53 ms·
A backlash against gender ideology is starting in universities
- neom 5y agohttps://www.printfriendly.com/p/g/9kgBJa https://www.printfriendly.com/p/g/9kgBJa
- uhorb 5y agoI think this page is my takeaway of the day. Thank you!
- seunoyebode 5y agohaha... yeah right. But doesn't work for ft.com articles
- runbathtime 5y agoAlso a white backlash against CRT that is anti white.
- altcognito 5y agoHey look another outrage article about censorship.
- 9wzYQbTYsAIc 5y ago> But it would be better if universities, which owe their success to a tradition of dissent and debate, did in fact defend it. From the article
- lr4444lr 5y agoA flyer with an image of a gun and text reading “shut the fuck up, terf” (trans-exclusionary radical feminist, a slur) was circulating Not accepting incivility from people is hardly what I'd call a "backlash". We don't operate our universities on the heckler's veto.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y agoAlso, I'm not aware of anyone who seriously considers "TERF" an offensive slur... It's like saying "bigot" is a slur, or being more afraid of being labelled a racist than actually being racist...
- ribosometronome 5y agoPlenty of TERFs consider it a slur and negative. JK Rowling, for example, wrote: "...activists who clearly believe themselves to be good, kind and progressive people swarmed back into my timeline, assuming a right to police my speech, accuse me of hatred, call me misogynistic slurs and, above all – as every woman involved in this debate will know – TERF."
- whoooooo123 5y agoThe term "TERF" is exclusively used by people who attack and criticise "TERFs". It's never said without hostility, and it's often accompanied by explicit calls for violence (try searching Twitter for "kill TERFs" and "punch TERFs".) So yes, it certainly is an offensive slur - those who use it invariably mean it an offensive way.
- JanneVee 5y ago> We don't operate our universities on the heckler's veto. I've seen a few videos from various Universities where invited speakers are shouted down because of supposed wrong views. But then it isn't the heckler's veto if their views are wrong or what?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nemo44x 5y agoWhat's weird is that not long ago is popular to say "I disagree with everything you have to say, but I'd die for your right to say it". It's amazing how times have changed from that shared belief. The videos you haven't seen are the ones that were never made because the wrong-view person was stopped from even giving their scheduled talk via "de-platforming".
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoI don’t know if this article is describing this phenomenon accurately, as the first paragraph contains an obvious falsehood: “ A flyer with an image of a gun and text reading “shut the fuck up, terf” (trans-exclusionary radical feminist, a slur) was circulating. ”. TERF isn’t a slur. No one has successfully beaten and killed a woman while calling her a TERF and then got away with it in court like the gay panic defense and the trans panic defense has. No one was lynched for being a TERF like black people have been. This is a gross talking point trying to claim victim positioning and is inaccurate journalism. The whole article is suspect to be sympathetic to anti-trans politics as a result. I do want to talk about how much gender has invaded the academic life in a way that gets in the way of education. Obviously, I don’t want even more gender politicking from the other “side”!
- beervirus 5y ago> TERF isn’t a slur. No one has successfully beaten and killed a woman while calling her a TERF and then got away with it in court That’s hardly the defining characteristic of a slur.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoI’ve associated the term slur in the common understanding with an actual history of marginalization, and I think the claim is totally unnecessary politicking in the reporting.
- zwieback 5y agoI think the courts are the right place for this battle, some fundamental free speech rights for both sides need to be enforced. I didn't think this would the necessary in academia but with universities turning into service industries it seems inevitable.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoRight or wrong courts pretty much always lag popular consensus in a democracy so the debate will happen elsewhere first.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoAs an adult return student in college currently, while I could engage in "free speech," the college is also free to expel me for creating a hostile environment for my views (I'm speaking generally here). Everybody hates Illinois Nazi's. But if a group them sprouted up at your school, can you really say it's fair freedom of speech-wise to shut them down at a publicly funded institution? No you can't. Not only that, but instructors can at whim grade you based on if they like you as opposed to legitimately getting good grades. Ultimately it just creates a system to be gamed by those wise enough to survive it. It's never been about education in the US. It's always been about "who can navigate the waters without getting labeled."
- tetranomiga 5y agoGender politics is a cancer on the left, even though I agree with it, it takes up so much time and energy away from things that would benefit everybody including trans people, like universal healthcare, better employee protection laws and better, more available education. Such a small percentage of the population has been the center point of so much discussion and debate, and for what benefit? All I see it doing is give the right-wing more ammunition to harden their bases.
- ixacto 5y agoYeah I’m not on the left any more and now an independent due to the left trying to use identity politics for political engagement. Still support what Bernie/Yang are doing though with trying to universalize healthcare and income though.
- istorical 5y agoThe same could be said for most wedge issues. In the US, gun rights and and abortion also become a focal point of US politics despite the existence of issues that deal with millions of preventable deaths (automobile safety, obesity epidemic, poverty), issues that deal with hundreds of thousands of displaced peoples and killed civilians (Afghanistan and Iraq war, war mongering over Syria, Libya, Iran, etc), and climate change, which our brightness minds continue to tell us could lead to not insubstantial percentages of all forms of life on our planet going extinct and billions or trillions of dollars of economic cost. But we just focus on emotional trigger point issues. See focus on and mass protests because of police brutality (hundreds of deaths a year) compared to zero widespread action on the injustice of the prison system (hundreds of thousands of lives ruined, literal slavery and imprisonment in cages over antiquated unequally applied drug laws).
- edrxty 5y agoThere's truth here, feels-over-reals is very much a problem in US politics. That said, feelings/perceptions have consequences if left unchecked. A few hundred people being "made an example of" by the police each year can functionally oppress an entire ethnic group in a country. All that said, in light of the previous example, it makes the abortion fight seem particularly...whimsical...given the stakes. The evangelicals believe they themselves are going to heaven regardless of what the non-evangelicals do and those getting abortions don't care so it's rather hard to point to a group being oppressed by their beliefs here.
- mabub24 5y agoOne thing I find quite odd is how the study of gender emerged out of an approach that demanded a critical understanding of assumptions and the things society insist upon (that there are only 2 genders, that gender is essentially related to biological sex rather than something that is manifest in social behaviour, ect.) and yet that view has twisted into a sort of all or nothing view that is extremely antagonistic to critical inquiry. The tendency for a number of trans activists and talking points to revert back to a kind of gender essentialism; the logical inconsistencies in the idea that one identifies a private gender identity, rather than a personal desire to transition or live as another gender; the insistence that a trans person has special insight into the concept of gender --- raise up any of these points and you bear the risk of being labelled a "transphobe" even though you are entirely committed to the protection of a trans persons rights and dignity. A small, extremely vocal minority insists that anyone that voices the slightest hesitation in accommodating trans people into gender/sex segregated social functions must be a transphobe or be complicit in the violence against trans people. It makes the entire conversation exhausting.
- tetranomiga 5y agoI dunno if I'd agree that it's a small vocal minority, zero-tolerance to anybody questioning the current dogma is seen everywhere where trans acceptance is a focus. Ten years ago I was told, by trans people, that there are physical differences between trans and cis brains. Say that today, and you get kicked out of LGBT spaces for being a transmedicalist or truscum. I have no idea whether it's true or not because you can't even find research on the subject because of how absurdly politicized the topic is.
- zozbot234 5y ago"Truscum" being the word for someone who thinks that changing one's gender and sexual characteristics might not be the greatest idea ever unless you actually have, like, gender dysphoria. Never mind the many, many people who are now pursuing "detransition" after going one step too far. I mean, what could possibly go wrong?
- 5y ago
- Moodles 5y ago> The arguments the two sides put forward, in other words, are complex and debatable. But many trans activists think that any disagreement is tantamount to hate speech and try to suppress it. This is 100% my personal experience also. Even on HN last week someone said I should try to be a "better human" and compared my suggestion that maybe someone might oppose transgender women in women's spaces for reasons other than pure hatred or phobia of trans people, to segregation of blacks and whites. It's just absolutely impossible to have any disagreement with them without them trying these inane mob bully tactics. Being outraged should not be your only argument. Take the case of Fallon Fox (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fallon_Fox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fallon_Fox): a mixed martial artist transgender woman (who didn't even disclose she used to be a he while she was competing against women), or Laurel Hubbard, the New Zealand transgender olympic weightlifter in the news this week. Even mentioning these cases which clearly have more to them than pure hatred or phobia of trans people, still get lambasted with abuse. What's really frustrating is that they don't really listen to what you actually say, but instead "read between the lines" and assume everything you say is just a ruse hidden behind some immense hatred and bigotry. How about no? Just take what I say at face value. No, I'm not full of hate. Yes, I know being transgendered must be hard. Yes, I do know some transgendered people (why is this relevant?). Yes, I am cisgendered myself. No, I really do think transgender women have an advantage in combat sports. No, again, I'm not full of hate... It's quite ridiculous. ... OP was flagged because...?
- recursivedoubts 5y agoThe idea is to set up rhetorical either-or's and then browbeat the majority into silence: Either you support unlimited immigration or you are a racist. Either you are 100% on board with the entire vaccine schedule or you are an anti-vaxxer. Either you say that Covid was a natural occurrence or you are a conspiracy theorist (and probably a racist too). And so on. Say what one will, but it's effective. I think one reason it works so well in the US is our puritan heritage, which has always had a strong manichean current in it. As the elites lost their religion, they retained this characteristic and it now manifests itself in the secular realm.
- zozbot234 5y ago
- ixacto 5y agoFreedom of expression/free speech doesn’t mean freedom not to be offended or that you have to agree with the views. If we do not support even the most offensive speech then we risk a very slippery slope leading to censorship and 1984.
- briandear 5y agoWe’ve already skipped so far down the slope that it’s unrecoverable. We’re in the midst of a Cultural Revolution. It’s bonkers how being gender-critical can get you fired or silenced or violently protested. Or how being anti-Marxist makes you a racist. Or how even having traditional values is worthy of being firebombed.
- Jotra7 5y agoThis comment right here shows where discourse is at with the right wing. Screaming and crying about some imagined persecution while controlling everything. I'm so sick of it.
- busterarm 5y ago> Or how being anti-Marxist makes you a racist. Especially given the historical record on empowered Marxists and saying/doing things that are extremely racist and homophobic.
- staplers 5y agoBeing pro-marxist 70 years ago meant jail time. It's always been this way, just for a different sect of people.
- tetranomiga 5y agoThere's no historical reason to think that not supporting extreme speech will lead to fascism. There are historical reasons to think that curbing extremist speech protects democracy (see the Weimar Republic).
- tarboreus 5y ago
- throwaway284534 5y agoThere’s a lot that’s already been said in this topic but I feel compelled to bring up the damage imposed by TERF talking points. The conversation goes something like this: “Transgender women possess an innate maleness that carries a non-zero threat to female spaces.” They believe that dictionary definitions of woman are prescriptive, declared at the chromosomes during birth, rather than descriptive, as in how one presents in both dress and phenotype. In my experience this is the center of every “debate.” It’s less about the merits of the cause and more about convincing this point against the hypothetical risk of a male who’s taken advantage of self identified gender. TERFs are generally not interested in dynamics of trans men, who seem to be more like “gender traitors” than their deceptive counterparts. Personally I find this whole movement a farce. Every talking point not only misaligns with trans women, it causes more harm to cis women at scale. “Real women” give birth — except hundreds of thousands who cannot. “Real women” look like the contemporary feminine ideal, yet 1 in 10 women suffer from PCOS enduring testosterone levels higher than any trans woman has to contend with. And the cake topper of them all, “trans women fuel negative stereotypes of femininity,” while simultaneously not appearing feminine enough, often barred from HRT until after puberty. This Goldilocks zone of womanhood is always out of reach, and therefore transness is never acceptable. - a trans woman
- benjohnson 5y agoI don’t think it’s fair to dismiss what seems to be a reasonable discussion as simply “TERF talking points” and then reframe what your opponents are saying in an un-sympathetic way.
- loopz 5y agoMaybe it's like telling ME patients it's all in their head, and they can be cured psychologically. It may work on some, but for many they get permanently damaged from too much pressure and stress. After such abuse and being ground down, it's hard to be sympathetic to ignorance and abuse. I don't know enough to conclude, but trying to understand and ask more questions is a first step.
- AnimalMuppet 5y ago
- foolinaround 5y agowhile this article focusses on the gender ideology issues, IMHO the censorship in universites is on a wider range of issues, with the common denominator being the viewpoints espoused in far-left circles (not passing judgement here on whether they are right or wrong) Enforced group-think is going to be the death of these universities.
- metalliqaz 5y ago"Enforced group-think is going to be the death of these universities." How?
- jollybean 5y agoBy expunging, shaming, expelling, disinviting, cancelling, eschewing, not offering positions, denying grants, avoiding publication, demoting those that don't meet the requirements of a radical orthodoxy. Noam Chomsky of all people (!), and a bunch of other staunchly centre-left luminaries had to take out a full page ad in Harper's to make the point. [2] How far would an ugly trend have to exhibit itself in order for these fairly respectable and otherwise mild mannered people to not only 1) notice but 2) act and then 3) make a big show out of it in a worldwide signal? They tried to cancel Stephen Pinker [2] for postulating that the problem of Law Enforcement in the USA is a generally overbearing justice system, not necessarily specific to one race, although conceding that's a problem. For that utterly reasonable statement, they tried to remove his Chair and participation a bunch of groups. He was fine, but 'they came for him' and were he to have been less prominent, 'they' would have won. It's intellectual cowardice and social bullying by angry people. My belief is that it's not even ideological at the end of the day, rather, it's the petty expression of power by those who've never had it before and who were transgressed themselves at some earlier point in their lives. [1] https://thehill.com/blogs/in-the-know/in-the-know/506314-jk-rowling-noam-chomsky-sign-letter-warning-of-restriction-of https://thehill.com/blogs/in-the-know/in-the-know/506314-jk-... [2] https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/15/us/steven-pinker-harvard.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/15/us/steven-pinker-harvard....
- breckenedge 5y ago
- anoncake 5y ago"Gender critical" people claim that someone's sex cannot be changed, not even using surgery and hormones. So what is sex then? Obviously not one's hormones as those can be replaced just fine. That leaves chromosomes, primary and secondary characteristics. They also claim that gender is more important than sex. When they, for example, address someone as "Dear Mr. Smith", they must be referring to their sex then. Which means they mean something like: - "Dear Smith, who has XY chromosomes" - "Dear Smith, who has a natural grown penis" - "Dear Smith, who has a penis that works well enough that I consider them a man - "Dear Smith, who can grow a beard" - "Dear Smith, whose shoulder width is typical for a human male" All of these are either bafflingly irrelevant, fucked up or inaccurate. So how exactly is one's sex relevant to anyone except their doctors and partners? > In February, when Donna Hughes, a professor of women\u2019s studies at Rhode Island University, published an article critical of gender ideology, petitions sprouted calling for her to be fired. The article, which the Economist didn't bother to link to: https://4w.pub/fantasy-worlds-on-the-political-right-and-left-qanon-and-trans-sex-beliefs-2/ https://4w.pub/fantasy-worlds-on-the-political-right-and-lef... It's more of a pamphlet filled with lies, sexism and conspiracy theories. I think academic freedom is too important to fire her over this, but I understand the petitions. > In February Holly Lawford-Smith, a professor of philosophy at the University of Melbourne, launched a website which invited women to describe their experiences of sharing female-only spaces with trans women. It is not a research project and its reports are unverified. Most describe a feeling of discomfort rather than any form of physical assault. So? I'm sure some women feel uncomfortable around black women. Or lesbians. Someone feeling uncomfortable around people of a given group is a common cause of discrimination and bigotry. > If Maya Forstater, a British researcher who lost her job because of her gender-critical views No, Mr. Forstater lost his job not because of his views but because "It is a core component of her belief that she will refer to a person by the sex she considered appropriate even if it violates their dignity and/or creates an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment".[1] [1] https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-50858919 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-50858919
- mkr-hn 5y agoMaya Forstater might be a trash goblin and disgrace to humanity, but she's still a she last I heard.
- neonate 5y agohttps://archive.is/vEsW4 https://archive.is/vEsW4
- gorgoiler 5y agoIn a shared space, should the people that share that space have the right to exclude someone if it makes the majority feel unsafe? What about if it makes just one of them feel unsafe? If one person says they feel unsafe, should they be asked to leave instead of the newcomer, with whom the majority are ambivalent? Basically what I’m getting at is what’s the algebra / game theory of creating safe spaces based on tolerance and intolerance?
- celeritascelery 5y agoWhen ever I see someone talk about “safe space”, I ask myself, “safe space for which ideas?” The things that are safe to discuss are different at thanksgiving dinner, a college designated safe-space, a therapist’s office, or a church meeting. There is no such thing as a universal “safe space” for all ideas.
- avereveard 5y agoOstracizing people based solely on one own feeling sits squarely against the whole concept of presumption of innocence, it's the apotheosis of prejudices against coexistence.
- HideousKojima 5y agoPresumption of innocence is a legal presumption, and it exists there for very good reasons that would take too long to get into. Requiring such a presumption outside of a legal context in the way you're suggesting would undermine a different fundamental right, the freedom of association. People should have the right to associate (and disassociate) with whomever they like for whatever reasons they like, no matter how arbitrary or petty.
- avereveard 5y agoa and b want to associate, a want to associate with c, c don't want to associate with b, b doesn't care as long as he can associate with a, as per the grandparent comment statement, given that neither a, b and c did anything reprehensible yet. everyone is free to act, but still a problem presents itself. what's the more just option for person a according to ethics and morals? that's the core of the conundrum, the right to associate and disassociate impacts other people freedoms, as such is the nature of interpersonal relations; of course individual have their individual freedom, but should A act on C prejudice, or in other word should C demand limits on A freedom (i.e. cancel culture) mind you, the issue is about C own personal perceived feeling of unsafeness, not on B having done anything against C.
- postmodernbrute 5y agoRight. Another loud article published on a very mainstream media about how a very established academic is being silenced and prevented from "debate". I wonder, if one collates all the articles on British media about transgender people, how many of them would actually concern the daily experiences of real transgender people, versus how many that consist of an established writer complaining loudly that they have been silenced? Or to put it more quantitatively: how many words uttered by real transgender people have been published on British media, and how many words of these brutally silenced "gender-criticals"?
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoTo put it bluntly, this is irrelevant. You put "debate" in quotes like it's somehow a dirty word, which is shocking and depressing to me. I DO care about what real transgender people have to say, and to be honest, especially on college campuses in the US, it is very easy to see they have a voice and are able to speak there opinion. I have no idea whether this academic's opinion is one I agree with. Primarily because she wasn't allowed to speak.
- postmodernbrute 5y agoShe was allowed to speak far more than any trans people has been allowed to speak - she is speaking on The Economist. I do not see any trans people speaking on The Economist. The same applies across the entirety of published British media. That you willfully ignore this epistemological injustice, does not render it irrelevant. The university ground is one of the very few places where real transgender people, along with other socially marginalised groups, are generally allowed to speak, and allowed to speak for themselves. They are particularly visible on campus, precisely because they are effectly not allowed to speak in other places. Such as The Economist and other print media. And yes, certain "debates" are quite dirty. Debates are not neutral fields of free intellectual inquiry, but potent manifestation of prevailing epistemological injustices. It is shocking and depressing, that certain people must again and again defend their own existence in "debates" premised on a claim to the absurdity of their condition. It is shocking and depressing, that sincere experiences of trans people are not taken, but rather must be put under the forensic lens of "debate" to be constantly challenged and invalidated. These "debates" are dirty constructs, serving as a powerful mechanism of collective gaslighting.
- fungiblecog 5y agoI think the irony of the current battle around identity is that we have been making steady progress based on the idea that personal characteristics shouldn't matter. However this whole debate is reversing that by not only saying it matters a great deal but that other people should be forced to defer to others personal choices even when it directly affects them
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mike00632 5y agoDo you feel the same way about nicknames? If you call someone by a nickname that they don't like and they let you know they prefer their own name then do you consider it too onerous to defer to them about it?
- handmodel 5y agoI don't think that is what commenter is saying. I, personally, of course defer to nicknames and pronouns. I think it is more similar to race-blind versus race-conscious policies - along with gender-blind versus gernder-concious. Is it better to assume that men and women are pretty much the same in academia and each are capable of the same thing? Or is it better to assume that men and women are intrinsically better at different things with certain characteristics. I think the answer is in the middle but clearly there has been a move in the last five years to say that gender inherently effects your worldview/characteristics while simultaneously saying that men/women should have equal outcomes in all fields. Its not internally consistent.
- klyrs 5y ago> Is it better to assume that men and women are pretty much the same in academia and each are capable of the same thing? Or is it better to assume that men and women are intrinsically better at different things with certain characteristics. This is something I think a lot of people misunderstand about [id]-consciousness. Is it better to assume that you as an individual have biases that align/oppose with overarching biases in our society, or is it better to assume that you alone, or society at large, are bias-free? Can we address inequality by treating everybody the same in this moment and ignoring the historical context they exist in, or do observed biases need to be compensated for in some manner?
- nepeckman 5y agoOne thing I find very troubling about articles like this is the tendency to frame hot political topics as essentially academic, while they are in fact very practical. Across the US and England, trans people are being denied access to health care, medically necessary operations, and effective therapeutic treatment. But this article doesn't discuss those issues, it only discusses the ramifications of this political reality.
- mdoms 5y agoThis article also doesn't discuss the plight of the Uyghurs, bee colony collapse or the atmosphere of Venus. Because that's not what this article is about.
- nepeckman 5y agoThe plight of the Uyghurs does not relate to the political oppression of trans people. Political oppression of trans people is inextricable from the discussion of anti trans ideology on college campuses. To make an analogy, this article is like writing about the Uyghur genocide, but instead of discussing concentration campus or the Chinese government, focusing instead on one individual who wasnt allowed to speak because they said "China has done nothing wrong." Do you see the problem? Instead of focusing on actual tragedy, I have derailed the conversation by framing the plight of this poor pro China individual as the real issue. Now the comments are debating the subjects of academic free speech and cancel culture instead of the real issue at hand.
- oofabz 5y agoI don't think gender ideology is an appropriate topic for HN. There is little to be gained and much to be lost from discussing it here. Little to be gained because it has nothing to do with software development, and because gender issues are thoroughly covered elsewhere. Much to be lost because gender issues are so divisive that we risk alienating members of our community.
- dang 5y agoHN is for topics that gratify intellectual curiosity, not "software development". Please see the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. You're certainly right that this is an inflammatory topic with strong political and ideological overlap, and as the guidelines explain, we don't want flamewar here, and we don't want ideological or political battle. The site exists for intellectual curiosity, and those things aren't compatible. There's a great deal of established moderation practice around this, if anyone wants to read past explanations: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=political%20overlap%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&so... https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comment&storyText=false&prefix=false&page=0&query=primarily%20test%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?sort=byDate&dateRange=all&type=comme... https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=curiosity%20optimiz%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor... That doesn't automatically make a story like this off topic for HN. It depends on whether there's enough new information in a story to support a substantive discussion. In this case, the topic is not just "gender ideology", it's ongoing developments at universities and in the discourse at large. All of these are significant and interesting phenomena. For that reason I turned the flags off on this submission. That's also established moderation practice (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20%22flags%22%20off%20turn&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...). It requires a judgment call, of course, and we don't always make the right calls—but not making any would be an even worse call. Of course it's commenters' responsibility to stick to the side guidelines if posting in such a thread. That means curious, thoughtful conversation and respect toward other commenters (and other people generally). Flamewar, flamebait, snark, name-calling, personal attacks and so on are not ok. People sometimes think that just because a topic is inflammatory it means they get carte blanche to spew what they will (e.g. "if you don't want me to post like this then you shouldn't allow this thread in the first place"). I call that argument "the topic made me do it", and not only is it false, the opposite is true: commenters here are under a greater obligation in cases like this, as the site guidelines make clear: "Comments should get more thoughtful and substantive, not less, as a topic gets more divisive."
- throwawaysea 5y agoThis is great news, because gender ideology has corrupted free inquiry and discourse in society as a whole, not just at universities. For example, the Royal Academy of Arts just issued an apology to an artist whose work they had removed from their shop due to pressure from trans rights activists (https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2021/jun/23/royal-academy-of-arts-apologises-to-jess-de-wahls-in-transphobia-row https://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2021/jun/23/royal-a...). There was also the case of Maya Forstater, who was allegedly let go from her job because of tweets saying that biological sex is real - she initially lost her case about employment discrimination but won upon appeal (https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-57426579 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-57426579). The trend in universities fighting for free speech and free inquiry is welcome and necessary. I have been concerned that things were going in the other direction when I saw the phrase "academic transphobia" appear, which was being used to de-platform certain people or stop certain research (see https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/stonewall-and-the-silencing-of-feminist-voices-at-universities https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/stonewall-and-the-silenc... or https://www.starobserver.com.au/news/university-of-melbourne-proposes-ban-on-academic-transphobia/203932 https://www.starobserver.com.au/news/university-of-melbourne...). Apart from the linked Economist article, another related recent positive news is that Open University launched a "Gender Critical Academic Research Network" (https://thecritic.co.uk/the-new-network-for-gender-critical-academics/ https://thecritic.co.uk/the-new-network-for-gender-critical-...). PS: if you support free speech in academia, check out FIRE (https://www.thefire.org/ https://www.thefire.org/). Since the ACLU is less focused on free speech issues these days (https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/the-disintegration-of-the-aclu-james-kirchick https://www.tabletmag.com/sections/news/articles/the-disinte...), FIRE has become the new defender of basic civil liberties.
- twirligigue 5y agoThere seems to be a new background assumption that one's identity can be chosen, whereas I think in reality it's inherited.
- ausbah 5y agoso you can't gain an identity by choosing to do certain things? I can't identify as a runner because I didn't inherit the genes that make me in the top 0.1% of all runners?
- dgb23 5y agoIt’s not really a choice, rather than an often very difficult process of discovery, if they manage to accept it at all. A good friend of mine struggled for years with their self acceptance and I only realized that in restrospect. But coming out liberated them and an avalanche of happiness, productivity and positivity happened. It’s a real struggle, and by belittling or ignoring it we can only make it worse. It’s time to listen, respect and embrace.
- ed25519FUUU 5y agoHow do you define “identity”?
- bob_roberts 5y agoYou shouldn't assume that nonbinary and trans people "choose" their identity. They might choose to acknowledge it, to themselves or to others. At least, that's been my experience. It was a realization, not a choice.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- anoncake 5y agoSo if you're female, it's because your parents are female?
- jeffrallen 5y agoAll fundamentalism is bad. Including this comment.
- danielodievich 5y agoOne of my favorite sci-fi authors is Ian M. Banks (discussed here on HN with regularity). His Culture series describe a post-scarcity interstellar society of human(oid)s who among many, many things can change their own gender just by thinking about it. After suitable body alteration time, you can be a male, female, or even something in between (that happens to be important part of one of the characters in one of the books), with most citizens transferring back and forth at least once to act as both a father and a mother at least once in their long lifetime. In this society, there is no gender inequality. Ian's own "A Few Notes on the Culture" essay http://www.vavatch.co.uk/books/banks/cultnote.htm http://www.vavatch.co.uk/books/banks/cultnote.htm states it best: A society in which it is so easy to change sex will rapidly find out if it is treating one gender better than the other; within the population, over time, there will gradually be greater and greater numbers of the sex it is more rewarding to be, and so pressure for change - within society rather than the individuals - will presumably therefore build up until some form of sexual equality and hence numerical parity is established. Until our science invents this, this is a great thought experiment to conduct.
- at_a_remove 5y agoSort of a star-bellied sneetches deal, yes.
- jollybean 5y agoThis won't happen though. It reminds me of 'Star Trek' futurism where we crudely apply some neat technology to our own circumstances, without thinking about the real dynamic changes that would come about if the tech did exist. If we ever get to the point of this level of technology, then the notion of 'gender' would be completely arcane. People would be 'growing' wings, tails, horns, extra limbs, extra large brains, fur, hoofs, cross breeding with animals, creating new species in petrie dishes. The 'regular humans' in that culture would be viewed like we view Amish people or Mennonites.
- dekhn 5y agoYou may also enjoy some of John Varley's early work (the short stories and books about the Eight Worlds). Physical sex changes (by cloning a new body and plopping the brain in, plus some extra "science magic" to make that work) are routine.
- Animats 5y agoSudden outbreak of common sense. We need, on social media, to learn how to deal more effectively with excessively loud, but not very numerous, activists. As some previous articles noted, trolling gets more clicks than facts. This empowers extremists, from Q-Anon on to trans activists.
- ausbah 5y agoit's very disingenuous to equate Q-Anon to trans rights activists
- bart_spoon 5y agoI'm not sure it is. There are disimilarities of course, but there are enough similarities to support the point they were making. That it makes you uncomfortable doesn't invalidate that.
- rootusrootus 5y agoWhat a tough problem to solve. My current thought on the gender identity issue is that society should default to the absolute minimum amount of categorizing people by their gender. What you identify as only matters to the extent that we divide people. Nobody would care if you used the women's bathroom, if such a thing did not exist. And when it is absolutely necessary for a distinction to exist, then we can spend the effort required to justify why, and along with that justification we should be able to clearly identify how it applies to transgender individuals. This would mean throwing out a lot of the more epheremeral complaints "I feel unsafe if there is a man in the bathroom." Why? Let's fix that part, then. Because there are going to be scary women too. I don't know. I don't have a really good answer I feel comfortable with. I do think a significant part of the problem, however, is not ideological, it is technological. It's way, way too easy to pile on with very little effort.
- IncRnd 5y ago> This would mean throwing out a lot of the more epheremeral complaints "I feel unsafe if there is a man in the bathroom." Why? Let's fix that part, then. Because there are going to be scary women too. Do you recognize that there are actual reasons that a woman might not want to go into a bathroom with 5 men in it?
- Udik 5y agoThat they peed all around the toilet?
- TedDoesntTalk 5y agoI recognize that. But isn’t that also a form of discrimination? The suggestion is that all men are capable of being perverts, using their camera phones inappropriately, bathroom harassment, etc. To build gender-specific bathrooms because of that generalization of men is hypocritical of the entire gender discrimination movement. Reverse discrimination.
- LatteLazy 5y agoCareful, it sounds like you might be banning 99% of a minority because 1% behaved badly. I know that's not what you intend. :)
- motohagiography 5y agoOne shouldn't expect courage from The Economist, but it's always wise to bet on their prudence. I don't read The Economist for facts or details so much as to get a sense of what topics a current establishment can no longer afford to ignore. The details are secondary to the neccessity that a writer, a sub-editor, and a senior editor with tremendous personal stake in maintaining access to the circles that define establishment media, have collectively recognized that to remain relevant as a publication, the risk/reward on any ensuing controversy still means the magazine has to acknowledge which way the wind is blowing. When The Economist says something is just starting, it means it's been brewing for at least several years and they need to comment on it. I don't think direct discourse on the topic improves the discussion on gender because the participants use a critical theory in which the promise of discourse is just bait to corner political targets for their mobs. However, we (and even The Economist) can recognize that popular tolerance for these tactics has finally reached an inflection point, and this change in attitude is what will finally allow real analysis and insight by thoughtful people into topics about gender.
- adventured 5y agoThe same has occurred in regards to race. For decades the ideological left preached, quite aggressively and consistently, that we must move to a post racial society, that race should not matter. This was the clear majority belief on the left as recently as the beginning of Obama's first term. My entire childhood was filled with that preached gospel: a person's character is what matters, do not pay attention to their skin color, look beneath that, their skin color is not what's important, what is important is what's on the inside. And so on. That ideology made tremendous sense to me. Now they are saying the exact opposite 24/7. Their messaging has entirely changed. Now race is paramount, the color of a person's skin matters in a huge way, everyone is to be divided by race, everyone is to be treated differently depending on their race. Society must be splintered by race. They're segregating everyone into tribes and pitting them against eachother. So was the former ideology bullshit, or is the new ideology bullshit. Their credibility is shot, not that anyone cares. Next week they'll switch it again if it serves their pursuit of power, and proceed to memory hole whatever the last ideology was that they were pushing as though it never happened.
- at_a_remove 5y agoThat's been my feeling -- one of them had to be wrong. And if you're wrong once, you can be wrong again, so perhaps it would be wise to be less certain of oneself.
- wetmore 5y agoI think the "they" in your post is actually a bunch of disparate groups. You are acting like there is internal inconsistency, but that's because the conflicting beliefs came out of different camps. Anyway, I think most people in support of the "new" ideology, as you call it, would say that the "old" ideology was flawed. Some might say it was bullshit, some might just say it was misguided or overly hopeful. Ideas change over time, I'm not sure why you think society's views on race should remain static, especially considering that the Civil Rights Movement was only a few generations ago. Every generation our theories of race change. The ideological right has also changed its stance on a lot of things. Do you also think that makes them have no credibility?
- 5y ago
- theknocker 5y agoThe word TERF is not a fucking "slur."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- noobermin 5y ago>“shut the fuck up, TERF” (trans-exclusionary radical feminist, a slur) I stopped reading there. The protestors are framed as crazy and insane but TERF is a slur, there's no "opinion" marker on the article, it's pretty clear the author is coming from a biased perspective although framed as objective. When they can't even start the article of a controversial topic with even a weak attempt at objectivity I know enough not to indulge.
- octernion 5y agoTERF is not a slur, lol. what?
- weakfish 5y agoYeah, asserting TERF, an acronym subsection of feminism, as a slur shows the true feeling behind the article.
- kerkeslager 5y agoWhy don't you quote the whole sentence there? > A flyer with an image of a gun and text reading “shut the fuck up, terf” (trans-exclusionary radical feminist, a slur) was circulating.
- noobermin 5y agoHow does that help??? TERF is not a slur, it is definitely used as an epithet, but only the targets of the term call it a slur making it obvious the authors are sympathetic to the terfs.
- kerkeslager 5y agoI'm not sure I understand the distinction you're making between "slur" and "epithet", but I suspect you're reading too much into that choice of word. The point I was making is that when you say "The protestors are framed as crazy"... it's not just framing. They sent a picture of a gun to a speaker--that IS crazy. If you can't even quote an entire sentence about the people you're defending, it's you that's doing the framing here. And yes, the author clearly has a bias. But if you refuse to read anyone who has a bias, you'd better just give up reading. You certainly showed a bit of bias in your selection of which parts of that sentence to quote. It seems like your real complaint is that you don't agree with the author--if that's the case, then this is your opportunity to say why you think the author is wrong. That's how you have a discussion with people you disagree with: you don't accuse them of bias, you don't try to shut them up, and you definitely don't send them pictures of guns. The truth has power. If what you're saying is actually true, you can get people to recognize it without making inane accusations, silencing naysayers, or making death threats. To be clear: I think it's perfectly fine to call someone a TERF if the accusation is true, and it's bad to be a TERF. But sending pictures of guns to people has no place in a civilized discussion, and we shouldn't be tolerating that behavior or covering it up.
- plank_time 5y agoI think we should accommodate trans people as much as we can, up to and including letting them be legally be considered the sex of their belief as long as they have transitioned to some degree, by taking hormones or surgery. However, I disagree with getting rid of biological sex. It’s absurd. Even down to the genetic level there is a biological definition of male and female and to say there isn’t is anti-science. We shouldn’t destroy science over this. Because of that I also don’t believe that trans women should be allowed to compete in competitive sports especially those that have dedicated their lives towards it. To put it in perspective, Serena Williams, one of the greatest if not the greatest tennis athlete of all time. She and Venus Williams were destroyed in her prime by the 200th ranked tennis player. The male tennis player felt like they were equivalent to a 600th ranked male player. The point being, you can’t make up for some genetic differences between men and women.
- anoncake 5y ago> I think we should accommodate trans people as much as we can, up to and including letting them be legally be considered the sex of their belief as long as they have transitioned to some degree, by taking hormones or surgery. Why do you think it's any of your business what other people do with their body? > To put it in perspective, Serena Williams, one of the greatest if not the greatest tennis athlete of all time. She and Venus Williams were destroyed in her prime by the 200th ranked tennis player. Looks like she is only the 201th greatest tennis player.
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y ago>I think we should accommodate trans people as much as we can, up to and including letting them be legally be considered the sex of their belief as long as they have transitioned to some degree, by taking hormones or surgery. See as they make up a smaller minority than most minority people in the US, I personally think that helping poor and working class people first would uplift them a lot quicker than letting trans people be trans. I mean it's great an all you get to be your own gender, but everybody will despise you knowing you got that way by tax payer money. If you got that way through working and paid for it yourself but were able to via worker protections and rights, the cultural stigma around it would be significantly far less vitriolic.
- metalman 5y agoMy personal experience of living and working,traveling with,family,friends,etc of all kinds of people including trans,gay,all the variants has left me with no conclusions whatsoever. On occasion someone would comment on another "that it takes all kinds to make the world go around" and I have never agreed,quite,my take is that there ARE all kinds and the world goes around anyway,and if you think that you are adjusted and are good with everyone then you dont get out much,cause if you are out there meeting new people in new situations well outside of your core group ,then you will find that there is no damn normal and a great deal that is just plain incomprehensible. Gender has become a team sport,and I have heard it said while with friends that so and so is "profesionaly gay" in that they have employment as a cultural sensitivity officer in a large organization and tend to become insuferable to all. I have also heard anicdotaly that F to M tranies often bail out of the "therapy" and come out with a new respect for men,in that having testosterone in thier system drives them to rage and anger and violence and they are astounded that men are not much much much worse that we are. Backlash you bet,and a good bit of it is comming from good honest people who are not strait and gendernormative. We need peace and prosperity for all,and pronouns will not supply that.
- drenvuk 5y agoCan someone please tell me how important this topic based on the amount of news time and eyeballs it attracts relative to the number of people that it affects? The numbers I can find for US citizens is: 0.6% or 1,988,696 out 331,449,281 of people total for the entirety of the US in 2021. >https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_demographics_of_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LGBT_demographics_of_the_Unite... In the UK where the featured article took place the latest poll I could find comes counts the number of people who selected "other" when choosing a sex at 0.4% or 224,632 people out of 64,596,800. >https://practicalandrogyny.com/2014/12/16/how-many-people-in-the-uk-are-nonbinary/ https://practicalandrogyny.com/2014/12/16/how-many-people-in... Personally I don't think this is very important compared to other topics. There are more blind people than trans people. There are more people with Alzheimer's than trans people. There are more people in the US who have lost a limb than trans people. I don't mean to downplay what is happening because it is happening but do you not think the amount of outrage this topic generates surpasses the level of impact we can have assuming we fix it? It just feels like we're being distracted.
- caeril 5y agoThere's a large segment of the population that feels actively threatened by trans rights. The two primary components are: 1. Parents and sexual violence victims concerned about the non-falsifiability of trans-identification and the related concerns of sexual predators claiming an identity they don't actually have to gain access to private spaces of women and girls. 2. Feminists (TERFs) who believe being a woman is a fundamental, biological identity and cannot be coopted by males. Interestingly enough, there's not much animosity toward trans-men. These groups exclusively concern themselves with trans-women. Mormons are probably another group due to the reliance of their theology on binary gender, but I don't see them as being particularly vocal on this topic.
- whateveracct 5y ago> Feminists (TERFs) One note: Nobody self-identifies as a TERF. Or at least not originally (I'm sure in Internet ire people do it ironically by now.) It's mostly a label used to crush nuanced conversation.
- joe_the_user 5y agoA relative of mine taught at a small art college a few years ago. The situation for college students, at least a certain segment, is that people with the transgender identity are far more common than they once were. That's the base reality, not the product of any ideology. And whatever it's point of origin, this reality for these isn't going to change. Now, you can object to various qualities of current gender ideologies and I'm not necessary uncritical myself. But these ideologies also mechanisms for accommodating the ability of transgender people existing minimally in the world. If someone intends to simply discard entirely these processes, they are essentially taking aim at this ability of transgender people to minimally exist. It's active question, to say the least. Transpeople today have a significant and growing chance of being murdered for being trans [1]. The attention put on this by the right wing also has resulted in violence masculine-appearing women. It should be noted that the Economist was talking about debate concerning whether transwomen should be put in men's or in women's prisons. How much do you think that's a matter of survival for these people? I'd love to see the details of gender ideology, the complex choices involved with hormones and surgery, etc debated more deeply but when the "debate" allows the question "should we allow these people to continue living?", you will see people willing to completely shut down discussion. [1] https://www.hrc.org/resources/fatal-violence-against-the-transgender-and-gender-non-conforming-community-in-2021 https://www.hrc.org/resources/fatal-violence-against-the-tra...
- neartheplain 5y ago>The situation for college students, at least a certain segment, is that people with the transgender identity are far more common than they once were. That's the base reality, not the product of any ideology. And whatever it's point of origin, this reality for these isn't going to change. A significant number of people who identity as trans later return to their original gender identity. This is known as "detransitioning:" https://www.thestranger.com/features/2017/06/28/25252342/the-detransitioners-they-were-transgender-until-they-werent https://www.thestranger.com/features/2017/06/28/25252342/the... It's a controversial topic, as many trans people see the existence of detrans people as a threat to the validity of their own identity. For their part, many detrans people resent the medical practitioners who they feel didn't adequately provide council or obtain informed consent before facilitating their transition, sometimes involving expensive, painful, and irreversible medical procedures. Some research also indicates most (!) children who identify as trans abandon this identity post-puberty: https://www.kqed.org/futureofyou/441784/the-controversial-research-on-desistance-in-transgender-youth https://www.kqed.org/futureofyou/441784/the-controversial-re... The Blocked and Reported podcast, which I generally find to be fair-minded and evenhanded, recently interviewed a detrans person who had worked at a SF gender transition clinic. I found their experience illuminating: https://barpodcast.fireside.fm/50 https://barpodcast.fireside.fm/50 The BBC and 60 Minutes have also produced reporting on this issue.
- kelvin0 5y agoWe should focus on giving ALL humans a nurturing environment and allow them to grow to achieve their full potential and in turn be able to share their talents to help others. There is pain, sorrow. There is also place to grow and live a meaningful life and be happy. Anything else is just nitpicking and a red herring. Creating an infinity of subcategories of humans is not the solution, because it incentives the us-them paradigm, and of course polarization of discourse. Intolerance in any forms is destructive in nature.
- f154hfds 5y agoI can't imagine what this debate must feel like to someone who grew up in the 50's, 60's and 70's. Until 10 years ago gay marriage wasn't official policy of Obama or Clinton or I believe the majority of the Democratic party. The pace is dizzying. It feels like a race to the bottom, but I don't know where the bottom even is. Without push back this could spell the end of women's sports, women's prisons - heck, pretty much all institutions for women (except natal/health related) are facing an existential crisis over this. Women's sports are the most obvious. Why would a woman participate in the highest level of competition if she has no chance of success no matter what she does because she was born with XX chromosomes? One transgender athlete in the meet is one thing. What happens when gold, silver and bronze are all taken away? Of all our recent societal enlightenments this one seems most ill-fated. Trans activists should be able to foresee this eventuality and realize it's a bridge too far. At the end of the day, we live in a culture where identity self-actualization is the paramount freedom without which one is considered oppressed. My question is really where do we settle out? Where are the boundaries that we recognize as a society are put there for our own protection? What happens when one person's self-actualization is in direct conflict with another's? When one group's (cis women) is in conflict with another's (trans women)?
- plank_time 5y ago> Until 10 years ago gay marriage wasn't official policy of Obama I think you are misremembering. Obama was actively against gay marriage and defended his views against gay marriage through the 2012 election. I think Biden was the one to first broach the topic in 2014 with his active support for it.
- f154hfds 5y agoI think that's what I'm saying too unless I misunderstand. 2012 was 9 years ago, and Obama was anti gay marriage. So was Clinton for that matter until about 2015. https://www.eqca.org/hillary-clinton-has-a-new-position-on-same-sex-marriage/ https://www.eqca.org/hillary-clinton-has-a-new-position-on-s...
- seph-reed 5y agoWhen I was in high school, we read both "1984" and "Brave New World." At the time I kind of thought: "liberals are more like BNW with drugs and 'karma' and such, and conservatives are more like 1984 with endless wars and refusing to acknowledge things." At some point in my life, it feels this has flipped. I now see conservatives as consuming soma (tv) to lull them into a false and simple world, and liberals as enforcing wrong-think. Obviously, life is much more complex than two books, and similarities can be drawn in any direction. But I still find it interesting having watched my perceptions flip.
- otde 5y agoOn other subjects on HN (software, mostly), I find curious, questioning people, who will, for the most part, engage very seriously with the subject matter. I think this is because users here engage with software -- the creation, maintenance, collaboration, the joy and misery of it all -- frequently and with a passion for nuance. When high-visibility articles on trans people show up, it's almost inevitably when our transness -- our ability to move through the world, to exist in certain spaces, or even if we exist at all -- is the subject of debate. I don't know how many cisgender folks here really get how fundamentally exhausting it is to have some part of your identity always be part of a debate, to be talked about or on rare occasions talked to, but almost never engaged with in a substantive way. It's just fear fear fear, 24/7 -- simulating hypothetical nightmare worlds where trans rapists lurk in bathrooms and prisons, where every Olympic gold medal is taken by a man masquerading as a woman, roving hordes of red-faced trans activists screaming incoherently online at nice, well-meaning, harmless people who just want to learn. I just wanted to put out there that the flattened, simplified perspectives trans people are portrayed with may not give you the whole picture, and I'd encourage people here to give perspectives from trans people the same (well, more, preferably) curiosity and interest that you might give to scare quotes and soundbites about prisons, bathrooms, and sports.
- worik 5y agoI agree that there is more heat than light in these debates. The Gender Critical Feminists do make up bogeyman stories about rapists in prisons, trans women disrupting breast feeding groups etcetera. The Trans lobby though has also been guilty of the same sort of thing. E.g. I am no fan of professional sport (I hope this kills it dead) but to claim that trans women have no advantage over natal women is opinion not fact. The main fault line ion our society is gender, and to claim otherwise is simply wrong. (Not all Trans activists do that, just as not all Gender Critical Feminists are mean). To me it is heartbreaking that this is not about fixing that fault line. No person has the right to take a interest in another person's gender unless they are their doctor or fancy them and are fussy. That is the issue we should address - how boys are raised to be violent sexual predators requiring female admiration and women are raised to be weak victims requiring male support. That is getting lost, instead of helping fix the fault line, this debate (the excess of heat, deficiency of light) is making it worse.
- pgcj_poster 5y agoI'm not going to read or respond to any of the comments in this thread because I don't want to self-harm today. However, I have to comment on the site linked in the article, noconflicttheysaid.org, because it's absolutely hilarious. It has stories about the supposed negative impact of trans women in women's spaces. I'm not cherry-picking; from the top, the stories on the first two pages are: 1. A woman and her two daughters went into a unisex bathroom. As you might expect, there were men there. Then nothing happened. Also, several years earlier, she went into a women's bathroom that indicated it allowed transgender women, but there weren't any there. https://www.noconflicttheysaid.org/post/scienceworks-immunologist-s-office-bathrooms https://www.noconflicttheysaid.org/post/scienceworks-immunol... 2. A trans woman in a Facebook group for mothers was trying to simulate a pregnancy and asked people there to share their experience with miscarriages since she knew she couldn't have a baby in the end. She also said she would like to breastfeed someone else's baby. As far as it's indicated, these requests were not made to anyone in particular, they were just posted in Facebook group. https://www.noconflicttheysaid.org/post/online-group-for-breastfeeding-mothers https://www.noconflicttheysaid.org/post/online-group-for-bre... 3. Some trans students at a girl's school don't have to wear the uniform, miss school a lot, and do school projects on transgender issues. Apparently, other students resent them for this. https://www.noconflicttheysaid.org/post/all-girls-senior-school https://www.noconflicttheysaid.org/post/all-girls-senior-sch... 4. A trans woman cursed at some counter-protesters at a trans rights rally. In the included video, we see that this was in reaction to the counter-protesters (although not the same ones apparently) spraying water(?) at people. https://www.noconflicttheysaid.org/post/who-s-unsafe-on-campus https://www.noconflicttheysaid.org/post/who-s-unsafe-on-camp... 5. A woman who was previously sexually assaulted by men says that she gets nervous and her body tenses up when she's sees a large man. She claims that this is something trans women will never understand. This is completely ridiculous: I myself have this reaction too if I'm alone or it's at night (in a way I did not before I transitioned), and I know other trans women who have similar anxieties about men in general. Anyway, the story is that a trans woman on a bus (where trans women have always been allowed) told some young women that they were pretty and asked them where they bought clothes and underwear. I'll admit that's a bit creepy, but no more so than things men already say to women in public spaces. And again, is the suggestion to ban trans women from buses? https://www.noconflicttheysaid.org/post/trans-woman-harassing-young-girls-on-melbourne-public-transport https://www.noconflicttheysaid.org/post/trans-woman-harassin... 6. There was a trans woman in a women's bathroom lingering near the sink. https://www.noconflicttheysaid.org/post/women-s-toilets-in-hospital https://www.noconflicttheysaid.org/post/women-s-toilets-in-h...
- rasengan0 5y agoLGBT+ are humans. And humans rights are for all. I tend to ignore articles about squabbling but groups influence change and adaptation is key to getting along [1] I learned new terms in the article like TERF and gender-critical. I'm sure there will be more jargon and terminology to fill the DEI consultancy industry. Not sure of the downstream effects but so far my USB cables are not gender fluid, but maybe that is not a good thing. Meanwhile, the globe is warming. [1] https://www.npr.org/2021/06/02/996319297/gender-identity-pronouns-expression-guide-lgbtq https://www.npr.org/2021/06/02/996319297/gender-identity-pro...
- nrjames 5y agoI worked for a company that hired 4 trans women (out of 7 people total) during a "diversity hiring" push, then touted the diversity of the hires. All of the trans women had been raised and had gone through university as white men, earning comp sci degrees, before transitioning in their mid- to late-twenties. While I do not debate that those individuals represent a type of diversity in the current company makeup, it always struck me that they likely received the same privileges that most white males do in technical degree programs. As competent programmers, I'm glad they found good jobs. Did they represent diversity hires? I still wonder how HR departments take this into consideration when pushing for diversity.
- cwkoss 5y agoI think meaning of the term diversity is often twisted into a binary outcome. If a company is 65% white and 35% Chinese is that more diverse than a company that is 70% white, 10% Chinese, 10% Indian, and 10% Vietnamese? Often, the above two examples would be flattened to just 35% or 30% Asian. But even my example is very reductive - China, for example, has many dozens of ethnic groups. I think 'diversity' is a very hard thing to quantify, which makes it more difficult to measure the effectiveness of initiatives to increase diversity. Can anyone point me towards better methods of measuring diversity? If society or a particular organization wishes to increase diversity, it seems important to be able to measure it with more nuance.
- jbay808 5y ago> Can anyone point me towards better methods of measuring diversity? It depends on what you want to achieve, but for companies, the goal is probably diversity of belief, opinion, culture, and experience. That way you can have a good spread of ideas and increase your odds of being able to understand your customers (who are probably also diverse). So you could run anonymized surveys of your staff asking things like "have you ever changed a baby's diaper", "do you play any instruments", "do you speak the same language at home as your grandparents do", "if you could only have one carbohydrate would you choose rice, pasta, bread, or potatoes", etc, and then measure the entropy of the responses.
- 5y ago
- weeblewobble 5y agoThis article is the number one most active post on Culture War (Hacker) News today. I'm not sure what that says about this forum but it's not good.
- dalbasal 5y agoI'm surprised that the article isn't more sports-centric. This "battle," has been mostly an elite-ish, university-centric one this far. Gender studies departments were always known as bastions of avant garde quirkiness. The Germaine Greare's of the world have always been at war with someone, name-calling and whatnot. Theatrical protests aren't new, and neither is their intensity. Leakage into the real world was indirect at best, and leakage into the elite world was usually in the form of recreational rhetoric. When ordinary people hear about it, it's usually from the politically polar... reaching for examples of crazy social progressives. Sports though... sports is something people actually care about. That's where "gender ideology" is now, and this is where things start to get serious... where we see what sticks and what doesn't. Prisons and shelters... those are bystanders, one way or another. ^ I'm not talking about the actual changes or lack thereof affecting trans people. I'm talking about the war over abstract philosophical points.. which manifest in specific areas such as prisons, sports, etc. The "fat man on a rail cart" scenarios.
- neartheplain 5y agoThe battle has very much leaked off-campus, and not just in sports. One intense area of disagreement involves the rights of trans children to medically transition without their parents' knowledge or consent. Research consistently shows that most children who identity as trans revert to their original gender identity post-puberty [0]. However, more states are now enabling children to seek and obtain irreversible gender transition care on their own, without parental consent, to include surgery and hormone therapy [1]: >[Seattle] minors age 13 and up are entitled to admit themselves for inpatient and outpatient mental health treatment without parental consent. Health insurers are forbidden from disclosing to the insured parents’ sensitive medical information of minor children—such as that regarding “gender dysphoria [and] gender affirming care.” Minors aged 13 to 18 can withhold mental health records from parents for “sensitive” conditions, which include both “gender dysphoria” and “gender-affirming care.” Insurers in Washington must cover a wide array of “gender-affirming treatments” from tracheal shaves to double mastectomies. >Oregon passed a law permitting minors 15 and older to obtain puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and surgeries at taxpayers’ expense—all without parental consent. In 2018, California passed a similar bill for all children in foster care, age 12 and up. Similarly, in a Canadian family court case involving a 14 year old trans child [2]: >Attempting to persuade AB to abandon treatment for gender dysphoria; addressing AB by his birth name; referring to AB as a girl or with female pronouns whether to him directly or to third parties; shall be considered to be family violence under s. 38 of the Family Law Act. In the event where the trans child de-transitions post-puberty, these procedures may leave them with severe body dismorphia or render them unable to produce or bear children. I don't have kids (yet), but I had body dismorphia as a young adult. It almost killed me, but I grew out of it in time. Fortunately, it wasn't the kind that compelled me to seek life-altering medical procedures. I fear that my future child may suffer from a similar case of temporary body dismorphia, seek and obtain permanent life-altering procedures which I am legally unable to prevent, and later come to deeply regret the damage done to their body by these procedures. Again, the best data we have on trans kids shows that most choose to revert to their original gender identity post-puberty [0]. [0] https://www.thestranger.com/features/2017/06/28/25252342/the-detransitioners-they-were-transgender-until-they-werent https://www.thestranger.com/features/2017/06/28/25252342/the... [1] https://www.city-journal.org/transgender-identifying-adolescents-threats-to-parental-rights https://www.city-journal.org/transgender-identifying-adolesc... [2] https://www.bccourts.ca/jdb-txt/sc/19/06/2019BCSC0604.htm https://www.bccourts.ca/jdb-txt/sc/19/06/2019BCSC0604.htm
- alfl 5y agoI think in 10 years we'll look back at what is now contemporary discourse as a reaction formation[0]. Essentially the left-wing version of homophobic closeted Republicans. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reaction_formation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reaction_formation
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zapdrive 5y agoSlightly off topic, but where can I get some popcorn?
- cryptica 5y agoMy view on gender is the same as anything else. We should accept the cards we're dealt and focus on our strengths. Nobody is making you focus on your problems, you can choose what to focus on. If you were born as the wrong gender, why would you focus on that? You will probably never win that battle. You can never be satisfied because you will never have what most other people have. You should try to focus on other things where you actually have a reasonable chance of success; of feeling satisfied. Most people are deepy dissatisfied with certain aspects of themselves and if you ignore these things long enough and focus on other things intensely, eventually, after a decade or two you may stop caring about your complexes completely.
- freemint 5y agoWhile this adopting this positive attitude will improve anyone's situation it might in fact only lead to a local Optima in the wellbeing of certain people and I find it unfair to restrict them away from a path leading to better solution for them. Not everyone works as you do.
- cryptica 5y agoIn my case, I focused away from my personal complexes for so long that nowadays I don't care about them at all. The negative emotion is completely gone. When I was younger, I was obsessed with my appearance and the sound of my voice. Thinking about them constantly and always feeling terrible about myself 24/7. Stuck in a loop. This led to a constant sense of self-loathing and kept my self-esteem low which probably made things worse. I had to bury myself in something difficult for years and really struggle at it in order to escape these negative feedback loops.
- syngrog66 5y agoexcellent to see. its been one of the more Orwellian trends I've seen in the US in recent years. I wouldnt say its even a top 5 or top 10 problem, but it is bad. its been increasingly unpleasant having to always worry whether any given sentence or idea shared on social media will be jumped on by an indoctrinated online mob, blind to all nuance.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- idontgiveash1t 5y agoHow am I supposed to accept the notion of gender when it's still contentious scientifically? This was something coined by a child abuser and gets you cancelled if you don't pay lip service. Sounds legit.
- AIX2ESXI 5y agoAbout freaking time, this has been way overdue. The ability to offend is to critically think. If you have cannot handle dissenting opinions or facts, this invalidates your movement or ideology. So that is why many are silenced. Academia is full of those who stifle others for power...
- karaterobot 5y agoI don't think the story here is about a backlash to gender ideology on campus per se: it's about a backlash to certain protest tactics that get used a lot. Namely, the practice of protesting a respected lecturer whose ideas you disagree with, and pressuring the administration to support your position with a formal denunciation so strong it starts looking libelous against the lecturer, damaging their career and sometimes their personal lives. Sooner or later, this is bound to backfire legally, so the administration has to be worried about it becoming widespread. It also changes the power dynamic in the university, making administrators defer to students out of intimidation, and probably creating a lot of enmity in the process. Until convinced otherwise, I'm viewing this as an example of the administration trying to reassert itself, and this particular gender ideology case just happens to be the proxy battle for that.
- apsec112 5y agoThis article seems to confusingly mix together free speech issues with the issue of whether things are true/moral. A lot of things are completely legal to say, but obviously false (eg, 2 + 2 = 5) or abhorrent (eg, Kim Jong Un is a great leader). You can support free speech without agreeing with a particular viewpoint.
- beckman466 5y ago> Yet the most worrying effect is likely to be invisible. An unknown number of university employees avoid expressing their opinion for fear it will damage their career or turn them into pariahs. The report about Essex says witnesses described a “culture of fear” among those with gender-critical views. Why the hell is this a bad thing? I also don't want to hear from conservatives about their anti-women abortion stances (which they Doublespeak-ingly refer to as their 'pro-life' position). Yes there are a bunch of conservatives in Europe, but fuck no can they stop women from having autonomy over their body and choosing to have an abortion. Also once you have a trans friend and you hear first hand about their journeys to figure themselves out, why would you intentionally misgender this friend and not honor their request for their chosen pronouns? At same point it's just purely about intentionally causing others pain; likely it's some unconscious pain originating from some traumas, which ends up getting directed and projected onto others. The Economist is neo-liberal and conservative drivel. Can't believe my economics teacher was trying to get us to read it.
- matchbok 5y agoNothing wrong with neo-liberal stances. I'll take that over the progressive left who seem to have missed every Econ class when they went to college (and operate exclusively on identity politics, like you)
- 0xcde4c3db 5y agoWith the focus on academic freedom and ideological hegemony, I can't help but feel like this article is tilling the soil for something akin to a "teach the controversy" campaign [1], i.e. the sort of thing that ideological movements turn to when they've run out of actual arguments that can stem the tide of a shifting consensus and have no option left but to invoke a sort of meta-debate about whether their ideas are receiving a fair hearing. It's not clear to me that "gender critics" are more broadly embracing this stance, but it wouldn't be much of a shock at this point. I suppose I'll keep an eye out for the announcement of "Expelled 2: No Gender Allowed" [2]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teach_the_Controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Teach_the_Controversy [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expelled%3A_No_Intelligence_Allowed https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expelled%3A_No_Intelligence_Al...
- etempleton 5y agoGender is a social construct. Sex is a medical definition. Gender can be fluid and ever changing. Sex is fixed at birth. This is obvious, but it is at the crux of every debate that is happening surrounding transgender people and so I really think people are struggling with the definitions. Or, more likely, it is all ideological lines in the sand. Can trans women compete in women’s sports? Well, why do women’s sports exist in the first place? They exist because there are phisological differences between males and females that render competition unfair in most all athletic contests. Each college and pro sports would be dominated by one sex. Most sports would be exclusively male, though gymnastics would likely be female dominated. If gender is fluid anyone could switch between the two at any time. Will people do this? Probably not. Will suddenly trans women take over womens’s sports if allowed? No. Almost certainly not, but it does kind of beg the question of why the category exists at all. People should be able to be themselves and do what they want as long as they aren’t infringing on others rights. And trans people are most certainly included in that. However, some people feel that transwomen are infringing upon women’s rights laws such as title ix. The answer to that lies in the question of are sports divided by gender or sex. If by gender every gender, of which there are many, would have equal claim to the same rights under title ix. This would be an impossible requirement to fill. The intention of the law was always to be divided by sex, not gender, even if historically we, as a society, have used the terms interchangeably.
- seaorg 5y agoAny form of dogma, no matter which side of the isle it comes from, is poison. Even things that seem silly like pronouns can be the seed from which serious problems arise. It’s because dogma is the absence of rational thought, and in that absence irrational beasts can grow very large.
- freemint 5y agoYet "Any form of dogma, no matter which side of the isle it comes from, is poison." is itself a dogma. Curious. Hoffstädter might have enjoyed this strange loop.
- Mindwipe 5y agoThe Economist is not neutral on this - it has numerous editorial staff with a long history of transphobia, and a very vested interest in trying to propagate a general backlash against rights for trans people. Much of this article is vague - things are "growing" with little evidence to back such assertions up. The reason for that is that they are primarily wishful thinking.
- matchbok 5y agoThey aren’t transphobic. They understand science. There’s a difference.
- Mindwipe 5y agoNo, they are actively transphobic. Even the Economist agrees, having withdrawn a piece calling for the compulsory sterilisation of transpeople previously.
- matchbok 5y agoAgain, no. One withdrawn article? That's it? Ok. They don't buy into the nonsense that males should be competing against females. Aka common sense.
- raxxorrax 5y agoYou just supplied a case example for their argument.
- swiley 5y agoThis was already starting when I was in university a couple years ago, more accurately people are hearing about it now.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]