35 ms·
Almost 90 percent of NYC bars and restaurants couldn’t pay August rent
- runawaybottle 6y agoBail them out. We bailed out far worse in this lifetime for us to wince at this.
- markdown 6y agoThat money just goes straight to landlords. Henry George's time has come.
- t-writescode 6y agoThose landlords also need bailing out. They need to pay their loans, as well.
- nradov 6y agoI don't want my tax money used to bail out landlords. Let the lenders foreclose. If the landlords didn't want to deal with loans then they should have paid cash for the properties.
- t-writescode 6y agoI'm interested in my tax money being used to help stabilize the local population to minimize harm to them during this time and thereby minimize unrest and keep the whole of it safer. If my money is going to be going to making missiles and weapons for overseas, some of it can come back and pay for rough times instead.
- AdamJacobMuller 6y agoA less drastic solution, which doesn't require much money, is to just force lenders to allow landlords who lost tenants or whose tenants can't pay to allow the landlord to defer loan payments (extending the final date of the loan). It's not exactly fair to landlords who own the properties outright, but, I can live with that.
- t-writescode 6y agoIs it turtles all the way up? Do the landlords who are paying down their mortgage also get a deferment? What do we do about the people that presently have no money? Do we also give them a stipend to pay for food, etc? Or force them onto credit cards?
- peteretep 6y agoIf you can borrow from the central bank, the buck stops at you. Seems fair
- nradov 6y agoMany commercial property mortgages already contain clauses allowing the borrower to defer payments if they don't have a tenant. For those that don't, well they should have negotiated better terms before taking out the loan.
- respondo2134 6y ago>>It's not exactly fair to landlords who own the properties outright, but, I can live with that. Well of course you're OK with that, you're obviously not a property investor who worked to get free and clear. What if instead we levied a special premium salary fee on technology workers who make more than the median salary? Not really fair but us worker bees are OK with it...
- imtringued 6y agoYou can live with endangering the banking infrastructure? The place where all your hard earned money is stored at? This will end with a bank bailout because nobody wants to lose their money because some idiot decided to implement deferment of loan payments.
- apta 6y agoHow will preventing lenders from foreclosing prevent harm? If anything, it will allow people to purchase property since prices will reduce as there is more supply in the market.
- username90 6y agoIt would be nice if it actually worked that way, but about 25% of US government spending are debt and not taxes in a normal year. So these bailouts doesn't come from your taxes, they are pure government debt that will crash the economy sometimes in the future when the government stops propping up the gdp via endless debt accumulation. Imagine if they were honest instead and said "We pay these bailouts now and increase taxes from 30% to 50% for the next 10 years to make up for it", how many would be happy?
- twblalock 6y ago> If the landlords didn't want to deal with loans then they should have paid cash for the properties. If the tenants didn't want to pay rent, they should not have signed leases. Why is it that tenants can get a break on their obligations but landlords can't? Why are tenants more deserving of help? Most landlords are not rich. They are providing a service to their tenants, who cannot afford to purchase buildings and would have no hope of opening a business if there were not landlords around willing to rent things out.
- nradov 6y agoOwning real estate is an investment, not a right. It's no different than any other investment. If I have a loss on leveraged stock investments should the government bail me out?
- twblalock 6y agoWe are not talking about investment losses here. We are talking about breach of contract. A renter signs a contract promising to pay rent. The value of the building, whether it drops or increases, is the investment component of being a landlord. That is not in dispute here. If a building drops in value the landlord just has to deal with it. But until now, if someone promised to pay rent and did not do it, a landlord could sue them, or evict them, because the landlord would be the victim of a breach of contract that has nothing to do with investment value. What is in dispute here is that people who promised to pay rent are being allowed to stop paying, but landlords who promised to pay their mortgages are not allowed to stop paying. That's not fair. It's not good for the economy either, because most businesses can't afford to buy property and need to rent from landlords, and we are now making it very unattractive to be a landlord.
- t-writescode 6y ago> but landlords who promised to pay their mortgages are not allowed to stop paying. Why not provide them an extension during this time, as well?
- denkmoon 6y agoDo I get a bailout for my losses on the share market? What if I had bought shares on margin? Why does one class of investor get a bailout but not others? (Why bailout any investor? Risk is part of investment.)
- runawaybottle 6y agoThe moral hazard argument does not work in this case for a variety of reasons.
- javagram 6y agoThe S&P 500 and NASDAQ are both up year to date. The government has already taken actions, including injecting trillions of dollars into the economy, to bail out shareholders. > Why bailout any investor? Risk is part of investment. The damage caused by this pandemic is so rare it is less than a 1-in-100-years event (1918 pandemic killed millions, but businesses were typically shuttered only for weeks at most, not 6 months). Certainly bailouts for natural disasters are quite common in other respects. And if the government were to seize your property via eminent domain, they owe you money. Why shouldn’t they also in justice pay out if they order your business shuttered for a half a year?
- swiley 6y agoGod no. They've been sitting on empty buildings for years. It's time for them to default on the underwater loans and let people actually put the wasted space to use. Every city in the US has a similar issue including the one near where I grew up and it's the weirdest most broken thing. I remember many times walking down streets flanked by empty buildings with homeless people sleeping outside.
- DeonPenny 6y agoThats not how any of this works. The problem with a market is you have a rate that if something is below it its not profitable for people to live in a place. Idk why people blame the building owners. And people who do this are always people with perfectly good couches in their living rooms but would never let a homeless person sleep there, but want others to give up a entire building.
- newfriend 6y agoAnd then you want to give them my money, taken from me by force by the government.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- swiley 6y agoThat would work in a normal market but the realestate market hasn't been allowed to correct because we keep bailing it out by having the fed buy up all the debt. This raises rent because it decreases the supply (people can just hold onto buildings as investments and not bother renting them out or wait for someone willing to pay something that should be above market value) and also raises inflation. Let me explain it to you simply: The landlords made a bad investment, bailing them out forces everyone else to pay for it. In the "it's my property" sense it's identical to forcing someone to house homeless people (although the comparison still isn't the same because the landlords generally don't live in the buildings they're renting out.)
- 6y ago
- dehrmann 6y agoAnd property taxes.
- jojobas 6y agoWould you also bail out those who bet on black and got red? When you bail out something like Ford you keep it running and collect tax revenue. If you don't, factories stop and the business essentially disappears. When a landlord goes bust nothing happens, other the financial loss for the landlord.
- refurb 6y agoWhen a landlord goes bust nothing happens, other the financial loss for the landlord. It's like the old saying "when you own the $10,000, that's your problem", "when you own the bank $1B, that's the banks problem". When 1/3 of NYC commercial real estate gets foreclosed, that's not just the landlord's problem, that's everyone's problem.
- jojobas 6y agoWhen 1/3 of NYC gets foreclosed the new tenants will swarm to rent the places at a discount and reopen the cafes and everything else as soon as they're allowed to operate.
- wmf 6y agoBailouts combined with mandated (maybe partial) rent forgiveness would ensure that money did not go straight to landlords.
- runawaybottle 6y agoI don’t want restaurants with good locations to lose their spot, even if it means bailing out landlords.
- ars 6y agoThere are "660,755" restaurants in the US (according to Google), and average rent is $5,000/month = $3,303,775,000 (3 billion per month). Seems doable? Except .... did you forget about all the other places not paying rent? My guess is around 10 million of them. So "only" $60 billion or so per month. Is that affordable? Well, do you want to pay that in taxes?
- t-writescode 6y agoLet's walk this forward some. Restaurants provide jobs, probably 20ish jobs per restaurant. If every restaurant closed down, that's something like 12 million unemployed people who can no longer find employment at those restaurants. Some of those employees might even make enough money to pay taxes and not get their tax money back. What do you think the solution is, rather than just slamming someone's theory on what to do?
- chottocharaii 6y agoMandatory rent holidays.
- ars 6y agoYah, those numbers just cover rent. If you want to cover payroll as well those numbers are going to skyrocket. If you think that's a good use of money, well, make your argument. But please include a cost while doing that. You can't just say "bail them out" and not say how much that will cost. Maybe it's affordable, maybe it's not - but be upfront with your numbers.
- runawaybottle 6y agoIt’s doable the same way VC funding for startups is doable. Post vaccine, we expect this industry to thrive again. Bail out the immediate financial commitments, and provide interest free federal loans that don’t have to be repaid for up to three years (similar to student loans). Hell, similar to the loans we gave too big to fail banks once upon a time. I’ve paid for unjust wars in my lifetime and I’ve paid for global financial scams in my lifetime, so I’m prepared to pay for simple restaurants surviving the apocalyptic numbers we’re hearing (60% of restaurants not reopening according to Yelp).
- jacquesc 6y agoLooks like The Onion was right on with their reporting: "Study Finds Most Restaurants Fail Within First Year Of It Becoming Illegal To Go To Them"
- MiroF 6y ago> "Study Finds Most Restaurants Fail Within First Year Of It Becoming Illegal To Go To Them Even without these laws, personal decisions would have decimated the business regardless. Even in places didn't shut down, patronage plummeted.
- anm89 6y agoDon't eat the onion.
- MiroF 6y agoI know it's the onion, I'm responding to the commentary that it's making. Many of its articles have depth to them.
- just-juan-post 6y agoIf people are scared and won't go to restaurants and bars then why continue to keep them closed? You are saying that patronage is already down so why even restrict them? Give people and businesses a choice in the matter. This is about letting individuals and businesses make their own decisions without the government forcing them to close.
- bmn__ 6y agoThat would be fine and dandy if the decision to engage in risky behaviour only affects the individuals and businesses making them. However, this is not the case in reality.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dehrmann 6y agoOnly related because NY, but NY state covid 19 new cases have been incredibly flat since June. I would think they'd trend closer to zero, up some, or just bounce around more. Normally, new cases are driven up by complacency and down by fear or policy, but there doesn't seem to be either happening quickly and subtly enough to keep new cases between 500 and 1000 for so long, and r0 should be metastable, so keeping it in that range for so long is unexpected.
- grey-area 6y agoYes there's something going on we don't understand, because some places that were hit very hard first time round are not seeing a second wave.
- dannyw 6y agoPerhaps the "something" is simply antibodies and herd immunity? 1. In April (!!), 1 in 5 NYCers tested positive for antibodies: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/23/nyregion/coronavirus-antibodies-test-ny.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/04/23/nyregion/coronavirus-anti... 2. Given asymmetric social contact patterns, experts estimate that ~20% may be the threshold for herd immunity of COVID: https://theconversation.com/coronavirus-could-it-be-burning-out-after-20-of-a-population-is-infected-141584 https://theconversation.com/coronavirus-could-it-be-burning-... I support looking at the science, and this means looking at it both ways; not just cherry-picking doom and worst case scenarios while ignoring best case scenarios. We can't afford to let an "overabundance of caution" kill businesses and our economy, for good.
- adventured 6y agoTo add to this, Sweden isn't seeing the big surge that France and Spain are seeing (among others, including Belgium and the Netherlands, both at or near record highs). Sweden's cases have dropped lower and have stayed there. Given their comparatively open approach to the virus, they should be seeing a surge. While it's possible it'll show up in the near future as it again spreads across parts of Europe, I think it's also plausible they've reached a partial herd immunity. The commonly repeated premise that you need ~60% to reach herd immunity is plainly false, that's a calculation meant for a vacuum. In reality people aren't numbers on a sheet or living in a vacuum, all people don't behave the same way, don't spread a virus the same way, aren't all similarly at risk, some large percentage of the population may already have immunity thanks to prior exposure to other coronaviruses, and so on.
- Blackthorn 6y agoWhat's really crazy is that movie theaters in this state aren't allowed to open, but still have to pay their property taxes (which will likely bankrupt them). I have no love for some of them, but bullshit is bullshit.
- altcognito 6y agoI thought it was obscene for some studios to charge upwards of $30 for their movie, and then not kick back some of that to theatres. It probably wouldn't take much to tide them over. They aren't running much in the way of expenses other than rent. Would have been a great tag to their sales pitch. But it's like they don't even think about theatres.
- RhysU 6y agoThey are still using the property. If one has an empty barn one pays property tax on it.
- 01100011 6y agoSubsidizing the restaurants without getting anything in return seems like a misallocation of capital. Allowing 'creative destruction' on a massive scale is harmful to social stability and frankly just cruel. People didn't plan for it, because it is implied in our various social contracts that they don't need to(and that may be wrong, but this is not the time to fix that). We should consider subsidizing the restaurants to continue to do what they do best: provide food. We need to meet in the middle and provide some assistance while still getting 'wealth'(desired goods and services in this case) but not fully subsidizing empty buildings and idle employees. The delivery or pick-up models work in a pandemic, but they fail to provide enough profit to keep businesses open. Let's bridge that gap. This isn't the time to test out your ideologically pure political/economic/social theories. We need to be pragmatic and get our people and economy through this crisis.
- gkoberger 6y agoYou can't end with "this isn't the time for ideology" after three paragraphs of YOUR ideology. For some restaurants, takeout is easy and they can make it work! For others, it really really isn't. What about bars, where most money is made on alcohol? You got it backward. These restaurants all presumably paid taxes and employed people, some for literally a century. Why do you expect them right now, when they're suffering the most, to "give something back" if they don't want to die?
- brutusborn 6y agoWhy should we not expect organizations to give something back?
- gkoberger 6y agoI answered that already. Because they paid taxes and employed people. It's like an insurance company that drops you as soon as you file a claim... you pay into a pool, expecting it to be there when you need it. This is an unheard of situation, don't forget. The government (rightfully so, in my opinion) is forcing these restaurants to shut down dining. It's not like they're shutting down because they're "lazy".
- baybal2 6y agoThere is a youtuber called Louis Rosman. He made a lot of videos describing the issue vividly.
- toper-centage 6y agoAh yes. He's a NYC real estate specialist, but also a part-time apple device repairman.
- viraptor 6y agoDoes anyone know what happens in practice with places where restaurants run in a space where the landlord defaulted? If the place is repossessed, I expect a bank which takes over the space would have more gain from literally anyone paying anything for the place until it's sold. On the other hand, I'm not sure the partial rent would be relevant at all to the bank which likely has no issues with sitting on an empty property. What's likely to happen in practice?
- dannyw 6y agoThe Fed creates new emergency program / SPV that purchases foreclosed properties from banks, leases it to the original landlord at near-zero rates; until the outlook is more table equity value becomes positive again and then this 'troubled asset' will be sold back to the original bank. Basically, expect several years of mortgage holidays for property owners, through the Fed. To inflate the property market, the Fed will continue to purchase mortgage backed securities, (they currently own 1/3 of all MBSes) driving down the cost of interest, which increases borrowing power and demand, and drives up home prices.
- paxys 6y agoIt's ridiculous that we couldn't coordinate a rent/mortgage forgiveness plan alongside all the customer bans put in place across the country. If a restaurant can't stay open, they shouldn't pay rent. If the property owner isn't getting rent, they shouldn't have to pay mortgage. And so on, up the entire chain.
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoThat's exactly what an economic contraction is. A long chain of payments not being made (regardless of one's legal obligation to do so). Breaking the chain causes new problems. It reduces spending and purse strings get tightened. When the mortgage doesn't get paid, the mortgage backed security isn't getting its repayments. The retirees living off the dividends from the REIT don't get paid. Then the retiree spends less in the economy, which would've paid the restaurant worker's wages. When the chain breaks, the whole system is impacted. Think of it as a graph. When payments aren't flowing from one node to the next due to crisis, the solution is to have the government ensure those payments be made via taking on debt in bad times (and less borrowing in good times).
- jjeaff 6y agoYes, but let's be honest, most retirees today aren't living off dividends. Except for those who are indirectly living off them through pension plans. And those huge pensions and funds will be the first to receive a bailout. The vast majority of the ownership of the stock market is owned by the very wealthy. Most of main street's wealth is in their home, and while home values dropping can hurt them, these assets aren't usually income generating.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kgc 6y agoWhat's at the top of the chain though?
- davidw 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- electro_blah 6y ago"They're not lying, it's commercial real estate."
- Jedd 6y ago> ... following six months of partial — and in some cases total — closure due to COVID-19 shutdowns. At the risk of appearing churlish -- given the preponderance of nation states around the world that had significantly shorter full lockdowns, and the USA's apparent predilection for litigation, it sounds like an excellent opportunity to make a compelling case against the causative elements.
- treelovinhippie 6y agoThe landlord leech class will be the death of the city.
- mshumi 6y agoWelcome to the everything bubble. We now have to choose whether people hurt in nominal or real terms. I think we will collectively decide to hurt real wealth rather than nominal wealth. All the two-sided obligations work out better that way. The difficulty of avoiding taxation on real wealth is probably for the 'greater good'.
- mjfl 6y agoWhat leverage do landlords have in enforcing payment, if no one would move in if they evict a business? I certainly would only pay very discounted rent until society reopens and I think it would be insane for anyone to suggest otherwise.
- ashtonkem 6y agoNot surprising. Restaurants were marginal businesses during the best of times; reducing capacity by 25-50% is a death sentence for all but the most profitable ones.
- aogaili 6y agoThings in the US seems absurd from an outsider perspective due to ideological beliefs. On the same month, you can read two articles coming from the US: 1) Jeff Bezos Becomes The First Person Ever Worth $200 Billion 2) Almost 90 percent of NYC bars and restaurants couldn’t pay August rent It doesn't take much thinking to conclude that there is something messed up with resource/capital allocation in this economy. But there are fanatic capitalist in the US with a blind/irrational faith in the "invisible hand" that is as dogmatic as praying for Zeus in greek mythology. Even worst, they can't even get their population to wear masks like many other countries to at least slow down the transmission, mainly due to another set of extreme dogmas and tribalism. It seems that superpowers can't help but get decayed from inside. With time and enough arrogance, world power societies tend sink in their own delusion when the rest of world pragmatically catch up and pass them by.
- RhysU 6y agoHypothetically, Bezos could own all of the bars in NYC, decide they are now a bad bet, and not pay their rents. He could invest elsewhere while those businesses go bankrupt. It would be wise of him, in this hypothetical, to deploy capital to a place where it would obtain better returns than propping up a broad cross-section of marginal businesses. To your last paragraph, all superpowers eventually fade. Look on my works ye mighty and, etc.
- aogaili 6y agoThank you I'll take a look. Again I'm not pointing at Bezos, he contributed a lot of great innovation to society and I'm a big user of Amazon services, I merely pointing out that things are really out of balance. And this inequality trend was bad before Corona and it just got way worst. So something seems fundamentally broken.
- RhysU 6y agoThroughout most of human history wealth/power has been wildly skewed into a small number of hands. The historical anomaly is that equality today has become pervasive to the point that we find inequality to be noteworthy. Current trends may be reversion to the historical mean without anything being fundamentally broken. It's been a hell of a good few centuries for much of humanity. We should keep it up, of course, but a reversion is normal in a dynamic system with feedback even when an upward trend is "sticking".
- jaaames 6y ago"Meanwhile, 90 percent reported they have been trying to negotiate their leases, but their landlords wouldn’t budge." This is alarming. It may seem like just another statistic lost in a bigger article, but it's symptomatic of a ticking time bomb in NYC, and commercial real estate more broadly. Louis Rossmann had an excellent breakdown of why the landlords won't budge on the leases https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NdfmMB1E_qk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NdfmMB1E_qk tl;dr - the loans on these restaurants are all bundled into commercial mortgage backed securities (sound familiar?) and sold to wholesale investors, and the landlords are unable to change the terms of the lease, or the banks will revalue the underlying asset based on a multiple of the rent, and the owner will either essentially get margin called, or end up with negative equity, and default on the loan. Can someone from Wall Street please add their thoughts?
- jshaqaw 6y agoIt is irrational behavior for these landlords to evict or pileup unrealistic future obligations. On the other side of covid it will be far better to have an existing in place restaurant or bar tenant than to try and lease space in a glut market and take on lots of tenant onboarding costs.