peasants angry at the government over injustice, the government angry at the peasants over constant demands that they can't keep up with, no serious solutions in sight. Technology can certainly help, but automated systems are only the implementation of laws, which misfire, and which humans are so good at getting around and exploiting. What you want, when things go awry, are rights, a set of laws, and a series of judges to which you can appeal. We assume, by inertia and analogy with our physical spaces, that we have those things, but we don't. My hope is that we can start to understand these things are necessary, and like security, instead of complaining it is too hard, simply see it as part of the problem definition.
- jscipione 4y agoIn related technocratic censorship news YouTube has begun algorithmically shadow banning comments that go against the woke state religion. This is clearly evident by the comment count not match the actual number of comments and is also easy to test by commenting something negative with key words like “Clinton” and “steal” and then looking for your comment in incognito mode. Our Democracy is in great peril because people cannot make an informed vote without having access to dissent and it’s no coincidence that this censorship is ramping up as we get closer to the midterm elections in the US. Ben Thompson being banned by Twitter is not an isolated event, it’s part of a larger assault on our human rights that is deepening ever more and more dangerously every day.
- johnchristopher 4y agoHow is one supposed to understand what's going in with that submission ? It's like getting one word out of a whole dispute between people. There's 0 context unless you know the particular players involved and the whole story.
- marban 4y agoMy 15y old Reddit Gold account was suspended after I posted a crypto-critical WSJ link. It's not your parent's Web anymore....
- lizardactivist 4y ago
- iLoveOncall 4y agoHe just spammed and got suspended for spam, nothing to see.
- pannSun 4y ago> After careful review Twitter's business is promoting their platform to users, and making money off showing ads to them. Calling whatever automated joke that took place a "careful review" is lying about their platform, about facts material to one's decision to keep, or start, using it. In other words, they are promoting their product using lies, no different than if they were selling cars, and claiming they had 4-wheel drive when in fact they have only 2. This is fraud, a crime.
- snailmailman 4y agoIs the link dead? The OP, and the links in many of the top replies trying to provide more context are all taking me to twitter pages that say “Hmm…this page doesn’t exist.”
- lapcat 4y agoYes, it appears that he deleted the old thread and posted a new thread with a screenshot of the old one: https://twitter.com/benthompson/status/1583163545268912129 https://twitter.com/benthompson/status/1583163545268912129 "Deleting this thread for the usual reasons (don’t want to deal with noise and my point wasn’t clear) FAQ: •Account was not scripted. Everything was posted by a human •A phone number was registered and a “Are you human” challenge was answered while posting •Account is back •What made me mad was the “After careful review” language. I felt lied to •As always, never tweet" The "Account was not scripted" comment goes against the assumption of a number of comments here defending Twitter's suspension.