11 ms·
Apple's Browser Engine Ban Persists, Even Under the DMA
- v5v3 1y agoThat you for your ongoing work Open Web Advocacy.
- Tepix 1y agoYes, Thank you! Someone has to do it, Apple is clearly dragging their feet as much as possible.
- v5v3 1y agoJust so you know, my post thanking you has 15 upvotes at present. So 16 people are thanking you together.
- v5v3 1y ago[flagged]
- v5v3 1y ago[flagged]
- croemer 1y ago17 now - great questions (I watched the YouTube clip https://youtu.be/_nRU9XUbnpM?si=ep1pHNCfWmQKVf5b https://youtu.be/_nRU9XUbnpM?si=ep1pHNCfWmQKVf5b) I feel you could be more aggressive in the questions given that no follow-up seems to be allowed. Apple's "were doing all of this for security" is clearly just a cheap excuse. You're given only one shot and are up against professional deflectors (lawyers). The lawyer's "I'm not discrediting you for who you do or don't get money from like Spotify" is just cheap rhetoric 101. He prefers to chip "You think You know better how to design our OS" rather than answer the question on how non-EU devs can test. Empty "we're engaging with Google/Mozilla...". That's not an answer!
- simondotau 1y agoThe open web requires browser diversity in order to remain healthy, far more than it needs individuals to have browser choice. The former is important for the health of open standards; the latter only matters if you believe the web is whatever Google implements in Chrome. Without healthy browser diversity, the web might as well be renamed the Chrome Protocol and the "browser choice" you care about so much is gone.
- quitit 1y agoAndroid already has all of the things being demanded of Apple and there is no dawn of a new age. No demand for web apps. No demand for alternative browser engines. All that's there is the Chrome desert with a near-total market share and a sprinkling of alternative app stores that few trust or use. It's a form of regulatory capture, coopting legislation to rid the market of remaining competition.
- simondotau 1y agoAgain, that's an argument for browser choice. What matters to me is browser diversity, even if it must come at the expense of browser choice. Apple forcing the use of WebKit on iOS is the last meaningful backstop against a Chrome monoculture.
- concinds 1y agoThat's a deeply fallacious argument. https://infrequently.org/2022/06/apple-is-not-defending-browser-engine-choice/ https://infrequently.org/2022/06/apple-is-not-defending-brow...
- simondotau 1y agoIt's not fallacious, that article is fallacious. By conflating choice and diversity, the article is poorly written and misrepresents the bigger picture. Browser diversity makes the internet better, while browser choice encourages developers to be lazy. Developers exclusively targeting Chrome and forcing users to switch isn't browser choice, it just replaces one kind of non-choice with another kind of non-choice.
- mtomweb 1y agoThanks so much! it’s been a four-year journey just to get this far, and none of it would have been possible without the volunteers who donate their time just for the belief in a better future for the web! Will be passing this comment on!
- TheDong 1y agoI agree with the point about non-EU web developers. As long as people in the US can't test their web app on "firefox for iOS" without first buying a plane ticket to the EU and getting an EU sim card, all eu-only browser engines on iOS will be second-class citizens. I think the next logical extension is that actually limiting general public use across the entire world makes apple less compliant with the DMA. Mozilla will not be able to justify putting significant effort into the iOS port as long as it can only reach a small fraction of users, so in reality the way to get browser-engine competition in the EU is to mandate that apple _not_ impose EU-specific rules about what apps can be installed.
- mtomweb 1y agoAnd it can’t just be the woefully insufficient TestFlight 10k users because there are possible upwards of a million developers who need to test their websites/web apps in the EU.
- ThatMedicIsASpy 1y agoWhat a load of BS. How can I test my website on safari without owning Apple hardware? I can't so I don't.
- freeAgent 1y agoIt’s relatively easy to own Apple hardware when one lives outside the EU, but basically impossible to use that hardware to run their own browser engine on iPhones or iPads.
- conradfr 1y agoNot the most practical but you can rent a macOS VM.
- ThatMedicIsASpy 1y agoA hobby dev will not do such thing.
- selckin 1y agoThis Apple policy is the only thing stopping chrome from having a full monopoly, and we should be careful trying to remove it
- elashri 1y agoIt is shame that this is true. However it should not mean that we need to accept this situation. Hopefully Google anti competitive practices with Chrome can be addressed at the same time.
- systemtest 1y agoThose popups I get multiple times a day about how this website works better on Chrome , which cover half my screen and which forward me to the App Store, are incredibly misleading. I have misclicked many times and then the App Store opens up. If you go back to the browser and hit the back button, it will again open the App Store. I have to press and hold the back button and skip multiple pages to get back to what I was doing.
- RegW 1y agoStrange - I don't get this in Firefox. I wonder if its because I'm in the UK or perhaps Privacy Badger is blocking it.
- elashri 1y agoI think we are talking about phones here because on macOS you can use any browser without limitation.
- systemtest 1y agoThis is with the Safari browser on iOS, using Google websites while not being logged in to Google. No content blockers.
- windward 1y agoMonopolies are made illegal because they limit consumer choice and the role of competition in the free market, distorting incentives. The status quo has all of the problems of a monopoly. Doing this or not doing this won't change that. But it will remove another barrier to consumers being able to do what they want.
- saagarjha 1y agoUnfortunately the problem here is that Apple decides that they are the only entity that knows how to do security and no you can't see how they do it. This means whatever choices they make are clearly the right ones.
- jadams84 1y ago[flagged]
- kouteiheika 1y agoYour shiny new iPhone exists because European ASML supplied the machines to make the chips inside of it. The pro-Apple bias on HN is truly insufferable sometimes.
- jadams84 1y ago[flagged]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 1y agoThis is Nokia erasure .. although admittedly they died. Europe was the innovator and market leader for a while there. There's a deeper market argument about the relatively open GSM versus the US CDMA which was more of a Qualcomm monopoly.
- swiftcoder 1y agoI think it's more the US did the whole embrace-extend-extinguish to all their EU competition. There were EU-developed smartphones up until Google/Apple ate the world.
- immibis 1y agoI remember a time when everyone wanted a Sony Ericsson phone.
- dminik 1y agoAmerica innovates by using Korean screens, British CPU architecture, Japanese cameras, Chinese manufacturing, Australian invented Wi-Fi, ... God the US superiority complex can be insufferable.
- fabian2k 1y agoThe simple fact that they restrict this to the EU, where they are forced to provide the option, shows that Apple is not serious about this. They're barely fulfilling the letter of the law here. If this would be only about security as Apple claims, there would be no reason to restrict this to the EU and to force Browser vendors to publish other engines as separate apps after they meet the security conditions Apple imposes.
- bapak 1y ago> Apple is not serious about this. They're barely fulfilling the letter of the law here. Is that surprising in any way? They've been asked to not reject third party browser engines in the EU. Check. Google has plenty of developers in the EU so I'm not even sure what people want exactly.
- tonyhart7 1y agothey want apple adhere to EU law for everyone outside the EU lol how can people think like this
- 9dev 1y agoNo. Apple claims they cannot implement this due to security concerns. Yet at the same time, they assure EU users that the Apple platform is of course secure. So which one is it? By limiting this change to the EU, Apple displays that they clearly are able to add support for multiple browser engines without compromising security if forced to, so the only reason left is their unwillingness to commit to their users freedom of choice. It’s just greed, nothing more.
- giingyui 1y agoIt’s actually the opposite, no? If it’s about security it makes sense they choose to compromise the security of their platform only where they are forced to.
- MangoToupe 1y ago
- bluesign 1y agoNow basically the situation is: No browser vendor wants to port their engine, because cost > benefit. I think the discussion should focus more on why benefit is this small for users to switch. With browser selection dialog, I think vendors have already 0 cost channel for UA. I don't think new binary would make a big difference.
- Jyaif 1y ago> Safari is the highest margin product Apple has ever made. Anybody has the number of committers to webkit from Apple? It would give us a good idea on the margin of the product. Assuming 100 engineers costing Apple 500k per year, that's 50 millions in investment for 20 billion in revenue. > For each 1% browser market share that Apple loses for Safari, Apple is set to lose $200 million in revenue per year. They should be investing like crazy to make Safari the best browser out there instead of just relying on their monopole. And why the fuck is there no Windows version to make their iOS users happy?
- Batman8675309 1y ago> They should be investing like crazy to make Safari the best browser out there instead of just relying on their monopole. And why the fuck is there no Windows version to make their iOS users happy? Simple. Apple doesn't want you to use Windows. They want you to buy an expensive Apple computer instead.
- robin_reala 1y agoWhy would you only count engineers?
- Jyaif 1y agoSame reason I choose 500k, it's an approximation.
- croemer 1y agoGiven that Stack overflow has 500 employees, I'd say Safari requires 500 people rather than 100.
- Jyaif 1y agoFWIW 119 unique @apple addresses appear in Webkit.git in the last year. ( `git log --since="1 year ago" --pretty="%cn <%ce>" | grep "apple" | sort -u | wc -l` ) Of course there's more to Safari than just Webkit, and there's more than just committers. So yes, the number may be close to 500 in total. Assuming a generous 500k cost per employee, we reach 250 million USD, which is less than 2% of what they get for Safari. Safari is essentially pure profit.
- shusaku 1y agoHonestly those barriers they complain about are not so high. I don’t believe any major browser vendor is deterred by this.
- mtomweb 1y agoWe do talk to the browser vendors. The bundle ID one by itself ensures it's unviable project. That's why 15 months in, there are no alternative browser engines in the EU.
- pickledoyster 1y agoOn top of that, iOS continues to push Safari on users by disregarding their default browser settings. Steps to reproduce: 0. Select a different default browser, delete the Safari app (just for good measure, even though it's not really possible just like deleting IE in older Win versions) 1. Open the Books app 2. Select text 3. Select Search 4. Press Search the Web 5. Safari search results open as you stare in disbelief
- boroboro4 1y agoThey do similarly with dates and calendar app. Disgraceful.
- FirmwareBurner 1y agoApple knows that what they're doing is against the law, but every day, every month, every year they can get away with it, till the hammer of the law inevitably strikes, is more money in their pocket. So delaying it by every means necessary is what's in their best interest, it's what their lawyers are paid to do because each such decision of conforming to the law boils down to an accounting decision for them: "are the potential fines bigger than the profits". You know a company has long lost the innovation race when the company is run by the lawyers and bean counters instead of the engineers, trying to milk their product lines form 10+ years ago. I wonder how long until they resort to becoming a patent troll ... oh wait. Their final form will be selling ads to their users.
- ezst 1y agoTech giants need to be dismantled.
- jjani 1y agoWestern governments just need to toughen up. If China tells Apple to stop doing something by next Monday, they'll have it changed by then. "But due process!!". For individuals and SMEs, sure. For mega companies, absolutely not. Getting to rake in billions of profits should come with a loss of privileges, not with a gain. That needs to be the trade-off.
- nntwozz 1y agoAnother reminder of Rockefeller’s reputed remark, “Competition is a sin.” Apple is behaving like the Standard Oil Company of the 2020s.
- wdb 1y agoI am not convinced this will help getting more browser engines in general. Currently, it's Chromium that dominates. That's worse than webkit only on iOS in my opinion.
- pmkary 1y agoI wonder why they should make iOS specific engines. To be honest only two things come to my mind: Shortcuts Integration and WebExtensions. Currently Orion is trying to bring extensions but I think there is a lot to be done for that to be considered operational and if that proves to work, then only remains Shortcuts which only lets you inject JS, or say get the content of a page from a "Safari" web page (while I think every webview is basically a Safari page). That brings me to this: Chrome extensions are valuable and we know as early as the rumors of Apple being forced to open up, Google started working on iOS port, but really, is there any justification for bringing a browser engine to iOS? I really don't understand how will it be beneficial when the user probably will notice anything. Also we only have like four players to enter: Google (which will come), Mozilla (broke and miss-managed as hell), GNOME Web (will never come), Ladybug Browser (they are crazy and will definitely come someday, but it takes a long time for them to be an actual player) So my question is: Will all this effort even fruit?
- agust 1y agoBrowser engines define the capabilities of web apps and websites. When they don't support APIs or have bugs, they impact negatively web software. Apple's WebKit is renowned to be lagging behind, refusing to implement crucial features and being rigged with bugs, hence limiting the capabilities and quality of web apps, and effectively preventing them to compete with native apps. Getting other browser engines on iOS would be beneficial for developers, businesses and end user by making mobile web apps viable.
- rgovostes 1y agoSo these web apps will prompt the user to install and configure a third-party browser engine?
- agust 1y agoThe likely outcome of alternate, capable browser engines coming to iOS will be to push Apple to invest in Safari so it can compete with them and not loose all of its market share. Otherwise, yes it's likely web apps will prompt their user to use a browser with a capable engine on iOS if they exist. Nothing to configure, install and use. Users will then be able to use capable web apps that take up a tenth of the storage of native apps, that are cheaper and portable across platforms — among many other benefits.
- stockresearcher 1y agoEven if you get past the roadblocks Apple has put in place, it’s not beer and skittles for browser makers in the EU. The CRA, which is now in effect, lists browsers as class I important products. Technical documentation, design documentation, user documentation, security conformance testing, a declared support period at the time of download, software bill of materials, the legal obligation to respond to and make all your internal documents available to market surveillance organizations, etc. And if the EU doesn’t publish harmonized development standards by 2027, you will be required to pay a 3rd party to come in and analyze you, your design, and the security of your browser, and make a report to send to the market surveillance organization, who gets to decide if you have the requisite conformance. Are you sure that anyone but the big boys want to make a browser in the EU? Here is the law, please point out where I am wrong. Much appreciated :) https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=OJ:L_202402847 https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=OJ:L...
- op00to 1y agoHoly cow, they’re serious: Penalties: • Up to €15 million or 2.5 % of global turnover for essential requirement failures. • €10 million or 2 % turnover for other obligations. • €5 million or 1 % turnover for misleading or incomplete documents On the one hand, these are important standards. On the other, it seems impossible for small shops to adhere to a lot of this.
- FirmwareBurner 1y agoHear me out, I have a tinfoil hat theory. What if, those requirements weren't put to help small shops making a new browser, but to guarantee the big shops who already have a browser are getting fined? *hits bong*
- gjsman-1000 1y agoAnd this is why the EU's GDP versus the US is now only 65% and shrinking. The regulations are about beating US companies into compliance, sometimes with righteous motives; but there's no forethought on how a domestic EU startup might be able to comply, or how a startup would convince investors to take the gamble.
- scarface_74 1y agoTwo of the arguments just aren’t true. If you use another browser today even if it does use Apple’s engine, Apple’s not making search revenue from Google. The second point is that it came out in the Epic trial that 90% of App Store revenue comes from games and in app purchasing. Those apps are not going to the web. Third, if the only thing stopping great web apps is Apple, why aren’t their popular web apps for Android and why do companies that produce iOS apps still create Android apps instead of telling Android users to just use the web?
- lozenge 1y agoYes but there's no reason to use another browser today, because the browsers aren't able to add differentiating features. I don't think you are correct to assume games can't go to the web. Any feature they need from native APIs can be added to the web. Full screen, gyro, vibration, multi touch, payment APIs, notifications, WASM and GPU support are already on the web!
- scarface_74 1y agoThen why aren’t profitable games based on web technology on Android if it is just Apple holding it back? But it’s not about the technology even then. Games make money via in app purchases by whales. In app purchasing is easy and they are able to tap into kids spending money. Most parents aren’t going to put their credit cards on kids phones. They will let kids do in app purchases with parental controls that are available on the App Store.
- quitit 1y agoConsidering Apple isn't even a go-to choice for gamers, the idea that iOS's minority market-share is holding back Windows, Android (and even macOS), is nothing short of farcical b/s-ing. Heck, most developers don't even produce versions of their games for any Apple hardware, even though there are plenty of cross-platform development suites.
- 1y ago
- ygritte 1y agoApple's malicious compliance all the way down. They need to get hit with fines that actually hurt.
- pxeger1 1y agoRelatedly, all Google apps (e.g. Maps) on iOS try very hard to push Chrome on you (even though iOS Chrome still has to use WebKit). When you click an external link, they present you the options of Chrome, Google (the search app), or Safari. This happens even if you don't have Chrome/Google installed, so they take you to the App Store instead of opening the webpage. If you choose Safari, it still doesn't open Safari, it opens a web view inside Google Maps, from where you have to press yet another button to get it to open as a actual Safari tab. The menu has a "remember my choice for next time" switch, but it seems to reset every few times so it constantly re-nags you. If the link goes to something that should open in another app (e.g. goes to instagram.com when I have the Instagram app installed), unless I satisfy its demands to install Chrome, it takes like 3 extra clicks to open in that other app.
- sumeno 1y agoI have never experienced this on iOS. I just tested it in Google maps and despite having Chrome installed it opened in Safari (my default) with no prompting or extra steps, it just immediately opened Safari
- layer8 1y agoGoogle Maps on iOS has a toggle “Ask me every time” that you can turn off, which maybe you did at some point.
- DanielHB 1y agoAre you in the EU?
- mahmoudhossam 1y agoI am in the EU and I still get the nag screen sometimes, it's awful.
- sumeno 1y agoNo
- 1y ago
- komali2 1y ago> Safari is the highest margin product Apple has ever made, accounts for 14-16% of Apple’s annual operating profit and brings in $20 billion per year in search engine revenue from Google. For each 1% browser market share that Apple loses for Safari, Apple is set to lose $200 million in revenue per year. Right now in many MRT stations throughout Taipei, there's ads for Safari. I don't think I ever in my life have seen an advertisement for a web browser until now. I guess now I know why.
- ingohelpinger 1y agosell your apple stonks
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- semiquaver 1y ago> Safari is the highest margin product Apple has ever made, accounts for 14-16% of Apple’s annual operating profit Does anyone know what this means? Safari is built in to the OS, how exactly would you measure its margin? Are they just talking about the Google search deal?
- nikanj 1y agoSafari has a minuscule team and brings in the Google money
- swores 1y agoI think it's a bit misleading to call Safari a "high margin product" based on that logic, considering they could have made even more profit by not making it at all and just charge Google the exact same money to let them ship Chrome as the default iOS browser... (I mean an actual Chrome browser, not the Chrome skin of a WebKit browser that Google currently has to settle for.) I'm not saying I'd prefer that scenario, just that it would have been a feasible choice for Apple and as such their Safari costs are actually profit losing not profit generating (other than potentially indirectly, if Apple is correct that limiting devices to their own browser engine improves the product and therefore aids device sales, but I don't think anyone would argue that's significant enough to call it their biggest profit driver).
- nchmy 1y agoThat scenario seems just completely illegal under the regulations that are being discussed
- swores 1y agoI'm talking about historic choices rather than current options - but yes I agree that even if they wanted to, they'd face legal trouble if they tried now to replace Safari with an exclusive deal for Chrome to be the only browser.
- 1y ago
- openplatypus 1y agoCan we finally start putting dimwit Apple execs in jail?
- p0w3n3d 1y agoFirst of all. We must not agree that all the market will be taken by one engine (i.e. Chromium) Sadly there's no incentive for this, of course we have Firefox (still, right?) but it may perish because of underfunding for example. We used to have opera, IE, those engines are lost. So what I think about the EU directive is that it basically allows one company (Google) take over the whole market. Because what we have to choose between is MS Edge (Chromium), Chrome (Chromium), Vivaldi (Chromium) and other Chromium based forks. And I forgot about Firefox which is the margin atm. I didn't want to say that Apple should allow other engines. What I wanted to say is that I'm scared that once iOS allows installation of chrome, there will become only one engine in the world and THIS will be THE MONOPOLY we don't want to have.
- 93po 1y agoi think it's unlikely firefox would perish. there are endless open source forks of major browsers, including FF, and even of mozilla themselves fell apart over night, people would continue to maintain. FF's real threat, as open source software, is either: 1. further capture of mozilla and intentional degradation by google to the point of obscurity 2. organizational implosion followed by google deliberating requiring changes to web standards that break firefox in a way that open source contributions struggle to keep up with 3. a paradigm shift in how we use the internet (i.e. people transition to interacting with AI 98% of the time)
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- p0w3n3d 1y agoTrue true true
- amiga386 1y ago> Firefox [...] may perish because of underfunding Hindsight is 20/20, but remember that Google has paid Mozilla 3.8 BILLION DOLLARS in the past 10 years alone: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Corporation#Finances https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Corporation#Finances You could do a lot with 3.8 billion dollars, if you spent it on your core mission and not chasing Bay Area trendy shit. Mitchell Baker is still there, making phat bank, she's just the chair of the Mozilla Foundation instead of being the CEO of Mozilla Corporation.
- United857 1y agoEdit: they finally did allow JIT for browsers. The article doesn’t mention Apple’s persistent refusal of JIT support for 3rd party JavaScript engines, which is a main barrier to implementing a performant 3rd party browser.
- ec109685 1y agoThey relaxed that for browser makers: https://developer.apple.com/documentation/browserenginekit/protecting-code-compiled-just-in-time https://developer.apple.com/documentation/browserenginekit/p...
- alex1138 1y agoWhy can't the internet just be fun for once
- Spivak 1y agoBecause the web became too "capable." Fun is incompatible with a platform made by and for serious businesses looking to make money with it. It's why the cozy web is a thing that emerged from the corporate theme park that the clear web has become.
- j45 1y agoIt's too bad Apple still doesn't allow different browser engines. Perhaps there's some scenario where webkit usage collapses and chrome increases here that I'm not seeing, and/or some security management issues. Increasingly I'm looking at remote streaming browsers to get what's needed for some use cases.
- WarOnPrivacy 1y agoThis browser engine ban is unique to Apple and no other gatekeeper imposes such a restriction. What other gatekeepers are relevant to the above? Is it just Google? DMA seems to be an EU thing, which I'm guessing makes Asia not relevant here.
- croemer 1y agoAsian countries could just say "We piggyback on DMA and require you to comply with the same rules"
- samat 1y agoI've got a flashback from all the 'civil society/advocacy forums' I've attended. Big Co. send the representatives whose sole purpose is to make it look like they care. They do not. Only state coercion — big fat fines (% of the total income) make any difference. I think personal criminal liability would be a nice step to make corporations finally respect the law, but that's too much to ask from late stage capitalism.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- Jhonnytom 1y ago[dead]