35 ms·
Chernobyl power plant captured by Russian forces
- throwoutway 5y agoIt is worth remembering that the Chernobyl sarcophagus was paid for by the EU. Not sure if that makes it EU property though
- gjsman-1000 5y agoWell, Russia will appreciate the gift. "Thanks for cleaning up the mess for us before we invaded."
- mtmail 5y agoLet by G7 but many other countries contributed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chernobyl_Shelter_Fund https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chernobyl_Shelter_Fund https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chernobyl_New_Safe_Confinement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chernobyl_New_Safe_Confinement
- docdeek 5y agoNot an expert but I would doubt it. Most every part of the EU has signs at testing to the fact that X (a road, a bridge, a building) was paid for by EU funds.
- tekno45 5y agonot a lot of people to look at signs in the literal middle of a nuclear exclusion zone.
- adamredwoods 5y agoIf it protects EU, then the EU has a stake in it: >> Russia wants to control the Chernobyl nuclear reactor to signal NATO not to interfere militarily, the same source said.
- thesaintlives 5y agoYes! Well worth remembering. Get your best pen out and write a complaint letter to President Putin. For sure it will stop the invasion dead in its tracks. Genius!
- agilob 5y agoEU also paid to build a city in what used to be Palestine, and before anyone moved in Israel demolished it all. No one even talked about it for more than a day > 319 Palestinian owned structures were demolished or seized, and 447 people (including 222 children) were displaced. Of the structures targeted in the six-month reporting period, 62 structures were funded by the EU or EU Member States with a value of nearly EUR 391,406. https://eeas.europa.eu/sites/default/files/20200528_final_six-month_report_on_demolitions_jul-dec_2019.pdf https://eeas.europa.eu/sites/default/files/20200528_final_si...
- rhn_mk1 5y agoWhat city? Can you post sources?
- agilob 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israeli_demolition_of_Palestinian_property https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israeli_demolition_of_Palestin... https://eeas.europa.eu/sites/default/files/20200528_final_six-month_report_on_demolitions_jul-dec_2019.pdf https://eeas.europa.eu/sites/default/files/20200528_final_si...
- jsiaajdsdaa 5y ago
- yabones 5y agoDo you really understand the implications of that statement?
- moffkalast 5y agoWe had a good run. Time for some small reptiles to try their hand at civilization next.
- Miner49er 5y agoMaybe OP is a Posadist.
- jazzyjackson 5y agoThanks for the rabbithole history lesson, reminds me of Bannon's "deconstruct the state" angle, an optimism that somehow things can improve after everything is destroyed...
- SyzygistSix 5y agoOr a dolphin. Or both.
- ascii_pasta 5y agoIt seem like maybe Ukraine should have kept theirs...
- hi41 5y agoMost documentaries I saw said that the Chernobyl plant is totally destroyed. So why capture it?
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoThe other reactors in the plant were operational until 2000. It's not about the plant though, it's about the city and the path to Kiev that it frees up.
- stickfigure 5y agoIs there any strategic significance to this? I thought it was closed?
- madaxe_again 5y agoTwo strategic points off the top of my head: One, the railhead. Afaik it’s operational and modern, as they used it for moving material for constructing the sarcophagus. Goes straight to Kiev. Makes for easy onwards transport of materiel from Belarus. Two, a gun to the head of Europe. They could threaten to destroy the containment, and/or to bomb the reactor building to aerosolise as much radioactive material as possible.
- asdff 5y agoWhy blow up a dirty bomb when they have 1000 real bombs?
- AitchEmArsey 5y agoNuking someone is a definitive, MAD-triggering event. Causing a radiological disaster "accidentally" would be entirely consistent with the "stop hitting yourself" diplomacy Russia has undertaken since moving against Ukraine in 2014.
- dathinab 5y agoAdditionally to what was already said in other threads about this: Why wast money?
- asdff 5y agoWhy do you care about saving money when you are planning on ending the world in the next hour?
- newuser94303 5y agoThey won't blow up Chernobyl. Ukraine is a top grain exporting nation. Without wheat, Ukraine's economy would be even worse and there would be no way to feed the people.
- hwers 5y agoI can't really tell what's going on here. Is the EU and America supposed to be helping out but it's all promises without real counter attacks? Is this just the calm before the storm as russia places their troops in the right spots while everyone looks on? Anyone who's smarter than me who could enlighten me?
- anigbrowl 5y agoBasically if EU/US forces engage Russians directly it's ww3. I think that's going to happen anyway, but mismatches in tempo are common and rational in the early stages of a conflict.
- Johnny555 5y agoThe EU and USA can't attack Russian troops directly without escalating the war far more than anyone wants. No one wants to provoke a nuclear nation, not even another nuclear nation. As long as Putin doesn't try to advance out of Ukraine, I doubt that NATO will offer any direct support beyond supplying arms and training.
- ethbr0 5y agoThere was a missed opportunity to seriously prevent war. NATO should have been requested to by Ukraine and declared a no fly zone for military aviation west of the Dnieper, before Russia invaded. An inability to use aviation would have severely slowed Russian plans.
- Johnny555 5y agoI really doubt that NATO would be willing to enforce this no-fly zone in a non-NATO nation, that would mean being willing to shoot down Russian military aircraft, which would surely escalate the war.
- ethbr0 5y agoNeither Iraq (1991+) nor Bosnia and Herzegovina (1993+) were NATO members, and it served its purpose there. And hence declaring it before Russia invaded. Which forces Russia to choose to shoot down NATO aircraft, or operate outside those zones.
- jl6 5y agoI guess this indicates that Russia intends to completely subdue Ukraine and back it into a corner. In such a scenario, a desperate Ukraine government could wield the plant as leverage by threatening some catastrophe. By removing it from their hands, Ukraine is denied this weapon of last resort. And Russia gains another weapon of last resort, should anyone think of putting them in the same position.
- BurningFrog 5y agoI fail to imagine how the reactor could practically be used as a weapon.
- injb 5y agoI think this is mainly a psychological move. It has people talking about nuclear fallout, radiation etc. That's the point.
- moffkalast 5y agoIt does pose the question what would actually happen should someone bomb the sarcophagus.
- rocqua 5y agoUnless the prevailing winds are really blowing towards the west, this would harm Russia and their newly conquered territory much more than it would harm the EU. It makes more sense as a bargaining chip with Ukraine than as a chip with the EU.
- Lammy 5y agoThe most interesting part of Chernobyl to me isn't even the power plant, but what it was powering: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duga_radar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duga_radar
- qbasic_forever 5y agoYeah the site is a massive liability for whoever controls it. There's a ton of work left to do to fully decommission it and make it safe.
- outside1234 5y agoHey, good news people, Switzerland is going to remain neutral and keep taking Russian money. And Germany doesn't want to stop Swift because they need sweet sweet natural gas from Russia
- jjtheblunt 5y agois there a citation for what you wrote? I thought I read the exact opposite of both your sentences some hours ago. perhaps things changed again?
- sbmthakur 5y agohttps://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/feb/24/kyiv-furious-as-eu-wavers-on-banning-russia-from-swift-payment-system https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/feb/24/kyiv-furious-a...
- sjsvsnd 5y ago
- notjustanymike 5y ago
- lend000 5y agoIt's hard to view the events unfolding with an objective gaze. Virtually all of western journalism condemns Russia's attacks unilaterally, which seems reasonable, considering people are dying to grow a dictator's empire. But then I read about the history of the conflict and see that Ukraine has had separatist states and civil war for years. It isn't like Ukraine is a stable, peaceful, and unwitting nation, like, say, Denmark. It's more similar to NATO "protecting" their national interests in Syria or Iraq. Not that I supported those interventions as ethical, either -- I just acknowledge the potential long term geopolitical motivations for doing so. Any Ukrainians or Russians have an alternative perspective to offer?
- dostick 5y agoDont project “separatist” feudal states of 100s year ago on to modern Ukraine. Modern Ukraine is nothing like that.
- crisdux 5y agoThis isn't a Ukrainian or Russian perspective, but an alternative perspective. John Mearsheimer gives a popular alternative perspective. He has a realist foreign policy perspective suggesting that the US and the west provoked Russia by trying to push Ukraine to join NATO and by intervening in the protests/coup in 2013/2014. Russia has a legitimate security interest in ensuring Ukraine does not join NATO and become militarized. https://www.mearsheimer.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/Why-the-Ukraine-Crisis-Is.pdf https://www.mearsheimer.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/Why-t...
- hamburga 5y agoVideo lecture from Mearsheimer, for the lazy: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JrMiSQAGOS4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JrMiSQAGOS4
- SyzygistSix 5y agoThank you for a written source. I much prefer it to a video lecture.
- msla 5y ago
- charliea0 5y agoThe Russian forces seem to be trying to encircle or assault Kyiv. I think they've taken the nuclear plant because it is a defensible point along their shortest line of advance. They wouldn't want to move past it without controlling the site.
- nine_k 5y agoAlso, either side would be pretty reluctant to bomb it, or otherwise battle too hard close to it. It's a great position to hold if you can.
- hutzlibu 5y ago"It's a great position to hold if you can." It is a great position to hold and fight in, because the area is pretty empty of civilians. And russia must avoid ukranian (russian in their eyes) civilian casualties, to not loose the little popular support they have for this war. And neither side will be so stupid to directly bomb the remains of the reactor, but I think it would need a serious direct bombing, for radiation to leak out. I don't think there can be still a major uncontrolled chain reaction. The worst that can happen under normal circumstances, is radiation leaking out. (but all this is from the back of my head knowledge, about documentaries about chernobyl, I might be wrong)
- bayesian_horse 5y agoThe issue is not about bombing or not bombing it, also the area is worthless from a strategic point of view. It's just that somebody has to be in control of it, and the Russians can't or don't want to depend on Ukrainian forces to do that right now.
- celticninja 5y agoI don't think Putin is worried about loss of life of Ukrainian citizens. He is worried about losing soldiers, or more importantly dead soldiers being repatriated on the news. They will cover up civilian casualties or blame them on Ukrainian troops. The only support for this will come from Russia domestically and it is that which he seeks to maintain with this war. Which I'm guessing he hoped would be quick and decisive, avoiding the bloodshed of Russian soldiers that will be his undoing at home.
- carabiner 5y agoCan we skip to the good part? Ahhh, ahh ah ah.
- GabrielMtn 5y agoMaybe tiktok or Instagram would be a better place for this comment.
- w0de0 5y agoThis development is a tactical prerequisite for besieging or attacking Kyiv. The exclusion zone covers the shortest route to the city from Belarus - the shortest route available to Russian forces. It’s also perhaps a strategic coup for Russia in two ways - but it could also be a boon to Ukraine. The coming days will elucidate which party most profits - probably Russia. Russia’s first strategic gain is simply one of properly executed rapid maneuver armored warfare. They now hold a redoubt that is difficult to safely attack, threatens Kyiv and the entire Dnipro plain, and preemptively protects their politically weakest supply line, Belarus. Russia’s second potential strategic boon here is more modern - they have seized an infowar high ground. The Financial Times this morning quotes an anonymous Russian security official claiming Chernobyl’s occupation creates a potent psychological deterrent against both strategic escalation and subtle tactical interference from the West. The disaster of 86 looms large in the minds of European polities, especially the Nordics. Placing the radioactive zone in the battle space may chill European feet. And in American minds, Chernobyl is unavoidably associated with the USSR and memories of a more dangerous iteration of Russia. (I expect many on this side of the Atlantic think the plant is in Russia.) Occupying it elevates the danger and the power associated with Russia nearer to Cold War levels of respect, which is a fundamental goal of Putin’s revanchism. However, in the Slavic societies of post-Soviet eastern Europe - including Russians themselves - Chernobyl connotes the corruption and failure of the USSR. Gorbachev himself blamed the Union’s destruction entirely on the loss of scientific and nuclear prestige, and national confidence, engendered by the disaster. So Russia risks reminding all their former satellite peoples of the last empire’s outcome. Ukraine’s morale and propaganda may turn the loss into a victory - especially if the Nordics polities, and German citizenry, favor outrage over trepidation. In this pursuit, Zelensky spoke several hours ago with Sweden’s PM about specifically the Chernobyl battle - and Ukraine’s FM called it an “attack on Europe.” I hope desperately that Ukraine gains greater European unity, and Russia gets further opprobrium among those Europeans who yet still take an understanding view of Putin’s new imperialism. But I suspect the affair will on the whole benefit Russia. All else aside, it’s clear they are fighting a conventional ground war. They need the hard tactical advantage of occupying this particular 1,000 square miles to win; even if they lose the information battle they have advanced their cause.
- marvin 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- paulus_magnus2 5y agoWe in the The West have some serious soul searching to do. A nuclear power has attacked a sovereign state and told us to stay away or something very bad will happen. They've been sabre rattling for weeks and weeks and we have frozen unable (or unwilling) to act. No good deed goes unpunished, every sanction has a cost etc etc but we're not ready to pay even a smallest price in order to save lives protect world peace. Or to save "western values" our leaders are wording at each opportunity. If we really wanted to stop the invasion we'd send half a million soldiers to "hang around" in Ukraine weeks ago. Or at least we'd send them thousands of anti helicopter and antitank missiles. We cannot prevent Russia's bombing and destruction of Ukraine but the missiles would easily stop an invasion. Russia is a country with extremely concentrated wealth and therefore power - the oligarchs are one of the few leverage points we have. If we temporarily froze (right now confisction would be more appropriate) assets owned by oligarchs in the west, deplatform them from payment systems, credit cards, universities, golden visas. Capture their yahts, jets they'd take care of Putin rather quickly. We know who they are, they're on the Forbes list posing for pictures. Somehow we in the west eagerly go after the weak (Ottawa protesters) but cannot seam to do the same towards rich (with power and means to corrupt). The rules based Western world has gone out of the window and we're quickly heading towards a world with two sets of rules (or rather two standards of rule enforcement).
- rhexs 5y agoGo send your own children to die first.
- w0de0 5y agoI agree our nations have done less than everything that could be done. I do think we've done quite better than could have been hoped around 2016. I believe your moral certainty is quite flawed: 1. It rests entirely on hindsight. These events only started seeming inevitable about 24 hours ago. Now we've found them to be true, we trust and are even impressed by the Americans' warnings. But these last weeks I little doubt the Bundestag's halls, and European couches everywhere, heard many recollections of Iraq's supposed WMD program. 2. You advocate a purely moral policy. There's a quiet part in every happy Westerner's mind that believes, without examination, in the ultimate and inevitable triumph of good over evil. To be fair, the past few generations experienced reassuring evidence for this assumption - and Hollywood keeps the reassurance alive. Unfortunately, the good guys do not always win; moral will cannot overcome geopolitical reality. Neither Realpolitik nor MAD were made defunct by 20 years of Pax Americana. History may have had a near-death experience, but she's apparently now quite recovered. Ukraine is Russia's neighbor. Ukraine is very much Russia's family: brothers who long cohabited. Ukraine's attitude towards Russia is legitimately a vital interest of Russia. Russia has, by right of force (Realpolitik!), complete dominance to act in Ukraine. Deterrence was always the only realistic option. 500,000 Western soldiers <500m from Moscow would be both target for, and, perhaps, sufficient justification in Russians citizens' eyes for the use of, tactical nukes. 3. It is unrealistic about how democracies work. Only the aggression your proposed policy is meant to prevent would be sufficient to convince democracies to implement it: an unfortunate catch-22. Democracies are extremely reluctant to go to war, which is good. The price paid is inevitably foolishness in global power politics. Roosevelt could not have started a pre-emptive war with Japan, though perhaps this would have been the optimal move. Similarly, there is no chance that, in the context of 20 years of unbroken peace, any Nato member would be interested in such a massive deployment directly next to Moscow. No scenario would have allowed this risk. If it did somehow happen, Russia's aggressive response could easily divide the alliance in recrimination for implementing such a reckless policy.
- BTCOG 5y agoWestern sanctions will do absolutely nothing but push Putin further into considering invading other neighboring nations. He's going to reform the Soviet Union. The president in Nicaragua has reportedly told able-bodied 18-45 year old men to prepare to support the Russian Federation in freeing people in Ukraine. This is going to spiral out of control, and talking will do nothing.
- g45ylkjlk45y 5y ago
- g45ylkjlk45y 5y ago
- seattle_spring 5y agoThe next iteration of S.T.A.L.K.E R. is going to be nuts.
- hamburga 5y agoIf you're looking for some background on the big picture and strategic goals of Russia and NATO/US, I just watched this (from U Chicago political scientist John Meirsheimer) and found it to be extremely helpful: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JrMiSQAGOS4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JrMiSQAGOS4
- ejb999 5y agoProbably not a bad idea to put all your troops and equipment stockpiles near an area that just about everyone is going to be reluctant to bomb indiscriminately - nobody wants to accidentally destroy that shell protecting that nuclear power plant I would imagine.
- swyx 5y agois this the same plant as the one from 1986? this plant is still active today? im very surprised.
- curtisblaine 5y agoNot active, but actively contained.
- rob74 5y agoactive as in radio-active...
- officeplant 5y agoThe other three reactors there were operational until 2000.
- kabdib 5y agoLooks like they removed the fuel in 2013. That's good. Huh, how often have nuclear reactors been in a theatre of war? Is this the first time?
- dredmorbius 5y agoNo, not the first. Israel bombed an Iraqi nuclear power plant in 1981. The plant had been completed but had not yet been fueled or gone critical (active). http://news.bbc.co.uk/onthisday/hi/dates/stories/june/7/newsid_3014000/3014623.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/onthisday/hi/dates/stories/june/7/news...
- Bud 5y agoUnclear to me why Reuters articles seem officially blessed on HN in the face of superior reporting from NYT or WaPo, etc. I guess the original reason for preferring Reuters or AP was, avoiding a paywall, but now of course, Reuters has a paywall. So I would opine that the traditional flagging/downvoting of NYT links for this kind of story, in favor of Reuters, should cease.
- azeirah 5y agoReuters at the very least is not American, it's international, I do believe that makes it more neutral than NYT and Washington Post. Also, there are local news sites such as kyivindependent.com, no paywalls of course.
- dudeinhawaii 5y agoI'm genuinely curious at what point a bully threatening you with MAD can be stopped if you value the existence of your own civilization? Say Russian conquers all of Ukraine and moves troops to the Polish border and parks some tanks a bit inside. What then? Strongly worded essays? If Russia isn't raining hell on Poland, then NATO is forced to .. apply sanctions, make threats, but take no action since the escalation and outcome, MAD, is not an acceptable trade for a tank crossing your border. Repeat until arrival at French coastline. The terrorist steps forward waving a trigger to a bomb and either you show him your bomb and threaten to blow yourselves both up, or you step back. At some point, the only option is to call the bluff and give him a good punch and hope that he values life as much as you and won't actually detonate. It has to be a solid one but not so hard as to make him think you might kill him, as that would make the detonation a certainty. I don't know that NATO has the guts to give Putin that bloody nose.
- nojokes 5y agoIf you value the existence of your own civilization then the only winning strategy to answer to a nuclear threat is counter threat with MAD. You have to be willing to go to the end with this. You really have to be willing to destroy yourself to destroy the one that is threatening you. There is no way around this or you loose everything.
- munk-a 5y agoI think that's a good point but I also think it's important to remember that war suuucks. A citizen in Ukraine right now is not having a good day, there have been arbitrary arrests and some fighting in the streets... but if other military powers got involved they'd be having an even worse day with mass destruction of property and loss of life. Escalating a conflict to using deadly force can be a necessary step to prevent tyrannical dictators, but it often has very steep short term costs to everyone innocent stuck in the middle. I personally am in favor of intervention at this point, but it isn't something to be considered lightly.
- Hokusai 5y agoThat happened in the Spanish civil war. Guernica famous painting depicts the bombing by Italian and German aviation of the city of Guernica. The United Kingdom didn't wanted to be part of it, thou. Ironically, I think that more countries intervention would have make the Spanish war bloodier but it could have stopped World War II.
- dillondoyle 5y agoI'm very skeptical of the following question, but I found from a reputable reporter on Twitter, and seems like at least not an obvious fake website. But I don't see how this can be true... Anyone smarter than me care to alleviate the following concerns: Increased radiation. On this map some of the levels go from ~750 nsv/h to 10,200. one at the center went from 2,000 to 65,000 in the last day. seems crazy and inconceivable? https://www.saveecobot.com/en/radiation-maps#10/51.3619/30.1183/gamma/comp+cams+fire https://www.saveecobot.com/en/radiation-maps#10/51.3619/30.1...
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoNo, that actually seems extremely plausible. Thanks for posting actual numbers and units! Look at the units. That's NANOsieverts. So the old radiation level was ~2x of what https://xkcd.com/radiation/ https://xkcd.com/radiation/ lists as the normal background level. Which m akes sense, because most of Chernobyl really isn't that bad nowadays. The new level is 65 microsieverts per hour. That's notable, but not some huge release of radiation, and it would still take days for you to hit the (annual) occupational hazard limit. The most plausible explanation, in my opinion, is that all the traffic kicked up a lot of contaminated dust. (Which is one of the reasons why you don't want to live there despite the "safe" radiation levels. The radiation level is only safe-ish as long as you don't breathe the dust.)
- dillondoyle 5y agoI just read that exact reason; Lots of tanks and movement kicking up top soil. Scary situation all around even if radiation is like 999 on a list of 1000 top concerns.
- calsy 5y ago-
- unclebucknasty 5y agoFirst, it's the West and its media that are clamoring for war, while Russia has no intention of invading. Now that Russia has invaded, the problem is that the media has a simplistic narrative of good guys and bad guys. Striking how much Russian propaganda has made its way onto HN.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- w0de0 5y agoRussian propaganda of the past ~decade has become extremely skilled at sounding reasonable to contrarian thinkers, and at fitting in to the broader Western zeitgeist. RT, less official media - perhaps the FSB itself - now cultivate native intellectuals (hard not to scare-quote that...) with opinions variously: genuinely pro-Putin, generally anti-liberal-world-order, chaotically damaging to the US polity in their demagoguery, or simply convenient for Russia's current goals. Folks like Tucker Carlson and Rep. Steve King. I mention this because I suspect most of your and mine (I see this too) encounters with Putin's latest obsequious bullshit on American internet fora are not actual progandists, or even consciously anti-democratic folks. They are simply ideological fellow travellers, perhaps devotees of one of Russia's special friends. In any case, I find this more likely than a secret American underground of RIA Novosti fans, or a vast human farm of cheap enough, yet still impeccably Englished, trolls.
- unclebucknasty 5y ago>Russian propaganda of the past ~decade has become extremely skilled at sounding reasonable to contrarian thinkers, and at fitting in to the broader Western zeitgeist. RT, less official media - perhaps the FSB itself - now cultivate native intellectuals To some extent it has, but seems to be targeted to a very specific profile. >In any case, I find this more likely than a secret American underground of RIA Novosti fans, or a vast human farm of cheap enough, yet still impeccably Englished, trolls. Not sure how these came to be the choices. I have undoubtedly seen multiple accounts parroting propaganda in lock-step on HN. And, I'm sure you'd acknowledge the pervasive trollbots/farms propagandizing Twitter and the like. So, it seems you're making an argument around the quality of the propagandizing as it relates to the likelihood of its source? Something like: poorly executed propaganda == actual propagandists well-executed propaganda == organic It's a bit of an oddly narrow argument but, that aside, it wouldn't surprise me in the least if HN was seen as a high-value target, worthy of more focused and higher quality propaganda efforts. In fact, there are several factors that make high-quality, lower-volume propaganda efforts worthwhile here. So, not sure why anyone would believe HN would be immune to "actual propagandists". Seems the opposite actually.
- nelblu 5y agoThis war makes me sick and very sad. It reminds me of the pale blue dot quote by Sagan : "Think of the rivers of blood spilled by all those generals and emperors so that, in glory and triumph, they could become the momentary masters of a fraction of a dot.". https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=wupToqz1e2g https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=wupToqz1e2g
- queuebert 5y agoI feel like humanity has gotten nowhere in my lifetime. I grew up watching Star Trek and was very optimistic about the future, but that has been dashed.
- MathMonkeyMan 5y agoWe have yet to discover intelligent life as we know it, or something like warp drive (which probably doesn't exist). A lot of the futurist premise of Star Trek will not apply until humanity faces something like that.
- gpt5 5y agoHumanity has lived through one of its most peaceful period in your lifetime, even when including the current war in Ukraine (which is much smaller than other active conflicts).
- tim333 5y agoThe news tends to focus on the bad stuff and ignore the progress that is made. Like back in the 60s third world poverty was a big thing and they've become way richer now and also have smartphones not that dissimilar to Star Trek communicators. In fact better in some ways - you couldn't watch Tik Tok or catch Pokemon on a communicator.
- deutschewelle 5y ago
- matkoniecz 5y ago
- sydthrowaway 5y agoFuck pUTIN
- JabavuAdams 5y agoOne thing to remember in all of these assessments is that Russia has the GDP of Canada, with almost 5x the population. Okay, they have lots of nukes, but maintaining and securing those are very expensive. Russia in 2022 is not the USSR of the '80s. It is not the Germany of the late '30s. They cannot take and hold Ukraine with the forces they've deployed, against an ongoing insurgency. Putin cannot cross the border into a NATO member and hope to survive. He knows this.
- bjoli 5y agoNow, if we could get China to join in on the sanctions the Russian economy is fucked. It will of course never happen, since China is the one enabling this.
- TeeMassive 5y agoRussia has too few soldiers to occupy Ukraine and maintain the peace. They're taking the population hostage by controlling what it needs to survive.
- wanda 5y agoFor those of you who can't wrap your heads around why Putin is invading Ukraine, I invite you to recall the invasions of Afghanistan in 2001 and Iraq in 2003 by the US and its allies. While artfully justified to Western audiences at the time, they have both been subjected to intense criticism and questions of legitimacy since. In the case of Iraq, if I am not mistaken, the war was an operation to disarm a country of WMDs that it apparently didn't possess. In the case of Afghanistan, the invasion occurred because, again if I am not mistaken, the US was not extended an invitation to come into their country and retaliate against al-Quaeda, a military organisation responsible for the 9/11 terrorist attacks against the US. So the US was forced to invite themselves. While I'm not going to get into the criticisms of the US and its allies for these occurrences right now, I would just like to point out that Russia's invasion of Ukraine is not all that different — in fact, it's actually more fruitful for Putin than the West's military ventures. Putin stands to lose very little in this act. Anyone currently dealing with Russia already is unlikely to be deterred by this episode for long, regardless of the cost to human lives. How many stopped dealing with the US when citizens of Afghanistan and Iraq were being killed? Sanctions are also likely to do very little. As I understand it, Russia was already under some sanctions, what will a few more do? SWIFT access revocation has to be agreed by all members, and even if that happened, things like that are why cryptocurrencies didn't evaporate 12 years ago, but have instead (with a degree of volatility) flourished. In terms of credibility in his own country, I suspect Putin's entire career as his country's president has been characterised by his outspoken belief that the USSR lives on and that he wants Russia to assert itself and its strength. It is likely this narrative, combined with his tight state control, relationships with oligarchs, and exports of oil and gas to countries who don't really fancy digging it up for themselves, that has kept him in power and popular with sizeable proportion of the Russian people. Many of whom probably do yearn for a return to the halcyon days. So invading a post-Soviet state with a good deal of embedded Russian culture probably only strengthens him in the view of his supporters, and his critics he can just arrest as debauched youths and traitors, I suppose. My point is that he will likely face little effective opposition to a literal land-grab on the home front. So what about aid coming to Ukraine from the West? Well, I've read a lot of people saying Putin is insane and irrational and could just hit the nuke button any time and his Western peers wouldn't have the stomach to do the same — for someone who wanted to face as little opposition as possible, that's pretty much the perfect impression to give off. And all it takes is a psychotic-sounding speech or two that Western media outlets — who were in dire need of a new attention-gripping story to maximise ad revenue now that the pandemic's not interesting — can whip into a firestorm with nuclear weapon mentions, Hitler comparisons, military strength assessments... Provided that you don't mind blowing up Ukrainian civilians — and I'm guessing Putin probably doesn't lose much sleep over it, much like Bush and Blair probably didn't think too much about Basra's residents — then this move gets you: + Ukraine, its infrastructure, its commodities, etc. + media exposure to flex your muscles to domestic and foreign audiences, consolidating your home political position, expanding your influence abroad, and cementing your legacy for years to come + a war with the odds firmly in your favour to train your military and test your weapons + a chance to antagonise already weak relations between the West and China + a chance to improve your own relations with China who'd love to have a relatively-ignored precedent upon which to rationalise a brief holiday to Taiwan + confirmation that no one in the West will fight you when you decide you look at the next non-NATO land-grab - Boris Johnson will use the opportunity to pretend he's Winston Churchill... call for SWIFT revocation that he knows will never happen... in order to pull himself out of his own hot mess - Joe Biden will babble on TV about something that is supposed to disguise the fact that he will never engage Russia in open war - the EU will have a meeting - NATO will have a meeting - a few bored professionals will insult you on the internet So, I suspect Putin probably did think the situation over, figured that if Ukraine joined NATO it would become impractical to attack, kind of a "now or never" moment for a leader who doesn't want to lose face entering what may be his last decade of his premiership before he decides to retire somewhere and write a best-selling guide to dealing with an alliance of 30 countries. Don't get me wrong, what Putin is doing is of course horrific and my heart goes out to the Ukrainian people. I honestly didn't think he would do it, but I see why he has invaded — because he has dared to do it, people will believe he'd do anything now, and he can do whatever he wants. Maybe he'll try a small ex-Soviet NATO country next. I wonder if anyone will pipe up then. I just felt the need to express how I am seeing these events unfold, because I believe that there is very little understanding of this situation in the West (as a British person, perhaps I am also guilty of this, but if so, I hope to be corrected so I may learn) and I think that's probably half the reason why no one is actually doing anything other than stopping trade with a nation that is probably quite capable of weathering a bit of economic turbulence.
- id02009 5y agoIsn't it the shortest path from Belarus to Kiev though Chernobyl? Is that really any other message than: they will approach Kiev or even try to capture it?
- ck2 5y agoThis is far more chilling to me https://imgur.com/6BeH4md https://imgur.com/6BeH4md "Estimate of areas of Ukraine captured by Russia since fighting began this morning" If this "works" that well for him, why stop at Ukraine?
- sakopov 5y agoRussia never ceases to amaze me even after spending half of my life living there. Its massive territory extends over 8 times zones stretching over 2 continents and it has historically been incapable of governing most of it. Everything outside of Moscow and Saint Petersburg (and a few other bigger cities) is often neglected and in constant state of poverty. Geopolitical stuff aside, this incessant need to have more land and more control when you can't even deal with the shit you already have is just baffling.
- deutschewelle 5y agoTheir whole concept of centralized governance is based on snitching and secret police since the Tsar days. The US is also a massive chunk of land with heavily armed populace, how does it deal with state wide enforcement? They both utilize a three letter agency that stands ready to infiltrate, assassinate, demoralize, discredit and reward snitches. It appears that violence seems to be the root of all power, and power has positive correlation with access to secrecy. The more secret and violent you are, the more you are feared. Fear of violence and the unknown amplify the need for careful self-regulating behaviors amongst the sentient group competing for scarce goods.
- 0xy 5y agoPoverty has declined by more than 50% in the last 20 years in Russia. How does this jive with a "constant state of poverty"? When people use anecdotes like this despite the data, it often just looks to me like bashing of developing economies.
- thecleaner 5y agoSure. Where are you stats coming from. ?
- pastacacioepepe 5y agoWorld bank is enough for you? The poverty headcount ratio for Russia went from 24.6% in 2002 to 10.7% in 2012, so it's actually a decrease of more than 50% in less than 20 years, even more than what stated by OP above. https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SI.POV.DDAY?end=2015&locations=1W-US-RU-CN&start=1989&view=chart https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SI.POV.DDAY?end=2015&lo...
- _zugs 5y ago[dead]
- DrJaws 5y agothis is important to the war, everybody knows that those who control the mutant faction, will win the war
- scaramanga 5y agoGee, as a Brit, I'm sure glad we didn't elect any of those anti-nuclear nutbags into office as we've been watching this situation unfold with grim concern for the last 30 years as every opportunity we've had to deal with these issues has been not just ignored but dismissed by our leaders with utter contempt /s
- jonyt 5y agoI think the commenters here relying on a more robust response if Putin invades a NATO country are being overly optimistic. Let's be honest with ourselves and recognize that without the US NATO is no match for Russia. Fragmented, with small and outdated armed forces, the Russian army would quickly roll over any resistance. Can you imagine a Republican president committing US troops to the defence of Lithuania in the current climate? Just look at what Trump is saying right now. If I were a European leader I'd be investing very heavily in an my armed forces right about now. Putin has succeeded in undermining the international order. First, by getting someone like Trump elected and undercutting faith in NATO. Second, by invading neighboring countries and having everyone realize this has no real consequences. It's likely that, unfortunately, the new world order is the old world order. Either a country has the power to defend itself or it doesn't. Other countries can't be relied upon to help.
- kaba0 5y agoFrance and Turkey has quite the army just by themselves and they are both NATO members. I wouldn’t be as pessimistic.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hutrdvnj 5y agoThe US has thousands of troops in Europe (NATO states). What do you think is going to happen if russia open fire at them. Biden made it very clear already, WW3 is the answer, but you suggest a republican president would just sit there tolerate deaths of US soldiers and talk about financial sanctions?
- kobalsky 5y ago> Putin has succeeded in undermining the international order. First, by getting someone like Trump elected do you think can he hand pick the next US president or just sway the election towards one party?
- nirui 5y agoDo Russian military knows how to safely operate the remaining functional reactors in the power plant? If Chernobyl episode 2 is just a wrong button away, the entire EU is in danger.
- zxienin 5y agoWhat’s the point and significance of capturing Chernobyl?
- KingKaram 5y ago