23 ms·
Tell HN: Help restore the tax deduction for software dev in the US (Section 174)
Companies building software in the US were hit hard a few years ago when the tax code stopped allowing deduction of software dev expenses. Now they have to be amortized over several years.
HN has had many discussions about this, including The time bomb in the tax code that's fueling mass tech layoffs - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44180533 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44180533 - (927 comments) a few days ago. Other threads are listed at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44203869 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44203869.
There's currently a major effort to get this change reversed. One of the people working on it is YC's Luther Lowe (https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=itsluther https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=itsluther). Luther has been organizing YC alumni to urge lawmakers to support this reversal. I asked him if we could do that on Hacker News too. He said yes—hence this thread :)
If you're a US taxpayer and if you agree that software dev expenses should be deductible like they used to be, please sign this letter to the relevant committee members: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1DkRGeef2e_tU2xf3TyEyd2JLlmZH8sGs6hhuVkokgpw/viewform?edit_requested=true https://docs.google.com/forms/d/1DkRGeef2e_tU2xf3TyEyd2JLlmZ....
(If you're not a US person, please don't sign the letter, since lawmakers will only listen to feedback from taxpayers and we don't want to dilute the signal.)
I'm sure not everyone here agrees with us—HN is a big community, there's no total agreement on anything—but this issue has as close to a community consensus as HN gets, so I think it makes sense to add our voices too.
Luther will be around to answer questions and hopefully HN can contribute to getting this done!
- nullc 1y agoAn obvious alternative would be tying it to any resulting copyrights and patents, without either there is no asset.
- stego-tech 1y agoI’m all for reverting that part of the tax code, but only on the condition that it’s inapplicable to H-1B visa or foreign worker salaries/payments, provided that employer pays local taxes in those countries for those roles. Keep good paying jobs in the USA. If we need immigrant labor, give them Green Cards instead of precarity.
- lazide 1y agoThe whole point is leverage/precarity.
- stego-tech 1y agoI make said argument fully aware of the point of such schemes. It’s why I suggested, “You know, this is a good opportunity to rebalance the scales somewhat by utilizing a shared goal to extract reasonable concessions.”
- lazide 1y agoMy point is the entire point of them is to extract unreasonable concessions. The math has only shifted even more favorably for extracting even more unreasonable concessions too. Or do you think there is a sudden lack of Indian H1B applicants? Or that tech workers suddenly have more political power than they previously did?
- stego-tech 1y agoI think any idiot with two functioning neurons can see the ruling class of India is trying to pull the same strategy China used to take manufacturing: consistently undercut foreign wages, centralizing knowledge and power before turning it on their customers and extracting wealth and power from countries or organizations that outsourced to them in the first place. I think it’s less a matter of who has more or less power, and more that there is an opportunity here for reconciliation in a way that most sides benefit to some significant degree. * Foreign workers in the USA have more earning potential under such a compromise, allowing them to send more money home or bring family members abroad * Foreign workers abroad see less exploitation and have more impact on domestic policies and industry * Domestic workers see a slowing or reversal of outsourcing, increasing wages and job prospects * Corporate leaders hold off another over-centralization of power by another hostile state, retaining agency and profits for themselves. “The math” is not the be-all-end-all of things, for if it were we would have never lowered taxes as low as we did, enacted debilitatingly unsustainable defined-benefits programs like many pensions and Social Security, or handed out corporate subsidies as if money was free. “The math” paints a clear outcome of the current path that harms the collective peoples of multiple countries just so a handful of monied-classes can reap most of the rewards for themselves. Stop relying solely on short-term data with limited constraints, or big data patterns absent context. Do some critical thinking and path predictions, and these sorts of answers become pretty glaringly obvious, as does the ability for a unique compromise to head things off now instead of a full-on hostile protectionist agenda if this is left unresolved.
- timr 1y agoWhat should we do with the "company" field?
- Supermancho 1y agoUnaffiliated or None, if you're gonna get in on it.
- vessenes 1y agoThanks for working on this guys. The current tax code is fairly crazy: you could spend a few million in salaries, sell 200k of software in a year and possibly owe taxes on that. Even if the company would otherwise be shutting down. The traditional capital asset treatment applied to software leaves a lot to be desired. Some software is a capital asset, but much just isn’t. Or at least should be considered to depreciate rapidly.
- ndriscoll 1y agoI would be surprised if nearly all software companies wouldn't consider their code to be a valuable capital asset. For example, do you think your company would be okay with releasing commits/snapshots of their source code and design docs into the public domain once they hit 5 years old? Or do they currently depreciate too quickly?
- Terr_ 1y agoI don't think that framing really tells us much, because there could be many reasons not to release that code that don't indicate it's an asset, such as (A) worries it might have still-relevant security issues, (B) costs of scrubbing other information like employee PII, or (C) the code is too useless to be worth the effort. If the goal is to measure retained value, I'd ask how much a competitor would pay to acquire your 5-year-old code (for direct use, not for hacking you) without feeling cheated afterwards.
- amluto 1y agoPossibly more than it cost to develop in the first place, at least in some industries. Which might result in utterly absurd tax treatment.
- BJones12 1y agoI think companies view it as a trade secret. Whether or not that particular app is making money, regardless of how old it is, they don't want to release the code.
- 1y ago
- wodenokoto 1y agoOther than it’s nice not to have your profession taxed, what is the argument that software development shouldn’t be taxed as opposed to all sorts of other white collar work?
- nluken 1y agoThe exact law is a bit more nuanced than a "tax deduction for software engineering", but I'm guessing OP put it that way because it makes for a snappier title on a SWE heavy forum like this one. I would check one of the threads that OP posted for more specific information on how the tax code changed a few years ago.
- lazide 1y agoThe proposal isn’t that it not be taxed. Rather that software dev be taxed like an expense, which is easy to track and rationalize, as compared to a capital improvement which is much harder to do so.
- kevin42 1y agoIt's not a matter of whether it's taxed. It's a matter of how the costs are expensed. If I invest a $1m in software development now, I'm not making any profit yet. I may not make a profit. It's a question over whether I need to pay taxes on potential future profit now.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- xnorswap 1y agoThe UK has (had) a tax credit for "Research and Development", intended to be a tax break for genuine R&D, but of course everyone lumped all software development into. The UK eventually put out guidance that business as usual development isn't really "research and development", but afaik there hasn't been a serious crackdown on the practice. It seems kind of absurd to pretend that most work that developers do is pioneering the profession. R&D tax breaks make sense, both to encourage genuine research but also to prevent brain-drain. Not taxing (or tax credits / refunds ) for line-of-business software isn't really excusable. It's bad that the law in the US has been changed in a cliff-edge way though.
- Mistletoe 1y agoWhat is a software dev expense and why should it be tax deductible?
- TimPC 1y agoBecause employee salaries are normally deductible as an expense for companies which generally pay taxes on something resembling profit rather than something resembling revenue. The issue is they are classifying software development as a research activity so the salary has to be amortized over five years with 20% of the expense applying in each of the five years.
- wulfgarbet 1y agoWhen a company that earns $150k/yr and hires a software engineer who costs $100k/yr, that company should be able to deduct that salary in full. The way it works today they must amortize it, taking only 20% per year. So they’d owe taxes on $130k of $150k, instead of the more rational $50k of $150k. This effort is to restore rationality.
- Mistletoe 1y agoWhy was the change made to amortize the tax?
- kbolino 1y agoTo bypass the filibuster. To pass a bill the normal way, you need 60% of the Senate to agree. But certain kinds of bills can be passed through "reconciliation" which only needs a simple majority. Such bills must be "budget neutral" as assessed by the CBO. So legislators throw in hacks like Section 174 in order to game the system and offset other provisions they actually want.
- NaOH 1y agoHere's more information on the Reconciliation Process for anyone interested. PDF: https://www.congress.gov/crs_external_products/R/PDF/R48444/R48444.3.pdf https://www.congress.gov/crs_external_products/R/PDF/R48444/...
- Salgat 1y agoMaybe we should focus on fixing H1B first?
- Jabrov 1y agoWhat's wrong with H-1B?
- KerrAvon 1y agoI'm going to preface this by saying that I support broad liberalization of border controls; immigrants are the backbone of the USA, the engine on which we run, and we should encourage immigration and make it easy for immigrants to settle here. We have the space and resources; anyone who tells you otherwise is lying to you for political gain. So, that said: H-1B shouldn't exist for software. The point of it is to fill jobs that cannot be filled by an American for some reason; a condition that doesn't exist in software development. Hire immigrants as software engineers, fine. But find a way to do it that isn't bullshit.
- SV_BubbleTime 1y agoHmm, I thought Americans were the backbone of the USA.
- AndriyKunitsyn 1y agoIt's a lottery with ~1/3 winning chance. I'd say most of foreign devs in the US are actually L-1 that is actually worse because L-1 prohibits the dev from changing jobs unless the dev gets a new visa.
- varispeed 1y agoIt's subsidy for big corporations so they can get cheap talent whilst removing incentives for domestic workers to learn the trade or upskill. You also get more people competing for resources which means higher prices. Quality of life going down whilst corporations getting richer.
- andrewl-hn 1y ago
- vasco 1y ago> but this issue has as close to a community consensus as HN gets Curious how this is assessed of you could share?
- dang 1y agoThe number of threads and the comments in those threads. e.g. from a few days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44208063 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44208063 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44208875 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44208875 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44207240 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44207240 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44205579 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44205579 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44205479 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44205479 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44204864 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44204864 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44204808 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44204808 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44188578 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44188578 I realize listing a few examples doesn't prove anything, but when I've skim these threads, I see lots of comments like that and few counterarguments. Hence my impression.
- vasco 1y agoThanks - interesting to focus on tax cuts for the already rich but I guess it does make sense if the people here want it.
- mixmastamyk 1y agoBackwards. Startups are typically quite cash poor at the beginning. This gives a huge advantage to the already established, rich companies.
- twodave 1y agoYou're not actually wrong. Reversing it would have immediate and far-reaching benefits for large companies. I suspect many of those would respond by going on hiring sprees. And also, reversing it would encourage more people to start software businesses. So while not a tax cut for small businesses that don't exist yet, it does help those future potential leaders make the leap.
- jayunit 1y agoThe top of the form says "[Letter text -- Please sign by June 4!]" -- is it still helpful to sign?
- lostdog 1y agoInteresting that YC is jumping on this tax code thing, but the shitty tax situation for employees trying to hold onto the equity they've earned is just ignored. The number one problem for startup employees is that the AMT tax makes it impossible to exercise options in a company that is doing well. YC is showing us that they will fight for changes to the tax code when it benefits their bottom line directly, but are silent when it comes to helping startup employees hold onto equity that they have earned. Think carefully before joining a YC startup as an employee.
- dang 1y agoIt's possible to care about more than one thing. Who doesn't?
- lostdog 1y agoYes, it is possible to care about more than one thing. YC was founded more than 20 years ago, and I don't recall any lobbying on the issue of employee tax treatment. If they do care about this they are being super quiet about it.
- SV_BubbleTime 1y agoH1B posts when?
- lisper 1y agoIt's much worse than that. The whole US tax system is severely regressive, with labor paying up to 50% incremental rate if your income is low enough, and return on capital paying as little as zero if you have enough of it.
- deadbabe 1y agoCan’t you just exercise early to avoid AMT?
- lostdog 1y agoOnce a startup hits series A, early exercise is often $X0,000 and a lot of people cannot afford to take a speculative bet with that kind of money.
- robomartin 1y agoSigned. That said, here's my perspective on 174 (which should be reverted to full deduction on the year the expense is incurred). You do not have to amortize 100% of your engineering costs. Not even close. Here's the key: Development costs incurred to remove uncertainty are amortized. All other costs are deductible during the tax year where they are incurred. How does this work? You are going to design a new robot arm. In January, you spend $100K to "remove uncertainty". In rough strokes, this means discovering all the things you don't know and need to know for this robot arm to become a product. This amount will be amortized over five years under 174. Now, with uncertainty removed, you spend an additional $1.1MM from January until December for engineering implementation. No uncertainty being removed. Just building a product. This is 100% deductible that tax year. Analogy: You want to build a new brick wall with specific properties. You spend $100K to develop a new type of brick and $1.1MM to build the wall using that brick. The $100K is amortized, the $1.1MM is deductible in one shot. BTW, at year 6 the amortization schedule reaches steady-state and you are amortizing the full $100K every year. In other words, the impact of 174, if treated intelligently, is the time value of money until steady state is reached for the engineering costs incurred to remove uncertainty. https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.174-2 https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/26/1.174-2
- jonas21 1y agoIf it's software, you do need to amortize 100%. Section 174 (as amended by the TCJA) has specific language to this effect [1]: > For purposes of this section, any amount paid or incurred in connection with the development of any software shall be treated as a research or experimental expenditure. i.e. it needs to be amortized. That's the part that people find most objectionable -- software development is special-cased for unfavorable tax treatment that does not apply to other fields. [1] https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-prelim-title26-section174&num=0&edition=prelim https://uscode.house.gov/view.xhtml?req=granuleid:USC-prelim...
- robomartin 1y agoI firmly believe 174 has to be repealed. Like many bills and regulatory overreach in the US, 174 does not promote and support entrepreneurship, risk-taking, investment, etc. All I am saying in my prior comment is that clever treatment of your engineering costs can improve tax outcomes. We have done just this --under the guidance of our tax attorneys-- and have had no problems at all. Of course, a company that is a pure software enterprise and not multi-disciplinary, like us, is, well screwed. Keep in mind that at year 6 you are effectively deducting your full R&D costs, even for a pure software company. The real cost is the TVM due to the phase shift, at year six you reach steady state (assuming steady costs).
- jaimsam 1y ago[dead]
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- varsketiz 1y agoSomehow I'm not a fan of HN using this community for lobbyism purposes.
- dang 1y agopg used to do it semi-regularly, especially on internet freedom isssues (edit: and software patents, IIRC), so arguably this is getting back to HN's roots. I remember he did an anti-SOPA thing on HN which involved some kind of banner at the top of the frontpage. It's probably saved at archive.org somewhere.
- varsketiz 1y agoI guess I understand internet freedom causes better. Also, they are universal worldwide, this is USA specific
- jandrewrogers 1y agoIt affects any software developers worldwide that work for US companies. The specific tax law is even worse for foreign developers, since it requires amortization of non-American software developer expenses over 15 years instead of 5 years. How much code is written that retains its value for 15 years?
- varsketiz 1y agoProbably less than 1%.
- mmooss 1y ago> internet freedom isssues Freedom - an essential public good - is much different than using HN for lobbying for tax policy that favors YC. You know that doing this is a big change. Why not be straightforward about it - including whose idea it is, what the parameters are, what the new policy is, etc.? If you feel you can't or feel hesitant, then you know something is wrong. It changes the nature of HN in my mind, to something manipulative - not unlike other social media, and not unlike the trend in other businesses who embrace manipulation to greater and greater degrees. We each have a personal responsibility to the world, as adults, to stand up for essential values. If we don't, in each of our communities, workplaces, and homes, who will? We are the only ones here; we aren't kids (not that you said we are, but to clarify the point) who can destroy things and leave it to the adults; nobody else will come in and save us. > getting back to HN's roots You can see a lot of companies and politicians using that - find some historical precedent and claim that is the 'roots'. There are many more roots then that.
- andrewmcwatters 1y agoYes, but with strong exceptions against offshoring software development labor and H-1B abuse. Both of these problems are rampant. I’ve seen entire shops with underpaid foreign workers and mass layoffs with workers replaced with offshore and nearshore firms.
- sdg3Q5g 1y agoIsn't this tied to the budget bill ("One Big Ugly Bill") that effectively removes the last way federal judge's can hold anyone in the Trump admin accountable?
- matthberg 1y agoExactly, this letter refers to the "reconciliation bill" without mentioning the better known (and more notorious) monikers "Big Beautiful Bill" or "One Big Ugly Bill". There are so many horrific things in it, the bill must be fully opposed, not endorsed with minor changes.
- duxup 1y agoThis is less on that specific topic and more general: While I enjoy the hacker news forums a great deal, I've no relationship with YC as an org. I am not sure that YC has any particular interest in things that might impact me as an individual contributor in an org as much as it impacts them. Understandably there's an everyone for themselves aspect here, but that makes these kinds of call to actions a bit hollow to me.
- dang 1y agoSure, YC is a business. But HN has so many people building software that there's also a community interest here—otherwise I wouldn't have suggested this thread. pg used to do this kind of thing on HN from time to time, especially on internet freedom issues, so this is a bit of return-to-roots for the site. SOPA is the one I remember but there were others.
- freedomben 1y agoJust my two cents of course, but I think this is an excellent post for HN. One of the most directly relevant to people in this community (even those who don't seem to understand why) in a very long time.
- JamesBarney 1y agoThis is something that both impacts them and impacts you if you're a developer. This tax treatment can increase the cost of a dev by 5-15% which leads to less hiring and a looser job market. Which will impact us even if we're not looking for work because most companies look at market rates when deciding raises.
- duxup 1y agoPossibly, but I think if YC companies could get away with just cutting everyone they would too. I don't doubt there's an impact here, but it's not because they have a real interest in any other topics that concern me and hiring, H1B and so on.
- jgalt212 1y agoAs a business owner, I've been adversely impacted by this. I still can't wrap my head around how this is legal or sustainable. If I buy $1MM of plant and equipment, I may not be able to expense it all in year 1, but I can relatively easily get a loan to finance the purchase of such--and manage my cashflows. The same is not for devs. I cannot easily get a loan for $1MM in dev salaries. In my own case, I don't need the loan to pay the salaries. I need the loan to pay the taxes for the portion of the salaries I cannot deduct as an expense. It's just insane.
- thaumasiotes 1y agoQuestion: say you buy the equipment personally and then rent it to your business. What does the tax treatment look like?
- jgalt212 1y agoIf the company is a pass through entity, I'm pretty sure this nets out to zero. I don't know how this nets out under a C corp.
- projektfu 1y agoA common arrangement is for a closely held corporation to rent its space from another corporation or LLC held by the same owner. This allows the asset to be protected from liability as well as simplifying accounting by splitting it into two businesses, the core business and the real-estate business. Tax-wise, it's a wash, if the income passes through to the same owners.
- silverlight 1y agoHappy to support this, desperately needs to be changed.
- mediaman 1y agoA lot of people don't know what this Section 174 is about, so here's a brief explainer. Normally, when you have expenses, you deduct them off your revenue to find your taxable profit. If you have $1 million in sales, and $900k in costs, you have $100k in profit, and the government taxes you on that profit. Section 174 says you can't do this for software engineers. If you pay a software engineer, that's not "really" an "expense", regardless of the fact that you paid them. What you've actually done, Congress said, is bought a capital good, like a machine. And for calculating tax owed, you have to depreciate that over several years (5 in this case). Depreciating means that if you pay an engineer $200k in a year, in tax-world you only had $40k of real expense that year, even though you paid them $200k. So the effect is that it makes engineers much more expensive, because normally when a company hires an engineer, like they spend on any other expense, they can at least think "well, they will reduce our profit, which reduces our tax obligation," but in this case software engineers are special and aren't deductible in the same way. In the case of the $200k engineer, you deduct the first $40k in the first year, then you can expense another $40k from that first year in the second year, the third $40k in the third year, and so on through the fifth year. So eventually you get to expense the entire first year of the engineer's pay, but only after five years. The effect is that companies wind up using their scarce capital to loan the federal government money for five years, and so engineers become a heavy financial burden. If a company hires too many engineers, they will owe the federal government income tax even in years in which they were unprofitable. These rules, by the way, don't apply to other personnel costs. If you hire an HR person or a corporate executive, you expense them in the year you paid them. It's a special rule for software engineers. It was passed by Congress during the first Trump administration in order to offset the costs of other corporate tax rate cuts, due to budgeting rules.
- api 1y agoDoesn’t this also unfairly penalize bootstrapped companies? VC track companies seldom have taxable profits.
- davidjfelix 1y agoIt may result in an outsized penalty to bootstrapped companies but being VC funded doesn't make you immune to this. VC funded companies with revenue will not be able to offset their revenue by reinvesting in R&D (software development) expenses, so in some cases they may be seen as having a profit when they previously wouldn't have. In those cases they'd have a tax burden.
- mupuff1234 1y agoCan we bundle this with closing the carry tax loophole?
- jsherwani 1y agoFor folks that don't know the background on this, here's a layperson summary: - A business is usually taxed on its profits: you deduct your revenue from the cost of producing that revenue, and the delta is what you are taxed on. - In software businesses, this usually means if you spend $1M in software development to develop a web app, and it makes $1.1M in that year, you'd get taxed on the $100K profits. - However, a few years ago, the IRS stopped allowing the $1M to be deducted in the year it was incurred. Instead, the $1M was to be amortized over 5 years, so now the business can only count $200K as the deductible expense for that year. So now it's going to be taxed on "profits" of $900K. Assuming the tax rate is 20%, that means the business owes $180K in taxes, even though it has a total of $100K in the bank after the actual expenses were paid. So it would have to either borrow to pay taxes or raise venture capital, meaning that VC-funded companies would be advantaged over bootstrapped ones! - The letter's goal is to bring things back to how they were (and how they are for all other businesses): let businesses deduct their actual expenses from their actual revenue, and tax that actual profit. I am neither a lawyer nor an accountant, this is just my understanding of this issue. Edit: Switched the tax rate to 20%. The logic is still the same.
- readthenotes1 1y agoWhy do you assume a 50% tax rate in the United States when it is only 21%?
- quietbritishjim 1y agoI think they meant "assume" like a mathematician, i.e., pretend it is this simple value to make all the calculations easier to understand. But it's still useful to know the real rate is 21%, thanks.
- cjbgkagh 1y agoState, city, property, social security tax, other fees and levies that should really be classified as taxes. The total tax burden can really add up.
- jsherwani 1y ago
- atxtechbro 1y agoSigned. As a US-based developer, I fully support restoring the deductibility of software development expenses. This policy change quietly gutted countless startups and engineering teams—it’s long past time we fix it. Appreciate YC and folks like @itsluther pushing this forward. This isn’t just a tax issue—it’s about keeping innovation and talent thriving in the US. Let’s get it done.
- arrowsmith 1y ago[flagged]
- andrewlgood 1y agoThat is actually why software development was allowed to be expensed prior to 2017 - to keep innovation thriving in the US. In 2017, they US simply stopped giving preferential treatment to R&D.
- smilliken 1y agoThe em dash was in popular use long before chatgpt. It's a useful grammatical symbol and a short dash is not a good substitute. Consider whether you'd use it if it was a dedicated key on your keyboard, if so then it's worth the small inconvenience to learn how to type it.
- arrowsmith 1y agoNot just the em dash, the whole post stinks of ChatGPT, and there are two other obvious tells in the sentence I quoted. If you know you know.
- smilliken 1y agoFair enough. I'm sensitive about the em dash being used as a tell, which I've seen mentioned once or twice, because I don't want people to dumb down punctuation to avoid being confused for an LLM. I'd guess it's a temporary issue until the LLMs get so good at blending in that we can't tell anymore.
- callamdelaney 1y agoIt’s just a salary expense, where should software come into it? Eg 1m salary costs 100k other costs 1.1m revenue 0 profit 0 tax Anything else doesn’t make sense to me
- bdcravens 1y agoAre there any sources for the argument why this should apply to software and not to, say, farm equipment? The cash flow and taxation story seems to be the same.
- xn 1y agopresumably it's status quo bias
- freedomben 1y agoWhen you buy farm equipment, you're getting something that (barring manufacturer defects, natural disasters, etc) is (nearly always at least) a long-term asset going to be providing a very predictable level of value over the next many years. Same with computers and things like that. With software development, the predictability is almost entirely non-existent for new and/or smaller software companies. I've personally worked on many projects/codebases that either never shipped or threw away huge parts of the code before shipping. You're not really taking a financial gamble . Also I think it's worth mentioning that, software engineers are people who are paid salaries, while farm equipment is not. A more accurate comparison would be if instead of buying a finished tractor you hired a couple of handymen to come build you one from scratch. It may or may not work at all. It might end up costing you 10x or 20x or more what you would have paid for an off-the-shelf solution (so valuing it at the labor cost is a ridiculous thing to do. Who in the market is going to buy a custom-built tractor at 20x the market rate?)
- rvba 1y agoHow is farm equipment predictable? Droughts and floods make farming unpredictable.
- jandrewrogers 1y agoThe value of farm equipment is independent of its use.
- andrewlgood 1y agoThere is an analogous set of rules for things like farm equipment. It is called accelerated depreciation and the government has used it for decades to increase incentives for purchasing capital equipment. Because software development did not already fit in the definition of a capitalizable expense, the lawmakers modified the research and development rules to allow it.
- arturocamembert 1y agoWhat's particularly wild about the choice to tax software development in this way is that it assumes that code is always asset. For companies that are pre product market fit, it's often a liability!
- andrewlgood 1y agoInteresting perspective. Firms actually have to evaluate each year whether it is really an asset. If they determine that product is no longer useful, they would write off the remaining balance immediately.
- siliconc0w 1y agoThis is where it's really important to use a bug tracker that can distinguish between bugs/maintenance and feature development. The former can be deducted but the latter has to be amortized.
- SteveNuts 1y agoThat doesn't help whatsoever in this situation, the wording does not leave any room for distinguishing bugs/maintenance and feature development.
- tzs 1y agoThe law says: > For purposes of this section, any amount paid or incurred in connection with the development of any software shall be treated as a research or experimental expenditure I don't see why that would not apply to software developed for bug fixes or maintenance.
- siliconc0w 1y agoRead the latest notice https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/n-23-63.pdf https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/n-23-63.pdf You can deduct internal tools, training, maintenance, data conversion activities, installation, distribution, marketing, promotion, etc. So it's definitely worth it to use an issue tracker to tie your engineer's commits to bugs and categorize their bugs as either feature development or one of these activities. Depending how aggressive you want to get, if a LLM builds a feature that you beta launch and the engineer fixes the LLM's mistakes to get it working you can probably argue that is correcting errors or defects in software that isn't adding new functionality and thus deductible.
- wg0 1y agoI wonder what has happened to the US legislators. Don't they do their homework or too desperate to patch the huge budget deficit?
- cesarb 1y agoForgive me if this has already been answered in one of the other threads (I haven't been following them), but: How does this work in other countries?
- andrewl-hn 1y agoIt's not amortized. I.e. the company simply subtracts all salaries for the year from the revenue and pays tax from the difference. Salaries being amortized means on year 1 you can only subtract X% of salaries and the taxable amount becomes much larger. Year 2 you will use the X% for the second year salary and another Y% for the already paid salary of the first year. So, the difference becomes less, and the taxes become less, too. For a stable company that has a constant revenue stream and an established body of workers there's no much of a difference: instead of paying all tax for current year salary you pay 6 chunks of tax for 6 different years of salaries - which would be about the same amount. For early companies things can be pretty tough. You may earn, say 100k in a year one and pay your employee 100k. Your company now has 0 in the bank, but for the taxation purposes the taxable amount is like (100k - 10% of 100k = 90k), at 20% corporate tax that would mean that the company has 0 in the bank but owes the government $18k in taxes. It's much harder to start a software business in this kind of environment.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- andreasgl 1y agoIn Sweden you have the option to capitalize software development costs, under some specific circumstances, but in general you would expense such costs immediately. Some startups do it to window-dress their balance sheet, though. But making it compulsory is absurd.
- chermi 1y agoCan someone steelman the positives for me? I don't see how it's anything but pure regulatory capture favoring established tech firms. A small company ramping up revenue simply can't handle this amortization while a large, established company can. That being said, I do think there's a little sloppiness in what is categorized as "R&D" in the software development. Is code maintenance R&D? Bug fixes? Performance improvements? Is it a "capital asset" no longer under R&D once it hits production? This aspect has always seemed too gray given how much money is at stake in taxes. But again, this complexity is an advantage for more established firms with legal departments and the infrastructure in place to document everything in order to handle audits. Which, in my view, is a form of regulatory capture; this presentation of symptoms of regulatory capture is pretty common. One potential argument I can see is that maybe this balances out since presumably the more established firms would have less "R&D" as a fraction of expenses to deduct in the first place? Edited to fix some typos and clarity.
- Analemma_ 1y ago> Can someone steelman the positives for me? They’re literally aren’t any. Treating payroll expenses as depreciating assets is insane, and that’s why it isn’t done in any other context— not in the US or anywhere else in the world. That sounds like a biased explanation, but it’s genuinely the truth: it was stuck in the Trump’s tax bill to help it evade budget balancing rules, but was designed to be so stupid that a future Congress would “surely” repeal it, after the TCJA had passed successfully. This sort of horse-trading happens all the time with budgets, but for whatever reason, this provision was never undone.
- redler 1y agoThe purpose, if you want to call it a positive, was to be one of many revenue increases designed to offset the cost of the income tax cuts that were the primary focus of that legislation.
- floxy 1y agoDoesn't this kind of make sense if software is an asset? If your company purchases a seat of Oracle or Solidworks or Windows 11 or whatever. I don't think you can expense that all at one time, you have to amortize over the useful life of the software, just like if it was a physical printing press or a backhoe. Similar if you were making a software program for sale or for use internally, there is the upfront costs associated with making the software, and then it gets used/sold for the next X number of years. And software never wears out, unlike a tractor; that's at least why physical goods are amortized over a finite life. Probably the biggest problem is that this conceptualization of software might be 20 years out of date.
- analog31 1y agoI wonder if something like this could also help the hardware industry, thus encouraging more manufacturing in the US.
- andrewlgood 1y agoThis has already been done in the hardware space for decades. Periodically the government will want to incentivize the purchase of capital equipment, including computer hardware, and will offer accelerated depreciation. Fully expensing things in the current year is just the most accelerated the IRS can make the depreciation. Note, by accelerating the depreciation, they are reducing taxes in the current year(s) while the program is in place (always have a limited period) but increasing them when the program expires.
- freedomben 1y agoLuther et al, would you be willing to share some high level statistics about the submissions, such as how many signatures it gets?
- itsluther 1y ago20 hours in, there are over 1,800 signatories. It appears the signatories are from nearly all states as well (minus Wyoming and North Dakota): https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1jxiSSfj4uG7UBOHPjCbHfYAIho30tiQ&usp=sharing https://www.google.com/maps/d/edit?mid=1jxiSSfj4uG7UBOHPjCbH...
- rietta 1y agoThis US tax code change directly impacted my small business in a very real way that was directly felt by my household. In the past, it was a big boon for us and helped me afford to pay for some open source work and experimental things that helped our customers in the long run. Now we are back to mostly doing work-for-hire consulting. Even the experimental work I am doing, I am just paying for it and writing it off as typical business expenses. I cannot afford to take the credit because that means no deduction for this year. I don't have the cash in this small business context.
- emorning3 1y ago[flagged]
- pbhjpbhj 1y agoProbably hoping for a bribe. Trump has made at least two clear mechanisms for that -- purchasing meal tickets or Trump-coin.
- freedomben 1y agoI would strongly suspect you over-estimate the number of people on HN who voted for Trump. Also, generally speaking, calling people "dummies" isn't usually an effective way to persuade them to examine your arguments rationally/logically.
- emorning3 1y ago[flagged]
- dang 1y agoYikes—you can't attack others like this here. I've banned the account. If you don't want to be banned on Hacker News, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- emorning3 1y ago[dead]
- gg-plz 1y agoThe military is being unleashed against civilians and this is the political issue you’re concerned about on today of all days? Dang, you’re one of the bad ones.
- dang 1y agohttps://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20randomness&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- chasd00 1y agowow, i'm going to copy/paste my response to someone upthread about how it's a bad idea for HN to get involved in political things like this. "The main issue to me is now every political issue that isn't raised here makes HN complicit in its success/failure. Once HN starts down this path it can only continue and accelerate or else face accusations of support/opposition through silence."
- AStonesThrow 1y ago[dead]
- hcfman 1y agoAnyone know what the situation in Europe is?
- FirmwareBurner 1y agoMost European countries don't have deductions for SW devs. Romania had it for a long time and removed it due to gov budget deficits. Some other CEE countries might still have them, but in general most socialist western European countries don't have them, which is why they don't have a tech industry.
- nnx 1y agoIs that a special case for SW devs or they also aren't able to deduct other employees?
- sireat 1y agoWhat do you mean? I am in Eastern Europe and as far as know software development costs are fully deductible just like any other employee costs. Even more so for startups in Estonia and Latvia (probably Lithuania too) you can fully deduct R&D in general - not sure for how long. That is you have you have 1M in sales 200k in net profit(after paying for everything including software development). If that 200k in net profit is plowed back into speculative R&D it does not incur income taxes until money is paid out. Even more so you can invest some 200k pre-tax in assets such as buildings. You only get taxed when you actually take out the money. In a way this is a pretty big loophole provided you are actually cash flow positive. Basically in Baltics you can follow the early Amazon strategy of not making net profit, but investing in growth.
- FirmwareBurner 1y ago>What do you mean? Exactly what I wrote. >I am in Eastern Europe and[...] Eastern Europe is not a country. Every EU country has completely different legal and tax regimes. And I specifically said that some CEE countries are the exception and do exactly what you said, but that high-tax/high-welfare EU countries usually do not, since their welfare deficit is so high they don't hand out special tax incentives for SW industry as they need to tax everything that moves in order to not go bust, and due to their tiny SW industry, tax breaks for SW work would be politically unpopular with the majority voters working in other industries which see SW devs as overpaid and spoiled already. It's a tragedy of the commons coupled with crabs in a bucket mentality. So how does your comment contradict mine? Read it again, maybe you missed it. >you can fully deduct R&D in general Depends what each country defines as R&D in their legal framework and how much creative accounting you're legally allowed to do. Some countries don't count web app development as R&D though, so of course have a lot less successful unicorns, and a less developed SW industry. R&D tends to be more like pharma, aerospace, lasers, bio engineering, that kind of stuff, not building another food delivery app.
- TheTaytay 1y agoThank you for helping to tackle this. The silence on this issue for the past few years from smaller software companies and their affiliates was surprising to me. The recent "time bomb" article was one of the few media pieces that actually took the time to describe it as anything other than a "tax cut for huge tech companies", which was refreshing. My current favorite theory as to why there hasn't been more of an outcry is that many companies ignored the rule change (either out of ignorance or as an alternative to going out of business), and are forced to remain silent.
- charlieyu1 1y agoAnd this benefits big firms because they are the only ones who can afford it. Same for most bullshit laws.
- winter_blue 1y ago> many companies ignored the rule change How does that even work? You’re saying many companies committed tax fraud by ignoring the law change and continued to deduct software developer salaries as they had in the past? I find that hard to believe.
- TheTaytay 1y agoYou're right. I take it back - not "most", but I would stand behind "many more than is typical for a change to the tax code". It snuck up on a LOT of people, including CPAs, and represented tax bills for businesses that were multiples of the previous year's tax bill, and sometimes _multiples_ of their actual cash profit. It's also so counter-intuitive that you can't deduct software dev salaries, that many people still don't believe it works the way the law says it works. If you read the comments here and in other threads where this has been mentioned, on Hacker News or elsewhere, years into this fiasco, you'll see widespread doubt and misunderstanding. Many people equate this to the same R&D rules for the older tax _credit_ or will argue that it can't possibly work the way the articles say it works. People don't magically begin to understand section 174 just because they run a business, and it's not in their financial interest _TO_ understand how it works. Many can't afford to.
- deleted 1y ago
- codingdave 1y agoSigning a letter is fine, but will not have the same impact as phone calls made to your representatives. https://5calls.org/why-calling-works/ https://5calls.org/why-calling-works/ You don't need to use that site - the point is that if you want to have the loudest voice, make some calls.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- sergiotapia 1y agoOk, say I call. What do I say: "Hey I want to show my support for the Big Beautiful Bill because it reverses the tax deduction for software engineers." And then what? (asking honestly lol for anyone who's done this before)
- codingdave 1y agoSay whatever you feel. They will listen to you and sort it out into support or opposition to current legislative efforts. You don't have to have a perfect script - just tell them what you think. But I would caution you to talk about the issues you care about, not telling them you support a specific bill. Because they need to know what issues you care about so that when legislators propose changes to the bills (which always happens), they know whether those changes are aligned with what they are hearing from the people. You'll note that the letter OP linked to does not say that it supports the bill - it supports a specific change they want to be prioritized.
- threeseed 1y ago[flagged]
- threeseed 1y ago[flagged]
- dang 1y ago
- skizm 1y agoI'm curious: what was the original argument for this special case of counting anyone involved in software dev as an asset instead of an employee?
- tomschwiha 1y agoThe idea is, that there is some asset generated by the devs (software, etc.). Same as a machine that you buy and that generates revenue over time (and loses value over time). So the work result (the software) of a dev generates revenue over time and the costs are spread over time as well.
- skizm 1y agoI guess I'm preaching to the choir here, but a machine has re-sale value outside of what it produces, which is what actually makes it a "asset". This argument could be applied to any knowledge worker that makes a spreadsheet since you can sell the spreadsheet.
- tomschwiha 1y agoI'm not sure if I can follow your argument. A software dev usually works on something that is actually sellable (the spreadsheet software itself or a SaaS platform). If we take Facebook the platform as an example, for sure you could sell the software. Or a startup like Windsurf that gets bought because of the software they developed. So from my perspective devs actually create assets. If there should be tax discounts to make it attractive to develop software is the political decision.
- andrewlgood 1y agoYou are actually pointing out the difference between physical assets and intangible assets. Mailing lists are the classic example of an intangible asset. Trademarks as well. For clarity, the argument is that a firm could sell the software developed by engineers if it wanted to
- kogus 1y agoI'm going to be that guy and just say that one of the many many harmful side effects of income taxes is the kind of social engineering power it gives politicians, who are neither qualified nor properly motivated to make good decisions with such tools. Income taxes are an unethical pollution to our society and government.
- SteveNuts 1y agoWhat do you propose instead?
- kogus 1y agoIn principle, I do not think the income tax should be replaced by anything at all. Most federal spending is either unnecessary or actively harmful. But practically speaking, I'd suggest a federal sales tax combined with a Universal Basic Income subsidy to all citizens (e.g., everyone gets a check for $X every month). The subsidy would cover the increase in prices for anyone below a certain income level - it would effectively produce a progressive tax structure without the privacy infringement. There would be no loopholes or exemptions to think about either.
- downrightmike 1y agoWe need zero interest rates back to actually get this to work, because that means essentially zero risk to any project. even s174 can't do that.
- righthand 1y agoCould LLM companies be lobbying to remove this tax incentive in hopes to help kill the job?
- daft_pink 1y agoI was under the impression that this was included in the current one big bill and will continue to be included. It’s not something we would expect to be removed.
- btilly 1y agoThe current one big bill does a 5 year reversion back to the old rules, and then goes back to the problem existing. So it is the same idea as the 2017 bill. See https://exactera.com/resources/what-one-big-beautiful-bill-act-means-for-your-rd-tax-credits/ https://exactera.com/resources/what-one-big-beautiful-bill-a... for details. I will warn you, though, that the provisions are complicated enough that it is hard to read the article. The problem is that we don't know whether this will get fixed in that time frame. Also that big bill introduces its own problems. A future Congress with debt financing problems may not realistically have the freedom to revert terms such as this one.
- daft_pink 1y agoFair enough. I missed that the point of this was to make it permanent instead of just getting it added to the bill or keeping it in the bill.
- breakingrules3 1y ago[dead]
- throwawaymaths 1y agothe real question is why is r&d for startups in general amortized in the first place? doesn't this discourage startups pursuing risky hard science ventures?
- fsckboy 1y agothe reason property plant and equipment is amortized over time instead of expensed right away is to match up the tax deduction with the profit. If building a factory and filling it with robots will produce cars over a 10 year period in the future, it makes sense to subtract those costs over the same 10 year period. Matching profits with expenses is essentially why accounting was invented in the first place, so financial statements would show smoother and continuous operation of a smooth and continuous company, instead of big peaks and valleys as if something had happened. With software companies, developing software (like Microsoft Windows) allows you to profit from that software over the next 5 years. Matching profits with expenses makes rational sense. Frequenty, politicians use the tax code to implement popular social policy. This way they can reward things and groups they want to, and still be able to say "we aren't giving subsidies, we aren't giving people cash, we are simply giving tax deductions and tax credits" These sorts of programs are, across the board, more distorting of the economy and make the tax code incomprehensibly more complex. But matching expenses against profits? makes perfect sense.
- throwawaymaths 1y agoyeah but a high risk venture going from zero has exactly this problem: you might fail to build your product, and crazy enough the weight of having x% tax may have made the difference. you should be able to choose if you'd like to do immediate accounting or amortized accounting.
- fsckboy 1y agoinvestors pay tax on profits, write off losses. The investors can add money in if they feel the idea is good. The tax code should not tilt the balance of the market. people on this site complaining about lobbyists, regulatory capture etc, up and down the page, but wanting their own industry favored is a great illustration of the problems we face.
- yieldcrv 1y agoIt’s in the big beautiful bill what’s the issue?
- jollyllama 1y agoWhy is it that tracking expenses as R&D is bad? Where I work, we started tracking our R&D hours compared to other work recently, and an increase in R&D hours has resulted in less tax burden. Edit: not sure why the downvote, it's an honest question. I'm not arguing anything.
- CodesInChaos 1y agoHaving to pay taxes earlier hurts liquidity. This is particularly problematic for small companies growing quickly, such as startups. For VC financed companies it means that they need to raise the money to pay the ta when they're still smaller, and thus have a lower valuation.
- jollyllama 1y agoThanks for the simplified explanation. It does make me question though whether this is really fueling layoffs at larger firms like Meta and Microsoft. Why wouldn't they be fine with paying the tax hit early?
- anigbrowl 1y agoI seem to remember people being broadly in favor of this change at the time it was first proposed because it would elevade software development and create more long-term stability, but in a world where the primary focus is on quarterly funding rounded and acquisitions it obviously skews the numbers and thus the potential founded/early investor upside. There are two possible motivations for the impending change. One is the argument that deducting 100% of developer labor isn't ideal because developers create IP whose value can compound as an asset, rather than the labor being 'consumed' in production as with manufacturing (where any long-term benefit after the initial sale goes to the consumer). The other is that it's a legislative stick designed to herd a powerful investor/donor lobby into supporting budget legislation in exchange for turning the favorable tax treatment faucet back on.
- lmeyerov 1y agoI don't recall there being favorable reception when Trump's Congress passed it nor since. At best, non-awareness, and 'cost of business' for whatever the other talking points at the time. You can see the older HN threads, people were shocked, and it comes up perennially, with calls to restore favorable tax treatment that incentivizes vs punishes business growth. Same pattern in social media responses to news articles.
- twodave 1y agoYes, as far as I can tell, this change was made to help balance the cost of other provisions in the TCJA. On paper, it would have at least let them claim they'd take in 5 years of extra tax revenue in from tech businesses (most of it in year 1). I don't think it has any long-term benefit for anyone, even the government.
- twodave 1y agoAnd the changes proposed in the Big Beautiful Bill actually do reverse it, and allow some retro-active (to tax year 2022) relief. So they're trying to undo it, and of course the Democratic party is calling it "a tax break for billionaires", which, of course, it is. But that doesn't really tell the whole story, either.
- alistairSH 1y agoPossibly dumb question... For a medium/large company, is this really a big deal? Their payroll is relatively stable year-over-year, so after a few years, it all evens out (very roughly). Or am I missing something? IE, is this really an anti-competition law, designed to protect entrenched tech industry players and prevent up-starts from, well, starting?
- beAbU 1y agoBased on everything I've read on it in this thread so far, it seems like it's pretty much hurting the little guys the most. Whether this is malicious or intentional or just incompetent or something I honestly don't know. Donald Trump's deeds and behaviour is just about the only place where I find myself unable to apply Hanlon's Razor.
- twodave 1y agoI think if you spend a few minutes reading about the origin of this change, it's pretty obvious this was a sacrificial lamb for the TCJA to pass. It gave them ~5 years of noticeable extra tax revenue they could use to balance the other provisions. So today, 8 years later, it's not doing anyone any good (and removing it, unless done carefully, might essentially reverse that 5 years of extra revenue, but all in a single year).
- murdockq 1y agoI've heard that many of the big tech layoffs where actually just moved / converting them to contracting groups, so they lose the direct head count but kept the developer via the intermediary. Have others heard this too and could this have been a way to label contractors differently so they don't fall under this tax code?
- walterbell 1y agoWhich entity typically owns a software asset created by contracted developers?
- andrewlgood 1y agoSome firms use proprietary software to run their business. The development costs of that development may be eligible to be capitalized under Section 174. The idea is to make it similar to if they simply bought software off the shelf which they would be allowed to capitalize. Before someone mentions Excel, most firms have a threshold the expense has to clear before it is considered for capitalization. Excel is under most firm’s threshold.
- processing 1y agoI built a lightweight grassroots advocacy tool for this. It figures out who your reps are and sends them a pre-filled note based on what matters to you (you can edit/customize it before it sends). Includes a call script too if you're up for calling... https://secure.legisletter.org/campaign/cmbpf5js80000l70d5fni6zfg https://secure.legisletter.org/campaign/cmbpf5js80000l70d5fn...
- garrickvanburen 1y agoWhat inspired working to reverse this now? I'm all for it, just curious as the law has existed for 8 years and been in effect for 3. Seemingly little interest from anyone in the tech world to put lobbying behind reversing it until this point. What changed?
- ghc 1y agoLobbying has been ongoing since the law was enacted. Congress came close to repealing it several times, with the House actually passing a bill to repeal it (Tax Relief for American Families and Workers Act of 2024). Just because Hacker News doesn't care doesn't mean it hasn't been a big focus of small business lobbying since before it came into effect. The actual reason it hasn't been repealed is politics: It makes the CBO budget deficit look much worse. It seems as though neither party wants the optics.
- nolok 1y agoA terrible tax bill during Trump 1 cutting taxes to anyone making lot of money and they needed to find some sort of source of income to compensate.
- LastTrain 1y agoNow is the time to strike because there is a very easy to manipulate person who will change things like this on an emotional whim.
- threeseed 1y agoI assume so it can be included in the Big Beautiful Bill. And if that is the case then shame on everyone who are happy to make themselves wealthier at the expense of the poor. People are literally going to die because of the cuts to Medicaid/SNAP in this bill.
- phendrenad2 1y agoAt the beginnning, to most people it seemed like a non-issue (oh no, amortize the costs over 5 years, cry me a river big tech etc. etc.). But now that the entire tech sector is crumbling, and nobody is getting hired, people are giving it another (well-deserved) look.
- xyst 1y agoI would appreciate some transparency. I have seen fictional/theoretical scenarios around this simplified to the following: "You have $1M in engineering expenses annually. So now instead of deducting $1M per year. Now you can only deduct $200K in that tax year. And then amortize it over 5 years" But we all know this isn’t a vacuum. The US tax code is massive, corporate tax reduced over decades. You are telling me this single paragraph in the US tax code is directly causing massive layoffs? Or is this single paragraph in the US tax code used as a scapegoat to initiate layoffs and then used to pump P&L and thus still approve C-level executive bonuses? These big companies have access to massive accounting firms and they can’t work their fucking magic on a single paragraph of text? I call bullshit on big tech.
- GuinansEyebrows 1y agoi'm torn. on one hand, i simply do not care if business do not want to pay more in taxes. in fact, i gladly accept the premise that business should pay more in taxes. in practice, the slippery slope argument is that this will entrench big-money players, which i don't support, because they'll be the only ones who can afford this. i also fear that it'll lead to an irresponsible adoption of "virtual coders" because it's cheaper than paying juniors. kind of a rock and a hard place for me.
- bawana 1y agoDoesnt this new law inhibit rapid turnover tho? Since it takes 5 years to get the full deduction of an employee’s salary, there is an incentive to keep the employee around. OTOH, the souless bean counters who want quarterly (if not shorter) time horizons, will simply decrease starting salaries and use other methods to be net zero. If they do shaft the software engineers, then the converse is true-no employee should stay at a job more than a year because only the corp will benefit as the deduction grows
- eximius 1y agoNot clear to me that this is true. The expense was incurred, they just claim it over 5 years. It's not clear that the same employee is required to be there in subsequent years to claim the expense from year 1 in year 2.
- verdverm 1y agoIt doesn't really matter how many devs you have in any given year. What 174 does is make software a capital expense with no choice in how it gets depreciated over time. It's like having to expense the electricians wages during factory construction over 5 years.
- jmcgough 1y agoThe short-term effect is that engineers become more expensive, so you can afford to hire less engineers. This creates more of a moat for large well-established companies at the expense of new startups.
- variaga 1y agoNot really - it incentivizes having the same total number of SW developers for many years, but they don't actually have to be the same people. If you work at $CORP for 1 year (or 1 minute), $CORP gets to deduct the 1/5th of what they paid you for all 5 years, whether you still work there or not.
- apt-apt-apt-apt 1y agoSeems like it'd incentivize layoffs. You have amortized deductions coming up, with layoffs you pay less to expensive engs and have relatively more saved up deductions than w/o amort. Thus, big short-term benefit to layoffs.
- sergiotapia 1y agoSigned, thank you so much for organizing this. I hope this change is made reality. We must retvrn.
- socalgal2 1y ago@dang (and others). If you want a groundswell of support have you consider have you considered reaching out to game devs and indie game devs? It seems like they'd all be negatively affected. They'd spread the word to players.
- dang 1y agoThat's a great idea but I don't know how to do it except by posting a thread like this one on HN itself.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- n_u 1y agoSigned and called my representative and senators. I ask simply "If I have $1m of revenue and $1m of expenses that is entirely software dev salaries, what do you think my profit is for that year? How much should I be taxed on that?" https://www.house.gov/representatives/find-your-representative https://www.house.gov/representatives/find-your-representati... https://www.senate.gov/senators/senators-contact.htm https://www.senate.gov/senators/senators-contact.htm
- TechDebtDevin 1y agoHot take. Maybe SWEs making lawyer money was always unsustainable.
- croemer 1y agoThere are US taxpayers and/or voters who don't live in the US
- bad_haircut72 1y agoluckily for me my startup makes no revenue so we're unaffected by this :sunglasses:
- pzo 1y agoWish someone in EU do similar signing / votes for lobbying EU for taxing US Tech companies or applying 15 years amortization for all US products as a revenge - sorry US but 15 years amortization for everyone outside US is just worldwide tariff for any other software producers, freelancers, etc.
- hintymad 1y agoDoes Section 175 apply to other professions? For example, if I hire a full-time handyman for my office, does their salary count as a deductible cost? Sorry if this sounds naive—I'm genuinely struggling to understand why the labor of software engineers would be treated differently from other kinds of work. It seems logical that either all labor costs should count as costs, or none should. If different types of jobs are treated differently, what's the reasoning behind that?
- jncfhnb 1y agoIf you hire someone to build you an office or office furniture, you are creating a long lived asset so it is capitalized If you hire someone to clean your office, you are not creating an asset so it is expensed Building software is generally creating a long lived asset
- hintymad 1y agoThanks. Capitalized expense means the expense can be amortized over years? If so, the short-term profit can be higher than expensed cost? That sounds bad in this context as more profit means more tax. However, the OP seems to argue that capitalized expense is good for tech companies. In the meantime, the parent comment says "Depreciating means that if you pay an engineer $200k in a year, in tax-world you only had $40k of real expense that year, even though you paid them $200k." and then "So the effect is that it makes engineers much more expensive". This seems to also imply that capitalized expense is worse for tech companies?
- PaulDavisThe1st 1y ago> Capitalized expense means the expense can be amortized over years? In the case of Sec 174, not can but must.
- jncfhnb 1y agoCapitalized means it’s treated as an investment into an asset rather than just a cost of doing business. The reason we do this is because we want revenue and expenses to reasonably match the time period where their value comes into play. For example, if you build 100 widgets for $1M this year, the labor and materials cost of those widgets are capitalized into inventory. Next year you sell them all for $2M. Capitalization rules would say you had no profit or loss in the first year, and $1M profit in the second year because the cost of the inventory gets expensed when the inventory is sold. Fixed assets like buildings, machinery, and now software have pre defined lifetimes that the expense is realized over. In the case of software, it’s 5 years. Tech companies don’t like this because they want to front load recognition of expenses to pay less taxes today.
- gortok 1y agoThe SSBA (Small Software Business Alliance) was set up by Michele Hansen -- co-founder of Geocodio, http://geocod.io http://geocod.io (and the SSBA is now run by another person) for this reason -- to raise awareness in Washington DC of the issue with the Section 174 Capitalization changes and the efforts to repeal it. https://ssballiance.org/ https://ssballiance.org/ She has also spoken about it on podcasts: https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=oF-xsDd1A4o https://www.youtube.com/watch?app=desktop&v=oF-xsDd1A4o
- mjwhansen 1y agoThanks for being part of SSBA and continuing to raise awareness!
- jweir 1y agoThe Small Software Business Alliance has been actively working on this issue since day one. https://ssballiance.org/about/engage/ https://ssballiance.org/about/engage/ And Michelle Hansen was an early organizer https://x.com/mjwhansen https://x.com/mjwhansen If you work at all in energy, the Clean Energy Business Network is also proactive in fighting for change. A couple of years ago they put me touch with Ron Wyden's staff. The Democrats are almost universally opposed to what was added to Section 174. https://www.cebn.org/media_resources/house-republicans-advanced-their-tax-reform-package-through-the-ways-and-means-committee/ https://www.cebn.org/media_resources/house-republicans-advan... Fight this thing - it is terrible. Not just for software but any innovative business in the USA.
- hermannj314 1y ago[flagged]
- jweir 1y agoYou know not what you speak of. I am small developer without funding. For every developer I hire I pay tax on 90% of their wages in year 1. So, if I hire a 200k a year developer, I have an increased tax liability of 180k. That works out to paying about $75k ~ $85k. So my 200k developer becomes an 285k developer. Now, eventually I could regain that cost, or I could do like I know of a few companies and commit tax fraud by not correctly reporting my expenses. BTW even as a partner I am hit by this - to correctly file my taxes I have to report my retirement savings as development revenue and pay tax on what is supposed to be tax free. Pretty cool.
- hermannj314 1y ago[flagged]
- soneca 1y agoMy understanding is that the salary of other types of workers do not follow this rule. If that’s correct, then the section means software developers are actually special snowflakes treated differently by the tax code
- doxeddaily 1y agoThis one hit my company pretty hard.
- pinoy420 1y ago[dead]
- flambojones 1y agoSalaries aren't a one-time expense, so is the amortization rolling? Like, year 1, you pay me $200k and deduct $40k. In year 2, you pay me another $200k, do you get to deduct $40k for year 1's salary and $40k for year 2's salary? I guess another way to ask is, does this mean that if you keep someone for 5 years and don't change my wages, is their yearly salary effectively fully deductible? If so, does that create incentives to try to keep employees longer-term in order to make them more cost-efficient?
- iblacksand 1y agoI also have this question. If this is true, as you note, full deduction is only possible if the wage is constant. So would this also provide an incentive for employers not to give raises, as this 'resets the clock'. The situation would be that employers want to keep employees for at least 5 years, but providing them with raises as an incentive to stay is also more expensive than it was previously. Seems like a bit of a mess.
- phyzix5761 1y agoThere's no difference if you fire and hire a new worker every year or you keep them long term. You carry the amortization over until its completely written off.
- flambojones 1y agoAhh good call. My $200k vs. your $200k doesn't really matter with a given year.
- andrewlgood 1y agoShort answer is yes. The finance team has to track each year’s expense as a “tax layer” and amortize it separately. By year 5, ignoring half-year or half-quarter conventions, if have a constant spend, the annual expense will be equal to fully expensing.
- kgwgk 1y agoThe short answer to some of those questions is yes. But clearly not for the final question: “does that create incentives to try to keep employees longer-term in order to make them more cost-efficient?”
- enceladus06 1y agoWe should not have carve out for software R&D or anything else. Business taxes as a whole are stupid and a convoluted mess, just let businesses make as much money as possible and roll with it. It would be much more efficient to tax consumption at a flat rate, and give a variable rebate for elderly/children/whatever.
- jfengel 1y agoAre you suggesting that we eliminate all tax deductions for businesses? Or that we eliminate corporate taxes entirely?
- hermannj314 1y agoIs lobbying for our interests how we become the bad guys? I dont want software development to become the oil and gas industry. More specifically, if software devs aren't creating capital assets, then what exactly is being bought during an acquisition? Don't we tell ourselves our work is building an asset that can be reused and sold. The operational aspect of our job still seems to be treated as opex. Our entire industry is built on the belief our software is an asset. This feels like big tech wiggling for a tax break but disguised as some grass roots effort to help small tech. I am strongly against this as the ethics feel very wrong. Our industry doesn't need tax welfare.
- schroeding 1y agoIMO, if you lobby for a thing which does not do harm to other people, you are not the bad guy. If you do, you are. Lobbying itself is not immoral. The oil and gas industry, and the tobacco industry et al., lobbied (and lobby) for things which they know were (and are) doing harm. This isn't the case here, IMO. Code is not an asset in all (I would even argue most) cases - proven by companies which open source the vast majority of their code and live from service contracts or certain addons to it, and basically pay developers to commit to open source software. Often they buy market- or mindshare. There is no way in hell e.g. Akamai wouldn't have been able to bootstrap "Linode 2". I'm unable to see the secret sauce why OpenAI couldn't have created their own VS Code fork instead of buying Windsurf. But why do that if you can acquire their existent customers / market share? Additionally, the term "acquihire" didn't plop into existence with no precedent. Being able to immediately get a full deductible for salary, which in many (western) countries is the norm for virtually all businesses, does not strike me as particularly immoral. It's a normal office job, developers do not create gold out of thin air. Big tech isn't even the most affected by this change, they (often) have obscene margins - small software companies do not.
- threeseed 1y ago> if you lobby for a thing which does not do harm to other people The reason this is being discussed now is because of its inclusion in the Big Beautiful Bill which will kill the poorest in society by kicking millions off Medicaid and food stamps and increase the debt to unsustainable levels. So if you support this tax cut for software developers you are the bad guy.
- matt3210 1y agoThis will stay because it’s a barrier to smaller companies and nothing significant for larger companies that make political donations
- micahwhite 1y agoSounds like you could use some help building a protest. Try outcryai.com and I think you’ll find it useful for bringing this campaign to the next level.
- Izikiel43 1y agoIs this for taxpayers or citizens? Not all taxpayers are citizens.
- GuinansEyebrows 1y agoit's for businesses.
- neilv 1y agoWhat other employee roles pretty directly produce assets that often have value for the company across multiple tax years? What kinds of workers who produce IP? What kinds of workers who build equipment retained by the company (not quickly sold)? And how are taxes for those employee expenses currently handled?
- andrewlgood 1y agoThink of scientists developing drugs at a pharmaceutical company. They were significantly impacted by the change in deductibility.
- droptablemain 1y agoMy understanding is that the current "Big Beautiful Bill" reverses this
- andrewlgood 1y agoDo not think that is correct. The original accelerated depreciation is simply not being renewed.
- twodave 1y agoIANAL, but the language of the bill seems to suggest GP was indeed correct: https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/house-bill/7024/text#H1312FC52A7C540A39BC68778312446EE https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/house-bill/7024... It seems they're going back to the system where one could choose to amortize those capital expenses, but not be required to.
- yrashk 1y agoseemingly only for domestic R&D
- nextn 1y agoDoes not restoring the tax deduction for software dev in the US help solo founders who don't draw salary to compete with large businesses?
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- cmogni1 1y agoDoes anyone know how AI coding fits in with S174? If a person’s “coding” part of the job is primarily running prompts and checking code outputs (quality control and minor reprompting) with the remainder of the time used for other activities, does this count as software engineering? It seems like an inevitable outcome of this is elaborate system-gaming to mitigate how much employees fall under S174…
- physhster 1y agoI'm afraid most of the damage is already done...
- Atreiden 1y agoSo this is a huge problem, and one worth tackling, but I worry very much about the timing of this post in the context of the bill being brought before the Senate now. We should not implement horrific legislation just because we agree with a single provision. Calling your representatives is the right path, but you MUST be explicit that you do not support the current bill being brought forth that addresses this. Here are a few pieces for context, if you're not informed about what's in this bill: https://thehill.com/opinion/finance/5339440-the-big-beautiful-bill-creates-a-5-billion-tax-shelter-for-private-school-donors/ https://thehill.com/opinion/finance/5339440-the-big-beautifu... https://archive.is/No4o9 https://archive.is/No4o9 Please, I beseech my fellow Americans, do not vocalize any support for this bill. We'll correct the ills of the 2017 administration in time, but this is not the way to do that.
- rbultje 1y ago> We'll correct the ills of the 2017 administration in time How? We have - at times - had democrats in charge since 2017 and they did nothing to resolve this either. We appear to be waiting for flying pigs.
- throwanem 1y agoSo because this is something we can do now and we want to do something now, we do this?
- vkou 1y agoSupporting this is making a deal with the devil because he offered you two bottles of whiskey. Its penny-wise and pound-foolish.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- throwanem 1y agoI hadn't seen they were asking for a retroactive carveout! For eight years. A decade's worth of massive, post facto tax clawback? I don't know who thought this was a good idea, but they really must not love YC or Hacker News, to put those names on the public face of this...
- the_arun 1y agoWhy payment to Software Engineers is not an expense for the current year? Is it because of the size of the expense? or some other rule that I am missing. Those employees are also paying taxes to those salaries as well. Isn't it? What is the catch? I'm confused.
- jeremyjh 1y agoWork on product is typically classified as R&D expense. R&D salaries are considered to be developing a capital asset that will yield returns for years. So the costs of it also are amortized over years. Bog standard accounting. The prior situation was actually an exception.
- strawhatguy 1y agoanother illustration why income taxes in general are bad.
- computerthings 1y ago[dead]
- justinzollars 1y agoI support this and am willing to help.
- phyzix5761 1y agoI've written on here a few times about this. This is part of the reason the job market is so difficult right now for software engineers. Let's get this changed!
- scrollaway 1y agoI want to propose an alternative for those here reading that are tired of the US and its administration, and are looking for an opportunity to move to Europe this year. I am looking for US-based founders who want to make the leap and move to EU. We're doing an incubator like no other, in Brussels at the heart of the EU capital. 15 startups, 6 months hybrid program, only US-based founders. Here in Belgium, software dev is taxed for correctly, and there's a 0% capital gains tax which is super attractive for startup founders. Everyone in the Fall 2025 cohort gets a 25% share of our take on any exits. That means by joining the incubator, you invest in 14 other startups by founders who are as crazy as you. This was created right here on HN, in a "Who is Hiring" job post, with feedback from the ensuing community. I'm looking for a few more founders to apply before July 1st. Deadline to apply July 1st. https://sevenseed.eu https://sevenseed.eu And if you aren't interested in making a startup but just want to move, email me, I will help you get a job in EU.
- zeckalpha 1y agoDisappointed there’s only two mentions of GAAP on this thread. This change aligns (to a closer extent than before) Tax accounting with GAAP accounting. Let’s say the tax code returns to pre-2017. Would the same people seeking this change seek a change to GAAP? No, because it would hurt their profitability.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- jmward01 1y agoIn general, anything that encourages companies to reinvest money into infrastructure, research, etc is a great idea. The trick is to make sure it actually does encourage research, infra, etc etc and doesn't just give a loophole for companies to take more profits and pay less tax.
- andrewlgood 1y agoFor clarity, there is another section, Section 41, that addresses tax credits for R&D. This is still active.
- MyPasswordSucks 1y agoThe tech community, correctly or incorrectly, is broadly seen as "anti-tax cuts", so - regardless of the actual merits of this particular tax cut - I'm not sure how well-received this campaign will be. I'd brace for some rather heavy sarcasm on social media for anyone brave enough to tread those waters.
- tekknik 1y agoIt bothers me when other software devs assume everybody is the same as them. In CA, sure likely most engineers are likely democrats. This does not mean they’re the majority. In fact many republican devs are still scared to speak out because of the censorship and canceling during COVID. You cannot make this assumption that we are broadly against tax cuts.
- grepfru_it 1y agoI would not use section 174 as a reason not to startup but rather as a way to ensure you are running a lean ship. It’s very possible the rule change could be retroactive. Thats just my poker take on this bluff. It may not be retrospective or it may not happen at all. But indecision will kill some startups, the ones who don’t will be a year or three ahead.
- Duskgmxx 1y ago[flagged]
- polskibus 1y agoHow does it work for outsourcing? Do you get full tax deduction if f you just pay offshore company to do dev?
- andrewlgood 1y agoI think people are missing the actual process used by Finance teams relating to this issue. I am a former CFO and spent a fair amount of time with this issue in my last role. The firm had a significant amount of software engineering expense related to its core operating system that was the backbone of the company. The FASB accounting rules drive the capitalization of software expenses, not the tax rules. The FASB definition of GAAP (Generally Accepted Accounting Principals) for US firms is very specific and requires significant detailed tracking to comply. As noted in one of the other posts, many companies want to capitalize as much software engineering expense as possible as that leads to higher operating income and net income. Bonuses, option grants and stock prices tend to be tied to those metrics. The argument is that building a piece of software should be treated like purchasing it off the shelf. If a firm pays $1M to implement SAP, it does not have to expense it all in one year, but rather depreciates it over its “expected life.” Since “expected life” is difficult to define for every piece of software, there are default lifetimes (similar to saying motor vehicles default to a 5 year depreciation schedule). Tax then generally follows the GAAP accounting except when the government intervenes to try and increase capital spending. Periodically the government will allow accelerated depreciation which increases operating expenses for tax purposes only which reduces current period cash taxes. Note total taxes do not change, only when they get paid. The Section 174 under discussion here is simply the same idea then applied to software development in an effort to juice hiring. For the people discussing whether the IRS is effectively tracking and enforcing this - the IRS really does not matter. A companies auditors enforce it. Without all of the necessary paperwork/digital audit trail, a firm in not permitted by the auditors to capitalize the expense. The same auditors have to sign off on the tax treatment as well. Finally, with respect to maintenance, the idea is meant to be similar to the treatment for machinery ( i.e. traditional capital expenditures). When a firm puts gas in the company truck or replaces tires or fixes a windshield, they do not capitalize those expenses. The idea is the expense do not fundamentally improve the item or meaningful extend the life beyond the initial expectations. Following that line of thought, maintenance releases are not thought to extend the life of the software while significant improvements to the software do and therefore can be capitalized. DISCLAIMER - while I was a CFO, I was not a Certified Accountant. What I have described above is what the accountants and my audit firms described to me as I worked through this issue in preparing financial statements.
- rr808 1y agoThe problem is that the most profitable and high paying companies are mostly software companies. If you want to raise tax revenue there aren't many other industries that can pay.
- 8note 1y agoive got a different thought in response to this: is all this ammortization stuff bumpkiss? not just for sorftware developmeent, but everything else that's required to be ammortized? software has been the growth area of actually making stuff for the past 20 years in the US. is it ammortization rules that have held back other investment?
- andrewlgood 1y agoAmortization/depreciation is actually pretty important for understanding the performance of a company. Imagine a firm buys a piece of software to run its business. In year 1 it pays $10M for the software then $1M per year in maintenance thereafter. The software enables the firm to make $2.5M Revenue in year 1 and ramp up to $3.5M thereafter. Assume no other expenses. Without amortization of the software expense, it would look like the business lost $7.5M in year 1, then made $2.5M per year for next 4 years. With amortization, the business makes $0.5M per year consistently which better reflects the stable nature of the business. Note: ($10M / 5 years =2 m·$/year ). Year 1: $2.5M Revenue - $2.0M amort = $0.5M profit. Years 2-5 have $3.5M revenue - ($2.0M amort + $1M maintenance)= $0.5M profit.
- horns4lyfe 1y agoWhy should I care about these companies when they seem dead set on outsourcing my work regardless of tax codes?
- fooker 1y agoWhy though? There's no shortage of software engineers. Something like this will fuel a over hiring boom just before AI gets good enough.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- graycat 1y agoOn "Section 174" and more on taxes from Hill, Barth & King LLC at https://hbkcpa.com/insights/proposed-tax-bill-addresses-trump-campaign-promises-and-expiring-tcja-provisions/ https://hbkcpa.com/insights/proposed-tax-bill-addresses-trum... is in part: Jobs Act. The bill also addresses the “big three” business tax provisions: deducting research and development expenses, 100% bonus depreciation, and loosening the rules for the deductibility of business interest. with deducting research and development expenses For more there is (with my reformating of the text): HBK Home / Insights / Proposed Tax Bill Addresses Trump Campaign Promises and Expiring TCJA Provisions Proposed Tax Bill Addresses Trump Campaign Promises and Expiring TCJA Provisions Date May 15, 2025 Earlier this week, the House Ways and Means Committee released details of a multi-trillion-dollar tax-cut bill. The legislation closely follows President Donald Trump’s campaign promises of no tax on tips and overtime, tax breaks for seniors and car buyers, and extension of much of the expiring 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act. The bill also addresses the “big three” business tax provisions: deducting research and development expenses, 100% bonus depreciation, and loosening the rules for the deductibility of business interest. Key Provisions (1) Permanent extension of individual income tax rates (no new millionaire’s tax rate) (2) Permanent extension of the higher standard deduction with temporary increases for 2025 through 2028 (3) Additional $4,000 standard deduction for seniors (subject to income limitations) (4) Estate and gift exemption increased to $15MM (5) State and local tax deduction is increased from $10,000 to $30,000 (subject to income limitations) (6) Child tax credit of $2,000 made permanent with an increase to $2,500 for 2025 through 2028 (7) Return of the $300/$600 above-the-line deduction for charitable contributions (8) 100% bonus depreciation for assets placed in service after 1/19/25 and before 1/1/2030 (9) Full expensing of Section 174 domestic research and experimental expenses for 2025 through 2029 (10) Increase in the Section 179 deduction to $2.5MM with the phaseout beginning at $4MM (11) Qualified business income deduction made permanent and increased to 23% (12) Addition of a special deduction for “Qualified Production Property” which allows 100% depreciation for manufacturing buildings (13) Eliminates many business, home and vehicle energy tax credits (14) Creating a new round of Qualified Opportunity Zones with investor tax benefits There is still substantial debate to come as this bill moves through Congress. We will continue to monitor developments and keep you updated on any changes that may affect your tax situation. Please contact HBK with any questions or to discuss how these potential tax changes might impact your specific financial circumstances. So items (8) and (9) seem to have to do with deducting "depreciation for assets" and "Section 174".
- matthberg 1y agoNote that this letter's requests DO NOT include voting against the reconciliation bill, just modifying it to add a carve-out to fix Section 174. While I agree that Section 174 desperately needs reform and is harmful to the tech industry, the bill as a whole must be opposed, not tweaked. There are many, many things wrong with the "Big Beautiful Bill", too many to fix through piecemeal efforts like this. It must be resolutely opposed, not endorsed with minor changes.
- tekknik 1y agoCare to elaborate?
- dwg 1y agoJapan has required amortization of capitalized software over five years for qualifying internal-use software since at least 2000. Correct me if I’m wrong, but I believe most other countries have similar rules. Until 2022, U.S. companies had a real competitive advantage. Software developer salaries in Japan are depressed—other roles too, but especially engineers. Without digging too deep, perhaps the previously unfavorable (now roughly equal) tax treatment of was perhaps a contributing factor.
- stroebs 1y ago> most other countries have similar rules. This is the first instance I’ve heard of where salaries aren’t considered remuneration for basic labour. It’s a fairly weird interpretation of reality that spending $200k on a human’s availability results in a guaranteed $200k of capital being created, regardless of which country this kind of tax law exists in.
- franciscop 1y agoDev here working in Japan for few years, I don't think the main reason software salaries are low in Japan is financial, but social/cultural. Software has traditionally not seen as valued as hardware, it was just an "extra" added on top of the hardware part. Basically never went through the startup revolution of the 2000s in US. Also Japan is still very hierarchical, so old ideas change much slower. I would say the combination of these 2 are the main reason software is not as valued as in e.g. America, but there are many others like lack of international competitiveness due to the low English skill, ZIRP, and the ones you note seem totally valid ofc. This is a very interesting recent report about salaries in Japan (e.g. foreigners, and/or foreigner companies get paid/pay a lot more): https://www.tokyodev.com/articles/software-developer-salaries-in-japan https://www.tokyodev.com/articles/software-developer-salarie...
- dwg 1y agoEssentially agree. Nonetheless, if reports are to be believed the post-rule change decline is significant, and I can’t help but wonder how big of a positive feedback loop—in other words a bubble—was being created. The gap was, after all, built up over several decades. The usual culprit you mentioned, perhaps aren’t as much of a factor as we usually ascribe to them. Just speculating. Thanks for sharing the report.
- gigatexal 1y agoI would like to see this as part of another bill not the big beautiful (sic) bill that is in the senate now.
- deleted 1y ago[deleted]
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 1y agoI would support the OBBBA changes to Section 174 for life sciences companies but not for software development.
- stephen_cagle 1y agoI always wonder when reading about things like this, and had a fun dinner discussion about it a while ago. What would happen with the following instead? 1) Remove all tax deductions entirely. 2) Have no corporate income tax at all. 3) Tax cash and cash equivalents at a very high rate (20% ???) per year, tax other assets at a lower rate (5%). Basically just have taxes that are high enough to encourage productive use of all assets (above inflation), and to really really encourage companies not to horde capital. Seems much simpler. I might also be convinced that taxes shouldn't even kick in until a corporation is above a certain size (5 milion USD?).
- piracyrules 1y ago[flagged]
- rubenvanwyk 1y agoDoesn't this incentivize outsourcing or fractional work to some degree, because that would still be counted as regular expenses?
- projektfu 1y agoIf the accounting is correct, a purchase of $1MM of software should be equal to paying $1MM to develop it in house, or paying a contractor $1MM to develop it for you. Similarly, if a shipping company wanted a new boat, it would be the same if they built it in house or if they had a shipbuilder make it.
- jay_kyburz 1y agoThis whole discussion has me thinking its unfair to force any capitalisation to be amortised over x years, whether its salaries or machinery. You spent the money, you're out of pocket, why not claim the expense.
- ninetyninenine 1y agoSoftware is one of the few things that the US still dominates at. Looks like this will change soon.
- phendrenad2 1y agoI think that was the whole point of this change. "Too much tech, not enough coal mines" seems to be Trump's whole thing.
- ninetyninenine 1y agoIt actually makes sense. Most of our brain power is being drained into tech when it could’ve went to other places. It’s a zero sum game. We have limited population and thus limited total IQ points that can be diverted into different technological fields. We definitely have an over allocation of points towards software at the detriment of other fields.
- zekrioca 1y agoNon US persons also pay taxes, so surely they should be able to sign this letter?
- runeks 1y agoNo, it sounds like they want signatures from only US taxpayers. Which makes sense.
- tonyhart7 1y agois not this would hit US innovation at tech sector???? after AI and this, senior engineer would be valued so much that they would get incentives for long tenure (more than ever)
- hkgjjgjfjfjfjf 1y ago[dead]
- alkonaut 1y agoAs I understood it, it makes a difference between R&D on one hand, and "maintenance" on the other hand. This has resulted in that my US corporate overlords are shifting maintenance work to the US (better for taxes) and doing greenfield development where I am in the EU. This must be excellent for morale in the US office, but I'm not complaining.
- rajeshpatel15 1y agoBy forcing software wages to be amortized over 5 years (15 for foreign devs), Section 174 has sapped cash flow, prompting layoffs and project cancellations totaling $3–4 M for some firms. Reinstating immediate expensing could unlock roughly $240 B in stuck deductions and supercharge R&D credits, materially bolstering hiring and keeping IP onshore. Has anyone modeled the macroeconomic gains of full expensing versus the budgetary trade-offs in the current $4.5 T tax proposal?
- barillaro 1y ago[dead]
- omnee 1y agoThe law can be a ass, as in this case. So I fully support this petition.
- _lex 1y agoI've been working on a project called x174 to deal with this disaster. Think of it as a bugfix. Will reach out Btw - this sort of project is what my startup does - we spin out autonomous projects - that could be companies - that provide social good and solve otherwise unsolvable problems.
- throwawayffffas 1y agoWait, I have questions, you are selling software or services with the software you make, right? The dev costs are costs related to the thing you are selling, so they are costs of goods no? So they should be deductable regardless, no?
- Dowwie 1y agoI support this effort. Government should tax economic gains, not revenue. A business with $1 million in revenue and $950,000 in expenses is far less profitable than a business with $1 million in revenue and $200,000 in expenses. If both were taxed on their $1 million revenue, the first business would be in a dire situation.
- Thorrez 1y ago>We therefore urge Congress to include a retroactive carve-out from Section 174’s amortization requirements What if I'm in favor of restoring the previous deduction behavior, but not of doing it retroactively?
- gmerc 1y agoTrump Giveth and Trump Taketh away. Find a billionaire to sponsor your request, throw in a golden toilet for Qatar plan, it's more effective than any other form of lobbying, or, lol, political process.
- selfselfgo 1y ago[dead]
- dr-detroit 1y ago[dead]
- adamc 1y agoI don't favor any tax breaks for big tech until they actually start paying meaningful taxes. There have been far too many giveaways. The country is running a massive deficit, and the current "solution" is to balloon the deficit and throw the poor under a bus.
- airstrike 1y agoNobody is arguing for a tax break for big tech. We're explaining how it hurts small tech. If anything, allowing the status quo to continue is helping big tech, so you should also be arguing for undoing this travesty.
- lurkshark 1y agoI agree with you to some extent, but what I’ll add is that “big tech” is well positioned to weather these changes. The part that concerns me is that this will probably push small companies to take on VC money they otherwise wouldn’t need to get through the early years. Then you have a reinforcement of VC profits concentrating wealth.
- panny 1y agoI think the most impactful thing you can say about Section 174 is that if it continues, I will be starting my startups outside the US. An employee should be taxed like an employee, not a panel truck. There is no guarantee the software developer will produce anything of great value, so this is a tax on unrealized gains.
- jart 1y agolool write a declaration of independence and I'll sign it. We don't have any representation in this government. The only solution is revolution.
- aklein 1y agoNowadays, with more and more economic output coming from knowledge work (IP), this depreciation and amortization approach feels hopelessly out of date. I don't know what a good replacement is, but I know software and IP more generally shouldn't be treated at all like a material good.
- rietta 1y agoI am writing my member of Congress right now. --- I'm writing to express my urgent concern regarding the negative impact of the 2022 Section 174 tax code changes on small businesses like mine. As owner of Rietta, Inc., a small cybersecurity firm, I still do much of the technical work. My wife and I have three young children under 6. My family and I have been directly negatively impacted by these changes from the 2017 act. Previously, the tax code helped us afford open-source and experimental work that benefited customers. For example, modernizing applications to run on Docker improved testing and deployment. Our State government clients now benefit, but this was once experimental. Now we're largely back to just work-for-hire consulting, treated as cost of goods sold. I don't have the cash to pay for experimental software development only to then amortize it over five years. If I have $100k revenue and spend $100k, the current code allows only a $20k deduction. I owe taxes on the other $80k despite no cash or documented asset value. Experimental software doesn't work like that in this field. I started this business 26 years ago. We provide important long-term custom programming and update work for private sector and State government clients ("STATE A" and "STATE B" judicial branches). Often, we work with code we didn't originally write. As a professional computer scientist and business owner, I rely on my CPA for tax compliance. If I've erred in my example, that's on me. But I can tell you this amortization requirement particularly cripples small businesses like Rietta, Inc., where cash flow is critical, severely limiting the quality of services I can afford to provide. I support undoing this tax change.
- markhahn 1y agocorporate tax is already so low that we shouldn't have this kind of deduction at all: make corps pay income tax like citizens. there can still be deductions, but the idea of writing off all the costs of doing business is like people being able to write off rent, food, clothing, transport, etc.
- game_the0ry 1y agoMy personal opinion - make corporate taxes go to 0% and shift tax burden to wealth and billionaires. Also, lower taxes on w2 income. Counterintuitive, but I think that would bring offshore corporate bank accounts bank on-shore and encourage hiring. Also, heavily penalize stock buybacks when corp tax rate goes to 0%.
- b8 1y agoIsn't there another law that taxes research and development?
- twodave 1y agoI am not sure I understand how amortizing these expenses benefits the government at all, as it is. I won't speak to the methods the government is using to value software, because others have made those points better than I could. First, I think the impact on large businesses has diminished greatly since 2022 anyway, so restoring the tax deduction would essentially give those businesses a 1-year "bump" in their deductions (since they'd be able to expense the previous 4 years of left-over deductions all at once, plus the current year in full). As far as I can tell, the expense isn't tied to individual workers, just the combined salary expense. So hiring/firing shouldn't be largely impacted. And, any benefit the government would have gotten from large corporations has (again, since 2022) now expired. For small businesses and start-ups, there is of course a much greater impact. And, ironically, I think the government is actually collecting less from small businesses in the long term, because the businesses that needed the full deduction to survive can't be collected from, having gone out of business. So the government isn't collecting any more taxes today than it used to. It is probably collecting less, depending on how much revenue has shifted from small (and now failing) businesses to large ones. And we're basically encouraging all of those more entrepreneurial technologists among us to go work for larger corporations instead of striking out on their own. I guess my question then, is, who does this tax code even benefit? Edit: looks like it was just a victim of the TCJA, meant to make TCJA look less expensive. I don't think it had its intended effect.
- ryanisnan 1y agoIs HN/YC going to submit the google form submissions to the relevant committee members on the signers' behalf?
- spruce_tips 1y agohonest question - why dont companies just hire software engineers under the guise of some other title like "researcher"? would that allow them to get around the 5 year depreciation? how is it even enforced?
- smeeger 1y agooh no! corporate profits!
- rietta 1y agoIf the software written in a one year period of time for $100k is an asset then I, as a small business owner, can go to the local credit union and take out a loan on favorable terms with the that asset as collateral. No, of course not! They would laugh me out of the branch or the loan would be credit card interest rates. Software is demonstrably NOT AN ASSET like a major piece of equipment.
- PrivacyAI 1y agoHow could this affect to companies that have employed software engineers overseas?
- danielmorozoff 1y agoDoes anyone have any insights into what type of engineering services the IRS defines as SRE - meaning, does forward / customer facing integration // engineering meet the SRE classification threshold?
- elCreator 1y agohttps://pro.bloombergtax.com/insights/federal-tax/rd-tax-credit-and-deducting-rd-expenditures/ https://pro.bloombergtax.com/insights/federal-tax/rd-tax-cre... good explanation is here
- yrashk 1y agoAs an international founder, I'd like the section 174 to be fully restored as it was before – not just for domestic R&D but offshore one as well, so we're not hit with 15 years deprecitation (it is as good as "infinity") I also own section174.com and sec174.com Would these help with visibility?
- AUSTINE001 1y agoGreat
- EnnEmmEss 1y agoDiscussion from beginning of 2023: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34627712 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34627712
- dang 1y agoYup, thanks! I put together this list at one point: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44203869 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44203869. Btw, this thread got a callout in https://www.axios.com/2025/06/20/silicon-valley-big-tech-tax-benefit https://www.axios.com/2025/06/20/silicon-valley-big-tech-tax... today, though they didn't link to it.