24 ms·
The absurdity of renting a car will no longer be tolerated
- rzz3 5y agohttps://archive.md/YJ95m https://archive.md/YJ95m
- avmich 5y agoCaptcha.
- elmerfud 5y agoNational emerald isle. I've never looked to another rental company after experiencing it.
- Aloha 5y agoAgree, I have probably spent two years behind the wheel of one of their cars, its the best in the business. You never know what you're gonna find once you get there, but you know there will be something that can comfortable sit five adults, and more or less hold their luggage, even if its a full size truck.
- mmcconnell1618 5y ago+1 to this process vs. going to a counter. You make a reservation online, show up at the rental car lot, walk to the emerald or executive aisle, pick any car you want, scan the barcode with the app on your phone, show your ID and the QR code at the gate and you drive away. Hertz Gold service is similar. Frequently renters have much more efficient ways to pick up and drop vehicles. Many US credit cards offer higher tier membership with rental car companies as a benefit. The time saving only is worth any small annual membership fees.
- chrisseaton 5y agoI'm sure it's genuinely a hard problem. If you don't have enough cars in a given area then there's zero you can do about it. You can't conjure them out of nowhere. You can't even order new ones anymore! Think about how complex airline operations are - getting the right plane in the right place at the right time - then imagine that with random pilots that may just not get where they said they would be at a given time.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> I'm sure it's genuinely a hard problem. If you don't have enough cars in a given area then there's zero you can do about it. You can make people pay for reservations, limit reservations based on stock, and only refund late cancellations when the loss has been mitigated by an actual rental or replacement paid reservation (using a FIFO queue of slots where a cancelled reservation goes behind unreserved stock of the same class). This is not an unsolved problem, this is just a problem the rental agencies are happy enough not solving because there is no adverse consequence for the bad experience they impose on customers.
- chrisseaton 5y agoHow do you guarantee a reservation? Literally keep the car at the pick-up point from the time it was ordered until the person gets there months later? Any other way, you're relying on someone returning a car to you in time at that location so you have it to give to the reserver. You're always reliant on random people bringing their cars back on time. You're always vulnerable to not being able to fulfil the reservation.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> How do you guarantee a reservation? Literally keep the car at the pick-up point from the time it was ordered until the person gets there months later? Any other way, you're relying on someone returning a car to you in time at that location so you have it to give to the reserver. Yes, any rental reservation, whether it's a hotel room or rental car, has some irreducible level of risk, because the prior renter may unlawfully hold over the rental, damage it, or do something else unforseen. Heck, even if you physically hold it from the point of reservation, it could be hit by a meteor. There are known ways to quantify and account for (either by holding back stock from reservation to cover incidents or holding back money to cover compensation) these things, and you can tune it how you like. The rental car industry, however, doesn't even try to manage the easily mitigated risks that are the entire reason reservation systems exist, because they take reservations but treat them as meaningless. This isn't hard.
- k1rac 5y agoAlways rent a car expecting an attempted to be ripped off. Know their rules and be nice. I've had surprisingly good experiences with a company with bad rep. Once i rented a car for 3 weeks for 0.73cents a day in low season. A fiat panda in south west europe. Im local there so it helped. Always make a chitchat with the person in the counter, get their name and ask them how i can avoid any issues. They are surprisingly nice and i can always name drop their name to the final inspector so they think i know them. ... Or just buy their insurance. Havent rented since covid thought.
- chrisseaton 5y ago> Or just buy their insurance Note that many credit cards cover your insurance.
- boring_twenties 5y agoAs noted below, very few credit cards offer primary insurance. The secondary insurance that the majority offer is mostly worthless. The United Explorer card from Chase is one of the few that offers primary.
- throwawayboise 5y agoYou also want to be sure they cover loss of use, which for a rental car would be the max daily rate for every day the damaged car is out of service for repair work.
- PraetorianGourd 5y agoDepends on where you are. Most credit card companies do not cover Republic of Ireland, for example. It’s odd because the same company does cover England so it isn’t the driving whole driving on the left thing.
- tomohawk 5y agoThe trick with Ireland is to buy a policy ahead of time that covers the EU. If you neglect to do this, you will need to buy the overpriced policy at the counter.
- nlh 5y agoI spent ~10 years in the rental car business (although the very very high end of it.) Let me say, it's a weird business with LOTS of quirks. Here's one: One of the biggest frustrations people have is that it seems impossible to actually get the car you reserved. Seinfeld even has a whole schtick about this - why is it called a "reservation" if it's not actually....a reservation? Reservations never work because the rental car companies don't enforce them. You can book any car with any rental company and cancel up until the minute of the rental or just not show up and there's no penalty. (Everyone forgets this part.) If a rental car company actually treated reservations like reservations, then they'd hold your Toyota Camry for you and not give it to someone else. But then when you decide not to show up for your rental, the rental company would be stuck because they planned for you to show up and you didn't. So they have two choices: Either assume there's only an X% chance you're going to show up and use that to roughly plan fleet availability for that given day (the current state of affairs which results in your not getting a car you reserved when X+10% of people show up that day instead of X%), or start penalizing people for not showing up so they can actually honor reservations. And why don't they do that? Good 'ol competition. Everyone is afraid to start enforcing reservations because if Hertz does but Enterprise doesn't, people are going to book with Enterprise ("Book w/ us and never pay a penalty when your plans change!"). You will notice that they are tip-toeing into this -- lots of companies now offer discounts for pre-paid (non-refundable) reservations, but the no-penalty-for-no-shows-pay-at-the-counter option is still there. And until it vanishes, the reservation issue will still be there.
- odiroot 5y ago> You can book any car with any rental company and cancel up until the minute of the rental or just not show up and there's no penalty. Is this some American thing? Every time I rented a car in Germany, I had to pre-pay at least some amount.
- devin 5y agoI know someone who exploited this and would just keep a reservation handy in their city in case they needed a car, cancelling at the last minute. It was basically a zipcar for them with no membership fee.
- throwaway55421 5y agoI've always found car rental to be the least competitive market out there. My car cost me £800 approx a year ago. I spent £150 on new tyres and I've since driven it almost 10K miles without much other than the odd oil change and brake pads etc. Add on insurance and tax and it'd be about 14-1600 annually if it exploded tomorrow. That's £5 a day. But there is literally nowhere I can rent a car for that. I can't do 10, 15, etc. And that £5 is an overestimate of the cost based on it having a residual value of 0 after 1 year. Mainstream car companies universally rent out cars that are far newer than most cars on the road. I get that renting out absolute bangers might be hard to manage, but surely there's a middle ground here. I would sell my car and rent if I could do so for less than 2x the all-in price of my current one, but I can't even get remotely close.
- gnfargbl 5y agoThe problem is likely scalability. There is no really scalable way to buy suitably reliable cars, of any age and mileage, for £800 each. It's very hard to do on even a one-off basis; a disappointingly high proportion of very cheap cars end up having serious faults that the MoT tester "somehow" didn't pick up on. I guess there could be a business in buying up 2/3 year old ex-lease cars and renting them, but I'm not sure who the customer would be. Short-term renters want new vehicles. Long-term renters... well, why would you rent a 3 year old VW when you could buy one for less?
- midasuni 5y agoWhen I rent a car it’s reliability. I don’t need one very often, when I do I fill in the form, pay £20 a day plus £10 for delivery/collection and the car is dropped off at my house and picked up when I return it.
- xur17 5y ago> I guess there could be a business in buying up 2/3 year old ex-lease cars and renting them, but I'm not sure who the customer would be. Short-term renters want new vehicles. Long-term renters... well, why would you rent a 3 year old VW when you could buy one for less? I do think there's a middleground that's underserved. I've considered booking 1-3 month work / travel trips to areas of the country that require a car, and my options are either 1. spend an absurd amount on a car rental or 2. buy a car and deal with selling it a few months later. The rental price always seems to scale linearly with the duration of the rental, which is fine for something short, but seems absurd for longer rentals given the typical "utilization" of a car.
- comeonseriously 5y agoHome Depot can rent you a truck for 4 hours with a CC, DL and a handshake. In/out in less than 10 min. Renting a car can be this easy. It just isn't.
- ARandomerDude 5y agoThis also involves driving an orange and white Home Depot billboard/truck and a decent probability that you just spent money buying things at Home Depot for which you now need a short term rental. A traditional rental car has neither of those corporate advantages and therefore has the situation described above about cancellations.
- aldebran 5y agoTheir point is that the process can be smooth and fast. Not necessarily that people should rent from Home Depot.
- mbrameld 5y agoAnd their point is that the process is smooth and fast because of the constraints that don't exist in the market at large.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThe process is just about the same for Uhaul and that has none of the "enable people to do more business with you" motive that the home depot rental truck does.
- midasuni 5y agoLast time I rented a van from hertz I selected the location to collect from (self storage place), the time to pick up, and drop off (2 hours later), and then picked it up.
- weare138 5y agoA van from U-Haul is a fraction of the price of car rental companies. You can rent a van for 7 days from U-Haul for only $139.65 and $.69/mile. For that price I don't care what the hell it looks like.
- mrfusion 5y agoI just don’t understand the super long process and usually waiting in huge lines so that they can have you sign something you could have done electronically. We’re talking hours of people’s lives when they’re already exhausted from travelling.
- joshfraser 5y agoEspecially when GetAround and Turo have shown that you don't need a check-in counter or long paper contracts to run a successful car rental business.
- globalise83 5y agoSo they can sell you add-ons with lower resistance, I suppose. It's like when you go to one of those kitchen salesroom places where they bombard you with decisions and save the highest margin add-ons for the end so that you just wearily OK them.
- Rebelgecko 5y agoMost of the big rental companies (Avis, Budget, Hertz, Enterprise, etc) let you do speedy checkin/out if you pre-populate some information like DL and CC# on their websites. If the "semi-frequent traveler" mentioned in the article hasn't signed up to skip the counter, he's probably not as seasoned as the article wants you to think. For example when I rent with Avis, the app tells me what parking spot my car is in. I just get in, show my driver's license to the attendant on the way out (some make you show your DL before you get your key, but usually this is a chance to get a free upgrade), and off I go. At some locations you can just grab any car you want from the lot and drive off. When I return the car, they're usually done printing my receipt before I've gotten my luggage out of the trunk.
- ufmace 5y ago> probably not as seasoned as the article wants you to think. I remember when the TSA split the security lines into "seasoned traveler", "regular people", and "families and children" for a while. The "seasoned traveler" line was actually the slowest, because everyone wanted to think that they were seasoned when they were actually disorganized fumbling newbies. The "families and children" line, meant to be the slow one, was actually the fastest, because everyone assumed it would be slow and went to another one. So all of the actually seasoned travelers knew that that "families and children" line was the real fast one. Funny how that works.
- mrfusion 5y agoIt really would be a great time for a startup to disrupt this entire industry. I wonder if ycombinator would get behind it? I looked at turo once but it seemed to have limited inventory and very high prices.
- thriftwy 5y agoCar sharing may eat car rentals by offering whole day plans. They already do it, actually. Where I live, car sharing by mobile app is prevalent but car rentals never took off.
- Consultant32452 5y agoUber has car rentals in some places. https://www.uber.com/us/en/u/uber-rent/ https://www.uber.com/us/en/u/uber-rent/
- diebeforei485 5y agoI've generally had good experiences with Avis Preferred, if I pre-pay for the reservation the car is kept ready and I don't need to speak to anyone- it just shows me the spot where the car is in the app. The downside with pre-paying is that they charge extra to extend it (not last minute extensions) which is weird.
- tokamak-teapot 5y agoThere are lots of car rental apps in the UK, but none seem to execute well. If anyone knows differently, please let me know. What I'd really like: 1. You open the app and press a button. 2. A car arrives at your location within a few minutes. 3. The driver hands you a key and leaves. 4. When you're finished with the car, you open the app and press a button. 5. Within a few minutes, a driver arrives and you hand them the key. This could have plenty of optimisations. For example: I probably want to go away from home and then back home. It might make most sense for me to have a pre-arranged schedule for receiving / returning the key. Perhaps I could have a regular booking on the app. In the future, maybe it's 'keyless' and it uses self-driving to get to me. Maybe it drives itself while I'm in it, and just goes and parks itself somewhere out of the way / free when I'm not actively using it. When I get 'it' back, maybe it's a different car - that's fine.
- anandoza 5y ago> The driver hands you a key and leaves How?
- tokamak-teapot 5y agoShadowed by another driver, who picks the first up, or brings an electric scooter with them (these are as common as Ubers around here now), or ... teleports?
- jameshart 5y agoWell, see, he opens an app, presses a button, and in three to five minutes, another driver shows up in a car, hands him a key and leaves.
- listenallyall 5y agorecursive car renting
- snypher 5y agoHow does the driver arrive in step 5? I've seen services that will drive you home after a night out where the driver arrives on a mini scooter that will fit in your trunk, but this only works in urban areas and with appropriate cars.
- boardwaalk 5y agoI rented a car a few weeks ago. It was probably 15 min checking and checking out (even considering a bumped bumper) and cost me ~375 USD for the week all in, so ~50 USD a day. I was afraid it would be much worse; I've heard of how crazy the car market has been in general. But I just didn't see it. I also don't give a crap what exact model I get as long as it is roughly the form factor that is promised. I suppose if I was on a sunny vacation and wanted to joy ride, I may care. But then I'm probably use Turo or something.
- Anechoic 5y agoI was afraid it would be much worse; I've heard of how crazy the car market has been in general. But I just didn't see it. It really depends on where you are. This fall, we had our pick of vehicles in Chicago & Seattle, while we paid $5,000 for s 3-day minivan rental in Minneapolis. YMMV.
- kylehotchkiss 5y ago$5000 for 3 days in minivan? Was Uber XL not an option?
- Anechoic 5y agoNope, we needed to haul around equipment for field work.
- 1123581321 5y agoWow, are you sure you don't mean $500? I've seen vans going for $150/day this year, which is pretty rich compared to pre-covid. We also had a tough time getting a large passenger van, waitlisted until the day before, but still managed to pay $1500 for 10 days.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoyeah $5000 can't be right lol
- 5y ago
- magicalhippo 5y ago> The rules are always shifting, too. You can’t pay with a debit card, for example, except that in some cases you can [...] We almost got our holiday ruined by that. Here in Norway, debit cards are the norm. I've never had an issue renting a car with a debit card. I've never had an issue using my debit card, even though someone else would be driving. However, when we showed up at Budget on the Big Island of Hawaii to check out our reserved car, we quickly found out things were not the same. My SO has a driving license but only a debit card. I had a credit card but no driving license. Since we were not from the US, they explained, the driver had to have a credit card. Mine wouldn't do. We went to Avis next doors (unsurprisingly the owner of Budget), and was met with the same demand. Our two week vacation seemed ruined before it got started, as there's hardly any bus service to talk about and we were quoted like $100 just for a one-way trip with a taxi to the place we'd be staying, and that was a "nice price" since we were in a pickle. We tried to call our bank back home to see if they could help us in any way, but predictably they couldn't. We asked if a sizable deposit would help, but no. Minute by minute we felt our dream vacation was turning into a nightmare as hope evaporated. After a few rounds back and forth with the person behind the counter the manager sensed something was up, and after explaining our situation she asked where we'd be staying. We'd found an Airbnb-like place so it was a residential address, and she gave it a few seconds before she said to enter that along with my SO's debit card details. Vacation saved!
- shawabawa3 5y agoMy experience with the US is if they ask for a credit card you can just give them a European debit card and it will work fine. I think maybe US debit cards don't support charging and refunding a deposit or something?
- garbagecoder 5y agoSome places will let you use a debit card, but want like a $2,500 deposit. Enterprise, I think?
- joe_the_user 5y agoEnterprise will accept a debit card and an up-to-date utility bill. But not at the airport, only in the retail locations not beside airports. At least officially. As the gp said, they can all relent and let you do it.
- simonebrunozzi 5y agoWe're talking about car rentals, and I'd like to tell you about my dozen or so times when I managed to book a car in Mexico and pay roughly $3-$4 a day, for 1-2 weeks total. The short version is that I never buy insurance, which is where most car rental companies make their money on for American tourists. Everyone else buys insurance. We don't (we book with a credit card that gives us insurance, simple as that). Every single time we have to go back and forth with the guy at the counter for 10 minutes, before he realizes that we won't buy the insurance, that our insurance is valid, and that we're going to get off with a super-cheap car rental on that day. Shurgs, gives us the keys, next customer por favor.
- cge 5y ago>Every single time we have to go back and forth with the guy at the counter for 10 minutes, before he realizes that we won't buy the insurance, that our insurance is valid, and that we're going to get off with a super-cheap car rental on that day. Shurgs, gives us the keys, next customer por favor. Irish car rental agencies have found the way around this, which is that, if you have valid insurance other than theirs, they'll happily rent to you, so long as you're content to have a significant portion of the car's entire value charged (not preauthorized, as much as they say that's what they're doing) to your credit card and refunded upon return.
- josephcsible 5y agoIf you have the credit limit for it, and it's refunded upon return, who cares?
- Overtonwindow 5y agoBoy I hate the insurance shakedown. Enterprise did that to me the other day, and they were not friendly when I politely told them no. They wanted to know who my insurance carrier was and what the policy was. I told him it was just fine and if they don’t like it I can go to somebody else. They did end up renting me the car, but I felt like I was being treated like a criminal. Another time: I was behind a couple at Hertz and the employee at the desk made those people call their insurance company on the spot to verify coverage. Ridiculous.
- hirundo 5y agoThis seems to be a coordination problem, and we have a kit of new tools to solve those. For instance, Uber, but for rentals. Basically vanilla ride-sharing, but the customer is the driver instead of passenger. The rental fleet consists of personal cars listed by private people. You can buy an extra car for your driveway and, upon safety certification, list it for rent. Or list your daily driver when you don't need it. The car owner gets a lot less per hour than if she were the driver, but for less labor. What showstoppers am I missing?
- misthop 5y agoThere are a few that seem to be getting off the ground. Kyte is Uber for rentals and Turo is Airbnb for rentals. I've looked into both recently for family travel that makes a car that seats six for 4/5 days more expensive than the flights. Cancelled the trip due to Omicron, but both looked to fill the need for a good price and in different ways.
- influx 5y agoI think you’re describing Turo.com
- hirundo 5y agoThanks, I wasn't aware of that. This seems to be a very good environment for them to grow in. I'd be interested in giving them a try. I've recently used a dog boarding service with a similar model, rover.com, with great success.
- wellthisisgreat 5y agoWe used Turo 3 times in 2 states and the results were always great. There are some quirks (California rentals were accompanied with a bigger service fees than the Colorado ones, for example). I am sure like with Airbnb there are some horror stories, but haven’t heard of any
- postingawayonhn 5y agoThere's plenty of those businesses already. I think Turo is the biggest.
- throwaway984393 5y ago“Since the pandemic, it’s just gotten dramatically worse,” he told me. “I mean, it never used to be this stressful to rent a car.” Ah, we come to the heart of the issue. The global pandemic finally affected the pampered customer, and that can not be tolerated. We get to travel in metal tubes in the sky going hundreds of miles per hour. When we land, safely, we can spend a pittance to borrow a practically new $25,000 piece of machinery and take it on a joy ride. And we can do this virtually anywhere in the world, with nothing more than a driver's license and a credit card. This is an amazing miracle and these people are acting like it's their birthright. Yeah, it's gonna take a couple hours for your miracle to be ready. The world is kind of dying right now. Meanwhile, trains, subways, buses, and taxis still exist. But if they don't get to drive their own machine whenever they want, look out - they might write an editorial.
- Animats 5y agoYes, the article does come across as privileged whining.
- arrow7000 5y agoSo because travel is a miracle we should all be grateful and not expect a business to treat its customers with respect or dignity?
- throwaway984393 5y agoIn the middle of a pandemic? Yes. Everyone should lower their expectations. This is not the time to complain about a privilege. It's not going to kill us to suffer the very small indignities of "waiting" and "not getting what we want" while people are dying, businesses are failing, people are being evicted because they can't work, etc. It's car rental, not the ability to obtain food and shelter.
- kortilla 5y ago> Meanwhile, trains, subways, buses, and taxis still exist. Only in some of the most boring places to visit.
- a-dub 5y agolike all things travel, my understanding is that renting a car isn't bad at all if you do it frequently enough. and yeah, there's some residual pandemic chaos. last i read about renting a car in the pandemic was a very sad story about someone who was paid poverty wages to shuttle one way rentals around who caught the virus and died because their economic circumstance and job function did not allow them to shelter in place. this piece is kinda cringey.
- twobitshifter 5y agoAn interesting fact about the rental industry learned during the pandemic was that the cars are all just bought on short term loans rather than being owned outright. The rental companies float the cost of the loan and it pay it off with the rental fees. Since they buy thousands of cars they get the lowest prices possible from manufactures, and they use this to their advantage to turn over their inventory on the used car market. During the pandemic this backfired on them since they weren’t able to rent the cars to pay the loans off and the car market also ground to a halt.
- sokoloff 5y agoUsed car prices went up pretty dramatically during the pandemic, especially once new car supply chains started to get disrupted. I’m sure the travel reduction was bad for them, but it’s not like they got stuck with a bunch of rotten tomatoes; the cars were still valuable.
- jeromegv 5y agoThis disruption was real and did happen at the beginning of the pandemic as the used car market was not up in March and April. It brought a major rental company to bankruptcy.
- chii 5y agoif only they have some liquidity/capital to pay the loans during the initial stages of the pandemic, and last long enough to see the price of used cars sky rocket, they could've sold those cars at a profit to pay back the loans and still be operating (with a reduced fleet i guess?).
- mst 5y agoIf (big if) I remember the Matt Levine stuff right this is kinda how Hertz came out relatively intact except with "spending a while in bankruptucy" in place of liquidity/capital. Though I don't think most people expected it to end that way since the "used car prices rising" thing was unexpected and I suspect their meme stock adventures were a pretty essential unexpected bonus that helped as well.
- umvi 5y agoI've had such a better experience with Turo that I pretty much use it exclusively now. I get exactly the type of car I reserved, pay what was quoted, and often the owners are willing to pickup/dropoff at airport economy lots for an extra fee. The experience is 100x better than car rental companies.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoi agree. Turo is quite nice.
- AlexCoventry 5y agoThere was a similar service a few years ago where car owners who had rented out their cars wound up with disastrous personal liability for accidents complete unknowns had caused while driving their cars. It looks as though Turo only offers $750K of third-party insurance. This looks like a really risky proposition for anyone thinking of renting their car through this service.
- Tempest1981 5y agoWhy would the car owner (vs. the driver) ever be on the hook for the amount over $750K? Some legal catch I don't understand, I'm sure.
- scheme271 5y agoLiability for medical costs or other costs combined with renting out an expensive supercar? People are putting ferraris, lamborghinis, and similar cars on Turo and a write off on one of those cars can easily hit 300-400k.
- josephcsible 5y agoI don't think that post was really about the amount of liability. I think it was questioning why the owner would ever be liable for any of it, rather than the driver being liable for all of it.
- lkrubner 5y agoThere are many quirks in the car rental business, and some of the biggest companies are struggling with their own internal history. For instance, the largest car rental companies have grown by way of acquisition. ZipCar is now owned by Avis Rental Car. But internally, trying to merge all of the different databases into a single database, or at least create a unified API to create the illusion of a single database, is an absolutely epic struggle. I have some experience, which I wrote up, and which was discussed here on Hacker News. The old conversation (and link to original) is here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20260114 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20260114
- tristor 5y agoAll the complaints in this article and in the comments seem like they originate from rare/one-time renters trying to find a deal. Meanwhile I have rented thousands of times over the years, with a flat rate, and never had an issue. The rate I pay is never the lowest, but it’s usually a decent deal and I always get a car, and of course now I have status with the rental company. I think trying to pay the lowest price possible suckers people into bad experiences. To a large degree you get what you’re willing to pay for.
- Digory 5y agoPeople are generally willing to go through a lot to get a lower price. I fly Southwest, which guarantees no seats, but offers free changes. A car rental usually comes with a flight, and the flights aren’t 100% reliable. The airlines don’t bear the cost of being late. If they’re delayed a day or a half day, people would seethe at the “sunk” costs of paying for the “missed” time. They’d rather be charged for actual time used than get a guarantee for a particular car at a particular time.
- kortilla 5y ago> I fly Southwest, which guarantees no seats, but offers free changes. I think you mean it doesn’t guarantee specific seats. It still absolutely has to guarantee you a seat on the plane or suffer the same penalty as any other airline for overbooking. They are not exempt from that requirement.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoYeah but all airlines overbook and they're pretty good at it, but sometimes there aren't enough seats, but it's certainly no a Southwest only thing. I've always done just fine with them.
- Digory 5y agoRight, just pointing out that people ITT seem to think there's a bigger market for reserving a particular (car/seat), with the buyer bearing the costs for changes. Southwest is the opposite of that, as are most of the rental car companies. That's how the 'full service' airlines reserved seats, but there isn't a lot of extra profit in it. People want cheap and flexible transportation more than they want a particular seat or car.
- JamesAdir 5y agoWhen we accepted journalism to be a collection of twits? No data, no real figures, no information from the companies. Just a collection of links and tweets wrapped in the author opinion which is based on anecdotes. I'm much worried from the state of journalism than the car rental business.
- AlexCoventry 5y agoMagazines have always carried this kind of garbage.
- yepthatsreality 5y agoThe absurdity of indicating blogging is journalism will no longer be tolerated
- zekrioca 5y agoI agree with you, but given that overall comments in here seem to agree with the article, I guess this is a two-way problem.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoThe Atlantic has some really good articles and times and then there are articles like these that are just puffery and misdirection claiming that we're all in late stage capitalism circling down the toilet of western civilization.
- civilized 5y ago"Late stage capitalism" is a meme beloved by early stage interns. They're dying for capitalism to end so they can fulfill their rightful role in society as anime appreciaters who are paid $150K a year.
- NoSorryCannot 5y agoYou really let that strawman know who's boss...
- 5y ago
- NoblePublius 5y agoWhy is Turo still banned in NY?
- vmception 5y ago> Most of the cars that Hertz rents out are owned by “special-purpose” subsidiaries of Hertz, from which Hertz then leases them. When Hertz was sliding into bankruptcy in spring 2020, it was because the company had missed lease payments—to put it crudely—to itself. I can barely understand this, yet I will walk into a rental-car office and suffer for it. I live for this corporate structure.
- noveltyaccount 5y agoWhat's the advantage of this? Portions of your corporation can go bankrupt without submarining the whole enterprise?
- vmception 5y agoThats what they do. It also earns money from leases (tax event), while itself pays a lease to a subsidiary (tax deduction). Who knows how the subsidiary is structured or returns money to shareholders or if it is located in a different jurisdiction with more favorable taxes. Each subsidiary is different. Each vehicle could theoretically be owned by a distinct subsidiary. Distributing vehicles in the best way to shield liability in the specific jurisdiction of operation. I really do wonder how they return money to shareholders. It could just be all about the potential of returning money to shareholders and never doing so.
- midhhhthrow 5y agoJust use Turo. We did that and it was great
- vzaliva 5y agoA frequent traveler I despise rental car agencies and try to avoid renting cars as much as possible. Here are the few options to consider: 1. Public transporation 2. Lyft/Uber/taxi 3. Zipcar (and similar) 4. turo.com
- stjohnswarts 5y agoThis person is claiming that renting a car is absurd? Does he not realize people need to get around when they arrive somewhere? Now that is what is absurd. I am sure the market and customer service is shit right now because of the car shortage, but it will be right back where it is after the pandemic blows over. These people discounting capitalism will always be proven wrong in the long run.
- kenneth 5y agoI don't rent cars very often, but it's always been a pleasant experience. I have National Emerald Club for free via my Amex card. Any time I need a car, I just click rent from the app on the cheapest car. Walk into the rental lot straight to the Emerald Aisle, pick any car I want (self-selecting my upgrade, I've gotten lucky with convertibles, SUVs, etc.), and drive it off. No talking to anyone. I simply show my license to the guard at the exit gate who records my check-out, and we're done. I've never experienced anything close to the horror stories mentioned by anyone here.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoI feel like this is very country specific. I've been driving different rentals for the past two months (all taken from local companies, avoid huge car rentals, they'll scam you over everything). Smooth process, no hassle, just sign a contract, pay, lock money for the insurance and go.
- nottorp 5y agoInteresting. The page simply does not scroll on my firefox. All I see is the title and the top part of a grey box that i assume is a stuck image. Mind, I have a lot of privacy plugins on and I'm not turning them off for them.
- Twisell 5y agoA pretty successful economic model here in France is non-profit consumer cooperative for care sharing https://citiz.coop/english https://citiz.coop/english Unfortunately this model is lagging behind in Paris because former mayor chooses to subsidize a big corporation to run care sharing and they let the fleet deteriorate before closing business. But in town that embraced the cooperative (and slightly subsidized model) it's working like a breeze.
- jyriand 5y agoIsn't there any Airbnb for renting cars?
- dredmorbius 5y agoUber / Lyft
- megablast 5y agoIt’s insane to me that people can’t survive a trip without a car.
- Veen 5y agoYes, but the insanity lies in the lack of decent public transport, not in the holiday-makers desire to travel around.
- alkonaut 5y agoThere is a lot of competition in this space. If you have a bad experience, don’t use them next time. If it takes more than a couple of minutes at a counter to pick up a car including queue time, that’s not acceptable. Switch. I have good experiences from Hertz, Europcar and Avis in Europe. Just pick up keys, usually the right car (some times obviously a switch within the class but that’s expected as it literally says “or similar” and it’s always similar e.g an A4 instead of a 3-series or a golf instead of a similar sized Toyota or whatever).
- amai 5y agoIs it really an issue that rental cars get stolen very often? I thought all the rental cars have some kind of tracking device installed by default.
- dfxm12 5y agoWhile the car is gone, that's one less car in your fleet that you can rent to someone else. I think there's some implication here that even if they are recovered, the stolen cars aren't necessarily brought back proper running condition. It's even more of an issue (like during the pandemic) when cars are in short supply and thus more expensive to replace.
- dfxm12 5y agoIt seems like one of the reasons rental car companies can get away with absurd stuff is because people see it as their only option. That's rarely the case. If people started taking the bus, the rental cars companies would probably have to improve their customer service, because they certainly won't be able to compete on price.
- rixed 5y agoI once asked at a rental desk, while they were verifying all the papers that I already uploaded online, why it took so long to rent a car when I can rent a full house in a few clicks with no physical interaction. They swiftly answered: because one can not drive away past the border with a house.