31 ms·
Interchange in Houston is the same size as an entire city center in Italy
- totalZero 6y agoI disagree with the notion that space is better used if it exhibits greater density of population. I don't believe it is very easy to drive in Siena, Italy. I also don't believe it is very easy to live under a highway interchange. To each space its own.
- dia80 6y agoIn Siena, you walk.
- totalZero 6y agoIn Houston, you drive. There is no reason to judge space in one place by the use patterns of a totally different place.
- kaesar14 6y agoWalking sounds less dangerous, less polluting, and better for overall health
- leetcrew 6y agoit is also slower and you cannot bring nearly as much with you. I love walking to restaurants, but I prefer to drive to the furniture store.
- j8014 6y agoDo you shower at the place you are walking or riding your bike? Just sweat your ass off all day long and hope everyone around you doesn't mind? You have about 1-2 minutes before your sweating through your clothing in Houston. It's 95F and ONLY 60% humidity right now.
- kaesar14 6y agoSounds like the kind of place humanity shouldn't be living
- crmrc114 6y agoI have lived in walking cities, I prefer to have a car. I can enjoy my own music or podcast- my own schedule in the case of mass transit. I can also enjoy my own aircon and heat settings. I know lots of people want to bike/walk everywhere- that is just not for me. I think this comes up everytime someone talks about urban planning here. Some people just have no interest in living within high density areas- I am one of them. I like being able to use a telescope and not hear cars.
- oblio 6y agoTragedy of the commons, though. Your immediate best interest might be bad for the community.
- johnisgood 6y agoWell, in all fairness, s/he did say: > I prefer to have a car. > I like being able to use a telescope and not hear cars. So I am not sure s/he cares much about the commons. :D
- crmrc114 6y agoI mean, like I also have bees and livestock. Not sure why my parent comment here is getting downvoted like crazy. But yeah some people just don't like the cosmopolitanism. Then again I enjoy Walden and nature. This is getting a bit meta and off topic. It does seem like any mention of cars on HN will get a slew of automobile haters and lovers in a flamewar. Not my goal here. Just saying different strokes, the common good depends on your optics.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ChickeNES 6y ago> I can enjoy my own music or podcast- my own schedule in the case of mass transit. I can also enjoy my own aircon and heat settings. I'm honestly confused, how are these things not possible in the city? My earbuds worked perfectly fine on the bus and train pre-covid, and my apartment has its own thermostat (and indeed its own HVAC system)
- kfarr 6y agoOne causes destruction of our shared planet and personal debt
- naringas 6y agoI bet it's also not necessary to drive in Siena, Italy
- totalZero 6y agoAnd yet it's necessary to drive in Houston. Imagine judging Siena based on the ease of driving. That would be equally as arbitrary as judging Houston by its space allocation to roadway interchanges.
- nend 6y agoI think the argument is that space is better used by designing for people, not for cars. Sometimes that means population density, but sometimes it means open plazas, pedestrian only streets, parks, etc.
- totalZero 6y agoThis is the part that got a few nanometers underneath my skin: Hendrix pulled this eye-opening comparison from a report compiled by the U.K.’s Building Better, Building Beautiful Commission, which sternly suggests that housing 30,000 Italians is less wasteful and more sustainable than using the same amount of acreage to simply move cars around. There’s truth to that, of course [...] There's no truth to that, of course. Houston is a gigantic port city and population center, in a region of the USA where automobiles are almost essential to life because everything is spread out and public transportation is sparse. Even if you only focus on designing for people, there are people commuting in those automobiles and their quality of life goes up when their daily commute doesn't include a series of congested off-ramps and on-ramps in bumper-to-bumper traffic. In Houston, the user drives. Just because Tuscany is nice doesn't mean there is any reason why space in places where the use case is different should be judged with Tuscany in mind as an ideal. To take it to the extreme, this article is akin to a comparison between the ISS and a soccer field. The author decided that the soccer field is a better use of space because it accommodates multiple times as many participants as the ISS.
- tssva 6y agoI also disagree but let's assume it is true. Houston would overall be a better user of space than Siena. The population density of the entire city of Siena is around 1200 per square mile. For Houston it is over 3600 per square mile.
- register 6y agoIn Siena it's just a pleasure to walk. And if you have the luck to live in the city center you just walk to the main square and spend your time there sipping a glass of Montepulciano at a local bar.
- mc32 6y agoOk? And? It’s interesting trivia but it doesn’t mean much. A well packed slum could fit 10x that amount in that land. Or you could have a vineyard or you could have a train station. It’s an arbitrary comparison. Land gets used in many different ways that make sense for the local people. Some seem “better” but that requires certain “assumptions “. Is arid desert “wasted”?
- save_ferris 6y agoThe article goes on to discuss the issue of sprawl and how cities like Houston are building themselves into a corner by constantly expanding infrastructure like this. The ironic part of this comparison is that Siena is a much older community than Houston, which, like most of America, embraced a sprawl mentality in the 50’s as a Cold War risk mitigation strategy. Climate change is arguably a more pressing threat to Houston than thermonuclear war, but the city doesn’t have many other options than to continue sprawling.
- criddell 6y agoThere are lots of options for Houston to evolve. The city is mostly how the electorate wants it.
- vidanay 6y agoKowloon Walled City was 50k population in a surface area of only 6.4 acres (2.6 hectare).
- postingawayonhn 6y agoNow compare Manhattan.
- apocalyptic0n3 6y agoDFW Airport alone has 80% of the total land area that Manhattan does, which is always an interesting little bit of trivia.
- csours 6y agoWell, no one was using the land at the time[0]. Everything has grown to touch DFW airport - I lived literally across the street from it in Euless. Also, a lot of the land there is used by businesses like UPS, Fed-Ex, etc. 0. I'm sure someone was, but not very many people.
- apocalyptic0n3 6y agoI'm not saying it's a waste of space or anything. Just that's it's interesting how large it is in comparison to Manhattan. It's about as useful a comparison as the one made in the article, frankly.
- exabrial 6y agoThe elephant in the room is the assumption that _everyone wants to be stacked on top of each other_. I do agree that designing cities around cars has ruined a lot of nice places though.
- pif 6y agoI agree with you, and I expressed the same point four years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11908567 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11908567
- oblio 6y agoThey don't want to be stacked, but they do want jobs, they want Chinese/Indian/French/... restaurants, they want daycares, they want schools, they want high-schools, they want notaries, and hospitals and clinics, they want shopping malls and delis, they want pharmacies and pawn shops, ... It's almost like wanting 50000 people with different professions nearby means you have to live next to 50000 people. Until we discover teleportation.
- johnbrodie 6y agoI'm confused as to whether you're describing urban living or suburban living. Both have everything mentioned, the latter without being stacked on top of your neighbors.
- oblio 6y agoIt's in the name. You only have "sub-urban living" because there is an "urban" nearby.
- luckylion 6y agoYou don't have to go to the urban center for everyday things though, you go there because that's where the jobs are. When full remote becomes more wide-spread, that might change things rapidly.
- larrydag 6y agoI live in Texas. This assertion is true of most cities in Texas also. Houston is the largest population center in Texas with 6M+ in the city. Also Houston is a busy center for interstate and international commerce especially for trucking.
- tssva 6y agoThere are almost 7M in the Houston metro area. The city of Houston itself has a population of around 2.3M.
- dhd415 6y agoThe Dallas-Ft Worth metro area is more populous than the Houston metro area by about 500k people.
- larrydag 6y agoYes that is true when you combine those 2 cities. Also known for their large interstate highway interchanges. In fact one of the newest is in North Dallas aptly named the "High Five" interchange.
- refurb 6y agoI'm sure I'll get down voted, but I don't find the Bay Area all that different. In the Bay Area it's just different towns all interconnected, while in Houston, all those towns were consolidated into one massive city (like LA). SF is only 1 million people and the dense, downtown core is not that big. Outside of the downtown cores of SF and Oakland, it's all just suburbs wrapped around the bay. And plenty of people have absolutely brutal commutes due to the sprawl. The only difference is they commute from "another city".
- pansa2 6y ago> is the same size What size, exactly? Is it a really big interchange, or a really small city?
- apacheCamel 6y ago>Siena’s history dates back millennia. Houston, meanwhile, was founded in 1836. Every time I am made aware of just how young the US is, it blows me away. I've never been to Europe, I would really love to go some day, but I can only imagine the feeling of actually seeing these really old places/structures in person.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 6y ago> I've never been to Europe, I would really love to go some day, but I can only imagine the feeling of actually seeing these really old places/structures in person. European cities are also relatively young. If you want to see old cities, you should visit the Middle East or China.
- namdnay 6y agoI think they mean the actual buildings and layouts, rather than the fact that people lived there 500 years ago. It's quite normal in Italy or Southern France for example to walk past churches that are 500-1000 years old
- immigrantsheep 6y agoI come from a very small town on the Adriatic coast and the church there is from the 6th century. The town itself was founded sometimes BC.
- docdeek 6y agoThe city I live in here in France is about 2000 years old. That might not be as old as some of the cities in the Middle East but relative to most cities it is doing pretty well, non?
- reddog 6y agoThats 10x older than the city I live in (Austin). But Jericho is 6x older than yours.
- 6y ago
- blakesterz 6y ago"Rather, Cold War–era urban design philosophy in the U.S. prioritized sprawl because older cities that had urbanized pre–World War II—New York, Chicago, Philadelphia, and Detroit—were seen as being susceptible to nuclear strikes. Less-dense cities such as Los Angeles and Houston were less likely to be targeted for a nuclear attack. Sprawl was a deterrent against Soviet aggression." That's the first time I've heard that. Interesting, if true.
- sithadmin 6y agoI'm not sure I buy it; it sounds like a 'just-so' story. Sprawl is popular because it allows for larger properties at lower prices relative to dense urban development. The vast majority of real estate developers have likely never seriously considered factors like probability of a nuclear strike as a criteria for selecting land for development.
- vidanay 6y agoI don't buy it at all. Population centers are secondary targets after military targets. Besides, the USSR and USA had (have) enough nukes that a spread out city is irrelevant.
- tikhonj 6y agoI'm not sure whether the story is true, but it's worth noticing that developers are not the only drivers here—changes zoning laws and federal funding both played a major role, and it seems plausible for the government to take nuclear strikes into account when charting a high-level policy for the country as a whole.
- Const-me 6y agoThey considered transportation infrastructure. See National Interstate and Defense Highways Act of 1956: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Aid_Highway_Act_of_1956 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Aid_Highway_Act_of_195... They also considered jobs availability. I wasn’t able to find good enough sources on the policies of the era, but many articles on the Internets say the sprawl of industries was caused in part by federal policies: https://www.jstor.org/stable/44250919 https://www.jstor.org/stable/44250919
- jp555 6y agoGDP: Houston, Texas = ~$500B/yr Siena, Tuscany = ~$11B/yr
- kaesar14 6y agoIs that the GDP of this highway interchange?
- mixedCase 6y agoWhile I don't think this direct comparison is valid (at least let's also have the per capita numbers, which I believe is around 60% higher in Houston if Google snippets are to be believed) one could argue that a portion of that GDP is enabled by road infrastructure such as this interchange.
- kaesar14 6y agoAmerica is the richest country on earth. It's such a kneejerk reaction of our countrymen to defend our insane way of life by bringing up GDP numbers instead of stuff like life expectancy, quality of life, access to equitable transportation. America being rich is known fact already. Edit: From your own happiness survey link - "The U.S. GNI per capita income is actually higher than in most of the countries ahead of the U.S. in the global ranking of happiness. There are about 130 countries that showed up as less happy than the U.S. in 2013. Despite our outstanding technological and economic progress over the past half-century, we are without significant achievements in life satisfaction and the subjective happiness of our population. In contrast, uncertainties and anxieties are high, social and economic inequalities have widened considerably and social trust is in decline. There is an impression that the U.S. has not been very effective at turning its great business capacities, human resources, productivity and natural wealth to the best aim: increased happiness." Don't give a damn about GDP.
- mixedCase 6y ago> It's such a kneejerk reaction of our countrymen to defend our insane way of life by bringing up GDP numbers I'm not from the US. I live in latin america where people think like you do and feel everyone is entitled to a bunch of "essential" things by the state using public money, and here I am watching Argentina from the other side of the river as it beats its poverty high score every day right after Venezuela did the same thing with the same exact steps. Just now they socialized the Internet, cable and telcos, wonder what else is going to be "essential". > From your own happiness survey link That is not my link. It's not even in the same comment subtree. > Don't give a damn about GDP. Well, pick a country around here from the ones that share your line of thought and just move. If you can get me one of them unhappy green cards on your way please let me know.
- kaesar14 6y agoWhat an incredible waste of space, fuel, and human time. Driving is the bane of American prosperity.
- sp332 6y agoAnd yet not only is Houston quite rich (on average anyway), but it consistently ranks #2 for happiness among major metro areas in Harris Happiness polls. http://www.city-data.com/blog/646-satisfaction-life-happiness-u-s/ http://www.city-data.com/blog/646-satisfaction-life-happines...
- kaesar14 6y agoAnd? Can't aspire to a better future where we don't sit in traffic for hours to get across the city, choking our skies with car smog and carbon dioxide that'll ruin the environment for future generations? Our design philosophy around cities are the biggest mistake made of 20th century American politics, and I'll die on that hill.
- refurb 6y agoDon’t live there if you don’t like it?
- kaesar14 6y agoWe all live in an interconnected world. The choices made around the country to prioritize cars have led to negative externalities for all of us.
- refurb 6y agoThe world is fully of negative externalities caused by others. That alone is not a good enough reason to force them to change their behavior. Sure, incentivize a dense urban area if that’s what you want. But you should realize a lot of people want a suburban environment.
- 6y ago
- komali2 6y agoEx houstonian here, university of houston and everything. Decently fun city, interesting history, cool people. The road and traffic situation is nightmarish. I slowly came to this realization in college when I went abroad a couple of times. I found out that didn't have to be How Things Are. The university of houston has a problem where students aren't attending classes because parking isn't available. Stories of trying to find a parking space for 40 minutes abound. There's lines of cars offering an air conditioned ride to parking spaces outside of classrooms, in return for their parking spot. If you miss an exit near the i45/i10 merge, you've added 20 minutes to your drive, minimum, as the next local exit will be a good five miles away, and then after that the next on ramp for your give freeway could well be on the other side of downtown. For some reason they built a light rail that criss crosses main street. For a great form of entertainment, search youtube for "Houston light rail accident." They're rarely really bad, more just stupid looking, some giant pick-up truck failing to see the train and getting booped. There's no zoning (kinda) so the industrial zones are mixed right in with residential, budding up against UH. So about 1/10 of the time I bicycled to school, I would be blocked by a mile long train that decided to simply park and block every road crossing I could take to the university. I made a habit of throwing my bike between the nonmoving cars and clambering over until my dad sent me a video of someone getting cut in half doing that. Growing up in the suburbs you'd have balls of steel to bicycle to a friend's house. Pickup trucks make a sport of fucking with bicyclists. Better to just wait for your parents to get home from work so they can drive you. Lord forbid you have a friend in the woodlands or something. Thought it was obnoxious to visit your friends in San Jose when you live in the bay area? The woodlands is like a trip to Sacramento, but only because of traffic and a 610 loop as wide as a continent. Public transit, lol. That's for poor people. I remember hosting a luncheon for our engineers (was a recruiter) and this old fart was talking about his 50 minute one way commute. It was a point of pride for these o&g engineers for some reason to measure their commutes. Then this engineer we brought in from mexico was like "oh, I live in that same neighborhood, why not take the bus? It gets on the HOV and gets me here in 30m." Old fart was flabbergasted. He didn't even know there was a bus. I don't blame him, they pick up at these huge ride share parking lots and it's not easy to figure out their schedule, or even how to pay. Anyway Houston traffic sucks and my conspiracy theory is it's because Shell and Chevron have downtown offices and the CEOs sit at the top of the tower where they can see a clogged i45, i10, 610, and 59, and cackle maniacally at the hordes of people trying to justify their 1 hour one way commutes to eachother and the choking fog of smog clouding around the city.
- jupp0r 6y agoSo a city of 30k people requires less infrastructure than a city of 6M people? Where are the examples of major metropolitan areas without big freeway intersections?
- jankassens 6y agoJust looking around Tokio on satellite view: there are a few highways, but nothing compared to the many-layered intersections you see in US cities like Los Angeles or San Diego.
- bonestamp2 6y agoTokyo is amazing in many ways, but especially infrastructure. I was embarrassed when I went there for I felt like the countries I grew up in were lazy by comparison. The most popular type of vehicle on the road there (in my observation) was a concrete truck. The subway system is unbelievable. They don't try to build huge line extensions every few years or decades the way we do, they are constantly expanding and improving it all the time. It's absolutely amazing what they have built there, and at the same time remained incredibly polite and gracious.
- timerol 6y agoAhmedabad, India appears to have about 6M people and 1 highway interchange. The interchange isn't even a full cloverleaf, but instead only allows 4 of the standard 8 cloverleaf options. In 2012 it was listed as India's best city to live in.
- anticensor 6y agoDo you mean this interchange: https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=16/22.9676/72.6599 https://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=16/22.9676/72.6599
- rsynnott 6y ago> Where are the examples of major metropolitan areas without big freeway intersections? Many European cities keep them largely outside (in a ring).
- smcl 6y agoA lot of people seem to be reading the headline, getting upset and immediately heading here to complain and getting on the defensive. The article is actually pretty interesting and isn't just trying to attack Houston, Texas, the USA or you personally.
- tuna-piano 6y agoIt's interesting that protests generally happen in dense parts of cities. Now imagine a city without a dense part - protesting becomes more difficult. Myanmar's non-democratic military government actually moved their capital from a dense city to a new city so spread out and with no downtown area - potentially to prevent the ability to protest the government. https://www.independent.co.uk/travel/inside-burma-s-ghost-town-capital-city-which-4-times-size-london-fraction-population-a7805081.html https://www.independent.co.uk/travel/inside-burma-s-ghost-to... I don't think that's why Houston is the way it is, and while there is still a downtown there, imagining mass protests in Houston seems much different than Hong Kong - due to the density.
- adolph 6y ago"Some of Haussmann's critics said that the real purpose of Haussmann's boulevards was to make it easier for the army to maneuver and suppress armed uprisings; Paris had experienced six such uprisings between 1830 and 1848, all in the narrow, crowded streets in the center and east of Paris and on the left bank around the Pantheon. These critics argued that a small number of large, open intersections allowed easy control by a small force." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haussmann%27s_renovation_of_Paris https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haussmann%27s_renovation_of_Pa...
- leetcrew 6y agois there any further explanation of this? it strikes me that narrow chokepoints would be more advantageous to the numerically inferior but better-equipped/trained force.
- bobthepanda 6y agomore advantageous to the numerically inferior who know the lay of the land, because it's much easier to conduct urban guerilla warfare in such instances. Armies during this period were all still about marching in formation, which doesn't work well in confined spaces where you can't really keep a formation.
- Aardwolf 6y agoYou can find as big highway interchanges in Italy too, e.g.: https://www.google.com/maps/@41.8177773,12.3911127,17z https://www.google.com/maps/@41.8177773,12.3911127,17z And you can most likely find small cities with 30K people in the US too (though I had trouble finding one of this size near Houston when scrolling through Google maps because the cities there look less dense and don't appear to have a discernible center at least from the look of the grid pattern of the streets).
- bmitc 6y agoYour link only shows a simple cloverleaf design, typically used at the intersection of only two highways or as an exit from a highway. Those are everywhere in U.S. cities, in certain regions as not everyone uses the cloverleaf. They are not super common in Texas though, which uses different designs. But either way, it is not close to the same size and complexity as the exchange, of which Houston has many, in the original post.
- hombre_fatal 6y agoThanks for taking the obnoxious "Yes, this" off the title. Yes, it's one of the weirdest pet-peeve trends over the past 5-10 years. No, I do not like it, thanks for asking. Wait, you didn't ask me? You mean nobody was asking me, it's just something I decided to couch in a response to a conversation that wasn't going on? But seriously, I wonder what's going on when we do this. My theory is that it originally caught on to lend credence to what we're saying when we pretend our statement is actually a response to an open question, though now it's just subconscious rhetorical device to emphasize a point, I would imagine. As for the article, growing up 45min outside of Houston, that interchange is all I think about when I entertain the idea of moving to Houston or DFW. There's something grotesque about it and the feeling it gives me. Cars, traffic, and this need to slave away in a commute. Austin keeps voting down highway extension proposals. I'm sure anyone who has to sit in Austin traffic daily hates that, but we can't have every damn city in Texas becoming a concrete metropolis.
- timbit42 6y agoI mean, "Yes, this" isn't as bad as starting with, "I mean".
- adolph 6y agoThis is the intersection of East Freeway and East Loop. It occupies about 1.58 km^2. It is an older interchange reflective of relatively modest traffic volume that set a wide space to ensure room for future growth (which didn't happen on the eastern side of the city). Many newer interchanges operate at higher volume and density. https://www.google.com/maps/@29.7748476,-95.2664193,17.32z https://www.google.com/maps/@29.7748476,-95.2664193,17.32z
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- xg15 6y ago> But it wasn’t strictly an “everything is bigger in Texas” ethos that caused Houston to sprawl the way that it does. Rather, Cold War–era urban design philosophy in the U.S. prioritized sprawl because older cities that had urbanized pre–World War II—New York, Chicago, Philadelphia, and Detroit—were seen as being susceptible to nuclear strikes. Less-dense cities such as Los Angeles and Houston were less likely to be targeted for a nuclear attack. Sprawl was a deterrent against Soviet aggression. That's the first time I've heard this theory. Would that have worked though? I don't know much about nuclear deterrence, but I'd imagine if the USSR already managed to evade the defenses and other obstacles and destroy the city center in a nuclear strike, it wouldn't be a lot of additional effort to send multiple rockets instead of only one and also target the suburbs. Not to mention that fallout, breakdown of infrastructure, disease and hunger that followed a strike would affect the entire city in any case.
- teachrdan 6y agoPart of this is brinkmanship. Even if there was no practical way this would improve even short-term survivability, if the Soviets believed that the US believed this would work, that would be enough to show the US would not be cowed by their nuclear arsenal. It was also a way to reassure US citizens that we were not completely vulnerable to nuclear annihilation. Same with backyard fallout shelters and teaching schoolchildren to hide from nuclear explosions under their school desks--the original school shooter drills.
- r00fus 6y agoBrinkmanship or security theatre?
- 1propionyl 6y agoOr option C: greed. Any way you slice it, nuclear deterrence, missile defense, containment theory and more generally any initiative motivated by the fear of imminent nuclear holocaust and the Red Menace were huge windfalls for industrial corporations from the end of WWII onward. It was an effective way to siphon huge amounts of money from the postwar federal coffers for corporations that had made bank during the war, but were now left to justify why the government should continue shoveling money at them. Now, this may not be the case for Houston's interchanges in particular, but it was certainly the case for many such endeavors going forward for decades. See also: SDI ("Star Wars"). And of course, there were other factors like suburbanization/white flight and the ascendant automobile industry. But all of these potential motivators were (are?) very entangled and hard to fully extricate from one another.
- syoc 6y agoThe source. Plenty of other pictures and examples. https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/861832/Living_with_beauty_BBBBC_report.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...
- hadrien01 6y agoImages and content about the interchange and the city center on pages 14 and 15
- alpineidyll3 6y agoThese highways suck to drive on and have as much delay as Illinois highways half the surface area. Its one of my least favorite parts about tx. The reason is largely that they just scaled up traffic patterns which are fine for 2 lanes to 6-7 lanes. It's absurd. The local legend in Austin is that the highway designer later committed suicide. I bike to work.
- davegauer 6y agoI heard the same suicide tale about The Stack when I lived in Phoenix. I wonder if this is a common urban legend? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Stack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Stack
- Nitrolo 6y agoI'm almost certain it is. There's a housing project in Rome that has the same tale, apparently the architect killed himself after seeing it completed. https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corviale https://it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corviale
- ryanmarsh 6y agoSurely the traffic can’t be worse than the humidity. Kind sir I call your attention to the condensation on the outside of your car windows.
- alpineidyll3 6y agoAustin is usually dry. Did you drive to Florida?
- stergios 6y agoDid anyone notice how little green space Siena has? The Houston interchange appears to have 100x the amount of green space as the entire city of Siena! Quite ironic! How was a city allowed to develop with almost no green space?
- severine 6y agoExpand your view: https://goo.gl/maps/dnKTT771b5mVcLzo8 https://goo.gl/maps/dnKTT771b5mVcLzo8
- romanoderoma 6y ago> How was a city allowed to develop with almost no green space? Siena, like other Tuscan hill towns, was first settled in the time of the Etruscans (c. 900–400 BC) Siena was built on a hill surrounded by some of the greenest valleys in Tuscany, the most notable one being the Chianti valley, home of the popular wine. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chianti https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chianti Trivia: the movie "The Gladiator" was shot in Pienza, in Val D'orcia, in Siena province. This is a shot of the famous Cypress trees road. http://www.clickalps.com/stock/blocks/image.php?id=81499 http://www.clickalps.com/stock/blocks/image.php?id=81499
- Udik 6y agoThe comparison is entirely pointless. There are interchanges in Italy that are of comparable size; just outside my home town, there are medium-sized factory buildings that are larger than its entire historical center, complete with its 13th century frescoed palaces. The area of the Sistine Chapel - 560 m^2- is easily dwarfed by that of most small supermarkets. The fact is that- unless scarce- space is valued- no, wait, it's defined- by what it contains and by your relation to it, not by its size. When traveling on a motorway you cross multiple times per second the entire length of your living room, a space where a centimetre-sized stain can give you nightmares. This beauty in the Netherlands ( https://www.spoorpro.nl/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/maasvlakte-luchtfoto-hbr-aeroview-20181.jpg https://www.spoorpro.nl/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/maasvlakt... ) is more or less the size of Manhattan. The Mona Lisa painting is smaller than the patch in your backyard where you keep your garbage cans. And so?
- rdiddly 6y agoSo Houstonians have to live every single day (probability of occurrence of "a day": 100%) with an infrastructure optimized for a nuclear attack that happens effectively never. Well, it was somebody's best guess at the right thing to do 65 years ago. But that's the sticky issue with large-scale infrastructure like this. If you get it wrong, or if you get it right but conditions later change, the costs associated with it start to balloon & become astronomical. But the short-term costs of changing it are even greater, so nobody wants to tear the band-aid off, and you're stuck bleeding money and productivity forever. (contrary mixture of metaphors there... heh)
- bluGill 6y agoIf they are right and there are a nuclear attack they survive, will your city? You fall for the same falicy as those who are saying covid isn't dangerous. (not that I disagree with you, but you haven't made a good argument)
- rdiddly 6y agoAs far as I know, I haven't made any argument. Regardless, the odds of COVID-19 transmission between two people standing together without masks must be at least 1000X higher than the odds that a nuclear attack will happen while they're standing there. That's enough for me to consider the two risks "different" shall we say, and guess which one I'm more likely to prepare for. Nobody prepares for every contingency. Most people look for some value of risk reduction divided by cost. If I decide to protect my house from school-bus-sized meteorites, the chance I will bankrupt myself trying to construct an adequate shield is near 100%, whereas the chance of such a meteorite hitting the house is pretty small. Given how much more likely plain old thievery is, and how cheap locks are, I should probably prioritize just buying a lock for the front door and remembering to lock it. Just like people prone to die from heart disease or just slowly waste their lives away in traffic should probably prioritize a simpler lifestyle above nuclear war prep. However and nonetheless, note that even with the small purchase of a door lock, I've already agreed to take on a (more than zero) costly and (to some degree) onerous preparation for something that may never happen. Who knows what the chance of a burglary is; you could estimate based on crime rates. But with 100% certainty, locking the door will be a small chore every day and will ruin some number of minutes of my life. Whether it was ultimately worth it would largely be determined by the value I place on certainty. Speaking of values, they're subjective. Let's say the school-bus-sized meteorite is confirmed to be coming right for my house, with 100% probability. But let's also say that I don't care whatsoever about the house. So I will still not do anything to mitigate. That's how I feel about a nuclear attack. The chance of a nuclear attack is (some number), but the chance of a nuclear attack happening, and my giving a shit about anything whatsoever afterward, is near zero. "Will I survive?" My answer is somewhere between "Who cares" and "I hope not." So obviously I'm not willing to undertake mitigations or live in Houston. But I will wear a mask during the pandemic for example because it's cheap and easy, temporary, and it works to reduce a risk that is pretty high.
- LatteLazy 6y agoSiena pop 30k Huston pop 2.3mil
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ryanmarsh 6y agoThe assertion that Houston’s layout is the result of Cold War nuke risk mitigation is a new one on me. The beltway opened in 1988. I grew up here and I’ve read many articles trying to explain why Houston is the way that it is. The truth is incredibly human and boring and wouldn’t sell display ads. Thus, the logical arguments that follow articles like this are complete nonsense. If you want to know why Houston is the way that it is, fly down here and I’ll drive you around and show you. You’ll be completely underwhelmed, but the tacos will more than make up for the trip.
- selimthegrim 6y agoMay come by soon looking for jobs; any taco leads?
- ryanmarsh 6y agoTacos A Go Go, Original Ninfas location, El Rey, Velvet Taco, Torchy’s, Balderas, any food truck, hell just google “great tacos in Houston”.
- adrianmonk 6y agoOne factor that hasn't been mentioned here is climate. Siena seems to have a very mild climate. Its average high temperature[1] in August is 28.3°C (82.9°F). Compare that to Houston's monthly high for August, which is 35°C (95°F). Houston is also very humid[3]. Most people don't want to take a 10-minute walk when it's 95°F and humid. You arrive at your destination panting and very sweaty. It's more comfortable to take a 10-minute drive in an air conditioned car. To some people, it's preferable even if the drive takes 30 minutes due to traffic. --- [1] https://en.climate-data.org/europe/italy/tuscany/siena-1089/ https://en.climate-data.org/europe/italy/tuscany/siena-1089/ [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_of_Houston https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_of_Houston [3] https://finance.yahoo.com/news/america-most-humid-cities-090000494.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/america-most-humid-cities-090...
- Flobin 6y agoYou say that as if there are no dense cities in places that have a similar climate as Houston. What about Taipei, for instance? Houston has a July average high temperature of 34,7 degrees C with an average relative humidity of 74,4. The same data for Taipei is 34,3 degrees C with a humidity of 73. Yet Houston has a population density of 1398,76/km2 whereas Taipei 9700/km2, almost 7 times as high. Data from Wikipedia. Actually, perhaps this map says it best: https://www.dropbox.com/s/tkoekp0or12ppjc/Screenshot%202020-08-31%20at%2022.51.57.png?dl=0 https://www.dropbox.com/s/tkoekp0or12ppjc/Screenshot%202020-... (If anything, building densely can create a lot of shade, which can be quite beneficial.)
- adrianmonk 6y agoArguably Taipei could have the motive, but not the opportunity, not like Houston does. The population of Taiwan[1] is 23.78 million, and its land area is 35,808 km^2. The population of Texas[2] is 29 million, and its land area is 676,587 km^2. So Taiwan has nearly (82%) as many people but 1/20th the land. Also, Taipei is boxed in by large mountains and the ocean, so there are lots of natural barriers discouraging sprawl. Houston is near the ocean, but aside from that there are no natural barriers. The land around it is super flat in every direction. The closest hill of any size is probably 150 miles away. --- [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taiwan https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taiwan [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas
- helen___keller 6y agoMost of these threads tend to devolve into attacking assumptions about how people want to live (high density vs low density, parking vs no parking, cars for every trip vs walking/transit most trips) I'll list out what I view as the two dominant views towards the development of a metropolitan region (I loosely define metropolitan region as a city and all the places around that city which can plausibly commute to a job inside the city. Or in other words, all land housing the people you may see every day). Let me know if you think I've got the two sides nailed down correctly. The urban mindset to developing a metropolitan region: * Cars are a luxury (and often a nuisance) and should not be required for essential, everyday travel. * The region expands both outwards (by adding high speed transit to surrounding neighborhoods), and upwards (replacing existing development with higher density development) * Key transportation infrastructure: public transit (bus, tram, train, subway), in addition to feet and bikes * (some amount of) Density is a key pattern: Having enough people per square mile to bring workers and customers, sustaining local businesses, as well as maintainable a taxable base large enough to pay for transit and other infrastructure * Multi use zoning is king: local storefronts and restaurants are considered beneficial for quality of life. Sufficiently dense streets thrive off the mixture of people and business. * "porous" neighborhoods (e.g. grid street layout) are a pattern: porous neighborhoods are more efficient on a mile-per-mile basis, helping to enable low-speed travel (read: foot & bike). This increases the amount of business-capable space within a neighborhood, which is beneficial to the local economy and quality of life of residents * Suburban mindset seen as harmful: suburban mindset seeks to expand outwards. This adds people who consume local infrastructure (e.g. driving on local roads, creating noise and pollution) but who might not live in city jurisdiction (i.e. can't be taxes in a straightforward manner), and aren't interested in contributing to the well-being of the city. Suburban mindset seeks to limit legal expansion of density, mandate parking minimums, cut urban spending for necessary infrastructure like transit, reduce quality of life by widening roads, building highways, and increasing speed limits, and continue an outward suburban expansion that will just accentuate existing problems with traffic and with car noises The suburban mindset to developing a metropolitan region: * Cars are the key mode of travel for the vast majority of destinations, and as such are a necessity * The region expands outwards by purchasing and developing surrounding farmland, and connecting this land to the city with high speed roads. This keeps land absurdly cheap. * Key transportation infrastructure: roads (with sufficiently high speeds and capacity), parking lots * Density is a key antipattern: More people per square mile brings congestion and noise, consume available parking, but offer little communal benefits as residents generally don't need to work or shop locally (no need to sustain local businesses) * Single use zoning is king: businesses want to locate on large roads with lots of traffic, people want to locate on small subdivisions with little traffic. Zoning enforces this to maintain everybody's quality of life. * "porous" neighborhoods are an antipattern: stores are not on local streets, so any porous neighborhoods mostly bring in through-traffic (which gives noise and pollution but no economic benefit). Thus a tiered freeway/highway/boulevard -> neighborhood -> subdivision pattern to residential space, in place of a city grid * Mandatory parking minimums useful, as parking is a valuable public good * Urban mindset seen as harmful: urban mindset seeks to build higher density housing in centralized places that already have bad traffic during rush hour, which will just make it worse. Urban mindset seeks to make more use of urban space with less parking, which offers a worse quality of life to suburbanites who wish to drive into the city. Urban mindset seeks to limit legal restrictions on density, which threatens to see multifamilies or apartment buildings in quiet neighborhoods that currently have low traffic and low noise (but won't when population density goes up). Urban mindset looks to spend on public transit, which is not useful at all to all the many people who live in the suburbs (but suburbanites may face state taxes or consumption taxes to fund transit, as well as increases in traffic due to construction)
- mcguire 6y agoOut of curiosity, how much traffic does the SS674 and SS223 see per day? That interchange appears to be the eastern connection between I10 and the 610 loop around central Houston. I10 is one of the major arteries between the east and west coasts. https://goo.gl/maps/CyoAESVtEQFRa4zb7 https://goo.gl/maps/CyoAESVtEQFRa4zb7
- abstractbarista 6y agoNow let's compare the GDP each supports.
- redm 6y agoAs someone who lives in Houston, the simple reason there is sprawl is because its flat and land is cheap. This makes it easy to live on large lots or on small average. It's also hot, so people spend more time indoors and drive everywhere.
- ska 6y agoDon't forget lack of zoning and state commitment to building highway/freeway infrastructure. It's partially a collective action problem. Since everyone has pretty much committed to doing nearly everything via car the marginal cost at either the individual or system level of adding one more car (side) trip is very low.
- wmeredith 6y agoI'm glad someone said this. The size of the interchange vs a small town in Italy is an odd comparison. Land and gas are cheap in one place and they're not in another. That's basically the end of the story.
- conductr 6y agoI’d say more to do with technology available at onset of growth. Modern versus ancient in terms of cities. I found the marketing brochure in my mid-century house in Dallas, they really thought that the Jetsons was going to happen. Same house was built north of downtown Dallas from some horse farms and pitched country life with modern conveniences. The exurbs that reach damn near Oklahoma now are still pitching the same thing while my house is very much considered in the city.
- jxramos 6y ago(still working to articulate this all precisely) I think a lot of these country to country comparisons bank off the fact that people presume they're dealing with an oranges to oranges comparison like two sporting teams or something equally sized. Evaluating two comparands on some single concept they both happen share in common without looking to the specifics is grossly inadequate. Concepts like city, country, state, hospital system, etc, can indeed both be shared between two countries at a conceptual level. However those concepts can take drastically different forms with their reality on the ground. The two comparands' actualizations of these concepts can be huge simply looking at scale alone. As far as I can tell the US dwarfs pretty much any EU country in terms of population, land mass/area, and a bunch of other stuff too I'd imagine. I'm awakening more to the fact that without highlighting from the outset any known differences in scale one can be lead to strange conclusions in the results of comparison. There's that common software architecture analogy regarding the techniques to build a single family detached house being woefully inadequate at building a skyscraper. It would be nice to have some normalized terminology of city and country etc that speaks more directly to the population scale at hand.
- volkadav 6y agofair, but try driving 85mph through the italian city in a giant cadillac with cow horns on the front bumper while blaring your favorite tunes and drinking something from a drive-through liquor store. ;)
- mmm_grayons 6y agoYou mean swangas aren't well-suited to european streets?
- simonebrunozzi 6y agoI think that 30,000 is an exaggeration, and if so, I just don't like when people sensationalize figures and bend facts to their liking. The problem would lie in this report [0], which is cited by the article and by the person tweeting about it. Happy to be proven wrong; but I know the area quite well (I grew up in Italy), and I immediately thought that the satellite picture of Siena depicted in the article, and in the tweet, does not contain 30,000 people. The entire "Comune" of Siena (roughly equivalent to a "County" in the UK or US) is ~53,000 people [1]. However, I would be surprised if the part of Siena depicted in the article, the city center, houses 30,000 people. See for yourself. Here's Assisi, roughly with a similar density as Siena, which has ~4,500 people living in the city center [2]. Here's Siena [3]. Just by approximation, I'd say that Siena's city center is in the range of maybe 15k? Not more than that. Also, it would be unfair to consider the fact that Siena's city center is also house for students, which live in different conditions than normal people. In that sense, even Harvard's dormitories have a high density, compared to any road structure in Texas. Anyway, just trying to make you reflect on the numbers - I hope my calculations are correct; or at least, the reasoning behind it should be good enough. As said, happy to be proven wrong. [0]: https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/861832/Living_with_beauty_BBBBC_report.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/... [1]: https://www.comune.siena.it/Il-Comune/Servizi/Statistica/Popolazione/POPOLAZIONE-RESIDENTE-ANNO-2018 https://www.comune.siena.it/Il-Comune/Servizi/Statistica/Pop... [2]: https://www.google.com/maps/place/53100+Siena,+Province+of+Siena,+Italy/@43.0713817,12.6070871,2650m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m5!3m4!1s0x132a2cbf34bf5313:0x5d731212f12343e3!8m2!3d43.318809!4d11.3307574 https://www.google.com/maps/place/53100+Siena,+Province+of+S... [3]: https://www.google.com/maps/place/53100+Siena,+Province+of+Siena,+Italy/@43.321355,11.3236881,2642m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m5!3m4!1s0x132a2cbf34bf5313:0x5d731212f12343e3!8m2!3d43.318809!4d11.3307574 https://www.google.com/maps/place/53100+Siena,+Province+of+S...
- inamberclad 6y agoWhich interchange? And this city (Houston) has so many problems I don't know where to start... Highways are one of them because nothing is dense, but its a brutally self reinforcing problem in a city that refuses to invest in any other kind of infrastructure.
- sunkenvicar 6y agoI think this is fake mews because the article is missing pictures. It would be trivial to create a really cool satellite overlay if it were true. Clicking the link just gives us a stylized “artist’s depiction”.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- person_of_color 6y agoI'll never get the US fascination with highways and ugly interchanges.