27 ms·
Can the Visa-Mastercard duopoly be broken?
- Jenny_Wengerd0 4y ago
- withinboredom 4y agoHaha. Ask American Express. They’d love to help.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- toss1 4y agoHaHa, yup, but it seems they're fat & happy where they are, with high fees on both sides. Their services are so much better than V/Mc that they could rapidly swamp V/Mc, IFF they'd reduce their fees. But they are obviously not interested in any other than the market segments they've got.
- sgjohnson 4y agoI doubt they care, as their business is built on quality, not quantity. Average Amex cardholder already charged to their card roughly 10x of what the average non-amex cardholder charges.
- 5555624 4y agoAMEX won't lower their surcharge. Until they do, they will always lose business to Visa and Mastercard.
- Rackedup 4y agoIt's pretty rare that my AMEX card gets refused...
- ab-dm 4y agoMight depend on the country. It happens a fair bit down in Australia
- ryandrake 4y agoMaybe USA-specific, but I've been AMEX-only for around 20 years, and have no regrets. They handle fraud and chargebacks with almost no effort or followup required. Very infrequently, I'll run into a cheap-ass merchant who doesn't take AMEX, and I will either not do business with them or just pay in cash.
- withinboredom 4y agoYeah, AMEX has lots of issues getting accepted outside the US. Some places won't accept tap-to-pay for Amex, but only chip+pin, or various other oddities, if they accept it at all.
- metadat 4y agoUn-paywalled: https://archive.ph/5HJal https://archive.ph/5HJal
- sudden_dystopia 4y agoThis is the best, and in my opinion, only use case for Ethereum
- bnchrch 4y agoThis is something I hope a blockchain solution breaks through. A thought on how to do it. 1. Create a stable coin 2. Create a credit card that uses this token 3. Tie using it to some reward, supercharge it with VC if you have to 4. Release a QR payment component where vendors don't have to pay to receive payment, get rewards and payees earn double rewards 5. Integrate that bad boy far and wide Worth noting that Stripe, Shopify and Square are also well placed to use a similar strategy
- Swizec 4y ago> This is something I hope a blockchain solution breaks through. Don't worry, Visa and probably Mastercard already have a crypto department. They've been digging into blockchain (and buying startups) for a while now.
- k__ 4y agoI read, at one of those companies hundreds of people are working on crypto/blockchain.
- karamanolev 4y agoSo far I think the first step has failed spectacularly a few times, let alone any follow up. I'm not saying the above is necessarily impossible, but at this point I've acquired an instant gag reflex when I hear blockchain. I'm not sure if that's a healthy approach for me, but it's true. Why does it have to be a blockchain instead of a government-mandated nonprofit (e.g. FedNow) to operate it? Wouldn't that have more oversight and less chances of massive fraud?
- junofan 4y agoThe Fed is absurdly profitable.
- toomuchtodo 4y agohttps://www.moderntreasury.com/learn/what-is-fednow https://www.moderntreasury.com/learn/what-is-fednow > FedNow is an instant payment service for both individuals and businesses. Once launched, the initial transaction limit will be $25,000. This means that FedNow be more useful for small businesses and retail payment needs until it is widely adopted and the transaction limit grows. > In early 2022, the Federal Reserve released pricing and fee details for their real-time settlement network. Because FedNow is government-operated, it’s mandated to break even and not turn a profit. A possible advantage of this is that FedNow may offer more competitive pricing than other payment systems, which encourages widespread adoption at a faster rate. Merchants can pass the CC surcharge through; I’d expect them to do so when a very low cost immediate settlement option is available. This will allow consumers to self select if they want the benefits of paying with a credit card (but paying for the privilege). Credit can be extended if needed by a financial institution, without using CC rails. Net 30? BNPL? Special financing arrangement? Pick your poison either prior to or after value transfer has occurred. The innovation is utility priced financial infrastructure, cutting out the rentseekers mentioned. (my note: it’s about five cents per FedNow value transfer transaction)
- karamanolev 4y ago> Merchants can pass the CC surcharge through Can they? I was under the impression (unverified) that they are under contract to provide the same prices for CC customers as they do for cash or debit card.
- kelnos 4y agoThat used to be the case, but changed in 2013 when a lawsuit settlement was reached that more or less did away with these sorts of contract terms[0]. That's why (at least where I live) gas stations that charge different prices for CCs and cash/debit are everywhere, some restaurants will offer some percentage off if you pay in cash, and some online services, even, pass credit card fees on to customers. I believe there are a few states in the US left where merchants can still be required to charge the same, but in most places in the US that's not the case. [0] https://smartpay.gsa.gov/content/surcharges https://smartpay.gsa.gov/content/surcharges
- immortaljoe 4y agoRupay in India seems to be doing it. Non affiliated video about it: https://youtu.be/B_AY4a3_-GQ https://youtu.be/B_AY4a3_-GQ
- db1234 4y agoVisa and Mastercard complained to US Govt about Indian Govt backing Rupay. I am sure they will lobby against any attempts to break their monopoly in US too.
- 10g1k 4y ago1.4 billion people in China use WeChat to pay for everything. They don't even bother with credit cards.
- joshxyz 4y agothis. this is crazy. ewallets are taking over.
- spaetzleesser 4y agoHow much does WeChat charge in fees?
- em_te 4y ago0.6% for business transactions 0% for peer to peer transactions 0% to transfer from your bank account to WeChat 0.001% to transfer from your WeChat to bank account
- reaperducer 4y agoFortunately, phones never get lost. Or broken. Or stolen. Or discharge. Or malfunction. Or lock people out for no good reason. I can put a $100 bill through the washing machine and it's still perfectly usable. When I can do that with a phone, maybe I'll switch. I ran a credit card through the washer and dryer last month, and even though it got bent, and the stripe doesn't work anymore, the chip does. And the numbers can be punched into a POS terminal if all else fails. E-wallets are putting your finances into a single point of failure. Tech people should know better.
- ars 4y agoI don't want to carry cash, but I don't need it to be a Credit Card. The new FedNow https://www.frbservices.org/financial-services/fednow/about.html https://www.frbservices.org/financial-services/fednow/about.... system might take a significant part of Visa/Mastercard business.
- toss1 4y agoCould be very cool - I didn't know abt this, thx for posting!
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoHuh. Apple-pay? In my college town, credit cards are on the way out.
- drexlspivey 4y agoApple pay is just an easy way to use your card
- jonny_eh 4y agoOr debit card
- rdtwo 4y agoIt’s on the discover card network
- snazz 4y agoYou’re thinking of Apple Cash, which is a Green Dot Bank debit card that used to use Discover and now uses Visa Debit. Apple Pay in general works with all four major networks and nearly any credit or debit card.
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoUntil they create their own I guess
- mekster 4y agoHow does your little college town effect the entirety of the market?
- pwinnski 4y agoApple Pay is using NFC to supply credit card info, but it's still most commonly Visa or Mastercard. Unless you mean the Apple Card, in which case it's a Mastercard.
- amelius 4y ago
- gz5 4y agothey also provide tremendous value. however, looked at from a disruptive innovation perspective, i think two questions are critical: + where can startups take the edges off the market, without taking them on front-on? certain segments, use cases, etc. + what tech innovations exist today (or are on the horizon) which a startup could leverage faster/better than visa/mastercard to better serve certain use cases better than v/m (e.g Dell (when they were a startup) was so much faster than IBM to incorporate Intel's new tech every cycle, which resulted in Dell customers getting more capable and less expensive pcs)
- alberth 4y agoLet’s compare against other consumer choices. Can the … - Coke-Pepsi duopoly be broken? - Google-Baidu? - Nearly any professional sport is a monopoly (NFL, NBA, etc) And soooo many more.
- lessname 4y agoBaidu is not a competitor to Google. Even if there was an English version of it, with so much censorship it wouldn't be able to compete. Bing and (maybe) Brave Search are small competitors to Google.
- echelon 4y ago> Coke-Pepsi duopoly be broken? Dr.Pepper, Monster Beverage, Redbull, Asahi, Arizona, and thousands of other smaller players exist. > Google-Baidu? Google is a search monopoly for English speakers. Steps should be taken to remove Google's ability to enforce via Chrome and Android, or prioritize adsense sites. Perhaps the DOJ can split their business units or force third party offerings to be required. > Nearly any professional sport is a monopoly (NFL, NBA, etc) If sports aren't fungible, XFL. If they are, there are thousands of leagues. Did you know Michael Jordan played golf?
- toast0 4y ago> Dr.Pepper Dr Pepper is often bottled and distributed by Pepsi or Coke, especially outside of the US. Coke has a competing "pepper" drink (Mr Pibb), but mostly markets it in areas where the Coke distributor doesn't have rights to Dr Pepper.
- echelon 4y agoThat's just business logistics, though, and the company is free to form relationships with other distributors if it so wishes. At the end of the day, the Dr. Pepper company is marketing and earning the lion's share of the margin for their product.
- avrionov 4y agoMonster Beverage is owned by Coca-Cola.
- sytelus 4y agoI still haven't understood why credit cards companies need to go through this complex multi-hop "settlement" pipeline that takes almost a day for transactions to get "processed". Is it because some banks still depend on mainframes doing batch processing?
- hn_throwaway_99 4y ago> Is it because some banks still depend on mainframes doing batch processing? Pretty much all banks use mainframes to do batch processing. "SFTP runs the world". I got heavy into fintech a couple years ago, and at first I thought "This is all insane." I was coming from a SaaS world where it's easy to think about transactional guarantees with API calls. I finally "got it" when I realized that pretty much all of our financial system in the US is based on the digitization of manual processes from the 50s and 60s. If you think of how banks worked before computers (e.g. large binders of ledgers that were manually reconciled), that's basically how it still works today, those big binders have just been turned into digital files that are processed by machines. I'm no fan of crypto, but the one place where I can see real utility for blockchain is as a backend settlement service for banks.
- Enginerrrd 4y ago>I'm no fan of crypto, but the one place where I can see real utility for blockchain is as a backend settlement service for banks. So... what does the crypto provide there that a simple authenticated communication protocol with a few redundant centralized servers doesn't?
- csomar 4y agoA blockchain will allow all these operators to transact safely. It's really just more secure because it's open (otherwise very quickly compromised). And blockchain tech has shown to be reliable when it comes to up-time and security (if you keep it simple).
- thematrixturtle 4y ago
- Areibman 4y agoDoes anyone sincerely believe FedNow will gain traction for consumer payments? The fees don’t seem particularly cheap (at least compared to something like Solana Pay), and the FedNow website does not inspire confidence.
- junofan 4y agoI don’t see the value add from the sender side.
- aidenn0 4y agoIf checking accounts get debit-only RTNs for cheap/free, this could potentially catch on. $0.06 per transaction with $25/month subscription fee is incredibly cheap, plus no chargebacks! Biggest issue I see is that the larger banks might not offer this to their customers so as to not cannibalize their credit card businesses and/or in-house payment system.
- kelnos 4y ago> $25/month subscription fee is incredibly cheap Cheap?! That's $300/yr, and is more expensive than most credit card annual fees (for cards that even have annual fees). And with FedNow you don't get any credit card benefits. I mean, I pay $550/yr for one of my credit cards, but I get like $2k of value out of it per year in benefits. Why would I want to pay $300/yr for something that lets me do something I can already do, for free or "cheaper than free"?
- aidenn0 4y agoThe way I read it is that $25 per month is only for RTNs that can receive credits. If you just want to pay for things (like a credit card) then you don't need to pay any subscription fee.
- rwbt 4y agoThat $25/month fee is for accounts that accept payments. I don't think debit accounts will have such a ridiculous fee.
- Veliladon 4y agoThe only thing I don't want to happen is for the duopoly to be broken up into a billion different little fiefdoms each with their own unregulated space. One of the reasons credit cards are so good is because there's a fuckton of regulations built into the legislation behind them in order to give an individual consumer a fighting chance against the financial industry. All these fintech companies wanting ACH access to my bank account? If a transaction gets fucked up (i.e. someone puts the decimal in the wrong place) it's my immediate and hard to fix problem. I have to deal with my bank's bureaucracy and their goodwill. In the meantime I have no access to my money. If someone fucks up the same using my credit card number it's one call and the company takes care of it and because it's in arrears I still have all my cash. Nope. It'll be a cold day in hell before I give any fintech get direct access to my checking account for payments.
- lima 4y agoThat's how it works in Europe (SEPA mandate) and it doesn't appear to be a problem. In Germany, very few people have credit cards, and mostly for online purchases. Everything else is done via direct debit. Fraudulent charges can be reversed just like a CC payment.
- mhrmsn 4y agoAre you talking about the Girocard (EC-Karte) system? Because there's also a lot of direct debit cards around that are all Mastercard/Visa branded. It's true though that using "real" credit cards is relatively uncommon.
- lima 4y agoYes, Girocard. Much lower fees. EC card is actually an older system that isn't really used anymore but the name stuck :-)
- n_ary 4y agoI think, I am living in different Germany, as for last 4-5 years, I only see oma/opa paying in cash. Everyone else carries one form or another of EC Karte or Debit Master/Visa. I rarely see some Gebuhrenfreis now and then, but most people have somekind of Debit ones. Even certain kebab/doner shops located near bahnhofs now accept cards, but inner area ones are still cash-only. Most asian shops are generally cash-only sadly.
- andersonmvd 4y agoIn Brazil many stores are dropping credit card and allowing only PIX (instant debit transfer) cause it's cheaper for business (0,22% avg transaction fee vs 1%-2% of credit cards - src (pt-only) https://g1.globo.com/economia/pme/noticia/2022/03/23/pix-e-muito-mais-barato-que-cartoes-para-lojistas-apontam-economistas-do-bc.ghtml https://g1.globo.com/economia/pme/noticia/2022/03/23/pix-e-m...). The President of Brazilian Central Bank recently said that "credit cards will soon cease to exist" src (pt only) https://www.poder360.com.br/economia/campos-neto-diz-que-cartao-de-credito-deixara-de-existir/ https://www.poder360.com.br/economia/campos-neto-diz-que-car...
- pkaye 4y agoI presume instant payments don't have the chargeback feature of credit card? That is the main benefit I care about credit cards.
- csomar 4y agoMy guess is charge backs are probably a US/Canada thing. Many countries have credit cards without the protections. It happens to work in the US because there is a credit score system, high volumes and most people play by the rules.
- Dannymetconan 4y agoThe EU also has charge backs as well. I would have assumed all credit cards would have this as a feature.
- 4ad 4y agoYou are right that in practice it's a US/Canada thing, but it's available everywhere. Customers simply don't know about it, banks don't advertise it and if you try to take advantage of it it's very likely you'll stumble upon a clerk who genuinely thinks that "it's impossible". But it is certainly possible and universally available. Consumers should simply know their rights and refuse to be pushed over by banks. Personally I have made use of "impossible" chargebacks in Romania, Austria, and Germany. Of course the process was obtuse and frustrating compared to the US.
- philip1209 4y agoFraud protection of credit cards is the root of modern e-commerce. In some ways, Visa and Mastercard are the privatized court systems of the internet. If I end up on a random, self-hosted ecommerce site and decide to make a purchase - what guarantee do I have that the item will show up or be as-described? If I bought something through a bank transfer, reversing that purchase would be incredibly difficult. And, suing a merchant is prohibitively slow, expensive, and arduous. Also, modern B2C SaaS is built on credit card subscriptions. The ability for a merchant to pull payments on a recurring basis from a credit card requires an incredible amount of trust. If consumers had to push payment every month or year to continue subscriptions (instead of having it automatically debited), then churn rates would skyrocket and modern SaaS multiples would crash - taking company valuations with it. So, I'm sure online merchants are happy to keep paying their ~3% fees as long as sales continue. Nobody wants to go back to "Cash on Delivery", and nobody wants to hire workers to knock on doors asking for bills to be paid.
- arcticbull 4y agoThe fees are 3% only in the US and the bulk of that is returned to buyers as cash back or loyalty points, and to offset the cost of loan origination and warranties. The EU has capped debit interchange at .2% and credit at .3%, Australia in the low 1s if I recall correctly. They just don’t really have rewards.
- jen729w 4y agoYeah typically around 1.5% in Australia. Which is often passed on to the consumer at the point of sale. We do have a non-Visa/MC payment system here in 'eftpos', which is ubiquitous. AFAIK this is exclusively debit not credit, but this isn't my area, I'm just a consumer. https://www.eftposaustralia.com.au https://www.eftposaustralia.com.au
- _carbyau_ 4y agoEFTPOS got kicked to the curb when paywave-with-no-pin started. And then the pandemic reinforced that idea for a lot of people. I don't know when I last used EFTPOS.
- legitster 4y agoI'm pretty confident Visa's dominance is a completely natural monopoly. There are plenty of 3rd party payment options (Amex and Diners' are still both fairly widely accepted) and nothing is stopping consumers from having multiple cards. But I think the network effects are too strong and we are seeing a pretty normal Pareto distribution. Even if you added 20 new market entrants with good coverage, consumers and businesses would still prefer to have Visa as the lingua franca of payments. I think it will also be pretty hard to get away from that 3.5% processing fee. That covers a lot of fraud prevention work that credit card companies take on for consumers and businesses. Will consumers be happy to give up those protections and reap back a percent or two on prices? And emerging payment technologies seem to create more opportunity for fraud.
- slaymaker1907 4y agoYeah, I think a lot of people are better off just paying 3.5% more but with the fraud protection. However, I still think this will be a huge improvement for a lot of other stuff like moving money between accounts at different banks or paying for large purchases which are guarded by a proper contract such as paying rent, buying a car, etc.
- klabb3 4y agoNot all, but a lot of fraud can be prevented with good 2FA. Chip+pin is usually hard enough for low effort fraudsters, and it's tried and tested in large parts of the world for decades. The US has effectively no effective 2FA. Signature is never verfiied in practice, and magnetic strips are dead simple to clone.
- adrr 4y ago3.5% isn't what merchants pay unless you're tiny. Highest interchange is around 2.5 and maybe you'll pay 0.25% in settlement fees. What interchange covers mainly is the cost of capital to give a consumer a 60 day interest free loan. Capital isn't free and this has real world costs to the bank underwriting the loans. Why you Chase or BOA debit card interchange rates are 0.05% because they aren't lending out their own money.
- dkobia 4y ago
- cardosof 4y agoCan the duopoly be broken? Yes, you can have Pix, the system created by the Brazilian Central Bank for instant, verified payments and some credit/installments features. It's cheaper for business but then a central bank will know all your transactions. There are some talks of sharing the system with Canada and other countries.
- bastardoperator 4y agoCan we get banks to adopt new banking platforms? Probably not...
- ojagodzinski 4y agoNo problem in Poland, we have Blik https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blik https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blik
- bastardoperator 4y agoThis looks more like payment processing, I'm thinking more along the line of internal banking platforms that talk to processors like Visa, Discover, AMEX. It's almost impossible to get around the below if your bank does anything with credit cards. American Express IP First Data Corp - FDC - FDMS - North Platform (CardNet) MasterCard Internet Gateway Service - MIGS USA Nova - US Bancorp TSYS - VITAL (VisaNet) First Data Corp - FDC - FDMS - Nashville Platform (ENVOY) First Data Corp - FDC - FDMS - Omaha Platform (FDR) First Data Corp - FDC - FDMS - South Platform (NaBANCO) NOVUS (Discover)
- madrox 4y agoI'm just grateful it's a duopoly and not a monopoly. Can you imagine how much worse the situation would be if one company soft-owned the entire space the way Facebook does with social media?
- jjcon 4y agoI'm not sure how facebook is a monopoly on really any level (see tiktok, twitter, youtube, snapchat, etc etc). Visa Mastercard duopoly also has 10x the barriers of entry that social media has.
- madrox 4y agoMy reasoning was that, across all Facebook-owned properties, they have ~7 billion MAU. All their top competitors combined are roughly half that. [1] This is all illustrative, of course. My salient point is that monopolies are only really held in check by the law. In this case, at least there's a significant competitor. 1: https://www.searchenginejournal.com/social-media/biggest-social-media-sites/#close https://www.searchenginejournal.com/social-media/biggest-soc...
- therealmarv 4y agoEuropean Union solved big part of the problem many years ago in 2015 with a new law. They capped the fees of Visa and Mastercard at max. 0.3% of the transaction volume on private consumer cards. It has many upsides (especially increased acceptance). The only downside: There are no real or good cashback programs (like getting 1-2% back) in Europe because of this.
- morepork 4y agoI wouldn't say that's a huge downside as in theory prices should be that little bit lower
- 4ad 4y agoAnd yet, they are higher. Of course, not because CC fees, but regardless of the reason, as the price of virtually everything that isn't a staple is higher in the EU, the fact that lower CC fees make prices trivially lower in this particular case is somewhat of an irrelevant point.
- carstenhag 4y agoInterchange yes, but that's only a small part of the price. Companies still have to pay 1-3%.
- StayTrue 4y agoMaybe I just hate money but IMO there are no good cashback schemes. A merchant-to-consumer wealth transfer that piggybacks on every transaction? Has a smell of fraud or corruption but not stinky enough for American regulators. Good job to the EU on this one.
- projektfu 4y agoMercado Pago, from the article, represents a merchant processor, and certain consumer services. However I think the big change in Brazil is Pix, offered by the central bank. It allows instantaneous bank transfers for most cash accounts. The fees are 0 or nearly 0. As far as I understand, Mercado Pago's big thing is installment plans. You can buy almost anything in Brazil "em ate 12x sem juros" or up to 12 installments without fees.
- jpollock 4y agoI don't understand how this is possible: "Merchants hand over some $138bn in fees each year; according to the National Retail Federation, a lobby group, it is their second-biggest cost after wages." Unless they're talking about more than just credit card fees? From the same article: "But credit-card fees are unregulated and meatier, usually sitting at about 2% of the transaction and rising to 3.5% for some premium-reward cards." Are they saying that retailers pay less than 4% of the retail price to acquire their goods? They pay more for credit cards than rent?
- crazygringo 4y agoThat jumped out at me too -- so I looked up what appears to be the source [1] and it does indeed state: > "Regardless of size, the fees are most merchants’ highest operating cost after labor" but I'm as incredulous as you are. Obviously things like cost of goods, and also usually rent, are also going to be higher. I can only assume it's based on some really misleading survey, and I'm honestly surprised to see The Economist, of all publications, repeat something so obviously economically questionable. (To be sure, they attribute the claim rather than state it, but they present it as if it's true.) [1] https://nrf.com/media-center/press-releases/retailers-say-small-businesses-are-hardest-hit-rising-credit-card-swipe https://nrf.com/media-center/press-releases/retailers-say-sm...
- dsr3 4y agoI would assume that in this context, the cost of goods is not measured in the operating expense. Notice the keyword 'operating cost'. It is common to have the COGS vs OpEx separated in the financial balance sheet.
- thematrixturtle 4y agoI presume inventory is not considered an "operating cost", which is fair enough. Rent absolutely should be one though.
- al2o3cr 4y agoI don't understand how this is possible Here's the explanation: according to the National Retail Federation, a lobby group Spoiler alert: most lobbyists are professional liars. If pressed they'll put up a smokescreen of "well I meant _operating_ costs, which of course are far smaller than cost-of-goods" but the lie is still printed in the article...
- mathiasgredal 4y agoWell, in Denmark you can use Dankort(https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dankort https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dankort), which does exactly the same as Visa or Mastercard, but the transactions are handled by Nets instead.
- superasn 4y agoFor all the red-tape and corruption we have here, I still think India has done a phenomenal job with UPI payments. I mean I don't even remember the last time I used my credit card considering I have even forgotten the pin codes now. One or two other thing I love about these UPI payments is that it doesn't seem to incur any 2 or 3% commissions(1) which is both great for the consumer and the merchant (as these costs would eventually be passed to the customer anyway). Also almost every cc machine, website and panwala has a the QR codes now so no need to carry a wallet or plastic cards. I can make payments of Rs.5 and that's fine. I don't even carry a wallet anymore to a mall or any place since my driver's lic/reg is in the digilocker app(2) and the credit card is the gpay/phonepe app. (1) Not really sure if there is or will be later, since I'm not a fintech person, but from what I can tell I don't see any commission on UPI payments yet. (2) https://www.google.com/search?q=digilocker+license+valid https://www.google.com/search?q=digilocker+license+valid
- munk-a 4y agoThe Interact network has done an extremely good job at breaking it in Canada. So yes, yes it can.
- marcodiego 4y agoIn Brazil we have pix: https://business.ebanx.com/en/resources/payments-explained/pix-instant-payment-system https://business.ebanx.com/en/resources/payments-explained/p... It is mostly a novelty here. It allows simple payments to be made using a smartphone, smartwatch... you can use an app to transfer money from one person to another. Basically everybody is using it now. You can buy popcorn in the streets and pay via pix. In many places it is common than paper money and, I think, it is already more popular than credit cards. It also pays much less taxes. I do think the credit card duopoly can be broken.
- Hanschri 4y agoI would like to show you the national payment system in Norway, BankAxept[0]. It's used in 8/10 purchases in physical stores. The system verifies the card has a sufficient balance before the transaction is verified, and charges the account instantly on purchase. The subscription to the network is 150 NOK/month, with each transaction costing 0,21 NOK each, before volume rebates. 1 EUR/USD is worth roughly 10 NOK at the time of writing, so about 15/0,021 for the subscription/transaction cost. I don't know much about VISA and MasterCard costs, but I would hazard a guess they're higher. I think the only time I ever use VISA is when purchasing things online, and even then I'm not quite sure it's always VISA. Fun fact, BankAxept stopped accepting the magnetic strip in 2011. Now chip & pin or NFC are the two main ways of paying, with NFC transactions under 500 NOK not requiring the PIN to be entered, except periodically for verification. [0]:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BankAxept https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BankAxept
- motohagiography 4y agoSure, but it requires a fork of the EMV/global platform protocols, and a technology change that obviates payment terminals. It will always exist as a legacy integration, but you basically need a parallel infrastructure with better economics. An open wireless tap protocol for cryptocurrency hardware wallets would do it, and then there would have to be a delegation wallet / cash register version where you can delegate payment collection to an employee without giving them the whole bank account, and then some kind of insurance to backstop inevitable fraud, and a market for securitzing and trading the bonds for that insurance, all with transaction fees that are competitive with cards and interac. Nothing current crypto exchanges and companies can't do today. I actually foresee these becoming popular as a reaction to CBDC's and the cashlessness that will very severely marginalize people and cut them out of the economy. Further, I could see shops themselves polarizing, where just like you may not go to a McDonalds (I haven't been in one in decades), there are places you go, and places you don't, and the places that only accept govt fiat will be the places you go when you don't have a better option. It will be like going to a small town greengrocer who accepts crypto or gives credit by private arrangement repayable in crypto vs. some globalized big box store. There's a floor on how stupid and overreaching regulations can be before the economics of peoples individual risk/reward calculation switches to evading them. It's literally the mechanism behind pervasive low level corruption in authoritarian regimes, where past a point, governments themselves have invented the incentives for citizens to evade them, and created massive underground economies as a result. Worse, the state benefits from the black market money and turns a blind eye to the criminals who support it, and that's how you get places like Chicago, Baltimore, LA, and to a lesser extent, Vancouver. Yes, the duopoly will be broken, but it will be the side effect of emerging cashless society policies from some spectacularly naive policymakers.
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 4y agoyes but by mandating that cash is used for payments instead of what the govt here is doing with its 80k fines for businesses that don't prop up the electronic payment scam.
- beefman 4y agohttps://archive.ph/5HJal https://archive.ph/5HJal
- Spooky23 4y agoThe whole premise of the article is dumb. Lots of small businesses like to cry about credit card fees, which is absurd given the value offered for the price charged. Not only do they drive spending, but they eliminate the casual embezzlement and pilferage that plagues cash businesses. My grandfather ran pubs, and use to quip that he’d fire any honest bartender, because the guy was smarter than him. When I was in college I worked for a company one summer that installed parking gates with credit card payment systems at big institutions. One customer was a hospital who reported 28% increases in parking sales… the guys who worked there were skimming the toll for years. You also need to pay labor to count the tills, manage the cash, etc. In any case, show me someone whining about a 3% fee and you’re showing me someone who’s out of touch with their business.
- crazygringo 4y agoIt really, really, really depends on the business. Most places still accept cash as well so they still have all the expenses around cash management, that's not going away. And most places also have records/safeguards to see if employees are skimming -- bars are one of the few exceptions where it can be trickier, simply because almost no cash-paying customers want a receipt and it's dark and busy. And when you factor in the fact that cash income can be hidden from the IRS in a way that credit card income can't, you can see how certain businesses might really wind up "paying" a lot more than just in credit card fees... ;)
- jollybean 4y agoI think this is completely wrong. It's not the 'credit' that drives this, so much as the 'digitization'. That can be achieved without credit. European countries have been doing it for a long time. Canada has 'Interac'. There is utterly no need for VISA/MC. A fairly simple banking standard could make it so that you could pay for stuff with some kind of card + PIN and that's it. There'd be a tiny fee which would help take care of fraud. Done. It already works in large economies. The US has regulatory capture by large corporations.
- Spooky23 4y agoPerhaps, but the US has a very different journey. Canada for example has like 60 banks. The US has 10,000+ banks and credit unions, and probably 3x more when the system started. Interop is different.
- crazygringo 4y ago> Households that bring in more than $135,000 a year recoup in points or perks around 0.6 percentage points of the interchange fees they pay. This is bizarre to me. When the Citibank Double Cash credit card exists for no annual fee and pays 2% back... why does anyone ever use any card that provides less? The only cards I use besides that one are the ones that give me 3% or 5% back in special categories. The idea that people average only 0.6% back is absurd to me. Am I missing something here? And we're not talking college students here with no credit history. This is households making more than $135K a year. Are people just not bothering to pick up free money?
- kube-system 4y agoObviously not all credit cards are the Citibank Double Cash card. But, there are multiple answers: 1. Some cards have features other than cash back that people want instead. i.e. promotional interest rates. 2. Some people carry a balance, in which case the benefits of using a lower interest card may way outweigh any cash back 3. Not everyone with incomes 135k+ have good credit scores.
- BenjiWiebe 4y agoHow about Discover? Also American Express, as mentioned in other comments.
- esturk 4y agoI know the title implies USA but in the global credit card market, there actually is a 3rd contender called UnionPay. In fact, by volume, it already exceeds MasterCard.[1] [1]https://nilsonreport.com/upload/Cover-1224-600.gif https://nilsonreport.com/upload/Cover-1224-600.gif
- doodlesdev 4y agoTo avoid the paywall, disable JavaScript :D
- Haegin 4y agoBetteridge's law of headlines.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- julienreszka 4y agoIf the fees encourage people to use cash instead of electronic money then at least it's good for privacy.
- pvsukale3 4y agoIndia is breaking this dominance by government backed Rupay and UPI payment methods. Both have 0 MDR charges. Rupay is a direct alternative to Visa and MasterCard. UPI is peer to peer payment system for any bank account linked with a phone and debit card. So far government has been successfully in both of these endeavours. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RuPay?wprov=sfla1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RuPay?wprov=sfla1 https://www.business-standard.com/article/economy-policy/rupay-s-market-share-tops-60-in-total-cards-issued-says-rbi-report-121012800046_1.html https://www.business-standard.com/article/economy-policy/rup...
- tushar-r 4y ago>Both have 0 MDR charges. Possibly not for long - https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/money-and-banking/rbi-mulls-introducing-charges-on-upi-based-funds-transfer/article65780249.ece https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/money-and-banking/rbi-m...
- FuturisticLover 4y agoIt's broken in India.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- woweoe 4y agoIt is broken in many countries including India and China. The issues are the duopoly over global transactions, the monopoly over the transactions, and the dominance of the US dollar in situations where other currencies would be more efficient.
- samarthr1 4y agoThe government of India has a competitor that is actually quite nice to use called Rupay. All public sector banks issue cards almost entirely with rupay now. Being government owned, it has 0 MDR.
- diogenescynic 4y agoI always thought this is where PayPal would excel, but they seem to also be reliant on the Visa/Mastercard duopoly themselves.
- apeace 4y agoLiving in New York City, I've noticed that there are a whole lot of businesses that are either cash-only or card-only. I always understood the cash-only ones. If you can get plenty of customers who are willing to pay in cash, why would you want to pay credit card fees? The card-only ones were harder for me to understand, until I realized that handling cash costs money, too. Somebody needs to count it all at least once a day, if not more. Employees can steal it. Robbers can steal it. You need a safe. You need cash registers. You need to get the cash deposited in the bank, by paying someone to go do that. You need to maintain an inventory of smaller bills and coins to make change. You need to train people on all of this. Even just the accounting costs might make up the 2-3 percent in fees. "Your register said you made $150 in cash that day, but the deposit that night was only $135." That's what you pay accountants to deal with, rather than just exporting from your Square account to Quickbooks or whatever. I had this realization because I went to a new coffee shop that had opened up. It appeared to be owned and operated by just one lady, and she was really nice. So, as I normally do for the nice local business owners in my neighborhood, I got out some cash instead of a card, thinking it would benefit her business. But then she told me they were card-only and it dawned on me: she's just one lady running a store by herself, _of course_ she doesn't want to deal with cash. So, I'm not sure the 2-3 percent fees are all that bad, though I could be convinced otherwise. Plenty of small business owners seem pretty happy just setting up a Square reader and not dealing with the headache of cash. I think there's a lot of value in that for them.
- throw__away7391 4y agoThe "cash only" businesses in NY are generally cheating on their taxes. A congressman was arrested a few years back for tax fraud on the profits from cash only businesses he owned in the city. His defense was that "this is a well-known common practice in the city".
- apeace 4y agoI don't doubt that for a second :)
- conjecTech 4y agoThis is a false dichotomy. Other countries have debit systems that solve all of the problems you outline and charge 0.1%.
- TheBlight 4y ago
- gsibble 4y agoI actually designed software that could integrate with existing POS systems (the really hard part) that allowed for interchange free commerce using a card or Apple Pay integration. I showed it to an investor. His only response was, "This is a very fast way to end up dead." You don't fuck with monopolies that bring in hundreds of billions to trillions of dollars in profit a year. People get killed for way less. On a secondary note, when I was working in payments, I once met the SVP of Payments for Wells Fargo. I got him drunk. He told me that when WF internally separated out their business units P&Ls, payments/interchange made up 64% of WF's total public Net Income.
- serial_dev 4y agoWhen I read "fast way to end up dead", I naively though as a company, meaning that you have no chance of getting traction and breaking into the market... I am still actually wondering if this would get you killed or you would face simply an uphill battle in the market and never get traction. In a sense it is similar to the two party system in the US. I wonder if there isn't a viable third party still today because people are so used to voting Republican or Democrat, and because all the institutions (including media) are set up in a way that makes it very hard to start a third party or because third parties that actually want to change the game are infiltrated and threatened behind the scenes.
- gsibble 4y agoIn this case, he meant physically dead. A few years later, my life was threatened credibly by a billionaire I was doing business with and it opened my eyes that murder is just another part of corporate America (usually made to look like suicides).
- CharlesW 4y ago> You don't fuck with monopolies that bring in hundreds of billions to trillions of dollars in profit a year. People get killed for way less. He didn't mean that a corporation would literally kill you, because that comes with the possibility of unimaginable risk. He meant that they had effectively-infinite resources to fight you for decades with an army of lawyers and politicians. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Kearns https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Kearns https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/visa-inc/summary?id=D000029689 https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/visa-inc/summary?id=D000029... https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/mastercard-inc/summary?id=D000022099 https://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/mastercard-inc/summary?id=D...
- vinsat 4y agoThey should look at how India is trying to break this with both UPI (bank to bank transfer) and Rupay (India's own VISA)
- TheRealPomax 4y agoMaybe start by not having banks that are so bad at actually doing what a bank should do that visa and mastercard can just move in and fill the gaping holes with credit cards. Until I moved to North America from Europe I had zero reason to even own a single one because banks just... you know... did banking. It's both possible and easy to send and receive money, without caring which banks are involved, instantly, for free.
- msravi 4y agoIn India, the duopoly is already broken by UPI (Universal Payments Interface). UPI provides zero-cost transfers and mobile payments between linked bank accounts and every little streetcorner store and sidewalk vendor accepts UPI payments. Also 2FA using SMS is required and enabled by default. You can pay by scanning a QR-code, or a mobile number, or a UPI ID. There's also an effort to allow "scanning" an audio-signal to enable non-smartphone devices.
- cuteboy19 4y agoIt's actually broken by RuPay cards (Rupee+Pay not Russia+Pay) which is a direct alternative to visa/MasterCard. It has like 30% market share already. Few years back the central bank realised that depending on a foreign company for such a basic thing might not be the best idea. And they were proven right with the Russia/SWIFT episode. Interestingly both Visa and MasterCard are currently lobbying (bribing) with the US government against RuPay
- crossroadsguy 4y agoTrue. RuPay is exploding in rural areas. I like the ideas. Competition is good. However I wish Govt fixed UPI glitches like as of now UPI doesn’t fail/succeed decisively at the time of payment attempt (this often causes huge inconvenience and sometimes monetary losses) and they must bring chargeback option to UPI.
- nicolinox 4y agoRevolut is well positioned to launch an alternative p2p multi-currency (fiat) for both consumers and businesses with the partnership with Stripe [0]. This would challenge both Visa-Mastercard and SWIFT. [0] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-07-06/revolut-partnering-with-stripe-for-payments-in-europe https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-07-06/revolut-p...
- pumpkinprog 4y agoNo problem at all. See Russian example. 10 years ago it was 50/50% Visa/Mastercard on the Russian market. Today it is like 30/30/30 Mir/Visa/MC (Mir is the national payment system). And even those 60% are not "real" Visa/MC, since they are being processed through a centralized platform, owned by the Russian Central Bank. For example, it helped to save all the cards in working condition when Visa/MC exited Russia
- orbital-decay 4y agoMir is a poor example. Government simply started to issue the paychecks through Mir, and this was a big deal in a country where government owns a huge share of the entire economy.
- theknocker 4y ago[dead]
- pmg1991 4y agoIt is already broken in India by RuPay