30 ms·
I think that just like it happened with Apple after they made it out of bankruptcy, Microsoft being the cool guys phase is slowly over. Xamarin is no more, aft
by pjmlp 1y ago
I think that just like it happened with Apple after they made it out of bankruptcy, Microsoft being the cool guys phase is slowly over.
Xamarin is no more, after the whole MAUI rewrite without backwards compatibility to Xamarin.Forms, killing VS4Mac, shortly after having rewriten the underlying Xamarin based IDE into Mac, what survives is a subset of Xamarin tech for mobile and WebAssembly workloads.
.NET is now cross platform, but only as long as it doesn't hurt VS sales, with GUI workloads, profilers, still being mostly Windows only, and partially supported on VSCode, which also has the same VS license.
A proper cross platform IDE experience requires getting Rider.
Then there is the issue they seem to be shoting into all directions, with GUI frameworks, Web, Blazor, Aspire, to see what sticks.
Github even with the previous CEO was already a delivery mechanism for Azure and AI efforts, now it will be full steam ahead, as per new org chart.
VC++ after betting other compilers in C++20 support, seems to have lost its resources struggling to deliver C++23, and also probably affected by the Secure Future Initiative, and decisions for safer languages.
But hey 4 trillion valuation, so from shareholders point of view, everything is going great.
- brightball 1y agoI’m glad Gitlab is still an option, just sitting there waiting to absorb the market pivot if Microsoft takes it the wrong way.
- brabel 1y agohttps://www.opencode.net/ https://www.opencode.net/
- ikidd 1y agoI see more people jump for Codeberg these days.
- mindcrash 1y agoOr even better, claim full sovereignty (again) and install Forgejo (https://forgejo.org/ https://forgejo.org/) on your own hardware. You'll get the same experience as Codeberg, because Codeberg is in fact running on Forgejo
- taxborn 1y agoIt’s a great piece of software. I set it up in a Docker container, and have a few of their CI runners on a couple machines I own. Great experience so far.
- Talinx 1y agoOneDev (https://onedev.io/ https://onedev.io/) is self-hostable, too, and works great.
- rockskon 1y agoHosting costs for self-hosting a popular git repo are prohibitive for many people.
- beeb 1y agoPeople aren't on these hosted platforms only for the git experience, they are for the social aspects and discoverability too.
- rsolva 1y agoForgejo is hard at work, defining and implementing federation, adding cross-forge interaction, social functionality and discovery: https://forgejo.org/faq/#is-there-a-roadmap-for-forgejo https://forgejo.org/faq/#is-there-a-roadmap-for-forgejo
- rapnie 1y agoAlso check the ActivityPub protocol extension for forge federation at https://forgefed.org https://forgefed.org which may be on the roadmap [0] of the Forgejo federation support, after they have implemented basic ActivityPub protocol support. Right now ForgeFed needs to mature a lot further, but also needs the help of the developer community to achieve that. [0] https://codeberg.org/forgejo-contrib/federation/src/branch/main/FederationRoadmap.md https://codeberg.org/forgejo-contrib/federation/src/branch/m...
- lordofgibbons 1y ago
- jzb 1y agoI love Codeberg, but they're struggling with growth/scaling -- if folks want to see Codeberg succeed, they need to open their wallets.
- michaelcampbell 1y agoBig limitation on private repos there.
- taxborn 1y agoAdditionally there is Codeburg/Forgejo, and for the atproto-enjoyers, tangled.sh is a new face that feels like it could be good.
- dboreham 1y agoAnd gitea (originally a Forgejo fork).
- iamdamian 1y ago> And gitea (originally a Forgejo fork). I don't think this is right. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gitea#Forgejo_fork https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gitea#Forgejo_fork.
- fisiu 1y agoVice versa, forgejo is a gitea fork.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- overfeed 1y agoDid you mean to say gitea was originally a Gogs fork? The lineage of those projects is Gogs => Gitea => Forgejo
- ghc 1y agoAmong enterprises I work with, I'm seeing way more migration to self-hosted Gitlab than I was a few years ago. Even among Azure-dependent orgs.
- rpep 1y agoI think there’s some risk with this though too - more and more is behind the enterprise tier. People try to work around this in various ways but its an unsatisfying experience. For e.g. trying to enforce merge request approval with pipeline stages.
- chaosharmonic 1y agoAs a Deno user, this news also makes me see more value in JSR. (Relative to npm's ownership, that is.)
- Aeolun 1y agoGitlab is not really an option for me. Their pricing is absolutely out of this world.
- hk__2 1y agoYes, as long as you don’t look at their pricing :/
- betteryourweb 1y agoI can see Gitlab in the same position in the near future. Only a matter of time...
- sunaookami 1y agoLeft Gitlab after they changed the UI nearly every month, it's still very cumbersome to use.
- waihtis 1y agoYou really think Microsoft has been ”cool” for the past decade or so? First the rampant spyware, then they gradually wreck every single piece of software into unusable buggy AI-slop-mess just to play the trashy MBA valuation games. I still hold nostalgic value for the old OSes (say up to XP/7) but everything after has been nothing but maximal profit extraction. Dont get me started on Azure
- riffraff 1y agoNot OP, but I do. The '90s/00s era of people hating on M$ and picturing them as the Borg had left room to the 10s/20s of MS being "friendly" and releasing open source and free things (typescript, vs code, core.net, wsl, work on python etc) and not completely screwing up acquisitions like GitHub or Mojang. Windows became adware, and office became some crappy online thing, but _microsoft_ had became nicer and gained goodwill. This seems to have started evaporating in the last year or so.
- owebmaster 1y agoThey didn't become cool, some people just let themselves get fooled by what they were offering for free.
- coliveira 1y agoOnly people without any sense of reality believed this. Being exploitative is a core feature of MS, since its foundation. It's like believing a serpent won't bite you. They're in the middle of the embrace, extend and extinguish cycle for open source technologies.
- pjmlp 1y agoYep, that is more of less the point I was making.
- anthk 1y agoWindows was already adware with WIndows 98. Active Desktop anyone?
- crinkly 1y ago
- EGreg 1y agoWhat about Wine? Is that still a thing? Visual Studio Code seems to be their big open source push, besides GitHub. Everyone uses it, and most development environments and UX are based on it. Used to be Atom, I remember.
- benterix 1y ago> Visual Studio Code ... open source Pick one.
- echoangle 1y agoThey meant VS Code (which is at least partially open source).
- kube-system 1y agohttps://github.com/microsoft/vscode/blob/main/LICENSE.txt https://github.com/microsoft/vscode/blob/main/LICENSE.txt
- madeofpalk 1y agoI don't understand how VS Code is an "open source push". It's technically open source, but open source doesn't seem to be strategically important to it.
- beached_whale 1y agoNot all of it is OSS. The core language servers are closed, I think.
- kaladin-jasnah 1y agoWine is still active, but I think mostly with Valve's proton, if that's the Wine you're talking about.
- radlad 1y agoPedantic, but VS Code does not share a lineage with Atom, besides the fact that it is built on Electron (which was, admittedly, originally built for Atom.)
- pbiggar 1y agoNot just that, but Microsoft's reputation is in the process of taking a nose dive over its human rights record https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/aug/06/microsoft-israeli-military-palestinian-phone-calls-cloud https://www.theguardian.com/world/2025/aug/06/microsoft-isra...
- pfisch 1y agoNobody even knows about this, no one thinks "Microsoft, hell no, they are a key player in the gaza conflict." No one really associates human rights with Microsoft's reputation. That is the domain of Palantir, Meta, etc.
- 1attice 1y agoas a former MSFT employee (who quit for reasons, well before the layoffs) I am not permitted to disparage or portray my former employer in a negative light. I'm just mentioning this for no reason whatsoever. It popped into my head, for some reason.
- jjani 1y agoFor life? How can you be bound by this? Unless you sold yourself out for an extra month pay.
- unethical_ban 1y agoThat seems literally illegal, unless the disparagement would reference specific, classified programs.
- mikestew 1y agoAs a former MSFT employee who disparages Microsoft on a regular basis, I ask: ‘dafuq did you get that idea?
- not_a_bot_4sho 1y agoI'm also a former employee but based in the US where such things are illegal. In what country are you bound by clauses like that? I've never heard Microsoft doing something like that before.
- bee_rider 1y agoApple and Microsoft seem very different companies. Apple is stylish and cool by default, with occasional stumbles. Even among tech people, they have good will even though they seem to regard the Open Source community with total ambivalence at best. Microsoft is the Walmart of operating system providers, that happened to buy a popular Git hosting site and briefly made noises that seemed not awful. In terms of coolness, Microsoft peaked right around the time they were hiring the cast of Friends to promote their OS.
- sho_hn 1y ago> Even among tech people, they have good will Wait, do they? I mostly remember: - A neglected desktop OS with slowly deteriorating quality - Aimless products like the Vision Pro that seems to have failed as the "get the devs excited" premium SDK launch everyone described it as - Rocky start issues on Apple Intelligence, nerfed Siri, etc. - Unexciting iPhone launch and lots of ridicule levied on Liquid Glass It's the laptop to get for compute/battery, which definitely is not nothing, but I'd say few tech people have been excited about Apple otherwise lately, as product or platform.
- fkyoureadthedoc 1y ago> but I'd say few tech people have been excited about Apple otherwise lately, as product or platform And probably fewer still consider switching to the alternatives. Apple is, for better or worse, usually the least bad option.
- yndoendo 1y agoYou have to pay me to use Apple, Microsoft, and Google products. None of those organizations are good. Apple and Google both use immutable locked down OSes on their main products that prevents improving device security, such as IP & DNS filtering / blocking. Microsoft user experience keeps getting worse. Latest version of Teams, as of today, says I'm at the "Calendar" screen and the navigation and content screen both show "Chat". "Calendar" was unpinned because I find Teams to be at interacting with content. No reason it should be a PDF viewer when the desktop application is actually usable allows for viewing chat and content at the same time. I understand developing for those platforms makes money or is needed for other products. Unless I have to develop products that support those companies, I will never pay with my personal income to support those organizations.
- segphault 1y agoMicrosoft not being terrible was a zero interest rate phenomenon. The news today is a lot worse than just Github not being independent anymore. It sounds like literally the entire development division is being rolled into this "Core AI" business unit. When Nadella announced plans to double the company's revenue by 2030, it was pretty clear that the enshitifiction was going to ramp up significantly, but it doesn't seem like it will ever relent now that they have to squeeze out more free cash flow to cover all of this AI capex. Windows is practically malware at this point, they've made extremely deep cuts to .NET engineering headcount, and it's just going to get worse.
- hinkley 1y agofifteen years ago I predicted that if we ever have a bloody AI revolution, the most likely case would be that it would be Microsoft's fault because they are the kings of unintended consequences. The second most likely case being some AI figuring out how to hack AWS to steal compute time, probably by getting access to billing information. Microsoft seems to be slowly pulling ahead at the moment.
- throwaway290 1y agoWait Microsoft was cool at some point?
- pjmlp 1y agoDid you missed the whole Microsoft <3 FOSS, right after Satya took over?
- mightysashiman 1y agodid anyone believe it?!
- palata 1y agoAll those people who use Linux on their Windows machine instead of just installing a proper Linux distro.
- leoc 1y agoYou can see the reactions in 2014: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7524082 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7524082 . Pretty positive overall!
- ragnese 1y agoIt was AstroTurfed to hell and back here and on Reddit. I know that much.
- owebmaster 1y agoYou can see it very regularly when typescript is mentioned
- jacquesm 1y agoNo way anybody really believed that. Or did they?
- throwaway290 1y agoUs people who remember EEE didn't
- newspaper1 1y agoThis is an odd comment. Xamarin has never been relevant. GitHub is historically OSS focused. Xamarin was some weird niche product for Windows devs. Hardly any overlap with GitHub’s core audience. I don’t know what will happen next, but hodgepodge of weird MS tech isn’t the lens to view this through.
- everfrustrated 1y agoDidn't the Xamarin guy became the CEO of GitHub at one point?
- pjmlp 1y agoOne of them, yes. Miguel never did, and is now focused on Swift and Apple.
- cdeutsch 1y agoThere was only ever one Xamarin CEO, Nat. Miguel was CTO
- newspaper1 1y agoYes, and that was an incredibly odd decision.
- yread 1y agoWhy do people need to create anthropomorphising narratives around companies? Don't be any company's cheerleader, use the stuff that's best for you (and the environment)
- pjmlp 1y agoAgreed, but apparently company cheerleadering never goes away.
- mirekrusin 1y agoThe same way cheerleading USA presidents doesn't go away, but if you look around you see things like Switzerland with direct democracy that just works without it.
- sixothree 1y agoIs he creating or is he relating what people think? I don't see this is him arguing so much as reporting.
- ozim 1y agoI built my career on MSFT stack I am going to be their cheerleader, don't want them to go down or stagnate as I would have to switch stack. I don't understand people who are just consumers and have no actual business to root for MSFT or AAPL or any other company.
- whoknowsidont 1y ago>I don't understand people who are just consumers They're not just consumers, they're actual engineers. People who simp for companies like MS are just acolytes in developer's clothing. If you only know one stack from one company, then you built your career on esoteric, arbitrary knowledge. Not on engineering things.
- motorest 1y ago> Then there is the issue they seem to be shoting into all directions, with GUI frameworks, Web, Blazor, Aspire, to see what sticks. Can you elaborate on why you believe that? I mean, with GUI frameworks it's pretty obvious MS is placing all their chips on WinUI3, even though they are not deprecating any legacy framework. I mean, their Win32 API is still alive and well, as well as MFC, ATL, etc. WPF still gets some minor updates too here and there. I have no idea what you mean by web, too. ASP.NET is perhaps one of the better maintained web frameworks around. What exactly do you interptet as a concern? Blazor is also Microsoft's alternative to JavaScript and it's main value proposition is being able to write webassembly apps using Microsoft technology exclusively. What do you think is replacing this? Pointing out Aspire is even weirder. It's a containerization framework to help with observability and manage distributed applications. What exactly is the overlap? I sense a great deal of confusion in your comments. What exactly are you trying to say?
- Lich 1y ago> I mean, with GUI frameworks it's pretty obvious MS is placing all their chips on WinUI3, even though they are not deprecating any legacy framework. WinUI3 is dead, lol. I tried to migrate from UWP to WinUI3, but it is literally dead. There doesn’t seem to be any team at MS actively working on it, the community calls have died, and the last build conf didn’t have any WinUI3 talks, all AI stuff. Yes, you can build apps with WinUI3, but development and support for it has stalled and I couldn’t justify moving the companies product over to WinUI3.
- pjmlp 1y agoNo they aren't placing all their chips on WinUI3, only those that never went through all reboots since Windows 8, believe that. WPF got taken out of legacy mode at BUILD 2024, exactly because hardly anyone outside Redmond cares about WinUI 3. Anyone that has been long enough around, has seen ASP.NET MVC 5, ASP.NET Core MVC (not compatible with MVC 5 predecessor), Razor Pages, Minimal APIs, Blazor,... So it is a mess doing consulting and depending on what .NET version the customer team is allowed to use, and existing code, what gets to be used by that portfolio. Minimal APIs have been designed to bring in Python and JavaScript developers into .NET, which many of us see as not working at all, while having created the need now everyone creates their own controllers infractruture, as means to tame having minimal APIs all over the place, there are even MVVM like frameworks now for that purpose. Blazor is really only usable as path forward for those still stuck in WebForms, due to the similar approach to do Web UIs, and to .NET shops without frontend teams. In the age of distributed computing with microservices and frontend teams, it is a hard sell to make them adopt Blazor and learn C#, instead of React, Angular, Vue. At least they have adopted TypeScript, the next language that Anders Hejlsberg decided to focus on. Aspire is something that has been pivoted, now they try to sell it as Microsoft's Pulumi, but everyone has to write the orchestration code in C#, thus only relevant to .NET shops. Maddy Montaquila has said in a few .NET podcast interviews that they are trying to use Aspire as means to sell .NET to UNIX shops, given the low adoption numbers outside the traditional Microsoft shops, even after almost a decade being open source.
- crinkly 1y ago> Then there is the issue they seem to be shoting into all directions, with GUI frameworks, Web, Blazor, Aspire, to see what sticks. This is Microsoft's primary strategy. There are a lot of victims out there. ... he says after spending several months porting a win32 app to Silverlight as part of a Gold Partner/MS case study with much fanfare, only to have to spent the next few years backporting everything into the win32 app it never replaced, and then it was shit canned and only the win32 version remains. We're planning to rewrite it in Qt at some point as some of our customers use RHEL.
- jongjong 1y agoI once worked for a company which outsourced the development of a Silverlight app for $1 million and then canned the whole thing one year later. It's just crazy how these life-changing amounts of money are thrown around like garbage in this industry.
- jongjong 1y agoOh and I didn't mention how these founders went on to raise more and more funding. It's like there is no connection to performance.
- pathartl 1y ago> Then there is the issue they seem to be shoting into all directions, with GUI frameworks, Web, Blazor, Aspire, to see what sticks. ... what? They could do a better job with the native frameworks, but the rest of these are completely unrelated. For web, MVC is pretty much dead and you might want to use Blazor SSR instead. Web API via controllers is still supported, but minimal API endpoints are the hot thing. Blazor is being treated as a first class product. Aspire is there to assist in local orchestration of distributed applications... and is built on Blazor.
- pjmlp 1y agoExactly that, now try to pick the best one of all of those on enterprise projects, depending on the version they are using, and there is no budget for updates.
- mightysashiman 1y agofirst time I've ever read "Microsoft" and "cool" in the same sentence.
- pferde 1y agoTechnically not true. We were muttering "Not cool, Microsoft, not cool!" quite regularly back in the 90s and early 00s. :)
- ackfoobar 1y ago> .NET is now cross platform, but only as long as it doesn't hurt VS sales, with GUI workloads, profilers, still being mostly Windows only, and partially supported on VSCode, which also has the same VS license. On HN I keep hearing that associating .NET with Windows is outdated perception. Writing JVM languages I feel that the developer experience is pretty much the same on any OS. It seems this cannot be said for .NET?
- SideburnsOfDoom 1y agoThe server deploy experience for .NET is pretty much the same on Windows or Linux. The developer tooling experience has more options on Windows.
- marcosdumay 1y agoPretty much no, it can't be said for .Net. It currently supports Linux as a running target for servers. It supports both running desktop software and development very badly.
- alternatex 1y agoIt supports Linux as a running target for console apps, which can be servers, background apps, systemd apps, etc. So everything except UI apps. The development experience with Rider is also great on Linux. I think you need to be more specific with the complaints because I have many beefs with Microsoft's approach to many things, but I could not pick up on what you meant.
- rahkiin 1y agoCan run SDL on linux and macos just fine, rendering visuals to the screen in X or Wayland.
- okanat 1y agoYou can use Avalonia to develop cross-platform apps with .NET. GUI stuff from Windows depends deeply on Win32 and how Windows's core APIs work. So expecting Microsoft to port stuff like .Net Windows Forms is meaningless. They are open source though. Maybe with some completion effort Wine can run them.
- ezoe 1y agoYou forgot to mention the gaming section. Microsoft is acquiring a lot of game developers, put it on hold for a few years, then close subsidiary and layoff all employees. I guess generating hype by acquisition and increase valuation cause more profit than developing a real product. I'm beginning to think that using Microsoft services(yes, GitHub included) is morally questionable behaviour right now. I can't support the current Microsoft behaviour of laying off many employees so casually.
- ivape 1y agoMicrosoft is acquiring a lot of game developers, put it on hold for a few years, then close subsidiary and layoff all employees. Sounds like they just bought the IP.
- tough 1y agowhich begs the question is it just good old EEE?
- pjmlp 1y agoYes, the whole XBox division has been a mess, especially after ABK. However XBox plus Microsoft Gaming Studios, is still one of the biggest group of AAA publishers, they have a big enough slice of the market. Hence why now they're dominating PlayStation charts with cross-platform games. Many Microsoft haters don't have an good enough idea of how big they have become on games industry, regardless of layoffs and such. SteamOS keeps being around until they feel like doing a netbooks like move, taking all their games out of Steam, or whatever else Microsoft might think of. Hence why I regularly complain Valve should keep trying to bring developers to target GNU/Linux natively instead of translating Windows games.
- grepfru_it 1y agoI would not be surprised if Steam came to Xbox
- 1y ago
- SideburnsOfDoom 1y ago> .NET is now cross platform, but only as long as it doesn't hurt VS sales, with GUI workloads, profilers, still being mostly Windows only, The monetisation of .NET is less about selling Windows licences, and more about selling Azure compute etc. The OS used on Azure is less relevant, you pay MS either way.
- TrueSlacker0 1y agoYou can run .net without azure very easily. I personally have 4x web apps written in .net 8, razor. They used to be on a aws windows instance years ago but it was overly expensive for what I needed. Then I switched them to a small digital ocean server running ubuntu. When I started these apps I wrote them on windows 7 for windows server. I switched the server probably 2 years ago. I recently made the switch off of windows to ubuntu as my daily driver, instead of going to 11. Everything still works great. I do miss visual studio, but I am getting used to linux and its tools now. Point is, server is running and there is zero azure involved.
- SideburnsOfDoom 1y ago> You can run .net without azure very easily That's true, and we're all well aware of it. I've done that for a job too. Nevertheless, the point stands. MS gives away a lot of the .NET tools for free. It is a "Loss leader", "to draw customers into a store where they are likely to buy other goods." (1). "You can't run .NET without Azure" is not what I said, what I said is that .NET is free, but MS believes that continuing to invest in it, drives Azure sales. Ask yourself why MS spends money developing tools such as Aspire or YARP. The fact that you specifically didn't buy some Azure today means little: this is still the plan, and it still seems to be broadly working. I have heard MS people say as much, and also say that the side-effect of some people running .NET on AWS etc is fine too. 1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_leader https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loss_leader
- justin66 1y ago> Microsoft being the cool guys phase is slowly over. That happened three decades ago.
- pjmlp 1y agoThere was a new wind after Satya took over, but apparently it is slowly gone now.
- pferde 1y agoThat was a mask the corporation put on in a bid to lure in the younger crowd who doesn't remember all the underhanded stuff Microsoft did in the past. But they haven't really changed at all.
- hinkley 1y agoThe thing that surprises me the most about Satya is how he managed to survive in MS so long if he really is different from the previous administration.
- jacquesm 1y agoTo me it never made a difference. There was a concerted effort to put lipstick on the pig but it was still a pig.
- lepicz 1y agoto put lipstick on the wrong end of a pig :) this is a mystery to me: ms has all the money in the world to make it right.. yet they can't. windows ecosystem is like one of those eastern european barnyards, where animals live and die between old halves tractors and rusty Lada(s).
- hinkley 1y agoMore like put lipstick on the scorpion. It is in their nature. It takes a lot of work to excise bad practices from an organization and removing the guilty parties is only step one. Everything continues to work the way the bad actors wanted them to work for a long, long time. Gates was bad. Balmer was worse. He was still in charge 11 years ago, in a company he helped build 40 years ago. Their personalities are the bones of that organization.
- righthand 1y agoNo need to extinguish what you can infinitely embrace with capital and extend into a puzzle.
- martin-t 1y agoI couldn't believe the number of people who were saying that "Microsoft are the good guys now" or "Microsoft loves open source now". Microsoft stopped openly attacking open source at a time when open source was clearly winning: - most servers were running linux - most phones and tablets were running android - people were buying tablets instead of desktops - Google was openly promoting open source through GSOC - large corporations were regularly releasing their tools as open source Most importantly, developers openly hated Microsoft for holding the industry back (remember IE6?). So they did what any good corporations does - they went along with the winning side. And now they they have positive emotional connotations in devs' minds, or at least organizational buy-in again, they can do what corporations do best - making money by abusing their position with barely any competition. --- The lesson here are: - Corporations should simply not have this amount of power. - Corporations are amoral, they don't have values, views or beliefs. They are systems designed for optimizing goals. You can never _trust_ a corporation - not because they are untrustworthy but because trust is a human-to-human level concept, it does not have any meaning in human-to-system interaction.
- okanat 1y agoI think big corporations are not amoral, they are immoral. There is no wealth that has been built obeying morality or showing emphaty. Once them two become obstacles for profits, they will be thrown out.
- martin-t 1y agoThe people in charge or corporations certainly are very often immoral. I don't think ascribing morality to a system is useful when it's comprised of many people who can be replaced at any time. But, I also think that top down hierarchical power structures are fundamentally harmful, abusive and exploitative so you do have a point. Cooperatives are much healthier structures.
- meindnoch 1y agoMicrosoft being the cool guys? The cool guys? Mwuhahahhaa. This gave me the good belly laugh I needed. For the last 25 years, Microsoft was known for: - being the no. 1 enemy of free software - shipping the worst web browser in existence, despite 80%+ market share - making corrupt deals with governments around the world to tie them to their office software suite - creating vendor-locked proprietary extensions to kill open technologies (ActiveX plugins, Silverlight, C++/CLI, MSJVM, etc.) - making cringe hardware that basically noone purchased (Zune, Windows Phone) The last time they might have been considered the "cool guys" was sometime in the 90s.
- jrepinc 1y agoAnd today they are even complicit in genocide and avid supporters of fascist USA dictator Trump, can hardly get less cool then that
- scarface_74 1y agoAs is half the US who voted for him…
- hdgvhicv 1y agoAnd every large company, whether they want to or not, because if they don’t bend the knee…
- SlowTao 1y agoMicrosoft has for the longest time been about business only. Any virtue signaling was just marketing. Years back they were gloating about how their AI systems (pre-LLM stuff) could allow for great oil production while at the same time talking projecting the image of a clean green future.
- Melatonic 1y agoZune was actually kinda nice - although I agree nobody bought it!
- hilux 1y agoMicrosoft hasn't been the cool guys since at least 1995, and probably long before that.
- pyuser583 1y agoHow is Rider v. VS? This is the sort of question I don't trust AI with yet.
- sixothree 1y agoRider is very nice and a perfectly competent development environment. It gets first class support and often has the ability to test preview features from dotnet upcoming language and runtimes. It's biggest problem is that it's not Visual Studio, so it is very hard for people who have lived in VS for a decade to move over. It does away with some bloat and also provides some features of Resharper natively instead of as an extension. You can quite literally use this as your primary development environment.
- CharlieDigital 1y agoVS - great if you are Windows only shop for dev and want all the bells and whistles Rider - has all of the the nice things JetBrains does and the best option on Mac if you need advanced refactoring; UI feels a bit cluttered at time (though they improved this). VSC - for whatever reason, I always end up back to VSC for .NET for backends. Good enough, fast, and lightweight enough. Plays nicely with Node and full-stack monorepos. I would commit to VSC and try to make it work. If you find you need advanced refactoring support, then try out Rider.
- pathartl 1y agoI have been a .NET dev for the past 8 years and have switched fully to Rider. The only thing I miss from VS is the quick nav to see all the properties and methods in a file on the top bar. Everything else is vastly better: - Auto complete is a bit smarter (even the free AI suggestions are better) - Refactoring across files is often faster - Package management is undoubtedly the latest performance difference. I would go from taking 1-2 minutes from using VS's "Manage packages for solution" to under 10 seconds in Rider. - In VS there's always a noticeable delay when the debugger hits a breakpoint / exception and the IDE takes a few seconds to actually display. This is about halved in Rider. - The built in terminal is vastly better than VS's, though not as good as Windows Terminal
- 1y ago
- pier25 1y agoI love C# and .NET is amazing for some specific use cases like REST APIs but there's so much stuff that just doesn't work or needs a lot more effort to get somewhere. MAUI is a mess. Blazor will never work as a general solution for full stack web apps. Even if a small app didn't have to download like 10MB of WASM code the DX is terrible and performance just as bad. Elixir Phoenix developed with a fraction of the budget is just so far ahead. C# hot reload has been broken for years. I doubt it will ever be as good as what you get in JS with Vite. Minimal APIs are a great idea but 4 years later and still fundamental features like validation are missing (it's coming in .NET 10). They've been investing a ton of effort into Aspire. It's cool but is it more important than core features? And now with AI, Microsoft is more distracted than ever and I'm starting to regret getting into .NET at all.
- sixothree 1y agoIs MAUI now just a simple wrapper for Blazor projects?
- the_real_cher 1y agoThey're releasing a feature on Windows which literally records your screen every few seconds! These guys are extremely bad guys.
- maxrmk 1y agoDo you work in devdiv at Microsoft? I can see the org chart in this comment haha
- pjmlp 1y agoNo, but I code for Microsoft platforms since MS-DOS 3.3, so one gets to know how it all works, when having read so many docs, MSJ articles, MSDN, PDC and BUILD sessions, podcats and what not.
- scarface_74 1y agoI’ve been in the industry for 30 years professionally and 10 years as hobbyist who paid as much attention to the industry as one could before the internet in the 80s early 90s including lying as a 9th grader pretending to be a big spender to get a free subscription to MacWeek and PCWeek. At no point in time was Microsoft one of the cool guys.
- ozim 1y ago.NET is now cross platform, but only as long as it doesn't hurt VS sales - I think MSFT doesn't care just as they don't care about GUI workloads, because only thing they care now is having developers run their stuff on Azure. You don't need VS for those cloud .NET apps and you don't need front end frameworks like Forms, Xamarin or MAUI. Seems like C++ is also something they would not be interested investing into when they can get people into cloud easier with C#.
- NullCascade 1y agoIt's funny. Nobody complains that there is a lack of free multi-platform desktop GUI profiling tools for Go, Python, Ruby, Elixir etc. Somehow we just accept those languages are only for web services, web apps, and command-line utilities. What is the problem with Microsoft keeping "nice to have" desktop GUI stuff for their own proprietary ecosystem when everything else has open sourced? Including the primitives needed for the community to build their own GUI and developer tooling stuff, just like JetBrains did with Rider.
- whoknowsidont 1y agoYeah guys, what's the difference between organic projects that have been open source since the start and a global technology conglomerate open sourcing things later that compete for mind share against those projects. What could be the difference? Oh dear, I just can't think of anything.
- informal007 1y agoIf Github/Copilot wins the war of coding assistant and becomes the next growth point in MS, the story will be total different. We shouldn't ignore the influence of trend, it's like the facebook in mobile era.
- frollogaston 1y agoI remember all the PR about Satya Nadella making the company cool, modern, user-friendly, and open source friendly. Thought wow, he must also be a hypnotist.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- ed_elliott_asc 1y agoI think Jetbrians Rider and vscode being “good enough” to stop Microsoft investing in another IDE for Mac
- Hilift 1y agoNo one wants cross platform.
- giancarlostoro 1y ago> A proper cross platform IDE experience requires getting Rider. I seem to remember a lot more .NET IDEs before .NET Core... This frustrates me.
- parasense 1y agoI'm not sure what you mean by some of the things you write, but the part about Microsoft being "cool guy phase" was hilarious. I'd say Microsoft buying GitHub was part of a strategy to not lose relevance in the world that moves slowly towards Open Source Software. Or put another way, the world moves in a direction away from Microsoft, and by capturing GitHub they can manipulate the outcomes that would otherwise have been adversarial to Microsoft interests. It's just like when Microsoft forked Java back in the 1990s, and later created .NET. The whole VSCode or Visual Studio thing... it's just Microsoft Word for software engineers, and the whole point is to create an ecosystem that locks people into the ecosystem. To think in terms of what Microsoft does, you have to step back and look into economic theory, at least a little bit. There is this idea in economics about isolated economies, and integrated economies. For example, Europe or North America relies on cheap manufactured goods from China, and so China's economy is intrinsically linked (integrated) into the economies of Europe or North America. THAT is the idea of what Microsoft does. They start by adding value, a soft-dependency you might say, and then make moves to becoming a hard dependency... to put into terms of a dependency graph. Then they link to dependency graphs together GitHub into VSCode, OpenAI into VSCode, One Drive into GitHub or One Drive into Hotmail... I'll say for sure, at least Microsoft has a strategy, unlike Google where they seem to have a lot of failed projects.
- kassha 1y ago"Microsoft being the cool guys phase" lol, ok
- ajdude 1y ago> Microsoft being the cool guys phase is slowly over I'm going to re-post something that I wrote in 2022: I'm a bit surprised at how many of my friends have jumped ship to Visual Studio Code, including those who are very much for free software. They have always been in the business of embrace, extend, extinguish[0]. People tend to forget how evil M$ used to be because recently they have seemed like a beacon for Open Source, but I think they are just still evil[1]. I think we're still dealing with the same Microsoft that we've dealt with through the 90s. They are not a champion of open source, and they are still up to their old tricks.[2] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31966414 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31966414 [1] https://keivan.io/the-day-appget-died/ https://keivan.io/the-day-appget-died/ [2] https://social.platypush.tech/@blacklight/108719097530863121 https://social.platypush.tech/@blacklight/108719097530863121
- lenkite 1y agoI don't get why Github is reporting to the AI Core Team. It should be the other way around.