16 ms·
Intel announces Arc B-series "Battlemage" discrete graphics with Linux support
- ramusing81 2y ago[flagged]
- LorenDB 2y ago@dang, this looks like spam.
- LinuxBender 2y agoThey've been at it all morning on a half dozen accounts. Best to click the comment time, downvote and flag it. Daniel will not likely see your comment unless you email him. It could be a bot campaign to auto-dead the domain they are spamming.
- rbanffy 2y agoFor me, the most important feature is Linux support. Even if I'm not a gamer, I might want to use the GPU for compute and buggy proprietary drivers are much more than just an inconvenience.
- zokier 2y agoSure, but open drivers have been AMDs selling point for a decade, and even nVidia is finally showing signs of opening up. So it's bit dubious if these new Intels really can compete on this front, at least for very long.
- whalesalad 2y agoI welcome a new competitor. Sucks to really only have one valid option on Linux atm. My 6600 is a little long in the tooth. I only have it becuase it is dead silent and runs a 5K display without issue - but I would definitely like to upgrade it for something that can hold its own with ML.
- talldayo 2y ago> Sucks to really only have one valid option on Linux atm. I don't think that's a super fair shake? Intel iGPUs have been around for a while if you had a laptop chip or iGPU-enabled desktop chip. They've supported Linux just fine for ages, and will fill any non-3D application you might have. And Nvidia chips are quite good on Linux nowadays - Wayland has been very usable since the 535-series drivers and nearly flawless since 550. You're right to be apprehensive about proprietary GPU hardware but I think there are plenty of options on the table right now.
- whalesalad 2y agoThe iGPU in my 13900K cannot run my 5K display with decent performance (in a desktop environment). I chalked it up to hardware issues but it could be drivers. I am on Debian Linux.
- Night_Thastus 2y agoWe'll have to wait for first-party benchmarks, but they seem decent so far. A 4060 equivalent $200-$250 isn't bad at all. for I'm curious if we'll get a B750 or B770 and how they'll perform. At the very least, it's nice to have some decent BUDGET cards now. The ~$200 segment has been totally dead for years. I have a feeling Intel is losing a fair chunk of $ on each card though, just to enter the market.
- rbanffy 2y agoI'd love to see their GPGPU software support under Linux.
- zargon 2y agoThe keywords you're looking for are Intel basekit, oneapi, and ipex. https://christianjmills.com/posts/intel-pytorch-extension-tutorial/native-ubuntu/#install-drivers https://christianjmills.com/posts/intel-pytorch-extension-tu... https://chsasank.com/intel-arc-gpu-driver-oneapi-installation.html https://chsasank.com/intel-arc-gpu-driver-oneapi-installatio...
- Aromasin 2y agoLots of interesting things packaged into OneAPI for developers to check out: https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/developer/tools/oneapi/overview.html https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/developer/tools/onea... I quite enjoyed using the CUDA to OneAPI migration tool. Was a bit dodgy at times, but for the most part helped me move a lot of stuff out of the NVIDIA walled garden.
- knowitnone 2y agoI don't know the numbers but the manufacture of the chip and the cards can't be that expensive...the design was probably much more expensive. Hopefully they are at least breaking even but hopefully making money. Nobody goes into business to lose money. Shareholders would be pissed!
- 2y ago
- jmclnx 2y ago>Battlemage is still treated to fully open-source graphics driver support on Linux. I am hoping these are open in such a manner that they can be used in OpenBSD. Right now I avoid all hardware with a Nvidia GPU. That makes for somewhat slim pickings. If the firmware is acceptable to the OpenBSD folks, then I will happly use these.
- rbanffy 2y agoThey are promising good Linux support, which kind of implies, at least, that everything but opaque blobs are open.
- rmm 2y agoI put an a360 Card into an old machine I turned into a plex server. It turned it into a transcoding powerhouse. I can do multiple indepdent streams now without it skipping a beat. Price-performance ratio was off the chart
- jeffbee 2y agoInteresting application. Was this a machine lacking an iGPU, or does the Intel GPU-on-a-stick have more quicksync power than the iGPU?
- 6SixTy 2y agoA not inconsequential possibility is that both the iGPU and dGPU are sharing the transcoding workload, rather than the dGPU replacing the iGPU. It's a fairly forgotten feature of Intel Arc, but I don't blame anyone because the help articles are dusty to say the least.
- kridsdale1 2y agoAny idea how that compares to Apple Silicon for that job? I bought the $599 MacBook Air with M1 as my plex server for this reason. Transcodes 4k HEVC and doesn’t even need a fan. Sips watts.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoAll Intel arc even the $99 A310 has HW accel h265 and AV1 encoding.
- machinekob 2y agoApple Silicon still don't support AV1 encoding but it is good enough for simple Jellyfin server i'm using one myself
- aryonoco 2y agoApple's hardware encode/decode for AV1 is quite literally, shit.
- Lapra 2y agoUnlabelled graphs are infuriating. Are the charts average framerate? Mean framerate? Maximum framerate?
- rbanffy 2y agoThe two graphs on the page show FPS.
- zamadatix 2y agoGP is asking what measure of FPS. The most likely value when unspecified is usually "mean FPS" but, being a marketing graph, it doesn't explicitly say.
- rbanffy 2y agoAs long as all bars show the same, is there much difference between “mean”, “minimum” as long as the settings are sensible? Keep in mind this is one benchmark (two, really) and you won’t precisely recreate the testing conditions, and it doesn’t matter because your use case is not running the tests.
- Archit3ch 2y agoThey say the best predictor for the future is the past. How was driver support for their A-series?
- Night_Thastus 2y agoDrivers were very rough at launch. Some games didn't run at all, some basic functionality and configuration either crashes or failed to work, some things ran very poorly, etc. However, it was essentially all ironed out over many months of work. They likely won't need to do the same discovery and fixing for B-series as they've already dealt with it.
- confident_inept 2y agoI'm really curious to see if these still rely heavily on resizable BAR. Putting these in old computers in linux without reBAR support makes the driver crash with literally any load rendering the cards completely unusable. It's a real shame, the single slot a380 is a great performance for price light gaming and general use card for small machines.
- jeffbee 2y agoWhat is the newest platform that lacks resizable BAR? It was standardized in 2006. Is 4060-level graphics performance useful in whatever old computer has that problem?
- bryanlarsen 2y agoSandy Bridge (2009) is still a very usable CPU with a modern GPU. In theory Sandy Bridge supported resizable BAR but in practice they didn't. I think the problem was BIOS's.
- stusmall 2y agoOh wow. That's older than I thought. This is definitely less of an issue than folks make out of it. I cling onto my old hardware to limit ewaste where I can. I still gave up on my old sandybridge machine once it hit about a decade old. Not only would the CPU have trouble keeping up, its mostly only PCIe 2.0. A few had 3.0. You wouldn't get the full potential even out of the cheapest one of these intel cards. If you are putting a GPU in a system like that I can't imagine even buying new. Just get something used off ebay.
- vel0city 2y agoThere were a lot of generations after Sandy Bridge which didn't have it; Sandy Bridge was just one generation that didn't really support it on the consumer side. Consumer boards and CPUs didn't really support it well until after 2018. I upgraded away from a Zen+ system because it didn't support it.
- mushufasa 2y agowhat's the current status of using cuda on non-gpu chips? IIRC that was one of the original goals of geohot's tinybox project, though I'm not sure exactly where that evolved
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 2y agoBit disappointed there's no 16gig(or more) version. But absolutely thrilled the rumours of Intel discrete graphics' demise were wildly exaggerated(looking at you, Moore's Law is Dead...). Very happy with my A770. Godsend for people like me who want plenty VRAM to play with neural nets, but don't have the money for workstation GPUs or massively overpriced Nvidia flagships. Works painlessly with linux, gaming performance is fine, price was the first time I haven't felt fleeced buying a GPU in many years. Not having CUDA does lead to some friction, but I think nVidia's CUDA moat is a temporary situation. Prolly sit this one out unless they release another SKU with 16G or more ram. But if Intel survives long enough to release Celestial, I'll happily buy one.
- khimaros 2y agohave you tested llama.cpp with this card on Linux? when i tested about a year ago, it was a nightmare.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 2y agoA few months ago, yeah. Had to set an environment variable(added to the ollama systemd unit file), but otherwise it worked just fine.
- gs17 2y ago> Intel with their Windows benchmarks are promoting the Arc B580 as being 24% faster than the Intel Arc A750 Not a huge fan of the numbering system they've used. B > A doesn't parse as easily as 5xxx > 4xxx to me.
- vesrah 2y agoThey're going in alphabetical order: A - Alchemist B - Battlemage C - Celestial (Future gen) D - Druid (Future gen)
- bee_rider 2y agoHey we complained about all the numbers in their product names. Getting names from the D&D PHB is… actually very cool, no complaints.
- gs17 2y agoYes, I understand that. I'm saying it doesn't read as easily IMO as (modern) NVIDIA/AMD model numbers. Most numbers I deal with are base-10, not base-36.
- BadHumans 2y agoThe naming scheme they are using is easier to parse for me so all in the eye of the beholder.
- baq 2y agoYou aren’t using excel or sheets I see?
- Ekaros 2y agoOn other hand considering Geforce is 3rd loop of base 10 maybe it is not so bad... Radeon is on other hand a pure absolute mess... Going back same 20 years. I kinda like the idea of Intel.
- CoastalCoder 2y agoGiven Intel's recent troubles, I'm trying to decide how risky it is to invest in their platform. Especially discrete GPUs for Linux gaming Fortunately, having their Linux drivers be (mostly?) open source makes a purchase seem less risky.
- babypuncher 2y agoI can't speak from experience with their GPUs on Linux, but I know on Windows most of their problems stem from supporting pre-DX12 Direct3D titles. Nvidia and AMD have spent many years polishing up their Direct3D support and putting in driver-side hacks that paper over badly programmed Direct3D games. These are obviously Windows-specific issues that don't come up at all in Linux, where all that Direct3D headache is taken care of by DXVK. Amusingly a big part of Intel's efforts to improve D3D performance on Windows has been to use DXVK for many titles.
- beAbU 2y agoIntel isn't going anywhere for at least a couple of hardware genrations. Buying a GPU is also not "investing" in anything. In 2 years' time you can replace it whith whatever is best value for money at that time.
- CoastalCoder 2y ago> Buying a GPU is also not "investing" in anything. It is in the (minor) sense that I'd rely on Intel for warranty support, driver updates (if closed source), and firmware fixes. But I agree with your main point that the worst-case downside isn't that big of a deal.
- throwaway48476 2y agoThere's no way you're going to maintain and develop the intel linux driver as a solo dev.
- CoastalCoder 2y ago
- Scene_Cast2 2y agoI wonder how many transistors it has and what the chip size it is. For power, it's 190W compared to 4060's 115 W. EDIT: from [1]: B580 has 21.7 billion transistors at 406 mm² die area, compared to 4060's 18.9 billion and 146 mm². That's a big die. [1] https://www.techpowerup.com/gpu-specs/arc-b580.c4244 https://www.techpowerup.com/gpu-specs/arc-b580.c4244
- zokier 2y ago> Both the Arc B580 and B570 are based on the "BMG-G21" a new monolithic silicon built on the TSMC 5 nm EUV process node. The silicon has a die-area of 272 mm², and a transistor count of 19.6 billion https://www.techpowerup.com/review/intel-arc-b580-battlemage-unboxing-preview/2.html https://www.techpowerup.com/review/intel-arc-b580-battlemage... These numbers seem bit more believable
- mastax 2y agoThose numbers are identical to the A770, and don't match the numbers from the preview[0], so I think that's a copy paste error. If we use the numbers from the preview: | |Arc A770|Arc B580|RTX 4060| |--------|--------|--------|--------| |Process |N6 |N5 |N5 | |Die Size|406mm^2 |272mm^2 |159mm^2 | |Trans. |21.7B |19.6B |18.9B | |Mem Bus |256 bit |192 bit |128 bit | |TDP |225W |190W |115W | |~Perf |90% |110% |100% | In terms of performance per die area it's a big improvement over A770 but still far behind Nvidia. It's interesting that the transistor density is so much lower than the 4060 despite having the same (or at least similar) process node. Speculating about why that may be: - Nvidia has better layout. - Intel is using higher performance (larger) transistor libraries or layout in order to hit the higher boost frequencies (2800 vs 2460). - Wider bus interface takes up more space. - The B580 may have 1 render slice and 64-bits of memory bus disabled, and they're not including those transistors in the count, but they still take up area. [0]: https://www.techpowerup.com/review/intel-arc-b580-battlemage-unboxing-preview/5.html https://www.techpowerup.com/review/intel-arc-b580-battlemage...
- ryao 2y agoThose numbers suggest that they have caught Nvidia in performance per transistor. As for the die area being larger, I suspect that the larger memory bus might be partly responsible. The transistors used for IO stopped shrinking on new nodes a while ago, so they use plenty of die area.
- treprinum 2y agoWhy don't they just release a basic GPU with 128GB RAM and eat NVidia's local generative AI lunch? The networking effect of all devs porting their LLMs etc. to that card would instantly put them as a major CUDA threat. But beancounters running the company would never get such an idea...
- gs17 2y agoEven 24 or 32 GB for an accessible price would sell out fast. NVIDIA wants $2000 for the 5090 to get 32.
- 01HNNWZ0MV43FF 2y agoJudging by the number of 16 GB laptops I see around, 128 GB of RAM would probably cost a bajillion dollars
- gs17 2y agoOne of the great things about having a desktop is being able to get that much for under $300 instead of the price of a second laptop.
- Cumpiler69 2y agoDesktop PCs RAM don't have the bandwidth and latency required for running AI.
- heraldgeezer 2y ago[flagged]
- pjmlp 2y agoThey all look like amusement parks nowadays.
- heraldgeezer 2y agoYou can get a clean Fractal Design case with 0 lights or RGB. You are showing your ignorance. :) Also, RGB means RGB... just set the color to white for a more clean look? But reading the manual is not for you.
- ThatMedicIsASpy 2y agoSR-IOV is supported on their iGPUs and outside of it exclusive to their enterprise offering. Give it to me on desktop and I'll buy.
- throwaway48476 2y agoIntel is allergic to competition.
- ThatMedicIsASpy 2y agoThere is no competition. People get old workstation/server cards
- throwaway48476 2y agoIntel has a huge problem with business units not competing with eachother.
- tadfisher 2y agoDo they still lock out ECC support on Core processors? I'm still running an ancient i3 for ECC support in my home server.
- scraptor 2y agoECC is supported on a random subset of processors (one of each performance tier) but the motherboard still costs 500$.
- ThatMedicIsASpy 2y agoECC requires workstation/server motherboards
- karmakaze 2y agoI wanted to have alternative choices than Nvidia for high power GPUs. Then the more I thought about it, the more it made sense to rent cloud services for AI/ML workloads and lesser powered ones for gaming. The only use cases I could come up with for wanting high-end cards are 4k gaming (a luxury I can't justify for infrequent use) or for PC VR which may still be valid if/when a decent OLED (or mini-OLED) headset is available--the Sony PSVR2 with PC adapter is pretty close. The Bigscreen Beyond is also a milestone/benchmark.
- oidar 2y agoWhich video card are you using for PSVR?
- karmakaze 2y agoI haven't decided/pulled-the-trigger but the Intel ARC series are giving the AMD parts a good run for the money. The only concern is how well the new Intel drivers work (full support for DX12) with older titles which are continuously being improved (for DX11, 10, and some for 9 others via emulation). There's likely some deep discounting of Intel cards because of how bad the drivers were at launch and the prices may not stay so low once things are working much better.
- gigaflop 2y agoDon't rent a GPU for gaming, unless you're doing something like a full-on game streaming service. +10ms isn't much for some games, but would be noticeable on plenty. IMO you want those frames getting rendered as close to the monitor as possible, and you'd probably have a better time with lower fidelity graphics rendered locally. You'd also get to keep gaming during a network outage.
- karmakaze 2y agoAbsolutely. By "and lesser powered ones for gaming" I meant purchase.
- babypuncher 2y ago
- BadHumans 2y agoI'm considering getting one to replace my 8 year old NVIDIA card but why are there 2 SKUs almost identical in price?
- layer8 2y agoBinning. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Product_binning#Core_unlocking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Product_binning#Core_unlocking
- tcdent 2y agoIf they were serious about AI they would have published TOPS stats at at least float32 and bfloat16. The lack of quantified stats on the marketing pages tells me Intel is way behind.
- andrewstuart 2y agoIntel can't compete head to head with Nvidia on performance. But surely it's easy enough to compete on video ram - why not load their GPUs to the max with video ram? And also video encoder cores - Intel has a great video encoder core and these vary little across high end to low end GPUs - so they could make it a standout feature to have, for example, 8 video encoder cores instead of 2. It's no wonder Nvidia is the king because AMD and Intel just don't seem willing to fight.
- AndrewDucker 2y agoWhich market segment wants to encode 8 streams at once for cheap, and how big is it?
- andrewstuart 2y agoStreaming and streamers want to do multi resolution streaming.
- AndrewDucker 2y agoAaah. I assumed that for that kind of thing Twitch did the transcoding.
- Schlaefer 2y agoTwitch did in the past (mostly), but it is trying pivot at the moment: Take tight control over the encoding settings on the client side and just pass the already encoded stream through the CDN. https://help.twitch.tv/s/article/multiple-encodes https://help.twitch.tv/s/article/multiple-encodes Also having different encoding settings for different purposes is desired (e.g. high quality local recording for an edit later while live streaming to different services at the same time [Twitch, Youtube, ...]). That said, I'm not aware of Intel limiting the number of encoding streams, so I don't know where the number 2 originates.
- hx8 2y agoI like Intel's aggressive pricing against entry/mid level GPUs, which hopefully puts downward pressure on all GPUs. Overall, their biggest concern is software support. We've had reports of certain DX11/12 games failing to run properly on Proton, and the actual performance of the A series varied greatly between games even on Windows. I suspect we'll see the same issues when the B580 gets proper third party benchmarking. Their dedication to Linux Support, combined with their good pricing makes this a potential buy for me in future versions. To be frank, I won't be replacing my 7900 XTX with this. Intel needs to provide more raw power in their cards and third parties need to improve their software support before this captures my business.
- smcleod 2y ago12GB of vRAM? What a wasted opportunity.
- machinekob 2y agoFor lowest end GPU? (and 2k gaming?) It is plenty even for most 4k games.
- smcleod 2y agoGaming sure, but not for GPU compute
- machinekob 2y agoYou most likely would buy 700x series for compute
- Wytwwww 2y agoWell hopefully they'll release a A770 replacement as well. I guess they rushed these cards to get ahead of Nvidia and AMD who should release their next gen early next year.
- ryao 2y agoI wonder if their partners can release 24GB cards.
- Sparkyte 2y agoIntel over there with two spears in the knees looking puzzled and in pain.
- declan_roberts 2y agoI think a graphics card tailored for 2k gaming is actually great. 2k really is the goldilocks zone between 4k and 1080p graphics before you start creeping into diminishing returns.
- icegreentea2 2y ago2k usually refers to 1080p no? The k is the approximate horizontal resolution, so 1920x1080 is definitely 2k enough.
- antisthenes 2y ago2k Usually refers to 2560x1440. 1920x1080 is 1080p. It doesn't make a whole lot of sense, but that's how it is.
- ortusdux 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2K_resolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2K_resolution
- nightski 2y agoThat's amusing because I think almost everyone I know confuses it with 1440p. I've never heard of 2k being used for 1080p before.
- Retric 2y ago“In consumer products, 2560 × 1440 (1440p) is sometimes referred to as 2K,[13] but it and similar formats are more traditionally categorized as 2.5K resolutions.”
- seritools 2y ago1440p is colloquially referred to as 2.5K, not 2K.
- 2y ago
- Implicated 2y ago12GB memory -.- I feel like _anyone_ who can pump out GPU's with 24GB+ of memory that are capable to use for py-stuff would benefit greatly. Even if it's not as performant as the NVIDIA options - just to be able to get the models to run, at whatever speed. They would fly off the shelves.
- cowmix 2y ago100% - this could be Intel's ticket to capture the hearts of developers and then everything else that flows downstream. They have nothing to lose here -- just do it Intel!
- evanjrowley 2y agoMaybe that's not too bad for someone who wants to use pre-existing models. Their AI Playground examples require at minimum an Intel Core Ultra H CPU, which is quite low-powered compared to even these dedicated GPUs: https://github.com/intel/AI-Playground https://github.com/intel/AI-Playground
- elorant 2y agoWould it though? How many people are running inference at home? Outside of enthusiasts I don't know anyone. Even companies don't self-host models and prefer to use APIs. Not that I wouldn't like a consumer GPU with tons of VRAM, but I think that the market for it is quite small for companies to invest building it. If you bother to look at Steam's hardware stats you'll notice that only a small percentage is using high-end cards.
- jmward01 2y ago12GB max is a non-starter for ML work now. Why not come out with a reasonably priced 24gb card even if it isn't the fastest and target it at the ML dev world? Am I missing something here?
- Implicated 2y agoI was wondering the same thing. Seems crazy to keep pumping out 12gb cards in 2025.
- shrewduser 2y agothese are the entry level cards, i imagine the coming higher end variants will have the option of much more ram.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tofuziggy 2y agoYes exactly!!
- enragedcacti 2y ago> Am I missing something here? Video games
- rs_rs_rs_rs_rs 2y agoIt's insane how out of touch people can be here, lol
- heraldgeezer 2y agoI have been trying to hold my slurs in reading this thread. These ML AI Macbook people are legit insane. Desktops and gaming is ugly and complex to them (because lego is hard and macbook look nice unga bunga), yet it is a mass market Intel wants to move in on. People here complain because Intel is not making a cheap GPU to "make AI" on when that's a market of maybe 1000 people. This Intel card is perfect for an esports gaming machine running CS2, Valorant, Rocket Leauge and casual or older games like The Sims, GoG games etc. Market of 1 million + right there, CS2 alone is 1mil people playing everyday. Not people grinding leetcode on their macs. Every real developer has a desktop, epyc cpu, giga ram and a nice GPU for downtime and run a real OS like Linux or even Windows (yes majority of devs run Windows)
- stracer 2y agoToo late, and it has a bad rep. This effort from Intel to sell discrete GPUs is just inertia from old aspirations, won't really help noticeably to save it, as there is not much money in it. Most probably the whole Intel ARC effort will be mothballed, and probably many more will.
- undersuit 2y agoNo reviews and when you click on the reseller links in the press announcement they're still selling A750s with no B-Series in sight. Strong paper launch.
- ksd482 2y agoWhat's the alternative? I think it's the right call since there isn't much competition in GPU industry anyway. Sure, Intel is far behind. But they need to start somewhere in order to break ground. Strictly speaking strategically, my intuition is that they will learn from this, course correct and then would start making progress.
- stracer 2y agoThe idea of another competitive GPU manufacturer is nice. But it is hard to bring into existence. Intel is not in a position to invest lots of money and sustained effort into products for which the market is captured and controlled by a much bigger and more competent company on top of its game. Not even AMD can get more market share, and they are much more competent in the GPU technology. Unless NVIDIA and AMD make serious mistakes, Intel GPUs will remain a 3rd rate product. > "They need to start somewhere in order to break ground" Intel has big problems and it's not clear they should occupy themselves with this. They should stabilize, and the most plausible way to do that is to cut the weak parts, and get back to what they were good at - performant secure x86_64 CPUs, maybe some new innovative CPUs with low consumption, maybe memory/solid state drives.
- jvanderbot 2y agoSeems to feature ray tracing (kind of obvious), but also upscaling. My experience on WH40K DT has taught me that upscaling is absolutely vital for a reasonable experience on some games.
- 1propionyl 2y ago> upscaling is absolutely vital for a reasonable experience on some games This strikes me as a bit of a sad state of affairs. We've moved beyond a Parkinson's law of computational resources –usage by games expands to fill the available resources– to resource usage expanding to fill the available resources on the highest end machines unavailable for less than a few thousand dollars... and then using that to train a model to simulate by upscaling higher quality or performance on lower end machines. A counterargument would be that this makes high-end experiences available to more people, and while in the individual case, I don't buy that that's where the incentives it creates are driving the entire industry. To put a finer point on it: at what percentage of budget is too much money being spent on producing assets?
- jvanderbot 2y agoIsn't it insane to think that rendering triangles for the visuals in games has gotten so demanding that we need an artificially intelligent system embedded in our graphics cards to paint pixels that look like high definition geometry? What a time to be alive. Our most advanced technology is used to cheat on homework and play video games.
- 1propionyl 2y agoIt is. And it strikes me as evidence we've lost the plot and a measure has ceased to be a good measure upon being a target. It used to be that more computational power was desirable because it would allow for developers to more fully realize creative visions that weren't previously possible. Now, it seems that the goal is simply visual fidelity and asset complexity... and the rest of the experience is not only secondary, but compromised in pursuit of the former. Thinking back on recent games that felt like something new and painstakingly crafted... they're almost all 2D (or look like it), lean on excellent art/music (and even haptics!) direction, have a well-crafted core gameplay loop or set of systems, and have relatively low actual system requirements (which in turn means they are exceptionally smooth without any AI tricks). Off the top of my head few years: Hades, Balatro, Animal Well, Cruelty Squad[0], Spelunky, Pizza Tower, Papers Please, etc. Most of these could just as easily have been made a decade ago. That's not to say we haven't had many games that are gorgeous and fun. But while the latter is necessary and sufficient, the former is neither. It's just icing: it doesn't matter if the cake tastes like crap. [0] a mission statement if there ever was one for how much fun something can be while not just being ugly but being actively antagonistic to the senses and any notion of good taste.
- Calimax 2y ago[dead]
- crowcroft 2y agoAnyone using Intel graphics cards? Aside from specs drivers and support can make or break the value prop of a gfx card. Would be curious what actually using is these is like.
- GiorgioG 2y agoI put an Arc card in my daughter's machine last month. Seems to work fine.
- Scramblejams 2y agoWhat OS?
- GiorgioG 2y agoWindows 11
- jamesgeck0 2y agoI use an A770 LE for PC gaming. Windows drivers have improved substantially in the last two years. There's a driver update every month or so, although the Intel Arc control GUI hasn't improved in a while. Popular newer titles have generally run well; I've played some Metaphor, Final Fantasy 16, Elden Ring, Spider-Man Remastered, Horizon Zero Dawn, Overwatch, Jedi Survivor, Forza Horizon 4, Monster Hunter Sunbreak, etc. without major issues. Older games sometimes struggle; a 6 year old Need for Speed doesn't display terrain, some 10+ year old indie games crash. Usually fixed by dropping dxvk.dll in the game directory. This fix cannot be used with older Windows Store games. One problematic newer title was Starfield, which at launch had massive frame pacing and hard crashing issues exclusive to Intel Arc. I've had a small sound latency issue forever; most visible with YouTube videos, the first half-second of every video is silent. I picked this card up for about $120 less than the GTX 4060. Wasn't a terrible decision.
- crowcroft 2y agoAppreciate the detail! I've always found the xx60 class of Nvidia cards to be the entry point for me when I'm putting together a gaming rig so might investigate Intel next time I'm putting a build together.
- imbusy111 2y agoNone of the store links work. Weird. Is this not supposed to be a public page yet?
- SirMaster 2y agoMust be an announcement rather than a launch I guess?
- kookamamie 2y agoWhy, though? Intel's strategy seems puzzling, to say the least.
- tokioyoyo 2y agoHard to get subsidies if you’re not releasing new lines of products.
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoOfficial page: https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/products/docs/discrete-gpus/arc/desktop/b-series/overview.html https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/products/docs/discre...
- SeqDesign 2y agothe new intel battlemage cards look sweet. if they can extend displays on linux, then i'll definitely be buying one
- greenavocado 2y agoI'm not a gamer and there is not enough memory in this thing for me to care to use it for AI applications so that leaves just one thing I care about: hardware accelerated video encoding and decoding. Let's see some performance metrics both in speed and visual quality
- bjoli 2y agoFrom what I have gathered, the alchemist av1 is about the same or sliiiightly worse than current nvenc. My a750 does about 1400fps for dvd encoding on the quality preset. I havent had the opportunity to try 1080p or 4k though.
- bloodyplonker22 2y agoI wanted Intel to do well so I purchased an ARC card. The problem is not the hardware. For some games, it worked fine, but in others, it kept crashing left and right. After updates to drivers, crashing was reduced, but it still happened. Driver software is not easy to develop thoroughly. Even AMD had problems when compared to Nvidia when AMD really started to enter the GPU game after buying ATI. AMD has long since solved their driver woes, but years after ARC's launch, Intel still has not.
- shmerl 2y agoDo you mean on Linux and are those problems with anv? Radv seems to be developed faster these days with anv being slightly more behind.
- jamesgeck0 2y agoI haven't experienced many crashing issues on Windows 11. What games are you seeing this in?
- sirn 2y agoIt's also a hardware problem. For example, Alchemist's EUs being SIMD8 but games requiring SIMD16, so it needs to be dispatched to two EUs in a lockstep, or the lack of support for Execute Indirect instruction commonly used in UE5 games, which is currently emulated in software, makes game compatibility a very hit-or-miss. Battlemage is supposed to fix all these architectural issues. EU in Xe2 is now SIMD16 (which is why the number of EUs per Xe2 core is halved from that of Xe1), and they've added all the previously software-emulated instructions, including Execute Indirect, so in theory Battlemage should be in a much better position in game compatibility side of things. On Linux side of things, lacking sparse residency support in i915 also contributes to game compatibility[1] (though this is now available under Mesa 24). This is something the new xe driver is supposed to fix, but it's still a long way to go until it's actually usable. [1]: https://www.phoronix.com/news/Intel-Vukan-Sparse-TR-TT https://www.phoronix.com/news/Intel-Vukan-Sparse-TR-TT
- bjoli 2y agoI love my a750. Works fantastic out of the box in Linux. He encoding and decoding for every format I use. Flawless support for different screens. I haven't regretted the purchase at all.
- bjoli 2y agoI wonder what happened to my brain writing the above. There is a "He" in there that makes no sense. Flawless support for "different" screens? I of course mean "many screens".
- MrDrMcCoy 2y agoProbably "The". Your sentence makes sense to me with that typo correction, as I have one of these cards as well, primarily for video transcoding.
- maxfurman 2y agoHow does this connect to Gelsinger's retirement, announced yesterday? The comments on that news were all doom and gloom, so I had expected more negative news today. Not a product launch. But I'm just some guy on HN, what do I know?
- wmf 2y agoI don't see any connection. This is a very minor product for Intel.
- Havoc 2y agoWho is the target audience for this? Well informed gamers know Intel's discrete GPU is hanging by a thread, so they're not hoping on that bandwagon. Too small for ML. The only people really happy seem to be the ones buying it for transcoding and I can't imagine there is a huge market of people going "I need to go buy a card for AV1 encoding".
- epolanski 2y agoCheap gaming rigs. They do well compared to AMD/Nvidia at that price point. Is it a market worth chasing at all? Doubt.
- spookie 2y agoIt's cheap, plenty of market when the others have forgotten the segment.
- zamalek 2y agoIf it works well on Linux there's a market for that. AMD are hinting that they will be focusing on iGPUs going forward (all power to them, their iGPUs are unmatched and NVIDIA is dominating dGPU). Intel might be the savior we need. Well, Intel and possibly NVK. Had this been available a few weeks ago I would have gone through the pain of early adoption. Sadly it wasn't just an upgrade build for me, so I didn't have the luxury of waiting.
- sosodev 2y agoAMD has some great iGPUs but it seems like they're still planning to compete in the dGPU space just not at the high end of the market.
- sangnoir 2y ago> Too small for ML. What do you mean by this - I assume you mean too small for SoTA LLMs? There are many ML applications where 12GB is more than enough. Even w.r.t. LLMs, not everyone requires the latest & biggest LLM models. Some "small", distilled and/or quantized LLMs are perfectly usable with <24GB
- helf 2y ago[dead]
- zenethian 2y agoThese are pretty interesting, but I'm curious about the side-by-side screenshot with the slider: why does ray tracing need to be enabled to see the yellow stoplight? That seems like a weird oversight.
- zamalek 2y agoIt's possible that the capture wasn't taken at the exact same frame, or that the state of the light isn't deterministic in the benchmark.
- tommica 2y agoProbably would jump to Intel once my 3060 gets too old
- Alifatisk 2y agoYou have a long time to go, unless you want to play the latest and greatest AAA games, but that will not be your cards fault, it's the game studios not optimizing their game.
- headgasket 2y agomy hunch is the path forward for intel on both the CPU and the GPU end is to release a series of consumer chipsets with a large number of PCIE 5.0 lanes, and keep iterating this. This would cannibalize some of the datacenter server side revenue, both that's a reboot... get the hackers raving about intel value for the money instead of EPYC. Or do a skunkworks ARM64 M1 like processor; there's a market for this as a datacenter part...
- pizzaknife 2y agotell it to my intc stock price
- bigiain 2y ago"Arc B"? Presumably graphics cards optimised for hairdressers and telephone sanitisers?
- JohnBooty 2y agoIt took me sooooo long to recognize this reference.
- 999900000999 2y agoI actually really like the Arc 770. However, this is going to go on clearance within 6 months. Good for consumers, bad for Intel. Also keep in mind for any ML task Nvidia has the best ecosystem around. AMD and Intel are both like 5 years behind to be charitable...
- senectus1 2y agoTypical, they release this on the day I pick up a brand new A770 16gb to toy with LLM stuff. ah well. pretty sure it'll do for my needs.
- brenainn 2y agoFrom the gaming side of things, I'm disappointed that Intel and AMD are focusing on the midrange market going forwards. I'm on Linux with a 6900XT and wasn't going to upgrade until there's a compatible option with acceptable raytracing performance (and when HDR is finally sorted out). The 4090 and other high tier cards are absurdly expensive, would be good to have competition in that segment.
- Venn1 2y agoI’ll pick up a B580 to see how it works with Jellyfin transcoding, OBS streaming using AV1, and, with some luck, Davinci Resolve. Maybe a little Blender? Other exciting tests will include things like fan control, since that’s still an issue with Arc GPUs. Should make for a fun blog post.
- ryanwwest 2y agoLooking forward to it! Would appreciate if you post a link here when you do, I'm excited to see how B series compares to A series for media encoding/decoding (assuming Battlemage is the same across all gpus the same way Alchemist was).
- JimRoepcke 2y ago"B-series", huh? I'm guessing their marketing department isn't known as the "A-team".
- matt3210 2y agoBut can it AI?
- s17tnet 2y agoWhat about sharing GPU across multiple VMs? Isn't Nvidia walled this feature behind unreasonably high price features?
- lhl 2y agoRecently I did some testing of the IPEX-LLM llama.cpp backend on LNL's Xe2: https://www.reddit.com/r/LocalLLaMA/comments/1gheslj/testing_llamacpp_with_intels_xe2_igpu_core_ultra/ https://www.reddit.com/r/LocalLLaMA/comments/1gheslj/testing... Based on scaling by XMX/engine clock napkin math, the B580 should have 230 FP16 TFLOPS and 456 GB/s MBW theoretical. At similar efficiency to LNL Xe2, that should be about pp512 ~4700 t/s and tg128 ~77 t/s for a 7B class model. This would be about 75% of a 3090 for pp and 50% for tg (and of course, 50% of memory). For $250, that's not too bad. I do want to note a couple things from my poking around. The IPEX-LLM [1] was very responsive, and was able to address an issue I had w/ llama.cpp within days. They are doing weekly update releases, so that's great. The IPEX stands for Intel Extension for PyTorch [2] and it is a mostly drop-in for PyTorch: "Intel® Extension for PyTorch* extends PyTorch* with up-to-date features optimizations for an extra performance boost on Intel hardware. Optimizations take advantage of Intel® Advanced Vector Extensions 512 (Intel® AVX-512) Vector Neural Network Instructions (VNNI) and Intel® Advanced Matrix Extensions (Intel® AMX) on Intel CPUs as well as Intel Xe Matrix Extensions (XMX) AI engines on Intel discrete GPUs. Moreover, Intel® Extension for PyTorch* provides easy GPU acceleration for Intel discrete GPUs through the PyTorch* xpu device." All of this depends on Intel oneAPI Base Kit [3] which has easy Linux (and presumably Windows) support. I am normally an AUR guy on my Arch Linux workstation, but those are basically broken and I had much more success installing oneAPI Base Kit (w/o issues) directly in Arch Linux. Sadly, this is also where there are issues some of the code is either dependent on older versions of oneAPI Base Kit that are no longer available (vLLM requires oneAPI Base Toolkit 2024.1 - this is not available for download from the Intel site anymore) or in dependency hell (GPU whisper simply will not work, ipex-llm[xpu] has internal conflicts from the get go), so it's not all sunshine. On average, ROCm w/ RNDA3 is much more mature (while not always the fastest, most basic things do just work now). [1] https://github.com/intel-analytics/ipex-llm https://github.com/intel-analytics/ipex-llm [2] https://github.com/intel/intel-extension-for-pytorch https://github.com/intel/intel-extension-for-pytorch [3] https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/developer/tools/oneapi/base-toolkit-download.html?packages=oneapi-toolkit&oneapi-toolkit-os=linux&oneapi-lin=offline https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/developer/tools/onea...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]