33 ms·
Ask HN: What tech were you convinced would take the world by storm but didn't?
- tlrobinson 9y agoThe converse is possibly even more interesting: what tech were you convinced would fail but took the world by storm?
- CryoLogic 9y agoSnapchat. But than again if we look at their finances (and stock), they have always been in the red and are resorting to selling glasses and hotdog costumes now (huge losses). So maybe they aren't that successful after all.
- thatgerhard 9y agosnapchat's biggest problem is the interface, it's extremely hard to use. I think the plan was to make it complicated so that older people don't get into it, turns out nobody wants to struggle using a selfie app
- Double_a_92 9y agoI think that's on purpose. So friends have to show you the app first... It kinda creates a "lock-in" effect, like "I already bothered to learn this with my friends, why change now?"
- nemothekid 9y ago>turns out nobody wants to struggle using a selfie app Tons of people use the app. The interface is central to its virality. Snap's growth wasn't a problem until Facebook did everything they could to clone it. Snaps failing because everyone is starting to realize that if you aren't GOOG or FB, you aren't worth spending $$$ on. Just the other day I saw an "OfferUp" ad on Snap that looked like a 90s banner ad. I can't tell if Snap went full self serve or if they are struggling to find people to buy on their platform. And who would after advertisers have been spoiled by FB's demographic data and GOOG's intent data? Edit: I feel like I spend a lot of time defending snapchat when I hardly use the app.
- thatgerhard 9y agoIMHO even if facebook cloned all the functionality, if people found snapchat easier to use they wouldn't have jumped ship the moment it became an option.
- Al-Khwarizmi 9y agoYes, that one totally got me as well... An app whose only novel idea is that the messages and photos you send delete themselves after some time, except for the fact that once they're in your friend's phone, they can of course take a screencap, or just have an app installed to store them... so the whole idea is based on cluelessness about basic security... and yet, there it is.
- iEchoic 9y agoIt's not based on cluelessness, people are aware that there are ways to circumvent the screenshot notification. The vast majority of people don't install third-party apps to save their friends' snaps, so content you share on Snapchat is still drastically less likely to be on someone's phone forever than if you were to send it some other way.
- BronSteeDiam 9y agoI was never about security. They use FOMO to create a daily habit. When you post, people see it and react quickly, which further strengthens the addiction.
- ckarmann 9y agoTwitter
- kobeya 9y agoIt's like Facebook, but without pictures, friends, or events! Just status updates. Oh, and they're limited to 140 characters. It's going to be awesome. /s
- sincerely 9y agoturns out restrictions can breed creativity :)
- christophilus 9y agoYeah. All of the tech listed here, but this one especially. When I first heard about it, I thought it was spectacularly stupid.
- aspett 9y agoReact. Who would've known people would come to like JSX? I used to think it was an abomination.. now it's great.
- swyx 9y agoi mean.. also Javascript. people learned to live with it, and it evolved to be more tolerable through a messy mishmash of tooling and language evolution.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoFacebook
- erik_seaberg 9y agoMyspace without stylesheets. And only your university friends even have access. Yeah, did not see that getting big.
- barrkel 9y agoYouTube - it didn't look profitable and I thought they'd go out of business
- erik_seaberg 9y agoI was worried rampant infringement suits might kill Google.
- hobofan 9y agoFrom official statements here and there, and especially the "Adpocalypse" happening this year, I doesn't look like they are profitable even now. Sometimes I think the only thing keeping Youtube alive as a Google product is that the internet would rip them to shreds if they were to shut it down.
- krapp 9y agoI think Google was expecting Youtube to no longer exist as an entity in its own right, but just be a part of Google+ after they integrated all of their properties into a massive Facebook killer social media app, but that was a colossal failure. Now, I think they want to use the infrastructure to build something that competes against Netflix and Amazon, but to do that they have to destroy the existing economic incentives for content creators and drive off as many content derivative users as they can (anyone incorporating or using licensed content, even as covered by fair use), and basically rebuild Youtube from the inside out.
- lj3 9y agoYouTube loses billions of dollars a year. If they weren't being subsidized by Google search profits, they would be out of business.
- umanwizard 9y agoBitcoin.
- narrator 9y agoI knew about Bitcoin quite early, but I was convinced the government would shut it down. I am mystified as to why they didn't.
- mslate 9y agoThey cannot--coordinating enforcement is impossible for nation state actors, at least not yet.
- cheeze 9y agoShutting it completely down is impossible, but making possession illegal is not.
- tlrobinson 9y agoPossibly because it's not actually as anonymous as some people believe.
- umanwizard 9y agoThe government can't just "shut down" whatever it wants in a society like the US with (relatively) strong rule of law.
- krapp 9y agoSome governments have banned it, many haven't. It's likely that Bitcoin (and cryptocurrencies in general) aren't, and never were, the existential threat to governments as a whole that anarcho-capitalists wanted it it to be. States and law enforcement are more likely to be concerned with what Bitcoin is used for, than the mere fact that it is used.
- kenbaylor 9y agoSame here. In the early days, the price was driven by emotion. Every time there was a problem, everyone sold and the price went to the floor.
- sjg007 9y agoAlexa and amazon.com
- cm2187 9y agoHas it taken over the world really? Techies love it but I am not convinced there is a mass market for it yet. I don't know if people really like talking to objects, and have non discoverable UIs.
- ridiculous_fish 9y agox86. Even Intel seemed bent on dismantling it with Itanium. And while they were distracted, AMD humiliated Goliath with the Opteron. It was EPIC - no wait, it wasn't!
- jl6 9y agoI don’t recall the Opteron stealing anybody’s lunch. It was the Athlon that outshone contemporary Pentium III chips.
- colejohnson66 9y agoWasn’t Itanium a good idea, just too ahead of its time?
- blattimwind 9y agoNo.
- thatgerhard 9y agodrones
- vortico 9y agoI can definitely understand why these have grown in popularity. Why is it a surprise?
- thatgerhard 9y agoI don't really know, I just kinda got blindsided.. i saw 1 or 2 people playing with drones and i was like "this is a specific group of people like the model aircraft folk" and then the next day it was everywhere. Now I can totally understand that it's an important evolution in tech and will probably solve the last mile problem (at least some of it) in the near future.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- vortico 9y agoUber. It's a "taxi service except about half the price because it starts over with no unions". If it's so profitable, why didn't other taxi services do it instead? Is the whole reason because it lowers the bar for taxi drivers to be hired, thus reaching those who would be fine with the lower pay?
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> If it's so profitable, why didn't other taxi services do it instead? Because that was illegal. This isn't a secret - it's constantly mentioned by pro-Uber and con-Uber groups. Reimagine it as "it's half the price because it is not the beneficiary of a government-granted monopoly on its business".
- joelaaronseely 9y agoGoogle! At the time I heard about this startup in the search space, I thought these people were idiots. Didn't they know that there was already Yahoo!, Ask Jeeves, HotBot, Alta Vista, Etc. Another search engine is doomed to failure - especially if they don't even know enough to spell "googol" correctly.
- OkGoDoIt 9y agoFacebook. I was convinced "social" was just a fad. Played around with the app platform in undergrad in 2008 but thought it would be stupid to build something completely reliant on a 3rd party social platform. I had the opportunity to join FB pre-IPO in 2010 but I still thought it was a fad that couldn't last. I just don't get social.
- Al-Khwarizmi 9y agoInstagram. Sharing pictures and comenting on them, like Fotolog.com in the early 2000s, but more closed (it didn't want you to browse photos on mobile without the app)... yeah, revolutionary.
- ejolto 9y agoInstagram has a slick, easy to use, minimalist ui. Fotolog.com looks messy in comparison.
- zimpenfish 9y agoFlickr should have owned the simple sharing of pictures in a social network because ... they already had one. I'd consider that the biggest, most damning failure of Yahoo!'s management that they didn't immediately devote huge resources to countering Instagram when it appeared.
- smt88 9y agoGoogle Glass
- digitalzombie 9y agoThose VR glasses for augmented reality, the google glasses... but nope.
- kobeya 9y agoIs it really augmented reality if it's just a HUD overlay? I was excited for Google Glass until I found out it was more about the camera and text overlays. I wanted stereoscopic full-frame overlays and bionic camera input...
- akkartik 9y agoRSS and Google Reader. What can I say, I was young and foolish.
- tehlike 9y agoTake the world by storm? Or become a utility? Looks like neither happened.
- akkartik 9y agoName a utility that didn't first take the world by storm.
- vortico 9y agoThe fundamental question for the users here is "should I read an article on a website, which is designed exactly as the users should read and explore it and has 100% support for all typographical element, or on a third party reader which displays a processed copy of the article and requires effort to set up?" RSS hasn't died, but it is definitely not growing, as those who prefer to use it are already using it.
- akkartik 9y agoThat's one question, sure, but there's nothing fundamental about it. Here's a second question: should I have to go to the frontpage of a website to find out what's new on it, or get notifications automatically when there's something new? Here's a completely unprocessed feedreader that I built as a Firefox extension until #$%# Mozilla killed it: https://github.com/akkartik/spew https://github.com/akkartik/spew. It answered your question with, "why yes, read each article precisely as it was intended to be read on its own website," but still used RSS feeds for push notifications. Best of both worlds. --- Here's a third question: should I prioritize articles based on how their website shows them to me, based on when they're posted, or by some other prioritization? This may be what stunted RSS: people chose with their feet to prioritize socially (reading what their friends shared: Facebook, Twitter, etc.) or by collaborative filtering (reading what people like them read: Reddit, HN, Lobsters, etc.) --- Here's a fourth question: do I want to be notified of every single post from a source? And this may be RSS's remaining niche. I no longer use it for high-volume sites like CNN or Buzzfeed. Those need prioritization. I do use it for ~250 extremely low-volume sources (that cumulatively yield a dozen or so stories a week) from whom I want to see everything: http://akkartik.name/feeds.xml http://akkartik.name/feeds.xml.
- the_decider 9y agoSemantic ontologies that would totally change the nature of search.
- nafey 9y agoYou gotta elaborate on that one
- akkartik 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semantic_Web https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Semantic_Web
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- williamscales 9y agoPreach. I'll pour one out for embedded semantic metadata that Facebook bludgeoned to death.
- narrator 9y agoThe problem with user supplied metadata is users lie. For example, the "keywords" meta field was mainly used for SEO spamming.
- williamscales 9y agoI dunno, I think as long as you do statistical analysis that's vulnerable to adverse inputs you're going to see the same problem. Meaning that you can infer the keywords and prevent obvious lies only until the users figure out how to trick your keyword machine into inferring the wrong keywords.
- hobofan 9y agoAs someone who only briefly dipped their toes into the semantic web topic, I found Googles' Knowledge Vault[0] to be a very interesting approach to the problem of "everybody lies". [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knowledge_Vault https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Knowledge_Vault
- the_decider 9y agoBrowser extensions
- hashim-warren 9y agoI was sure the Facebook Platform would take over the world. I thought the fast success of Zynga would create a blueprint for all web apps would be built in the future
- swyx 9y agohmm that's an interesting thought. I have no explanation for it either. My best suggestion for why this didn't happen was the world went mobile and the Android/Apple app store then become the platforms because of the install base and the tighter integration. Facebook (and msft of course) really, really, really fumbled mobile. Not news to anyone but i never thought of it in this context.
- zerostar07 9y agoI think it did. It's facebook itself that killed it as soon as their ecosystem had enough content of its own. In fact, i believe even today there's an opportunity for a social network for silly games. its a great way to make random new friends.
- altitudinous 9y agoKinect - such a human interface that doesn't require direct integration with hardware or technical knowledge or buttons, and a lot of fun in the games I played. But it failed.
- flockonus 9y agoMaybe the product failed, but the technology I'll argue it did not
- popcorncolonel 9y agoClassic Microsoft. See the Windows Phone as well.
- kobeya 9y agoIt's built into the top of the iPhone X... I wouldn't call that a failure.
- swyx 9y agoi'm still shocked that Microsoft decided to discontinue that.. there was so much great research being done on the back of that little device.
- eklavya 9y agoMemristor. I thought that will reshape the entire industry.
- swyx 9y agothese things? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memristor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Memristor why didn't they? (at a high level... im not too smart about these EE topics)
- henrikeh 9y agoAFAIK very difficult to manufacture/effects guarding its behavior are poorly understood. Another issue is that memristors are not part of any standard curriculum and thus limits the number of people who will work on it.
- contingencies 9y agoX3D - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X3D http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X3D Rationale: It was the 1990s, VRML flew but didn't quite make it. 3D hardware acceleration had arrived, gaming was exploding, Descent and Quake had proven complex worlds and freedom of movement were possible on commodity hardware, and talk of buffering 3D content in video streams seemed to make perfect sense for next generation passive entertainment. Product placements, architectural documentation, mechanical design courses, etc. What killed it (IMHO): Took too long to standardize, too much formalism, no consumer electronics manufacturers on board sending actual products to market. If they had done an IETF approach ("rough consensus and running code") they may not have missed the window of opportunity.
- kobeya 9y agoIt ain't dead yet... https://www.x3dom.org/ https://www.x3dom.org/
- Animats 9y agoX3D is VRML, just with XML delimiters.
- vortico 9y agoWouldn't a Javascript X3D-to-WebGL wrapper solve this? That would allow time for adoption to happen during the standardization process, until browsers begin to implement it natively. If nobody is using this now with a JS wrapper, then why should browsers standardize it?
- greggman 9y agoWhat killed IMO and what will continue to kill these kinds of things for a long time is that nearly all 3D applications need massive amounts of custom optimization solutions. Stuff like X3D gets you a few cubes on the screen. Then you want to do GTA or Google Maps or Minecraft or pick your app and suddenly your generic scene graph just isn't good enough.
- 0xcde4c3db 9y agoIn the '90s I was convinced that basically everything with a name attached to it was going to be built around PowerPC and MIPS processors. When StrongARM went to Intel, I figured ARM was basically dead outside of controller/coprocessor/offload applications and expected Pentium II/III to suffer a similar fate to Pentium Pro.
- kobeya 9y agoRISC-V is a derivative of MIPS heritage and there's still a chance it will take the world by storm...
- 0xcde4c3db 9y agoI thought RISC (Berkeley) and MIPS (Stanford) were originally rival projects, with RISC being more closely related to SPARC. I wasn't there, though.
- michaelchisari 9y agoThe blockchain. A strange thing to say when Bitcoin is nearing $8k each, but I'm not interested in cryptocurrencies as an abstract store of value based on the fever of the market. By now, however, I really thought someone would have found a use for the blockchain as the underpinning of some kind of new app or tech that would be able to create real value for bitcoin or whichever crypto they built it on. However, we just haven't seen that. We have a lot of gambling, a lot of whales moving the waters, and a lot of irrational exuberance. But no solid tech. It's still early, but I haven't even heard of anything in the works that really knocks my boots off. All in all, I'm glad people are getting rich (although my hunch is that most getting rich were so to begin with), but so far the tech part of it all has been a big disappointment. I guess other than finding a way to make space heaters that generate money. That's pretty cool.
- jjn2009 9y ago2017 was the biggest year for blockchain by a huge margin by many metrics (see https://coinmarketcap.com/charts/ https://coinmarketcap.com/charts/). there is now 200 billion dollars in this space, give it another year or two. Some things will shake out for sure, probably a lot of it, but many efforts will lead to production applications.
- pandler 9y agoThat's the thing. Blockchain tech is still pretty early stage in terms of reaching the general consumer. Yes, Bitcoin has been around for 8+ years now, but it takes a damn long time for a brand new type of technology to mature and work out the kinks. Ethereum has only been around for about 3 (2014). It's easy to look at the space right now and see that it isn't currently viable, but that sentiment completely ignores the passage of time and the fact that we are moving towards the goal of general applicability. Yes, there will probably be a 2000's style shakeout of all the failed or mislead or me-too attempts, but the fact that there are so many projects popping up should tell you that we are still trying to figure out what we can and should do with blockchain.
- kobeya 9y agoWell, what are you looking for? There's lots of tech developments happening in the bitcoin space, from mimblewimble to lightning to confidential assets & zero knowledge proofs. But it sounds like none of this is what you had in mind?
- Jtsummers 9y agoI'm not sure I expected it to take the world "by storm", but I expected more from Google Wave. It was a great concept, by a major company, but it was too slow on release and the rollout killed it. In retrospect, it probably wouldn't have lasted anyways. Google was in the process of minimizing their federated communication services by that point, and that was another major selling point of Google Wave's initial proposal. But the rollout, that was just the worst way to ever get a product into the hands of users. If you got in they gave you some number of invites. You'd set them up to be sent out to your friends or coworkers or whatever. Turned out, it just put them in a queue to eventually get an invite. Wave was fundamentally a collaboration platform, without anyone to collaborate with it had zero value. Fantastic way to fail.
- mwidell 9y agoI agree. Looking back though, I think that platforms such as Slack, have incorporated many of the key things that made Google Wave a great concept.
- Jtsummers 9y agoTrue. Chat bots supply some of the functionality. In Wave you could have bots which would replace, alter, or add content based on things you typed in or some other rules. Like you could have a stock ticker bot, or one that inserted maps, or ones to do live translations. The collaborative document editing in Google Docs improved afterwards, the Google Wave wikipedia entry doesn't mention this but I have some vague recollection of some of their work being migrated into Google Docs to improve it in that regard. That may be completely wrong though since I can't seem to verify it.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoIndeed, and the technologies developed there made their way into Slack, Google Docs, GMail / Inbox, and a bunch of other products.
- ajdlinux 9y agoMy primary recollection of Wave was that it ran really slowly on the browsers and computers I had at the time, which also wouldn't have helped.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- knackers 9y agoGoogle Wave. RIP T_T
- bitwarrior 9y agoNanotubes. Seemed like it was all upside, the stuff we were going to be making starships out of.
- kobeya 9y agoIt will be. When we're able to manufacture them in large quantities and with few imperfections. Give it time.
- vortico 9y agoYup, it hasn't gone away or stopped growing. It might be taking too long for journalists to find interest in it right now, but that has low correlation to the research effort.
- swyx 9y agomind explaining a little more in terms of how far away we might be able to mass produce these things?
- vortico 9y agoI'm not in the field so I don't want to try to guess how long it will be. But of course it will be in gradual increments of cost, quality, and size. There won't be an exact point in time where we transition to being able to mass produce this material on a large scale.
- kobeya 9y agohttp://www.molecularassembler.com/Nanofactory/ http://www.molecularassembler.com/Nanofactory/ (Science is legit, but needs a better website.)
- newsbinator 9y agoAlso it would be nice if accidentally inhaling them (during the manufacturing process, or in the wild) didn't directly cause cancer.
- j45 9y agoPalm/HP/LG WebOS - JavaScript based os a few years ahead of it's time in mobile form.
- dizzystar 9y agoI was rooting for them back then. Web OS was truly second to none at that time. Really too bad.
- j45 9y agoIt is interesting to imagine what WebOS would look like now with WebAssembly and the ability to load binaries into a browser interface. At this point, it might have to sit on top of for Android. No sooner did I type that sentence than I decided to google it, WebOS has been rebranded to LuneOS, which sits on top of Android. https://pivotce.com/tag/luneos/ https://pivotce.com/tag/luneos/ Other interesting reads: http://www.openwebosproject.org/ http://www.openwebosproject.org/ https://www.cnet.com/news/open-webos-reborn-as-luneos-for-mobile-devices/ https://www.cnet.com/news/open-webos-reborn-as-luneos-for-mo...
- examancer 9y agoCame here to vote for this. I even published an app to their store during the ~2 weeks it looked like HP was going to throw their weight behind the TouchPad. It was really ahead of its time and most of its major metaphors can be found in the surviving mobile OSes. Just wish the web-centric development model survived as well. I have WebOS on my LG TV now. It sucks.
- jetti 9y agoI'm curious as to why you think WebOS on your TV sucks? I too have it and am content with it. To be fair, though, I don't have any other smart TV OS experience to compare it to. I really enjoyed the HP Touchpad with WeBOS but there were some rendering issues with it that I noticed when going to certain websites. My father in law got me one during the flash sale as he worked at OfficeMax Corporate at the time and had access. For ~$60 it wasn't too bad at all.
- em3rgent0rdr 9y agoFuel Cells.
- donpdonp 9y agoYes Hydrogen Fuel Cells! Toshiba was claiming in 2006 that they were coming for laptop batteries. I still think the future of energy is solar cells, using water+electrolysis to get hydrogen for storage, and a fuel cell for conversion back to electricity.
- eyko 9y agoThe semantic web, and speech to text.
- geowwy 9y agoI expected PCs to be in every home pretty much forever. Now a lot of non-tech people prefer phones and tablets.
- flatline 9y agoI’m a tech person and hardly ever use my home computer any more. And nowadays I only have the one.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Muuuchem 9y agoCurious, aren't phones and tablets essentially just smaller personal computers?
- PostOnce 9y agoAs kobeya points out https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15719171 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15719171 they are not the same thing they do less; the software is restricted, especially on iOS, there are _rules_ set out by the manufacturer about what is acceptable in software on the platform, both thematically and functionally. An app generally can't interfere with other apps, it can't be a dope wars style game about drugs; there are a lot more caveats, but I am far from aware of them all. For a long time you couldn't get a compiler or interpreter on iOS, so you couldn't use your "computer" to make more software... so it wasn't general-purpose at all, since you by definition couldn't change its purpose without the ability to make new software.
- ajdlinux 9y agoThe bigger difference, to me, isn't so much that the walled-garden ecosystems restrict a phone/tablet's use as a general-purpose computer, than the form factors and interfaces of the device being appropriate for different forms of content creation, manipulation and consumption. Phones and tablets are great for consuming certain types of content, and having a portable camera with networking has enabled a lot of content creation. But a phone isn't a great device for doing something like long-form writing.
- beamatronic 9y agoWebTV
- Double_a_92 9y agoWell didn't it? Considering Youtube and Netflix... Or is that some specific technology that I don't know about?
- vortico 9y agoNo, it hasn't. Still, the majority of TV viewers use TV utility providers, not ISPs. When the average couch dweller sits down, grabs a remote, and turns on Netflix instead of "channel 42" on cable TV, WebTV will be commonplace, but it won't happen until the young Netflix-watching generation completely replaces the older cable-watching generation.
- jayflux 9y agoThis is moving a lot faster than you think, we may be thinking more in years than generations.
- Darthy 9y agoHe's probably referring to the 1995 set-top box company cofounded by Steve Perlman: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MSN_TV#The_WebTV_set-top_box https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MSN_TV#The_WebTV_set-top_box
- santaclaus 9y ago3D printing.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- api 9y agoIt's huge in prototyping and is being used to build parts that can't be made any other way. Just never took off for personal use.
- epx 9y agoWindows Phone
- kobeya 9y agoThe general-purpose computer. It's a dinosaur on the verge of extinction at the hands of walled-garden app stores on phones and tablets. I never, ever expected that to happen.
- justhackedme 9y agoThis is wrong. If you're 10 or 65 this is correct, but for anyone else the PC has not only been increasing in use but other parts of your life are filled with other computers.
- Silhouette 9y agoThat's profoundly disappointing, I agree, but in a sense perhaps we geeks only have ourselves to blame. We didn't solve the basic (to any normal user) problems of ease of use and security, despite having decades to do so. We also didn't start routinely educating the next generation of kids in how useful and powerful programming skills are. Consequently, for many people personal computing has been reduced to little more than a mechanism for consuming online content and for relatively simple communications using a few trusted channels. The one comfort is that someone still needs to be creating all that content and all those communications channels, and those people are always going to benefit from something much more capable than a small, lock-down touchscreen+WiFi device.
- kobeya 9y ago> The one comfort is that someone still needs to be creating all that content and all those communications channels, and those people are always going to benefit from something much more capable than a small, lock-down touchscreen+WiFi device. Maybe. Let's see what the next generation of visual programming and IDE UX bring.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 9y ago>We didn't solve the basic (to any normal user) problems of ease of use and security This user is a strawman. The problem we didn't solve was decoupling ourselves from corporations controlling our user experience, because we didn't create a good enough alternative for getting stuff done.
- pera 9y agoLisp, p2p everything, and GNU/Linux on desktop...
- chx 9y agoWell, Linux on the desktop kind of happened this year, it's just running on the Windows desktop, this time. Here's how I set up Windows 10 coming from Linux. https://github.com/chx/chx.github.io/wiki/How-I-set-up-my-Windows-10-(coming-from-Linux) https://github.com/chx/chx.github.io/wiki/How-I-set-up-my-Wi...
- King-Aaron 9y agoBetamax :(
- too_tired 9y agoEnd-to-end email encryption.
- vortico 9y agoMeaning PGP, or services like ProtonMail? If PGP, it's a huge hassle to set up, and both parties have to do it, so it's no surprise it is rarely used.
- true_religion 9y agoXhtml. I bought into it completely but hmtl5 is a better system.
- nayuki 9y agoXHTML5 works today, and my site is live proof. It helps catch dumb typos when typing HTML code by hand. It also means the CSS is more likely to be applied to the correct DOM tree.
- Kiro 9y agoI had a look at your site and it looks like normal HTML to me, except <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?> at the top. How does that help anything?
- AndrewOMartin 9y agoMany sites are very subtly not normal HTML.
- Kiro 9y agoExample from this site?
- nayuki 9y agoThe biggest difference is serving with the header "Content-Type: application/xhtml+xml". This triggers strict XML parsing in the browser, and any syntax error produces a big ugly yellow screen.
- indubitable 9y agoI thought this was going to be 'The VR Thread.' I still don't entirely understand why virtual reality didn't really catch on. I think there were some very poor business decisions by Facebook which were treating it as a success before it had even launched -- trying to ring-fence a platform, both hardware and software, whose early demographic is going to be entirely high information users seems a very questionable decision. But beyond this, I don't really understand why it didn't catch on. The first time I tried it I was hooked simply due to the issue of presence. Though perhaps the fact I ended up never purchasing a device answers my own question -- I had no interest in a Facebook driven platform, and the price point to get involved with VR for things like the Vive did not mesh well with the availability of software, as well as the fact that hardware tends to rapidly iterate.
- phantom_package 9y agoDitto on presence. I bought a Vive and it's been... interesting. I actually haven't touched any games in months, but I still break it out every few weeks to prototype something in Unity/Unreal. Also, I've been using Google Blocks a ton to create lowpoly models for use in games. I think the tech is way too compelling to go away anytime soon, but it's obviously not the splash hit that Facebook/etc predicted it would be.
- rytill 9y agoIt depends on your metric for success. VR already has research applications and artists are using it for 3D modeling. VR gaming is neat, but in my expectations, not going to be the core focus of the technology. Generally, VR is about natural control of a simulated environment. I suspect within a few years, when our hardware gets better/is stable and more groups are developing applications, you'll see VR become a central component of more systems.
- Animats 9y agoSpend 10 minutes with an HTC Vibe or an Oculus Rift on your head, and you'll be impressed. Now spend 4 hours. Most of those things end up in closets. Or on eBay.
- 9y ago
- Johnny_Brahms 9y agoI am still waiting for all my favourite applications to be extendable in GNU Guile. On a more general note, I am still waiting for the world to fall for lisp in general.
- jknoepfler 9y ago> On a more general note, I am still waiting for the world to fall for lisp in general. Gah, aren't we all? Watching John Carmack push Scheme for the Oculus Rift 2 [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ydyztGZnbNs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ydyztGZnbNs] made me feel like something was right in the universe.
- leavethebubble 9y agoWhy not just leave the lisp-bubble and admit it's a terrible type of language which is behind of ML languages in terms of productivity, safety and performance?
- socksy 9y agoGood thing that there isn't an ML bubble then ;)
- marcosdumay 9y ago> Gah, aren't we all? Since I found Haskell, no. Not anymore. And I don't expect Haskell to take over the world either. I do expect a large crop of new languages that extend on the concept, and some of them to take over the world.
- eadmund 9y agoAs someone who's spent the last week implementing two different Schemes atop two different languages (Lua & Go), I think I can explain why GNU Guile didn't take off: Scheme. The problem with Scheme is that it's an utterly lovely little language with some wonderfully neat concepts which is great for teaching students about continuations … and it happens to have some broken features, like DYNAMIC-WIND instead of UNWIND-PROTECT, and some design decisions seemed wise at the time but in retrospect were foolish (Lisp-1 seems really awesome, right until you have to use it every day; eliminating NIL and making '() truthy seems very elegant and orthogonal but is actually a right royal pain — and don't even get me started about forbidding (car '())). Scheme pursued a foolish simplicity, foregoing the complexity necessary to deal with the real world. It's a wonderful language for implementing language interpreters, but I wouldn't want to write large programs in it. For that, the only thing worth using is Common Lisp.
- kapilkaisare 9y agoI remember holding the ideas behind Jini (now practically defunct Apache River[0]) in very high regard. [0]: https://river.apache.org/ https://river.apache.org/
- erik_seaberg 9y agoThank you, I actually forgot about how excited I had once been about untrusted mobile code.
- andrewstuart 9y agoCDROM & "interactive multimedia" Linked Data & "Open Data" On the other hand, I really wasn't convinced about the web until I essentially missed the giant early opportunities, which I was well placed to capitalize on.
- wbl 9y agoNuclear power. Carbon free. Reliable. No waste if you reprocess. Cheap fuel.
- api 9y agoThree things are killing it: It is exponentially harder to finance a few huge super costly projects than loads of small ones. It has a high "PITA factor." That stands for pain in the you know what. A high PITA factor means there is a very long tail of non obvious problems that compound and multiply. It looks much better on paper than in real life because on paper that stuff doesn't show up. An exponential is now in place for solar and storage. It would not surprise me if almost all energy outside aviation and a few heavy industry applications is solar and batteries by 2050.
- wbl 9y agoIt would surprise me. Battery chemistry has already tried everything on the periodic table together, and storage remains expensive. Right now more solar leads to more natural gas to cover loads when the sun doesn't shine. Load shifting can only go so far.
- Jeff_Brown 9y ago> already tried everything on the periodic table together Shall we consider the size of the space to explore? If n is the number of elements, at first blush it's n*2. But there are compounds -- more than nine million organic compounds alone. Electrical and temperature treatments can have different effects -- and those are functional spaces, you don't just choose a current, you vary the current over time. Simple positioning can have an effect: rotate one surface relative to another and it can behave totally differently. Wafers behave differently than strings, which behave differently than spheres and crystals, which behave differently than dust ... If there was a race between our exploring the entire chemical space and colonizing the universe, I would not know which to bet on.
- godisdad 9y agoTypes.
- Jeff_Brown 9y agoAnd purity! And I'm still waiting for dependent types. Idris looks beautiful but I'm afraid to commit to such a new language.
- kdoherty 9y agoI remember being in high school when Google Plus came out and thinking it would be incredibly popular. I totally missed the mark, and it's funny because while I thought it would take off with other people, I never really used it myself.
- Kequc 9y agoI touched on this before in my rambling. Google botched it, not the product itself as the initial offering of G+ was actually really really good. Far better than Facebook, a return to basics in a clean interface with Circles. Groups being a feature Facebook later added. When Google launched G+ it was actually one of two new products the primary one being Google Accounts. Before that point you needed to use a Gmail account to sign up on any of Google's services and it made everything a big pain when you had more than one Gmail. Now with a single Google Account you could sign in to Google's entire ecosystem, including all of your Gmail accounts at the same time. It also came with a free, ad-free, totally simple, you-don't-have-to-use-it social network called G+. Google should have marketed this all honestly. Instead they started talking up G+, and hid Google Accounts underneath it. This was a huge mistake. The general public felt like they were being tricked, because they were, albeit far less nefarious reasons than was assumed. Nobody wanted to give their name, to sign up to G+, and therefore rejected both G+ and the Google Accounts system. This compounded because Google really needed everyone to switch to the new account system. Otherwise they were doomed to continue supporting both Gmail authentication and Google Accounts authentication forever. So Google began pushing for people to create Google Accounts, as you would imagine. People then saw this as Google trying to force them to give their full name, trust was already gone. Amazing to me people trusted Facebook over Google because at the time Google so far had a very good record protecting private information. Now that's all gone of course but at the time they had an incredible amount of good will which was seemingly not reciprocated and now Google is a slimy gross privacy succubus the same as Facebook is. Probably they just threw their hands up and said 'fuck it'. Google tried to further reduce complexity in their myriad of different platforms. They now had two social networks G+ and Youtube. G+ was going to eventually absorb and replace Youtube, it would have been pretty elegant really. The first step was to have the Google Accounts system absorb Youtube accounts. People resisted this again because at this point good will was gone. Eventually Google gave up on everything. Now G+ is a cesspool of tacked on features, advertising, just a bad smell entirely. It did have a lively base for a short while. Things really went downhill after the Youtube consolidation because G+ suddenly had what was notoriously one of the worst communities on the internet, Youtube comments. Google has I believe still not successfully moved everyone over to Google Accounts. Youtube was never successfully merged into G+. G+ is pretty much dead at this point. Nothing went well at all and now Google has to support a million different things that all barely work. Meanwhile Youtube hasn't seen a facelift in about a decade while Google figures out what it wants to do with it.
- saluki 9y agoQR Codes . . . although they are BIG IN JAPAN
- dnh44 9y agoWell you should see how common they are in China.
- mszcz 9y agoI don't know and I can't tell if that's sarcasm ;)
- cheeze 9y agoIMO the biggest issue with them is that the average consumer doesn't know what to do with them. Neither iPhone or Android (that I'm aware of at least) expose an easy way to read a QR code which would be intuitive to even a large minority of users.
- vadimberman 9y agoSegway and Code Morphing Software by Transmeta.
- susi22 9y agoSpaced repetition is the most efficient way to learn associations. Thought, it's still barely.
- marcus_holmes 9y agoOptical computing. I remember talking to a bloke working on it back in 1990, and he said they had a working optical transistor so all the hard bits were done. Soon we'd have computers that used multiple frequencies of light to process operations concurrently on the same hardware! Still waiting...
- btown 9y agoThese computers do exist on tabletops in labs; the problem is that it's comparatively difficult/expensive to mass-produce and miniaturize these components compared to silicon (where you can etch billions of transistors at once on a modern CPU). There are really cool things you can do, especially in terms of continuous/non-discretized-time computations, but I wouldn't hold your breath for this to become mainstream.
- avian 9y agoAre you talking about analog computing? We tried that both with electronic and mechanical computers and it obviously didn’t work out since nobody uses them anymore. What benefits do optical computers have in that regard?
- krylon 9y agoI once heard somebody talk about analog computers who is old enough to have used them. The impression I got was that they did work excessively well on a very narrow niche of problems (simulations, mostly). But "programming" them was a huge pain, and for the general purpose arena, they were not useful.
- marcosdumay 9y agoThey would be comparing them with the digital computers of the same time. There's a reason people used analog computers back them, and there's a reason nobody uses them now. Most of the reason is about how noise interferes with small components, and it's a physical reality that won't go away.
- Animats 9y agoVirtual worlds. The "metaverse" of Snow Crash. "Snow Crash", the TV series, has been green-lighted by Amazon. That may drum up more interest. Second Life comes close. They've had a working system for over a decade and have with adequate solutions to most of the problems. But it's hard to use, and not that many people are interested.
- Blazespinnaker 9y agoYeah, SL is probably closest but they can't seem to get their users interested in headsets. Kinda ironic in a way.
- Animats 9y agoWho wants to wear a VR headset for hours on end?
- Blazespinnaker 9y agoYeah, I think it makes a very poignant statement about the potential of VR headsets when VR enthusiasts don't want to use them. SLers are the real deal, people like zuck just don't get it. Too many people have dismissed SL foolishly. Glad it survived and proved them mostly wrong.
- jabretti 9y ago>Too many people have dismissed SL foolishly. Glad it survived and proved them mostly wrong. I dunno, ten years ago a lot of people were predicting that Second Life would be the Next Big Thing, and assuring me that I should really be buying up Second Life real estate with my hard-earned real-world money because soon it'd be worth a lot more. Second Life has survived, but it certainly hasn't gone mainstream. It's just another weird corner of the internet with its own community, and good luck to 'em.
- whatyoucantsay 9y agoNearly every PSVR owner I've met.
- realrocker 9y agoSmartwatches. I was convinced enough to bet two years of my life working on them.
- pimmen 9y agoI have two big reasons why I didn't get a smart watch. Number one is the price, I just don't think it's worth hundreds of dollars not to pick up my phone when I get a notification. The other is that the interface is too small to do anything but consuming notifications or looking at a compass. And, I just don't see the problem being solved by speech recognition either, I don't want the rest of the bus to know that I have to Google "where do I buy bigger condoms?".
- sigi45 9y agoMy reason: Don't like to add another thing on the power cord every night.
- swyx 9y agoi was also extremely excited about them but didnt bet a career. i think its a combination of the tech (esp battery tech but also networking) not quite being there yet + a lot of people just plain don't wear watches no matter what. i wouldn't give up on them just yet (for that subset of the general population)
- Blazespinnaker 9y agoYahoo pipes. I am still holding out hope for this, especially AI pipelines.
- jraines 9y agoNFC, Wave, Glass, semantic web, the DCI architecture; a few frameworks that I wouldn't want to speak ill of because they're not dead yet and their maintainers pop in here.
- blowski 9y agoNFC seems to be rather popular.
- sigi45 9y agoI bought my NFC Phone 3,9 Years ago, never used it. Apple is now doing something with it and it might come but it should have taken of way earlier. Right now i have already a contact less credit card and that works like a charm.
- blowski 9y agoCorrect me if I’m wrong, but don’t Apple Pay and Android Pay already use NFC?
- sigi45 9y agoThats what i meant with Apple. Android pay exists? Is it useable? Haven't seen that anywhere.
- blowski 9y agoI live in London, and both Apple Pay and Android Pay are almost ubiquitous here. I recently hired a rowboat from a guy at renting them at the side of a river in the countryside - and paid with Apple Pay. Admittedly, I’ve no idea how much either are used, and how widespread they are outside London.
- sigi45 9y agoNice, still hoping for it to arrive in germany. There was one supermarket where i was able to pay with there app (it used a 4 digit code). It was quite nice to receive the digital bon per email. It would have been easy to make automatic analysis from them but after just a few weeks, the supermarket switched brand.
- rssllm 9y agoThe Physical Web.
- grumblestumble 9y agoE-Ink. It is the "correct" choice for display technology, and with enough research money put into it, it could replace these abominable light-emitting displays. But what we already have is "good enough", despite all of the hidden costs, and so we're stuck with it.
- Double_a_92 9y agoHave you ever played gameboy as a kid?
- andai 9y agoTransflective LCDs are another tech that didn't go anywhere. It lets you use LCDs outdoors by reflecting the natural light, which solves the problems of color and video. There were even models with solar cells embedded, so not only you get longer battery life but recharge in the sun.
- SyneRyder 9y agoI think that's what the Pebble Time watches used, a transflective Sharp Memory LCD (that Pebble calls "e-paper"). In direct sunlight, the screens are actually easier to read, and the colors are really vibrant. Indoors, it's a bit dim without using a backlight, though still better than a blank screen. It seems to be the key to the Pebble's 7 - 10 day battery life even with an always-on display.
- vortico 9y agoI'm out of date. Does E-ink still have ~500ms latency of refreshing the screen? If so, that's the #1 reason I believed it wouldn't be successful when I used them 6 years ago.
- theshrike79 9y agoBut they're still amazing for status displays, e-readers and stuff that don't need low latencies. What's keeping them from being more popular is the price, anything over a 1" e-ink display costs a literal arm and a leg.
- codesternews 9y agoMobile Augmented Reality or ARKit, But it was just hype as previous. I mean nothing in mainstream. I think main reason is UX or User Interface. It is very hard for people who do not know how it works and expect it to work perfect (in low light etc) as with normal user interface of smartphone. It was not very intuitive for normal user because of Smartphone limitations. I can think that it might take in future if they improve the correctness of platform. It have lot of potential and let's see what future brings.
- swyx 9y agoSame, I was very optimistic. but even in good lighting I was disappointed by ARKit's performance. Still it is too early to judge the success.
- kromem 9y agoGive it time. Just as a frame of reference, the original iPad sold less units in its first year than the PlayStation VR. Virtual reality is still in its infancy, and honestly AR is a technology that's going to have to build on top of a lot of VR's technical underpinnings. Hardware growth takes a lot longer and more iterations than software. VR is going to be huge eventually, and AR is then going to dwarf VR... eventually. There's a lot of work in wireless signal standards, battery life, displays, and pure computational power that needs to happen before these technologies can deliver on the promise though. We're slightly past the Newton stage, and somewhere behind the Windows Mobile 3.1 era with these technologies. It's going to still be a while before we see the "iPhone" for VR/AR, and even then, it'll be a few years before we see mass adoption. But in my opinion, the end result is an inevitably.
- losteverything 9y agoVideo calls
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- croisillon 9y agoSony's MiniDisc music format!
- VinzO 9y agoI came here to say that. It was much more convenient than burning CDs.
- trhway 9y agoQuantum computers. I thought so until i spent some time looking at superposition&entanglement and got convinced that there is no superposition&entanglement. Looking at the published Bell inequality experiments i see exactly opposite of what whose experiments supposedly confirm :/
- tnitsche 9y agoMobile/Micro payments. There is still no friction free solution, where I would be sure, my mother could use it.
- vortico 9y agoThis would be my #1, as it would have drastically changed (for better or worse) the internet. Although, it's a psycological problem instead of a technical one. You can put a PayPal button or Stripe popup on your page using technology today, which will usually take 10 seconds (given that the user is logged into those services, since we're assuming that this micro-payments practice is common), but it's a wild expectation that people would actually get used to willingly give up a nonzero amount of time to pay for something so small as an article. Another problem may have been this. If everyone on the internet agreed that say, watching a video should cost $0.02/minute, then people would get accustomed to paying this amount because that's such a small cost. But it's only a $0.02 decision for a content creator to restrict or allow it to be watched for free, and if say, 5% of artists just decided to "eat" the potenential earnings, then you'd have 5% of free videos and 95% premium videos. The 5% free videos would prevent the 95% of videos from being watched, because why would anyone pay to watch a video if you can watch another one for free. Basically I'm saying that this idealization of micropayment content is destroyed by free content, whether that is a good thing or not. I do this myself with respect to Android apps, since I don't take my time seriously enough to pay the occassional $1 per app.
- alexasmyths 9y agoThis is because VISA/AMEX have an oligarchy, and VISA is backed by the banks, i.e. the entities that issue credit. So, the financial system is 'behind' the crapy payment scheme. Something would have to come along to basically offer credit without all that. I'm mostly surprised that Amazon and/or Wallmart have not simply done that. I'll bet Bezos does some day: a low-interest rate 'Amazon Card' that other merchants can use, credit provided by Amazon (not banks), and it's 0% payment for other merchants.
- vortico 9y ago
- technofiend 9y agoIridium held so much promise and was such a disappointment.
- swyx 9y agothe radioactive element? what was the promise you were excited about?
- technofiend 9y agoThe satellite phone provider that filed for bankruptcy.
- theotherplanb 9y agoFor the record, Iridium is stable.
- farseer 9y agoI would have thought, by now Anti Ageing related research and products would be mainstream but most of that area is still fringe research and the products seem like snake oil.
- swyx 9y agoAnti Ageing seems too broad a category to be useful. were there any specific vectors or products you had particular hopes for?
- grahamburger 9y ago3D printing. Turns out making little plastic shapes isn't all that useful. Seems obvious in hindsight.
- sigi45 9y agoThat was the main motivation why i never bought one. I had never good enough ideas to buy it for that price.
- icebraining 9y agoMe neither, but I have ordered a few prints for various projects involving home maintenance and theater props. Quite useful, if not life changing.
- chx 9y agoI believe the problem is the sort of plastic used. You need structural strength in most things and filament pieces melted together is just not cutting it.
- cheeze 9y agoAbsolutely. One area that they have revolutionized is casting. Hell, even Jay Leno's crew used a 3d printer to create prototype parts that were no longer made and then cast the plastic printed part into a sand mold using aluminum.
- vlehto 9y agoThe next step would be to 3D print the sand mold directly.
- greggman 9y agoI thought the point was you just use the plastic as a mold for something else
- swyx 9y agolittle plastic shapes? no. but big metal industrial parts that were impossible to machine might be a thing? I confess no knowledge as to their real commercial success so far.
- antfarm 9y agoBeacon technology in shops.
- antfarm 9y agoUbiquitous P2P networking.
- antfarm 9y agoInteractive computer simulations of complex adaptive systems, i.e. flight simulators for decision makers.
- swyx 9y agoi remember the Scorpion guy claimed to have built something like that and somehow applied it to war scenario modeling in Afghanistan? Smelled like a crock of b.s. but then again I don't have a 200 IQ for those who dont know about it: its this thing: https://scorpioncomputerservices.com/scengen https://scorpioncomputerservices.com/scengen
- phillc73 9y agoUDP for fast file transfer. Working in the television industry at the time and a few companies were making tools based on UDP, for sending large files across public networks. Smartjog, Aspera, Signiant. The companies are still around, but only operating in the B2B space as far as I know. I thought this technology was going to replace FTP. People wanting to punt bigger and bigger files around, they needed better tools. Smartjog even open sourced an early version of their tool. Anyway, it didn't happen. I'm not in the televisual industry anymore and find myself entirely satisfied with the current file transfer tools commonly available (FTP!). I guess there was just never consumer demand and I was looking at things from the perspective of a very narrow niche.
- nikanj 9y agoThe #1 most used file transfer tool seems to be Dropbox. I put stuff into mine, give you a link and everything magically works.
- phillc73 9y agoYes, that's a nice workflow for non-technical users. However, if you're transfering 50GB files, this takes some time. UDP behind the scenes could fix that. I guess consumers just aren't punting 50GB of data around all that much, so there's not enough wait time pain to justify it.
- stephen_g 9y agoThe biggest problem with UDP is NAT, since UDP is connectionless. Still, it is extensively used in all sorts of applications. The reason it's not used to much in file transfer is because you basically need to re-implement everything you get for free with TCP for reliable transfer. Secondly, one of the big things that made TCP slow for large file transfer was that the way most TCP congestion control algorithms worked meant that transfer rates would drop quickly as latency increased. Google have come up with an algorithm that drastically improves this [1], and contributed it to the Linux kernel. I expect their strategy will be adopted by most operating systems. I believe Google is already using it, and I read something on Netflix's tech blog that they are at least trialing it. For small files, TCP slow-start is an issue but protocols like HTTP/2 can work around this by multiplexing multiple downloads through one connection. So I don't think there will be much advantage to UDP based file transfer for things that you want reliability for. 1. http://queue.acm.org/detail.cfm?id=3022184 http://queue.acm.org/detail.cfm?id=3022184
- MBO35711 9y agoSpace flight. Sigh!
- johan_larson 9y agoI'm disappointed none of the various constructed "universal" languages (like Esperanto) ever took off. Having a single common language spoken by everyone would be enormously useful. As it is, the closest we have is English, but it's a natural language and therefore complicated and difficult to learn.
- theshrike79 9y agoEnglish is a surprisingly versatile language. You can get your point across with pidgin english just fine, and it's the most spoken language in the world. On the other hand you have people who master the language on a whole new level, like Douglas Adams.
- superplussed 9y agoChinese is #1 according to Wikipedia.
- Freak_NL 9y agoThat list comes with a fair warning about its reliability at the top though¹. English is indisputably the largest second language (L2) spoken in the world, and is vying for the position of most spoken language with Mandarin Chinese. 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_languages_by_total_number_of_speakers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_languages_by_total_num...
- bpicolo 9y ago"For example, English has about 400 million native speakers but, depending on the criterion chosen, can be said to have as many as 2 billion speakers." So depending on how you choose you metric, English wins overall
- hnaccount91 9y agoYeah, but it's all inside one region isn't it? Comprising of China (obv), HK/Macau, Taiwan and parts of Vietnam maybe (not sure). Like everyone likes citing this fact to me as though it is mind bending, but if that language is never going to spread out, then what's the point of counting it as a "widely" spoken language.
- throw-away-8 9y agoLisp machines. Expert systems. Functional languages: Scheme, Ocaml, etc. Itanium. OpenStack.
- chx 9y agoIntel Itanium. Hell, everyone was convinced! https://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2339629,00.asp https://www.pcmag.com/article2/0,2817,2339629,00.asp
- coke 9y agoMach microkernal and GNU Hurd
- kumarski 9y agoCRISPR. My naivete surrounded me. I didn't realize that even though there was a high output of genetic marker tests that very few if of them would result in viable CRISPR targets. There's 60K genetic marker tests on the market. 8 to 10 new ones come out each day. Humanity has little hope of figuring out the sort of "druggable targets." Genome Wide Association Studies aren't like websites or apps waiting to be optimized with more data. The more data you feed in the more obfuscated the truth becomes. Drug discovery is hard and CRISPR modifications are technology way ahead of clear problem framing. https://omicsomics.blogspot.com/2017/03/targets-drugability-revisited.html https://omicsomics.blogspot.com/2017/03/targets-drugability-... For 12 years, I've had a chronic autoimmune disorder that I had hoped would be solved by the likes of a massive genetic dataset of Ulcerative Colitis twins that had been separated at birth where one twin had the disease and the other didn't. I had hoped that CRISPR would be the solution given enough problem context from a solid GWAS, but this was foolish. Our best bets in biotech are not in the latest technologies, they are in ensuring that basic science, phase 0, and phase 1 trials get large unfettered funding. I had hoped Liz Parrish's outfit would make leaps and bounds in genetic modification for patients like me, but that ended up being baloney. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11560943 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11560943 CRISPR technologies are like bullets to attack problems, but the operator is always increasingly blind. Bonferroni Corrections abound and family wise error rate are unforgiving in all things related to GWAS studies.
- swyx 9y agowhoa this is non consensus (to the biology-uneducated me). thank you for pointing this out, the mass media is still on the CRISPR hype train. Oh dear.
- seehafer 9y ago> CRISPR technologies are like bullets to attack problems This is a correct and useful analogy. Nonetheless, biologists are excited about CRISPR because, to continue your analogy, we were previously working with spears. And now we have bullets. Still don't know where to quite fire them yet. But it's a nontrivial advance.
- 88e282102ae2e5b 9y ago
- Simulacra 9y agoGoogle Glass. I thought this would become standard, miniaturized, and used in all aspects of life. Perhaps I read Daemon too much, but I was sure Glass would fly
- swyx 9y agoit died when the word "Glasshole" was coined.
- toyg 9y agoIt had everything to do with recording. People wouldn’t mind people flaunting weird gadgetry, but the feeling of being recorded was too creepy. It didn’t help that a lot of early adopters were very creepy to start with. It could have revolutionised journalism, and I still think we will eventually get something like it once the tech is really invisible, but the social aspect will take ages to sort out.
- netsharc 9y agoMaybe in 15 years... toddlers nowadays have so many smartphone cameras being pointed at them for their mom's Instasnapbooktwit feed, they will probably grow up being used to have lenses pointed at them.
- toyg 9y agoTbh it looks like the opposite might be happening, exactly as a reaction to the invasive approach from their exhibitionist parents who grew up before the ‘00s (when exposure was valuable and scarce). Most kids I see are moving towards technologies where recording is managed very consciously (staged ala instagram or ephemeral ala snapchat). Camera awareness has gone up, hoodies have become everyday clothing... Rather than “I’ll be recorded, whatever”, the attitude I see emerging is “I need to know when I’ll be recorded because I know it can make or ruin me”. The revenge-porn laws imho are the first salvo in what will become a campaign to redraw the relationship we have with cameras, in the long run.
- examancer 9y agoFlying cars. I remember seeing prototypes in late 80s and early 90s, constantly showing up on Discovery Channel programs I watched as a kid like Beyond 2000 or Next Step. Over time it seemed increasingly far out, but, possible. Eventually I realized things like how catastrophic a break down or accident would be meant it will likely never happen. I and everyone else who thought flying cars were on the horizon were suckers.
- swyx 9y agosame here. It took me an embarrassingly long time to come around to Elon's view that we need to go down, not up.
- anon1253 9y agoWe have helicopters though, even quadcopters that can carry people, not to mention airplanes. But general purpose "flying cars" are a ridiculous idea: the failure mode is catastrophic (as you pointed out), the noise will be terrible (especially in cities), not to mention pollution (you might not care about CO2, but breathable air is still nice). And there's regulation, since there are no roads you need centralized control (e.g commercial/military flight control systems) which makes it almost impossible to scale and would mean sacrificing to great extend the benefits of cars: autonomy. And above that it solves a weird problem: congestion and capacity, but those are better tackled with self-driving cars and better public transit.
- fallingmeat 9y agoCueCat. Coupon clipping was going to be rocked!
- swyx 9y agowere you actually convinced it would take the world by storm? is there a deeper story here?
- robk 9y agoOS/2
- swyx 9y agowhy were you convinced it would take over the world? I'm pretty ignorant on OS history, but would love to learn.
- fallingmeat 9y agoWebvan. I could have ordered groceries to my door!
- swyx 9y agoi mean.. you were right... eventually!
- zwischenzug 9y agoerlang. As a programmer it was a revelatory thing of beauty. When we tried to spread it within our org we found that the 'typical' (even relatively strong) programmer resisted its concepts and found it hard to learn. Therefore it didn't scale for us.
- gozur88 9y agoHow very odd. That's one language I found intuitive.
- zwischenzug 9y agoYeah, me too. It's an interesting thing. The C syntax and imperative mindset is hard for a lot of people to get. Especially if they're not motivated by the effort.
- unboxed_type 9y agoMost probably because of a lack of functional programming mindset.
- jetti 9y agoTo me, Erlang syntax is odd and a put off. However, I am digging Elixir and diving into Erlang when need be for OTP functionality not yet wrapped by Elixir.
- qilo 9y agoLarge OLED panels everywhere: TVs, monitors, laptops, etc. There was a lot of excitement, once blue color longevity issues were solved, how it is easier and thus cheaper to manufacture, how soon it'll outcompete LCD. 20 years later still waiting.
- d3ckard 9y agoThat one is just becoming true I guess.
- magoghm 9y agoFractal image compression.
- bsaul 9y agoBeOS . That was the best os at the time by far, stellar performance, fantastic C++ api usable by a newbie, i still haven’t found a GUI as responsive as this one. DVD-audio. Great multi channel, high rate, high resolution audio. But it required the whole production chain to upgrade as well as new consumer equipement, and they competed with sony own format ( which was also a failure)... But it would have given the record industry a few more years of revenue before the bandwidth would have been sufficient to download or stream music with this resolution.
- bhnmmhmd 9y agoSimilarly, Windows 10 Mobile didn't take off either. Before that, even Windows Phone became a failure. I was really excited when I got my Lumia 920 [0]: The OS was just so solid, sleek, and fast. Too bad Microsoft didn't put adequate effort into it. It's as if they couldn't care less about this OS. [0]: Not to mention the great, solid design of the hardware by Nokia.
- IshKebab 9y agoI'm not surprised DVD-Audio and co failed. Their quality is indistinguishable from CDs despite what audiophiles would have you believe, and by the time they came out MP3 was clearly the future.
- bsaul 9y agoeven if you don’t believe in very high quality audio like me, the fact is we’re listening to stereo music, but viewing movies on 5.1 systems. This would have been different with dvd-a. I would have loved to listen to a live concert cd with surround sound.
- jasode 9y ago>5.1 systems. This would have been different with dvd-a. I would have loved to listen to a live concert cd with surround sound. As to your specific DVD-Audio example, I think it didn't widely catch on because most music is consumed (1) with earphones (2) in the car (3) as incidental background while multitasking. The scenario of "purposeful" music listening by sitting in the center sweet spot of a 5.1 setup is very rare. There's also a long history of technology that's "superior" but isn't accepted by the masses. There's a "law of diminishing returns" and/or other dimensions of utility (such as convenience) have higher priority than quality. Examples: - quadrophonic sound[1] is more immersive than 2-channel stereo but people didn't buy it - satellite radio is higher quality sound than FM radio but Sirius XM remains a niche and won't penetrate the market like FM did. Yes, FM had higher fidelity than AM and listeners switched but the same didn't happen for satellite. - 24bit-96kHz or 192kHz audio did not take over 16bit-44kHz (1411kbps). Instead, the opposite happened and more listeners consumed lower quality 128kbps mp3 and AAC files. Lower quality was driven by Napster + iPod + Spotify. Convenience trumped highest fidelity. - Bluray discs : more customers pay for digital streaming (often with lower resolution than 1080p) than upgrading the old DVDs to Bluray. There was more market penetration with VHS to DVD. - large 3D tv screens : the explosive growth is smaller screens on mobile phones playing Youtube rather than 3D content like Avatar. 3D is now seen as a gimmick fad. History has shown that we always overestimate how technical "quality" drives consumer adoption. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quadraphonic_sound https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quadraphonic_sound
- jFriedensreich 9y agoThe famo.us frontend framework. The initial demos and vision seemed impressive and i fell for it. Unfortunately they got over ambitious and failed to get something solid enough out fast enough.
- dejv 9y agoSmart homes as with computer controlled switches and automation.
- with_a_herring 9y agoPlan 9 from Bell Labs
- PeachPlum 9y agoI was a user from 2000. The first question new users would ask was "where's the web browser". You basically had to run two computers, one with Linux/Windows and one Plan9. The next question was "what are the keyboard shortcuts" and the answer was "escape toggles text entry in the shell, research says using the mouse is quicker". It was a hard sell.
- hannob 9y agoI would have expected robots and automation technologies that replace human workers to come much faster to everyday life. Of course this is happening in some areas, but not nearly as much as it could happen. Just one example: It's easy to imagine running a shop that works with little to no workers. The closest thing that exists are these self-checkout cashiers, but even these aren't that prevalent, the norm is still a human cashier.
- blattimwind 9y agoA foreshadowing of this is that while industrial robots can do impressive work, they do this in a very specific set of constraints: - they are very expensive in relation to consumer income - they are complex to program - generally specialized: more or less general purpose frames (like your typical 5 axis arm) with special single-purpose tools mounted to them - safety architecture is generally: total enclosure, no human access/interaction during operation, if not totally enclosed usually with light curtains or very stringent requirements. A general-purpose helper bot looks like a completely different beast from this angle.
- peterkelly 9y agoLinux as a desktop OS
- k3a 9y agoUnfortunately. I still use it as my primary desktop but I see why people prefer others. It seems like most people don't want flexibility and configurability and they don't want to learn to manage OS. They just want to use PC comfortably and don't care about anything. For example one of a few things I find annoying on Linux is multiple GUI frameworks, each having it's own OpenFileDialog so I can't always easily open recent folder or recent file. It looks totally different in Qt and in GTK. I think Linux kernel is very solid and cool. But userspace is a mess, there is probably not enough standardization. For example also X11 (hacky, security problems) vs still buggy and unfinished Wayland. :( Compare that to OSX frameworks. Yet I love free software, appreciate all effort people put into it and will continue using it. Maybe one day I will also be able to help GNU/Linux improve..
- b0rsuk 9y agoSeparate screen for touching on the back of the mobile device. I forgot how the device was called, but there was a Blackberry or similar device that didn't have your oily fingers smearing the very screen you're trying to interact with. You didn't obscure the display with fingers. Instead, the touch-sensitive rectangle was on the back of the device, and cursor was displayed on front side, in the spot corresponding to the spot you touched.
- arketyp 9y agoThat's brilliant. With phones getting thinner this would feel even more natural. It would probably allow for better tactile feedback technologies as well, and even thinner devices.
- gempir 9y agoI like the trend of adding this functionality to the fingerprint sensor. I have a pixel 2 and I can swipe down the notifications by swiping down on the fingerprint sensor.
- anonymous5133 9y agocell phone coverage broadcast by satellites. FCC eventually killed off the plan. A company called light squared launched a satellite to have it done.
- api 9y agoThe open web, open OSes, open in general. We (average HN users) use these things but most people use walled garden platforms all the time. For non techies the trend is that way. Computing market seems to be bisecting into pro and consumer. Two issues have prevented this open computing for the masses IMO: 1. Spam and malware. Any open system that gets any user base becomes spam hell. This is even happening to the more open of the walled gardens now (e.g. YouTube) so the future will likely be even more closed. 2. People like "free" and with no revenue stream you can't pay programmers to work on the parts that are not fun. This includes UX, which is a brutal grind. Walled gardens have a revenue stream from being surveillance driven advertising platforms users can't customize.
- anodari 9y agoSegway
- reacweb 9y agogoogle glasses. For me, a smartphone should not have a display (only be a touchpad) and the glasses should be the display+camera+headset.
- wj 9y agoPalm. A computer (some with wireless Internet) in your pocket!
- brudgers 9y agoTHOR-CD, http://articles.latimes.com/1988-04-22/business/fi-1732_1_compact-disc http://articles.latimes.com/1988-04-22/business/fi-1732_1_co...
- magoghm 9y agoCyc.
- Lapsa 9y agoMicrosoft LightSwitch :->
- RalphJr45 9y agoI thought the laptop arms race would be raw power and battery not weight, thinness and style.
- lowry 9y agoCompetition in laptops stalled, it is probably ripe for disruption. Looking the shameful Thinkpad 25, and the hype around it... there is a market for a developer laptop that does not suck.
- hyperpallium 9y agoLaptops were disrupted years ago by netbooks, which got killed by phones.
- magoghm 9y agoExpert systems.
- ainiriand 9y agoAny GNU/Linux desktop for the common user.
- magoghm 9y agoGenetic algorithms.
- redeploy-test 9y agoOnly a matter of time
- vog 9y agoParser generators. They get better and easier to use every year (PEGs being the newest kid on the street), but we still see loads of buggy ad-hoc parsers with loops and regexes. And many of those bugs turn into actual security issues.
- Jeff_Brown 9y agoYes, these are great! Text.Megaparsec.Expr blew my mind. It lets you write something that can evaluate expressions like "(3 + 4/(-2)) * 7" -- a nested expression parser, with prefix, postfix and infix operators of varying associativity and precedence -- in 12 lines of code. I made a repo about it [here](https://github.com/JeffreyBenjaminBrown/megaparsec/tree/master/Expr-studies https://github.com/JeffreyBenjaminBrown/megaparsec/tree/mast...).
- cjsuk 9y agoWindows Phone 7 :(
- jetti 9y agoI really liked aspects of my Windows Phone but there were other things that just drove me crazy. It would lock up when I was on a call and I wouldn't be able to do anything. I'd have to pull the battery in order to get it back to a usable state. The speakers were terribly soft too, I couldn't hear my phone ring if it fell under the couch. I absolutely loved the live tiles though.
- cjsuk 9y agoYes that was always the problem. If it worked properly it would have been amazing. But it didn't. My daughter has a Lumia 650 and it's a buggy pile of crap. That's SOP from MSFT mobile products.
- Heraclite 9y agoNFC on the phone. I thought it would revolutionise lots of things. Turns out it took 10 years longer than I expected and is just a "fun" feature for now.
- jpatokal 9y agoNFC & Android/Apple Pay is actually kinda amazing if you live in a country like Australia where tap to pay is universally supported. It's starting to get traction for transport smart cards as well.
- no_gravity 9y agoVR glasses / headsets I remember when I tried the first headset sometime between 1999 and 2002. I thought "This will be big". 15 years later it's still not big. Tablets I expected tablets to become omnipresent. But phones took that spot instead.
- Manicdave 9y agoGoogle glasses and those VR headsets
- magoghm 9y agoNeWS (Network Extensible Window System). Although, we now have web browsers + JavaScript (not exactly the same thing, but there are some similarities).
- magoghm 9y agoThe Connection Machine.
- magoghm 9y agoFORTH.
- magoghm 9y agoThe Eiffel Programming Language.
- magoghm 9y agoOberon.
- ps3udo 9y agoRebol
- peterburkimsher 9y agoSmalltalk. Everybody was supposed to be able to program, not just professional software developers.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoBelieve it or not, that was the original goal of COBOL.
- eadmund 9y agoAnd SQL! The problem is that it turns out most human beings don't actually think in a clear and logical manner, and thus there's a need for someone to translate unclear and illogical statements into clear and logical instructions for a computer — that someone is a programmer.
- hyperpallium 9y agoAnd BASIC! BTW I find maths, with equations that are true in both directions, much less intuitive than programming, with functions that accept input and return output. I suppose maths is "clear and logical statements", code is "clear and logical instructions". Does that mean maths is easier than programming for most people?
- d--b 9y agoTheranos, hands down. I don't understand why we need more than a drop of blood for medical tests. A drop is a lot of molecules.
- Al-Khwarizmi 9y agoI don't know if this has a name, but... ICQ-like "searchable" instant messaging. Let me explain myself. In the late 90s, there was an IM client called ICQ. For starters, its UI was leaps and bounds ahead of anything to be seen in the next decade, and it had functionality like bots or groups, that has again become widespread a few years ago. But what I'm talking about is the fact that I could look for "female, age between 16 and 20, who likes writing, RPGs and electronic music and is available for chat" and results would come up. You could enter your data, interests, hobbies, etc. in the program and mark yourself as available (only if you wanted) and it was a really nice way to meet people. I collected stamps at the time so I remember I would search for people who were stamp collectors in countries for which I had no stamp, leading to stamp exchanges apart from some interesting conversation (as you could also throw some of your interests in in the search window). I thought that was the future and the tech could only get better from there, but then came MSN Messenger, with really bare-bones features in general and in particular no "searchable" functionality, and displaced ICQ. And since then, nothing similar has appeared. Instant messengers are focused on talking to people you already know, and if you want to meet new people, you have to use specific-purpose communities or dating sites. But good luck finding someone who likes writing, RPGs and electronic music at the same time... That function of searching people by interests in a huge directory of people (not restricted, e.g., to a dating site) is what I thought would take the world by storm, and as far as I know it doesn't even exist anymore at enough scale to be meaningful, at least in the West (maybe in WeChat, QQ or one of those apps used in Asia they have something similar, I don't know).
- azeirah 9y agoI had some succes with Omegle. They support a feature where you can select a topic you're interested in.
- dabockster 9y ago> Omegle Too many people named Dan.
- muzani 9y agoI thought the same thing too. It's quite sad that talking to people is usually limited to dating, and dating has become a domain of Tinder. I remember an era when chat rooms like IRC had thousands of people online at a time. It didn't scale past this, but it was very exciting. Maybe there is a market for something like a real-time Reddit, but it's a lot harder to pull off because there needed to be many people on at the same time before it could but critical mass.
- magoghm 9y agoSpace Colonies.
- foobazzy 9y agoNokia + Belle operating system. It was a beautiful future I dreamed of.
- alfiedotwtf 9y agoBBSes
- magoghm 9y agoLisp for AI. Frames for Knowledge Representation.
- Jeff_Brown 9y agoFrames might come back: https://research.googleblog.com/2017/11/sling-natural-language-frame-semantic.html https://research.googleblog.com/2017/11/sling-natural-langua...
- amelius 9y agoLaptop battery power that lasts a month.
- muzani 9y agoI expected microtransaction games to take off, but not in the form of "pay to win" as it is today. I expected things like buying side quests or episodes for games. People could just pay for as much content as they would play. It would have been similar to how musicians could sell singles instead of albums. Paradox games and CS:GO seem to have adopted this model very well but it never happened in mobile games, where microtransactions would have been most successful.
- Zpalmtree 9y agoWell, DLC is pretty common in PC games.
- amelius 9y agoI was convinced at some point that CPU clocks would become much faster than the 4Ghz that seems to have become the limit.
- pknerd 9y agoInternet Explorer... kidding :P
- timthelion 9y agoMicrosoft XAML and .NET. They seem popularish, but the lack of an open ecosystem means that they didn't take the world by storm.
- magoghm 9y ago4GL (Fourth Generation Languages). I never thought they would take the world by storm, but many people in the 1980's thought they were the future of (business) software.
- ananthrk 9y agoSemantic web
- sicher 9y agoMagic wands.
- zerostar07 9y agoVR, until i tried it.
- swah 9y agoSegways - I thought every one moving by more than a block would be on one.
- zinckiwi 9y agoThe Commodore Amiga. Used it from release in 1985 through to 1993, at which point I had to admit defeat and defect. Much has been written, including a great retrospective on Ars, but its failure wasn't due to engineering. Way ahead of its time. Minidisc. This was generally popular in Hong Kong and Japan, perhaps other parts of the world, but in the US I gather it was marketed as a CD alternative instead of a mix-tape alternative. Digital copy protection hobbled the latter immediately, of course. I still used a pair of them ten years after getting my first player as a poor man's two-track recorder.
- ekianjo 9y agoThe Amiga was awesome and it did sell quite well in some areas like in Europe. Its failure on the US market is clearly what killed it, as well as the lack of innovation after the Amiga 500... It did take over the world by storm with the Video Toaster though - and stayed there even long after it was dead.
- alexee 9y agoOnline accredited bachelor degree in CS, it seems there is a lot of resistance in this area too, why it takes so long for Coursera/Udacity to implemented this?
- Dowwie 9y agoThe semantic web. It spawned an entire generation of academic study, but aside from assuring job security for researchers hasn't amounted to anything beyond their ivory towers.
- perlgeek 9y agoI get the impression that "dumb" crawling and machine learning have turned out to be more practicable.
- mannykannot 9y agoIt is definitely more practicable in the sense that no-one has figured out how to implement the vision of the semantic web.
- jacobr 9y agoI remember my huge number of delicious bookmarks tagged with "folksonomy" and other buzz words.
- michaelmior 9y agoThat's not entirely true. It's perhaps a far cry from the original goal but Schema.org markup has definitely caught on mostly thanks to use by Google for rich snippets.
- lolive 9y agoThanks for mentionning it. Beyond some very nice pieces of software created by clever SW developpers (let's mention DBPedia Spotlight, RelFinder, Semantic MediaWiki, N3.js) I mostly agree with your argument. To be the devil's advocate, in my opinion, data lakes are just a new buzzword that will eventually become what the Semantic Web was supposed to be. With some millions dollars, companies will aggregate and interlink their datasets. There are then one step away from extracting their master data from their data lake & publish it as Linked Corporate Data. From that, the public part of will be published as Linked Open Data.
- captainmuon 9y agoPeer-to-peer file sharing. There was a time when Napster, Kazaa, eMule were king. The content industry fought against it, but developers came up with decentralized solutions like DHTs or supernodes. I was convinced the next step would be friend-of-a-friend sharing. You only share files with your direct friends. But they can pass on these files automatically, so their friends can get the files, too. The friends of your friend don't know that the file is originally coming from you, it is completely transparent. The goal is to not let anybody you don't trust know what you are down- or uploading. I would piggyback on the social graph of existing networks to get started. I actually had a prototype of the friend discovery code, based on XMPP (using custom stanzas). You login with your credentials, and it shows you all your friends that are using the same app. It worked with GTalk, Facebook Messenger, and Skype (via Skype API). One nice feature was that this worked without getting an API key from Facebook etc., or having a central server. I was so pissed when they all changed their APIs to make this impossible. It felt like a conspiracy to stop this use case. I still think if somebody pulled this off, it might work, and it would be pretty distruptive (in the good and the bad sense of the word). It would be the last word in the debate between "data wants to be free, change society to enable what technology promises" and "data has to be a commodity, restrict technology because in capitalism we can't feed artists otherwise".
- fsloth 9y agoI think the biggest motivation for peer-to-peer networks was the lack of legal options for digitally accessing movies and music. The current streaming services and online stores have reduced this ache.
- rodolphoarruda 9y agoI agree. In fact, I started to realize I've been using sites like The Pirate Bay just to get a sense of what people are watching, new releases etc. Ratings would tend to be very low, of course, it's their culture to say that any movie sucks; but at least I can get a list of titles and then search for them in paid service providers.
- 9y ago
- 1065 9y agoHolidays on the moon never got the traction I was hoping for.
- Jeff_Brown 9y agoThis will happen for sure, at least for princes and the like.
- DoubleGlazing 9y agoInteractive digital TV. back when digital TV launched in the UK during late 1998, the major platofrm (Sky, ONdigital, Telewest and ntl) were all hyping up their interactive services. Sky's service was called Open.... (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open.... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Open....) and you could order pizza, email, go shopping, dating, betting etc. Sky were so convinced it was going to be a money spinner they gave away all the boxes for free. The underlying technology was also used to add interactively to TV shows. For example you could choose the camera angle in some football games and the BBC made a documentary about dinosaurs that worked like a multimedia CD-ROM. Most of these services lasted less than five years, the services were sluggish, the proprietary tech didn't help and in any case the web did it better. I didn't think the shopping/commercial side would succeed, but I was convinced there would be a huge market for interactive TV. Nope, there wasn't.
- arethuza 9y agoI remember looking at some of this stuff when I worked at an interactive TV company in the early 2000s - I remember being deeply troubled looking at the MHEG spec: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MHEG-5 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MHEG-5
- Tade0 9y agoLeap motion. I bought one used just three months after rollout - should have seen this as a red flag back then. The user experience was great - for the first 30 minutes. After that the pain related to holding the hand in the air was becoming to annoying to ignore. Switching between this and the mouse/touchpad proved to be a great optimum though. Anyway I successfully used it for my master's thesis to precisely place a few microphones in space, but after that I stopped using it altogether - too few useful applications to bother.
- ekianjo 9y ago3DO. I was not "convinced it would take the world by storm" but I really liked the idea of a console standard that anyone could manufacture, all compatible with each other. The PC equivalent for consoles. Too bad it did not work out (and there are many reasons why it did not, but that's not the place here to discuss it).
- monk_e_boy 9y agoAPI / AI government. It seems that we could replace a lot of politicians with a simple bash script. Voting reform. It seems that with fake news and real news labelled as fake news, stupid facebook memes, junk internet adverts on everything... I thought the internet would be better. It started off with so much promise. Lots of smart people connected together, they all chanted "Get the masses online!" ... it turns out that comes with its own set of issues.
- kapauldo 9y agoVirtual reality.. It was a solution looking for a problem last decade and is still.
- adrianmsmith 9y agoGWT. To create client-side web apps, rather than writing Javascript, write Java and have it transpiled to Javascript. Java has IDEs, isn't a new language to learn (like Dart), has static type checking, support for refactoring in the IDEs, etc. GWT could do tree shaking, obfuscation, etc. You could write your server code in Java, and "call" remote server methods from your client code, "passing" Java objects transparently back and forth between the client and the server. It was released in around 2006, it was not without issues but seemed to be a much better way to develop complex client code than the Javascript options available in 2006, as far as I could see. It never really took off. Google moved their team over to Dart at some point. I guess the Oracle Java lawsuit meant Google were unenthusiastic about continuing to have anything to do with Java where they didn't need to. The compile times were slow. Not all Java compiled so you had to have a mental model in your head not only of Java but also the Javascript that was going to be generated which was mental overhead.
- BjoernKW 9y agoGWT was quite complex. You had to write a lot of code for achieving very little. There also was a huge impedance mismatch between Java and JavaScript at the time. Nowadays you can write decent functional code in Java but back then you needed anonymous classes for that.
- adrianmsmith 9y agoThat's true, but while it was difficult back then to write functional code in Java (now solved), it was difficult back then to write class-based object-oriented code in Javascript (now solved).
- abritinthebay 9y agoIf you go into JS classes assuming they work at all like Java/C++ classes... you’ll have a bad time. They’re just sugar around protypical object-oriented code.
- bambax 9y ago
- ryandrake 9y agoOpenGL: For a brief, glorious period, we had the promise of a truly cross-platform general-purpose graphics API. Then Microsoft began its relentless assault on it, ran its tried-and-true 1990s playbook on it and eventually FUDded it into irrelevance on the Windows platform. For a short while, it at least held up as a Linux/Mac solution, and survived on Windows as a second-class citizen. For the last few years, however, Apple seems to have even abandoned it for their own proprietary technology, dooming developers back to the bad-old-days of needing to support N platform-specific APIs if they want to support N platforms. As Trump would say: "Sad!"
- bhouston 9y agoOpenGL is the basis of computer graphics on Andriod and Linux and works well on Windows. So it is fairly universal these day. It does work well. There are always new proprietary APIs to compete with OpenGL and they usually jump ahead but then OpenGL slowly but surely consumes them.
- jawns 9y agoIn early 2013 I read this article: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/02/130220084442.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/02/130220084442.h... It described what seemed like an incredible advance in capacitor design that would allow xenon flashes to be installed in even the slimmest of smartphones. I consider xenon flashes, which are found in most cameras that aren't smartphones, to be wildly superior to LED flashes, which are used in phones, and assumed that within a couple of years, the new technology would be ubiquitous. But it never happened. So far as I know, the partnership between Nanyang Technological University and Xenon Technologies never really went anywhere. After a couple of years of waiting, I even went so far as to try to contact the researchers to find out what happened, but never got a response. I hope that someday this tech does hit the mass market. Although LED flash quality has improved somewhat, xenon flashes are still so much better.
- VLM 9y agoToken Ring Networking as a protocol/concept (not so much physical IBM hardware, of course) rather than CSMA/CD. It naturally makes sense that allocating BW via a token would be much more power efficient and faster than transmitting into the void and hoping for no collision. Its hard to get line rate traffic with CSMA/CD but the financial services co I was working at back then had very high util in the upper 90%s for hours. I also miss ATM and its complicated and semi-obscure adaptation layers, pretty cool although toward its death it was just a weird way to send pt-to-pt ethernet frames. ISDN was like that too, a whole protocol stack, pretty interesting exciting ideas, toward the end it was just a 128K pt-pt interface for internet access and of course a voice trunk signalling protocol replacing old E+M signalling. Both could have been interesting/cool. X.25 switching never really took off either.
- sah2ed 9y agoI did a cursory search [0] on Token Ring vs CSMA/CD and it appears that "worse is better" is why CSMA/CD won out. CSMA/CD was much cheaper to deploy than Token Ring. "Token-Ring has been a bit of a mystery for many people. This is due to the fact that Ethernet, and other Carrier Sense Multi Access - Collision Detection (CSMA/CD) networks, are the most widely installed network topology. This is because most network designers cannot look past the initial cost of Token-Ring. While Token-Ring does cost more per port to install, it offers vast benefits over Ethernet and other CSMA/CD topologies." [0] http://www.let.rug.nl/bosveld/algoritmiek/aptokenhc7.htm http://www.let.rug.nl/bosveld/algoritmiek/aptokenhc7.htm
- delgaudm 9y agoThe Lytro Camera[1]. The idea of refocusing a photo after the fact felt like an absolute revelation. Their initial camera was somewhat affordable, but ended up being just downright awful. The pictures were low res, low quality, and the camera was difficult to use and lacked basic, yet essential functions. I was a super-excited early adopter. After I got the camera I think I took, maybe 100 pictures with mine and it's sat in a box of disappointment ever since, because you couldn't actually do anything with the crummy pictures it took. All I wanted was a reasonably good 4MP image where I could refocus a picture on my kid's face when the camera focused on the wall behind her so I could send that picture to grandma, or post it to facebook. They clearly had something else very different in mind and the novelty of all the interactive-y stuff they added around the refocusing forgot that what we(I) actually wanted was a picture. It's all fine that I ended up not taking more pictures becuase the one place you could see them is being shut down at the end of the month. They appear to have pivoted to professional cinema. [1] https://www.wired.com/2011/06/lytro-camera-lets-you-focus-photos-after-you-take-them/ https://www.wired.com/2011/06/lytro-camera-lets-you-focus-ph...
- ryanchants 9y agoIn the same vein, I'm excited about the Light L16[0]. But with the hefty price tag, I don't know if I can get on it this early. If takes off, then the price is comparable to a DSLR and a few lenses, but right now I'm hesitant. [0] https://light.co/ https://light.co/
- greggman 9y agoI wanted to like Lytro but after trying it I realized I don't want to refocus later. Just don't care. I'm not saying some Pros wouldn't want that but for the masses my guess was "no, can't be bothered" On the other hand, what I do expect to happen maybe is my mobile camera will advance to the point where it takes 1000 images in 1/1000th of a second so I can just wave it around then then post process any image at nearly any resolution any dof so I don't need lenses, don't even have to aim much. Unfortunately actually processing 1000 images in a short amount of time is 10-20yrs off? I'm a little surprised at their pro video camera hasn't been more popular. It seems like the no need for a green screen feature would be useful for getting better lighting for effects scenes.
- therealmarv 9y agoVR (yes the standalone/PC systems or the one which you can have with your phone). I have the feeling it's dying already because most non geeks are not really interested into it. It's like 3D TV of 2017.
- zimpenfish 9y agoIt's not just that non-geeks aren't really interested; it's that it has a whole bunch of barriers as well for those that are interested. 1. You need a reasonably powerful PC or PS4 ($$$) 2. You need the VR kit itself ($$) 3. You need space to use it 4. You need to be physically able to use it 5. You need a lack of motion sickness, etc. 6. There's bugger all games at the moment 7. Probably something else I've not thought of
- lookACamel 9y ago7. You need to find time to use it. (Pairs nicely with reason 3.) Currently, VR is a separate activity which doesn't fit into one's existing activities. It's a nice experience the first time, but what's the compelling reason to turn it into a habit?
- zimpenfish 9y ago8. Wildly unportable (pairs with 7 and 3) - you can't play it whilst commuting, travelling, etc.
- rf15 9y agoa lot of geeks are also not into it: it is advertised as giving you more degrees of freedom and immersion, but VR gives you half the features of these degrees (free hand movements! looking around wherever you please!) and feels limiting because it cannot offer you the other half (proper free movement, you're tied down by cables, have to set up your room for it, etc.) Also, after a short while, you stop seeing "3D" as it is because your brain abstracts it all away anyways and will draw a similar 3D experience out of a moving 2D image and a proper stereoscopic one. (not to mention that the price is pretty off the charts too)
- AndrewDucker 9y agoAsynchronous circuits: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asynchronous_circuit https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asynchronous_circuit I was convinced that we were going to enter a new phase of computing, where the processor wasn't stuck at the speed of its slowest component.
- baldfat 9y agoIt will have to happen sometime in our life time.
- zimpenfish 9y agoFractal Image Compression. Way better than JPEG in the mid-1990s but patents + expensive restrictive licenses left it pretty much dead in the water as a result.
- bstamour 9y agoxhtml: it's just a good idea, IMO.
- dexterdexter 9y agoSegway! I'm surprised no one else mentioned this. The hype equaled the excitement it triggered on people. Personally, it signaled the arrival of the future at the time. Fast forward to today and they are just niche transportation devices used by tourists and to a lesser degree by some security officials.
- krapp 9y agoThe hype with Segway was high as long as no one knew what it was... for a while people were seriously speculating that it was an anti-gravity hoverboard like from Back to the Future or something just as exotic - but as soon as everyone found out it was just a scooter (albeit a slightly clever one), the hype vanished.
- GFischer 9y agoI thought videocalls and live video-shopping would be ubiquitous (and I put my money where my mouth was). I still think we're due more interactive shopping experiences.
- michaelmior 9y agoAren't video calls pretty ubiquitous now? (Facetime, Skype, etc.) Not in connection to shopping though.
- c_shu 9y ago1. E-book and products like evernote/google keep. I rarely write things on paper now because I often experience the difficulty of copying/searching. On computers copying/searching is a breeze. 2. VoIP, Skype, WhatsApp, etc. Many years ago I thought they can totally replace traditional phone calls, at least for 99% users. But that didn't happen. 3. Technologies for telecommuting. Less congestion, less pollution. And it saves both time and money. But it's still not so popular. (In Asia, it's very rare.)
- albeebe1 9y agoI remember going to a cafe in Harvard Square called Cybersmiths in the mid 90s. You got a card, loaded some money on it, then you could surf the world wide web at high speeds. I thought you were going to see these types of cafes everywhere, but high speed internet to the home put them out of business.
- ufo 9y agoThese still exist in many third world countries. A similar service is also available for PC gaming because even when people have a PC at home with internet, they might need a better PC with a better connection to be able to play their favourite games.
- jraby3 9y ago3D printing. I thought it'd put China out of business and we'd all be able to 3D print random plastic Chinese goods on demand from everyone's home.
- shove 9y agoWebGL. I spent ~10 years doing Flash / ActionScript and when Jobs nixed the mobile Flash plugin, I figured everything would shift to HTML5 / WebGL. Nope. The era of fancy, interactive websites faded into the rearview mirror. I'm sure most of you don't miss it, but there was so much amazing work. Rather than the budgets shifting to Three.js etc, it went to apps or dried up completely.
- disease 9y agoThere is still demand for interactive, animated and "flashy" websites in the educational sector.
- shove 9y agoAny way you slice it, demand is probably less than a tenth what it once was.
- gilbetron 9y agoWebGL is fantastic, but writing compelling software with it is significantly more difficult than just using "normal" web libraries because you have to be able to think in rendering terms, use linear algebra (a bit), etc. And the thing is, it turns out it is really difficult to find something to do using WebGL that isn't easier to understand in a normal 2D visualization. I think there is great stuff to be done (and is done) with WebGL, but most of it is in the background and subtle. "Walking through a data world" is just a dumb idea, for lots of reasons. But using WebGL to speed up 2D visualizations works great, as is using it to make more interesting 2D visualizations. However, that is a subtle art.
- hutzlibu 9y agoSince in my experience WebGL is still not really stable on many devices (especially mobile), I think its time, combined with wasm, is about to come ...
- culot 9y agoBack in like 1994 I was certain that RoboBoard BBS software was the future of the online world. But no.
- 0x4f3759df 9y agoLinux on the Desktop.
- vssr 9y agoSpeech to text. 20 years ago there were programs already doing a fairly good job at it. By now I'd expected to see people recite written documents to their computer instead of typing them. Not the case.
- virtualized 9y agoSolid State Drives. In 2012 I did not expect that you could still buy $2000 laptops with spinning rust in 2017.
- dsschnau 9y agoyeah but that's just because spinning platters are still cheaper by the byte - if you don't care much about performance you buy that. But any computer worth using (imo) has a ssd in it, and that's been the case since 2012.
- lldata 9y agoScala ... now betting on Kotlin to replace Java.
- rodolphoarruda 9y agoWearables. I was expecting much better sensors and services to be consumed, specially in the Healthcare field. What I see now is extreme attention to design and looks of smartwatches, but little talk on the type of value the could be adding to people's lives when connected to online services, phones or what have you.
- virtualized 9y agoEmail. I work at a software development shop and most of our internal Email-like communication happens face-to-face or via phone. "Will you be available for a meeting two weeks from now?" "I just wanted to tell you that I checked in my code." "Please answer my trivially Google-able programming question right now." "Tell person X that I want to talk to them later." "The boss just told me [important news that concerns several people who are not at work today]." I have to assume that most of the world works like that and Open Source communities are the great exception to this rule.
- adrianmsmith 9y agoI have been thinking about this recently and come to the following conclusion: - If you receive a call, it breaks your flow, which is bad. - If you send an email, it breaks your flow, which is bad. (As you have to wait for an answer, and do something else in the meantime.) So if you have a question, the optimal strategy (for you) is to make a call. But if someone else has a question, the optimal strategy (for you) is they email you. There's even a further level, which is that if someone else has a question, it's optimal (for you) that they email you, and you call them to give your answer, and discuss it until it's done. So if it's up to you (and you're thinking only about your own productivity above all else) then tell people to email you when they need something, but call them when you need something.
- bane 9y agoI thought (and still think) the phone as single computing device is going to replace desktops and laptops via some kind of dock of some sort. There's been a few attempts at it by Dell and Microsoft and a few others, but none really satisfactory. I think the most successful to date is the Nintendo Switch.
- robodale 9y agoI thought this as well. I'd love to plug my phone into a laptop-looking-thingy...and instantly have a keyboard, screen, and maybe a battery (to keep the phone charged up).
- eatplayrove 9y agoWhat about the Intel compute stick and similar?
- bpicolo 9y agoCan't use it as a phone. The all-purpose compute device is the shtick they want
- ezconnect 9y agoSamsung is advertising that usage when promoting the current Galaxy phones
- bane 9y agoYou're right, here it is. https://www.samsung.com/us/explore/dex/ https://www.samsung.com/us/explore/dex/
- dpcx 9y agoThere actually was an Android based device that did this years ago. 2011/2012, I think; you could connect the phone to an external device that gave you a mouse, keyboard, and screen. The only problem was that the external device was something like $300 on top of the phone. Edit: https://www.amazon.com/AT-Laptop-Dock-Motorola-ATRIX/dp/B004M17D62 https://www.amazon.com/AT-Laptop-Dock-Motorola-ATRIX/dp/B004... - Motorola Atrix Lapdock
- atomicbeanie 9y agoGoogle Wave
- antjanus 9y agoAdobe Air. HTML/CSS/JS in a native executible with access to native methods? It sounded like a dream. ANd yeah, you can do Adobe Air without Flash. You could build desktop apps and phone apps with the same tools on top of it. I really liked the desktop stuff. I made a couple of apps and used a ton of Adobe Air apps (non-Flash) back in the day. Thought it was the future. It failed, for some reason. ^^^^ this is the reason why the rise of Electron wasn't surprising to me. In fact, I was surprised by people being surprised. I realize that Electron is WAY more sophisticated but "desktop web apps" have been around for a while.
- shove 9y agoit was soooooo slow though. But yeah, the comparison to Electron et al is spot on.
- antjanus 9y agonot for smaller apps. I mean, can't imagine running VS Code on it.
- ashleyn 9y agoMicrosoft flirted with it as far back as Windows 95, in the form of the HTA (HTML Application).
- _wmd 9y agoHTA were awesome, I wrote a very rich UI Innosetup-alike entirely in it back in the late 90s. Everything was there, it exposed pretty much any system interface via COM, and everything pristinely documented in Microsoft style
- j_s 9y agoPerhaps V8 + baseline hardware performance pushed Electron over the threshold to usable.
- abritinthebay 9y agoIt was slow as hell, that was the main issue. It’s still around however.
- arca_vorago 9y agoWireless power. In about 2007 I was convinced it was "the future", but other than a few mobile devices with "lay it directly on top of this charging pad" setups, the safety and power-loss issues seem to be pretty large barriers to overcome.
- roryisok 9y agoWindows phones! And before those, minidiscs
- wokawoka 9y agoMicrosoft Bob
- xonaether 9y agoJetpacks
- MichaelGG 9y agoF#. Back in 2006 I first stumbled upon it and was amazed. It had so much potential. Everything C# did, and more, better. I was sure we'd see 20% of MS devs moving to it. I underestimated the momentum of MS, the power of embarrassment of hiring a high-profile figure to be shown up by a researcher, the incredible anti-FP and even anti-generics...resentment(?) that MS kept towards them. Plus the insane comments from actual developers that literally did not understand the basics of C# ("C is a subset of C#" and "var is dynamic typing" <- comments from a public high-profile MS hire). I've basically given up hope on programming becoming better over time. A lot of apps are boring grunt work anyway, so the edge in using better tools can be beaten just by throwing a lot of sub-par people at it. On the plus side, for people looking to strike it rich in "tech", knowing tech isn't really a prerequisite. Persistence and the 'hacker' spirit, even if it means you spend all night writing something in PHP that would literally be one line if you know what you were doing, hey, that's what leads to big exits.
- whistlerbrk 9y agoDon't give up. I see FP growing every day. I saw a Haskell job listing yesterday for $180k/yrly. These skills are valuable and becoming more valued. I think the Xamarin purchase bodes well for F# which I have an intention of learning. My understanding is it is more popular in Europe btw.
- RyanZAG 9y agoI feel it's more a case of functional programming trying to target the wrong segment - albeit out of necessity. There's two kinds of programs being made. First most common one is the kind you're talking about here: grunt work. It's not about the code, but more about having the code do a straight forward task with very flexible constraints. A web app that talks to a database and does a few simple transformations -- like forum software or a todo app. The second type is the interesting one: actual difficult code that does something unique and difficult and can take years to write by very experienced developers. Usually the difficult part here is coming up with the correct algorithm and then applying it, often with performance considerations being extremely important as the code is doing a lot of work. An impressive new MMORPG game, a new rendering technique, complex simulations, control code for rockets or advanced batteries. The big program with functional programming is that it's never been positioned as a solution to the second type. Generally people trying the second type are told to use C, C++ or recently, Rust. Functional programming is marketed as making the first type "better" because trying to market it as being more efficient than C/C++ has not worked as people rely on micro benchmarks for these decisions. But this falls apart with the argument you gave: for the first type, it's better to just hire more junior programmers as there's nothing really difficult involved. And using a functional language makes it extremely difficult to hire junior programmers, because functional languages are aimed at advanced programmers. It's a massive product-market fit problem.
- mindcrime 9y agoVarious approaches to authentication / identity management: OpenID WS-Federation etc. Multicast XHTML, XQuery/XPath/XLink/XPointer/etc.
- mncolinlee 9y agoNear-field communication (NFC). It came out in 2010 for Android and Microsoft phones, but has been hamstrung by Apple for most of its development. I had several startup ideas which required NFC market penetration on phones, but which even today are impractical due to Apple's chokehold on NFC APIs for fear of a payments competitor. In order to even find "tap to pair" devices, you often need to seek out the one manufacturer or option available. There should be personal phone-to-phone "tap to pay" by e-cash or cryptocurrency. "Tap to auth" using your phone. "Tap to key exchange" should be part of doing business, sending "business card" contact details as well. Samsung had S-Beam, "tap to share files" securely with WiFI Direct. But even with the addition of Core NFC, you need to find a responsible adult with an Android phone to even write a single bit as an iPhone owner.
- allthing 9y agoWe use it in products at work and it always works seamlessly. It could be a quick and easy way to pair a phone to a car or connect a phone to WiFi. Just tapping is way more efficient than the current connecting options when you're near the hardware you want to connect with.
- deerpig 9y agoFor me it was VRML. I was working with SGI (not for) in Hong Kong at the time and it was amazing what you could do with it. They were even pushing it for use in interactive 3D banner ads. I went to the Tokyo event where they streamed someone in a motion capture suit in Mountain View with the animated figure being rendered on a browser in Tokyo. Very cool stuff. I wish it had taken off.
- Raphmedia 9y agoPokemon Go. It did take the world by storm but promptly died due to incompetence from Niantic. One can only hope that they didn't set enthusiasm for AR games too far back.
- jetti 9y agoI don't think Niantic was responsible for the decline but just the game itself was. It only garnered the attention it did because of the Pokemon name but at the end of the day the game was a grind. I saw a lot of people lose interest because there was nothing really unique about it. Everybody that I knew that played it turned the AR off as well, so it became just another game.
- Raphmedia 9y ago> I don't think Niantic was responsible for the decline but just the game itself was. They re-skinned their previous game and only added a gym fighting minigame. It's entirely their fault. Even today the game doesn't have all the features shown in the trailer. Their game has no end-game content either so even the core demographic lost any reason to play.
- jetti 9y agoThat is true. I guess you can't blame the game without putting the blame on the developers. I'm honestly shocked that the game got approved by all parties involved, though I'm sure it still made a bunch of money for all parties involved.
- CodeCube 9y agoI still can't believe that trading pokemon between friends wasn't a day 1 feature.
- turc1656 9y agoPaypal used to have this feature that allowed you to install a browser add-on and you could generate a CC number on the fly that was good for either one time use or recurring use (for subscription services). This feature served two primary purposes: 1) to be able to pay using PayPal on sites that didn't support it 2) to help prevent against fraud which was becoming a massive problem at the time. If the number was stolen, it immediately wasn't good anymore and a hacker/thief could not use the CC number to purchase/steal anything. It was that second aspect that I thought would totally eliminate all credit card fraud and make people comfortable with online purchases on smaller sites. I have no idea why PayPal killed the program, but even before it did, not many people used it. I was the only person I knew that was even aware it existed. EDIT - if anyone is curious, I looked it up. Two ex-PayPal employees explain here: https://www.quora.com/Why-did-PayPal-discontinue-their-one-time-credit-card-numbers https://www.quora.com/Why-did-PayPal-discontinue-their-one-t...
- TheCoreh 9y agoInteresting, my bank does that, and I use it a lot.
- astura 9y agoIt's not just PayPal. I think Discover and American Express both had that feature but killed it off. Bank of America still has it and (IIRC) Chase does too.
- doctorsher 9y agoCitibank still has this feature as well.
- astura 9y agoDoh! When I said Chase I actually meant Citibank. Chase doesn't to my knowledge. In my defense both start with C....
- doctorsher 9y ago
- TallGuyShort 9y agoAdapteva's Parallela. I don't follow the semiconductor industry that closely, so perhaps very similar architectures are becoming more common, but as someone with a passing interest in HPC I was very excited about their crowd-sourced board for playing with parallel programming on an architecture built just for that, but it suffered from many problems typical of crowd-sourcing. It was delivered late with a lot of business problems leading up to it. I played with it a bit and haven't heard of it otherwise since.
- deepnotderp 9y agoSilicon on insulator. I was convinced the entire industry would rapidly adopt it and that it would quickly replace bulk CMOS.
- johnchristopher 9y agoRSS.
- peterburkimsher 9y agoAirships. I wish they got off the ground.
- work_account 9y ago...ba-dum-tss...
- fixermark 9y agoTechShop. ;) (context: https://techcrunch.com/2017/11/15/techshop-shuts-down-all-u-s-locations-declares-bankruptcy/ https://techcrunch.com/2017/11/15/techshop-shuts-down-all-u-...)
- rticesterp 9y ago3D Sports. 2005, in Austin one local theater showed the National Championship in 3D. To this day this was the best football viewing experience I've come across. During the game, I could see the holes open for running backs as they opened and later closed in a split second. I felt like I was actually on the field as a player as the game played out. At half time, everyone gathered in the lobby of the theater and there was just this feeling that this was the future of watching sports in talking to other people. I was convinced at that time that 3D would eventually be the way that everyone watched sports and that this would eventually top the in game experience. I'm still surprised that theaters and sports networks haven't partnered to display more sporting events in this fashion.
- ezconnect 9y agoGoogle Glass. When I first saw it, I thought it would be the greatest tool every human should have.
- Iwan-Zotow 9y agoPlan9 (or rather whole stack of P9/Alef/Inferno/Limbo). Seems so elegant, small, could run everywhere
- krapp 9y agoI didn't expect it to take the world by storm, but I expected Hack to be a lot more popular by now than it seems to be.
- awinder 9y agoI was pretty convinced that microtransactions were going to become super ubiquitous and solve a lot of monetization problems. Particularly in terms of press / media. I think you could make arguments that this still might be true in a long-term sense, and theres some movement in this space still, but I don't think this has panned out to be the slam-dunk hit that I thought it would be.
- GnarfGnarf 9y agoBubble memory. Josephson junction.
- simonsarris 9y agoGoogle Wave had so many potential routes to usability as a kind of collaborative scratch pad. Google Keep and the now-very-good Google Docs collaborating is what we really needed all along, I guess.
- sidcool 9y agoGoogle Keep is still quite low on features.
- jetti 9y agoSega Channel[0]. My buddy had it around ~1995 and it was amazing. Sleeping over at his house was always unique because they would change up what games they offered each month. There are game streaming services offered now, such as Playstation Now and I think Gamefly has game streaming as well, but it amazes me that it didn't catch on sooner. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sega_Channel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sega_Channel
- dquail 9y agoBiometric Auth. My first job out of university in 2003 was with a biometric security company. even back then the technology was shockingly mature. But yet getting deployed was so difficult. I also remember in 2004 going to my favorite waterslide park and being able to use my fingerprint to get in and out of my locker - rather than an awkward key or combo. But a year later those lockers were replaced by clunky combo ones.
- harrisreynolds 9y agoParts of the old Web Services stack. It is obvious why SOAP died (to me at least). It was a solution in search of a problem that was already solved by REST/HTTP with generic payloads. BUT.... things like WSDL that gave you an interface description... it would be nice if something like that had survived. The closest thing to this that I know of is Swagger. But not having a standard machine-readable way to integrate with REST APIs/services is a missing piece of the puzzle I think. The Web Services Description Language provided that. I'm surprised that or an equivalent never got traction.
- grandalf 9y agoIt's fascinating to read everyone's responses. Mine are: - mobile devices with extremely long battery life (weeks) - mobile devices that can be put into a dishwasher and do not need to be treated gently. - HashCash - non-ai personal assistant/concierge services - Theranos-like tech - Teledildonics
- jrs95 9y agoI dunno about that last one. It seems like most consumer tech is trending towards teledildonics, metaphorically speaking ;)
- hyperpallium 9y ago> mobile devices with extremely long battery life (weeks) Problem is charging overnight solves this for most people, and they turn to other needs.
- grandalf 9y agoMaybe. But I see lots of cases for sale w extra batteries, public charging stations, portable batteries, etc. I have to scramble to avoid a dead phone a few times per month, usually after not charging the night before.
- apapli 9y ago100VG-AnyLAN. Was superior to Ethernet in performance but it’s proprietary nature held it back.
- raphinou 9y agoSun readable laptop screens. The olpc had one and a tablet was also produced with such a screen, which could switch from color mode to e-ink mode. Amazes me we still don't have sun readable screens for laptop and smartphones.
- johnmw 9y agoJava applets. Back in the mid 90's Java was at the peak of its hype cycle and was the darling language. I thought the idea of writing an app in a 'modern advanced' language, compiling it down to a bytecode, and running it in your browser was the future of the web. And if someone had told me back then that Javascript would be the language of the web I would have spat my coffee out laughing. Unfortunately speed, security, and the need to install a seperate run-time/plugin layer were too much for people at the time. But hey, now 20 years later we are finally starting to see that vision in Web Assembly. ;-)
- hnmullany 9y agoI wrote a whole blog post with source data on the history of Gartner's tech predictions in its Hype Cycle. https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/8-lessons-from-20-years-hype-cycles-michael-mullany/ https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/8-lessons-from-20-years-hype-...
- JustSomeNobody 9y agoMesh networking. I figured by now the cost of nodes would be so low and the technology so far more advanced that everyone could just stick a few nodes around and we'd have a completely free, open and decentralized internet.
- ilkan 9y agoGoogle Glass. IMHO they mistakenly went after the consumer and advertising markets instead of starting with maintenance workers and hobbyists. On a related note, I also expected some mobile computers would be "cyberdecks", embedded in the keyboard. Instead, the computer is the screen.
- SimbaOnSteroids 9y agoGlass failed because it was too early for the tech, they needed to be able have the functionality of the the camera they had but make it something you didn't immediately notice. Also the display mechanism needed to be less noticeable as well. What killed Glass was that it made people uncomfortable. Also glass relaunched in July targeting enterprise applications.
- mdjorgensen 9y agoAgreed. Here's more on the enterprise relaunch for anyone interested: https://www.wired.com/story/google-glass-2-is-here/ https://www.wired.com/story/google-glass-2-is-here/
- ilkan 9y agoI expected Remote Desktop to be on every system... it's really frustrating that I can't remotely see and configure my elderly mom's iPhone screen when she needs tech support. "Do you see an x? Or is there something that looks like a backwards arrow? No? A less-than symbol? Or the word Back? No? Cancel? Maybe at the bottom?"
- Viper007Bond 9y agohttps://www.teamviewer.us/features/ios-screen-sharing/ https://www.teamviewer.us/features/ios-screen-sharing/
- MarkMMullin 9y agoThe original idea of the internet as a highly distributed fault tolerant system that could route around localized failures. I will admit that part of that philosophy emerged when leaving arpanet and trying to get stupid bang email addys and netnews flowing over dialup :-)
- DannyB2 9y agoTen years ago I was debating with a friend that GPUs would gradually change into massive general purpose processors. Instead they have remained special purpose and difficult to program. My thinking was that with a large number of cores of processors that are more general in nature, you could still do great graphics. But you could do many other things as well. There are plenty of problems that are embarrassingly parallel if done right. There are also plenty of applications for adding significant amounts of computational power at the cost of a good graphics card. Computer vision. Speech recognition. Speech synthesis. Photo and video editing filters and processes. Even amazing scream savers.
- lookACamel 9y agoWell deep learning is pretty general purpose so ...
- mmgutz 9y agoMS Silverlight. I thought the world needed a better Flash and with MS behind it and IE was still popular enough. I was a corporate C# developer so I saw everything through Microsoft. It turns out iPhone killed Flash. MS could hardly get anyone to adopt Silverlight.
- sterex 9y agoThis happens quite a bit even now. Many corporate Microsoft technology developers have a myopic view of the software world. This is on a downward trend, but still exists.
- dennisgorelik 9y agoMicrosoft Silverlight had a good overall idea, but bad implementation: 1) Bad API (too complex). 2) Awkward installer.
- dogcow 9y agoXMPP - federated instant messaging
- ricardobeat 9y agoBump, a technology that allowed you to match two devices (phone and/or computer) over the internet. You did this by literally bumping them together, or bumping the phone against your spacebar on a computer. A mix of geolocation, timing, and accelerometer data. I used it a lot for file sharing, exchanging contact cards. Worked like magic, until Google bought and murdered it.
- NautilusWave 9y agoMirasol display technology. I wouldn't be surprised if the display's colors simply weren't saturated enough to be marketable; but I still pine for a screen that I could actually see better under bright light instead of struggling with glare.
- CM30 9y agoFrom the gaming world, some I believed would be popular (but ended up failing) are: 1. Augmented reality. When I played around it with on the 3DS, I thought the idea was going to really blow up and end up having a ton of games based around it. And in the first year or two, we did get a few like that. Such as Kid Icarus Uprising having said features or Spirit Camera being entirely based on the technology. But it quickly died off afterwards, and since about 2012 I don't think I've seen a single major game on the system where AR has been a central feature. Same goes with other consoles and systems too. It's occasionally been advertised (like with Microsoft and the Hololens or whatever it is), but it's generally remained a niche idea. 2. Also, the eReader. No, not the Kindle type, that thing the Game Boy Advance had in the early 00s where you could scan cards to unlock features in games. I genuinely believed that would be a huge revolution, to the point of importing the device from America to try it out. Alas, it failed pretty damn hard, and even the titles which had support for it in the US dropped said support in the European versions. 3. For non gaming stuff, VRML was a good example as well. Again, I thought the future of the internet would be 3D worlds accessed through the browser, and looked at the sites writing about it as if they were a glimpse of a high tech future only a few years off in the distance. Nope, VRML failed, and pretty much every attempt to implement VR functionality in the browser died too. 4. Also, I'm not sure if it counts as revolutionary on a tech level, but at one point there was a lot of talk about using oauth to tie various communities together into something akin to a forum network or Reddit equivalent. I think a group called Zoints tried this in the early 00s or so, and I expected their service to do pretty well off it. Again, didn't really happen. Shared login systems did, in the most basic sense (login with Facebook/Twitter/Google/whatever) but it seemed people preferred walled gardens run by large companies over individual communities networked together. Finally, there were an awful lot of Google products and services I expected to take the world by storm too. Google Wave has already been mentioned, but Google Buzz was another one too. Think it acted as a neat alternative to using Facebook comments or Diqus when it was active. But yeah, my record with tech predictions is not exactly a great one.
- Steel_Phoenix 9y agoProjection mapping. It seems like a natural step between standard interfaces and AR. We've had the tech for a while. I want devices that use projected touchscreens. I loved the idea of Augmented Reality Sandbox as a type of toy for my kids. It seems like the tech got skipped over in anticipation of an AR tech that has yet to hit market.
- hyperpallium 9y agoI liked this too. There have been some phones with it; problem is projectors use a lot of power.
- pers0n 9y agoE-ink RSS Virtual reality Webrtc FirefoxOS
- aryehof 9y agoI thought that we would see a world where we would increasingly "mash-up" a solution using different services accessible through APIs. One where service and data providers would provide a programmable interface to their functionality (and data), perhaps in addition to their own user-interface. It was conceivable for a time, however it didn't occur to me that doing so would mean no advertising dollars for them, unless they made their offering as "walled gardens". Truly to me, it seems that "advertising, marketing and consumerism" are what makes the world go around.
- Jeff_Brown 9y agoAnybody who thinks reading and writing is powerful, and anybody who thinks sharing is powerful, ought to be excited about knowledge graphs. Knowledge graphs are powerful -- they underpin Google search, Facebook, Siri, etc. And open source tools exist for keeping your own knowledge graph. (Here's my favorite: https://github.com/synchrony/smsn/wiki/ https://github.com/synchrony/smsn/wiki/. It has, to my knolwedge, two ongoing users.) I was part of a small study group once -- four to seven people, meeting daily for a couple hours to share economics notes. It was critical -- I could not have made it through the first year of grad school otherwise. Knowledge graphs can scale to far greater numbers of users. So many people are biting their nails about the rise of AI. I belive we could leverage existing technology to bring about human superintelligence before then. Internally, our minds work nonlinearly, but when it comes to written media, we process text linearly. That is slow, wasteful -- if someone writes a book full of gems of wisdom, but scatters redundant illustrations, obvious examples, or unnecessary motivating passages between them, you've got to wade through that chaff in order to find the gems. Knowledge graphs let us write and read nonlinearly -- faster, better targeted, hence able to cover more information, more kinds of information. It's like tables of contents all the way down. Writing is great because it allows a reader to build on the work of earlier writers. Knowledge graphs, in addition to that, let readers build on the work of other readers. If I mark a passage as "obvious" or "critical" or "beautiful", that metadata can guide another reader. Online systems already use this idea to some extent -- facebook likes, reddit and HN votes, etc. can help inform reader choices. But knowledge graphs in principle allow for arbitrarily general metadata -- for instance, "show me every statement [group] has written about [topic] which has been marked useful for [goal] by at least [number] readers". Publishing even a small body of useful, organized information can be extremely valuable. Craigslist, for instance. Although there was an obvious economic argument for publishing the information on Craigslist. In fact, economics might be making us stupid. Non-monetizable information is of enormous importance. Globally, we are experiencing an epistemic crisis. Huge swaths of the public mistrust science, journalism, history. We appear to be at least nearly as susceptible to fascism as we were in the thirties. The arguments for freedom of speech, or civil rights, or being kind to strangers, ought to be as obvious to us as which job pays how much money. Camus talked about something he called "philosophical suicide", wherein someone stops trying to think high thoughts. They fall into an economic routine, the specialize, their awareness narrows. They might excel at what they do. But a world full of such narrow thinking is a dangerous place. I had heart surgery, almost died, and for years after, knowledge-gardened furiously. I wrote, reviewed, organized, categorized. I pondered long passages and reduced them to a few words, which became easier to process. What is pleasure? What are the elements of consciousness? Where is my boundary of certainty in ethics? Can I enumerate the state space of a conversation? It was a transformative experience -- I changed from an awkward, selfish, angry young man to a warm, gregarious, relaxed middle-aged man. It was also slow, because I was working alone, and I used trees, which are less expressive than graphs. I can only dream of how transformative it would be to process those ideas in a group, nonlinearly, using a knowledge graph.
- firozansar 9y agoPersonally I thought Google Glass had the potential but technically its not dead yet.
- stfnhrrs 9y ago:CueCat this device allowed you to open up a link from a magazine or newspaper without typing it, truly a timesaver! I can't figure out why everyone wasn't using these. Also had a really cute form factor.