14 ms·
US private credit defaults hit record 9.2% in 2025, Fitch says
See also: https://alternativecreditinvestor.com/2025/10/22/us-banks-exposure-to-private-credit-hits-300bn/ https://alternativecreditinvestor.com/2025/10/22/us-banks-ex...
- FrustratedMonky 8mo agoThe US Ponzi scheme coming to an end. It works great while everything is going up. 2008 Financial Crisis was triggered by Oil prices. There were lots of problematic structural elements that were fine if nobody looked close. Oil was just the sideway hit on the building to knock it over. Just takes a nudge to collapse. And here we go again.
- reliabilityguy 8mo ago> 2008 Financial Crisis was triggered by Oil prices. Not by the subprime mortgages given to anyone with a pulse?
- alphawhisky 8mo agoNow the subprime credit of entire cities is being sold bank to bank. I'd argue that's a direct escalation of the 2008 credit crisis.
- floatrock 8mo agoI thought it was by the layers upon layers of interconnected unregulated derivatives valued at a few orders of magnitude above the underlying subprime mortgages given to anyone with a pulse.
- JumpCrisscross 8mo ago> it was by the layers upon layers of interconnected unregulated derivatives valued at a few orders of magnitude above the underlying subprime mortgages given to anyone with a pulse It was interconnected derivatives and structured products linked to banks that caused a liquidity crisis in the former to cause a crisis of confidence in the latter. Meanwhile: "In the letter, Morgan Stanley said the fund wasn’t designed to offer full liquidity because of the nature of its investments, and that credit fundamentals across the underlying portfolio have been broadly stable. The bank's shares fell 2% in premarket trading Thursday" [1]. [1] https://www.wsj.com/livecoverage/stock-market-today-dow-sp-500-nasdaq-03-12-2026/card/morgan-stanley-private-credit-fund-hit-with-redemption-requests-IS8PSZh497HC5aF4CkGN https://www.wsj.com/livecoverage/stock-market-today-dow-sp-5...
- kryogen1c 8mo ago> liquidity crisis in the former to cause a crisis of confidence in the latter Wait what? Your thesis is the GFC was caused by a liquidity crunch/bank run? Isn't that... not true? Isn't the proximal to distal chain of events government encouraged subprime loans -> inaacurately valued MBS -> exponential, unregulated derivative instruments -> leveraged contagion. What does market confidence have to do with any of that?
- JumpCrisscross 8mo ago> your thesis is the GFC was caused by a liquidity crunch/bank run? Isn't that... not true? It's absolutely proximally true and it's not just my thesis. From Wikipedia: "The first phase of the crisis was the subprime mortgage crisis, which began in early 2007, as mortgage-backed securities (MBS) tied to U.S. real estate, and a vast web of derivatives linked to those MBS, collapsed in value. A liquidity crisis spread to global institutions by mid-2007 and climaxed with the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers in September 2008, which triggered a stock market crash and bank runs in several countries" [1]. > government encouraged subprime loans -> inaacurately valued MBS -> exponential, unregulated derivative instruments -> leveraged contagion The subprime crisis shouldn't have been bigger than the S&L crisis [2]. What turned it into a financial crisis was the credit crunch that followed. That crunch was caused by folks running on banks that had sponsored these products. On "inaccurately valued MBS," note that the paper marked AAA mostly paid out like a AAA security. It would be like if you were perfectly good for your word and I lent you money, but then I wanted to sell on that debt to a third party who didn't trust you at a 50% discount. What does "properly valued" mean in that context? It's ambiguous in a dangerous way. (In this analogy, you wind up paying back the debt at face value. But years later, albeit on schedule.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_financial_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2008_financial_crisis [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Savings_and_loan_crisis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Savings_and_loan_crisis
- FrustratedMonky 8mo agoThat was the structural problem. Definitely bad. A weak economy propped up by some 'fake' money. Oil was more of the outside force that put a shock to that weak system.
- FrustratedMonky 8mo agoThat was the structural problem. But it was swept under the rug, it was hidden by market constantly going up. Ponzi schemes can hide in a market going up, because nobody is trying to pull money back out. Suddenly everyone wanting their money, and the shortfall suddenly become apparent. Oil prices suddenly made everyone try to pull money out, and 'woops there is nothing here'.
- floatrock 8mo agoI did make a snarky derivatives comment elsewhere in the thread, but I do see you're not wrong about oil prices peaking at $138 in June 2008 (Lehman collapsed in September 2008): https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DCOILBRENTEU https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DCOILBRENTEU
- marcosdumay 8mo agoI think the GP is trying to say that oil prices where the nudge that pushed the bad loans and derivatives out of stability. I don't remember oil getting expensive back then, but it's a long time ago.
- naijaboiler 8mo agoit did. GFC was a financial recession no doubt, but oil prices was one of the final things that tipped everything over. Oil prices climbed high, slowed economic activity a bit, and the whole financial that teetering just collapsed.
- m0llusk 8mo agoThere were many involved factors, but the 2008 financial crisis was started when Ben Bernanke raised interest rates.
- nine_zeros 8mo ago[dead]
- jacquesm 8mo agoThis time it took ~35 blows with a sledgehammer. You have to be impressed with the degree of resilience here, even a chaos monkey like Trump has a hard time completely destroying the US economy even when all checks & balances utterly fail.
- fabian2k 8mo agoIt feels a bit like in a Road Runner cartoon. We already ran well past the cliff, just haven't noticed yet that we should be falling down.
- ToucanLoucan 8mo agoTrump is a symptom, not a cause. One of probably hundreds of mediocre failsons gifted unbelievable wealth in the birth lottery who’s greatest achievement in life was managing to not lose all of it to his awful business acumen and utter refusal to listen to a single living person. Every industry’s leadership is full of trumps, many more palatable personally, many far better spoken, many even with better politics but none fundamentally are any actually better for society. They don’t understand their company, the products it makes, they have utterly no care for anything besides the quarterly stock price and their lack of care costs real people their jobs and ruins the products we use every day. And, they are why every company is ripping the copper out of its own walls instead of actually building a business that will last.
- thelastgallon 8mo agoSpot on! I worked with execs at a FAANG, they don't have the foggiest idea what they are doing! Extraordinarily dumb, and they get all their 'information' and take decisions from gatekeeping orgs which are super incompetent. This is the one org where incompetency is a super weapon. These orgs don't take competent people, because they won't be loyal to you and do your bidding. And worse, if the execs realize there is a competent person, they will come straight you, bypassing the gatekeeping hierarchy.
- blakesterz 8mo ago"Most of the private credit loans were floating rate and tied to the federal funds rate, which has persisted at a high level over the past three years. Fitch pointed to this as a catalyst for last year's defaults." I wanted to dismiss that and say ... but it's not really historically high. I suppose it really is not IF you look WAY back. It actually has persisted at a relatively high level if you look back to 2009, which is more than a short time now. I guess it is fair to say the federal funds rate has persisted at a high level over the past three years now isn't it? https://www.macrotrends.net/2015/fed-funds-rate-historical-chart https://www.macrotrends.net/2015/fed-funds-rate-historical-c... Also interesting to note, "Fitch recorded NO defaults in the software sector last year. The rating agency noted it categorizes software issuers into their main target market sectors when applicable."
- trgn 8mo ago> but it's not really historically high i dont think the inflationary seventies and eighties are great lodestar low interest rates are historically a sign of a stable polity and economy. so if anything, we want the conditions for prolonged low interest rates, rather than prolonged high interest rate.
- ferguess_k 8mo agoThe problem of the current situation is that even 5% is considered as a high interest for many people, if not most of them. Inflation already pushes up the base price, and if the interest rate keeps on 5% and above many people simply won't consume, which will further pull down the economy. For example, we decided to keep our vehicle for another 4-5 years instead of buying a new one. The same Hyundai vehicle of the same model, but different year (2026 v.s. 2020), has gone up 8,000 CAD (10K CAD considering tax), with a much higher rate (5.99% v.s. 0%). There is no way I'm buying another car in the foreseeable future. We can definitely afford it, but we won't. The whole world has pushed up prices of food, housing and pretty much everything higher. This is the real problem -- although I wouldn't say it is the root problem.
- cmiles8 8mo agoPrivate credit is cracking and lending standards are tightening behind the scenes. If you’re not building cash reserves right now you’re going to wish you had. The distressed opportunities ahead go to whoever kept dry powder while everyone else was chasing growth. If your business is light on free cash flow (ie everyone in AI at the moment) buckle up as there are storm clouds ahead. If you’re running a business that relies on external cash (VCs, loans/bonds, etc) to keep things going things will get very ugly.
- mothballed 8mo agoWell it only took 5 years of destroying responsible savers with every policy imaginable to make sure they get crushed by those who availed themselves of the negative real rate loan inflation machine. How many people are left remaining that were dumb enough to take that strategy and are still standing? If you were operating on a cash basis for the last 5 years you were mostly wiped out by people leveraged to the 9s on debts and meanwhile your buying power was erased.
- cmiles8 8mo agoInterest rates on things like CDs and low-risk bonds have been decent for a while now. It’s not been painful to sit on cash reserves provided you were smart about where the cash was parked. It’s not an either/or, it’s just a question of who was participating in the boom while preparing for storms ahead vs those all in on the boom. What implodes in the period ahead are things that are massively over leveraged and can’t absorb a hit without doubling down again with more funding/loans and such. These are the folks and companies that get wiped out.
- persecutor 8mo agoGo figure. Employers don't want to pay living wages or hire anyone these days.
- persecutor 8mo agoGo figure. Employers don't want to pay living wages or hire.
- WarmWash 8mo agoEmployers will never be able to pay a living wage, because the real problem is a lack of housing. Rents and mortgages will always outrun wage increases in the current market.
- flammafex 8mo agoStop paying rent. Stop going to work. Pirate everything. No constitution. No copyright. Starve the beast. Don't let anyone who bought into this way of life get away with robbing the rest of us. And don't let anyone who brought children into this cruelty hear the end of it: what they did was evil.
- 3842056935870 8mo agoNow Skid Row hobos are commenting on HN, just great.
- hnthrow0287345 8mo agoPeople have cried wolf or been wrong about incoming crashes and bubble pops so many times that this signal -- whether it's a good signal or not -- simply won't change anything I do. I'm sure someone somewhere could make a trade off of this article and this signal is definitely for them.
- bluGill 8mo agoEven if this was a reliable signal for most of us it shouldn't change anyway. Timing the market is hard, so if you have a job keep investing in your retirement accounts and let dollar cost averaging work it out - odds are you are buying at fire sale prices. If you are one of those who lose your job - it doesn't matter much if the economy is good or bad, you need to adjust a lot of things (even in the best of times sometimes by chance you can be out of work for a long time) If you are the manager of a mutual fund you can take useful action on signals like this if you can figure out what they mean. Most people don't have enough money to be worth trying to take action.
- bittercynic 8mo agoYou may not be able to properly let dollar cost averaging do its thing if you rely on your job to invest, since there's a high correlation between periods where people are out of work and periods where asset prices are lower.
- bluGill 8mo agoEven in the worst part of the great depression 75% of the people had a job. Most years where much better. Don't get me wrong, if you don't have a job things are bad. If you have a job but it isn't giving good raises, or it is a worse job than you are qualified for things are bad. However things are not hopeless for the majority of people even when things are really bad, and you can get through it.
- vmbm 8mo agoIt is incredibly hard to make money going short. Even if you are right about the direction, most short positions require interest payments to hold, or have some sort of decay built into the structure. So timing is everything and even then, if the underlying security slowly grinds down (instead of a quick abrupt move) you could still lose if the interest/decay on the short position outruns the downward movement on the underlying. I have been actively trading in the market for a little over a year now, and while winning on a short position is probably the most satisfying trade for me, the overwhelming majority of those trades are losses and at this point I mostly treat them as hedges. I suspect that is true for most market participants as well.
- bargainbin 8mo agoLuckily debt will be solved by the power of AGI, right? Just one more data centre! One more GPU! It can nearly write a basic three tier application with only 10 critical security vulnerabilities all by itself! Definitely think we’re in for a rough year financial prospects wise, and doesn’t even feel like we recovered from the 2008 crash properly.
- lenerdenator 8mo agoWe didn't recover from the 2008 crash properly because we didn't introduce consequences for those who created it.
- SoftTalker 8mo agoIn fact we rewarded them. We bailed them out by printing a lot of money. We then printed more money during the pandemic to pay people to stay home and watch Netflix. Probably a lot more examples. All that money flowing around that has no basis in actual productivity or value created. It's got to correct at some point. One of the corrections is how much more everything costs now, but I don't think that has fully absorbed the excess.
- wussboy 8mo agoI would argue the second instance (pandemic) was much more nearly what a good government should do than the first one
- SoftTalker 8mo agoIt may be what they should have done, but the effect was still inflationary. There is no free lunch.
- piva00 8mo agoIt was inflationary but would spread out the pain over the recovery period after the crisis, the other option was to allow 100% of the pain to be felt immediately: economy shutting down, people losing their jobs, diminished household spending, less money circulating in the economy, businesses still running having fewer orders/customers, more people being laid off, all the way until the crisis passed. Between the latter and the former I believe the former was a much smarter choice in the medium to long term.
- bArray 8mo agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20260312130613/https://www.marketscreener.com/news/us-private-credit-defaults-hit-record-9-2-in-2025-fitch-says-ce7e5fd8df8fff2d https://web.archive.org/web/20260312130613/https://www.marke... ^ Encase the link also responds with this for you: Access Denied You don't have permission to access "http://www.marketscreener.com/news/us-private-credit-defaults-hit-record-9-2-in-2025-fitch-says-ce7e5fd8df8fff2d" on this server.
- rvnx 8mo agoPretty sure the solution that US politicians will find will be to create new dollars out of thin air, so instead of increasing taxes they increase the money supply. Of course this is going to increase prices, but then they can blame China / Russia / Iran whoever is the scapegoat at that time.
- tartoran 8mo agoThat’s a tax on the poor
- bee_rider 8mo agoIt would cause inflation, isn’t that sort of a tax on people who have more wealth than income? (Which includes people like retirees, so, I’m not saying this is a universally good thing).
- bad_haircut72 8mo agoNo because assets hold their worth. Poor people have no assets
- mothballed 8mo agoPoor people are hit a lot harder, but rich still have to pay capital gains on inflation even despite having no real change in value. So the rich pay inflation at the rate * 0.2. Poor pay it at the rate * 1.0 (5x the rate of the rich).
- JumpCrisscross 8mo ago> rich still have to pay capital gains on inflation “Pay” is doing a lot of work there. My house is half equity half debt. The debt gets to be paid off with inflated dollars. And I pay no capital gains on the appreciation. I can, however, tap it for liquidity if I need it.
- rglover 8mo agoMisleading title* > The default rate among U.S. corporate borrowers of private credit rose to a record 9.2% in 2025 Emphasis added. Headline makes it sound like retail credit, not corporate specifically. *Edit: Not misleading, just an unfamiliar term/usage from my perspective. I'm not a finance guy so didn't know the difference and assumed others wouldn't either. Mea culpa.
- lxgr 8mo agoPrivate as in private (i.e. non-public) corporation, not as in individual/retail/natural person borrowers.
- kgwgk 8mo agoThat’s not what it means though. It’s done through a partnership. Or not, if we count Business Development Companies as “private credit” - but then they are not usually private corporations either.
- airstrike 8mo agoFWIW when I read "private credit" I think of private issuers, not retail.
- Mattwmaster58 8mo agoThat's exactly where my mind went as soon as I read the title. HN rules say to "use the original title, unless it is misleading". I think the original title meets the misleading bar but I can't speak for other readers.
- omcnoe 8mo ago"Private credit" is a finance term of art. It could be misleading if you don't have context for the correct definition, but that's true of many posts on this site.
- BikiniPrince 8mo ago
- mikkupikku 8mo ago[flagged]
- SegfaultSeagull 8mo agoThis comment should be flagged for casting aspersions on a minority group.
- mikkupikku 8mo agoZionism is an ideology, not a "minority group". People associate with it due to their values (most often, Christianity), not because of the way they were born.
- computronus 8mo agoImportant to note that this is about "U.S. corporate borrowers of private credit", so companies and not individuals.
- airstrike 8mo agoSkip the blogspam and read the original article: https://www.reuters.com/business/us-private-credit-defaults-hit-record-92-2025-fitch-says-2026-03-06/ https://www.reuters.com/business/us-private-credit-defaults-...
- tetromino_ 8mo agoPaywalled
- _ache_ 8mo agoWhat the hell ?! Nearly 10% ?! How can it be?! World wide, it seems to be around 4% since 2004. Page 22 (French but it's just numbers, you can read it). <https://www.eib.org/files/publications/thematic/gems_default_statistics_private_and_sub_sovereign_lending_2001_2019_fr.pdf https://www.eib.org/files/publications/thematic/gems_default...>
- Ekaros 8mo agoIt is easy to keep your head above water level for surprisingly long times. Just look how some people in retail manage to rack up credit card and other type of debt. And it is especially so when money given is not their own, but instead they get to take cut. Which these funds can do. They might even just take promises that you will pay in future and even allow adding the interest on top of loan amount. Numbers look good, bonuses look good. Fundamentally this can only last so long and now is the time it starts to blow up.
- tsunamifury 8mo agoYea the market will correct any time now from 2009. Things will stay the way they are for as long as people want them to. The economy and money is fundamentally made up. It’s so funny when these types come out and start talking about made up fundamentals as if they are physics.
- SpaceL10n 8mo agoI'm not surprised. Weren't we getting signals like 3 or 4 months ago that used car repossessions were ticking up? That's a breaking point for folks. The economic boulder keeps rolling and I'm not wearing any shoes. Spiking the price of oil is definitely going to help. This too shall pass?
- tsunamifury 8mo agoWrong market
- javcasas 8mo agoI have been following this development for a couple weeks, and now it's on HN. How long until the elevator guy tells me about it?
- ycombinatornews 8mo agoYou have an elevator guy?! /s
- JumpCrisscross 8mo agoYeah, I'm going down a bit of a rabbit hole this morning. Turns out Wells Fargo's $59.7bn of private-credit lending is equal to 44% of its CE Tier 1 capital [1]. Meanwhile, Deutsche Bank got back to being Deutsche Bank while I was not looking [2]. [1] https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/72971/000007297125000239/ex993-wellsfargo3q25pres.htm https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/72971/00000729712500... [2] https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/deutsche-bank-highlights-private-credit-risks-portfolio-grows-2026-03-12/ https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/deutsche-bank-highl...
- RobRivera 8mo agoDeutsche gonna Deutsche. Recruitment tables should just have a banner that reads 'we've already spent your bonus on legal fees, here's some chocolate'
- JumpCrisscross 8mo agoI'm re-running some of the Fed's stress tests and, somehow, still find myself flabbergasted that DB is at the top of my risk list. Despite only having $12bn of exposure, if they see a 60% loss on that risk alone (assuming 60% recovery and 1.5x leverage), they breach their 4.5% capital requirement. That's the lowest threshold I'm finding across all of the banks the Fed stress tests. Now 50% loss means wipe out. But given the size of the portfolio, there is also the concentration risk. A single private-credit firm going bust shouldn't take out a bank. But that seems–seems!–to be what I'm seeing.
- wizardforhire 8mo agoAs long as nobody knows then it isn’t risk… /s
- r_lee 8mo agodon't worry, they're adopting AI
- JumpCrisscross 8mo agoReason this number caught my eye: last year the Fed's stress tests found "loss rates from [non-bank financial institution] exposures (i.e., the percentage of loans that are uncollectible) were estimated at 7%, under a severe recession in scenario one" [1]. That's the scenario in which unemployment goes to 10%, home prices crash by 33%, the stock market halves and Treasuries trade at zero percent yield [2]. [1] https://www.mfaalts.org/industry-research/2025-fed-stress-test-private-credit-and-hedge-funds-are-not-a-systemic-risk/ https://www.mfaalts.org/industry-research/2025-fed-stress-te... [2] https://www.federalreserve.gov/publications/2025-june-dodd-frank-act-stress-test-introduction.htm?utm_source=chatgpt.com https://www.federalreserve.gov/publications/2025-june-dodd-f...
- npilk 8mo agoWhat's odd is according to the article, this index estimated an ~8% default rate in 2024. So maybe the stress test was measuring something different? It's weird to think the stress test would find a lower loss rate during a severe recession than in the most recent year with data available.
- JumpCrisscross 8mo ago> maybe the stress test was measuring something different? The Fed is measuring the loss on bank loans to the private-credit lenders. A 10% portfolio loss shouldn't result in those lenders defaulting to their banks. By my rough estimate, one can halve the portfolio loss rate to get the NBFI-to-bank loss rate. So a 10% portfolio loss means we're around a 5% expected long-run loss to the banks. Which is still weirdly high, so I feel like I must be missing something...
- adam_arthur 8mo agoThe 9% of borrowers defaulting stat cited in the title is not the same as 9% of the loanbook defaulting. As stated in the article, 9% is the number of borrowers that defaulted, which was concentrated in smaller borrowers (thus smaller loans). And then, again, you can say probably half of the dollar amount of those defaults are recoverable. Bond defaults spiked to around 6% in aggregate in 2008, to use a worst case example.
- lizknope 8mo agoI've never heard the term private credit so I googled it. > Private credit refers to loans provided to businesses by non-bank institutions—such as private equity firms, hedge funds, and alternative asset managers—rather than traditional banks . Is that correct? So if these companies go under does anyone care? If they go under are they a systemic risk to the economy like the banks in 2008 that got a taxpayer bailout?
- Ekaros 8mo agoTwo funny things: Banks have lend to these institutions as they couldn't lend themselves. Might be systematic risk. Lot of pension capital is tied to these vehicles. So they go under. Many people won't be getting their pensions in short or long term...
- we_have_options 8mo agoWell, yes, as the article mentions. If this increases a bank's losses, then the bank could become insolovent.
- SlinkyOnStairs 8mo ago> So if these companies go under does anyone care? This is nowhere near as bad as the 2008 crisis, no. The banks don't really use the checking/savings account money for this. If you've invested in something that either invests in Private Credit or is reliant on Private Credit, then it'll suck for you personally. ... One teeny tiny extremely important detail: Private Credit is bankrolling the AI industry's datacenter construction. If anything happens to significantly increase interest rates, several datacenter companies and Oracle go bankrupt. The other big tech firms have taken on lots of debt as well so expect spending cuts there too, even if they survive. The systemic risk isn't in "bankers fucked it up again", it's in the AI bubble.
- azath92 8mo agoI find the money stuff newsletter by Matt Levine (bloomberg) great for this, the link is behind a paywal, but the newsletter is free. strong rec. todays newseltter https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/newsletters/2026-03-11/private-credit-gets-marked-down https://www.bloomberg.com/opinion/newsletters/2026-03-11/pri... From that newseltter: > At the Financial Times, Jill Shah and Eric Platt report: >JPMorgan Chase ... informed private credit lenders that it had marked down the value of certain loans in their portfolios, which serve as the collateral the funds use to borrow from the bank, according to people familiar with the matter. >... >The loans that have been devalued are to software companies, which are seen as particularly vulnerable to the onset of AI. ... From what i can tell the problem isn't that an individual who had cash to invest in a private (tech in this case) company goes down the problem is that a company "private credit firms run retail-focused funds (“business development companies” or BDCs)" which took out a bunch of loans to invest in private tech companies is now having the underlying assets that they got those loans against (long term investments in private tech companies) valued lower. the link im missing is what happens when people who also invested in BDCs want their money back, where their actual money is locked up in long term investments made to private tech companies, and their ability to get loans is now valued lower. I think this is called a "run" where if someone starts pulling money out, and ultimately you cant, then its a race to get your money out before others do, which applies to both the individuals and the institutional loans. Note: my quotes are from the bloomberg newsletter i mention, which helped me, not the OP article. And i am writing as much to clarify my own thinking as from a place of understanding. I welcome clarification.
- cs702 8mo agoTrouble has been brewing in private credit for quite a while, but lenders and investors have been reluctant to write anything down, resorting to all kinds of "extend and pretend" games to avoid write-downs.[a] tick-tock, tick-tock, tick-tock... --- [a] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47351462 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=47351462
- RobRivera 8mo agoWhat kind of trouble is brewing from the migration of partner capital committment to credit based on NAV? What is the risk, probability of actualizing the risk, and the outcome of actualized risk? The ticktock ticktock routine reads like baseless fearmongering to me.
- cs702 8mo agoMy understanding is that many private credit funds have been very lax about conducting basic due diligence on the creditworthiness of borrowers. For example, take First Brands, a multi-billion-dollar company which filed for bankruptcy last year. First Brands had pledged the same assets as collateral for loans from multiple private-credit funds. Those loans were being carried at a fantasy NAV of 100 cents per dollar, until suddenly they were not. Did none of these lenders submit UCC filings so other lenders could check which assets had already been pledged as collateral? Did none of these lenders ever check to see which assets had already been pledged? Did all these lenders make loans based on blind trust? Failing to check and verify that assets have not been pledged as collateral to other lenders is an amateur mistake. It's reckless, really. The equivalent in home-mortgage lending would for a mortgage lender never even bothering to check that a homeowner isn't getting multiple first-lien mortgages simultaneously on the same home, then forgetting to put the first lien on the property title. My take is that for many private credit funds, NAVs are basically fantasy.
- bombcar 8mo agoOnce you get outside of things that are highly standardized (like home loans to individuals) you quickly find out that no matter how regulated, finance is done on a handshake.
- gzread 8mo agoTo private credit firms. Most of what banks do is private credit, the news is them funding private credit firms.
- deleted 8mo ago[deleted]
- happytoexplain 8mo agoI don't know a lot about finance. What is the definition/significance of "firm" in this context (if that's not a complicated question)?
- lokar 8mo agoA private credit firm is a non-bank entity that raises money from wealthy investors, pension funds, etc to loan out to businesses. The funds are generally locked up for several years to match the duration of the loans. They also borrow money from banks to add leverage to this basic setup.
- aewens 8mo agoNot who you asked, but I think making the nuance between retail and corporate credit. With firms being corporate credit (i.e. we aren’t talking about individuals / retail).
- lokar 8mo agoNo. There are kind of 3 types of loans: - bonds. Loans interned to be bought by a range if investors and traded over time. Arranged and unwritten by investment banks. - bank loans. The classic loan. The bank takes depositor money (that the depositor can take back anytime!) and loans it to someone or some company. The bank holds the loan - private credit. Like a bank loan, but they get their money from long term investments by wealth people and institutions, add bank loans for leverage, and then hold the loan.
- JumpCrisscross 8mo ago
- plagiarist 8mo agoGovernment removes regulations, economy collapses, government bails out the wealthy, quants get ski trips and bonuses while families starve.
- NickC25 8mo agoAnd to make matters worse, those who remove regulations then get voted out, but show up on infotainment "opinion" shows disguised as news broadcasts....and whine that those who were voted in to fix the mess aren't fixing the problem fast enough, so those who caused the problem should be voted back in. And lo and behold, they get voted back in, to cause more damage.
- voidfunc 8mo agoIts a big beautiful system!
- sciencesama 8mo agoDemocracy
- frogperson 8mo agoIts un-fixable. The situation cant be explained simply enough for the majority of americans. Even if some of them do mange to understand, it will be quickly forgotten amid the flood of trump sewage we are sprayed with every day.
- RankingMember 8mo agoI think we'll get there (to explanation), but it'll be through the lizard-brain-level pain of poverty instead of rational understanding unless we get much better at communicating to the least willing to listen among us.
- butterlesstoast 8mo agoI picked a bad time to rewatch Mr. Robot
- kelp6063 8mo agoUnless I'm misunderstanding something, this isn't that big of a number in the larger scale of US banking; According to the numbers in the article that's only about 2.5% of all bank lending (300B/1.2T, with the 1.2T being ~10%)
- deleted 8mo ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 8mo ago> this isn't that big of a number in the larger scale of US banking It's not. It's just that we're seeing potentially 10% losses on the portfolio level [1], which could imply up to–up to!–5% losses to the banks' loans to those lenders. Again, tens of billions of dollars of losses are totally absorbable. But Morgan Stanley's stock price took a hit when it gated one of these funds [2]. And some banks (Deutsche Bank, somehow, fucking again, Deutsche Bank) have small ($12n) but concentrated portfolios where a single wipeout could materially impair their ~$80bn of risk-weighted assets. [1] https://www.reuters.com/business/us-private-credit-defaults-hit-record-92-2025-fitch-says-2026-03-06/ https://www.reuters.com/business/us-private-credit-defaults-... [2] https://www.wsj.com/livecoverage/stock-market-today-dow-sp-500-nasdaq-03-12-2026/card/morgan-stanley-private-credit-fund-hit-with-redemption-requests-IS8PSZh497HC5aF4CkGN https://www.wsj.com/livecoverage/stock-market-today-dow-sp-5...
- kelp6063 8mo agogood explanation, thanks
- JumpCrisscross 8mo agoYou're welcome! Also, bank credit is like $20tn in the U.S. [1]. [1] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/TOTBKCR https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/TOTBKCR
- dopamean 8mo agoyou're the only person replying to comments on this post that seems to know what they're talking about. what do you do for a living?
- cs702 8mo agoTrouble has been brewing in private credit for quite a while, but lenders and investors have been reluctant to write anything down, resorting to all kinds of "extend and pretend" games to avoid write-downs. tick-tock, tick-tock, tick-tock...
- deleted 8mo ago[deleted]
- rvz 8mo agoLooks like we have another problem in the banking system once again, even before AGI has even been fully realized. We are definitely in the year 2000 in this cycle [0] and between now and somewhere in 2030, a crash is incoming. Let's see how creative the banks will get to attempt to escape this conundrum. But until then... Probably nothing. [0] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45960032 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45960032
- NickC25 8mo ago>Let's see how creative the banks will get to attempt to escape this conundrum. They don't need to get creative, they just need to buy congress or the administration. Same as they've done every time things get messy. And you know what? It works every time.
- hedora 8mo agoWell, the question isn't "is there any consequence for the bank managers"? The answer to that is "No, never, not even during the French Revolution". The question is "How long can they keep extracting money before the economy implodes?" The people producing macroeconomic indicators in the US were fired about 6 months ago for putting out an honest report. Since then there's been very little correlation between public sentiment on the economy and the official indicators. So, we're definitely in some sort of overhang situation, where the economy is imploding, but the stock market goes up. I think that's unprecedented in the US. In developing countries, when this happens, it usually leads to things like hyperinflation. So, I guess the real questions are: "How do you short the dollar?", and "How can you tell when the banks start doing it?" so you know when to jump off the merry-go-round.
- kentonv 8mo agoSince a lot of people here aren't familiar with the private credit situation, here's my understanding, which comes almost entirely from reading Money Stuff, a daily column by Matt Levine. If you are a tech person who wants to learn about finance, I recommend it! It's a lot more entertaining than most finance industry reporting. "Private credit" is an idea that has been hot in finance for the last several years, originating from the great financial crisis (GFC). After the GFC, regulations made it very hard for banks to make business loans with any kind of risk anymore. So instead, new non-bank institutions stepped in to make loans to businesses. These "private credit" institutions raise money from investors, and lend it to businesses. The investors are usually institutions who are OK with locking up their money long-term, like insurance companies and pension funds. This all seems a lot safer than having banks making loans: banks get their funding from depositors, who are allowed to withdraw their deposit any time they want. So a bank really needs to hold liquid assets so they are prepared for a run on the bank, and corporate borrowing is not very liquid. Insurance companies and pension funds have much more predictability as to when they actually will need their money back, so can safely put it in private credit with long horizons. It's not quite so clean, though. It's actually common for banks to lend money directly to private credit lenders, who then lend it out to companies. But when this happens, typically the bank is only lending a fraction of the total and arranges that they get paid back first, so it's significantly less risky than if they were loaning directly to the companies. Of course, the non-bank investors get higher returns on their riskier investment. And the returns have been pretty good. Or were. With the banks suddenly retreating from this space, there was a lot of money to be made filling the gap, and so private credit got a reputation for paying back really good returns while being more predictable than the stock market. But this meant it got hot. Really hot. It got so hot that there were more people wanting to lend money than there were qualified borrowers. When that happens, naturally standards start to degrade. And then interest rates went up, after having been near-zero for a very long time. And now a lot of borrowers are struggling to pay back their loans on time. And the lenders need to pay back investors, so sometimes they are compromising by getting new investors to pay back the old ones, and stuff. It's getting precarious. Meanwhile a lot of private credit institutions are hoping to start accepting retail investors. Not because retail investors have a lot of money and are gullible, no no no. 401(k) plans are by definition locked up for many years, so obviously should be perfect for making private credit investments! Also those 401(k)s today are all being dumped into index funds which have almost zero fees, whereas private credit funds have high fees. Wait, that's not the reason though! But just as they are getting to the point of finding ways to accept retail investors, it's looking like the returns might not be so great anymore. Could be a crisis brewing. Even if the banks are pretty safe, it's not great if pensions and insurance companies lose a lot of money...
- Tesl 8mo agoOne guy has twice as much money as that. Can't be a big deal.
- deleted 8mo ago[deleted]
- erikig 8mo agoEquity/net worth is not quite the same as the liquid capital needed to cover losses or service debt.
- ploden 8mo ago> the top five lenders in the private credit market include Wells Fargo, which leads the way with $59.7bn (£44.8bn) in lending anything Wells Fargo leads in must be bad
- dakolli 8mo agoActually I believe they're just actually complying with new laws to disclose their balance sheets for these types of loans. Many other banks like JP Morgan have much higher amounts of these loans on their balance sheets, but refuse to report and are exploiting certain loopholes. The requirement to disclose has only existed for a year I believe, but many are kicking the can or claiming that it would cause them issues.
- lizknope 8mo agoWells Fargo so big its suing itself July 10, 2009 https://www.denverpost.com/2009/07/10/lewis-wells-fargo-so-big-its-suing-itself/ https://www.denverpost.com/2009/07/10/lewis-wells-fargo-so-b... My normal bank was acquired by Wells Fargo in 2008 and they also owned my mortgage. When I went to pay off my mortgage in 2012 they required a cashier's check for the final payment of around $80. I asked if we could do it electronically like all of the previous payments and they said no. So I walked into my local bank asking for a cashier's check of that amount and the bank teller told me that most people would accept a personal check for that little. I said yeah but YOU don't. She looked at me funny. So she asked who to make the cashier's check out to. I said "Wells Fargo" and she looked at me funny again and said "Wells Fargo is us, the check comes FROM Wells Fargo. Who do I put on the TO line" and I said "Wells Fargo" She again looked at me funny and I explained that I am paying off my mortgage. Wells Fargo is where I have my bank account and my mortgage. She said "Can't we just do it electronically?" to which I said "You would think but apparently your employer can't handle that and told me to get a cashier's check and FedEx overnight to them." She rolled her eyes and then started laughing.
- adabyron 8mo agoHighly recommend listening to past episodes on The Real Eisman Playbook podcast for more info on this topic & banking in general. https://podcasts.apple.com/bz/podcast/the-real-eisman-playbook/id1818671690 https://podcasts.apple.com/bz/podcast/the-real-eisman-playbo... He's one of the "Big Short" guys but more importantly he has great guests on. Everyone is trying to teach & inform, not sell. He's been calling this risk out for over a year, especially once the White House started trying to allow retirement accounts access to private credit. For a lot of people that was the big alert, even before Jamie Dimon said he saw "cockroaches".
- JumpCrisscross 8mo ago> He's been calling this risk out for over a year Any figures or lenders he's focussed on?
- adabyron 8mo agoI can't remember the names. Best bet if you don't want to listen is to just get summaries or transcriptions of the episodes you can an LMM questions on. The info on his podcasts isn't telling you who to short. It's more who has gone under & general knowledge.
- adam_arthur 8mo agoThere is so much misinformed fear-mongering about private credit right now. Important Facts: 1) The majority of private credit funds are classed as "permanent capital". When you put money into these vehicles, you give the Asset Manager discretion over when to give the money back. Redemptions are often gated at ~5% per quarter. (So there cannot, by definition, be a run on the bank) 2) Credit is senior to equity, so if you expect mass defaults in private credit, it means the majority of private equity is effectively wiped out. Private equity has to be effectively a 0 before private credit takes any losses. 3) The average "recovery rate" for senior secured loans is 80%. Even if private equity gets wiped to 0, the loss that private credit incurs is cushioned significantly by the collateral backing the loan. These are not unsecured loans the borrower can just walk away from. (The price of senior secured loans dropped by ~30% in 2008, as a worst case datapoint) 4) Default rates on many of the major private credit managers is ~<1% in recent years. There are other estimates stating higher default rates, but that often classifies PIK income as a default. A loan modified and extended with added PIK that ultimately gets repaid is not a "true" default. 5) Finally, it's true that NAVs are likely overstated, but generally it's by a modest amount. Every Asset Manager today could go out tomorrow, mark NAVs down by 20% and suddenly there is no crisis. (The stocks of Asset Managers have already traded down such that this seems expected and priced in anyway)
- JumpCrisscross 8mo ago> Private equity has to be effectively a 0 before private credit takes any losses Technically yes. But the overlap between private equity as it's commonly described and private credit is slim. > average "recovery rate" for senior secured loans is 80% Oooh, source? (I'm curious for when this was measured.) > A loan modified and extended with added PIK that ultimately gets repaid is not a "true" default True. It's a red flag, nonetheless. > Every Asset Manager today could go out tomorrow, mark NAVs down by 20% and suddenly there is no crisis Correct. The question is if 20% is enough, and if a 20% markdown creates a vicious cycle as funding for e.g. re- or follow-on financing dries up. You seem knowledgable about this. I'm coming in as an equities man. Would you have some good sources you'd recommend that make the dovish cash for private credit today?
- 8mo ago
- fairity 8mo agoSo, if I’m following: Banks are lending to private equity firms to fund purchases of businesses. Many of these businesses are SaaS which means their valuations are tumbling. It seems possible that valuations tumble so much that the private equity owner no longer has any incentive to operate the business, bc all future cash flows will belong to the bank. What happens in practice then? Will banks actually step in and take operational control? Will the banks renegotiate terms such that the private equity owners are incentivized to continue as stewards? Or, will they prefer to force a business sale immediately?
- JumpCrisscross 8mo ago> Banks are lending to private equity firms to fund purchases of businesses Not quite. Private credit is to debt what private equity is to equity. (Technically, any non-bank originated debt that isn't publicly traded is private credit. Conventionally, it's restricted to corporate borrowers.) So bank exposure to private credit generally means banks lending to non-banks who then lend to corporate borrowers.
- jmalicki 8mo agoWhat does this typically look like? Who is the intermediary here between the bank and corporate borrowers - are these buy side created SPVs?
- JumpCrisscross 8mo ago> Who is the intermediary Business development companies [0]. Blue Owl. BlackRock [1]. > are these buy side created SPVs? Great question! Not always [2]. [0] https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/private-credit-funds-slide-investors-sell-out-2026-03-12/ https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/private-credit-fund... [1] https://www.blackrock.com/corporate/newsroom/press-releases/article/corporate-one/press-releases/blackrock-acquires-hps-investment-partners https://www.blackrock.com/corporate/newsroom/press-releases/... [2] https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/meta-secures-30bn-blue-owl-finance-package-for-louisiana-data-center-report/ https://www.datacenterdynamics.com/en/news/meta-secures-30bn...
- NoboruWataya 8mo agoThe concern here seems to be that the credit risk on the underlying borrowers is being transferred to banks through the loans made by the banks to the private credit firms. But the banks' lending to the private credit firms is subject to the same regulations and constraints as their lending to other borrowers (the same regulations and constraints that led them not to lend to the underlying borrowers in the first place). When banks lend to private credit funds/firms, it tends to be through senior, secured loans which will be less risky than the underlying loans.
- JumpCrisscross 8mo ago> the banks' lending to the private credit firms is subject to the same regulations and constraints as their lending to other borrowers Yes. > the same regulations and constraints that led them not to lend to the underlying borrowers in the first place No. Non-bank financial institutions (NBFIs a/k/a shadow banks) compete with banks. They also borrow from banks. > When banks lend to private credit funds/firms, it tends to be through senior, secured loans which will be less risky than the underlying loans Correct. Assuming 1.5x leverage and 60% recovery, you'd expect no more than half of portfolio losses to transmit to their lenders.
- NoboruWataya 8mo ago> No. Non-bank financial institutions (NBFIs a/k/a shadow banks) compete with banks. They also borrow from banks. How is this inconsistent with what I said? I was just making the point that the reason for the rise of private credit is that banks are less willing / able to lend, particularly to riskier borrowers, as a result of post-2008 banking regulations. So private lenders have stepped in to fill that gap.
- JumpCrisscross 8mo ago> the reason for the rise of private credit is that banks are less willing / able to lend, particularly to riskier borrowers, as a result of post-2008 banking regulations. So private lenders have stepped in to fill that gap That may have been true once. It's rarely true now. Banks and shadow banks compete for the same borrowers.
- booleandilemma 8mo agoRelated: Veteran fund manager George Noble warns that a private credit crisis may be unfolding in real time https://finance.yahoo.com/news/veteran-fund-manager-george-noble-093001508.html?guccounter=1 https://finance.yahoo.com/news/veteran-fund-manager-george-n...
- dkga 8mo agoFor those that want a broader context on private credit, the Bank for International Settlements has been publishing some great material on the topic, including the connections between private credit and other corners of the financial system. Some examples follow. --- [0] https://www.bis.org/publ/qtrpdf/r_qt2503b.htm https://www.bis.org/publ/qtrpdf/r_qt2503b.htm [1] https://www.bis.org/publ/bisbull106.pdf https://www.bis.org/publ/bisbull106.pdf [2] https://www.bis.org/publ/work1267.pdf https://www.bis.org/publ/work1267.pdf
- nstj 8mo agoFor the OP: what’s your view on the overall private credit situation? Who are the bag holders and how bad is the contents of the bag? You seem to be answering a number of other questions in the post so interested to hear your impetus for sharing in the first place. nb: thank you for being an ongoing contributor to the site! I see your handle cropping up a lot in substantive conversations
- michaelbarton 8mo agoI wonder if anyone can say if there’s much risk of sub prime private credit? Not sure if that’s the right term. My understanding is that synthetic CDOs are the rise again, this backed by private credit - which the article is discussing
- nicwolff 8mo agoMeanwhile: https://www.marketscreener.com/news/us-private-credit-defaults-hit-record-9-2-in-2025-fitch-says-ce7e5fd8df8fff2d https://www.marketscreener.com/news/us-private-credit-defaul...
- resters 8mo agoBanks are following incentives that exist because of government policies, and in doing that they create significant moral hazard. The finance industry's main innovation is rent seeking. We all know what is going to happen, it's just a question of when.
- newzino 8mo ago[flagged]
- ineedasername 8mo agoLast year Jamie Dimon said there were some going to be some “cockroaches” found lingering unattended to in lots of private credit portfolios— the implication at the time was not that it was systemic and deep, merely that various incentives and market forces have meant a shakeout of either the incremental as-it-happens variety or slightly larger ones of multiple happening at a time. Since then I’ve seen small things indicating lots of people quietly checking their books for such. In the last week or two this has accelerated. A lot. Every few days there are ratchets tightening things up. Dimon just put some hard limits on some private credit lines and what they could take out. A few other banks trying to take other precautions.
- smallmancontrov 8mo ago> the implication at the time was not that it was systemic and deep How is that what you took away from this? > When you see one cockroach, there are probably more… Everyone should be forewarned on this. -Jamie Dimon
- ineedasername 8mo agoI took that to be what it was intended it convey, and what Dimon wanted people to feel about what he said. That maybe they should poke around their own books but he wasn’t telling people “well ‘08 all over again” My own read of the subtext was something a bit different. Dimon saw something he really didn’t like and my guess would be that more than just a handful of people at JP Morgan were having their next few days or longer personal plans cancelled—- or that it had already settled from something like that— to find whatever they had in the way of cockroaches. And so Dimon’s public statement was a soft nudge to try and get others to do the same, cautiously and slowly without panicking. It’s tea leaves but the time since then seems to bear that out, with right now’s world economic volatility being a good opportunity for many places to go a little more aggressively in reigning in whatever they have in cockroach’s with some cover from that volatility and distraction to not have to explain too much more or get too much scrutiny that would accelerate things beyond manageable. Overall, my take was that Dimon is still probably pissed off about SV bank and trying to make sure whatever shape or size this private credit rot may have doesn’t go down quite that haphazardly.
- iwontberude 8mo agoUnemployment increasing, CPI fairly stable, and credit tightening will cause the Fed to open the spigot. Here is a good entry for precious metals.
- goldylochness 8mo agois this not the subprime mortgage problem all over again?
- etempleton 8mo agoSame basic issue, but not exactly the same thing in terms of sector or potential impact. The sub prime mortgage delinquency rate remains low as home loans became much more strict after 2008. So that portion of the economy is relatively safe right now. PE is a much smaller market and so the fallout from a private equity collapse, while significant, would theoretically be less likely to negatively disrupt the total market to the same extent as the 2008 housing crisis.
- biffles 8mo agoHaving worked in IB / PE my whole career (both buying & selling businesses and distressed debt, primarily in the middle market) it is always fun when my area of domain hits the front page and I can read the confident opinions folks have on my industry. I think most people in this thread are missing the boat. First, it’s important to realize that “default” does not imply wipeout. Default just means that you’ve violated a credit agreement, and that can be solved many different ways. Sometimes it’s solved by the sponsor restructuring the debt (injecting equity, asking for covenant/interest relief); sometimes it’s a true Ch 11 bankruptcy; in very rare cases, it can be a true Ch 7 liquidation. But even in those destruction-of-value scenarios, first-lien recoveries run 50-70% of “par value” borrowed. Lenders are smart, their job is to underwrite these deals, and they’re compensated for this with healthy interest rates - typically S+500-650 plus fees, which comes out to 10–12% unlevered returns. So they are basically pricing junk bonds, and in exchange get senior secured risk with real covenants around what the business can / can’t do. Second, the myth that PE firms can just saddle a company with debt at the lender’s expense with no skin in the game and walk away with a profit while the company files for bankruptcy is hilarious, in part because it obviously doesn’t hold up to the slightest bit of scrutiny. The typical PE firm is buying a middle market business for 10-12x EBITDA on average. In today’s world, lenders will usually let you put 4.5-5.5x EBITDA on the business as leverage (in the ZIRP era, you could push things up closer to 7x, sometimes above that if it’s a stellar business). So on a typical 10x deal with 5x debt, 50% of the capital structure is PE firm equity which gets wiped out first before the lender loses a dollar. If that happens, the PE fund’s investor returns crater, which means no more Fund II/III/IV, which means no more fees for them to generate. (As an aside, the typical “fees” paid by portfolio companies to the PE firm are, at least in modern limited partner agreements, largely offset against management fees and recaptured by the fund’s investors. The PE firm is not getting rich off these fees, at least not anymore.) Third, private credit is not your local commercial bank. Many of the largest private credit firms are actually PE firms themselves - e.g., Apollo, Ares, and Blackstone, who are all known as “private equity” have actually become more valuable to the public investor community due to their private credit business. These are not sadsack regional banks and credit unions getting hoodwinked by New York finance elites. In many cases, they are the same firms, with the same resources (in-house restructuring / “workout” teams, portfolio ops, etc.). It’s important to realize that private credit funds raise capital from institutions and HNW individuals with locked-up commitments - it is the exact same investor base as PE, and fundamentally a very similar business, they just invest at a different part of the capital stack. Because of this, risk of contagion is very low. Bank exposure to private credit is something like 1.5% of their portfolio - it is tiny. The extent of the blowback will be that a pension fund investing in alternatives has a poor return in one asset class across a dozen - it’s not systemic risk. Finally, what IS true is that pre-ZIRP portfolios and software-heavy credits (something like 15-20% of leveraged loans outstanding) are in a tough spot. These businesses are either failing or they have too much debt that has “re-rated” to higher interest rates as interest rate hedges fell off. What happens from here is that the companies with structural issues in their business model will cease to exist (e.g., certain SaaS businesses). This happens all the time - it’s capitalism. But the good businesses are not going to disappear because of a bad cap structure - they will just get recapitalized.
- PowerElectronix 8mo agoOh, that's why they were pushing so hard to get private equity into 401k's. They wanted to pass the bag to regular folks.
- renecito 8mo agoOk, I think I now got where all the AI money was coming from.