56 ms·
Facebook to ban white nationalist content
- oyvey 8y agoI would never become sympathetic to the ideas of white nationalism if it wasnt for the exposure to them on mainstream media platforms. This makes me mad as hell. How am I supposed to call this a democracy? Might as well live in communist china.
- jimrhods23 8y agoI'm glad. Now we can stop using it as a scapegoat for all of the worlds problems.
- Wohlf 8y agoPeople will never stop blaming human issues on businesses and devices. It's much easier to blame Facebook and demand they change that it is to get people to change.
- xienze 8y agoThe bigger question is, will they also ban content that would be construed as hate speech if you simply replaced the words “white people” with “[!white] people”?
- draw_down 8y agoI guess that is a bigger question. And I think they’re free to answer it as they see fit.
- jitl 8y agoThis is not the bigger question.
- xienze 8y agoSure it is, because it sounds like Facebook isn’t committed to getting rid of all hate speech, just the kind that isn’t socially acceptable. Same with Twitter.
- terryschiavo22 8y agoCame here to say this. You can't have it both ways.
- fixermark 8y agoI think we're about to watch us have it both ways.
- ceejayoz 8y agoFacebook's rules have always been a bit bizarre here. https://www.propublica.org/article/facebook-hate-speech-censorship-internal-documents-algorithms https://www.propublica.org/article/facebook-hate-speech-cens... > One document trains content reviewers on how to apply the company’s global hate speech algorithm. The slide identifies three groups: female drivers, black children and white men. It asks: Which group is protected from hate speech? The correct answer: white men.
- cypherpunks01 8y agoFacebook certainly did not invent the idea of protected classes, USGOVT and tons of news/social companies all use the exact same notion when determining what constitutes illegal discrimination and disallowed hate speech.
- ceejayoz 8y agoI really don't think this is the same interpretation of "protected classes" as the US government uses: > White men are considered a group because both traits are protected, while female drivers and black children, like radicalized Muslims, are subsets, because one of their characteristics is not protected. I'm fairly certain a state that tried to ban female drivers or (openly via legislation; this next one definitely happens in practice) punish black children disproportionately would find themselves in hot water with the Feds.
- crushcrashcrush 8y agoThis is a wake up call. Attention everyone: this is a real problem. White nationalism and fascism is resurgent. It's real, it's around us, and it's not going to go away without a fight. Regardless of your politics, Trump, Russia, China has enabled this to balkanize traditional institutions of democracy and cooperation (USA/NATO/UN). If you're not outraged, you're not paying attention.
- 40dslf 8y agoI think fascism is resurgent (minimally) because democracy is failing some people. Not because China is doing anything.
- partiallypro 8y agoIt's actually not on the rise at all, in fact it is down; just like crime across the board is down. We live in arguably the most peaceful and tolerant time in human history. The number of "hate crimes" in FBI stats is up, but those numbers are often misleading. The only place I actually see a slight resurgence is actually in Europe, and it's largely a backlash against the Syrian immigration crisis...which will generally resolve itself as people move back now that the war is over. China is...a different story, largely because Chinese culture treats rights in a much different light than the West. That being said, if you compare modern China to China of the 70s or 80s, it is vastly better.
- ptaipale 8y agoThis gets off-topic, but immigration crisis in Europe is not really about Syria, and it's not over either, despite changes in situation in Syria. (Otherwise I agree that in almost everywhere, people live the best time humanity has had.)
- JohmMirt 8y agoOh please! Just please!! NATO especially was never an institution of democracy. White Supremasists and Neo Nazis are in resurgence in Ukraine ever since your beloved US supported a hideous coup over.
- rc_kas 8y agoIt wasn't banned already? What the hell?
- weberc2 8y agoFrom TFA: > Our policies have long prohibited hateful treatment of people based on characteristics such as race, ethnicity or religion – and that has always included white supremacy. We didn’t originally apply the same rationale to expressions of white nationalism and separatism because we were thinking about broader concepts of nationalism and separatism – things like American pride and Basque separatism, which are an important part of people’s identity.
- atonse 8y agoGood to see the Valley is starting to get off its "we are just a platform, all information should be free and neutral no matter how bad, so we're not responsible" extremism of the past few years and understand that some forms of speech are harmful should not ever be encouraged and accelerated on any platform or technology, ever. To the people that say "Where does it end?" – that's pretty easy. Let's start with curbing speech that encourages harming others. They've been dragged kicking and screaming into this realization but we'll take it.
- Kalium 8y ago> To the people that say "Where does it end?" – that's pretty easy. Let's start with curbing speech that encourages harming others. This may come as a surprise to you, but this response will not be comforting to those with genuine concerns about civil liberties. Avoiding the question of where to draw the final line with the question of where to draw the first one just implies that you intend to draw more lines in the future.
- kevinh 8y agoThis isn't the first line though–Facebook already bans things like ISIS propaganda. This is in a similar bucket.
- ThomPete 8y agoWhite nationalism isn't even remotely like ISIS propaganda. I am no fan of that ideology for sure but it's actually about something very different than most people think and most people haven't actually spent the time understanding their argument before they form an opinion about it. Edit: Find it pretty crazy that this can't even be discussed without people accusing me of all sorts of things.
- rexpop 8y agoStochastic terrorism? It's still a terrorism pipeline. It's all well and good for you to say "white nationalism is very different from what most people think," but that doesn't stop the OP from being right. Nationalism of all kinds root from an insecurity, and white nationalism in particular is proppogated in colonial societies to encourage the alienation of brown colonial workers via, among other acts, stochastic terrorism. It's a lot like ISIS propaganda.
- gettingsnarky 8y agoI guess it's a good thing for Trump that he uses Twitter, then.
- duxup 8y agoI suspect there is some value in pushing such content off of large sites to reduce the surface area available for recruitment. I used to think that pushing such content off a site or forum was futile and calling it for what it is on a site had value, I'm not sure that is the case anymore. If you look on platforms like reddit and such where you have groups in subreddits calling for race wars, general hatred, and violence and of course the lesser efforts to just normalize hate takes place... there's no discussion anyway. In their own subs any hint of anything less than absolute commitment to their talking points of the day, ever changing theories, and general hatred is an instant ban from their subreddit(s). Then they venture out spam their fake news articles / take over other subs and push their message with endless streams of new accounts. There is no discussion, just constant spam, memes and etc. We've seen topics like Gamergate, incels and such (while not that tasteful to begin with) quickly pulled to the extreme and go from something about "gaming journalism" or general angst to an identity movement steeped in fear / hate, harassment, and for some actual violence. I suspect there may be some value in ushering these people away, if only to prevent recruitment of some others who otherwise might avoid their message that fear or dissatisfaction with life and other problems can be explained with hate.
- rexpop 8y agoAll those patriarchal forums are the top-end of a stochastic terrorism funnel. 1. [The Pewdiepipeline](https://youtu.be/pnmRYRRDbuw https://youtu.be/pnmRYRRDbuw] 2. [Kill All Normies: Online Culture Wars from 4chan and Tumblr to Trump and the Alt-Right](http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/34858587-kill-all-normies http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/34858587-kill-all-normies)
- Macross8299 8y ago>calling it for what it is on a site had value, The terrifying thought is that this might be a product of scale more than anything else. Because of the bullshit asymmetry principle, it's easier to produce propaganda than debunk it and "call it what it is," so any sufficiently large and scaled platform will almost certainly eventually be flooded with propaganda bullshit.
- 8y ago
- hhs 8y agoThis is good. I am, though, concerned about the negative externalities that could arise. Will this lead to new and stranger commercial activities?
- mrguyorama 8y agoIf you want a negative example, check out Voat. It started as a "less moderated/censored reddit" and quickly filled with actual nazis and other vitriol. A business cannot survive on "We accept hate speech" in the same way 4chan has never really been a business proposition; Nobody wants to look like they are supporting hate speech so advertisers won't go near it with a ten foot pole. IMO, this is a good thing, and implies there is at least some decency in the world
- hhs 8y agoSo true, I can see that point, thanks.
- 0815test 8y ago"The trouble with fighting for human freedom is that one spends most of one’s time defending scoundrels. For it is against scoundrels that oppressive laws are first aimed, and oppression must be stopped at the beginning if it is to be stopped at all."
- fixermark 8y agoWith respect, putting a bad idea in quotation marks doesn't make it a good idea. Mencken was extremely intelligent, but applied over-broadly, the concept embodied in this quote implies we should defend even murderers against the oppression of banning murdering. I much prefer "Yes, I'd give the Devil benefit of law, for my own safety's sake."
- bscphil 8y agoOn the other hand, a website doesn't need to be a good business proposition to be a good platform. In fact some might say being a good business proposition is outright opposed to the values needed in a good platform. (In case it's unclean, I don't think Voat or the .chans are good platforms either.)
- untog 8y agoI'd encourage people to please read the post before they comment. It seems that this isn't actually Facebook targeting a specific ideology, it is removing a previous rule that excluded that ideology: > We didn’t originally apply the same rationale to expressions of white nationalism and separatism because we were thinking about broader concepts of nationalism and separatism – things like American pride and Basque separatism, which are an important part of people’s identity. I've been plenty critical of Facebook in the past, but this post is refreshingly honest. I hope it's followed up by some discernible results.
- identity-haver 8y agoI don't think this is correct. They seem to be saying that they allow posting about nationalism and separatism, and white nationalism content was allowed under this umbrella, but now they specifically disallow white nationalism and separatism. Honestly though, posting about any serious separatist movement has a good chance of violating their "terrorism" community standard: "Any non-governmental organization that engages in premeditated acts of violence against persons or property ... in order to achieve a political, religious, or ideological aim" You can't tell me with a straight face that if Facebook existed 50 years ago, Sinn Fein would be allowed to post on Facebook, because they were not the IRA.
- ProAm 8y agoWhy not ban all racism, all hate, everything? Doing just one is PR only.
- untog 8y agoRead the article.
- vernie 8y agoBut I wanna be mad.
- ProAm 8y agoI did, this is so selectively enforced its comical. That's my point.
- untog 8y agoI guess you must have brushed over the part where it says: > Our policies have long prohibited hateful treatment of people based on characteristics such as race, ethnicity or religion – and that has always included white supremacy. We didn’t originally apply the same rationale to expressions of white nationalism and separatism because we were thinking about broader concepts of nationalism and separatism – things like American pride and Basque separatism, which are an important part of people’s identity. Very specifically, it points out that they are not just "doing one", they are bringing one in line with a broader policy that is applied to many different types of hate. So I'm really not sure what point you're trying to make.
- ProAm 8y agoWhy not just ban all nationalism or nationalistic posts? Depending on ones relative position it's hateful towards others. But regardless: > Our policies have long prohibited hateful treatment of people based on characteristics such as race, ethnicity or religion I'm just saying this has always been selectively enforced at FB, the reason they are speaking to white nationalism now is because of recent current events and they are in the spotlight. I feel this is purely this is a convenient PR campaign. Not that it's an easy topic to control or address all the platforms have issues with this, but FB is being opportunistic for press.
- rmbryan 8y agoI don't know as much about hate as I should, perhaps, but it seems arbitrary to make rules about what's hate and what's not. This part, especially, from the article... We also need to get better and faster at finding and removing hate from our platforms. Over the past few years we have improved our ability to use machine learning and artificial intelligence to find material from terrorist groups. Last fall, we started using similar tools to extend our efforts to a range of hate groups globally, including white supremacists. We’re making progress, but we know we have a lot more work to do. My question is, how are you going to know when you're done? What would Facebook look like if they didn't have any more work to do on hate? I'm honestly asking this.
- soared 8y agoThe definition of hate speech and its boundaries has been thoroughly explored by the US supreme court. A taste of it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hate_speech_in_the_United_Stat...
- rmbryan 8y agoTHANK YOU! That was helpful to read. This is my favorite bit, from right at the top: "Hate speech in the United States is not regulated, in contrast to that of most other liberal democracies.[1] The U.S. Supreme Court has repeatedly ruled that hate speech is legally protected free speech under the First Amendment. The most recent Supreme Court case on the issue was in 2017, when the justices unanimously reaffirmed that there is effectively no "hate speech" exception to the free speech rights protected by the First Amendment."
- anth_anm 8y agoI like that part too, because it also brings up the notion that US version of near absolute free speech is not the only on that exists. That other countries have banned hate speech without falling into totalitarianism, banning legitimate political discourse, or falling into the other traps that a "slippery slope" argument pushes.
- gatherhunterer 8y agoThere is merit to maintaining an open environment. Censorship makes the censored content seem lucratively dangerous; it looks like the powers that be are afraid of what some people are saying. I think it is best to let bad arguments fail on their own merit. The problem is that most people are unable to recognize a bad argument.
- ianleeclark 8y agoThe problem is that an open environment cannot work when there are bad faith interlocutors actively seeking to undermine that open environment. There's a famous Sartre quote that deals with the paradox of tolerance in regards to anti-semites.
- pathseeker 8y agoEither they are presenting valid arguments or they aren't. If you have the mental tools to analyze and quickly dismiss arguments it doesn't matter if they aren't acting in good faith.
- DoofusOfDeath 8y ago> Either they are presenting valid arguments or they aren't. I agree. But one problem with bad-faith actors is they can bring productive discussion to a near standstill, due to the time / attention / emotional-energy costs.
- antt 8y agoAnd yet Jews have only been murdered in countries that did not have freedom of speech. Words are an antidote to sticks and stones which stop people from breaking others bones.
- rhcom2 8y agoThat's absurd. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pittsburgh_synagogue_shooting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pittsburgh_synagogue_shooting
- dfee 8y agoThere was a good Intelligence Squared debate about this recently “Constitutional Free Speech Principles Can Save Social Media Companies from Themselves”: https://www.intelligencesquaredus.org/debates/constitutional-free-speech-principles-can-save-social-media-companies-themselves https://www.intelligencesquaredus.org/debates/constitutional...
- randyrand 8y agoThere was a time when the FB newsfeed was chronological, and just showed what your fiends posted as they post them. It seems like less blame for the world's problems could be put on FB if it was just treated as a dumb bulletin board. Why not go back to Facebook being a "dumb pipe?"
- blackflame7000 8y agoFacebook went public and now has an obligation to shareholders to make money so that means replacing the dumb pipe with highly targetted ads and articles
- themacguffinman 8y agoHow does that change Facebook's dilemma? Facebook faces PR pressure because they host the content at all, serving it chronologically or non-chronologically makes no difference. Who is complaining that the problem is really that Facebook serves white nationalist content in the wrong order?
- 40dslf 8y agoSeparatism too? As a Spaniard I couldn't be happier about that.
- ceejayoz 8y agoYou'll be disappointed here. They are specifically targeting white nationalism/separatism. They specifically exclude other types in the article. > We didn’t originally apply the same rationale to expressions of white nationalism and separatism because we were thinking about broader concepts of nationalism and separatism – things like American pride and Basque separatism, which are an important part of people’s identity.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- anth_anm 8y ago> American pride and Basque separatism, which are an important part of people’s identity. I'm not saying it should be banned, but "American pride" being an important part of people's identity is really part of the problem.
- 40dslf 8y agoSo separatism is only bad if it targets non-whites? So when Basques and Catalans say they want to leave because the rest of the country, especially the south, is full of half-moorish lazy fucks, that is cool. Guess the same about the two halves of Italy. I don't care as I don't use Facebook, but it's a double standard.
- ceejayoz 8y ago> So separatism is only bad if it targets non-whites? I can't speak for Facebook, and I'm not super with-it on the conflicts in Spain, but it seems like they're making the distinction between "we want our own country" and "we want our own country and we want to violently purge everyone else from it".
- narrator 8y agoAs an anti-racist conservative, the most fun I have on the internet these days is arguing racists out of their beliefs on the armpits of the internet. I relish my downvotes there. I would be bummed about these beliefs being banned everywhere because I wouldn't get to exercise my Internet debate skills to make a positive impact on the world without worrying about trampling on somebody's right to an echo chamber.
- bdhe 8y agoWhat does it mean to be an anti-racist conservative, and what do you think about the conservatism movement in that you have to use that extra qualifier?
- whatshisface 8y agoThe vast majority of both conservatives and liberals are passive about the vast majority of issues. It would make sense that if you are actively seeking out specific conflicts, you can add an anti- prefix. If the parent specifically seeks out and engages with racists then they are much more anti-racist than the average person irrespective of political alignment. The conservative side definitely does not include "arguing with people on voat" as a platform.
- bdhe 8y ago> The vast majority of both conservatives and liberals are passive about the vast majority of issues. While this might be true, it doesn't necessarily mean that the views held by conservatives and liberals as a whole are comparable. I cannot for the life of me imagine someone being called a pro-racist liberal, it just doesn't compute. But someone who looks the other way and claims to be conservative? Sure, plenty of those folks to go around. > The conservative side definitely does not include "arguing with people on voat" as a platform. While true, I think the author recognizes that sadly conservatism doesn't often include anti-racism in its platform which is what my comment was trying to highlight.
- rexpop 8y ago
- function_seven 8y agoI consider myself a free speech absolutist. Or very nearly so. But that runs both ways. Not only do I think that almost all (to borrow a mathematical term) speech should be permitted, but also that the onus is on the speaker to make themselves heard or to find an audience. No company or platform owes them anything. In earlier times, that meant that no newspaper or printing press was required to print everything sent their way. Today it's the centralized websites that also don't have this obligation. If FB decides to ban bigots, or YouTube wants to kick anti-vaxxers off their site, so be it. You can host your own video if you'd like, or maintain a personal blog site.* You are not entitled to widespread distribution. Never have been. * Which leads to a place where I'll agree on obligations: root infrastructure like DNS or network connectivity. Those are the common carriers of our Internet.
- rexpop 8y agoI don't understand your position. The 1A is fulfilled—in word and spirit—to your satisfaction so long as government puts up no barriers to speech, even if private, quasi-monopolistic firms filter speech to their own ends?
- function_seven 8y agoI think you do understand it, yeah. The only caveat to that is the private control of what I believe to be public infrastructure. The wires that connect all of us.
- gpm 8y agoWhat makes the wire public infrastructure and facebook not? What would facebook have to do to become public infrastructure, or comcast have to do to become not?
- ellard 8y agoOne is contracted by the US government to provide public infrastructure (and AFAIK still hasn't fulfilled their end of the agreement), and the other is an entity that operated and grew organically to provide a service that the government didn't ask for.
- botwriter 8y agoThere is a clear difference between white nationalism and white supremacy. I'm no fan of Britain turning multicultural and all the child rape and stabbings that it brings, but I don't think that the white race is superior to others.
- marvindanig 8y agoToo little, too late. Brexit is around the corner spiraling Britain down to chaos not seen for a hundred years. America is hurting its closest allies with a joker that pathetic dictators love to watch. Meh. Anonymity is still very important for the web. Until FB moves away from the 'face' part of their book, it's a terrible outcome for the Internet any day even with all kinds of curation that they are announcing now. Anonymity = Free speech.
- kansface 8y agoThis type of hyperbolic comment doesn't belong on HN.
- marvindanig 8y agoI know you would say that it doesn't belong here. Especially when it hurts bottomline of your favorite bay area brag. ;-)
- sparkie 8y agoBrexit is good for Britain, but bad for the EU. The only chaos is in parliament which is betraying the British electorate by going against their vote to leave and trying to remain at all cost. They will meet their maker at the next general election and any decisions they're making now will be overturned anyway. The world actually enjoys watching Donald Trump because they see the USA as a world leader, and look up to it as an example. If the USA is doing great, then other countries can do great too! Making America Great Again is making the world great. On the other hand, you have "progressive" dominated cities like San Francisco which have become cesspits, and the world is definitely not thinking "I wish we were more like that!" Quite the opposite - the real jokers are the democrats fighting for the title of the most degenerate.
- JimBrimble35 8y agoI fully support scrubbing hateful content from any place where it appears. I think people should take note though, that this is the exact point in time when the machinery for censoring and filtering the internet is being implemented. Although hateful speech is a great use case for this technology I can't help but wonder what it will get pointed at next. This isn't the kind of development that can sit back idly after performing its primary function.
- philwelch 8y agoThe arguments for censorship and "deplatforming" follow the fashions of the times. In one era, the notion of screenwriters inserting subtle communist propaganda into Hollywood films was terrifying enough to motivate an industry blacklist. In an earlier era, advocating resistance to the draft was considered dangerously treasonous. Somehow these threats always seem less severe in hindsight than they seemed at the time, though.
- JimBrimble35 8y agoI think that's an interesting argument, but I also think you need to consider the type of tooling and the reach of content in today's world. The apparatus that we have for tracking an identifying individuals and their media consumption habits gives unprecedented control over perception at a very granular level. It also sounds like the events that you mention were dealt with quickly and severely, maybe they would have been more severe threats given the space and time to form more completely. My fear is that we'll get to a point where people won't know about the suffering or injustice that is occurring in the world without physically going to the places where it's happening. Or that people will have to go to extreme lengths or break the law simply to escape their filter bubble. /tinfoil hat
- philwelch 8y ago> It also sounds like the events that you mention were dealt with quickly and severely, maybe they would have been more severe threats given the space and time to form more completely. In the case of draft resistance in the world wars, perhaps. We did win those wars within 2 and 4 years of the US entering them, respectively. In the case of the Hollywood blacklist, the Communist screenwriters became a cause celebre and, once the anti-Communists went overboard, were rehabilitated within Hollywood. This is despite the fact that they were members of an organization under the control of the USSR under Stalin. To some extent there was even an informal counter-purge of Hollywood conservatives who supported the blacklists and investigations. > My fear is that we'll get to a point where people won't know about the suffering or injustice that is occurring in the world without physically going to the places where it's happening. Ah, back to the last hundred thousand years of human history!
- throwawaymanbot 8y agoAwwwww, poor baby fasc.. No doubt they'll mess this up too.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- dna_polymerase 8y agoI am very much pro free speech. In the sense of nothing should be disallowed. I think platforms should be built in a way that there really cannot arise an ultra-(right/left/X) bubble. Facebook should build mechanisms like they can be found here on HN. If I would write something really offensive I'd get downvoted and eventually my post would vanish. That feedback by the community is extremely important, because I get to learn what goes and what not. Just deleting unwanted opinions makes things worse. People build up aggression against "the system" and feel censored by the wrong mechanisms. If I, however, see that the majority dislikes my opinions I know where the problem is.
- dsfyu404ed 8y ago>Our efforts to combat hate don’t stop here. As part of today’s announcement, we’ll also start connecting people who search for terms associated with white supremacy to resources focused on helping people leave behind hate groups. People searching for these terms will be directed to Life After Hate, an organization founded by former violent extremists that provides crisis intervention, education, support groups and outreach. The fact that they're readily going down the slippery slope of propaganda by identifying people with Wrong(TM) beliefs and directing them at the Right(TM) beliefs does not sit well with me. Censorship aside, this is a different issue and a very dangerous precedent for a "platform" to be setting IMO.
- aabeshou 8y agoWhat exactly makes you uncomfortable with calling genocidal racism "Wrong(TM)", and helping people leave it? Are you also uncomfortable with them banning child porn, or is that an example of punishing wrongthink too? EDIT: I invite downvoters to tell me why they disagree?
- im3w1l 8y agoI think you have a misunderstanding of the word "white nationalism". I'd recommend looking it up to understand what is happening here. But in short it means the belief that there is a white race and that it has a right to preserve itself and it's culture. Genocidal racism was never allowed on facebook. After this move they will censor a lot of legitimate things.
- qualipetv 8y agoWhite nationalism is not a legitimate thing and I implore you to get in contact with networks that help individuals get out of hate groups.
- im3w1l 8y agoYour jumping to conclusions exemplifies why this move by facebook is so incredibly dangerous. You jump from "censoring white nationalism will censor legitimate opinions" (such as there "there is a white race" - a question on which there are good arguments for both sides, and which it's reasonable to debate), to I hold such opinions. Then you jump from a few of those opinions to hatred. And then you jump from there to being part of hate groups. Calm down and think.
- panarky 8y agoCurious that a post about eliminating white nationalist content actually includes an image with white nationalist content. https://imgur.com/a/fSm1pHa https://imgur.com/a/fSm1pHa It's perhaps an unintentional example of the difference between advocacy (banned) and education or discussion (not banned). Very interested in how Facebook will distinguish between them when both use identical words.
- bcruddy 8y agoDid you read the sentence right below that conveniently cropped screenshot? | Searches for terms associated with white supremacy will surface a link to Life After Hate’s Page, where people can find support in the form of education, interventions, academic research and outreach.
- randyrand 8y agoWhy not ban all racist nationalism entirely? What is unique about white nationalism versus Chinese nationalism in China, or black nationalism in South Africa? There are many racist movements all around the world. Only banning white nationalism is giving fuel to the white nationalist belief that whites are being unfairly targeted. That's not something we should encourage IMO.
- miguelmota 8y agoOne step at a time. Facebook is based in the US so it makes sense to tackle problems occurring in the US first.
- philwelch 8y agoThe notion is that the history of European colonialism and imperialism "justifies" black and Chinese nationalism as a countermeasure to white supremacy. There's a "punching up" vs. "punching down" model that pretty much explains most "hypocrisy" on this issue. For instance, even subtle hints of anti-Semitism expressed by white Westerners (e.g. being anti-George Soros in particular) are condemned far more vehemently than anti-Semitism expressed by black people or Muslims, because of the perception that Jews, being perceived as predominantly white and Westernized themselves, are more privileged than blacks and Muslims but less privileged than white Gentiles. I don't agree with this mentality myself because the tides can turn a lot faster than your ideological model of privilege and oppression can change to reflect it, but it's similar to the ideas that are commonly expressed on the left and serves as a decent predictive model of their attitudes.
- dredmorbius 8y agoFacebook found specifically that such power dynamics are exceedingly contextual, though the role of Western European culture as effectively globally predominant puts an additional burden on anyone arguing for Western European superiority. Radiolab covered this recently: Post No Evil | Radiolab | Duration: 1:11:45 | Published: Fri, 17 Aug 2018 07:20:00 -0400 | Episode: http://www.wnycstudios.org/story/post-no-evil/ http://www.wnycstudios.org/story/post-no-evil/ Media: https://www.podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/audio.wnyc.org/radiolab_podcast/radiolab_podcast18postnoevil.mp3 https://www.podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/audio.wnyc.org/radi... Podcast: https://www.podcastrepublic.net/podcast/152249110 https://www.podcastrepublic.net/podcast/152249110 Back in 2008 Facebook began writing a document. It was a constitution of sorts, laying out what could and what couldn’t be posted on the site. Back then, the rules were simple, outlawing nudity and...
- umvi 8y ago> Last fall, we started using [machine learning and artificial intelligence] to extend our efforts to a range of hate groups globally, including white supremacists So... is this going to be a train wreck like YouTube's content ID where certain keywords will trigger the robots to censor my post with no human to appeal to? "Sorry, you said: '80 years ago today Hitler committed suicide and axis power was extinguished.' This post contains keywords associated with dangerous groups and individuals and has been removed."
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoI am not a ‘white person’ (whatever that means) ...but I don’t want to see ‘white nationalist content’ banned. When people communicate on a public platform unself consciously, they reveal themselves openly and freely. There is no greater protection to vulnerable populations than transparency. Freedom of speech is a gift and a valuable tool.This move is dumb beyond words.
- anth_anm 8y ago> There is no greater protection to vulnerable populations than transparency This is somewhat true, but your argument has a pretty big flaw. > When people communicate on a public platform unself consciously, they reveal themselves openly and freely This simply isn't true. You aren't revealing that you read this content. THe authors aren't always revealing themselves. Those who don't really do themselves any harm because they tend to be well established as white supremacists already. Richard Spencer doesn't care if someone calls him racist and evil. This is why people take photos and plaster them online when white supremacists march. People get recognized, that's the point where they can be called out. > Freedom of speech is a gift and a valuable tool. These people are radicalizing young men into committing violent acts. They should be banned the same way terrorist content has been removed from other platforms.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoI think terrorist content is different from nationalism/racism. The latter is still a deeply held belief. Regardless of how we feel about it, everyone has the right to feel love or hate or superiority. This is really a failure of state to install controls and protections from out of control elements. This is a breakdown of state measures to deter/punish unlawful acts and failure to protect WHEN actions occur rather than breakdown of society. One cannot make an entire society conform. To me, that’s terrorism too.
- CamperBob2 8y agoThis is a breakdown of state measures to deter/punish unlawful acts and failure to protect WHEN actions occur rather than breakdown of society. You could say that Facebook has effectively privatized prior restraint, given the "town square" arguments made elsewhere in the thread. Great when we happen to agree with the views being restrained, I suppose.
- ordu 8y ago> We didn’t originally apply the same rationale to [...] because we were thinking about [...] things like American pride and Basque separatism [...] What do they mean by "American pride"? Googling it brings a lot of marketing, I do not know how to filter all of that to find out an idea.
- fixermark 8y agoI think they mean "'Murican pride." ;)
- Dylan16807 8y agoSearch "patriotism".
- ordu 8y agoSo it is not a meme, like a song or some group of active people from the past or anything like that?
- Dylan16807 8y agoCorrect, they were referring to a very general concept as far as I am aware.
- andrewla 8y agoI am also nearly a free speech absolutist, but I feel that platforms like YouTube and FB are nearly in-scope. I can't specifically say what the criteria is, but there's some notion of how much responsibility they take for the content. Something like the notion of a DMCA shield; where a platform can expose third-party content without consequences so long as they response to take-down requests means that they do not get to do filtering. If they get to do filtering and curation, then they are also directly responsible for copyright violations or libelous use of their platform -- the shield shouldn't apply unless it cuts both ways. That is, by accepting some immunity from the consequences of free speech, they are then subject to free speech restrictions on their enforcement of their own opinions. A newspaper, for example, is not subject to the same restriction -- they are responsible for all content they publish, so can choose to publish or not publish whatever they want. This isn't a precise framing, but I'm trying to capture some of my general thoughts on why I find it unappealing that YouTube and Facebook can filter out content that they deem offensive. Facebook has a natural filtering mechanism through the ability for a user to restrict what they see. If you find content offensive, unfriend or block the person and you're done. Youtube can exercise some discretion in auto-play and recommendations, but they shouldn't be able to ban content unless they are required to do so by inheriting legal requirements.
- inetknght 8y agoDMCA is a United States law, isn't it? So what about mix-region content? What about content from a region in which the content is legal but it's not legal in the region from the person making the complaint?
- andrewla 8y agoI believe the DMCA's safe harbor provisions were adopted independently by most other jurisdictions, and there may even have been international treaties establishing some of the rules. Most sites are unlikely to contest take-down notices regardless of jurisdiction; that is incumbent on the party posting the content.
- 8y ago
- tathougies 8y agoWhy are white people specifically targeted. As someone of an Indian background, I've seen plenty of Hindu nationalist content on Facebook, and -- despite it actually affecting my Christian family who are still in India -- there is no ban on that content. Such nationalism has led to more violence and death than any of the white nationalism stories.
- botwriter 8y agofacebook only moderates posts in English There was plenty of videos of the NewZealand shooter still up on Brazilian facebook
- gowld 8y agonon-Hindus do not have sufficient political or economic power in India and/or Facebook's multinational context.
- commandlinefan 8y agoIn fairness, they've been censoring middle-eastern terrorist content (Al Qaeda, ISIS, etc.) for quite a while now.
- odorousrex 8y agoCynical Answer: It's affecting FB's bottom line. White nationalism is in the news and on the rise in the US/Europe and therefore spooking advertisers who only really care what the pundits in US/Europe are talking about. This soothes them over = money for FB. My hope is that the algorithms and models developed for slowing the spread of White Nationalism will also work (down the road) for things like Hindu Nationalism, Chinese, etc.
- baddox 8y agoIs that really cynical? The presence of hate groups on your platform being bad for your bottom line is a good thing, right?
- odorousrex 8y ago
- sunseb 8y agoA brave new world. Sleep well people.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- weberc2 8y agoThe obvious questions are and always have been "what constitutes 'harmful speech'?" and "who gets to decide?". Sure, we can agree that "white supremacy" is harmful, but in the last 5 years we've seen the definition of white supremacy slide from "people who espouse views that whites are better than nonwhites" to "people who espouse views that are not in line with progressive orthodoxy".
- djsumdog 8y agoAnd what about more complex things? Twitter and Twitch bans people who question some of the modern beliefs on gender ideology, even if they bring up the discussion respectfully. Not to mention, it just means extremists go to platforms that welcome them (Voat, Gab and others). That means platforms that use to have a big mix of views, like Reddit, are now horribly one sided and those other platforms are all extremist. Keep in mind, we're not seeing the "right" or "moral" view. We're seeing Twitter/Facebook/Reddit's CEOs/Mods/deciders views.
- thecommentary 8y agoTwitter is considering telling journalists to learn to code as hate speech now - we have already slipped down that slope even on the simple things.
- acdha 8y agoDo you have a citation for that? All of the reports which I saw were that specific people harassing specific users were flagged as violating the abusiveness clause of the terms of service. Nobody said anything about hate speech or even non-targeted rude remarks before the usual right-wing grievance machine started whining about a private company enforcing its contractual terms.
- rhcom2 8y agoTwitter said that was part of a "targeted harassment campaign", not hate speech.
- golergka 8y agoI would love for all people around the world to become level-headed and rational enough so we can have complete and total free speech. Personally, I enjoy 4chan and don't experience any negative emotions conserving to people who openly advocate genocide that would target me and my family. However, people en masse are different, and tech platforms have to acknowledge that. So, I believe it is a good thing to ban and police hate speech, at least when private companies do it (and not government).
- fixermark 8y agoWithout delving too deeply, because I don't want to engender any negative emotions: do you take the people who openly advocate genocide against you seriously? If you do and it doesn't cause you to experience any negative emotions, I am surprised. If you don't, I am also surprised. In light of what has happened in Pittsburgh and Christchurch.
- golergka 8y agoMy mother and grandparents have had to make a run for a bomb shelter a few times this week. So, yeah, I don't think that people who have "from the river to the sea" in their bio are joking.
- Octoth0rpe 8y agoAbout damn time.
- john_moscow 8y agoDoes it mean that other nationalist content is allowed?
- gowld 8y agoIt's OK to say you believe that you are pro free-speech only in cases of government/military/police censorship. It's not OK to redefine free speech to mean "government censorship", especially not to call your position "very nearly absolutist". You believe that private companies have the moral right to censor and filter user-generated content. That's your opinion/morality. But it's not "free speech absolutism" in the common English language.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- hn_throwaway_99 8y ago> It's not OK to redefine free speech to mean "government censorship" I beg to disagree, and in fact I believe you are the one that is redefining free speech. "Free speech" as I have known it has always referred just to government restrictions, because the government is the only entity that has the very unique punative powers that they do. Indeed, a strong corrolary to free speech, freedom of the press, by definition means that a (private) journalism organization is free to publish (or not publish) whatever they want. I do agree that the relatively new, immense power of large technology companies with respect to how we communicate may require a sense of updating what we mean by "free speech", but this would be an update - it is not inherent to the original meaning of free speech.
- throwawaysea 8y agoFree speech means freedom from censorship. And from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship > Censorship is the suppression of speech, public communication, or other information, on the basis that such material is considered objectionable, harmful, sensitive, or "inconvenient". Censorship can be conducted by a government, private institutions, and corporations. From Merriam-Webster (https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/censorship https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/censorship), where there is no mention of 'censorship' being a government-specific concept: > the institution, system, or practice of censoring From Oxford (https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/censorship https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/censorship), where again there is no mention of 'censorship' being a government-specific concept: > The suppression or prohibition of any parts of books, films, news, etc. that are considered obscene, politically unacceptable, or a threat to security.
- whatiseu 8y agoDoes this include policing the debate about EU expansion to Turkey or Morocco?
- insickness 8y agoMarsh v. Alabama, 326 U.S. 501 (1946), was a case decided by the United States Supreme Court, in which it ruled that a state trespassing statute could not be used to prevent the distribution of religious materials on a town's sidewalk, even though the sidewalk was part of a privately owned company town. The Court based its ruling on the provisions of the First Amendment and Fourteenth Amendment. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_v._Alabama https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marsh_v._Alabama > "Ownership does not always mean absolute dominion. The more an owner, for his advantage, opens up his property for use by the public in general, the more do his rights become circumscribed by the statutory and constitutional rights of those who use it."
- ceejayoz 8y agoOf course, the follow-ups are important, too: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lloyd_Corp._v._Tanner https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lloyd_Corp._v._Tanner I'd put Facebook more in the "mall" example than the "company town" one.
- CobrastanJorji 8y agoThe mall got out of it because there were many alternate places to distribute messages, so banning mall speech didn't significantly stifle overall speech. That probably still also applies to Facebook today, but not by a wide margin.
- philwelch 8y agoOne could argue that this implies an antitrust issue, no?
- ceejayoz 8y agoIf places like Twitter didn't exist, sure.
- stcredzero 8y ago
- kadendogthing 8y agoI'm going to caution against people using the phrase "free speech" as a thought terminating cliche when discussing this. Banning speech can and typically has been harmful, especially when governments get involved with doing it. No one is ignorant about this fact. But we're collectively discovering that not doing anything about what can be published and said is just about as harmful, if not more so in concentrated circumstances. There will be irrational people who act irrational on fundamental erroneous information. It's a practical matter, not an ideological one. White supremacist ideas aren't up for debate. There isn't a point in debating them. And the people adhering to these ideals aren't looking for a debate and most definitely won't consider other ideas. You can't debate rationally with someone who hasn't arrived at their position in a rational manner. There's also something else at play here. We're seeing new systems that replaced old ones re-implement "lost" functionality they thought wasn't needed. Turns out it was, in fact, needed. The old media empire of yesteryear was always subject to regulations around the content they spread. If bitcoin is an exercise in why we need financial regulations, facebook and other social media networks are an exercise in why we need content and publishing regulations.
- someguydave 8y agoAre black nationalist ideas up for debate? Who gave you the power to decide what is up for debate?
- kadendogthing 8y agoRemoving yourself from any kind of rational framework removes the required considerable characteristic of an idea or view point. Especially when those ideas and view points have been tried on top of just generally being a Bad Idea (TM). So I haven't done anything. There's no need to start an epistemological bankrupt conversation here. Or to engage in philosophical waxing about intellectual curiosity surrounding view points that serve no purpose.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- FakeComments 8y agoIt’s interesting that Facebook chose to focus on the problem of white nationalism when the national press is talking about an actor faking a crime to incite hatred against white people and create a false narrative about white nationalism. What steps is Facebook taking to prevent racially motivated hoaxes meant to incite hatred, like the one by Jussie Smollett? Ive seen repeated and consistent misrepresentation and lies on the issue by public figures, such as Mr Smollett or the case of the media harping about police shootings massacring unarmed people, only to find shooting unarmed people is rare and the breakdown corresponds to who commits crimes. Or the consistent representations of the police being violent, only to discover later they acted with appropriate force. Im not sure I buy the narrative that this is a problem, rather than lies for power.
- Inu 8y agoMight sound good in theory, but in effect it means that some low ranking Facebook employee will have to decide whether Jordan Peterson is allowed to publish on Facebook or whether he is to be categorized as a white supremacist, a decision the outcome of which will vary according to ideological disposition, the ability to read and comprehend texts, and the power to navigate the realm of ambiguity and conflicting interpretations.
- itry2develop 8y agoWhat about Black Nationalism? Or Asian Nationalism?
- chubot 8y agoI don't have a strong opinion on this particular issue, but I don't think your comment gets to the core of it. If Facebook decided to ban all Chinese, Islamic, or African-American content, then the conversation would be completely different. People wouldn't say, "so be it -- go set up your own servers". Obviously they have to make a value judgement, and they have done so here and said as much (which I appreciate). In other words, they made a considered and conscious decision that's beyond my expertise. But it's still a value judgement about particular content. The decision really can't be made on an abstract "free speech" basis.
- fixermark 8y agoIf we're limiting our discussion to US law and mores, then at least in the context of banning African-American content, there's specific federal law they'd be tripping over. That same law has not been (and probably should not be) extended to protect white supremacy or white separatism, which are political ideologies.
- caprese 8y ago> then at least in the context of banning African-American content, there's specific federal law they'd be tripping over which specific federal law would that be? I can't think of any law protecting content about specific groups
- fixermark 8y agoDepending on how you turn your head and squint, Title II of the Civil Rights Act (assuming we can interpret Facebook as a public accommodation engaging in interstate commerce). ... though it's unclear whether it's more of a private club.
- caprese 8y agoTitle II's definition of public accommodation is limited to "any inn, hotel, motel, or other establishment which provides lodging to transient guests"
- interlocutor 8y agoAttitudes towards free speech have changed a lot in recent times. I believe this is related to the rise of social media. The advent of social media had made it too easy to spread hate online. This has caused an upheaval in attitudes towards free speech. For example, consider that UC Berkeley which gave birth to the Free Speech Movement is now making news for banning controversial/harmful speech, such as that by Ann Coulter. The people (as opposed to governments) have decided that some censorship is in order. This is a natural evolution of societal norms. This particular evolution was causated by social media, and it is befitting to see that a social media company is now in the news for censoring harmful speech. This type of censorship, as opposed to absolute free speech, will be the new normal.
- talmand 8y agoAt what point do such things change into a public discourse problem? Do we wait until it can be shown that companies such as Facebook, Twitter, Google, etc. influenced elections because they refused to serve information from a candidate they didn't like? If we aren't already there, it's not long before it is. What do you think would happen if these "private companies" with such deep hooks into our communication infrastructure suddenly decided to remove all data associated to the Republican Party? For that matter, the Democratic Party? It seems to me that Facebook and Twitter are trying to have it both ways. They can choose to police the content provided by their users but can't be held responsible for said content? Are they a publisher or a platform? I don't think comparing old thinking based around old methods of communication compares to what we have today, it requires new thinking. These aren't like newspapers sold by kids on the corner in a city that can have dozens of newspapers countering each other. Imagine if there were only three newspapers in the entire country, soon the world, controlled by a small group of people who wish to use their publishing for their own agendas. Tim Pool is right, at this rate, sooner or later, the Feds will come knocking and will shut that party down.
- commandlinefan 8y ago> influenced elections In fairness to Google and Facebook, etc. TV networks have always been super biased and had far more reach than internet platforms - and it was actually conservatives who shut down (with good reason) the "fairness doctrine" that would have forced them to carry content they didn't necessarily agree with.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- burfog 8y agoWe're already there. Repeating a previous study, which had shown bias in the 2016 election, Dr. Robert Epstein shows that bias in the 2018 election pushed voters towards democrats. Approximately 4.6 million undecided voters are likely to have flipped. Numerous districts, particularly CA 45, are likely to have been flipped by Google's weaponized bias. There has also been an awful lot of bans of beginner politicians, all on one side, often corrected after the election (damage is done) with a lame excuse about algorithms making mistakes.
- XIVMagnus 8y agoI'm seeing comments mainly focusing on "free speech" and that no company or monopoly should control it. I think we are stemming away from the actual GOOD that comes from banning such content. Why are we allowing people who influence others to do harmful things to minorities? Why should we give people with harmful ideas a platform to begin with? If they feel like they need to be heard, sure let them develop their own platform and spread it among themselves. Rather than influence young people who don't know any better. That's just my opinion on the matter.
- jeffdavis 8y agoThe US President has identified himself as a "nationalist"[1], and appears to be racially white. So how would this policy apply to Trump supporters and their speech? This is a general problem with trying to ban speech. It's often very hard to figure out what someone intends to mean versus how others interpret it versus what it "really means". Especially when symbols, slogans, etc., come into play, not to mention different audiences. That ensures that this policy will be applied inconsistently and have unintended consequences, and create a flurry of argument over what was banned, by whom, and why. It's just a mess and does not help the discourse. [1] https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2018/10/24/trump-says-hes-nationalist-what-means-why-its-controversial/1748521002/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/politics/2018/10/24/trum...
- dragonwriter 8y ago> The US President has identified himself as a "nationalist"[1], and appears to be racially white A white nationalist is not the same as a nationalist who is white; a white nationalist is one who adheres to the ideology of white nationalism.
- jeffdavis 8y agoI understand that, but I was trying to point out the difficulty in drawing that distinction when it comes to applying a censorship policy.
- iheartpotatoes 8y agoLots of slippery-slope fanatics posting today. When they start banishing speech that is not about exterminating nonwhites, then we can have that conversation. (For example: Elizabeth Warren speaking out against Facebook.) But until then let's just agree that supporting groups who actively incite violence and march for exterminating nonwhites is a BAD THING. OK? JFC I can't believe how many people are so eager to cite Voltaire and a flimsy knowledge of the 1st Amendment (hint: it only applies to government suppression) to stand up for white supremacy.
- sparkie 8y agoSpeech that is about "exterminating nonwhites" is already illegal speech. It is incitement to commit crime. There does not need to be new rules or laws to prevent this speech - there just needs to be enforcement of the existing rules, which is fine, and I think everyone, including most right-wingers will agree that such laws should be enforced, and it is correct that media platforms block posts as soon as they are alerted to them. The issue isn't about banning speech which is about "exterminating nonwhites", but about banning speech which discusses something else, but which takes a gigantic stretch of imagination to be considered about "exterminating nonwhites". What you want to ban isn't speech which is illegal (incitement to commit crime), but in fact, anything you imagine can be misrepresented to be considered equivalent. The only limit to your restrictions on speech are your imagination!
- iheartpotatoes 8y agoPlease. You are pretending White Supremacy is this totally benign thing because you are ignoring reality in pursuit of egalitarian ideology. You cannot simply ignore context for the sake of argument.
- sparkie 8y agoYou can take anything out of context and present it as something else to make an argument, and it goes both ways. People can take something totally benign and present it as if it were a white supremacist argument. It's not hard to imagine this being stretched to limit my speech. I'm white, and I'm also a nationalist - one who believes that nation states are the best means of managing humans who have a shared culture and traditions. How much of a stretch would it be to call me a "white nationalist?" I mean, lexicographically, it is an accurate use of two adjectives which describe me. However, I'm certainly not a "white nationalist" in the sense that might suggest I am in any way a white supremacist. If white nationalist content is banned, does this mean that I cannot discuss nationalism because I am white - and therefore, a loon can trivially make the link that if I am white, and nationalist, then I must be a white nationalist? Doh! What about white people who wish to celebrate their cultural heritage, peacefully, by suggesting that they should not have to give up or sacrifice their culture or traditions for fear that they might offend someone. Of course, it doesn't take imagination to think that a loon my consider this to be "white supremacism", because it is already happening! The idea that there exists some large "exterminate nonwhites" network is a cartoon version of reality. There exist a small number of deranged humans who think that their skin color makes them superior, and an even smaller fraction of them who think that therefore, they must kill people who do not share that skin color. These are not at all representative of whites, nationalists, conservatives or free speech advocates, who are the real targets of recent censorship. I mean, Alex Jones might be a nutcase, but I've not heard any evidence suggesting he has been calling for exterminating people. He has publicly apologized countless times for his handling of the Sandy Hook case which is the alleged reason he is banned. And Sargon of Akkad is an outspoken critic of white nationalists, but if we take this one word he said out of context then we've got him cornered! You are the one pretending pal. You are pretending slippery slopes do no exist and that rules and laws only apply to the thing they were originally written to apply to. What utopia has this ever happened in? The only rules which can't be abused are the rules which don't exist in the first place. A rule which is in place is a rule which will be abused. Selective enforcement of rules also exists, and is commonly used to politically censor one side while openly allowing the opposing viewpoint. Now if there are real cases of incitement to commit any crime against people because of their skin color, or anything else even, then I'm all for enforcement of rules and laws as they should be. This isn't what the censorship and assaults on free speech are about at all.
- lgleason 8y agoMany are rightfully making the argument that they are a common carrier because of their monopoly in the space. Right now there really isn't a viable competitor to them. The same is true with Twitter etc. because they are all substantially different products. IMHO I would supports Facebook's right to do this if: 1. They gave up the safe harbor protections and were subject to the same liabilities as news organizations. 2. Or they were broken up. Otherwise, this is akin to kicking someone out of the town square without the ability to move to another one....and that is not free speech...
- anigbrowl 8y agoI'd argue that there are lots of alternatives. But the smaller and less exclusive ones which tolerate extreme content often have reputations like Mos Eisley spaceport, so while people can gather and organize there relatively freely it seriously limits their fundraising and recruitment outreach.
- aestetix 8y agoDoes this mean Facebook can now be considered a publishing platform, and thus liable for content put on the site?
- duality 8y agoIt should.
- mythrwy 8y agoWell what can they do really? If they leave content up after big incidents they are enabling. If they take it all down, they are promoting certain points of view over others. Both will have folks screaming. Probably they were smart enough to do the math and determined which action likely results in less blowback. That's all. Then again, Facebook like many public areas always was a cesspool in my opinion. Not a fan of drinking from cesspools. So they can do whatever brings in the most money and I'm sure they will.
- caprese 8y agoNice move I was annoyed that instagram has now become just reshares of twitter and facebook posts that spread the same message without being indexed as easily as the text versions are Hope they don't go after things I like and target my accounts next! I know how the limitations of their process and lack of appeals or justification. Also easy enough to find my friends on group chats elsewhere I would have very different views if these were state run systems, but fortunately that's not relevant here.
- throwawaysea 8y agoLarge privately-owned platforms carry so much discourse across today's society, that censorship and deplatforming in those spaces has the same impact as governmental censorship, for most intents and purposes. Even if these corporations do not constitute what we might traditionally call a "monopoly", they control a large-enough share of traffic to have significant impact when they take artificial actions. That sizable impact is exactly why they are being targeted (not just on this topic but others) by activists or other agents pushing for deplatforming/censorship favorable to their causes. The big risk is this: when only a few entities funnel so much societal discourse or control our communication infrastructure or process payments, those entities making arbitrary decisions about who they serve has similar impacts/risks to the government imposing similar restrictions through the law. These companies should not act as a thought police and should not impose their own personal governance above what is minimally required by the law. Nor should they rely on the judgment of an angry mob to make decisions.
- robenkleene 8y ago"The same impact as governmental censorship, for most intents and purposes." False and dangerous. Government censorship means imprisonment and other forms of punishment, sometimes including death. This doesn't mean your point is wrong (I don't think it is), but it's more effective to make your argument on its own merits rather than making a false equivalency.
- overthemoon 8y ago"Free speech" comes up so fast in this conversation it stifles any other aspects, like what counts as "public". We have to figure out exactly what it means that Facebook is a massive platform with billions of users centrally controlled by a corporation and how that affects us, and free speech issues are only one aspect. I find it so strange how people on the left and right swap argument styles on the issue of free speech, though. As pointed out by Freddie DeBoer, people on the left want to strictly define free speech as government intervention and criticism, contradicting their usual tendency to interpret law more broadly. Then the right, contradicting their own approach to law interpretation, want a more expansive interpretation of free speech to include things like corporate censorship on platforms that aren't necessarily "public" as we'd traditionally understand it, but have public-y qualities nonetheless. Anyway, good riddance to white supremacy, but this is a transparent bid by Facebook for PR repair. Their public image was trashed by the 2016 election on several fronts, and this hardly rectifies it. It seems like cynical bullshit to me. EDIT: It also makes me think of Freddie DeBoer's essay "Planet of Cops": https://medium.com/@jesse.singal/planet-of-cops-50889004904d https://medium.com/@jesse.singal/planet-of-cops-50889004904d
- root_axis 8y agoWhat is it about nazis and white supremacists that causes everyone to boot them from their platform? From cloudflare to microsoft to twitter and now facebook, why is everyone so hostile to them? They just can't catch a break, if this keeps up they'll only be able to host content on platforms that are supportive of the message or they'll be forced to build their own platforms and since so many people are hostile to them already nobody will use their platform except people with similar beliefs (e.g. voat). Should these companies really be allowed to just ban them simply because they regard their ideologies as repugnant? edit: I'll note here that the above should be read as tongue-in-cheek sarcasm, but I do think the question is worthwhile when considered in earnest by those who support nazi speech on private platforms.
- deegles 8y agoYes.
- api 8y agoI'm still such a fence sitter on this. I am fairly close to a free speech absolutist, but I agree with others that FB is a private platform and isn't obligated to provide bandwidth to anyone. Another concern of mine though is that just banning this stuff atrophies our ability to effectively debate it.
- kyleperik 8y agoQuite clearly this is just a move to gain back support. But this has nothing to do with free speech. If I tell someone something, they have no obligation to broadcast what you said. Why should Facebook act differently? I don't like that they're targeting such a specific group. I think we should be on the lookout for real racism, and this is certainly an example of that.
- oyvey 8y agoThe purpose of free speech is that you can influece the reality you live in, without that its useless, might as well not have it. As such free speech requires to be allowed on the most popular social platforms. Just like free speech had to be allowed on a towns square.
- rdl 8y agoThis seems absurd and unreasonable once you look at it more closely. If any group of people say they want to go live apart from others (white, gay, men, linux users, whatever), I'm fine with that. I wouldn't want to live in a racial separatist region myself, but I have no problem with other people choosing to do so. Treating black nationalists as heroes (which in a historical sense they were) while making white nationalists a target of scorn seems...unsustainable. If FB wanted to redirect funding from "bad" things they don't like to a decent group, Life After Hate is about as bad as SPLC. There have to be better groups focused on helping people of various types.
- oh_sigh 8y agoThe difference being that white nationalists generally don't want to run away to a large private homestead and live out their lives privately and whitely - they want to convert the existing multiracial society they live in into a uniracial one.
- baddox 8y agoThe problem is when you say you want to live apart from others, but you want that to be right here where there happen to currently be other people. When you say that, even if you claim to not be advocating for violence or forceful removal, that is effectively what you’re advocating. There are white nationalist groups that actually use the phrase “peaceful ethnic cleansing.”
- antt 8y agoThere are also Muslim groups who say as much. "We will just out breed them" is a common tactic used to great effect in Kosovo and Western Macedonia by Albanians. The shooting in Christchurch referenced a video from the Mosque in question that spelled the same thing out. Unfortunately I can't share the video due to laws which would put me in jail. [0] Is your objection to them saying it out loud, or saying it in English? [0] Isn't censorship grand? Now instead of seeing the video yourself you have to trust someone else to tell you what's in it.
- 8y ago
- staticautomatic 8y agoI'm in favor of values-based governance. At some point you have to say "these are our values" and if you don't share them then don't use our platform. They do not necessarily teach a specific solution to a specific problem, but they can guide you toward an internally consistent position on one. As a practical matter, you must be willing to rank-order your values. Many emerging rights issues, particularly those involving speech and religion, simply cannot be dealt with if you treat all rights as equal and inviolable. This is government 101.
- 781 8y agoSo is the Scottish independence movement now forbidden on Facebook? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Separatism_in_the_United_Kingdom https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Separatism_in_the_United_Kingd...
- charliesharding 8y agoAs a non-white person living in America, this is scary to see. It's a policy targeting a specific race of people's content... How is that not racist? It will only foment more resentment and retaliatory sentiment while serving to make "certain kinds of racism" socially acceptable as long as it's the "right race" to discriminate against. Ban ethno-nationalists if you feel so inclined, not {{insertRaceHere}} nationalism. Otherwise this is a slippery slope to head down
- chapium 8y agoI don't see why facebook would be obliged to host content they don't agree with. These people will always find a platform on the internet. Facebook doesn't need to make their recruitment more convenient.
- charliesharding 8y agoI get what you're saying but if they're going to curate what content that they put forth, then they cease to be a platform and they become a publisher. Publishers are liable for much more under the eyes of the law. They can't cherry pick the advantages from the two systems without any of the drawbacks.
- NoodleIncident 8y agoPlatforms choose what to remove, and Publishers choose what to include. No matter how much a Platform removes, it never becomes a Publisher.
- shrimpx 8y agoThis seems a rather pedantic difference -- "let it be posted and remove it later" versus "reject it upon submission."
- chapium 8y agoThats quite an interesting question. Filtering is not publishinng, the content is user generated. However they are taking on an editorial role. Also, they are not a newspaper, so terminology from that kind of medium might not be useful. Any platform that offers freedom is going to have problems on the head and tail of their platform. I feel facebook is trying to adjust where they make that slice and are justified in doing so, from a moral basis and according to the wishes of their shareholders.
- edmundkorley 8y agoAt least in the United States, it is the power dynamic that differentiates White Nationalism. White nationalists and their ideology have penetrated the Senate, the White House, and our police force to name just a few places of power. This has huge and potentially violent consequences for non-Whites in the U.S. and needs to be take more seriously. We have seen historical manifestations of this from slavery to contemporary voter discrimination. Rote quotation of the First Amendment ignores this and we need to change our policies to keep everybody safe.
- inherentFloyd 8y agoI am not from India, but you do understand that the party that has majority control over India, the BJP, is a blatantly Hindu Nationalist party? I would argue this makes them even more entrenched in nationalist politics than here in the US. Look at the hundreds of killings and mutilations over cows that the government of India seriously turns a blind eye to.
- oh_sigh 8y agoYou can claim that white nationalism has penetrated the White House all you want, but there is no evidence of this being the case.
- craftyguy 8y agoUh, Trump invited Steve Bannon into his cabinet. They did not part ways because of Bannon's extreme white nationalist views...
- oh_sigh 8y agoYou would need to show that Trump invited Bannon into the White House because of his white nationalist views, and not because of his abilities in other areas. Which I don't think you can do. Also, if Steve Bannon is a white nationalist, it seems weird that Trump would support him, considering that presumably makes him want to get rid of parts of Trump's own family(Ivanka/Jared and their kids).
- PavlovsCat 8y agoLet me guess, they'll do it with a total lack of transparency and accountability, e.g. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QzlPhxf4Rd0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QzlPhxf4Rd0 ?
- tomphoolery 8y agoTook them long enough. Guess it had to come to accidentally causing a regime change in a major world power that ends up being bad for everyone involved. You get zero points, Facebook. And everyone who works for Facebook.
- return0 8y agoGood. Facebook is not a free speech platform, it's a medium like the old media. The more mature it gets the more it will look like TV. They have no reason to pretend to appeal to the geekies or their besties in the valley - they re big enough on their own. Good. On to other ventures
- hodder 8y agoFacebook is a private company. They are free to purge whatever they want off the platform for whatever they determine is in their best interest. And that is how it should be. White nationalists are not a protected group, therefore it is not discrimination. If FB wanted to purge all pro Republican or all Democrat articles from the platform, that would also be in their right (though not best interest).
- wolco 8y agoIn the case of facebook. If they removed one side from debating that side will leave. Creating a smaller more similiar group of people. That would go against the goal of connecting the world and change the goal to connecting the left or right. Plenty of those sites. Facebook's ideal strategy is not to get involved.
- bduerst 8y agoExcept deplatforming is shown to work against alt-right hate speech: https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/bjbp9d/do-social-media-bans-work https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us/article/bjbp9d/do-social-... Anti-semitic speech has traditionally relied on soap boxes to spread their message, for decades before the internet even existed. That's why most academics won't engage them, because these groups are not interested in genuine discussion but in broadcasting their prejudice.
- lazyjones 8y agoVICE is trash content, not journalism. And the current debate obviously stems from the tragic results of increased alt-right hate speech, despite all the "deplatforming".
- JamesLeonis 8y agoAd Hominem. If you want the data, check out these studies from the quoted researchers: 1: http://comp.social.gatech.edu/papers/cscw18-chand-hate.pdf http://comp.social.gatech.edu/papers/cscw18-chand-hate.pdf 2: https://datasociety.net/output/oxygen-of-amplification/ https://datasociety.net/output/oxygen-of-amplification/
- someguydave 8y ago1. Is a study on how effectively Reddit banned some users 2. Is some woman’s opinion on how people should write about Internet-related news Neither of those sources demonstrate that banning “alt-right” content “works” unless you mean that banning results in bans.
- black-tea 8y agoWith the first link the chain is forged, first speech censored, first thought forbidden, first freedom denied, chains us all, irrevocably.
- smsm42 8y agoLegally, of course, FB is completely right. Morally - try to replace "white nationalism" with, say, "communism" (one can argue communists killed a lot of people, so why not?), "Christianity", "Islam", "Black separatism", "Wiccans"... I could continue forever, but I hope you get the point. If you're consistently fine with any $GROUP put there, no matter how much you love it/disgusted by it, then your position is consistent and you are one of about 0.001% of people that has a consistent free speech position. For the rest, the answer would be "but this is completely different - $INGROUP can not be banned, they are a nice people that sometimes are misunderstood, but $OUTGROUP are definitely all violent bigots that should be banned everywhere for everybody's safety". Of course, FB does not owe anybody to neither have consistent free speech position, nor support free speech at all, nor be an inclusive platform. They could convert their site to the fan club of Jar Jar Binks tomorrow and make every user to pledge loyalty to Supreme Lord Jar Jar or take a hike. Completely within their rights. Presenting themselves as an open platform while executing a clear political censorship is less morally clear (though of course still legally completely OK). It doesn't matter that political censorship is now directed to the group that is outgroup for most people here - it always starts that way. It never ends there.
- harrumph 8y ago> one can argue communists killed a lot of people, so why not? Because in the really existing world, we are in no way faced with a growing trend of violent leftists shooting up mosques, driving their cars into protestors, infiltrating police departments, perpetrating 73% of fatal extremist incidents in the US, receiving attaboys and cover from the Oval Office, poisoning YouTube RIYL algos, etc.
- Macross8299 8y ago> receiving attaboys and cover from the Oval Office I don't recall of any incident where the President congratulated a white nationalist terrorist or said anything that could even be conceived as such, do you have a source for this?
- harrumph 8y ago
- dayvid 8y agoI wish larger tech companies would follow Jack Dorsey's path and have more open communication about their policies. His debate with Tim Pool on the Joe Rogan podcast[0] especially provided insight into why they're making these type of decisions. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DZCBRHOg3PQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DZCBRHOg3PQ
- m0zg 8y agoSo now you will be banned if you're white and think that US politicians should put the interests of the US first in foreign and domestic policy? That'll eliminate the majority of their US user base.
- _iyig 8y agoSo what about black nationalism? The Dallas mass-shooter, Micah Xavier Johnson, was reportedly radicalized in part by various black power Facebook groups: https://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-dallas-police-shooting-live-suspect-joined-facebook-groups-that-1468001887-htmlstory.html https://www.latimes.com/nation/la-na-dallas-police-shooting-...
- Corya0687 8y agoWell... the fbi has a specific intiative targeting them(BIE). And while they are a problem, they aren't nearly as big of a threat.
- mesozoic 8y agoSo antifa is next right?
- Shekelberg 8y agoWhy "white nationalist" specifically? Is Facebook's policy that nationalism is okay for everyone except whites? What about pro-Israel content (Jewish nationalism)? Countless Palestinians have been murdered or displaced for that cause. Obviously this is not a principled stance against "hate speech", it's just another example of a powerful organization run by Jews using it's power to attack whites.
- oh_sigh 8y agoWhy not just any race-based nationalism? It seems weird that facebook would ban white nationalism but black nationalism can go on.
- mesozoic 8y agoDoes this mean that they implicitly support any hate groups that they aren't specifically banning? Antifa, IRA, Isis and the like?
- ConceptJunkie 8y agoI think it's fine if Facebook wants to ban white nationalist content, however I don't trust their judgement with respect to deciding what is "white nationalist" content or not, because as we've seen the MSM will label anything that it doesn't like as racist, and Facebook definitely falls in with this crowd, and this could be just an excuse to block things they don't want because it goes against their political agenda, and they can use "but muh white nationalism" as an excuse.
- hannasanarion 8y agoBlame the white nationalists for deliberately trying to turn everything into a dogwhistle, with stuff like "Operation O-KKK" where they flooded social media with fake outrage at nonexistent people saying that (HN doesn't support emoji, ok symbol should go here) is racist, thereby turning the it into a racist symbol through the medium of trolling. Nazis around the world now use it to identify themselves while calling it """ironic""" to anyone who asks. Turning benign stuff racist is how modern racists thrive and spread their ideas, and pretending they don't exist doesn't help.
- contrarian1000 8y agoWhen are they going to ban Wakanda? Black Nationalism? Chinese Nationalism? Indian Nationalism? They aren't because "anti white nationlist" is code for anti-white. People are being attacked for having tshirts that say "Its OK to be white". How about applying rules evenly for everyone instead of pushing a certain political agenda?
- C14L 8y agoI don't believe Facebook. This is just a publicity move. If they really wanted to combat the hatred they cause, then they should change their algorithm and stop putting stories on top that cause the most emotional reactions (and clicks in consequence).
- malloreon 8y agoZero credit for deciding white hate is bad 15 years after your company's founding.
- AgentME 8y agoBetter late than never. A lot of commenters seem to be giving them negative credit for this outcome, and a number of people who claim to want racist content gone are also giving them negative or zero credit. As someone that wants racist content gone, this seems like a perverse state of affairs. No wonder they allowed it for so long given this.
- malloreon 8y agoThen facebook should name and fire every single person who fought this long to keep racism prosperous on facebook. facebook is not a monolith, it is a collection of people making evil decisions every single day. When it takes them 15 years to overturn just one of their evil decisions, there still should be some penalty for it.
- AgentME 8y agoI was mainly talking about outsiders who Facebook presumably tries to please, like commenters in this thread. It could be that any number of Facebook employees personally wanted to get rid of racist content, but Facebook thought that would be an extremely unpopular decision. Assuming the sentiment across this entire HN thread isn't unique to HN, I can see why they might have thought this would be an unpopular decision and maybe a bit of why they took so long to make it. I'm very glad they decided to do it.
- jh0486 8y agoFacebook, Instagram, Twitter, Youtube, etc.. are user-generated content publishers. They have the right to refuse whatever content they feel like. This is the same as a newspaper refusing to publish an op-ed they don't agree with.
- drablyechoes 8y agoWhen white nationalists (neo-nazis) come to power, the rights to free speech and religious expression would be the first things they eliminate. If we care at all about preserving the basic civil rights that form the foundation of a free democratic society, then we must strangle white nationalism in the cradle. These nazis cowardly hide behind the right to free speech, which they secretly detest. The fewer platforms they have to disseminate their hate speech and propaganda, the better off we are as a society. The concept of a free and open debate in the "marketplace of ideas" does not imply all ideas are equally valid or require that we do not exclude dangerous ideology from the being part of legitimate discourse. We are marching straight toward a second holocaust and protecting the free speech of nazis only accelerates the pace.
- rufus_2 8y agoCensoring them confirms their narrative and only makes young white men who've been exposed to their rhetoric pay closer attention.
- DigiMortal 8y agoCensorship is evil, facebook sucks, whats new
- angel_j 8y agoBetter ban patriotism too.
- ghani 8y agoNo! That is a terrible thing.
- toomim 8y ago> Going forward, while people will still be able to demonstrate pride in their ethnic heritage, we will not tolerate praise or support for white nationalism and separatism. So you can praise and support your ethnic nationality, as long as you're not white.
- 2_listerine_pls 8y ago"Only white people can be racist because they got the best color. The unfortunate need pride to feel good about themselves so we are keeping them"
- nepeckman 8y agoWhite is not an ethnic nationality. A person from Ireland has no ethnic or national ties to a person from Italy. The fact that the citizens of those two countries were not considered "white" 100 years ago demonstrates the invalidity of "white" as an ethnic or national group.
- patagonian 8y ago> White is not an ethnic nationality This is not true for all intents and purposes, and it's bizarre to mention nationality in a thread about white nationalism. "Ethnicity" refers to both fine-grained and broader ethnic identification. Being black is absolutely an ethnicity, while being Yoruba is too. By looking at an White American's DNA profile, one can predict their ethnic identificationwith 98% accuracy.Historically thiss was also the case, it's just that Christianity was the standardmarker for being European/white. Even if that weren't true, being white is still an ethnic group as people perceive it today > A person from Ireland has no ethnic or national ties to a person from Italy They do, it's called being ethnically European. The Irish and Italians share a genetic similarity, historical, religious, cultural, and linguistic affinity. Consider how much closer to Algeria Italy is, yet Algerians and Italians share none of these similarities and gues what... Algerians aren't white. > The fact that the citizens of those two countries were not considered "white" 100 years ago demonstrates the invalidity of "white" as an ethnic or national group. This is completely and demostrably untrue. The U.S. Naturalisation Act of 1790 and the following acts limited U.S. immigration to "whites of good character". In this period, more immigrants came from Ireland and Italy combined than nearly anywhere else.Ben Franklin even specifically referred to Irish as white. Your comment demonstrates the invalidity of your knowledge of this topic to be honest
- nonazis 8y agogo to gab if you wanna hang with other nazis, no platforms for white supremacy.
- ghobs91 8y agoFar right: private businesses such as bakeries should be allowed to refuse service to whoever they want! Also the far right: why is Facebook censoring my ability to spread hate speech! I'm oversimplifying it, but the hypocrisy and lack of self-awareness is astounding.
- gberger 8y agoThis is a strawman. Who actually says both these things?
- MockObject 8y agoSeems no more hypocritical and self-awareness-lacking than arguing that Facebook has the right to turn away white nationalists, but that a bakery must serve all the cakes. Either way, it's conceptual gerrymandering to carefully carve out a wiggly boundary that -- strictly by coincidence! -- protects their own side and restrains the other side.
- ghobs91 8y agoYou're equating someone asking for a cake for their same-sex marriage to hate speech? Are you kidding?
- MockObject 8y agoNo, I'm equating one business refusing a customer to another business refusing a customer. That is how analogies work.
- wozer 8y agoThis seems very America-centric. I wonder what it means for the rest of the world. I guess a Finnish person living in Finland can now no longer use Facebook to express a wish that the demographics of his home country stay unchanged?
- andrewmcwatters 8y agoFrom the modern, multiracial American perspective, yes that would be xenophobic.
- duality 8y ago"I guess a Finnish person living in Finland can now no longer use Facebook to express a wish that the demographics of his home country stay unchanged?" Your guess is probably correct.
- Dowwie 8y agoWhat would happen if Facebook introduced friction during sharing, making the decision to share more salient? For instance, click "share" and get prompted with questions about whether the source is trustworthy and whether you personally would accept responsibility if the content were misleading or misinforming, etc.
- sabujp 8y agoGood, they try to hide behind the 1st amendment but there's only one endgame that they're after, and we know how that turned out.
- AndyMcConachie 8y agoNot sure how I feel about this, but I do think it would be interesting to see a white supremacist challenge this in court.
- fullshark 8y agoHow does the ban work? The user is banned? The content is shadowbanned? What exactly are they doing? I can't figure it out from the message.
- otabdeveloper2 8y agoThought experiment for ya: > Facebook to ban homosexual hookup content How about that, eh? Funny how a simple change of political platform will U-turn your support of so-called 'free speech'!
- darkwizard42 8y agoThere is a relatively far line from 'free speech' to 'free speech that actively encourages discrimination, harm of others, or infringing on others rights' As a private platform, Facebook is free to curb the topic you have suggested, in the same way you are free to avoid said private platform.
- qntty 8y agoPresumably people who support this policy wouldn't consider it a bolstering of free speech, whether it's justified or not.
- alexmingoia 8y agoThe great thing about the Internet is that anyone can publish a website and any other Internet user can access it. The web is pleasant over here in the blogosphere. People write what they want, and readers read what they want. There’s no clamor about ads, algorithms, and censorship. Try it sometime!
- qwerty456127 8y agoWhy just white? I've read asian nationalism (incl. in US) happens to be nasty too. E.g. an asian-american girl dated a white boy and had to face lots of ridiculous hate speech in Facebook.
- cowwithbeef 8y agoI am surprised their PR team didn't advise them to use the neutral term "ethno-nationalist."
- shiado 8y ago.
- dragonwriter 8y ago[For context, the post above, before all of its content was edited out, called for “enforcing” CDA Section 230 against tech firms by making them liable as publishers for user content] You aren't calling for 230 to be enforced, you are calling for it to be abolished. Which is already happening one step at a time (SESTA/FOSTA), each of which radically accelerates self-censorship. Actually, I suspect a lot of the self-censorship that happens that isn't connected to legal changes but is connected to popular mood is to avoid political pressure for new limits on the 230 safe harbor which would force even more drastic self censorship.
- cynoclast 8y agoI can't believe people are applauding this. The whole "you can go make your own platform, facebook/google/twitter/youtube doesn't owe you anything" excuse is bullshit. Look at what happened when people DID try to make their own platform with Gab. They were DDOSed and people uploaded child porn and then reported it to try to get the whole site shut down to prevent people who were silenced elsewhere from talking there too. They're behaving more like the nazis than the white nationalists! Cheering on authoritarian censorship of things you don't want to hear doesn't make you virtuous it makes you a coward. The solution to bad speech isn't censorship, it's better speech: First they came for the socialists, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a socialist. Then they came for the trade unionists, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a trade unionist. Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out— Because I was not a Jew. Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me. -Martin Niemöller
- aszantu 8y agothey could just use their algorithm to make unwanted content insignificant... This will not quench the problem with nationalists, it just drive them to other plattforms and they will become more radicalized because they only hear their own voices there.
- omegaworks 8y agoYour assumption being that Facebook presently serves as an effective platform for deradicalizing extremists. Do you have evidence backing that up? Because from what I've seen[1], Facebook has been serving the opposite purpose: showing people things that reinforce their beliefs and trigger outrage reactions for clicks. 1. https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/15/technology/myanmar-facebook-genocide.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/10/15/technology/myanmar-facebo...
- m23khan 8y agoas a person of color, I would be very grateful if facebook can also ban material offensive towards Whites as well as hate literature towards white -- and this should include translation of non-English messages/materials in long run to weed such things out.
- tomohawk 8y agoSo, who gets to decide what a "white nationalist" is? These guys? https://freebeacon.com/issues/soros-bankrolls-unverified-hate-crime-database-used-by-major-media-outlets/ https://freebeacon.com/issues/soros-bankrolls-unverified-hat...
- europsucks 8y agoBut what exactly is "white nationalist content"? If I say something positive about Trump, will it already get me banned? What if I disagree with something a PoC says? Of course FB as a private company is entitled to censor whatever they want. In a general sense, I don't really understand the need, as usually in social networks like Facebook people only see the stuff they want to see. There are lots of tools to facilitate your own filter bubble, and people use them. So the worry that "ideology x is spreading via Facebook" is somewhat unfounded in my opinion.
- normalperson 8y agowill they ban Black Nationalism as well?
- OpenBSD-supreme 8y agoIt's extremely unlikely, because: das raycis!
- piokoch 8y agoHmm, I don't even know what "white nationalist" mean. Nationalism is often confused with chauvinism. The difference is rather important. Nationalism is a natural and mostly positive attitude: a person lives at some place (country, city, village), surrounded by people with that person spends most of the time, with whom that person talks, trades. So it is natural to be more eager to help those people around than someone living on the other side of the globe. On the other hand, chauvinism is a negative attitude, this is misunderstood nationalism. The good example is the following. Let's say I have kids and my neighbour too. Obviously I want the best for my kids, so I take care of them, send them to a good school, so they have the best possible education and perspectives - this is "nationalism". It does not mean that I wish anything bad for my neighbour and his kids. Now, chauvinism means that I am going to hurt my neighbour's kids, since they are competition for mine, and this is obviously bad. So, coming back to the FB declaration, "white nationalist" does not make much sense. The colour of the skin is hardly a predictor of common interests. I assume FB means chauvinism, otherwise they will have to ban all international sport competitions news (funs are naturally nationalistic since they support national team), they will have to also ban all national holidays, including 4th July, as they are nationalistic by very nature.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> So, coming back to the FB declaration, "white nationalist" does not make much sense That's because you are trying to reason out what it might mean as if it were a simple combination of two words whose meaning should be transparent from the constituentsz rather than a name for adherents to the ideology named “white nationalism” which isn't “white” modifying “nationalism” but rather a construct with (very loosely; it was originally a bit of a PR term for those selling it) the same relationship to the idea of a (putative) “white nation” with specific traits that “nationalism” has to “nation”. But, you know, you don't have to guess about things like that, there are search engines and decent general references at hand any time you have access to the internet, so even if you didn't know the meaning, you could easily look it up and find out. [0] [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_nationalism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_nationalism
- b1r6 8y agoI despise these weird nationalists, but this is the final straw; I've deleted FB over this. :)
- piokoch 8y ago"Today we’re announcing a ban on praise, support and representation of white nationalism and separatism on Facebook and Instagram" First of all, why white nationalism, how about black or yellow nationalism, are they ok? Second thing, they will ban "separatism". Really? Are you FB guys really going to ban Kurds who want their own land, are you going to ban Palestinians who want their own land? If FB existed 30 years ago, would it ban anty-communistic opposition in central and eastern Europe which was fighting to get separated from Soviet Union? What the about Scots, what if they want to separate from UK? Will they be banned? Same with Catalans?
- KorematsuFred 8y ago"But over the past three months our conversations with members of civil society and academics who are experts in race relations around the world" Sorry I do not agree with this sort of shit. I have left facebook long back as a platform. I do not want some Phd in Gender Studies and Race relation to dictate what I can read and what I can not.
- OpenBSD-supreme 8y agoAgreed. What was once a movement for rights has become an industry of oppression determination (and guess what? It's based on a Marxism-like system of oppressor/oppressed classes!).
- patrickg_zill 8y agoWill Facebook ban Chinese nationalist, Black/Mexican/etc. nationalist accounts also? Or maybe Jewish nationalist content? If not, then why not?
- kacamak 8y agoWho decides what white nationalist content is? This is just another move towards wrongthink.
- tonymet 8y agoDoes anyone know what this means in practice?
- mamon 8y agoOk, what about black nationalist content? Asian nationalists, Jewish nationalists?
- cowwithbeef 8y agoT
- d_burfoot 8y agoI think this is bad news for Facebook, the tech industry, and America as a whole. This kind of activity is going to prompt an enormous backlash from the right. And the right-wingers aren't going to make fine distinctions between the good tech companies and the bad ones. Censorship may be a necessary evil, but if so, it must be done by duly elected or appointed government officials. FB and other tech platforms should build APIs that allow government officials to make the relevant decisions about when a piece of content is unacceptable. That is a principled and nonpartisan strategy that will allow the tech companies to focus on what they're good at - technology innovation - and avoid what they're bad at - politics and public relations.
- garbonicc 8y agoSo now facebook is explicitly editorializing content, are they now exempt from safe harbor provisions and legally responsible for illegal content published on the platform?
- pc2g4d 8y agoIf the views can't expressed, then they can't be refuted either. Banning this sort of content from Facebook will only foster a sense of persecution in white nationalists, which will likely strengthen their movement overall, while isolating them further from contrary opinions. John Stuart Mill's "On Liberty" is essential reading for those who wish to silence speech they find offensive, especially corporations which may or may not have the right to regulate content on their all-but-universal, essential-to-modern-life platforms. In the meantime we should all ask ourselves how we can move forward to a world where no single Facebook-like entity has so much say over the ability of Americans to freely assemble, speak, and publish in the modern world.
- beat 8y agoI don't buy the "essential to modern life" part. I've quit FB cold turkey, because I concluded that it was making my life worse. And I seem so far to be happier for it, and to have lost very little.
- root_axis 8y agoI don't see what's so complicated about it. Facebook will set some standards and they will meter out moderation action as they feel is necessary. Will it be selectively applied in some cases? Yes. Will they get it wrong sometimes? Yes. So what? People who don't like Facebook's approach to moderation can quit, protest or otherwise boycott Facebook. This is the same problem of moderation that has always existed in online communities, the only difference between today and the past is that today the masses feel like they are entitled to use these platforms.
- gfodor 8y agothe other difference today is that 'the masses' used to mean ~millions of Internet-connected people staring at screens on their desks, now it means the whole damned planet, at all times. as these networks have grown to global scale we need to assess them for what they are, not for abstractions that may be less relevant now that these systems represent unprecedented "public squares"
- root_axis 8y ago> millions of Internet-connected people staring at screens on their desks, now it means the whole damned planet, at all times. So what? Those people use Facebook because they like to do so. If you feel like Facebook treats you unfairly then stop using it. It is permissible to communicate with people that use Facebook even if you don't use it. If you fundamentally disagree with the way Facebook operates then stop using it. Just stop using it.
- gfodor 8y agoI deactivated my account years ago. My point wasn't about me, but about the fact that these platforms are intertwined enough into society they are blurring the lines between optional service customers can switch off of, and global-scale utilities that are necessary to operate in society.
- root_axis 8y ago
- 089723645897236 8y agoNothing wrong with deplatforming.
- IhateRenoSaveMe 8y agowell no one held a gun to your head and made you login to Facebook. All censorship is wrong and the reason this country has become a spoiled crybaby filled cesspool of offended snowflakes. The supreme court has also ruled that there is no such thing as hate speech! Get over someone else's words you shallow bitch baby!
- SovietDissident 8y agoYes, FB is a private company and all that. But they have clearly been censoring speech and cannot be protected by common carrier rules, as they are a publisher. This change of designation, of course, would be a significant financial blow, once they started losing lawsuits. But you can bet that if one considers their gov't influence and status as a money-spigot for leftist politicians, they have no fear of this actually happening. It's only the little people who have to worry about running afoul of the law---not HRC and not FB. Welcome to the late Roman Empire.
- IhateRenoSaveMe 8y agoAll censorship is bad! The supreme court has ruled that there is no such thing as hate speech. Stop letting someone else's words ruin your life...shallow weak minded snowflakes. What happened to "sticks & stones may break my bones but words will never hurt me?" Just because you are offended does not mean anything. Who cares if you get offended its a personal thing, keep it to yourself and stop crying! And the word "offended" is definitely a vaginal word, no self respecting man would ever admit to being offended!
- ivanstame 8y agoFuck you Facebook!
- Simon_says 8y agoMy router bans Facebook content.
- roenxi 8y agoThey've left a lot of room for the details to be stupid. 1) In particular, what about black nationalists, Chinese nationalists, etc, etc? 2) One of their main justifications is "conversations with members of civil society and academics". It seems unlikely that these conversations are with politically neutral groups, particularly since academics focused on race relations tend to self select for slightly off-beat views of the world. Also, to poke touchy subject, white nationalism includes some much milder ideas than white supremacy does like 'white people should maintain their majority in majority-white countries'. A reasonable and rational person could hold that view after reviewing what happens to minorities in any country. Look at the Jews in Germany or the white farmers in Zimbabwe. Whites don't have a magical pass to be free from racial discrimination and ethnic cleansing. Whites should be allowed to organise around race like everyone else, as long as they keep it civil and nonviolent. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_nationalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White_nationalism
- beat 8y agoAnd when Richard Spencer asks if we should maybe just send every black person to Africa and create an all-white America, he's being civil and nonviolent. Which is the problem.
- antt 8y agoWhen I say that we should send every non Indian person back to where they came from and create an all Indian North America I'm also being civil and nonviolent. Yet I don't see facebook banning that type of speech.
- daveheq 8y agoWhat if they end up banning dissent material that merely looks like white nationalist material because of popular mischaracterizing narratives by fear-mongering clickbait newsfeeds?
- Teknoman117 8y ago> Going forward, while people will still be able to demonstrate pride in their ethnic heritage, we will not tolerate praise or support for white nationalism and separatism. Can anyone elaborate on this? Speaking as one of them, I'd hazard to say that the majority of 'white people' in the United States are so far distant from their 'ethnic heritage' that we'd just define it as 'American'. Mexican-Americans celebrate their Mexican heritage, Japanese-Americans celebrate their Japanese heritage, etc. What does your average 'white person' celebrate? We don't know a heck of a lot about my mom's side other than that her father is French Canadian and her mother is Polish American. Dad's side has been here since the 17th century (according to my grandmother anyways).
- undersuit 8y ago>What does your average 'white person' celebrate? Holidays they imported from their European past. Saint Patrick's Day isn't originally a drinking holiday, it's a Christian religious holiday. My friend with Serbian ancestry celebrates 'Serbian Christmas' or Julian Orthodox Christmas. Lots and lots of Christianity.
- golemiprague 8y agoWhy only white nationalist? Why not black nationalist? or Japanese nationalist? or Chinese nationalist? Facebook is a global company after all, if an African country says that they don't want white immigration will they keep this opinion up or is it just applied to whites in America?. What about other unsavoury opinions from the left side? Why white nationalist is any different to no borders propaganda? Aren't they both dangerous to people in America?
- gramstrong 8y agoI don't think that private censorship is necessarily a problem, but I do think that corporations having the authority to exercise what is a pretty effective form of muting is a problem. This is of course due to the size and prevalence of Facebook as a platform. I don't think the solution (or best solution, at least) is to break up the tech giants as Elizabeth Warren would suggest. I would instead prefer to see some form of socialized media platforms that take the market question out of the equation (does white supremacy content hurt Facebook more than removing it would?). This is of course, because, the market is not always right (even though in this case I would make a strong argument that it is). I'm not sure what the best social media model for such a platform would be -- preferably something mostly non-anonymous like Facebook, but self-moderated (within the bounds of the law) like Reddit used to be.
- egao1980 8y agoThis is clear discrimination. As if people with different shades of skin being nationalists are nicer than white nationalists. Is it 1984 already or we still have some time?
- dragonwriter 8y ago> This is clear discrimination Every decision is discrimination. > As if people with different shades of skin being nationalists are nicer than white nationalists. A “white nationalist” isn't “a nationalist with white skin” but “an adherent to the ideology of white nationalism”. You can be a white-skinned nationalist and not be a white nationalist. > Is it 1984 already or we still have some time? 1984 didn't feature discrimination against either white nationalists or white-skinned nationalists, so it seems unrelated to your complaint.
- egao1980 8y agoWhite nationalists = nationalists that think that white people are better than other, but we have guys from ICGJC and other afrosupremacist groups, etc. Why not ban them all? 1984 is mentioned as a reference to the dystopian world of propaganda and Facebook / Google are quickly turning into corporate Ministry of Truth.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> White nationalists = nationalists that think that white people are better than other No, white nationalism is not “nationalism” + “white preference”. It's closer to nationalism around a concept of a white nation. > but we have guys from ICGJC and other afrosupremacist groups, etc. Why not ban them all? Because we don't see scores of bodies piled up motivated by the message of those groups.
- butthurt2347 8y ago> Because we don't see scores of bodies piled up motivated by the message of those groups. You leave Islam out of this.
- henvic 8y agoAs an anarcho-capitalist, I feel very happy that Facebook is banning nationalist content. They should have done it ages ago. However, banning all separatists? Well. Not all separatists are created equally. Sometimes it is a question of getting out of a union for the sake of reducing the state, and this is in no way vile. Quite the opposite.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- Causality1 8y ago"Facebook to pretend they're banning white nationalist content by adding a couple of keywords to a blacklist." They will put zero real effort into this because they put zero effort into everything.
- dexx 8y agoI support free speech (in the truest sense). If Facebook wasn't a platform so many use then I might support there censorship as creating a space for a unique kind of dialogue. Just like hacker news has certain rules that help shape this unique community. But since there as big as they are, and since there not the only ones censoring this kind of content. There not just creating a unique space, there making it extremely difficult if not impossible in some cases, for this perspective to be voiced at all. And that is damaging to free speech.
- CarlSchmitt 8y agoDo we consider Jews white? Is Zionism allowed?
- btilly 8y agoIn principle, who could be opposed? In practice, how will this actually work out? True story. I have a friend who got a temporary ban from Facebook (I think 90 days?) for commenting on a story about a Texas billionaire paying to hunt endangered animals, "How much would it cost to hunt Texas billionaires?" That was considered a violation of their anti-bullying stance. Knowing her, it wasn't. It was sarcasm. Moving on to this policy, I'm happy to see neonazis and the KKK have a hard time. But there are people in the UK and EU who would see Brexit as being a separatist cause motivated by racial animosity. Will we see discussion of a future such measure banned by Facebook on such grounds? And remaining banned even for people who support it on economic grounds because they think that having to follow EU policies on GDPR, copyright, and so on will be a net negative for the UK? Facebook is going to have some difficult conversations ahead. And the more of these lines that they draw, the more difficult boundary cases they will run into.
- Veraticus 8y agoBecause Facebook can misapply its policies does not mean it should have no policies, it merely means it should implement them better. Obviously there are other kinds of content that Facebook could ban, but merely because those things exist doesn't mean this shouldn't also be banned.
- KerryJones 8y ago"it merely means it should implement them better" this is the theory of every government committee, ever. In practice, generally, _it doesn't happen_. I believe private companies are usually better, but still highly dependant on size and a number of other factors. I definitely don't have faith that FB will wield this well, and the worse part is it will probably pretty hard to find out from the silenced parties when they f!@# up until much later.
- SlowRobotAhead 8y agoNo, it means that while you can cheer this decision today, how do you know it won’t be used against you in the future? Or if the decision maker sensed your intentions or sarcasm or if you don’t beleive your speech to be hateful but someone else does. The whole point of defending speech you don’t agree with is it promises that arbitrary rules won’t be used when YOUR speech runs afoul or someone else’s feelings. Let me phrase it to you like this... if Mark Zuckerburg who you may generally agree with leaves Facebook and is replaced by let’s say Donald Trump and his assistant Mike Pence; do you still think it should be Facebook as a service provider’s policy to gauge what offensive speech is? Maybe it’s not Facebook’s job to ban legal things you personally don’t agree with.
- dbg31415 8y agoCool, morality determined by ad revenue opportunities. What could go wrong? Clearly nobody is going to shed any tears over Nazis... but is it wrong to support Palestinian claims to Jerusalem? Where's the line? I don't like this move since I feel it will just push people into places where we can't determine real identification, should that be needed after a crime. I don't like this move because I don't, fundamentally, think we should all have to agree with Zuck to have a voice online. I don't like this move because it's reactionary, and there's no consistent philosophy behind why these groups would be banned but not others. Just feels skeezy to censor people, no matter how skeezy those people are.
- iliketosleep 8y agoIn practice, it's going to be an arbitrary mess. They draw a series of vaguely defined lines across highly nuanced issues, make their fancy press release, and then send it off to implemented by underpaid and undertrained workers (in 3rd world sweatshops last time I checked).
- Macross8299 8y ago>3rd world sweatshops Jeez man, Arizona isn't that bad, I wouldn't call it third world [1] Jokes aside, you are correct that Facebook does have lots of third-party contractors that do moderation located in underdeveloped countries and Facebook seems to exploit a lot of their contractor labor, regardless of where that labor is located. [1]: https://www.theverge.com/2019/2/25/18229714/cognizant-facebook-content-moderator-interviews-trauma-working-conditions-arizona https://www.theverge.com/2019/2/25/18229714/cognizant-facebo...
- sunshinelackof 8y agoGetting caught up in the freedom of speech question is folly. In context it reads as a not-so subtle dismissal of racism. I’m not even questioning the right to free speech. But when the first response to platforms removing white nationalist content is about “just wanting to have a conversation,” people of colour tune out. Freedom of speech is a valid concern, but I think in this instance it belongs further back in the sprint queue. In regard to comments concerning why it only addresses white-nationalism, understand that these statements are made in the context of North America’s on-going flirtations with white nationalism going back 300 years. It’s not an easy pill to swallow and speaks little about individuals regardless of colour.
- hokobomo 8y ago> Facebook to ban white nationalist content This is _literally_ racist
- lazyjones 8y agoIf they ban it like they claim to ban ISIS content or respect our privacy (Zuck's "privacy first" vision), nobody needs to worry.
- duado 8y agoAnd the slippery slope begins. I am not a white nationalist (I’m not even white) but I think that recent immigration trends in Europe are illustrative and that we should avoid a similar situation occurring in the United States. Am I now a Nazi?
- JPKab 8y agoMy question is this: Are they also going to ban other ethno nationalist movements? Last I checked, the Hebrew Israelites (a black nationalist and anti semitic group) are on FB. They believe that the people who currently identify as Jews are evil impostors.
- dragonwriter 8y agoAnd the last time there was a “Hebrew Israelite”-motivated mass killing was... when, exactly?
- kortilla 8y agoIrrelevant? Violent hate speech doesn’t have to result in a mass killing before you ban it.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> Violent hate speech doesn’t have to result in a mass killing before you ban it. I would say that, where there is debate over the level of danger and need to take action to restrain hate speech, whether or not that particular kind of hate speech is motivating violent acts and on what scale is a quite legitimate factor to consider.
- chrischen 8y agoDunno about that one but the last anti-Jewish mass killing wasn't that long ago.
- dragonwriter 8y ago> the last anti-Jewish mass killing wasn't that long ago. Indeed. And it was motivated by white nationalism, not the Hebrew Israelite movement, so it's kind of a weird thing to bring up if you are trying to make the case that deplatforming the latter has as strong a case as the former.
- 8y ago
- EGreg 8y agoWhat about other nationalist or bigoted content? Like the new Black Panther Party (Black Nationalists) or Louis Farrakhan’s comments about Jews?
- qwsxyh 8y agoVery glad to see everyone here is defending white nationalists. Exactly the kind of content I expected to see on this website First they came for the Nazis. And I did not speak up because I was not a Nazi. Then they came for the pedophiles. And I did not speak up because I was not a pedophile. Then they didn't come for me, because I'm not morally reprehensible, and life was good.
- Amemaster 8y agoAre you trying to change your nationality ? do you need work papers ? do you want to travel ? do you need papers you cant have ?if yes , then you are in the right place at the right time We are an independent group of specialized IT professionals and data base technicians who are specialized in the production of Real and Novelty quality documents such as passports,drivers license,id cards,stamps,visas,diplomas of very high quality and other products for all countries: USA, Australia,UK, Belgium, Brazil, Canada, Italian, Finland, France, Germany, Israel, Mexico, Netherlands, South Africa, Spain, Switzerland, . This list is not full.contact General ,To get the additional information and place the order, BEST COUNTERFEIT EURO,POUNDS & DOLLAR NOTES. Key words Canada Cards United States Cards Student Cards International Cards Private Cards Adoption Certificates Baptism Certificates Birth Certificates Death Certificates Divorce Certificates Marriage Certificates Custom Certificates High School Diplomas G.E.D. Diplomas Home School Diplomas College Degrees University Degrees Trade Skill Certificates Social Security Validate SSN Number Driver License Search Spy Products Voice Changers Listening Devices Invisible Ink DMV Record Inquiry Background Check Investigate Anyone Skype : Dr.koffi hassan WASHINGTON TIMES EXECUTIVE COMITTEE MEMBER BRITISH AFRICAN LEAGUE OF NATIONS SECRETARIAT WHATSAPP:+237694717781
- la6470 8y agoThey should ban ALL kind of hate speech not just white ones.
- throwit04 8y agoThis is racist. What about other forms of nationalist content? Nope. Just that by white people. Chomsky's reversal test: Would it be racist to ban black nationalist content? If the answer is yes, then it is also racist to ban white nationalist content. Don't be racist, facebook. Ban all nationalist content.
- tmcw 8y agoNot everyone on the orange website is a ‘free speech absolutist’, or foolishly conflates freedom of speech with platform access. Good on them for finally cracking down on bad ideas.
- GreaterFool 8y agoWhat exactly is "white nationalism"?
- unimpressive 8y ago"Let’s go all the way back to 1996 and talk about Section 230. I think historians are completely in agreement that this is the law that made the internet what it is today. ---- We thought it was going to be helpful. We never realized it was going to be the linchpin to generating investment in social media. We envisioned that the law would be both a sword and a shield. A shield so that you could have this opportunity, for particularly small and enterprising operations to secure capital, and then a sword [by allowing them to moderate without facing liability over the practice], which said you’ve got to police your platforms. And what was clear during the 2016 election and the succeeding events surrounding Facebook, is that technology companies used one part of what we envisioned, the shield, but really sat on their hands with respect to the sword, and wouldn’t police their platforms." - Ron Wyden on Section 230 https://www.theverge.com/2018/7/24/17606974/oregon-senator-ron-wyden-interview-internet-section-230-net-neutrality https://www.theverge.com/2018/7/24/17606974/oregon-senator-r... I see a lot of people in this thread expressing the view that by moderating their content Facebook is becoming responsible for it. To the extent that's true under the law, it's not necessarily a great idea. Certainly the intent from a lawmaking perspective when some of the underlying framework was written is that this wouldn't be the case. You could moderate and remove bad actors from your platform without fearing legal persecution for it.
- seventytwo 8y agoGOOD. Now do anti-vaxxers and flat earthers.
- ardy42 8y ago> Our efforts to combat hate don’t stop here. As part of today’s announcement, we’ll also start connecting people who search for terms associated with white supremacy to resources focused on helping people leave behind hate groups. People searching for these terms will be directed to Life After Hate, an organization founded by former violent extremists that provides crisis intervention, education, support groups and outreach. I wonder if they can re-purpose this technology to re-direct people who post content critical of Facebook and social media to pro-Facebook propaganda.
- Lidador 8y agoHow about blue, red, green, black, yellow or purple nationalist content?
- nyxxie 8y agoThis ethnocentric approach to censorship is terrifying. Somewhere in Facebook is a small group of people who have the hubris to say they can decide on what’s right and what’s wrong, and are enforcing these views on some 1/9th of the world’s population. With outright banning white nationalism, they’re essentially shown us that they’re willing to play ideological kingmaker if anything enters the current news cycle that is viewed as evil. How are people ok with this? Whatever your opinions are on the subject matter that was banned today are, are you honestly ok with the idea that people are now deciding what billions are allowed to see in broad strokes? History is filled with examples of controversial viewpoints being viewed as societal cancer only to be later accepted in some form as sane. Are we really going to now decide that we’ve reached final evolution and can now start judging wrongthink? I view this as part of an alarming trend of people simply getting tired of seeing people they disagree with continue to exist and wishing they and their speech were just gone. It terrifies me that this is starting to get political will and we’re shifting to censorship as a solution.
- scarlac 8y ago> With outright banning white nationalism, they’re essentially shown us that they’re willing to play ideological kingmaker if anything enters the current news cycle that is viewed as evil. There have been doing this since they launched. You could not post semi-nudity even for educational purposes. Remember the breast-cancer debacle? You couldn't post anything that incites violence. The list is fairly long and is often referred to as their "Community Guidelines". Twitter has rules. Reddit has rules. Most online communities do in fact have rules of some sort and in the end it's up to humans to patrol it.
- hackerbabz 8y agoIf white nationalism is 'later accepted as sane', I don't want to be alive in that world. But chances are, I won't have a choice in the matter.
- peterhadlaw 8y agoI just don't get why people can't be adults and just decide what conservations they do or do not want to participate in. Instead of the Masters of Universe building tools to more easily manage and filter desired conversations, they enforce the "views of the anointed" at every turn.
- vixen99 8y agoSome of the people you won't be hearing from on FB are here. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_X_nationalist_organizations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_X_nationalist_organiza... where X = white.
- vixen99 8y agoSome of the people you won't be hearing from on FB are here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_X_nationalist_organizations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_X_nationalist_organiza... where X = white.
- smarri 8y agoI reduced my chance of seeing toxic content by deleting Facebook.
- walkthrow 8y agoThis whole idea of "racism" is a pile of garbage sold to gullible people by corporations and governments whose motivations for discouraging "racism" and "white nationalism" and so on are things like increasing profits and decreasing costs. They couldn't care about people from other countries for any other reason. Most of the people making the decisions at these companies and governments live in areas that are the whitest areas in the country. All facebook is doing is using its power to try to silence people who get in the road of their own profit margins and political goals. This is really a war. The Christchurch killer specifically said he wanted this censorship to happen after he committed his killings and now they are happening. Sites like 4chan are now blocked in Australia and New Zealand. Silicon Valley is removing everything that they disagree with. 1984 has finally arrived. The problem is that the backlash will probably be extreme and violent, just as the Christchurch killer wanted. Considering most countries around the world such as China and India are in actual practice ethnically nationalists, why aren't facebook banning them? You can look at the specific policies of China, Japan, etc, and see ethnic nationalism in actual practice. Are they banning all Chinese and Japanese government accounts from Facebook? Of course not.
- tu7001 8y agoAnybody expected freedom of speech in Facebook?
- ptah 8y agointeresting 180 degree turn for them. will they also stop banning people for calling out nazis?
- pqs 8y agoThe major problem I see here is why making a specific policy for a specific group of radicals? This problem could be tackled with the generic rules already in place, such as "it is forbidden on Facebook to promote violence". There are many violent chauvinisms in the world that are not white, and they should be treated equally.
- cannedslime 8y agoBut its okay to be a south african black nationalist. Its OK to pose with decapitated heads if you are of arabic descent, but its not okay to be white apparently.
- pqs 8y agoThat's exactly the point. In Africa, India, South-East Asia, and other places there is a lot of violent racism and nationalism going on.
- cannedslime 8y agoWhen you ban groups with relatively harmless names such as "Its OK to be white" I think you just end up giving people an eye opener... Its NOT OK to be white? I guess that makes it easier for Caucasians to decide their political affiliation... I mean just search for terms like "kill white people" "Kill whitey" etc. There is plenty of people glorifying white South Africans getting slaughtered in their bedrooms on facebook. But I guess thats OK, because fuck dey white man am i rite?
- zerogvt 8y agoRegardless of anyone's political affiliation and/or fear or trust in moderation, FB is a company operating a private service. Private as opposed to general elections where you and I have a constitutional right to participate. FB service is FB's home not our collective. So, I don't get why their new rule (long overdue IMHO especially after the NZ shootings) is a cause of concern, criticism or outrage. I should also remind you that similar (equally sane IMHO) bylaws apply in the current forum - at least from what I've seen as long as I'm here.
- Pimpus 8y agoHave you tried reading more of the discourse before proclaiming to the world you don't understand it.? Or did you skip that step.
- cannedslime 8y agoI just realized that facebook have deleted most generation identity pages. Im not affiliated with GI, but afaik they have ONLY done peaceful protests and they aren't even white nationalists... What the hell, this is beyond dystopian.
- messo 8y agoThe direction that Facebook and Twitter is moving in is likely to provide a decent boost to smaller but federated social media like Mastodon, PixelFed, Pleroma etc. The corporate-owned and "one-size-fits-all" media seems to come apart at the seams as it struggles to balance an impossible array of different concerns across countless communities and cultures.
- featherrust 8y agoGross. About time to replace facebook.
- tjpnz 8y agoI don't think anyone with leftist or conservative views (at least how we define them today) would have it in them to murder 50 innocents in a mosque. I don't see the slippery slope applying here either - the views held by white supremacists haven't exactly evolved over the years .
- baud147258 8y agoI'd hope they would also ban antifa/black block content too. Those assholes are trashing the city where I live every weekend for months
- pmarreck 8y agoWhite racists used free-speech-limiting laws against Martin Luther King, Jr. You start limiting free speech, that's going to cut both ways, eventually. I've had comments on Facebook get auto-censored simply by discussing racism while trying to combat it. Talk about shooting yourself in the foot!
- djanogo 8y agoAs a brown person this pisses me off, liberals keep pushing for these social justice rules on the platforms to silence content they find offending. If your argument is that "they don't have right to access the platform", you are acting ignorant when you know there are only handful of platforms on internet. The next step would be blocking DNS registrations of websites whose content you don't agree with, oh wait there is entire country which does this and you disagree with that country's rules too.
- mike10010100 8y ago> you are acting ignorant when you know there are only handful of platforms on internet. Your continued participation in said platforms ensures that they will remain the "only" platforms on the internet. There is absolutely nothing guaranteeing you a right to have a private entity host your information, especially when you're paying absolutely nothing for them to do so. > The next step would be blocking DNS registrations of websites whose content you don't agree with Slippery slope fallacy incoming!
- jakeogh 8y agoYou do realize calling slippery slope a fallacy does not mean it's something you should ignore... right? Incrementalism is -by far- the most common technique used to implement totalitarianism.
- mike10010100 8y agoBlocking access to information via DNS blocks is an entirely different concept than private entities not wishing to host extremist content on their private platforms.
- jakeogh 8y agoSounds like a slippery slope.
- 8y ago
- rurban 8y agoThey'll have big problems in many Asian countries then, where patriotic and racist nationalistic extremism is much more widespread. Think of India, China, Japan or Korea. Hindi nationalism is not much different from "white" nationalism and racism, mostly even worse. Will they block 50% of their user base there? How to draw a line?