30 ms·
Skimpflation: A reason inflation is worse than the government says it is
- Animats 5y agoAirline seats should get a "hedonic adjustment" downward as seat pitch increases.
- dnautics 5y agoTvs should get a hedonic adjustment equal to the cube of their diagonal length.
- lamontcg 5y agoAnd the quartic reciprocal of the number of ads they force down your throat.
- tda 5y agoI would much rather have an old fashioned dumb tv than a spying, adverising injecting, sluggish smart tv with crappy apps that never get updated. So the hedonic adjustment should definitely be negative.
- ralusek 5y agoI just bought a smart tv and never gave it my wifi. I just use it with Apple TV.
- efaref 5y agoComing soon: TVs with 5G cellular access (sold as a feature) so don't even need to input your wifi. (https://www.tvtechnology.com/opinions/five-ways-5g-will-change-television https://www.tvtechnology.com/opinions/five-ways-5g-will-chan...)
- TeMPOraL 5y agoIMO the adjustment should not be proportional to f(diagonal length), but f(diagonal length, average living room diagonal length), because the optimal viewing experience comes from picking a correct TV size for the distance between you and the screen. I'm also seconding the proposal for negative hedonic adjustment on TVs (and arguably everything) that's a function of amount of advertising shown through them.
- nvmd 5y ago150 years later and Bastiat still got it.
- giorgioz 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fr%C3%A9d%C3%A9ric_Bastiat https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fr%C3%A9d%C3%A9ric_Bastiat Thank you. I did not know Bastiat.
- sammalloy 5y ago> Alan Cole first woke up to what we're calling skimpflation this summer. What? Everything the article mentions became noticeable a year ago, sometime in July of 2020.
- mistermann 5y agoI am actually impressed they said "a" reason rather than "the" reason, attention to detail.
- quickthrower2 5y agoAnd humility too (rather than the clickbaity 'the')
- russellbeattie 5y ago> The quality of service seems to be deteriorating everywhere. Given that it's generally accepted that the U.S. economy is no longer based on the production of goods, and is mostly a service economy now, this doesn't seem to bode well. I wonder if this is like a normal vicious cycle which will eventually be broken, or if this is a permanent change? Based on personal experience living in Europe, a society can function quite well even with a pathetic level of customer service. This might be the new normal.
- throwawaygh 5y ago> Based on personal experience living in Europe, a society can function quite well even with a pathetic level of customer service. This might be the new normal. How do you mean? I've always much preferred European service to American service. But then, I also loathe interacting with waiters as if we're old friends or something and get unbelievably frustrated when someone tries to bag my groceries.
- kaesar14 5y agoTry getting anything done with a French or German bank. American customer service is several levels better than my experience with European institutions.
- jay_kyburz 5y agoWe have been using self checkout for a few years here in Australia, and the thought of having to even go through a normal checkout with a cashier now kind of yuck.
- KingOfCoders 5y agoThe problem with hedonistic inflation calculation: Should it reflect how things get more expensive or reflect the level of living? There are two forces, one which wants to represent costs and one which wants to represent value. It at least makes comparing GDP between countries most difficult, because everyone calculates inflation differently - usually the US has the biggest gains in GDP because it calculates inflation lowest. Also: http://www.shadowstats.com/alternate_data/inflation-charts http://www.shadowstats.com/alternate_data/inflation-charts
- chaostheory 5y agoDo they even add food and gas prices to core CPI?
- KingOfCoders 5y ago"Why Food and Energy Prices Are Excluded - Food and energy prices are exempt from this calculation because their prices can be too volatile or fluctuate wildly. Food and energy are necessary staples, meaning demand for them doesn't change much even as prices rise" https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/coreinflation.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/coreinflation.asp
- anchpop 5y agoyes. gas is included in the transportation group
- chaostheory 5y agoIs it? I thought both it and food were excluded from the core index because their prices were too "volatile"
- foota 5y agoCross country comparison should be based on PPP (Purchasing Power Parity), the amount that currency can purchase in the country.
- nathanvanfleet 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- knownjorbist 5y agoWe're dealing with a perfect storm of supply chain and staffing problems... of course it seems like validation to inflation fetishists.
- daxfohl 5y agoI think some inflation will do us good. Things get pricier so people buy less, thus require the things they do buy to last longer, and we move away from the disposable everything culture and all its byproducts.
- fsckboy 5y ago>thus require the things they do buy to last longer that will not be the effect of inflation. manufacturing products to the requirement that products last longer (or not) is on a much longer timescale than inflationary factors.
- brutusborn 5y agoI hope that your intuition is correct, but I think the opposite is equally as plausible: prices are "sticky" so producers cut costs to compensate, exacerbating high disposal frequency.
- dominotw 5y agolets make poor ppl buy less
- eru 5y ago> Things get pricier so people buy less, [...] That's not how inflation works. First, you can't reason from a price change. Things might get more expensive because there's more demand (ie people buying more), or because supply is disrupted. Second, inflation is a general rise in the price level. That includes a rise in wages. If you 'want' people to buy less stuff, you need to lower their real incomes. That can happen in a period of general inflation, general deflation, or even stable prices. See also https://www.econlib.org/archives/2014/02/never_reason_fr.html https://www.econlib.org/archives/2014/02/never_reason_fr.htm...
- kamaal 5y ago>>That includes a rise in wages. That's not how it works either. When the price of fuel increases, the cost to send a worker from point A to point B increases. However the worker salaries don't change all that much, or at-least not uniformly.
- busymom0 5y agoHere in Canada, canned bean can went from 67c to $1 and the salt less ones went from 87c to $1.27 within a month. Cat food can went from $1.69 to $2.29. I am not rich and for now I can still afford food. But this is definitely insane and the poor are suffering hard.
- kmonsen 5y agoWow, that’s a 50% monthly inflation rate!! The canned beans will be $129 in a year and almost 17k in two years.
- angelzen 5y agoThat's how inflation behaved in many historical situations. I'm bookmarking this comment, at least I'll have the pleasure of "I told you so" if the authorities fail to bring inflation under control.
- swader999 5y agoMy cat is going to freak out if he has to only eat the dry kibbles.
- imtringued 5y agoYou mean in exceptional situations. Hyperinflation is the exception not the norm.
- bickfordb 5y agoIf only the US had some way to import a larger workforce
- HideousKojima 5y agoAnd put higher demand on housing, inflating home and rental prices even further?
- eru 5y agoIf only they had some way of creating more housing?
- HideousKojima 5y agoLand (especially desirable land near good jobs) is in far more limited supply than people willing to immigrate to the US. Zoning and other regulations not withstanding.
- jpgvm 5y agoThe land around most population centers in the US is used incredibly wastefully. If you compare the density of a modern Asian city to a US city the comparison is pretty woeful (probably contributes to the "going back in time" feeling when visiting the US also). Land is there it's just being used wrong.
- seanmcdirmid 5y agoNone of those dense Asian cities are affordable. Yes, Shanghai is dense, but for sale prices are as dear as in SF, maybe even dearer if we compare comparable housing rather than just averages.
- eru 5y agoThe sky is the limit.
- 5y ago
- lend000 5y agoSkimpflation is one problem with CPI -- falling under the umbrella of somewhat arbitrary hedonic adjustments. But the main problem is more fundamental. CPI is calculated by surveying what a bunch of median Americans bought, and weights it by HOW MUCH OF IT they bought. For example, the weight of gasoline oscillated ~100% from its low from 2003-2007 because oil prices increased significantly during this time (median Americans drove less/bought more fuel efficient cars). And therein lies the problem. If you poll the median, and the median tends to spend all of their money (just reallocating it according to priorities), what you are really measuring is the median household budget. Which is why any chart of "real wages" is a flat line, which is obviously not accurate. So CPI is a load of crap. Real inflation over the last 40 years has probably averaged closer to 3% (see the Big Mac index) than the <2% quoted by bureaucrats and politicians. To improve it, they could look at the 1000 highest volume items in the economy and measure changes in prices of those. Many of those are raw materials, so this would make hedonic adjustments a bit easier, too.
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agoWhat happens when the 1000 highest volume items change under your proposal?
- lend000 5y agoSame thing they do with the current system. Normalize and replace, and don't expect much of a shock from relatively low volume items breaking in and out of the 900-1000 rank.
- ACow_Adonis 5y agoas someone with a bit of an economics and official statistics background as well as tech (albeit not in the US), one of my frustrations with visiting hacker news are these threads on non-tech topics. for instance: CPI. how is it calculated? I haven't downvoted this post, but let's use it as an example. here's how CPI appears to be calculated: https://www.bls.gov/opub/hom/cpi/calculation.htm https://www.bls.gov/opub/hom/cpi/calculation.htm by my reading, the basic methodology is to obtain a basket of goods and consumer items and then track the price change in those items. yes, it's more complicated than that in the actual methodology in reality, there's likely some debatable things like hedonic adjustment and a real question over what the index should track, but the general idea seems sound. this post seems to suggest that CPI is based on some kind of longitudinal household survey methodology weighted for how much individual households consume over time, and that statisticians and economists are simpletons fooled by basic household budget substitution effects as prices and consumption patterns shift. CPI becomes "a load of crap". But the error seems to be in the original post's incorrect misunderstanding of how CPI is actually calculated. and the actual method is somewhat closer to his suggested base-item method.
- silisili 5y agoI'm not an economist. I am a consumer, though. And I'm older, so I have 'habits' that don't tend to change. My rent has gone up 30%. What used to cost me 100 something in groceries now regularly goes into the 200s. I'm nothing if not an observationalist, but this CPI is horse dung. For someone like my family, I wouldn't believe any number less than 20%. The sad thing is, I've never talked to a single friend or family member that said otherwise. So what is the government reporting?
- smnrchrds 5y ago20% over a year or a decade? If it is the former, what has the average annual inflation been over the past, let's say 30 years, in your opinion?
- silisili 5y agoYear. I think inflation was pretty steady up until about 2019. Then it went insane. If I had to pick an average, 3 or 4% until aforementioned year.
- nappy 5y agoYou live in a different part of the country than almost anyone else. The goods you buy, even in your area, can vary significantly. If you're trying to buy a gallon of milk, things aren't so different. A car, yeah that's gotten pricey. But your anecdotal experience is no reason to doubt the statistics on what is happening broadly.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mjevans 5y agoIt used to be a slow creep you noticed, but kind of grumbled at... In the last 2 years it's _noticeable_ and painful.
- omgitsabird 5y ago
- dominotw 5y agowhat i dont understand is how are workers who are quiting managing to get by.
- XorNot 5y agoPeople keep interpreting this as "they're just not working!" whereas the actual answer is much closer to "people have utterly lost their tolerance for terrible bosses, and 'worker shortage' means there's plenty of ability to shop around".
- smt88 5y agoThe majority of retail and restaurant workers who quit have gone into white-collar administrative jobs.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rsj_hn 5y agoCurious, where are you getting your data?
- Jensson 5y agoWhy didn't they do that before the pandemic?
- Sargos 5y agoThe upgraded unemployment payments might have acted as a sort of UBI that gave those looking to change careers or get a better position time to plan, learn, and complete the long and arduous process. Having a buffer lets people focus on what's important for them and this pandemic gave nearly everyone more time and, for some, the means to safely take the next step.
- smt88 5y ago1. I doubt there is one answer that applies to everyone. 2. I don't know, and I doubt anyone else does either at the moment. My guess is that it was a combination of issues: - more time, freedom, and money to look for a new job - worsening treatment of workers - vicious cycle of turnover leading to burnout leading to more turnover - increased demand for low-skill white-collar jobs as services (especially technology) boomed - continued urbanization, forcing low-wage workers to move away from urban jobs and into remote work
- jeffwilcox 5y agoA majority of the businesses we visit have "closed bathrooms for COVID-19 safety"... so much savings opportunity!
- LeonM 5y agoHotels I have visited recently have all stopped cleaning rooms, due to "COVID-19 safety". But, when you request so at the reception, they will clean it (fresh towels is nice when you stay a week). Don't get me wrong, I think this is actually smart, because most guest don't need to have their room cleaned every day. This is a massive cost saver for hotels. However, you'd expect prices to go down by this cost saving measure, but instead, they have gone up. Less service, higher prices.
- jb1991 5y ago> This is a massive cost saver for hotels. It's also good eco-sense in a world that is weary of climate change risks. Even before the pandemic, I usually opted-out of daily room cleaning.
- atom_arranger 5y agoI've always felt cynical about the "save water" flyers all over hotels. If they really want me to choose to save water they should offer a discount if I decline the service.
- jb1991 5y agoThe fact that their profit margins might increase if you decline cleaning service doesn’t change the fact that declining cleaning service is still a nice choice for the environment.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI never wanted someone coming into my room in the first place. I can clean it myself, and it does not get dirty anyway in a few days.
- Rinum 5y agoCPI includes many loss leaders, e.g. milk and bananas. So is it really fair to benchmark inflation off of the retail prices of those items if the retailer is losing increasingly more money on them while making up for it on other inflated/shrinkflated goods?
- ACow_Adonis 5y agowhy wouldn't it be appropriate? whatever the profit/loss on individual retailer's books, actual goods are being transferred for actual monetary prices. if the system was unsustainable, CPI would adjust just as the prices and products adjusted in the system. which is presumably almost exactly what you'd want out of a measure like CPI. CPI's job is not to determine whether a situation is profitable or sustainable.
- enos_feedler 5y agoI use to spend $30/day on car rentals and get upgrades for free. Now I spend $50/day on car rentals and get some old shit box with tons of miles that smells like stale cigarettes.
- gpapilion 5y agoHow much of this do you think is attributed to selling of car fleets during the start of the pandemic? As the rental companies tried to survive I assumed they sold down there fleets and now can’t rebuild them due to supply chain madness.
- switch007 5y agoNot much. I think it’s greed. I saw regular new car deliveries at my local Hertz over the last 6 months. They’ve not lacked inventory from what I can see for a while now
- donatj 5y agoHertz very narrowly avoided going entirely under, I think it’s probably a force other than greed while they’re here clawing to life.
- switch007 5y agoThey’re in a good position now supposedly after shedding a lot of debt (nice Tesla order they placed recently eh). They exited bankruptcy in June.
- enos_feedler 5y agoA big factor for sure. I rented a car in Sept 2020 and was surprised to see no cars available when nobody was traveling. Usually keys are waiting for me (elite member) but had to wait line (!!!) to get a clean car _at the airport_. However, I think this shows there is a lot of room for both price movement and QoS movements down, and consumers just shrugging it off.
- 5y ago
- twofornone 5y agoHow could there possibly not be massive inflation given the amount of money that we've printed in the last two years? And the current administration is using these completely misleading inflation numbers to justify even more spending on ready bloated and unsustainable social programs [0]- all while failing to secure the border and expanding the pool of spending recipients. This is effectively a tax on the native middle class - and apparently a big one. I did not consent to any of this; did you? 0. https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.nbcnews.com/think/amp/ncna1261838 https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.nbcnews.com/think/amp/ncna1...
- Proven 5y ago[dead]
- greendestiny_re 5y ago"But Cole believed that the government, while accounting for quality improvements, still failed to capture how much better products and services were getting. He didn't believe it was some sort of Illuminati conspiracy of Satan-worshipping pedophiles juicing the statistics."
- rpmisms 5y agoNext year on "Oh, Alex Jones was right again"...
- ChuckMcM 5y agoMy read on this is that it seems like the equivalent of a subtweet about pay inequality. If that is indeed the case then they should be arguing for something I wrote the SEC about a couple of years ago which is to have public companies report their salary costs broken down by executive pay and non-executive management pay and non-executive non-management pay. And to report the population of individuals in each cohort. That 'pie' of payroll costs can be split up anyway a company chooses, but the weighting of it will allow investors to understand the future prospects of a company that under pays its rank and file relative to its executives and management.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y ago> non-executive management pay and non-executive non-management pay. I'm curious why you make a distinction between managers and non-managers - (though I get where you're coming from: I agree that at most companies the only way to climb upwards is into management), but in some industries there are opportunities for horizontal-promotion and other non-management promotions (for example, being an engineering technical advisor who reports directly to the CEO while having no reports of their own and having a total-comp far north of a normal IC eng) Oh, then there's also companies like law-firms where lawyer partners in the firm aren't necessarily managers nor executives either, so I'm not sure how that would be fairly reported to represent the state of the income distribution.
- ashtonkem 5y agoI think most of us in the tech field overestimate the number of jobs where a high level IC can be comped equivalent to low level management. That’s really not the norm for most jobs, and often the pay gradients into management and senior management can be very steep.
- ChuckMcM 5y agoI distinguish them because, in the US at least, pay for managers is significantly higher than it is for individual contributors and there are fewer of them. There is a further gap between executive (director and above) and non-executive management with respect to both bonuses and equity allocation.
- deepGem 5y agoSo I took a weekend off to visit another city just for the heck of it, to figure out how inflation and COVID have impacted the travel industry. I am surprised. I flew to Mumbai on a low cost airline and stayed at a 5 star property. The rates and service levels are at per-COVID levels. The flight was packed, but expensive compared to pre-COVID levels. The hotel a totally different story. The crowds are marginally thinner. On a Monday morning what would otherwise be a bustling morning at one of the flagship hotels in SoBo, there are a handful of guests. Yet the service levels are top notch, food is fabulous. So I guess companies that are hard pressed to show profits at any expense are skimping on stuff to show profits but there are others who are not sacrificing service and quality levels for profits. Though the latter are far and few. My reading is that, sadly the skimping will continue for a long long time. Once companies discover a new path to profitability, it’s very hard for them to give up on that unless there are several market and demand forces which act against the skimping. For instance, volume. Once volume picks up, there will be no option to but get rid of the skimping in order to save time. But volume picking up is a huge if. I doubt the travel and leisure volumes will ever reach pre-pandemic levels.
- santiagobasulto 5y agoEverybody is (rightfully) addressing the article and the current status, which seems to be: inflation has risen. Now, let’s discuss possible scenarios. Do you think they’d do a shock measure to reduce monetary offer and reduce inflation, highly raising interest rates? Or it’d be more gradual and we have to get used to live with inflation for the next ~5 years?
- mikewarot 5y agoIf you look at Shadow-stats, they compute the M3 money supply as about 28% more than last year[1], and that trend doesn't seem to be abating. This is likely going to end up somewhere between the Nixon shock, and World Depression I. One thing very likely to happen is that the US Dollar stops being the world's reserve currency, and we stop getting real goods in return for promises backed by the same folks who play chicken with the debt ceiling every year or so. I suspect we'll have a rough decade, and if we decide to start making our own goods, things will improve, if not, we're going to end up like England, talking about our former glory. 1 - http://www.shadowstats.com/alternate_data/money-supply-charts http://www.shadowstats.com/alternate_data/money-supply-chart...
- emodendroket 5y ago> Cole was formerly a senior economist at the Joint Economic Committee of the U.S. Congress, where he used to advise Sen. Mike Lee, R-Utah, and write official economic reports. These days he's a writer at Full Stack Economics. For most of his economics career, he says, he had believed that official government statistics actually made inflation seem worse than it really was. He had thought they didn't fully capture improvements in the quality of products and services when quantifying changes in prices. > [...] > Mismeasuring inflation has important implications. For example, it's common to hear people argue that the real, or inflation-adjusted, wage of the typical American worker has stagnated in recent decades. But if the government has been overstating inflation in its statistics, this means American workers' paychecks actually go further and living standards have gotten better than official statistics say. So this guy's been spending years saying inflation was much lower than the stats show for political reasons and now he's saying the opposite at a time when that would happen to be politically opportune. Hm.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mikewarot 5y agoMany older people saved large amounts of money in their bank accounts, and were expecting to live off the interest in their savings account once they retired. The interest they were due was effectively stolen when the central banks started giving away free money, it was a massive transfer of wealth. Many of that same generation counted on Social Security, and CPI adjustments to help save them from poverty. The CPI numbers were pushed down to keep the costs of benefits those retirees were entitled to receive artificially low. Another transfer of wealth / theft. Now the rest of the population has seen their crappy but steady wages evaporate on a whim, and will no longer settle for less than an actual living wage. A rebalancing is going to have to take place, and somehow the wealth needs to be transferred back to the working class, or things will get very violent, very quickly. Once that kicks off, our near peers will funnel weapons into the US, and a civil war will make us the latest 3rd world country.
- throw0101a 5y ago> our near peers will funnel weapons into the US The US is the arms dealer of the world. It is American weapons going into Mexico and other Latin American countries that are causing problems there. The lawful/licensed gun owners in Canada have to put up with potential bans because of the too ready availability of guns in the US that are smuggled over the border and make headlines.
- rspeele 5y agoI assume GP was talking about serious crew served weapons like artillery, MANPADS, and the like. You are correct that the US is already set in terms of small arms, with its civilian population owning more guns than all the militaries of the world combined[0]. That being said I think GP's prediction of a civil war triggered by inflation is hysteria. [0]https://www.smallarmssurvey.org/sites/default/files/resources/SAS-Infographics-global-firearms-holdings.pdf https://www.smallarmssurvey.org/sites/default/files/resource...
- czechdeveloper 5y ago> our near peers will funnel weapons into the US There are enough weapons in USA, no need for anyone to do that.
- acd 5y agoCentral bank try keep inflation at 2% by lowering interest that will in turn increase wage inflation. Systematic fault central banks has made is a) Wage inflation prize of goods is globalized in a global economy and cannot be controlled by local central banks. b) robotics, automation and startups are funded partly by loans and thus its deflationary. Ie loaning/investing in automation by loans acts deflationary not inflationary. Mix of cause and effect. Low inflation by globalization not wage inflation by low interest rate. That is why we are seeing higher inflation on locally produced goods for example hair dresser, lunch. But not so much inflation on globalized goods like Tv, electronics.
- myAccount1234 5y agoI very much like your analysis. We need to look into more details and the very different nature of things today. We are still viewing inflation as if there is one economy. But there are many different (global) markets resulting in very cheap things (e.g. from abroad - TVs) and expensive things (e.g. locally - Food). We need to add this to our view and also anticipate where these modern factors lead to: Wage stagnation, still high increase in prices for local goods + development of the "cheap goods producing countries". Last factor will also increase the prices of those goods, which could set off this time bomb (and cause the civil war mentioned).
- imtringued 5y agoImbalanced trade is one of the biggest drivers of wage stagnation. Export surplus countries must keep their wages artificially low which forces importing countries to compete by cutting their wages. I.e. low wages in Germany drag the entire EU's wage level down.
- imtringued 5y ago>b) robotics, automation and startups are funded partly by loans and thus its deflationary. Ie loaning/investing in automation by loans acts deflationary not inflationary. I actually agree but the argument is kind of funny. It would imply that we are far away from any physical constraints and that issuing more liquid credit (money) just accelerates technological progress which makes the original problem worse. I.e. unfair distribution of earning opportunities which leave some people with all the money and others with no money.
- G3rn0ti 5y ago> It's when, instead of simply raising prices, companies skimp on the goods and services they provide. This is old news. For food and beverages it’s a well known phenomenon: The average package sizes have been decreasing over time for some standard products to keep the nominal price constant. In Europe, for example, Coca Cola started to sell 250ml (8.5oz) cans a couple of years ago instead of the regular 330ml (11.2oz) ones.
- quickthrower2 5y agoThat's shrinking. Skimping would be Coca Cola diluting their product with water, or using some kind of cheaper to produce cans/bottles that are more likely to burst open.
- TheJoeMan 5y agoI would argue that changing the product itself is shrinkflation. This new skimpflation would be say removing the perforated handles on Coke cardboard cases to save money on stamping machines.
- dataexporter 5y agoYes, it is generally considered shrinkflation[1] and the author does mention that. It can be overcome by measuring unit prices for items. However, in cases like the lack of services and delays - it doesn't really capture it. I've often noticed extremely long wait times for customer service calls due to reduced staffing. These are numbers that are missed in the official CPI calculations. 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shrinkflation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shrinkflation
- h2odragon 5y ago> instead of the regular 330ml (11.2oz) ones. Soda cans used to be 12oz. and dinosaurs roamed the earth...
- janandonly 5y agoI advise everyone who is weary/untrusting of the official CPI to check out Shadowstats. http://www.shadowstats.com http://www.shadowstats.com
- pjc50 5y agoWhy is it more trustworthy, or is it just "agrees with my prejudices"?
- nootropicat 5y agoOld prediction from 2013: There will be no "collapse" the way some of these people think of it. It's not going to be like the movie "Dawn of the Dead" or whatever where one day suddenly shit hits the fan and prices skyrocket and everyone begins to riot and the SS comes marching down the street to kill everyone. There will be no "happening". It's far more insidious than that. Read the poem "The Hollow Men" by TS ELiot and you'll understand. You'll just notice that every day simple things will become a little more expensive. Everyone's homes and apartments will start to get smaller. your work hours will get longer, but your pay will decrease. You'll see family and friends less, and find that in time you care less about them. Every day you'll find yourself lowering your standards for everything: work, food, relationships, etc. Job security will no longer exist as a concept. You'll notice houses and apartments shrinking. People will start hanging on clothing longer and longer. Less people will get married, even less will have children. People will engross themselves in technological distractions and fantasy while never truly experiencing the real world. Whatever dream people used to have about what their lives were going to be will become for them a distant memory. The only thing left for them will be the reality of their debt and their poverty. And every minute of every day they will be told: "You are stupid, ugly and weak, but together we are free, prosperous and safe." That is the collapse. The reduction of the American man into a feudal serf, incapable of feeling love or hate, incapable of seeing the pitiful nature of his situation for what it is or recognizing his own self worth.
- Panzer04 5y agoIs this seriously what people think? That sounds totally nonsensical. Do people just completely forget how far we’ve come to get today? Just totally romanticise anything in the past? Get real…
- CryptoBanker 5y agoPeople “forget” the American Civil War and the Holocaust… they can forget anything if they try hard enough
- barcoder 5y agoThe mention of the deteriorating services at Disneyland reminded me of Banky's Dismaland[1] [1] http://m.artbanksy.com/dismaland.html http://m.artbanksy.com/dismaland.html
- UweSchmidt 5y agoReporting inflation is complex and the natural bias is to report it too low, so that more money can be "printed". The idea of the "Big Mac index" suggests the need for alternative metrics. Consumer organizations should get to work on this and have their index published in the media along with the official numbers.
- h2odragon 5y agoThere's several alternative infaltion indexes, but they get dismissed because of perceived bias or tribal purity.
- jwilk 5y agoText-only version: https://text.npr.org/1048892388 https://text.npr.org/1048892388
- gifnamething 5y agoDistraught that reality hasn't kept up with their predictions, inflation hawks are now writing fanfiction.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoI can't believe important government economists didn't notice it. They can't be that insulated from real life. This "skimpflation" is everywhere around us. It's one of the most frequent sources of complaints on this site. And it's not just about services, but also products. Everything is made with increasingly worse components, to worse quality standards. Value engineered to the point of barely being usable. And then some. The other day we had a perfect example of this in the space of kitchen toys[0]. Few weeks earlier, the world learned that HDD manufacturers replace components of their products with cheaper/worse ones as months go on, without changing the product name. What I remember from this is learning that it's not them, it's everyone, everywhere, all the time. Replacing components without changing the SKU. Making worse quality versions of the same product, with the same name/model number, dedicated for Black Friday sales. Etc. I guess I'm glad to know someone up there in US GOV is finally noticing. EDIT: I'm even more surprised about the whole discussion thread focusing around various indicators and anecdotes from the last two years. I think we should focus on how things were evolving in the years before COVID-19, because the pandemic kind of thrown the whole economy into a disarray, but the underlying causes of hidden forms of inflation were present for much longer than that. -- [0] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29048819 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29048819
- edem 5y ago[This video][0] explains it. Basically they have all sorts of math tricks to make you believe that inflation is OK. I think the problem is not the FED. The problem is the people who let the FED get away with this __fraud__. [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uhzK9YhrtEU&ab_channel=GeorgeGammon https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uhzK9YhrtEU&ab_channel=Georg...
- lumost 5y agoI'm starting to suspect that any single measure of inflation is pretty meaningless. I'll grant that the CPI measures some kind of inflation, and I'll grant that the Fed does keep CPI in check. I don't think CPI captures the the typical inflation that I see in housing, education, and other costs over the last 10 years. I don't think CPI is capturing the cost increases in food and other goods over the last 2 years. I think we need some additional measures of CPI which capture "opportunity cost inflation", "basic goods inflation", and "non-productive asset inflation". It's easy to claim substitution for city center housing by living further away from the city, or moving to a tier-2/tier-3 city - but this also comes with the opportunity cost of jobs. Similar claims can be made for deferring education/medical costs or choosing cheaper alternatives. Opportunity costs add up over prolonged periods of time. A generation who had to substitute out high quality opportunities due to inflation will eventually be poorer for it.
- _Understated_ 5y agoAs an anecdote, in 2013 I "measured" inflation as it affected me. By this I mean the things I buy like petrol, food, utilities, insurance etc. I looked at bank statements from 2011 and 2012 and compared them to the 2013 bank statements. It wasn't 100% accurate as a couple of things changed but it was definitely close enough to be applicable. In 2013 I was paying out 13% more for roughly the same stuff yet the official government figure was was less than 3% per annum. So my own inflation in that two year period was twice what the government said it should be. In short, it doesn't surprise me that they're talking shit about inflation! High inflation won't win you an election. I haven't checked 2021 vs 2019/2020 yet but I will in January 2022... although, I may not want to :(
- gaze 5y agoThen tax the money out of circulation. The solution is obvious. You might start with the segment of the population who hasn’t been paying their taxes.
- ODILON_SATER 5y agoI would recommend this small article by economist John Cochrane <a href="https://johnhcochrane.blogspot.com/2021/10/supply.html">https://johnhcochrane.blogspot.com/2021/10/supply.html</a> https://johnhcochrane.blogspot.com/2021/10/supply.html">http.... The corporate media in general is very quick on this one calling it a transitory inflation. I am not sure that's case. We may be in for a bad stretch. Supply-side inflation can be very damaging and hard to fix, especially when the government is pushing a stimulus bill that, not only does not address the issue, it will potentially make it worse by throwing even more sand in the gears of the supply chain. People should plan accordingly.
- jacknews 5y agoI agree that 'hedonic value' should be tracked, but it has no place in inflation calculations, IMHO. For example, let's say I enjoy a fast-food burger, a BK whopper. It costs, for sake of argument $4. Now suppose, BK add some extra pickles, sauce and a bigger burger across their range, but up the price of a whopper to $4.50. But, with a hedonic adjustment, the burger still only costs $4, since the $4.50 price rise is 'fake news' as it includes extra burger, etc. Because this adjustment is included in the inflation figures, my next wage review will reflect the fact that I can still get 'just as much burger' for the same price as last year. But the reality of course is that I have to pay more for the same 'level' of burger, even though it got better. IMHO, Inflation figures should reflect the cost of inhabiting various social levels, and average those. The overall material quality of life of a society should be an entirely separate metric, probably a replacement for GDP which is quite flawed.
- Dylan16807 5y agoI feel like the vast majority of products you're buying are either bulk purchases or have versions at many many price points, making them immune to this effect.
- oliwarner 5y agoAnother anecdote for the pile. Our weekly shops have gone from £130 to £190 over the past couple of months with little appreciable difference in content. All our friends have noticed similar. Some have had to change their shopping habits to make ends meet. I don't understand how RPI and CPI inflation markers aren't reflecting this but this a trend we're not going to be able to afford much longer.
- deathanatos 5y agoThe article reminds me of one of my recent experiences flying. The airline (SWA) cancelled our connection. As in, they still flew us half-way, but allowed the connection to leave, stranding everyone on the connection. We were only marginally delayed, and even the most short-sighted analysis of "which of these is costlier" would have told you that cancelling the connection was dumb. But airlines treat weather as 100% unpredictable events, and so… They offered to give us a voucher for a hotel, since they were stranding us overnight. We had to call a number for the voucher to make the hotel reservation. They guy on the line: "I'm sorry, I need to know where you are. I don't have a 'Saint Louis Airport' in my system." I'm, of course, sitting in Saint Louis at the time. I gave him the IATA code, and "Ah, Lambert International!" so that was annoying. But then the "discount". We arrived at the hotel, and they initially didn't want to give us the discount, despite there also somehow being a reservation in their system? "We don't offer that discount." Well, okay, that's nice, and not my problem. After negotiating the discount back into existence, between me and the hotel clerk also then realized that my AAA membership was a better discount. I just want to give money, and receive flight. Weather is fine, but lately it hasn't been weather cancelling my flights, but mismanagement & "oh, we don't have a crew for your flight" or "uh, we don't have a plane". These really ought to be full refunds + you still deliver carriage, so that these failures get rectified. There are increasingly more and more examples I find like this, where I as a consumer cannot acquire the good or service I want at any price: I'm settling for a high price and a very substandard product or service.
- ALee 5y agoI wonder how much of this labor is a choice between online labor versus choosing not to work retail where the profit is a lot lower, meaning your take-home is equal to your costs. Let's assume that you can make a reasonable living in a different part of town instead of commuting to a service sector job. Add on top of that, you get to control your hours and there also seems to be more and more foot traffic in that part of town. As you start moving to that part of town, you realize that it's so much closer to your work that you save money on transportation and you have free time to pursue investing or other ways to better yourself. I don't think we would ever have issues with labor moving to better parts of town, right? The only issue is that this better part of town is the internet. I wonder if the larger long-standing effects of COVID were an experiment on the general population that they could make money outside of what they've been told.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jklinger410 5y agoCombine skimplation with wealth inequality and lowered product quality and you will begin to see how far gone we are. Imagine, like global warming, if certain people knew that massive inflation was occurring, but that a correction would slow down their profits. Then imagine, like global warming, those people spent all of their time disguising this reality rather than trying to fix it. We're pretty far into the grift at this point.