50 ms·
The Ethereum merge is done
- neotrope 4y agoMerge is confirmed. "It went as well as it could". It eliminated 0.2% of global energy usage (bitcoin at 0.5%)
- michaelwww 4y agoThese guys seem to think so: Ethereum Mainnet Merge Viewing Party https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nx-jYgI0QVI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nx-jYgI0QVI
- TylerE 4y ago
- michaelwww 4y agoSep 14, 2022 at 11:43 p.m. PDT Updated Sep 15, 2022 at 12:01 a.m. PDT The Ethereum Merge Is Done, Opening a New Era for the Second-Biggest Blockchain https://www.coindesk.com/tech/2022/09/15/the-ethereum-merge-is-done-did-it-work/ https://www.coindesk.com/tech/2022/09/15/the-ethereum-merge-...
- konspence 4y ago
- Yuioup 4y agoThe thing I've noticed about comments in a lot of HN threads about Crypto is that each comment posted is long, like really long and I'm none the wiser. That raises alarm bells with me.
- mightyRodri 4y ago(albeit with some compromises)
- RedShift1 4y agoCan you elaborate?
- mightyRodri 4y ago
- miguelmota 4y agoYes, it did work. No missed slots and high participation rate. Exceeded expectations. Congrats to all the devs!
- Uehreka 4y agoI gotta say, I’ve been really cynical about this and honestly thought Ethereum would keep putting off the move to PoS forever. I’m very very happy to be wrong. I still don’t see the value in cryptocurrency as a project, but now that it’s not rolling back years of renewable energy development, I’m down to have some much more interesting conversations about Ethereum, and I may even be willing to buy some and try it out.
- adh636 4y agoPoW incentivizes renewable energy development. It's certainly not rolling it back. It used to also incentivize GPU production, but as of today that has been diminished as well. Instead it is only current asset holders who reap the rewards. EDIT: Edited to include at least one source on the connections between PoW and renewable energy. This just scratches the surface though. https://squareup.com/us/en/press/bcei-white-paper https://squareup.com/us/en/press/bcei-white-paper
- bhaak 4y agoSure, that's why we had crappy GPU before crypto currencies. Gamers had to put off buying new GPU because they were misused for POW. Ask them about the "incentivized GPU production".
- Ragnarork 4y agoIf anything, it incentivized the production of GPU artificially limited for the exact work needed for PoW. Good job!
- hagbarth 4y agoAs it was before.
- vestrigi 4y agoPoW incentivizes renewable energy development for useless mining, but not for anything more than that I guess. At least the renewables can now be used to power other more necessary demands, if the owners don’t move on to mine other coins that are compatible with their rigs.
- JonathanBeuys 4y agoIt worked. And it reduces the world's energy bill by 0.5%: https://twitter.com/JonathanBeuys/status/1570305323629527046 https://twitter.com/JonathanBeuys/status/1570305323629527046 I feel a great disturbance in the force. As if a million miners cried out all at once and then were suddenly silenced.
- scambier 4y agoWait, the Ethereum blockchain alone was consuming 0.5% of the world's total energy?
- isoprophlex 4y agoCompletely indefensible in a world beset with global warming and energy shortages
- Barrin92 4y agousual comparison was that the energy consumption is comparable to nations like the Netherlands or Finland, so seems about right.
- ollifi 4y agoThere is lot of talk and debate about building wind, nuclear doing the green transition etc. in Finland. I guess like in every country. Somehow it makes me sad that group of open source developers could do more today than we ever can to help the planet no matter how much we scale back. Although they built the hell machine in the first place, so maybe better if they would not have ever done anything.
- OJFord 4y agoWell, in that perspective 'green production' seems like the right thing to be talking about (vs. cutting usage, say) - if you over-produce you can always export, selling 'green' energy to a country that might otherwise have been buying 'brown'.
- 4y ago
- qualifiedai 4y agowow! It did work, the merge is confirmed, no transactions dropped! Congratulations to all the devs!!!
- dereg 4y agoI’m really curious what the GPU miners are going to be doing with their cards. Today may be as big a moment for gamers as it is for ETH devs.
- archerx 4y agoMine other coins.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- awestroke 4y agoWhich ones? BTC is only mined on ASICs, other top coins are POS.
- PanosJee 4y agoEven if they did nobody buys anything rn
- bhaak 4y agoEthereum had about 80-90% of the whole hashrate of GPU mineable coins. The next biggest one was ETC with about 5% of the hashrate of Ethereum. They can't go all to other coins. It won't be profitable.
- parker_mountain 4y agoThey've been divesting heavily over the past few months. Prices cratered and high end cards have been going under MSRP for weeks.
- teruakohatu 4y agoSelling them?
- that_guy_iain 4y agoSwitch to a different currency that is still proof of work? I mean if you've got all the gear and just need to change was software is running and you get back to making money, wouldn't you?
- rvz 4y agoGood. The merge worked and they are not burning up the planet. Now when are those Deep Learning systems in these data centers going to stop incinerating the planet with their useless deep learning models that not only are broken but require constant retraining and wasteful CO2 energy usage for years without any efficient alternatives?
- bambataa 4y agoI do find it interesting that people hate on crypto for its energy consumption but ignore all the other wasteful computation.
- mrpopo 4y agoCrypto has a far lower ratio on utility/speculation than other wasteful computations. Deep learning is changing the world in many visible ways (with a whole lot of speculation regardless).
- betwixthewires 4y agoYour bias shines through here. What visible ways? Machine generated photographs? About as useful as NFTs... I can, right now, send liquid assets to any human being on the planet with an internet connection without asking a financial institution, government, bank, payment processor or phone company for permission. That's utility, that's changing the world in a visible way.
- mrpopo 4y agoYou make it sound as if financial institutions and banks didn't have a purpose. There is far more negative utility in this. Governments, banks and financial institutions prevent tax fraud, apply workers' rights, redistribute money, etc. Of course they're not perfect. In that case fix your government, not the money system.
- betwixthewires 4y ago
- Animats 4y agoThe bottom just fell out of the used GPU market. NVidia Tesla 80 24GB on sale for US$79 in quantity. [1] [1] https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=p2380057.m570.l1313&_nkw=GPU&_sacat=0 https://www.ebay.com/sch/i.html?_from=R40&_trksid=p2380057.m...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- franga2000 4y agoThe 79$ one I see has over 300$ in shipping, which is a standard scam on eBay.
- squeaky-clean 4y agoOutside the USA maybe? I see free shipping from seller fifakingdom, estimated delivery Sep 20-22.
- sertsa 4y agoIs a card like this useful to run Stable Diffusion, etc?
- guywhocodes 4y agoFrom what I gather you would want the M40 if anything as it is a single GPU with access to all of the 24GB for SD inference. But if you are going to do smaller you might as well get a 3060 12GB as it will be about 3x faster.
- capableweb 4y ago12GB is on the lower end of what you want for SD though. Granted, optimizations are still happening, but if you wanna do something like 1024x1024 or higher, you should at least get 24GB.
- 4y ago
- lmarcos 4y ago> The Merge is one of the largest technological events in the industry to date. I feel kinda ashamed. I work in the IT industry and I claim to have knowledge about ("good") software engineering practices, distributed systems, compilers, algorithms, etc. Nevertheless, I didn't understand a word of what the article is saying. Could you recommend serious references (preferably books and not random blogs) I could read to catch up with what's going on with crypto these days? I'm not planning to "buy" crypto; I would like to understand the technicalities.
- mightyRodri 4y agoI wouldnt worry, the whole system up to this point has used "technobabble" as a means to confuse and impress outsiders. When reading up on it, there is no meaning to find besides "yep, its a linked list allright".
- lmarcos 4y agoI thought the same at the beginning. Yet somehow I think I'm missing something a bit more complex (complicated?) than just "linked lists". I don't want to understand only the theory but also the "practice" (e.g., one could read all about distributed systems... But one really gets the gist of it until one has to deal with real world networks in the cloud or on prem, dealing with real systems)
- mightyRodri 4y agoHave you seen the "Line goes up" summary by Dan Olson? It puts the crypto sphere into context. From that many descisions and marketing practices start to make sense.
- fastball 4y agoCrypto being full of grifters does not mean that the actual developers in the space are using "technobabble" in order to sound smarter without actually introducing new concepts. Crypto is actually innovating in ways that are broadly applicable to computer science in general, e.g. with all the work being done on Zero-Knowledge Proofs. And those innovations require new words because they are new concepts. I think it should be somewhat obvious to anyone that has actually looked at the space that devs are not just re-naming existing ideas.
- pshc 4y agoThe validator of the first proof of stake block earned just over 45 ETH as everyone clamored to get their transaction in this historic block: https://etherscan.io/block/15537394 https://etherscan.io/block/15537394
- jazzyjackson 4y agoThe validator is randomly chosen, no? So we essentially have a lottery as a banking system now?
- duskwuff 4y agoWorse: a lottery for the rich. Validators are required to stake at least 32 ETH (~$52k USD) to participate.
- AgentME 4y agoThere are validator pools that let people stake smaller values.
- tsujp 4y agoThis is categorically incorrect. You can have any amount of ETH (up to 32 because there's no value in going higher) and be a validator participant if you partake in a pool.
- duskwuff 4y agoAs I understand it, staking ETH in a pool doesn't mean you get to act as a validator in any capacity. That's handled by whoever is running the pool.
- samatman 4y agoSure, but that doesn't make the difference between getting a lottery ticket and not getting one. If you have 1 ETH in the pool when the validator hits, you get the corresponding fraction of the award, minus the pool fee.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoI assume it has been debated again and again, but since I don't know the answer I'm going to ask: We often complain people hold cryptocurrencies instead of using them as money. Isn't this change going to make this worse ?
- nailer 4y agoThe merge won’t affect gas fees, which makes Eth unsuitable for small purchases when the network is busy. Apparently Eth will do other work in future to fix that though.
- 0xrips 4y agonot just work in the future, work is being done right now! https://www.eip4844.com/ https://www.eip4844.com/
- miguelmota 4y agoStablecoins are mostly what people use for payments. ETH is what's staked on the beacon chain.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoI never use stable coins for payment, and I don't know anybody who does despite being in crypto since btc was at $8. I do pay stuff in BTc and get paid in BTC once in a while and see people in my bubble do the same. We use stable coins to limit taxe exposure, mainly. It's true eth has never been a mean of exchange for any of us and more a platform for smart contract (my friends at kryll.io use it for that).
- Tenoke 4y agoThe majority who trade crypto use stablecoins for payment all the time. It's the default on most exchanges, and for a lot of the biggest pairs on DEXs.
- 4y ago
- joaquincabezas 4y agocalling it “The Merge” (with capital letters) makes it sound like a blockbuster action movie. I’ll say I prefer the book.
- colesantiago 4y agoThis doesn't really change anything, I still cannot find any legitimate use cases for blockchain, Proof of Stake or not. I would happy to be proven wrong, but this is extremely rare as I can't find any legitimate actual useful use case since Bitcoin and Ethereum's existence.
- miguelmota 4y ago> I still cannot find any legitimate use cases for blockchain Blockchains solve the double-spend problem. Allows for scarcity in the digital realm. Ethereum is a platform for decentralized finance, anyone can borderlessly lend and borrow in seconds. Endless possibilities.
- talhof8 4y agoWhen will those endless possibilities meet reality though?
- miguelmota 4y agoIt's a reality to the people of Latin America who use stablecoins on Ethereum to hedge against their own country's inflation.
- geysersam 4y ago> allows for scarcity Sounds great...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kuschku 4y agoSince when do we want scarcity? One of the largest advantages of the web was that it allows for a digital post-scarcity economy.
- nly 4y ago> anyone can borderlessly lend and borrow in seconds. You can only do _secured_ lending and borrowing, and only where the security is, itself, a highly liquid digital token. Person A lending USDC to person B, taking ETH for security, isn't doing much for the world at large except allowing B to defer his capital gains tax. Unsecured lending, backed only by the faith or expectations we have around future cash flows, is how the world creates opportunity for true investment and growth... and impossible in a trustless and anonymous system like crypto. Hardly limitless possibilities
- 0xfoobar 4y agoFor those interested in understanding the tech rather than the typical bashing things as beneath them, I wrote up a detailed technical explainer of how Ethereum PoS works: https://0xfoobar.substack.com/p/ethereum-proof-of-stake https://0xfoobar.substack.com/p/ethereum-proof-of-stake
- SilasX 4y agoGuess you can update this part now! >3. PoS (Ethereum, soon™)
- 0xfoobar 4y agoIndeed! :)
- atomlib 4y agoWhat's Substack? Is that new Medium?
- speedylight 4y agoThat’s how I always thought about it yeah.
- NavinF 4y agoYeah it's like Medium except it has less fluff/self-promotion.
- lloppal 4y agoIt's like Medium but wants you to pay for newsletters.
- polisteps 4y agoWhich is fairer imo than paying for the whole site. I prefer creator control on which content is paid and which content is not.
- toastal 4y ago
- quantified 4y ago> Edgington, who began his career researching climate science before eventually landing in crypto, understood where his daughter was coming from. “Rightly or wrongly, she'd absorbed a very toxic environmental narrative,” he said. “I mean, it's kind of hard to defend ‘stickers for grownups’ that emit, by some estimates, a megaton of [carbon dioxide] a week.”
- latchkey 4y agoOn a personal note, Ben is a really really nice and smart guy. I have a huge amount of respect for him.
- quantified 4y agoWe're all complex, multidimensional people. He's probably a really good parent. But "toxic environmental narrative"?
- proto-n 4y agoI think someone can be toxic and at the same time be right about what they say
- quantified 4y agoIs the environmental narrative toxic in that it poisons our minds, or that the enviroment itself is being poisoned? Totally agree with your point. Our politics and society don't do a good job with that.
- treelovinhippie 4y ago
- swarnie 4y agoDoes this make ETH useful in the real world or is it still a tehcno-ponzi scheme?
- PanosJee 4y agoJust Fiat 2.0
- kybernetikos 4y agoIt immediately improves the environmental story if you had previously wanted to use smart contracts but didn't think it was ethical for environmental reasons. ETH was already potentially useful in the real world if you were on an L2 like zksync - low fees, fast enough to work, decent UX with wallets like Argent. Only thing missing was wide adoption. Having said that, the merge is actually just the first of a multipart set of upgrades that should make the L2s massively better than they are today. We're still at the 'potentially' useful rather than the actually useful, but things improve the whole time.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoIt's still not really used for anything that really matters to anyone (in a business sense). Until now the high cost and low transaction volume meant that it was just not really suitable for its intended use as a transactional store of ledgers of stuff unless the stored entries were extremely high in value and relatively rare. But on paper building something useful now is a bit easier as transaction cost is likely to come down and the network should support a more reasonable transaction volume. When your global transaction volume per hour is capped below what even a small web server running on a tiny computer would easily handle, there isn't much you can do with it in the real world. And when those transactions then cost you tens/hundreds of dollars and take minutes/hours to clear, any utility that might exist goes out of the window. It's a complete non starter for anyone looking to do some transactions that actually have business value. Why would you? It's many orders of magnitude worse than what a plain old database gives you on all relevant dimensions. That was the status quo up until the merge. Now that that is in the past, we'll see. I personally doubt Ethereum will be the tool of choice for this kind of thing. If you are serious about building something that does something useful, there are better tools available.
- salex89 4y agoCan we have our GPUs back now?
- timeon 4y agoIt depends... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32844350 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32844350
- AgentME 4y agoETC's block reward pays for a certain amount of mining to happen. If demand for ETC and its price stay about the same, then ETC's block reward won't change. Nearly all of the miners who quit mining ETH will find it not profitable to mine ETC. (If they all started mining ETC, then the reward would be split too many ways, it wouldn't be profitable for anyone, and people would exit until the reward was split less.)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- leroman 4y agoGreat! Unlike BTC the miners can sell their gear so they are not down on their investment.. I imagine BTC miners putting up a good fight if this was on the table and they stand to lose all their asics
- andruby 4y agoIs there a real proposal to turn BTC into PoS?
- leroman 4y agoIf this works for ETH, I don't believe there's a real reason why this couldn't work for BTC ** ** big asterisk here as I have spent no time trying to understand how they made it work for ETH and how/if this actually applies to BTC..
- valzam 4y agoThere are huge concerns over centralization. As it stands 2-3 entities (e.g. Lido, binance and Coinbase) over 50% of all validators. This is due to a mix of issues (no withdrawal making liquid staking very attractive, 32Eth limit leading to hugely inflates numbers of validators and no stake delegation creating the need for off chain pools). I would say there is about a 1-2% chance that BTC adopts PoS on a good day. Based on what Ethereum has delivered it's very close to 0.
- survirtual 4y agoThis is laughable. I support bitcoin because it is a pattern that allows value transfer absent intermediaries, binds value directly to energy and computational capacity (work), and has clear mechanisms for any new party to enter into consensus. In other words, if PoW is attacked by say a governmental entity, a massive mining op or central mining shuts down, it does not fail. The hash rate just gets distributed. I don’t support bitcoin to get rich. I support it for freedom from tyranny. I support it for independence from oligarchs, banking authoritarians, and a corrupted monetary system. PoS is a carry over of aristocracy and oligarchs. The oligarchs are just called “stakers” now. And with a name behind the stakers, governments can enter and control the mechanisms. With a massive stake locked in an asset you become vulnerable to control from external forces. There are so many problems with this pattern one could write, at the very least, a very long article on it. But it would seem reason and freedom is as a fart in the wind these days. Tldr: Bitcoin will never move to PoS because it is inferior.
- SilverBirch 4y agoThere are two interesting things I want to watch from this. The first is I'm interested to see what kind of bull run ETH goes on. The merge has been incredibly long coming, it has huge risks and I think that puts downward pressure on price, you really don't want to be doing stuff in ETH at the moment because there's a fairly good chance something goes wrong, someone stealds $XBn and runs off and the Ethereum guys go "Well I guess we're going to have a centralized intervention and reset the chain back to date Y" (this famously happened with the first DAO). So as that risk dissipates I would expect a decent price run. I'll be very interested if that doesn't happen since it says a lot about broader market conditions. The second thing I'm interested in is that ETH was the vast majority of revenue for GPU miners. I read an article on HN a few months ago about how once ETH is gone the rest of the PoS chains put together won't yield enough revenue to be profitable for the vast vast majority of current ETH miners. This alone could have a massive ripple effect on the used GPU market. Interesting to see where that goes.
- cowtools 4y ago>So as that risk dissipates I would expect a decent price run. The risk you're describing is a social-political one. As long as the users do not fork with the etherium developers, that will not happen. Change to PoS has nothing to do with it. I look forward to the increased GPU supply.
- paulgb 4y ago> The risk you're describing is a social-political one. As long as the users do not fork with the etherium developers, that will not happen. Change to PoS has nothing to do with it. Are you saying that the market did not price in any technical risk? I don’t follow crypto markets closely (and don’t own any), but given the number of crypto bug exploits and the unprecedented nature of this merge, that seems unlikely to me. Even a social-political risk averted is a risk averted.
- andruby 4y agoI'm also expecting a lot of GPU's to flood the used markets. Coupled with the next generation of GPU's being released soon.
- presentation 4y ago> “Proof-of-stake is like running an app on your MacBook,” he said. “It's like running Slack. It's like running Google Chrome or running Netflix. Obviously, your MacBook plugs into the wall and uses electricity to run. But no one thinks about the environmental impact of running Slack, right?” People do think about that. But definitely an improvement!
- valzam 4y agoIt's also completely untrue. Staking is unprofitable if you cannot guarantee uptime of your node. In fact Ethereum includes slashing for inactivity, so not only do you lose out on rewards if you shut of your MacBook, you run the risk of losing Ethereum. Unless of course you stake with a centralized pool, which defeats the whole purpose.
- hugocbp 4y agoI think that specific part is meant more to be read as "consume as much energy as an app running on your MacBook", not "you can stake your ETH in your notebook".
- SilasX 4y agoNo one with any influence thinks about that. Have you see the typical CPU/network overhead of an application compared to what it accomplishes? :-p
- presentation 4y agoPeople definitely think about it RE mobile apps and battery life. As well as just leaving electronics on all day vs at least sleeping them. But yea purely for energy cost of using apps, that’s pretty fringe.
- SilasX 4y agoI know at least one clear counterexample for mobile: MetaMask, a widely used crypto wallet app, noticeably drains battery while it's in use. Usually down 3% within a minute of opening, and it's been like that for a while.
- goethes_kind 4y ago
- optimiz3 4y agoCurious to see if this plays out anything like the insider lockup period expiring after an IPO. Anyone with ETH locked up in a 2.0 beacon validator has suffered brutal drawdowns from the peak.
- yieldcrv 4y agoThis phase doesn’t unlock validator funds
- whatisweb3 4y agoCongrats to the devs. This is a historic moment for computing and distributed tech, and will pave the way for Ethereum’s next updates: scalability, privacy, stronger censorship resistance, easier UX and account abstraction.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- olalonde 4y agoA good moment of humility I hope for all those HN experts who implied Ethereum's transition to Proof of Stake would never happen.
- yieldcrv 4y agoJust the sound of goal posts moving. But these posts are more easily ignored now.
- timeon 4y agoIs Ethereum Classic going to be relevant?
- hotcoffeebear 4y agoThere will be more recent PoW fork. But probably ETC will see new miners flocking.
- boltzmann-brain 4y agoI'm just glad I renamed the word for staking in Tezos from "forging" to "baking". There's now about a million companies with names referring to baking in some way. I don't think there would be a lot of financial companies that have forging in the name. It might well have been a detractor for Ethereum PoS as well.
- EdwardDiego 4y agoI feel like you have an overly emotional attachment to this, given your need to make this comment. People say things that turn out to be wrong all the time, but you seem to have become resentful that they disbelieved this would happen. Odd way to approach a technology.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yieldcrv 4y agoCongratulations miners, validators, and hosted validator services! Big win for sustainability and industry!
- once_inc 4y agoA recent study by an American governmental organisation (I don't remember which) recently showed that Bitcoin can be used to reduce methane emissions. This in turn would make Bitcoin mining and Proof-of-work net carbon negative (significantly so if my memory of the graph accompanying the news isn't letting me down). edit: also, this is a new frontier that combines the best of both worlds for energy suppliers, bitcoin miners, governments and the environment.
- salmonlogs 4y agoLet's be clear: Bitcoin is NOT reducing methane emissions or carbon emissions. Crypto mining cannot reduce anything. This is just a straw man. The study you reference discussed burning waste methane to turn into electricity, rather than gas flaring. That electricity could be used for anything. Water desalination, stored for grid balancing, powering agricultural needs or offsetting the electrical needs of the gas facilities.
- vntok 4y ago> That electricity could be used for anything. Water desalination, stored for grid balancing, powering agricultural needs or offsetting the electrical needs of the gas facilities. No it precisely could not, because there's no transport infrastructure, storage or grid balancer there. That's why they were flaring in the first place.
- once_inc 4y agosigh, one of these days, I'm going to be able to downvote despite being heavily suppressed for having a fact-based opinion about Bitcoin, which is the result of literally years of study. Until then, you have my upvote.
- noipv4 4y agoyou can obtain the poap if you attended the party like so: https://youtu.be/Nx-jYgI0QVI?t=10993 https://youtu.be/Nx-jYgI0QVI?t=10993
- whatisweb3 4y agoCongrats to the devs. This is a historic moment for computing and distributed tech, and will pave the way for Ethereum’s next updates: scalability, privacy, stronger censorship resistance, easier UX and account abstraction.
- EdwardDiego 4y ago> This is a historic moment for computing A) Really? B) Bit early to be proclaiming historic events. On account of, well, history is very much post-tense.
- whatisweb3 4y agoYes, of course this is my opinion. The transition has been years in the making and the amount of research and contributions to computing, distributed systems, and cryptography that this transition has created has been immense.
- rblion 4y agoELI5 anyone?
- can16358p 4y agoEthereum was using an algorithm called "Proof of Work" to secure the blockchain's state and it was using huge amount of energy as it literally was using hashing power of GPUs to verify/generate Ethereum "blocks" (immutable units containing transactions) to get Ether as rewards. The Merge changed this algorithm to "Proof of Stake", killing the GPU mining and the energy consumption completely (at least for Ethereum) and the new algorithm secures the network by giving incentives to Ether stakeholders (anyone can be, by the way) to secure the network instead of computing hashes on GPUs. This single event reduced world's energy usage by 0.2% overnight.
- rieTohgh6 4y agoNo more mining for ETH. And all other crypto together (not counting Bitcoin, which uses ASIC) have 20x less daily mining reward compared to ETC. That means a lot used GPU cards will hit the market, since huge part of pie just disappeared.
- lakomen 4y agoIt and all the other energy wasting planet destroying "coins" need to be forbidden.
- ForHackernews 4y agoI think this is great news because it reduces wasted energy. The sooner cryptocurrency stops boiling the ocean, the sooner the rest of us can ignore it. I have no problem with weird nerds having their own hobbies (I have a model train set!) as long as they are not actively hurting anyone. Now do the same for bitcoin.
- unnouinceput 4y agoYou do realize that the entire cryptocurrency space (all coins, regardless of their names) are using less electricity than the total of electronics that are in standby in US only. So, if you want to have an impact, better to reorient your efforts to have the industry do away with standby idea. That was a good idea 5 decades ago in 70's, when electronics were expensive and they lasted a decade. But nowadays, with planned obsolesce, it makes no sense to have standby technology implemented to make the electronics last longer because they fail after one year anyway due to other factors rather than transient response on startup (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transient_response https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transient_response & https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transient_state https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transient_state) So, boiling the ocean is not done by this anyway, my point.
- akx 4y agoDon't suppose you have any data to show to back that electricity claim?
- unnouinceput 4y agoThere was an article that said bitcoin blockchain uses as much energy as entire country of Argentina, which made rounds here in HN (https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-56012952 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-56012952). In that graph there you also get US consumption too. And China's as well. Now compare them and tell me again the oceans are boiling because of bitcoin.
- jcranmer 4y ago
- gwd 4y agoSo there's an article with information about how to run a validator from home [1]. But my question is, what the typical ROI for this sort of thing? Not just from your stake of 32 ETH, but from the hardware depreciation, electricity costs, etc? I like the idea of a non-PoW blockchain, and I don't mind taking some risks, but before I invest $60k in becoming a validator, I'd like to know what the potential payback might be. [1] https://ethereum.org/en/staking/solo/ https://ethereum.org/en/staking/solo/
- 0x64 4y agoAPY depends on the current validator count, decreasing as more validators come online. Currently, the base APY is around 4 %. On top of that, you have to factor in luck: block proposals are randomly assigned to validators, and they include a random amount of tips depending on network activity. You could propose a block that nets you 0.01 ETH in tips, or a block with 50 ETH in tips. On average, I believe the post-Merge APY has been estimated to be ≈6 % (non-cumulative). Hardware can be anything. Even a RasPi 4 with 8 GB of memory can be made to work. Any old x64 machine with two or more cores works. 16 GB of memory is recommended, as is a 2 TB SSD to minimize down-time. Storage requirements are likely to go down in the medium-term, as e.g. state expiry get implemented. I’d recommend an Intel NUC. They use laptop CPUs, so electricity consumption is around 5–20 watts. For networking, you’ll need around 5 Mb/s up and down after the initial sync.
- zeroclip 4y agoIn addition to the APY described by sibling comment, validators can also run MEV-Boost to increase their APY: > You should run mev-boost to earn a fair share of the MEV extracted in the blocks you propose. Connecting your consensus client to mev-boost allows you to get full blocks from a network of block builders optimized for MEV extraction. This can increase validator rewards by 75.3%, or give an APR of 12.86% rather than a non-MEV APR of 7.35% from staking eth. https://boost.flashbots.net/ https://boost.flashbots.net/
- somerandomguy33 4y agoSo, nobody is going to mention Pulsechain? It's supposed to do what the Ethereum merge won't: Fix the fees. It also comes with one of the biggest airdrops for Ethereum holders. Look into it. Cheers!
- Quindecillion 4y agoGreat, now all that energy can be "wasted" rendering pixels with GPUs instead. This was always going to happen. Eth was never going to realistically compete with Bitcoin for energy. Now Bitcoin is the only PoW network remaining, as it should be. Looking forward to seeing Bitcoin play a pivotal role in renewable energy infrastructure build-out and capturing flared and vented methane to be one of the biggest carbon-negative industries on the planet. It arrived right when we needed it to tackle carbon emissions.
- shmde 4y ago> Great, now all that energy can be "wasted" rendering pixels with GPUs instead. Just like it was supposed to.
- Quindecillion 4y agoPoint is the energy will still be spent and the carbon emitted if the grid is still primarily runs on fossil fuels. Energy use isn't the problem. Carbon emissions are. Green the grid, don't try to police people's energy use.
- kaba0 4y agoEnergy production is flexible to a degree and it very much depends on energy usage. Up to 0.5% of the total energy usage of the word just disappeared overnight, so it is safe to claim that a big percentage of that difference won’t even be produced, decreasing carbon emission.
- survirtual 4y agoPeople have had plenty of time to understand bitcoin. If they are so seeped in ignorance still, just let time do the convincing. We have dirty shipping barges, endless pounds of meat, useless use of cars, tvs for entertainment, computers for the same, private jets, hell planes in general, skyscrapers for jobs that don’t matter, roads to nowhere, and so, so much more wasted energy — but a sovereign monetary system that is free from corruption in its creation and in transfer, and THIS is the great evil energy user? How utterly daft people are to not see the plainness of this attack on freedom. They are like sheep to the slaughter. Time is a brutal teacher. Freedom lost is regained through suffering.
- xyst 4y agohuge for the platform and the environment, especially after years of “the merge is coming soon”. Very bullish outlook
- signa11 4y agohopefully, this move will make lots of gpus redundant...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- roschdal 4y agoBitcoin is using too much energy, and this energy is needed for more important things like heating and transportation.
- mckirk 4y agoWell that's easy: a 2kW Bitcoin miner heats your house just as well as a 2kW electric furnace. (I'm kidding but I'm also not; I'm regularly amazed by the fact that the most complex and intricate computational machines have exactly the same 'output' as the most basic 'heat this piece of metal' contraptions, when looked at as a blackbox.)
- yread 4y agoHave you heard of heatpumps?
- russdill 4y agoWhy do I suddenly hear some familiar jazz?
- mckirk 4y agoI definitely have, and I wouldn't use an electric furnace nowadays unless there was no alternative. That's what the 'I'm kidding' was meant for. Sadly, heat pumps can't mine Bitcoins on the side afaik, so I couldn't use those for the analogy :P
- jefftk 4y agoWhile resistive heating was state of the art for years, and you might as well do some computation with the electricity before turning into heat, we can now make systems that are far more efficient ("200%" and up) by moving heat instead of generating it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_pump https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_pump
- anticensor 4y agohttps://bitcoinminingheater.com/ https://bitcoinminingheater.com/ is a thing. It even has a built-in thermostat to regulate its mining output to your desired temperature.
- MintDice 4y ago
- phartenfeller 4y agoI appreciate it wasting less precious energy. But this change also means that "Decentralisation" and "Power to the people" are fading away right? The wealthy actors are the ones dictating the transaction now and they also on top get paid for being rich. This does not sound like a "better financial system" for me. Also, don't forget the DAO Fork[0] where with the "ungovernable Blockhain" it was decided a transaction was not ok and it was removed?! [0] https://ethereum.org/en/history/#dao-fork https://ethereum.org/en/history/#dao-fork
- funklute 4y ago> But this change also means that "Decentralisation" and "Power to the people" are fading away right? But it was always like this, also with proof of work. PoS and PoW are both just variations of "proof of resources", which in turn is a convenient substitution for likelihood that one's voting power is independent. If you want to give "power to the people", you need some way of estimating independent voting power, that is not tied to resources.
- mrcartmeneses 4y agoLike with ballots tied to people’s real identity in some kind of “polling station”?
- bawolff 4y agoIf you're willing to admit a central authority to authenticate who can and cannot vote, cryptocurrency becomes easy. Really bitcoin is fundamentally trying to solve the problem that its impossible to tell who is a "real" person on the internet. If you dont have that problem everything is trivial.
- boltzmann-brain 4y agoIndeed, for more nuance here's a full explanation of the problem being dealt with by various Proof of Whatever algorithms: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sybil_attack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sybil_attack They always rely on scarcity of something: scarcity of processing power, scarcity of being on the ledger of the blockchain and owning an amount of currency, scarcity of hard disk space, etc.
- jsvaughan 4y agoDoes anyone know whether we will see an immediate jump in transactions per second due to this?
- asenna 4y agoWe will not. The throughput of the system does not get affected right now and so does the gas fee, it does not change.
- astannard 4y agoThis sounds fab, I worry all the energy saved in ethereum will just be transferred over to crunching bitcoin instead and no actual energy will be saved.
- nonameking2026 4y agoYou can't withdraw Ethereum.
- blurbleblurble 4y agoThe Ethereum people were very clever to call this extreme fork a merge :)
- EdwardDiego 4y agoI look forward to their rebase :D
- lambdadmitry 4y agoWhat boggles my mind is that there is no withdrawal from staking and almost no one talks about it. That is, staking right now is a one way street with a promise to be able to withdraw some time in the future and returning only about 4% gross annually, which is laughably low for something that risky. It's well hidden in Ethereum press releases, the only mention I can quickly find is the FAQ entry titled 'Misconception: "The Merge enabled staking withdrawals."' here [1]. It's not just about transparency either. The whole system's security rests on game theory. Not being able to withdraw must affect incentives, which means the introduction of withdrawals will change the system in ways that were not tested yet. [1]: https://ethereum.org/en/upgrades/merge/ https://ethereum.org/en/upgrades/merge/
- Darkstryder 4y agoWithdrawals haven’t been enabled _yet_. Per your own link it will be enabled in an upcoming upgrade. Of course you can argue this upcoming upgrade will never happen. But you could argue the same about the merge upgrade, and this one did happen in the end.
- EdwardDiego 4y ago> Of course you can argue this upcoming upgrade will never happen. If software development has taught me anything, it's to never depend on the anticipated future kindness of software projects I don't control.
- lambdadmitry 4y agoI'm saying that right now staking is an activity with a serious risk of losing all of the staked money, an undefined period of the money being inaccessible, and just 4% gross reward for that, which is so poor I can only imagine very specific people engaging in it. It doesn't make sense financially, so the people doing that are either foolish, enthusiasts, or looking for other ways to profit such as regulatory capture, which should not inspire confidence. What's more, it's expected to change, changing the rules of a system relying on incentives to stay sound. In that sense it's not even releasing an alpha version, it's releasing a different product and promising to launch the announced one some time later.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ftulp 4y agoEthereum is anti-cryptocurrency. It is a bribe to get unprincipled people to betray Bitcoin, and the best interests of humanity.
- jongjong 4y ago> The Merge is one of the largest technological events in the industry to date. One of the largest financial events for sure, but technologically there is hardly any innovation there.
- 0xrips 4y agocurious, have you looked into the years worth of research and work that actually went into the merge? it didn't materialize out of thin air, people had to build it first.
- jongjong 4y agoFor sure there was a lot of work, but hardly any innovative work. Most of the work was busy-work/unnecessary complexity - As is almost always the case with mainstream blockchain projects. PoS was innovative back in 2016. Blockchain migration to a new tech and consensus mechanism is also not new; it has already been done by hundreds of projects over the last 5 years. One of the reserve banks' two mandates is 'maximum employment' - IMO, blockchain is one of the clearest examples were you can see the reserve bank's policies working as planned. There is no limit to the complexity and job creation potential of these over-engineered blokchain projects. Complexity compounds and so does the creation of (less-than-useless) jobs needed to handle all that unnecessary complexity... Solving problems while adding even more complexity on top. The only innovation is the financial innovation involved in convincing so many rich suckers to pour their money into something which is so inefficient and poorly designed... Somehow tricking them into thinking that the charitable creation of unnecessary jobs is a profitable long term activity. The real bright minds are those working for the Federal Reserve.
- lofaszvanitt 4y agoBah, there goes the wonderful concept of energy backed money down the drain.
- pharmakom 4y agoIntuitively to me it seems that PoS can never work. With PoW the physical reality of scarce energy secures the chain - you can’t spend energy on one computation and another. With PoS we secure it by holding Ether, but what determines who holds Ether? The chain! But that’s what we are trying to secure. Is this turtles all the way down? Can anyone enlighten me?
- tomtomistaken 4y agoEther is also scarce. You can't spend one Ether multiple times for staking.
- elAhmo 4y agoIs ether really scarce? There is no limit to the amount of ETH unlike bitcoin, so scarcity doesn't seem to be built in in the currency as with BTC.
- tomtomistaken 4y agoyes, ether is scarce at any given point.
- 70rd 4y agoScarce energy does not secure PoW, the value of the mined currency does, in the same way that scarce supply does not secure the gold standard, it's the value of gold (the 'fiat' shared illusion that it's a reserve). I can fork a PoW chain with a difficulty bomb so that the difficulty is 1000x that of mainnet for any given hashrate. Energy is still scarce, you can't double spend energy on my chain and the 'real' one. Yet my chain isn't secure, because no one will recognize it as canonical: the rewards it yields aren't worth expending effort for. I think you're confused about what the chain is securing. It's not who owns what, it's who spends WHEN. Distributed consensus of ownership does not require PoW/PoS, these were invented to solve double spending/censorship attacks that were a problem in P2P networks. You can't attack a chain to muddle the past, only the present. A successful attack on ETH won't change who holds ETH, it will only prevent agreeing on who receives it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- irae 4y agoLet's congratulate ETH from consuming 99.9 less energy, thus having 99.9% less value. IMO they essentially transformed something revolutionary, which is value secured by the masses. Anyone could mine and help ETH be secure. Now the rich (steakers) control the system. Which is essentially what happens with the current economy dominated by the rich. They are simply trying to change the "who". Alienating the miners was precisely the move to show in ETH the rich rule, the poor suffer. Same old capitalism as usual.
- c01n 4y agoCongratz Ethereum, sorry for doubting you. Now let bug bounties begins (:
- b800h 4y agoWhat I can't understand is that it hasn't affected the price. Surely something like this should increase confidence?
- throwamon 4y agoYou must be new to trading
- durdn 4y agoThe date of the merge has been known for sometime, so the price increase has been mostkly priced in the previous weeks (see recent pumps). Unfortunately the recent US CPI info release has sent the markets (including crypto ones) into a frenzy. In any case I am optimistic that the price of Eth will explode once the better part of this "recession" is behind us.
- b800h 4y agoMakes sense. The bit I didn't understand was that presumably there was uncertainty around whether the merge would be successful. But perhaps there still is, or like you say, the CPI info release has obscured things.
- sidcool 4y agoELI5 anyone? What does this exactly mean?
- timbit42 4y agoEthereum now uses 99.5% less electricity. That's all it means.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- franky47 4y agoQuote from the article: > “I feel very proud, you know, that I'll be able to look back and say I've had a role to play in removing a megaton of carbon from the atmosphere every week." -- Edgington There's a very important difference in not emitting carbon into the atmosphere and actively removing carbon from the atmosphere. Both are critically necessary and complementary, but I don't see how Edgington thinks that switching off PoW suddenly makes Ethereum carbon-negative.
- Slartie 4y agoEspecially since the carbon emissions of Ethereum were a product of Ethereum's existence in the first place, hence an entirely self-made problem, produced by the very people developing and pushing the platform. It's a lot like someone being an active part of a group of gangsters taking hostages, then turning around and helping the police freeing them, only to then brag about how proud he/she is of having a role in freeing those poor innocent people.
- xtracto 4y agoI love Ethereum and am a strong believer in Blockchain technology, but everytime I hear the "Ethereum PoS is a win for the environment" reminds me of the Simpons episode when Bart says something like: "I'm going to smoke and then quit smoking" to what Homer replies congratulating him because quitting smoking is one of the most difficult things to do... It is very misleading, and naive.
- cphoover 4y agoLol hillarious
- jqpabc123 4y agoHe's not saying it is "carbon-negative" --- he's saying it is more efficient and avoids a megaton of carbon that would otherwise have been released.
- 4y ago
- ineedasername 4y agoPrior to the merge ethereum’s trust was controlled by the organizations with the most money who bought/built massive data centers to mine it. With the merge & staking that abstraction layer has disappeared and it’s still the organizations with the most money who control it. Sure it’s great that non-productive math problems no longer need to be solved & consume so much energy and hardware to make it all work. And it may be an incremental improvement over traditional global finance because there is a much greater ability to publicly scrutinize what goes on. But no one should consider this a fundamental paradigm shift & democratization compare to traditional financial systems controlled by a a very small number of big players. Their influence still can override the mining process that’s supposed to be the final word on transactions. Although I’ll clarify a bit: I’m actually a proponent of having a layer of human judgement that can fix a problem when things go off the rails. The issue is that in crypto this layer is even less accessible to smaller players than in traditional finance. The DAO was able to throw its weight around and get a hard fork, but how many other groups with much less influence have suffered from similar problems and exploits without that same benefit? Yes, even in traditional finance there are some types of irreversible fraud. But for every day transactions, for using money as a daily part of transactions necessary to live your life and not just as a speculative investment, crypto falls far short. If a criminal spies on my credit card # as I make a purchase and uses that to go on a spending spree I can fix it with the credit card company with little cost but a few hours of time and frustration. If my wallet is pick pocketed or I simply lose it by accident I have a similar recourse to mitigate the fallout. Crypto? No. It may, eventually, have some other benefits though that’s yet to be seen. But as a major change & liberation of people from massively powerful banks and governments there seems to be nothing more that shouted rhetoric and wishful thinking.
- Waterluvian 4y agoNot using up a goat load of electricity is like 99% of why this change is great. Let people speculate on their funny money without harming everyone. A lateral move on the other details is rather unsurprising.
- once_inc 4y ago
- politician 4y agoI expect the major stakers to find themselves looking at OFAC sanctions in about 48 hours contingent on implementing strict AML/KYC procedures.
- agentultra 4y agoNow they're going to pay for the damage done to the environment for the last six years that they've profited off of, right? No? Oh okay so it doesn't matter. I guess the miners have stopped operations, sold off their businesses, and moved on then. Trouble is that governments and regulators are cracking down. I don't think it will be long before the SEC finally makes moves that will blanket label cryptocurrencies as securities. And we will see more arrests and trials. Once NFTs and web3 and everything else is wiped off the market I doubt there will be much left here. It's always been a solution in search of a problem. Update To clarify, what I'm saying is that the environmental angle here of using less energy isn't a concern for the Ethereum project. If the merge didn't work and they had to delay again they wouldn't have hesitated to delay again and continue burning energy on PoW at all. And they're not going to pay reparations for the damage they have already done because that's not what this is about, is it?
- neprotivo 4y agoIt looks like the new Blockchain is quite centralized. 45% of blocks are mined by just two addresses: https://twitter.com/santimentfeed/status/1570339602346684416?t=iU6Slz7in0UsROvVPxH6gA&s=19 https://twitter.com/santimentfeed/status/1570339602346684416...
- kranke155 4y agoThose could be exchanges ? Which would mean they represent very large numbers of users. Seems the most likely explanation. The idea that this isn’t true in BTC or PoW seems like a wild fiction to me.
- mudrockbestgirl 4y agoProbably liquid staking providers, including exchanges that offer that service.
- kordlessagain 4y agoMining pools do this.
- doomroot 4y agoNot really the same. Mining pools simply point their capital at an api while those staking with exchanges literally give them their capital. With stratum V2 on the horizon (allows miners to construct their own blocks while in a pool) the similarities will be even less.
- DennisP 4y agoBut either way, it's a central entity ordering transactions and putting transactions in blocks. The real question is, how much capital do you need to be a block producer. For Ethereum that's 32 ETH; with 400K validators and 12-second blocks you'll produce one every 55 days on average. So on Bitcoin, the largest remaining PoW network, how much capital do you need to produce a block that often?
- djhworld 4y agoDoes this mean GPU prices will go down? At least according to this article the validator nodes can be run on a Raspberry Pi [1] [1] https://ethereum.org/en/energy-consumption/ https://ethereum.org/en/energy-consumption/
- ChadNauseam 4y agoGPUs are ridiculously cheap now, compared to how they used to be. You can buy a 3070 from newegg for $599 and they’ll throw in a free monitor to sweeten the deal for you
- aeyes 4y agoThe 3070 had a $499 MSRP when it launched, I wouldn't call this deal "ridiculously cheap".
- cma 4y agoThat's the same price in inflation adjusted dollars (tech usually drops price faster than inflation raises it, but not recently).
- parkingrift 4y agoMSRP is $499 and that's already inflated $120 over the previously established MSRP. I would consider a $3070 at $400 to be back to normal.
- le-mark 4y agoThat’s what I’m wondering. There are a few gpu mineable coins, will miners switch to those, and keep gpu prices high?
- muttled 4y agoMost of the rewards in GPU mining were from Ethereum. There won't be enough money to go around to make it worth the electricity once ETH is no longer mineable. Lots of mining businesses are going to go out of business or switch to Bitcoin/ASICs, and they're going to dump those used graphics cards on the market as they do.
- pedro_hab 4y agoI think this is nice, it forces people that want to participate to have skin in the game. With proof of work there is incentive for people not invested in crypto to mine as much as possible and sell everything. If a big enough computer is created, someone not interested in crypto can take money away from it, or if the computer is big enough even destroy it, a quantum computer for instance, should make a 51% attack on a network as proof it is a quantum computer. I know it is unlikely, I myself think is impossible. But the incentive is there. With proof of stake there is no incentive to do it, a 51% attack is idiotic since you have to buy so much.
- rtkwe 4y agoOnly if your only goal is monetary gains. A group could still want to if they only wanted to trash a particular chain.
- ohgodplsno 4y ago>If a big enough computer is created, someone not interested in crypto can take money away from it, or if the computer is big enough even destroy it, a quantum computer for instance, should make a 51% attack on a network as proof it is a quantum computer. Thank you for this vision of a happier future.
- seydor 4y agoImagine if people voted or staked dollars to decide how many dollars the Fed or ECB should print. It looks like it had been suboptimal for most of history that s why the previous monetary systems successively failed. Maybe there is some kind of game-theoretic gradient that leads to monetary failure by default, which needs to be fixed by central banking . But there is no place in the world where people vote their central bankers, they are among the most opaque world leaders out there.
- seydor 4y agoDoes Eth have an advantage now vs. even more trusted actors like Binance? Binance has a history of relative reliability and is better understood by people. The unknown crowd of ETH stakers is .. unknown, but it demands our trust. Why should we trust it?
- platz 4y ago> “Rightly or wrongly, she'd absorbed a very toxic environmental narrative,” he said. “I mean, it's kind of hard to defend ‘stickers for grownups’ that emit, by some estimates, a megaton of [carbon dioxide] a week.” What was the "toxic environmental narrative"?
- sfjailbird 4y agoThis thread is HN jumping the shark for me. The merge is freaking incredible. Switching the engine of a $60 billion financial network in-flight. Permanent power savings the scale of a country. An incredible coordination between a huge number of diverse parties all over the world. Everything open source. And all we get is a rehash of tired old arguments against cryptocurrencies. This was originally a forum for hackers, makers and entrepreneurs. It does not seem like that anymore.
- adhoc_slime 4y agoTo be fair, the article talks about none of that and focuses on the high-level traders perspective. I'd bet that a write up of the process of the merge would be a huge hit on HN.
- aliqot 4y agoI want to have the same faith as you, but I've been here since y2, and it has seldom been positive. I get it, I'm in the same field of research and can't stand what traders have done to the industry. 0. In the beginning we had no legitimacy, so we courted regulators and current financial types in as a means of legitimacy by proxy. 1. Those financial types and regulators who had open minds joined, shenanigans ensued, and we saw a replaying of all the dirty tricks that were outlawed in traditional markets like front-running. 2. Then fast forward to where we are now; industry types who came in early are making a killing and funding legislation like New York's BitLicense, which pushes toward centralization by outlawing participation for 'unaccreddited' types like the nerds who built this whole shindig. For folks like me who just want to build distributed systems and tackle issues like consensus, it's hard to be taken seriously, because we're all just trying to do our work but we're trapped in this casino where there's starting to be more pinky rings than poker chips and it's only getting worse.
- seydor 4y agoBut this is the opposite of hacking. Feels like turning ETH to a political system. Soon you ll have the "republican party of ETH" forming. Those are natural self-organized outcomes when groups of humans are trusted with power.
- bosky101 4y agoCurious, what was the last block, can someone point me to it, want to see how close my few transactions were to the last block
- coffeeblack 4y agoWow! Bitcoin, your turn!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- apeace 4y ago> It's like Finland has suddenly shut off its power grid So, have we observed global energy usage go down by about one Finland? Shouldn't that be observable somehow? Shouldn't there be some power stations reducing their output as a reaction to reduced demand? Anyone know how this would be visible, and on what kind of time frame we expect it to become visible? I'm not claiming it hasn't happened. I just feel surprised to not see more coverage of that in this article, nor here in the comments. Energy efficiency is largely the point of this major change. Shouldn't there be graphs of the power grids everywhere showing a big drop? Maybe my expectations are just off on that.
- TheDudeMan 4y agoIf you were a crypto miner and had a pile of GPUs would they be powered-off right now? Of course not.
- shabbatt 4y agowell it certainly won't be used to mine Ethereum anymore and if this is the trend we will see more "high volume" coins see dropping PoW even further. Those pile of GPU are going to be a write off since prices are dropping and supply issue improves as well.
- mox1 4y agoif you are part of a mining pool, its possible they just auto-switched you to mine another coin (Ethereum Classic, LiteCoin, etc)
- dcolkitt 4y agoThere's virtually no other ASIC resistant (i.e. can use GPU) PoW coin left to mine. There's the proof-of-work ETH fork, but it only has a market cap less than 2% of than real ETH. So even though they juiced the block rewards, miner rewards are more than 90% lower, which isn't enough to pay for electricity of the previous hash rate.
- 4y ago
- browningstreet 4y agoAre there resources that tell you how to do moderately complex things in ethereum/crypto properly/safely? I've dug in every once in a while, but the people doing things in crypto seem to have crypto "stacks", and those stacks aren't transparently obvious. I haven't been able to find the useful entry point into these things.
- matkoniecz 4y ago> how to do moderately complex things in ethereum/crypto properly/safely? As far as I know it is not achievable. Even doing it in normal banking system is quite tricky with BTC/ETH it is basically hopeless.
- ideamotor 4y agoSo, it’s no longer “rent seeking” behavior, now it’s a digital collectable that enables rent collection.
- tootie 4y ago"pointing out that it might make ETH, the network's native token, deflationary." Isn't deflation basically the whole point now? Anyone who buys crypto with the expectation of its price going up is essentially betting on deflation. That's what economists predicted when bitcoin launched and it seems to have held up. Most crypto (certainly BTC and ETH) have no intrinsic value. They pay no dividends, offer no equity. They are described as currency, not assets. So price fluctuations must be explained in terms of inflation and deflation. Rising price is deflation.
- yboris 4y agoWhy did the price drop? If the merge went successfully, I'd expect people to have more confidence in the future, and thus buy - driving the price up.
- Tepix 4y agoSell the news. Besides, BTC and ETH care tightly coupled. Perhaps some people sold BTC because they think it is now at a disadvantage compared to ETH and bizarrely it caused ETH to drop in price as well.
- nateunch 4y agoProof-of-stake does not solve the Byzantine General's Problem. Therefore, it does not provide decentralized consensus. PoW is the only known solution: https://gist.github.com/oleganza/8cc921e48f396515c6d6 https://gist.github.com/oleganza/8cc921e48f396515c6d6 This paper attempts to provide proof but fails (https://eprint.iacr.org/2016/889.pdf https://eprint.iacr.org/2016/889.pdf), they effectively assume away the Bizantine Generals Problem.
- nateunch 4y agoProof-of-stake does not solve the Byzantine General's Problem. Therefore, it does not provide decentralized consensus. This effectively "unsolves" that which PoW solved. This paper is not proof (https://eprint.iacr.org/2016/889.pdf https://eprint.iacr.org/2016/889.pdf), they assume away the Byzantine Generals problem.
- jlkid225 4y agoSo Nvidia stock tanking?
- giamma 4y agoThis article is biased: "That innovation was the essential ingredient behind decentralized finance (DeFi) and NFTs" as if defi was already globally in use! And later: “Rightly or wrongly, she'd absorbed a very toxic environmental narrative,” I am actually very glad that new generations have a much better understanding of environmental risks and I find very difficult to sympathize for a ecosystem that is such energy greedy.
- pozdnyshev 4y ago
- chris123 4y agoThe fatal flaws of PoS, centralization, censorship, benefit the few of the expense of the many will become apparent.
- biztos 4y agoIn the interest of levity, and at the risk of downvotery, I ask: > So... it's done? And the blockchain answereth: > It's done. :-) https://youtu.be/1_TuEO6Mttw https://youtu.be/1_TuEO6Mttw
- biztos 4y agoI'm OK with being downvoted for irrelevance but in case anyone doesn't get the reference: A great deal was made of the change to Proof Of Stake, enough that it sort of became an end to itself, and the conversations about how exactly it would be safe or even a smart thing to do -- national energy output of country X notwithstanding -- got very hand-wavy. And yet it came to pass. The sci-fi reference linked here is about that, precisely. A big decision is made, the affected parties think they know all the implications, and yet -- well, see the movie.
- beefield 4y agoJust wondering if there is a betting market somewhere that would show odds for e.g. such a bug in the PoS that Ethereum needs to roll back to PoW within the next 6 months?
- akrymski 4y agoGreat, we've replaced regulated banks by a handful of unregulated and pseudo-anonymous entities (pools & brokers).
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JaggerFoo 4y agoDon't forget about the Merge song "Pandas are not known for running" - a true classic. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eCpj9tMIDIY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eCpj9tMIDIY Cheers
- nikolay 4y agoIs this why it's down over 10%?
- aaroninsf 4y agoStake or work, smart contracts remain not just a failed experiment, but a horribly horribly horribly failed experiment with a lot of broken dreams and broken people in their wake. And Ethereum's transaction rate necessitates a bunch of hacks rife with their own grift, vulnerability, opacity, and manipulation. Yay for removing one of the more egregious of the ten things fundamentally wrong with this, I guess.
- blobbers 4y agoPeople say this will be "good" for the environment, but isn't it just "less bad". The very existence uses up energy.
- up2isomorphism 4y agoThe mere fact that this thing can be “merged” means Etherum is a joke. Obviously this is not surprising since there was a fork happened.
- husamia 4y agoEOS has multi signature keys, active keys and primary keys