24 ms·
Nobody Really Knows How the Economy Works. A Fed Paper Is the Latest Sign
- yamrzou 5y agoDon't central banks know enough to be able to set the monetary policy appropriately?
- bullen 5y agoThe "economy" runs on fusion. http://sprout.rupy.se/article?id=210 http://sprout.rupy.se/article?id=210
- pdonis 5y agoThis is supposed to be a new discovery?
- lvl100 5y agoI think this is more or less aimed at macroeconomics. And to be frank, macro and monetary economics are mostly bullshit. And you really don’t need these top down policies when we are capable of facilitating demand at an individual level. Yes, we have the tools and tech to do that today but we also have extremely slow government and extremely powerful cluster of people trying to keeps things at status quo. In other words, not in my lifetime.
- amelius 5y agoThe biggest problem is people (an entire profession) claiming to know how the economy works.
- goatlover 5y agoDo economists really claim that? Or do they study economic behavior and try to make predictive models to better their understanding? It seems like the general public misunderstands what economists do, and the misunderstanding is due to ideological/political reasons.
- smackeyacky 5y agoIts the poor record of predictive ability that damns economics and economists.
- cottager2 5y agoEconomists definitely claim to know how things work. I vividly remember reading neo-liberal gospel (the economic theory, not political leaning) in the NYT opinion section written by Paul Krugman 10 years ago. Allowing completely free trade will be great he said. Prices will be lowered and the economy will run more efficiently. Maybe that’s true, but it also hollowed out the U.S. manufacturing base and consequently the middle class. You don’t see articles like that anymore.
- paganel 5y agoIt was the same in Europe and things have changed, it's true, nowadays you have the US officials close to the president quoted with: > Biden official says protecting US steel a national security issue [1] on the front page of the Financial Times. [1] https://www.ft.com/content/e1f33362-2c36-4f99-9b11-7dcd82ee7c06 https://www.ft.com/content/e1f33362-2c36-4f99-9b11-7dcd82ee7...
- G3rn0ti 5y ago> Maybe that’s true, but it also hollowed out the U.S. manufacturing base and consequently the middle class. Citation needed. Edit: Just as a counter point consider reading this article: https://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-schiller-shrinking-middle-class-20190131-story.html https://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-schiller-shrinki...
- TrispusAttucks 5y ago[1] China really is to blame for millions of lost U.S. manufacturing jobs, new study finds [1] https://www.marketwatch.com/amp/story/china-really-is-to-blame-for-millions-of-lost-us-manufacturing-jobs-new-study-finds-2018-05-14 https://www.marketwatch.com/amp/story/china-really-is-to-bla...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- heresie-dabord 5y agoEconomics is extremely useful as a form of employment for economists. -- Galbraith
- amelius 5y agoYes, but my point goes further than that.
- imtringued 5y agoIndeed, the thing we call economy is changing all the time. Economics try to explain how the economy works that's not the same as being 100% sure.
- ur-whale 5y ago> Economics try to explain how the economy works This is a common mistake. Explaining how things work is entirely useless (unless all you're interested in is feeling good about yourself). The only thing that matters for a so-called scientific discipline (which economists claim to be, but really aren't) is its predictive power. If "explaining how things works" actually produces something that has predictive power, then yes, you've got something. If all it does is produce explanations of what happened after the fact, what you have is intellectual masturbation.
- williamtrask 5y agohttps://archive.is/v0ifa https://archive.is/v0ifa
- roenxi 5y agoThe Fed employs some very clever people. They never believed that public fears of inflation tend to be self-fulfilling. They "believed" officially because if they didn't then their policy would be reckless, and pointing out the rather obvious reality like this Rudd bloke is doing might well be bad for a career. The logic is like saying we would all get a pony if we believed hard enough. Economics doesn't work that way, there is an underlying reality that people are trying to sniff out and some error bars around where prices end up because the signals are all noisy.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> never believed that public fears of inflation tend to be self-fulfilling Inflation expectations being self fulfilling is the entire reason we measure the former.
- recursivedoubts 5y agoThe Federal Reserve's job is to keep the banking system afloat, w/ the big banks functioning and well fed. And they do a good job of it. Everything else in "the economy" is incidental.
- debo_ 5y agoI hope "well fed" was an intentional pun!
- HPsquared 5y agoNot underfed or overfed.
- nabla9 5y agoTo be clear, that's your (somewhat cynical) opinion of what their job is. I assume that you think Fed is cynical and sinister organization. Their offical job description is. "maximum employment, stable prices, and moderate long-term interest rates." (aka the so called dual mandate).
- jrochkind1 5y agoIf you want to be cynical about it, I don't think that's even cynical enough. How about: Optimize between maximizing profits of the rich and minimizing chance of social disorder or rebellion from the poor being too numerous and too miserable.
- dageshi 5y agoA quote from a book by Terry Pratchett that springs to mind... "They think they want good government and justice for all, Vimes, yet what is it they really crave, deep in their hearts? Only that things go on as normal and tomorrow is pretty much like today." I've often wondered if for the majority in a lot of societies, that isn't essentially true.
- 5y ago
- nabla9 5y ago"Nobody knows" is too simplistic a take. Nobody knows when they don't know anymore is more accurate. A better way to describe the situation is that most mainstream established macroeconomic theories/models work only conditionally. They match reality accurately only in certain periods, on the condition that myriad of other factors doesn't become important. Over time, some excluded variables become important. The explanatory power of the old model erodes. When the theory is finalized and explains the situation for the era it was created, it may be already outdated. Inflation expectations theory works reasonably well for fast growth, increasing labor force industrial era. It's not so good in 2% annual GPD growth, aging or slowly growing labor force era. The new school of economists thinks that that inflation is not likely to be a long-term problem. Fed will be back in trying to get inflation up in 1-2 years. Old school economists who look at the older models and data from 50-90s think that expectations will keep inflation going once it starts.
- csours 5y agoTo emphasize: people can describe the rules that governed the economy of the past. Problems: Companies and people are constantly changing how they do business to best exploit the economy. This can change how things work in large and small ways - every financial disaster leads to a raft of rule changes.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- _wldu 5y agoYep. Economists and meteorologists. What they try to predict is sort of like trying to predict where the disc will land in Plinko [1]. Neither of them have a clue until it actually happens... "Our models showed the disc going the other way (especially the European Model), but we were wrong again. Tune in tomorrow while we talk fast and act confident again." [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_The_Price_Is_Right_pricing_games#Plinko https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_The_Price_Is_Right_pri...
- fulafel 5y agoMeteorologists have it easy, because weather doesn't react to the forecast and modify its behaviour to invalidate it.
- shrimp_emoji 5y agoSelf-aware weather with neurosis...
- cubano 5y agoPersonally, I always love the "50% chance of rain" forecast as it perfectly describes that they have no idea if its going to rain or not, but yet sounds so scientific and official.
- posco 5y agoPredicting 50% can be validated: if I say a coin will be heads 50% of the time, I know more than nothing: I know more than someone who incorrectly claims it will be heads 75% of the time. And we can quantify in various ways how much better the 50% prediction is than the 75% prediction.
- Stratoscope 5y agoThat's actually not what "50% chance of rain" means. Here's a pretty good explanation: https://www.wsfa.com/2019/08/23/what-does-chance-rain-really-mean/ https://www.wsfa.com/2019/08/23/what-does-chance-rain-really... And many more: https://www.google.com/search?q=50%25+chance+of+rain https://www.google.com/search?q=50%25+chance+of+rain
- nkurz 5y agoI applaud the New York Times for prominently linking to the full paper from the article. In case anyone missed the link: https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/feds/files/2021062pap.pdf https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/feds/files/2021062pap...
- Dudeman112 5y agoI wholeheartedly agree. Publishing a news article about sciencey stuff without providing the bloody citation should be a crime.
- gjs278 5y agothank you dan g and the other worthless mods for auto collapsing this thread. god forbid I decide what to read myself, your hints are once again useless
- sokoloff 5y agoI know you’re being hyperbolic there, but if I take it at face value, I’m left wondering if that would pass First Amendment protections. I suspect most such policies would be in violation of 1A.
- shkkmo 5y agoI see a pretty obvious argument that this would be a content neutral regulation that serves the public good.
- sokoloff 5y agoYes, I see that argument as well. 1A doesn’t say “Congress may pass laws abridging the freedom of the press only when they serve the public good” but has rather stricter/broader prohibitions.
- shkkmo 5y agoIf you study the history of US case law you will see "content neutral" [0] regulation that "serves a public good" is often used as part of the standard to decide when the US government is allowed to restrict speech. [0] https://mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/937/content-neutral https://mtsu.edu/first-amendment/article/937/content-neutral The "content neutral" part is really important because it is what allows a huge range of government regulations that ideally are equally applied to everyone regardless of how popular a message is. The "public good" part is a portion of showing that a speech limiting regulation is narrowly tailored enough to achieve that public good without unnecessarily hampering speech. Regardless of what you think about the validity of these court decisions, there is reasonable precedent to think that such a law would survive a 1A challenge.
- mvanaltvorst 5y agoThe minute we have solved AGI, will we have solved economics as well? I would imagine that if you just pit 100,000 smart agents against each other with a virtual currency you could calculate the ideal government policies to maximise welfare.
- ashleyn 5y agoNo, because as long as scarcity exists, there's going to be winners and losers - and losers will not be happy being selected as the losers. Whether it's by a bureau or by machine.
- scoopdewoop 5y agoScarcity is largely artificial, but ok
- rybosworld 5y agoThe earths resources are finite, no?
- imtringued 5y agoThe assumption is that the population is finite as well. I don't know how things are going to end.
- djbebs 5y agoNo it isn't
- imtringued 5y agoThere is artificial scarcity of jobs, i.e. employment opportunities. Think about how in a recession people lose their job even though they want to pay rent and buy food. It's because the remaining full time jobs pile up on fewer people. This results in a downward spiral as people without incomes can't spend and those with incomes become cautious and save instead of spending their money. Let's say the maslow hierarchy ranks needs according how productive they are with shelter and food at the bottom being the most productive and social needs at the top being the least productive. By that logic we should be employing people according to their needs to achieve high productivity in the economy. If you have two employees and fire one the economy will shift away from the productive part of the economy to the less productive part because the second employee is no longer able to buy food. Income welfare exists for this very reason. To take the surplus of the first employee and reallocate it to food and rent. If we had "job welfare" then we would take the jobs and spread them out over more people. Instead of, "oh you want to eat? too bad we won't let you work" it's "you eat, you work"
- mattmcknight 5y agoCan't read the NYT article, but the headline is a bit of a misstatement. It should be, "nobody can fully control or predict the results of how the market economy works". The source paper gets deeply into the work of Lucas, but misses the foundational nature of the Lucas Critique [1] (and Campbell's law, et cetera) in the effectiveness of economic policymaking. One challenge with setting fixed policy boundaries, particularly those based on fuzzy things like expectations, is that the reporting on the expectations affects the expectations. It's as if when the meteorologist predicts rain, people take some protective actions, that reduce the chances of rain. Thus, predictions of the effects of policy must take into account the predicted reactions to the policy. But if people know that policy is being constructed to already take into account the expected reactions, this will again affect their reactions, so policy needs to be adjusted to take into account these second order reactions, and so on. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucas_critique https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lucas_critique
- rossdavidh 5y agoWhen I'm considering how much to ask for (or demand) in pay, I'm not primarily thinking about inflation. I'm thinking about the supply and demand for my type of labor. If I think I could get more, but inflation is low, that doesn't stop me from asking for more. If I think there's a labor surplus right now, but inflation is high, I am nonetheless unlikely to walk out in search of higher wages. Similar logic, I expect, applies to the boss side of things.
- smt88 5y agoAlmost no one thinks about supply and demand when negotiating for a job. Most workers have little sense of demand for their position, and even if they did, most jobs are not fungible. Location is extremely important, as are subjective things like culture and the brand of the employer. All that to say: the Econ 101 conception of supply and demand in the labor market is almost never enough to explain the labor market even in very simple terms. That's why the labor market is often doing "unexpected" things, like having trouble filling high-paid jobs driving trucks.
- rossdavidh 5y agoIf I'm getting a lot of recruiter emails, I know demand is high. If I get emails from former coworkers looking for news of job openings, I know supply is high. I think I'm not too unusual in that regard.
- smt88 5y agoYou are unusual in that regard. Most workers are blue-collar and don't get recruited.
- rossdavidh 5y agoTrue, in that case it would be, "do I see lots of 'Now Hiring' signs around town?" Which, currently in Austin, TX, USA where I live, I do. Sometimes more specific, at construction sites, wanting specific trades.
- freeduck 5y agoThe simple idea of you print more money therefore each dollar, euro... has less value, therefore inflation. Works for me
- imtringued 5y ago1 Apple = $1 I borrow $100 from the bank which creates $100. I buy seeds and plant trees. I sell 100 Apples to pay the loan back. Did the value of the dollar go down? No it didn't. This is how the supply of money can go up much faster than inflation.
- kazen44 5y agoin the end though, a dollar, euro or whatever is just a abstract unit which represents hours of labour spend. Inflation is making the hours worked in the past worth less, and forces people to spend their money early to get maximum effectiveness out of their work. From a labourer's perspective, inflation is making the results from work done in the past worth less, while those who have the means to take risks can negate these negative side effects.
- freeduck 5y agowhat does the labourer's perspective have to do with anything. if there are a 100 dollars today and tomorrow there are 200. a dollars worth is halved right? or? Got some secret insight on supply demand, that the general public is unaware of? I would sooo like to know :-)
- slavboj 5y agoGlad the NYT / federal reserve board have caught up with points from 1920s tier von Mises & Hayek.
- etherael 5y agoShhhh, if they notice their ideas are already held by their opposition they'll never accept them.
- JamisonM 5y ago"For example, when inflation has been low in the recent past, workers might not demand raises as they would in a world where inflation was high; after all, their existing paychecks go pretty much as far as they used to. You don’t need some theory involving inflation expectations to get there." Isn't what is described here /actually/ a theory about inflation expectations? Literally this mechanism that recent inflation creates the expectation of more inflation and that drives behaviour that generates further inflation.. and no one is sure how to turn that back around without a crushing recession. Isn't that the conventional wisdom this article is allegedly skewering?
- bo1024 5y agoI think the point of that quote is people reacting only to the present and the past. I.e. not any beliefs (expectations) about the future.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 5y agoCracking down hard on rent seeking parasites would go a long way to reduce costs in healthcare, housing, and the automotive industry.
- salawat 5y agoAnd... Welcome to a bunch of layoffs from rent seeking parasite industries while all the fat cats try to park their capital somewhere else ahead of the regulatory crackdown curve. The problem is centralization of wealth, absurd expectations on the returns of capital, and the coupled wage theft that enables those returns, popularized by an entire generation of Welch worshippers, and skewed expectations created by export of production, and increasing reliance on safe-harbor third world labor prices. It's all way more interconnected than it looks.
- imtringued 5y agoAs wealth inequality rises there are more people who have no idea what to do with their wealth and more people who have ideas but no wealth. According to Dirk Löhr the biggest driver of wealth inequality is just good old real estate and it's mostly the land that appreciated in value. Chasing land rents (I mean speculation on rising land values, not renting out apartments as a landlord) feels wholly unproductive.
- echopurity 5y agoAnybody who claims to "know how the economy works" definitely does not know how the economy works. It's pretty sad that one economist pointing this out is a big deal. It's the result of echo chambers like HN.
- akinity 5y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20211003121747/https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/01/upshot/inflation-economy-analysis.html https://web.archive.org/web/20211003121747/https://www.nytim...
- fallingfrog 5y agoI would love to see economics reparameterized in terms of it being a social network, with nodes and links, and then trying to measure how much the network is clustered or more un-clustered, the power relations between central and peripheral nodes (rulers and workers), and how that affects total network efficiency and how that affects inequality. And how resources flow between nodes and how when network connections break (people lose jobs or other business relationships) it can cascade through the network, and how the clusteredness affects how much and how fast it cascades. That is probably where the business cycle comes from imho. It just seems like nobody is looking at the problem from the right perspective. Then once you have a model with realistic qualitative behaviors- once you can identify the important variables like clusteredness and inequality, identify constraints and artificial forcings like government programs, then you can try to measure those variables in the real world and you might be able to make some near term projections that have actual predictive power. You could also make some predictions of how new government programs will impact things you care about like total productivity, how precarious or robust each individual's situation might be (do people have second chances or do they collapse into homelessness after one bad decision or accident), what the baseline economic outcome is (do we have people starving), etc. Right now I really don't feel like the state of the field of economics is advanced to the point where anybody is able to apply economics to problems we care about in any kind of rigorous way. After the fact you can always find some economist that will say "I predicted this" but you can also find 99 others who didn't predict it. And the people who get put in charge of the federal reserve are always one of the other 99. In fact I get the distinct impression that nobody in a position of power actually cares whether economics produces reliable intelligence. After the year 2000 bubble, after the financial collapse, nobody in a position of authority at that moment should have ever held a government job again. But yet here we are. (Same thing goes with the people who said that the Iraq war would pay for itself and that Afghanistan would be quick and easy- why do those people still have jobs?? But that's a tangent.) We are so used to catastrophic incompetence that we can't imagine any other situation.
- satellite2 5y agoIt think that's why most central banks are showing interest in distributed ledgers for traditional currencies, so that the flow of cash actually become visible. Basically it is well known that the economy is a gigantic graph and that graph theory might help answer fundamental questions about it. The issue is that you need a massive amount of data to have a somewhat accurate model. The central banks do have some data (none on cash tough) as banks have some reporting requirements but generally those data are available only in aggregate and in economics (or basically any forecasting activity) the devil is in the details.
- tombert 5y agoThis feels like one of those "and water is wet" type posts. I can't stand basically any political commentary anymore, at least in regards to economics. It feels like everyone has "simple" solutions to the best way to solve every economic problem, and it doesn't really seem like the economy can easily be reduced to a ten second Fox News soundbyte.
- andy_ppp 5y agoIsn’t it just as simple as there is a supply of money that everyone is chasing that expands forever if governments let it. If it stops expanding governments cause recessions if it expands more people get richer but this leads to everyone getting really scared there is too much money (debt) and so people start doing things to repay the money supply causing a recession. It can’t possibly be this simple so governments need to pretend it’s much more complex than that and that their tough stewardship of the economy is going to save the day.
- geoduck14 5y ago^^^This, but add in a bag of weasels and I'm pretty sure we got it figured out.
- imtringued 5y agoI don't see 2% inflation as some kind of evil thing. The problem is that things like automation reduce the need to work by some degree so people get to work less but employment tends to pile up on fewer people. People don't measure prosperity by how much wealth their work produces. They measure prosperity by how much their job pays. It's employment that decides everything. Since work has become a social activity people actually like to work more than they demand work themselves. So people compete for fewer and fewer full time jobs as productivity rises. Here is my explanation. 8 people work at a restaurant and spend 5 hours out of 40 per week making pasta. Someone invents a pasta machine. So now everyone gets to work 35 hours. The boss decides to fire one worker so that the remaining employees work full time again. Everyone is competing desperately to not end up as the last guy without a job. Full employment in this scenario would require people to eat the additional pasta (=consume more) that the machine produces. If you truly believed that the 8th person would find a better job then it wouldn't matter if you fire them or not. In fact, if you create a new full time job that needs 40 hours of work, then all 8 restaurant employees would apply at your company because they know they get to work 5 hours more. The best out of 8 would be chosen for the new job. One person leaves the restaurant, resulting in full employment of the 7 restaurant workers. Meanwhile if you just fire a random restaurant worker then it is entirely possible that one of the 7 employed workers is switching jobs and the unemployed worker has to get back to work at the restaurant. It's quite inefficient.
- imtringued 5y agoI like the headline. Nobody really knows how the economy works. Economics is an attempt to explain how wealth and prosperity are created. That also means some branches are biased towards what we already have. It gets especially bad when morality is used because from the perspective of something as uncaring as an economy there are no meaningful morals, they are all made up. I personally think the vast majority of economic problems are caused by modeling errors. The model we use to look at the real economy is too rigid to represent it. The laziest way to explain the rigidities is to just blame someone else, most of the time governments. However, getting rid of goverments doesn't seem to get rid of all rigidity because, as it turns out, our physical world is constrained by more than just politics. What's often forgotten is that governments can also fight against natural forces that reduce flexibility in the economy. Therefore the answer is neither more government or less government. No it's the usual boring answer. What we need is better governments. It's like a supply and demand situation. There is demand for a certain size of government and the supply is often either too high or too low. The goal is to find a balance.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Economics is an attempt to explain how wealth and prosperity are created To expand on the question's unknowability, "wealth" and "prosperity" are measures on a population's utility functions. "Utility" is an attempt at mapping the set of possible things a person could want to an ordered set [1]. This goes to the heart of preference, free will and consciousness. Fortunately, at a population level, persistent effects do manifest. But we don't know why. Because at the individual level, they're inexplicable (if existent at all). This is why, by the way, economics often finds inspiration in particle physics. Not because people are particles. But because it's a field that has developed techniques and methods that make useful population-level predictions without completely understanding the individual components. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Utility
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoFraming the question as one of "more" or "less" government seems to contain an implicit assumption about the value of government itself. The value of any government. It assumes all government is qualitatively the same. Hence the only question is whether we should have more or less. Whether that is a reasonable assumption to make is left as a question for the reader.
- paulpauper 5y agoIt is vivid evidence that macroeconomics, despite the thousands of highly intelligent people over centuries who have tried to figure it out, remains, to an uncomfortable degree, a black box. The ways that millions of people bounce off one another — buying and selling, lending and borrowing, intersecting with governments and central banks and businesses and everything else around us — amount to a system so complex that no human fully comprehends it. Still not harder than modern physics or modern math. Unknowable is not the same as complicated. The lottery is easy to play and model mathematically but unknowable. It's not that hard to understand: an economy is a set of inputs: govt. spending, personal consumption, innovation, private investment, etc. and then based on these inputs the economy either grows or shrinks, and then this can be indexed to some baseline such as CPI. The understanding of this stuff dates back to the 50s. Just because recessions cannot be predicted does not mean the economy is a black box.
- andrepd 5y agoMuch to the contrary, it is much much much harder than any system in fundamental physics. The economy (like the weather, or cells) is a much more complex system than a black hole or a hadron. Furthermore, it actually has a peculiarity unique to studying systems of humans (as does psychology or sociology): predictions about the system affect the system, which makes it even more difficult to distinguish true predictions from self-fulfiling prophecies.
- mahogany 5y agoI agree -- as a "former mathematician", I find economics to be much more daunting than math, and I'm skeptical about anyone who has more than a modicum of certainty about it. Modern mathematics is certainly complex, but there are definitive axioms that are nearly universally agreed-upon, and proofs operate on logic alone. It's like a hard game with known rules. Are there definitive axioms in economics that apply to the real world with irrational actors? As you say, I think the key component that introduces all the uncertainty is: humans. You can't prove anything interesting about a human-based system using pure logic (at least not that I'm aware of). I'm reminded of the quote by Von Neumann: "If people do not believe that mathematics is simple, it is only because they do not realize how complicated life is." But I will be the first to admit that my economics understanding is shallow. I'm curious: what are examples of theorems or definitive truths in economics that we know apply to the real world with real humans?
- qqtt 5y agoAlong similar lines, nobody "really knows" how Google search works. Sure, you have some experts who can talk about how parts of the algorithm work, you have the underlying bones of page rank, you even have SEO experts who can get you reasonably close to the top search results. But is there a single individual on earth who knows all the ins and outs of all the minutiae of every single aspect of Google search - from search result algorithm to ingestion to crawling to artificial intelligence? Not a chance. You don't even have to get as complicated as Google search - any reasonably complex software system with hundreds of engineers working on it will be beyond the comprehension of any human being - fully understanding that is (which also entails knowing exactly all the edge cases, all the bugs, all the unexpected results possible, etc.) How does the economy work? Nobody knows - but that doesn't mean nothing intelligent can be said about it, or that the Fed can't make reasonable decisions on imperfect information - just like any other incredibly complex system that humans struggle to understand.
- jawarner 5y agoI don’t know. Google search is an engineered system, but the economy is an emergent system.
- _xnmw 5y agoThis is a really bad analogy. We can understand Google Search far, far better than the economy. Google itself is just one small part of the economy. We can test hypotheses, run concrete tests in seconds, and we have SEO experts which can reasonably reliably get you to the top in a few months. There is no equivalent for the economy. We can't run macro-scale real-world tests. Hypotheses are basically unverifiable.
- omegalulw 5y agoSoftware (and economy) get big and complex due to emergent properties that arise from base rules. This is why, for most large projects, no one _needs_ to know the entirety and all the edge case to make modifications and improvements, you focus on base rules and build off from there. For software that would be individual components and whatever invariants you have set up. And then you you build off of these to reason at higher levels. Attempting to know the whole thing at once "and all the edge cases" is quite wasteful.
- seiferteric 5y agoWould also explain why centrally planned economies probably don't work as well and will be less dynamic.
- newaccount2021 5y ago90% of central planning is having a central bank. That's pulled form a quote from Lenin btw. In much of its early history, the Soviet economy outperformed many other leading industrial economies, which is what scared capitalists in the West so profoundly in the 1930s. It did so at a great and terrible cost that would be unacceptable in a free society, but it performed nonetheless. China today is another example of central planning and high performance. In any case, the US is clearly a planned economy - the Fed even states its inflation target, and there is a target employment rate.
- whatshisface 5y agoHow could the free market determine the money supply?
- rsj_hn 5y agoThe free market always determines the money supply, that’s not the issue. Money is created when banks make loans and is destroyed when loans are repaid. The problem is sometimes this mechanism breaks down during a banking crisis and turn get deflation or it balloons in a speculative bubble and you get inflation.
- whatshisface 5y agoI learned in economics 101 that although banks are individually responsible for making the money, the overall supply is ultimately controlled by the interest rate and reserve requirements. Both are set by the government. The free market determines who the money is supplied to, but it doesn't determine the money supply.
- fighterpilot 5y ago
- joelbondurant 5y agoBuy bitcoin, bye banks.
- Animats 5y agoWell, yes. From the Fed perspective, they've discovered the hard way that the few knobs they can adjust, such as the discount rate, don't do what they thought they did. Tax and spending policy can control an economy at a finer level of detail, but if taken beyond simple goals, like "increase exports" or "build war materiel", tends to result in boondoggles with lobbies behind them. The dairy industry, NASA, ethanol from corn, and university administration staffs are well known examples. As a control system, it has too much lag for stable control. One thing that the pandemic has made clear is that today's "free market" has more lag than previously thought. Half-empty store shelves are the new normal. There's a correction, but it's slow. It takes several years to react to a disruption. With long supply chains, back-propagation of market signals through the supply chain takes longer. With today's excessive outsourcing, there may be only a few places in the world making some minor but essential item. Worse, that minor but essential item may not be a big money-maker for the producers, and so they lack the incentive to add capacity. Then there's overshoot. It now looks like there will be a semiconductor fab glut around 2023.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> the few knobs they can adjust, such as the discount rate, don't do what they thought they did What is the evidence for this? We have low rates spurring inflation expectations, in the population, and concerns, at the Fed. That's about as orthodox as monetary policy gets.
- Animats 5y agoThat, 2009-2020, real interest rates went all the way to 0, and even negative, in attempts to generate more economic activity. Yet this didn't generate inflation.(The pandemic did, but that's a different effect.) That was quite unexpected.[1] [1] https://www.babson.edu/academics/executive-education/babson-insight/finance-and-accounting/an-insiders-guide-to-negative-interest-rates/ https://www.babson.edu/academics/executive-education/babson-...
- mihaic 5y agoI find it hard to believe that there could ever really be a good economic model. Predicting the weather works with a supercomputer since all the processes (temperature, pressure, etc) can be modeled as continuous. A very successful Spiderman movie saving Sony's quarterly profits hangs often on a coin-toss. Our lives are governed by relatively simple rules of physics but the world is in an incredibly complex state. Economics takes the output of those rules of physics and tries to wrangle the state of all the atoms in the world into some simple values, and then uses some simple equations to make predictions. How is this not worse than spherical cows?
- joe_the_user 5y agoLots of system consisting of discreet pieces can be modeled fairly exactly. The thing that makes economies very hard to predict is they're a combination of people acting according to quantifiable economic incentives and people acting accord to a collection of ideas, fashions and emotions that can switch unpredictably or simply aren't known.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Predicting the weather works with a supercomputer since all the processes (temperature, pressure, etc) can be modeled as continuous Except it's not continuous. That assumption works most of the time. But sometimes--often--it doesn't. Particle interactions chaotically manifest systemic effects in unpredictable, dramatic ways. The limitations on our current models of fluid dynamics and economics are uncannily symmetric. (The latter fails more unexpectedly.)
- mihaic 5y agoWell, yes, my main point was that the weather is much closer to a perfect continuous model than the economy, and we get weather predictions wrong all the time. I doubt we'll have a change with the economy in the next 50 years.
- MuffinFlavored 5y ago> Predicting the weather works with a supercomputer since all the processes (temperature, pressure, etc) can be modeled as continuous. Why can't the flow of money be modeled? Don't we have enough data on human behavior historically? Can't we trace where money generally ends up? Using the recently printed money isn't a super great example because as far as I understand, it's mainly held up in the banking system. Maybe the stimulus money given to American citizens recently would be a better example. We know some of it went to savings, some of it went to bills, some of it went to frivolous purchases, etc. If AI can detect fraud / objects on a road and make decisions, why can't a few of the most common economic possibilities be fed into some kind of model?
- joe_the_user 5y agoThe paper disputes the idea that people’s expectations for future inflation matter much for the level of inflation experienced today. What I have been reading lately gives me the impression that different patterns of capital allocation have changed inflation dynamics. There's excess demand for older-generation used by the auto industry. In text book economics, that would lead to higher prices and then more factories and the meeting of that demand at a higher level. But what happens is chip makers, the only ones apparently capable of making even older generation chip factories, won't allocate capital for such factories because they view as on their way regardless of demand. So essentially, with huge capital allocations, companies won't chase short-term demand surges because they don't want to be left with future excess capacity (which is more costly than any immediate payoff). Look at Nvidia actively fighting the demand of crypto miners for their products. This seems to be a barrier to any inflationary spiral (increased demand leads to shortfalls, not higher prices and production. Maybe prices too but increases not propagating). So, it's not that the economy is incomprehensible but it's structure changes and so it's structure can't be captured by pure economic theory.
- cannabis_sam 5y ago> So, it's not that the economy is incomprehensible but it's structure changes and so it's structure can't be captured by pure economic theory. Pure economic theory is an oxymoron, other fields dealing with human behavior figured this out a long time ago, while economics desperately clung to the idea that it was actually math, rather than a social science. (Otherwise I agree with you)
- xchaotic 5y agojust a small nitpick in the overall correct train of thought - is that it this reduction in output still does drive up the inflation - as fewer cars are made, their price increases (and it has knock on effects of increasing prices to anything affected by cars - delivery, logistics, you name it)
- WalterBright 5y agoInflation is a general rise in prices, not a rise in the price of one or a few goods. In order for prices to rise generally, there has to be an increase in the money supply relative to the goods and services it represents.
- boomskats 5y agoPretty sure South Park nailed how the economy works with the Margaritaville episode [0] [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wz-PtEJEaqY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wz-PtEJEaqY
- TheMechanist 5y agoThe South Park model is surprisingly accurate. See Ray Dalio’s model here: https://www.bridgewater.com/research-and-insights/how-the-economic-machine-works https://www.bridgewater.com/research-and-insights/how-the-ec...
- ur-whale 5y agoEconomists are really good at providing explanation after the fact, which makes people feel good because it feels like they understand what's going on. That's why economists are still in business to this day. However, when it comes to predictive power, the entire field's output is exactly nil.
- ur-whale 5y ago> A new Fed paper suggests nobody really knows And no one is surprised, least of of all economists (whose livelihood depends on it but know exactly how much BS their field is) and politicians, who, like tribal chieftains of old using sooth-Sayers to give justification to their decisions find economists very useful.
- tomcam 5y agoConsider the source. It is by an employee of the Fed. The fed, like Federal Express, is a private corporation. It is not an arm of the government. I’m not saying the analysis is untrue. I’m just saying that this is not an unbiased source.
- Geee 5y agoJust stop meddling with the economy and it'll work perfectly. Soviet Union had the world's smartest economists trying to control their economy, and probably wrote smart scientific articles with all kinds of complex mathematics trying to prove each other wrong. To me it seems obvious that laissez-faire economy would just stabilize itself in the most optimal way. I don't know if the economists actually know this, but can't do it because of politics or their own benefit.
- maxerickson 5y ago"work perfectly" and "optimal" aren't objective states, they are opinions.
- throwawaygh 5y agoExactly. Carbon is optimally priced. Obviously.
- dddw 5y ago"Stop medling with the economy" probably stems from before abolition...
- incompatible 5y agoThe economy, back when it was on a gold standard so that the money supply was more constant, tended to show a strong boom-bust cycle. The bust would lead to bankruptcies and unemployment. I'm not sure if this counts as "working perfectly" or not. These days, central banks flood the economy with money if there's the slightest hint of anything going wrong, so that interest rates have persistently tended to zero and even below. A capitalist economy is based on government intervention, in any case. They provide all the enforcement of contracts and property rights, and do some wealth redistribution, especially helping people who can't survive from what the market provides. Without the latter, it seems inevitable that the system devolves into a few winners and many losers, and such a system will eventually be overthrown by the losers.
- noahtallen 5y agoIt really depends what “most optimal” means. For example, our regulatory system today is the result of companies crossing a line that society is unhappy with: - Massive pollution. Think of the burning Cuyahoga River or the terribly smoggy Pittsburgh. - Horrible working conditions. Where plenty of employees (including children) were forced to work more hours than healthy, and in environments which kill them. A similar modern example is hospitals price gouging super basic medical supplies. Those are the natural results of companies operating in a purely profit-driven manner. A laissez-faire economy has no concept of morality or rights, just of profit. Given that most people are completely unwilling to live under those sorts of conditions, our society has interjected itself into the economy to protect our rights. That happens via government regulation. If we remove regulations and “stop meddling with the economy,” companies will take the cheapest route to profit, because they basically have to. With no regulations, that means many companies won’t build expensive filtering systems to reduce pollution or wool quickly disregard expensive or time consuming safety rules. I’m also not convinced that laissez-faire actually works at all when the primary goal of the sector in question ought to be different from profit. A great example is health care, where the primary goal should be human well-being and health, but being profit focused would be completely at odds. If you’re profit-focused, there’s nothing stopping you from fixing prices very high because the person getting emergency services doesn’t have a chance to shop around or look at competition. In fact, any place that competition can’t or doesn’t exist is very bad for society and consumers. Any sort of monopoly means prices are very high and quality is very low. And monopolies always form over time in a laissez-fairs economy because it’s the best way to increase profit. And yet this is completely to the detriment of society and consumers —- e.g. to the detriment of everyone who exists. (I would posit that even a Walmart exec would have parts of their life that would be better if Walmart wasn’t monopolizing small markets.) How do these problems get solved without “meddling” in the economy?
- littleme2020 5y agohttps://coincircle.com/l/nyZPq_OEKj https://coincircle.com/l/nyZPq_OEKj
- ryebit 5y agoIMO, economics is an area that will continually be hampered by models that don't fit, and increasing complexity. Any model that predicts things simply and well, will be gamed; thus requiring a more complex model. Or as Goodhart's Law[1] has it: "When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure." That's presuming we never reach some economic state so perfect, that even with an accurate model, no one can find an extra advantage, nor can it be disrupted by natural events. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law
- api 5y agoI have thought this for years. It’s like they don’t realize they are studying a living system, and even worse one that is actively trying to invalidate their models.
- zwaps 5y agoBut that quote is literally from an economist... as is Lucas' critique?
- ryebit 5y agoI don't think that invalidates the quote. It's how I came across it in the first place. I think economists are well aware of the nature of the beast they're studying. And even if doing the task is daunting, and the landscape changing as it's described, it's still worth it. Especially if anyone finds fixed points which do have the property that describing them doesn't invalidate them.
- dredmorbius 5y agoLiving organisms also adapt to their environments and models which understand them. If you want to get to base levels, look at metabolism, energy inputs, conversion efficiencies, productive activity, and immunity / defence / risk dynamics. Economic analysis arose out of cost accounting in which those inputs were specifically discounted, under-priced, and/or externalised.
- 5y ago
- canada_dry 5y ago> that long-term inflation expectations are not just interesting but are a decisive determinant of real-time inflation I think economists neglect to include an obvious factor: people are greedy opportunists. When inflation first get reported on (in some tangentially related sector) the most opportunistic and greedy businesses jump at the opportunity to bump prices. When less opportunistic (but still greedy) businesses see one of their suppliers bumping prices, they follow suit and it quickly gains momentum.
- solveit 5y ago> I think economists neglect to include an obvious factor In general, if you ever find yourself thinking that an entire discipline is neglecting an obvious factor, you should check whether that's actually true. I am pretty sure that your phenomenon of opportunistic price-hikes at reports of irrelevant inflation is either 1. Well-understood to not happen. or 2. Somebody's PhD thesis.
- canada_dry 5y ago> find yourself thinking that an entire discipline is neglecting an obvious factor Fair. Perhaps I'd rephrase it to "economists might be able to better understand the inflation phenomenon by recognizing that people are - by nature - greedy opportunists".
- cwp 5y agoSounds like motivated reasoning to me. We've had 40 years of pretty successful economic policy, but we'd really, really like to spend a huge amount of money when there's already a shortage of workers. But hey, who really knows, right? Maybe inflation won't be a problem.
- thedstrat 5y agoHe talks as if the inverse correlation between interest rates and inflation no longer applies. But I don't think that the data shows that.
- swayvil 5y agoOh they know. They know exactly how it works. But it's a secret.
- starkd 5y agoSomewhat disturbed by this article. It feels almost like the author's purpose might be to justify further monetizing the debt, so they don't have to address the inflation problem by tighter monetary policy. I hope I'm wrong here.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoNot exactly surprising. A while ago I had the task to automate a part of my company’s business process. After meeting probably 20 people I concluded that everybody does their part and somehow it works ok but there is nobody who really knows what’s going on.
- chmsky00 5y agoMy take is beyond economic activity to enable the biological survival of the species, our economics are historically built on gossip and political whimsy. I suspect there are many fewer rules needed than we’ve been lead to believe. We like to believe it must be complicated because of course society is. But social laws are based on social network effects which are politically manipulated. So in conclusion, it’s rhetorically a free market but in practical terms it’s gamed by social corruption as usual, requiring ever more Byzantine economic theory to capture the edge cases. Infinitely big little numbers have allowed economists to iterate on the edge, but socially it’s belly button digging.
- m0zg 5y agoSociety itself is built on gossip and bullshit, if you think about it. Ability to gossip and make up bullshit is the main thing which enables large groups of people to work as a semi-coherent whole. All of the social constructs we participate in are little more than blind faith. Lawyers are basically priests, legalese is the prayer, and the laws are the Bible. Those who sin (go against the law) or reject the society entirely are severely punished. And so on and so forth. This is not a novel idea, there are books written about it. Which is to say that just because it's bullshit doesn't make it any less valid, yet bullshit is typically much harder to model as it lacks the internal logic that a non-bullshit system would have. It's full of contradictions and non-sequiturs. This could explain why economists (and especially Paul Krugman) are so consistently wrong about everything.
- mikewarot 5y agoFirst, assume a frictionless spherical banker... ; - ) How the economy works is pretty basic, knowing where all the corners of fraud lie is the part that makes it complicated.
- adolph 5y agoThe curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design. Friedrich August von Hayek https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/economic-sciences/1974/hayek/lecture/ https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/economic-sciences/1974/hay...
- aazaa 5y agoOne of the problems with looking at the economy through the lens of inflation is defining "inflation" itself. Consider the Wikipedia definition: > In economics, inflation (or infrequently, price inflation) is a general rise in the price level of an economy over a period of time. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation What is "the price level of an economy?" How do you measure it? What factors are included and excluded? Why? Who decides? Do we include real estate? Financial assets like stocks and bonds? Or do we stick to things like milk and eggs. Housing? Is that an asset or a consumable? And this happens before we can really talk about what causes inflation to increase or decrease. The problem with most of the discussions of inflation I've read and seen is that each side has its own, often implicit, definition of inflation.
- massinstall 5y agoThis. Thank you for a thoughtful comment.
- rdtwo 5y agoSometimes this question matters but sometimes like now it doesn’t. You really have to contort your basket hard to not see inflation in 2021. No matter what you pick it’s up10-20%
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 5y ago> What is "the price level of an economy?" How do you measure it? Your link has a lot of options: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation#Measures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inflation#Measures Sure, we usually use CPI, and it has some downsides, but all the measures are correlated to some degree. Headlines regularly use the U-6 unemployment rate, but academics usually use U-3. Nothing's stopping you from using a different measure of inflation in a discussion, and I'd personally love to hear your take.
- treeman79 5y agohttps://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B00PKQMFT8/ref=tmm_aud_swatch_0?ie=UTF8&qid=&sr= https://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B00PKQMFT8/ref=tmm_aud_swatch... Basic economics. Amazing book that really explains the fundamentals from cave people economics to modern housing theory.
- known 5y agoIMO 3% inflation is desirable for progress; "Give me control of a nation's currency print/supply, and I care not who makes its laws" --Rothschild (b. 1744) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency_in_circulation#Total_currency_in_circulation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Currency_in_circulation#Tota...
- mountainboy 5y agonobody really knows... pretty much what Mises, Hayek and other Austrian economists have been saying for 100+ years. Fatal conceit anyone? "The curious task of economics is to demonstrate to men how little they really know about what they imagine they can design. To the naive mind that can conceive of order only as the product of deliberate arrangement, it may seem absurd that in complex conditions order, and adaptation to the unknown, can be achieved more effectively by decentralizing decisions and that a division of authority will actually extend the possibility of overall order. Yet that decentralization actually leads to more information being taken into account." --F.A. Hayek
- CSSer 5y agoLink to the paper: https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/feds/files/2021062pap.pdf https://www.federalreserve.gov/econres/feds/files/2021062pap...
- ralfd 5y agohttps://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2021/10/do-inflation-expectations-matter-for-inflation.html https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2021/10/do... > I went to read the paper, and I have to say I am baffled. It didn’t change my priors at all. I didn’t see new empirical estimates, or new theoretical arguments, and furthermore I didn’t see the most relevant factors discussed much. I did see a lot of pokes at Friedman, Phelps, and Lucas (and there is also an introductory assertion that, even given enough time, markets with flexible prices do not clear. Then he goes on to deny that the theory of household choice is sufficient to derive downward-sloping demand…why do that???). > I would start by looking at the clearest cases where inflationary expectations do matter. If inflation rates become quite high (say above forty percent?), many people switch to alternate currencies. Or in hyperinflations the velocity of money, after some point, accelerates very dramatically, thereby fueling the inflation further. So inflation expectations really do matter, as supported by both theory and evidence. Contrary to Rudd, the theoretical case is there, though the question of magnitude at lower inflation rates is largely an open one. But let’s not slip from “open” to “we are justified in thinking they don’t matter very much at all.”
- nftartfund 5y agoPersonally I think it's due to our reductionistic approaches, the economy is not some cold lifeless mechanical object, it's a living organism. I like the idea of examining "relationships" rather than models, we could better quantify social elements. No references unfortunately, just my stream of thought!
- weavie 5y agoI have just started reading Marx. I believe one of the core aspects of his analysis of capitalism is exactly what you mentioned here - the economy is a living organism and to truly understand it you have to understand the relationships. I'm still working it out, so I would very much appreciate it if someone here had more insight to confirm/deny my understanding?
- elb2020 5y agoI think it's sort of self-fulfilling when it comes to the economy. The economy, after all, is the system of all of us using the maximum of our brains and abilities to compete with each other in the making of money. I think it's a chaotic system by it's very definition.
- timka 5y agoThis guy knows https://fondmx.pro/en/ https://fondmx.pro/en/
- ladyattis 5y agoEver since the fallout of the Great Recession we've had to deal with the reality of dead money in the system being much larger than what's in circulation. Heck, I suspect that's been the case for decades earlier than that but over all I think now we can account for it better due to our use of computers to keep track of the balance sheets. So in effect we got a better picture of what's going on but not the reason for it happening. And it would be nice if economists would take chances on less mainstream theories in economics to see what actually works rather than keep using overly simplified models that pretend to be right when they can't even match on the most basic trends in the economy.