7 ms·
Intel might be too big to fail
- BoredPositron 2y agoThe zombification of failed tech corps continues.
- FrankWilhoit 2y agoThe resources to prevent Intel from failing no longer exist. The only option will be to redefine failure.
- echelon 2y agoThe US needs more chip fab startups. Put the money there.
- cj 2y agoI’m not so sure. Building chips isn’t like building software.
- nickthegreek 2y agoIt’s ease of completion doesn’t change the calculus of its importance.
- Retric 2y agoEase of success changes the calculus relative to other options.
- exabrial 2y agoCompeting against state backed cheap labor, with little environmental oversight is incredibly hard. We've had pockets of success using automation; but a lot of the problems we create for ourselves too.
- _heimdall 2y agoI do believe that's where tariffs would come into play. They're a politically heated topic these days, but tariffs are meant to help manage exactly such a situation.
- exabrial 2y agoThey also have been successful in pockets, but in my mind they're a blunt instrument and its rarely worked. And you're right about politically heated, thats probably the biggest problem. Not to sound like a Trumper, b/c I'm not: The media crucified Trump for installing a tariff on Chinese solar centers, which were being produced below cost with state sponsored material and labor. The Chinese intent was to keep Americans from developing the mass manufacturing capability, but this played into the hands of the US Media who painted it as "anti climate change". We are our own worst enemy.
- _heimdall 2y ago100% agree on both accounts. Tariffs often don't work, or only partly meet their original goals. They're especially bad if done as a blanket tariff rather than target on specific products or industries. Not sure if Trump would actually be planning to add targeted tariffs or blanket tariffs. Hopefully not the later, if we're stuck with him rather than stuck with Harris.
- qaq 2y agoA competitive FAB is 15B that would be one hell of a seed round.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoTSMC is spending $65B to build its fab in Arizona. Hard to imagine a startup raising that much money. And where's the IP going to come from? This is not like build a car factory.
- gmerc 2y agoThe playbook is so fucking obvious. Take over quasi monopolist, loot through stock buybacks, offload to retail, start writing articles calling for rescue
- jessfyi 2y agoAny part of "saving" Intel should include a mechanism barring them from putting any more money that should be spent on R&D towards stock buybacks ($152B since 1990 as of September.) That said quoting the former Intel CEO (who still owns 3,245,986 shares) as "[one of the] expert[s] who says breaking up Intel won't do any good" seems like journalist malpractice--and makes me all the more certain it should be subsumed by a company with executives hungry to actually win again.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoMost companies should be banned from doing this.
- applied_heat 2y agoWhat is wrong with giving the profit to shareholders? That is why the shareholders bought the shares.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoIt creates a massive conflict of interest for the company executives and favors short-term profits vs long-term sustainability of the company.
- toast0 2y agoBuybacks are just dividends with better tax implications that somehow make people angry. Companies historically are expected to pay dividends, at least when their business is doing well. Business at Intel was doing well for most of 1990-2017. There was some time after the Pentium 4 stopped scaling before the Pentium 4M offered a recovery, and the Itanium mess; but overall pretty good until 2017.
- YZF 2y agoBuybacks aren't exactly like dividends because they directly affect the pricing of the stock by interfering with the supply and demand. That said I think people are mostly angry about the conflict of interest where CEOs that have current and future shares are making decisions by what will maximize their personal returns rather than what's best for the company and shareholders. When a company with growth prospects does well it should invest those $$$'s into things like R&D and expansion. Companies that pay their profit as dividend are generally not expected to grow as much and their stock prices (P/E) tends to reflect that. That said the taxation aspect is maybe a problem and should be addressed if it's not working as intended.
- exabrial 2y agoAwesome, I can't wait for me the taxpayer to breathe life into the smoldering shell of a company where the executives and unlimited layers of useless middle management used financial engineering to fool investors about the internal situation while extracting as much money as possible and then bailing out on golden parachutes and landing in soft thick piles of bonuses. Remember when we did this in 2008 under the Obama administration? We gave them $10bil and they paid out "contractually obligated bonuses" with more than half of the money? https://www.theguardian.com/business/2009/jul/31/wall-street-bonuses-bailout https://www.theguardian.com/business/2009/jul/31/wall-street... Just let it fail. If you're really paranoid, pass a law preventing and foreign buyers from snapping up the ip or fabs and we'll just fine, but that's probably not even needed.
- amelius 2y ago> Just let it fail. How about we do something about the financial hackers who are just laughing their way to the bank either way?
- kevmo 2y agoBillionaires should not exist.
- lifestyleguru 2y agoThey give back through their charities and foundations. How would you cope with your life without their charities?
- lgvln 2y agoWhat about using the tariffs on Chinese products to support American companies/interests?
- _heimdall 2y agoTariffs, by design, would already be helping american companies/interests. The point of a tariff is to increase the cost of foreign goods, allowing untariffed companies to better compete.
- _heimdall 2y agoI appreciate the obligatory silent down votes on a political hot button issue. I'd be interested to hear why someone disagrees with me here to go along with a down vote.
- ksec 2y agoIntel is the closest US has to compete on Foundry. And it doesn't take that much money relatively speaking to help them out. I also think they are not far behind. They wont replace or overthrown TSMC anytime soon. But they should be competitive enough. My only question is do shareholders have enough patients to allow Pat to do the right thing.
- mrweasel 2y ago> My only question is do shareholders have enough patients Honestly: Screw the shareholders, this is entirely on them and their short term thinking. The stock market is so broken, with it's quarterly mindset. Businesses needed long term thinking and stability. If the shareholders feel that they need to make a profit trading short term, they can go buy f-ing Dogecoin and play the lottery.
- datavirtue 2y agoI was looking at an overlay of VPU (energy utility ETF) and SPY (S&P500 ETF) and was shocked to see that going back to 2007 both married up exactly until the pandemic when the S&P went to the moon. I think a lot of retail short-term "investors" entered the market and they are all still there trying to get rich trading breakouts. There is precedent for this (1920s and 1990s) but not at this scale and level of ameture.
- mrmetanoia 2y ago"Another reason why the Capitol and the White House wouldn’t want to see Intel fail is because it’s one of America’s top exporters, with its export revenue in 2023 exceeding $40 billion." The capitalist class are the fucking NY Yankees of the world - never has so little been done with so much. What a bunch of greedy idiots running shit into the ground.
- mrweasel 2y agoAMD and Intel just switched places, before Ryzen AMD was a failing company, threatening to not one give Intel a near monopoly, but also handing Nvidia a true monopoly. If AMD can be turned around, why can't Intel, a much larger company with more diverse product lines (not as many as previous, but still). It's not even that Intel aren't selling chips, I'd guess that they are still massively outselling AMD. The fact that Intel can't make money is a failure of management and I feel like the media needs to attack that much harder than they have been. The type of management which have been prevailing for the past 20 - 25 years aren't going to save companies like Intel and Boing, both companies that should have be thriving, but they've become complacent and forgot about the products, focusing on short term stock value. Also Intel doesn't appear to make an actual lose and can still pay dividends in some quarters, so they aren't failing that hard. A turn around in sales is needed, but I don't feel it's as bad as it's made out to be. The media makes it sound like bankruptcy is right around the corner.
- insane_dreamer 2y agoThe problem is not that Intel sales are down. It's that it's spending a massive amount ($160B) on fabs. Fabs are expensive, and much more so if in the US than in Taiwan. It's costing TSMC $65B to build one on Arizona. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/intel-spent-over-160-000-114742092.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/intel-spent-over-160-000-1147...
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 2y agoYes, every company should ditch their fabs it's not profitable. Oh wait...
- scoofy 2y agoThe point is that foreign fabs are a very real multi-national security risk. Even if we decide that friend-shoring is acceptable, the best 'we' (folks in the US or the 'west') can do outside of Intel is Samsung. Depending on TSMC in Taiwan is a disaster waiting to happen, and it also makes a great power conflict there more likely as the asymmetric advantages increase for non-western powers if they were to capture the island. Game-theory would probably suggest that the west should do whatever they can to bring fabrication home, because subsidizing fabs is less expensive than war.
- wg0 2y agoOn a tangent, why there is a general feeling of decline everywhere from Adobe's frustrated customer base to Boeing to Intel and Google's search returning pages and pages of sponsored ads? What's happening?
- Jgrubb 2y agoProbably just decades of quarterly thinking, deregulation, consolidation, extraction, socialized losses, and privatized wins arriving at their obvious and inevitable destination.
- datavirtue 2y agoProgress. The established norms keep getting rug-pulled. Hopefully we can get the replicators built before we all die off.
- DanAtC 2y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enshittification https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enshittification
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- orev 2y agoIt’s caused by Wall St’s need to see constant growth, which becomes cancerous once a company has completely dominated its global market. The company is forced to squeeze existing customers once it’s no longer possible to find new ones (because the pool of all possible customers has already been converted to actual customers).
- Schiendelman 2y agoThis is normal, interestingly. The companies you're used to are aging. New companies are supplanting them as new ideas win. More and more computing is done on phones, meaning Apple, TSMC, Qualcomm, and others are replacing Intel. Adobe is being supplanted by Pixelmator, Blackmagic, and even Instagram. Some of Boeing is being supplanted by SpaceX. Some will be replaced with companies like Boom, and Anduril. This is the hardest one - military contractors have a thumb on the scale from our government. What you're seeing is not decline - it's that these industries are changing in ways that are hard to recognize.
- Hizonner 2y agoAny bailout must of course be contingent on replacing the entire board and the top three layers of management, with at least 50 percent of the replacements being outside hires. Oh, and the government gets preferred stock commensurate with its investment.
- underbiding 2y agoWhy is bailout still seen as the best solution? These industries should be nationalized. Despite the naysayers there are plenty of nation-owned assets that work fine this way and if its this important then it sounds like a worthy candidate for it.
- EasyMark 2y agoThat will never happen in the USA (at least not as the country we know it as)
- 14 2y agoLet’s save them with the condition all chips have even more back doors.
- monkburger 2y agoIn 2008, taxpayers bailed out the banks but not the economy. Deja Vu.
- gruez 2y agoThat's patently false. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effects_of_the_2008%E2%80%932010_automotive_industry_crisis_on_the_United_States#Federal_government_bailout_process_and_timeline https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effects_of_the_2008%E2%80%9320... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Recovery_and_Reinvestment_Act_of_2009 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Recovery_and_Reinvest...
- monkburger 2y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_Economic_Stabilization_Act_of_2008 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emergency_Economic_Stabilizati...
- mullingitover 2y agoThe problem for Intel is the fabs have their own version of Moore’s law: their prices increase exponentially.
- avazhi 2y agoWell I’m sure intel hopes they are. But given the positions of AMD, Apple, and Nvidia, they aren’t. The only real concerns would be warranty obligations, but it isn’t like Intel would just disappear over night - they’d be gobbled up by somebody bigger (which at this point is literally everybody else in the industry) and presumably as part of an acquisition or Chapter 11 the buyer would have to agree to honor warranty claims for it to pass regulatory or court approval. Gonna be one hell of a show watching them death spiral. 60ish years of inertia and corporate ego will will surely not go quietly into that good night, even when it’s inevitable.
- jmclnx 2y agoI do not understand this "Intel failing" meme. In 2022, 2023 Intel made a profit, but seems this year so far no profits. In spite of that, I think this whole hand wringing is because "Intel is not Nvidia".
- ptek 2y agoIntel outside. Motorola inside. Oh yeah it’s no longer early 90s
- betimsl 2y agomight? -- excuse me, is.
- spoaceman7777 2y agoPeople here seem to be filling in a lot of details from their imagination. Intel's losses all revolve around upgrading and spinning up their new fabs, fabs for which there is no other global competition besides TSMC and Samsung. The latest process was delayed. Once they start filling orders, they will be the ones filling the hole that could be left in US microchip capabilities that are in imminent danger, being largely based in Taiwan. Their new desktop chips are cracked, their Gaudi 3 accelerators, that just started shipping five weeks ago, are a shade better than H100's, for half the cost, and with improved and much more affordable capabilities for interconnect, in addition to other features. It's incredibly important for the US to continue its push to building up the domestic TSMC, Intel, and related chip infrastructure that it has so far funded (though, has largely not paid out, contributing even further to Intel's current situation). Perhaps, if tariffs really do come in, we'll see the many fab-less chip designers that people are praising in this thread bring their manufacturing back to American manufacturers. As they damned well should.
- BenFranklin100 2y agoIntel seems like it would benefit with an Elon Musk type of character in charge. Cut out the needless layers of management and go hard core engineering.
- BeetleB 2y agoUnlike Twitter, fabs actually do need a large number of employees. And unlike whatever he's building at Tesla and SpaceX, changing a fab process is an order of magnitude more expensive, and the engineering/science is a lot more sophisticated. There's a reason semiconductor manufacturing is considered the most advanced manufacturing on the planet.
- BenFranklin100 2y agoThus an emphasis on engineering. Building rockets is no walk in the park either.
- mitjam 2y agoIntel is a huge asset, they missed major industry changes, like EUV, ARM, GPU, and splitting design and foundry. I still believe they can come back strong, but need bold decisions to regain defensible competitive advantages.
- EasyMark 2y agoThey have to trim the middle management fat, 1st, before anything else will succeed.
- rekabis 2y agoBailouts are constructive under only one circumstance: when all shareholders lose a proportional stake in the company in exchange for financial intervention, with said stake going to the government/taxpayers as a public control/interest. As in, if a company receives a bailout equivalent to 50% of the company’s market value, all shareholders have their stake in the company decreased by 50%, permanently and irrevocably.
- dzonga 2y agosome of these crucial companies -- gvt should own the at least 40%. fuck the free market. because of the expertise needed - if the expertise leaves your country, it will never come back. Intel is one of those companies - where the gvt gets two board seats, while being close to a majority shareholder. not 50% but 40% ish. I have libertarian leanings btw.
- AzzyHN 2y agoI haven't read the article yet, but I disagree on principle. AMD processors are a drop-in replacement for any and all software running on Intel chips (except for things that interact with the Management Engine, but that's a small portion of software I hope). Aside from it leaving only one major x86 CPU manufacturer, the only thing Intel's absence would cause would be a massive amount of paperwork, as every system integrator under the sun has to figure out contracts with AMD.
- Havoc 2y agoOh most certainly. Much like Boeing can kill however many they want, intel isn’t going down. National strategic interest in both cases overrides near all
- nightowl_games 2y agoThis is why I'm ultimately bullish on intel
- EasyMark 2y agolol given the nat sec issues with allow intel to fail, I agree with you, doesn't mean there won't be a bailout with forced bankrupcy like they did the automakers who wanted bailed out.
- nightowl_games 2y agoOnly question is when to buy
- Scottn1 2y agoI'm actually fascinated the rise-and-fall of some mega corporations over time as times/habits change. IBM, Sears, Etc. At one point Sears was THE place to shop for everything from back-to-school clothes, appliances and Christmas. In the early 2000's I would have thought you were either a giant fool, or a time-traveler, had you tried to tell me by 2024 Intel would be de-listed from the Dow and talk of taxpayer bailout or bankruptcy. They had a monopoly on PC/Servers. As crazy as it currently may sound but one day we could be discussing the downfall of Amazon, Microsoft and Google. Does anyone know of good books about the business-cycle and life/death of companies?
- dranudin 2y agoI have read "Mastering the Market Cycle" by Howard Marks, once, and liked it in general. The topic is the market cycle itself with focus on investing. It is not about specific companies or technologies, though.
- DrNosferatu 2y agoCapitalism for those below, Communism for the ones above!