24 ms·
A quick breakdown of what SWIFT is and why it matters
- dopa42365 5y agoIs there some sort of "tweet-chain combiner" extension? Can't think of a worse format to share a few sentences of text.
- js2 5y agohttps://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1496861068945154056.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1496861068945154056.html
- tosh 5y agoFor reading: https://threadreaderapp.com/ https://threadreaderapp.com/ For authoring: https://threadstart.io/ https://threadstart.io/ but I’m sure there are more
- dang 5y ago"Please don't complain about tangential annoyances—things like article or website formats, name collisions, or back-button breakage. They're too common to be interesting." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- easton 5y agohttps://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1496861068945154056.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1496861068945154056.html
- tpoacher 5y agothank you
- jdrc 5y agobitcoin is going to be tricky. unless most miners are in russia they can be convinced to fork chains
- gruez 5y ago1. Russia has been building up gold reserves, not crypo reserves 2. It's actually much harder than convincing 51% of miners that Russia is bad. You'll need to get them to agree on a list of addresses to freeze/sanction. Given that bitcoin addresses are pseudonymous, I'd imagine on agreeing on such a list would be politically impossible. Not to mention, how such action would affect trust in the network and the value of bitcoin
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- decremental 5y agoI doubt the majority of bitcoin miners live in places that care about the western neoliberal agenda.
- Ekaros 5y agoI doubt they much care about neoliberal agenda in first place. It is all about profit. Or being outside that system.
- astoor 5y agoThere's plenty of services which map Bitcoin addresses to real-world entities, e.g. Chainalysis Reactor, so coming up with a list of addresses to freeze/sanction would be the easy part.
- gruez 5y ago>coming up with a list of addresses to freeze/sanction would be the easy part. Coming up with a list of suspects is easy, convincing others that they're totally guilty is the hard part. I doubt miners would want a company like Chainalysis to be judge, jury and executioner of the bitcoin network.
- kache_ 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_signature https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_signature There are protocols that work around address banning
- gruez 5y ago>Russia has also been building an in-house system since 2014—the last time SWIFT cutoff was threatened—which may mean they are able to temper some of the impact a cutoff would have on its economy. If they're building a replacement, doesn't that also mean we should use "cut off SWIFT" now, rather than later when it'll be ineffective?
- Thaxll 5y agoReplacement that other country don't use so I'm not sure exactly what it would be used for, just connecting to China maybe?
- elliekelly 5y agoSWIFT is kind of like Facebook. It has the benefit of “everyone” already using it. So even if you make your own Facebook it won’t have the same functionality as Facebook and it’s very unlikely everyone from Facebook will be motivated enough to make an account on your platform, too.
- xenocratus 5y agoI'm way too far away from power on anything like this so I might be terribly wrong, but I imagine that cutting off SWIFT might convince other countries doing bad things to consider adhering to Russia's system, if they see the West willing to cut them off as well. You then get fragmentation and SWIFT losing some of its "soft power".
- baybal2 5y agoRussia already uses multiple alternative settlement systems with China, Iran, and few other buddies like Norko, and Belarus. > You then get fragmentation and SWIFT losing some of its "soft power". This already lost any power it had in 2014, because the threat of disconnection was wasted. An honestly, EU lost its face now to talk "soft power." Every foreign head of state going to meet EU bureaucrats will now look at them, and think "can I rely on these people who threw out every treaty for a want of sleeping without a blanket?"
- 5y ago
- 45lkjl45yk 5y ago
- exogeny 5y ago
- l4yj3lkzf 5y ago[dead]
- User23 5y agoInterestingly SWIFT was used to effectively depose a Head of State already, specifically Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI. The Vatican's Bank was banned from the system and allowed back on after Benedict's resignation. The lesson was not lost on Russia or China and they have been building an alternative system called BRICS. Edit: Here's a contemporary source[1] from a "reputable" newspaper. It doesn't mention SWIFT by name but that's what it was. There were other "reputable" sources covering the story more explicitly back in 2013 as well, but web search's extreme recency bias leaves me unable to find them. Perhaps visit your local university library and they can help you search the periodicals. [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/pope-struggled-to-lift-sacred-secrecy-of-vatican-finances/2013/02/15/a1620d06-7760-11e2-b102-948929030e64_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/europe/pope-struggled-t...
- mschuster91 5y agoThe only reference I could find about that is an obscure Italian blog with the comment section filled with absurd conspiracy theories. Do you have some credible sources?
- mohanmcgeek 5y agoBRICS is not an alternative to SWIFT. Russia, India, China -- the RIC -- in BRICS are each working on/have their own SWIFT like system. There's a BRICS bank though.
- pmontra 5y agoMaybe this? https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-20903443 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-20903443
- mdiesel 5y agoThe timing would imply that Benedict XVI resigned (at least in part) due to the scandal involving blackmail of homosexual members of the church. The wiki page on the resignation doesn't go into that at all, but does link to the scandal in the "See Also" section. > On 17 December 2012, the Pope received a report on "Vatican lobbies" ... . The same day, the Pope reportedly decided to resign, a decision he made public in February 2013 It's possible that multiple factors added up to make the job too overwhelming for one man of his age, but the "vatileaks" scandal appears to be far more significant in coverage from what I can see.
- chiefalchemist 5y agoIDK. In an interconnected global economy my sanction of you hurts you, but it hurts me as well. For example, the higher price of oil is good for Russia and OPEC, but not the rest of us.So where is the pain? Certainly there are things that Russia has that the West needs. In addition, if Russians are generally used to less - and the West isn't - then again where is the pain? After two years of pandemic are most Americans up for this? Most importantly, how can this not influence the 2024 election? Finally, I listened to (most of) Biden's speech yesterday and I was stunned by the irony. Per invasion Putin was effectively saying "Russia can't trust The West. They're out to get us" and Biden follows that with "Lookout Vlad...we're gonna put a hurting on Russia." Doesn't this validate Putin's narrative? I understand...it's complicated. But it's also 2022, not 1952.
- mupuff1234 5y agoHigh price of oil is good for Russia only if they have buyers. And yes, in the short term it will hurt us but in the longer term you are disarming the influence of a bad actor with the added benefit of incentivizing cleaner energy and perhaps more efficient means of transportation.
- netsharc 5y agoSeems like China is fine with taking the oil. And China knows the world won't seriously sanction it...
- mupuff1234 5y agoYes, but then China can easily squeeze them on the price (being the single big buyer)
- chiefalchemist 5y agoTrue. But it's relative. Even if Russia get 75% of the market price, that's still a solid buck. And since they can control the chaos, they can manipulate price. So if everyone loses, not just Russia, and relatively The West has more to lose, where is the pain for Russia?
- ck2 5y agoWell that didn't age well https://archive.today/XqZzK https://archive.today/XqZzK > When Western nations threatened Russia’s access to Swift in 2014, Alexei Kudrin, a onetime finance minister close to President Vladimir Putin, estimated that it could reduce Russia’s gross domestic product by 5% in a year. Cutting Russia off from Swift could have ramifications for other nations as well, since Russia is a key energy supplier to Europe and countries rely on the Swift system to pay for fuel. Russian officials have repeatedly denied assertions that they intend to invade Ukraine.
- TekMol 5y agoI often wonder how money is stored. It can't be just a number on a computer in a bank, right? Otherwise some Russian bank could just increase that number to whatever they like. And say "Look, we own 100 Trillion USD. Now let's go shopping.". So I guess USD needs to be recognized by the US somehow? Could the US simply "void" all USD that are owned by Russia?
- dcolkitt 5y agoLet's just talk about USD specifically. (Other currencies work pretty similar, just with different central banks.) The "single source of truth" is the Federal Reserve. Member banks (about 10,000 US domestic banks) can hold reserves directly at the Fed. Any reserve bank can directly transfer Fed reserves to another member bank or to the US Treasury using FedWire. The Fed "creates money" simply by crediting a member bank's reserve. This is done in two ways, one is by paying interest on reserves. So if you're a member bank holding one million in reserves, the Fed simply bumps your balance up every night to reflect your interest payments. The other is by the Fed conducting "open market operations". When it wants to stimulate the economy by "providing liquidity" the NY Federal Reserve trading desk will buy treasury bonds and pay for them simply by crediting the balance of whichever member bank sold the bonds. Member banks themselves can "create money" in the form of demand deposits. If you have one million in your checking account at Chase bank, all you really have is a promise by Chase bank to give you or whoever you want to send money to one million dollars. Essentially money is created the same way the Fed creates money, your checking account is nothing more than a credit in Chase's database. However Chase's ability to create money is highly regulated and constrained. Banks have to conform to strict capital and leverage constraints. The OCC and other banking regulators will require that Chase hold enough assets in high enough quality to cover its deposit "liabilities". Some fraction of those assets will be dollars held as reserves at the Fed. Some will be bonds or loans, i.e. promises by other high-quality actors to pay dollars. Some of those assets could even be risky stocks, low quality bonds, commodities, etc. However the "risk-weighted" leverage ratio quickly scales up with risk. In exchange for this regulation, deposits held at Chase or other member banks are treated as equivalent to Federal reserve dollars. That's because if for some reason, Chase is unable to pay back its depositors when they demand their money back, the Federal Reserve will "create money" to meet the obligations. This is essentially why bank runs no longer exist in modern banking. Then there's the concept of "money markets", which is short-duration, high-quality assets that are essentially treated as "money-like". Often this tends to be short-term commercial paper from high-quality corporate issuers. A promise from Apple to pay $1.00 in 30 days is treated as "almost a dollar" by most of the market. In this sense, Apple can also "create money". But it's highly constrained, because it would quickly lose its credit rating or breach covenants in its longer-term bonds if it did so. Finally there's the concepts of "eurodollar deposits". These are dollar deposits held at non-American banks but denominated in dollars. For example you could hold $1 million dollars at Mitsubishi bank in Japan, and you have a claim against Mitsubishi to pay out dollars whenever you want. Mitsubishi is not an American bank, and therefore is not directly regulated or insured by the Federal reserve. In some sense this makes eurodollars slightly less safe than dollars held at domestic member banks. That being said Mitsubishi is regulated by Japanese banking regulations and implicitly insured by the BOJ (central bank of Japan). Mitsubishi will also make sure its dollar liabilities are never that large relative to its yen-assets. In the case of Mitsubishi failing, its highly likely the BOJ would bail them out by creating yen in the same way the Fed creates dollars. Some of that yen could be converted to dollars on the open FX market, and make the dollar depositors whole. Hence eurodollars are essentially just as safe as regular dollars as long as they're inside another high-quality banking system.
- eole666 5y agoGlad it's not about the Swift language
- sega_sai 5y agoAll these sanctions are a bit of the joke when you are dealing with an insane leader in a country without elections and sitting on top of a pile of reserves. And the west is not doing one thing that could actually actually make a difference -- cutting oil and gas export because the west thinks it'll be too expensive for the west. I feel these sanctions are still more of signalling, than actually doing something useful to help Ukraine.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> All these sanctions are a bit of the joke when you are dealing with an insane leader in a country without elections Russia has elections, but even having an unelected autocrat doesn't mean that governments are immune to popular opinion. Ask Louis XVI of France or, perhaps more relevantly here, Tsar Nicholas II of all the Russias.
- sega_sai 5y agoI know that technically they have elections (I'm a Russian living abroad), they just count in a 'special way' so they get the result they want. And yes I agree popular uprisings is a possibility. But in the case of Germany in 1930-1940s that didn't quite work.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- stickfigure 5y agoThat's because Hitler kept winning. He militarized the Rhineland in 1936, the allies did nothing. He took over Austria in 1938, the allies did nothing. He occupied Czechoslovakia later the same year, the allies did nothing. With every win, Hitler's popularity increased at home. He's reported to have been quite surprised when the allies finally declared war after Poland. We have a word for this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeasement https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeasement Neville Chamberlain negotiated with Hitler over handing Germany large swaths of Czech territory critical for border defense. The Czechs weren't invited to the conversation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peace_for_our_time https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peace_for_our_time We know how that turned out.
- hamilyon2 5y agoRussian citizens like me will be hit hardest, as usual. Large institutions and wealthy individuals will find another ways to transfer money. Costs of goods and services will rise.
- ex3ndr 5y agoYeah I just lost my business banking and can't anymore get payments from the states. But, most Russians support war, I don't care about them and ok with small inconvenience.
- hurflmurfl 5y agoI know this might be perceived as a flame-inviting response, but who are those "most Russians" that "support war". Even pretty patriotic people in my social circle don't support it. Now, of course, it might just be me and my circle, but the "majority supporting war" might also be someone's circle, and not really representative of reality. In any case, from what I see, most people are just afraid. Withdrawing cash, some stocking food. It's not like the west is watching a horror show, and the people in Russia are watching a comedy. Everyone's losing. I honestly don't know who's the winning party here. I don't really care much about the state of Russia, and maybe, just maybe the sanctions will have some positive effect; just wanted to say that "most Russians support war" is a very shabby argument in support of approving of punishing "most Russians".
- daenz 5y agoI was watching a mainstream news report (I'll try to find it and edit my comment) where the host and the guest were talking about the impact of economic sanctions. They said it's not intended to stop Russia, but to inflict pain on the citizens, so that they citizens will turn against leadership. In that moment, it really clicked for me how much normal people are pawns to be used in much larger games. And there apparently is no morality when dealing with pawns, unless it is convenient.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nimbius 5y agoquite a few commenters have pointed out SWIFT as a hand of soft power and i think its important to understand the twitter post doesnt mention an important fact: SWIFT was created in order that Europe may resist Kissingers increasingly capricious hand of soft power as it emerged as a lead sap in an increasingly arbitrary US foreign policy. 40 years ago the US had become effectively drunk on soft-power moves against states it perceived as even remotely objective to US interests. Is your president elect too socialist? you get an aircraft carrier floating in your strait for a year. did you nationalize your oil fields? sanctions mean you cant sell it to anyone. Cuba to this day still enjoys endless sanctions for resisting regime change. in 2022 sanctions are to international diplomacy as a tantrum is to a toddler. theyre effectively meaningless as most capable, observant countries have managed to sidestep in part or in whole the once dominant US hegemony of finance and trade. even the threat of a blue-water naval presence is an unspeakable taboo as Russia is one of a handful of emerging countries you wouldnt dare send an aircraft carrier to patrol, unless its goal was to secure the ocean floor. The only meaningful threat SWIFT offers is the ability to assuage short-term market fears among traders that dont fully understand just how inapplicable SWIFT is in this case.
- jorblumesea 5y ago> in 2022 sanctions are to international diplomacy as a tantrum is to a toddler. theyre effectively meaningless This is just straight up wrong. This is why the Magnitsky Act got Putin so rattled. It is also why Putin has said being cut off from swift is an act of war. If it's meaningless, why does Russia care so much?
- s_dev 5y agoNah -- Bill Browder seems to be a expert on this exact topic. He's saying to pull Russia from Swift. His experience suggests he is intimately familiar with the financial world and the consequences. He's the genesis of the Magnitsky Act -- the one thing that actually scares Putin. I know this because Putin even said if Russia was removed from Swift he would consider it an act of war. https://twitter.com/Billbrowder/status/1496799227082649603 https://twitter.com/Billbrowder/status/1496799227082649603
- setheron 5y agoHonest question: are sanctions that affect normal citizens OK if it's through SWIFT? In my mind that would cause the populace to be more frustrated with Putin for what he's done.
- kgeist 5y agoPutin will simply accuse the West of trying to make lives of Russians more miserable (technically it wasn't Putin who cut Russia from SWIFT) and many people will believe him, considering that thanks to fake news on state TV the majority believe the crisis was provoked by NATO. It won't work.
- mcguire 5y agoOn the other hand, it will damage the Russian economy, which will in turn damage the Russian ability to field military forces.
- pschastain 5y agoRelevant: https://www.economist.com/the-economist-explains/2022/02/25/why-the-west-is-reluctant-to-deny-russian-banks-access-to-swift https://www.economist.com/the-economist-explains/2022/02/25/...
- optimalsolver 5y agoHow many people complaining about the weaksauce sanctions proposed against Russia would be prepared to deal with the effects of more stringent measures? I'm thinking especially of people in Europe castigating politicians for not wanting to clamp down hard on the Russian energy sector. The way I see it, the europols are in a no-win situation. If they go easy on Russia and keep the gas and oil flowing, they look like weak and waffling appeasers, which yes, they are. If they cut off the Russian gas supply, will the people posting Ukrainian flags on Twitter remember or care about the noble root causes when faced with unprecedented energy prices? I.e. the politicians know their people better than they know themselves, and they're well aware that showing support on social media is one thing, but being asked to make drastic sacrifices is quite another. These politicians will not survive if they do what their voters are clamoring for them to do. Of course, they probably wouldn't be in this position if they hadn't taken energy strategy advice from Greta Thunberg, but that's neither here nor there.
- andrepd 5y ago> Of course, they probably wouldn't be in this position if they hadn't taken energy strategy advice from Greta Thunberg, but that's neither here nor there. What the fuck? I'm pretty positive that the energy strategy of major western powers was not radically revamped in two years on the advice of a teenager. If anything, they're in this position because they pursued an opposite strategy to what ecologists advocate: reduce dependency on fossil fuels including Russian natural gas, and invest massively in renewables + nuclear to bridge the gap.
- buu700 5y agoI think what they were referring to was Germany prematurely decommissioning nuclear plants only to start replacing them with coal and (more importantly) Nord Stream 2, which I never understood either. I can't comment on whether Greta Thunberg had anything to do with that, but I do see in a recent article that she appears to be anti-nuclear: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/dec/21/eu-in-row-over-inclusion-of-gas-and-nuclear-in-sustainability-guidance https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/dec/21/eu-in-row-over...
- whoomp12342 5y agothis guy doesnt use twitter like twitter
- thriftwy 5y ago
- I_am_tiberius 5y agoIf you are pro SWIFT exclusion of Russia, please like this tweet (or a similar one). https://twitter.com/IchBin_RO/status/1497274721418760193 https://twitter.com/IchBin_RO/status/1497274721418760193
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- morelisp 5y agoWhat good will liking a tweet do? If you are pro-SWIFT-exclusion-of-Russia and live in Germany please contact your national representatives and let them know you're willing to bear some hardship so others don't have to.
- deutschewelle 5y agoThanks I had quite a laugh reading your last sentence because most peers here in Berlin couldn't be bothered to report anything that doesn't directly impact them. For people living somewhere out rural shthole in West Germany perhaps might be triggered enough to file a report with the myriad of administrative concerns available to the spoiled citizen
- morelisp 5y agoOn average you're not wrong but it's still more effective than liking a random tweet.
- MandieD 5y ago#PullisGegenPutin (sweaters against Putin) - turn the thermostat down to 18 C (64 F) and throw on a sweater. Then call and email your feckless MdB.
- deutschewelle 5y agoHow will Germany pay for Russian oil if they cannot use SWIFT anymore? I know! Our politicians will simply use whatever financial system that Russia will propose. It would be even possible to trade a fleet of AMGs for a week of oil if need be. Removing SWIFT would only delay trade between Russia and Germany not hinder it in anyway. In fact bartering system would produce more efficiencies, a bullet proof AMG G-wagon for instance would fetch more oil than a regular C-class offered to Putin's low ranking officers! All in all, Ukraine gains nothing from this action, it would only give Putin the political ammunition to sell the narrative that Russia is under attack. The US certainly stands to gain everything and risk nothing in this region and its puzzling to me why Ukraine would choose this as a hill to die on as if their self sacrifice would move the hearts and minds of NATO officers on some emotional basis
- ilaksh 5y agoI would make a comment about cryptocurrency being relevant to replace this system, but I know it will just be buried and ignored.
- moonchrome 5y agoUmm - crypto would prevent any sort of sanctions ? How is that a good thing ?
- patrickaljord 5y agoBecause sanctions don't work and not everyone agree they are needed?
- leodriesch 5y agoFor a Russian Citizen that would probably be a good thing.
- jancsika 5y ago> A cutoff from SWIFT may also have longer-term second-order effects on Bitcoin and non-fiat currencies. And remember that Bitcoin has a fascinating property here-- the more demand there is for transactions on it, the better it gets at scaling for something approaching SWIFT level of transactions. Oh wait I'm thinking of Bittorrent's scaling wrt popular torrents. Yeah, Bitcoin's ability to scale is complete shit.
- asasidh 5y ago
- errantmind 5y agoBitcoin's Lightning Network scales just fine, but based on your comment it doesn't look like you are interested in how Bitcoin works, instead wanting to jump on a bandwagon.
- dskloet 5y agoLighting doesn't work for large transactions, and isn't trustless for very small transactions. And lightning relies and being able to close channels so lighting security breaks when Bitcoin is congested.
- errantmind 5y agoYou have pointed out a few caveats, but LN works well for the vast majority of transactions. What point are you trying to make?
- pavlov 5y agoAlso, if global Bitcoin demand increases because it’s used to circumvent Russian sanctions, the more likely it becomes that Western governments will simply shut down exchanges within their reach. And that would certainly have a chilling effect on Bitcoin price.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- errantmind 5y agoWhile, in principle, I support sanctions against Russia for their actions, I can't help but think they are using Ukraine as part of a larger economic game. Basically, they are forcing countries to take sides to some degree, and any country that wants to continue trading with Russia will have to adopt an alternative financial system/network, one that is not Dollar-centric like most of the world currently uses. I think Putin means to hold out economically as long as possible and give other countries a chance to adopt this financial network and eventually get to a point where Russia doesn't need to play by the West's rules anymore, because sanctions will have a diminished effect.
- psychlops 5y agoPretty sure it's China using Russia for part of its larger economic game to accomplish the goals you mention.
- chalst 5y agoI think this has things the wrong way around. Russia and China have for the last twenty years been trying to break free of the dollar-centric financial system with some degree of success: both countries have, for instance, built up large gold reserves. Now Russia is using that prior preparation to engage in old-fashioned revanchism. Rather than being a move in a bigger game, I think this is Russia cashing in its chips. The potential for bad consequences for Russia in the months ahead depends to a large degree on how China reacts.
- eunos 5y agoWhat? China is still biggest dollar forex out there.
- redisman 5y agoChina is very different philosophically. Hide your strength, bide your time. Their economy has also had a meteoric rise unlike Russia which is a flatlined raw resource economy. I mean Russia did for about 8 years but China is going for multi decade before they start cashing in.
- ChildOfChaos 5y agoSo bitcoin is going to go up? Asking for a friend.
- rglover 5y agoIt's very likely. It would be an effortless switch to Bitcoin for Russia and give them access to a currency/network completely invulnerable to nation state controls. Blocking SWIFT for Russia would be a very, very, very stupid idea because it would precipitate the collapse of the U.S. Dollar. Which, I'd bet, is intentional because the central banks want to push out CBDCs they control and populations are primed to support it willfully (in opposition to Bitcoin) thanks to several years of anti-Russia propaganda. It's a perfect mousetrap. All Russia has to do is tell European countries reliant on its energy exports that they'll only be accepting Bitcoin moving forward. This would force those countries to scramble to get Bitcoin (if they don't have it already), forcing the price up rapidly.
- sealthedeal 5y agoCEO and co-founder of Routefusion here, a cross-border bank to bank payment API. We use the SWIFT network regularly. I can 100% confirm that all money in the world is just literally numbers, and it is balanced by the different federal reserve systems around the world to ensure no one can "create" money without notifying everyone. I guess if I was super cool I would do an AMA because this is the only thread that is really my time to shine hahaha.
- joelbondurant4 5y ago
- periheli0n 5y agoWhat would keep some entity that has its SWIFT access revoked from switching to China's CIPS or even crypto? Would it be merely an inconvenience, requiring the change of a few processes, or would it create hard problems?
- user432678 5y agoI would say, good luck trying to sell gas or oil for bitcoins if the buyer even doesn’t want to have a business with you.
- JulianMorrison 5y agoI'm guessing it depends on the kind of sanctions. If dealing with rogues makes you a rogue, internationally, then CIPS may shy away from it.
- daniel-grigg 5y agoIn the short term, both. Longer term yes, many countries would migrate to other systems which mitigates the value of SWIFT. Fear of that happening is part of the reluctance to use it as a political weapon.
- elliekelly 5y agoThe two systems aren’t mutually exclusive. You can be a SWIFT member or participant and also use CIPS or cryptocurrency, though I think switching to crypto for payments would create a ton of procedural issues for most financial institutions.
- sealthedeal 5y agoIf we "cut" off SWIFT it would hurt Europe and the States just as much as it would Russia because this is how all money moves. Think paying for natural gas, oil, commodities, etc etc.
- aqme28 5y agoIsn't that kind of how all sanctions work? Eliminating trade hurts both parties equally, though the effects will be felt less to the bigger party.
- stepanhruda 5y agoNitpick: doesn’t have to be equally - one party in a trade can gain more than the other, not necessarily proportionally to size (but both end up better off than not trading). The key is to sanction areas where the losses hurt the other side more than you.
- morelisp 5y agoThat's... that's the point. We should not be paying them for gas. We should not be funding their war.
- redisman 5y agoGermany shut down their nuclear plants and built a expensive pipeline from Russia to use nat gas instead. Why?! This mistake could be one of the biggest in EU in the 2020s
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- svilen_dobrev 5y agoWhat is robbing a bank compared with founding a bank? Bertolt Brecht ...
- _8j50 5y agoOne of my favorite hacks: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bangladesh_Bank_robbery https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bangladesh_Bank_robbery Almost stole a billion dollars, if it wasn't for a very obvious typo.
- LeoPanthera 5y agoNon-mobile URL: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bangladesh_Bank_robbery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bangladesh_Bank_robbery
- supernova87a 5y agoI have always wondered, what combination of manual vs. automatic processes are happening when one makes a bank wire (actual wire transfers, not ACH)? Because whenever I have done wires, in addition to the bank/IBAN/account numbers, there are all these manual fields like "for further credit to" etc. that are clearly having to be interpreted by someone. And very often errors come up and the funds are held or in limbo on one end or another. Does anyone have a good explanation of what happens both on the initiating bank side and receiving bank side when a wire is done? I imagine that this is why it still costs $25-40 to handle them.
- jonp888 5y agoIn Europe bank transfers are free and the standard way of transferring money. Cheques are pretty much extinct. If American banks charge for them it's most likely because they can. It's standard practice in retail banking to offer commonly used things cheaply and then earn back the cost by charging loads for anything unusual. As for how it actually works, in the European Bank I worked at we debited the account and then put the transfer in a batch file and sent it to the central bank which processed them every few hours. If the transaction failed for unknown reasons, someone would, I think manually review it.
- conductr 5y agoTo my recollection it’s manual and yes that’s why it’s expensive. Imagine it gets added to a queue, then daily via swift, the banks settle with each other. The queue has a bunch of different stuff and is a net single transfer between bank A and B depending on who owes who today. The manual part confirms that it was added to the queue which allows them the comfort of giving you access to the cash immediately. I think the fed insures these transactions and requires immediate availability of funds.
- Pxtl 5y agoCanadian PM Trudeau just publicly announced his government's support for booting Russia out of the SWIFT system a few minutes ago. So the international pressure is there.
- polski-g 5y agoCountries who don't matter generally don't matter.
- bonyt 5y agoIf you want a fun podcast about a crazy heist involving SWIFT, check out The Lazarus Heist. https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/w13xtvg9/episodes/downloads https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/w13xtvg9/episodes/downloads
- mepian 5y agoDo Mastercard and Visa require SWIFT to function within the borders of Russia?
- june_twenty 5y agoThe way people write things on Twitter amuses me. Is this person a SWIFT expert or did they just google all this stuff to be able to tweet about it? Plus.. I can't read it all because Twitter throws a sign up modal.
- murphyslab 5y agoHe's an "investor/entrepreneur" FWIW. To read, you can always use ThreadReader. Just pop the Tweet's URL in there: https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1496861068945154056.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1496861068945154056.html
- krick 5y agoThere isn't anything really in this "explanation" that cannot be googled within seconds much less that would require him to be an expert. For me it explains nothing. I don't know, maybe it is a little enlightening for a person that never heard of SWIFT before, that didn't know it's "something related to international payments" and now he does. But I'm not sure this qualifies as an explanation.
- user3939382 5y agoI can tell you something you can’t Google in 2 seconds: have a close friend who’s also a programmer that worked on SWIFT: the transactions are conducted through XML files on FTP(!) drops.
- prox 5y agoWhat the heck. I can’t wrap my head on how that would work. Can you elaborate?
- user3939382 5y agoYep, and actually I worked on the US Federal Financial Aid system and the transactions between the DOE and schools work the same way (called SAIG Mailbox) Look up ISO 20022 and “store and forward”
- deleted 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- MichaelMoser123 5y agosubmitted the same comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30473047 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30473047 link: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/feb/25/western-powers-have-realised-russia-is-largely-immune-to-sanctions-ukraine-putin https://www.theguardian.com/world/2022/feb/25/western-powers... Comes as a shock, it seems that Ukraine has been sold out. Key passage: "As Hosuk Lee-Makiyama, the head of the European Centre for International Political Economy, said, Europe has allowed itself to become more integrated with Russia, while Russia has separated itself from Europe. He said EU countries owned a combined €300bn of Russian assets that would be vulnerable to confiscation if a full-blooded financial war broke out. The UK owns billions more via firms such as BP, which has a near-20% stake in the Russian oil company Rosneft. “Sanctions are one of the few options that European countries have in a conflict situation like this. If you disconnect North Korea or Iran from the international financial system, you do not expose yourself to that much damage.” Speaking on BBC News, he added: “But while I don’t say it is impossible to envisage Russia being barred from the Swift system, it is a nuclear option that means you exterminate yourself along with your enemy.”"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- benreesman 5y ago[flagged]
- benreesman 5y ago[flagged]
- est 5y agoI remember read somewhere SWIFT can handle any currency, it's just most banks process US dollars only. US can audit every transaction after 911. EU invented INSTEX to buy oil from Iran to avoid the SWIFT ban.
- jollybean 5y agoAside from SWIFT, we're not even talking about Nodstream 1 or other things. This 'target the gov. and leaders not the people' is also a bit rubbish for 2 reasons: 1) The people are the country, they are not hugely separable. The people won't really feel the pain or 'see consequences' directly from SWIFT. It's a total abstraction. Even if their prices rise, the attribution will be lost. 2) Putin's approval post invasion is 69%. 5% of Russians think that Russia is responsible for the Ukrainian invasion. 50% believe that NATO is responsible. Just absorb that for a moment. Despite some of the current protests that we see on the news (which are amplified in the Western press to the point of being a bit propagandistic), Russians are themselves complicit in what is going on, and at very minimum, things should be done to make a very clear populist signal to them. a) Cancel all travel visas b) Disallow all flights in/out of Russia to all friendly states. c) Cancel a lot of consumer facing business: Starbucks, IKEA, iPhones and definitely entertainment, film, clothing brands, music apparel etc. Definitely cancel everything related to Football/Soccer. And ban all participation from any kid of international events. None of this 'Athletes from Russia technically no the Russian team' rubbish. d) Send anyone on short-term business/study home. You can finish out the year, but your not coming back to Harvard next year - sorry - your Oligarch/Elite parents are complicit. None of that will have dire consequences for anyone - but every single Russian will be hit with the message: you don't get nice cappuccinos when you're gleefully invading a neighbouring country. If you want nice shiny toys, get a new leader. Putin is actually not invulnerable. His approval has been low over the last bit, he has people who want to replace him, the Oligarch and Big Business really do not like him, and the population could turn on him pretty quickly. I believe part of the reason he was so physically distance from other members of his staff was not just COVID, but I suggest he's paranoid about a coup, which is after all the most common way for a Russian leader to go.
- baby 5y agoIt was always hard for me to understand exactly what SWIFT is. From what I could get, it’s a bunch of protocols that were standardized in order for banks to communicate between them. When you buy something in thailand with your apple card, barclay’s debit your account, talks to the feds, the feds talks to the BIS or some bank in thailand or some bank that might be able to talk to thailand, and so on. I think swift is the protocol each bank and central bank use to communicate. If it is so, I’m not sure how you can cut swift from a country. It doesn’t sound like a centralized thing.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> If it is so, I’m not sure how you can cut swift from a country. It doesn’t sound like a centralized thing. Like any other sanctions: the government says “If you do X, don't do it with any Russian bank. If you do, people with guns will come, throw you personally in jail, and impose financial penalties on your business.” And then transactions from Russian banks to banks in countries with that kind of sanctions suddenly have a very high rate of falling into the bit bucket without having any business effect.
- neilwilson 5y agoLoans create deposits. When a bank issues a loan, it creates the equivalent deposit automatically. That's the loan department of a bank. The treasury department of a bank then persuades the ultimate holders of those deposits to swap them for bank bonds and equity, which then fulfils the 'capital requirements' of regulation. In other words lending is not restricted by quantity, but by price. Banks are never constrained by regulations on the liability side. All they do is change the price of money. The way Russia will pay people is by the Russian Treasury paying whoever needs paying in Roubles. That creates an automatic overdraft for the Russian Treasury at the Russian central bank that balances the additional commercial reserves the transfer journal creates. And that's all they need to do. They don't even need to pay interest if they don't want to. How do I know this? Because that's how the UK's Bank of England and Treasury works, which along with colleagues I have documented in very great detail[0] People in Russia will accept those roubles because Putin will tax them in roubles and throw them in gulags if they don't pay. As long as he taxes enough, there won't be any inflation. That's all the Russian authorities need to do to ensure a flow of real goods and services towards the Russian war machine. They are self-sufficient in everything that matters, and anything else he needs he can source via China in exchange for oil, gas and other natural resources. What would be really entertaining is if Russia demanded that other countries settle their gas bill in Roubles. Then confiscate foreign holdings of them. How long then before the EU sues for peace? Swift is a glorified email system between banks, and can replaced by a different email/MQ system between banks. Correspondence banking existed for centuries before we had computers. The excessive excitement over Swift belies the reality of how transactions are settled by banks on the ground. Stopping Putin transacting in other currencies is irrelevant. Since the world is stopping selling stuff to Russia he will have no bills in other currencies to settle. The only people that suffer are those providing the transaction services in the West, who will earn less and may have to lay off workers. Putin doesn't need our money. He has his own. [0]: https://gimms.org.uk/2021/02/21/an-accounting-model-of-the-uk-exchequer/ https://gimms.org.uk/2021/02/21/an-accounting-model-of-the-u...
- norswap 5y agoI was hoping for something more technical! Does someone have something like that?
- thesimonlee 5y agoThink of SWIFT as a large Websphere MQ installation, distributed across several data-centers. You get an IP access by installing a router, leasing telecoms connectivity. You get access to publish/subscribe with an SSL certificate exchange. You get access to send/receive to a specific node(Bank) with another SSL exchange. It is important to realize nodes can only send messages to those addresses which have been trusted, i.e. keys exchanged. So a bank (Bank-A) trusts you to send SWIFT messages, all you can do with these messages is make accounting debits & credits within that bank. e.g. please debit $100 from my account number 12345 to account 67890. You can also chain the messages, something like, debit my account $100, credit the account of Bank-B, and send my message on to Bank-B. The message to Bank-B might say (debit Bank-B and) credit John-Doe-account. (It's the job of the treasury department within the bank to monitor & keep these nostro [other bank] accounts funded) Perhaps not obvious, but banks don't have hundreds of correspondent accounts. So to send money from a small town bank in Peru, to another small town bank in Palau, there are going to be a lot of these back-to-back transactions. The pathways are determined by hardcoded rules - not by SWIFT - but by each bank in the chain. So sanctioning SWIFT is one part. The other part is getting every bank on SWIFT to remove all correspondent banking rules going via Russia. (Quite nice work I suppose). Since the messages themselves are just XML, and not partially large, you could easily put all the days messages which got rejected into a .zip & use email (I suspect this is common operationally anyway). Any kind of sanction on SWIFT would instantly lead to private MQ (or whatever flavor of messaging) infrastructure springing up everywhere & total chaos for every bank in the world (i.e. quite different to Iran). This would cause a reduction in the number of correspondent accounts each bank would be willing to maintain. So longer pathways, slower international payments. I doubt SWIFT could recover from a sanction. It would just close down. The endgame being heterogeneous networks, poorer monitoring, so the USA lose. The sanctions put on individual Russian banks can be monitored (by SWIFT). In likelihood they are not used as correspondent banks. >How does the system guarantee that nobody's creating money without notifying everyone? SWIFT doesn't do this. I suppose a special audit is triggered (see Wirecard ) and the Auditor should catch it.